| বাংলা | |||
| পালি | অট্ঠকথা | টীকা | অন্ন |
| 1101 পারাজিক পালি 1102 পাচিত্তিয় পালি 1103 মহাবগ্গ পালি (বিনয়) 1104 চূলবগ্গ পালি 1105 পরিবার পালি | 1201 পারাজিককণ্ড অট্ঠকথা-১ 1202 পারাজিককণ্ড অট্ঠকথা-২ 1203 পাচিত্তিয় অট্ঠকথা 1204 মহাবগ্গ অট্ঠকথা (বিনয়) 1205 চূলবগ্গ অট্ঠকথা 1206 পরিবার অট্ঠকথা | 1301 সারত্থদীপনী টীকা-১ 1302 সারত্থদীপনী টীকা-২ 1303 সারত্থদীপনী টীকা-৩ | 1401 দ্বেমাতিকাপালি 1402 বিনয়সংগহ অট্ঠকথা 1403 বজিরবুদ্ধি টীকা 1404 বিমতিবিনোদনী টীকা-১ 1405 বিমতিবিনোদনী টীকা-২ 1406 বিনয়ালংকার টীকা-১ 1407 বিনয়ালংকার টীকা-২ 1408 কঙ্খাবিতরণীপুরাণ টীকা 1409 বিনয়বিনিচ্ছয়-উত্তরবিনিচ্ছয় 1410 বিনয়বিনিচ্ছয় টীকা-১ 1411 বিনয়বিনিচ্ছয় টীকা-২ 1412 পাচিত্যাদিযোজনাপালি 1413 খুদ্ধসিক্খা-মূলসিক্খা 8401 বিসুদ্ধিমগ্গ-১ 8402 বিসুদ্ধিমগ্গ-২ 8403 বিসুদ্ধিমগ্গ-মহাটীকা-১ 8404 বিসুদ্ধিমগ্গ-মহাটীকা-২ 8405 বিসুদ্ধিমগ্গ নিদানকথা 8406 দীঘনিকায় (পু-বি) 8407 মজ্ঝিমনিকায় (পু-বি) 8408 সংযুত্তনিকায় (পু-বি) 8409 অঙ্গুত্তরনিকায় (পু-বি) 8410 বিনয়পিটক (পু-বি) 8411 অভিধম্মপিটক (পু-বি) 8412 অট্ঠকথা (পু-বি) 8413 নিরুত্তিদীপনী 8414 পরমত্থদীপনী সংগহমহাটীকাপাঠ 8415 অনুদীপনীপাঠ 8416 পট্ঠানুদ্দেস দীপনীপাঠ 8417 নমক্কারটীকা 8418 মহাপণামপাঠ 8419 লক্খণাতো বুদ্ধথোমনাগাথা 8420 সুতবন্দনা 8421 কমলাঞ্জলি 8422 জিনালংকার 8423 পজ্জমধু 8424 বুদ্ধগুণগাথাবলী 8425 চূলগন্থবংস 8426 মহাবংস 8427 সাসনবংস 8428 কচ্চায়নব্যাকরণং 8429 মোগ্গল্লানব্যাকরণং 8430 সদ্দনীতিপ্পকরণং (পদমালা) 8431 সদ্দনীতিপ্পকরণং (ধাতুমালা) 8432 পদরূপসিদ্ধি 8433 মোগ্গল্লানপঞ্চিকা 8434 পযোগসিদ্ধিপাঠ 8435 বুত্তোদয়পাঠ 8436 অভিধানপ্পদীপিকাপাঠ 8437 অভিধানপ্পদীপিকাটীকা 8438 সুবোধালংকারপাঠ 8439 সুবোধালংকারটীকা 8440 বালাবতার গণ্ঠিপদত্থবিনিচ্ছয়সার 8441 লোকনীতি 8442 সুত্তন্তনীতি 8443 সূরস্সতীনীতি 8444 মহারহনীতি 8445 ধম্মনীতি 8446 কবিদপ্পণনীতি 8447 নীতিমঞ্জরী 8448 নরদক্খদীপনী 8449 চতুরারক্খদীপনী 8450 চাণক্যনীতি 8451 রসবাহিনী 8452 সীমাবিসোধনীপাঠ 8453 বেস্সন্তরগীতি 8454 মোগ্গল্লান বুত্তিবিবরণপঞ্চিকা 8455 থূপবংস 8456 দাঠাবংস 8457 ধাতুপাঠবিলাসিনিয়া 8458 ধাতুবংস 8459 হত্থবনগল্লবিহারবংস 8460 জিনচরিতয় 8461 জিনবংসদীপং 8462 তেলকটাহগাথা 8463 মিলিদটীকা 8464 পদমঞ্জরী 8465 পদসাধনং 8466 সদ্দবিন্দুপকরণং 8467 কচ্চায়নধাতুমঞ্জুসা 8468 সামন্তকূটবণ্ণনা |
| 2101 সীলক্খন্ধবগ্গ পালি 2102 মহাবগ্গ পালি (দীঘ) 2103 পাথিকবগ্গ পালি | 2201 সীলক্খন্ধবগ্গ অট্ঠকথা 2202 মহাবগ্গ অট্ঠকথা (দীঘ) 2203 পাথিকবগ্গ অট্ঠকথা | 2301 সীলক্খন্ধবগ্গ টীকা 2302 মহাবগ্গ টীকা (দীঘ) 2303 পাথিকবগ্গ টীকা 2304 সীলক্খন্ধবগ্গ-অভিনবটীকা-১ 2305 সীলক্খন্ধবগ্গ-অভিনবটীকা-২ | |
| 3101 মূলপণ্ণাস পালি 3102 মজ্ঝিমপণ্ণাস পালি 3103 উপরিপণ্ণাস পালি | 3201 মূলপণ্ণাস অট্ঠকথা-১ 3202 মূলপণ্ণাস অট্ঠকথা-২ 3203 মজ্ঝিমপণ্ণাস অট্ঠকথা 3204 উপরিপণ্ণাস অট্ঠকথা | 3301 মূলপণ্ণাস টীকা 3302 মজ্ঝিমপণ্ণাস টীকা 3303 উপরিপণ্ণাস টীকা | |
| 4101 সগাথাবগ্গ পালি 4102 নিদানবগ্গ পালি 4103 খন্ধবগ্গ পালি 4104 সলায়তনবগ্গ পালি 4105 মহাবগ্গ পালি (সংযুত্ত) | 4201 সগাথাবগ্গ অট্ঠকথা 4202 নিদানবগ্গ অট্ঠকথা 4203 খন্ধবগ্গ অট্ঠকথা 4204 সলায়তনবগ্গ অট্ঠকথা 4205 মহাবগ্গ অট্ঠকথা (সংযুত্ত) | 4301 সগাথাবগ্গ টীকা 4302 নিদানবগ্গ টীকা 4303 খন্ধবগ্গ টীকা 4304 সলায়তনবগ্গ টীকা 4305 মহাবগ্গ টীকা (সংযুত্ত) | |
| 5101 এককনিপাত পালি 5102 দুকনিপাত পালি 5103 তিকনিপাত পালি 5104 চতুক্কনিপাত পালি 5105 পঞ্চকনিপাত পালি 5106 ছক্কনিপাত পালি 5107 সত্তকনিপাত পালি 5108 অট্ঠকাদিনিপাত পালি 5109 নবকনিপাত পালি 5110 দশকনিপাত পালি 5111 একাদশকনিপাত পালি | 5201 এককনিপাত অট্ঠকথা 5202 দুক-তিক-চতুক্কনিপাত অট্ঠকথা 5203 পঞ্চক-ছক্ক-সত্তকনিপাত অট্ঠকথা 5204 অট্ঠকাদিনিপাত অট্ঠকথা | 5301 এককনিপাত টীকা 5302 দুক-তিক-চতুক্কনিপাত টীকা 5303 পঞ্চক-ছক্ক-সত্তকনিপাত টীকা 5304 অট্ঠকাদিনিপাত টীকা | |
| 6101 খুদ্ধকপাঠ পালি 6102 ধম্মপদ পালি 6103 উদান পালি 6104 ইতিবুত্তক পালি 6105 সুত্তনিপাত পালি 6106 বিমানবত্থু পালি 6107 পেতবত্থু পালি 6108 থেরগাথা পালি 6109 থেরীগাথা পালি 6110 অপদান পালি-১ 6111 অপদান পালি-২ 6112 বুদ্ধবংস পালি 6113 চরিয়াপিটক পালি 6114 জাতক পালি-১ 6115 জাতক পালি-২ 6116 মহানিদ্দেস পালি 6117 চূলনিদ্দেস পালি 6118 পটিসম্ভিদামগ্গ পালি 6119 নেত্তিপ্পকরণ পালি 6120 মিলিন্দপঞ্হ পালি 6121 পেটকোপদেস পালি | 6201 খুদ্ধকপাঠ অট্ঠকথা 6202 ধম্মপদ অট্ঠকথা-১ 6203 ধম্মপদ অট্ঠকথা-২ 6204 উদান অট্ঠকথা 6205 ইতিবুত্তক অট্ঠকথা 6206 সুত্তনিপাত অট্ঠকথা-১ 6207 সুত্তনিপাত অট্ঠকথা-২ 6208 বিমানবত্থু অট্ঠকথা 6209 পেতবত্থু অট্ঠকথা 6210 থেরগাথা অট্ঠকথা-১ 6211 থেরগাথা অট্ঠকথা-২ 6212 থেরীগাথা অট্ঠকথা 6213 অপদান অট্ঠকথা-১ 6214 অপদান অট্ঠকথা-২ 6215 বুদ্ধবংস অট্ঠকথা 6216 চরিয়াপিটক অট্ঠকথা 6217 জাতক অট্ঠকথা-১ 6218 জাতক অট্ঠকথা-২ 6219 জাতক অট্ঠকথা-৩ 6220 জাতক অট্ঠকথা-৪ 6221 জাতক অট্ঠকথা-৫ 6222 জাতক অট্ঠকথা-৬ 6223 জাতক অট্ঠকথা-৭ 6224 মহানিদ্দেস অট্ঠকথা 6225 চূলনিদ্দেস অট্ঠকথা 6226 পটিসম্ভিদামগ্গ অট্ঠকথা-১ 6227 পটিসম্ভিদামগ্গ অট্ঠকথা-২ 6228 নেত্তিপ্পকরণ অট্ঠকথা | 6301 নেত্তিপ্পকরণ টীকা 6302 নেত্তিবিভাবিনী | |
| 7101 ধম্মসংগণী পালি 7102 বিভঙ্গ পালি 7103 ধাতুকথা পালি 7104 পুগ্গলপঞ্ঞাত্তি পালি 7105 কথাবত্থু পালি 7106 যমক পালি-১ 7107 যমক পালি-২ 7108 যমক পালি-৩ 7109 পট্ঠান পালি-১ 7110 পট্ঠান পালি-২ 7111 পট্ঠান পালি-৩ 7112 পট্ঠান পালি-৪ 7113 পট্ঠান পালি-৫ | 7201 ধম্মসংগণি অট্ঠকথা 7202 সম্মোহবিনোদনী অট্ঠকথা 7203 পঞ্চপকরণ অট্ঠকথা | 7301 ধম্মসংগণী-মূলটীকা 7302 বিভঙ্গ-মূলটীকা 7303 পঞ্চপকরণ-মূলটীকা 7304 ধম্মসংগণী-অনুটীকা 7305 পঞ্চপকরণ-অনুটীকা 7306 অভিধম্মাবতারো-নামরূপপরিচ্ছেদো 7307 অভিধম্মত্থসংগহো 7308 অভিধম্মাবতার-পুরাণটীকা 7309 অভিধম্মমাতিকাপালি | |
| 中文 | |||
| 巴利 | 義註 | 複註 | 藏外典籍 |
| 1101 巴拉基咖(波羅夷) 1102 巴吉帝亞(波逸提) 1103 大品(律藏) 1104 小品 1105 附隨 | 1201 巴拉基咖(波羅夷)義註-1 1202 巴拉基咖(波羅夷)義註-2 1203 巴吉帝亞(波逸提)義註 1204 大品義註(律藏) 1205 小品義註 1206 附隨義註 | 1301 心義燈-1 1302 心義燈-2 1303 心義燈-3 | 1401 疑惑度脫 1402 律攝註釋 1403 金剛智疏 1404 疑難解除疏-1 1405 疑難解除疏-2 1406 律莊嚴疏-1 1407 律莊嚴疏-2 1408 古老解惑疏 1409 律抉擇-上抉擇 1410 律抉擇疏-1 1411 律抉擇疏-2 1412 巴吉帝亞等啟請經 1413 小戒學-根本戒學 8401 清淨道論-1 8402 清淨道論-2 8403 清淨道大複註-1 8404 清淨道大複註-2 8405 清淨道論導論 8406 長部問答 8407 中部問答 8408 相應部問答 8409 增支部問答 8410 律藏問答 8411 論藏問答 8412 義注問答 8413 語言學詮釋手冊 8414 勝義顯揚 8415 隨燈論誦 8416 發趣論燈論 8417 禮敬文 8418 大禮敬文 8419 依相讚佛偈 8420 經讚 8421 蓮花供 8422 勝者莊嚴 8423 語蜜 8424 佛德偈集 8425 小史 8427 佛教史 8426 大史 8429 目犍連文法 8428 迦旃延文法 8430 文法寶鑑(詞幹篇) 8431 文法寶鑑(詞根篇) 8432 詞形成論 8433 目犍連五章 8434 應用成就讀本 8435 音韻論讀本 8436 阿毗曇燈讀本 8437 阿毗曇燈疏 8438 妙莊嚴論讀本 8439 妙莊嚴論疏 8440 初學入門義抉擇精要 8446 詩王智論 8447 智論花鬘 8445 法智論 8444 大羅漢智論 8441 世間智論 8442 經典智論 8443 勇士百智論 8450 考底利耶智論 8448 人眼燈 8449 四護衛燈 8451 妙味之流 8452 界清淨 8453 韋桑達拉頌 8454 目犍連語釋五章 8455 塔史 8456 佛牙史 8457 詞根讀本注釋 8458 舍利史 8459 象頭山寺史 8460 勝者行傳 8461 勝者宗燈 8462 油鍋偈 8463 彌蘭王問疏 8464 詞花鬘 8465 詞成就論 8466 正理滴論 8467 迦旃延詞根注 8468 邊境山注釋 |
| 2101 戒蘊品 2102 大品(長部) 2103 波梨品 | 2201 戒蘊品註義註 2202 大品義註(長部) 2203 波梨品義註 | 2301 戒蘊品疏 2302 大品複註(長部) 2303 波梨品複註 2304 戒蘊品新複註-1 2305 戒蘊品新複註-2 | |
| 3101 根本五十經 3102 中五十經 3103 後五十經 | 3201 根本五十義註-1 3202 根本五十義註-2 3203 中五十義註 3204 後五十義註 | 3301 根本五十經複註 3302 中五十經複註 3303 後五十經複註 | |
| 4101 有偈品 4102 因緣品 4103 蘊品 4104 六處品 4105 大品(相應部) | 4201 有偈品義注 4202 因緣品義注 4203 蘊品義注 4204 六處品義注 4205 大品義注(相應部) | 4301 有偈品複註 4302 因緣品註 4303 蘊品複註 4304 六處品複註 4305 大品複註(相應部) | |
| 5101 一集經 5102 二集經 5103 三集經 5104 四集經 5105 五集經 5106 六集經 5107 七集經 5108 八集等經 5109 九集經 5110 十集經 5111 十一集經 | 5201 一集義註 5202 二、三、四集義註 5203 五、六、七集義註 5204 八、九、十、十一集義註 | 5301 一集複註 5302 二、三、四集複註 5303 五、六、七集複註 5304 八集等複註 | |
| 6101 小誦 6102 法句經 6103 自說 6104 如是語 6105 經集 6106 天宮事 6107 餓鬼事 6108 長老偈 6109 長老尼偈 6110 譬喻-1 6111 譬喻-2 6112 諸佛史 6113 所行藏 6114 本生-1 6115 本生-2 6116 大義釋 6117 小義釋 6118 無礙解道 6119 導論 6120 彌蘭王問 6121 藏釋 | 6201 小誦義注 6202 法句義注-1 6203 法句義注-2 6204 自說義注 6205 如是語義註 6206 經集義注-1 6207 經集義注-2 6208 天宮事義注 6209 餓鬼事義注 6210 長老偈義注-1 6211 長老偈義注-2 6212 長老尼義注 6213 譬喻義注-1 6214 譬喻義注-2 6215 諸佛史義注 6216 所行藏義注 6217 本生義注-1 6218 本生義注-2 6219 本生義注-3 6220 本生義注-4 6221 本生義注-5 6222 本生義注-6 6223 本生義注-7 6224 大義釋義注 6225 小義釋義注 6226 無礙解道義注-1 6227 無礙解道義注-2 6228 導論義注 | 6301 導論複註 6302 導論明解 | |
| 7101 法集論 7102 分別論 7103 界論 7104 人施設論 7105 論事 7106 雙論-1 7107 雙論-2 7108 雙論-3 7109 發趣論-1 7110 發趣論-2 7111 發趣論-3 7112 發趣論-4 7113 發趣論-5 | 7201 法集論義註 7202 分別論義註(迷惑冰消) 7203 五部論義註 | 7301 法集論根本複註 7302 分別論根本複註 7303 五論根本複註 7304 法集論複註 7305 五論複註 7306 阿毘達摩入門 7307 攝阿毘達磨義論 7308 阿毘達摩入門古複註 7309 阿毘達摩論母 | |
1 Namo tassa bhagavato arahato sammāsambuddhassa 礼敬彼世尊、阿罗汉、正自觉者 Aṅguttaranikāye 增支部 Ekakanipāta-ṭīkā 一集复注 Ganthārambhakathā 序言 Anantañāṇaṃ [Pg.1] karuṇāniketaṃ,Namāmi nāthaṃ jitapañcamāraṃ; Dhammaṃ visuddhaṃ bhavanāsahetuṃ,Saṅghañca seṭṭhaṃ hatasabbapāpaṃ. 我今顶礼无尽智,慈悲所依,已降伏五魔之导师;能灭有因之清净法;已摧一切恶之殊胜僧伽。 Kassapaṃ taṃ mahātheraṃ, saṅghassa pariṇāyakaṃ; Dīpasmiṃ tambapaṇṇimhi, sāsanodayakārakaṃ. 我礼敬彼大长老迦叶(Kassapa),僧伽之领导者;于铜鍱岛(Tambapaṇṇi),令教法兴盛者。 Paṭipattiparādhīnaṃ, sadāraññanivāsinaṃ; Pākaṭaṃ gagane canda-maṇḍalaṃ viya sāsane. 专于行道,常住阿兰若(arañña);于教法中,如空中明月般显耀。 Saṅghassa pitaraṃ vande, vinaye suvisāradaṃ; Yaṃ nissāya vasantohaṃ, vuḍḍhippattosmi sāsane. 我礼敬僧伽之父,于律(Vinaya)极娴熟者;依彼而住,我于教法中得增长。 Anutheraṃ mahāpaññaṃ, sumedhaṃ sutivissutaṃ; Avikhaṇḍitasīlādi-parisuddhaguṇodayaṃ. 我礼敬大慧副长老(Anuthera),善慧之名普闻;戒行无缺,清净功德之源。 Bahussutaṃ satimantaṃ, dantaṃ santaṃ samāhitaṃ; Namāmi sirasā dhīraṃ, garuṃ me gaṇavācakaṃ. 我今顶礼多闻、具念、调伏、寂静、得定之智者,我僧团之导师。 Āgatāgamatakkesu[Pg.2], saddasatthanayaññusu; Yassantevāsibhikkhūsu, sāsanaṃ suppatiṭṭhitaṃ. 通达圣典与论理,精通声明(saddasattha)之义;于彼弟子比丘众中,教法得以善安立。 Yo sīhaḷindo dhitimā yasassī,Uḷārapañño nipuṇo kalāsu; Jāto visuddhe ravisomavaṃse,Mahabbalo abbhutavuttitejo. 彼僧伽罗(Sīhaḷa)王,坚毅而有名望,具广博慧,精通诸艺(kalā);生于清净日月王族,力大无穷,行止非凡,威德卓著。 Jitvārivaggaṃ atiduppasayhaṃ,Anaññasādhāraṇavikkamena; Pattābhiseko jinadhammasevī,Abhippasanno ratanattayamhi. 以无与伦比之勇武,征服极难降伏之敌群;已受灌顶,奉行胜者之法,于三宝有甚深净信。 Ciraṃ vibhinne jinasāsanasmiṃ,Paccatthike suṭṭhu viniggahetvā; Sudhaṃva sāmaggirasaṃ pasatthaṃ,Pāyesi bhikkhū parisuddhasīle. 于长久分裂之胜者教法中,善伏敌对者;令具足净戒之比丘,饮誉为甘露之和合味。 Katvā vihāre vipule ca ramme,Tatrappitenekasahassasaṅkhe; Bhikkhū asese catupaccayehi,Santappayanto suciraṃ akhaṇḍaṃ. 建造广阔庄严之精舍(vihāra),于中供养无数比丘;以四资具(catupaccaya)令众皆足,长时无有间断。 Saddhammavuddhiṃ abhikaṅkhamāno,Sayampi bhikkhū anusāsayitvā; Niyojayaṃ ganthavipassanāsu,Akāsi vuddhiṃ jinasāsanassa. 希求正法增长,亦亲自教诫比丘;于教典(gantha)与观(vipassanā)中策励,令胜者之教法增长。 Tenāhamaccantamanuggahīto,Anaññasādhāraṇasaṅgahena; Yasmā parakkantabhujavhayena,Ajjhesito bhikkhugaṇassa majjhe. 我蒙彼以无与伦比之摄受,惠我无上恩典;因彼“精进臂”(Parakkantabāhu)王,于比丘僧团中,我受劝请。 Tasmā [Pg.3] anuttānapadānamatthaṃ,Seṭṭhāya aṅguttaravaṇṇanāya; Sandassayissaṃ sakalaṃ suboddhuṃ,Nissāya pubbācariyappabhāvaṃ. 是故,我将依止古阿阇梨(pubbācariya)之德威力,为作此最胜之《增支部》释义(Aṅguttara-vaṇṇanā),阐明幽微文句之义,令一切皆易于了知。 Ganthārambhakathāvaṇṇanā 序言注释 1. Saṃvaṇṇanārambhe ratanattayaṃ namassitukāmo tassa visiṭṭhaguṇayogasandassanatthaṃ ‘‘karuṇāsītalahadaya’’ntiādimāha. Visiṭṭhaguṇayogena hi vandanārahabhāvo, vandanārahe ca katā vandanā yathādhippetamatthaṃ sādheti. Ettha ca saṃvaṇṇanārambhe ratanattayappaṇāmakaraṇappayojanaṃ tattha tattha bahudhā papañcenti ācariyā, mayaṃ pana idhādhippetameva payojanaṃ dassayissāma, tasmā saṃvaṇṇanārambhe ratanattayappaṇāmakaraṇaṃ yathāpaṭiññātasaṃvaṇṇanāya anantarāyena parisamāpanatthanti veditabbaṃ. Idameva hi payojanaṃ ācariyena idhādhippetaṃ. Tathā hi vakkhati – 1. 于释义(saṃvaṇṇanā)之始,为礼敬三宝,并为彰显其殊胜功德,故说“慈悲清凉心”等偈。实因具足殊胜功德,方堪受礼敬;而向堪受礼敬者行礼,则能成就所期之义。于此,诸阿阇梨(ācariya)对释义之初礼敬三宝之目的,已有多番阐述,然我等仅示此中意趣。是故当知,于释义之始礼敬三宝,乃为令所承诺之释义得以无障圆满。此即为作者于此所意指之目的。诚如其后所言: ‘‘Iti me pasannamatino, ratanattayavandanāmayaṃ puññaṃ; Yaṃ suvihatantarāyo, hutvā tassānubhāvenā’’ti. “我此净信心,礼敬三宝所生福;愿以此威力,善除诸障碍。” Ratanattayappaṇāmakaraṇena cettha yathāpaṭiññātasaṃvaṇṇanāya anantarāyena parisamāpanaṃ ratanattayapūjāya paññāpāṭavato, tāya paññāpāṭavañca rāgādimalavidhamanato. Vuttañhetaṃ – 于此,通过礼敬三宝,能令所承诺之释义(saṃvaṇṇanā)无障圆满,是因供养三宝能得智慧敏利,而此智慧敏利则源于能摧破贪等垢染。诚如所言: ‘‘Yasmiṃ, mahānāma, samaye ariyasāvako tathāgataṃ anussarati, nevassa tasmiṃ samaye rāgapariyuṭṭhitaṃ cittaṃ hoti, na dosapariyuṭṭhitaṃ cittaṃ hoti, na mohapariyuṭṭhitaṃ cittaṃ hoti, ujugatamevassa tasmiṃ samaye cittaṃ hotī’’tiādi (a. ni. 6.10; 11.11). “摩诃男(Mahānāma),圣弟子随念如来之时,其心不为贪所缠,不为嗔所缠,不为痴所缠,其心于尔时正直。”等。 Tasmā ratanattayapūjanena vikkhālitamalāya paññāya pāṭavasiddhi. 是故,由供养三宝,涤除垢染,智慧得以敏利成就。 Atha vā ratanattayapūjanassa paññāpadaṭṭhānasamādhihetuttā paññāpāṭavaṃ. Vuttañhi tassa samādhihetuttaṃ – 又,供养三宝乃智慧之近因与定之因,故能得智慧敏利。其为定之因,诚如所言: ‘‘Ujugatacitto [Pg.4] kho pana, mahānāma, ariyasāvako labhati atthavedaṃ, labhati dhammavedaṃ, labhati dhammūpasaṃhitaṃ pāmojjaṃ, pamuditassa pīti jāyati, pītimanassa kāyo passambhati, passaddhakāyo sukhaṃ vediyati, sukhino cittaṃ samādhiyatī’’ti (a. ni. 6.10; 11.11). “摩诃男(Mahānāma),圣弟子心正直时,得义之感受,得法之感受,得与法相应之欣悦;心欣悦者,喜由之生;意欢喜者,身得轻安;身轻安者,感受安乐;有安乐者,心得安定。” Samādhissa ca paññāya padaṭṭhānabhāvo vuttoyeva – ‘‘samāhito yathābhūtaṃ pajānātī’’ti (saṃ. ni. 3.5; 4.99; 5.1071). Tato evaṃ paṭubhūtāya paññāya paṭiññāmahattakataṃ khedamabhibhuyya anantarāyena saṃvaṇṇanaṃ samāpayissati. 定为慧之近因,此义已说,如言:“心定者,能如实知见。”(《相应部》3.5; 4.99; 5.1071) 由是,凭借如此敏利之慧,能克服因所作承诺重大而生之疲厌,无有障碍地完成此释义。 Atha vā ratanattayapūjāya āyuvaṇṇasukhabalavaḍḍhanato anantarāyena parisamāpanaṃ veditabbaṃ. Ratanattayappaṇāmena hi āyuvaṇṇasukhabalāni vaḍḍhanti. Vuttañhetaṃ – 又当知,由供养三宝,能增长寿、色、乐、力,故能无障圆满。实因礼敬三宝,寿、色、乐、力得以增长。诚如所言: ‘‘Abhivādanasīlissa, niccaṃ vuḍḍhāpacāyino; Cattāro dhammā vaḍḍhanti, āyu vaṇṇo sukhaṃ bala’’nti. (dha. pa. 109) – “好乐礼敬者,恒常敬长上;四法得增长:寿、色、乐与力。”(《法句经》109) Tato āyuvaṇṇasukhabalavuddhiyā hoteva kāriyaniṭṭhānaṃ. 是故,由寿、色、乐、力之增长,事业必能成就。 Atha vā ratanattayagāravassa paṭibhānāparihānāvahattā. Aparihānāvahañhi tīsupi ratanesu gāravaṃ. Vuttañhetaṃ – 又,于三宝恭敬,能令辩才不失。实因此恭敬能致不退。诚如所言: ‘‘Sattime, bhikkhave, aparihānīyā dhammā. Katame satta? Satthugāravatā, dhammagāravatā, saṅghagāravatā, sikkhāgāravatā, samādhigāravatā, sovacassatā, kalyāṇamittatā’’ti (a. ni. 7.34). “诸比丘,此七不退法。何等为七?谓敬师、敬法、敬僧、敬学、敬定、言语柔和、善友谊。”(《增支部》7.34) Hoteva ca tato paṭibhānāparihānena yathāpaṭiññātaparisamāpanaṃ. 由是,因辩才不失,必能如所承诺而圆满完成。 Atha vā pasādavatthūsu pūjāya puññātisayabhāvato. Vuttañhi tassā puññātisayattaṃ – 又,于净信之境行供养,能生殊胜福德。其福德之殊胜,诚如所言: ‘‘Pūjārahe pūjayato, buddhe yadi va sāvake; Papañcasamatikkante, tiṇṇasokapariddave. “供养于应供,佛陀或声闻;彼等超戏论,已渡忧悲河。 Te [Pg.5] tādise pūjayato, nibbute akutobhaye; Na sakkā puññaṃ saṅkhātuṃ, imettamapi kenacī’’ti. (dha. pa. 195-196; apa. thera 1.10.1-2); 供养如是者,寂灭无所畏;其福德难量,无人能算计。”(《法句经》195-196; 《长老譬喻》1.10.1-2) Puññātisayo ca yathādhippetaparisamāpanūpāyo. Yathāha – 殊胜福德,乃是成就所愿之方便。如言: ‘‘Esa devamanussānaṃ, sabbakāmadado nidhi; Yaṃ yadevābhipatthenti, sabbametena labbhatī’’ti. (khu. pā. 8.10); “此为天人藏,能予一切欲;凡有祈愿者,因此悉可得。”(《小诵》8.10) Upāyesu ca paṭipannassa hoteva kāriyaniṭṭhānaṃ. Ratanattayapūjā hi niratisayapuññakkhettasambuddhiyā aparimeyyappabhāvo puññātisayoti bahuvidhantarāyepi lokasannivāse antarāyanibandhanasakalasaṃkilesaviddhaṃsanāya pahoti, bhayādiupaddavañca nivāreti. Tasmā vuttaṃ – ‘‘saṃvaṇṇanārambhe ratanattayappaṇāmakaraṇaṃ yathāpaṭiññātasaṃvaṇṇanāya anantarāyena parisamāpanattha’’nti. 行于正方便者,事业必能成就。供养三宝,实为无上福田,能生无量威力之殊胜福德,是故即便身处多障世间,亦足以摧破一切障缘及诸烦恼,并能止息怖畏等灾患。是故言:“于释义之始礼敬三宝,乃为令所承诺之释义得以无障圆满。” Evañca sappayojanaṃ ratanattayavandanaṃ kattukāmo paṭhamaṃ tāva bhagavato vandanaṃ kātuṃ tammūlakattā sesaratanānaṃ ‘‘karuṇāsītalahadayaṃ…pe… gativimutta’’nti āha. Tattha yassā desanāya saṃvaṇṇanaṃ kattukāmo, sā na vinayadesanā viya karuṇāpadhānā, nāpi abhidhammadesanā viya paññāpadhānā, atha kho karuṇāpaññāpadhānāti tadubhayappadhānameva tāva sammāsambuddhassa thomanaṃ kātuṃ ‘‘karuṇāsītalahadayaṃ, paññāpajjotavihatamohatama’’nti vuttaṃ. Tattha kiratīti karuṇā, paradukkhaṃ vikkhipati apanetīti attho. Atha vā kiṇātīti karuṇā, paradukkhe sati kāruṇikaṃ hiṃsati vibādhatīti attho. Paradukkhe sati sādhūnaṃ kampanaṃ hadayakhedaṃ karotīti vā karuṇā. Atha vā kamiti sukhaṃ, taṃ rundhatīti karuṇā. Esā hi paradukkhāpanayanakāmatālakkhaṇā attasukhanirapekkhatāya kāruṇikānaṃ sukhaṃ rundhati vibandhatīti attho. Karuṇāya sītalaṃ karuṇāsītalaṃ, karuṇāsītalaṃ hadayaṃ assāti karuṇāsītalahadayo, taṃ karuṇāsītalahadayaṃ. 如此,欲行有益之三宝礼敬者,因其余二宝以世尊为根本,故先礼敬世尊,而言“悲心清凉……解脱诸趣”。于此,将欲作释义之教法,非如律教说以悲为主,亦非如阿毗达摩教说以慧为主,实乃悲慧并重。为赞颂以悲慧二者为主之正自觉者,故言“悲心清凉,慧光破除痴暗”。其中,“kirati”(驱散)故为悲(karuṇā),意谓驱散、去除他人之苦。或“kiṇāti”(伤害)故为悲,意谓他人有苦时,伤害、妨碍具悲心者。或他人有苦时,令善者心生撼动、忧恼,故为悲。或“kam”为乐,而悲能阻碍(rundhati)之。此悲以欲去除他人之苦为相,因不顾己乐,故能阻碍、束缚具悲心者之乐,此其义也。由悲而清凉,是为“悲清凉”;其心悲清凉,是为“具悲清凉心”者,即此“具悲清凉心”。 Tattha kiñcāpi paresaṃ hitopasaṃhārasukhādiaparihānicchanasabhāvatāya, byāpādāratīnaṃ ujuvipaccanīkatāya ca sattasantānagatasantāpavicchedanākārappavattiyā mettāmuditānampi cittasītalabhāvakāraṇatā upalabbhati, tathāpi dukkhāpanayanākārappavattiyā parūpatāpāsahanarasā avihiṃsabhūtā [Pg.6] karuṇā visesena bhagavato cittassa cittappassaddhi viya sītibhāvanimittanti vuttaṃ – ‘‘karuṇāsītalahadaya’’nti. Karuṇāmukhena vā mettāmuditānampi hadayasītalabhāvakāraṇatā vuttāti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Atha vā asādhāraṇañāṇavisesanibandhanabhūtā sātisayaṃ niravasesañca sabbaññutaññāṇaṃ viya savisayabyāpitāya mahākaruṇābhāvaṃ upagatā karuṇāva bhagavato atisayena hadayasītalabhāvahetūti āha – ‘‘karuṇāsītalahadaya’’nti. Atha vā satipi mettāmuditānaṃ sātisaye hadayasītibhāvanibandhanatte sakalabuddhaguṇavisesakāraṇatāya tāsampi kāraṇanti karuṇāva bhagavato ‘‘hadayasītalabhāvakāraṇa’’nti vuttā. Karuṇānidānā hi sabbepi buddhaguṇā. Karuṇānubhāvanibbāpiyamānasaṃsāradukkhasantāpassa hi bhagavato paradukkhāpanayanakāmatāya anekānipi asaṅkhyeyyāni kappānaṃ akilantarūpasseva niravasesabuddhakaradhammasambharaṇaniratassa samadhigatadhammādhipateyyassa ca sannihitesupi sattasaṅkhārasamupanītahadayūpatāpanimittesu na īsakampi cittasītibhāvassa aññathattamahosīti. Etasmiñca atthavikappe tīsupi avatthāsu bhagavato karuṇā saṅgahitāti daṭṭhabbaṃ. 于此,虽说慈与喜,因其具有希望他人获得利益安乐且不失去的自性,且与瞋、不乐直接对立,能以断除有情相续中热恼的方式而起作用,可作为令心清凉之因;然而,悲以去除痛苦的方式而起作用,以不忍他人受苦为作用,以不害为本质,故被说为是世尊之心清凉的殊胜之因,犹如心轻安(cittappassaddhi),故言“悲心清凉”。或应了知,由悲为主,亦说慈与喜为令心清凉之因。又或,悲心遍及一切所缘,已达大悲之境,犹如基于不共智之殊胜而有超胜、无余的一切知智(sabbaññutaññāṇa),故说悲心是世尊之心极度清凉之因,而言“悲心清凉”。又或,纵使慈与喜是令心极度清凉之因,然悲心是一切佛陀功德之殊胜原因,故亦是彼二者之因,因此说唯有悲心是世尊“心清凉之因”。一切佛陀功德,实以悲为因。世尊欲去除他人之苦,以悲之威力熄灭轮回苦之热恼,于无量无数劫中,为圆满一切成佛之法而精勤不倦,已证得法自在(dhammādhipateyya),纵然面对由有情诸行所引生的令心热恼之缘,其心之清凉亦丝毫不变。于此义理抉择中,应了知,于此三种状况下,世尊之悲皆被含摄。 Pajānātīti paññā, yathāsabhāvaṃ pakārehi paṭivijjhatīti attho. Paññāva ñeyyāvaraṇappahānato pakārehi dhammasabhāvāvajotanaṭṭhena pajjototi paññāpajjoto. Savāsanappahānato visesena hataṃ samugghātitaṃ vihataṃ. Paññāpajjotena vihataṃ paññāpajjotavihataṃ, muyhanti tena, sayaṃ vā muyhati, mohanamattameva vā tanti moho, avijjā. Sveva visayasabhāvappaṭicchādanato andhakārasarikkhatāya tamo viyāti mohatamo, paññāpajjotavihato mohatamo etassāti paññāpajjotavihatamohatamo, taṃ paññāpajjotavihatamohatamaṃ. Sabbesampi hi khīṇāsavānaṃ satipi paññāpajjotena avijjandhakārassa vihatabhāve saddhādhimuttehi viya diṭṭhippattānaṃ sāvakehi paccekasambuddhehi ca savāsanappahānena sammāsambuddhānaṃ kilesappahānassa viseso vijjatīti sātisayena avijjāpahānena bhagavantaṃ thomento āha – ‘‘paññāpajjotavihatamohatama’’nti. “了知”(pajānāti)故为慧(paññā),意谓如其自性而以种种方式通达。慧,因断除所知障,能以种种方式照亮诸法自性,故如光(pajjoto),是为“慧光”。连同习气(vāsanā)一并断除,故为殊胜地摧毁、根除、破灭。由慧光所破灭,是为“慧光所破”。因其而迷惑,或自迷惑,或仅是迷惑之性,是为痴(moha),即无明(avijjā)。此痴因遮蔽所缘自性,犹如黑暗,故为“痴暗”。其痴暗为慧光所破,是为“具慧光破痴暗”者,即此“具慧光破痴暗”。一切漏尽者虽皆以慧光破除无明之暗,然与信解脱者、见至之声闻及独觉相比,正自觉者连同习气一并断除,其烦恼之断除有此殊胜差别。为赞叹世尊以超胜方式断除无明,故言“慧光破除痴暗”。 Atha [Pg.7] vā antarena paropadesaṃ attano santāne accantaṃ avijjandhakāravigamassa nibbattitattā, tattha ca sabbaññutāya balesu ca vasībhāvassa samadhigatattā, parasantatiyañca dhammadesanātisayānubhāvena sammadeva tassa pavattitattā bhagavāva visesato mohatamavigamena thometabboti āha – ‘‘paññāpajjotavihatamohatama’’nti. Imasmiñca atthavikappe ‘‘paññāpajjoto’’ti padena bhagavato paṭivedhapaññā viya desanāpaññāpi sāmaññaniddesena, ekasesanayena vā saṅgahitāti daṭṭhabbaṃ. 又或,因世尊不待他人教导,于自相续中究竟灭除无明黑暗,并于彼处证得一切知及于诸力得自在;又因以说法之殊胜威力,于他相续中亦能令此(无明之灭)如实生起,故唯世尊尤应以灭除痴暗而受赞叹,而言“慧光破除痴暗”。于此义理抉择中,当知“慧光”一词,以总说(sāmaññaniddesa)或存一法(ekasesanaya)之方式,亦含摄了世尊之通达慧(paṭivedhapaññā)与教说慧(desanāpaññā)。 Atha vā bhagavato ñāṇassa ñeyyapariyantikattā sakalañeyyadhammasabhāvāvabodhanasamatthena anāvaraṇañāṇasaṅkhātena paññāpajjotena sabbañeyyadhammasabhāvacchādakassa mohandhakārassa vidhamitattā anaññasādhāraṇo bhagavato mohatamavināsoti katvā vuttaṃ – ‘‘paññāpajjotavihatamohatama’’nti. Ettha ca mohatamavidhamanante adhigatattā anāvaraṇañāṇaṃ kāraṇopacārena sasantānamohatamavidhamanaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. Abhinīhārasampattiyā savāsanappahānameva hi kilesānaṃ ñeyyāvaraṇappahānanti, parasantāne pana mohatamavidhamanassa kāraṇabhāvato anāvaraṇañāṇaṃ ‘‘mohatamavidhamana’’nti vuccatīti. 又或,因世尊之智以了知所知之边际,故能以名为无碍智(anāvaraṇañāṇa)、足以彻见一切所知法自性之慧光,摧破覆盖一切所知法自性之痴暗。此乃世尊不共之摧灭痴暗,故作是言:“慧光破除痴暗”。于此,就摧破痴暗而言,无碍智因已被证得,故以因喻果,当知即是摧破自相续之痴暗。实因宿愿圆满,连同习气断除烦恼,即是断除所知障。然于他相续中,无碍智为摧破痴暗之因,故亦被称为“摧破痴暗”。 Kiṃ pana kāraṇaṃ avijjāsamugghātoyeveko pahānasampattivasena bhagavato thomanānimittaṃ gayhati, na pana sātisayaniravasesakilesappahānanti? Tappahānavacaneneva tadekaṭṭhatāya sakalasaṃkilesagaṇasamugghātassa vuttattā. Na hi so tādiso kileso atthi, yo niravasesaavijjāpahānena na pahīyatīti. 然则,是何原因,仅取根除无明此一断除成就作为赞叹世尊之由,而非以超胜、无余地断除一切烦恼而赞叹呢?因说“断彼(无明)”,即是同义,已说根除一切杂染之聚。实无任何烦恼,能于无明被无余断除后而不断除。 Atha vā vijjā viya sakalakusaladhammasamuppattiyā, niravasesākusaladhammanibbattiyā saṃsārappavattiyā ca avijjā padhānakāraṇanti tabbighātavacanena sakalasaṃkilesagaṇasamugghāto vutto eva hotīti vuttaṃ – ‘‘paññāpajjotavihatamohatama’’nti. 又或,犹如明为一切善法生起之主因,无明亦为一切不善法生起及轮回流转之主因。是故,言“摧破彼(无明)”,即已说及根除一切杂染之聚。故言:“慧光破除痴暗”。 Narā ca amarā ca narāmarā, saha narāmarehīti sanarāmaro, sanarāmaro ca so loko cāti sanarāmaraloko, tassa garūti sanarāmaralokagaru, taṃ sanarāmaralokagaruṃ. Etena devamanussānaṃ viya tadavasiṭṭhasattānampi yathārahaṃ guṇavisesāvahatāya bhagavato upakārataṃ [Pg.8] dasseti. Na cettha padhānappadhānabhāvo codetabbo. Añño hi saddakkamo, añño atthakkamo. Īdisesu hi samāsapadesu padhānampi appadhānaṃ viya niddisīyati yathā ‘‘sarājikāya parisāyā’’ti (cūḷava. 336). Kāmañcettha sattasaṅkhārabhājanavasena tividho loko, garubhāvassa pana adhippetattā garukaraṇasamatthasseva yujjanato sattalokassa vasena attho gahetabbo. So hi lokīyanti ettha puññapāpāni tabbipāko cāti ‘‘loko’’ti vuccati. Amaraggahaṇena cettha upapattidevā adhippetā. 人(narā)与天人(amarā),即人天(narāmarā);与人天俱,故为俱人天(sanarāmara);既是俱人天,又是世间,故为俱人天世间(sanarāmaraloka);其师,即人天世间之师,指向那位人天世间之师。此句显示,世尊不仅利益天人,亦依其余众生各自的情况,因其殊胜功德而饶益他们。于此,不应计较主次关系,盖词序与义序有别。在此类复合词中,主要者亦可如非主要者般被指陈,例如“与王俱之会众(sarājikāya parisāyā)”。诚然,依众生、行、器之分,世间有三种,然此处意在表达“师”(garu)之义,且此义仅适用于能行尊敬者,故应取“众生世间”之义。因为在此中,善恶业及其果报被视为“世间”(loka),故称“世间”。此处所取之“天人”,意指化生天(upapattidevā)。 Atha vā samūhattho lokasaddo samudāyavasena lokīyati paññāpīyatīti. Saha narehīti sanarā, sanarā ca te amarā cāti sanarāmarā, tesaṃ lokoti sanarāmaralokoti purimanayeneva yojetabbaṃ. Amarasaddena cettha visuddhidevāpi saṅgayhanti. Tepi hi maraṇābhāvato paramatthato amarā. Narāmarānaṃyeva ca gahaṇaṃ ukkaṭṭhaniddesavasena yathā ‘‘satthā devamanussāna’’nti (dī. ni. 1.157). Tathā hi sabbānatthapariharaṇapubbaṅgamāya niravasesahitasukhavidhānatapparāya niratisayāya payogasampattiyā sadevamanussāya pajāya accantūpakāritāya aparimitanirupamappabhāvaguṇavisesasamaṅgitāya ca sabbasattuttamo bhagavā aparimāṇāsu lokadhātūsu aparimāṇānaṃ sattānaṃ uttamagāravaṭṭhānaṃ. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘sanarāmaralokagaru’’nti. 又或者,“世间”(loka)一词有集合之义,因其由聚集而被认知、安立。与人俱,故为俱人(sanarā);彼等俱人亦是天人,故为俱人天(sanarāmarā);彼等之世间,即人天世间(sanarāmaraloka),应依前述方法组合。此处以“天人”(amara)一词亦含摄清净天(visuddhidevā),因彼等无有死亡,故于胜义中为“不死”(amarā)。而仅取人天,是为作殊胜指陈,如言“天人之师(satthā devamanussānaṃ)”。诚然,世尊以远离一切无义为先,致力于成办无余之利益安乐,具足无上加行圆满,对包含天人在内之众生极为饶益,具备无量、无譬、无上之威力与殊胜功德,于一切众生中最为第一。于无量世界界(lokadhātu)中,世尊为无量众生无上崇敬之处。是故说为“人天世间之师”。 Sobhanaṃ gataṃ gamanaṃ etassāti sugato. Bhagavato hi veneyyajanūpasaṅkamanaṃ ekantena tesaṃ hitasukhanipphādanato sobhanaṃ, tathā lakkhaṇānubyañjanappaṭimaṇḍitarūpakāyatāya dutavilambitakhalitānukaḍḍhananippīḷanukkuṭikakuṭilākuṭilatādi- dosarahitamavahasitarājahaṃsavasabhavāraṇamigarājagamanaṃ kāyagamanaṃ ñāṇagamanañca vipulanimmalakaruṇāsativīriyādiguṇavisesasahitamabhinīhārato yāva mahābodhi anavajjatāya sobhanamevāti. Atha vā sayambhuñāṇena sakalampi lokaṃ pariññābhisamayavasena parijānanto ñāṇena sammā gato avagatoti sugato, tathā lokasamudayaṃ pahānābhisamayavasena pajahanto anuppattidhammataṃ āpādento sammā gato atītoti sugato, lokanirodhaṃ nibbānaṃ sacchikiriyābhisamayavasena sammā gato adhigatoti [Pg.9] sugato, lokanirodhagāminipaṭipadaṃ bhāvanābhisamayavasena sammā gato paṭipannoti sugato. ‘‘Sotāpattimaggena ye kilesā pahīnā, te kilese na puneti na pacceti na paccāgacchatīti sugato’’tiādinā (cūḷani. mettagūmāṇavapucchāniddeso 27) nayena ayamattho vibhāvetabbo. Atha vā sundaraṃ ṭhānaṃ sammāsambodhiṃ, nibbānameva vā gato adhigatoti sugato, yasmā vā bhūtaṃ tacchaṃ atthasaṃhitaṃ veneyyānaṃ yathārahaṃ kālayuttameva ca dhammaṃ bhāsati, tasmā sammā gadatīti sugato, da-kārassa ta-kāraṃ katvā. Iti sobhanagamanatādīhi sugato, taṃ sugataṃ. “善逝”(Sugata)者,谓其所行(gataṃ)善妙(sobhanaṃ)。世尊为调伏众生而前往,此行能究竟成办彼等之利益安乐,故是善妙;其色身由相好(lakkhaṇānubyañjana)所庄严,身行远离迟缓、摇摆、拖曳、僵硬、弯曲等过失,步态如鹅王、牛王、象王、狮子王,故是善妙;其智行亦然,具足广大清净之悲、念、精进等殊胜功德,从发心乃至大菩提(mahābodhi)皆无过失,故是善妙。又或者,以自生智,通过遍知通达(pariññā-abhisamaya)而了知一切世间,是善(sammā)去(gato),故为善逝;通过断除通达(pahāna-abhisamaya)而舍弃世间集(lokasamudaya),令其不再生起,是善去,故为善逝;通过现证通达(sacchikiriya-abhisamaya)而证得世间灭(lokanirodha)——涅槃,是善去,故为善逝;通过修习通达(bhāvanā-abhisamaya)而行于趣向世间灭之道(lokanirodhagāminī-paṭipadā),是善去,故为善逝。此义当依《小义释》(Cūḷaniddesa)所说:‘以预流道(sotāpattimagga)所断之诸烦恼,彼等烦恼不再来、不返回、不复归,故为善逝’等理趣而阐明。又或者,已行至(gato)善妙(sundaraṃ)之处,即正等觉(sammāsambodhi)或涅槃,故为善逝。又或者,因其所说之法真实、不虚、有益,且对所化众生应机、应时,故为善说(sammā gadati),将da音转为ta音,亦成“善逝”(sugata)。如是,因其行善妙等而为善逝。向彼善逝(致敬)。 Puññapāpakammehi upapajjanavasena gantabbato gatiyo, upapattibhavavisesā. Tā pana nirayādivasena pañcavidhā. Tāhi sakalassapi bhavagāmikammassa ariyamaggādhigamena avipākārahabhāvakaraṇena nivattitattā bhagavā pañcahipi gatīhi suṭṭhu mutto visaṃyuttoti āha – ‘‘gativimutta’’nti. Etena bhagavato katthacipi gatiyā apariyāpannataṃ dasseti, yato bhagavā ‘‘devātidevo’’ti vuccati. Tenevāha – “趣”(gati)者,谓由善恶业(puññapāpakamma)而当往生之处,是受生有(upapattibhava)的差别。彼等依地狱(niraya)等而有五种。因世尊已证得圣道(ariyamagga),令所有趣向于有(bhava)的业(kamma)皆不得生果而止息,故世尊已于五趣善得解脱(suṭṭhu mutto)、不相应(visaṃyutta),是故说为“于诸趣解脱”(gativimutta)。此表明世尊不摄于任何一趣,是故被称为“天中天”(devātideva)。因此说: ‘‘Yena devūpapatyassa, gandhabbo vā vihaṅgamo; Yakkhattaṃ yena gaccheyyaṃ, manussattañca abbaje; Te mayhaṃ āsavā khīṇā, viddhastā vinaḷīkatā’’ti. (a. ni. 4.36); “凡能令我受天身(devūpatti),或为乾闼婆(gandhabba)、飞鸟(vihaṅgama);凡能令我得夜叉(yakkha)性,或往为人(manussatta)者——我彼诸漏(āsava)已尽,已被摧毁、根除。”(《增支部》A.N. 4.36) Taṃtaṃgatisaṃvattanikānañhi kammakilesānaṃ aggamaggena bodhimūleyeva suppahīnattā natthi bhagavato gatipariyāpannatāti accantameva bhagavā sabbabhavayonigativiññāṇaṭṭhitisattāvāsasattanikāyehi suparimutto, taṃ gativimuttaṃ. Vandeti namāmi, thomemīti vā attho. 诚然,彼等导致流转于各趣(gati)的业(kamma)与烦恼(kilesa),已于菩提树下为世尊以无上道(aggamagga)善断,故世尊不摄于任何趣。世尊已究竟、完全地解脱于一切有(bhava)、生(yoni)、趣(gati)、识住(viññāṇaṭṭhiti)、有情居(sattāvāsa)及众生部类(sattanikāya)。向彼于诸趣解脱者(gativimutta)(致敬)。“我礼敬”(Vandeti)者,意谓“我敬礼”(namāmi)或“我赞叹”(thomemi)。 Atha vā gativimuttanti anupādisesanibbānadhātuppattiyā bhagavantaṃ thometi. Ettha hi dvīhi ākārehi bhagavato thomanā veditabbā attahitasampattito parahitappaṭipattito ca. Tesu attahitasampatti anāvaraṇañāṇādhigamato savāsanānaṃ sabbesaṃ kilesānaṃ accantappahānato anupādisesanibbānappattito ca veditabbā, parahitappaṭipatti lābhasakkārādinirapekkhacittassa sabbadukkhaniyyānikadhammadesanato viruddhesupi niccaṃ hitajjhāsayato ñāṇaparipākakālāgamanato ca. Sā panettha āsayato payogato ca duvidhā, parahitappaṭipatti tividhā ca, attahitasampatti [Pg.10] pakāsitā hoti. Kathaṃ? ‘‘Karuṇāsītalahadaya’’nti etena āsayato parahitappaṭipatti, sammāgadanatthena sugatasaddena payogato parahitappaṭipatti, ‘‘paññāpajjotavihatamohatamaṃ gativimutta’’nti etehi catusaccasampaṭivedhanatthena ca sugatasaddena tividhāpi attahitasampatti, avasiṭṭhena ‘‘paññāpajjotavihatamohatama’’nti etena cāpi attahitasampatti parahitappaṭipatti pakāsitā hotīti. 又或者,“于诸趣解脱”(gativimutta)一句,是赞叹世尊证得无余依涅槃界(anupādisesa-nibbānadhātu)。于此当知,赞叹世尊有二种方式:自利成就(attahitasampatti)与利他行持(parahitappaṭipatti)。其中,自利成就当知为:证得无碍智(anāvaraṇañāṇa)、连同习气(savāsana)彻底断尽一切烦恼(kilesa)、以及证得无余依涅槃(anupādisesa-nibbāna)。利他行持则为:心于利养、恭敬等无所希求,宣说能出离一切苦之法,纵对怨敌亦常怀利益之心,并等待彼等智慧成熟之时机。于此,利他行持依发心(āsaya)与实行(payoga)而有二种,自利成就则开显为三种。云何?以“悲心清凉”(karuṇāsītalahadayaṃ)一句,显示依发心之利他行持;以“善逝”(sugata)一词“善说”之义,显示依实行之利他行持。以“智慧明灯破除痴暗”(paññāpajjotavihatamohatamaṃ)与“于诸趣解脱”(gativimuttaṃ)此二句,以及“善逝”(sugata)一词“通达四谛”之义,显示三种自利成就。而以“智慧明灯破除痴暗”一句,亦同时开显自利成就与利他行持。 Atha vā tīhi ākārehi bhagavato thomanā veditabbā hetuto, phalato, upakārato ca. Tattha hetu mahākaruṇā, sā paṭhamapadena dassitā. Phalaṃ catubbidhaṃ ñāṇasampadā, pahānasampadā, ānubhāvasampadā, rūpakāyasampadā cāti. Tāsu ñāṇappahānasampadā dutiyapadena saccappaṭivedhanatthena ca sugatasaddena pakāsitā honti, ānubhāvasampadā tatiyapadena, rūpakāyasampadā yathāvuttakāyagamanasobhanatthena sugatasaddena lakkhaṇānubyañjanapāripūriyā vinā tadabhāvato. Upakāro anantaraṃ abāhiraṃ karitvā tividhayānamukhena vimuttidhammadesanā. So sammāgadanatthena sugatasaddena pakāsito hotīti veditabbaṃ. 又或者,当知赞叹世尊有三种方式:从因、从果、从利益。其中,大悲(mahākaruṇā)是因,由第一句(paṭhamapada)显示。果有四种:智成就(ñāṇasampadā)、断成就(pahānasampadā)、威力成就(ānubhāvasampadā)、色身成就(rūpakāyasampadā)。其中,智成就与断成就由第二句(dutiyapada)及“善逝”(sugata)一词“通达圣谛”之义所开显;威力成就由第三句(tatiyapada)开显;色身成就由“善逝”(sugata)一词“身行善妙”之义所开显,因为若无相好(lakkhaṇānubyañjana)圆满,则无此善妙身行。利益(upakāra)则是指(世尊)亲身无间地以三乘(tividhayāna)法门宣说解脱之法。当知此义由“善逝”(sugata)一词“善说”之义所开显。 Tattha ‘‘karuṇāsītalahadaya’’nti etena sammāsambodhiyā mūlaṃ dasseti. Mahākaruṇāsañcoditamānaso hi bhagavā saṃsārapaṅkato sattānaṃ samuddharaṇatthaṃ katābhinīhāro anupubbena pāramiyo pūretvā anuttaraṃ sammāsambodhiṃ adhigatoti karuṇā sammāsambodhiyā mūlaṃ. ‘‘Paññāpajjotavihatamohatama’’nti etena sammāsambodhiṃ dasseti. Anāvaraṇañāṇapadaṭṭhānañhi maggañāṇaṃ, maggañāṇapadaṭṭhānañca anāvaraṇañāṇaṃ ‘‘sammāsambodhī’’ti vuccatīti. Sammāgamanatthena sugatasaddena sammāsambodhiyā paṭipattiṃ dasseti līnuddhaccapatiṭṭhānāyūhanakāmasukhallikattakilamathānuyogasassatucchedābhinivesādiantadvayarahitāya karuṇāpaññāpariggahitāya majjhimāya paṭipattiyā pakāsanato sugatasaddassa. Itarehi sammāsambodhiyā padhānappadhānabhedaṃ payojanaṃ dasseti. Saṃsāramahoghato sattasantāraṇañhettha padhānaṃ payojanaṃ, tadaññamappadhānaṃ. Tesu padhānena parahitappaṭipattiṃ dasseti, itarena attahitasampattiṃ. Tadubhayena attahitāya [Pg.11] paṭipannādīsu catūsu puggalesu bhagavato catutthapuggalabhāvaṃ dasseti. Tena ca anuttaradakkhiṇeyyabhāvaṃ uttamavandaneyyabhāvaṃ attano ca vandanakiriyāya khettaṅgatabhāvaṃ dasseti. 此处,以“具慈悲清凉心”一句,显示正等觉的根本。因为世尊被大悲心所驱使,为救度众生脱离轮回泥沼而立下誓愿,次第圆满诸波罗蜜,证得无上正等觉,故慈悲是正等觉的根本。以“以智慧明灯破除无明黑暗”一句,显示正等觉本身。道智以无碍智为近因,而以道智为近因的无碍智,被称为“正等觉”。以“善逝”之名,因其“正确行往”之义,显示了正等觉的行道,此名宣示了由慈悲与智慧所摄持、远离沉滞与掉举、耽于欲乐与自我折磨、常见与断见等二边的中道。以其余诸名,则显示了正等觉主要与次要的功用。从轮回大洪流中救度众生,是其主要功用;其余则为次要。其中,主要功用显示了利他之行,次要功用显示了自利成就。通过此二者,显示了世尊在四种补特伽罗中,是为第四种。由此,显示了世尊是无上福田、至上应礼敬者,并显示了自身的礼敬行为是以世尊为殊胜福田。 Ettha ca karuṇāgahaṇena lokiyesu mahaggatabhāvappattāsādhāraṇaguṇadīpanato bhagavato sabbalokiyaguṇasampatti dassitā hoti, paññāgahaṇena sabbaññutaññāṇapadaṭṭhānamaggañāṇadīpanato sabbalokuttaraguṇasampatti. Tadubhayaggahaṇasiddho hi attho ‘‘sanarāmaralokagaru’’ntiādinā papañcīyatīti. Karuṇāgahaṇena ca upagamanaṃ nirupakkilesaṃ dasseti, paññāgahaṇena apagamanaṃ. Tathā karuṇāgahaṇena lokasamaññānurūpaṃ bhagavato pavattiṃ dasseti lokavohāravisayattā karuṇāya, paññāgahaṇena samaññāya anatidhāvanaṃ. Sabhāvānavabodhena hi dhammānaṃ samaññaṃ atidhāvitvā sattādiparāmasanaṃ hotīti. Tathā karuṇāgahaṇena mahākaruṇāsamāpattivihāraṃ dasseti, paññāgahaṇena tīsu kālesu appaṭihatañāṇaṃ catusaccañāṇaṃ, catupaṭisambhidāñāṇaṃ, catuvesārajjañāṇaṃ. Karuṇāgahaṇena mahākaruṇāsamāpattiñāṇassa gahitattā sesāsādhāraṇañāṇāni, cha abhiññā, aṭṭhasu parisāsu akampanañāṇāni, dasa balāni, cuddasa buddhañāṇāni, soḷasa ñāṇacariyā, aṭṭhārasa buddhadhammā, catucattālīsa ñāṇavatthūni, sattasattati ñāṇavatthūnīti evamādīnaṃ anekesaṃ paññāpabhedānaṃ vasena ñāṇacāraṃ dasseti. Tathā karuṇāgahaṇena caraṇasampattiṃ, paññāgahaṇena vijjāsampattiṃ. Karuṇāgahaṇena attādhipatitā, paññāgahaṇena dhammādhipatitā. Karuṇāgahaṇena lokanāthabhāvo, paññāgahaṇena attanāthabhāvo. Tathā karuṇāgahaṇena pubbakāribhāvo, paññāgahaṇena kataññutā. Tathā karuṇāgahaṇena aparantapatā, paññāgahaṇena anattantapatā. Karuṇāgahaṇena vā buddhakaradhammasiddhi, paññāgahaṇena buddhabhāvasiddhi. Tathā karuṇāgahaṇena paresaṃ tāraṇaṃ, paññāgahaṇena sayaṃtaraṇaṃ. Tathā karuṇāgahaṇena sabbasattesu anuggahacittatā, paññāgahaṇena sabbadhammesu virattacittatā dassitā hoti. 此处,以悲心的把握显示了世尊成就世间广大境界的殊胜功德,以智慧的把握显示了一切知智的立足处——道智,从而显示了所有出世间功德的圆满。这两者的把握所成就的意义,就用“人天导师”等词语来详细阐述。以悲心的把握显示了无染的亲近,以智慧的把握显示了远离。同样地,以悲心的把握显示了世尊依照世间的共识而行动,因为悲心是世间通用的;以智慧的把握显示了不超越共识。如果不了解诸法的自性,就超越共识,就会陷入对众生等的执着。同样地,以悲心的把握显示了大悲等至,以智慧的把握显示了在过去、现在、未来三世中无碍的智慧,即四圣谛智、四无碍解智、四无畏智。因为悲心的把握已经包含了大悲等至智,剩余的殊胜智慧,比如六神通、八众中不动摇智、十力、十四佛陀智、十六智行、十八佛法、四十四智事、七十七智事等等,都通过无数智慧的差别来显示智慧的运行。同样地,以悲心的把握显示了行圆满,以智慧的把握显示了明圆满。以悲心的把握显示了自依止,以智慧的把握显示了法依止。以悲心的把握显示了世间依怙,以智慧的把握显示了自依怙。同样地,以悲心的把握显示了先行者,以智慧的把握显示了感恩。同样地,以悲心的把握显示了不害他,以智慧的把握显示了不害自。或者说,以悲心的把握是成佛之法的成就,以智慧的把握是佛陀果位之成就。同样地,以悲心的把握是度他,以智慧的把握是自度。同样地,以悲心的把握显示了于一切有情生起饶益心,以智慧的把握显示了于一切法离染心。 Sabbesañca buddhaguṇānaṃ karuṇā ādi tannidānabhāvato, paññā pariyosānaṃ tato uttarikaraṇīyābhāvato. Iti ādipariyosānadassanena [Pg.12] sabbe buddhaguṇā dassitā honti. Tathā karuṇāgahaṇena sīlakkhandhapubbaṅgamo samādhikkhandho dassito hoti. Karuṇānidānañhi sīlaṃ tato pāṇātipātādiviratippavattito, sā ca jhānattayasampayoginīti. Paññāvacanena paññākkhandho. Sīlañca sabbesaṃ buddhaguṇānaṃ ādi, samādhi majjhe, paññā pariyosānanti evampi ādimajjhapariyosānakalyāṇā sabbe buddhaguṇā dassitā honti nayato dassitattā. Eso eva hi niravasesato buddhaguṇānaṃ dassanupāyo, yadidaṃ nayaggahaṇaṃ, aññathā ko nāma samattho bhagavato guṇe anupadaṃ niravasesato dassetuṃ? Tenevāha – 一切佛陀功德中,悲是开端,因为悲是功德之因;智慧是终结,因为智慧之后没有更进一步的所作。这样通过展示开始和结束,就显示了一切佛陀的功德。同样,以悲的把握,就显示了以戒蕴为前导的定蕴。因为戒以悲为因,由此才会产生远离杀生等恶行的行为,并且此悲心与三禅相应。说到智慧,即是慧蕴。戒是一切佛陀功德的开始,定是中间,慧是结尾,这样始中终善,就显示了一切佛陀的功德,因为这是以理路展示的。这正是全面展示佛陀功德的方法,也就是这种把握理路的方式,否则谁能够无余地逐一展示世尊的功德呢?因此说—— ‘‘Buddhopi buddhassa bhaṇeyya vaṇṇaṃ,Kappampi ce aññamabhāsamāno; Khīyetha kappo ciradīghamantare,Vaṇṇo na khīyetha tathāgatassā’’ti. (dī. ni. aṭṭha. 1.304; 3.141; ma. ni. aṭṭha. 2.425; udā. aṭṭha. 53; bu. vaṃ. aṭṭha. 4.4; apa. aṭṭha. 2.7.parappasādakattheraapadānavaṇṇanā); 纵使佛陀赞佛陀,纵经一劫复演说;劫寿穷尽时已逝,如来功德说不尽。 Teneva ca āyasmatā sāriputtattherenapi buddhaguṇaparicchedanaṃ pati anuyuttena ‘‘no hetaṃ, bhante’’ti paṭikkhipitvā ‘‘apica me, bhante, dhammanvayo vidito’’ti vuttaṃ. 即使是具寿舍利弗长老,在衡量佛陀功德时,也曾拒绝说“世尊,此非我所能”,而是说:“世尊,我已通达法随顺。” 2. Evaṃ saṅkhepena sakalasabbaññuguṇehi bhagavantaṃ abhitthavitvā idāni saddhammaṃ thometuṃ ‘‘buddhopī’’tiādimāha. Tattha buddhoti kattuniddeso. Buddhabhāvanti kammaniddeso. Bhāvetvā sacchikatvāti ca pubbakālakiriyāniddeso. Yanti aniyamato kammaniddeso. Upagatoti aparakālakiriyāniddeso. Vandeti kiriyāniddeso. Tanti niyamanaṃ. Dhammanti vandanakiriyāya kammaniddeso. Gatamalaṃ anuttaranti ca tabbisesanaṃ. 2. 像这样以简略的方式,用一切遍知功德赞叹世尊之后,现在为了赞叹正法,接着说了“佛亦”等。在这里,“佛”是主格指称;“佛果”是宾格指称;“修习证得”是前时动词指称;“凡”是不定宾格指称;“到达”是后时动词指称;“礼敬”是动词指称;“彼”是定指;“法”是礼敬动词的宾格指称;“离垢”与“无上”则是它的修饰语。 Tattha buddhasaddassa tāva ‘‘bujjhitā saccānīti buddho, bodhetā pajāyāti buddho’’tiādinā (mahāni. 192; cūḷani. pārāyanatthutigāthāniddeso 97; paṭi. ma. 1.162) niddesanayena attho veditabbo. Atha vā savāsanāya aññāṇaniddāya accantavigamato, buddhiyā vā vikasitabhāvato buddhavāti buddho jāgaraṇavikasanatthavasena. Atha vā kassacipi ñeyyadhammassa anavabuddhassa abhāvena ñeyyavisesassa kammabhāvena aggahaṇato kammavacanicchāya abhāvena avagamanatthavaseneva [Pg.13] kattuniddeso labbhatīti buddhavāti buddho yathā ‘‘dikkhito na dadātī’’ti. Atthato pana pāramitāparibhāvito sayambhuñāṇena saha vāsanāya vihataviddhaṃsitaniravasesakileso mahākaruṇāsabbaññutaññāṇādiaparimeyyaguṇagaṇādhāro khandhasantāno buddho. Yathāha – 此处“佛陀”一词,应当首先根据“觉悟诸谛者是佛陀,令众生觉悟者是佛陀”等等的解释方式来理解其含义(见《大义释》192;《小义释·彼岸道赞偈释》97;《无碍解道》1.162)。或者说,因为彻底灭尽了连同习气的无明眠,或者因为智慧的开展故,所以称为佛陀,从觉醒与开展之义而言。又或者说,因为没有任何应知法未被觉悟,由于没有将殊胜所缘作为宾格来把握,因为不存在表示宾格的词语之期望,所以仅仅从理解之义而言,可获得主格指称,如同“受戒者不给予”一般,佛陀亦然。但就真实意义而言,佛陀是波罗蜜圆满,以自生智故,连同习气,无余地摧毁、破坏、灭尽了烦恼,是具有大悲、一切知智等无量功德的蕴相续。正如所说—— ‘‘Buddhoti yo so bhagavā sayambhū anācariyako pubbe ananussutesu dhammesu sāmaṃ saccāni abhisambujjhi, tattha ca sabbaññutaṃ patto balesu ca vasībhāva’’nti (mahāni. 192; cūḷani. pārāyanatthutigāthāniddeso 97; paṭi. ma. 1.161). “所谓佛陀,即是彼世尊,自证成觉,无有师承,于往昔未闻之法中,亲自现证诸谛,并于其中证得一切知智,于诸力中获得自在。” Api-saddo sambhāvane. Tena ‘‘evaṃ guṇavisesayutto sopi nāma bhagavā’’ti vakkhamānaguṇadhamme sambhāvanaṃ dīpeti. Buddhabhāvanti sammāsambodhiṃ. Bhāvetvāti uppādetvā vaḍḍhetvā ca. Sacchikatvāti paccakkhaṃ katvā. Upagatoti patto, adhigatoti attho. Etassa buddhabhāvanti etena sambandho. Gatamalanti vigatamalaṃ, niddosanti attho. Vandeti paṇamāmi, thomemi vā. Anuttaranti uttararahitaṃ, lokuttaranti attho. Dhammanti yathānusiṭṭhaṃ paṭipajjamāne apāyato ca saṃsārato ca apatamāne katvā dhāretīti dhammo. Ayañhettha saṅkhepattho – evaṃ vividhaguṇagaṇasamannāgato buddhopi bhagavā yaṃ ariyamaggasaṅkhātaṃ dhammaṃ bhāvetvā, phalanibbānaṃ pana sacchikatvā anuttaraṃ sammāsambodhiṃ adhigato, tamevaṃ buddhānampi buddhabhāvahetubhūtaṃ sabbadosamalarahitaṃ attano uttaritarābhāvena anuttaraṃ paṭivedhasaddhammaṃ namāmīti. Pariyattisaddhammassapi tappakāsanattā idha saṅgaho daṭṭhabbo. “亦”字表可能义。由此“如是具足殊胜功德者,彼即名为世尊”一句,彰显对所述功德的推测。“佛果”指正等觉。“修习”即生起与增长。“现证”谓亲证。“达成”即获得,其义同“证得”。此与“佛果”相关联。“离垢”即远离污垢,“无过”为其义。“礼敬”即顶礼或赞叹。“无上”即无有更胜,“出世间”为其义。“法”谓如教奉行者,能令其不堕恶趣与轮回,守护修行者,故名为法。此处要义概说如下:如是具足种种功德的佛陀、世尊,修习圣道之法,现证道果与涅槃,证得无上正等觉。我今顶礼此能为诸佛成佛之因、远离一切过患与污垢、因自身无与伦比而成为无上的通达正法。于此亦当知包含教法,因其能开显彼义故。 Atha vā ‘‘abhidhammanayasamuddaṃ adhigañchi, tīṇi piṭakāni sammasī’’ti ca aṭṭhakathāyaṃ vuttattā pariyattidhammassapi sacchikiriyāsammasanapariyāyo labbhatīti sopi idha vutto evāti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Tathā ‘‘yaṃ dhammaṃ bhāvetvā sacchikatvā’’ti ca vuttattā buddhakaradhammabhūtāhi pāramitāhi saha pubbabhāge adhisīlasikkhādayopi idha dhammasaddena saṅgahitāti veditabbā. Tāpi hi vigatappaṭipakkhatāya gatamalā, anaññasādhāraṇatāya anuttarā cāti. Tathā hi sattānaṃ sakalavaṭṭadukkhanissaraṇāya katamahābhinīhāro mahākaruṇādhivāsanapesalajjhāsayo [Pg.14] paññāvisesapariyodātanimmalānaṃ dānadamasaññamādīnaṃ uttamadhammānaṃ satasahassādhikāni kappānaṃ cattāri asaṅkhyeyyāni sakkaccaṃ nirantaraṃ niravasesānaṃ bhāvanāpaccakkhakaraṇehi kammādīsu adhigatavasībhāvo acchariyācinteyyamahānubhāvo adhisīlaadhicittānaṃ paramukkaṃsapāramippatto bhagavā paccayākāre catuvīsatikoṭisatasahassamukhena mahāvajirañāṇaṃ pesetvā anuttaraṃ sammāsambodhiṃ abhisambuddhoti. 或者,如义注中所说“他通达了阿毗达摩理趣海,并省察三藏”,因此应知,教法的现证与省察之理路也包含在此处。同样地,由于有“通过修习并证悟法”的说法,因此应知,与成佛之法——波罗蜜(pāramitā)一起,前阶段的增上戒学(adhisīlasikkhā)等也包含在此处的“法”字中。这些法因远离对立而离垢,因无与伦比而无上。诚然,世尊为使有情脱离一切轮回之苦,发起大愿,安住于大悲,具有柔和的意乐,在四阿僧祇劫(asaṅkhyeyya)又十万大劫中,通过恭敬、持续、无余地修习与亲身实践,于业等方面获得自在,具有不可思议的广大威力,增上戒与增上心达到最高圆满,于缘起(paccayākāra)方面,以二十四万亿种方式放出大金刚智,证得无上正等正觉。 Ettha ca ‘‘bhāvetvā’’ti etena vijjāsampadāya dhammaṃ thometi, ‘‘sacchikatvā’’ti etena vimuttisampadāya. Tathā paṭhamena jhānasampadāya, dutiyena vimokkhasampadāya. Paṭhamena vā samādhisampadāya, dutiyena samāpattisampadāya. Atha vā paṭhamena khayañāṇabhāvena, dutiyena anuppādañāṇabhāvena. Paṭhamena vā vijjūpamatāya, dutiyena vajirūpamatāya. Purimena vā virāgasampattiyā, dutiyena nirodhasampattiyā. Tathā paṭhamena niyyānabhāvena, dutiyena nissaraṇabhāvena. Paṭhamena vā hetubhāvena, dutiyena asaṅkhatabhāvena. Paṭhamena vā dassanabhāvena, dutiyena vivekabhāvena. Paṭhamena vā adhipatibhāvena, dutiyena amatabhāvena dhammaṃ thometi. Atha vā ‘‘yaṃ dhammaṃ bhāvetvā buddhabhāvaṃ upagato’’ti etena svākkhātatāya dhammaṃ thometi, ‘‘sacchikatvā’’ti etena sandiṭṭhikatāya. Tathā purimena akālikatāya, pacchimena ehipassikatāya. Purimena vā opaneyyikatāya, pacchimena paccattaṃ veditabbatāya dhammaṃ thometi. ‘‘Gatamala’’nti iminā saṃkilesābhāvadīpanena dhammassa parisuddhataṃ dasseti, ‘‘anuttara’’nti etena aññassa visiṭṭhassa abhāvadīpanena vipulaparipuṇṇataṃ. Paṭhamena vā pahānasampadaṃ dhammassa dasseti, dutiyena pabhavasampadaṃ. Bhāvetabbatāya vā dhammassa gatamalabhāvo yojetabbo. Bhāvanāguṇena hi so dosānaṃ samugghātako hotīti. Sacchikātabbabhāvena anuttarabhāvo yojetabbo. Sacchikiriyānibbattito hi taduttarikaraṇīyābhāvato anaññasādhāraṇatāya anuttaroti. Tathā ‘‘bhāvetvā’’ti etena saha pubbabhāgasīlādīhi sekkhā sīlasamādhipaññākkhandhā dassitā honti. ‘‘Sacchikatvā’’ti etena saha asaṅkhatāya dhātuyā asekkhā sīlasamādhipaññākkhandhā dassitā hontīti. 此处,“修习”(bhāvetvā)一词以明成就赞叹法,“现证”(sacchikatvā)一词以解脱成就赞叹法。同样,前者以禅定成就,后者以解脱成就。前者以等持成就,后者以等至成就。或者,前者以尽智,后者以无生智。前者以电光喻,后者以金刚喻。前者以离贪成就,后者以灭尽成就。同样,前者以出离,后者以解脱。或者,前者以因,后者以无为。或者,前者以见,后者以远离。或者,前者以增上,后者以不死赞叹法。或者说,“修习此法而证得佛果”,以此善说性赞叹法;“现证”一词以此现见性赞叹。同样,前者以无时性,后者以来见性。或者,前者以引导性,后者以各自证知性赞叹法。“离垢”(gatamala)一词通过显示没有烦恼,来彰显法的清净;“无上”(anuttara)一词通过显示没有其他更殊胜者,来彰显其广大圆满。或者,前者显示法的断成就,后者显示法的生起成就。就法是应修习的性质而言,“离垢”应与之相应,因为通过修习的力量,它能根除各种过患。就法是应现证的性质而言,“无上”应与之相应,因为由现证而生,再无更高可为,且不与他共,故为无上。同样,“修习”一词,连同之前的戒等,显示了有学的戒、定、慧蕴;“现证”一词,连同无为界,显示了无学的戒、定、慧蕴。 3. Evaṃ [Pg.15] saṅkhepeneva sabbadhammaguṇehi saddhammaṃ abhitthavitvā idāni ariyasaṅghaṃ thometuṃ ‘‘sugatassā’’tiādimāha. Tattha sugatassāti sambandhaniddeso. ‘‘Tassa puttāna’’nti etena sambandho. Orasānanti puttavisesanaṃ. Mārasenamathanānanti orasaputtabhāve kāraṇaniddeso tena kilesappahānameva bhagavato orasaputtabhāve kāraṇaṃ anujānātīti dasseti. Aṭṭhannanti gaṇanaparicchedaniddeso. Tena ca satipi tesaṃ sattavisesabhāvena anekasatasahassabhāve imaṃ gaṇanaparicchedaṃ nātivattantīti dasseti maggaṭṭhaphalaṭṭhabhāvānativattanato. Samūhanti samudāyaniddeso. Ariyasaṅghanti guṇavisiṭṭhasaṃhatabhāvaniddeso. Tena asatipi ariyapuggalānaṃ kāyasāmaggiyaṃ ariyasaṅghabhāvaṃ dasseti diṭṭhisīlasāmaññena saṃhatabhāvato. 3. 如此简略地以一切法功德赞叹正法后,现在开始称颂圣僧团,说“善逝的”等。此处“善逝的”是关系格的解释,与“他的子嗣”一句相关联。“亲生的”是子嗣的形容词。“降伏魔军者”一句是成为亲生子的原因的解释,由此显示,断尽烦恼即是世尊认可为亲生子的原因。“八”是数量限定的解释。由此显示,即使圣者们作为特殊个体有成百上千之多,也不会超过这个数量限定,因为他们不会超出道与果的范畴。“众”是集合的解释。“圣僧团”是具有殊胜功德的和合体的解释。由此也显示,即使圣者们身体未聚集一处,只要见与戒共通而和合,即构成圣僧团。 Tattha urasi bhavā jātā saṃbaddhā ca orasā. Yathā hi sattānaṃ orasaputtā attajatāya pitu santakassa dāyajjassa visesena bhāgino honti, evametepi ariyapuggalā sammāsambuddhassa savanante ariyāya jātiyā jātatāya bhagavato santakassa vimuttisukhassa ariyadhammaratanassa ekantena bhāginoti orasā viya orasā. Atha vā bhagavato dhammadesanānubhāvena ariyabhūmiṃ okkamamānā okkantā ca ariyasāvakā bhagavato ure vāyāmajanitābhijātitāya nippariyāyena orasaputtāti vattabbataṃ arahanti. Sāvakehi pavattiyamānāpi hi dhammadesanā ‘‘bhagavato dhammadesanā’’icceva vuccati taṃmūlakattā lakkhaṇādivisesābhāvato ca. 在此,“亲生”(orasa)是指从胸(ura)中出生、产生且相连。正如众生的亲生子,因为是自身所生,所以特别有资格继承父亲的财产;这些圣人也是如此,因为听闻了正等觉者的教法而生于圣种姓,完全有资格分享世尊所拥有的解脱之乐和圣法之宝,所以如亲生子一般,称为“亲生”。或者说,由于世尊说法的威力,正在进入或已经进入圣地的圣弟子们,因由精进而生的高贵出身,理所当然地堪称世尊的“亲生子”。即使是弟子们所宣说的法,也仍然被称为“世尊之法”,因为它们根源相同,并且在特征等方面没有差别。 Yadipi ariyasāvakānaṃ ariyamaggādhigamasamaye bhagavato viya tadantarāyakaraṇatthaṃ devaputtamāro, māravāhinī vā na ekantena apasādeti, tehi pana apasādetabbatāya kāraṇe vimathite tepi vimathitā eva nāma hontīti āha – ‘‘mārasenamathanāna’’nti. Imasmiṃ panatthe ‘‘māramārasenamathanāna’’nti vattabbe ‘‘mārasenamathanāna’’nti ekadesasarūpekaseso katoti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Atha vā khandhābhisaṅkhāramārānaṃ viya devaputtamārassapi guṇamāraṇe sahāyabhāvūpagamanato kilesabalakāyo ‘‘senā’’ti vuccati. Yathāha – ‘‘kāmā te paṭhamā senā’’tiādi [Pg.16] (su. ni. 438; mahāni. 28, 68, 149). Sā ca tehi diyaḍḍhasahassabhedā, anantabhedā vā kilesavāhinī satidhammavicayavīriyasamathādiguṇappaharaṇehi odhiso vimathitā vihatā viddhastā cāti mārasenamathanā, ariyasāvakā. Etena tesaṃ bhagavato anujātaputtataṃ dasseti. 即使圣弟子们在证得圣道时,天子魔或魔军不像对世尊那样,为了制造障碍而能完全挫败他们;然而,当那些应被他们击退的因缘被摧破时,魔军也确实被摧破了。因此说“摧破魔军者”。在此义中,当应说“摧破魔与魔军者”时,却说“摧破魔军者”,当知这是作了同类词的部分省略。或者,如同蕴魔、行魔,天子魔也因在毁坏功德方面成为助伴,故烦恼力的聚合体被称为“军”。如言:“欲为汝初军”等。而那具有一千五百种或无量种差别的烦恼大军,被圣弟子们以念、择法、精进、止等功德为武器,彻底地摧破、击溃、粉碎,因此圣弟子是“摧破魔军者”。以此显示他们是随世尊而生的子嗣。 Ārakattā kilesehi, anaye na iriyanato, aye ca iriyanato ariyā niruttinayena. Atha vā sadevakena lokena saraṇanti araṇīyato upagantabbato, upagatānañca tadatthasiddhito ariyā, ariyānaṃ saṅghoti ariyasaṅgho, ariyo ca so saṅgho cāti vā ariyasaṅgho, taṃ ariyasaṅghaṃ. Bhagavato aparabhāge buddhadhammaratanānampi samadhigamo saṅgharatanādhīnoti assa ariyasaṅghassa bahūpakārataṃ dassetuṃ idheva ‘‘sirasā vande’’ti vuttanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. 因远离诸烦恼,因不行于非道,且行于正道,依词源学而为“圣者”。或者,因堪为包括天神在内的世间所皈依、所亲近,且亲近者能成就其义利,故为“圣者”。圣者之僧团为“圣僧团”,或彼为圣者且为僧团,故为“圣僧团”;即此圣僧团。在世尊之后,佛宝与法宝的证得亦有赖于僧宝,为了显示此圣僧团的巨大助益,故在此处说“我今头面礼”,当如是了知。 Ettha ca ‘‘sugatassa orasānaṃ puttāna’’nti etena ariyasaṅghassa pabhavasampadaṃ dasseti, ‘‘mārasenamathanāna’’nti etena pahānasampadaṃ sakalasaṃkilesappahānadīpanato. ‘‘Aṭṭhannampi samūha’’nti etena ñāṇasampadaṃ maggaṭṭhaphalaṭṭhabhāvadīpanato. ‘‘Ariyasaṅgha’’nti etena pabhavasampadaṃ dasseti sabbasaṅghānaṃ aggabhāvadīpanato. Atha vā ‘‘sugatassa orasānaṃ puttāna’’nti ariyasaṅghassa visuddhanissayabhāvadīpanaṃ, ‘‘mārasenamathanāna’’nti sammāujuñāyasāmīcippaṭipannabhāvadīpanaṃ, ‘‘aṭṭhannampi samūha’’nti āhuneyyādibhāvadīpanaṃ, ‘‘ariyasaṅgha’’nti anuttarapuññakkhettabhāvadīpanaṃ. Tathā ‘‘sugatassa orasānaṃ puttāna’’nti etena ariyasaṅghassa lokuttarasaraṇagamanasabbhāvaṃ dīpeti. Lokuttarasaraṇagamanena hi te bhagavato orasaputtā jātā. ‘‘Mārasenamathanāna’’nti etena abhinīhārasampadāsiddhaṃ pubbabhāge sammāpaṭipattiṃ dasseti. Katābhinīhārā hi sammāpaṭipannā māraṃ māraparisaṃ vā abhivijinanti. ‘‘Aṭṭhannampi samūha’’nti etena viddhastavipakkhe sekkhāsekkhadhamme dasseti puggalādhiṭṭhānena maggaphaladhammānaṃ pakāsitattā. ‘‘Ariyasaṅgha’’nti aggadakkhiṇeyyabhāvaṃ dasseti. Saraṇagamanañca sāvakānaṃ sabbaguṇānaṃ ādi, sapubbabhāgappaṭipadā sekkhā sīlakkhandhādayo majjhe, asekkhā sīlakkhandhādayo pariyosānanti ādimajjhapariyosānakalyāṇā saṅkhepato sabbe ariyasaṅghaguṇā pakāsitā honti. 于此,“善逝之亲生子”一句,显示圣僧团的来源圆满;“摧破魔军者”一句,因其阐明了断除一切杂染,故显示其断除圆满;“八辈之集合”一句,因其阐明了道位与果位,故显示其智慧圆满;“圣僧团”一句,因其阐明了在一切僧团中居于首位,故显示其来源圆满。或者,“善逝之亲生子”,是阐明圣僧团的清净依止性;“摧破魔军者”,是阐明其正行、直行、如理行、和敬行之品格;“八辈之集合”,是阐明其应供等特质;“圣僧团”,是阐明其无上福田性。同样地,“善逝之亲生子”一句,阐明圣僧团出世间皈依的真实性,因由出世间皈依,他们才成为世尊的亲生子。“摧破魔军者”一句,显示由发愿圆满所成就的前期正行,因为已发愿并如理正行者,方能战胜魔罗或魔众。“八辈之集合”一句,以个人为基础,显示已摧毁敌对法的有学与无学之法,因为道与果之法是依个人而开示的。“圣僧团”一句,显示其最上应供性。皈依是声闻弟子一切功德之始,有学戒蕴等及前期行道为中,无学戒蕴等为终。简言之,圣僧团的一切功德,初善、中善、后善,皆已开显。 4. Evaṃ [Pg.17] gāthāttayena saṅkhepato sakalaguṇasaṃkittanamukhena ratanattayassa paṇāmaṃ katvā idāni taṃnipaccakāraṃ yathādhippete payojane pariṇāmento ‘‘iti me’’tiādimāha. Tattha ratijananaṭṭhena ratanaṃ, buddhadhammasaṅghā. Tesañhi ‘‘itipi so bhagavā’’tiādinā yathābhūtaguṇe āvajjentassa amatādhigamahetubhūtaṃ anappakaṃ pītipāmojjaṃ uppajjati. Yathāha – 4. 如是以三偈,通过简要称颂一切功德的方式,对三宝作礼敬后,现在将此恭敬之行回向于所期望的利益,而说“如是我”等。其中,因能生起喜悦,故为“宝”,即佛、法、僧。因为,当人以“彼世尊亦即……”等文,思惟其如实功德时,便会生起作为证得不死之因的无量喜悦与踊跃。如言: ‘‘Yasmiṃ, mahānāma, samaye ariyasāvako tathāgataṃ anussarati, nevassa tasmiṃ samaye rāgapariyuṭṭhitaṃ cittaṃ hoti, na dosa…pe… na mohapariyuṭṭhitaṃ cittaṃ hoti, ujugatamevassa tasmiṃ samaye cittaṃ hoti tathāgataṃ ārabbha. Ujugatacitto kho pana, mahānāma, ariyasāvako labhati atthavedaṃ, labhati dhammavedaṃ, labhati dhammūpasaṃhitaṃ pāmojjaṃ, pamuditassa pīti jāyatī’’tiādi (a. ni. 6.10; 11.11). “摩诃男,当圣弟子忆念如来时,彼于尔时,心不为贪所缠绕,不为瞋……不为痴所缠绕,彼于尔时,心缘如来而得正直。摩诃男,心正直的圣弟子得义之觉解,得法之觉解,得法相应之欣悦,欣悦者生起喜”等(《增支部》6.10;11.11)。 Cittīkatādibhāvo vā ratanaṭṭho. Vuttañhetaṃ – 或者,被珍视等状态,是“宝”的含义。如是说: ‘‘Cittīkataṃ mahagghañca, atulaṃ dullabhadassanaṃ; Anomasattaparibhogaṃ, ratanaṃ tena vuccatī’’ti. (dī. ni. aṭṭha. 2.33; saṃ. ni. aṭṭha. 3.5.223; khu. pā. aṭṭha. 6.3; su. ni. aṭṭha. 1.226); “被珍视、极昂贵,无与伦比、难得见,为最上士所受用,是故彼名称为宝。” Cittīkatabhāvādayo ca anaññasādhāraṇā buddhādīsu eva labbhantīti. 而被珍视等状态,是不共于他者,唯于佛陀等之中可得。 Vandanāva vandanāmayaṃ yathā ‘‘dānamayaṃ, sīlamaya’’nti (dī. ni. 3.305; itivu. 60). Vandanā cettha kāyavācācittehi tiṇṇaṃ ratanānaṃ guṇaninnatā, thomanā vā. Pujjabhāvaphalanibbattanato puññaṃ, attano santānaṃ punātīti vā. Suvihatantarāyoti suṭṭhu vihatantarāyo. Etena attano pasādasampattiyā, ratanattayassa ca khettabhāvasampattiyā taṃ puññaṃ atthappakāsanassa upaghātakaupaddavānaṃ vihanane samatthanti dasseti. Hutvāti pubbakālakiriyā. Tassa ‘‘atthaṃ pakāsayissāmī’’ti etena sambandho. Tassāti yaṃ ratanattayavandanāmayaṃ puññaṃ, tassa. Ānubhāvenāti balena. 礼敬即是“礼敬所成”,犹如“布施所成”、“持戒所成”。此处,礼敬是以身、语、意对三宝功德的倾心,或为称扬赞叹。因能产生可敬状态之果,故为“福德”;或因能净化自身相续,故为“福德”。“善除障碍”即是“善破障碍”。以此显示:凭借自身净信的圆满,以及三宝作为福田的圆满,此福德有力能摧破阐明义理时的破坏性灾患。“Hutvā”(已)是表示先时动作的动词,与“我将开显义理”相关联。“Tassa”(彼之)是指由礼敬三宝所成之福德。“Ānubhāvena”(以威力)即是以其力量。 5. Evaṃ [Pg.18] ratanattayassa nipaccakārakaraṇe payojanaṃ dassetvā idāni yassā dhammadesanāya atthaṃ saṃvaṇṇetukāmo, tassā tāva guṇābhitthavanavasena upaññāpanatthaṃ ‘‘ekakadukādipaṭimaṇḍitassā’’tiādimāha, ekakādīni aṅgāni uparūpari vaḍḍhetvā desitehi suttantehi paṭimaṇḍitassa visiṭṭhassāti attho. Etena ‘‘aṅguttaro’’ti ayaṃ imassa āgamassa atthānugatā samaññāti dasseti. Nanu ca ekakādivasena desitāni suttāniyeva āgamo. Kassa pana ekakadukādīhi paṭimaṇḍitabhāvoti? Saccametaṃ paramatthato, suttāni pana upādāya paññatto āgamo. Yatheva hi atthabyañjanasamudāye suttanti vohāro, evaṃ suttasamudāye āgamoti vohāro. Ekakādīhi aṅgehi uparūpari uttaro adhikoti aṅguttaro, āgamissanti ettha, etena, etasmā vā attatthaparatthādayoti āgamo, ādikalyāṇādiguṇasampattiyā uttamaṭṭhena taṃtaṃabhipatthitasamiddhihetutāya paṇḍitehi varitabbato varo, āgamo ca so varo ca seṭṭhaṭṭhenāti āgamavaro, āgamasammatehi vā varoti āgamavaro. Aṅguttaro ca so āgamavaro cāti aṅguttarāgamavaro, tassa. 5. 如是说明礼敬三宝之作用后,今欲阐释彼说法之义,首先以称颂功德之方式,引出“以一二等庄严”等语,其义是:由逐次增上之一支、二支等所开示之经典所庄严之殊胜者。以此显示:“增支部(Aṅguttara)”此名与此阿含(āgama)之义相符。难道不是以一支等方式所开示之经典即是阿含吗?那么,以一支、二支等所庄严者究竟是谁呢?此从究竟真实而言确实如此,然阿含是依经典而安立的。犹如义与文句之集合有经典之称,如是经典之集合有阿含之称。以一支等支分逐次增上、更胜、更多,故称增支部;于此中、依此、或由此而达成自利利他等,故称阿含;由于具备初善等功德圆满之最胜性,能成就所求愿望,故为智者所选取,称为“胜”(vara);阿含与胜,以其卓越义,即为“胜阿含”(āgamavara);或为诸阿含所公认之殊胜者,故称“胜阿含”。增支部与此胜阿含,即“增支部胜阿含”(aṅguttarāgamavaro),属于彼者。 Puṅgavā vuccanti usabhā, asantasanaparissayasahanassa paripālanādiguṇehi taṃsadisatāya dhammakathikā eva puṅgavāti dhammakathikapuṅgavā, tesaṃ. Hetūpamādippaṭimaṇḍitanānāvidhadesanānayavicittatāya vicittapaṭibhānajananassa. Sumaṅgalavilāsinīādīsu (dī. ni. aṭṭha. 1.ganthārambhakathā; ma. ni. aṭṭha. 1.ganthārambhakathā; saṃ. ni. aṭṭha. 1.1.ganthārambhakathā) pana ‘‘buddhānubuddhasaṃvaṇṇitassā’’ti vuttaṃ. Buddhānañhi saccappaṭivedhaṃ anugamma paṭividdhasaccā aggasāvakādayo ariyā buddhānubuddhā. Ayampi āgamo tehi atthasaṃvaṇṇanāvasena guṇasaṃvaṇṇanāvasena ca saṃvaṇṇito eva. Atha vā buddhā ca anubuddhā ca buddhānubuddhāti yojetabbaṃ. Sammāsambuddheneva hi tiṇṇaṃ piṭakānaṃ atthavaṇṇanākkamo bhāsito, yā ‘‘pakiṇṇakadesanā’’ti vuccati. Tato saṅgāyanādivaseneva sāvakehīti ācariyā vadanti. Idha pana ‘‘dhammakathikapuṅgavānaṃ vicittapaṭibhānajananassa’’icceva thomanā katā. Saṃvaṇṇanāsu cāyaṃ ācariyassa pakati, yā taṃtaṃsaṃvaṇṇanāsu ādito tassa tassa saṃvaṇṇetabbassa dhammassa visesaguṇakittanena thomanā. Tathā hi sumaṅgalavilāsinīpapañcasūdanīsāratthappakāsanīsu aṭṭhasālinīādīsu [Pg.19] ca yathākkamaṃ ‘‘saddhāvahaguṇassa, paravādamathanassa, ñāṇappabhedajananassa, tassa gambhīrañāṇehi ogāḷhassa abhiṇhaso nānānayavicittassā’’tiādinā thomanā katā. “Puṅgavā”者,谓牛王(usabha),因说法者具守护等功德,能无畏承受一切危险,与彼相似,故称“说法牛王”。彼等以因喻等所庄严之种种说法方式,能生起多彩之辩才。在《善吉祥庄严》(Sumaṅgalavilāsinī)等义注中则说:“为佛及随佛者所赞叹。”诸佛证悟真理后,随佛通达真理之上首弟子等圣者,即是随佛者(anubuddha)。此阿含亦因彼等以义理阐释、以功德称颂而受赞叹。或者说,“佛及随佛者”应连接理解。三藏之义理阐释次第,正是由正等觉者所开示,此被称为“杂说法”(pakiṇṇakadesanā)。其后由弟子们在结集等时传承下来,此是古代论师们之说法。此处只是赞叹“说法牛王们能生起多彩辩才”。论师在进行释义时之惯例是:在各种释义中,首先通过称扬所要阐释之法的殊胜功德来进行赞叹。例如,在《善吉祥庄严》、《破除戏论》(Papañcasūdanī)、《显扬心义》(Sāratthappakāsinī)、《含义阐明》等义注中,就依次赞叹了“能引生信心之功德”、“摧破他论”、“能生起智慧之差别”、“为具甚深智慧者所反复探究,具种种巧妙方法”等。 6. Attho kathīyati etāyāti atthakathā, sā eva aṭṭhakathā, ttha-kārassa ṭṭha-kāraṃ katvā yathā ‘‘dukkhassa pīḷanaṭṭho’’ti (paṭi. ma. 1.17; 2.8). Āditotiādimhi paṭhamasaṅgītiyaṃ. Chaḷabhiññatāya paramena cittavasībhāvena samannāgatattā jhānādīsu pañcavidhavasitāsabbhāvato ca vasino, therā mahākassapādayo, tesaṃ satehi pañcahi. Yāti yā aṭṭhakathā. Saṅgītāti atthaṃ pakāsetuṃ yuttaṭṭhāne ‘‘ayaṃ etassa attho, ayaṃ etassa attho’’ti saṅgahetvā vuttā. Anusaṅgītā ca yasattherādīhi pacchāpi dutiyatatiyasaṅgītīsu. Iminā attano saṃvaṇṇanāya āgamanavisuddhiṃ dasseti. 6. 以之言说义,故为“义说”( atthakathā),即是义注(aṭṭhakathā),此乃将“ttha”音转为“ṭṭha”,如“苦为逼迫义”那样(《无碍解道》Paṭisambhidāmagga 1.17; 2.8)。“最初”者,谓在第一次结集时。因大迦叶(Mahākassapa)等长老们具足六神通,凭借最上之心自在力,且于禅定等拥有五种自在,故被称为自在者(vasin),由彼等五百位长老。“彼”(yā)者,谓彼义注。“所结集”(saṅgītā)者,是为了阐明意义,在适当之处,以“此是此义,此是彼义”之方式收集而诵出。其后亦由耶舍(Yasa)长老等在第二、第三次结集中再次结集。以此显示自身释义传承之清净性。 7. Sīhassa lānato gahaṇato sīhaḷo, sīhakumāro. Taṃvaṃsajātatāya tambapaṇṇidīpe khattiyānaṃ, tesaṃ nivāsatāya tambapaṇṇidīpassa ca sīhaḷabhāvo veditabbo. Ābhatāti jambudīpato ānītā. Athāti pacchā. Aparabhāge hi asaṅkaratthaṃ sīhaḷabhāsāya aṭṭhakathā ṭhapitāti. Tena sā mūlaṭṭhakathā sabbasādhāraṇā na hotīti idaṃ atthappakāsanaṃ ekantena karaṇīyanti dasseti. Tenevāha – ‘‘dīpavāsīnamatthāyā’’ti. Tattha dīpavāsīnanti jambudīpavāsīnaṃ, dīpavāsīnanti vā sīhaḷadīpavāsīnaṃ atthāya sīhaḷabhāsāya ṭhapitāti yojanā. 7. 因执取(lāna)与捕捉(gahaṇa)狮子(sīha)而得名“狮子”(Sīhaḷa),即狮子王子。由于此王族血统之故,铜鍱洲(Tambapaṇṇidīpa)的刹帝利们,以及铜鍱洲本身,应知被称为“狮子”。“带来”(ābhatā)者,谓从瞻部洲带来。其后,为免混杂故,以僧伽罗语(Sīhaḷabhāsā)确立了义注。因此彼根本义注(mūlaṭṭhakathā)并非普遍适用,此《显扬义》(Atthappakāsanī)必须专门撰写,以此显示。故说:“为岛民之利益。”此处“岛民”者,谓瞻部洲之居民,或谓为狮子洲(Sīhaḷadīpa)之居民的利益,以僧伽罗语确立了义注,应如是理解。 8. Apanetvānāti kañcukasadisaṃ sīhaḷabhāsaṃapanetvāna. Tatoti aṭṭhakathāto. Ahanti attānaṃ niddisati. Manoramaṃ bhāsanti māgadhabhāsaṃ. Sā hi sabhāvaniruttibhūtā paṇḍitānaṃ manaṃ ramayatīti. Tenevāha – ‘‘tantinayānucchavika’’nti, pāḷigatiyā anulomikaṃ pāḷicchāyānuvidhāyininti attho. Vigatadosanti asabhāvaniruttibhāsantararahitaṃ. 8. “除去”(apanetvāna)者,谓去除犹如外衣之僧伽罗语(Sīhaḷabhāsā)。“从彼”(tato)者,谓从义注(aṭṭhakathā)中。“我”(ahaṃ)者,谓指称自己。“悦意语”(manoramaṃ bhāsaṃ)者,谓摩揭陀语(Māgadhabhāsā)。因其是合乎自然语法之语言,能令贤者喜悦。故说:“顺应经文之规则”(tantinayānucchavika),其义是顺应巴利文之规则,依随巴利文之影子。“离过”(vigatadosa)者,谓没有不合乎自然语法之其他语言。 9. Samayaṃ avilomentoti siddhantaṃ avirodhento. Etena atthadosābhāvamāha. Aviruddhattā eva hi theravādāpi idha pakāsīyissanti. Theravaṃsadīpānanti thirehi sīlakkhandhādīhi samannāgatattā therā[Pg.20], mahākassapādayo, tehi āgatā ācariyaparamparā theravaṃso. Tappariyāpannā hutvā āgamādhigamasampannattā paññāpajjotena tassa samujjalanato theravaṃsadīpā, mahāvihāravāsino therā, tesaṃ. Vividhehi ākārehi nicchīyatīti vinicchayo, gaṇṭhiṭṭhānesu khīlamaddanākārena pavattā vimaticchedakathā. Suṭṭhu nipuṇo saṇho vinicchayo etesanti sunipuṇavinicchayā. Atha vā vinicchinotīti vinicchayo, yathāvuttatthavisayaṃ ñāṇaṃ. Suṭṭhu nipuṇo cheko vinicchayo etesanti sunipuṇavinicchayā. Etena mahākassapādittheraparamparābhato, tatoyeva ca aviparīto saṇhasukhumo mahāvihāravāsīnaṃ vinicchayoti tassa pamāṇabhūtataṃ dasseti. 9. “不违时”(samayaṃ avilomento)者,谓不违背宗义(siddhanta)。此言表明其义无谬误。正因无违逆,故于此亦将阐明上座部(Theravāda)之观点。“上座传承明灯”(theravaṃsadīpānaṃ)者,谓因具足戒蕴等坚固品德故称上座(thera),如大迦叶(Mahākassapa)等,由彼等传下之师资相承即是上座传承(theravaṃsa)。因包含于此传承中,教证圆满,以智慧之灯照亮此传承,故称“上座传承明灯”,谓大寺(Mahāvihāra)之长老们。“决择”(vinicchaya)者,谓以种种方式来决定;是在疑难之处,犹如以楔破结般,为断除疑惑而作的论说。具足极为善巧、微细之决择,故称“善巧决择者”(sunipuṇavinicchayā)。或者说,“决择”者,谓决断,即对如上所述之义的认知。具足极为善巧、练达之决择,故称“善巧决择者”。以此显示,从大迦叶等上座传承而来,因此毫无错谬、细致微妙之大寺僧众的决择,可作为标准。 10. Sujanassa cāti ca-saddo sampiṇḍanattho. Tena ‘‘na kevalaṃ jambudīpavāsīnaṃyeva atthāya, atha kho sādhujanānaṃ tosanatthañcā’’ti dasseti. Tena ca ‘‘tambapaṇṇidīpavāsīnampi atthāyā’’ti ayamattho siddho hoti uggahaṇādisukaratāya tesampi bahūpakārattā. Ciraṭṭhitatthanti ciraṭṭhitiatthaṃ, cirakālāvaṭṭhānāyāti attho. Idañhi atthappakāsanaṃ aviparītabyañjanasunikkhepassa atthasunītassa ca upāyabhāvato saddhammassa ciraṭṭhitiyā saṃvattati. Vuttañhetaṃ bhagavatā – 10. “与善人”(sujanassa ca)一词中的“与”(ca)字,是为了表示总括。由此可知“不仅仅是为了瞻部洲居民的利益,而且是为了善人的喜悦”。由此“也是为了铜鍱洲(Tambapaṇṇidīpa)居民的利益”之义理得以成立,因为其易于学习受持,对他们也有很多益处。“为长久住立”(ciraṭṭhitatthaṃ)是指为了长久住立的利益,意为为了长久存续。因为此《显扬义》(Atthappakāsanī)是无谬误文句之善安立与善引导义理之方法,故能有助于正法(saddhamma)的长久住立。世尊曾说过: ‘‘Dveme, bhikkhave, dhammā saddhammassa ṭhitiyā asammosāya anantaradhānāya saṃvattanti. Katame dve? Sunikkhittañca padabyañjanaṃ, attho ca sunīto’’ti (a. ni. 2.21). “诸比丘,此二法有助于正法住立、不混乱、不消失。是哪二法呢?妥善安立的文句,以及妥善引导的义理。”(增支部2.21) 11-12. Yaṃ atthavaṇṇanaṃ katthukāmo, tassā mahantattaṃ pariharituṃ ‘‘sāvatthipabhūtīna’’ntiādimāha. Tenāha – ‘‘na idha vitthārakathaṃ karissāmi, na taṃ idha vicārayissāmī’’ti ca. Tattha dīghassāti dīghanikāyassa. Majjhimassāti majjhimanikāyassa. ‘‘Saṅgītīnaṃ dvinnaṃ yā me atthaṃ vadantenā’’tipi pāṭho. Tatthapi saṅgītīnaṃ dvinnanti dīghamajjhimanikāyānanti attho gahetabbo. Meti karaṇatthe sāmivacanaṃ, mayāti attho. Sudanti nipātamattaṃ. Heṭṭhā dīghassa majjhimassa ca atthaṃ vadantena sāvatthipabhutīnaṃ nagarānaṃ yā vaṇṇanā katā, tassā vitthārakathaṃ na idha bhiyyo karissāmīti [Pg.21] yojetabbaṃ. Yāni ca tattha vatthūni vitthāravasena vuttāni, tesampi vitthārakathaṃ na idha bhiyyo karissāmīti sambandho. 11-12. 欲作义理之释义,为避免其浩瀚,故说“始于舍卫城(Sāvatthī)等”。因此他说:“我不会在此作详细解说,也不会在此探究”。其中,“长部”即长部(Dīghanikāya),“中部”即中部(Majjhimanikāya)。亦有异读为:“由我宣说二部结集(Saṅgīti)之义”。于此,“二部结集”亦应解为长部与中部二尼柯耶(Nikāya)。“me”是与格,但用于作格义,意为“由我”。“sudaṃ”仅是不变词。应如是结合:“先前解说长部与中部之义时,对舍卫城等城市所作的释义,其详细解说我不会在此再作”。并且,对于那些在此处已详细讲述的事物,其详细解说我亦不会在此再作,应如是关联。 13. Idāni ‘‘na idha vitthārakathaṃ karissāmī’’ti sāmaññato vuttassa atthassa pavaraṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘suttānaṃ panā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Suttānaṃ ye atthā vatthūhi vinā na pakāsantīti yojetabbaṃ. 13. 现在,为显示前文总说的“我不会在此作详细解说”之义的要点,故说“诸经的”等等。应如是结合:诸经之义,若无事缘(vatthu)则不显。 14. Yaṃ aṭṭhakathaṃ kattukāmo, tadekadesabhāvena visuddhimaggo ca gahetabboti kathikānaṃ upadesaṃ karonto tattha vicāritadhamme uddesavasena dasseti – ‘‘sīlakathā’’tiādinā. Tattha sīlakathāti cārittavārittādivasena sīlassa vitthārakathā. Dhutadhammāti piṇḍapātikaṅgādayo terasa kilesadhunanakadhammā. Kammaṭṭhānāni sabbānīti pāḷiyaṃ āgatāni aṭṭhatiṃsa, aṭṭhakathāyaṃ dveti niravasesāni yogakammassa bhāvanāya pavattiṭṭhānāni. Cariyāvidhānasahitoti rāgacaritādīnaṃ sabhāvādividhānena sahito. Jhānāni cattāri rūpāvacarajjhānāni, samāpattiyo catasso āruppasamāpattiyo. Aṭṭhapi vā paṭiladdhamattāni jhānāni samāpajjanavasībhāvappattiyā samāpattiyo. Jhānāni vā rūpārūpāvacarajjhānāni, samāpattiyo phalasamāpattinirodhasamāpattiyo. 14. 欲作义注者,应将《清净道论》(Visuddhimagga)视为其一部分,在为说法者作教导时,以“戒论”等纲要形式,开示其中所探讨的诸法。其中,“戒论”是指以作持与止持等方式广说戒。“头陀法”(Dhutadhamma)是指乞食支等十三种能抖落烦恼之法。“一切业处”是指巴利圣典中所出的三十八种,以及义注中的两种,即所有无余的、作为瑜伽业修行之所依的业处。“具足行仪规定”(cariyāvidhānasahito)是指与贪行等自性差别相应的行仪规定。四“禅”是色界四禅,四“等至”(samāpatti)是四无色等至。或八种禅,仅指已得者,因达到入定自在而称“等至”。或“诸禅”指色界与无色界禅,“诸等至”指果等至与灭尽等至。 15. Lokiyalokuttarabhedā cha abhiññāyo sabbā abhiññāyo. Ñāṇavibhaṅgādīsu āgatanayena ekavidhādinā paññāya saṃkaletvā sampiṇḍetvā nicchayo paññāsaṅkalananicchayo. 15. 世间与出世间之别的六神通(abhiññā),即一切神通。依照《智分别》(Ñāṇavibhaṅga)等所说之理,以一法等方式,由慧统摄、集结后所作的决断,即是“慧集结决断”。 16. Paccayadhammānaṃ hetuādīnaṃ paccayuppannadhammānaṃ hetupaccayādibhāvo paccayākāro, tassa desanā paccayākāradesanā, paṭiccasamuppādakathāti attho. Sā pana ghanavinibbhogassa sudukkaratāya saṇhasukhumā, nikāyantaraladdhisaṅkararahitā, ekattanayādisahitā ca tattha vicāritāti āha – ‘‘suparisuddhanipuṇanayā’’ti. Paṭisambhidādīsu āgatanayaṃ avissajjetvāva vicāritattā avimuttatantimaggā. 16. 缘法之因等,对于缘生法,作为因缘等的状态,即是缘相(paccayākāra);对其解说即是“缘相解说”(paccayākāradesanā),意即“缘起论”(paṭiccasamuppādakathā)。然而,此法因剖析密集(ghana-vinibbhoga)极为困难,故于彼处以微细、离于他部见解之混杂、具足一性理等而作探讨,因此说“极为清净、微细之理”。因其探讨不舍《无碍解道》(Paṭisambhidāmagga)等中所说之理,故为“不离圣典之道”。 17. Iti pana sabbanti iti-saddo parisamāpane, pana-saddo vacanālaṅkāre, etaṃ sabbanti attho. Idhāti imissā aṭṭhakathāya na vicārayissāmi punaruttibhāvatoti adhippāyo. 17. “如是,然而,一切”(iti pana sabbaṃ)中,“iti”一词表总结义,“pana”一词为语气庄严词,其意为“所有这些”(etaṃ sabbaṃ)。“于此”(idha)的意趣是:在此义注中,因会重复,故我将不再探讨。 18. Idāni [Pg.22] tasseva avicāraṇassa ekantakāraṇaṃ niddhārento ‘‘majjhe visuddhimaggo’’tiādimāha. Tattha ‘‘majjhe ṭhatvā’’ti etena majjhabhāvadīpanena visesato catunnaṃ āgamānaṃ sādhāraṇaṭṭhakathā visuddhimaggo, na sumaṅgalavilāsinīādayo viya asādhāraṇaṭṭhakathāti dasseti. ‘‘Visesato’’ti ca idaṃ vinayābhidhammānampi visuddhimaggo yathārahaṃ atthavaṇṇanā hoti evāti katvā vuttaṃ. 18. 现在,为确定不作探讨的根本原因,故说“《清净道论》居中”等。其中,通过“居中而立”来阐明其中心地位,显示《清净道论》(Visuddhimagga)是四部阿含(āgama)的共同义注(sādhāraṇaṭṭhakathā),不像《善吉祥光》(Sumaṅgalavilāsinī)等是个别义注(asādhāraṇaṭṭhakathā)。而说“特别”(visesato),是因《清净道论》亦适当地为律藏与阿毗达摩作了义理之释义。 19. Iccevāti iti eva. Tampīti visuddhimaggampi. Etāyāti manorathapūraṇiyā. Ettha ca ‘‘sīhaḷadīpaṃ ābhatā’’tiādinā atthappakāsanassa nimittaṃ dasseti, ‘‘dīpavāsīnamatthāya sujanassa ca tuṭṭhatthaṃ ciraṭṭhitatthañca dhammassā’’ti etena payojanaṃ, apanetvāna tatohaṃ, sīhaḷabhāsa’’ntiādinā. ‘‘Sāvatthipabhutīna’’ntiādinā ca karaṇappakāraṃ. Heṭṭhimanikāyesu visuddhimagge ca vicāritānaṃ atthānaṃ avicāraṇampi hi idha karaṇappakāro evāti. 19. “如是”(icceva)即“iti eva”。“彼”(tampi)亦指《清净道论》。“以此”(etāya)指《满足希愿》(Manorathapūraṇī)。于此,“从狮子洲带来”等语,显示了阐明义理的因缘;“为了岛上居民的利益、为了善人的欢喜、为了正法长久住立”说明了其目的;“我从那里去除僧伽罗语”等语,以及“舍卫城等”说明了造论的方式。因为下部诸尼柯耶和《清净道论》中已探讨过的义理,于此不再探讨,这本身即是造论方式之一。 Ganthārambhakathāvaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 造论缘起之释义终。 1. Rūpādivaggavaṇṇanā 1. 色等品释义 Nidānavaṇṇanā 缘起释义 Vibhāgavantānaṃ sabhāvavibhāvanaṃ vibhāgadassanavaseneva hotīti paṭhamaṃ tāva nipātasuttavasena vibhāgaṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘tattha aṅguttarāgamo nāmā’’tiādimāha. Tattha tatthāti ‘‘aṅguttarāgamassa atthaṃ pakāsayissāmī’’ti yadidaṃ vuttaṃ, tasmiṃ vacane, ‘‘yassa atthaṃ pakāsayissāmī’’ti paṭiññātaṃ, so aṅguttarāgamo nāma nipātasuttavasena evaṃ vibhāgoti attho. Atha vā tatthāti ‘‘aṅguttaranissitaṃ attha’’nti etasmiṃ vacane yo aṅguttarāgamo vutto, so nipātasuttādivasena edisoti attho. 有分别法之自性的阐明,唯通过显示其分别而成就。因此,首先为依篇集(nipāta)的方式显示其分别,故说“于彼,名为增支部”等等。其中,“于彼”(tattha)者,意指在“我将阐明增支阿含之义”此语中,所承诺要阐明其义的增支阿含,是依篇集而如是分别。或,“于彼”者,意指在“增支所依之义”此语中所说的增支阿含,是依篇集等而有如此类别。 Idāni taṃ ādito paṭṭhāya saṃvaṇṇitukāmo attano saṃvaṇṇanāya paṭhamamahāsaṅgītiyaṃ nikkhittānukkamena pavattabhāvadassanatthaṃ ‘‘tassa nipātesu…pe… vuttaṃ nidānamādī’’tiādimāha. Tattha yathāpaccayaṃ tattha tattha desitattā paññattattā ca vippakiṇṇānaṃ dhammavinayānaṃ saṅgahetvā gāyanaṃ kathanaṃ saṅgīti. Etena taṃtaṃsikkhāpadānaṃ suttānañca ādipariyosānesu [Pg.23] antarantarā ca sambandhavasena ṭhapitaṃ saṅgītikāravacanaṃ saṅgahitaṃ hoti. Saṅgīyamānassa atthassa mahantatāya pūjanīyatāya ca mahatī saṅgīti mahāsaṅgīti, paṭhamā mahāsaṅgīti paṭhamamahāsaṅgīti, tassā pavattikālo paṭhamamahāsaṅgītikālo, tasmiṃ paṭhamamahāsaṅgītikāle. Nidadāti desanaṃ desakālādivasena aviditaṃ viditaṃ katvā nidassetīti nidānaṃ. Yo lokiyehi upogghātoti vuccati, svāyamettha ‘‘evaṃ me suta’’ntiādiko gantho veditabbo. Na ‘‘sanidānāhaṃ, bhikkhave, dhammaṃ desemī’’tiādīsu (a. ni. 3.126) viya ajjhāsayādidesanuppattihetu. Tenevāha – ‘‘evaṃ me sutantiādikaṃ āyasmatā ānandena paṭhamamahāsaṅgītikāle vuttaṃ nidānamādī’’ti. 现在,欲从头开始阐释,为显示其阐释是依第一次大结集所确立的次第而进行,故说“彼于诸篇集中……乃至……所说的缘起等”等等。其中,法与律因随缘于各处说与制,故为散乱,将其收集、合诵、讲述,即是结集。由此,各个学处及诸经的开头、结尾与中间,依关联而安立的结集者之语,皆被摄集。因所结集之义理重大且应受崇敬,故名大结集。第一次大结集即是初次大结集,其发生之时即是第一次大结集之时。所谓“缘起”(nidāna),即是通过说法的时间、地点等,使未闻者得闻,未知者得知,而作开示。世间所说的“序言”(upogghāta),在此处应理解为“如是我闻”等文句。这不像“诸比丘,我依缘起说法”等(《增支部》3.126)经文中的“缘起”,是指意乐等说法生起之因。因此说:“‘如是我闻’等文句,是具寿阿难在第一次大结集时所说的缘起等”。 1. ‘‘Sā panesā’’tiādinā bāhiranidāne vattabbaṃ atidisitvā idāni abbhantaranidānaṃ ādito paṭṭhāya saṃvaṇṇituṃ ‘‘yaṃ paneta’’nti vuttaṃ. Tattha yasmā saṃvaṇṇanaṃ karontena saṃvaṇṇetabbe dhamme padāni padavibhāgaṃ tadatthañca dassetvā tato paraṃ piṇḍatthādinidassanavasena ca saṃvaṇṇanā kātabbā, tasmā padāni tāva dassento ‘‘evanti nipātapada’’ntiādimāha. Tattha padavibhāgoti padānaṃ viseso, na padaviggaho. Atha vā padāni ca padavibhāgo ca padavibhāgo, padaviggaho ca padavibhāgo ca padavibhāgoti vā ekasesavasena padapadaviggahā padavibhāgasaddena vuttāti veditabbaṃ. Tattha padaviggaho ‘‘jetassa vanaṃ jetavana’’ntiādinā samāsapadesu daṭṭhabbo. 1. 以“彼如是”(Sā panesā)等句,已指明外缘(bāhiranidāna)中应说之事,今为从初释义内缘(abbhantaranidāna),故说“此如是”(yaṃ paneta)。其中,因行释义者于当释之法,须先展示诸词、词之分别及其义,其后当以总义等示导而作释义,是故先展示诸词,说“‘如是’(evam)是助词(nipātapada)”等。其中,“词之分别”(padavibhāgo)是诸词之差别,非“词之分解”(padaviggaho)。或,诸词与词之分别合为“词之分别”;或,词之分解与词之分别合为“词之分别”;或当知,以“词之分别”一词,依单存法(ekasesa)而说为诸词与词之分解。其中,词之分解当于复合词中见,如“胜者(Jeta)之林(vana)为祇陀林(Jetavana)”等。 Atthatoti padatthato. Taṃ pana padatthaṃ atthuddhārakkamena paṭhamaṃ evaṃ-saddassa dassento ‘‘evaṃ-saddo tāvā’’tiādimāha. Avadhāraṇādīti ettha ādi-saddena idamatthapucchāparimāṇādiatthānaṃ saṅgaho daṭṭhabbo. Tathā hi ‘‘evaṃgatāni puthusippāyatanāni, evamādīnī’’tiādīsu idaṃ-saddassa atthe evaṃ-saddo. Gata-saddo hi pakārapariyāyo, tathā vidhākāra-saddā ca. Tathā hi vidhayuttagatasadde lokiyā pakāratthe vadanti. ‘‘Evaṃ su te sunhātā suvilittā kappitakesamassū āmukkamaṇikuṇḍalābharaṇā odātavatthavasanā pañcahi kāmaguṇehi samappitā samaṅgībhūtā paricārenti seyyathāpi tvaṃ etarahi [Pg.24] sācariyakoti. No hidaṃ, bho gotamā’’tiādīsu (dī. ni. 1.286) pucchāyaṃ. ‘‘Evaṃ lahuparivattaṃ (a. ni. 1.48), evamāyupariyanto’’ti (dī. ni. 1.244; pārā. 12) ca ādīsu parimāṇe. “由义”(Atthato)即“由词义”(padatthato)。为以抉择义之次第(atthuddhārakkamena),先展示‘evaṃ’一词的词义,故说“‘evaṃ’一词”等等。在“决定等”(Avadhāraṇādi)中,“等”字当知包含“此义”(idam-attha)、“疑问”(pucchā)、“限量”(parimāṇa)等义。例如,在“如是众多技艺处,如是等等”等句中,‘evaṃ’一词用于‘此’(idam)词之义。‘gata’一词是‘方式’(pakāra)的同义词,‘vidhā’和‘ākāra’二词亦然。世人以‘vidhā’、‘yutta’和‘gata’等词表达‘方式’之义。例如,在“如是,汝善沐浴、善涂香、修剪发须、佩戴珠宝耳环、身着白衣,具足圆满五欲而受用,犹如汝今与师俱。此事不然,乔达摩尊者”等句(长部1.286)中,用于疑问。在“如是迅速变易”(增支部1.48)、“如是寿命终结”(长部1.244;波罗夷12)等等句中,用于限量。 Nanu ca ‘‘evaṃ su te sunhātā suvilittā evamāyupariyanto’’ti ettha evaṃ-saddena pucchanākāraparimāṇākārānaṃ vuttattā ākārattho eva evaṃ-saddoti? Na, visesasabbhāvato. Ākāramattavācako hi evaṃ-saddo ākāratthoti adhippeto yathā ‘‘evaṃ byākho’’tiādīsu (ma. ni. 1.234; pāci. 417; cūḷava. 65), na pana ākāravisesavācako. Evañca katvā ‘‘evaṃ jātena maccenā’’tiādīni (dha. pa. 53) upamādiudāharaṇāni upapannāni honti. Tathā hi ‘‘yathā hi…pe… bahu’’nti (dha. pa. 53) ettha puppharāsiṭṭhāniyato manussūpapattisappurisūpanissayasaddhammassavanayonisomanasikārabhogasampatti- ādidānādipuññakiriyāhetusamudāyato sobhāsugandhatādiguṇayogato mālāguṇasadisiyo pahūtā puññakiriyā maritabbasabhāvatāya maccena sattena kattabbāti jotitattā puppharāsimālāguṇāva upamā. Tesaṃ upamākāro yathā-saddena aniyamato vuttoti ‘‘evaṃ-saddo upamākāranigamanattho’’ti vattuṃ yuttaṃ, so pana upamākāro niyamiyamāno atthato upamāva hotīti āha – ‘‘upamāyaṃ āgato’’ti. Tathā ‘‘evaṃ iminā ākārena abhikkamitabba’’ntiādinā upadisiyamānāya samaṇasāruppāya ākappasampattiyā yo tattha upadisanākāro, so atthato upadeso evāti vuttaṃ – ‘‘evaṃ te…pe… upadese’’ti. Tathā evametaṃ bhagavā, evametaṃ sugatāti ettha bhagavatā yathāvuttamatthaṃ aviparītato jānantehi kataṃ tattha saṃvijjamānaguṇānaṃ pakārehi haṃsanaṃ udaggatākaraṇaṃ sampahaṃsanaṃ, yo tattha sampahaṃsanākāroti yojetabbaṃ. 然,于“如是汝等善沐浴、善涂香……如是寿命终结”等句中,‘evaṃ’一词既表示询问方式与限量方式,故此词岂非仅是方式义吗?不然,因有差别故。‘evaṃ’一词仅是方式的表达,意为方式义,如“如是解说”等句(中部1.234;波逸提417;小品65),而非表示方式的差别。如是,“如是生者必死”等(法句53)的比喻等例方能成立。诚然,于“譬如……乃至……众多”(法句53)中,阐明了犹如从花堆积集众多花鬘,众多福业亦然,其因缘聚合乃得生为人、亲近善士、听闻正法、如理作意、财富具足、行布施等,并具足色泽、芳香等功德,此等福业应由有必死之性的有情所作,故花堆与花鬘即是比喻。彼比喻的方式,由‘yathā’一词不确定地表达,故说“‘evaṃ’一词是比喻方式的总结义”是恰当的;然彼比喻方式被确定时,从义理上即是比喻本身,故说:“用于比喻”。同样,“应以此方式前进”等等,所教示的符合沙门规范的威仪具足,其中教示的方式,从义理上即是教导,故说:“如是汝……乃至……用于教导”。同样,在“世尊如是,善逝如是”中,了知世尊所说之义无有颠倒者,对其中所存在的功德,以各种方式令生欢喜、令心激昂,即是赞叹,此处应连结为“赞叹的方式”。 Evamevaṃ panāyanti ettha garahaṇākāroti yojetabbaṃ, so ca garahaṇākāro ‘‘vasalī’’tiādikhuṃsanasaddasannidhānato idha evaṃ-saddena pakāsitoti viññāyati. Yathā cettha, evaṃ upamākārādayopi upamādivasena vuttānaṃ puppharāsiādisaddānaṃ sannidhānatoti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Evaṃ, bhanteti khotiādīsu pana dhammassa sādhukaṃ savanamanasikārena niyojitehi bhikkhūhi attano tattha ṭhitabhāvassa paṭijānanavasena vuttattā [Pg.25] ettha evaṃ-saddo vacanasampaṭicchanattho vutto, tena ‘‘evaṃ, bhante, sādhu bhante, suṭṭhu bhante’’ti vuttaṃ hoti. Evañca vadehīti ‘‘yathāhaṃ vadāmi, evaṃ samaṇaṃ ānandaṃ vadehī’’ti vadanākāro idāni vattabbo evaṃ-saddena nidassīyatīti nidassanattho vutto. Evaṃ noti etthāpi tesaṃ yathāvuttadhammānaṃ ahitadukkhāvahabhāve sanniṭṭhānajananatthaṃ anumatiggahaṇavasena ‘‘no vā, kathaṃ vo ettha hotī’’ti pucchāya katāya ‘‘evaṃ no ettha hotī’’ti vuttattā tadākārasanniṭṭhānaṃ evaṃ-saddena vibhāvitanti viññāyati. So pana tesaṃ dhammānaṃ ahitāya dukkhāya saṃvattanākāro niyamiyamāno avadhāraṇattho hotīti āha – ‘‘evaṃ no ettha hotītiādīsu avadhāraṇe’’ti. 于“Evamevaṃ panāyanti”中,当连结为“谴责方式”,且当知此谴责方式是因临近“贱民”(vasalī)等斥责之词,而由此处之“evaṃ”词所明示。如此处然,比喻方式等亦当见是因临近以比喻等方式所说之花堆等词。于“尊者,如是”(Evaṃ, bhante)等句中,因诸比丘被策励于善听闻、作意正法,以承诺自住于彼之方式而说,故此处“evaṃ”词说为承诺言词义,由此而有‘尊者,如是;尊者,善哉;尊者,甚善’之说。于“汝当如是说”(Evañca vadehī)中,“如我所说,汝当如是对沙门阿难说”,此言说方式今由“evaṃ”词所指示,故说为指示义。于“于我等如是”(Evaṃ no)中,亦为令彼等于前述诸法为无益、引苦之事生起决信,以征求同意之方式提问“不然乎?汝等于此云何?”,答曰“我等于此如是”,故当知是以“evaṃ”词阐明彼方式之决信。然彼诸法转向无益、痛苦之方式,于确定时,即为决定义,故说:“于‘我等于此如是’等句中,为决定义”。 Nānānayanipuṇanti ekattanānattaabyāpāraevaṃdhammatāsaṅkhātā, nandiyāvaṭṭatipukkhalasīhavikkīḷitaaṅkusadisālocanasaṅkhātā vā ādhārādibhedavasena nānāvidhā nayā nānānayā. Nayā vā pāḷigatiyo, tā ca paññattiādivasena saṃkilesabhāgiyādilokiyāditadubhayavomissakatādivasena kusalādivasena khandhādivasena saṅgahādivasena samayavimuttādivasena padhānādivasena kusalamūlādivasena tikapaṭṭhānādivasena ca nānappakārāti nānānayā, tehi nipuṇaṃ saṇhaṃ sukhumanti nānānayanipuṇaṃ. Āsayova ajjhāsayo, te ca sassatādibhedena tattha ca apparajakkhatādibhedena ca aneke, attajjhāsayādayo eva vā samuṭṭhānaṃ uppattihetu etassāti anekajjhāsayasamuṭṭhānaṃ. Atthabyañjanasampannanti atthabyañjanaparipuṇṇaṃ upanetabbābhāvato. Saṅkāsanapakāsanavivaraṇavibhajanauttānīkaraṇapaññattivasena chahi atthapadehi akkharapadabyañjanākāraniruttiniddesavasena chahi byañjanapadehi ca samannāgatanti vā attho daṭṭhabbo. “善巧种种理趣”(Nānānayanipuṇaṃ):或名为一性、异性、无作用、法尔,或名为南迪亚旋转(nandiyāvaṭṭa)、三莲花(tipukkhala)、狮子奋迅(sīhavikkīḷita)、钩形审察(aṅkusadisālocana),或依所依等差别而有多种理趣,是为“种种理趣”。或,理趣即圣典之理路(pāḷigatiyo),彼等依施设(paññatti)等,依杂染分(saṃkilesabhāgiya)、世间(lokiya)等、二者杂糅等,依善(kusala)等,依蕴(khandha)等,依摄(saṅgaha)等,依时解脱(samayavimutta)等,依勤(padhāna)等,依善根(kusalamūla)等,依三法组发趣(tikapaṭṭhāna)等,而有种种类别,故称“种种理趣”。通过这些理趣达到善巧、微细、精妙,称为“善巧种种理趣”。“意乐”(Āsaya)即“胜解”(ajjhāsaya),这些胜解有常见(sassata)等多种差别,其中又有少尘(apparajakkha)等差别,多种多样;或者说,自胜解等是其生起之因,称为“多种胜解所生”(anekajjhāsayasamuṭṭhānaṃ)。“义文具足”(Atthabyañjanasampannaṃ),是指义与文圆满,无须增益。或当知其义为:具足六种义门,即开示(saṅkāsana)、阐明(pakāsana)、解说(vivaraṇa)、分析(vibhajanā)、显扬(uttānīkaraṇa)、安立(paññatti);并具足六种文门,即字母(akkhara)、词句(pada)、文辞(byañjana)、形式(ākāra)、语法(nirutti)、解释(niddesa)。 Vividhapāṭihāriyanti ettha pāṭihāriyapadassa vacanatthaṃ ‘‘paṭipakkhaharaṇato rāgādikilesāpanayanato ca pāṭihāriya’’nti vadanti. Bhagavato pana paṭipakkhā rāgādayo na santi, ye haritabbā. Puthujjanānampi vigatūpakkilese aṭṭhaguṇasamannāgate citte hatapaṭipakkhe iddhividhaṃ pavattati, tasmā tattha pavattavohārena ca na sakkā idha ‘‘pāṭihāriya’’nti vatthuṃ. Sace pana mahākāruṇikassa bhagavato veneyyagatā ca kilesā [Pg.26] paṭipakkhā, tesaṃ haraṇato ‘‘pāṭihāriya’’nti vuttaṃ, evaṃ sati yuttametaṃ. Atha vā bhagavato ca sāsanassa ca paṭipakkhā titthiyā, tesaṃ haraṇato pāṭihāriyaṃ. Te hi diṭṭhiharaṇavasena ca diṭṭhippakāsane asamatthabhāvena ca iddhiādesanānusāsanīhi haritā apanītā hontīti. ‘‘Paṭī’’ti vā ayaṃ saddo ‘‘pacchā’’ti etassa atthaṃ bodheti ‘‘tasmiṃ paṭipaviṭṭhamhi, añño āgañchi brāhmaṇo’’tiādīsu (su. ni. 985; cūḷani. pārāyanavaggo, vatthugāthā 4) viya, tasmā samāhite citte vigatūpakkilese katakiccena pacchā haritabbaṃ pavattetabbanti paṭihāriyaṃ, attano vā upakkilesesu catutthajjhānamaggehi haritesu pacchā haraṇaṃ paṭihāriyaṃ, iddhiādesanānusāsaniyo ca vigatūpakkilesena katakiccena ca sattahitatthaṃ puna pavattetabbā, haritesu ca attano upakkilesesu parasattānaṃ upakkilesaharaṇāni hontīti paṭihāriyāni bhavanti. Paṭihāriyameva pāṭihāriyaṃ, paṭihāriye vā iddhiādesanānusāsanisamudāye bhavaṃ ekamekaṃ pāṭihāriyanti vuccati. Paṭihāriyaṃ vā catutthajjhānaṃ maggo ca paṭipakkhaharaṇato, tattha jātaṃ, tasmiṃ vā nimittabhūte, tato vā āgatanti pāṭihāriyaṃ. Tassa pana iddhiādibhedena visayabhedena ca bahuvidhassa bhagavato desanāyaṃ labbhamānattā āha – ‘‘vividhapāṭihāriya’’nti. “种种神变(Vividhapāṭihāriya)”中,关于“神变(pāṭihāriya)”一词的语义,有说:“因其能摧伏对立、去除贪等烦恼,故为‘神变’。”然而,世尊已无贪等对立的烦恼需要去除。即使是凡夫,当其心远离随烦恼、具足八种功德、摧伏对立时,也能发起神通(iddhi),因此依据世俗的说法,此处亦不能称为“神变”。不过,如果说对于大悲世尊而言,所化有情的烦恼即是对立,去除彼等烦恼被称为“神变”,这样说就合理了。或者,外道(titthiya)是世尊及教法的对立,摧伏他们即是神变。因为他们因其邪见被去除,以及无力阐明其见解,而被神通、记心术(ādesanā)和教诫(anusāsanī)所摧伏、去除。“Paṭī”这一前缀,有时也表示“之后”的意思,如同“在他进入后,另一位婆罗门来了”等句。因此,由已得心专注、已离随烦恼、已作所应作者,于其后所发起的,即是神变。或者,在自身的随烦恼已被第四禅(catutthajjhāna)和道(magga)去除之后,再行去除(他人烦恼之事),即是神变。神通、记心术和教诫,是由已离随烦恼、已作所应作者,为了有情的利益而再次发起的;并且,在自身的随烦恼已被去除时,它们成为去除其他有情之随烦恼的工具,因此是神变。神变即是神变本身;或者,在由神通、记心术、教诫所构成的集合中,其中每一个都称为神变。或者,第四禅和道,因能摧伏对立面,故为“paṭihāriya”(能摧伏者);而生于其中,或以其为因,或从其而来的,即是“pāṭihāriya”(神变)。由于在世尊的教导中,可以见到它有神通等差别以及所缘的差别而为多种,故说“种种神变”。 Na aññathāti bhagavato sammukhā sutākārato na aññathāti attho, na pana bhagavato desitākārato. Acinteyyānubhāvā hi bhagavato desanā. Evañca katvā ‘‘sabbappakārena ko samattho viññātu’’nti idaṃ vacanaṃ samatthitaṃ bhavati, dhāraṇabaladassanañca na virujjhati sutākārāvirujjhanassa adhippetattā. Na hettha atthantaratāparihāro dvinnaṃ atthānaṃ ekavisayattā, itarathā thero bhagavato desanāya sabbathā paṭiggahaṇe samattho asamattho cāti āpajjeyyāti. “非他(Na aññathā)”的含义是:就从世尊面前听闻的形态而言“非他”,而非就世尊教导的形态而言。因为世尊的教导具有不可思议的威力(acinteyyānubhāva)。这样一来,“谁能以一切方式了知?”这句话便得以成立,并且(阿难陀的)持力(dhāraṇabala)之展现也不相矛盾,因为此处的意趣在于不与听闻的形态相违。此处并无舍弃另一义的问题,因为两种含义指向同一对象。否则,长老(thera)就会陷入既能又不能完全领受世尊教导的矛盾之中。 ‘‘Yo paro na hoti, so attā’’ti evaṃ vuttāya niyakajjhattasaṅkhātāya sasantatiyaṃ vattanato tividhopi me-saddo kiñcāpi ekasmiṃyeva atthe dissati, karaṇasampadānasāminiddesavasena pana vijjamānabhedaṃ sandhāyāha – ‘‘me-saddo tīsu atthesu dissatī’’ti. “非他者,即是自我”,由于“me”这个词用于如此所述、被称为“自己的、内在的”自身相续(sasantati)中,所以尽管三种“me”字看似仅用于同一意义,但考虑到其在具格(karaṇa)、为格(sampadāna)、属格(sāminiddesa)用法上的现有差别,故说:“‘me’字可见于三种意义中。” Kiñcāpi [Pg.27] upasaggo kiriyaṃ viseseti, jotakabhāvato pana satipi tasmiṃ suta-saddo eva taṃ tamatthaṃ vadatīti anupasaggassa suta-saddassa atthuddhāre saupasaggassa gahaṇaṃ na virujjhatīti dassento ‘‘saupasaggo ca anupasaggo cā’’ti āha. Assāti sutasaddassa. Kammabhāvasādhanāni idha sutasadde sambhavantīti vuttaṃ – ‘‘upadhāritanti vā upadhāraṇanti vā attho’’ti. Mayāti atthe satīti yadā me-saddassa kattuvasena karaṇaniddeso, tadāti attho. Mamāti atthe satīti yadā sambandhavasena sāminiddeso, tadā. 为了表明“虽然前缀(upasagga)修饰动词(kiriya),但由于其指示作用(jotakabhāva),即使有前缀,‘suta’一词本身也能表达其各自的意义,因此在阐释无前缀(anupasagga)的‘suta’一词时,引用带前缀(saupasagga)的词并不矛盾”,故说“带前缀与不带前缀”。“它的(Assa)”即指“suta”一词的。此处“suta”一词可有宾格(kamma)和状态(bhāva)两种派生,故说其义为“被领受者(upadhārita)”或“领受(upadhāraṇa)”。当“me”字在行动上是具格(karaṇaniddesa)的表述时,其义为“由我(mayā)”。当其是基于关系而作属格(sāminiddesa)的表述时,其义为“我的(mama)”。 Sutasaddasanniṭṭhāne payuttena evaṃ-saddena savanakiriyājotakena bhavitabbanti vuttaṃ – ‘‘evanti sotaviññāṇādiviññāṇakiccanidassana’’nti. Ādi-saddena sampaṭicchanādīnaṃ sotadvārikaviññāṇānaṃ tadabhinīhaṭānañca manodvārikaviññāṇānaṃ gahaṇaṃ veditabbaṃ. Sabbesampi vākyānaṃ evakāratthasahitattā ‘‘suta’’nti etassa sutamevāti ayamattho labbhatīti āha – ‘‘assavanabhāvappaṭikkhepato’’ti. Etena avadhāraṇena niyāmataṃ dasseti. Yathā ca sutaṃ sutamevāti niyāmetabbaṃ, taṃ sammā sutaṃ hotīti āha – ‘‘anūnādhikāviparītaggahaṇanidassana’’nti. Atha vā saddantaratthāpohanavasena saddo atthaṃ vadatīti sutanti assutaṃ na hotīti ayametassa atthoti vuttaṃ – ‘‘assavanabhāvappaṭikkhepato’’ti. Iminā diṭṭhādivinivattanaṃ karoti. Idaṃ vuttaṃ hoti – na idaṃ mayā diṭṭhaṃ, na sayambhuñāṇena sacchikataṃ, atha kho sutaṃ, tañca sammadevāti. Tenevāha – ‘‘anūnādhikāviparītaggahaṇanidassana’’nti. Avadhāraṇatthe vā evaṃ-sadde ayamatthayojanā – ‘‘karīyatī’’ti tadapekkhassa suta-saddassa ayamattho vutto ‘‘assavanabhāvappaṭikkhepato’’ti. Tenevāha – ‘‘anūnādhikāviparītaggahaṇanidassana’’nti. Savana-saddo cettha kammattho veditabbo ‘‘suyyatī’’ti. 在“suta”一词的结尾处,所使用的“evaṃ”一词应作为听闻行为(savana-kiriya)的指示,故说:“‘evaṃ’(如是)是耳识(sotaviññāṇa)等识之作用的指示。”其中的“等(ādi)”字,当知包含领受(sampaṭicchana)等耳门识(sotadvārika-viññāṇa)以及由其引生的意门识(manodvārika-viññāṇa)。由于所有句子都带有“eva”(仅)字的含义,因此对于“sutaṃ”(所闻),可以得到“sutaṃ eva”(仅仅是所闻)的意义,故说:“通过排除非听闻的状态。”通过此决定义(avadhāraṇa),显示了其确定性。并且,正如“所闻”应被确定为“仅仅是所闻”,此即为如实地听闻,故说:“显示了无缺、无增、无倒的领受。”或者,词语通过排除其他词义的方式来表达意义,因此“sutaṃ”(所闻)即是“非未闻”,此即其义,故说:“通过排除非听闻的状态。”此举排除了“所见(diṭṭha)”等。此即是说:这不是我所见,不是以自觉智(sayambhuñāṇa)所亲证,而是所闻,并且是如实地听闻。因此说:“显示了无缺、无增、无倒的领受。”或者,当“evaṃ”一词有决定义时,其义理结合如下:对于与其相关的“suta”一词,其义被说为“排除非听闻的状态”。因此说:“显示了无缺、无增、无倒的领受。”此处的“savana”(听闻)一词,当知其有宾格义,即“被听闻(suyyati)”。 Evaṃ savanahetusavanavisesavasena padattayassa ekena pakārena atthayojanaṃ dassetvā idāni pakārantarehi taṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘tathā eva’’ntiādi vuttaṃ. Tattha tassāti yā sā bhagavato sammukhā dhammassavanākārena pavattā manodvāraviññāṇavīthi, tassā. Sā hi nānappakārena ārammaṇe pavattituṃ samatthā. Tathā ca vuttaṃ – ‘‘sotadvārānusārenā’’ti. Nānappakārenāti vakkhamānānaṃ anekavihitānaṃ [Pg.28] byañjanatthaggahaṇānaṃ nānākārena. Etena imissā yojanāya ākārattho evaṃ-saddo gahitoti dīpeti. Pavattibhāvappakāsananti pavattiyā atthibhāvappakāsanaṃ. Sutanti dhammappakāsananti yasmiṃ ārammaṇe vuttappakārā viññāṇavīthi nānappakārena pavattā, tassa dhammattā vuttaṃ, na sutasaddassa dhammatthattā. Vuttassevatthassa pākaṭīkaraṇaṃ ‘‘ayañhetthā’’tiādi. Tattha viññāṇavīthiyāti karaṇatthe karaṇavacanaṃ, mayāti kattuatthe. 如是,以一种方式,即通过听闻之因(savanahetu)与听闻之差别(savanavisesa),说明了三词(padattaya)的义理结合(atthayojana)之后,现在为了以其他方式来说明,而说“如是(tathā eva)”等。其中,“它的(tassā)”是指那在世尊面前以闻法方式生起的意门心路(manodvāraviññāṇavīthi)。此心路确实能够以多种方式在所缘(ārammaṇa)上运作。如是亦说:“随顺耳门。”“以多种方式(nānappakārena)”是指以多种形态领会下文将述的各种文句与意义。由此显示,在此义理结合中,“evaṃ”一词取方式义。“显示运作状态(pavattibhāvappakāsana)”即是显示运作的存在。“‘所闻’即是法的开显”,这是因为,上述心路以多种方式运作于其上的那个所缘,其本身是法,故如此说;并非因为“suta”一词有“法”的意义。对已说之义的阐明,即是“此中……”等文。其中,“以心路(viññāṇavīthiyā)”是具格(karaṇa)用法,表工具义;“由我(mayā)”是作格(kattu)用法,表作者义。 Evanti niddisitabbappakāsananti nidassanatthaṃ evaṃ-saddaṃ gahetvā vuttaṃ nidassetabbassa nidassitabbattābhāvābhāvato. Tena evaṃ-saddena sakalampi suttaṃ paccāmaṭṭhanti dasseti. Sutasaddassa kiriyāsaddattā savanakiriyāya ca sādhāraṇaviññāṇappabandhappaṭibaddhattā tattha ca puggalavohāroti vuttaṃ – ‘‘sutanti puggalakiccappakāsana’’nti. Na hi puggalavohārarahite dhammappabandhe savanakiriyā labbhatīti. 为显明应被指示之相,故取“如是”一词为示例而说,因为应被指示者并非不可指示。因此,用“如是”一词显示整部经皆已被总括。由于“所闻”(suta)一词是动词,且听闻行为又与共同意识相续相关联,并且其中有个人之称谓,故说——“‘所闻’是个人之作用的显明”。因为若法相续中无个人之称谓,则听闻之行为即无法成立。 Yassa cittasantānassātiādipi ākāratthameva evaṃ-saddaṃ gahetvā purimayojanāya aññathā atthayojanaṃ dassetuṃ vuttaṃ. Tattha ākārapaññattīti upādāpaññatti eva dhammānaṃ pavattiākārupādānavasena tathā vuttā. Sutanti visayaniddesoti sotabbabhūto dhammo savanakiriyākattupuggalassa savanakiriyāvasena pavattiṭṭhānanti katvā vuttaṃ. Cittasantānavinimuttassa paramatthato kassaci kattuabhāvepi saddavohārena buddhiparikappitabhedavacanicchāya cittasantānato aññaṃ viya taṃsamaṅgiṃ katvā vuttaṃ – ‘‘cittasantānena taṃsamaṅgīno’’ti. Savanakiriyāvisayopi sotabbadhammo savanakiriyāvasena pavattacittasantānassa idha paramatthato kattubhāvato, savanavasena cittapavattiyā eva vā savanakiriyābhāvato taṃkiriyākattu ca visayo hotīti katvā vuttaṃ – ‘‘taṃsamaṅgīno kattuvisaye’’ti. Sutākārassa ca therassa sammānicchitabhāvato āha – ‘‘gahaṇasanniṭṭhāna’’nti. Etena vā avadhāraṇatthaṃ evaṃ-saddaṃ gahetvā ayamatthayojanā katāti daṭṭhabbaṃ. “于彼心相续”等句,亦是取“如是”一词为行相之义,为显示与前述解释不同之义而说。此处所说之“行相施設”,即是取著施設,诸法依其生起之行相与取著而如是说。“所闻”是指所缘的解释,即可闻之法,由于听闻行为之作者个人的听闻行为而成为生起之所依,故如是说。从胜义而言,即使不存在任何离于心相续之作者,然依世俗言说,为欲表达由智所构想之差别言说,犹如将与心相续相应者视作异于心相续而说,故说:“心相续与其相应者。”可闻之法,即使是听闻行为之所缘,然于此处,从胜义而言,由于依听闻行为而生起之心相续是作者,或由于依听闻而生起之心自身即是听闻行为,故听闻行为之作者亦成为所缘境,因此说:“与其相应者于作者境。”又因长老如实决定所闻之行相,故说:“执持决定。”应知,亦可取“如是”一词为强调之义,而作此意义之解释。 Pubbe sutānaṃ nānāvihitānaṃ suttasaṅkhātānaṃ atthabyañjanānaṃ upadhāritarūpassa ākārassa nidassanassa, avadhāraṇassa vā pakāsanasabhāvo [Pg.29] evaṃ-saddoti tadākārādiupadhāraṇassa puggalapaññattiyā upādānabhūtadhammappabandhabyāpāratāya vuttaṃ – ‘‘evanti puggalakiccaniddeso’’ti. Savanakiriyā pana puggalavādinopi viññāṇanirapekkhā natthīti visesato viññāṇabyāpāroti āha – ‘‘sutanti viññāṇakiccaniddeso’’ti. Meti saddappavattiyā ekanteneva sattavisayattā viññāṇakiccassa ca tattheva samodahitabbato ‘‘meti ubhayakiccayuttapuggalaniddeso’’ti vuttaṃ. Avijjamānapaññattivijjamānapaññattisabhāvā yathākkamaṃ evaṃsaddasutasaddānaṃ atthāti te tathārūpapaññattiupādānabyāpārabhāvena dassento āha – ‘‘evanti puggalakiccaniddeso, sutanti viññāṇakiccaniddeso’’ti. Ettha ca karaṇakiriyākattukammavisesappakāsanavasena puggalabyāpāravisayapuggalabyāpāranidassanavasena gahaṇākāraggāhakatabbisayavisesaniddesavasena kattukaraṇabyāpārakattuniddesavasena ca dutiyādayo catasso atthayojanā dassitāti daṭṭhabbaṃ. “如是”一词的本质,是显明往昔所闻、名为经的种种义理与文句之已把握相状、行相、指示或确定。由于把握彼等行相是作为个人(puggala)施設之所依的法相续的运作,故说:“‘如是’是个人作用的解释。”然而,听闻行为即使是个人论者(puggalavādin)也承认,若无识则无法成立,故特别指出识之作用,说:“‘所闻’是识之作用的解释。”“我”字,因其言说之运用,完全以有情为对象,且识之作用亦应于其中协调统一,故说:“‘我’是兼具两种作用之个人的解释。”“非有施設”与“现有施設”之本质,依次为“如是”声与“所闻”声之义。为显示彼等作为如是施設之执取运作之相,故说:“‘如是’是个人作用的解释,‘所闻’是识之作用的解释。”在此应知,通过显示工具、行为、作者、宾语的差别,通过指示个人作用及其作用领域,通过指示把握的行相、把握者及其所缘的差别,以及通过指示作者、工具、运作与作者,已显示了第二等四种意义的解释。 Sabbassapi saddādhigamanīyassa atthassa paññattimukheneva paṭipajjitabbattā sabbapaññattīnañca vijjamānādivasena chasu paññattibhedesu antogadhattā tesu ‘‘eva’’ntiādīnaṃ paññattīnaṃ sarūpaṃ niddhārento āha – ‘‘evanti ca meti cā’’tiādi. Tattha evanti ca meti ca vuccamānassatthassa ākārādino dhammānaṃ asallakkhaṇabhāvato avijjamānapaññattibhāvoti āha – ‘‘saccikaṭṭhaparamatthavasena avijjamānapaññattī’’ti. Tattha saccikaṭṭhaparamatthavasenāti bhūtatthauttamatthavasena. Idaṃ vuttaṃ hoti – yo māyāmarīciādayo viya abhūtattho, anussavādīhi gahetabbo viya anuttamattho ca na hoti, so rūpasaddādisabhāvo, ruppanānubhavanādisabhāvo vā attho saccikaṭṭho paramattho cāti vuccati, na tathā ‘‘evaṃ me’’tipadānaṃ atthoti. Etamevatthaṃ pākaṭataraṃ kātuṃ ‘‘kiñhettha ta’’ntiādi vuttaṃ. Sutanti pana saddāyatanaṃ sandhāyāha – ‘‘vijjamānapaññattī’’ti. Teneva hi ‘‘yañhi taṃ ettha sotena upaladdha’’nti vuttaṃ. ‘‘Sotadvārānusārena upaladdha’’nti pana vutte atthabyañjanādi sabbaṃ labbhati. Taṃ taṃ upādāya vattabbatoti sotapathamāgate dhamme upādāya tesaṃ upadhāritākārādino paccāmasanavasena evanti, sasantatipariyāpanne khandhe upādāya meti vattabbattāti attho. Diṭṭhādisabhāvarahite saddāyatane pavattamānopi [Pg.30] sutavohāro ‘‘dutiyaṃ tatiya’’ntiādiko viya paṭhamādīni diṭṭhamutaviññāte apekkhitvā pavattoti āha – ‘‘diṭṭhādīni upanidhāya vattabbato’’ti. Assutaṃ na hotīti hi sutanti pakāsito ayamatthoti. 由于一切可由言说通达之义,皆须通过施設之门方能把握,且一切施設皆包含于现有等六种施設分类中,故在确定“如是”等施設之自性时,说:“如是”与“我”等。此处所说“如是”与“我”之义,因其行相等法不具自相,故说其为“非有施設”,并说:“从真实义与胜义而言,为非有施設。”其中“从真实义与胜义而言”,是指基于真实义与最上义而言。此意谓:凡非如幻影阳焰等之非真实义,亦非如传闻等可执取之非最上义者,彼色声等自性,或变坏、感受等自性之义,方称为真实义与胜义,而“如是我”等词之义则非如此。为使此义更显明,故说:“此处何者?”等语。然而“所闻”是就声处而言,故说:“现有施設。”正因此故,说:“凡于此处以耳所证得者。”然而,若说“依耳门随顺而证得”,则义理、文句等一切皆可得。应依彼彼而说:当法入耳道时,依其所把握之行相等而反思,故说“如是”;依自相续所摄之蕴而说“我”,此即其义。虽然在声处中没有见等自性,但“所闻”之世俗言说,即使如“第二、第三”等,亦是参照最初所见、所闻、所识而生起,故说:“需依所见等而说。”“非未曾闻”即是“所闻”,此义即是如此显示。 Attanā paṭividdhā suttassa pakāravisesā evanti therena paccāmaṭṭhāti āha – ‘‘asammohaṃ dīpetī’’ti. Nānappakārappaṭivedhasamattho hotīti etena vakkhamānassa suttassa nānappakārataṃ duppaṭivijjhatañca dasseti. Sutassa asammosaṃ dīpetīti sutākārassa yāthāvato dassiyamānattā vuttaṃ. Asammohenāti sammohābhāvena, paññāya eva vā savanakālasambhūtāya taduttarikālapaññāsiddhi. Evaṃ asammosenāti etthāpi vattabbaṃ. Byañjanānaṃ paṭivijjhitabbo ākāro nātigambhīro, yathāsutadhāraṇameva tattha karaṇīyanti satiyā byāpāro adhiko, paññā tattha guṇībhūtāti vuttaṃ – ‘‘paññāpubbaṅgamāyā’’tiādi ‘‘paññāya pubbaṅgamā’’ti katvā. Pubbaṅgamatā cettha padhānabhāvo ‘‘manopubbaṅgamā’’tiādīsu (dha. pa. 1, 2) viya, pubbaṅgamatāya vā cakkhuviññāṇādīsu āvajjanādīnaṃ viya appadhānatte paññā pubbaṅgamā etissāti ayampi attho yujjati, evaṃ satipubbaṅgamāyāti etthāpi vuttanayānusārena yathāsambhavamattho veditabbo. Atthabyañjanasampannassāti atthabyañjanaparipuṇṇassa, saṅkāsanappakāsanavivaraṇavibhajanauttānīkaraṇapaññattivasena chahi atthapadehi akkharapadabyañjanākāraniruttiniddesavasena chahi byañjanapadehi ca samannāgatassāti vā attho daṭṭhabbo. 长老反思自身所通达之经的种种特相为“如是”,故说:“显示无痴。”此谓“能通达种种特相”,以此显示即将讲述之经具有多种特相且难以通达。“显示所闻之无错谬”,乃因如实显示所闻之行相故说。“以无痴”,即以无迷惑,或指以听闻时所生之慧,以及其后所成就之慧。“如是以无错谬”,此处亦应如是说。文句所应通达之行相并非极深奥,只需如闻持诵即可,于此正念之作用更重,智慧则为辅助,故说“以慧为先导”等,作“以慧为先”。此处之“先导性”,如“意为先导”等(《法句经》1, 2)所示,是主导之义;或者,如眼识等中作意等虽为先导而非主导,然智慧是其先导,此义亦可成立。如是,“以念为先导”中,亦应依照上述方式理解其相应之义。“具足义与文者”,即义与文圆满者,或应理解其义为:以显示、阐明、开显、分析、揭示、施設六种义句,以及以字母、词、文句、形式、语言、解释六种文句所具足。 Yonisomanasikāraṃ dīpeti evaṃ-saddena vuccamānānaṃ ākāranidassanāvadhāraṇatthānaṃ aviparītasaddhammavisayattāti adhippāyo. Avikkhepaṃ dīpetīti ‘‘cittapariyādānaṃ kattha bhāsita’’ntiādipucchāvase pakaraṇappattassa vakkhamānassa suttassa savanaṃ samādhānamantarena na sambhavatīti katvā vuttaṃ. Vikkhittacittassātiādi tassevatthassa samatthanavasena vuttaṃ. Sabbasampattiyāti atthabyañjanadesakappayojanādisampattiyā. Aviparītasaddhammavisayehi viya ākāranidassanāvadhāraṇatthehi yonisomanasikārassa, saddhammassavanena viya ca avikkhepassa yathā yonisomanasikārena phalabhūtena attasammāpaṇidhipubbekatapuññatānaṃ siddhi vuttā [Pg.31] tadavinābhāvato. Evaṃ avikkhepena phalabhūtena kāraṇabhūtānaṃ saddhammassavanasappurisūpanissayānaṃ siddhi dassetabbā siyā assutavato sappurisūpanissayarahitassa ca tadabhāvato. Na hi vikkhittacittotiādinā samatthanavacanena pana avikkhepena kāraṇabhūtena sappurisūpanissayena ca phalabhūtassa saddhammassavanassa siddhi dassitā. Ayaṃ panettha adhippāyo yutto siyā, saddhammassavanasappurisūpanissayā na ekantena avikkhepassa kāraṇaṃ bāhiraṅgattā, avikkhepo pana sappurisūpanissayo viya saddhammassavanassa ekantakāraṇanti. Evampi avikkhepena sappurisūpanissayasiddhijotanā na samatthitāva. No na samatthitā vikkhittacittānaṃ sappurisapayirupāsanābhāvassa atthasiddhattā. Ettha ca purimaṃ phalena kāraṇassa siddhidassanaṃ nadīpūrena viya upari vuṭṭhisabbhāvassa, dutiyaṃ kāraṇena phalassa siddhidassanaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ ekantavassinā viya meghavuṭṭhānena vuṭṭhippavattiyā. “‘如理作意’显示”,其意是:‘如是’(evaṃ)一词所指的行相、显示、确定之义,皆以不颠倒之正法为所缘。“‘显示不散乱’”,乃因在“心之遍取于何处说”等提问的情况下,即将讲述之经文,若无定力则无法听闻,故如是说。“‘心散乱者’”等语,皆为支持此义而说。“‘一切圆满’”,指义理、文句、说法者、时机、运用等圆满。犹如如理作意以不颠倒之正法为所缘的行相、显示、确定之义,不散乱亦以听闻正法为所缘。正如以作为果的如理作意,说(能)成就自身正愿与往昔所作福德,因其不可分离。如是,应通过作为果的不散乱,显示作为因的听闻正法与亲近善士的成就,因为未曾听闻者与无亲近善士者,则无此成就。然而,“‘心不散乱者’”等支持性言语,则显示了通过作为因的不散乱与亲近善士,(能)成就作为果的听闻正法。此处之意应是:听闻正法与亲近善士并非绝对是不散乱之因,因其为外缘;而不散乱,则如亲近善士一般,是听闻正法的绝对之因。即使如此,通过不散乱来彰显亲近善士的成就,也并未得到支持。不,并非未得到支持,因为心散乱者无亲近善士,此义已然成立。此处,前一种情况应视为以果显示因的成就,犹如以河水泛滥推断上游有雨;第二种情况应视为以因显示果的成就,犹如以必然降雨的乌云升起推断降雨的发生。 Bhagavato vacanassa atthabyañjanappabhedaparicchedavasena sakalasāsanasampattiogāhanākāro niravasesaparahitapāripūritākāraṇanti vuttaṃ – ‘‘evaṃ bhaddako ākāro’’ti. Yasmā na hotīti sambandho. Pacchimacakkadvayasampattinti attasammāpaṇidhipubbekatapuññatāsaṅkhātaguṇadvayaṃ. Aparāparaṃ vuttiyā cettha cakkabhāvo, caranti etehi sattā sampattibhavesūti vā. Ye sandhāya vuttaṃ – ‘‘cattārimāni, bhikkhave, cakkāni, yehi samannāgatānaṃ devamanussānaṃ catucakkaṃ vattatī’’tiādi (a. ni. 4.31). Purimapacchimabhāvo cettha desanākkamavasena daṭṭhabbo. Pacchimacakkadvayasiddhiyāti pacchimacakkadvayassa atthitāya. Sammāpaṇihitatto pubbe ca katapuñño suddhāsayo hoti tadasiddhihetūnaṃ kilesānaṃ dūrībhāvatoti āha – ‘‘āsayasuddhi siddhā hotī’’ti. Tathā hi vuttaṃ – ‘‘sammāpaṇihitaṃ cittaṃ, seyyaso naṃ tato kare’’ti (dha. pa. 43), ‘‘katapuññosi tvaṃ, ānanda, padhānamanuyuñja, khippaṃ hohisi anāsavo’’ti (dī. ni. 2.207) ca. Tenevāha – ‘‘āsayasuddhiyā adhigamabyattisiddhī’’ti. Payogasuddhiyāti yonisomanasikārapubbaṅgamassa dhammassavanappayogassa visadabhāvena. Tathā cāha – ‘‘āgamabyattisiddhī’’ti, sabbassa vā kāyavacīpayogassa niddosabhāvena. Parisuddhakāyavacīpayogo hi vippaṭisārābhāvato avikkhittacitto pariyattiyaṃ visārado hotīti. 世尊的言说,以义理、文句、类别、界限而遍入一切教法圆满之相,是无余圆满利他之因,故说:“如是善妙之相。”此乃与“无有”相关联。“后二轮的圆满”,是指名为自身正愿与宿世所作福的二种功德。或谓众生依此等轮而在善趣中流转。如经中所说:“诸比丘,有此四轮,具足此四轮的天人,其四轮运转”等(《增支部》4.31)。此处的前后次第,当依说法次第而观。“后二轮的成就”,即是后二轮的存在。有正愿者、宿世已作福者,其意乐清净,因为远离彼等成就之障——烦恼,故说:“意乐清净得以成就。”如是亦说:“正愿所系之心,能令其更胜妙”(《法句经》43),以及“阿难(Ānanda),汝已作福,勤修精进,速当无漏”(《长部》2.207)。故说:“由意乐清净,证达之明了得以成就。”“行持清净”,是指以如理作意为前导的闻法行持的明晰性。如是亦说:“教典之明了得以成就”,或指一切身语行持的无过失性。身语行持清净者,因为无追悔,心不散乱,于教理(pariyatti)能得娴熟。 Nānappakārapaṭivedhadīpakenātiādinā [Pg.32] atthabyañjanesu therassa evaṃ-saddasuta-saddānaṃ asammohadīpanato catuppaṭisambhidāvasena atthayojanaṃ dasseti. Tattha sotappabhedapaṭivedhadīpakenāti etena ayaṃ suta-saddo evaṃ-saddasannidhānato, vakkhamānāpekkhāya vā sāmaññeneva sotabbadhammavisesaṃ āmasatīti dasseti. Manodiṭṭhikaraṇānaṃ pariyattidhammānaṃ anupekkhanasuppaṭivedhā visesato manasikārappaṭibaddhāti te vuttanayena yonisomanasikāradīpakena evaṃ-saddena yojetvā, savanadhāraṇavacīparicayā pariyattidhammā visesena sotāvadhānappaṭibaddhāti te avikkhepadīpakena suta-saddena yojetvā dassento sāsanasampattiyā dhammassavane ussāhaṃ janeti. Tattha dhammāti pariyattidhammā. Manasā anupekkhitāti ‘‘idha sīlaṃ kathitaṃ, idha samādhi, idha paññā, ettakā ettha anusandhayo’’tiādinā nayena manasā anu anu pekkhitā. Diṭṭhiyā suppaṭividdhāti nijjhānakkhanti bhūtāya, ñātapariññāsaṅkhātāya vā diṭṭhiyā tattha tattha vuttarūpārūpadhamme ‘‘iti rūpaṃ, ettakaṃ rūpa’’ntiādinā suṭṭhu vavatthapetvā paṭividdhā. 以“种种通达之阐明”等句,长老于义理与文句中,以不迷惑之阐明,显示“如是”(evaṃ)与“闻”(suta)二字,是依四无碍解而作的义理结合。其中,以“闻声差别通达之阐明”,显示此“闻”字,因其邻近“如是”字,或依其后文,通常触及应闻之殊胜法。对于以意与见所行的教法,因其不随观则难以善通达,故特别与作意(manasikāra)相连,因此配合以依所说之理而阐明如理作意的“如是”字;又,听闻、受持、言语熟练的教法,特别与听闻专注相连,故配合以阐明不散乱的“闻”字,从而于教法圆满中,激发闻法之精进。此处之“法”,指教法(pariyattidhammā)。“以意随观”是指,以“此处说戒,此处说定,此处说慧,此处有如是连贯”等方式,以意一一随观。“以见善通达”是指,以审察忍可之见,或以名为知遍知之见,于彼处所说之色法与无色法,如“此是色,色有如许”等,善加确立而通达。 Sakalena vacanenāti pubbe tīhi padehi visuṃ visuṃ yojitattā vuttaṃ. Asappurisabhūminti akataññutaṃ, ‘‘idhekacco pāpabhikkhu tathāgatappaveditaṃ dhammavinayaṃ pariyāpuṇitvā attano dahatī’’ti (pārā. 195) evaṃ vuttaṃ anariyavohārāvatthaṃ. Sā eva anariyavohārāvatthā asaddhammo. Nanu ca ānandattherassa ‘‘mamedaṃ vacana’’nti adhimānassa, mahākassapattherādīnañca tadāsaṅkāya abhāvato asappurisabhūmisamatikkamādivacanaṃ niratthakanti? Nayidamevaṃ, ‘‘evaṃ me suta’’nti vadantena ayampi attho vibhāvitoti dassanato. Keci pana ‘‘devatānaṃ parivitakkāpekkhaṃ tathāvacananti edisī codanā anavakāsā’’ti vadanti. Tasmiṃ kira khaṇe ekaccānaṃ devatānaṃ evaṃ cetaso parivitakko udapādi ‘‘bhagavā parinibbuto, ayañca āyasmā desanākusalo idāni dhammaṃ deseti, sakyakulappasuto tathāgatassa bhātā cūḷapituputto, kiṃ nu kho sayaṃ sacchikataṃ dhammaṃ deseti, udāhu bhagavato eva vacanaṃ yathāsuta’’nti, evaṃ tadāsaṅkitappakārato asappurisabhūmisamokkamādito atikkamādi vibhāvitanti. Attano adahantoti ‘‘mameda’’nti attani aṭṭhapento. Appetīti [Pg.33] nidasseti. Diṭṭhadhammikasamparāyikaparamatthesu yathārahaṃ satte netīti netti, dhammoyeva netti dhammanetti. “以全部言说”,是因前面三句已各自结合而说。“非善士之境”,即不知恩(akataññuta)。如“此处有某恶比丘,学习如来所宣说之法与律后,却据为己有”(《律藏》195)所说之非圣者行持状态。彼非圣者行持状态即是非法。难道具寿阿难(Ānanda)长老生起“此是我言”的增上慢,以及具寿大迦叶(Mahākassapa)长老等人当时无此疑虑,故说超越非善士之境等言说,是无意义的吗?并非如此,因说“如是我闻”者,亦阐明此义。然而,有些人说:“此言说是针对诸天的思惟,故此等责难无有立足之地。”据说当时有些天神心中生起如是思惟:“世尊已般涅槃,此具寿善于说法,今正说法,彼乃释迦族人,如来之堂弟,究竟是自证之法,抑或仅是世尊之言说,如其所闻?”如是,因当时有此疑虑,故阐明超越非善士之境等。“不据为己有”(attano adahanto),是指不将“此是我言”归于自己。“交付”(appeti)即是“显示”(nidasseti)。“引导”(netti)是指于现法、来世与究竟义中,如其所应引导众生,故名引导;法即是引导,故名“法引导”(dhammanetti)。 Daḷhataraniviṭṭhā vicikicchā kaṅkhā. Nātisaṃsappanaṃ matibhedamattaṃ vimati. Assaddhiyaṃ vināseti bhagavatā bhāsitattā sammukhā cassa paṭiggahitattā khalitaduruttādiggahaṇadosābhāvato ca. Ettha ca pañcamādayo tisso atthayojanā ākārādiatthesu aggahitavisesameva evaṃ-saddaṃ gahetvā dassitā, tato parā catasso ākāratthameva evaṃ-saddaṃ gahetvā vibhāvitā, pacchimā pana tisso yathākkamaṃ ākāratthaṃ nidassanatthaṃ avadhāraṇatthañca evaṃ-saddaṃ gahetvā yojitāti daṭṭhabbaṃ. 更根深蒂固的“疑”(vicikicchā)是“犹豫”(kaṅkhā)。不甚蔓延、仅是意见分歧的是“疑虑”(vimati)。由于是世尊所说,且当面领受,又无错谬恶说等执取之过,故能破除不信。在此,第五等三种义释,是取“如是”一词,仅就其于相状等义中未把握特殊性者而显示;其后四种,是取“如是”一词,仅阐明其相状义而阐释;最后三种,则依次取“如是”一词,分别对应相状义、例证义与限定义而组合,应当这样看待。 Eka-saddo aññaseṭṭhaasahāyasaṅkhādīsu dissati. Tathā hesa ‘‘sassato attā ca loko ca, idameva saccaṃ moghamaññanti ittheke abhivadantī’’tiādīsu (ma. ni. 3.27) aññatthe dissati, ‘‘cetaso ekodibhāva’’ntiādīsu (dī. ni. 1.228; pārā. 11) seṭṭhe, ‘‘eko vūpakaṭṭho’’tiādīsu (dī. ni. 1.405; 2.215; ma. ni. 1.80; saṃ. ni. 3.63; cūḷava. 445) asahāye ‘‘ekova kho, bhikkhave, khaṇo ca samayo ca brahmacariyavāsāyā’’tiādīsu (a. ni. 8.29) saṅkhāyaṃ. Idhāpi saṅkhāyanti dassento āha – ‘‘ekanti gaṇanaparicchedaniddeso’’ti. Kālañca samayañcāti yuttakālañca paccayasāmaggiñca. Khaṇoti okāso. Tathāgatuppādādiko hi maggabrahmacariyassa okāso tappaccayappaṭilābhahetuttā. Khaṇo eva ca samayo. Yo khaṇoti ca samayoti ca vuccati, so eko evāti hi attho. Mahāsamayoti mahāsamūho. Samayopi khoti sikkhāpadapūraṇassa hetupi. Samayappavādaketi diṭṭhippavādake. Tattha hi nisinnā titthiyā attano attano samayaṃ pavadantīti. Atthābhisamayāti hitappaṭilābhā. Abhisametabboti abhisamayo, abhisamayo attho abhisamayaṭṭhoti pīḷanādīni abhisametabbabhāvena ekībhāvaṃ upanetvā vuttāni. Abhisamayassa vā paṭivedhassa visayabhūto attho abhisamayaṭṭhoti tāneva tathā ekattena vuttāni. Tattha [Pg.34] pīḷanaṃ dukkhasaccassa taṃsamaṅgino hiṃsanaṃ avipphārikatākaraṇaṃ. Santāpo dukkhadukkhatādivasena santapanaṃ paridahanaṃ. “一”字可见于“其他”、“最胜”、“无伴”、“计数”等义。例如,在“‘我与世间是常,唯此是实,余者为虚’,如是,一些人如是说”等句(《中部》3.27)中,用于“其他”义;在“心一境性”等句(《长部》1.228;《波罗夷》11)中,用于“最胜”义;在“独自远离”等句(《长部》1.405, 2.215;《中部》1.80;《相应部》3.63;《小品》445)中,用于“无伴”义;在“诸比丘,仅有此一刹那、一时机得住梵行”等句(《增支部》8.29)中,用于“计数”义。此处亦为显示计数义而说:“‘一’是计数限定的解释。”“时与机缘”,指适时与众缘和合。“刹那”,即机会。如来出世等,实为道与梵行的机会,因其是得彼助缘之因。刹那即是机缘。所谓刹那与机缘,其义实为同一。“大时”,即大集会。“机缘”也是圆满学处的因。“持论者”,即持见论者。因为在那里的外道们坐着宣说各自的学说。“义现观”,即获得利益。应被现观者即是现观;现观之义即是现观的对象,“逼迫”等是通过“应被现观”这一性质而被统一言说的。或者,作为现观或通达之对象的义理,即是现观的对象,彼等亦如是作为一者而被言说。其中,“逼迫”,就苦谛而言,是指对具足此苦者的损害,使其无法分散。“热恼”,是指由苦苦等而有的烧灼、煎熬。 Tattha sahakārikāraṇe sanijjhaṃ sameti samavetīti samayo, samavāyo. Sameti samāgacchati ettha maggabrahmacariyaṃ tadādhārapuggalehīti samayo, khaṇo. Sameti ettha, etena vā saṃgacchati satto, sabhāvadhammo vā sahajātādīhi, uppādādīhi vāti samayo, kālo. Dhammappavattimattatāya atthato abhūtopi hi kālo dhammappavattiyā adhikaraṇaṃ karaṇaṃ viya ca kappanāmattasiddhena rūpena voharīyatīti. Samaṃ, saha vā avayavānaṃ ayanaṃ pavatti avaṭṭhānanti samayo, samūho yathā ‘‘samudāyo’’ti. Avayavasahāvaṭṭhānameva hi samūhoti. Avasesapaccayānaṃ samāgame eti phalaṃ etasmā uppajjati pavattati cāti samayo, hetu yathā ‘‘samudayo’’ti. Sameti saṃyojanabhāvato sambaddho eti attano visaye pavattati, daḷhaggahaṇabhāvato vā saṃyuttā ayanti pavattanti sattā yathābhinivesaṃ etenāti samayo, diṭṭhi. Diṭṭhisaṃyojanena hi sattā ativiya bajjhantīti. Samiti saṅgati samodhānanti samayo, paṭilābho. Samassa yānaṃ, sammā vā yānaṃ apagamoti samayo, pahānaṃ. Abhimukhaṃ ñāṇena sammā etabbo abhisametabboti abhisamayo, dhammānaṃ aviparīto sabhāvo. Abhimukhabhāvena sammā eti gacchati bujjhatīti abhisamayo, dhammānaṃ aviparītasabhāvāvabodho. Evaṃ tasmiṃ tasmiṃ atthe samayasaddassa pavatti veditabbā. Samayasaddassa atthuddhāre abhisamayasaddassa udāharaṇaṃ vuttanayena veditabbaṃ. Assāti samayasaddassa. Kālo attho samavāyādīnaṃ atthānaṃ idha asambhavato, desadesakaparisānaṃ viya suttassa nidānabhāvena kālassa apadisitabbato ca. 于此,就协力因而言,为达成果而会合、聚合,故为“时”(samayo),即“和合”(samavāyo)。道与梵行及其所依之人(puggala)于此会合、聚集,故为“时”,即“刹那”(khaṇo)。众生于此、或因此而会合,或自性法与其俱生法等、或与生起等会合,故为“时”,即“时间”(kālo)。虽然时间在胜义上并非实有,但因其是诸法生起的依处与作用,故以假名安立之相而使用。诸部分平等(samaṃ)或共同(saha)行进、流转、安住,故为“时”,即“集合”(samūho),如“聚集”(samudāyo)。因为诸部分的共同安住即是集合。其余诸缘和合时,果从此而生、而转起,故为“时”,即“因”(hetu),如“集”(samudayo)。因其结缚之性而连结,于自境转起;或因其坚固执取之性,众生被其相应,随各自的执着而转起,故为“时”,即“见”(diṭṭhi)。因为众生被见结深深地束缚。会合(samiti)、结合(saṅgati)、聚合(samodhāna),故为“时”,即“获得”(paṭilābho)。平等之行(samassa yānaṃ),或正确地远离(sammā yānaṃ apagamo),故为“时”,即“断”(pahānaṃ)。以智慧正对、应被完全了知,故为“现观”(abhisamayo),即诸法不颠倒的自性。以正对的方式,以智慧而行、而往、而觉,故为“现观”,即对诸法不颠倒自性的觉悟。如是,应知“时”(samaya)一词在彼彼义中的用法。在阐明“时”一词的意义时,“现观”一词的例子应如前述之理而知。“此”(assa)指“时”一词。其义为“时间”,因为“和合”等义于此不成立,且如国家、说法者、听众等,时间亦应作为经的缘起而被指出。 Kasmā panettha aniyamitavaseneva kālo niddiṭṭho, na utusaṃvaccharādivasena niyametvāti āha – ‘‘tattha kiñcāpī’’tiādi. Utusaṃvaccharādivasena niyamaṃ akatvā samayasaddassa vacane ayampi guṇo laddho hotīti dassento ‘‘ye vā ime’’tiādimāha. Sāmaññajotanā hi visese avatiṭṭhatīti. Tattha diṭṭhadhammasukhavihārasamayo devasikaṃ jhānasamāpattīhi vītināmanakālo, visesato sattasattāhāni. Suppakāsāti dasasahassilokadhātuyā pakampanaobhāsapātubhāvādīhi [Pg.35] pākaṭā. Yathāvuttabhedesu eva samayesu ekadesaṃ pakārantarehi saṅgahetvā dassetuṃ ‘‘yo cāya’’ntiādimāha. Tathā hi ñāṇakiccasamayo attahitappaṭipattisamayo ca abhisambodhisamayo, ariyatuṇhībhāvasamayo diṭṭhadhammasukhavihārasamayo, karuṇākiccaparahitappaṭipattidhammikathāsamayo desanāsamayoyeva. 然则,为何此处以不确定的方式而非以季节、年份等来限定时间呢?答曰:“于此,即使……”等。为显示在‘时’(samaya)一词的用法上,不以季节、年份等方式限定亦能获得此等好处,故说:“或此等……”等。因为总说亦可适用于别说。其中,现法乐住之时,是指每日安住于禅定而度过的时间,特别是七七日。‘善 प्रकाश’(suppakāsā)是指通过一万个世界系的震动、光明显现等而昭著。为了以其他方式总摄并展示上述各种时间中的一部分,故说:“而此……”等。例如,智业之时与自利行之时即是正觉之时;圣默然之时即是现法乐住之时;悲业、利他行与法说之时即是说法之时。 Karaṇavacanena niddeso katoti sambandho. Tatthāti abhidhammavinayesu. Tathāti bhummakaraṇehi. Adhikaraṇattho ādhārattho. Bhāvo nāma kiriyā, kiriyāya kiriyantaralakkhaṇaṃ bhāvenabhāvalakkhaṇaṃ. Tattha yathā kālo sabhāvadhammaparicchinno sayaṃ paramatthato avijjamānopi ādhārabhāvena paññāto taṅkhaṇappavattānaṃ tato pubbe parato ca abhāvato ‘‘pubbaṇhe jāto, sāyanhe gacchatī’’ti ca ādīsu, samūho ca avayavavinimutto avijjamānopi kappanāmattasiddho avayavānaṃ ādhārabhāvena paññāpīyati ‘‘rukkhe sākhā, yavarāsiyaṃ sambhūto’’tiādīsu, evaṃ idhāpīti dassento āha – ‘‘adhikaraṇaṃ…pe… dhammāna’’nti. Yasmiṃ kāle, dhammapuñje vā kāmāvacaraṃ kusalaṃ cittaṃ uppannaṃ hoti, tasmiṃ eva kāle, dhammapuñje ca phassādayopi hontīti ayañhi tattha attho. Yathā ‘‘gāvīsu duyhamānāsu gato, duddhāsu āgato’’ti dohanakiriyāya gamanakiriyā lakkhīyati, evaṃ idhāpi ‘‘yasmiṃ samaye, tasmiṃ samaye’’ti ca vutte ‘‘satī’’ti ayamattho viññāyamāno eva hoti padatthassa sattāvirahābhāvatoti samayassa sattākiriyāya cittassa uppādakiriyā, phassādīnaṃ bhavanakiriyā ca lakkhīyatīti. Yasmiṃ samayeti yasmiṃ navame khaṇe, yasmiṃ yonisomanasikārādihetumhi, paccayasamavāye vā sati kāmāvacaraṃ kusalaṃ cittaṃ uppannaṃ hoti, tasmiṃyeva khaṇe hetumhi paccayasamavāye ca phassādayopi hontīti ubhayattha samayasadde bhummaniddeso kato lakkhaṇabhūtabhāvayuttoti dassento āha – ‘‘khaṇa…pe… lakkhīyatī’’ti. 此谓以工具格(karaṇavacana)作了解释,此为关联。“其中”(tattha)是指在阿毗达摩与律藏中。“如是”(tathā)是指以处格(bhumma)。依止义(adhikaraṇattha)即是所依义(ādhārattha)。所谓“有”(bhāva)即是“行”(kiriyā),以一行作为另一行的表征,即是“以有表有”(bhāvenabhāvalakkhaṇaṃ)。此处,譬如时间,虽为自性法(sabhāvadharma)所限定,究竟上本身不存在,然以依止作用而施设,如刹那生起之事物前后皆无,故曰“早上出生,傍晚离去”等;又如集合,脱离组成部分而实际不存在,仅仅是假名安立,然以组成部分之依止作用而施设,如“树上有枝,麦堆中生”等;为显示此处亦然,故曰“依止……乃至……诸法”。于某时,或于法聚(dhammapuñja)中欲界善心(kāmāvacaraṃ kusalaṃ cittaṃ)生起,即于彼时,及于法聚中触等(phassādayo)亦存在,此即其中之义。譬如“挤牛奶时去,挤完奶后回”,以挤奶之行标识前往之行;如是,此处“于某时,即于彼时”等语句中,“有”(satī)此义应如是理解,因为词义并非不存在,以时间的存在作用,心的生起作用,以及触等的存在作用被标识出来。所谓“于某时”,即于第九刹那(navame khaṇe),或于如理作意(yonisomanasikāra)等因缘、或于诸缘和合(paccayasamavāya)时,欲界善心生起,即于彼刹那、因缘及诸缘和合时,触等亦存在,两处“时”一词皆作处格解释,因其与作为表征的状态相应,故曰“刹那……乃至……被标识”。 Hetuattho karaṇattho ca sambhavati ‘‘annena vasati, ajjhenena vasati, pharasunā chindati, kudālena khaṇatī’’tiādīsu viya. Vītikkamañhi sutvā bhikkhusaṅghaṃ sannipātāpetvā otiṇṇe vatthusmiṃ taṃ puggalaṃ paṭipucchitvā [Pg.36] vigarahitvā ca taṃ taṃ vatthuṃ otiṇṇakālaṃ anatikkamitvā teneva kālena sikkhāpadāni paññāpento bhagavā viharati sikkhāpadapaññattihetuñca apekkhamāno tatiyapārājikādīsu viya. 因义(hetuattho)与工具义(karaṇattho)亦可成立,例如“以食物维生,以学习安住,用斧头砍伐,用锄头挖掘”等。听闻违犯后,世尊召集比丘僧团,于所发生之事上询问该人(puggala),加以呵责后,不逾越事发之时,即于彼时制定学处(sikkhāpada),并省察制定学处之因由,如同第三波罗夷(pārājika)等。 Accantameva ārambhato paṭṭhāya yāva desanāniṭṭhānaṃ parahitappaṭipattisaṅkhātena karuṇāvihārena. Tadatthajotanatthanti accantasaṃyogatthajotanatthaṃ. Upayogavacananiddeso kato yathā ‘‘māsaṃ ajjhetī’’ti. Porāṇāti aṭṭhakathācariyā. Abhilāpamattabhedoti vacanamattena viseso. Tena suttavinayesu vibhattibyattayo katoti dasseti. 从最初开始直至说法完毕,皆以名为“利益他人之行”的悲住(karuṇāvihāra)。其旨在阐明,即旨在阐明“完全连接”(accantasaṃyoga)之义。此是以业格(upayogavacana)作的解释,例如“学习一月”。“古人”(porāṇa)即是义注师(aṭṭhakathācariya)。“仅是言说上的差别”(abhilāpamattabheda)即是“仅在言辞上的不同”。此显示在经藏与律藏中已运用了格的变化(vibhattibyattayo)。 Idāni ‘‘bhagavā’’ti imassa atthaṃ dassento āha – ‘‘bhagavāti garū’’tiādi. Bhagavāti vacanaṃ seṭṭhanti seṭṭhavācakaṃ vacanaṃ, seṭṭhaguṇasahacaraṇaṃ seṭṭhanti vuttaṃ. Atha vā vuccatīti vacanaṃ, attho. Yasmā yo ‘‘bhagavā’’ti vacanena vacanīyo attho, so seṭṭhoti attho. Bhagavāti vacanamuttamanti etthāpi eseva nayo. Gāravayuttoti garubhāvayutto garuguṇayogato. Garukaraṇaṃ vā sātisayaṃ arahatīti gāravayutto, gāravārahoti attho. Sippādisikkhāpakā garū honti, na ca gāravayuttā, ayaṃ pana tādiso na hoti, tasmā garūti vatvā gāravayuttoti vuttanti keci. Vuttoyeva, na idha vattabbo visuddhimaggassa imissā aṭṭhakathāya ekadesabhāvatoti adhippāyo. 今为解释“世尊”(bhagavā)一词之义,故说:“世尊即是师长”(bhagavāti garū)等。“世尊”一词最胜,是说此词为最胜者之称谓,因与最胜之德相应,故说为最胜。或曰,“称谓”(vacanaṃ)即是“义”(attho)。因为以“世尊”一词所称之义,即是最胜义。“世尊是无上之称谓”,此处之理路亦然。“具恭敬”(gāravayutto)者,因与师长之德相应,故具师长之性。或因值得格外恭敬,故为“具恭敬”,意即“值得崇敬”(gāravāraho)。传授技艺等之师长(garū),未必“具恭敬”,而此(世尊)则不然。是故,有说者言:说了“师长”之后,复说“具恭敬”。此义已说,不在此处重述,意为此义注乃《清净道论》之一部分故。 Dhammasarīraṃ paccakkhaṃ karotīti ‘‘yo vo, ānanda, mayā dhammo ca vinayo ca desito paññatto, so vo mamaccayena satthā’’ti (dī. ni. 2.216) vacanato dhammassa satthubhāvapariyāyo vijjatīti katvā vuttaṃ. Vajirasaṅghātasamānakāyo parehi abhejjasarīrattā. Na hi bhagavato rūpakāye kenaci sakkā antarāyo kātunti. Desanāsampattiṃ niddisati vakkhamānassa sakalasuttassa evanti niddisanato. Sāvakasampattiṃ niddisati paṭisambhidāpattena pañcasu ṭhānesu bhagavatā etadagge ṭhapitena mayā mahāsāvakena sutaṃ, tañca kho mayā sutaṃ, na anussutikaṃ, na paramparābhatanti imassa atthassa dīpanato. Kālasampattiṃ niddisati ‘‘bhagavā’’ti padassa sannidhāne payuttassa samayasaddassa kālassa buddhuppādappaṭimaṇḍitabhāvadīpanato[Pg.37]. Buddhuppādaparamā hi kālasampadā. Tenetaṃ vuccati – 现证法身,是依“阿难(Ānanda),我为你们所说、所制的法与律,在我灭度后,便是你们的导师”之语,以法有导师之作用而说。身如金刚之密合,因其身不为他人所坏。确实无人能损害世尊的色身。指示说法圆满,乃因其指明了下文将说的全部经文皆是如此。指示声闻圆满,乃因其阐明此义:“此乃由我——已证无碍解(paṭisambhidā)、于五处被世尊置于第一位之大声闻——所亲闻,非辗转听闻,非依传统传来”。指示时间圆满,乃因其阐明了在“世尊”一词附近所用的“时”(samaya)一词,显示了该时间为佛陀出世所庄严。佛陀出世实为最上之时间圆满。是故说: ‘‘Kappakasāye kaliyuge, buddhuppādo aho mahacchariyaṃ; Hutāvahamajjhe jātaṃ, samuditamakarandamaravinda’’nti. (dī. ni. ṭī. 1.1; saṃ. ni. ṭī. 1.1.1 devatāsaṃyutta); 劫浊争斗世,佛陀出世何奇哉!如于烈火中生,莲华绽放蜜香溢。 Bhagavāti desakasampattiṃ niddisati guṇavisiṭṭhasattuttamagarugāravādhivacanabhāvato. “世尊”(bhagavā)一词表示说法者圆满,盖此词具功德殊胜、众生至上、师长及值得恭敬等称谓之义故。 Evaṃnāmake nagareti kathaṃ panetaṃ nagaraṃ evaṃnāmakaṃ jātanti? Vuccate, yathā kākandassa isino nivāsaṭṭhāne māpitā nagarī kākandī, mākandassa nivāsaṭṭhāne māpitā mākandī, kusambassa nivāsaṭṭhāne māpitā kosambīti vuccati, evaṃ savatthassa isino nivāsaṭṭhāne māpitā nagarī sāvatthīti vuccati. Evaṃ tāva akkharacintakā vadanti. Aṭṭhakathācariyā pana bhaṇanti – ‘‘yaṃ kiñci manussānaṃ upabhogaparibhogaṃ, sabbamettha atthī’’ti sāvatthi. Satthasamāyoge ca ‘kiṃ bhaṇḍamatthī’ti pucchite ‘sabbamatthī’ti vacanamupādāya sāvatthi. 于名为此之城,此城何以得此名?据说,犹如在迦干陀(Kākanda)仙人住处所建之城名为迦干陀城,在摩犍陀(Mākanda)仙人住处所建之城名为摩犍陀城,在拘睒婆(Kusamba)仙人住处所建之城名为憍赏弥(Kosambī),同样地,在舍卫(Savattha)仙人住处所建之城名为舍卫城(Sāvatthī)。此乃语源学家(akkharacintaka)之说。而义注师(aṭṭhakathācariya)则说:因“凡是人之所用、所享,此处一切皆有(sabbam ettha atthi)”,故名舍卫城。又,商队聚集时,若被问及“有何货物?”,答曰“一切皆有(sabbam atthi)”,故取此语而名为舍卫城。 ‘‘Sabbadā sabbūpakaraṇaṃ, sāvatthiyaṃ samohitaṃ; Tasmā sabbamupādāya, sāvatthīti pavuccati. (ma. ni. aṭṭha. 1.14; khu. pā. aṭṭha. 5.maṅgalasuttavaṇṇanā; udā. aṭṭha. 5; paṭi. ma. 2.1.184); 一切资具常丰足,舍卫城中集圆满;是故总括摄一切,舍卫美名由此称。 ‘‘Kosalānaṃ puraṃ rammaṃ, dassaneyyaṃ manoramaṃ; Dasahi saddehi avivittaṃ, annapānasamāyutaṃ. 憍萨罗(Kosala)都城美且妍,赏心悦目甚可观;十音喧阗未曾断,饮食丰饶人共欢。 ‘‘Vuddhiṃ vepullataṃ pattaṃ, iddhaṃ phītaṃ manoramaṃ; Āḷakamandāva devānaṃ, sāvatthipuramuttama’’nti. (ma. ni. aṭṭha. 1.14; khu. pā. aṭṭha. 5.maṅgalasuttavaṇṇanā); 繁荣增长臻圆满,昌盛丰饶心所安;恰似天神阿罗迦(Āḷakamandā),舍卫胜城最无上。 Avisesenāti na visesena, vihārabhāvasāmaññenāti attho. Iriyāpathavihāro…pe… vihāresūti iriyāpathavihāro dibbavihāro brahmavihāro ariyavihāroti etesu catūsu vihāresu. Samaṅgiparidīpananti samaṅgibhāvaparidīpanaṃ. Etanti viharatīti etaṃ padaṃ. Tathā hi taṃ ‘‘idhekacco gihisaṃsaṭṭho viharati sahanandī sahasokī’’tiādīsu (saṃ. ni. 4.241) iriyāpathavihāre āgataṃ, ‘‘yasmiṃ samaye, bhikkhave, bhikkhu vivicceva kāmehi [Pg.38]… paṭhamaṃ jhānaṃ upasampajja viharatī’’tiādīsu (dha. sa. 499; vibha. 624) dibbavihāre, ‘‘so mettāsahagatena cetasā ekaṃ disaṃ pharitvā viharatī’’tiādīsu (dī. ni. 1.556; 3.308; ma. ni. 1.77, 459, 509; 2.309, 315, 451, 471; 3.230, vibha. 642, 643) brahmavihāre, ‘‘so khohaṃ, aggivessana, tassāyeva kathāya pariyosāne tasmiṃyeva purimasmiṃ samādhinimitte ajjhattameva cittaṃ saṇṭhapemi sannisādemi ekodiṃ karomi, samādahāmi, yena sudaṃ niccakappaṃ viharāmī’’tiādīsu (ma. ni. 1.387) ariyavihāre. “无差别”(Avisesena)即“不以差别”,意为“住的共通性”。威仪住(Iriyāpathavihāra)……乃至……于诸住中,即于威仪住、天住(Dibbavihāra)、梵住(Brahmavihāra)、圣住(Ariyavihāra)这四种住中。“阐明具足”(Samaṅgiparidīpana)即“阐明具足的状态”。“此”(etaṃ)即指“住”(viharati)这个词。诚然,它在“于此,某人与在家众交往,同喜同忧而住”等句中,用于威仪住;在“诸比丘,比丘完全远离诸欲……证入初禅而住”等句中,用于天住;在“彼以慈心遍满一方而住”等句中,用于梵住;在“阿耆毗舍那(Aggivessana),我于彼谈话之末……令心于内安立、安住、一趣、等持,我因此而能恒常安住”等句中,用于圣住。 Tattha iriyanaṃ pavattanaṃ iriyā, kāyappayogo. Tassā pavattanūpāyabhāvato ṭhānādi iriyāpatho. Ṭhānasamaṅgī vā hi kāyena kiñci kareyya gamanādīsu aññatarasamaṅgī vā. Atha vā iriyati pavattati etena attabhāvo, kāyakiccaṃ vāti iriyā, tassā pavattiyā upāyabhāvato pathoti iriyāpatho, ṭhānādi eva. So ca atthato gatinivattiādiākārena pavatto catusantatirūpappabandho eva. Viharaṇaṃ, viharati etenāti vā vihāro. Divi bhavo dibbo, tattha bahulappavattiyā brahmapārisajjādidevaloke bhavoti attho. Tattha yo dibbānubhāvo, tadatthāya saṃvattatīti vā dibbo, abhiññābhinīhāravasena mahāgatikattā vā dibbo, dibbo ca so vihāro cāti dibbavihāro, catasso rūpāvacarasamāpattiyo. Arūpasamāpattiyopi ettheva saṅgahaṃ gacchanti. Brahmānaṃ, brahmāno vā vihārā brahmavihārā, catasso appamaññāyo. Ariyo, ariyānaṃ vā vihāro ariyavihāro, cattāri sāmaññaphalāni. So hi ekaṃ iriyāpathabādhanantiādi yadipi bhagavā ekenapi iriyāpathena cirataraṃ kālaṃ attabhāvaṃ pavattetuṃ sakkoti, tathāpi upādinnakasarīrassa ayaṃ sabhāvoti dassetuṃ vuttaṃ. Yasmā vā bhagavā yattha katthaci vasanto veneyyānaṃ dhammaṃ desento nānāsamāpattīhi ca kālaṃ vītināmento vasatīti sattānaṃ attano ca vividhahitasukhaṃ harati upaneti uppādeti, tasmā vividhaṃ haratīti viharatīti evamettha attho veditabbo. 其中,行动的运作名为“威仪”(iriyā),即身体的运用。因其运作的方式是站立等,故称“威仪路”(iriyāpatha)。具足站立者能以身体有所作为,或具足行走等任一[威仪]。或者说,有情以此活动、行动,或说身体的作业,即是“威仪”;因其行动的方式如道路,故称“威仪路”,即站立等。就义理而言,它是以行走、停止等形态运作的四相续色之流。住(viharaṇaṃ),或以此而住,故为“住”(vihāra)。生于天界者为“天”(dibba),意为多活动于梵众天等天界。其中,为成就天之威力,或因神通与决意(abhiññā-abhinīhāra)而有大趣,故为“天”;天且是住,故为“天住”(dibbavihāra),即四色界定。无色界定(arūpasamāpatti)亦摄于此中。梵天(brahmā)之住,或诸梵天之住,为“梵住”(brahmavihāra),即四无量心(appamaññā)。圣者(ariya)之住,或诸圣者之住,为“圣住”(ariyavihāra),即四沙门果(sāmaññaphala)。至于“障碍一种威仪”等句,虽然世尊能以一种威仪长久维持生命,但此乃为显示此所取之身的自性而说。又,因为世尊无论住于何处,皆为所化众生说法,并以各种等至度过时日,为众生及自身带来、引致、生起种种利益与安乐,故此中应理解“带来种种[利益]而住”(viharati)之义。 Jetassa [Pg.39] rājakumārassāti ettha attano paccatthikajanaṃ jinātīti jeto. Sotasaddo viya hi kattusādhano jetasaddo. Atha vā raññā pasenadikosalena attano paccatthikajane jite jātoti jeto. Rañño hi jayaṃ āropetvā kumāro jitavāti jetoti vutto. Maṅgalakāmatāya vā tassa evaṃnāmameva katanti jeto. Maṅgalakāmatāya hi jeyyoti etasmiṃ atthe jetoti vuttaṃ. Vitthāro panātiādinā ‘‘anāthapiṇḍikassa ārāme’’ti ettha sudatto nāma so, gahapati, mātāpitūhi katanāmavasena, sabbakāmasamiddhatāya pana vigatamaccheratāya karuṇādiguṇasamaṅgitāya ca niccakālaṃ anāthānaṃ piṇḍamadāsi. Tena anāthapiṇḍikoti saṅkhaṃ gato. Āramanti ettha pāṇino, visesena vā pabbajitāti ārāmo, tassa pupphaphalādisobhāya nātidūranaccāsannatādipañcavidhasenāsanaṅgasampattiyā ca tato tato āgamma ramanti abhiramanti, anukkaṇṭhitā hutvā nivasantīti attho. Vuttappakārāya vā sampattiyā tattha tattha gatepi attano abbhantaraṃyeva ānetvā rametīti ārāmo. So hi anāthapiṇḍikena gahapatinā jetassa rājakumārassa hatthato aṭṭhārasahiraññakoṭīhi santhārena kiṇitvā aṭṭhārasahiraññakoṭīhi senāsanāni kārāpetvā aṭṭhārasahiraññakoṭīhi vihāramahaṃ niṭṭhāpetvā evaṃ catupaññāsahiraññakoṭipariccāgena buddhappamukhassa bhikkhusaṅghassa niyyātito, tasmā ‘‘anāthapiṇḍikassa ārāmo’’ti vuccatīti imamatthaṃ nidasseti. 于“胜王子”(Jetassa rājakumārassa)一句中,“胜”(Jeto)指战胜自己的敌人。如“sota”一词,“jeta”一词也是作者格。或谓,因憍萨罗国波斯匿王战胜敌人时,王子出生,故名“胜”。将国王的胜利归于王子,故称王子为“胜”。或为求吉祥而为他取此名“胜”。为求吉祥,本应作“应胜”(jeyyo),却说为“胜”。至于“于给孤独园中”(anāthapiṇḍikassa ārāme)的详细解释:彼长者名为善施,此乃父母所取之名。因其财富圆满,无有悭吝,具足慈悲等德,恒常施食予无依者,故得名“给孤独”。众生于此喜乐,尤其是出家者,故为“园林”(ārāma);因其花果之美,及不远不近等五种住所之德,人们从各处前来喜乐、欢喜,无忧而住。或因其具备所述之圆满条件,能将去往各处之人引至其内,令其喜乐,故名“园林”。此园林乃给孤独长者从胜王子手中,以一亿八千万金币铺地购得,又以一亿八千万金币建造住所,再以一亿八千万金币举行园林庆典,总计布施五亿四千万金币,供养以佛陀为首的比丘僧团。因此,被称为“给孤独园”。此为阐明其义。 Tatthāti ‘‘ekaṃ samayaṃ bhagavā sāvatthiyaṃ viharati jetavane anāthapiṇḍikassa ārāme’’ti yaṃ vuttaṃ vākyaṃ, tattha. Siyāti kassaci evaṃ parivitakko siyā, vakkhamānākārena kadāci codeyya vāti attho. Atha tattha viharatīti yadi jetavane anāthapiṇḍikassa ārāme viharati. Na vattabbanti nānāṭhānabhūtattā sāvatthijetavanānaṃ, ‘‘ekaṃ samaya’’nti ca vuttattāti adhippāyo. Idāni codako tameva attano adhippāyaṃ ‘‘na hi sakkā’’tiādinā vivarati. Itaro sabbametaṃ aviparītaṃ atthaṃ ajānantena tayā vuttanti dassento ‘‘na kho panetaṃ evaṃ daṭṭhabba’’ntiādimāha. Tattha etanti ‘‘sāvatthiyaṃ viharati jetavane anāthapiṇḍikassa ārāme’’ti etaṃ vacanaṃ. Evanti ‘‘yadi tāva bhagavā’’tiādinā [Pg.40] yaṃ taṃ bhavatā coditaṃ, taṃ atthato evaṃ na kho pana daṭṭhabbaṃ, na ubhayattha apubbaṃ acarimaṃ vihāradassanatthanti attho. Idāni attanā yathādhippetaṃ aviparītamatthaṃ, tassa ca paṭikacceva vuttabhāvaṃ, tena ca appaṭividdhataṃ pakāsento ‘‘nanu avocumha…pe… jetavane’’ti āha. Evampi ‘‘jetavane anāthapiṇḍikassa ārāme viharati’’cceva vattabbaṃ, na ‘‘sāvatthiya’’nti codanaṃ manasi katvā vuttaṃ – ‘‘gocaragāmanidassanattha’’ntiādi. “于彼”(tattha)即指“一时,世尊住于舍卫城祇陀林给孤独园”此句中的“于彼”。“应有”(siyā)意为:或许有人会如此思惟,或将以下述方式提出质难。“那么,若住于彼”(Atha tattha viharati)意为:若住于祇陀林给孤独园。“则不应说”(Na vattabbaṃ),其意为:因舍卫城与祇陀林是不同之处所,且已说“一时”。现在,质难者以“诚然不可能”(na hi sakkā)等句阐明己意。另一方则显示:“此皆由你不了知无颠倒之义而说”,并言“然此事不应如是见”等。其中,“此事”(etaṃ)即指“住于舍卫城祇陀林给孤独园”此句。“如是”(evaṃ)意为:你所质难的“若世尊……”等,其义理不应如是见,并非为了在两处显示无先无后地安住。现在,为阐明自己所认为的无颠倒之义、此事早已宣说、以及对方尚未通达,而说:“我等岂非已说……于祇陀林”等。即便如此,仍应只说“住于祇陀林给孤独园”,而不说“于舍卫城”,心中存此质难,故说“为显示行乞村”等。 Avassañcettha gocaragāmakittanaṃ kattabbaṃ. Tathā hi taṃ yathā jetavanādikittanaṃ pabbajitānuggahakaraṇādianekappayojanaṃ, evaṃ gocaragāmakittanampi gahaṭṭhānuggahakaraṇādivividhapayojananti dassento ‘‘sāvatthivacanenā’’tiādimāha. Tattha paccayaggahaṇena upasaṅkamapayirupāsanānaṃ okāsadānena dhammadesanāya saraṇesu sīlesu ca patiṭṭhāpanena yathūpanissayaṃ uparivisesādhigamāvahanena ca gahaṭṭhānuggahakaraṇaṃ, uggahaparipucchānaṃ kammaṭṭhānānuyogassa ca anurūpavasanaṭṭhānapariggahenettha pabbajitānuggahakaraṇaṃ veditabbaṃ. Karuṇāya upagamanaṃ, na lābhādinimittaṃ. Paññāya apagamanaṃ, na virodhādinimittanti upagamanāpagamanānaṃ nirupakkilesataṃ vibhāveti. Dhammikasukhaṃ nāma anavajjasukhaṃ. Devatānaṃ upakārabahulatā janavivittatāya. Pacurajanavivittañhi ṭhānaṃ devā upasaṅkamitabbaṃ maññanti. Tadatthaparinipphādananti lokatthanipphādanaṃ, buddhakiccasampādananti attho. Evamādināti ādi-saddena sāvatthikittanena rūpakāyassa anuggaṇhanaṃ dasseti, jetavanādikittanena dhammakāyassa. Tathā purimena parādhīnakiriyākaraṇaṃ, dutiyena attādhīnakiriyākaraṇaṃ. Purimena vā karuṇākiccaṃ, itarena paññākiccaṃ. Purimena cassa paramāya anukampāya samannāgamaṃ, pacchimena paramāya upekkhāya samannāgamaṃ dīpeti. Bhagavā hi sabbasatte paramāya anukampāya anukampati, na ca tattha sinehadosānupatito paramupekkhakabhāvato. Upekkhako ca na parahitasukhakaraṇe appossukko mahākāruṇikabhāvato. Tassa mahākāruṇikatāya lokanāthatā, upekkhakatāya attanāthatā. 此处必须说明行乞村落的叙述。正如祇陀林等地的叙述具有多种利益,例如利益出家众等,行乞村落的叙述也具有利益在家众等多种功能。因此经中以“以舍卫城为例”等语开始说明。其中,通过提供资具、提供亲近侍奉的机会、说法开示、使他们安住在皈依和戒律中、随顺根机而引导他们获得更高成就等方式利益在家众;通过接受教导和提问、随顺修行而获得适合居住之处等方式利益出家众。以悲心接近,不是为了利养等原因;以慧远离,不是因为冲突等原因——显示接近和远离都没有染污。“法乐”指的是无过失之乐。天神多有助益,因为(此地)远离人群。天神认为,远离众人之处是应当亲近的。“成就其义利”指的是达成世间福利,意即“圆满佛陀事业”。像这样等等语句中,“等”字表示:以舍卫城的叙述显示对色身的利益,以祇陀林的叙述显示对法身的利益。前者显示依他而行,后者显示依自而行。或者说前者是悲之事业,后者是慧之事业。前者显示世尊具足最胜悲悯,后者显示世尊具足最胜舍心。世尊以最胜悲悯怜悯一切众生,却不为贪爱、嗔恚所染,故能安住于最胜舍;虽安住于舍,然不因此而对他人利益安乐漠不关心,因其具足大悲故。因其大悲,故为世间依怙;因其舍心,故为自身依怙。 Tathā hesa bodhisattabhūto mahākaruṇāya sañcoditamānaso sakalalokahitāya ussukkamāpanno mahābhinīhārato paṭṭhāya [Pg.41] tadatthanipphādanatthaṃ puññañāṇasambhāre sampādento aparimitaṃ kālaṃ anappakaṃ dukkhamanubhosi, upekkhakatāya sammā patitehi dukkhehi na vikampitatā. Mahākāruṇikatāya saṃsārābhimukhatā, upekkhakatāya tato nibbindanā. Tathā upekkhakatāya nibbānābhimukhatā, mahākāruṇikatāya tadadhigamo. Tathā mahākāruṇikatāya paresaṃ ahiṃsāpanaṃ, upekkhakatāya sayaṃ parehi abhāyanaṃ. Mahākāruṇikatāya paraṃ rakkhato attano rakkhaṇaṃ, upekkhakatāya attānaṃ rakkhato paresaṃ rakkhaṇaṃ. Tenassa attahitāya paṭipannādīsu catutthapuggalabhāvo siddho hoti. Tathā mahākāruṇikatāya saccādhiṭṭhānassa ca cāgādhiṭṭhānassa ca pāripūrī, upekkhakatāya upasamādhiṭṭhānassa ca paññādhiṭṭhānassa ca pāripūrī. Evaṃ purisuddhāsayappayogassa mahākāruṇikatāya lokahitatthameva rajjasampadādibhavasampattiyā upagamanaṃ, upekkhakatāya tiṇāyapi amaññamānassa tato apagamanaṃ. Iti suvisuddhaupagamāpagamassa mahākāruṇikatāya lokahitatthameva dānavasena sampattīnaṃ pariccajanā, upekkhakatāya cassa phalassa attano apaccāsīsanā. Evaṃ samudāgamanato paṭṭhāya acchariyabbhutaguṇasamannāgatassa mahākāruṇikatāya paresaṃ hitasukhatthaṃ atidukkarakāritā, upekkhakatāya kāyampi analaṅkāritā. 如此,这位菩萨为大悲心所策励,为利益一切世间而勤勉不懈,从发起大誓愿开始,为实现其目标而圆满福德与智慧资粮,经历了无数的时间,忍受了无量苦难;因具足舍,即使正受诸苦,亦不为所动。因大悲心而趋向轮回,因舍而厌离轮回。同样,因舍而趣向涅槃,因大悲心而证得涅槃。因大悲心而不伤害他人,因舍而不畏于他人。因大悲心,守护他人即是守护自己;因舍,守护自己即是守护他人。因此,他成就了(四种人中)为自他利益行道的第四种人。因大悲心而圆满真实决意与布施决意,因舍而圆满寂止决意与智慧决意。这样,具足清净意乐与精进者,因大悲心,仅为利益世间而受持王位等世间圆满;因舍,视如草芥而舍离。像这样具足极清净之取舍者,因大悲心,仅为利益世间而以布施的方式舍弃诸般圆满;因舍,而不希求其果报。这样,从最初发心以来,具足稀有、殊胜功德者,因大悲心,为众生的利益和安乐而行极难行之事;因舍,甚至不庄严其身。 Tathā mahākāruṇikatāya carimattabhāve jiṇṇāturamatadassanena sañjātasaṃvego, upekkhakatāya uḷāresu devabhogasadisesu bhogesu nirapekkho mahābhinikkhamanaṃ nikkhami. Tathā mahākāruṇikatāya ‘‘kicchaṃ vatāyaṃ loko āpanno’’tiādinā (dī. ni. 2.57; saṃ. ni. 2.4, 10) karuṇāmukheneva vipassanārambho, upekkhakatāya buddhabhūtassa satta sattāhāni vivekasukheneva vītināmanaṃ. Mahākāruṇikatāya dhammagambhīrataṃ paccavekkhitvā dhammadesanāya appossukkanaṃ āpajjitvāpi mahābrahmuno ajjhesanāpadesena okāsakaraṇaṃ, upekkhakatāya pañcavaggiyādiveneyyānaṃ ananurūpasamudācārepi anaññathābhāvo. Mahākāruṇikatāya katthaci paṭighātābhāvenassa sabbattha amittasaññābhāvo, upekkhakatāya katthacipi anurodhābhāvena sabbattha sinehasanthavābhāvo. Mahākāruṇikatāya paresaṃ pasādanā, upekkhakatāya [Pg.42] pasannākārehi na vikampanā. Mahākāruṇikatāya dhammānurāgābhāvena tattha ācariyamuṭṭhiabhāvo, upekkhakatāya sāvakānurāgābhāvena parivāraparikammatābhāvo. Mahākāruṇikatāya dhammaṃ desetuṃ parehi saṃsaggamupagacchatopi upekkhakatāya na tattha abhirati. Mahākāruṇikatāya gāmādīnaṃ āsannaṭṭhāne vasatopi upekkhakatāya araññaṭṭhāne eva viharaṇaṃ. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘purimenassa paramāya anukampāya samannāgamaṃ dīpetī’’ti. 同样地,因大悲心,他于最后一世见到老、病、死而生起悚惧;因舍心,对于如同天界般殊胜的受用亦无执着,毅然大出离。同样地,因大悲心,他以“世间真是困苦啊”等语,从悲悯入手而开启观(vipassanā);因舍心,成佛后七个七日都安住于远离之乐。因大悲心,即使省察到法义深奥而对说法不甚热心,仍以大梵天劝请为由而创造机缘;因舍心,对于五比丘等所调伏者,即使其行为不合宜,亦心无变异。因大悲心,于任何处皆无嗔恨,故于一切处无敌对想;因舍心,于任何处皆无偏爱,故于一切处无亲昵之情。因大悲心,令他人生起净信;因舍心,面对他人净信之相亦不动摇。因大悲心,对法无贪爱,故无师拳;因舍心,对弟子无贪爱,故无眷属侍奉。因大悲心,即使为说法而与他人交往;因舍心,亦不于其中生起喜乐。因大悲心,即使住于村落附近;因舍心,仍常住于阿兰若处。因此说:“前者显示其具足最胜悲悯”。 Tanti tatrāti padaṃ. ‘‘Desakālaparidīpana’’nti ye desakālā idha viharaṇakiriyāvisesanabhāvena vuttā, tesaṃ paridīpananti dassento ‘‘yaṃ samayaṃ…pe… dīpetī’’ti āha. Taṃ-saddo hi vuttassa atthassa paṭiniddeso, tasmā idha kālassa desassa vā paṭiniddeso bhavitumarahati, na aññassa. Ayaṃ tāva tatra-saddassa paṭiniddesabhāve atthavibhāvanā. Yasmā pana īdisesu ṭhānesu tatra-saddo dhammadesanāvisiṭṭhaṃ desakālañca vibhāveti, tasmā vuttaṃ – ‘‘bhāsitabbayutte vā desakāle dīpetī’’ti. Tena tatrāti yatra bhagavā dhammadesanatthaṃ bhikkhū ālapati bhāsati, tādise dese, kāle vāti attho. Na hītiādinā tamevatthaṃ samattheti. Nanu ca yattha ṭhito bhagavā ‘‘akālo kho tāvā’’tiādinā bāhiyassa dhammadesanaṃ paṭikkhipi, tattheva antaravīthiyaṃ ṭhito tassa dhammaṃ desesīti? Saccametaṃ, adesetabbakāle adesanāya idaṃ udāharaṇaṃ. Tenevāha – ‘‘akālo kho tāvā’’ti. 此中,“tatra”(于彼处)一词,是“指明处所与时间”之义。为显示那些在此作为对“安住”这一行为的限定而被提及的处所与时间,故说“于某时……乃至……显示”。“taṃ”(彼)字是对已述义理的指代,因此在此处应是指代时间或处所,而非其他。以上是对“tatra”一词作为指代时的义理阐明。然而,由于在此类语境中,“tatra”一词亦阐明说法的特定处所与时间,因此说:“或显示适合说法之处所与时间”。是故,“tatra”意指世尊为说法而向比丘们致辞、开示的彼处、彼时。以“诚然非……”等语,支持此义。或问:世尊岂非站立某处,以“跋希亚(Bāhiya),现在非是时候”等语拒绝为跋希亚说法,而后即于街巷中站立为他开示法要吗?诚然如此,此乃于不应说法之时不说的范例。因此(世尊)说:“现在非是时候”。 Yaṃ pana tattha vuttaṃ – ‘‘antaragharaṃ paviṭṭhamhā’’ti, tampi tassa akālabhāvasseva pariyāyena dassanatthaṃ vuttaṃ. Tassa hi tadā addhānaparissamena rūpakāye akammaññatā ahosi, balavapītivegena nāmakāye. Tadubhayassa vūpasamaṃ āgamento papañcaparihāratthaṃ bhagavā ‘‘akālo kho’’ti pariyāyena paṭikkhipi. Adesetabbadese adesanāya pana udāharaṇaṃ ‘‘atha kho bhagavā maggā okkamma aññatarasmiṃ rukkhamūle nisīdi (saṃ. ni. 2.154), vihārapacchāyāyaṃ paññatte āsane nisīdī’’ti (dī. ni. 1.363) ca evamādikaṃ idha ādisaddena saṅgahitaṃ. ‘‘Atha kho so, bhikkhave, bālo idha pubbe nesādo idha pāpāni kammāni karitvā’’tiādīsu (ma. ni. 3.251) padapūraṇamatte kho-saddo, ‘‘dukkhaṃ kho agāravo viharati [Pg.43] appatisso’’tiādīsu (a. ni. 4.21) avadhāraṇe, ‘‘kittāvatā nu kho, āvuso, satthu pavivittassa viharato sāvakā vivekaṃ nānusikkhantī’’tiādīsu (ma. ni. 1.31) ādikālatthe, vākyārambheti attho. Tattha padapūraṇena vacanālaṅkāramattaṃ kataṃ hoti, ādikālatthena vākyassa upaññāsamattaṃ. Avadhāraṇatthena pana niyamadassanaṃ, tasmā āmantesi evāti āmantane niyamo dassito hoti. 彼处所说“我们已进入村内”,亦是为了婉转地显示当时时机不宜。当时,他因长途跋涉而色身不适,又因强烈的喜悦而名身不适。世尊为了等待此二者平息,避免戏论,故以“时机不对”的方式婉转拒绝。至于在不应说法之处未说法之例,如“尔时,世尊离开道路,坐于某树下”(《相应部》2.154),以及“坐于寺院阴凉处所设之座上”(《长部》1.363)等,皆为此处“等”字所含摄。“诸比丘,此愚人往昔曾为猎人,于此造作恶业”等句(《中部》3.251)中,“kho”仅为填充词;“无恭敬、无随从而住,实为痛苦”等句(《增支部》4.21)中,(kho)表确定之义;“贤友,当导师独住时,弟子们为何不随学远离”等句(《中部》1.31)中,(kho)表起始之时,意为句子之开端。其中,填充词仅作为言辞的修饰,起始之时仅作为句子的引介。而确定之义则显示出限定,因此,(当说)‘他确实称呼了’时,即是在称呼中显示了限定。 Bhagavāti lokagarudīpananti kasmā vuttaṃ, nanu pubbepi bhagavāsaddassa attho vuttoti? Yadipi vutto, taṃ panassa yathāvutte ṭhāne viharaṇakiriyāya kattu visesadassanatthaṃ kataṃ, na āmantanakiriyāya, idha pana āmantanakiriyāya, tasmā tadatthaṃ puna ‘‘bhagavā’’ti pāḷiyaṃ vuttanti tassatthaṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘bhagavāti lokagarudīpana’’nti āha. Tena lokagarubhāvato tadanurūpaṃ paṭipattiṃ patthento attano santikaṃ upagatānaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ ajjhāsayānurūpaṃ dhammaṃ desetuṃ te āmantesīti dasseti. Kathāsavanayuttapuggalavacananti vakkhamānāya cittapariyādānadesanāya savanayoggapuggalavacanaṃ. Catūsupi parisāsu bhikkhū eva edisānaṃ desanānaṃ visesena bhājanabhūtāti sātisayaṃ sāsanasampaṭiggāhakabhāvadassanatthaṃ idha bhikkhuggahaṇanti dassetvā idāni saddatthaṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘apicā’’tiādimāha. Tattha bhikkhakoti bhikkhūti bhikkhanadhammatāya bhikkhūti attho. Bhikkhācariyaṃ ajjhupagatoti buddhādīhi ajjhupagataṃ bhikkhācariyaṃ, uñchācariyaṃ, ajjhupagatattā anuṭṭhitattā bhikkhu. Yo hi appaṃ vā mahantaṃ vā bhogakkhandhaṃ pahāya agārasmā anagāriyaṃ pabbajito, so kasigorakkhādijīvikākappanaṃ hitvā liṅgasampaṭicchaneneva bhikkhācariyaṃ ajjhupagatattā bhikkhu, parappaṭibaddhajīvikattā vā vihāramajjhe kājabhattaṃ bhuñjamānopi bhikkhācariyaṃ ajjhupagatoti bhikkhu, piṇḍiyālopabhojanaṃ nissāya pabbajjāya ussāhajātattā vā bhikkhācariyaṃ ajjhupagatoti bhikkhūti evamettha attho daṭṭhabbo. Ādinā nayenāti ‘‘chinnabhinnapaṭadharoti bhikkhu, bhindati pāpake akusale dhammeti bhikkhu, bhinnattā pāpakānaṃ akusalānaṃ dhammānaṃ bhikkhū’’tiādinā (vibha. 510) vibhaṅge āgatanayena. Ñāpaneti avabodhane, paṭivedaneti attho. 为何说“‘世尊’是‘世间导师’的阐明”?难道之前不也解释过“世尊”一词的含义吗?即使解释过,那也是为了显示作为前述住处之行为的主事者的特殊性,而非针对称呼的行为;此处则是针对称呼的行为。因此,为了显示此义,经文中再次使用“世尊”一词,并说“‘世尊’是‘世间导师’的阐明”。此言显示,世尊因其世间导师的身份,期盼前来亲近他的比丘们能行持相应的行仪,故为随顺他们的意乐而说法,并称呼他们。“适合听闻教法之人”是指适合听闻接下来要说的摄心教法之人。在四众中,比丘们尤其堪为此类教法的法器,此处提及比丘,是为了显示他们是超胜的教法领受者。在说明了这一点后,现在为了解释词义,而说“再者”等。其中,“比丘”(bhikkhu)的意思是,因其乞食之法性,故为比丘。所谓“行于乞食”,是指行于佛陀等所行之乞食,即拾遗之行,因行此道故为比丘。凡舍弃或多或少的财富,从在家而出家者,他舍弃农耕、畜牧等生计,仅以领受(僧人)相好即是行于乞食,故为比丘;或因其生计依附于他人,即使在寺院中食用粥饭,亦是行于乞食,故为比丘;或因依于团食而对出家生起精进,亦是行于乞食,故为比丘。此处的含义应如是理解。“以‘等’所指之理”是指,如《分别论》(Vibhaṅga, 510)中所来的道理:“穿着破碎衣者是比丘;他破除(bhindati)诸恶不善法,故为比丘;因破除了诸恶不善法,故为比丘”等。“令知”(ñāpane)即是令觉悟,意为令通达。 Bhikkhanasīlatāti [Pg.44] bhikkhanena jīvanasīlatā, na kasivāṇijjādinā jīvanasīlatā. Bhikkhanadhammatāti ‘‘uddissa ariyā tiṭṭhantī’’ti (jā. 1.7.59) evaṃ vuttā bhikkhanasabhāvatā, na yācanakohaññasabhāvatā. Bhikkhane sādhukāritāti ‘‘uttiṭṭhe nappamajjeyyā’’ti (dha. pa. 168) vacanaṃ anussaritvā tattha appamajjanā. Atha vā sīlaṃ nāma pakatisabhāvo, idha pana tadadhiṭṭhānaṃ. Dhammoti vataṃ. Sādhukāritāti sakkaccakāritā ādarakiriyā. Hīnādhikajanasevitanti ye bhikkhubhāve ṭhitāpi jātimadādivasena uddhatā unnaḷā, ye ca gihibhāve paresaṃ adhikabhāvampi anupagatattā bhikkhācariyaṃ paramakāruññataṃ maññanti, tesaṃ ubhayesampi yathākkamaṃ ‘‘bhikkhavo’’ti vacanena hīnajanehi daliddehi paramakāruññataṃ pattehi parakulesu bhikkhācariyāya jīvikaṃ kappentehi sevitaṃ vuttiṃ pakāsento uddhatabhāvaniggahaṃ karoti. Adhikajanehi uḷārabhogakhattiyakulādito pabbajitehi buddhādīhi ājīvavisodhanatthaṃ sevitaṃ vuttiṃ pakāsento dīnabhāvaniggahaṃ karotīti yojetabbaṃ. Yasmā ‘‘bhikkhavo’’ti vacanaṃ āmantanabhāvato abhimukhīkaraṇaṃ, pakaraṇato sāmatthiyato ca sussusājananaṃ sakkaccasavanamanasikāraniyojanañca hoti, tasmā tamatthaṃ dassento ‘‘bhikkhavoti iminā’’tiādimāha. Tattha sādhukaṃ savanamanasikāreti sādhukasavane sādhukamanasikāre ca. Kathaṃ pana pavattitā savanādayo sādhukaṃ pavattitā hontīti? ‘‘Addhā imāya sammāpaṭipattiyā sakalasāsanasampatti hatthagatā bhavissatī’’ti ādaragāravayogena kathādīsu aparibhavādinā ca. Vuttañhi ‘‘pañcahi, bhikkhave, dhammehi samannāgato suṇanto saddhammaṃ bhabbo niyāmaṃ okkamituṃ kusalesu dhammesu sammattaṃ. Katamehi pañcahi? Kathaṃ na paribhoti, kathitaṃ na paribhoti, na attānaṃ paribhoti, avikkhittacitto dhammaṃ suṇāti ekaggacitto, yoniso ca manasikaroti. Imehi kho, bhikkhave, pañcahi dhammehi samannāgato suṇanto saddhammaṃ bhabbo niyāmaṃ okkamituṃ kusalesu dhammesu sammatta’’nti (a. ni. 5.151). Tenevāha – ‘‘sādhukaṃ savanamanasikārāyattā hi sāsanasampattī’’ti. “乞食为性”(bhikkhanasīlatā)是指以乞食为生的品性,而非以农耕、经商等为生的品性。“乞食为法”(bhikkhanadhammatā)是指如“圣者依此而住”所说的乞食之本性,而非谄媚欺瞒的求乞本性。“于乞食中善行”(bhikkhane sādhukāritā)是指忆念“应起,不应放逸”(《法句经》168)之语,并于其中不放逸。又或者,“性”(sīla)是本性、习性,此处则指其所依;“法”(dhamma)是行持的规范;“善行”(sādhukāritā)是恭敬而行、审慎之行。“为卑下者与优胜者所行”是指:对于那些虽身为比丘,却因种姓等而骄慢者,以及那些因未达他人之优胜地位而对乞食生活心生卑劣者,(世尊)依次用“诸比丘”一词,对前者,通过开示此为卑下贫穷者于他家行乞维生的生活方式,来抑制其骄慢;对后者,通过开示此为佛陀等出身高贵刹帝利家族、为净化生计而行的生活方式,来抑制其卑劣感。应如是配合理解。因为“诸比丘”一词,作为称呼,有令其面向之作用;从文义及功能上,又能令其生起听闻之欲,并令其恭敬听闻、如理作意。因此,为了显示此义,而说“以‘诸比丘’……”等。其中,“善听闻作意”是指于善听闻及善作意中。那么,如何令听闻等行为得以善行呢?即是藉由恭敬尊重之心,不轻慢说法等,并思惟:“确实,依此正行,一切教法之成就必将入手。”诚如所说:“诸比丘,听闻正法者若具足五法,则堪能趣入决定之道,于诸善法中达于正性。是哪五法呢?不轻慢说法者,不轻慢所说之法,不轻慢自己,听法时不心散乱、一心专注,并如理作意。诸比丘,听闻正法者若具足此五法,则堪能趣入决定之道,于诸善法中达于正性。”(《增支部》5.151)因此说:“教法之成就,实依于善听闻作意。” Pubbe sabbaparisāsādhāraṇattepi bhagavato dhammadesanāya ‘‘jeṭṭhaseṭṭhā’’tiādinā bhikkhūnaṃ eva āmantane kāraṇaṃ dassetvā idāni bhikkhū [Pg.45] āmantetvāva dhammadesanāya payojanaṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘kimatthaṃ pana bhagavā’’ti codanaṃ samuṭṭhāpeti. Tattha aññaṃ cintentāti aññavihitā. Vikkhittacittāti asamāhitacittā. Dhammaṃ paccavekkhantāti hiyyo tato paraṃ divasesu vā sutadhammaṃ pati pati manasā avekkhantā. Bhikkhū āmantetvā dhamme desiyamāne ādito paṭṭhāya desanaṃ sallakkhetuṃ sakkontīti imamatthaṃ byatirekamukhena dassetuṃ ‘‘te anāmantetvā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. 从前,世尊的说法虽然普遍适用于所有集会,但通过“上首、最胜”等语称呼比丘,已显示其原因。现在,为了说明说法前先称呼比丘的目的,而提出“世尊为何如此?”的疑问。于此,“心念他事”即心有旁骛,“心绪纷乱”即心不专注。“反复思惟法义”是指对昨天或更早前所听闻的法,用心反复地观察思惟。之所以说“若不先称呼他们”等语,是为了通过对比的方式说明,当称呼比丘们说法时,他们就能从一开始领会法义。 Bhikkhavoti cettha sandhivasena i-kāralopo daṭṭhabbo. Bhikkhavo itīti ayaṃ iti-saddo hetuparisamāpanādiatthapadatthavipariyāyapakārāvadhāraṇanidassanādianekatthappabhedo. Tathā hesa ‘‘ruppatīti kho, bhikkhave, tasmā rūpanti vuccatī’’tiādīsu (saṃ. ni. 3.79) hetvatthe dissati. ‘‘Tasmātiha me, bhikkhave, dhammadāyādā bhavatha, mā āmisadāyādā. Atthi me tumhesu anukampā. Kinti me sāvakā dhammadāyādā bhaveyyuṃ, no āmisadāyādā’’tiādīsu (ma. ni. 1.19) parisamāpane. ‘‘Iti vā iti evarūpā naccagītavāditavisūkadassanā paṭivirato’’tiādīsu (dī. ni. 1.13) ādiatthe. ‘‘Māgaṇḍiyoti tassa brāhmaṇassa saṅkhā samaññā paññatti vohāro nāmaṃ nāmakammaṃ nāmadheyyaṃ nirutti byañjanamabhilāpo’’tiādīsu (mahāni. 73, 75) padatthavipariyāye. ‘‘Iti kho, bhikkhave, sappaṭibhayo bālo, appaṭibhayo paṇḍito, saupaddavo bālo, anupaddavo paṇḍito, saupasaggo bālo, anupasaggo paṇḍito’’tiādīsu (ma. ni. 3.124) pakāre. ‘‘Atthi idappaccayā jarāmaraṇanti puṭṭhena satā, ‘ānanda, atthī’tissa vacanīyaṃ. ‘Kiṃ paccayā jarāmaraṇa’nti iti ce vadeyya. Jātipaccayā jarāmaraṇaṃ iccassa vacanīya’’ntiādīsu (dī. ni. 2.96) avadhāraṇe. ‘‘Atthīti kho, kaccāna, ayameko anto, natthīti kho, kaccāna, ayaṃ dutiyo anto’’tiādīsu (saṃ. ni. 2.15; saṃ. ni. 3.90) nidassane. Idhāpi nidassane eva daṭṭhabbo. Bhikkhavoti hi āmantanākāro. Tamesa iti-saddo nidasseti ‘‘bhikkhavoti āmantesī’’ti. Iminā nayena ‘‘bhaddante’’tiādīsupi yathārahaṃ iti-saddassa attho veditabbo. Pubbe ‘‘bhagavā āmantesī’’ti vuttattā ‘‘bhagavato paccassosu’’nti [Pg.46] idha ‘‘bhagavato’’ti sāmivacanaṃ āmantanameva sambandhiantaraṃ apekkhatīti iminā adhippāyena ‘‘bhagavato āmantanaṃ paṭiassosu’’nti vuttaṃ. ‘‘Bhagavato’’ti pana idaṃ paṭissavasambandhena sampadānavacanaṃ yathā ‘‘devadattāya paṭissuṇotī’’ti. Yaṃ nidānaṃ bhāsitanti sambandho. Imassa suttassa sukhāvagāhaṇatthanti kamalakuvalayujjalavimalasādurasasalilāya pokkharaṇiyā sukhāvataraṇatthaṃ nimmalasilātalaracanāvilāsasobhitaratanasopānaṃ vippakiṇṇamuttātalasadisavālukācuṇṇapaṇḍarabhūmibhāgaṃ titthaṃ viya suvibhattabhittivicitravedikāparikkhittassa nakkhattapathaṃ phusitukāmatāya viya paṭivijambhitasamussayassa pāsādavarassa sukhārohanatthaṃ dantamayasaṇhamuduphalakañcanalatāvinaddhamaṇigaṇappabhāsamudayujjalasobhaṃ sopānaṃ viya suvaṇṇavalayanūpurādisaṅghaṭṭanasaddasammissitassa kathitahasitamadhurassaragehajanavijambhitavicaritassa uḷāraissariyavibhavasobhitassa mahāgharassa sukhappavesanatthaṃ suvaṇṇarajatamaṇimuttāpavāḷādijutivissaravijjotitasuppatiṭṭhitavisāladvārabāhaṃ mahādvāraṃ viya ca atthabyañjanasampannassa buddhānaṃ desanāñāṇagambhīrabhāvasaṃsūcakassa imassa suttassa sukhāvagāhatthaṃ. 此处于“bhikkhavo”ti一句,应知其“i”音因连声(sandhi)而省略。此“iti”(即)字,有原因、总结、“等”义、词义解释、方式、限定、示例等多种含义。例如,在“诸比丘,彼毁坏,是故名为色”(saṃ. ni. 3.79)等句中,用于“原因”义。在“是故,诸比丘,汝等当为法之继承人,勿为财之继承人。我于汝等有怜悯心:云何我弟子等当为法之继承人,而非财之继承人?”(ma. ni. 1.19)等句中,用于“总结”义。在“远离如是或如是之歌舞、音乐、观剧等”(dī. ni. 1.13)等句中,用于“等”义。在“玛甘迪亚(Māgaṇḍiya)是彼婆罗门之称呼、俗名、概念、语、名、名业、名说、词、文、称”(mahāni. 73, 75)等句中,用于“词义解释”义。在“如是,诸比丘,愚者有怖,智者无怖;愚者有难,智者无难;愚者有灾,智者无灾”(ma. ni. 3.124)等句中,用于“方式”义。在“若被问:‘老死有此缘耶?’当言:‘阿难,有。’若言:‘老死以何为缘?’当言:‘老死以生为缘。’”(dī. ni. 2.96)等句中,用于“限定”义。在“迦旃延,‘有’,此为一端;迦旃延,‘无’,此为第二端”(saṃ. ni. 2.15; saṃ. ni. 3.90)等句中,用于“示例”义。于此,亦应知其为“示例”义。“Bhikkhavo”(诸比丘)实为称呼之形式,此“iti”字示例之,如言“称呼‘诸比丘’”。循此理,于“bhaddante”ti(尊者)等句中,亦应随宜了知“iti”字之义。前已言“世尊称呼”,故于“回应世尊”一句,“bhagavato”(世尊的)为属格,其称呼本身即期待另一关联词,是故言“回应世尊之称呼”。然“bhagavato”一词,因与“回应”相关,亦作与格,犹如“回应提婆达多”。其关联为“所说之缘起”。为令此经易于通达,犹如为使人易于进入莲花、睡莲庄严、清净悦意之池水,而设以洁净石板、华丽宝阶、遍撒珍珠般白沙之渡口;犹如为使人易于登上高耸欲触星辰之胜殿,而设以象牙、软木、金藤交缠、众宝光明之阶梯;亦如为使人易于进入金镯脚钏碰撞声、谈笑甜音交织、家人自在往来、富贵庄严之大宅,而设以金、银、摩尼、珍珠、珊瑚等光芒照耀、善安宽大之大门。同样,此经义丰文美,能示诸佛说法智慧之甚深,亦为令其易于通达。 Etthāha – ‘‘kimatthaṃ pana dhammavinayasaṅgahe kayiramāne nidānavacanaṃ, nanu bhagavatā bhāsitavacanasseva saṅgaho kātabbo’’ti? Vuccate, desanāya ṭhitiasammosasaddheyyabhāvasampādanatthaṃ. Kāladesadesakanimittaparisāpadesehi upanibandhitvā ṭhapitā hi desanā ciraṭṭhitikā hoti asammosadhammā saddheyyā ca. Desakālakattuhetunimittehi upanibaddho viya vohāravinicchayo. Teneva ca āyasmatā mahākassapena ‘‘cittapariyādānasuttaṃ, āvuso ānanda, kattha bhāsita’’ntiādinā desādipucchāsu katāsu tāsaṃ vissajjanaṃ karontena dhammabhaṇḍāgārikena ‘‘evaṃ me suta’’ntiādinā imassa suttassa nidānaṃ bhāsitaṃ. Apica satthusampattippakāsanatthaṃ nidānavacanaṃ. Tathāgatassa hi bhagavato pubbacaraṇānumānāgamatakkābhāvato sammāsambuddhabhāvasiddhi. Na hi sammāsambussa pubbacaraṇādīhi attho atthi sabbattha appaṭihatañāṇacāratāya ekappamāṇattā ca ñeyyadhammesu. Tathā ācariyamuṭṭhidhammamacchariyasāsanasāvakānānurāgābhāvato khīṇāsavabhāvasiddhi. Na hi sabbaso khīṇāsavassa te sambhavantīti suvisuddhassa parānuggahappavatti. Evaṃ [Pg.47] desakasaṃkilesabhūtānaṃ diṭṭhisīlasampadādūsakānaṃ avijjātaṇhānaṃ accantābhāvasaṃsūcakehi ñāṇappahānasampadābhibyañjanakehi ca sambuddhavisuddhabhāvehi purimavesārajjadvayasiddhi, tato ca antarāyikaniyyānikadhammesu sammohābhāvasiddhito pacchimavesārajjadvayasiddhīti bhagavato catuvesārajjasamannāgamo attahitaparahitappaṭipatti ca nidānavacanena pakāsitā hoti. Tattha tattha sampattaparisāya ajjhāsayānurūpaṃ ṭhānuppattikappaṭibhānena dhammadesanādīpanato, idha pana rūpagarukānaṃ puggalānaṃ ajjhāsayānurūpaṃ ṭhānuppattikappaṭibhānena dhammadesanādīpanatoti yojetabbaṃ. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘satthusampattippakāsanatthaṃ nidānavacana’’nti. 于此,或问:“结集法、律之时,何故须说缘起?岂非仅当结集世尊所说之语?”答曰:为令教法确立、不乱、可信。教法若与时、地、说者、缘由、会众等相联系而确立,则能长久住世,法义不乱,亦堪信受。犹如世间判决,亦须依于说者、时间、作者、因由、时机。正因如此,具寿大迦叶(Mahākassapa)问曰:“贤友阿难(Ānanda),《心遍取经》(Cittapariyādānasutta)于何处说?”等,法藏之主阿难作答时,即以“如是我闻”等语,说此经之缘起。再者,说缘起亦为彰显导师之圆满成就。如来、世尊之正等觉成就,乃因其无须凭借往昔行持、推论、传承或思辨。正等觉者实无须此等,因其智遍行一切处而无碍,且于诸所知法平等一味。同样,其漏尽成就,乃因其无师拳(秘不示人)、法悭、及于教法弟子无爱染。此等于究竟漏尽者绝不存在,故其所行纯为利益他人。如是,通过彰显能指示智慧与断惑圆满之佛陀清净相,即能成就前二无畏;又因于障碍法与出离法无有迷惑,从而成就后二无畏。是故,世尊具足四无畏及自利利他之行,皆由缘起之说而得以彰显。佛于各处,皆随会众根机意乐,以应时之智而说法;于此,亦随重色之人(rūpagaruka puggala)根机意乐,以应时之智而说法。故曰:“说缘起为彰显导师之圆满成就。” Tathā sāsanasampattippakāsanatthaṃ nidānavacanaṃ. Ñāṇakaruṇāpariggahitasabbakiriyassa hi bhagavato natthi niratthakā paṭipatti, attahitatthā vā. Tasmā paresaṃ eva atthāya pavattasabbakiriyassa sammāsambuddhassa sakalampi kāyavacīmanokammaṃ yathāpavattaṃ vuccamānaṃ diṭṭhadhammikasamparāyikaparamatthehi yathārahaṃ sattānaṃ anusāsanaṭṭhena sāsanaṃ, na kapparacanā. Tayidaṃ satthucaritaṃ kāladesadesakaparisāpadesehi saddhiṃ tattha tattha nidānavacanehi yathārahaṃ pakāsīyati. ‘‘Idha pana rūpagarukānaṃ puggalāna’’ntiādi sabbaṃ purimasadisameva. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘sāsanasampattippakāsanatthaṃ nidānavacana’’nti. Apica satthuno pamāṇabhāvappakāsanena vacanena sāsanassa pamāṇabhāvadassanatthaṃ nidānavacanaṃ, tañca desakappamāṇabhāvadassanaṃ heṭṭhā vuttanayānusārena ‘‘bhagavā’’ti ca iminā padena vibhāvitanti veditabbaṃ. Bhagavāti hi tathāgatassa rāgadosamohādisabbakilesamaladuccaritadosappahānadīpanena vacanena anaññasādhāraṇasuparisuddhañāṇakaruṇādiguṇavisesayogaparidīpanena tato eva sabbasattuttamabhāvadīpanena ayamattho sabbathā pakāsito hotīti. Idamettha nidānavacanappayojanassa mukhamattanidassanaṃ. 同样,为显示教法之圆满而说因缘言教。因为世尊以智慧与慈悲摄持一切行为,故无无义之行,亦非为自利。因此,正等觉者的一切行为皆为利益他人而发起,其全部身、语、意业,如其所行而被言说,以现法、后世及究竟义,随宜地作为对众生的教诫,此即是教法,而非虚构之说。此导师的行谊,连同时间、地点、说法者、听众及处所,由各处相应的因缘言教而随宜地被开示。“于此,对重色之人”等,一切皆如前述。是故说:“为显示教法之圆满而说因缘言教”。再者,为以显示导师之权威性的言教来开示教法的权威性,而说因缘言教。而此开示说法者之权威性,当知已通过“世尊”一词,依如下所述之理而阐明。因为“世尊”一词,通过开示如来已断除贪、瞋、痴等一切烦恼垢染与恶行过失,通过阐明其具备不共于他、极为清净的智慧、慈悲等殊胜功德,并由此开示其为一切众生中之最上者,此义已全然被揭示。此为于此略示因缘言教之目的。 Nikkhittassāti desitassa. Desanā hi desetabbassa sīlādiatthassa veneyyasantānesu nikkhipanato ‘‘nikkhepo’’ti vuccati. Suttanikkhepaṃ vicāretvāva vuccamānā pākaṭā hotīti sāmaññato bhagavato desanāya samuṭṭhānassa vibhāgaṃ dassetvā ‘‘etthāyaṃ desanā evaṃsamuṭṭhānā’’ti desanāya samuṭṭhāne dassite suttassa sammadeva nidānaparijānanena vaṇṇanāya suviññeyyattā vuttaṃ. Tattha yathā [Pg.48] anekasataanekasahassabhedānipi suttantāni saṃkilesabhāgiyādipaṭṭhānanayavasena soḷasavidhataṃ nātivattanti, evaṃ attajjhāsayādisuttanikkhepavasena catubbidhabhāvanti āha – ‘‘cattāro hi suttanikkhepā’’ti. Ettha ca yathā attajjhāsayassa aṭṭhuppattiyā ca parajjhāsayapucchāhi saddhiṃ saṃsaggabhedo sambhavati ‘‘attajjhāsayo ca parajjhāsayo ca, attajjhāsayo ca pucchāvasiko ca, aṭṭhuppattiko ca parajjhāsayo ca, aṭṭhuppattiko ca pucchāvasiko cā’’ti ajjhāsayapucchānusandhisabbhāvato, evaṃ yadipi aṭṭhuppattiyā attajjhāsayenapi saṃsaggabhedo sambhavati, attajjhāsayādīhi pana purato ṭhitehi aṭṭhuppattiyā saṃsaggo natthīti na idha niravaseso vitthāranayo sambhavatīti ‘‘cattāro suttanikkhepā’’ti vuttaṃ. Tadantogadhattā vā sesanikkhepānaṃ mūlanikkhepavasena cattārova dassitā. Yathādassanañhettha ayaṃ saṃsaggabhedo gahetabboti. “已置”(Nikkhittassa)即是“已说示”(desitassa)。因为说法是将应说的戒等义理置于所化有情的心相续中,故称为“置”(nikkhepa)。因为在考察了经的安立(suttanikkhepa)之后,所作的释义才会变得清晰,所以,在总说世尊说法的生起分类,并开示了“此处的说法是如此生起”这一说法的生起之后,由于经的因缘被正确了知,其释义就变得容易理解,故如是说。于此,犹如百千种经,依杂染品等发趣之理,亦不超越十六种;如是,依自意乐等经的安立,亦有四种。故说:“经的安立实有四种”。于此,犹如自意乐与事起,及他意乐与提问,其相互结合会产生差别,如:“自意乐与他意乐”、“自意乐与依问而说”、“事起与他意乐”、“事起与依问而说”,此乃因意乐与提问有相续之故。如是,纵使事起与自意乐亦可结合而产生差别,然当自意乐等在前时,则与事起无结合。故于此不作无遗之广说,而说“经的安立有四种”。或因其余的安立已包含于此中,故仅依根本安立而开示四种。于此,当如所示而理解此结合之差别。 Tatrāyaṃ vacanattho – nikkhipīyatīti nikkhepo, suttaṃ eva nikkhepo suttanikkhepo. Atha vā nikkhipanaṃ nikkhepo, suttassa nikkhepo suttanikkhepo, suttadesanāti attho. Attano ajjhāsayo attajjhāsayo, so assa atthi kāraṇabhūtoti attajjhāsayo. Attano ajjhāsayo etassāti vā attajjhāsayo. Parajjhāsayepi eseva nayo. Pucchāya vaso pucchāvaso, so etassa atthīti pucchāvasiko. Suttadesanāvatthubhūtassa atthassa uppatti atthuppatti, atthuppattiyeva aṭṭhuppatti ttha-kārassa ṭṭha-kāraṃ katvā. Sā etassa atthīti aṭṭhuppattiko. Atha vā nikkhipīyati suttaṃ etenāti suttanikkhepo, attajjhāsayādi eva. Etasmiṃ atthavikappe attano ajjhāsayo attajjhāsayo. Paresaṃ ajjhāsayo parajjhāsayo. Pucchīyatīti pucchā, pucchitabbo attho. Pucchāvasena pavattaṃ dhammappaṭiggāhakānaṃ vacanaṃ pucchāvasikaṃ, tadeva nikkhepasaddāpekkhāya pulliṅgavasena vuttaṃ – ‘‘pucchāvasiko’’ti. Tathā aṭṭhuppatti eva aṭṭhuppattikoti evamettha attho veditabbo. 于此,其语义为:“被置”(nikkhipīyati)故为“置”(nikkhepo),经即是置,故为“经置”(suttanikkhepo)。或,“放置”(nikkhipanaṃ)即“置”(nikkhepo),经之置为“经置”(suttanikkhepo),义即“经的说示”(suttadesanā)。“自己之意乐”(attano ajjhāsayo)为“自意乐”(attajjhāsayo);此作为原因而存在,故为“依自意乐”(attajjhāsayo)。或,“自己之意乐属于此”,故为“依自意乐”。“他意乐”(parajjhāsayo)亦同此理。“随于问”(pucchāya vaso)为“随问”(pucchāvaso);此存在于此,故为“依问而说”(pucchāvasiko)。“作为经说示之事由的义理之生起”为“义生起”(atthuppatti);“义生起”即是“事起”(aṭṭhuppatti),乃`ttha`音变为`ṭṭha`音。此存在于此,故为“依事起而说”(aṭṭhuppattiko)。或,“经由此而被置”,故为“经置”,即自意乐等。于此义之分别中,“自己之意乐”为“自意乐”。“他人之意乐”为“他意乐”。“被问”(pucchīyati)故为“问”(pucchā),即可问之义。依提问而发起的、对领法者所说之言,是“依问而说”(pucchāvasikaṃ,中性)。此词因关联于“置”(nikkhepa)一词,故以阳性说为“依问而说”(pucchāvasiko)。如是,“事起”(aṭṭhuppatti)即是“依事起而说”(aṭṭhuppattiko)。于此当如是了知其义。 Apicettha paresaṃ indriyaparipākādikāraṇanirapekkhattā attajjhāsayassa visuṃ suttanikkhepabhāvo yutto kevalaṃ attano ajjhāsayeneva dhammatantiṭṭhapanatthaṃ pavattitadesanattā. Parajjhāsayapucchāvasikānaṃ pana paresaṃ ajjhāsayapucchānaṃ desanāpavattihetubhūtānaṃ uppattiyaṃ pavattitānaṃ [Pg.49] kathamaṭṭhuppattiyā anavarodho, pucchāvasikaaṭṭhuppattikānaṃ vā parajjhāsayānurodhena pavattitānaṃ kathaṃ parajjhāsaye anavarodhoti? Na codetabbametaṃ. Paresañhi abhinīhāraparipucchādivinimuttasseva suttadesanākāraṇuppādassa aṭṭhuppattibhāvena gahitattā parajjhāsayapucchāvasikānaṃ visuṃ gahaṇaṃ. Tathā hi brahmajāladhammadāyādasuttādīnaṃ vaṇṇāvaṇṇaāmisuppādādidesanānimittaṃ ‘‘aṭṭhuppattī’’ti vuccati. Paresaṃ pucchaṃ vinā ajjhāsayaṃ eva nimittaṃ katvā desito parajjhāsayo, pucchāvasena desito pucchāvasikoti pākaṭoyamatthoti. Attano ajjhāsayeneva kathesīti dhammatantiṭṭhapanatthaṃ kathesi. Vimuttiparipācanīyā dhammā saddhindriyādayo. Ajjhāsayanti adhimuttiṃ. Khantinti diṭṭhinijjhānakkhantiṃ. Mananti paññatticittaṃ. Abhinīhāranti paṇidhānaṃ. Bujjhanabhāvanti bujjhanasabhāvaṃ, paṭivijjhanākāraṃ vā. Rūpagarukānanti pañcasu ārammaṇesu rūpārammaṇagarukā rūpagarukā. Cittena rūpaninnā rūpapoṇā rūpapabbhārā rūpadassanappasutā rūpena ākaḍḍhitahadayā, tesaṃ rūpagarukānaṃ. 再者,于此,自意乐不依赖他人根熟等因,纯粹依自己之意乐为建立法统而发起说法,故其作为一种单独的经安立是合理的。然而,对于依他意乐与依问而说者,既然他人的意乐与提问是说法发起的因缘,当它们生起时,如何不被包含在“事起”中呢?或者,对于依问而说与依事起而说者,既然是随顺他人的意乐而发起,又如何不被包含在“他意乐”中呢?此不应作如是诘难。因为,只有脱离了他人的发愿、遍问等的经说示之因的生起,才被取为“事起”,故“依他意乐”与“依问而说”被单独列出。诚然,如《梵网经》(Brahmajālasutta)、《法嗣经》(Dhammadāyādasutta)等,其说法的因缘,如称赞、非难、利养的生起等,被称为“事起”(aṭṭhuppatti)。不待他人提问,仅以其意乐为缘而说,是“依他意乐”;依提问而说,是“依问而说”。此义甚明。“依自己之意乐而说”,即为建立法统而说。能令解脱成熟之法,即信根(saddhindriya)等。“意乐”(ajjhāsaya)即胜解(adhimutti)。“忍”(khanti)即见审察忍(diṭṭhinijjhānakkhanti)。“意”(mana)即施设心(paññatticitta)。“发愿”(abhinīhāra)即誓愿(paṇidhāna)。“觉性”(bujjhanabhāva)即觉之自性(bujjhanasabhāva),或通达之行相(paṭivijjhanākāra)。“重色者”(rūpagarukā)即于五所缘中重色所缘者。其心倾向于色(rūpaninna)、偏向于色(rūpapoṇa)、趋向于色(rūpapabbhāra)、热衷于见色(rūpadassanappasuta)、心为色所牵引(rūpena ākaḍḍhitahadayā),此即重色者。 Paṭisedhatthoti paṭikkhepattho. Kassa pana paṭikkhepatthoti? Kiriyāpadhānañhi vākyaṃ, tasmā ‘‘na samanupassāmī’’ti samanupassanākiriyāpaṭisedhattho. Tenāha – ‘‘imassa pana padassā’’tiādi. Yo paro na hoti, so attāti lokasamaññāmattasiddhaṃ sattasantānaṃ sandhāya – ‘‘aha’’nti satthā vadati, na bāhirakaparikappitaṃ ahaṃkāravisayaṃ ahaṃkārassa bodhimūleyeva samucchinnattā. Lokasamaññānatikkamantā eva hi buddhānaṃ lokiye visaye desanāpavatti. Bhikkhaveti ālapane kāraṇaṃ heṭṭhā vuttameva. Aññanti apekkhāsiddhattā aññatthassa ‘‘idāni vattabbaitthirūpato añña’’nti āha. Ekampi rūpanti ekaṃ vaṇṇāyatanaṃ. Samaṃ visamaṃ sammā yāthāvato anu anu passatīti samanupassanā, ñāṇaṃ. Saṃkilissanavasena anu anu passatīti samanupassanā, diṭṭhi. No niccatoti ettha iti-saddo ādiattho, evamādikoti attho. Tena ‘‘dukkhato samanupassatī’’ti evamādīni saṅgaṇhāti. Olokentopīti devamanussavimānakapparukkhamaṇikanakādigatāni rūpāni anavasesaṃ sabbaññutaññāṇena olokentopi. Sāmaññavacanopi yaṃ-saddo ‘‘ekarūpampī’’ti rūpassa [Pg.50] adhigatattā rūpavisayo icchitoti ‘‘yaṃ rūpa’’nti vuttaṃ. Tathā purisasaddo pariyādiyitabbacittapuggalavisayoti rūpagarukassāti visesitaṃ. Gahaṇaṃ ‘‘khepana’’nti ca adhippetaṃ, pariyādānañca uppattinivāraṇanti āha – ‘‘catubhūmakakusalacitta’’nti. Tañhi rūpaṃ tādisassa parittakusalassapi uppattiṃ nivāreti, kimaṅgaṃ pana mahaggatānuttaracittassāti lokuttarakusalacittassapi uppattiyā nivāraṇaṃ hotuṃ samatthaṃ, lokiyakusaluppattiyā nivārakatte vattabbameva natthīti ‘‘catubhūmakakusalacittaṃ pariyādiyitvā’’ti vuttaṃ. Na hi kāmaguṇassādappasutassa purisassa dānādivasena savipphārikā kusaluppatti sambhavati. Gaṇhitvā khepetvāti attānaṃ assādetvā pavattamānassa akusalacittassa paccayo hontaṃ pavattinivāraṇena muṭṭhigataṃ viya gahetvā anuppādanirodhena khepetvā viya tiṭṭhati. Tāva mahati lokasannivāse tassa pariyādiyaṭṭhānaṃ avicchedato labbhatīti āha – ‘‘tiṭṭhatī’’ti yathā ‘‘pabbatā tiṭṭhanti, najjo sandantī’’ti. Tenāha – ‘‘idha ubhayampi vaṭṭatī’’tiādi. “否定义”(Paṭisedhattho)即是“排斥义”(paṭikkhepattho)。那么要排斥什么呢?因为语句以动词为主,所以‘我不随观’(na samanupassāmi)就是对“随观”(samanupassanā)这一行为的否定。因此说“此词”(imassa padassa)等。不是他人的就是自己,这是依世俗概念所成的有情相续而言——导师(satthā)说‘我’,不是指外道所构想的我慢的境界,因为我慢在菩提树下就已经被根除了。诸佛在世间领域的说法,确实不超越世俗概念。“比丘们”(Bhikkhavo)这一呼格,其原因在前面已经说过了。“其他”(aññaṃ)一词,因其关联性而有“其他”之义,故说‘是“现在所要说的女色”之外的其他’。“一色亦”(ekampi rūpaṃ)指的是一个色处。平等、不平等,如实、正确地随观,是为随观(samanupassanā),即是智(ñāṇaṃ);以染污的方式随观,亦是随观,此为见(diṭṭhi)。在“非恒常”(no niccato)中,“iti”一词是“等”的意思,即“如此等等”之义。因此,它也包含了“随观为苦”等。“遍观”(Olokentopi)指的是,即使以一切知智(sabbaññutaññāṇa)遍观天、人、天宫、劫波树、摩尼宝、黄金等一切色法,亦无遗余。即使是泛说,“yaṃ”一词,因为“一色亦”已经指明了色,故欲表达色的范畴,因此说“任何色”(yaṃ rūpaṃ)。同样,“男人”(purisa)一词是指其心可被占据的个人(puggala),故特指为“重色者”。“执取”(gahaṇaṃ)亦意指“去除”(khepanaṃ),而“占据”(pariyādānaṃ)则意指阻止其生起,故说“四地善心”。那种色能阻止如此微小的善心生起,更何况是广大心与无上心呢?因此,它能够阻止出世间善心的生起,至于阻止世间善心的生起,就更不用说了。所以说“占据了四地善心”。对于沉迷于欲乐滋味的男人,不可能通过布施等方式产生有广大果报的善心。“执取而去除”(Gaṇhitvā khepetvā)是说:当它成为正在享受自身而生起的不善心的缘时,通过阻止其生起,如同握在手中般地执取;通过不生起的灭,如同去除般地安住。在如此广大的世间聚落中,其心被占据的状态持续不断,故说“安住”(tiṭṭhati),犹如“山岳屹立,江河奔流”。因此说‘此处两者皆适用’(idha ubhayampi vaṭṭati)等。 Yathayidanti sandhivasena ākārassa rassattaṃ yakārāgamo cāti āha – ‘‘yathā ida’’nti. Itthiyā rūpanti itthisarīragataṃ tappaṭibaddhañca rūpāyatanaṃ. Paramatthassa niruḷho, paṭhamaṃ sādhāraṇato saddasatthalakkhaṇāni vibhāvetabbāni, pacchā asādhāraṇatoti tāni pāḷivasena vibhāvetuṃ – ‘‘ruppatīti kho…pe… veditabba’’nti āha. Tattha ruppatīti sītādivirodhipaccayehi vikāraṃ āpādīyati, āpajjatīti vā attho. Vikāruppatti ca virodhipaccayasannipāte visadisuppatti vibhūtatarā, kuto panāyaṃ visesoti ce? ‘‘Sītenā’’tiādivacanato. Evañca katvā vedanādīsu anavasesarūpasamaññā sāmaññalakkhaṇanti sabbarūpadhammasādhāraṇaṃ rūppanaṃ. Idāni atthuddhāranayena rūpasaddaṃ saṃvaṇṇento ‘‘ayaṃ panā’’tiādimāha. Rūpakkhandhe vattatīti ‘‘oḷārikaṃ vā sukhumaṃ vā’’tiādivacanato (ma. ni. 1.361; 2.113; 3.86, 89; vibha. 2). Rūpūpapattiyāti ettha rūpabhavo rūpaṃ uttarapadalopena. Rūpabhavūpapattiyāti ayañhettha attho. Kasiṇanimitteti pathavīkasiṇādisaññite paṭibhāganimitte. Rūppati attano phalassa sabhāvaṃ karotīti rūpaṃ, sabhāvahetūti [Pg.51] āha – ‘‘sarūpā…pe… ettha paccaye’’ti. Karacaraṇādiavayavasaṅghātabhāvena rūpīyati nirūpīyatīti rūpaṃ, rūpakāyoti āha – ‘‘ākāso…pe… ettha sarīre’’ti. “Yathayidaṃ”(正如这)是由于连声(sandhi),“ā”元音缩短并加入了“y”辅音,故说即是“yathā idaṃ”。“女色”(Itthiyā rūpaṃ)是指女身之色及与其相关的色处(rūpāyatana)。[此词]是胜义的确定用法。首先应从共通方面阐明词与义的特征,然后从不共通方面,依圣典来阐明,故说:‘应知“色”(rūpa)即毁坏(ruppati)之义……’。此中,“毁坏”(ruppati)是指被寒冷等敌对的缘所导致变异,或遭受变异之义。当敌对的缘聚集时,变异的生起,即不同状态的生起,会更为显著。若问:此差别从何而来?由“以寒冷……”等语可知。如此,在受等法中,并没有“色”这个名称,而“毁坏性”是一切色法共通的普遍特征。现在,以揭示义理的方式阐释“色”一词,故说“此复……”等。[色]用于色蕴,是依“或粗或细……”等语。在“生于色界”(Rūpūpapattiyā)中,“色”(rūpa)是“色有”(rūpabhava)省略了后一词。此处的意义是“生于色有”。“在遍相中”(Kasiṇanimitte)是指在地遍等所谓的似相(paṭibhāganimitta)中。因为它“毁坏”(ruppati),或因为它能成就其果的自性,故为“色”(rūpa)。此为自性因,故说:‘自相……于此缘中’。因为由手、足等支分的集合,它被“显现”(rūpīyati)、被“认知”(nirūpīyati),故为“色”(rūpa),即色身,故说:‘虚空……于此身中’。 Rūpayati vaṇṇavikāraṃ āpajjamānaṃ hadayaṅgatabhāvaṃ pakāsetīti rūpaṃ, vaṇṇāyatanaṃ. Ārohapariṇāhādibhedarūpagataṃ saṇṭhānasampattiṃ nissāya pasādaṃ āpajjamāno rūpappamāṇoti vuttoti āha – ‘‘ettha saṇṭhāne’’ti. Piyarūpantiādīsu sabhāvattho rūpasaddo. Ādisaddena rūpajjhānādīnaṃ saṅgaho. ‘‘Rūpī rūpāni passatī’’ti ettha ajjhattaṃ kesādīsu parikammasaññāvasena paṭiladdharūpajjhānaṃ rūpaṃ, taṃ assa atthīti rūpīti vutto. Itthiyā catusamuṭṭhāne vaṇṇeti itthisarīrapariyāpannameva rūpaṃ gahitaṃ, tappaṭibaddhavatthālaṅkārādirūpampi pana purisacittassa pariyādāyakaṃ hotīti dassetuṃ – ‘‘apicā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Gandhavaṇṇaggahaṇena vilepanaṃ vuttaṃ. Kāmaṃ ‘‘asukāya itthiyā pasādhana’’nti sallakkhitassa akāyappaṭibaddhassapi vaṇṇo paṭibaddhacittassa purisassa cittaṃ pariyādāya tiṭṭheyya, taṃ pana na ekantikanti ekantikaṃ dassento ‘‘kāyappaṭibaddho’’tiāha. Upakappatīti cittassa pariyādānāya upakappati. Purimassevāti pubbe vuttaatthasseva daḷhīkaraṇatthaṃ vuttaṃ yathā ‘‘dvikkhattuṃ bandhaṃ subandha’’nti. Nigamanavasena vā etaṃ vuttanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Opammavasena vuttanti ‘‘yaṃ evaṃ purisassa cittaṃ pariyādāya tiṭṭhatī’’ti sakalamevidaṃ purimavacanaṃ upamāvasena vuttaṃ, tattha pana upamābhūtaṃ atthaṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘yathayidaṃ…pe… itthirūpa’’nti vuttaṃ. Pariyādāne ānubhāvo sambhavo pariyādānānubhāvo, tassa dassanavasena vuttaṃ. 它“显现”(rūpayati)颜色变化,显示出深入人心的状态,故为“色”(rūpa),即色处(vaṇṇāyatana)。依于身高、体宽等不同色法所成就的形体,而心生喜悦,这被称为“以色为量”(rūpappamāṇo),故说:‘于此形相中’。在“可爱色”(Piyarūpaṃ)等语中,“色”一词是自性义。“等”字包含了色禅等。在‘有色者见诸色’(Rūpī rūpāni passati)中,“色”(rūpa)是指于自身头发等,通过预备想而获得的色禅。因为他有此禅那,故被称为“有色者”(rūpī)。在说女人的四因生色时,只取了包含在女身中的色。但为了显示与女身相关的衣物、装饰等色也能占据男人的心,故说“再者……”等。通过提及香与色,说的是涂香。诚然,即使是那被注意到‘是某女人的装饰’的、不与身体相连的色,也能占据那心已系缚的男人的心,但这并非绝对。为了显示是绝对的,故说“与身体相连的”。“适合”(Upakappati)是指适合于占据心。“如前”(Purimasseva)是为了巩固前面所说之义而说,犹如“捆绑两次更牢固”。或者,应知这是作为结论而说。或者,是作为譬喻而说。“任何如此占据男人心的”这整句前面的话,是作为譬喻而说。其中,为了显示作为譬喻的意义,故说“正如……女色”。在占据中,有力用、有可能,即“占据的威力”(pariyādānānubhāvo)。这是为了显示此义而说。 Idaṃ pana ‘‘itthirūpa’’ntiādivacanaṃ pariyādānānubhāve sādhetabbe dīpetabbe vatthu kāraṇaṃ. Nāgo nāma so rājā, dīghadāṭhikattā pana ‘‘mahādāṭhikanāgarājā’’ti vutto. Asaṃvaraniyāmenāti cakkhudvārikena asaṃvaranīhārena. Nimittaṃ gahetvāti rāguppattihetubhūtaṃ rūpaṃ subhanimittaṃ gahetvā. Visikādassanaṃ gantvāti sivathikadassanaṃ gantvā. Tattha hi ādīnavānupassanā ijjhati. Vatthulobhena kuto tādisāya maraṇanti asaddahanto ‘‘mukhaṃ tumhākaṃ dhūmavaṇṇa’’nti te daharasāmaṇere uppaṇḍento vadati. 然而,“女色”等语,是在“占据的威力”中,应被确立、应被阐明的“事”(vatthu)与“因”(kāraṇa)。那位国王名叫龙(Nāga),但因有长牙,故被称为“大牙龙王”(Mahādāṭhikanāgarājā)。“以不防护的方式”(Asaṃvaraniyāmena)是指以不防护眼门的方式。“取相”(Nimittaṃ gahetvā)是指执取了那作为贪欲生起之因的色的净相(subhanimitta)。“前往观看街道”(Visikādassanaṃ gantvā)是指前往观看尸林(sivathikadassanaṃ)。因为在那里,过患随观(ādīnavānupassanā)得以成就。[他]因贪恋事物(vatthu),不信‘这样的人怎么会死?’,并嘲弄那些年轻沙弥说:‘你们的脸色像烟一样。’ Ratanattaye suppasannattā kākavaṇṇatissādīhi visesanatthañca so tissamahārājā saddhāsaddena visesetvā vuccati. Daharassa cittaṃ pariyādāya [Pg.52] tiṭṭhatīti adhikāravasena vuttaṃ. Niṭṭhituddesakiccoti gāme asappāyarūpadassanaṃ imassa anatthāya siyāti ācariyena nivāritagāmappaveso pacchā niṭṭhituddesakicco hutvā ṭhito. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘atthakāmānaṃ vacanaṃ aggahetvā’’ti. Nivatthavatthaṃ sañjānitvāti attanā diṭṭhadivase nivatthavatthaṃ tassā matadivase sivathikadassanatthaṃ gatena laddhaṃ sañjānitvā. Evampīti evaṃ maraṇasampāpanavasenapi. Ayaṃ tāvettha aṭṭhakathāya anuttānatthadīpanā. 对三宝有净信故,为与黑वणṇatissa)等人相区别,那位帝须大王被特别称为“信帝须”(Saddhātissa)。“占据幼童之心”是依其语境而言。所谓“完成诵学任务者”,是指因老师认为“在村中见到不适宜的景象可能对他不利”而禁止他进入村庄,之后他完成了诵学任务而安住下来。因此说:“没有听从为他着想的人的劝告。”所谓“认出所穿之衣”,是指他认出了自己见到她那天她所穿的衣服,这衣服是在她去世那天去尸陀林时得到的。所谓“像这样”,即指甚至通过导致死亡的方式。以上是对义注中未明了之义的阐明。 Nettinayavaṇṇanā 导论释义 Idāni pakaraṇanayena pāḷiyā atthavaṇṇanaṃ karissāma. Sā pana atthasaṃvaṇṇanā yasmā desanāya samuṭṭhānappayojanabhājanesu piṇḍatthesu ca niddhāritesu sukarā hoti suviññeyyā ca, tasmā suttadesanāya samuṭṭhānādīni paṭhamaṃ niddhārayissāma. Tattha samuṭṭhānaṃ nāma desanānidānaṃ, taṃ sādhāraṇamasādhāraṇanti duvidhaṃ. Tattha sādhāraṇampi ajjhattikabāhirabhedato duvidhaṃ. Tattha sādhāraṇaṃ ajjhattikasamuṭṭhānaṃ nāma lokanāthassa mahākaruṇā. Tāya hi samussāhitassa bhagavato veneyyānaṃ dhammadesanāya cittaṃ udapādi, yaṃ sandhāya vuttaṃ – ‘‘sattesu ca kāruññataṃ paṭicca buddhacakkhunā lokaṃ volokesī’’tiādi (ma. ni. 1.283; mahāva. 9; saṃ. ni. 1.173). Ettha ca hetāvatthāyapi mahākaruṇāya saṅgaho daṭṭhabbo yāvadeva saṃsāramahoghato saddhammadesanāhatthadānehi sattasantāraṇatthaṃ taduppattito. Yathā ca mahākaruṇā, evaṃ sabbaññutaññāṇaṃ dasabalañāṇādayo ca desanāya abbhantarasamuṭṭhānabhāvena vattabbā. Sabbañhi ñeyyadhammaṃ tesaṃ desetabbākāraṃ sattānañca āsayānusayādiṃ yāthāvato jānanto bhagavā ṭhānāṭṭhānādīsu kosallena veneyyajjhāsayānurūpaṃ vicittanayadesanaṃ pavattesīti. Bāhiraṃ pana sādhāraṇaṃ samuṭṭhānaṃ dasasahassamahābrahmaparivārassa sahampatibrahmuno ajjhesanaṃ. Tadajjhesanuttarakālañhi dhammagambhīratāpaccavekkhaṇājanitaṃ appossukkataṃ paṭippassambhetvā dhammassāmī dhammadesanāya ussāhajāto ahosi. Asādhāraṇampi abbhantarabāhirabhedato duvidhameva. Tattha abbhantaraṃ yāya mahākaruṇāya yena ca desanāñāṇena [Pg.53] idaṃ suttaṃ pavattitaṃ, tadubhayaṃ veditabbaṃ. Bāhiraṃ pana rūpagarukānaṃ puggalānaṃ ajjhāsayo. Svāyamattho aṭṭhakathāyaṃ vutto eva. 现在我们将依论典之法对圣典作义释。此义释,因在确定教法的起源、目的、所化众生及核心要义之后,即变得容易理解和领会,是故我们首先要阐明经教的起源等。其中,“起源”(samuṭṭhāna)指说法之因缘,分共通与不共二种。共通起源又分内在与外在二类。所谓共通的内在起源,即世主(lokanātha)的大悲心。世尊(bhagavā)正是因大悲心所策励,才生起为所化众生说法的意念。如经中所说:“因于众生起悲悯,以佛眼观视世界”等。此处当知,大悲心甚至在因地时亦已含摄,直至其为以正法之手救度众生脱离轮回大流而生起。如同大悲心,一切知智、十力智等亦当说是教法的内在起源。因为世尊如实了知一切所应知法、说示此等法的方式,以及众生的意向、随眠等,故能以其善巧,随顺所化众生的根机,开展出种种教法。共通的外在起源,则是一万大梵天为眷属的娑婆主梵天(Sahampatibrahma)的劝请。正是在他劝请之后,世尊思惟法义甚深而生起的不热心才得以平息,作为法主,才生起说法之热忱。不共起源亦分内在与外在二类。其中,内在者当知是何种大悲心与何种说法之智促使本经生起;外在者则是那些重视色身的个人的意向。此义在义注中已说。 Payojanampi sādhāraṇāsādhāraṇato duvidhaṃ. Tattha sādhāraṇaṃ yāva anupādāparinibbānaṃ vimuttirasattā bhagavato desanāya. Tenevāha – ‘‘etadatthā kathā, etadatthā mantanā’’tiādi. Asādhāraṇaṃ pana tesaṃ rūpagarukānaṃ puggalānaṃ rūpe chandarāgassa jahāpanaṃ, ubhayampetaṃ bāhirameva. Sace pana veneyyasantānagatampi desanābalasiddhisaṅkhātaṃ payojanaṃ adhippāyasamijjhanabhāvato yathādhippetatthasiddhiyā mahākāruṇikassa bhagavatopi payojanamevāti gaṇheyya, iminā pariyāyenassa abbhantaratāpi siyā. 目的(payojana)亦分共通与不共二种。其中,共通者,乃世尊教法以解脱为味,直至无取般涅槃(anupādāparinibbāna)。因此他说:“为此义而说,为此义而论”等。不共者,则是令那些重视色身的个人舍弃对色身的欲贪。此二者皆是外在的。然而,若将此目的——即在所化众生相续中由说法之力所成就者,以及此所期之义的实现亦是大悲世尊的目的——作如是理解,那么依此道理,它亦可为内在的。 Apica tesaṃ rūpagarukānaṃ puggalānaṃ rūpasmiṃ vijjamānassa ādīnavassa yāthāvato anavabodho imissā desanāya samuṭṭhānaṃ, tadavabodho payojanaṃ. So hi imāya desanāya bhagavantaṃ payojeti tannipphādanaparāyaṃ desanāti katvā. Yañhi desanāya sādhetabbaṃ phalaṃ, taṃ ākaṅkhitabbattā desakaṃ desanāya payojetīti payojananti vuccati. Tathā tesaṃ puggalānaṃ tadaññesañca veneyyānaṃ rūpamukhena pañcasu upādānakkhandhesu ādīnavadassanañcettha payojanaṃ. Tathā saṃsāracakkanivattisaddhammacakkappavattisassatādimicchāvādanirākaraṇaṃ sammāvādapurekkhāro akusalamūlasamūhananaṃ kusalamūlasamāropanaṃ apāyadvārapidahanaṃ saggamaggadvāravivaraṇaṃ pariyuṭṭhānavūpasamanaṃ anusayasamugghātanaṃ ‘‘mutto mocessāmī’’ti purimapaṭiññāvisaṃvādanaṃ tappaṭipakkhamāramanorathavisaṃvādanaṃ titthiyadhammanimmathanaṃ buddhadhammapatiṭṭhāpananti evamādīnipi payojanāni idha veditabbāni. 复次,于那些重视色身的个人,不能如实了知色身中存在的过患,是此教法的起源;了知彼过患,则是其目的。因为那(对过患的)了知促使世尊宣说此教法,此教法即是为了成就它。凡教法所应成就之果,因其为所希求,能促使说法者宣说教法,故称为“目的”。同样,令那些人及其他所化众生,通过色身来观察五取蕴的过患,亦是此处的目的。此外,如:止息轮回之轮、转动正法之轮、破除常边等邪见、推崇正见、根除不善根、培植善根、关闭恶趣之门、开启天界与圣道之门、平息缠、根除随眠、不违“我已解脱,亦将解脱他人”之初誓、挫败与此相违的魔罗(Māra)之愿、摧破外道(titthiya)之法、建立佛法等,亦当知是此处的目的。 Yathā te puggalā rūpagarukā, evaṃ tadaññe ca sakkāyagarukā sakkāyasmiṃ allīnā saṅkhatadhammānaṃ sammāsambuddhassa ca paṭipattiṃ ajānantā asaddhammassavanasādhāraṇaparicariyamanasikāraparā saddhammassavanadhāraṇaparicayappaṭivedhavimukhā ca bhavavippamokkhesino veneyyā imissā desanāya bhājanaṃ. 犹如那些重视色身的个人,其他一些重视有身(sakkāya)、执著于有身、不了知诸有为法与正等觉者之道、专事听闻非正法、行凡俗事、作不如理意,且背离听闻、受持、修习、证悟正法,却又寻求从“有”中解脱的所化众生,是此教法的根器。 Piṇḍattā [Pg.54] cettha rūpaggahaṇena rūpadhāturūpāyatanarūpakkhandhapariggaṇhanaṃ rūpamukhena catudhammānaṃ vaṭṭattayavicchedanūpāyo āsavoghādivivecanaṃ abhinandananivāraṇasaṅgatikkamo vivādamūlapariccāgo sikkhattayānuyogo pahānattayadīpanā samathavipassanānuṭṭhānaṃ bhāvanāsacchikiriyāsiddhīti evamādayo veditabbā. 总而言之,于此当知:通过执取色,总摄了色界、色处、色蕴;以色为门径,是辨析漏、暴流等四法、及切断三轮转(vaṭṭattaya)的方法;是防止喜悦、超越执著、舍弃诤根、勤修三学、阐明三断、修行止观(samatha-vipassanā)、成就修习与作证等。 Ito paraṃ pana soḷasa hārā dassetabbā. Tattha ‘‘rūpa’’nti sahajātā tassa nissayabhūtā tappaṭibaddhā ca sabbe rūpārūpadhammā taṇhāvajjā dukkhasaccaṃ. Taṃsamuṭṭhāpikā tadārammaṇā ca taṇhā samudayasaccaṃ. Tadubhayesaṃ appavatti nirodhasaccaṃ. Nirodhappajānanā paṭipadā maggasaccaṃ. Tattha samudayena assādo, dukkhena ādīnavo, magganirodhehi nissaraṇaṃ, rūpārammaṇassa akusalacittassa kusalacittassa ca pariyādānaṃ phalaṃ. Yañhi desanāya sādhetabbaṃ payojanaṃ, taṃ phalanti vuttovāyamattho. Tadatthaṃ hidaṃ suttaṃ bhagavatā desitanti. Yathā taṃ kusalacittaṃ na pariyādiyati, evaṃ paṭisaṅkhānabhāvanābalapariggahitā indriyesu guttadvāratā upāyo. Purisassa kusalacittapariyādānenassa rūpassa aññarūpāsādhāraṇatādassanāpadesena atthakāmehi tato cittaṃ sādhukaṃ rakkhitabbaṃ. Ayamettha bhagavato āṇattīti ayaṃ desanāhāro. Assādādisandassanavibhāvanalakkhaṇo hi desanāhāro. Vuttañhetaṃ nettippakaraṇe – 此外,应当说明十六种理趣。其中,“色”是指与生俱来、作为其所依且与之相关联的一切色法与非色法,除贪之外,即是苦谛。那使之生起且以之为所缘的贪,即是集谛。此二者的不生起,即是灭谛。了知灭的行道,即是道谛。于此,以集谛显示味(assāda),以苦谛显示过患(ādīnava),以道谛和灭谛显示出离(nissaraṇa);以色为所缘的不善心和善心的断尽,即是果(phala)。凡是教说所要成就的目的,即是所说的果义。世尊宣说此经,即是为了此目的。为使善心不被耗尽,依靠审察修习之力防护诸根门,即是方法(upāya)。对于善心因色法而耗尽的人,希求利益者应当通过指示此色法的不共性,来善护其心。此即世尊之教令(āṇatti),此乃教说理趣(desanāhāra)。教说理趣的特征即是开示味、过患、出离等。《导论》(Nettippakaraṇa)中也如是说: ‘‘Assādādīnavatā, nissaraṇampi ca phalaṃ upāyo ca; Āṇattī ca bhagavato, yogīnaṃ desanāhāro’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “味与过患,出离以及果,方法以及世尊的教令,是诸瑜伽行者的教说理趣。” Desīyati saṃvaṇṇīyati etāya suttatthoti desanā, desanāya sahacaraṇato vā desanā. Nanu ca aññepi hārā desanāsaṅkhātassa suttassa atthasaṃvaṇṇanāto desanāya sahacārino vāti? Saccametaṃ, ayaṃ pana hāro yebhuyyena yathārutavaseneva viññāyamāno desanāya saha caratīti vattabbataṃ arahati, na tathāpare. Na hi assādādīnavanissaraṇādisandassanarahitā suttadesanā atthi. Kiṃ pana tesaṃ assādādīnaṃ anavasesānaṃ vacanaṃ desanāhāro, udāhu [Pg.55] ekaccānanti? Niravasesānaṃyeva. Yasmiñhi sutte assādādīnavanissaraṇāni sarūpato āgatāni, tattha vattabbameva natthi. Yattha pana ekadesena āgatāni, na ca sarūpena, tattha anāgataṃ atthavasena niddhāretvā hāro yojetabbo. 以此开示、阐明经义,故称“教说”(desanā);或因与教说俱行,故称“教说”。然,其他理趣(hāra)不也因阐明名为“教说”的经义而与教说俱行吗?诚然如此。但此理趣大多仅依文句本身即可了知,故堪称与教说俱行,其他理趣则不然。实无不含示味、过患、出离等的经教。然则,是遍说此等味等,方为教说理趣(desanāhāra),抑或说其一分?是遍说。若于某经中,味、过患、出离等已自相呈现,则无须多言。若仅呈现一分,且非自相,则应依义推求其未呈现者,而运用此理趣。 Sayaṃ samantacakkhubhāvato taṃdassanena sabhāvato ca ‘‘aha’’nti vuttaṃ. Bhikkhanasīlatādiguṇayogato abhimukhīkaraṇatthañca, ‘‘bhikkhave’’ti vuttaṃ. Attābhāvato aparatādassanatthañca ‘‘añña’’nti vuttaṃ. Ekassa anupalabbhadassanatthaṃ anekabhāvappaṭisedhanatthañca ‘‘ekarūpampī’’ti vuttaṃ. Tādisassa rūpassa abhāvato adassanato ca ‘‘na samanupassāmī’’ti vuttaṃ. Tassa paccāmasanato aniyamato ca ‘‘ya’’nti vuttaṃ. Idāni vuccamānākāraparāmasanato tadaññākāranisedhanato ca ‘‘eva’’nti vuttaṃ. Visabhāgindriyavatthuto sabhāgavatthusmiṃ tadabhāvato ca ‘‘purisassā’’ti vuttaṃ. Nimittaggāhassa vatthubhāvato tathā parikappitattā ca ‘‘cittaṃ pariyādāya tiṭṭhatī’’ti vuttaṃ. Evanti vuttākāraparāmasanatthañceva nidassanatthañca ‘‘yathā’’ti vuttaṃ. Attano paccakkhabhāvato bhikkhūnaṃ paccakkhakaraṇatthañca ‘‘ida’’nti vuttaṃ. Itthisantānapariyāpannato tappaṭibaddhabhāvato ca ‘‘itthirūpa’’nti vuttanti evaṃ anupadavicayato vicayo hāro. Vicīyanti etena, ettha vā padapañhādayoti vicayo, viciti eva vā tesanti vicayo. Padapucchāvissajjanapubbāparānuggahanaṃ assādādīnañca visesaniddhāraṇavasena pavicayalakkhaṇo hi vicayo hāro. Vuttampi cetaṃ – 因[世尊]己身具足圆满知见(samantacakkhu),亲见其法自性,故说“我”(ahaṃ)。为令比丘具足乞食之行等功德且正对[法],故说“诸比丘”(bhikkhave)。为示无我且不见有他,故说“其他”(aññaṃ)。为示一法不可得且否定众多之有,故说“任何一个色”(ekarūpampi)。因无有、不见如是之色,故说“我未见”(na samanupassāmi)。因其被审察且不确定,故说“其”(yaṃ)。因指称当下所说之相状且否定其他相状,故说“如此”(evaṃ)。因[女色]为异类根之所缘,且于同类根之所缘中无此,故说“男人”(purisassa)。因其为取相之所缘且被如是构想,故说“心被占据而住”(cittaṃ pariyādāya tiṭṭhati)。为指称所说“如此”之相状且作为示例,故说“犹如”(yathā)。因[法]为自身所亲证且为令诸比丘亲证,故说“此”(idaṃ)。因其摄于女性相续且与彼相连,故说“女色”(itthirūpaṃ)。如是随文逐句审察,即是抉择理趣(vicayo hāro)。以此审察,或于此中审察文句、提问等,故为“抉择”;或彼即是审察,故为“抉择”。抉择理趣的特征即是:通过对文句的问答、对前后文的辅助、以及对味等差别的确定,来进行详尽的审察。此亦曾说: ‘‘Yaṃ pucchitañca vissajjitañca, suttassa yā ca anugīti; Suttassa yo pavicayo, hāro vicayoti niddiṭṭho’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “所问与所答,以及对经的随释,对经的详审,此即抉择理趣。” Anādimati saṃsāre itthipurisānaṃ aññamaññarūpābhirāmatāya ‘‘itthirūpaṃ purisassa cittaṃ pariyādāya tiṭṭhatī’’ti yujjatīti ayaṃ yuttihāro. Byañjanatthānaṃ yuttāyuttavibhāgavibhāvanalakkhaṇo hi yuttihāro. Vuttampi cetaṃ – 于无始轮回(saṃsāra)中,男女耽染彼此色相,故“女色(itthirūpaṃ)占据男人心”之说为合理。此即合理理趣(yuttihāro)。合理理趣的特征即是辨明文句与义理的合理与否。此亦曾说: ‘‘Sabbesaṃ hārānaṃ, yā bhūmī yo ca gocaro tesaṃ; Yuttāyuttiparikkhā, hāro yuttīti niddiṭṭho’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “于所有理趣,考察其所依之地与行境,辨其合理与否,此即合理理趣。” Yuttīti [Pg.56] ca upapatti sādhanayutti, idha pana yuttivicāraṇā yutti uttarapadalopena ‘‘rūpabhavo rūpa’’nti yathā. Yuttisahacaraṇato vā yutti. 理趣(yutti)即是成立、证成之理。然于此,“理趣”乃“理趣之审察”,如“色有”(rūpabhava)省略后字而为“色”(rūpa)。或因与理趣俱行,故称“理趣”。 Itthirūpaṃ ayoniso olokiyamānaṃ indriyesu aguttadvāratāya padaṭṭhānaṃ, sā kusalānaṃ dhammānaṃ abhāvanāya padaṭṭhānaṃ, sā sabbassapi saṃkilesapakkhassa parivuddhiyā padaṭṭhānaṃ. Byatirekato pana itthirūpaṃ yoniso olokiyamānaṃ satipaṭṭhānabhāvanāya padaṭṭhānaṃ, sā bojjhaṅgānaṃ bhāvanāpāripūriyā padaṭṭhānaṃ, sā vijjāvimuttīnaṃ pāripūriyā padaṭṭhānaṃ, kusalassa cittassa pariyādānaṃ sammohābhinivesassa padaṭṭhānaṃ, so saṅkhārānaṃ padaṭṭhānaṃ, saṅkhārā viññāṇassāti sabbaṃ āvattati bhavacakkaṃ. Byatirekato pana kusalassa cittassa apariyādānaṃ tesaṃ tesaṃ kusalānaṃ dhammānaṃ uppādāya pāripūriyā padaṭṭhānanti ayaṃ tāva avisesato nayo. Visesato pana sīlassa apariyādānaṃ avippaṭisārassa padaṭṭhānaṃ, avippaṭisāro pāmojjassātiādinā yāva anupādāparinibbānaṃ netabbaṃ. Ayaṃ padaṭṭhāno hāro. Sutte āgatadhammānaṃ padaṭṭhānabhūte dhamme tesañca padaṭṭhānabhūteti sambhavato padaṭṭhānabhūtadhammaniddhāraṇalakkhaṇo hi padaṭṭhāno hāro. Vuttañcetaṃ – 非如理观察女色,是诸根不防护的近因(padaṭṭhāna);彼是诸善法不修习的近因;彼是一切杂染品增长的近因。反之,如理观察女色,是念住修习的近因;彼是诸觉支修习圆满的近因;彼是明与解脱圆满的近因。善心的耗尽,是痴与执取的近因;彼是诸行的近因;行是识的近因,如是整个有轮(bhavacakka)转起。反之,善心不耗尽,是彼彼善法生起与圆满的近因。此为总说。别说者,戒(sīla)不衰退,是无悔的近因;无悔是喜悦的近因,如是乃至可引至无取般涅槃(anupādāparinibbāna)。此即近因理趣(padaṭṭhāno hāro)。近因理趣的特征即是:确定经中所说诸法的近因法,以及在可能的情况下,确定彼等的近因法。此亦曾说: ‘‘Dhammaṃ deseti jino, tassa ca dhammassa yaṃ padaṭṭhānaṃ; Iti yāva sabbadhammā, eso hāro padaṭṭhāno’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “胜者(jina)说示法,亦说彼法之近因;如是乃至一切法,此即近因理趣。” Padaṭṭhānanti āsannakāraṇaṃ. Idha pana padaṭṭhānavicāraṇā padaṭṭhānotiādi yuttihāre vuttanayeneva veditabbaṃ. 近因(padaṭṭhāna)即是近缘(āsannakāraṇa)。然于此,“近因”乃“近因之审察”等,当知此理如同于合理理趣中所说。 Ekarūpanti ca rūpāyatanaggahaṇena channampi bāhirānaṃ āyatanānaṃ gahaṇaṃ bāhirāyatanabhāvena ekalakkhaṇattā. Cittanti manāyatanaggahaṇena channampi ajjhattikānaṃ āyatanānaṃ gahaṇaṃ ajjhattikāyatanabhāvena ekalakkhaṇattā. Evaṃ khandhadhātādivasenapi ekalakkhaṇatā vattabbā. Ayaṃ lakkhaṇo hāro. Lakkhīyanti etena, ettha vā ekalakkhaṇadhammā avuttāpi ekaccavacanenāti lakkhaṇo. Sutte anāgatepi dhamme vuttappakāre āgate viya niddhāretvā yā saṃvaṇṇanā, so lakkhaṇo hāro. Vuttampi cetaṃ – “一色”(ekarūpa)是通过摄取色处(rūpāyatana)来总摄六外处(bāhirāyatana),因为它们作为外处具有同一特征(ekalakkhaṇa)。“心”(citta)是通过摄取意处(manāyatana)来总摄六内处(ajjhattikāyatana),因为它们作为内处具有同一特征。像这样,依照蕴(khandha)、界(dhātu)等,也可以说具有同一特征。此即特征(lakkhaṇa)章。所谓“特征”,即由此而被标示;或者说,于此,即使未言及的同特征法,亦能通过某一说法而被标示。在经中,即使对尚未出现的法,也像已经出现那样,通过已说的方式来确定并加以释义(saṃvaṇṇanā),此即特征章。经中也曾如此说—— ‘‘Vuttamhi [Pg.57] ekadhamme, ye dhammā ekalakkhaṇā keci; Vuttā bhavanti sabbe, so hāro lakkhaṇo nāmā’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “于一法被说时,凡具同一特征之法,悉皆被说;此章名为特征章。”(netti. 4 niddesavāra) Nidāne imissā desanāya rūpagarukānaṃ puggalānaṃ rūpasmiṃ anādīnavadassitā vuttā, ‘‘kathaṃ nu kho ime imaṃ desanaṃ sutvā rūpe ādīnavadassanamukhena sabbasmimpi khandhapañcake sabbaso chandarāgaṃ pahāya sakalavaṭṭadukkhato mucceyyuṃ, pare ca tattha patiṭṭhāpeyyu’’nti ayamettha bhagavato adhippāyo. Padanibbacanaṃ niruttaṃ, taṃ ‘‘eva’’ntiādinidānapadānaṃ ‘‘nāha’’ntiādipāḷipadānañca aṭṭhakathāyaṃ tassā līnatthavaṇṇanāya ca vuttanayānusārena sukarattā na vitthārayimha. 在这教法(desanā)的缘起(nidāna)中,提及了那些看重色(rūpa)的人(puggala)未见色之过患(ādīnava)。世尊(bhagavā)在此处的意趣是:“这些人听闻此教法后,如何能通过观察色之过患,从而彻底舍弃对一切五蕴(khandhapañcaka)的欲贪(chandarāga),从一切轮回之苦中解脱,并且也能使他人安住于此呢?”至于词语的抉择(padanibbacana)与释词(nirutta),即对“eva”等缘起词与“nāha”等圣典词,及其在义注(aṭṭhakathā)中对隐义的释义(līnatthavaṇṇanā),因依循已说之理趣易于了知,故我们不再详述。 Padapadatthadesanādesanānikkhepasuttasandhivasena pañcavidhā sandhi. Tattha padassa padantarena sambandho padasandhi. Padatthassa padatthantarena sambandho padatthasandhi, yo ‘‘kiriyākārakasambandho’’ti vuccati. Nānānusandhikassa suttassa taṃtaṃanusandhīhi sambandho, ekānusandhikassa ca pubbāparasambandho desanāsandhi, yā aṭṭhakathāyaṃ ‘‘pucchānusandhi, ajjhāsayānusandhi, yathānusandhī’’ti tidhā vibhattā. Ajjhāsayo cettha attajjhāsayo parajjhāsayoti dvidhā veditabbo. Desanānikkhepasandhi catunnaṃ suttanikkhepānaṃ vasena veditabbā. Suttasandhi idha paṭhamanikkhepavaseneva veditabbā. ‘‘Kasmā panettha idameva cittapariyādānasuttaṃ paṭhamaṃ nikkhitta’’nti nāyamanuyogo katthaci na pavattati. Apica ime sattā anādimati saṃsāre paribbhamantā itthipurisā aññamaññesaṃ pañcakāmaguṇasaṅkhātarūpābhirāmā, tattha itthī purisassa rūpe sattā giddhā gadhitā laggā laggitā āsattā, sā cassā tattha āsatti dubbivecanīyā. Tathā puriso itthiyā rūpe, tattha ca dassanasaṃsaggo garutaro itaresañca mūlabhūto. Teneva hi bhagavā ‘‘kathaṃ nu kho mātugāme paṭipajjitabba’’nti (dī. ni. 2.203) puṭṭho ‘‘adassanamevā’’ti avoca. Tasmā bhagavā pañcasu kāmaguṇesu rūpe chandarāgahāpanatthaṃ idameva suttaṃ paṭhamaṃ desesi. Nibbānādhigamāya paṭipattiyā ādi resā paṭipattīti. Yaṃ pana ekissā desanāya desanantarena saṃsandanaṃ, ayampi desanāsandhi. Sā idha evaṃ veditabbā. ‘‘Nāhaṃ, bhikkhave…pe… tiṭṭhatī’’ti ayaṃ desanā. ‘‘Ye kho, bhikkhave, cakkhuviññeyyā rūpā iṭṭhā kantā manāpā piyarūpā kāmūpasaṃhitā rajanīyā[Pg.58], tañce bhikkhu abhinandati abhivadati ajjhosāya tiṭṭhati, tassa taṃ abhinandato abhivadato ajjhosāya tiṭṭhato uppajjanti aneke pāpakā akusalā dhammā’’ti (saṃ. ni. 4.118) imāya desanāya saṃsandati. Tathā ‘‘rūpe maññati, rūpesu maññati, rūpato maññati, rūpaṃ ‘me’ti maññati. Rūpaṃ, bhikkhave, anabhijānaṃ aparijānaṃ avirājayaṃ appajahaṃ abhabbo dukkhakkhayāyā’’ti (saṃ. ni. 4.112) evamādīhi desanāhi saṃsandatīti ayaṃ catubyūho hāro. Viyūhīyanti vibhāgena piṇḍīyanti etena, ettha vāti byūho, nibbacanādīnaṃ catunnaṃ byūhoti catubyūho, catunnaṃ vā byūho etthāti catubyūho. Nibbacanādhippāyādīnaṃ catunnaṃ vibhāgalakkhaṇo hi catubyūho hāro. Vuttañhetaṃ – 依词、词义、教说、教说纲目、经文之结合,有五种结合。其中,词与另一词之关联为词结合。词义与另一词义之关联为词义结合,此即所谓“作用与作者之关联”。对于具有多种脉络的经,以各各脉络作关联;对于单一脉络的经,则作前后关联,此为教说结合,于义注(aṭṭhakathā)中分为三:“问答脉络、意乐脉络、如理脉络”。此中意乐当知有自意乐与他意乐二种。教说纲目结合当知依四种经文纲目。经文结合于此当知仅依第一纲目。“为何此处首先置《心遍取经》?”如是诘难于何处皆不成立。复次,此等众生于无始轮回中流转,男女相互于五妙欲(pañcakāmaguṇa)所摄之可爱色相而喜乐,其中女于男色,心生染著、贪恋、缠缚、执着,此执着难以辨别。同样,男于女色亦然,其中见之交往尤为严重,且为其他之根本。是故世尊被问及“应如何对待女人”(dī. ni. 2.203)时,答曰“不见为妙”。因此,世尊为断除于五妙欲中对色之欲贪,首先宣说此经。此即为证得涅槃之道的开端。又,一教说与另一教说之相互衔接,此亦为教说结合。于此当如是知:“诸比丘,我不……乃至……存续。”此为一教说。其与“诸比丘,凡眼所识之色,为可喜、可爱、可意、悦意、引欲、可染者,若比丘于彼欢喜、称赞、执取而住,则彼因欢喜、称赞、执取而住,生起众多恶不善法”(saṃ. ni. 4.118)此一教说相衔接。同样,亦与“于色作想,于诸色中作想,由色作想,思‘色是我所’。诸比丘,于色不了知、不遍知、不离贪、不舍断者,不能灭苦”(saṃ. ni. 4.112)等教说相衔接。此即四类章。由此而分别、总合,或于此中分别、总合,故为“类”(byūho);四者之类,故为“四类”(catubyūho)。以抉择释词、意趣等四者为特征,故为四类章。经中亦如是说—— ‘‘Neruttamadhippāyo, byañjanamatha desanānidānañca; Pubbāparānusandhī, eso hāro catubyūho’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “释词与意趣,文句与教说因缘,以及前后脉络,此即四类章。”(netti. 4 niddesavāra) ‘‘Nāhaṃ, bhikkhave, aññaṃ…pe… itthirūpa’’nti etena ayonisomanasikāro dīpito. Yaṃ tattha cittaṃ pariyādiyati, tena yonisomanasikāro. Tattha ayonisomanasikaroto taṇhāvijjā parivaḍḍhanti, tāsu taṇhāgahaṇena nava taṇhāmūlakā dhammā āvaṭṭanti, avijjāgahaṇena avijjāmūlakaṃ sabbaṃ bhavacakkaṃ āvaṭṭati, yonisomanasikāraggahaṇena ca yonisomanasikāramūlakā dhammā āvaṭṭanti, catubbidhañca sampatticakkanti. Ayaṃ āvaṭṭo hāro. Āvaṭṭayanti etena, ettha vā sabhāgavisabhāgā ca dhammā, tesaṃ vā āvaṭṭananti āvaṭṭo. Desanāya gahitadhammānaṃ sabhāgāsabhāgadhammavasena āvaṭṭanalakkhaṇo hi āvaṭṭo hāro. Vuttampi cetaṃ – “诸比丘,我不见其他……乃至女色”,此句阐明了不如理作意。于彼处心被遍取,由此而有如理作意。于彼处,行不如理作意者,贪与无明增长;于彼等中,因执取贪,九种贪根法回转;因执取无明,一切无明根之有轮回转;因执取如理作意,如理作意为根之法及四种成就轮回转。此即回转章。由此而回转,或于此中有同分、不同分诸法,或彼等之回转,故名“回转”。以教说所取诸法,依同分、不同分法而回转为特征,此即回转章。经中亦如是说—— ‘‘Ekamhi padaṭṭhāne, pariyesati sesakaṃ padaṭṭhānaṃ; Āvaṭṭati paṭipakkhe, āvaṭṭo nāma so hāro’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “于一近因处,寻求其余近因处;于对立法中回转,此章名为回转章。”(netti. 4 niddesavāra) Rūpaṃ catubbidhaṃ kammasamuṭṭhānaṃ, cittasamuṭṭhānaṃ, utusamuṭṭhānaṃ, āhārasamuṭṭhānaṃ, tathā iṭṭhaṃ iṭṭhamajjhattaṃ aniṭṭhaṃ aniṭṭhamajjhattanti. Idha pana iṭṭhaṃ adhippetaṃ. Cittaṃ kusalacittamettha veditabbaṃ. Taṃ kāmāvacaraṃ, rūpāvacaraṃ, arūpāvacaraṃ, lokuttaranti catubbidhaṃ. Vedanādisampayuttadhammabhedato anekavidhanti [Pg.59] ayaṃ vibhattihāro. Vibhajīyanti etena, ettha vā sādhāraṇāsādhāraṇānaṃ saṃkilesavodānadhammānaṃ bhūmiyoti vibhatti. Vibhajanaṃ vā etesaṃ bhūmiyoti vibhatti. Saṃkilesadhamme vodānadhamme ca sādhāraṇāsādhāraṇato padaṭṭhānato bhūmito vibhajanalakkhaṇo hi vibhattihāro. Vuttampi cetaṃ – 色有四种:业生、心生、时节生、食生;以及可意、中等可意、不可意、中等不可意。于此,意指可意者。此中心当知为善心。其有四种:欲界、色界、无色界、出世间。因与受等相应法之差别而有多种。此即分别章。由此而分别,或于此中,为共通与不共通之杂染、清净诸法之地,故为“分别”。或分别此等地,故为“分别”。于杂染法与清净法,从共通与不共通、近因、地而作分别,此即分别章之特征。经中亦如是说—— ‘‘Dhammañca padaṭṭhānaṃ, bhūmiñca vibhajjate ayaṃ hāro; Sādhāraṇe asādhāraṇe ca neyyo vibhattī’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “此章分别法、近因以及地;于共通与不共通中,当知此分别为。”(netti. 4 niddesavāra) Itthirūpaṃ purisassa cittaṃ pariyādāya tiṭṭhati ayoniso manasikaroto, yoniso manasikaroto na pariyādiyati susaṃvutindriyattā sīlesu samāhitassāti ayaṃ parivatto hāro. Paṭipakkhavasena parivattīyanti iminā, ettha vā sutte vuttadhammā, parivattanaṃ vā tesanti parivatto. Niddiṭṭhānaṃ dhammānaṃ paṭipakkhato parivattanalakkhaṇo hi parivatto hāro. Vuttañhetaṃ – 女色能占据不如理作意男人的心,而如理作意、善护诸根、安住于戒者,其心则不被占据,此即回转释式。依对治而回转,或于此经中回转所说诸法,或彼等之回转,故名“回转”。已阐明诸法,从对治面回转,即是回转释式之特征。如是说: ‘‘Kusalākusale dhamme, niddiṭṭhe bhāvite pahīne ca; Parivattati paṭipakkhe, hāro parivattano nāmā’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); 于善不善法,已阐明、修习与断除;于对治法中回转,名为回转释式。 Bhikkhave, samaṇā pabbajitāti pariyāyavacanaṃ. Aññaṃ paraṃ kiñcīti pariyāyavacanaṃ. Rūpaṃ vaṇṇaṃ cakkhuviññeyyanti pariyāyavacanaṃ. Samanupassāmi olokessāmi jānāmīti pariyāyavacanaṃ. Evaṃ itthaṃ imaṃ pakāranti pariyāyavacanaṃ. Purisassa puggalassāti pariyāyavacanaṃ. Cittaṃ viññāṇaṃ manoti pariyāyavacanaṃ. Pariyādāya gahetvā khepetvāti pariyāyavacanaṃ. Tiṭṭhati dharati ṭhātīti pariyāyavacanaṃ. Yathā yena pakārena yenākārenāti pariyāyavacanaṃ. Itthī nārī mātugāmoti pariyāyavacananti ayaṃ vevacano hāro. Vividhaṃ vacanaṃ ekassevatthassa vācakametthāti vivacanaṃ, vivacanameva vevacanaṃ. Vividhaṃ vuccati etena atthoti vā vivacanaṃ, vivacanameva vevacanaṃ. Ekasmiṃ atthe anekapariyāyasaddappayojanalakkhaṇo hi vevacano hāro. Vuttañhetaṃ – 诸比丘,“沙门”、“出家者”是同义词。“其他”、“另外”、“任何”是同义词。“色”、“颜色”、“眼所识”是同义词。“我随观”、“我观看”、“我知道”是同义词。“如是”、“如此”、“此方式”是同义词。“男人”、“个人”是同义词。“心”、“识”、“意”是同义词。“遍取”、“执取”、“耗尽”是同义词。“住立”、“持续”、“站立”是同义词。“如”、“以何方式”、“以何行相”是同义词。“女人”、“女子”、“女性”是同义词——此即同义词释式。种种言辞为同一意义之表述,此为“别说”(vivacana),别说即同义词(vevacana)。或,以此说种种义,故为“别说”,别说即同义词。于一义中运用多种同义词,即是同义词释式之特征。如是说: ‘‘Vevacanāni bahūni tu, sutte vuttāni ekadhammassa; Yo jānāti suttavidū, vevacano nāma so hāro’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); 于一法,经中说诸多同义词;通经者知此,名为同义词释式。 Rūpaṃ [Pg.60] kāḷasāmādivasena anekadhā paññattaṃ. Puriso khattiyādivasena anekadhā paññatto. Cittaṃ parittamahaggatādivasena anekadhā paññattaṃ. ‘‘Pariyādāyā’’ti ettha pariyādānaṃ pariyādāyakānaṃ pāpadhammānaṃ vasena vītikkamapariyuṭṭhānādinā ca anekadhā paññattaṃ. Ayaṃ paññattihāro. Pakārehi, pabhedato vā ñāpīyanti iminā, ettha vā atthāti paññatti. Ekekassa dhammassa anekāhi paññattīhi paññāpetabbākāravibhāvanalakkhaṇo hi paññattihāro. Vuttañhetaṃ – 色,依黑、青等而有多种施设。人,依刹帝利等而有多种施设。心,依小、大等而有多种施设。于“遍取”,其遍取是依遍取者之诸恶法,通过违犯、缠等而有多种施设。此即施设释式。以此令知种种方式或差别,或义在于此,故为“施设”。以多种施设,阐明每一法所应施设之行相,即是施设释式之特征。如是说—— ‘‘Ekaṃ bhagavā dhammaṃ, paññattīhi vividhāhi deseti; So ākāro ñeyyo, paññattī nāma so hāro’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); 世尊以种种施设,宣说于一法;应知此行相,名为施设释式。 Virodhipaccayasamavāye visadisuppattiruppanavaṇṇavikārāpattiyā taṃsamaṅgino hadayaṅgatabhāvappakāsanaṃ rūpaṭṭhoti aniccatāmukhena otaraṇaṃ, aniccassa pana dukkhattā dukkhatāmukhena, dukkhassa ca anattakattā suññatāmukhena otaraṇaṃ. Cittaṃ manoviññāṇadhātu, tassā pariyādāyikā taṇhā tadekaṭṭhā ca pāpadhammā dhammadhātūti dhātumukhena otaraṇaṃ. Evaṃ khandhāyatanādimukhehipi otaraṇaṃ vattabbanti ayaṃ otaraṇo hāro. Otārīyanti anuppavesīyanti etena, ettha vā suttāgatā dhammā paṭiccasamuppādādīsūti otaraṇo. Paṭiccasamuppādādimukhena suttatthassa otaraṇalakkhaṇo hi otaraṇo hāro. Vuttañhetaṃ – 于相违缘和合中,由生起变坏、色变异,而显明彼相应者之心意状态,此为色之义。故由无常门切入;复因无常为苦,故由苦门切入;又因苦为无我,故由空门切入。心是意界,其遍取者为渴爱,与彼同处之诸恶法为法界,此即由界门切入。如是,亦应说由蕴、处等门切入,此即入门释式。由此而入、而趣入,或于此,经来诸法入于缘起等中,故为“入门”。由缘起等门令经义趣入,即是入门释式之特征。如是说—— ‘‘Yo ca paṭiccuppādo, indriyakhandhā ca dhātuāyatanā; Etehi otarati yo, otaraṇo nāma so hāro’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); 缘起、根、蕴、以及界、处;凡由此而入者,名为入门释式。 Nāhaṃ, bhikkhave…pe… samanupassāmīti ārambho. Evaṃ purisassa cittaṃ pariyādāya tiṭṭhatīti padasuddhi, na pana ārambhasuddhi. Yathayidantiādi padasuddhi ceva ārambhasuddhi cāti ayaṃ sodhano hāro. Sodhīyanti samādhīyanti etena, ettha vā sutte padapadatthapañhārambhāti sodhano. Sutte padapadatthapañhārambhānaṃ sodhanalakkhaṇo hi sodhano hāro. Vuttañhetaṃ – “诸比丘,我不……(乃至)……随观”,此为开端。“如是,男人之心被遍取而住”,此为句之清净,而非开端之清净。“正如这样”等,既是句之清净,亦是开端之清净,此即清净释式。由此而清净、而确立,或于此经中,句、句义、问、开端,故为“清净”。于经中,清净句、句义、问、开端,即是清净释式之特征。如是说—— ‘‘Vissajjitamhi pañhe, gāthāyaṃ pucchitāyamārabbha; Suddhāsuddhaparikkhā, hāro so sodhano nāmā’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); 于已答之问,于所问偈颂,从开端起;考察净不净,彼名为清净释式。 Aññanti [Pg.61] sāmaññato adhiṭṭhānaṃ kassaci visesassa anāmaṭṭhattā. Ekarūpampīti taṃ avikappetvā visesavacanaṃ. Yathayidanti sāmaññato adhiṭṭhānaṃ aniyamavacanabhāvato. Itthirūpanti taṃ avikappetvā visesavacananti ayaṃ adhiṭṭhāno hāro. Adhiṭṭhīyanti anuppavattīyanti etena, ettha vā sāmaññavisesabhūtā dhammā vinā vikappenāti adhiṭṭhāno. Suttāgatānaṃ dhammānaṃ avikappanavaseneva sāmaññavisesaniddhāraṇalakkhaṇo hi adhiṭṭhāno hāro. Vuttampi cetaṃ – “其他”,为总说之安立,因未触及任何别说。“一色”,此为不加分别之别说。“正如这样”,为总说之安立,因其为不定之说。“女色”,此为不加分别之别说。此即安立释式。由此而安立、而随转,或于此,总说与别说之法无需分别,故为“安立”。仅依不加分别,确定经来诸法之总说与别说,即是安立释式之特征。此亦如是说—— ‘‘Ekattatāya dhammā, yepi ca vemattatāya niddiṭṭhā; Tena vikappayitabbā, eso hāro adhiṭṭhāno’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); 诸法或阐明为一性,或阐明为种种性;不应以此作分别,此为安立释式。 Rūpassa kammāvijjādayo kammacittādayo ca hetu. Samanupassanāya āvajjanādayo. Kusalassa cittassa yoniso manasikārādayo. Pariyādāyāti ettha pariyādānassa ayonisomanasikārādayoti ayaṃ parikkhāro hāro. Parikaroti abhisaṅkharoti phalanti parikkhāro, hetu paccayo ca. Parikkhāraṃ ācikkhatīti parikkhāro, hāro. Parikkhāravisayattā, parikkhārasahacaraṇato vā parikkhāro. Sutte āgatadhammānaṃ parikkhārasaṅkhātahetupaccaye niddhāretvā saṃvaṇṇanālakkhaṇo hi parikkhāro hāro. Vuttañhetaṃ – 色之因,为业、无明等,及业心等。随观之因,为转向等。善心之因,为如理作意等。于“遍取”,其遍取之因,为不如理作意等,此即资具释式。造作、行作其果,故为“资具”,即因与缘。开示资具,故为资具释式。因其为资具之境,或与资具俱行,故为“资具”。确定经来诸法名为“资具”之因缘后而作阐释,即是资具释式之特征。如是说—— ‘‘Ye dhammā yaṃ dhammaṃ, janayantippaccayā paramparato; Hetumavakaḍḍhayitvā, eso hāro parikkhāro’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); 诸法生何法,依缘而辗转;抉择出其因,此为资具释式。 Purisassa cittaṃ pariyādāya tiṭṭhatīti ettha pariyādāyikā visesato taṇhāvijjā veditabbā tāsaṃ vasena pariyādānasambhavato. Tāsu taṇhāya rūpamadhiṭṭhānaṃ, avijjāya arūpaṃ. Visesato taṇhāya samatho paṭipakkho, avijjāya vipassanā. Samathassa cetovimutti, phalavipassanāya paññāvimutti. Tathā hi tā rāgavirāgā avijjāvirāgāti visesetvā vuccantīti ayaṃ samāropano hāro. Samāropīyanti etena, ettha vā padaṭṭhānādimukhena dhammāti samāropano. Sutte āgatadhammānaṃ padaṭṭhānavevacanabhāvanāpahānasamāropanavicāraṇalakkhaṇo hi samāropano hāro. Vuttañhetaṃ – 于“男人之心被遍取而住”,应知其遍取者,别则为爱与无明,因依彼等而有遍取。于彼等中,爱以色为所依,无明以无色为所依。别则,爱之对治为奢摩他,无明之对治为毘婆舍那。奢摩他之果为心解脱,果位之毘婆舍那之果为慧解脱。是故,彼等被分别说为离贪与离无明。此即等置释式。由此而等置,或于此,由近因等门而等置诸法,故为“等置”。考察经来诸法之近因、同义词、修习、断除、等置,即是等置释式之特征。如是说—— ‘‘Ye [Pg.62] dhammā yaṃ mūlā, ye cekatthā pakāsitā muninā; Te samāropayitabbā, esa samāropano hāro’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); 诸法以何为根,及牟尼所说一义;彼等应等置,此为等置释式。 Ettāvatā ca – 到此为止—— ‘‘Desanā vicayo yutti, padaṭṭhāno ca lakkhaṇo; Catubyūho ca āvaṭṭo, vibhatti parivattano. 宣说、抉择、正理、立足处、特征;四阵、回转、分别、转变。 Vevacano ca paññatti, otaraṇo ca sodhano; Adhiṭṭhāno parikkhāro, samāropano soḷaso’’ti. (netti. 1 uddesavāra) – 同义词、施设、趣入、净化、安立、资具、增上,共十六种。(《导论》第一品,举示品) Evaṃ vuttā soḷasa hārā dassitāti veditabbā. Harīyanti etehi, ettha vā suttageyyādivisayā aññāṇasaṃsayavipallāsāti hārā. Haranti vā sayaṃ tāni, haraṇamattameva vāti hārā phalūpacārena. Atha vā harīyanti voharīyanti dhammasaṃvaṇṇakadhammappaṭiggāhakehi dhammassa dānaggahaṇavasenāti hārā. Atha vā hārā viyāti hārā. Yathā hi anekaratanāvalisamūho hārasaṅkhāto attano avayavabhūtaratanasamphassehi samupajaniyamānahilādasukho hutvā tadupabhogijanasarīrasantāpaṃ nidāghapariḷāhūpajanitaṃ vūpasameti, evameva tepi nānāvidhaparamattharatanappabandhā saṃvaṇṇanāvisesā attano avayavabhūtaparamattharatanādhigamena samuppādiyamānanibbutisukhā dhammappaṭiggāhakajanahadayaparitāpaṃ kāmarāgādikilesahetukaṃ vūpasamentīti. Atha vā hārayanti aññāṇādinīhāraṃ apagamaṃ karonti ācikkhantīti vā hārā. Atha vā sotujanacittassa haraṇato ramaṇato ca hārā niruttinayena yathā ‘‘bhavesu vantagamano bhagavā’’ti (visuddhi. 1.144; pārā. aṭṭha. 1.verañjakaṇḍavaṇṇanā). 如是所说,当知已开示十六理趣(hārā)。通过它们,于经、偈等范围内的无知、疑惑、颠倒得以被带走(harīyanti),故称为“理趣”。或它们自身带走(haranti)彼等,或仅是带走的行为,依果立名,故称“理趣”。又或,说法者与受法者通过法的施与受,而运载(harīyanti)、称说(voharīyanti),故称“理趣”。又或,如璎珞(hārā),故称“理趣”。譬如,由众多宝珠串联而成的璎珞,因其构成的宝珠相互触碰而生起喜悦之乐,从而平息享用者因酷暑热恼所生的身体烦热;同样地,这些由种种胜义宝珠所组成的特殊释义,也因证得其构成的胜义宝珠而生起寂灭之乐,从而平息受法者心中由欲贪等烦恼所生的热恼。又或,它们能导致(hārayanti)无知等的去除、远离,或说它们能开示,故称“理趣”。又或,依词源学之理,因其能摄受(haraṇato)、愉悦(ramaṇato)听者之心,故称“理趣”,如言:“世尊(bhagavā)于诸有中已断所行”。(《清净道论》1.144;《波罗夷注释》1.维兰迦品释(verañjakaṇḍavaṇṇanā))。 Ito paraṃ pana nandiyāvaṭṭādipañcavidhanayā veditabbā – tattha taṇhāvijjā samudayasaccaṃ, tāsaṃ adhiṭṭhānādibhūtā rūpadhammā dukkhasaccaṃ, tesaṃ appavatti nirodhasaccaṃ, nirodhappajānanā paṭipadā maggasaccaṃ. Taṇhāgahaṇena cettha māyāsāṭheyyamānātimānamadappamādapāpicchatāpāpamittatāahirikaanottappādivasena akusalapakkho netabbo. Avijjāgahaṇena viparītamanasikārakodhūpanāhamakkhapaḷāsaissāmacchariya- sārambhadovacassatābhavadiṭṭhivibhavadiṭṭhiādivasena akusalapakkho netabbo. Vuttavipariyāyato [Pg.63] kusalapakkho netabbo. Kathaṃ? Amāyāasāṭheyyādivasena aviparītamanasikārādivasena ca. Tathā samathapakkhiyānaṃ saddhindriyādīnaṃ, vipassanāpakkhiyānaṃ aniccasaññādīnañca vasena vodānapakkho netabboti ayaṃ nandiyāvaṭṭassa nayassa bhūmi. Yo hi taṇhāavijjāhi saṃkilesapakkhassa suttatthassa samathavipassanāhi vodānapakkhassa ca catusaccayojanamukhena nayanalakkhaṇo saṃvaṇṇanāviseso, ayaṃ nandiyāvaṭṭanayo nāma. Vuttañhetaṃ – 此后当知南迪亚回转(nandiyāvaṭṭa)等五种理趣。其中,渴爱(taṇhā)与无明(avijjā)是集谛(samudayasaccaṃ),作为其所依等之色法是苦谛(dukkhasaccaṃ),彼等之不行是灭谛(nirodhasaccaṃ),了知灭之道是道谛(maggasaccaṃ)。于此,执取渴爱时,应通过虚伪、欺诈、慢、过慢、放逸、恶欲、恶友、无惭、无愧等,而导向不善品;执取无明时,应通过不如理作意、忿、恨、覆、恼、嫉、悭、争、恶言、有见、无有见等,而导向不善品。与上说相反,则应导向善品。如何导向?即通过不虚伪、不欺诈等,以及如理作意等。同样,对于止(samatha)品,应通过信根等而导向;对于观(vipassanā)品,应通过无常想等而导向清净品。此即南迪亚回转理趣之基础。凡是以渴爱与无明为杂染品,以止与观为清净品,通过四圣谛结合之门,具有引导特征的特殊释义,此即名为南迪亚回转理趣。如是说: ‘‘Taṇhañca avijjampi ca, samathena vipassanāya yo neti; Saccehi yojayitvā, ayaṃ nayo nandiyāvaṭṭo’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “以止与观,引导渴爱与无明,并与诸谛相结合,此理趣即南迪亚回转。”(《导论》第四品,解释品) Nandiyāvaṭṭassa viya āvaṭṭo etassāti nandiyāvaṭṭo. Yathā hi nandiyāvaṭṭo anto ṭhitena padhānāvayavena bahiddhā āvaṭṭati, evamayampi nayoti attho. Atha vā nandiyā taṇhāya pamodassa vā āvaṭṭo etthāti nandiyāvaṭṭo. 其回转如南迪亚回转(nandiyāvaṭṭa),故称南迪亚回转。譬如南迪亚回转由内部固定的主要部分带动外部旋转,此理趣亦然,此即其义。又或,于此中有喜悦(nandiyā)、渴爱(taṇhāya)或欢喜(pamodassa)之回转,故称南迪亚回转。 Heṭṭhā vuttanayena gahitesu taṇhāvijjātappakkhiyadhammesu taṇhā lobho, avijjā moho, avijjāya sampayutto lohite sati pubbo viya taṇhāya sati sijjhamāno āghāto doso iti tīhi akusalamūlehi gahitehi, tappaṭipakkhato kusalacittaggahaṇena ca tīṇi kusalamūlāni gahitāni eva honti. Idhāpi lobho sabbāni vā sāsavakusalamūlāni samudayasaccaṃ, tannibbattā tesaṃ adhiṭṭhānagocarabhūtā upādānakkhandhā dukkhasaccantiādinā saccayojanā veditabbā. Phalaṃ panettha vimokkhattayavasena niddhāretabbaṃ, tīhi akusalamūlehi tividhaduccaritasaṃkilesamalavisamaakusalasaññāvitakkādivasena akusalapakkho netabbo, tathā tīhi kusalamūlehi tividhasucaritasamakusalasaññāvitakkasaddhammasamādhivimokkhamukhādivasena vodānapakkho netabboti ayaṃ tipukkhalassa nayassa bhūmi. Yo hi akusalamūlehi saṃkilesapakkhassa kusalamūlehi vodānapakkhassa suttatthassa ca catusaccayojanāmukhena nayanalakkhaṇo saṃvaṇṇanāviseso, ayaṃ tipukkhalanayo nāma. Tīhi avayavehi [Pg.64] lobhādīhi saṃkilesapakkhe, alobhādīhi ca vodānapakkhe pukkhalo sobhanoti tipukkhalo. Vuttañhetaṃ – 依前述理趣,在所摄取的渴爱、无明及其相应法中,渴爱即是贪(lobha),无明即是痴(moha);与无明相应,如血中有脓,当渴爱存在时,瞋(āghāta)即是恚(dosa)便生起。如是,三不善根(akusalamūla)已被摄取,其对治法则由善心之摄取而三善根(kusalamūla)亦被摄取。于此,贪或一切有漏善根是集谛,由此所生、作为其所依与所缘的诸取蕴(upādānakkhandhā)是苦谛等,当知此四谛之结合。其果报当依三解脱门(vimokkhattaya)而抉择。以三不善根,应将不善品导向三恶行、杂染、垢、不正、不善想、不善寻等;同样,以三善根,应将清净品导向三善行、正、善想、善寻、正法、定、解脱门等。此即三瓣花(tipukkhala)理趣之基础。凡是以不善根解释杂染品,以善根解释清净品,并以四圣谛结合之门来引导经义的特殊释义,此即名为三瓣花理趣。因其在三部分——杂染品的贪等,与清净品的无贪等——上是卓越的(pukkhalo)、美好的(sobhano),故称三瓣花。如是说: ‘‘Yo akusale samūlehi,Neti kusale ca kusalamūlehi; Bhūtaṃ tathaṃ avitathaṃ,Tipukkhalaṃ taṃ nayaṃ āhū’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “谁以不善根引导不善法,以善根引导善法;真实、如实、不虚妄,彼等称此理趣为三瓣花。”(《导论》第四品,解释品) Vuttanayena gahitesu taṇhāvijjātappakkhiyadhammesu visesato taṇhādiṭṭhīnaṃ vasena asubhe ‘‘subha’’nti, dukkhe ‘‘sukha’’nti ca vipallāsā, avijjādiṭṭhīnaṃ vasena anicce ‘‘nicca’’nti, anattani ‘‘attā’’ti vipallāsā veditabbā. Tesaṃ paṭipakkhato kusalacittaggahaṇena siddhehi sativīriyasamādhipaññindriyehi cattāri satipaṭṭhānāni siddhāniyeva honti. 依前述理趣,在所摄取的渴爱、无明及其相应法中,当知尤其有颠倒(vipallāsa):由渴爱(taṇhā)与邪见(diṭṭhi)故,于不净(asubha)作净想,于苦(dukkha)作乐想;由无明(avijjā)与邪见故,于无常(anicca)作常想,于无我(anattani)作我想。其对治法,则由善心之摄取,通过已成就的念(sati)、精进(vīriya)、定(samādhi)、慧(paññā)诸根(indriya),四念处(satipaṭṭhāna)自然成就。 Tattha catūhi indriyehi cattāro puggalā niddisitabbā. Kathaṃ? Duvidho hi taṇhācarito mudindriyo tikkhindriyoti, tathā diṭṭhicarito. Tesu paṭhamo asubhe ‘‘subha’’nti vipariyesaggāhī satibalena yathābhūtaṃ kāyasabhāvaṃ sallakkhento bhāvanābalena taṃ vipallāsaṃ samugghātetvā sammattaniyāmaṃ okkamati. Dutiyo asukhe ‘‘sukha’’nti vipariyesaggāhī ‘‘uppannaṃ kāmavitakkaṃ nādhivāsetī’’tiādinā (ma. ni. 1.26; a. ni. 4.14; 6.58) vuttena vīriyasaṃvarabhūtena vīriyabalena paṭipakkhaṃ vinodento bhāvanābalena taṃ vipallāsaṃ vidhametvā sammattaniyāmaṃ okkamati. Tatiyo anicce ‘‘nicca’’nti vipallāsaggāhī samathabalena samāhitacitto saṅkhārānaṃ khaṇikabhāvaṃ sallakkhento bhāvanābalena taṃ vipallāsaṃ samugghātetvā sammattaniyāmaṃ okkamati. Catuttho santatisamūhakiccārammaṇaghanavañcitatāya phassādidhammapuñjamatte anattani ‘‘attā’’ti micchābhinivesī catukoṭikasuññatāmanasikārena taṃ micchābhinivesaṃ viddhaṃsento sāmaññaphalaṃ sacchikaroti. Subhasaññādīhi catūhipi vā vipallāsehi samudayasaccaṃ, tesamadhiṭṭhānārammaṇabhūtā pañcupādānakkhandhā dukkhasaccantiādinā saccayojanā veditabbā. Phalaṃ panettha cattāri sāmaññaphalāni, catūhi cettha vipallāsehi caturāsavoghayogaganthaagatitaṇhupādānasallaviññāṇaṭṭhitiapariññādivasena akusalapakkho netabbo, tathā catūhi satipaṭṭhānehi [Pg.65] catubbidhajjhānavihārādhiṭṭhānasukhabhāgiyadhammaappamaññāsammappadhānaiddhipādādivasena vodānapakkho netabboti ayaṃ sīhavikkīḷitassa nayassa bhūmi. Yo hi subhasaññādīhi vipallāsehi sakalassa saṃkilesapakkhassa saddhindriyādīhi ca vodānapakkhassa catusaccayojanāvasena nayanalakkhaṇo saṃvaṇṇanāviseso, ayaṃ sīhavikkīḷito nāma. Vuttañhetaṃ – 在此,应以四根解释四种人(puggala)。如何?贪行者(taṇhācarita)有两种:钝根者(mudindriya)和利根者(tikkhindriya);见行者(diṭṭhicarita)亦然。其中第一种人,于不净中颠倒地执取为“净”,以念力(satibala)如实辨知身的自性,以修习力(bhāvanābala)根除那颠倒(vipallāsa),趣入正性决定(sammattaniyāma)。第二种人,于苦中颠倒地执取为“乐”,如经中所说“对已生的欲寻,他不忍受”等,以作为精进防护的精进力(vīriyabala)消除对立法,以修习力破除那颠倒,趣入正性决定。第三种人,于无常中颠倒地执取为“常”,以奢摩他力(samathabala)令心得定,辨知诸行(saṅkhāra)的刹那性,以修习力根除那颠倒,趣入正性决定。第四种人,因被相续、聚合、作用、所缘的密集性所欺,于仅是触等法聚的无我(anattā)中,错误地执著为“我”(attā),以四句空性作意摧毁那邪执(micchābhinivesa),现证沙门果(sāmaññaphala)。应知,以净想等四种颠倒而有集谛(samudayasacca),以作为其所依与所缘的五取蕴(pañcupādānakkhandha)而有苦谛(dukkhasacca)等,此即谛的结合(saccayojanā)。此处的果是四沙门果。于此,应通过四种颠倒,从四漏(āsava)、四暴流(ogha)、四轭(yoga)、四结(gantha)、邪行(agati)、贪(taṇhā)、取(upādāna)、箭(salla)、识住(viññāṇaṭṭhiti)、未遍知(apariññā)等方面,引导至不善品;同样,通过四念住(satipaṭṭhāna)、四种禅住、决意、与乐相应的法、无量心(appamaññā)、正精进(sammappadhāna)、神足(iddhipāda)等,引导至清净品(vodānapakkha),这就是狮子游戏(sīhavikkīḷita)法门之地。凡是以净想等颠倒引导所有杂染品(saṃkilesapakkha),以信根(saddhindriya)等引导清净品,并以四圣谛的结合作为引导的特征,此种特别的释义(saṃvaṇṇanāvisesa)即是所谓的狮子游戏。正如经中所说: ‘‘Yo neti vipallāsehi,Kilese indriyehi saddhamme; Etaṃ nayaṃ nayavidū,Sīhavikkīḷitaṃ āhū’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “谁以颠倒(vipallāsa)引导杂染(kilesa),以诸根(indriya)引导正法(saddhamma);善解法门(naya)者,称此法门为狮子游戏(sīhavikkīḷita)。” Asantāsanajavaparakkamādivisesayogena sīho bhagavā, tassa vikkīḷitaṃ desanā vacīkammabhūto vihāroti katvā vipallāsatappaṭipakkhaparidīpanato sīhassa vikkīḷitaṃ etthāti sīhavikkīḷito, nayo. Balavisesayogadīpanato vā sīhavikkīḷitasadisattā nayo sīhavikkīḷito. Balaviseso cettha saddhādibalaṃ, dasabalāni eva vā. 世尊(bhagavā)如同狮子,具有无畏(asantāsana)、敏捷(java)、精进(parakkama)等殊胜特质。他的教导是言语行为(vacīkamma)的展现,如同狮子的嬉戏(vikkīḷita)。由于阐明了颠倒(vipallāsa)及其对治法(paṭipakkha),故此法门名为狮子游戏(sīhavikkīḷita)法门。或者因为彰显殊胜力,如同狮子游戏(sīhavikkīḷita)一般,所以此法门称为狮子游戏。此处的殊胜力是指信(saddhā)等力,或者就是十力(dasabala)。 Imesaṃ pana tiṇṇaṃ atthanayānaṃ siddhiyā vohāranayadvayaṃ siddhameva hoti. Tathā hi atthanayattayadisābhāvena kusalādidhammānaṃ ālocanaṃ disālocanaṃ. Vuttañhetaṃ – 此三种义理法门(atthanaya)的达成,则两种言说(vohāra)法门自然成立。因为,凭借三种义理法门的指引,观察善(kusala)等法,就是“方向观察(disālocana)”。正如经中所说: ‘‘Veyyākaraṇesu hi ye,Kusalākusalā tahiṃ tahiṃ vuttā; Manasā olokayate,Taṃ khu disālocanaṃ āhū’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “凡在解说(veyyākaraṇa)中,善(kusala)与不善(akusala)法,处处被宣说;以心善观察,彼称之为方向观察(disālocana)。” Tathā ālocitānaṃ tesaṃ dhammānaṃ atthanayattayayojane samānayanato aṅkuso viya aṅkuso. Vuttañhetaṃ – 如是观察(ālocita)诸法后,以三种义理法门(atthanaya)来统摄,就像象钩(aṅkusa)一般,故称为“象钩(aṅkusa)”。正如经中所说: ‘‘Oloketvā disalocanena, ukkhipiya yaṃ samāneti; Sabbe kusalākusale, ayaṃ nayo aṅkuso nāmā’’ti. (netti. 4 niddesavāra); “以方向观察(disālocana)而观察,提起并统摄;所有善(kusala)与不善(akusala),此法门名为象钩(aṅkusa)。” Tasmā manasāva atthanayānaṃ disābhūtadhammānaṃ locanaṃ disālocanaṃ, tesaṃ samānayanaṃ aṅkusoti pañcapi nayāni yuttāni honti. 因此,以心观察作为义理法门(atthanaya)之方向的诸法,即是方向观察(disālocana);统摄它们称为“象钩(aṅkusa)”。这五种法门(naya)都是恰当的。 Ettāvatā [Pg.66] ca – 至此,即是: ‘‘Paṭhamo nandiyāvaṭṭo, dutiyo ca tipukkhalo; Sīhavikkīḷito nāma, tatiyo nayalañjako. 第一是喜旋(nandiyāvaṭṭa),第二是三种人(tipukkhala);第三是名为狮子游戏(sīhavikkīḷita)的法门标帜(nayalañjaka)。 Disālocanamāhaṃsu, catutthaṃ nayamuttamaṃ; Pañcamo aṅkuso nāma, sabbe pañca nayā gatā’’ti. (netti. 1 uddesavāra) – 他们说方向观察(disālocana)是第四殊胜法门(naya);第五名为象钩(aṅkusa),所有五种法门(naya)皆已阐明。” Evaṃ vuttapañcanayāpi ettha dassitāti veditabbā. Nayati saṃkilesaṃ vodānañca vibhāgato ñāpetīti nayo, lañjeti pakāseti suttatthanti lañjako, nayo ca so lañjako cāti nayalañjako. Idañca suttaṃ soḷasavidhe suttantapaṭṭhāne saṃkilesabhāgiyaṃ byatirekamukhena nibbedhāsekkhabhāgiyanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Aṭṭhavīsatividhe pana suttantapaṭṭhāne lokiyalokuttaraṃ sattadhammādhiṭṭhānaṃ ñāṇaññeyyaṃ dassanabhāvanaṃ sakavacanaṃ vissajjanīyaṃ kusalākusalaṃ anuññātaṃ paṭikkhittañcāti veditabbaṃ. 当知,如是所说的五种法门(naya)也已在此处显示。能通过区分而揭示杂染与清净,故称法门(naya);能阐明、展现经文之义,故称标帜(lañjaka);法门与标帜结合,故称法门之标帜(nayalañjaka)。当知此经在十六种经的建立中,以反显方式(byatirekamukhena)属于杂染分(saṃkilesabhāgiya),以及厌离分(nibbedhabhāgiya)与无学分(asekkhabhāgiya)。另外,在二十八种经的建立中,当知它包含世间法与出世间法、七种法的基础、智与所知、见与修、自说、应答、善与不善、允许与禁止。 Tattha soḷasavidhasuttantaṃ paṭṭhānaṃ nāma ‘‘saṃkilesabhāgiyaṃ suttaṃ, vāsanābhāgiyaṃ suttaṃ, nibbedhabhāgiyaṃ suttaṃ, asekkhabhāgiyaṃ suttaṃ, saṃkilesabhāgiyañca vāsanābhāgiyañca suttaṃ, saṃkilesabhāgiyañca nibbedhabhāgiyañca suttaṃ, saṃkilesabhāgiyañca asekkhabhāgiyañca suttaṃ, vāsanābhāgiyañca nibbedhabhāgiyañca suttaṃ, vāsanābhāgiyañca asekkhabhāgiyañca suttaṃ, nibbedhabhāgiyañca asekkhabhāgiyañca suttaṃ, saṃkilesabhāgiyañca vāsanābhāgiyañca nibbedhabhāgiyañca suttaṃ, saṃkilesabhāgiyañca vāsanābhāgiyañca asekkhabhāgiyañca suttaṃ, saṃkilesabhāgiyañca nibbedhabhāgiyañca asekkhabhāgiyañca suttaṃ, vāsanābhāgiyañca nibbedhabhāgiyañca asekkhabhāgiyañca suttaṃ, saṃkilesabhāgiyañca vāsanābhāgiyañca nibbedhabhāgiyañca asekkhabhāgiyañca suttaṃ, neva saṃkilesabhāgiyaṃ na vāsanābhāgiyaṃ na nibbedhabhāgiyaṃ na asekkhabhāgiyaṃ sutta’’nti (netti. 89) evaṃ vuttasoḷasasāsanapaṭṭhānāni. 在此处,十六种经的建立(suttantapaṭṭhāna)名为:“杂染分经(saṃkilesabhāgiyaṃ suttaṃ)、熏习分经(vāsanābhāgiyaṃ suttaṃ)、厌离分经(nibbedhabhāgiyaṃ suttaṃ)、无学分经(asekkhabhāgiyaṃ suttaṃ)、杂染分与熏习分经、杂染分与厌离分经、杂染分与无学分经、熏习分与厌离分经、熏习分与无学分经、厌离分与无学分经、杂染分、熏习分与厌离分经、杂染分、熏习分与无学分经、杂染分、厌离分与无学分经、熏习分、厌离分与无学分经、杂染分、熏习分、厌离分与无学分经、非杂染分、非熏习分、非厌离分、非无学分经”。如此所说的十六种教法建立。 Tattha saṃkilissanti etenāti saṃkileso, saṃkilesabhāge saṃkilesakoṭṭhāse pavattaṃ saṃkilesabhāgiyaṃ. Vāsanā puññabhāvanā, vāsanābhāge pavattaṃ vāsanābhāgiyaṃ, vāsanaṃ bhajāpetīti vā vāsanābhāgiyaṃ. Nibbijjhanaṃ lobhakkhandhādīnaṃ padālanaṃ nibbedho, nibbedhabhāge [Pg.67] pavattaṃ, nibbedhaṃ bhajāpetīti vā nibbedhabhāgiyaṃ. Pariniṭṭhitasikkhā dhammā asekkhā, asekkhabhāge pavattaṃ, asekkhe bhajāpetīti vā asekkhabhāgiyaṃ. Tesu yattha taṇhādisaṃkileso vibhatto, idaṃ saṃkilesabhāgiyaṃ. Yattha dānādipuññakiriyavatthu vibhattaṃ, idaṃ vāsanābhāgiyaṃ. Yattha sekkhā sīlakkhandhādayo vibhattā, idaṃ nibbedhabhāgiyaṃ. Yattha pana asekkhā sīlakkhandhādayo vibhattā, idaṃ asekkhabhāgiyaṃ. Itarāni tesaṃ vomissakanayavasena vuttāni. Sabbāsavasaṃvarapariyāyādīnaṃ vasena sabbabhāgiyaṃ veditabbaṃ. Tattha hi saṃkilesadhammā lokiyasucaritadhammā sekkhā dhammā asekkhā dhammā ca vibhattā. Sabbabhāgiyaṃ pana ‘‘passaṃ na passatī’’tiādikaṃ udakādianuvādavacanaṃ veditabbaṃ. 于此,以此而染污,故为“染污”(saṃkilesa);于染污部分、染污类别中转起者,为“染污分”(saṃkilesabhāgiya)。“熏习”(vāsanā)即福德修习(puññabhāvanā);于熏习部分转起者,为“熏习分”(vāsanābhāgiya);或说,其令修习熏习,故为“熏习分”。“决断”(nibbedha)即刺破、毁坏贪蕴等;于决断部分转起者,或说,其令修习决断,故为“决断分”(nibbedhabhāgiya)。已圆满学处之法为“无学”(asekkha);于无学部分转起者,或说,其令修习无学,故为“无学分”(asekkhabhāgiya)。于此等经中,凡分别贪等染污处,此为“染污分”。凡分别布施等福行之事处,此为“熏习分”。凡分别有学(sekkhā)之戒蕴等处,此为“决断分”。凡分别无学(asekkhā)之戒蕴等处,此为“无学分”。其余诸经,则依混合之理而说。应知,通过《一切漏防护经》(Sabbāsavasaṃvarapariyāya)等,可知“一切分”(sabbabhāgiya)。于彼经中,染污法、世间善法、有学法与无学法皆被分别。又,“一切分”当知为如“见而不见”等以水等为例的复述之语。 Aṭṭhavīsatividhaṃ suttantapaṭṭhānaṃ pana ‘‘lokiyaṃ, lokuttaraṃ, lokiyañca lokuttarañca, sattādhiṭṭhānaṃ, dhammādhiṭṭhānaṃ, sattādhiṭṭhānañca dhammādhiṭṭhānañca, ñāṇaṃ, ñeyyaṃ, ñāṇañca ñeyyañca, dassanaṃ, bhāvanā, dassanañca bhāvanā ca, sakavacanaṃ, paravacanaṃ, sakavacanañca paravacanañca, vissajjanīyaṃ, avissajjanīyaṃ, vissajjanīyañca avissajjanīyañca, kammaṃ, vipāko, kammañca vipāko ca kusalaṃ, akusalaṃ, kusalañca akusalañca anuññātaṃ, paṭikkhittaṃ, anuññātañca paṭikkhittañca, thavo’’ti (netti. 112) evamāgatāni aṭṭhavīsati sāsanapaṭṭhānāni. Tattha lokiyanti loke niyutto, loke vā vidito lokiyo. Idha pana lokiyo attho yasmiṃ sutte vutto, taṃ suttaṃ lokiyaṃ. Tathā lokuttaraṃ. Yasmiṃ pana sutte padesena lokiyaṃ, padesena lokuttaraṃ vuttaṃ, taṃ lokiyañca lokuttarañca. Sattaadhippāyasattapaññattimukhena desitaṃ sattādhiṭṭhānaṃ. Dhammavasena desitaṃ dhammādhiṭṭhānaṃ. Ubhayavasena desitaṃ sattādhiṭṭhānañca dhammādhiṭṭhānañca. Iminā nayena sabbapadesu attho veditabbo. Buddhādīnaṃ pana guṇābhitthavanavasena pavattaṃ suttaṃ thavo nāma – 又有二十八种经之安立法:“世间、出世间、世间与出世间;有情依、法依、有情与法依;智、所知、智与所知;见、修、见与修;自说、他说、自说与他说;应答、不应答、应答与不应答;业、异熟、业与异熟;善、不善、善与不善;开许、遮止、开许与遮止;赞颂”(netti. 112),如是传来二十八种教法安立法。其中,“世间”者,谓系属于世间,或为世间所知。于此,若经中所说为世间义,则彼经为“世间”。“出世间”亦然。若经中部分说世间,部分说出世间,则为“世间与出世间”。以有情意趣、有情概念为门径而说者,为“有情依”。依法而说者,为“法依”。依二者而说者,为“有情与法依”。以此理趣,应知一切文句之义。又,以赞颂佛陀等功德而转起之经,名为“赞颂”。 ‘‘Maggānaṭṭhaṅgiko seṭṭho, saccānaṃ caturo padā; Virāgo seṭṭho dhammānaṃ, dvipadānañca cakkhumā’’ti. (dha. pa. 273; netti. 170; peṭako. 30) ādikaṃ viya – “诸道中,八支道最胜;诸谛中,四句最胜;诸法中,离欲最胜;诸两足中,具眼者最胜。”(dha. pa. 273; netti. 170; peṭako. 30)等,即是如此。 Nettinayavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 《导论》释义终。 2. Saddagarukādīnanti [Pg.68] ādisaddena gandharasaphoṭṭhabbagaruke saṅgaṇhāti. Āsayavasenāti ajjhāsayavasena. Utusamuṭṭhānopi itthisantānagato saddo labbhati, so idha nādhippetoti ‘‘cittasamuṭṭhāno’’ti vuttaṃ. Kathitasaddo ālāpādisaddo. Gītasaddo sarena gāyanasaddo. Itthiyā hasanasaddopettha saṅgahetabbo tassapi purisena assādetabbato. Tenāha – ‘‘apica kho mātugāmassa saddaṃ suṇāti tirokuṭṭā vā tiropākārā vā hasantiyā vā bhaṇantiyā vā gāyantiyā vā, so tadassādetī’’tiādi. Nivatthanivāsanassāti khalitthaddhassa nivāsanassa. Alaṅkārassāti nūpurādikassa alaṅkārassa. Itthisaddotveva veditabboti itthipaṭibaddhabhāvato vuttaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘sabbopī’’tiādi. Avidūraṭṭhāneti tassa hatthikulassa vasanaṭṭhānato avidūraṭṭhāne. Kāyūpapannoti sampannakāyo thirakathinamahākāyo. Mahāhatthīti mahānubhāvo hatthī. Jeṭṭhakaṃ katvāti yūthapatiṃ katvā. 2. “所重之声等”(Saddagarukādīnaṃ)一句中,“等”字摄集所重之香、味、触。“依意乐”(Āsayavasena)即依倾向(ajjhāsayavasena)。虽有时节所生之声,进入女身相续中,然非此处所意,故说“心所生”。“言说声”(Kathitasaddo)即谈话等声。“歌声”(Gītasaddo)即以音调歌唱之声。此处亦应摄入女人之笑声,因其亦为男人所享受。是故说:“又,闻女人于孤邸(kuṭi)后或墙后或笑、或语、或歌之声,彼即享受之”等。“所穿之衣”(Nivatthanivāsanassa)即粗劣之衣。“庄严具”(Alaṅkārassa)即脚镯等庄严具。“应知唯是女声”,此乃因其与女人相关而说。是故说“一切”等。“于不远处”(Avidūraṭṭhāne)即于彼象群住处之不远处。“身躯具足”(Kāyūpapanno)即身躯圆满、坚固、硕大。“大象”(Mahāhatthī)即有大威力之象。“立为首领”(Jeṭṭhakaṃ katvā)即立为象群之主。 Kathinatikkhabhāvena siṅgasadisattā aḷasaṅkhātāni siṅgāni etassa atthīti siṅgī, suvaṇṇavaṇṇatāya mahābalatāya ca sīhahatthiādimigasadisattā migo viyāti migo. Tattha tattha kiccaṃ netubhāvena cakkhuyeva nettaṃ, taṃ uggataṭṭhena āyataṃ etassāti āyatacakkhunetto. Aṭṭhi eva taco etassāti aṭṭhittaco. Tenābhibhūtoti tena migena abhibhūto ajjhotthaṭo niccalaggahito hutvā. Karuṇaṃ rudāmīti kāruññapatto hutvā rodāmi viravāmi. Paccatthikabhayato mutti nāma yathā tathā sahāyavato hoti, na ekākinoti āha – ‘‘mā heva maṃ pāṇasamaṃ jaheyyā’’ti. Tattha mā heva manti maṃ evarūpaṃ byasanaṃ pattaṃ attano pāṇasamaṃ piyasāmikaṃ tvaṃ māheva jahi. 因其坚硬锐利,状似兽角,且有名为“阿罗”(aḷa)之角,故为“有角者”(siṅgī);又因其色如黄金,力大无穷,犹如狮、象等兽,故为“兽”(migo)。于处处引导事务,故眼即是引导者(netta);其眼因突出而长,故为“长眼引导者”(āyatacakkhunetto)。“骨即是皮”(aṭṭhittaco)谓其皮仅存骨。“为彼所制伏”(Tenābhibhūto)即为彼兽所制伏、压倒、不动地抓住。“我悲切地哭泣”(Karuṇaṃ rudāmi)意为:我心生悲悯而哭泣、哀号。从敌人之怖畏中得解脱,须有同伴,非独行者能为,故说:“愿勿舍我如生命!”于此,“愿勿舍我”(mā heva maṃ)意为:你切勿舍弃我这遭遇如此灾厄、与你生命相等之爱夫。 Kuñce girikūṭe ramati abhiramati, tattha vā vicarati, koñjanādaṃ nadanto vā vicarati, ku vā pathavī, tadabhighātena jīratīti kuñjaro. Saṭṭhihāyananti jātiyā saṭṭhivassakālasmiṃ kuñjarā thāmena parihāyanti, taṃ sandhāya evamāha. Pathabyā cāturantāyāti catūsu disāsu samuddaṃ patvā ṭhitāya cāturantāya pathaviyā. Suppiyoti suṭṭhu piyo. Tesaṃ tvaṃ vārijo seṭṭhoti ye samudde vā gaṅgāya vā yamunāya vā nammadānadiyā vā kuḷīrā, tesaṃ sabbesaṃ vaṇṇasampattiyā mahantattena ca vārimhi [Pg.69] jātattā vārijo tvameva seṭṭho pasatthataro. Muñca rodantiyā patinti sabbesaṃ seṭṭhattā tameva yācāmi, rodamānāya mayhaṃ sāmikaṃ muñca. Athāti gahaṇassa sithilakaraṇasamanantarameva. Etassāti paṭisattumaddanassa. 于山峰(girikūṭa)之林(kuñca)中欢喜、乐于其中,或于彼处游行,或作吼声而游行;又或,“ku”为地,因其践踏而毁坏(jīrati),故为“毁地者”(kuñjara)。“六十岁”(Saṭṭhihāyanaṃ)者,谓象于生来六十岁时体力衰退,就此而说。“于四际之地”(Pathabyā cāturantāya)者,谓于四方抵达海洋之四际地。“苏毗亚”(Suppiyo)即极可爱(suṭṭhu piyo)。“汝为彼等水生中之最胜”(Tesaṃ tvaṃ vārijo seṭṭho)者,谓于海洋、恒河(Gaṅgā)、亚穆纳河(Yamunā)或讷尔默河(Nammadā)中之蟹(kuḷīra)等,于彼等一切中,因色之圆满与体之巨大,且生于水中,故“水生”(vārijo)之汝为最胜、最上。“放开哭泣者之夫”(Muñca rodantiyā patiṃ)者,谓因汝为一切中最胜,我唯求于汝:“请放开我这哭泣者之夫”。“尔时”(Athā)即于抓捕稍松之后。“此”(Etassa)即为制伏怨敌。 Pabbatagahanaṃ nissāyāti tisso pabbatarājiyo atikkamitvā catutthāya pabbatarājiyaṃ pabbatagahanaṃ upanissāya. Evaṃ vadatīti ‘‘udetayaṃ cakkhumā’’tiādinā (jā. 1.2.17) imaṃ buddhamantaṃ mantento vadati. “依止山林深处”(Pabbatagahanaṃ nissāya)者,谓越过三条山脉(pabbatarāji)后,依止于第四条山脉之山林深处。“如是说”(Evaṃ vadati)者,谓念诵“此具眼者升起”(udetayaṃ cakkhumā)等(jā. 1.2.17)此一佛陀明咒(buddhamanta)而说。 Tattha udetīti pācīnalokadhātuto uggacchati. Cakkhumāti sakalacakkavāḷavāsīnaṃ andhakāraṃ vidhamitvā cakkhuppaṭilābhakaraṇena yantena tesaṃ dinnaṃ cakkhu, tena cakkhunā cakkhumā. Ekarājāti sakalacakkavāḷe ālokakarānaṃ antare seṭṭhaṭṭhena rañjanaṭṭhena ca ekarājā. Harissavaṇṇoti harisamānavaṇṇo, suvaṇṇavaṇṇoti attho. Pathaviṃ pabhāsetīti pathavippabhāso. Taṃ taṃ namassāmīti tasmā taṃ evarūpaṃ bhavantaṃ namassāmi vandāmi. Tayājja guttā viharemha divasanti tayā ajja rakkhitā hutvā imaṃ divasaṃ catuiriyāpathavihārena sukhaṃ vihareyyāma. 此处“升起”(udetī)是指从东方世界(pācīnalokadhātu)升起。“有眼者”(Cakkhumā)是指驱散整个轮围世界(sakalacakkavāḷa)居民的黑暗,使他们获得眼睛,因此成为有眼者。“唯一君王”(Ekarājā)是指在所有照亮轮围世界者中,因其卓越与光辉而为唯一君王。“金色”(Harissavaṇṇa)是指与金色同色,意为黄金色。“照亮大地”(Pathaviṃ pabhāseti)即照亮大地者。“我礼敬您”(Taṃ taṃ namassāmi)是指因此我礼敬、顶礼如此的您。“愿我们今日在您的守护下安乐度日”(Tayājja guttā viharemha divasaṃ)是指愿我们今日在您的守护下,于四威仪中安乐度过此日。 Evaṃ bodhisatto imāya gāthāya sūriyaṃ namassitvā dutiyagāthāya atīte parinibbute buddhe ceva buddhaguṇe ca namassati ‘‘ye brāhmaṇā’’tiādinā. Tattha ye brāhmaṇāti ye bāhitapāpā parisuddhā brāhmaṇā. Vedagūti vedānaṃ pāraṃ gatā, vedehi pāraṃ gatāti vā vedagū. Idha pana sabbe saṅkhatadhamme vidite pākaṭe katvā katāti vedagū. Tenevāha – ‘‘sabbadhamme’’ti. Sabbe khandhāyatanadhātudhamme salakkhaṇasāmaññalakkhaṇavasena attano ñāṇassa vidite pākaṭe katvā tiṇṇaṃ mārānaṃ matthakaṃ madditvā sammāsambodhiṃ pattā, saṃsāraṃ vā atikkantāti attho. Te me namoti te mama imaṃ namakkāraṃ paṭicchantu. Te ca maṃ pālayantūti evaṃ mayā namassitā ca te bhagavanto maṃ pālayantu rakkhantu. Namattu buddhānaṃ…pe… vimuttiyāti ayaṃ mama namakkāro atītānaṃ parinibbutānaṃ buddhānaṃ atthu, tesaṃyeva catūsu phalesu ñāṇasaṅkhātāya bodhiyā atthu, tathā tesaññeva arahattaphalavimuttiyā [Pg.70] vimuttānaṃ atthu, yā ca nesaṃ tadaṅgavikkhambhanasamucchedappaṭippassaddhinissaraṇasaṅkhātā pañcavidhā vimutti, tāya vimuttiyāpi ayaṃ mayhaṃ namakkāro atthūti attho. Imaṃ so parittaṃ katvā, moro carati esanāti idaṃ pana padadvayaṃ satthā abhisambuddho hutvā āha. Tassattho – bhikkhave, so moro imaṃ parittaṃ imaṃ rakkhaṃ katvā attano gocarabhūmiyaṃ pupphaphalādīnaṃ atthāya nānappakārāya esanāya caratīti. 菩萨用这首偈颂向太阳致敬后,又用第二首偈颂礼敬过去已般涅槃的诸佛及佛德,即“婆罗门”等。此处“婆罗门”(brāhmaṇā)指已断除罪恶、清净的婆罗门。“通达吠陀者”(Vedagū)是说已超越吠陀,或已到达吠陀彼岸者。此处则指已如实了知并显明一切有为法(saṅkhatadhamma)者,故称“通达吠陀者”。因此说:“通达一切法”。即已如实照见五蕴、处、界等一切法的自相(salakkhaṇa)与共相(sāmaññalakkhaṇa),降伏三魔,证得正等正觉,或已超脱轮回之义。“愿彼等受我礼敬”(Te me namo)是指愿他们接受我的礼敬。“愿彼等护佑于我”(Te ca maṃ pālayantū)是指愿我所礼敬的世尊们护佑我、保护我。“礼敬诸佛……乃至……解脱”(Namattu buddhānaṃ…pe… vimuttiyā)是指:愿我此礼敬归于过去已般涅槃的诸佛,亦归于他们于四果中所证智慧之菩提,以及他们所证阿罗汉果的解脱,乃至他们所具的对治(tadaṅga)、镇伏(vikkhambhana)、断除(samuccheda)、安息(paṭippassaddhi)、出离(nissaraṇa)等五种解脱——愿我此礼敬亦归于彼解脱。“彼作此护咒,孔雀行觅食”,这两句是世尊成等正觉后所说。其义为:诸比丘,那孔雀作此护咒护持自己后,为求花果等,在自己的觅食地(gocarabhūmi)四处觅食。 Evaṃ divasaṃ caritvā sāyaṃ pabbatamatthake nisīditvā atthaṃ gacchantaṃ sūriyaṃ olokento buddhaguṇe āvajjetvā nivāsaṭṭhāne rakkhāvaraṇatthāya puna brahmamantaṃ vadanto ‘‘apetaya’’ntiādimāha. Tenevāha – ‘‘divasaṃ gocaraṃ gahetvā’’tiādi. Tattha apetīti apayāti atthaṃ gacchati. Imaṃ so parittaṃ katvā moro vāsamakappayīti idampi abhisambuddho hutvā āha. Tassattho – bhikkhave, so moro imaṃ parittaṃ imaṃ rakkhaṃ katvā attano nivāsaṭṭhāne vāsaṃ saṃkappayitthāti. Parittakammato puretaramevāti parittakammakaraṇato puretarameva. Morakukkuṭikāyāti kukkuṭikāsadisāya moracchāpikāya. (孔雀)白天觅食后,傍晚坐在山顶,望着西沉的太阳,忆念佛陀功德,为了守护住处而再次念诵梵咒,说“离去”等语。因此(经中)说“白天觅食后”等。此处“离去”(apeti)即是“消失”、“落下”之意。“彼作此护咒,孔雀安排住处”,此亦是世尊证得正等觉后所说。其义是:诸比丘,那孔雀作此护咒作为守护后,在自己的住处安顿下来。“比作护咒更早”(Parittakammato puretarameva),即比行护咒之仪更早。“为孔雀雏”(Morakukkuṭikāya)是指为如母鸡般的孔雀幼鸟。 3. Tatiye rūpāyatanassa viya gandhāyatanassapi samuṭṭhāpakapaccayavasena viseso natthīti āha – ‘‘catusamuṭṭhānika’’nti. Itthiyā sarīragandhassa kāyāruḷhaanulepanādigandhassa ca tappaṭibaddhabhāvato avisesena gahaṇappasaṅge idhādhippetagandhaṃ niddhārento ‘‘svāya’’ntiādimāha. Tattha itthiyāti pākatikāya itthiyā. Duggandhoti pākatikāya itthiyā sarīragandhabhāvato duggandho hoti. Idhādhippetoti iṭṭhabhāvato assādetabbattā vuttaṃ. Kathaṃ pana itthiyā sarīragandhassa duggandhabhāvoti āha – ‘‘ekaccā hī’’tiādi. Tattha assassa viya gandho assā atthīti assagandhinī. Meṇḍakassa viya gandho assā atthīti meṇḍakagandhinī. Sedassa viya gandho assā atthīti sedagandhinī. Soṇitassa viya gandho assā atthīti soṇitagandhinī. Rajjatevāti anādimati saṃsāre avijjādikilesavāsanāya parikaḍḍhitahadayattā phoṭṭhabbassādagadhitacittatāya ca andhabālo evarūpāyapi duggandhasarīrāya itthiyā rajjatiyeva. Pākatikāya itthiyā sarīragandhassa duggandhabhāvaṃ dassetvā idāni visiṭṭhāya ekaccāya itthiyā tadabhāvaṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘cakkavattino [Pg.71] panā’’tiādimāha. Yadi evaṃ īdisāya itthiyā sarīragandhopi idha kasmā nādhippetoti āha – ‘‘ayaṃ na sabbāsaṃ hotī’’tiādi. Tiracchānagatāya itthiyā ekaccāya ca manussitthiyā sarīragandhassa ativiya assādetabbabhāvadassanato puna tampi avisesena anujānanto ‘‘itthikāye gandho vā hotū’’tiādimāha. Itthigandhotveva veditabboti tappaṭibaddhabhāvato vuttaṃ. 3. 第三,如色处一般,香处在生起之缘方面也无差别,故说“四缘所生”。由于女人的体香与涂在身上的香料等香气,因其(与女人)相关,有被无差别地执取的可能,为了指明此处所意指的香,而说“自身的”等。其中,“女子”指普通女子。“恶臭”指普通女子的体香是恶臭。“此处所意指的”是从可意、可品味的角度而言。如何说明女子的体香是恶臭呢?(经中)说“譬如有些”等。其中,具有如马之气味的称为马气女,具有如公羊之气味的称为羊气女,具有如汗液之气味的称为汗气女,具有如血液之气味的称为血气女。“必然贪着”指的是,在无始轮回中,因内心被无明等烦恼习气所牵引,又因心贪着于触的滋味,盲昧的凡夫即使对此类身有恶臭的女子也必然会贪着。说明了普通女子的体香是恶臭之后,现在为了说明特殊的某些女子无此情况,故说“但转轮王的”等。若如此,这类女子的体香亦是可意的,为何此处不意指呢?回答说“此非所有女子都有”。由于可见到畜生道的女子及某些人类女子的体香非常可品味,因此又无差别地允许说“或为女身之香”等。“当知即是女人香”,这是因其(与女人)相关而说。 4. Catutthādīsu kiṃ tenāti jivhāviññeyyarase idhādhippete kiṃ tena avayavarasādinā vuttena payojanaṃ. Oṭṭhamaṃsaṃ sammakkhetīti oṭṭhamaṃsasammakkhano, kheḷādīni. Ādisaddena oṭṭhamaṃsamakkhano tambulamukhavāsādiraso gayhati. Sabbo so itthirasoti itthiyāvassa gahetabbattā. 4. 于第四等处,“那有何用?”是指:既然此处意指的是舌识所识之味,那么说由肢体等所生之味有何用处呢?“涂抹唇肉者”(oṭṭhamaṃsasammakkhano)是指涂抹唇肉之物,即唾液等。通过“等”字,摄取涂抹唇肉的槟榔、口香剂等之味。“所有那些都是女人味”,是因其必然是从女人处获得。 5. Itthiphoṭṭhabboti etthāpi eseva nayo. Yadi panettha itthigatāni rūpārammaṇādīni avisesato purisassa cittaṃ pariyādāya tiṭṭhanti, atha kasmā bhagavatā tāni visuṃ visuṃ gahetvā desitānīti āha – ‘‘iti satthā’’tiādi. Yathā hītiādinā tamevatthaṃ samattheti. Gametīti vikkhepaṃ gameti, ayameva vā pāṭho. Gametīti ca saṅgameti. Na tathā sesā saddādayo, na tathā rūpādīni ārammaṇānīti etena sattesu rūpādigarukatā asaṃkiṇṇā viya dassitā, na kho panetaṃ evaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ anekavidhattā sattānaṃ ajjhāsayassāti dassetuṃ – ‘‘ekaccassa cā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Pañcagarukavasenāti pañcārammaṇagarukavasena. Ekaccassa hi purisassa yathāvuttesu pañcasupi ārammaṇesu garukatā hoti, ekaccassa tattha katipayesu, ekasmiṃ eva vā, te sabbepi pañcagarukātveva veditabbā yathā ‘‘sattisayo aṭṭhavimokkhā’’ti. Na pañcagarukajātakavasena ekekārammaṇe garukasseva nādhippetattā. Ekekārammaṇagarukānañhi pañcannaṃ puggalānaṃ tattha āgatattā taṃ jātakaṃ ‘‘pañcagarukajātaka’’nti vuttaṃ. Yadi evaṃ tena idha payojanaṃ natthīti āha – ‘‘sakkhibhāvatthāyā’’ti. Āharitvā kathetabbanti rūpādigarukatāya ete anayabyasanaṃ pattāti dassetuṃ kathetabbaṃ. 5. 关于“女触”,道理亦然。如果女性的色等所缘不加分别地占据了男人的心,那么世尊(bhagavā)为何要将它们一一分别开示呢?回答说:“如导师所说”等。通过“譬如”等来阐明此义。`Gametī`是`vikkhepaṃ gameti`(平息散乱)之意,或作此读。`Gametī`亦作`saṅgameti`(聚合)解。不像其他声等,不像其他色等所缘,以此显示众生于色等所缘的执重似乎是各不相混的。但不应如是见,因为众生的意乐(ajjhāsaya)有多种,故说“于某一(众生)”等。“以五种执重”是指以对五种所缘的执重。某一男人对前述五种所缘皆有执重,某一(男人)则于其中数种,或仅于一种,此等皆应知为“五种执重”,犹如“七力士与八解脱”(sattisayo aṭṭhavimokkhā)。并非依《五执重本生》之义,因其意并非仅指对单一所缘的执重。因为在彼处,有五位对单一所缘执重的个人(puggala),故彼本生(jātaka)名为《五执重本生》。若问:然则于此有何用?答曰:“为作证故”。应引述而说,以显示“此等人因于色等执重而遭不幸灾祸”。 6-8. Tesanti [Pg.72] suttānaṃ. Uppaṇḍetvā gaṇhituṃ na icchīti tassa thokaṃ virūpadhātukattā na icchi. Anatikkamantoti saṃsandento. Dve hatthaṃ pattānīti dve uppalāni hatthaṃ gatāni. Pahaṭṭhākāraṃ dassetvāti aparāhi itthīhi ekekaṃ laddhaṃ, mayā dve laddhānīti santuṭṭhākāraṃ dassetvā. Parodīti tassā pubbasāmikassa mukhagandhaṃ saritvā. Tassa hi mukhato uppalagandho vāyati. Hāretvāti tasmā ṭhānā apanetvā, ‘‘harāpetvā’’ti vā pāṭho, ayamevattho. 6-8. “彼等”(Tesaṃ),指诸经。“不愿嘲讽地接受”(Uppaṇḍetvā gaṇhituṃ na icchi),是说因他稍微丑陋而不愿(接受)。“不逾越”(Anatikkamanto),意为比对、连接。“两朵到了手中”(Dve hatthaṃ pattāni),即两朵青莲到了手中。“现出欢喜之相”(Pahaṭṭhākāraṃ dassetvā),是说‘其他女子各得一朵,我得了两朵’,以此现出满足之相。“她哭了”(Parodi),是因忆起前夫的口气。因他口中散发着青莲之香。“带走”(Hāretvā),即从彼处移走;或读作“使人带走”(harāpetvā),其义相同。 Sādhu sādhūti bhāsatoti dhammakathāya anumodanavasena ‘‘sādhu sādhū’’ti bhāsato. Uppalaṃva yathodaketi yathā uppalaṃ uppalagandho mukhato nibbattoti. Vaṭṭameva kathitanti yathārutavasena vuttaṃ. Yadipi evaṃ vuttaṃ, tathāpi yathārutamatthe avatvā vivaṭṭaṃ nīharitvā kathetabbaṃ vimuttirasattā bhagavato desanāya. “说善哉善哉”(Sādhu sādhūti bhāsato),指随喜说法而说“善哉,善哉”。“犹如青莲出于水”(Uppalaṃva yathodake),是说犹如青莲,青莲之香从其口中发出。“仅说轮回”(Vaṭṭameva kathitaṃ),是说依文句之义而说。虽然如是说,但不应只说文句之义,应阐明出离轮回之义而说,因为世尊(bhagavato)的教法以解脱味为本质。 Rūpādivaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 色等品释义终。 Iti manorathapūraṇiyā aṅguttaranikāya-aṭṭhakathāya 于《满足希求》——增支部义注中 Paṭhamavaggavaṇṇanāya anuttānatthadīpanā niṭṭhitā. 第一品释义之未显义阐明终。 2. Nīvaraṇappahānavaggavaṇṇanā 2. 断盖品释义 11. Dutiyassāti dutiyavaggassa. Ekadhammampīti ettha ‘‘ekasabhāvampī’’ti iminā sabhāvatthoyaṃ dhammasaddo ‘‘kusalā dhammā’’tiādīsu viyāti dassitaṃ hoti. Yadaggena ca sabhāvattho, tadaggena nissattattho siddho evāti ‘‘nissattaṭṭhena dhammo veditabbo’’ti vuttaṃ. Subhanimittanti dhammapariyāyena vuttaṃ. Tañhi atthato kāmacchando vā siyā. So hi attano gahaṇākārena subhanti, tenākārena pavattanakassa aññassa kāmacchandassa nimittattā ‘‘subhanimitta’’nti ca vuccati. Tassa ārammaṇaṃ vā subhanimittaṃ. Iṭṭhañhi iṭṭhākārena vā gayhamānaṃ rūpādiārammaṇaṃ ‘‘subhanimitta’’nti vuccati. Ārammaṇameva cettha nimittaṃ. Tathā hi vakkhati – ‘‘subhanimittanti rāgaṭṭhāniyaṃ ārammaṇa’’nti. Samuccayattho vā-saddo anekatthattā nipātānaṃ. Bhiyyobhāvāyāti punappunaṃ bhāvāya. Vepullāyāti vipulabhāvāya, vaḍḍhiyāti attho. Ajāto nijjāto. Sesapadāni tasseva [Pg.73] vevacanāni. Kāmesūti pañcasu kāmaguṇesu. Kāmacchandoti kāmasaṅkhāto chando, na kattukamyatāchando na dhammacchando. Kāmanavasena rajjanavasena ca kāmo eva rāgo kāmarāgo. Kāmanavasena nandanavasena ca kāmo eva nandīti kāmanandī. Kāmanavasena taṇhāyanavasena ca kāmataṇhā. Ādisaddena ‘‘kāmasneho kāmapariḷāho kāmamucchā kāmajjhosāna’’nti etesaṃ padānaṃ saṅgaho daṭṭhabbo. Tattha vuttanayeneva kāmatthaṃ viditvā sinehanaṭṭhena kāmasneho, pariḷāhanaṭṭhena kāmapariḷāho, mucchanaṭṭhena kāmamucchā, gilitvā pariniṭṭhāpanaṭṭhena kāmajjhosānaṃ veditabbaṃ. Kāmacchando eva kusalappavattito cittassa nīvaraṇaṭṭhena kāmacchandanīvaraṇaṃ, soti kāmacchando. Asamudācāravasenāti asamudācārabhāvena. Ananubhūtārammaṇavasenāti ‘‘idaṃ nāmeta’’nti vatthuvasena utvā tasmiṃ attabhāve ananubhūtassa ārammaṇassa vasena. Rūpasaddādibhedaṃ pana ārammaṇaṃ ekasmimpi attabhāve ananubhūtaṃ nāma nattheva, kimaṅgaṃ pana anādimati saṃsāre. 11. “第二”(Dutiyassa),即第二品。“于一法”(Ekadhammampi),此处以“于一自性”(ekasabhāvampi)说明“法”(dhamma)一词为自性义,如于“善法”(kusalā dhammā)等中。由于是自性义,因此无我义(nissattaṭṭha)便得以成立,故说“当知法为无我义”。“净相”(Subhanimitta),是经教中所说。其义实为欲贪。它因其执取的方式而为“净”,又因是引生其他欲贪之“相”(因缘),故称“净相”。或其所缘为净相。可意之色等所缘,若以可意的方式被执取,则称为“净相”。此处,相即是所缘。如将来会说:“净相,是引生贪欲的所缘。”`vā`字为连接义,因小品词有多义。“为增长”(Bhiyyobhāvāya),即为数数生起。“为广大”(Vepullāya),即为广大,义为增长。“未生”(ajāto),“已灭”(nijjāto)。其余诸词皆是其同义词。“于诸欲”(Kāmesu),指于五妙欲。“欲贪”(kāmacchanda),指名为“欲”之“贪”,非“欲作愿”(kattukamyatāchanda),亦非“法欲”(dhammacchanda)。因欲而染,即是欲染(kāmarāga)。因欲而喜,即是欲喜(kāmanandī)。因欲而爱,即是欲爱(kāmataṇhā)。以“等”字当知包含“欲爱”(kāmasneha)、“欲烧”(kāmapariḷāha)、“欲痴”(kāmamucchā)、“欲吞没”(kāmajjhosāna)等词。应知其义如前述,以贪爱为义是欲爱,以烧灼为义是欲烧,以昏迷为义是欲痴,以吞没完尽为义是欲吞没。欲贪,因其能障蔽心中善法生起,故为欲贪盖(kāmacchandanīvaraṇa);此即欲贪。“以不现行”(Asamudācāravasena),即以不现行之状态。“以未曾体验的所缘”(Ananubhūtārammaṇavasena),是说依于“此名为某某”的事物,而于此生中未曾体验过的所缘。然而,色、声等差别所缘,于一生之中尚无未曾体验者,何况于无始轮回之中。 Yaṃ vuttaṃ – ‘‘asamudācāravasena cā’’tiādi, taṃ atisaṃkhittanti vitthārato dassetuṃ – ‘‘tatthā’’tiādimāha. Tattha bhavaggahaṇena mahaggatabhavo gahito. So hi oḷārikakilesasamudācārarahito. Tajjanīyakammakatādikāle pārivāsikakāle ca caritabbāni dveasīti khuddakavattāni nāma. Na hi tāni sabbāsu avatthāsu caritabbāni, tasmā tāni na mahāvattesu antogadhānīti ‘‘cuddasa mahāvattānī’’ti vuttaṃ. Tathā āgantukavattaāvāsikagamika-anumodanabhattagga- piṇḍacārikaāraññakasenāsanajantāgharavaccakuṭiupajjhāya- saddhivihārikaācariya-antevāsikavattānīti etāni cuddasa mahāvattāni nāmāti vuttaṃ. Itarāni pana ‘‘pārivāsikānaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ vattaṃ paññāpessāmī’’ti (cūḷava. 75) ārabhitvā ‘‘na upasampādetabbaṃ, na chamāyaṃ caṅkamante caṅkame caṅkamitabba’’nti (cūḷava. 81) vuttāni pakatatte caritabbavattāni chasaṭṭhi, tato paraṃ ‘‘na, bhikkhave, pārivāsikena bhikkhunā pārivāsikavuḍḍhatarena bhikkhunā saddhiṃ, mūlāyapaṭikassanārahena, mānattārahena, mānattacārikena, abbhānārahena bhikkhunā saddiṃ ekacchanne āvāse vatthabba’’ntiādīni pakatatte caritabbehi anaññattā visuṃ visuṃ agaṇetvā pārivāsikavuḍḍhatarādīsu puggalantaresu caritabbattā [Pg.74] tesaṃ vasena sampiṇḍetvā ekekaṃ katvā gaṇitāni pañcāti ekasattativattāni. Ukkhepanīyakammakatavattesu vattapaññāpanavasena vuttaṃ – ‘‘na pakatattassa bhikkhuno abhivādanaṃ paccuṭṭhānaṃ…pe… piṭṭhiparikammaṃ sāditabba’’nti idaṃ abhivādanādīnaṃ assādiyanaṃ ekaṃ, ‘‘na pakatatto bhikkhu sīlavipattiyā anuddhaṃsetabbo’’tiādīni (cūḷava. 51) ca dasāti evaṃ dvāsīti honti. Etesveva pana kānici tajjanīyakammakatādivattāni kānici pārivāsikādivattānīti aggahitaggahaṇena dvāvīsativattanti veditabbaṃ. ‘‘Cuddasa mahāvattānī’’ti vatvāpi ‘‘āgantukagamikavattāni cā’’ti imesaṃ visuṃ gahaṇaṃ imāni abhiṇhaṃ sambhavantīti katvā. Kileso okāsaṃ na labhati sabbadā vattappaṭipattiyaṃyeva byāvaṭacittatāya. Ayonisomanasikāranti aniccādīsu ‘‘nicca’’ntiādinā pavattaṃ anupāyamanasikāraṃ. Sativossagganti satiyā vissajjanaṃ, sativirahanti attho. Evampīti vakkhamānāpekkhāya avuttasampiṇḍanattho pi-saddo. 所谓“以无违犯(asamudācāra)故”等语过于简略,故为详释而说“其中”等。其中,“有取”(bhavaggahaṇa)摄取了广大的有(mahaggatabhava),此有远离粗重烦恼之现行。在呵责羯磨(tajjanīyakamma)时及别住(pārivāsa)期间,应行持的名为八十二种微细行仪(khuddakavatta)。此等并非在所有情况下都要行持,故不包含在大行仪(mahāvatta)中,是故说“十四大行仪”。即客比丘行仪(āgantukavatta)、住处比丘行仪(āvāsikavatta)、游行比丘行仪(gamikavatta)、随喜行仪(anumodanāvatta)、食堂行仪(bhattaggavatta)、乞食行仪(piṇḍacārikavatta)、林野行仪(āraññakavatta)、卧坐具行仪(senāsanavatta)、浴室行仪(jantāgharavatta)、厕所行仪(vaccakuṭivatta)、戒师行仪(upajjhāyavatta)、共住弟子行仪(saddhivihārikavatta)、阿阇梨行仪(ācariyavatta)、依止弟子行仪(antevāsikavatta),此等称为十四大行仪。其余的,从“我将为别住比丘制定行仪”开始,到“不应授具足戒,不应在地上经行,应在经行处(caṅkama)经行”为止,共六十六种应在恢复正常状态(pakatatta)中行持的行仪。此后,又有“诸比丘,别住比丘不应与更久别住比丘、应行本日治(mūlāyapaṭikassanā)者、应行摩那埵(mānatta)者、正行摩那埵者、应行出罪(abbhāna)者同住一屋檐下”等。这些行仪与应在恢复正常状态下履行的行仪并无不同,故未分别计算,而是根据其应在别住年长者等不同人(puggala)身上履行的情况,将之合并计算为五种,总计七十一种行仪。在举罪羯磨(ukkhepanīyakamma)行仪中,为制定行仪而说:“不应乐受恢复正常状态之比丘的礼敬、起立……背部按摩”等,这不乐受礼敬等算一种,还有“不应因戒律上的过失而罢黜恢复正常状态的比丘”等十条,总共八十二条。在这些行仪中,有些是呵责羯磨等行仪,有些是别住等行仪,以计入未计入者的方式,应知共有二十二种行仪。虽然说了“十四大行仪”,又说“客比丘、游行比丘行仪等”,是因为这些行仪经常发生。由于心恒常专注于行仪的实践,烦恼无机可乘。不如理作意(ayoniso manasikāra),是指对无常等事物,以“常”等方式生起的不如理作意。失念(sativossagga),是指舍弃正念,即没有正念之意。“如是亦”(evampi)中的“亦”(pi)字,是着眼于下文,有总结前文未尽之义。 Anusandhivasenāti pucchānusandhiādianusandhivasena. Pubbāparavasenāti pubbāparaganthasallakkhaṇavasena. Gaṇhantassāti ācariyamukhato gaṇhantassa. Sajjhāyantassāti ācariyamukhato uggahitaganthaṃ sajjhāyantassa. Vācentassāti pāḷiṃ tadatthañca uggaṇhāpanavasena paresaṃ vācentassa. Desentassāti desanāvasena paresaṃ dhammaṃ desentassa. Pakāsentassāti attano attano saṃsayaṭṭhāne pucchantānaṃ yāthāvato atthaṃ pakāsentassa. Kileso okāsaṃ na labhati rattindivaṃ ganthakammesuyeva byāvaṭacittatāya. Evampīti vuttasampiṇḍanattho pi-saddo. Evaṃ sesesupi. 所谓“由连结故”(anusandhivasa),是指由提问的连结等方式。所谓“由前后故”(pubbāparavasa),是指由了知前后文句的方式。所谓“受持者”(gaṇhanta),是指从老师口中受持者。所谓“诵习者”(sajjhāyanta),是指诵习从老师口中学习的经文者。所谓“教授者”(vācenta),是指通过令他人学习巴利及其义理的方式来教授者。所谓“说法者”(desenta),是指通过说法的方式为他人宣讲法者。所谓“开示者”(pakāsenta),是指为提问各自疑惑之处者,如实地开示其义。由于昼夜心皆专注于经书之事,烦恼无机可乘。“如是亦”(evampi)中的“亦”(pi)字,是为了总结已说之义。其余亦如是。 Dhutaṅgadharo hotīti vuttamevatthaṃ pakāseti ‘‘terasa dhutaṅgaguṇe samādāya vattatī’’ti. Bāhullāyāti cīvarādipaccayabāhullāya. Yathā cīvarādayo paccayā bahulaṃ uppajjanti, tathā āvattassa pavattassāti attho. Parihīnajjhānassāti jhānantarāyakarena visabhāgarūpadassanādinā kenaci nimittena parihīnajjhānassa. Vissaṭṭhajjhānassāti asamāpajjanavasena pariccattajjhānassa. Bhassādīsūti ādi-saddena gaṇasaṅgaṇikaniddānavakammādiṃ saṅgaṇhāti. Sattasu vā anupassanāsūti ettha satta anupassanā nāma aniccānupassanā dukkhānupassanā anattānupassanā nibbidānupassanā virāgānupassanā [Pg.75] nirodhānupassanā paṭinissaggānupassanā khayānupassanā vayānupassanā vipariṇāmānupassanā animittānupassanā appaṇihitānupassanā suññatānupassanā adhipaññādhammavipassanā yathābhūtañāṇadassanaṃ ādīnavānupassanā paṭisaṅkhānupassanā vivaṭṭānupassanāti imāsu aṭṭhārasasu mahāvipassanāsu ādito vuttā aniccānupassanādi-paṭinissaggānupassanāpariyantā satta. Ettha yaṃ vattabbaṃ, taṃ visuddhimaggasaṃvaṇṇanāto (visuddhi. mahāṭī. 2.741) gahetabbaṃ. “持头陀支者”,即是阐明前文所说的“受持十三种头陀功德而住”。“为丰足故”(bāhullāya),是指为衣服等资具丰足故。其义为,如衣服等资具大量生起,如是辗转增盛。所谓“退失禅那者”,是指因见到能障碍禅那的不相称之色等某种相而退失禅那者。所谓“放舍禅那者”,是指因不能入定而放弃禅那者。所谓“谈说等”,此中“等”字包含群聚、睡眠、新事务等。所谓“于七种随观”,此处的七种随观,即无常随观、苦随观、无我随观、厌离随观、离贪随观、灭随观、舍遣随观。在无常随观、苦随观、无我随观、厌离随观、离贪随观、灭随观、舍遣随观、尽随观、败坏随观、变易随观、无相随观、无愿随观、空随观、增上慧法观、如实智见、过患随观、审察随观、还灭随观这十八种大观(mahāvipassanā)中,是指从最初所说的无常随观到舍遣随观为止的七种。此处应说之义,当从《清净道论》大疏(Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā)(第二卷741页)中获取。 Anāsevanatāyāti purimattabhāve jhānena vikkhambhitakilesassa kāmacchandādiāsevanāya abhāvato. Ananubhūtapubbanti tasmiṃ attabhāve ananubhūtapubbaṃ. Jātoti etasseva vevacanaṃ sañjātotiādi. Nanu ca khaṇikattā sabbadhammānaṃ uppannassa kāmacchandassa taṅkhaṇaṃyeva avassaṃ nirodhasambhavato niruddhe ca tasmiṃ puna aññasseva uppajjanato ca kathaṃ tassa punappunabhāvo rāsibhāvo cāti āha – ‘‘tattha sakiṃ uppanno kāmacchando’’tiādi. Aṭṭhānametanti akāraṇametaṃ. Yena kāraṇena uppanno kāmacchando na nirujjhati, niruddho ca sveva puna uppajjissati, tādisaṃ kāraṇaṃ natthīti attho. “因不习行故”(anāsevanatāya),是指于过去生以禅那镇伏烦恼,故无习行欲贪等。所谓“未曾体验”,是指于此生中未曾体验。所谓“生”(jāta),是“已生”(sañjāta)等的同义词。然则,一切法皆是刹那性,已生之欲贪于彼刹那必定灭尽,灭后复有他法新生,云何有数数生起与积聚之事?故说:“此处一度生起的欲贪”等。“此非可能”(aṭṭhānametaṃ),即此非其因。其义为:没有能令已生之欲贪不灭,或已灭之欲贪复生的因缘。 Rāgaṭṭhāniyanti rāgajanakaṃ. Aniccādīsu niccādivasena viparītamanasikāro, idha ayonisomanasikāroti āha – ‘‘anicce nicca’’ntiādi. Ayonisomanasikāroti anupāyamanasikāro, kusaladhammappavattiyā akāraṇabhūto manasikāroti attho. Uppathamanasikāroti kusaladhammappavattiyā amaggabhūto manasikāro. Saccavippaṭikūlenāti saccābhisamayassa anunulomavasena. Āvajjanātiādinā āvajjanāya paccayabhūtā tato purimuppannā manodvārikā akusalajavanappavatti phalavohārena tathā vuttā. Tassa hi vasena sā akusalappavattiyā upanissayo hoti. Āvajjanāti bhavaṅgacittaṃ āvajjayatīti āvajjanā. Anu anu āvajjetīti anvāvajjanā. Bhavaṅgārammaṇato aññaṃ ābhujatīti ābhogo. Samannāharatīti samannāhāro. Tadevārammaṇaṃ attānaṃ anubandhitvā uppajjamāno manasi karoti ṭhapetīti manasikāro. Ayaṃ vuccati ayonisomanasikāroti ayaṃ anupāyauppathamanasikāralakkhaṇo ayonisomanasikāro nāma vuccati. “贪之所依”(rāgaṭṭhāniya),即生贪者。于无常等作常等想的颠倒作意,此处说为不如理作意,如言“于无常作常想”等。不如理作意(ayoniso manasikāra),即非方便作意,义为非善法生起之因的作意。歧途作意(uppathamanasikāro),即非善法生起之道的作意。所谓“与圣谛相违”,即不随顺于圣谛的证悟。所谓“转向”(āvajjana)等,是指在此之前生起、作为转向之缘的意门不善速行流,这是以果立名的说法。依此,彼成为不善生起的强依止缘。转向(āvajjana):令有分心转向,故名转向。随转向(anvāvajjanā):再三转向,故名随转向。专注(ābhoga):弯向有分所缘之外的所缘,故名专注。统摄(samannāhāra):全面把握,故名统摄。作意(manasikāro):将同一所缘与自身相联系而生起,置于心中,故名作意。此即名为不如理作意,其特征为非方便作意与歧途作意。 12. Dutiye [Pg.76] bhattabyāpatti viyāti bhattassa pūtibhāvena vippakārappatti viya, cittassa byāpajjananti cittassa vikārabhāvāpādanaṃ. Tenevāha – ‘‘pakativijahanabhāvo’’ti. Byāpajjati tena cittaṃ pūtikummāsādayo viya purimapakatiṃ jahatīti byāpādo. Paṭighoyeva uparūpari uppajjamānassa paṭighassa nimittabhāvato paṭighanimittaṃ, paṭighassa ca kāraṇabhūtaṃ ārammaṇaṃ paṭighanimittanti āha – ‘‘paṭighassapi paṭighārammaṇassapi etaṃ adhivacana’’nti. Aṭṭhakathāyanti mahāaṭṭhakathāyaṃ. 12. 第二,“食物的过患”,犹如食物因腐烂而变质;“心的变质”是指令心产生变异的状态。因此说:“舍离本性”。心因此而变坏,犹如腐臭的酸粥等舍弃了先前的自性,此即“瞋恚”。瞋恚本身,因其是不断生起的瞋恚之相,故为“瞋恚相”。又,作为瞋恚之因的所缘,亦是“瞋恚相”,故说:“此为瞋恚及瞋恚所缘之称谓。”(经文所言)“在义注中”,是指在《大义注》(Mahāaṭṭhakathā)中。 13. Tatiye thinatā thinaṃ, sappipiṇḍo viya avipphārikatāya cittassa ghanabhāvo baddhatāti attho. Medhatīti middhaṃ, akammaññabhāvena hiṃsatīti attho. ‘‘Yā tasmiṃ samaye cittassa akalyatā’’tiādinā (dha. sa. 1162) thinassa, ‘‘yā tasmiṃ samaye kāyassa akalyatā’’tiādinā (dha. sa. 1163) ca middhassa abhidhamme niddiṭṭhattā vuttaṃ – ‘‘cittassa akammaññatā thinaṃ, tiṇṇaṃ khandhānaṃ akammaññatā middha’’nti. Satipi aññamaññāvippayoge cittakāyalahutādīnaṃ viya cittacetasikānaṃ yathākkamaṃ taṃtaṃviseso siyā, yā tesaṃ akalyatādīnaṃ visesapaccayatā, ayametesaṃ sabhāvoti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Kapimiddhassāti vuttamevatthaṃ vibhāveti ‘‘pacalāyikabhāvassā’’ti. Akkhidalānaṃ pacalabhāvaṃ karotīti pacalāyiko, pacalāyikassa bhāvo pacalāyikabhāvo, pacalāyikattanti vuttaṃ hoti. Ubhinnanti thinamiddhānaṃ. ‘‘Vitthāro veditabbo’’ti iminā sambandho veditabbo. Cittassa akalyatāti cittassa gilānabhāvo. Gilāno hi akalyakoti vuccati. Vinayepi vuttaṃ – ‘‘nāhaṃ, bhante, akalyako’’ti (pārā. 151). Kālaṃ khamatīti hi kalyaṃ, arogatā, tassaṃ niyutto kalyako, na kalyako akalyako. Akammaññatāti cittagelaññasaṅkhātova akammaññatākāro. Olīyanāti olīyanākāro. Iriyāpathūpatthambhitañhi cittaṃ iriyāpathaṃ sandhāretuṃ asakkontaṃ rukkhe vagguli viya khīle laggitaphāṇitavārako viya ca olīyati lambati, tassa taṃ ākāraṃ sandhāya – ‘‘olīyanā’’ti vuttaṃ. Dutiyapadaṃ upasaggena vaḍḍhitaṃ. Kāyassāti vedanādikkhandhattayasaṅkhātassa nāmakāyassa. Akalyatā akammaññatāti heṭṭhā vuttanayameva. Megho viya ākāsaṃ onayhatīti onāho. Onayhatīti ca chādeti avattharati vāti attho[Pg.77]. Sabbatobhāgena onāhoti pariyonāho. Aratiādīnaṃ attho vibhaṅge (vibha. 856) vuttanayeneva veditabboti tattha vuttapāḷiyā dassetuṃ – ‘‘vuttaṃ heta’’ntiādimāha. 13. 第三,“迟钝”即是迟缓(thina),其义为心如酥团,因不舒展而凝滞、束缚。“损害”故为昏沉(middha),其义为以不堪任性而损害。由于在阿毗达摩(abhidhamma)中,对迟缓是依“尔时心之不适”等(《法集论》1162)文句、对昏沉是依“尔时身之不适”等(《法集论》1163)文句而作解释,故说:“心之不堪任性是迟缓,三蕴之不堪任性是昏沉。”即使彼此不相离,心与心所亦各有其特殊性,犹如心身轻快等。应知,彼等不适等之特殊缘性,即是其自性。“如猴之昏沉”,是为阐明前述“昏昏欲睡的状态”。令眼睑摇晃者,是为“摇晃者”(pacalāyiko);摇晃者的状态,是为“摇晃状态”(pacalāyikabhāvo),亦即“摇晃性”(pacalāyikattaṃ)。两者,是指迟缓与昏沉。“广说应知”,应知此与前文相关。“心不适”即是心的病态。病人被称为“不适者”。在律藏中亦说:“尊者,我并非不适者。”能堪忍时节,故为“适宜”(kalya),即无病。致力于此者,为“适宜者”(kalyako);非适宜者,为“不适宜者”(akalyako)。“不堪任性”(akammaññatā)即是名为心病的不堪任状态。“滞着”(olīyanā)即是滞着的状态。为威仪所支持的心,当无法维持威仪时,犹如树上的蝙蝠,又如粘在木桩上的糖浆块,滞着、下垂。针对此状态,故说“滞着”。第二词由前缀增强其义。“身”,是指由受等三蕴所构成的名身。“不适”(akalyatā)、“不堪任性”(akammaññatā)之义,如前所述。如云覆盖天空,故为“覆盖”(onāho)。“覆盖”(onayhati)即是遮蔽、笼罩之义。周遍覆盖,故为“遍覆”(pariyonāho)。不乐等词义,当知如《分别论》(Vibha. 856)所说。为显示彼处所说之圣典文句,故云“此乃所说”等。 Tattha pantesūti dūresu, vivittesu vā. Adhikusalesūti samathavipassanādhammesu. Aratīti ratippaṭikkhepo. Aratitāti aramanākāro. Anabhiratīti anabhiratabhāvo. Anabhiramanāti anabhiramanākāro. Ukkaṇṭhitāti ukkaṇṭhanākāro. Paritassitāti ukkaṇṭhanavaseneva paritassanā, ukkaṇṭhitasseva tattha tattha taṇhāyanāti vuttaṃ hoti. Paritassitāti vā kampanā. Tandīti jātiālasiyaṃ, pakatiālasiyanti attho. Tathā hi kusalakaraṇe kāyassa avipphārikatā līnatā jātiālasiyaṃ tandī nāma, na rogautujādīhi kāyagelaññaṃ. Tandiyanāti tandiyanākāro. Tandimanatāti tandiyā abhibhūtacittatā. Alasassa bhāvo ālasyaṃ, ālasyāyanākāro ālasyāyanā. Ālasyāyitassa bhāvo ālasyāyitattaṃ. Iti sabbehipi imehi padehi kilesavasena kāyālasiyaṃ kathitaṃ. Thinamiddhakāraṇānañhi rāgādikilesānaṃ vasena nāmakāyassa ālasiyaṃ, tadeva rūpakāyassāpīti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Jambhanāti phandanā. Punappunaṃ jambhanā vijambhanā. Ānamanāti purato namanā. Vinamanāti pacchato namanā. Sannamanāti samantato namanā. Paṇamanāti yathā tantato uṭṭhitapesakāro kismiñcideva gahetvā ujuṃ kāyaṃ ussāpeti, evaṃ kāyassa uddhaṃ ṭhapanā. Byādhiyakanti uppannabyādhitā. Iti sabbehipi imehi padehi thinamiddhakāraṇānaṃ rāgādikilesānaṃ vasena kāyabaddhanameva kathitaṃ. Bhuttāvissāti bhuttavato. Bhattamucchāti bhattagelaññaṃ. Balavabhattena hi mucchāpatto viya hoti. Bhattakilamathoti bhattena kilantabhāvo. Bhattapariḷāhoti bhattadaratho. Tasmiñhi samaye pariḷāhuppattiyā upahatindriyo hoti, kāyo jīratīti. Kāyaduṭṭhullanti bhattaṃ nissāya kāyassa akammaññataṃ. Akalyatātiādi heṭṭhā vuttanayameva. Līnanti avipphārikatāya paṭikuṭitaṃ. Itare dve ākārabhāvaniddesā. Thinanti sappipiṇḍo viya avipphārikatāya ghanabhāvena ṭhitaṃ. Thiyanāti ākāraniddeso. Thiyibhāvo thiyitattaṃ[Pg.78], avipphāravaseneva baddhatāti attho. Imehi pana sabbehipi padehi thinamiddhakāraṇānaṃ rāgādikilesānaṃ vasena cittassa gilānākāro kathitoti veditabbo. Purimā cattāro dhammāti arati, tandī, vijambhitā, bhattasammadoti ete cattāro dhammā. Yadā thinamiddhaṃ uppannaṃ hoti, tadā aratiādīnampi sambhavato ‘‘upanissayakoṭiyā pana hotī’’ti vuttaṃ, upanissayakoṭiyā paccayo hotīti attho. 其中,“于边鄙处”(pantesu)指于远处或于僻静处。“于增上善法”(adhikusalesu)指于奢摩他(samatha)与毘婆舍那(vipassanā)法。“不乐”(arati)即是排斥喜爱。“不乐性”(aratitā)即是不喜乐的状态。“不欢喜”(anabhirati)即是不欢喜的状态。“不欣悦”(anabhiramanā)即是不欣悦的状态。“厌倦”(ukkaṇṭhitā)即是厌倦的状态。“热望”(paritassitā)即是因厌倦而热望,亦即厌倦者于处处生起渴爱。或说,“热望”(paritassitā)即是战栗。“懒惰”(tandī)即是天生怠惰,其义为本性怠惰。于行善时,身不舒展、退缩,此天生怠惰名为“懒惰”,而非因疾病、时节等所致的身病。“怠惰性”(tandiyanā)即是怠惰的状态。“怠惰心”(tandimanatā)即是心为怠惰所胜。怠惰者的状态为“怠惰”(ālasyaṃ),怠惰的状态为“怠惰性”(ālasyāyanā),已成怠惰的状态为“已成怠惰性”(ālasyāyitattaṃ)。如是,所有此等语词皆依烦恼而说身之怠惰。应知,由作为昏沉、迟缓之因的贪等烦恼,而有名身之怠惰,色身亦然。“呵欠”(jambhanā)即是身体摇动。再再呵欠为“频呵欠”(vijambhanā)。“前屈”(ānamanā)即是向前弯曲。“后仰”(vinamanā)即是向后弯曲。“周屈”(sannamanā)即是向四周弯曲。“伸展”(paṇamanā)即是身体向上挺立,犹如织工从织机起身,抓住某物而挺直身体。“病苦”(byādhiyakaṃ)即是已生之病。如是,所有此等语词皆依作为昏沉、迟缓之因的贪等烦恼,而说身之束缚。“食后”(bhuttāvissa)即是食者。“食昏”(bhattamucchā)即是食后不适。因饱食而如昏厥。“食疲”(bhattakilamatho)即是因食而疲倦。“食恼”(bhattapariḷāho)即是食后热恼。尔时,因热恼生起,诸根受损,身体衰败。“身粗重”(kāyaduṭṭhullaṃ)即是缘于食物而身不堪任。“不适”(akalyatā)等,如前所述。“退缩”(līnaṃ)即是因不舒展而蜷缩。其余二者为状态的解释。“迟缓”(thinaṃ)即是如酥团,因不舒展而凝滞。“迟缓性”(thiyanā)是状态的解释。迟缓的状态(thiyibhāvo)或已成迟缓性(thiyitattaṃ),其义为因不舒展而受束缚。应知,所有此等语词皆依作为昏沉、迟缓之因的贪等烦恼,而说心之病态。“前四法”即是不乐、懒惰、频呵欠、食后昏沉此四法。当昏沉、迟缓生起时,不乐等亦可能生起,故说“于强依止分位而有”,其义为于强依止分位而为缘。 14. Catutthe uddatassa bhāvo uddhaccaṃ. Yassa dhammassa vasena uddhataṃ hoti cittaṃ, taṃsampayuttā vā dhammā, so dhammo uddaccaṃ. Kucchitaṃ kataṃ kukataṃ, duccaritaṃ sucaritañca. Akatampi hi kukatameva. Evañhi vattāro honti ‘‘yaṃ mayā na kataṃ, taṃ kukata’’nti. Evaṃ katākataṃ duccaritaṃ sucaritañca kukataṃ, taṃ ārabbha vippaṭisāravasena pavattaṃ pana cittaṃ idha kukatanti veditabbaṃ. Tassa bhāvo kukkuccaṃ. Cittassa uddhatākāroti cittassa avūpasamākārova vutto. Avūpasamalakkhaṇañhi uddhaccaṃ. Yathāpavattassa katākatākāravisiṭṭhassa duccaritasucaritassa anusocanavasena virūpaṃ paṭisaraṇaṃ vippaṭisāro. Kukkuccassapi katākatānusocanavasena cittavikkhepabhāvato avūpasamākāro sambhavatīti āha – ‘‘cetaso avūpasamoti uddhaccakukkuccassevataṃ nāma’’nti. Sveva ca cetaso avūpasamoti uddhaccakukkuccameva niddiṭṭhaṃ. Tañca attanova attanā sahajātaṃ na hotīti āha – ‘‘ayaṃ pana upanissayakoṭiyā paccayo hotī’’ti. Upanissayapaccayatā ca purimuppannavasena veditabbā. 14. 第四,掉的状态为掉举(uddhaccaṃ)。心因此法而掉举,或与此相应的诸法,此法即是掉举。所作的恶事为恶作(kukataṃ),即恶行与善行。未作之事亦是恶作,因为人们会说:“我所未作之事,即是恶作。”如此,已作与未作的恶行和善行是恶作。但缘于此而生起的追悔之心,于此当知为追悔(kukkucca)。其状态即是追悔。心的掉举相,即是心的不平静相。不平静即是掉举的特征。对于已发生、已作与未作、善与恶之行,以追悔的方式进行扭曲的反思,即是懊悔(vippaṭisāro)。追悔亦因追悔已作与未作之事而心散乱,故可能出现不平静相,如是说:“心不平静,即掉举、追悔之名。”此心不平静,即指掉举与追悔。而此法不与自身俱生,故说:“此实为亲依止缘(upanissayapaccaya)一类。”其亲依止缘之性,当知是由先前已生起之法而来。 15. Pañcame vigatā cikicchā assāti vicikicchā. Sabhāvaṃ vicinanto tāya kicchatīti vā vicikicchā. 15. 第五,疑(vicikicchā)。无有对治之法,故为疑。或因探究自性而感到困难,故为疑。 16. Chaṭṭhe hetuṃ vā paccayaṃ vā na labhatīti ettha hetuggahaṇena janakaṃ kāraṇamāha, paccayaggahaṇena anupālanakaṃ kāraṇaṃ. Hetunti vā upādānakāraṇaṃ. Paccayanti sahakāraṇaṃ vuttaṃ. Tanti kilesaṃ. Vivaṭṭetvā arahattaṃ gaṇhātīti vivaṭṭābhimukhaṃ cittaṃ pesetvā vipassanaṃ vaḍḍhento arahattaphalaṃ gaṇhāti. Bhikkhāya caranti etthāti bhikkhācāro, gocaragāmassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ, tasmiṃ bhikkhācāre. Vayaṃ āgammāti dārabharaṇānurūpaṃ vayaṃ āgamma. Āyūhantoti upacinanto. Aṅgārapakkanti vītaccikaṅgāresu pakkaṃ. Kiṃ nāmetanti bhikkhū garahanto āha. Jīvamānapetakasattoti [Pg.79] jīvamāno hutvā ‘‘teneva attabhāvena petabhāvaṃ pattasatto bhavissatī’’ti parikappavasena vuttaṃ. Kuṭanti pānīyaghaṭaṃ. Yāva dāruṇanti ativiya dāruṇaṃ. Vipāko kīdiso bhavissatīti tayā katakammassa āyatiṃ anubhavitabbavipāko kīdiso bhavissati. 16. 第六,不能获得因或缘。此处,以“因”(hetu)指生起之因,以“缘”(paccaya)指助持之因。或说“因”为根本原因,“缘”为辅助原因。此指烦恼。转变而证得阿罗汉果,意即令心朝向解脱,增长观(vipassanā),证得阿罗汉果。于此行乞,故为乞食行(bhikkhācāra),此乃乞食村(gocaragāma)之别称,即于此乞食行中。来到年龄,意即来到适合娶妻养家的年龄。努力,即增长。炭火上烤,即在无焰炭火上烤。“这算什么?”意即比丘呵斥道。活着的饿鬼,是就假设而说,意即活着并“将以此身成为饿鬼”。“罐”(kuṭa)指饮水罐。“何其残酷”意即非常残酷。“果报将如何?”意即你所造之业未来将要体验的果报会是怎样。 Visaṅkharitvāti chedanabhedanādīhi vināsetvā. Dīpakamigapakkhinoti attano nisinnabhāvassa dīpanato evaṃladdhanāmā migapakkhino, yena araññaṃ netvā nesādo tesaṃ saddena āgatāgate migapakkhino vadhitvā gaṇhāti. Theranti cūḷapiṇḍapātikatissattheraṃ. Iddhiyā abhisaṅkharitvāti adhiṭṭhānādivasena iddhiṃ abhisaṅkharitvā. Upayogatthe cetaṃ karaṇavacanaṃ. Aggipapaṭikanti accikaraṇaṃ, vipphuliṅganti attho. Passantassevāti anādare sāmivacanaṃ. Tassa therassāti tassa milakkhatissattherassa. Tassāti tassā aggipapaṭikāya. Paṭibalassāti uggahaṇasajjhāyādīsu paṭibalassa. Dukkhaṃ upanisā kāraṇametissāti dukkhūpanisā, dukkhanibandhanā dukkhahetukā saddhāti vuttaṃ hoti. Vattamukhena kammaṭṭhānassa kathitattā ‘‘vattasīse ṭhatvā’’ti vuttaṃ. Palālavaraṇakanti palālapuñjaṃ. “解构”(Visaṅkharitvā)意即通过切割、破坏等方式摧毁。“诱饵鸟兽”(Dīpakamigapakkhino)指因能显露自身所在而得名的鸟兽,猎人将它们带入森林,利用其叫声吸引来的鸟兽,然后加以捕杀。“长老”(thera)指小乞食者帝须长老(Cūḷapiṇḍapātikatissatthera)。“以神通力造作”(Iddhiyā abhisaṅkharitvā)意即通过决意等方式施展神通。此为表用途之工具格。“火星”(Aggipapaṭikā)指点火之物,意为火花。“见彼之时”(Passantasseva)是表示轻视的所有格。“彼长老”指弥勒迦帝须长老(Milakkhatissatthera)。“彼”指彼火星。“有能力者”(Paṭibalassa)指于受持、读诵等事有能力者。“苦为近因”(Dukkhūpanisā),是说此信以苦为近因(upanisā)、为所缘、为因由。因从业处(kammaṭṭhāna)之行持(vatta)方面说,故言“立于行持之首”。“茅草覆盖物”(Palālavaraṇakaṃ)指茅草堆。 Ārambhathāti samathavipassanādīsu vīriyaṃ karotha. Nikkamathāti kosajjato nikkhamatha, kāmānaṃ vā panūdanāya nikkhamatha, ubhayenapi vīriyameva vuttaṃ. Vīriyañhi ārambhanakavasena ārambho, kosajjato nikkhamanavasena ‘‘nikkamo’’ti vuccati. Yuñjatha buddhasāsaneti buddhassa bhagavato pariyattipaṭipattipaṭivedhasaṅkhāte tividhasāsane yuñjatha yogaṃ karotha. Evamanuyuñjantā maccuno senaṃ dhunātha viddhaṃsetha. Tattha maccuno senanti – “当勤修”(Ārambhatha)意即当于止(samatha)、观(vipassanā)等精进。“当出离”(Nikkamatha)意即当从懈怠中出离,或为断除诸欲而出离;二者皆指精进。精进,因其开始努力,故名“勤修”(ārambho);因其出离懈怠,故名“出离”(nikkamo)。“当致力于佛陀教法”(Yuñjatha buddhasāsane),意即当致力于世尊(bhagavā)所说之教(pariyatti)、行(paṭipatti)、证(paṭivedha)三法。如是致力于此者,“当摧破死魔之军”。其中,死魔之军是: ‘‘Kāmā te paṭhamā senā, dutiyā arati vuccati; Tatiyā khuppipāsā te, catutthī taṇhā pavuccati. “欲为汝初军,不乐说为二;饥渴为三军,渴爱说为四。 ‘‘Pañcamaṃ thinamiddhaṃ te, chaṭṭhā bhīrū pavuccati; Sattamī vicikicchā te, makkho thambho te aṭṭhamo. “昏沉为五军,怯懦说为六;疑为第七军,覆、慢为第八。 ‘‘Lābho [Pg.80] siloko sakkāro,Micchāladdho ca yo yaso; Yo cattānaṃ samukkaṃse,Pare ca avajānāti. “利养、声誉、恭敬,及不正当所得之名声;凡自赞毁他者。 ‘‘Esā namuci te senā, kaṇhassābhippahārinī; Na naṃ asūro jināti, jetvā ca labhate sukha’’nti. (su. ni. 438-441) – “此乃汝魔军,黑暗者之锋;非勇者不胜,胜之得安乐。” Evamāgataṃ kāmādibhedaṃ maccuno senaṃ. Ettha ca yasmā āditova agāriyabhūte satte vatthukāmesu kilesakāmā mosayanti, te abhibhuyya anagāriyabhāvaṃ upagatānaṃ pantesu senāsanesu aññataraññataresu vā adhikusalesu dhammesu arati uppajjati. Vuttañhetaṃ – ‘‘pabbajitena kho, āvuso, abhirati dukkarā’’ti (saṃ. ni. 4.331). Tato te parappaṭibaddhajīvikattā khuppipāsā bādhati, tāya bādhitānaṃ pariyesanataṇhā cittaṃ kilamayati. Atha nesaṃ kilantacittānaṃ thinamiddhaṃ okkamati, tato visesamanadhigacchantānaṃ durabhisambhavesu araññavanapatthesu pantesu senāsanesu viharataṃ utrāsasaññitā bhīru jāyati. Tesaṃ ussaṅkitaparisaṅkitānaṃ dīgharattaṃ vivekarasamanassādayamānānaṃ viharataṃ ‘‘na siyā nu kho esa maggo’’ti paṭipattiyaṃ vicikicchā uppajjati. Taṃ vinodetvā viharataṃ appamattakena visesādhigamena mānamakkhathambhā jāyanti. Tepi vinodetvā viharataṃ tato adhikataraṃ visesādhigamanaṃ nissāya lābhasakkārasilokā uppajjanti. Lābhādīhi mucchitvā dhammappatirūpakāni pakāsento micchāyasaṃ adhigantvā tattha ṭhitā jātiādīhi attānaṃ ukkaṃsenti, paraṃ vambhenti, tasmā kāmādīnaṃ paṭhamasenādibhāvo veditabbo. Naḷāgāranti naḷehi vinaddhatiṇacchannagehaṃ. 如是,死魔之军有欲等差别。此处,最初在家的有情,被欲所依(vatthukāma)与欲烦恼(kilesakāma)所迷惑;克服此等而出家后,于偏僻的住处,或于其他增上善法中,生起不乐(arati)。如经中所说:“贤友(āvuso),出家者实难有乐趣。”其后,因其生活依赖他人,而受饥渴(khuppipāsā)所恼;受此困扰,寻觅之爱(taṇhā)令心疲惫。继而,心疲惫者,为昏沉睡眠(thinamiddha)所侵;于是,未证得殊胜境界,住于难以抵达的森林、荒野等偏僻住处时,生起名为惊恐的怯懦(bhīru)。彼等长夜疑虑不安,虽享受独住之味,却于修行中生起“此道或非正道”之疑(vicikicchā)。遣除此疑而住,因些微成就而生起慢、覆、顽固(māna-makkha-thambha)。再遣除此等而住,因获得更殊胜的成就,而生起利养、恭敬、名声(lābha-sakkāra-siloka)。沉溺于利养等,宣说相似法,获得邪名,并以此为据,以种姓等抬高自己、贬低他人。是故,当知欲等为第一军等的次第。“芦苇屋”(Naḷāgāra)指用芦苇编织、以草覆盖的房屋。 Vihassatīti uggahaṇasajjhāyanamanasikārādīhi viharissati. Jātisaṃsāranti punappunaṃ jātisaṅkhātasaṃsāravaṭṭaṃ. Dukkhassantaṃ karissatīti dukkhassa antasaṅkhātaṃ nibbānaṃ sacchikarissati. Palālapuñjāhanti palālapuñjaṃ ahanti padacchedo. Tatiyaṃ ṭhānanti anāgāmiphalaṃ sandhāya vadati. “他将住”(Vihassati)意即他将通过受持、读诵、作意等方式而住。“生之轮回”(Jātisaṃsāra)指不断重复的、名为“生”的轮回之流。“他将尽苦边”(Dukkhassantaṃ karissati)意即他将亲证名为苦之终结的涅槃。“我乃草堆”(Palālapuñjāhaṃ)是“草堆”(palālapuñjaṃ)与“我”(ahaṃ)的分解。“第三地”(Tatiyaṃ ṭhānaṃ)是指不还果(anāgāmiphala)。 Tivassabhikkhukāleti upasampadato tīṇi vassāni assāti tivasso, tivasso ca so bhikkhu cāti tivassabhikkhu, tassa, tena vā [Pg.81] upalakkhito kālo tivassabhikkhukālo, tasmiṃ. Yadā so tivasso bhikkhu nāma hoti, tadāti vuttaṃ hoti. Kammaṃ karotīti bhāvanākammaṃ karoti. Ganthakammanti ganthavisayaṃ uggahaṇādikammaṃ. Piṇḍāpacitiṃ katvāti antovasse temāsaṃ dinnapiṇḍassa kilesakkhayakaraṇena apacitiṃ pūjaṃ katvā. Piṇḍāpacitiṃ karonto hi bhikkhu yehi attano yo piṇḍapāto dinno, tesaṃ tassa mahapphalabhāvaṃ icchanto attano santānameva kilesakkhayakaraṇena visodhetvā arahattaṃ gaṇhāti. “三年比丘期”(Tivassabhikkhukāla)是指自受具足戒起已满三年的比丘,即“三年比丘”(tivassabhikkhu);或指以此比丘为标志的时间。也就是说,当他被称为三年比丘之时。“作业”是指修习禅修之业。“学业”(Ganthakamma)是指学习、背诵等与经典相关之业。“行食施之报”(Piṇḍāpacitiṃ katvā)是指在雨安居的三个月内,通过断除烦恼来回报所接受的食物。行食施之报的比丘,希望布施食物者能获得大果报,故通过断除烦恼来净化自身心流,从而证得阿罗汉果。 Mahābhūtīti ettha pūjāvacano mahantasaddo, bhūtīti ca nāmekadesena tissabhūtittheraṃ ālapati. Bhavati hi nāmekadesenapi vohāro yathā ‘‘devadatto datto’’ti. Mahābhūtīti vā piyasamudāhāro, so mahati bhūti vibhūti puññañāṇādisampadā assāti mahābhūti. Channaṃ sepaṇṇigacchamūlanti sākhāpalāsādīhi channaṃ ghanacchāyaṃ sepaṇṇigacchamūlaṃ. Asubhakammaṭṭhānaṃ pādakaṃ katvāti kesādiasubhakoṭṭhāsabhāvanāya paṭiladdhaṃ upacārasamādhiṃ appanāsamādhiṃ vā pādakaṃ katvā. Asubhavisayaṃ upacārajjhānādikammamevettha upari pavattetabbabhāvanākammassa kāraṇabhāvato ṭhānanti kammaṭṭhānaṃ. 于“Mahābhūti”一句,“mahanta”(大)是敬语,而“bhūti”是截取帝须菩提长老(Tissabhūtitthera)名字的一部分来称呼他。确实存在以名字的一部分来称呼的用法,例如“提婆达多(Devadatta)”可简称为“Datta”。或者,“Mahābhūti”(大成就者)也是一种爱称,意指他具有广大的福德、智慧等成就,故称“Mahābhūti”。“于枝叶繁茂之Sepaṇṇi树下”(Channaṃ sepaṇṇigacchamūlaṃ)是指在枝叶等覆盖之下,浓荫密布的Sepaṇṇi树根处。“以不净业处为基础”(Asubhakammaṭṭhānaṃ pādakaṃ katvā)是指,以修习头发等不净部分而获得的近行定或安止定为基础。在此,以不净为所缘的近行禅等禅修之业,因是更高阶禅修开展之因,故为“处”(ṭhāna),合称“业处”(kammaṭṭhāna)。 Sahassadvisahassasaṅkhāmattattā ‘‘mahāgaṇe’’ti vuttaṃ. Attano vasanaṭṭhānato therassa santikaṃ gantvāti attano vasanaṭṭhānato ākāsena gantvā vihārasamīpe otaritvā divāṭṭhāne nisinnattherassa santikaṃ gantvā. Kiṃ āgatosīti kiṃkāraṇā āgatosi. Sabbesu rattidivasabhāgesu okāsaṃ alabhantoti so kira thero ‘‘tuyhaṃ okāso na bhavissati, āvuso’’ti vuttepi ‘‘vitakkamāḷake ṭhitakāle pucchissāmi, bhante’’ti vatvā ‘‘tasmiṃ ṭhāne aññe pucchissantī’’ti vutte ‘‘bhikkhācāramagge, bhante’’ti vatvā ‘‘tatrāpi aññe pucchantī’’ti vutte dupaṭṭanivāsanaṭṭhāne, saṅghāṭipārupanaṭṭhāne, pattanīharaṇaṭṭhāne, gāme caritvā āsanasālāya yāgupītakāle, bhanteti. Tatthāpi therā attano kaṅkhaṃ vinodenti, āvusoti. Antogāmato nikkhamanakāle pucchissāmi, bhanteti. Tatrāpi aññe pucchanti, āvusoti. Antarāmagge, bhanteti. Bhojanasālāya bhattakiccapariyosāne, bhante. Divāṭṭhāne pādadhovanakāle, bhanteti. Tato paṭṭhāya [Pg.82] yāva aruṇā apare pucchanti, āvusoti. Dantakaṭṭhaṃ gahetvā mukhadhovanatthaṃ gamanakāle, bhanteti. Tadāpi aññe pucchantīti. Mukhaṃ dhovitvā āgamanakāle, bhanteti. Tatrāpi aññe pucchissantīti. Senāsanaṃ pavisitvā nisinnakāle, bhanteti. Tatrāpi aññe pucchanti, āvusoti. Evaṃ sabbesu rattidivasabhāgesu yācamāno okāsaṃ na labhi, taṃ sandhāyetaṃ vuttaṃ – ‘‘evaṃ okāse asati maraṇassa kathaṃ okāsaṃ labhissathā’’ti. Bhante, nanu mukhaṃ dhovitvā senāsanaṃ pavisitvā tayo cattāro pallaṅke uṇhāpetvā yonisomanasikārakammaṃ karontānaṃ okāsalābhena bhavitabbaṃ siyāti adhippāyena vadati. Maṇivaṇṇeti indanīlamaṇivaṇṇe. 因其数量仅一两千,故称“大群”。“从自己住处前往长老处”是指从自己住处腾空而行,在寺院附近降落,前往坐在日间住处之长老座前。“为何而来?”是问来此的缘由。“在所有日夜时分都得不到机会”——据说那位长老虽说:“贤友,你将没有机会。”他仍回答:“尊者,我将在思惟台上站立时请教。”长老说:“在那个地方,有其他人会问。”他又说:“尊者,于乞食途中。”长老说:“那里也有其他人问。”他又说:“于穿下裙处、披僧伽梨处、取钵处、入村乞食后于食堂喝粥时。”长老说:“贤友,在那里,长老们也会消除自己的疑惑。”他又说:“尊者,出村时。”长老说:“贤友,那里也有其他人问。”他又说:“尊者,在半路上。”“尊者,在食堂用完餐后。”“尊者,在日间住处洗脚时。”长老说:“贤友,从那时起直到天亮,都有其他人问。”他又说:“尊者,拿杨枝去刷牙时。”长老说:“那时也有其他人问。”他又说:“尊者,洗完脸回来时。”长老说:“那里也有其他人问。”他又说:“尊者,进入住处坐下时。”长老说:“贤友,那里也有其他人问。”就这样,他在所有日夜时分请求,都得不到机会,针对此事而说:“若无此机缘,于死时何得机缘?”他的意思是:“尊者,难道洗完脸,进入住处,暖好三四个坐具,行如理作意之时,不应有机会吗?”“如宝珠之色”是指如蓝宝石之色。 Ghaṭentassevāti vāyāmantasseva. Visuddhipavāraṇanti ‘‘parisuddho aha’’nti evaṃ pavattaṃ visuddhipavāraṇaṃ. Arahantānameva hesā pavāraṇā. Kāḷakaṃ vāti mahantaṃ kāḷakaṃ sandhāya vadati, tilako vāti khuddakaṃ sandhāya. Ubhayenapi sīlassa parisuddhabhāvameva vibhāveti. “精勤者”(Ghaṭentassa)即努力者。“清净自恣”(Visuddhipavāraṇa)即“我已清净”如此进行的清净自恣。此诚为阿罗汉之自恣。“或黑斑”(kāḷakaṃ)是指大的黑点,“或黑痣”(tilako)是指小的黑点。两者皆为彰显戒之全然清净。 Padhānakammikāti padhānakamme niyuttā. Laddhamagganti laddhūpāyaṃ, paṭhamameva laddhūpadesanti vuttaṃ hoti. Apattānīti chaḍḍitāni. Alābūneva sāradeti saradakāle vātātapahatāni tattha tattha vippakiṇṇaalābūni viya. Kāpotakānīti kapotakavaṇṇāni. Tāni disvāna kā ratīti tāni evarūpāni aṭṭhīni disvā tumhākaṃ kā nāma rati, nanu appamattakāpi rati kātuṃ na vaṭṭatiyevāti attho. Dutiyakathaṃ akathitapubboti attano vuḍḍhatarena saddhiṃ vuttavacanassa paccanīkaṃ dutiyakathaṃ akathitapubbo. “精勤修行者”(Padhānakammikā)即致力于修行者。“得道者”(Laddhamagga)即得法者,意为最初已得教导者。“被弃者”(Apattāni)即被丢弃者。“如秋日之葫芦”(Alābūneva sārade)即如秋天时被风日吹晒而四处散落的葫芦。“鸽色者”(Kāpotakāni)即如鸽羽之色。“见此何可乐?”(Tāni disvāna kā rati)意指:见到这般骨骸,你们有何可乐之处?难道不应生起丝毫喜爱之心吗?“未曾言于二”(Dutiyakathaṃ akathitapubbo)是指对于比自己年长者所说之言,从未说过相违的第二句话。 Tadaṅgena, tadaṅgassa pahānaṃ tadaṅgappahānaṃ. Yañhi rattibhāge samujjalitena dīpena andhakārassa viya tena tena vipassanāya avayavabhūtena ñāṇaṅgena paṭipakkhavaseneva tassa tassa pahātabbadhammassa pahānamidaṃ tadaṅgappahānaṃ nāma. Yathā kāmacchandādayo na cittaṃ pariyuṭṭhāya tiṭṭhanti, evaṃ pariyuṭṭhānassa nisedhanaṃ appavattikaraṇaṃ vikkhambhanaṃ vikkhambhanappahānaṃ. Yañhi sasevāle udake pakkhittena ghaṭena sevālassa viya tena tena lokiyasamādhinā nīvaraṇādīnaṃ paccanīkadhammānaṃ vikkhambhanamidaṃ vikkhambhanappahānaṃ nāma. Sammā upacchijjanti etena kilesāti samucchedo, pahīyanti etena kilesāti pahānaṃ, samucchedasaṅkhātaṃ [Pg.83] pahānaṃ niravasesappahānanti samucchedappahānaṃ. Yañhi asanivicakkābhihatassa rukkhassa viya ariyamaggañāṇena saṃyojanādīnaṃ dhammānaṃ yathā na puna vattanti, evaṃ pahānamidaṃ samucchedappahānaṃ nāma. Paṭippassambhati vūpasammati kilesadaratho etāyāti paṭippassaddhi, phalaṃ, sāyeva pahānanti paṭippassaddhippahānaṃ. Sabbe kilesā sabbasaṅkhatā vā nissaranti apagacchanti etenāti nissaraṇaṃ, nibbānaṃ, tadeva pahānanti nissaraṇappahānaṃ. Paṭippassambhayamānanti paṭippassambhaṃ kilesavūpasamaṃ kurumānaṃ. Lokiyalokuttarehīti tadaṅgavikkhambhanappahānānaṃ lokiyattā, itaresaṃ lokuttarattā vuttaṃ. 随分断(tadaṅgappahāna)是指,通过观(vipassanā)的各个部分——即作为对治法的智支(ñāṇaṅga),犹如夜晚以明灯驱散黑暗,来断除那些应断之法。镇伏断(vikkhambhanappahāna)是指,防止欲贪(kāmacchanda)等烦恼生起缠绕内心,令其不现行,此即镇伏。又如将陶瓶放入长满浮萍(sevāla)的水中,浮萍便被排开,与此类似,凭借世间禅定(lokiyasamādhi)的力量来镇伏五盖(nīvaraṇa)等敌对法,此即镇伏断。永断(samucchedappahāna)是指,烦恼(kilesa)由此被彻底截断、灭尽,这种彻底无余的断除即是永断。又如被雷电击中的树木,通过圣道智(ariyamaggañāṇa)彻底断除结(saṃyojana)等法,使其永不再生,此即永断。寂静断(paṭippassaddhippahāna)是指,烦恼的躁动(kilesadaratha)由此平息、止息,此即圣果(phala),这种断除即是寂静断。出离断(nissaraṇappahāna)是指,一切烦恼、一切有为法(saṅkhata)由此出离、远离,此即涅槃(nibbāna),这种断除即是出离断。“正令寂静”(paṭippassambhayamānaṃ)是指使烦恼止息(kilesavūpasama)。“由世间与出世间”(lokiyalokuttarehi)是说,随分断和镇伏断属于世间(lokiya),其余诸断属于出世间(lokuttara)。 Nimīyati phalaṃ etena uppajjanaṭṭhāne pakkhipamānaṃ viya hotīti nimittaṃ, kāraṇassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Asubhassa nimittaṃ, asubhameva vā nimittanti asubhanimittaṃ. Asubhanissitampi hi jhānaṃ nissite nissayavohārena asubhanti voharīyati yathā ‘‘mañcā ukkuṭṭhiṃ karontī’’ti. Tenevāha – ‘‘dasasu asubhesu uppannaṃ sārammaṇaṃ paṭhamajjhāna’’nti. Anicce aniccantiādinā nayena vuttassāti iminā catubbidhaṃ yonisomanasikāraṃ dasseti. Heṭṭhā cettha idha ca catubbidhassa ayonisomanasikārassa yonisomanasikārassa ca gahaṇaṃ niravasesadassanatthaṃ katanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Tesu pana asubhe ‘‘asubha’’nti manasikāro idhādhippeto, tadanukūlattā vā itaresampi gahaṇaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. 以此衡量,犹如将果实置于其生起之处,故为“相”(nimitta)。此是“因”(kāraṇa)之同义词。不净之相,或不净即是相,故为不净相(asubhanimitta)。因为依止于不净的禅那(jhāna),依于所依止之物,亦被称为“不净”,犹如说“床在叫喊”。因此说:“于十不净中生起、有所缘的初禅(paṭhamajjhāna)。”以“于无常作无常想”等理所说,此显示了四种如理作意(yonisomanasikāra)。应知,于前文及此处,提及四种不如理作意(ayonisomanasikāra)与如理作意,是为了无遗漏地展示。于此等中,于不净作“不净”想,是此处之意趣;亦应知,其余作意因与之相应,故亦被含摄。 Ekādasasu asubhesu paṭikūlākārassa uggaṇhanaṃ, yathā vā tattha uggahanimittaṃ uppajjati, tathā paṭipatti asubhanimittassa uggaho. Upacārappanāvahāya asubhabhāvanāya anuyuñjanaṃ asubhabhāvanānuyogo. Bhojane mattaññuno thinamiddhābhibhavābhāvā otāraṃ alabhamāno kāmacchando pahīyatīti vadanti. Bhojananissitaṃ pana āhāre paṭikūlasaññaṃ, tabbipariṇāmassa tadādhārassa tassa ca udariyabhūtassa asubhatādassanaṃ, kāyassa ca āhāraṭṭhitikatādassanaṃ yo uppādeti, so visesato bhojane pamāṇaññū nāma, tassa ca kāmacchando pahīyateva. Dasavidhañhi asubhanimittanti pākaṭavasena vuttaṃ. Kāyagatāsatiṃ pana gahetvā ekādasavidhampi asubhanimittaṃ veditabbaṃ. 于十一种不净(asubha)中,把握厌恶之相(paṭikūlākāra),或如于彼处生起取相(uggahanimitta),如是行持,即为不净相之把握(asubhanimittassa uggaho)。致力于能带来近行(upacāra)与安止(appanā)的不净修习(asubhabhāvanā),即是不净修习之勤行(asubhabhāvanānuyoga)。有人说,饮食知量者,因昏沉睡眠(thinamiddha)不得其便,欲贪(kāmacchanda)遂得断除。然而,若能生起于食所依之厌恶想(paṭikūlasañña),见其消化、见其容器、见其在腹中之不净,并见身体依食而住,此人方为殊胜之饮食知量者,其欲贪亦必断除。所谓十种不净相,是依显而易见者而言。若计入身至念(kāyagatāsati),则当知有十一种不净相。 Abhutvā udakaṃ piveti pānīyassa okāsadānatthaṃ cattāro pañca ālope abhutvā pānīyaṃ piveyyāti attho. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘catunnaṃ [Pg.84] pañcannaṃ ālopānaṃ okāse satī’’ti. Abhidhammaṭīkākārena panettha ‘‘cattāro pañca ālope, bhutvāna udakaṃ pive’’ti pāṭhaṃ parikappetvā aññathā attho vaṇṇito, so aṭṭhakathāya na sameti. Asubhakammikatissatthero dantaṭṭhidassāvī. “食前饮水”(abhutvā udakaṃ piveti),意为给饮品留出空间,即在吃完前,尚余四五口食物量时饮水。因此说:“尚有四五口食物之量时(即应饮水)。”于此,《阿毗达摩》(Abhidhamma)复注(ṭīkā)的作者构想了“食四五口后,乃饮于水”(cattāro pañca ālope, bhutvāna udakaṃ pive)的读法,并作了别解,此说与义注(aṭṭhakathā)不合。修不净业的帝须长老(Asubhakammikatissatthero)是见牙骨者。 17. Sattame mijjati hitapharaṇavasena siniyhatīti mitto, hitesī puggalo, tasmiṃ mitte bhavā, mittassa vā esāti mettā, hitesitā. Tattha ‘‘mettā’’ti vutte appanāpi upacāropi vaṭṭati sādhāraṇavacanabhāvatoti āha – ‘‘mettāti ettāvatā pubbabhāgopi vaṭṭatī’’ti. Api-saddo appanaṃ sampiṇḍeti. Appanaṃ appattāya mettāya suṭṭhu muccanassa abhāvato cetovimuttīti ‘‘appanāva adhippetā’’ti vuttaṃ. 17. 第七,以施与利益而润泽、慈爱,故为“友”(mitto),即有利他心之人(puggala)。于友中存在,或此属于友,故为“慈”(mettā),即有利他之心。于此,当说“慈”时,因其为通称,故安止(appanā)与近行(upacāra)皆适用。故说:“仅言‘慈’,亦适于前分。”“亦”(api)字,总括安止。因为未达安止之慈,则无善妙解脱,故于“心解脱”(cetovimutti)一词,说“意指安止”。 Sattesu mettāyanassa hitūpasaṃhārassa uppādanaṃ pavattanaṃ mettānimittassa uggaho. Paṭhamuppanno mettāmanasikāro parato uppajjanakassa kāraṇabhāvato mettāmanasikārova mettānimittaṃ. Kammaṃyeva sakaṃ etesanti kammassakā, sattā, tabbhāvo kammassakatā, kammadāyādatā. Dosamettāsu yāthāvato ādīnavānisaṃsānaṃ paṭisaṅkhānavīmaṃsā idha paṭisaṅkhānaṃ. Mettāvihārīkalyāṇamittavantatā idha kalyāṇamittatā. Odissakaanodissakadisāpharaṇānanti attaatipiyamajjhattaverivasena odissakatā, sīmāsambhede kate anodissakatā, ekādidisāpharaṇavasena disāpharaṇatā mettāya uggahaṇe veditabbā. Vihāraracchagāmādivasena vā odissakadisāpharaṇaṃ. Vihārādiuddesarahitaṃ puratthimādidisāvasena anodissakadisāpharaṇaṃ. Evaṃ vā dvidhā uggahaṇaṃ sandhāya – ‘‘odissakaanodissakadisāpharaṇa’’nti vuttaṃ. Uggaho ca yāva upacārā daṭṭhabbo. Uggahitāya āsevanā bhāvanā. Tattha sabbe sattā, pāṇā, bhūtā, puggalā, attabhāvapariyāpannāti etesaṃ vasena pañcavidhā. Ekekasmiṃ averā hontu, abyāpajjhā, anīghā, sukhī attānaṃ pariharantūti catudhā pavattito vīsatividhā anodhisopharaṇā mettā. Sabbā itthiyo, purisā, ariyā, anariyā, devā, manussā, vinipātikāti sattādhikaraṇavasena pavattā sattavidhā aṭṭhavīsatividhā vā, dasahi disāhi disādhikaraṇavasena pavattā dasavidhā ca, ekekāya [Pg.85] vā disāya sattādiitthādiaverādibhedena asītādhikacatusatappabhedā ca odhisopharaṇā veditabbā. Mettaṃ bhāventassāti mettājhānaṃ bhāventassa. Tvaṃ etassa kuddhotiādi paccavekkhaṇāvidhidassanaṃ. Appaṭicchitapaheṇakaṃ viyāti asampaṭicchitapaṇṇākāraṃ viya. Paṭisaṅkhāneti vīmaṃsāyaṃ. Vattaniaṭaviyaṃ attaguttattherasadise. 于诸有情,令慈爱、利益生起与转起,即是把握慈心相。最初生起的慈心作意,因其为后续生起之因,此慈心作意即是慈心相。“业是他们的所有物”,故为“业属己者”(kammassakā),即有情;此状态即是业属己性(kammassakatā)、业继承性(kammadāyādatā)。于嗔与慈,如实审察其过患与功德,于此即是“省察”(paṭisaṅkhāna)。安住于慈者拥有善友,于此即是“善友性”(kalyāṇamittatā)。关于有指定、无指定及方向遍满:依自己、极爱者、中庸者、怨敌,为有指定(odissaka);破除界限后,为无指定(anodissaka);依遍满一方等,为方向遍满。于修慈之把握阶段当知此。或依寺院、街道、村落等,为有指定的方向遍满;不指定寺院等,而依东方等方向,为无指定的方向遍满。针对此二种把握,故说“有指定与无指定的方向遍满”。应知把握直至近行定。把握之后,修习即是培育。其中,依“一切有情、一切有息者、一切生物、一切个人、一切有自体者”此五种,于每一种中,开展“愿他们无怨、无害、无恼,快乐地护持自己”四种,成就二十种无指定的遍满慈。依“一切女人、男人、圣者、非圣者、天、人、堕恶趣者”七种,有二十八种;依十方,有十种;或于每一方,依有情等、女人等及无怨等之差别,当知有四百八十种有指定的遍满慈。“修慈者”,即修慈禅(mettājhāna)者。“你对此人生气”等,是为开示省察之法。“如未被接受之礼物”,即如未被收下之供礼。“省察”(paṭisaṅkhāneti),即审察。如在瓦达尼亚(Vattaniya)森林的自护长老(Attaguttatthera)。 18. Aṭṭhame kusaladhammasampaṭipattiyā paṭṭhapanasabhāvatāya tappaṭipakkhānaṃ visosanasabhāvatāya ca ārambhadhātuādito pavattavīriyanti āha – ‘‘paṭhamārambhavīriya’’nti. Yasmā paṭhamārambhamattassa kosajjavidhamanaṃ thāmagamanañca natthi, tasmā vuttaṃ – ‘‘kosajjato nikkhantattā tato balavatara’’nti. Yasmā pana aparāparuppattiyā laddhāsevanaṃ uparūpari visesaṃ āvahantaṃ ativiya thāmagatameva hoti, tasmā vuttaṃ – ‘‘paraṃ paraṃ ṭhānaṃ akkamanato tatopi balavatara’’nti. Panūdanāyāti nīharaṇāya. Yathā mahato palighassa ugghāṭakajanassa mahanto ussāho icchitabbo, evamidhāpīti ‘‘nikkamo cetaso palighugghāṭanāyā’’ti vuttaṃ. Mahāparakkamo eva parena kataṃ bandhanaṃ chindeyya, evamidhāpīti vuttaṃ – ‘‘parakkamo cetaso bandhanacchedanāyā’’ti. 18. 第八,因其具有建立善法行持、干竭其对治品之性,且从发勤界等而转起,故说为“初发勤”(paṭhamārambhavīriya)。因为仅有初发勤,尚不能摧破懈怠、获得力量,故说:“因脱离懈怠,故比前者更有力。”又因其通过数数生起而得以修习,能引生更高之殊胜,变得极为坚固,故说:“因次第趋向更高境界,故比后者更有力。”“为遣除”(panūdanāya),即为引出(nīharaṇāya)。犹如开启巨大门闩者,须有大精勤,此处亦然,故说:“出离,为开启心之门闩。”唯有大精进者,方能斩断他人所设之束缚,此处亦然,故说:“精进,为斩断心之束缚。” Āraddhaṃ saṃsādhitaṃ paripūritaṃ vīriyaṃ etassāti āraddhavīriyo, nipphannavīriyo, āraddhaṃ paṭṭhapitaṃ vīriyaṃ etassāti āraddhavīriyo. Vīriyārambhappasutoti āha – ‘‘āraddhavīriyassāti paripuṇṇavīriyassaceva paggahitavīriyassa cā’’ti. Catudosāpagatanti atilīnatādīhi catūhi dosehi apagataṃ. Catudosāpagatattameva vibhāveti ‘‘na ca atilīna’’ntiādinā. Atilīnañhi bhāvanācittaṃ kosajjapakkhikaṃ siyā, atipaggahitañca uddhaccapakkhikaṃ. Bhāvanāvīthiṃ anajjhogāhetvā saṅkocāpatti atilīnatā. Ajjhogāhetvā antosaṅkoco ajjhattaṃ saṃkhittatā. Atipaggahitatā accāraddhavīriyatā. Bahiddhā vikkhittatā bahivisaṭavitakkānudhāvanā. Tadetaṃ vīriyaṃ caṅkamādikāyikappayogāvahaṃ kāyikaṃ, tadaññaṃ cetasikaṃ. Rattidivassa pañca koṭṭhāseti pubbaṇhasāyanhapaṭhamamajjhimapacchimayāmasaṅkhāte pañca koṭṭhāse. Tadubhayampīti kāyikaṃ cetasikañca vīriyaṃ. Milakkhatissattherassa mahāsīvattherassa ca vatthu heṭṭhā dassitameva. “已发起、已成就、已圆满的精进属于他,故为‘发勤精进者’(āraddhavīriyo),即已成就精进者;已发起、已建立的精进属于他,故为‘发勤精进者’。经中说‘发勤精进者’,是指‘具足精进与策励精进两者’。‘远离四过失’,指远离过度懈怠等四种过失。通过‘不过于懈怠’等句来阐明远离四过失。修行之心若过度懈怠,则偏于懒惰;若过度策励,则偏于掉举。不投入修行之道而退缩,是过度懈怠;投入后内心紧缩,是内在收摄;过度策励,是精进过猛;心向外散乱,是追逐向外发散的寻思。此精进若能引生经行等身体力行,则为身精进;其余则为心精进。‘昼夜五时’,指上午、下午、初夜、中夜、后夜这五个时段。‘两者’,即身精进与心精进。弥罗迦帝须长老(Milakkhatissatthera)与大希瓦长老(Mahāsīvatthera)的故事已在前面说明。” Pītimallakattherassa [Pg.86] vatthu pana evaṃ veditabbaṃ. So kira gihikāle mallayuddhāya āhiṇḍanto tīsu rajjesu paṭākaṃ gahetvā tambapaṇṇidīpaṃ āgamma rājānaṃ disvā raññā katānuggaho ekadivasaṃ kilañcakāsanasālādvārena gacchanto ‘‘rūpaṃ, bhikkhave, na tumhākaṃ, taṃ pajahatha, taṃ vo pahīnaṃ dīgharattaṃ hitāya sukhāya bhavissatī’’ti (saṃ. ni. 3.33-34; 4.102; ma. ni. 1.247) natumhākavaggaṃ sutvā cintesi – ‘‘neva kira rūpaṃ attano, na vedanā’’ti. So taṃyeva aṅkusaṃ katvā nikkhamitvā mahāvihāraṃ gantvā pabbajjaṃ yācitvā pabbajito upasampanno dvemātikā paguṇaṃ katvā tiṃsa bhikkhū gahetvā avaravāliyaaṅgaṇaṃ gantvā samaṇadhammaṃ akāsi. Pādesu avahantesu jaṇṇukehi caṅkamati. Tamenaṃ rattiṃ eko migaluddako ‘‘migo’’ti maññamāno pahari, satti vinivijjhitvā gatā. So taṃ sattiṃ harāpetvā pahāramukhāni tiṇavaṭṭiyā pūrāpetvā pāsāṇapiṭṭhiyaṃ attānaṃ nisīdāpetvā okāsaṃ kāretvā vipassanaṃ vaḍḍhetvā saha paṭisambhidāhi arahattaṃ patvā ukkāsitasaddena āgatānaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ byākaritvā imaṃ udānaṃ udānesi – 关于毕帝马拉长老(Pītimallakatthera)的故事,当如是了知。据说他在家时,为习摔跤而游历三国,夺得锦标后,来到铜鍱洲(Tambapaṇṇidīpa),觐见国王并蒙赏识。一日,他经过象牙匠堂门口,听闻《非汝等所有品》(Natumhākavagga)中说:“诸比丘,色非汝等所有,当舍离之。舍离彼,将为汝等带来长夜的利益与安乐。”(《相应部》3.33-34; 4.102;《中部》1.247) 他心想:“原来色非我所有,受亦非我所有。”他以此为策励,出家前往大寺(Mahāvihāra)请求出家。受具足戒后,他通晓二部《母论》,带领三十位比丘前往阿瓦罗瓦利园(Avaravāliyaaṅgaṇa)修习沙门法。因双脚磨损,他便用双膝经行。一夜,有个猎人误以为他是野兽而射之,箭矢穿身而过。他让人拔出箭矢,用草团塞住伤口,让身体坐于石上,令观智得以生起,增长观,最终证得阿罗汉果,具足四无碍解。他为闻其咳嗽声而来的比丘们解说后,诵出此自说偈: ‘‘Bhāsitaṃ buddhaseṭṭhassa, sabbalokaggavādino; Na tumhākaṃ idaṃ rūpaṃ, taṃ jaheyyātha bhikkhavo. (dī. ni. aṭṭha. 2.373; ma. ni. aṭṭha. 1.106); “最胜佛陀所说,一切世间最上语者所言:‘此色非汝等所有,诸比丘,当舍离之。’” ‘‘Aniccā vata saṅkhārā, uppādavayadhammino; Uppajjitvā nirujjhanti, tesaṃ vūpasamo sukho’’ti. (dī. ni. aṭṭha. 2.373; ma. ni. aṭṭha. 1.106; theragā. 1168); “诸行实无常,是生灭之法;生已复归灭,彼等之寂灭为乐。” Kuṭumbiyaputtatissattherassapi vatthu evaṃ veditabbaṃ. Sāvatthiyaṃ kira tisso nāma kuṭumbiyaputto cattālīsa hiraññakoṭiyo pahāya pabbajitvā agāmake araññe viharati, tassa kaniṭṭhabhātubhariyā ‘‘gacchatha, naṃ jīvitā voropethā’’ti pañcasate core pesesi, te gantvā theraṃ parivāretvā nisīdiṃsu. Thero āha – ‘‘kasmā āgatattha upāsakā’’ti? Taṃ jīvitā voropessāmāti. Pāṭibhogaṃ me upāsakā gahetvā ajjekarattiṃ jīvitaṃ dethāti. Ko te, samaṇa, imasmiṃ ṭhāne pāṭibhogo bhavissatīti? Thero mahantaṃ pāsāṇaṃ gahetvā ūruṭṭhīni bhinditvā ‘‘vaṭṭati upāsakā pāṭibhogo’’ti āha. Te apakkamitvā caṅkamanasīse aggiṃ katvā nipajjiṃsu. Therassa vedanaṃ vikkhambhetvā [Pg.87] sīlaṃ paccavekkhato parisuddhasīlaṃ nissāya pītipāmojjaṃ uppajji. Tato anukkamena vipassanaṃ vaḍḍhento tiyāmarattiṃ samaṇadhammaṃ katvā aruṇuggamane arahattaṃ patto imaṃ udānaṃ udānesi – 关于居士子帝须长老(Kuṭumbiyaputtatissatthera)的故事,当如是了知。据说在舍卫城(Sāvatthī),有位名叫帝须的居士子,舍弃四十俱胝财产而出家,住于无村落的森林中。他最小弟弟的妻子派遣五百盗贼说:“去,杀了他!”他们前去围住长老坐下。长老问:“优婆塞们为何而来?”答:“为取你性命。”长老说:“优婆塞们,请收下我的抵押品,给我一夜活命的时间。”他们问:“沙门,在此处,你有什么可作抵押?”长老拿起一块大石头,击碎自己的双腿骨,说:“优婆塞们,这抵押品可以吗?”他们退去后,在经行道的尽头生火躺下。长老抑制剧痛,省察戒行,因戒行清净而生起喜悦与踊跃。其后,他次第增长观,于一夜三时中修习沙门法,至黎明时证得阿罗汉果,诵出此自说偈: ‘‘Ubho pādāni bhinditvā, saññapessāmi vo ahaṃ; Aṭṭiyāmi harāyāmi, sarāgamaraṇaṃ ahaṃ. “我已折断双足,我将令汝等了知;我实厌患、羞耻于带着贪欲而死。” ‘‘Evāhaṃ cintayitvāna, yathābhūtaṃ vipassisaṃ; Sampatte aruṇuggamhi, arahattaṃ apāpuṇi’’nti. (visuddhi. 1.20; dī. ni. aṭṭha. 2.373; ma. ni. aṭṭha. 1.106); “我如是思惟后,已如实地观照;当黎明到来时,我即证阿罗汉果。” Atibhojane nimittaggāhoti atibhojane thinamiddhassa nimittaggāho, ‘‘ettake bhutte taṃ bhojanaṃ thinamiddhassa kāraṇaṃ hoti, ettake na hotī’’ti thinamiddhassa kāraṇākāraṇaggāho hotīti attho. Byatirekavasena cetaṃ vuttaṃ, tasmā ettake bhutte taṃ bhojanaṃ thinamiddhassa kāraṇaṃ na hotīti bhojane mattaññutāva atthato dassitāti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘catupañca…pe… taṃ na hotī’’ti. Divā sūriyālokanti divā gahitanimittaṃ sūriyālokaṃ rattiyaṃ manasikarontassapīti evamettha attho veditabbo. Dhutaṅgānaṃ vīriyanissitattā vuttaṃ – ‘‘dhutaṅganissitasappāyakathāyapī’’ti. “‘于过量饮食中取相’,意指于过量饮食时,执取昏沉睡眠之相,即执取其因与非因,心想:‘吃这么多食物是昏沉睡眠的原因,吃这么多则不是。’此乃以否定的方式而说,因此当知,其义实为显示于饮食知量。是故说:‘四五口……则不会有。’‘白昼日光’,于此当知其义为:即使在夜间,也作意于白昼所取之日光相。由于头陀支依于精进而行,故说‘乃至依于头陀支的适宜开示’。” 19. Navame jhānena vā vipassanāya vā vūpasamitacittassāti jhānena vā vipassanāya vā avūpasamakarakilesavigamanena vūpasamitacittassa. Kukkuccampi katākatānusocanavasena pavattamānaṃ cetaso avūpasamāvahatāya uddhaccena samānalakkhaṇanti ubhayassa pahānakāraṇaṃ abhinnaṃ katvā vuttaṃ. Bahussutassa ganthato atthato ca suttādīni vicārentassa tabbahulavihārino atthavedādippaṭilābhasambhavato vikkhepo na hoti. Yathā vidhippaṭipattiyā yathānurūpapattikārappavattiyā ca vikkhepo ca katākatānusocanañca na hotīti ‘‘bāhusaccenapi uddhaccakukkuccaṃ pahīyatī’’ti āha. Yadaggena bāhusaccena uddhaccakukkuccaṃ pahīyati, tadaggena paripucchakatāvinayappakataññutāhipi taṃ pahīyatīti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Vuddhasevitā ca vuddhasīlitaṃ āvahatīti cetaso vūpasamakarattā ‘‘uddhaccakukkuccappahānakārī’’ti vuttaṃ, vuddhataṃ pana anapekkhitvā kukkuccavinodakā vinayadharā kalyāṇamittāti vuttāti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Vikkhepo ca pabbajitānaṃ yebhuyyena [Pg.88] kukkuccahetuko hotīti ‘‘kappiyākappiyaparipucchābahulassā’’tiādinā vinayanayeneva paripucchakatādayo niddiṭṭhā. 19. “第九,‘其心已由禅那或观而得止息’,意指其心已由禅那或观,通过令心不得安宁的烦恼之离去而得以止息。恶作亦因追悔已作与未作之事而生,因其能导致心不安宁,故与掉举之相相同。因此,说此二者的断除之因并无差别。多闻者因时常思察经文义理,能得义解等成就,故无散乱。如法行持、如理而行,则无散乱与追悔,故说‘以多闻亦能断除掉举、恶作’。当知,在多闻能断除掉举、恶作的程度上,好乐请问与精通律藏亦能断除它们。亲近长者能带来心的寂止,故说‘能断除掉举、恶作’。然而,当知此处所说能消除恶作的持律者与善友,并非仅指年长者。出家人的散乱大多由恶作引起,故以‘多请问何为如法、何为不如法’等句,依律藏之理指明了请问等方法。” 20. Dasame bahussutānaṃ dhammasabhāvāvabodhasambhavato vicikicchā anavakāsā evāti āha – ‘‘bāhusaccenapi…pe… vicikicchā pahīyatī’’ti. Kāmaṃ bāhusaccaparipucchakatāhi sabbāpi aṭṭhavatthukā vicikicchā pahīyati, tathāpi ratanattayavicikicchāmūlikā sesavicikicchāti āha – ‘‘tīṇi ratanāni ārabbha paripucchābahulassapī’’ti. Ratanattayaguṇāvabodhehi ‘‘satthari kaṅkhatī’’tiādivicikicchāya asambhavoti. Vinaye pakataññutā ‘‘sikkhāya kaṅkhatī’’ti (dha. sa. 1008; vibha. 915) vuttāya vicikicchāya pahānaṃ karotīti āha – ‘‘vinaye ciṇṇavasībhāvassapī’’ti. Okappaniyasaddhāsaṅkhātaadhimokkhabahulassāti saddheyyavatthuno anuppavisanasaddhāsaṅkhātaadhimokkhena adhimuccanabahulassa. Adhimuccanañca adhimokkhuppādanamevāti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Saddhāya vā taṃninnapoṇatā adhimutti adhimokkho. Nīvaraṇānaṃ paccayassa ceva paccayaghātassa ca vibhāvitattā vuttaṃ – ‘‘vaṭṭavivaṭṭaṃ kathita’’nti. 20. 第十,由于多闻者能通达法性(dhammasabhāva),故无生疑之余地,因此说:“多闻亦……能断疑。”虽然通过多闻与请问,所有八事疑都能断除,但其余的疑是以关于三宝的疑为根本,故说:“即使是多请问三宝”。由于通达三宝的功德,故“于导师生疑”等疑不会生起。精通律藏者,能断除“于学处生疑”(Dhs. 1008; Vibh. 915)所说的疑,故说:“于律娴熟。”“多有胜解(adhimokkha)者”,是指对于可信之事,通过名为信的深入而多有胜解。当知胜解即是胜解的生起。或者说,以信而对此倾向、倾心,即是信解(adhimutti)、胜解(adhimokkho)。由于已阐明诸盖(nīvaraṇa)之因与断因,故说:“轮回(vaṭṭa)与解脱(vivaṭṭa)已阐明。” Nīvaraṇappahānavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 断盖品释义终。 3. Akammaniyavaggavaṇṇanā 3. 不调品释义 21. Tatiyassa paṭhame abhāvitanti samathavipassanābhāvanāvasena na bhāvitaṃ tathā abhāvitattā. Tañhi ‘‘avaḍḍhita’’nti vuccati paṭipakkhābhibhavena paribrūhanābhāvato. Tenāha bhagavā – ‘‘akammaniyaṃ hotī’’ti. 21. 第三(经)的第一(句)中,“未修习”是指没有以止(samatha)与观(vipassanā)的方式修习,因此才是未修习。这被称为“未增长”,因为缺乏通过克服对立面而达成的增长。因此,世尊说:“成为不调的。” 22. Dutiye vuttavipariyāyena attho veditabbo. Paṭhameti tatiyavaggassa paṭhamasutte. Vaṭṭavasenāti vipākavaṭṭavasena. Tebhūmakavaṭṭanti tebhūmakavipākavaṭṭaṃ. Vaṭṭapaṭilābhāya kammanti vipākavaṭṭassa paṭilābhāya upanissayabhūtaṃ kammaṃ, tassa sahāyabhūtaṃ kilesavaṭṭampi kammaggahaṇeneva saṅgahitanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Vivaṭṭapaṭilābhāya kammanti vivaṭṭādhigamassa upanissayabhūtaṃ kammaṃ. Yaṃ pana carimabhavanibbattakaṃ kammaṃ, taṃ vivaṭṭappaṭilābhāya kammaṃ hoti, na hotīti? Na hoti vaṭṭapādakabhāvato. Carimabhavapaṭisandhi [Pg.89] viya pana vivaṭṭūpanissayoti sakkā viññātuṃ. Na hi kadāci tihetukapaṭisandhiyā vinā visesādhigamo sambhavati. Imesu suttesūti imesu pana paṭhamadutiyasuttesu yathākkamaṃ vaṭṭavivaṭṭameva kathitaṃ. 22. 第二(经)应依前述相反之义理解。“第一”是指第三品的第一经。“依于轮转”即依于异熟轮转。“三地轮转”即三地异熟轮转。“为得轮转之业”是指作为获得异熟轮转之助缘的业,并且当知,作为其助伴的烦恼轮转(kilesavaṭṭa)亦包含在“业”这一概念中。“为得解脱之业”是指作为证得解脱(vivaṭṭa)之助缘的业。至于那产生最后有的业,它是否是为得解脱的业呢?不是,因为它具有作为轮转之基础的性质。但如同最后有之结生一样,可以被理解为解脱的助缘。因为若无三因结生,殊胜的证悟绝不可能发生。在这几部经中,即在这第一、第二两部经中,依次阐述了轮转(vaṭṭa)与解脱(vivaṭṭa)。 23. Tatiye abhāvitanti ettha bhāvanā nāma samādhibhāvanā. Sā yattha āsaṅkitabbā, taṃ kāmāvacarapaṭhamamahākusalacittādiabhāvitanti adhippetanti āha – ‘‘devamanussasampattiyo’’tiādi. 23. 第三(经)中,“未修习”,此处的修习是指定的修习。此修习应被预想之处,即欲界第一大善心等未被修习,其意是指“天人善趣”等。 24. Catutthe yasmā cittanti vivaṭṭavaseneva uppannacittaṃ adhippetaṃ, tasmā jātijarābyādhimaraṇasokādidukkhassa anibbattanato mahato atthāya saṃvattatīti yojanā veditabbā. 24. 第四(经)中,因为这里的心是指以解脱(vivaṭṭa)的方式生起的心,所以当知其义理连结是:由于不再产生生、老、病、死、愁等苦,故能导向大利益。 25-26. Pañcamachaṭṭhesu uppannanti avigatuppādādikhaṇattayampi abhāvitaṃ bhāvanārahitaṃ apātubhūtameva paṇḍitasammatassa uppannakiccassa asādhanato yathā ‘‘aputto’’ti. So hi samattho hutvā pitu puttakiccaṃ asādhento aputtoti loke vuccati, evaṃ sampadamidaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘kasmā’’tiādi. Tesu dhammesūti lokuttarapādakajjhānādīsu. Thero pana matthakappattameva bhāvitaṃ cittaṃ dassento ‘‘maggacittamevā’’ti āha. 25-26. 第五、第六(经)中,“已生起”是指即使是未脱离生、住、灭三刹那的(心),如果未经修习、远离修习、未曾显现,由于不能成办智者所认可的已生起(的心)的作用,就如同(世间说)“无子”一样。那人虽然有能力,却不履行儿子对父亲的义务,因此在世间被称为无子,此处也是同样的道理。因此说:“为何”等。“在那些法中”是指在作为出世间基础的禅那(jhāna)等法中。然而,长老为了显示已达顶点的修习之心,因此说:“只是道心。” 27-28. Sattamaṭṭhamesu punappunaṃ akatanti bhāvanābahulīkāravasena punappunaṃ na kataṃ. Imānipi dveti imesu dvīsu suttesu āgatāni imānipi dve cittāni. 27-28. 第七、第八(经)中,“不数数行”是指不以多次修习的方式数数而行。“此二者亦尔”是指在这两部经中出现的这两种心。 29-30. Navame adhivahatīti āneti. Dukkhenāti kicchena. Duppesanatoti dukkhena pesetabbato. Matthakappattaṃ vipassanāsukhaṃ pākatikajjhānasukhato santatarapaṇītataramevāti āha – ‘‘jhānasukhato vipassanāsukha’’nti. Tenāha bhagavā – 29-30. 第九(经)中,“运载”意为带来。“以苦”意为艰难。“难驱使”意为难以被驱使。已达顶点的观(vipassanā)之乐,比通常的禅那(jhāna)之乐更为寂静、更为殊胜,因此说:“观乐于禅乐”。世尊因此说: ‘‘Suññāgāraṃ paviṭṭhassa, santacittassa bhikkhuno; Amānusī rati hoti, sammā dhammaṃ vipassato. “比丘入空室,心意寂静者,正观于诸法,得非人安乐。” ‘‘Yato [Pg.90] yato sammasati, khandhānaṃ udayabbayaṃ; Labhatī pītipāmojjaṃ, amataṃ taṃ vijānata’’nti. (dha. pa. 374); “何时何地思,诸蕴之生灭,即得喜与乐,此乃知者之甘露。”(dha. pa. 374); Tañhi cittaṃ vissaṭṭhaindavajirasadisaṃ amoghabhāvato. 此心因其无谬性,犹如投出的因陀罗金刚杵。 Akammaniyavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 不调品释义终。 4. Adantavaggavaṇṇanā 4. 未调伏品释义 31-36. Catutthassa paṭhame adantanti cittabhāvanāya vinā na dantaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘satisaṃvararahita’’nti. Catutthe tatiye vuttavipariyāyena attho veditabbo. Pañcamachaṭṭhesu purimasadisoyevāti tatiyacatutthasadiso eva. 31-36. 第四品的第一(经)中,“未调伏”是指未经心的修习而不调伏。因此说“无念防护”。第四品第三(经)的意思应按照与前面所说相反的方式来理解。第五、六(经)与前面相同,即与第三、四(经)相同。 37-38. Sattamaṭṭhamesu upamā panetthāti yathā paṭhamādīsu adantahatthiassādayo upamābhāvena gahitā, evamettha satthamaṭṭhamesu ‘‘asaṃvutagharadvārādivasena veditabbā’’ti vuttaṃ. 37-38. 第七、第八(经)中的譬喻:正如初品等中以未调伏的象、马等作为譬喻,同样,在此第七和第八(经)中,应以“未守护的家门”等方式来理解。 39-40. Navamadasamesu catūhipi padehīti adantādīhi catūhi padehi yojetvā navamadasamāni suttāni vuttānīti yojanā. 39-40. 第九、第十(经)中,其义理连结是:第九和第十经是结合“未调伏”等四种词句而说的。 Adantavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 未调伏品释义终。 5. Paṇihitaacchavaggavaṇṇanā 5. 善立明净品释义 41. Pañcamassa paṭhame upamāva opammaṃ, so eva attho, tasmiṃ opammatthe bodhetabbe nipāto. Seyyathāpīti yathāti attho. Ettha ca tatra bhagavā katthaci atthena upamaṃ parivāretvā dasseti vatthasutte viya, pāricchattakopama (a. ni. 7.69) aggikkhandhopamādi (a. ni. 7.72) suttesu viya ca. Katthaci upamāya atthaṃ parivāretvā dasseti loṇambilasutte (a. ni. 3.101) viya, suvaṇṇakārasattasūriyopamādisuttesu [Pg.91] (a. ni. 7.66) viya ca. Imasmiṃ pana sālisūkopame upamāya atthaṃ parivāretvā dassento ‘‘seyyathāpi, bhikkhave’’tiādimāhāti potthakesu likhanti, taṃ majjhimaṭṭhakathāya vatthasuttavaṇṇanāya (ma. ni. aṭṭha. 1.70) na sameti. Tattha hi idaṃ vuttaṃ – 41. 第五品第一(经)中,“譬喻”(upamā)即是“比喻”(opamma),是同一意义,此处的助词是为了阐明比喻的含义。“譬如”(seyyathāpi)就是“如同”(yathā)的意思。在此,世尊有时用义理来围绕譬喻进行阐释,就像《衣经》(Vatthasutta)、《巴瑞恰达树《本行》》(Pāricchattakopama Sutta)和《火蕴《本行》》(Aggikkhandhopama Sutta)等经文那样;有时用譬喻来围绕义理进行阐释,就像《盐块经》(Loṇakapalla Sutta)、《金匠经》(Suvaṇṇakāra Sutta)与《七日喻经》(Sattasūriya Sutta)等经文那样。然而,在这《稻芒《本行》》(Sālisūkopama Sutta)中,(世尊)是以譬喻来围绕义理进行阐释,以“诸比丘,譬如”等开头,经书中是这样记载的,但这与《中部·义注》中《衣经》的释义并不一致。因为在那里是这样说的: Seyyathāpi, bhikkhave, vatthanti upamāvacanamevetaṃ. Upamaṃ karonto ca bhagavā katthaci paṭhamaṃyeva upamaṃ dassetvā pacchā atthaṃ dasseti, katthaci paṭhamaṃ atthaṃ dassetvā pacchā upamaṃ, katthaci upamāya atthaṃ parivāretvā dasseti, katthaci atthena upamaṃ. Tathā hesa ‘‘seyyathāpissu, bhikkhave, dve agārā sadvārā, tattha cakkhumā puriso majjhe ṭhito passeyyā’’ti sakalampi devadūtasuttaṃ (ma. ni. 3.261 ādayo) upamaṃ paṭhamaṃ dassetvā pacchā atthaṃ dassento āha. ‘‘Tirokuṭṭaṃ tiropākāraṃ tiropabbataṃ asajjamāno gacchati, seyyathāpi, ākāse’’tiādinā pana nayena sakalampi iddhividhaṃ atthaṃ paṭhamaṃ dassetvā pacchā upamaṃ dassento āha. ‘‘Seyyathāpi, brāhmaṇapuriso sāratthiko sāragavesī’’tiādinā (ma. ni. 1.314) nayena sakalampi cūḷasāropamasuttaṃ upamāya atthaṃ parivāretvā dassento āha. ‘‘Idha pana, bhikkhave, ekacce kulaputtā dhammaṃ pariyāpuṇanti suttaṃ…pe… seyyathāpi, bhikkhave, puriso alagaddatthiko’’tiādinā nayena sakalampi alagaddasuttaṃ (ma. ni. 1.238) mahāsāropamasuttanti evamādīni suttāni atthena upamaṃ parivāretvā dassento āha. Svāyaṃ idha paṭhamaṃ upamaṃ dassetvā pacchā atthaṃ dassetīti. 诸比丘,“犹如”,这只是譬喻的说法。世尊作譬喻时,有时先说譬喻后说义理,有时先说义理后说譬喻,有时用譬喻围绕义理,有时用义理围绕譬喻。例如,世尊在整部《天神使者经》(Devadūtasutta)中,先说譬喻后说义理,说道:“诸比丘,譬如有两座带门的屋子,有眼之人站在中间便能看见……”。又如,在关于神通变化的整个段落中,先说义理后说譬喻,说道:“能穿墙、穿壁、穿山无碍,犹如在空中……”。又如,在整部《小木髓《本行》》(Cūḷasāropamasutta)中,世尊用譬喻围绕义理,说道:“譬如,需要木髓的婆罗门男子去寻找……”。又如,在《蛇喻经》(Alagaddasutta)、《大木髓《本行》》(Mahāsāropamasutta)等经中,世尊用义理围绕譬喻,说道:“诸比丘,于此,有些良家子学习佛法……譬如需要蛇的人……”。此处就是先举譬喻后说义理。 Ettha hi cūḷasāropamādīsu (ma. ni. 1.312) paṭhamaṃ upamaṃ vatvā tadanantaraṃ upameyyatthaṃ vatvā puna upamaṃ vadanto upamāya atthaṃ parivāretvā dassetīti vutto. Alagaddūpamasuttādīsu pana atthaṃ paṭhamaṃ vatvā tadanantaraṃ upamaṃ vatvā puna atthaṃ vadanto atthena upamaṃ parivāretvā dassetīti vutto. Tenevettha līnatthappakāsiniyaṃ vuttaṃ – ‘‘upameyyatthaṃ paṭhamaṃ vatvā tadanantaraṃ atthaṃ vatvā puna upamaṃ vadanto upamāya atthaṃ parivāretvā [Pg.92] dassetī’’ti vutto. Atthena upamaṃ parivāretvāti etthāpi eseva nayoti. Idha pana katthaci atthena upamaṃ parivāretvā dasseti. ‘‘Vatthasutte viya pāricchattakopamaaggikkhandhopamādisuttesu viya cā’’ti vuttaṃ. Tattha vatthasutte tāva ‘‘seyyathāpi, bhikkhave, vatthaṃ saṃkiliṭṭhaṃ malaggahitaṃ, tamenaṃ rajako yasmiṃ yasmiṃ raṅgajāte upasaṃhareyya. Yadi nīlakāya, yadi pītakāya, yadi lohitakāya, yadi mañjiṭṭhakāya, durattavaṇṇamevassa aparisuddhavaṇṇamevassa. Taṃ kissa hetu? Aparisuddhattā, bhikkhave, vatthassa. Evameva kho, bhikkhave, citte saṃkiliṭṭhe duggati pāṭikaṅkhā’’tiādinā (ma. ni. 1.70) paṭhamaṃ upamaṃ dassetvā pacchā upameyyattho vutto, na pana paṭhamaṃ atthaṃ vatvā tadanantaraṃ upamaṃ dassetvā puna attho vutto. Yena katthaci atthena upamaṃ parivāretvā dasseti. Vatthasutte viyāti vadeyya. 于此,如《小木髓《本行》》(Ma. Ni. 1.312)等经中,是先说譬喻,接着说被喻之义,然后再说譬喻,这被称为“以譬喻围绕义理”而开示。然而在《蛇喻经》等经中,则是先说义理,接着说譬喻,再重复义理,这被称为“以义理围绕譬喻”而开示。因此,在《隐义显明论》(Līnatthappakāsinī)中说:“先说被喻之义,接着说义理,再重复譬喻,这被称为‘以譬喻围绕义理’而开示。”“以义理围绕譬喻”于此也是同样的方法。然而此处,“有时以义理围绕譬喻来显示,就像《衣经》(Vatthasutta)和《巴瑞恰达树譬喻》、《火蕴譬喻》等经中所说的那样”。其中,在《衣经》中:“诸比丘,譬如一件被污染、沾染尘垢的衣服,染匠无论用哪种染料——无论是蓝色、黄色、红色还是茜草色——来染色,其颜色都会很差,颜色不纯净。那是什么原因呢?诸比丘,因为衣服不干净。同样的,诸比丘,如果心被污染,则可预期堕于恶趣。”(Ma. Ni. 1.70)等,是先显示譬喻,之后才说被喻之义,而不是先说义理,接着显示譬喻,然后再重复义理。凭什么说这是“有时以义理围绕譬喻来显示,就像《衣经》那样”呢? Tathā pāricchattakopamepi ‘‘yasmiṃ, bhikkhave, samaye devānaṃ tāvatiṃsānaṃ pāricchattako koviḷāro paṇḍupalāso hoti, attamanā, bhikkhave, devā tāvatiṃsā, tasmiṃ samaye honti paṇḍupalāso dāni pāricchattako koviḷāro, na cirasseva dāni pannapalāso bhavissati…pe… evameva kho, bhikkhave, yasmiṃ samaye ariyasāvako agārasmā anagāriyaṃ pabbajjāya ceteti. Paṇḍupalāso, bhikkhave, ariyasāvako tasmiṃ samaye hotī’’tiādinā (a. ni. 7.69) paṭhamaṃ upamaṃ dassetvā pacchā attho vutto. Aggikkhandhopame ‘‘passatha no tumhe, bhikkhave, amuṃ mahantaṃ aggikkhandhaṃ ādittaṃ sampajjalitaṃ sajotibhūtanti. Evaṃ, bhanteti. Taṃ kiṃ maññatha, bhikkhave, katamaṃ nu kho varaṃ yaṃ amuṃ mahantaṃ aggikkhandhaṃ ādittaṃ sampajjalitaṃ sajotibhūtaṃ āliṅgetvā upanisīdeyya vā upanipajjeyya vā, yaṃ khattiyakaññaṃ vā brāhmaṇakaññaṃ vā gahapatikaññaṃ vā mudutalunahatthapādaṃ āliṅgetvā upanisīdeyya vā upanipajjeyya vā’’tiādinā (a. ni. 7.72) paṭhamaṃ upamaṃyeva dassetvā pacchā attho vutto, na pana paṭhamaṃ atthaṃ vatvā tadanantaraṃ upamaṃ dassetvā puna attho vutto, tasmā ‘‘katthaci atthena upamaṃ parivāretvā dasseti vatthasutte viya pāricchattakopamaaggikkhandhopamādisuttesu viya cā’’ti na vattabbaṃ. 同样,在《巴瑞恰达树譬喻》中:“诸比丘,当三十三天众的巴瑞恰达树(pāricchattaka)树叶变黄时,诸比丘,三十三天众那时心生欢喜:‘巴瑞恰达树如今树叶变黄,不久将落叶……’……诸比丘,正是如此,当圣弟子思虑从在家而出家时,诸比丘,圣弟子在那时就如同那变黄的树叶。”(A. Ni. 7.69)等,是先显示譬喻,之后才说义理。在《火蕴譬喻》中:“诸比丘,你们看见那大火蕴,点燃、燃烧、发光吗?”“是的,世尊。”“诸比丘,你们怎么想?是拥抱那点燃、燃烧、发光的大火蕴而坐下或躺下更好,还是拥抱手脚柔软的刹帝利女、婆罗门女或居士女而坐下或躺下更好呢?”(A. Ni. 7.72)等,也是先显示譬喻,之后才说义理,而不是先说义理,接着显示譬喻,然后再重复义理。因此,不应该说“有时以义理围绕譬喻而显示,就像《衣经》、《巴瑞恰达树譬喻》和《火蕴譬喻》等经中所说的那样”。 Keci [Pg.93] panettha evaṃ vaṇṇayanti ‘‘atthaṃ paṭhamaṃ vatvā pacchā ca upamaṃ dassento atthena upamaṃ parivāretvā dasseti nāma, upamaṃ pana paṭhamaṃ vatvā pacchā atthaṃ dassento upamāya atthaṃ parivāretvā dasseti nāma, tadubhayassapi āgataṭṭhānaṃ nidassento ‘vatthasutte viyā’tiādimāhā’’ti. Tampi ‘‘katthaci atthena upamaṃ parivāretvā dasseti vatthasutte viya pāricchattakopamaaggikkhandhopamādisuttesu viya cā’’ti vattabbaṃ, evañca vuccamāne ‘‘katthaci upamāya atthaṃ parivāretvā dasseti loṇambilasutte viyā’’ti visuṃ na vattabbaṃ ‘‘aggikkhandhopamādisutte viyā’’ti ettha ādisaddeneva saṅgahitattā. Loṇambilasuttepi hi – 于此,有些人如此解释:“先说义理后说譬喻,这称为‘以义理围绕譬喻’而开示;而先说譬喻后说义理,这称为‘以譬喻围绕义理’而开示。为了表明这两种情况都有出处,所以说‘如《衣经》等’。”即便如此,也应说:“有时以义理围绕譬喻来开示,如《衣经》(Vatthasutta)、《巴瑞恰达树譬喻》(Pāricchattakopama)、《火蕴譬喻》(Aggikkhandhopama)等经。”如此说时,便不必另外说“有时以譬喻围绕义理来开示,如《咸酸味喻经》(Loṇambilasutta) ”,因为“《火蕴譬喻》等经”中的“等”字已包含了它。在《咸酸味喻经》中也是如此: ‘‘Seyyathāpi, bhikkhave, paṇḍito byatto kusalo sūdo rājānaṃ vā rājamahāmattaṃ vā nānaccayehi sūpehi paccupaṭṭhito assa ambilaggehipi tittakaggehipi kaṭukaggehipi madhuraggehipi khārikehipi akhārikehipi loṇikehipi aloṇikehipi. “诸比丘,譬如一位贤明、干练、善巧的厨师,为国王或大臣准备了各种汤品:酸味的、苦味的、辣味的、甜味的、碱味的、非碱味的、咸的、不咸的。” ‘‘Sa kho so, bhikkhave, paṇḍito byatto kusalo sūdo sakassa bhattassa nimittaṃ uggaṇhāti ‘idaṃ vā me ajja bhattasūpeyyaṃ ruccati, imassa vā abhiharati, imassa vā bahuṃ gaṇhāti, imassa vā vaṇṇaṃ bhāsati. Ambilaggaṃ vā me ajja bhattasūpeyyaṃ ruccati, ambilaggassa vā abhiharati, ambilaggassa vā bahuṃ gaṇhāti, ambilaggassa vā vaṇṇaṃ bhāsati…pe… aloṇikassa vā vaṇṇaṃ bhāsatī’ti. Sa kho so, bhikkhave, paṇḍito byatto kusalo sūdo lābhī ceva hoti acchādanassa, lābhī vetanassa, lābhī abhihārānaṃ. Taṃ kissa hetu? Tathā hi so, bhikkhave, paṇḍito byatto kusalo sūdo sakassa bhattanimittaṃ uggaṇhāti. Evameva kho, bhikkhave, idhekacco paṇḍito byatto kusalo bhikkhu kāye kāyānupassī viharati…pe… vedanāsu…pe… citte…pe… dhammesu dhammānupassī viharati ātāpī sampajāno satimā vineyya loke abhijjhādomanassaṃ. Tassa dhammesu dhammānupassino viharato cittaṃ samādhiyati, upakkilesā pahīyanti, so taṃ nimittaṃ uggaṇhāti. “诸比丘,那贤明、干练、聪慧的厨师,会掌握其主人的饮食征相:‘今天我的主人喜欢这种菜肴,他会取用这种,会多拿这种,会称赞这种。或者今天我的主人喜欢酸味的菜肴,他会取用酸味的,会多拿酸味的,会称赞酸味的……乃至……会称赞无盐的。’诸比丘,那贤明、干练、聪慧的厨师,能获得衣服、薪水和赏赐。这是什么原因呢?诸比丘,因为那贤明、干练、聪慧的厨师,掌握其主人的饮食征相。同样地,诸比丘,于此,有位贤明、干练、聪慧的比丘,于身随观身而住……于受……于心……于法随观法而住,热忱、正知、具念,调伏世间的贪与忧。当他于法随观法而住时,心得以安定,诸随烦恼被断除,他便掌握了那个相。” ‘‘Sa [Pg.94] kho, bhikkhave, paṇḍito byatto kusalo bhikkhu lābhī ceva hoti diṭṭheva dhamme sukhavihārānaṃ, lābhī hoti satisampajaññassa. Taṃ kissa hetu? Tathā hi so, bhikkhave, paṇḍito byatto kusalo bhikkhu sakassa cittassa nimittaṃ uggaṇhātī’’ti (saṃ. ni. 5.374) – “诸比丘,那贤明、干练、聪慧的比丘,能获得现法乐住,能获得念与正知。这是什么原因呢?诸比丘,因为那贤明、干练、聪慧的比丘,掌握了自心之相。” Evaṃ paṭhamaṃ upamaṃ dassetvā pacchā attho vutto. ‘‘Suvaṇṇakārasūriyopamādisuttesu viya cā’’ti idañca udāharaṇamattena saṅgahaṃ gacchati suvaṇṇakārasuttādīsu paṭhamaṃ upamāya adassitattā. Etesu hi suvaṇṇakāropamasutte (a. ni. 3.103) tāva – 如此,先示譬喻,后说其义。而“犹如《金匠经》与《太阳经》等”此句,仅为概括举例而已,因为在《金匠经》(Suvaṇṇakārasutta)等经中,并非先示譬喻。在这些经中,例如于《金匠《本行》》(Suvaṇṇakāropamasutta)中: ‘‘Adhicittamanuyuttena, bhikkhave, bhikkhunā tīṇi nimittāni kālena kālaṃ manasi kātabbāni, kālena kālaṃ samādhinimittaṃ manasi kātabbaṃ, kālena kālaṃ paggahanimittaṃ manasi kātabbaṃ, kālena kālaṃ upekkhānimittaṃ manasi kātabbaṃ. Sace, bhikkhave, adhicittamanuyutto bhikkhu ekantaṃ samādhinimittaṃyeva manasi kareyya, ṭhānaṃ taṃ cittaṃ kosajjāya saṃvatteyya. Sace, bhikkhave, adhicittamanuyutto bhikkhu ekantaṃ paggahanimittaṃyeva manasi kareyya, ṭhānaṃ taṃ cittaṃ uddhaccāya saṃvatteyya. Sace, bhikkhave, adhicittamanuyutto bhikkhu ekantaṃ upekkhānimittaṃyeva manasi kareyya, ṭhānaṃ taṃ cittaṃ na sammā samādhiyeyya āsavānaṃ khayāya. Yato ca kho, bhikkhave, adhicittamanuyutto bhikkhu kālena kālaṃ samādhinimittaṃ…pe… paggahanimittaṃ…pe… upekkhānimittaṃ manasi karoti, taṃ hoti cittaṃ muduñca kammaniyañca pabhassarañca, na ca pabhaṅgu, sammā samādhiyati āsavānaṃ khayāya. “诸比丘,致力于增上心的比丘,应当适时作意三相:适时作意定相,适时作意策励相,适时作意舍相。诸比丘,若致力于增上心的比丘,仅仅作意定相,其心则可能趋向于懈怠。诸比丘,若致力于增上心的比丘,仅仅作意策励相,其心则可能趋向于掉举。诸比丘,若致力于增上心的比丘,仅仅作意舍相,其心则不能为断尽诸漏而正等持。然而,诸比丘,当致力于增上心的比丘,适时作意定相……策励相……舍相时,其心变得柔软、适业、光净且不败坏,为断尽诸漏而正等持。” ‘‘Seyyathāpi, bhikkhave, suvaṇṇakāro vā suvaṇṇakārantevāsī vā ukkaṃ bandheyya, ukkaṃ bandhitvā ukkāmukhaṃ ālimpeyya, ukkāmukhaṃ ālimpitvā saṇḍāsena jātarūpaṃ gahetvā ukkāmukhe pakkhipeyya, ukkāmukhe pakkhipitvā kālena kālaṃ abhidhamati, kālena kālaṃ udakena paripphoseti, kālena kālaṃ ajjhupekkhati. Sace, bhikkhave, suvaṇṇakāro vā suvaṇṇakārantevāsī vā taṃ jātarūpaṃ ekantaṃ abhidhameyya, ṭhānaṃ taṃ jātarūpaṃ [Pg.95] daheyya. Sace, bhikkhave, suvaṇṇakāro vā suvaṇṇakārantevāsī vā taṃ jātarūpaṃ ekantaṃ udakena paripphoseyya, ṭhānaṃ taṃ jātarūpaṃ nibbāpeyya. Sace, bhikkhave, suvaṇṇakāro vā suvaṇṇakārantevāsī vā taṃ jātarūpaṃ ekantaṃ ajjhupekkheyya, ṭhānaṃ taṃ jātarūpaṃ na sammā paripākaṃ gaccheyya. Yato ca kho, bhikkhave, suvaṇṇakāro vā suvaṇṇakārantevāsī vā taṃ jātarūpaṃ kālena kālaṃ abhidhamati, kālena kālaṃ udakena paripphoseti, kālena kālaṃ ajjhupekkhati, taṃ hoti jātarūpaṃ muduñca kammaniyañca pabhassarañca, na ca pabhaṅgu, sammā upeti kammāya. Yassā yassā ca piḷandhanavikatiyā ākaṅkhati, yadi paṭṭikāya yadi kuṇḍalāya yadi gīveyyakena yadi suvaṇṇamālāya, tañcassa atthaṃ anubhoti. “诸比丘,譬如金匠或金匠的学徒,建起熔炉,建好熔炉后涂抹炉口,涂好炉口后用钳子夹起黄金放入炉口。放入炉口后,他适时鼓风,适时洒水,适时静置。诸比丘,若金匠或金匠的学徒对那黄金一味地鼓风,那黄金就可能烧毁。若金匠或金匠的学徒对那黄金一味地洒水,那黄金就可能熄灭。若金匠或金匠的学徒对那黄金一味地静置,那黄金就不能完全成熟。而诸比丘,当金匠或金匠的学徒对那黄金适时鼓风,适时洒水,适时静置时,那黄金变得柔软、适业、光净且不败坏,完全适于作业。无论他想制作何种饰品,如饰带、耳环、项链或金鬘,都能达成其目的。” ‘‘Evameva kho, bhikkhave, adhicittamanuyuttena bhikkhu…pe… sammā samādhiyati āsavānaṃ khayāya. Yassa yassa ca abhiññāsacchikaraṇīyassa dhammassa cittaṃ abhininnāmeti abhiññāsacchikiriyāya, tatra tatreva sakkhibhabbataṃ pāpuṇāti sati satiāyatane’’ti (a. ni. 3.103) – “诸比丘,同样地,致力于增上心的比丘……乃至……为断尽诸漏而正等持。无论对于哪种应以胜智亲证的法,当他为亲证而倾心于此时,只要因缘具足,他就在彼彼之处达到能够亲证的状态。” Evaṃ paṭhamaṃ atthaṃ dassetvā tadatantaraṃ upamaṃ vatvā punapi attho evaṃ paṭhamaṃ atthaṃ dassetvā tadanantaraṃ upamaṃ vatvā punapi attho vutto. 如此,先开示义理,接着说譬喻,然后又再解说义理。 Sattasūriyopame ca – 在《七日经》(Sattasūriya Sutta)的譬喻中—— ‘‘Aniccā, bhikkhave, saṅkhārā, adhuvā, bhikkhave, saṅkhārā, anassāsikā, bhikkhave, saṅkhārā, yāvañcidaṃ, bhikkhave, alameva sabbasaṅkhāresu nibbindituṃ alaṃ virajjituṃ alaṃ vimuccituṃ. Sineru, bhikkhave, pabbatarājā caturāsītiyojanasahassāni āyāmena, caturāsītiyojanasahassāni vitthārena, caturāsītiyojanasahassāni mahāsamudde ajjhogāḷho, caturāsītiyojanasahassāni mahāsamuddā accuggato. Hoti so kho, bhikkhave, samayo, yaṃ kadāci karahaci dīghassa addhuno accayena bahūni vassāni bahūni vassasatāni bahūni vassasahassāni bahūni vassasatasahassāni devo na vassati, deve [Pg.96] kho pana, bhikkhave, avassante ye kecime bījagāmabhūtagāmā osadhitiṇavanappatayo, te ussussanti visussanti na bhavanti. Evaṃ aniccā, bhikkhave, saṅkhārā, evaṃ adhuvā, bhikkhave, saṅkhārā’’tiādinā (a. ni. 7.66) – “诸比丘,诸行无常;诸比丘,诸行不恒;诸比丘,诸行不可靠。诸比丘,于此,足以对一切行厌离,足以离欲,足以解脱。诸比丘,山王须弥山(Sineru)长八万四千由旬,宽八万四千由旬,深入大海八万四千由旬,高出大海八万四千由旬。有这样一个时期,经过漫长时日,许多年、许多百年、许多千年、许多十万年,天不降雨。诸比丘,天不降雨时,所有种子生的、根生的植物、药草、草木,都会干枯、枯萎,不复存在。诸比丘,诸行就是如此无常,诸行就是如此不恒。” Paṭhamaṃ atthaṃ dassetvā tadanantaraṃ upamaṃ vatvā punapi attho vutto. Atha vā ‘‘sūriyassa, bhikkhave, udayato etaṃ pubbaṅgamaṃ etaṃ pubbanimittaṃ, yadidaṃ aruṇuggaṃ. Evameva kho, bhikkhave, bhikkhuno ariyassa aṭṭhaṅgikassa maggassa uppādāya etaṃ pubbaṅgamaṃ etaṃ pubbanimittaṃ, yadidaṃ kalyāṇamittatā’’ti yadetaṃ saṃyuttanikāye (saṃ. ni. 5.49) āgataṃ, taṃ idha sūriyopamasuttanti adhippetaṃ siyā. Tampi ‘‘katthaci upamāya atthaṃ parivāretvā dassetī’’ti iminā na sameti paṭhamaṃ upamaṃ vatvā tadanantaraṃ atthaṃ dassetvā puna upamāya avuttattā. Paṭhamameva hi tattha upamā dassitā, ‘‘imasmiṃ pana sālisūkopame upamāya atthaṃ parivāretvā dassento seyyathāpi, bhikkhaveti ādimāhā’’ti. Idampi vacanamasaṅgahitaṃ vatthasuttassa imassa ca visesābhāvato. Ubhayatthāpi hi paṭhamaṃ upamaṃ dassetvā pacchā attho vutto, tasmā evamettha pāṭhena bhavitabbaṃ ‘‘tatra bhagavā katthaci paṭhamaṃyeva upamaṃ dassetvā pacchā atthaṃ dasseti vatthasutte viya pāricchattakopama- (a. ni. 7.69) aggikkhandhopamādisuttesu (a. ni. 7.72) viya ca, katthaci atthena upamaṃ parivāretvā dasseti suvaṇṇakārasattasūriyopamādisuttesu (a. ni. 7.66) viya, imasmiṃ pana sālisūkopame paṭhamaṃ upamaṃ dassetvā pacchā atthaṃ dassento seyyathāpi, bhikkhaveti ādimāhā’’ti. Aññathā majjhimaṭṭhakathāya virujjhati. Idhāpi ca pubbenāparaṃ na sameti. Majjhimaṭṭhakathāya vuttanayeneva vā idhāpi pāṭho gahetabbo. 首先开示义理,其后说譬喻,再复说义理。或者,“诸比丘,太阳升起有此前行、此前相,即是黎明。诸比丘,正是如此,比丘生起圣八支道亦有此前行、此前相,即是善友。”这句出自《相应部》(saṃ. ni. 5.49)的话,在此处或意指《日喻经》(Sūriyopamasutta)。但这也不符合“有时用譬喻环绕义理而开示”之说,因为(经中)是先说譬喻,后开示义理,之后未再重说譬喻。因为在那里,一开始就开示了譬喻。“然而,在此《稻秆喻经》(Sālisūkopama)中,是以譬喻环绕义理而开示,故说‘诸比丘,犹如……’”——此说亦不成立,因为它与《衣经》(Vatthasutta)并无差别。因为在这两部经中,都是先开示譬喻,后说义理。因此,此处的文句应为:“在那里,世尊有时先开示譬喻,后开示义理,如《衣经》、《巴瑞恰达树喻经》(Pāricchattakopama, a. ni. 7.69)、《火蕴喻经》(Aggikkhandhopama, a. ni. 7.72)等;有时用义理环绕譬喻而开示,如《金匠经》(Suvaṇṇakāra)、《七日经》(Sattasūriya, a. ni. 7.66)等;然而,在此《稻秆喻经》中,是先开示譬喻,后开示义理,故说‘诸比丘,犹如……’”。否则,便与《中部义注》(Majjhimaṭṭhakathā)相违。并且,此处(的解释)也与前文不符。或者,此处也应依《中部义注》所说之理来理解经文。 Kaṇasadiso sāliphalassa tuṇḍe uppajjanakavālo sālisūkaṃ, tathā yavasūkaṃ. Sūkassa tanukabhāvato bhedavato bhedo nātimahā hotīti āha – ‘‘bhindissati, chaviṃ chindissatīti attho’’ti. Yathā micchāṭhapitasālisūkādi akkantampi hatthādiṃ na bhindati bhindituṃ ayoggabhāvena ṭhitattā, evaṃ ācayagāmicittaṃ avijjaṃ na bhindati bhindituṃ [Pg.97] ayoggabhāvena uppannattāti imamatthaṃ dasseti ‘‘micchāṭhapitenā’’tiādinā. Aṭṭhasu ṭhānesūti ‘‘dukkhe aññāṇa’’ntiādinā vuttesu dukkhādīsu catūsu saccesu pubbantādīsu catūsu cāti aṭṭhasu ṭhānesu. Ghanabahalanti cirakālaparibhāvanāya ativiya bahalaṃ. Mahāvisayatāya mahāpaṭipakkhatāya bahuparivāratāya bahudukkhatāya ca mahatī avijjāti mahāavijjā. Taṃ mahāavijjaṃ. Mahāsaddo hi bahubhāvatthopi hoti ‘‘mahājano’’tiādīsu viya. Taṇhāvānato nikkhantabhāvenāti tattha taṇhāya abhāvameva vadati. 稻芒(sālisūka)是稻谷顶端生出的、状如微尘的毛,麦芒(yavasūka)也是如此。因芒细薄易断,其所造成的伤口不大,故说:“它会刺入,意即会割破皮肤。”譬如放置不当的稻芒等物,即使被手脚等踩到,因其所处位置不宜刺入,故不能刺穿;同样地,趣向积集的心,因其生起时即不宜于断除,故不能断除无明。此义由“放置不当”等语所开示。“于八处”,即于“于苦无知”等所说的苦等四谛,以及于过去际等四处,共八处。“坚固厚重”(Ghanabahala),是说因长时熏习而极为厚重。因其所缘广大、敌对强大、眷属众多、苦报深重,故无明为“大无明”(mahāavijjā)。“大”(mahā)字亦有“多”义,如“大众”(mahājano)等。所谓“已出离贪爱之交织”,是说彼处无有贪爱。 42. Dutiye pādeneva avamaddite akkantanti vuccamāne hatthena avamadditaṃ akkantaṃ viya akkantanti ruḷhī hesāti āha – ‘‘akkantanteva vutta’’nti. Ariyavohāroti ariyadesavāsīnaṃ vohāro. Mahantaṃ aggahetvā appamattakasseva gahaṇe payojanaṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘kasmā panā’’tiādi āraddhaṃ. Tena ‘‘vivaṭṭūpanissayakusalaṃ nāma yoniso uppāditaṃ appaka’’nti na cintetabbaṃ, anukkamena laddhapaccayaṃ hutvā vaḍḍhamānaṃ khuddakanadī viya pakkhandamahoghā samuddaṃ, anukkamena nibbānamahāsamuddameva purisaṃ pāpetīti dīpeti. Paccekabodhiṃ buddhabhūminti ca paccatte upayogavacanaṃ. Vaṭṭavivaṭṭaṃ kathitanti yathākkamena vuttaṃ. 42. 第二,当说“踩踏”(akkanta)是指以足压制时,以手压制亦可称为“踩踏”,此为惯用语,故说:“即称为‘踩踏’”。“圣言”(Ariyavohāra)即圣地居民的言说。为显示不取大者而取微小者之用意,故开始“为何……”等论述。因此,不应思惟:“名为‘还灭依止善’(vivaṭṭūpanissayakusala)者,只是少量如理生起而已。”此是为阐明:它虽如小河,但次第获得助缘而增长,终如奔腾的洪流汇入大海,能次第引导人到达涅槃(nibbāna)大海洋。“独觉菩提”(paccekabodhi)与“佛地”(buddhabhūmi)是各自适用的词语。“流转与还灭”(vaṭṭavivaṭṭa)是依序而说。 43. Tatiye dosena paduṭṭhacittanti sampayuttadhammānaṃ, yasmiṃ santāne uppajjati, tassa ca dūsanena visasaṃsaṭṭhapūtimuttasadisena dosena padūsitacittaṃ. Attano cittenāti attano cetopariyañāṇena sabbaññutaññāṇena vā sahitena cittena. Paricchinditvāti ñāṇena paricchinditvā. Iṭṭhākārena etīti ayo, sukhaṃ. Sabbaso apeto ayo etassa, etasmāti vā apāyo, kāyikassa cetasikassa ca dukkhassa gati pavattiṭṭhānanti duggati, kāraṇāvasena vividhaṃ vikārena ca nipātiyanti etthāti vinipāto, appakopi natthi ayo sukhaṃ etthāti nirayoti evamettha attho veditabbo. 43. 第三,“因瞋而心秽”(dosena paduṭṭhacittaṃ)者,谓心与相应法(sampayuttadhammā)一同,于其生起之相续中,被瞋所污染,此瞋能败坏其心与相续,如同混有毒药的腐臭尿液。“以自心”(Attano cittena),即以伴随自己他心智(cetopariyañāṇa)或一切知智(sabbaññutaññāṇa)之心。“遍察”(Paricchinditvā),即以智遍察。“乐”(ayo),因其以可意之相而来(iṭṭhākārena eti),即是安乐(sukha)。“恶趣”(apāyo),因其完全远离(apeto)安乐(ayo)。“恶道”(duggati),是身心之苦的去处(gati)、生起处。“堕处”(vinipāto),是众生因各种缘由与变异而堕落(nipātīyanti)之处。“地狱”(nirayo),是此处无有(natthi)安乐(ayo)。此中之义,应如是了知。 44. Catutthe saddhāpasādena pasannanti saddhāsaṅkhātena pasādena pasannaṃ, na indriyānaṃ avippasannatāya. Sukhassa gatinti sukhassa pavattiṭṭhānaṃ. Sukhamevettha gacchanti, na dukkhanti vā sugati. Manāpiyarūpāditāya saha aggehīti saggaṃ, lokaṃ. 44. 第四,“以信净而心净”(saddhāpasādena pasannaṃ),是指以名为“信”的净信而清净,而非因诸根的不清明。“乐之趣”(Sukhassa gati),即乐的生起处。或因此处唯趣向乐(sukha)而非苦,故名“善趣”(sugati)。因有可意(manāpiya)的色等,且与最胜(agga)者同在,故名“天界”(sagga),即世间(loka)。 45. Pañcame [Pg.98] pariḷāhavūpasamakaro rahado etthāti rahado, udakapuṇṇo rahado udakarahado. Udakaṃ dahati dhāretīti udakadaho. Āviloti kalalabahulatāya ākulo. Tenāha – ‘‘avippasanno’’ti. Luḷitoti vātena āloḷito. Tenāha – ‘‘aparisaṇṭhito’’ti. Vātābhighātena vīcitaraṅgamalasamākulatāya hi parito na saṇṭhito vā aparisaṇṭhito. Vātābhighātena udakassa ca appabhāvena kalalībhūto kaddamabhāvappattoti āha – ‘‘kaddamībhūto’’ti. Sippiyo muttasippiādayo. Sambukā saṅkhasalākavisesā. Carantampi tiṭṭhantampīti yathālābhavacanametaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. Tameva hi yathālābhavacanataṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘etthā’’tiādi āraddhaṃ. 45. 第五,“湖”(rahado),因此处有能平息热恼(pariḷāha)的湖。充满水的湖,即“水湖”(udakarahado)。能容纳(dahati)或保持(dhāreti)水,故名“水池”(udakadaho)。“浑浊”(āvilo),是因泥多而混浊。故说“不清澈”(avippasanno)。“搅动”(luḷito),是被风搅动。故说“不平静”(aparisaṇṭhito)。因风吹打,充满波浪、浮沫与污垢,故四周不平静,或说“不宁静”。因风吹打及水量不足而变成泥泞,达到泥泞的状态,故说“成泥”(kaddamībhūto)。“贝”(sippiyo)指珍珠贝等。“螺”(sambukā)指某种特定的螺贝。“或行或住”,当知此是随宜之说。为显示此随宜之说,故开始“在此……”等论述。 Pariyonaddhenāti paṭicchāditena. Tayidaṃ kāraṇena āvilabhāvassa dassanaṃ. Diṭṭhadhamme imasmiṃ attabhāve bhavo diṭṭhadhammiko, so pana lokiyopi hoti lokuttaropīti āha – ‘‘lokiyalokuttaramissako’’ti. Pecca samparetabbato samparāyo, paraloko. Tenāha – ‘‘so hi parattha atthoti parattho’’ti. Iti dvidhāpi sakasantatipariyāpanno eva gahitoti itarampi saṅgahetvā dassetuṃ – ‘‘apicā’’tiādimāha. Ayanti kusalakammapathasaṅkhāto dasavidho dhammo. Satthantarakappāvasāneti idaṃ tassa āsannabhāvaṃ sandhāya vuttaṃ. Yassa kassaci antarakappassāvasāneti veditabbaṃ. Ariyānaṃ yuttanti ariyānaṃ ariyabhāvāya yuttaṃ, tato eva ariyabhāvaṃ kātuṃ samatthaṃ. Ñāṇameva ñeyyassa paccakkhakaraṇaṭṭhena dassananti āha – ‘‘ñāṇameva hī’’tiādi. Kiṃ pana tanti āha – ‘‘dibbacakkhū’’tiādi. “被缠缚”(Pariyonaddhena),意即“被覆盖”(paṭicchāditena)。此是开示(心)因(烦恼)而浑浊之状。“现法”(Diṭṭhadhamma)即此自体中之存在,是为“现法之利”(diṭṭhadhammiko)。而此又通于世间与出世间,故说“世间与出世间混合”。“后世”(samparāyo),因死后(pecca)当往,即是来世(paraloko)。故说:“彼实为他处之利,故为‘他利’(parattho)。”如是,两种利益皆摄于自身相续中,为亦包含其他,故说“再者……”。此即名为十善业道之十种法。“刀杖中劫末”是针对其临近状态而说。当知,这是指任何一个中劫的末期。“圣者所宜”(Ariyānaṃ yuttaṃ),即适合圣者成就圣性,因此能成就圣性。“见”(dassana)即是智,因其能现见所知法,故说“实乃智……”。此为何者?答曰:“天眼……”。 46. Chaṭṭhe acchoti tanuko. Tanubhāvameva hi sandhāya ‘‘abahalo’’ti vuttaṃ. Yasmā pasanno nāma accho na bahalo, tasmā ‘‘pasannotipi vaṭṭatī’’ti vuttaṃ. Vippasannoti visesena pasanno. So pana sammā pasanno nāma hotīti āha – ‘‘suṭṭhu pasanno’’ti. Anāviloti akaluso. Tenāha – ‘‘parisuddho’’tiādi. Saṅkhanti khuddakasevālaṃ, yaṃ ‘‘tilabījaka’’nti vuccati. Sevālanti kaṇṇikasevālaṃ. Paṇakanti udakamalaṃ. Cittassa āvilabhāvo nīvaraṇahetukoti āha – ‘‘anāvilenāti pañcanīvaraṇavimuttenā’’ti. 46. 第六句,“accho”意为“清澈”。正是指其清澈之性,故说“不浓稠”。因清澈者(pasanno)本是清澈(accho)而非浓稠,故说“亦可称之为清澈”。“Vippasanno”指特别清澈。彼乃真正之清澈者,故说“极清澈”。“Anāvilo”意为无浊。故说“纯净”等语。苔藓(saṅkha)指微小水草,即所谓“芝麻籽”。水藻(sevāla)指一种水藻(kaṇṇikasevālaṃ)。水垢(paṇaka)指水中污垢。心之浑浊状态乃由五盖所致,故说“无浊(anāvilena)即解脱五盖”。 47. Sattame [Pg.99] rukkhajātānīti ettha jātasaddena padavaḍḍhanameva kataṃ yathā ‘‘kosajāta’’nti āha – ‘‘rukkhānamevetaṃ adhivacana’’nti. Koci hi rukkho vaṇṇena aggo hoti yathā taṃ rattacandanādi. Koci gandhena yathā taṃ gosītacandanaṃ. Koci rasena khadirādi. Koci thaddhatāya campakādi. Maggaphalāvahatāya vipassanāvasena bhāvitampi gahitaṃ. ‘‘Tattha tattheva sakkhibhabbataṃ pāpuṇātī’’ti (a. ni. 3.103) vacanato ‘‘abhiññāpādakacatutthajjhānacittameva, āvuso’’ti phussamittatthero vadati. 47. 第七句,“rukkhajātāni”(树木种类)中,此处“jāta”(种类)一词仅为词语之增广,如说“kosajāta”(丝所生),故说:“此即树木之异名。”有些树木因颜色而最上,如红檀香(rattacandana)等;有些因气味而最上,如牛头旃檀(gosītacandana);有些因味道而最上,如儿茶(khadira)等;有些因坚硬而最上,如瞻波迦(campaka)等。以观(vipassanā)修习而能带来道果者亦被摄取。依“于彼处即能作证”之语,弗沙蜜多(Phussamitta)长老说:“贤友,此即神通基础(abhiññāpādaka)之第四禅心。” 48. Aṭṭhame cittassa parivattanaṃ uppādanirodhā evāti āha – ‘‘evaṃ lahuṃ uppajjitvā lahuṃ nirujjhanaka’’nti. Adhimattapamāṇattheti atikkantapamāṇatthe, pamāṇātītatāyanti attho. Tenāha – ‘‘ativiya na sukarā’’ti. Cakkhuviññāṇampi adhippetamevāti sabbassapi cittassa samānakhaṇattā vuttaṃ. Cittassa ativiya lahuparivattibhāvaṃ theravādena dīpetuṃ – ‘‘imasmiṃ panatthe’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Cittasaṅkhārāti sasampayuttaṃ cittaṃ vadati. Vāhasatānaṃ kho, mahārāja, vīhīnanti potthakesu likhanti, ‘‘vāhasataṃ kho, mahārāja, vīhīna’’nti pana pāṭhena bhavitabbaṃ. Milindapañhepi (mi. pa. 4.1.2) hi katthaci ayameva pāṭho dissati. ‘‘Vāhasatāna’’nti vā paccatte sāmivacanaṃ byattayena vuttanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Aḍḍhacūḷanti thokena ūnaṃ upaḍḍhaṃ. Kassa pana upaḍḍhanti? Adhikārato vāhassāti viññāyati. ‘‘Aḍḍhacuddasa’’nti keci. ‘‘Aḍḍhacatuttha’’nti apare. Sādhikaṃ diyaḍḍhasataṃ vāhāti daḷhaṃ katvā vadanti, vīmaṃsitabbaṃ. Catunāḷiko tumbo. Pucchāya abhāvenāti ‘‘sakkā pana, bhante, upamaṃ kātu’’nti evaṃ pavattāya pucchāya abhāvena na katā upamā. Dhammadesanāpariyosāneti sannipatitaparisāya yathāraddhadhammadesanāya pariyosāne. 48. 第八句,心之转变,即是生起与灭尽,故说:“如此迅速生起又迅速灭尽。”“Adhimattapamāṇatthe”意为超越限量,即超越常规,意为超越度量。故说:“极其不易。”眼识(cakkhuviññāṇa)亦复如是,因一切心识之刹那相同。为阐明上座部所说之心极其快速转变,故说“在此义上”等语。心行(cittasaṅkhāra)是指心与心所法。大王,书本上写“vāhasatānaṃ kho, mahārāja, vīhīnaṃ”(一百车稻谷),然应读作“vāhasataṃ kho, mahārāja, vīhīnaṃ”(一百车稻谷)。《弥兰王问经》(Milindapañha)中亦有此读法。或说“vāhasatānaṃ”是各自之属格,以变格而说,应如是理解。“Aḍḍhacūḷa”意为少许,不足一半。那么是什么的一半呢?依上下文,显然是指一车(vāha)之一半。有些人说“十三车半”(aḍḍhacuddasa),另一些人说“三车半”(aḍḍhacatuttha)。有些人坚定地说“一百五十余车”,应仔细思考。“Catunāḷiko tumbo”指一个四那利(nāḷika)的容器。因无“尊者,可以作比喻吗?”之提问,故未作比喻。说法结束(dhammadesanāpariyosāne)是指对聚集之大众所作说法的结束。 49. Navame pabhassaranti pariyodātaṃ sabhāvaparisuddhaṭṭhena. Tenāha – ‘‘paṇḍaraṃ parisuddha’’nti. Pabhassaratādayo nāma vaṇṇadhātuyaṃ labbhanakavisesāti āha – ‘‘kiṃ pana cittassa vaṇṇo nāma atthī’’ti? Itaro arūpatāya ‘‘natthī’’ti paṭikkhipitvā pariyāyakathā ayaṃ tādisassa cittassa parisuddhabhāvanādīpanāyāti dassento ‘‘nīlādīna’’ntiādimāha. Tathā hi ‘‘so evaṃ samāhite citte parisuddhe pariyodāte’’ti (dī. ni. 1.243-244; ma. ni. 1.384-386, 431-433; pārā. 12-13) vuttaṃ[Pg.100]. Tenevāha – ‘‘idampi nirupakkilesatāya parisuddhanti pabhassara’’nti. Kiṃ pana bhavaṅgacittaṃ nirupakkilesanti? Āma sabhāvato nirupakkilesaṃ, āgantukaupakkilesavasena pana siyā upakkiliṭṭhaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘tañca kho’’tiādi. Tattha attano tesañca bhikkhūnaṃ paccakkhabhāvato pubbe ‘‘ida’’nti vatvā idāni paccāmasanavasena ‘‘ta’’nti āha. Ca-saddo atthūpanayane. Kho-saddo vacanālaṅkāre, avadhāraṇe vā. Vakkhamānassa atthassa nicchitabhāvato bhavaṅgacittena sahāvaṭṭhānābhāvato upakkilesānaṃ āgantukatāti āha – ‘‘asahajātehī’’tiādi. Rāgādayo upecca cittasantānaṃ kilissanti vibādhenti upatāpenti cāti āha – ‘‘upakkilesehīti rāgādīhī’’ti. Bhavaṅgacittassa nippariyāyato upakkilesehi upakkiliṭṭhatā nāma natthi asaṃsaṭṭhabhāvato, ekasantatipariyāpannatāya pana siyā upakkiliṭṭhatāpariyāyoti āha – ‘‘upakkiliṭṭhaṃ nāmāti vuccatī’’ti. Idāni tamatthaṃ upamāya vibhāvetuṃ ‘‘yathā hī’’tiādimāha. Tena bhinnasantānagatāyapi nāma iriyāya loke gārayhatā dissati, pageva ekasantānagatāya iriyāyāti imaṃ visesaṃ dasseti. Tenāha – ‘‘javanakkhaṇe…pe… upakkiliṭṭhaṃ nāma hotī’’ti. 49. 第九(经)中说“光明”,是指其自性清净无染。因此说:“洁白清净”。“光明”等名称,是指在色法中可得的殊胜之处。有人问:“心难道有颜色吗?”对方回答说,心是无色法,所以“没有”颜色。这是譬喻说,旨在阐明如此这般的心是清净的,因此说“青色等”。正如经中说:“如此,在等持、清净、皎洁的心中”。因此说:“此心因无烦恼而清净光明”。那么,有分心(bhavaṅgacitta)是否没有烦恼呢?是的,从自性上来说没有烦恼,但由于客尘烦恼(āgantukaupakkilesa),可能会被染污。因此说“彼且”等。此处,之前因为是自己和那些比丘所亲见,所以用“此”来指代,现在因为是回顾,所以用“彼”来指代。“ca”字是引入意义,“kho”字是用作语气词,或者表示确定。因为将要说的含义是确定的,并且烦恼不是与有分心同时存在,所以烦恼是外来的,因此说“非俱生”等。贪等烦恼会扰乱、困扰、折磨心相续,因此说:“烦恼,即贪等”。有分心从究竟义(nippariyāyato)上来说,没有被烦恼所染污的状态,因为没有混合在一起;但是由于属于同一心相续,所以会有被染污的状态,因此说“名为染污”。现在用譬喻来阐明这个含义,因此说“例如”等。因此,即使发生在不同心相续上的行为,在世间也会受到指责,更何况发生在同一心相续上的行为呢?这表明了这种特殊性。因此说:“在速行刹那(javanakkhaṇa)……名为染污”。 50. Dasame bhavaṅgacittameva cittanti ‘‘pabhassaramidaṃ, bhikkhave, citta’’nti vuttaṃ bhavaṅgacittameva. Yadaggena bhavaṅgacittaṃ tādisapaccayasamavāye upakkiliṭṭhaṃ nāma vuccati, tadaggena tabbidhurapaccayasamavāye upakkilesato vimuttanti vuccati. Tenāha – ‘‘upakkilesehi vippamuttaṃ nāma hotī’’ti. Sesamettha navamasutte vuttanayānusārena veditabbaṃ. 50. 第十(经)中说:“诸比丘,此心是光明的”,此处的“心”指的正是“有分心”(bhavaṅgacitta)。当有分心在适当的因缘和合下被烦恼染污时,就称为染污;当它在缺乏那些因缘的情况下从烦恼中解脱时,就称为解脱。因此说:“名为从烦恼解脱”。其余部分应当按照第九经中所说的方法来理解。 Paṇihitaacchavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 善导清澈品释义终。 6. Accharāsaṅghātavaggavaṇṇanā 6. 弹指品释义 51. Chaṭṭhassa paṭhame assutavāti ettha ‘‘sādhu paññāṇavā naro’’tiādīsu (jā. 2.18.101) atthitāmattassa bodhako vā-saddo. ‘‘Sīlavā hoti kalyāṇadhammo’’tiādīsu (ma. ni. 3.381) pasaṃsāvisiṭṭhāya atthitāya. ‘‘Paññavā hoti [Pg.101] udayatthagāminiyā paññāya samannāgato’’tiādīsu (dī. ni. 3.317; ma. ni. 2.25) atisayatthavisiṭṭhāya atthitāya, tasmā yassa pasatthaṃ atisayena vā sutaṃ atthi, so sutavā, saṃkilesaviddhaṃsanasamatthaṃ pariyattidhammassavanaṃ, taṃ sutvā tathattāya paṭipatti ca ‘‘sutavā’’ti iminā padena pakāsitā. Sotabbayuttaṃ sutvā kattabbanipphattivasena suṇīti vā sutavā, tappaṭikkhepena na sutavāti assutavā. 51. 在第六(经)的第一个词“无闻”(assutavā)中,例如在“贤善有慧之人”等句中,“有”(-vā)字仅表示存在;在“持戒者,具善法者”等句中,“有”字表示值得赞扬的特质;在“有慧者,具足通达生灭之慧”等句中,“有”字表示殊胜的特质。因此,凡是有值得称赞或极其殊胜的听闻的人,就是“有闻者”(sutavā)。能摧毁烦恼的教法听闻(pariyattidhammassavana),以及听闻之后的如实修行(tathattāya paṭipatti),都由“有闻”一词表明。因为听闻了应该听闻的,并且由于应作之事已经完成,所以称为“有闻”;与此相反,不听闻的,就是“无闻”。 Ayañhi akāro ‘‘ahetukā dhammā (dha. sa. 2 dukamātikā), abhikkhuko āvāso’’tiādīsu (pāci. 1047) taṃsamāyoganivattiyaṃ diṭṭho. ‘‘Appaccayā dhammā’’ti (dha. sa. 7 dukamātikā) taṃsambandhibhāvanivattiyaṃ. Paccayuppannañhi paccayasambandhīti apaccayuppannattā ataṃsambandhitā ettha jotitā. ‘‘Anidassanā dhammā’’ti (dha. sa. 9 dukamātikā) taṃsabhāvanivattiyaṃ. Nidassanañhi ettha daṭṭhabbatā. Atha vā passatīti nidassanaṃ, cakkhuviññāṇaṃ. Taggahetabbatānivattiyaṃ, tathā ‘‘anāsavā dhammā’’ti (dha. sa. 15 dukamātikā). ‘‘Appaṭighā dhammā (dha. sa. 10 dukamātikā) anārammaṇā dhammā’’ti (dha. sa. 55 dukamātikā) taṃkiccanivattiyaṃ. ‘‘Arūpino dhammā acetasikādhammā’’ti taṃsabhāvanivattiyaṃ. Tadaññatā hi idha pakāsitā. ‘‘Amanusso’’ti tabbhāvamattanivattiyaṃ. Manussattamattaṃ natthi, aññaṃ taṃsadisanti. Sadisatā hi ettha sūcitā. ‘‘Assamaṇo samaṇapaṭiñño abrahmacārī brahmacāripaṭiñño’’ti (a. ni. 3.13) ca taṃsambhāvanīyaguṇanivattiyaṃ. Garahā hi idha ñāyati. ‘‘Kacci bhoto anāmayaṃ (jā. 1.15.146; 2.20.129) anudarā kaññā’’ti ca tadanappabhāvanivattiyaṃ. ‘‘Anuppannā dhammā’’ti (dha. sa. 17 tikamātikā) taṃsadisabhāvanivattiyaṃ. Atītānañhi uppannapubbattā uppādidhammānañca paccayekadesasiddhiyā āraddhuppādabhāvato kālavinimuttassa ca vijjamānattā uppannānukūlatā, pageva paccuppannānanti tabbidhuratā hettha viññāyati. ‘‘Asekkhā dhammā’’ti (dha. sa. 11 tikamātikā) tadapariyosānanivattiyaṃ. Tanniṭṭhānañhettha pakāsitanti evaṃ anekesaṃ atthānaṃ jotako. Idha pana ‘‘arūpino dhammā (dha. sa. 11 dukamātikā), acetasikā dhammā’’tiādīsu (dha. sa. 57 dukamātikā) viya taṃsabhāvanivattiyaṃ daṭṭhabbo, aññattheti attho. Etenassa sutādiñāṇavirahaṃ dasseti. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘āgamādhigamābhāvā ñeyyo assutavā itī’’ti. 此“a-”前缀在‘无因法’(dha. sa. 2 dukamātikā)、‘无比丘的住处’(pāci. 1047)等词中,表示其不具足相应的结合。‘无缘法’(dha. sa. 7 dukamātikā)表明其断绝因缘关联。因为缘生法必与缘相关,而无缘生法即无此关联,此处阐明此义。‘无示现法’(dha. sa. 9 dukamātikā)表示其远离自身体性。此处所谓‘示现’即指可见性。或者说,‘示现’即能见者,指眼识。此词显示其不具足被眼识取用的特质。同理,‘无漏法’(dha. sa. 15 dukamātikā)亦复如是。‘无对法’(dha. sa. 10 dukamātikā)、‘无所缘法’(dha. sa. 55 dukamātikā)等词,表明其远离相应作用。‘无色法’、‘非心所法’等词,则显示其自身体性的差异。此处彰显其与他法不同之性。‘非人’一词仅表示其不具备人类属性。虽无人性,却有与其相似之处。此处暗示其相似性。‘非沙门而自称沙门,非梵行者而自称梵行者’(a. ni. 3.13),则表明其不具备所宣称的功德。此处可见呵责之义。‘尊者无恙否’(jā. 1.15.146; 2.20.129)、‘少女未孕否’等语,则表示其不具足相应的状态(如无病、未孕)。‘未生法’(dha. sa. 17 tikamātikā)一词,表明其远离与已生法相似的状态。因为过去法已经生起,未来应生之法也因部分因缘具足而开始生起,而脱离时间限制的涅槃也已存在,这些都与‘已生’的状态相符顺,更何况是现在法呢?此处所理解的是其不具足这种状态。‘无学法’(dha. sa. 11 tikamātikā)表示其已完成修学。此处阐明其究竟之义。如是种种义理,皆可依此类推。在此,‘无色法’(dha. sa. 11 dukamātikā)、‘非心所法’(dha. sa. 57 dukamātikā)等词,当知亦复如是,皆用于否定其自性,其义为“相异”。由此显示其缺乏教理与证悟之智。故说:“由无教理与证悟,当知为无闻者。” Idāni [Pg.102] tassatthaṃ vivaranto ‘‘yo hī’’tiādimāha. Tattha yasmā khandhadhātādikosallenapi upakkilesaupakkiliṭṭhānaṃ jānanahetubhūtaṃ bāhusaccaṃ hoti. Yathāha – ‘‘kittāvatā nu kho, bhante, bahussuto hoti? Yato kho, bhikkhu, khandhakusalo hoti. Dhātu…pe… āyatana…pe… paṭiccasamuppādakusalo hoti. Ettāvatā kho, bhikkhu, bahussuto hotī’’ti. Tasmā ‘‘yassa ca khandhadhātuāyatanapaccayākārasatipaṭṭhānādīsū’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Tattha vācuggatakaraṇaṃ uggaho. Atthaparipucchanaṃ puripucchā. Kusalehi saha codanāpariharaṇavasena vinicchayakaraṇaṃ vinicchayo. Ācariye pana payirupāsitvā atthadhammānaṃ āgamanaṃ sutamayañāṇavasena avabujjhanaṃ āgamo. Maggaphalanibbānānaṃ sacchikiriyā adhigamo. 现在为阐明其义,而说“实乃”等。于此,因为多闻是了知随烦恼及被染污法之因,即使是仅精通蕴、界等亦然。如所说:“尊者,如何为多闻?比丘,若善于蕴,善于界……处……缘起,比丘,如是为多闻。”是故说“于蕴、界、处、缘起、念住等”。其中,口诵为“受持”;问义为“遍问”;与善者共同通过诘问与辩护的方式抉择为“决断”;再者,亲近师长,学习义理与法,以闻所成慧了知,是为教理(āgama);亲证道、果、涅槃,是为证悟(adhigama)。 Bahūnaṃ nānappakārānaṃ sakkāyadiṭṭhādīnaṃ avihatattā tā janenti, tāhi vā janitāti puthujjanā. Avighātameva vā jana-saddo vadati. Puthu satthārānaṃ mukhullokikāti ettha puthū janā satthupaṭiññā etesanti puthujjanā. Sabbagatīhi avuṭṭhitāti ettha janetabbā, jāyanti vā ettha sattāti janā, gatiyo, tā puthū etesanti puthujjanā. Ito pare jāyanti etehīti janā, abhisaṅkhārādayo, te etesaṃ puthū vijjantīti puthujjanā. Abhisaṅkhārādiattho eva vā jana-saddo daṭṭhabbo. Oghā kāmoghādayo. Rāgaggiādayo santāpā. Te eva sabbepi vā kilesā pariḷāhā. Puthu pañcasu kāmaguṇesu rattāti ettha jāyatīti jano, rāgo gedhoti evamādiko, puthu jano etesanti puthujjanā. Puthūsu janā jātā rattāti evaṃ rāgādiattho eva vā jana-saddo daṭṭhabbo. 由于未能断除多种多样的有身见(sakkāyadiṭṭhi)等,他们(凡夫)能生起众多(烦恼),或为彼等所生,故称凡夫。或者,“jana”一词仅表示无障碍。或者,“普”指众多师长,这些众生仰赖众多师长(的教导),故称凡夫。或者,“普”指未脱离一切趣(gati)者,此处“jana”指应被生起,或有情于此生起,故为“众生”;而诸趣对他们而言是普遍的,故称凡夫。从此之后由这些产生,称为“jana”,即行(abhisaṅkhāra)等;这些行等普遍存在于这些众生中,故称凡夫。或者,“jana”一词应理解为行等义。欲流(kāmogha)等是瀑流(ogha);贪火(rāgaggi)等是热恼(santāpa);或者说一切烦恼都是烧灼(pariḷāha)。或者,“普”指沉溺于五欲(kāmaguṇa)者,此处“jana”指生起之物,即贪、渴爱(gedha)等;这些(贪爱)普遍存在于他们(众生)之中,故称凡夫。或者,“jana”一词应理解为贪等义,即众多众生沉溺于贪爱。 Rattāti vatthaṃ viya raṅgajātena cittassa vipariṇāmakarena chandarāgena rattā sārattā. Giddhāti abhikaṅkhanasabhāvena abhigijjhanena giddhā gedhaṃ āpannā. Gadhitāti ganthitā viya dummocanīyabhāvena tattha paṭibaddhā. Mucchitāti kilesavasena visaññibhūtā viya anaññakiccā mohamāpannā. Ajjhopannāti anaññasādhāraṇe viya katvā gilitvā pariniṭṭhāpetvā ṭhitā. Laggāti vaṅkakaṇṭake viya āsattā, mahāpalipe yāva nāsikaggā palipannapuriso viya uddharituṃ asakkuṇeyyabhāvena nimuggā[Pg.103]. Laggitāti makkaṭālepe ālaggabhāvena sammasito viya makkaṭo pañcannaṃ indriyānaṃ vasena ālaggitā. Palibuddhāti sambaddhā, upaddutā vā. Āvutāti āvaritā. Nivutāti nivāritā. Ovutāti paliguṇṭhitā, pariyonaddhā vā. Pihitāti pidahitā. Paṭicchannāti chāditā. Paṭikujjitāti heṭṭhāmukhajātā. “染着”(Rattā),如同布匹为染料所染,心因能令其变化的欲贪(chandarāga)而染,是为彻底染着(sārattā)。“贪婪”(Giddhā),是因渴求的自性而贪求(abhigijjhana),陷入贪欲(gedha)。“执取”(Gadhitā),如被捆绑(ganthitā)一般难以解脱,于此被牢牢地束缚(paṭibaddhā)。“沉迷”(Mucchitā),是因烦恼(kilesa)而如同失去知觉(visaññibhūtā)一般,无暇他顾,陷入愚痴(moha)。“吞没”(Ajjhopannā),是如同独占、吞噬并彻底完成一般地存在。“黏着”(Laggā),是如同被弯钩刺(vaṅkakaṇṭaka)一样黏着(āsattā),如同陷入巨大泥潭的人没顶至鼻尖,因无法拔出而沉没(nimuggā)。“黏附”(Laggitā),是如同猴子黏在捕猴胶(makkaṭālepa)上,因五根(indriya)而被黏附。“缠缚”(Palibuddhā),是被束缚(sambaddhā),或被困扰(upaddutā)。“覆盖”(Āvutā),是被遮蔽(āvaritā)。“障蔽”(Nivutā),是被阻碍(nivāritā)。“包裹”(Ovutā),是被缠绕(paliguṇṭhitā),或被遍覆(pariyonaddhā)。“遮盖”(Pihitā),是被掩盖(pidahitā)。“遮蔽”(Paṭicchannā),是被覆盖(chāditā)。“颠倒”(Paṭikujjitā),是面朝下(heṭṭhāmukhajātā)。 ‘‘Assutavā’’ti etena avijjandhatā vuttāti āha – ‘‘andhaputhujjano vutto’’ti. Cittaṭṭhiti cittapariggaho natthīti yāya paṭipattiyā cittassa upakkilesaṃ tato vippamuttiñca yathāsabhāvato jāneyya, sā cittabhāvanā cittaṭṭhiti. Ekārammaṇe suṭṭhu samādhānavasena avaṭṭhitiṃ pādakaṃ katvā pavattitā sampayuttadhammehi nissayārammaṇehi ca saddhiṃ cittassa pariggahasaññitā vipassanābhāvanāpi natthi, yāya vuttamatthaṃ yathāsabhāvato jāneyya. “无闻”(Assutavā)一词,是说为无明所蒙蔽,故言“盲昧凡夫”(andhaputhujjana)。说他“心无住(cittaṭṭhiti)、心无把握(cittapariggaha)”,是说他没有那种能如实了知心之随烦恼(upakkilesa)及从彼解脱(vippamutti)的修行,即心修习(cittabhāvanā)或心住。他也无有被称为“把握心”的观(vipassanā)修习,此修习是以于单一所缘(ekārammaṇa)善安住为基础,与相应法(sampayuttadhamma)及所依所缘(nissayārammaṇa)共同运作,藉此能如实了知上述义理。 52. Dutiye sutavāti padassa attho anantarasutte vuttoyeva. Ariyasāvakoti ettha catukkaṃ sambhavatīti taṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘atthi ariyo’’tiādi āraddhaṃ. Paccekaṃ saccāni buddhavantoti paccekabuddhā. Nanu sabbepi ariyā paccekameva saccāni paṭivijjhanti dhammassa paccattavedanīyabhāvato? Nayidamīdisaṃ paṭivedhaṃ sandhāya vuttaṃ. Yathā pana sāvakā aññesaṃ nissayena saccāni paṭivijjhanti paratoghosena vinā tesaṃ dassanamaggassa anuppajjanato. Yathā ca sammāsambuddhā aññesaṃ nissayabhāvena saccāni abhisambujjhanti, na evamete, ete pana aparaneyyā hutvā aparanāyakabhāvena saccāni paṭivijjhanti. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘paccekaṃ saccāni buddhavantoti paccekabuddhā’’ti. 52. 第二,“有闻者”(sutavā)一词的含义已在前一经中说过。“圣弟子”(Ariyasāvaka)一词,于此可有四种,为示此义,故开始说‘有圣者’等。“独自觉悟诸谛者,是为独觉”(paccekabuddha)。问:难道非一切圣者皆独自证悟诸谛吗?因法是当各自体验的。答:此非指此种证悟。声闻(sāvaka)弟子是依止他人而证悟诸谛,若无他音(paratoghosa),其见道(dassanamagga)则不生起。又如正等觉者(sammāsambuddha)作为他人之所依而圆满觉悟诸谛,彼等(独觉)则非如是,彼等乃是不为他所引导(aparaneyya)、无有其他导师而证悟诸谛。是故说:“独自觉悟诸谛者,是为独觉”。 Atthi sāvako na ariyoti ettha pothujjanikāya saddhāya ratanattaye abhippasanno saddhopi gahito eva. Gihī anāgataphaloti idaṃ pana nidassanamattaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. Yathāvuttapuggalo hi saraṇagamanato paṭṭhāya sotāpattiphalasacchikiriyāya paṭipannoicceva vattabbataṃ labhati. Svāyamattho dakkhiṇāvisuddhisuttena (ma. ni. 3.376 ādayo) dīpetabbo. Sutavāti ettha vuttaattho nāma attahitaparahitappaṭipatti, tassa vasena sutasampanno. Yaṃ sandhāya vuttaṃ – ‘‘so ca hoti sutena upapanno, appampi [Pg.104] ce sahitaṃ bhāsamāno’’ti ca ādi. Ariyasāvakoti veditabboti ariyassa bhagavato dhammassavanakicce yuttappayuttabhāvato vuttaṃ. Upakkilesehi vippamutti anupakkiliṭṭhatā, tassā yathāsabhāvajānanaṃ daḷhatarāya eva cittabhāvanāya sati hoti, na aññathāti ‘‘balavavipassanā kathitā’’ti vuttaṃ. 所谓“有非圣弟子”,于此,应知以凡俗之信而于三宝生净信者,亦摄于其中。“在家未证果者”,此仅为例示。盖如上所说之人(puggala),从归依时起,即可称为已趣向于证悟预流果(sotāpattiphala)之行者。此义当以《布施清净经》(Dakkhiṇāvisuddhisutta)阐明。所谓“多闻者”,此处所说之义,即自利利他之行,依此而成就多闻。如言:“彼由多闻而成就,纵所言甚少亦具义理”等。应知“圣弟子”之称,乃因其正勤投入于听闻世尊之圣法。从诸随烦恼(upakkilesa)解脱,即是不染污之状态,对此如实了知,唯有于心修习极为坚固时方能成就,非由他法。故说“此乃强力之观(vipassanā)”。 53. Tatiye aggikkhandhopamasuttantaaṭṭhuppattiyanti aggikkhandhopamasutte (a. ni. 7.72) desanāaṭṭhuppattiyaṃ. Taṃdesanāhetukañhi ekaccānaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ micchāpaṭipattiṃ nimittaṃ katvā bhagavā imaṃ suttaṃ desesi. Avijahitameva hoti sabbakālaṃ suppatiṭṭhitasatisampajaññattā. Yasmā buddhānaṃ rūpakāyo bāhirabbhantarehi malehi anupakkiliṭṭho sudhotajātimaṇisadiso, tasmā vuttaṃ – ‘‘upaṭṭhākānuggahatthaṃ sarīraphāsukatthañcā’’ti. Vītināmetvāti phalasamāpattīhi vītināmetvā. Kālaparicchedavasena vivittāsane vītināmanaṃ vivekaninnatāya ceva paresaṃ diṭṭhānugatiāpajjanatthañca. Nivāsetvāti vihāranivāsanaparivattanavasena nivāsetvā. Kadāci ekakassa, kadāci bhikkhusaṅghaparivutassa, kadāci pakatiyā, kadāci pāṭihāriyehi vattamānehi ca gāmappaveso tathā tathā vinetabbapuggalavasena. Upasaṃharitvāti himavantādīsu pupphitarukkhādito ānetvā. Oṇatuṇṇatāya bhūmiyā satthu padanikkhepasamaye samabhāvāpatti, sukhasamphassavikasitapadumasampaṭicchanañca suppatiṭṭhitapādatāya nissandaphalaṃ, na iddhinimmānaṃ. Nidassanamattañcetaṃ sakkharākaṭhalakaṇṭakasaṅkukalalādiapagamo sucibhāvāpattīti evamādīnampi tadā labbhanato. 53. 于第三《火蕴《本行》》(Aggikkhandhopamasutta)之缘起中:于《火蕴《本行》》(增支部7.72)的说法缘起中,世尊(Bhagavā)因某些比丘的邪行,以此为由而说此经。由于正念正知(satisampajañña)恒常善住,故永不舍离。因诸佛色身内外离垢,犹如善加擦拭之宝珠,故言:“为利益侍者,亦为身体安适”。度过(时间),即是以果定(phalasamāpatti)度过。在限定时间内于寂静处度过,是为了倾向于远离(viveka),亦是为了令他人见而仿效。着衣,即是更换住处所穿之衣。或独自一人,或为比丘僧团围绕,或以常态,或示现神通(pāṭihāriya)而入村落,皆随所应度化之人(puggala)而定。供养,即是从喜马拉雅山(Himavanta)等处,从盛开的花树等取来。高低不平之地面,于导师落足之时,即变为平坦;又有悦意触感之莲花绽开承接,此乃双足善住之自然果报,非神通所造。此仅为例示,如碎石、瓦砾、荆棘、木桩、污泥等物之消失,地面变为洁净等事,当时亦可得见。 Indakhīlassa anto ṭhapitamatteti idaṃ yāvadeva veneyyajanavinayatthāya satthu pāṭihāriyaṃ pavattanti katvā vuttaṃ. Dakkhiṇapādeti idaṃ buddhānaṃ sabbapadakkhiṇatāya. ‘‘Chabbaṇṇarasmiyo’’ti vatvāpi ‘‘suvaṇṇarasapiñjarāni viyā’’ti idaṃ buddhānaṃ sarīre pītābhāya yebhuyyatāya vuttaṃ. Madhurenākārena saddaṃ karonti daṭṭhabbasārassa diṭṭhatāya. Bheriādīnaṃ pana saddāyanaṃ dhammatāva. Paṭimānentīti ‘‘sudullabhaṃ idaṃ ajja amhehi labbhati, ye mayaṃ īdisena paṇītena āhārena bhagavantaṃ upaṭṭhahāmā’’ti patītamānasā mānenti pūjenti. Tesaṃ santānāni oloketvāti [Pg.105] tesaṃ tathā upaṭṭhākānaṃ puggalānaṃ atīte etarahi ca pavattacittasantānāni oloketvā. Arahatte patiṭṭhahantīti sambandho. Tatthāti vihāre. Gandhamaṇḍalamāḷeti catujjātiyagandhena kataparibhaṇḍe maṇḍalamāḷe. “仅置于因陀罗柱(Indakhīla)内”,此乃为调伏所化有情(veneyyajana),导师示现神通(pāṭihāriya)而说。“以右足”,此乃因诸佛一切皆以右为先。虽言“六色光(chabbaṇṇarasmi)”,然说“犹如金色汁液”,此乃因佛身以黄色光辉为主。发出悦耳之声,是为令所应见之精要得以被见。至于鼓(bheri)等发声,则纯属自然。所谓“恭敬”,即是心怀喜悦地尊敬、供养,心想:“我等今日得以如此殊胜之食供养世尊,实为难得”。“观察彼等之相续”,即是观察彼等如是供养之人(puggala)过去与现在生起之心相续。其关联在于“安住于阿罗汉果(arahatta)”。“于彼处”,即于精舍(vihāra)中。“香环楼阁”(Gandhamaṇḍalamāḷa),即以四种香料(catujjātiyagandha)所制之圆形楼阁。 Dullabhā khaṇasampattīti satipi manussattappaṭilābhe patirūpadesavāsaindriyāvekallasaddhāpaṭilābhādayo guṇā dullabhāti attho. Cātumahārājika…pe… vasavattibhavanaṃ gacchantīti idaṃ tattha suññavimānāni sandhāya vuttaṃ. Bhagavā gandhakuṭiṃ pavisitvā pacchābhattaṃ tayo bhāge katvā paṭhamabhāge sace ākaṅkhati, dakkhiṇena passena sīhaseyyaṃ kappeti. Sace ākaṅkhati, buddhāciṇṇaphalasamāpattiṃ samāpajjati. Atha yathākālaparicchedaṃ tato vuṭṭhahitvā dutiyabhāge pacchimayāme tatiyakoṭṭhāse viya lokaṃ voloketi veneyyānaṃ ñāṇaparipākaṃ passituṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘sace ākaṅkhatī’’tiādi. “刹那善缘难得”(khaṇasampatti),其义为:纵得人身,然生于适宜之地、诸根无缺、获得正信等功德,亦是难得。“往生四天王天(Cātumahārājika)……乃至他化自在天(Vasavatti)”,此乃针对彼处空置之天宫而言。世尊(Bhagavā)进入香室(gandhakuṭi)后,将午后时分作三份:于第一份时间,若有意乐,则右胁而作狮子卧;若有意乐,则入诸佛惯行之果定。其后,依所定时限从定中起,于第二份时间,如后夜之第三分时,观察世间,以见所化有情之智是否成熟。是故说“若有意乐”等。 Kālayuttanti pattakallaṃ, ‘‘imissā velāya imassa evaṃ vattabba’’nti taṃkālānurūpaṃ. Samayayuttanti tasseva vevacanaṃ, aṭṭhuppattianurūpaṃ vā. Samayayuttanti vā ariyasamayasaṃyuttaṃ. Desakālānurūpameva hi buddhā bhagavanto dhammaṃ desenti, desentā ca ariyasammataṃ paṭiccasamuppādanayaṃ dīpentāva desenti. Atha vā samayayuttanti hetūdāharaṇasahitaṃ. Kālena sāpadesañhi bhagavā dhammaṃ deseti, kālaṃ viditvā parisaṃ uyyojeti, na yāva samandhakārā dhammaṃ deseti. “应时”(Kālayutta),即恰逢其时,如“于此时,应对此人作如是说”,乃适合彼时。“应机”(Samayayutta)是其同义词,或指适合缘起。“应机”亦可指与圣教相应。诸佛世尊(Bhagavā)说法,实乃契合时地;说法之时,亦必开显圣者所许之缘起法。又,“应机”亦指具足因缘与譬喻。世尊说法,必应时且有理据,知时而遣散会众,不会说法直至天黑。 Utuṃ gaṇhāpeti, na pana malaṃ pakkhāletīti adhippāyo. Na hi bhagavato kāye rajojallaṃ upalimpatīti. Tato tatoti attano attano divāṭṭhānādito. Okāsaṃ labhamānāti purebhattapacchābhattapurimayāmesu okāsaṃ alabhitvā idāni majjhimayāme okāsaṃ labhamānā, bhagavatā vā katokāsatāya okāsaṃ labhamānā. Pacchābhattassa tīsu bhāgesu paṭhamabhāge sīhaseyyakappanaṃ ekantikaṃ na hotīti āha – ‘‘purebhattato paṭṭhāya nisajjāpīḷitassa sarīrassā’’ti. Teneva hi tattha ‘‘sace ākaṅkhatī’’ti tadā sīhaseyyakappanassa anibaddhatā vibhāvitā. Kilāsubhāvo parissamo[Pg.106]. Sīhaseyyaṃ kappeti sarīrassa kilāsubhāvamocanatthanti yojetabbaṃ. Buddhacakkhunā lokaṃ voloketīti idaṃ pacchimayāme bhagavato bahulaṃ āciṇṇavasena vuttaṃ. Appekadā avasiṭṭhabalañāṇehi sabbaññutaññāṇeneva ca bhagavā tamatthaṃ sādhetīti. 令人取水,其意并非为洗去污垢。盖因世尊(Bhagavā)身上实不沾染尘垢。“从彼处彼处”,即从各自的日间住处等。所谓“得机缘”,即于食前、食后及初夜时分未得机缘,今于中夜时分得机缘,或因世尊给予机缘而得。于食后三时分中,第一时分行狮子卧并非固定不变,故言:“为从食后以来因久坐而疲惫之身”。正因如此,彼处所言“若有意乐”,即阐明了彼时行狮子卧并非定则。疲乏即是劳累。应如是结合:行狮子卧,是为了解除身体的疲乏。“以佛眼观众生世间”,此乃就世尊于后夜时分多行此法而言。有时,世尊亦凭借所余之力与智,以及一切知智,而成办此事。 Imasmiṃyeva kicceti pacchimayāmakicce. Balavatā paccanutāpena saṃvaḍḍhamānena karajakāye mahāpariḷāho uppajjatīti āha – ‘‘nāmakāye santatte karajakāyo santatto’’ti. Nidhānagatanti sannicitalohitaṃ sandhāya vuttaṃ. Uṇhaṃ lohitaṃ mukhato uggañchīti lohitaṃ uṇhaṃ hutvā mukhato uggañchi. Ṭhānanti bhikkhupaṭiññaṃ. Taṃ pāpaṃ vaḍḍhamānanti bhikkhupaṭiññāya avijahitattā tathā pavaḍḍhamānapāpaṃ. Antimavatthuajjhāpannānampi upāyena pavattiyamāno yonisomanasikāro sātthako hotiyevāti dassento ‘‘jātasaṃvegā’’tiādimāha. Aho sallekhitanti aho ativiya sallekhena itaṃ pavattaṃ. Kāsāvapajjototi bhikkhūnaṃ bahubhāvato ito cito ca vicarantānaṃ tesaṃ kāsāvajutiyā pajjotito. Isivātaparivātoti sīlakkhandhādīnaṃ nibbānassa ca esanato isīnaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ guṇagandhena ceva guṇagandhavāsitena sarīragandhena ca parito samantato vāyito. “就在此时应当作”是指后夜应做之事。由于不断增长的强烈追悔,色身产生了极大的热恼,因此说:“名身炽热时,色身亦炽热。”“埋藏之物”指的是积聚的血液。“热血从口中涌出”即血液变热后从口中涌出。“立场”指的是比丘的誓言。“那罪恶不断增长”即因未放弃比丘的誓言,其罪恶亦如此增长。为显示即使是犯了根本罪(antimavatthu)的人,若能善巧地运用如理作意,也能获得利益,故说“生起悚惧”等语。“啊!善于削减!”即“啊!因极度的削减而行”。“袈裟之光”即因比丘众多,于此彼处行走,其袈裟之光芒得以照耀。“仙人之风吹拂”即寻求戒蕴等及涅槃的仙人比丘们,其功德之香及被功德之香所熏的身体之香,从四周吹拂而来。 Dhammasaṃvego uppajji anāvajjanena pubbe tassa atthassa asaṃviditattā. Dhammasaṃvegoti ca tādise atthe dhammatāvasena uppajjanakaṃ sahottappañāṇaṃ. Assāsaṭṭhānanti cittassāsakāraṇaṃ kammaṭṭhānaṃ. Sabbesaṃ kiccānaṃ pubbabhāgo sabbapubbabhāgo. ‘‘Sabbe sattā averā hontū’’tiādinā hi cittassa paṭṭhānaṃ upaṭṭhānaṃ hitapharaṇaṃ. Itaraṃ ito thokaṃ mahantanti katvā idaṃ ‘‘cūḷaccharāsaṅghātasutta’’nti vuttaṃ. Accharāsaṅghāto vuccati aṅguliphoṭanakkhaṇo akkhinimisakālo, yo ekassa akkharassa uccāraṇakkhaṇo. Tenāha – ‘‘dve aṅguliyo paharitvā saddakaraṇamatta’’nti. Sabbasattānaṃ hitapharaṇacittanti sabbesampi sattānaṃ sammadeva hitesitavasena pavattacittaṃ. Āvajjento āsevatīti hitesitavasena āvajjento. Āvajjanena ābhujantopi āsevati nāma ñāṇavippayuttena. Jānantoti tathā ñāṇamattaṃ uppādentopi. Passantoti tathā ñāṇacakkhunā paccakkhato viya vipassantopi. Paccavekkhantoti tamatthaṃ pati [Pg.107] pati avekkhantopi. Saddhāya adhimuccantotiādi pañcannaṃ indriyānaṃ vasena vuttaṃ. Abhiññeyyantiādi catusaccavasena vuttaṃ. Sabbameva cetaṃ vitthārato, sāmaññena āsevanadassanamevāti idhādhippetameva āsevanatthaṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘idha panā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. 法随感(dhammasaṃvega)生起,是因为先前未曾作意,不了知其义。法随感,即于此等义中,由法性而生起的与愧相应的智慧。慰藉处(assāsaṭṭhāna)是指能令心得到慰藉的业处(kammaṭṭhāna)。一切事业的先导,是所有先导中的先导。以“愿一切众生无怨”等语,即是心的立足处、现起处、利益遍满处。因另一部经比这部稍大,故此经被称为《小弹指经》(Cūḷaccharāsaṅghātasutta)。弹指(accharāsaṅghāta)是指弹响手指的刹那、眨眼的片刻,即发出一个音节的刹那。因此说:“弹响两指发出声音的片刻”。“令心遍满一切众生之利益”是指对一切众生,以真正希望其获得利益之心而行。作意而修习,是指以希望其获得利益之心而作意。即使是以不与智相应的作意而投入,也称为修习。知者,即如是生起智慧而已。见者,即以智慧之眼如亲见般而观。审察者,即对此义反复省察。信解等,是依五根而说。应遍知等,是依四圣谛而说。这一切若详细而言,通常即是修习的显现。此处为显示修习之义,故说“于此”等。 Arittajjhānoti avirahitajjhāno. Atucchajjhānoti jhānena atuccho. Cāgo vā vevacananti āha – ‘‘apariccattajjhāno’’ti. Viharatīti padassa vibhaṅge (vibha. 540) āgatanayena atthaṃ dassento ‘‘viharatīti iriyatī’’tiādimāha. Ayaṃ panettha saddattho – viharatīti ettha vi-saddo vicchedatthajotano. Haratīti neti, pavattetīti attho, vicchinditvā harati viharatīti vuttaṃ hoti. So hi ekaṃ iriyāpathabādhanaṃ aññena iriyāpathena vicchinditvā aparipatantaṃ attabhāvaṃ harati pavatteti, tasmā ‘‘viharatī’’ti vuccati. Iriyatīti ṭhānanisajjādikiriyaṃ karonto pavattati. Pavattatīti ṭhānādisamaṅgī hutvā pavattati. Pāletīti ekaṃ iriyāpathabādhanaṃ iriyāpathantarehi rakkhanto pāleti. Yapeti yāpetīti tasseva vevacanaṃ. Ekañhi iriyāpathabādhanaṃ aññena iriyāpathena vicchinditvā aparipatantaṃ attabhāvaṃ pālento yapeti yāpetīti vuccati. Caratīti ṭhānanisajjādīsu aññatarasamaṅgī hutvā pavattati. Iminā padenāti ‘‘viharatī’’ti iminā padena. 无离禅(arittajjhāno)即不离于禅(avirahitajjhāno)。不空禅(atucchajjhāno)即因禅而不空。或者说,是“不放弃禅那”(apariccattajjhāno)的意思。关于“住”(viharati)一词,在《分别论》(Vibha. 540)中,依其所说之理而显示其义,云“住即行”等。此处的词义是:“住”(viharati)中的“vi”字,表示中断之义。“harati”是引导、持续的意思,即中断后引导,故说为“住”。因为他以一种威仪(iriyāpatha)中断另一种威仪所带来的障碍,使不坏的身体得以维持、持续,故称为“住”。“行”(iriyati)是指做着站、坐等行为而持续。“持续”(pavattati)是指具足站立等而持续。“守护”(pāleti)是指以其他威仪守护,以断绝一种威仪所带来的障碍。“维持”(yapeti)和“延续”(yāpeti)是它的同义词。以一种威仪中断另一种威仪所带来的障碍,守护着不坏的身体,这被称为“维持”和“延续”。“行”(carati)是指具足站、坐等其中之一而持续。通过此词,即通过“住”(viharati)一词。 Iriyāpathavihāroti ettha iriyanaṃ pavattanaṃ iriyā, kāyappayogo kāyikakiriyā. Tassā pavattanūpāyabhāvato iriyāya patho iriyāpatho, ṭhānanisajjādi. Na hi ṭhānanisajjādīhi avatthāhi vinā kiñci kāyikakiriyaṃ pavattetuṃ sakkā. Ṭhānasamaṅgī vā hi kāyena kiñci kareyya, gamanādīsu aññatarasamaṅgī vā. Viharaṇaṃ, viharati etenāti vā vihāro, iriyāpathova vihāro iriyāpathavihāro, so ca atthato ṭhānanisajjādiākārappavatto catusantatirūpappabandho eva. Ovādānusāsanīnaṃ ekānekavārādivisiṭṭhoyeva bhedo, na pana paramatthato tesaṃ nānākaraṇanti dassetuṃ – ‘‘paramatthato panā’’tiādimāha. Tattha ese eke ekaṭṭhetiādīsu eso eko ekatthotiādinā attho veditabbo. 威仪住(iriyāpathavihāra)。于此,行(iriyanaṃ)、转(pavattanaṃ)为“威仪”(iriyā),即身体的运用、身体的活动。因其为行动的方便之道,故“威仪之道”(iriyāya patho)即是“威仪路”(iriyāpatho),指站、坐等。若无站、坐等状态,则任何身体活动皆无法进行。人或具足站姿以身体做事,或具足行走等其中之一。住(viharaṇaṃ),或因此而住,故为“住”(vihāro)。威仪路即是住,故为“威仪住”。就义理而言,它即是依站、坐等姿态而转起的四种色法相续。为显示教诫(ovāda)与教示(anusāsanī)仅有一次、多次等差别,于胜义(paramattha)中并无不同,故说“于胜义中”等。其中,“此等、一、一义”等,应理解为“此、一、一义”等义。 Raṭṭhassa[Pg.108], raṭṭhato vā laddho piṇḍo raṭṭhapiṇḍo. Tenāha – ‘‘ñātiparivaṭṭaṃ pahāyā’’tiādi. Tattha ‘‘amhākamete’’ti viññāyantīti ñātī, pitāmahapituputtādivasena parivaṭṭanaṭṭhena parivaṭṭo, ñātiyeva parivaṭṭo ñātiparivaṭṭo. Theyyaparibhogo nāma anarahassa paribhogo. Bhagavatā hi attano sāsane sīlavato paccayā anuññātā, na dussīlassa. Dāyakānampi sīlavato eva pariccāgo, na dussīlassa attano kārānaṃ mahapphalabhāvassa paccāsīsanato. Iti satthārā ananuññātattā dāyakehi ca apariccattattā saṅghamajjhepi nisīditvā paribhuñjantassa dussīlassa paribhogo theyyāya paribhogo theyyaparibhogo. Iṇavasena paribhogo iṇaparibhogo paṭiggāhakato dakkhiṇāvisuddhiyā abhāvato iṇaṃ gahetvā paribhogo viyāti attho. 从国家(raṭṭhassa),或从国土(raṭṭhato)所得的食物(piṇḍo),为“国食”(raṭṭhapiṇḍo)。因此说:“舍弃亲族围绕(ñātiparivaṭṭaṃ)”等。于此,“此等是我等之人”如此被认知者,为“亲族”(ñāti);以祖父、父、子等辗转之义为“围绕”(parivaṭṭo);亲族即是围绕,故为“亲族围绕”。“盗用”(theyyaparibhogo),即不应得者的受用。因为世尊(bhagavā)在自己的教法中,只允许持戒者受用资具(paccayā),不允许破戒者(dussīla)受用。施主们也只布施给持戒者,不布施给破戒者,因为他们期望自己的善行能有大果报。因此,不为导师所许,亦非施主所施,破戒者即使坐在僧团之中受用,其受用亦是盗用,称为“盗用”。“负债受用”(iṇaparibhogo),是指因领受者无有清净福田之德,犹如负债而受用。 Dātabbaṭṭhena dāyaṃ, taṃ ādiyantīti dāyādā, puttānametaṃ adhivacanaṃ, tesaṃ bhāvo dāyajjaṃ, dāyajjavasena paribhogo dāyajjaparibhogo, puttabhāvena paribhogoti vuttaṃ hoti. Sekkhā hi bhikkhū bhagavato orasaputtā, te pitu santakānaṃ dāyādā hutvā te paccaye paribhuñjanti. Kiṃ pana te bhagavato paccaye paribhuñjanti, udāhu gihīnanti? Gihīhi dinnāpi bhagavatā anuññātattā bhagavato santakā ananuññātesu sabbena sabbaṃ paribhogābhāvato, anuññātesuyeva ca paribhogasambhavato. Dhammadāyādasuttañcettha sādhakaṃ. 以应施之义为“嗣物”(dāyaṃ);领受此物者为“法嗣”(dāyādā),此为“子”的同义词;他们的状态为“继承”(dāyajjaṃ);依继承而受用,为“继承受用”(dāyajjaparibhogo),即是以子的身份而受用。有学比丘(sekkhā bhikkhu)是世尊的亲生子(orasaputta),他们作为父亲所有物的继承人而受用那些资具。然则,他们是受用世尊的资具,还是居士的资具呢?即使是居士所施,因已为世尊所允许,故属于世尊所有;未被允许的,则完全不能受用,唯有被允许的才可能受用。于此,可以《法嗣经》(Dhammadāyādasutta)为证。 Vītarāgā eva taṇhāya dāsabyaṃ atītattā sāmino hutvā paribhuñjantīti āha – ‘‘khīṇāsavassa paribhogo sāmiparibhogo nāmā’’ti. Avītarāgānañhi taṇhāparavasatāya paccayaparibhoge sāmibhāvo natthi, tadabhāvena vītarāgānaṃ tattha sāmibhāvo yathāruciparibhogasambhavato. Tathā hi te paṭikūlampi appaṭikūlākārena, appaṭikūlampi paṭikūlākārena, tadubhayampi vajjetvā ajjhupekkhanākārena paccaye paribhuñjanti, dāyakānañca manorathaṃ pūrenti. Yo panāyaṃ sīlavato paccavekkhitaparibhogo, so iṇaparibhogassa paccanīkattā āṇaṇyaparibhogo nāma hoti. Yathā hi iṇāyiko attano ruciyā icchitaṃ desaṃ gantuṃ na labhati, evaṃ iṇaparibhogayutto lokato [Pg.109] nissarituṃ na labhatīti tappaṭipakkhattā sīlavato paccavekkhitaparibhogo ‘‘āṇaṇyaparibhogo’’ti vuccati, tasmā nippariyāyato catuparibhogavinimutto visuṃyevāyaṃ paribhogoti veditabbo. So idha visuṃ na vutto, dāyajjaparibhogeyeva vā saṅgahaṃ gacchati. Sīlavāpi hi imāya sikkhāya samannāgatattā ‘‘sekho’’tveva vuccati. Imesu paribhogesu sāmiparibhogo dāyajjaparibhogo ca ariyānaṃ puthujjanānañca vaṭṭati, iṇaparibhogo na vaṭṭati. Theyyaparibhoge kathāyeva natthi. Kathaṃ panettha sāmiparibhogo dāyajjaparibhogo ca puthujjanānaṃ sambhavati? Upacāravasena. Yo hi puthujjanassapi sallekhappaṭipattiyaṃ ṭhitassa paccayagedhaṃ pahāya tattha anupalittena cittena paribhogo, so sāmiparibhogo viya hoti. Sīlavato pana paccavekkhitaparibhogo dāyajjaparibhogo viya hoti dāyakānaṃ manorathassa avirādhanato. Kalyāṇaputhujjanassa paribhoge vattabbameva natthi tassa sekkhasaṅgahato. Sekkhasuttaṃ (saṃ. ni. 5.13) hetassa atthassa sādhakaṃ. 离贪者(vītarāgā)因已超越渴爱之奴役(taṇhāya dāsabyaṃ)而成为主人,故说漏尽者(khīṇāsava)的受用为“主宰受用”(sāmiparibhogo)。未离贪者因受渴爱支配,于受用资具时并无自主权;离贪者则无此束缚,故能依其意乐而受用。诚然,彼等对不适意之物能以适意的方式受用,对适意之物亦能以不适意的方式受用,或舍弃此二者而以中舍心受用资具,同时亦满足施者之愿。而持戒者的省察受用(paccavekkhitaparibhogo),因与负债受用(iṇaparibhoga)相违,故称“无债受用”(āṇaṇyaparibhogo)。犹如负债之人不得随意前往想去的地方,同样,行负债受用者不得出离世间(lokato nissarituṃ)。正因与此相反,持戒者的省察受用才被称为“无债受用”。因此,当知此受用在无譬喻的意义上,实是独立于四种受用之外。此处未将其单独列出,或可摄于继承受用(dāyajjaparibhoga)中。持戒者亦因具足此学处(sikkhā),故被称为“有学”(sekho)。于此等受用中,主宰受用与继承受用通于圣者(ariya)与凡夫(puthujjana),负债受用则不通。至于盗用受用(theyyaparibhoga),则更无论矣。凡夫如何能有主宰受用与继承受用?此乃从譬喻(upacāra)而言。若凡夫安住于减损行(sallekhappaṭipatti),舍弃对资具的贪求,以不染著之心受用,此即类似主宰受用。而持戒者的省察受用,因不违施者之愿,故类似继承受用。至于善凡夫(kalyāṇaputhujjana)的受用,因已摄入有学之列,则无庸赘言。《有学经》(Sekkhasuttaṃ, saṃ. ni. 5.13)可为此义之证。 Imassa bhikkhunoti accharāsaṅghātamattampi kālaṃ mettacittaṃ āsevantassa bhikkhuno. Amogho raṭṭhapiṇḍaparibhogoti ‘‘ayaṃ pabbajito samaṇo bhikkhūti āmisaṃ dentānaṃ tāya mettāsevanāya attano santāne dosamalassa vā tadekaṭṭhānañca pāpadhammānaṃ pabbājanato vūpasamanato saṃsāre ca bhayassa sammāva ikkhaṇato ajjhāsayassa avisaṃvādanenassa amogho raṭṭhapiṇḍaparibhogo. Mahaṭṭhiyanti mahatthikaṃ mahāpayojanaṃ. Mahapphalanti vipulapphalaṃ. Mahānisaṃsanti mahānissandapphalaṃ. Mahājutikanti mahānubhāvaṃ. Mahāvipphāranti mahāvitthāraṃ. Ettha ca paṭhamaṃ kāraṇaṃ mettāsevanāya tassa bhikkhuno sāmiādibhāvena raṭṭhapiṇḍaparibhogārahatā, dutiyaṃ parehi dinnassa dānassa mahaṭṭhiyabhāvakaraṇaṃ. Ko pana vādoti mettāya āsevanamattampi evaṃmahānubhāvaṃ, ko pana vādo bahulīkāre, ettha vattabbameva natthī’’ti attho. “于此比丘”者,谓于弹指(accharāsaṅghāta)之间修习慈心之比丘。“受用国食不唐捐”者,谓布施食物予“此出家沙门比丘”之人,因彼比丘修习慈心,能驱除、平息其自身相续中之瞋垢或与此同处之恶法,且能如实观察轮回之怖畏,其意乐不虚,故受用国食不唐捐。“有大利益”者,谓有大义利、大用途。“有大果报”者,谓有广大之果。“有大功德”者,谓有大异熟果。“有大光明”者,谓有大威力。“有大遍满”者,谓有大扩展。于此,第一因者,谓彼比丘因修习慈心,具足主宰等相,故堪受用国食;第二因者,谓能令他人所施之物具有大利益。“何待多言”者,其义为:仅修习慈心便有如是大威力,更何况多修习?于此实无庸赘言。 54. Catutthe uppādeti vaḍḍhetīti ettha bhāvanāsaddassa uppādanavaḍḍhanatthatā pubbe vuttā eva. 54. 于第四处,“令生起”与“令增长”,于此,“修习”(bhāvanā)一词具有令生起与令增长之义,此义已如前说。 55. Pañcame [Pg.110] imesu dvīsūti catutthapañcamesu. ‘‘Tatiye vuttanayeneva veditabba’’nti vatvā tathā veditabbataṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘yo hi āsevatī’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Tena āsevanābhāvanāmanasikārānaṃ atthavisesābhāvamāha. Yadi evaṃ suttantassa desanā kathanti āha – ‘‘sammāsambuddho panā’’tiādi. Yāya dhammadhātuyāti sabbaññutaññāṇamāha. Tena hi dhammānaṃ ākārabhedaṃ ñatvā tadanurūpaṃ ekampi dhammaṃ tathā vibhajitvā bhagavā dasseti. Tīhi koṭṭhāsehīti āsevanābhāvanāmanasikārabhāgehi. Mettā hi sabbavatthuno mettāyanavasena ānītā sevanā āsevanā, tassā vaḍḍhanā bhāvanā, avissajjetvā manasi ṭhapanaṃ manasikāro. 55. 第五,于此二者,即第四与第五。“当知如第三所说之理”,为示此义,故说“若有修习”等。以此说明修习(āsevanā)、培育(bhāvanā)、作意(manasikāra)三者于义无别。若尔,经教当如何解释?故说“然正等觉者”等。“以法界”者,乃指一切知智。世尊(bhagavā)了知诸法之相别,故能依此,纵唯一法,亦详为分别开示。“以三部分”者,即修习、培育、作意三部分。于一切有情,由散发慈心而引生之行,是为修习;令其增长,是为培育;不舍而置于心中,是为作意。 56. Chaṭṭhe aniyamitavacanaṃ ‘‘ime nāmā’’ti niyametvā avuttattā. Niyamitavacanaṃ ‘‘akusalā’’ti sarūpeneva vuttattā. Asesato pariyādinnā honti appakassapi akusalabhāgassa aggahitassa abhāvato. Akusalaṃ bhajantīti akusalabhāgiyā. Akusalapakkhe bhavāti akusalapakkhikā. Tenāha – ‘‘akusalāyevā’’tiādi. Paṭhamataraṃ gacchatīti paṭhamataraṃ pavattati, paṭhamo padhāno hutvā vattatīti attho. Ekuppādādivasena hi ekajjhaṃ pavattamānesu catūsu arūpakkhandhesu ayameva paṭhamaṃ uppajjatīti idaṃ natthi, lokuttaramaggesu viya pana paññindriyassa, lokiyadhammesu manindriyassa puretarassa bhāvo sātisayoti ‘‘sabbete manopubbaṅgamā’’ti vuttaṃ. Tathā hi abhidhammepi (dha. sa. 1) ‘‘yasmiṃ samaye kāmāvacaraṃ kusalaṃ cittaṃ uppannaṃ hotī’’ti cittaṃ pubbaṅgamaṃ jeṭṭhaṃ katvā desanā pavattā. Suttesupi vuttaṃ – ‘‘manopubbaṅgamā dhammā (dha. pa. 1, 2), chadvārādhipati rājā’’ti (dha. pa. aṭṭha. 2.buddhavaggo, erakapattanāgarājavatthu). Tenāha – ‘‘ete hī’’tiādi. Tesaṃ mano uppādakoti ca yadaggena mano sampayuttadhammānaṃ jeṭṭhako hutvā pavattati, tadaggena te attānaṃ anuvattāpento te tathā uppādento nāma hotīti katvā vuttaṃ. Aṭṭhakathāyaṃ pana cittassa jeṭṭhakabhāvameva sandhāya rājagamanaññāyena sahuppattipi paṭhamuppatti viya katvā vuttāti ayamattho dassito. Anvadevāti eteneva cittassa khaṇavasena paṭhamuppattiyā abhāvo dīpitoti daṭṭhabbo. Tenevāha – ‘‘ekatoyevāti attho’’ti. 56. 第六,不限定语,因未如“此等名为”般加以限定。限定语,因已如“不善”般由其自相而说。此等皆被无余含摄,因无有丝毫未被把握之不善部分。行不善者,为不善分者;住于不善一方者,为不善朋党者。故说“唯是不善”等。“最先而行”,即最先转起,义为作为首要者而转起。于四无色蕴依同时生起等而一同转起时,并无此蕴先生起之说;然如于出世间道中慧根为首,于世间法中意根尤为卓越,故说“一切皆以意为前导”。诚然,于阿毗达摩(abhidhamma)中亦说:“于某时,欲界善心生起”,此即以心为前导、为首而说。经中亦说:“诸法意先行”(dha. pa. 1, 2),“六门之主如王”(dha. pa. aṭṭha. 2.buddhavaggo, erakapattanāgarājavatthu)。故说“此等实为”等。“意为彼等之生起者”,此说乃因:当意作为相应法中之首要者而转起时,即能引导彼等随己而转,令彼等如是生起。然于义注(aṭṭhakathā)中,则着眼于心之首要性,以国王出巡为例,将同时生起说为犹如先生起,此义已明。“紧随”一词,正说明心于刹那间并无先生起,当知此理。故说:“义为同时”。 57. Sattame [Pg.111] catubhūmakāpi kusalā dhammā kathitāti ‘‘ye keci kusalā dhammā’’ti anavasesapariyādānato vuttaṃ. 57. 第七,四地之善法亦被宣说,故说“任何善法”,乃为无余含摄之故。 58. Aṭṭhame idanti liṅgavipallāsena niddeso, nipātapadaṃ vā etaṃ ‘‘yadida’’ntiādīsu viyāti āha – ‘‘ayaṃ pamādoti attho’’ti. Pamajjanākāroti pamādāpatti. Cittassa vossaggoti imesu ettakesu ṭhānesu satiyā aniggaṇhitvā cittassa vossajjanaṃ sativiraho. Vossaggānuppadānanti vossaggassa anu anu padānaṃ punappunaṃ vissajjanaṃ. Asakkaccakiriyatāti etesaṃ dānādīnaṃ kusaladhammānaṃ pavattane puggalassa vā deyyadhammassa vā asakkaccakiriyā. Satatabhāvo sātaccaṃ, sātaccena kiriyā sātaccakiriyā, sāyeva sātaccakiriyatā, na sātaccakiriyatā asātaccakiriyatā. Anaṭṭhitakiriyatāti aniṭṭhitakiriyatā nirantaraṃ na anuṭṭhitakiriyatā ca. Olīnavuttitāti nirantarakaraṇasaṅkhātassa vipphārassa abhāvena olīnavuttitā. Nikkhittachandatāti kusalakiriyāya vīriyachandassa nikkhittabhāvo. Nikkhittadhuratāti vīriyadhurassa oropanaṃ, osakkitamānasatāti attho. Anadhiṭṭhānanti kusalakaraṇe appatiṭṭhitabhāvo. Ananuyogoti ananuyuñjanaṃ. Kusaladhammesu āsevanādīnaṃ abhāvo anāsevanādayo. Pamādoti sarūpaniddeso. Pamajjanāti ākāraniddeso. Pamajjitattanti bhāvaniddeso. Parihāyantīti iminā pamādassa sāvajjataṃ dasseti. Tayidaṃ lokiyānaṃ vasena, na lokuttarānanti āha – ‘‘uppannā…pe… ida’’ntiādi. 58. 第八,“此”(idaṃ)是透过语性转换所作的解释,或者它是一个如“即是”(yadidaṃ)等的不变词,所以说:“此即放逸之义”。放逸之行相即是放逸之事。心之舍弃,是指在这些地方,心不为念所摄持而任其放纵,即是失念。相继舍弃,是指一再地、持续地舍弃。不恭敬行,是指在行布施等善法时,对个人或所施之物不恭敬。持续的状态是恒常(sātaccaṃ),以恒常而行是恒常之行(sātaccakiriyā),此即是恒常之行(sātaccakiriyatā),非恒常之行即是不恒常之行(asātaccakiriyatā)。不稳固之行(anaṭṭhitakiriyatā)是指未完成之行,以及非持续之行。懈怠的行为(olīnavuttitā),是指因缺乏持续的努力而行为迟滞。舍弃欲(nikkhittachandatā),是指舍弃了行善的精进欲。舍弃担(nikkhittadhuratā),是指卸下了精进的重担,意即心意退缩。不决意(anadhiṭṭhānaṃ),是指于行善不坚定。不勤勉(ananuyogo),是指不努力。于诸善法不修习等,即是“不修习”等词的含义。放逸(pamādo),是自性的解释。放逸行(pamajjanaṃ),是行相的解释。放逸的状态(pamajjitattaṃ),是状态的解释。“会退失”(parihāyanti)一词,显示了放逸的过患。这是就世间法而言,非就出世间法而言,所以说:“已生起……乃至……此”等。 59. Navame na pamajjati etenāti appamādo, pamādassa paṭipakkho satiyā avippavāso. Atthato niccaṃ upaṭṭhitāya satiyā etaṃ nāmaṃ. Pamādo pana satiyā satisampajaññassa vā paṭipakkhabhūto akusalacittuppādo daṭṭhabbo. Tenāha – ‘‘pamādassa paṭipakkhavasena vitthārato veditabbo’’ti. 59. 第九,“因此而不放逸”,故为“不放逸”(appamādo),即放逸的对治,与念不分离。从意义上说,此名称是指恒常现起的念。而放逸,则应被视为与念或念与正知相对立的不善心生起。因此说:“应从其作为放逸的对治来详细理解。” 60. Dasame kucchitaṃ sīdatīti kusīto da-kārassa ta-kāraṃ katvā, tassa bhāvo kosajjaṃ, ālasiyanti attho. 60. 第十,“以卑劣的方式沉滞”(kucchitaṃ sīdati),是为“懈怠者”(kusīto),此中“da”音转为“ta”音。其状态为“懈怠”(kosajjaṃ),意即懒惰。 Accharāsaṅghātavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 弹指品释义 终。 7. Vīriyārambhādivaggavaṇṇanā 7. 精进等品释义 61. Sattamassa [Pg.112] paṭhame vīrānaṃ kammanti vīriyaṃ, vidhinā vā īrayitabbaṃ pavattetabbanti vīriyaṃ, tadeva kusalakiriyāya padhānaṭṭhena ārambho vīriyārambho. Āraddhavīriyatā paggahitavīriyatā paripuṇṇavīriyatāti paccekaṃ vīriyatāsaddo yojetabbo. 61. 第七品第一,“勇者(vīra)之行”,是为“精进”(vīriyaṃ);或“应以方法(vidhinā)激发、推动”,是为“精进”。那精进本身,因其在善行中作为首要之事,故为“发起”(ārambho),合为“发起精进”(vīriyārambho)。“已发起精进的状态”(āraddhavīriyatā)、“已策励精进的状态”(paggahitavīriyatā)、“已圆满精进的状态”(paripuṇṇavīriyatā),应知每一词皆是精进的状态。 62. Dutiye mahatī icchā etassāti mahiccho, tassa bhāvo mahicchatā. Mahāvisayo lobho mahālobho mahantānaṃ vatthūnaṃ bahūnañca abhigijjhanato. Itarītarātiādinā pabbajitānaṃ uppajjanamahicchatā vuttā. Pañcahi kāmaguṇehītiādi gahaṭṭhānaṃ vasena vuttaṃ. Icchāti sabhāvaniddeso. Icchāgatāti icchāpavattā. Mahicchatāti mahāicchatā. Atthato panāyaṃ rāgo evāti vuttaṃ – ‘‘rāgo sārāgo’’tiādi. 62. 第二,“有大欲者”(mahiccho),是指他有巨大的欲望;其状态为“大欲”(mahicchatā)。范围广大的贪是为大贪,因为它贪求众多贵重之物与大量物品。“种种”等词,是说明出家人生起的大欲。而“五种欲乐”等,是就居家者的情况而说。“欲”(icchā),是自性的解释。“由欲所致”(icchāgata),是指由欲而转起。“大欲”(mahicchatā),即是巨大的欲望。从意义上说,这其实就是贪,如经中所说:“贪、强烈的贪”等。 63. Tatiye appicchassāti ettha appa-saddo abhāvattho ‘‘appābādho hoti appātaṅko’’tiādīsu (ma. ni. 2.304) viyāti āha – ‘‘anicchassā’’ti. Loke pākaṭassa hi akkhirogakucchirogādibhedassa ābādhassa abhāvaṃ sandhāya ‘‘appābādho’’ti vuttaṃ. Idāni vuttamevatthaṃ pākaṭataraṃ kātuṃ ‘‘ettha hī’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Byañjanaṃ sāvasesaṃ viya parittakepi appasaddassa dissamānattā. Attho pana niravaseso sabbaso paccayicchāya abhāvassa adhippetattā. Tenāha – ‘‘na hī’’tiādi. 63. 第三,于“少欲者”(appicchassa)一词中,“少”(appa)字是“无”的意思,如同在“少病、少恼”(appābādho hoti appātaṅko)(《中部》2.304)等经文中的用法,所以说即是“无欲者”(anicchassa)。所谓“少病”,是指没有世间常见的眼病、腹病等疾病。现在为了更清楚地说明此义,而说“于此”等。从文句上看,“少”(appa)一词似乎有“尚有少量”的含义,但其意义却是“全无”,因为此处意指完全没有对资具的欲求。因此说“实无”等。 Icchāya abhāveneva appiccho nāma hotīti imamatthaṃ pakārantarena dīpetuṃ – ‘‘apicā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Atricchatā nāma atra atra icchā. Asantaguṇasambhāvanatāya pāpā lāmikā nihīnā icchā pāpicchatā. Yāya paccayuppādanatthaṃ attani vijjamānaguṇe sambhāveti, paccayānaṃ paṭiggahaṇe ca na mattaṃ jānāti, ayaṃ mahicchatā. Asantaguṇasambhāvanatāti attani avijjamānānaṃ guṇānaṃ vijjamānānaṃ viya paresaṃ pakāsanā. Santaguṇasambhāvanatāti icchācāre ṭhatvā attani vijjamānasīladhutadhammādiguṇavibhāvanā. Tādisassapi paṭiggahaṇe amattaññutāpi hoti, sāpi abhidhamme āgatāyevāti sambandho. Dussantappayoti duttappayo. 为了以另一种方式阐明“因无欲求,故名少欲者”之义,而说“再者”等。“极欲”(atricchatā),是指于此处、彼处生起欲求。“恶欲”(pāpicchatā),是指因夸示自身不实的功德而生起的邪恶、低劣、卑下的欲求。为了获得资具而显扬自身已有的功德,且在接受时不知适量,此为“大欲”(mahicchatā)。“夸示不实功德”(asantaguṇasambhāvanatā),是指向他人宣扬自身没有的功德,犹如拥有一般。“显扬已有功德”(santaguṇasambhāvanatā),是指住于正当的行为中,显扬自身所具有的戒、头陀行等功德。即使是这样的人,在接受时也可能不知节制,此亦关乎阿毗达摩中所说之法。“难满足者”(dussantappayo)即是“难令满足者”(duttappayo)。 Atilūkhabhāvanti [Pg.113] pattacīvaravasena ativiya lūkhabhāvaṃ. Tadassa disvā manussā ‘‘ayaṃ amaṅgaladivaso, sumbhakasiniddhapattacīvaro ayyo pubbaṅgamo kātabbo’’ti cintetvā, ‘‘bhante, thokaṃ bahi hothā’’ti āhaṃsu. Ummujjīti manussānaṃ ajānantānaṃyeva pathaviyaṃ nimujjitvā gaṇhantoyeva ummujji. Yadi thero ‘‘khīṇāsavabhāvaṃ jānantū’’ti iccheyya, na naṃ manussā ‘‘bahi hothā’’ti vadeyyuṃ, khīṇāsavānaṃ pana tathācittameva na uppajjeyya. “极其粗劣的状态”,是指衣钵非常粗陋。人们看到后心想:“今天真不吉利,应该让衣钵光洁油亮的尊者走在前面。”于是说:“尊者,请稍微退到后面去。”“浮现”,是指在人们不知不觉中,他潜入地里,取了东西后才浮现出来。如果长老希望人们知道他是漏尽者,人们就不会说“请到后面去”了;然而,漏尽者根本不会生起这样的心。 Appicchatāpadhānaṃ puggalādhiṭṭhānaṃ catubbidhaicchāpabhedaṃ dassetvā punapi puggalādhiṭṭhānena catubbidhaṃ icchābhedaṃ dassento ‘‘aparopi catubbidho appiccho’’tiādimāha. Paccayaappicchoti paccayesu icchārahito. Dhutaṅgaappicchoti dhutaguṇasambhāvanāya icchārahito. Pariyattiappicchoti bahussutasambhāvanāya icchārahito. Adhigamaappicchoti ‘‘ariyo’’ti sambhāvanāya icchārahito. Dāyakassa vasanti appaṃ vā yaṃ dātukāmo bahuṃ vāti dāyakassa cittassa vasaṃ, ajjhāsayanti attho. Deyyadhammassa vasanti deyyadhammassa abahubhāvaṃ. Attano thāmanti attano pamāṇaṃ. Yattakena attā yāpeti, tattakasseva gahaṇaṃ. Yadi hītiādi saṅkhepato vuttassa atthassa vivaraṇaṃ. Pamāṇenevāti yāpanappamāṇeneva. 在以少欲为主,依人(puggala)而立,显示了四种欲的差别后,又再次依人而立,说明四种欲的差别,而说:“另有四种少欲者”等。资具少欲者,是对资具无欲求。头陀行少欲者,是不为被称誉有头陀功德而生欲。教理少欲者,是不为被称誉博学而生欲。证悟少欲者,是不为被称誉为“圣者”而生欲。“随顺施者”,是指随顺施者的心意,即随顺其意乐,无论他想布施多或少。“随顺所施之物”,是指随顺所施之物量少。“随顺自身体力”,是指随顺自己的食量。只取能维持身体所需的份量。“若”等词,是对前文所略说之义的阐释。“仅依所需之量”,即仅依维持色身之量。 Ekabhikkhupi nāññāsīti sosānikavatte sammadeva vattitattā ekopi bhikkhu na aññāsi. Abbokiṇṇanti avicchedaṃ. Dutiyo maṃ jāneyyāti dutiyo sahāyabhūtopi yathā maṃ jānituṃ na sakkuṇeyya, tathā saṭṭhi vassāni nirantaraṃ susāne vasāmi, tasmā ahaṃ aho sosānikuttamo. Upakāro hutvāti uggahaparipucchādīhi pariyattidhammavasena upakāro hutvā. Dhammakathāya janapadaṃ khobhetvāti lomahaṃsanasādhukāradānacelukkhepādivasena sannipatitaṃ itarañca ‘‘kathaṃ nu kho appaṃ ayyassa santike dhammaṃ sossāmā’’ti kolāhalavasena mahājanaṃ khobhetvā? Yadi thero bahussutabhāvaṃ jānāpetuṃ iccheyya, pubbeva janapadaṃ khobhento dhammaṃ katheyya. Gatoti ‘‘ayaṃ so, yena rattiyaṃ dhammakathā katā’’ti jānanabhāvena pariyattiappicchatāya purāruṇāva gato. “一比丘亦不知”是指,因正确地实践冢间住行(sosānikavatta),故无一比丘知晓。“不间断(abbokiṇṇa)”即无间断。“第二人应知我”是指,为使第二位同伴亦不能了知我,如是六十年来不间断地住于冢间,因此我乃冢间住行者中最殊胜者。“成为助益”是指,通过学习、提问等方式,在教法方面成为助益。“以说法震动国土”是指,通过(听法者)毛骨悚然、高呼善哉、抛掷衣物等方式,聚集起来的众人发出“如何才能从尊者处听闻少许法义?”的喧哗声,以此震动大众吗?若长老欲显示其博学,则应先震动国土而后说法。“已去”是指,因(不欲)人知“此即昨夜说法之人”,为(显示)对所学(法)的少欲,故于黎明前离去。 Tayo [Pg.114] kulaputtā viyāti pācīnavaṃsadāye sāmaggivāsaṃvuṭṭhā anuruddho, nandiyo, kimiloti ime tayo kulaputtā viya. Etesupi hi anuruddhattherena bhagavatā ‘‘atthi pana vo anuruddhā evaṃ appamattānaṃ ātāpīnaṃ pahitattānaṃ viharantānaṃ uttarimanussadhammo alamariyañāṇadassanaviseso adhigato phāsuvihāro’’ti (ma. ni. 1.328) puṭṭhena ‘‘idha pana mayaṃ, bhante, yāvadeva ākaṅkhāma, vivicceva kāmehi vivicca akusalehi dhammehi savitakkaṃ savicāraṃ vivekajaṃ pītisukhaṃ paṭhamaṃ jhānaṃ upasampajja viharāmā’’tiādinā (ma. ni. 1.328) anupubbavihārasamāpattīsu ārocitāsu itare therā na icchiṃsu. Tathā hi te pakkante bhagavati āyasmantaṃ anuruddhaṃ etadavocuṃ – ‘‘kinnu mayaṃ āyasmato anuruddhassa evamārocimha ‘imāsañca imāsañca vihārasamāpattīnaṃ mayaṃ lābhino’ti? Yaṃ no āyasmā anuruddho bhagavato sammukhāpi āsavānaṃ khayaṃ pakāsetī’’ti? Ghaṭīkāropi attano ariyabhāve kikissa rañño bhagavatā ārocite na attamano ahosi? Tenāha – ‘‘ghaṭīkārakumbhakāro viyā’’ti. Imasmiṃ panattheti ‘‘yathayidaṃ, bhikkhave, appicchatā’’ti vutte appicchatāsaṅkhāte atthe. Balavaalobhenāti daḷhatarappavattikena alobhena. “如三位良家子”是指,如在东方竹林(Pācīnavaṃsadāya)和合而住的阿那律(Anuruddha)、南迪亚(Nandiya)、金毗罗(Kimila)这三位良家子。世尊曾问阿那律长老:“阿那律,你们如此不放逸、热忱、精勤而住,是否已证得超越人法的、圣智见的殊胜安乐住?”阿那律回答:“世尊,于此,我们随其所欲,皆能离诸欲、离诸不善法,成就并安住于有寻有伺、离生喜乐的初禅……”他依次叙说了所证得的次第住定,但其他长老对此不悦。因为当世尊离开后,他们对具寿阿那律说:“我们何曾向具寿阿那律报告过‘我们已得此等住定’?为何具寿阿那律在世尊面前宣说我们已尽诸漏(āsava)?”又如陶师伽提迦罗(Ghaṭīkāra),当世尊向迦尸王吉基(Kiki)揭示其圣者身份时,他亦不喜。故说“如陶师伽提迦罗”。“于此义中”是指,在“诸比丘,此即少欲”中所说的少欲之义。“以强力无贪”是指,以更强而生起的无贪。 64. Catutthe natthi etassa santuṭṭhīti asantuṭṭhi, tassa bhāvo asantuṭṭhitā. Taṃ pana sarūpato dassento ‘‘asantuṭṭhe puggale…pe… lobho’’ti āha. Sevantassātiādīni aññamaññavevacanāni. 64. 第四,“于此无满足”即为不满足(asantuṭṭhi),其状态为不满足性(asantuṭṭhitā)。为显示其自性,故说:“于不满足之人……乃至……贪(lobha)”。“交往者(sevantassa)”等是同义词。 65-67. Pañcame tussanaṃ tuṭṭhi, samaṃ, sakena, santena vā tuṭṭhi etassāti santuṭṭhi, tassa bhāvo santuṭṭhitā. Yassa santosassa atthitāya bhikkhu ‘‘santuṭṭho’’ti vuccati, taṃ dassento ‘‘itarītarapaccayasantosena samannāgatassā’’ti āha – cīvarādike yattha katthaci kappiye paccaye santussanena samaṅgībhūtassāti attho. Atha vā itaraṃ vuccati hīnaṃ paṇītato aññattā, tathā paṇītampi itaraṃ hīnato aññattā. Apekkhāsiddhā hi itaratā. Iti yena dhammena hīnena vā paṇītena vā cīvarādipaccayena santussati, so tathā pavatto alobho itarītarapaccayasantoso, tena samannāgatassa[Pg.115]. Yathālābhaṃ attano lābhānurūpaṃ santoso yathālābhasantoso. Sesapadadvayepi eseva nayo. Labbhatīti vā lābho, yo yo lābho yathālābho, tena santoso yathālābhasantoso. Balanti kāyabalaṃ. Sāruppanti bhikkhuno anucchavikatā. 65-67. 第五,喜悦(tussana)即是满足(tuṭṭhi)。以平等(samaṃ)、以己所有(sakena)或以现有(santena)而满足,故为知足(santuṭṭhi),其状态为知足性(santuṭṭhitā)。因具有此知足,比丘被称为“知足者”。为显示此义,故说“具足随缘资具之知足”,意即对任何适宜的衣物等资具皆能知足。又,“彼此(itara)”一词,因其异于殊胜,故称低劣;同样,因其异于低劣,殊胜者亦可称为“彼此”。“彼此”之性,实由对待而立。是故,无论对低劣或殊胜的衣物等资具皆能知足,如是生起的无贪(alobha)即是“随缘资具之知足”,具足此者(即是知足者)。“随其所得”而知足,即是随得满足(yathālābhasantoso)。其余二句亦同此理。又,所“得”者(labbhati)为“利”(lābha),任何利得皆为“随得”(yathālābha),于此知足即是随得满足。“力(bala)”指身力(kāyabala)。“适宜(sāruppa)”指适合比丘之身份。 Yathāladdhato aññassa apatthanā nāma siyā appicchatāpi pavattiākāroti tato vinivecitameva santosassa sarūpaṃ dassento ‘‘labhantopi na gaṇhātī’’ti āha. Taṃ parivattetvā pakatidubbalādīnaṃ garucīvaraṃ aphāsubhāvāvahaṃ sarīrakhedāvahañca hotīti payojanavasena na atricchatādivasena taṃ parivattetvā lahukacīvaraparibhogo santosavirodhi na hotīti āha – ‘‘lahukena yāpentopi santuṭṭhova hotī’’ti. Mahagghacīvaraṃ bahūni vā cīvarāni labhitvā tāni vissajjetvā tadaññassa gahaṇaṃ yathāsāruppanaye ṭhitattā na santosavirodhīti āha – ‘‘tesaṃ…pe… dhārentopi santuṭṭhova hotī’’ti. Evaṃ sesapaccayesupi yathāsāruppaniddese api-saddaggahaṇe adhippāyo veditabbo. Muttaharītakanti gomuttaparibhāvitaṃ, pūtibhāvena vā chaḍḍitaṃ harītakaṃ. Buddhādīhi vaṇṇitanti appicchatāsantuṭṭhīsu bhikkhū niyojetuṃ ‘‘pūtimuttabhesajjaṃ nissāya pabbajjā’’tiādinā (mahāva. 73, 128) buddhādīhi pasatthaṃ. Paramasantuṭṭhova hoti paramena ukkaṃsagatena santosena samannāgatattā. Yathāsāruppasantosova aggoti tattha tattha bhikkhu sāruppaṃyeva nissāya santussanavasena pavattanato aggo. Chaṭṭhasattamesu natthi vattabbaṃ. “于已得之外不希求”亦可谓少欲(appicchatā)之行相。为显示与此有别的知足之自性,故说“虽得而不取”。然而,对体弱者等,厚重衣物会带来不适与身体疲劳,故因实际需要而非贪欲等更换轻便衣物,受用轻便衣物并不违背知足,故说:“虽以轻便衣物维生,亦是知足。”获得昂贵或多件衣物后,舍弃彼等而受用其他适宜之物,因安住于随宜之道,故不违背知足,故说:“受持彼等……亦是知足。”如是,于其余资具,亦应依随宜之解释,了知(经文)中“亦”字之意。“牛尿诃梨勒(muttaharītaka)”指以牛尿浸渍,或因腐烂而弃之诃梨勒。“为佛陀等所赞叹”是指,为令比丘行于少欲知足,佛陀等以“依陈弃药而出家”等语(《大品》73, 128)而赞叹。“即是究竟知足者”,因其具足最上、最胜之知足。“随宜知足为最上”,因比丘于处处皆依适宜而行知足,故为最上。第六、七句无甚可说。 68-69. Aṭṭhamanavamesu na sampajānātīti asampajāno, tassa bhāvo asampajaññaṃ. Vuttappaṭipakkhena sampajaññaṃ veditabbaṃ. 68-69. 第八、九句,“不正知(na sampajānāti)”故为不正知者(asampajāno),其状态为不正知(asampajañña)。应通过与此相反者来了知正知(sampajañña)。 70. Dasame pāpamittā devadattasadisā. Te hi hīnācāratāya, dukkhassa vā sampāpakatāya ‘‘pāpā’’ti vuccanti. Tenākārena pavattānanti yo pāpamittassa khanti ruci adhimutti tanninnatātaṃsampavaṅkatādiākāro, tenākārena pavattānaṃ. Catunnaṃ khandhānamevetaṃ nāmanti catunnaṃ arūpakkhandhānaṃ [Pg.116] ‘‘pāpamittatā’’ti etaṃ nāmaṃ. Yasmā assaddhiyādipāpadhammasamannāgatā puggalā visesato pāpā puññadhammavimokkhatāya, te yassa mittā sahāyā, so pāpamitto, tassa bhāvo pāpamittatā. Tenāha – ‘‘ye te puggalā assaddhā’’tiādi. 70. 第十,恶友,如提婆达多(Devadatta)之流。彼等因行为卑劣,或因招致痛苦,故被称为“恶”。“以彼行相而行”是指,随恶友之忍耐、喜好、胜解、倾向、偏向等行相而行。“此仅四蕴之名”是指,“恶友性(pāpamittatā)”此名乃指四无色蕴。因具足不信等恶法之人,远离善法,故为特恶。若以彼等为友、为伴,即是恶友,其状态即是恶友性。故说:“彼等人为不信者”等。 Vīriyārambhādivaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 精勤发趣品释义终。 8. Kalyāṇamittādivaggavaṇṇanā 8. 善友品释义 71. Aṭṭhamassa paṭhame buddhā, sāriputtādayo vā kalyāṇamittā. Vuttapaṭipakkhanayenāti ‘‘pāpamittatā’’ti pade vuttassa paṭipakkhanayena. 71. 第八品第一节,善友为佛陀,或舍利弗(Sāriputta)等。“以所述之对反方法”是指,以与“恶友性”一词所述相反之方法。 72-73. Dutiye yogoti samaṅgībhāvo. Payogoti payuñjanaṃ paṭipatti. Ayogoti asamaṅgībhāvo. Appayogoti appayuñjanaṃ appaṭipatti. Anuyogenāti anuyogahetu. 72-73. 第二,相应(yoga)即是和合(samaṅgībhāva)。实行(payoga)即是应用(payuñjana)、实践(paṭipatti)。不相应(ayoga)即是不和合(asamaṅgībhāva)。不实行(appayoga)即是不应用(appayuñjana)、不实践(appaṭipatti)。“由勤行”是指因勤行故。 74. Catutthe bujjhanakasattassāti catunnaṃ ariyasaccānaṃ paṭivijjhanakapuggalassa. Aṅgabhūtāti tasseva paṭivedhassa kāraṇabhūtā. Ettha ca cattāri ariyasaccāni bujjhati, aññāṇaniddāya vāpi bujjhatīti bodhīti laddhanāmo ariyasāvako bujjhanakasatto, tassa bujjhanakasattassa. Bodhiyāti tassā dhammasāmaggisaṅkhātāya bodhiyā. Bujjhanaṭṭhena bodhiyo, bodhiyo eva saccasampaṭibodhassa aṅgāti vuttaṃ. ‘‘Bujjhantīti bojjhaṅgā’’ti. Vipassanādīnaṃ kāraṇānaṃ bujjhitabbānañca saccānaṃ anurūpaṃ bujjhanato anubujjhantīti bojjhaṅgā, paṭimukhaṃ paccakkhabhāvena abhimukhaṃ bujjhanato paṭibujjhantīti bojjhaṅgā, sammā aviparītato bujjhanato sambujjhantīti bojjhaṅgāti evaṃ atthavisesadīpakehi upasaggehi anubujjhantītiādi vuttaṃ. Bodhisaddo sabbavisesayuttaṃ bujjhanasāmaññena saṅgaṇhāti. Bodhāya saṃvattantīti iminā tassā dhammasāmaggiyā bujjhanassa ekantakāraṇataṃ dasseti. Evaṃ panetaṃ padaṃ vibhattamevāti vuttappakārena etaṃ ‘‘bojjhaṅgā’’ti (paṭi. ma. 2.17) padaṃ niddese paṭisambhidāmagge vibhattameva. 74. 第四,所谓“觉悟者(bujjhanakasatta)”,是指能彻知四圣谛者。所谓“作为组成部分”,即是此彻知之因。于此,因觉悟四圣谛,或从无明睡眠中觉醒,圣弟子获得了‘菩提’之名,他就是觉悟者,此即是对该觉悟者而言。所谓“菩提”,即是那名为法和合的菩提。以觉悟之义为菩提,菩提即是如实觉悟真理的组成部分,故说“因觉悟故为觉支”。与观(vipassanā)等原因和应被觉知的真理相应地觉知,故为随觉支;直接面对而觉知,故为对觉支;正确无误地觉知,故为正觉支。像这样,通过阐明意义差别的词头,以“随觉知”等来说明。菩提一词,以普遍的觉悟含摄了一切特殊的觉悟。“导向菩提”,这显示了那个法和合是觉悟的决定性原因。就这样,这个词“觉支”(bojjhaṅgā)已在《无碍解道》(Paṭisambhidāmagga)的解释(niddesa)中被详细分析。 75. Pañcame [Pg.117] yāthāvasarasabhūmīti yāthāvato sakiccakaraṇabhūmi. Sāti yāthāvasarasabhūmi. Vipassanāti balavavipassanā. Keci ‘‘bhaṅgañāṇato paṭṭhāyā’’ti vadanti. Vipassanāya pādakajjhāne ca satiādayo bojjhaṅgapakkhikā eva pariyāyabodhipakkhiyabhāvato. Tatthātiādi catubbidhānaṃ bojjhaṅgānaṃ bhūmivibhāgadassanaṃ. 75. 第五,是随顺其事之地(yāthāvasarasabhūmi),即如实地履行其职责之处。此即随顺其事之地。观(vipassanā)是强有力的观。有些人说“从坏灭智(bhaṅgañāṇa)开始”。在观的基础禅那中,念等觉支亦属觉支一分,因其为菩提分(bodhipakkhiya)的同义词之故。于彼,说明了四种觉支的地的划分。 76. Chaṭṭhe tesaṃ antareti tesaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ antare. Kāmaṃ saṅgītiāruḷhavasena appakamidaṃ suttapadaṃ, bhagavā panettha sannipatitaparisāya ajjhāsayānurūpaṃ vitthārikaṃ karotīti katvā idaṃ vuttaṃ – ‘‘mahatī desanā bhavissatī’’ti. Gāmanigamādikathā natthīti tassā kathāya atiracchānakathābhāvamāhu. Tathā hi sā pubbe bahuñātikaṃ ahosi bahupakkhaṃ, idāni appañātikaṃ appapakkhanti aniccatāmukhena niyyānikapakkhikā jātā. Etāyāti yathāvuttāya parihāniyā. Patikiṭṭhanti nihīnaṃ. Mama sāsaneti idaṃ kammassakatajjhānapaññānampi visesanameva. Tadubhayampi hi bāhirakānaṃ tappaññādvayato sātisayameva sabbaññubuddhānaṃ desanāya laddhavisesato vivaṭṭūpanissayato ca. 76. 第六,“在他们中间”是指在那些比丘中间。诚然,这句经文因被纳入结集而简短,但世尊在此为聚集的会众,随其意乐作了详尽开示,因此说“将有大法宣说”。没有村庄、城镇等话题,他们说那不是畜生论。因为那些话题,先前是多亲友、多党派的,现在是少亲友、少党派的,从无常的角度,已转变为导向出离的一分。所谓“由此”,即如前所说的衰退。所谓“卑劣”,是指低下的。所谓“我的教法”,这是业为己有(kammassakata)、禅那、智慧等的殊胜之处。那两者(禅那与智慧)也确实远超外道者的那两种智慧,因其从一切知佛陀的教说中获得殊胜,且以趋向涅槃为依止。 77. Sattame tesaṃ cittācāraṃ ñatvāti tathā kathentānaṃ tesaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ tattha upagamanena attano desanāya bhājanabhūtaṃ cittappavattiṃ ñatvā. Kammassakatādīti ādisaddena jhānapaññādīnaṃ catunnampi paññānaṃ gahaṇaṃ. 77. 第七,所谓“得知他们的心行”,即了知那些如此讲述的比丘们前来此处,其心念活动已成为自己说法的容器。所谓“业为己有(kammassakata)等”,是以“等”字含摄禅那、智慧等,以及四种智慧。 78-80. Aṭṭhamādīsu heṭṭhā vuttanayenevāti ‘‘yā esa mama sāsane’’tiādinā heṭṭhā vuttanayeneva. Sesamettha uttānatthameva. 78-80. 第八等处,如同前面所说的方式,即如“凡于我教法中”等处所说的方式一样。其余部分在此处意义显而易见。 Kalyāṇamittādivaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 善友等品释义终。 81-82. Navame vagge natthi vattabbaṃ. 81-82. 第九品无所当说。 10. Dutiyapamādādivaggavaṇṇanā 10. 第二放逸等品释义 98-115. Dasame vagge ajjhattasantāne bhavaṃ ajjhattikaṃ. Ajjhattasantānato bahiddhā bhavaṃ bāhiraṃ. Vuttapaṭipakkhanayenāti ‘‘avināsāyā’’ti evamādinā attho gahetabbo. Catukkoṭiketi ‘‘anuyogo akusalānaṃ[Pg.118], ananuyogo kusalānaṃ, anuyogo kusalānaṃ, ananuyogo akusalāna’’nti (a. ni. 1.96) evaṃ pariyosānasutte āgatanayaṃ gahetvā ‘‘nāhaṃ, bhikkhave, aññaṃ ekadhammampi samanupassāmī’’tiādinā (a. ni. 1.11) āgatasuttānaṃ samaññā jātā. 98-115. 第十品中,于内相续中生起的为内在。于内相续之外生起的为外在。所谓“以所说对治之理”,其义应依“为了不坏灭”等而取。所谓“四句”,是取自结尾经文中所说的方法,即‘致力于不善法,不致力于善法,致力于善法,不致力于不善法’(增支部1.96),由此,‘诸比丘,我不见有其他一法’等(增支部1.11)经文的通称便产生了。 130. Suttantanaye yathācodanā saṃkilesadhammānaṃ vipariyesanaṃ, taṃtaṃdhammakoṭṭhāsānañca ūnato adhikato ca pavedanaṃ adhammaṃ dhammoti dīpanaṃ. Tesaṃyeva pana aviparītato anūnādhikato ca pavedanaṃ dhammaṃ dhammoti dīpanaṃ. Evaṃ vinayappaṭipattiyā ayathāvidhippavedanaṃ adhammaṃ dhammoti dīpanaṃ. Yathāvidhippavedanaṃ dhammaṃ dhammoti dīpanaṃ. Suttantanayena pañcavidho saṃvaravinayo pahānavinayo ca vinayo, tappaṭipakkhena avinayo. Vinayanayena vatthusampadādinā yathāvidhippaṭipatti eva vinayo, tabbipariyāyena avinayo veditabbo. Tiṃsa nissaggiyā pācittiyāti ettha iti-saddo ādyattho. Tena dvenavuti pācittiyā, cattāro pāṭidesaniyā, satta adhikaraṇasamathāti imesaṃ saṅgaho. Ekatiṃsa nissaggiyāti ettha ‘‘tenavuti pācittiyā’’tiādinā vattabbaṃ. Sesamettha suviññeyyameva. 130. 依经教之理,不如理地寻求杂染法,以及对各个法蕴或减或增地宣说,是将非法说为法。反之,对这些法如实不颠倒、不增不减地宣说,是将法说为法。同样,在律的实践上,不如法地宣说,是将非法说为法;如法地宣说,是将法说为法。依经教之理,五种防护律与断律即是律,与此相反的即是非律。依律教之理,凭借事件的圆满等如理行持即是律,与此相违的当知为非律。在“三十尼萨耆波逸提(nissaggiya pācittiya)”中,iti一词有“等”的含义。因此,九十二波逸提、四波罗提提舍尼、七灭诤法(adhikaraṇasamathā)都包含在内。在“三十一尼萨耆”中,应说“九十二波逸提”等。其余的在此处很容易理解。 Adhigantabbato adhigamo, maggaphalāni. Nibbānaṃ pana antaradhānābhāvato idha na gayhati. Paṭipajjanaṃ paṭipatti, sikkhattayasamāyogo. Paṭipajjitabbato vā paṭipatti. Pariyāpuṇitabbato pariyatti, piṭakattayaṃ. Maggaggahaṇena gahitāpi tatiyavijjāchaṭṭhābhiññā vijjābhiññāsāmaññato ‘‘tisso vijjā cha abhiññā’’ti punapi gahitā. Tato paraṃ cha abhiññāti vassasahassato paraṃ cha abhiññā nibbattetuṃ sakkonti, na paṭisambhidāti adhippāyo. Tatoti abhiññākālato pacchā. Tāti abhiññāyo. Pubbabhāge jhānasinehābhāvena kevalāya vipassanāya ṭhatvā aggaphalappattā sukkhavipassakā nāma, maggakkhaṇe pana ‘‘jhānasineho natthī’’ti na vattabbo ‘‘samathavipassanaṃ yuganaddhaṃ bhāvetī’’ti (a. ni. 4.170) vacanato. Pacchimakassāti sabbapacchimassa. Kiñcāpi ariyo aparihānadhammo[Pg.119], sotāpannassa pana uddhaṃ jīvitapariyādānā adhigatadhammo uppanno nāma natthi, paccayasāmaggiyā asati yāva uparivisesaṃ nibbattetuṃ na sakkonti, tāva adhigamassa asambhavo evāti āha – ‘‘sotāpannassa…pe… nāma hotī’’ti. Tassidaṃ manussalokavasena vuttanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. 因应被证得,故为证得,即道与果。涅槃因其不隐没之故,此处不予含摄。因应去实践,故为实践,即三学之结合;或因应被行持,故为实践。因应被遍学,故为遍学,即三藏。虽已由道摄取了第三明与第六神通,但因明与神通的通称,故再次摄取为“三明六通”。其意为:此后,即千年之后,才能生起六神通,而非无碍解(paṭisambhidā)。所谓‘其后’,是指神通之时后。所谓‘彼等’,是指诸神通。在前期,因无禅定之喜爱,仅依纯粹的观(vipassanā)而住,证得最上果者,名为干观者;但在道的刹那,则不能说“无禅定喜爱”,因经中说“修习止观双运”。所谓‘最后的’,是指一切之中最后的。虽然圣者是不退法者,但对须陀洹而言,此后直至命终,若无因缘和合,则不能生起更高的殊胜境界,因此(更高的)证悟亦不可能,(新的)已证之法也不会生起。故说:“对须陀洹……乃至……名为”。当知此说是依人界而言。 Na codentīti aññamaññasmiṃ vijjamānaṃ dosaṃ jānantāpi na codenti na sārenti. Akukkuccakā hontīti kukkuccaṃ na uppādenti. ‘‘Asakkaccakārino hontī’’ti ca paṭhanti, sāthalikatāya sikkhāsu asakkaccakārino hontīti attho. Bhikkhūnaṃ satepi sahassepi dharamāneti idaṃ bāhullavasena vuttaṃ. Antimavatthuanajjhāpannesu katipayamattesupi bhikkhūsu dharantesu, ekasmiṃ vā dharante paṭipatti anantarahitā eva nāma hoti. Tenevāha – ‘‘pacchimakassa…pe… antarahitā hotī’’ti. 他们即使知道彼此间存在的过失,也不互相指责、不互相劝诫。他们没有忧悔,即不生起忧悔。“他们行为不恭敬”也有此读法,其义是由于懈怠,在学处上行为不恭敬。即使有成百上千的比丘住世——这是从多数而言。即使只有少数比丘住世,或只有一位比丘住世,若他们不犯最后之罪,则修行就不会断绝。因此说:“最后的……传承不灭”。 Antevāsike gahetunti antevāsike saṅgahetuṃ. Atthavasenāti aṭṭhakathāvasena. Matthakato paṭṭhāyāti uparito paṭṭhāya. Uposathakkhandhakamattanti vinayamātikāpāḷimāha. Āḷavakapañhādīnaṃ viya devesu pariyattiyā pavatti appamāṇanti āha – ‘‘manussesū’’ti. 摄受弟子,即为了接引弟子。所谓依义,即依义注。从顶端开始,即从上方开始。仅布萨犍度,是指《律藏》的《母论》。如阿拉威问等经,教法在天界的流传是无量的,因此说“在人间”。 Oṭṭhaṭṭhivaṇṇanti oṭṭhānaṃ aṭṭhivaṇṇaṃ, dantakasāvaṃ ekaṃ vā dve vā vāre rajitvā dantavaṇṇaṃ katvā dhārentīti vuttaṃ hoti. Kesesu vā allīyāpentīti tena kāsāvakhaṇḍena kese bandhantā allīyāpenti. Bhikkhugottassa abhibhavanato vināsanato gotrabhuno. Atha vā gottaṃ vuccati sādhāraṇaṃ nāmaṃ, mattasaddo luttaniddiṭṭho, tasmā ‘‘samaṇā’’ti gottamattaṃ anubhavanti dhārentīti gotrabhuno, nāmamattasamaṇāti attho. Kāsāvagatakaṇṭhatāya, kāsāvaggahaṇahetuuppajjanakasokatāya vā kāsāvakaṇṭhā. Saṅghagatanti saṅghaṃ uddissa dinnattā saṅghagataṃ. Taṃ sarīranti taṃ dhātusarīraṃ. 驼骨色,即骆驼骨的颜色,是指将牙齿用赭色物染一两次,使其呈现骨色而佩戴。或附于发上,即用那块袈裟布条束发。坏种姓者,因其压倒、毁坏比丘的种姓。或者,种姓(gotta)是说共同的名称,其中“仅”(matta)一词是省略语,因此,他们仅承受、拥有“沙门”之名,故为坏种姓者,意思是仅有名义的沙门。因袈裟围颈,或因获得袈裟而生忧,故名“袈裟颈”。归属僧伽,即因指定给予僧伽,故归属僧伽。那个身体,即那个舍利身。 Tenevāti pariyattiantaradhānamūlakattā eva itaraantaradhānassa. Sakko devarājā chātakabhaye paratīragamanāya bhikkhū ussukkamakāsīti adhippāyo. Neti ubhayepi paṃsukūlikatthere dhammakathikatthere ca. Therāti tattha ṭhitā sakkhibhūtā therā. Dhammakathikattherā ‘‘yāva tiṭṭhanti [Pg.120] suttantā…pe… yogakkhemā na dhaṃsatī’’ti idaṃ suttaṃ āharitvā ‘‘suttante rakkhite sante, paṭipatti hoti rakkhitā’’ti iminā vacanena paṃsukūlikatthere appaṭibhāne akaṃsu. Idāni pariyattiyā anantaradhānameva itaresaṃ anantaradhānahetūti imamatthaṃ byatirekato anvayato ca upamāhi vibhāvetuṃ ‘‘yathā hī’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Taṃ suviññeyyameva. 正因教法的隐没是其他隐没的根本。其意是:帝释天王(Sakka devarājā)因饥荒之惧,激励比丘们前往彼岸。并非指粪扫衣长老和说法长老两者。长老,是指当时在场作为见证的长老们。说法长老引用“只要经文存续……乃至……安稳就不会消亡”这段经文,并以“经文若受护持,修行亦得护持”之语,使粪扫衣长老们无言以对。现在,为从反面和正面,用譬喻阐明“教法不隐没,才是其他法不隐没之因”此义,故说“犹如……”等。这很容易理解。 Dutiyapamādādivaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 第二放逸等品释义终。 140-150. Ekādasamadvādasamavaggā suviññeyyā eva. 140-150. 第十一、十二品易于理解。 13. Ekapuggalavaggavaṇṇanā 13. 一人品释义 170. Ekapuggalassāti ekapuggalavaggassa. Tenāha – ‘‘paṭhame’’ti. Ekoti gaṇanaparicchedo, tato eva dutiyādipaṭikkhepattho. Padhānāsahāyatthopi ekasaddo hotīti tannivattanatthaṃ ‘‘gaṇanaparicchedo’’ti āha. Sammutiyā desanā sammutidesanā. Paramatthassa desanā paramatthadesanā. Tatthāti sammutiparamatthadesanāsu, na sammutiparamatthesu. Tenāha – ‘‘evarūpā sammutidesanā, evarūpā paramatthadesanā’’ti. Tatridaṃ sammutiparamatthānaṃ lakkhaṇaṃ – yasmiṃ bhinne, buddhiyā vā avayavavinibbhoge kate na taṃsamaññā, sā ghaṭapaṭādippabhedā sammuti, tabbipariyāyena paramatthā. Na hi kakkhaḷaphusanādisabhāve so nayo labbhati. Tattha rūpādidhammasamūhaṃ santānavasena pavattamānaṃ upādāya puggalavohāroti puggaloti sammutidesanā. Sesapadesupi eseva nayo. Uppādavayavanto sabhāvadhammā na niccāti aniccāti āha – ‘‘aniccanti paramatthadesanā’’ti. Esa nayo sesapadesupi. Nanu khandhadesanāpi sammutidesanāva. Rāsaṭṭho vā hi khandhaṭṭho koṭṭhāsaṭṭho vāti? Saccametaṃ, ayaṃ pana khandhasamaññā phassādīsu pavattatajjāpaññatti viya paramatthasannissayā tassa āsannatarā, puggalasamaññādayo viya na dūreti paramatthasaṅgahā vuttā. Khandhasīsena vā tadupādānasabhāvadhammā eva gahitā. Nanu ca sabhāvadhammā sabbepi sammutimukheneva desanaṃ ārohanti, na samukhenāti sabbāpi desanā sammutidesanāva siyāti? Nayidamevaṃ, desetabbadhammavibhāgena desanāvibhāgassa adhippetattā. Na hi saddo kenaci pavattinimittena vinā atthaṃ pakāsetīti. 170. 所谓“一人”,即一人品。因此说“于初品”。“一”是数量的限定,由此排除第二等义。因“一”字亦有主要、无伴之义,为简别此义,故说“数量的限定”。依世俗的教说为“世俗说”,依胜义的教说为“胜义说”。此中,是指于世俗说与胜义说,而非于世俗与胜义本身。因此说:“如是者为世俗说,如是者为胜义说。”此中,世俗与胜义的相状是:当其被破坏,或以智慧将其部分分解后,其名称即不存在,如瓶、布等类别,是为世俗;与此相违者,是为胜义。于坚、触等自性中,此理不可得。此中,依于色等诸法之聚合相续流转而有“人”之言说,故说“人”是世俗说。其余诸例,理亦同然。有生灭的自性法并非恒常,故说“无常”,此为胜义说。其余诸例,理亦同然。问:蕴说不也是世俗说吗?蕴义岂非积聚义、部分义?答:诚然。但“蕴”此名称,犹如依触等而起的世俗概念,是依止于胜义,较“人”等名称更为切近,而非远离,故摄于胜义说。或以蕴为首,即摄彼所依之自性法。问:一切自性法,岂非皆由世俗而得言说,非由自性?如是,一切教说皆应为世俗说。答:不然。教说之分别,意在所说之法的分别。因为声音若无任何应用的根据,则无法开显其义。 Sammutivasena [Pg.121] desanaṃ sutvāti ‘‘idhekacco puggalo attantapo hoti attaparitāpānuyogamanuyutto’’tiādinā (pu. pa. 174) sammutimukhena pavattitadesanaṃ sutamayañāṇuppādavasena sutvā. Atthaṃ paṭivijjhitvāti tadanusārena catusaccasaṅkhātaṃ atthaṃ saha vipassanāya maggapaññāya paṭivijjhitvā. Mohaṃ pahāyāti tadekaṭṭhakilesehi saddhiṃ anavasesaṃ mohaṃ pajahitvā. Visesanti aggaphalanibbānasaṅkhātaṃ visesaṃ. Tesanti tādisānaṃ veneyyānaṃ. Paramatthavasenāti ‘‘pañcimāni, bhikkhave, indriyānī’’tiādinā (saṃ. ni. 5.471-476 ādayo) paramatthadhammavasena. Sesaṃ anantaranaye vuttasadisameva. 听闻世俗说,即如“此中,有一人(puggala)是苦行者,勤于苦行”等(《人施设论》),通过听闻以世俗方式宣说的教法而生起闻所成智。通达义,即依此以观(vipassanā)与道慧通达名为四圣谛之义。断除痴,即连同与之一义的诸烦恼,无余断除愚痴。殊胜,即名为最高果与涅槃的殊胜法。彼等,即指如是所化之众。依胜义,即如“诸比丘,有此五根”等(《相应部》),是依胜义法。余者如前述。 Tatrāti tassaṃ sammutivasena paramatthavasena ca desanāyaṃ. Desabhāsākusaloti nānādesabhāsāsu kusalo. Tiṇṇaṃ vedānanti nidassanamattaṃ, tiṇṇaṃ vedānaṃ sippuggahaṇaṭṭhānānampīti adhippāyo. Teneva sippuggahaṇaṃ parato vakkhati. Sippāni vā vijjāṭṭhānabhāvena vedantogadhāni katvā ‘‘tiṇṇaṃ vedāna’’nti vuttaṃ. Kathetabbabhāvena ṭhitāni, na katthaci sannicitabhāvenāti vedānampi kathetabbabhāveneva ṭhānaṃ dīpento ‘‘guhā tīṇi nihitā na gayhantī’’tiādimicchāvādaṃ paṭikkhipati. Nānāvidhā desabhāsā etesanti nānādesabhāsā. 此中,即于依世俗与依胜义的教说中。善巧方言,即善巧于各地方言。三吠陀,此仅为例示,意指亦含三吠陀作为学习技艺之处。因此,学习技艺将于后文述及。或将诸技艺作为知识之基,含摄于吠陀中,故说“三吠陀”。阐明吠陀之存在是为了言说,而非为了储藏于某处,以此驳斥“三者藏于洞中,不可得”等邪见。有多种方言者,即“多方言”。 Paramo uttamo attho paramattho, dhammānaṃ yathābhūtasabhāvo. Lokasaṅketamattasiddhā sammuti. Yadi evaṃ kathaṃ sammutikathāya saccatāti āha – ‘‘lokasammutikāraṇā’’ti, lokasamaññaṃ nissāya pavattanatoti attho. Lokasamaññā hi abhinivesena viññeyyā, nāññāpanā ekaccassa sutassa sāvanā viya na musā anatidhāvitabbato tassā. Tenāha bhagavā – ‘‘janapadaniruttiṃ nābhiniveseyya, samaññaṃ nātidhāvaye’’ti. Dhammānanti sabhāvadhammānaṃ. Bhūtakāraṇāti yathābhūtakāraṇā yathābhūtaṃ nissāya pavattanato. Sammutiṃ voharantassāti ‘‘puggalo, satto’’tiādinā lokasamaññaṃ kathentassa. 最上至极的意义是胜义,即诸法如实的自性。世俗则仅是世间的约定俗成。若如此,为何说世俗的言说具有真实性呢?答曰:“因世间共许故”,意即依靠世间共识而成立。世间共识是依执取而被了知的,但它不像某些传闻那样虚假,因为它不应被逾越。因此世尊说:“不应执着于地方言说,不应逾越世间共识。”“诸法”,指自性法。“真实因”,指如实之因,因其依靠如实而成立。“说世俗者”,指说“补特伽罗、有情”等世间共识之人。 Hirottappadīpanatthanti lokapālanakicce hirottappadhamme kiccato pakāsetuṃ. Tesañhi kiccaṃ sattasantāne eva pākaṭaṃ hotīti puggalādhiṭṭhānāya kathāya taṃ vattabbaṃ. Esa nayo sesesupi. Yasmiñhi [Pg.122] cittuppāde kammaṃ uppannaṃ, taṃsantāne eva tassa phalassa uppatti kammassakatā. Evañhi kataviññāṇanāso akatāgamo ca natthīti sā puggalādhiṭṭhānāya eva desanāya dīpetabbā. Tehi sattehi kātabbapuññakiriyā paccattapurisakāro. Sopi santānavasena niṭṭhapetabbato puggalādhiṭṭhānāya eva kathāya dīpetabbo. Ānantariyadīpanatthanti cutianantaraṃ phalaṃ anantaraṃ nāma, tasmiṃ anantare niyuttāni taṃnibbattanena anantarakaraṇasīlāni, anantarakaraṇapayojanāni vāti ānantariyāni, mātughātādīni, tesaṃ dīpanatthaṃ. Tānipi hi santānavasena niṭṭhapetabbato ‘‘mātaraṃ jīvitā voropetī’’tiādinā (paṭṭhā. 1.1.423) puggalādhiṭṭhānāya eva kathāya dīpetabbāni, tathā ‘‘so mettāsahagatena cetasā ekaṃ disaṃ pharitvā viharatī’’tiādinā (dī. ni. 1.556; 3.308; ma. ni. 1.77; 2.309; 3.230; vibha. 642-643) ‘‘so anekavihitaṃ pubbenivāsaṃ anussarati ekampi jāti’’ntiādinā (dī. ni. 1.244-245; ma. ni. 1.148, 384, 431; pārā. 12), ‘‘atthi dakkhiṇā dāyakato visujjhati, no paṭiggāhakato’’tiādinā (ma. ni. 3.381) ca pavattā brahmavihārapubbenivāsadakkhiṇāvisuddhikathā puggalādhiṭṭhānā eva katvā dīpetabbā sattasantānavisayattā. ‘‘Aṭṭha purisapuggalā (saṃ. ni. 1.249) na samayavimutto puggalo’’tiādinā (pu. pa. 2) ca paramatthakathaṃ kathentopi lokasammutiyā appahānatthaṃ puggalakathaṃ katheti. Etena vuttāvasesāya kathāya puggalādhiṭṭhānabhāve payojanaṃ sāmaññavasena saṅgahitanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Kāmañcetaṃ sabbaṃ apariññātavatthukānaṃ vasena vuttaṃ, pariññātavatthukānampi pana evaṃ desanā sukhāvahā hoti. 为阐明惭愧法,即在护世之责中,从作用上开示惭愧之法。因其作用唯于有情相续中显现,故应以个人(puggala)为依止而说。此理亦通于其余。于何心生起时业已生起,其果报亦仅于彼相续中生起,此即业属自己(kammassakatā)。如是,则无已作业之消逝,亦无未作业之到来,此理应以个人为依止之教说而开示。彼诸有情所应行之福业,即是个人努力(paccattapurisakāro)。此亦须依相续而成就,故应以个人为依止而说。为阐明无间业(ānantariya)故,死后即生之果报名为“无间”。于此无间中,能引生它的、具有无间作用的,即是无间业,如杀母等。此亦须依相续而成就,故如《发趣论》(Paṭṭhāna)所说“夺母性命”等,应以个人为依止而说。同样,如“彼以慈俱心,遍满一方而住”等,“彼忆念种种宿住,乃至一生”等,“布施(dakkhiṇā)之清净依于施者,非依于受者”等所说之梵住(brahmavihāra)、宿住(pubbenivāsa)、布施清净之说,皆因关涉有情相续,故须以个人为依止而开示。又如“八种士夫(purisapuggalā)”、“非时解脱之人”等,纵然在说胜义(paramattha)之时,为不舍世俗共许(lokasammuti),亦说个人。由此当知,其余未说之教说,其以个人为依止之用意,乃是为了以共通方式摄集之。诚然,此等皆是为未遍知事理者而说,然对此已遍知事理者,如是教说亦能带来安乐。 Ekapuggaloti visiṭṭhasamācārāpassayavirahito ekapuggalo. Buddhānañhi sīlādiguṇena sadevake loke visiṭṭho nāma koci natthi, tathā sadisopi samānakāle. Tenāha – ‘‘na imasmiṃ loke parasmiṃ vā pana buddhena seṭṭho sadiso ca vijjatī’’ti (vi. va. 1047; kathā. 799), tasmā sadisopi koci natthi. Hīnopi apassayabhūto nattheva. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘visiṭṭhasamācārāpassayavirahito ekapuggalo’’ti. Ye [Pg.123] ca sīlādiguṇehi natthi etesaṃ samāti asamā, purimakā sammāsambuddhā. Tehi samo majjhe bhinnasuvaṇṇanekkhaṃ viya nibbisiṭṭhoti asamasamaṭṭhenapi ekapuggalo aññassa tādisassa abhāvā. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘asadisaṭṭhenā’’tiādi. “独一之人(ekapuggala)”,即无有更胜者、相等者及可依止的个人。因诸佛以戒等功德,于含括天人的世界中,实无有更殊胜者,同时亦无有相等者。故云:“于此世间或他世间,不见有比佛更胜或相等者。”是故,连相等者亦无。更无一个低劣者可作为其依止。故云:“无有更胜者、相等者及可依止者的独一之人。”又,彼等于戒等功德上无有相等者,故名“无等(asama)”,此指过去的诸正等觉者。与彼等“无等者”相等,犹如中央断裂的金饰,并无殊胜,故以“与无等者相等”之义,亦是“独一之人”,因无有其他如此之人。故云:“以无与伦比之义”等。 Sattaloko adhippeto sattanikāye uppajjanato. Manussaloke eva uppajjati devabrahmalokānaṃ buddhānaṃ uppattiyā anokāsabhāvato. Kāmadevaloke tāva nuppajjati brahmacariyavāsassa aṭṭhānabhāvato tathā anacchariyabhāvato. Acchariyadhammā hi buddhā bhagavanto. Tesaṃ sā acchariyadhammatā devattabhāve ṭhitānaṃ loke na pākaṭā hoti yathā manussabhūtānaṃ. Devabhūte hi sammāsambuddhe dissamānaṃ buddhānubhāvaṃ devānubhāvatova loke dahati, na buddhānubhāvato. Tathā sati ‘‘ayaṃ sammāsambuddho’’ti nādhimuccati na sampasīdati, issarakuttaggāhaṃ na vissajjeti, devattabhāvassa ca cirakālāvaṭṭhānato ekaccasassatavādato na parimuccati. Brahmaloke nuppajjatīti etthāpi eseva nayo. Sattānaṃ tādisaggāhavinimocanatthañhi buddhā bhagavanto manussasugatiyaṃyeva uppajjanti, na devasugatiyaṃ. Yasmā imaṃ cakkavāḷaṃ majjhe katvā iminā saddhiṃ cakkavāḷānaṃ dasasahassasseva jātikkhettabhāvo dīpito ito aññassa buddhānaṃ uppattiṭṭhānassa tepiṭake buddhavacane āgataṭṭhānassa abhāvato. Tasmā vuttaṃ – ‘‘imasmiṃyeva cakkavāḷe uppajjatī’’ti. 此处意指有情界(sattaloka),因(佛陀)生于有情之居所(sattanikāya)故。(佛陀)仅生于人界,因天界与梵界非佛陀出生之处。于欲界天亦不出生,因彼处非梵行(brahmacariya)住处,且不显稀有故。诸佛世尊实为稀有之法。当他们住于天身时,其稀有法性于世间不能如人身时那般显现。若正等觉者为天身,世人见其佛陀威力,会认为是天神威力,而非佛陀威力。如此,则不能确信“此是正等觉者”,不能生起净信,不能舍弃造物主之邪见,且因长住天身,亦不能解脱于常见(sassatavāda)。于梵界不出生,其理亦同。为令有情解脱如是邪见,诸佛世尊仅生于人善趣,不生于天善趣。又,以此轮围世界(cakkavāḷa)为中心,连同此世界在内的一万个轮围世界被开示为佛陀的诞生区域,除此之外,三藏(tipiṭaka)佛语中未曾提及其他佛陀出生之处。是故云:“仅于此轮围世界中出生”。 Idha uppajjantopi kasmā jambudīpe eva uppajjati, na sesadīpesūti? Keci tāva āhu – ‘‘yasmā pathaviyā nābhibhūtā buddhabhāvasahā acalaṭṭhānabhūtā bodhimaṇḍabhūmi jambudīpe eva, tasmā jambudīpe eva uppajjatī’’ti. Eteneva ‘‘tattha majjhimadese eva uppajjatī’’ti etampi saṃvaṇṇitanti daṭṭhabbaṃ tathā itaresampi avijahitaṭṭhānānaṃ tattheva labbhanato. Yasmā purimabuddhānaṃ mahābodhisattānaṃ paccekabuddhānañca nibbattiyā sāvakabodhisattānaṃ sāvakabodhiyā abhinīhāro sāvakapāramiyā sambharaṇaparipācanañca buddhakkhettabhūte imasmiṃyeva cakkavāḷe jambudīpe eva ijjhati, na aññattha. Veneyyajanavinayanattho ca buddhuppādo, tasmā aggasāvakamahāsāvakādiveneyyavisesāpekkhāya imasmiṃ jambudīpe eva buddhā nibbattanti, na sesadīpesu. Ayañca nayo sabbabuddhānaṃ āciṇṇasamāciṇṇoti tesaṃ uttamapurisānaṃ [Pg.124] tattheva uppatti sampatticakkānaṃ viya aññamaññūpanissayatāya daṭṭhabbā. Tena vuttaṃ – aṭṭhakathāyaṃ ‘‘tīsu dīpesu buddhā na nibbattanti, jambudīpe eva nibbattantīti dīpaṃ passī’’ti (dī. ni. aṭṭha. 2.17; bu. vaṃ. aṭṭha. 27 avidūrenidānakathā). (佛陀)于此出生,为何仅于瞻部洲(Jambudīpa)出生,而非于其余诸洲?有人说:“因大地的任何部分都无法胜过、能承受佛位的、已成不动之处的菩提道场(bodhimaṇḍa),仅存于瞻部洲,故(佛陀)仅于瞻部洲出生。”由此当知,“仅于中土(Majjhimadesa)出生”之说亦得以阐明,因其他不可舍弃之处亦仅于彼处可得。又,因过去诸佛、大菩萨(mahābodhisatta)、独觉佛(paccekabuddha)之出生,以及声闻菩萨(sāvakabodhisatta)对声闻菩提(sāvakabodhi)的发愿、声闻波罗蜜(sāvakapāramī)的积集与圆满,皆仅于此佛土(buddhakkhetta)——轮围世界中的瞻部洲——方得成就,而非他处。佛陀出世是为了调伏所化有情,故为顾及上首弟子(aggasāvaka)、大弟子(mahāsāvaka)等特殊所化众,诸佛仅于此瞻部洲出生,而非于其余诸洲。此乃一切诸佛所行之惯例,当知彼等最上之人于彼处出生,犹如幸运之轮,辗转相依。故义注(aṭṭhakathā)云:“诸佛不于三洲出生,仅于瞻部洲出生,当知此洲。” Ubhayampidaṃ vippakatavacanameva uppādakiriyāya vattamānakālikattā. Uppajjamānoti vā uppajjituṃ samattho. Sattiattho cāyaṃ māna-saddo. Yāvatā hi sāmatthiyena mahābodhisattānaṃ carimabhave uppatti icchitabbā, tatthakena bodhisambhārasambhūtena paripuṇṇena samannāgatoti attho. Bhedoti viseso. Tameva hi tividhaṃ visesaṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘esa hī’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Aṭṭhaṅgasamannāgatassa mahābhinīhārassa siddhakālato paṭṭhāya mahābodhisatto buddhabhāvāya niyatabhāvappattatāya bodhisambhārapaṭipadaṃ paṭipajjamāno yathāvuttasāmatthiyayogena uppajjamāno nāmāti attho uppādassa ekantikattā. Pariyesantoti vicinanto. Paripakkagate ñāṇeti iminā tato pubbe ñāṇassa aparipakkatāya eva laddhāvasarāya kammapilotiyā vasena bodhisatto tathā mahāpadhānaṃ padahīti dasseti. Arahattaphalakkhaṇe uppanno nāma ‘‘uppanno hotī’’ti vattabbattā. Āgatova nāma hetusampadāya sammadeva nipphannattā. 此二者皆为未完成语(vippakatavacana),因其为现在时态,表达正在生起的行为(uppādakiriyā)。“正在生起”(uppajjamāno)或“有能力生起”(uppajjituṃ samattho)。此处的“māna”一词有能力(satti)之义。大菩萨于最后生,其生起所应具备之能力,即是圆满具足由菩提资粮(bodhisambhāra)所成之能力义。“差别”(bheda)即是特殊(viseso)。为说明此三种特殊之处,故说“此乃……”等。具足八支大誓愿(aṭṭhaṅgasamannāgatassa mahābhinīhārassa)的大菩萨,从成就之时起,为求佛果而得决定,行菩提资粮道(bodhisambhārapaṭipadā),依前述能力而生起,因其生起是决定的,故名为“正在生起”。“寻求”(pariyesanto)即是探寻。“于智慧成熟时”(paripakkagate ñāṇe),此句显示,此前因智慧尚未成熟,业障(kammapilotiyā)才得以乘机,菩萨因此而行大精进(mahāpadhānaṃ padahati)。于阿罗汉果(arahattaphala)之相生起时,可说为“已生”(uppanno)。“已来”(āgato)则因其因缘具足而自然成就。 Hitatthāyāti lokiyalokuttarassa hitassa siddhiyā. Sukhatthāyāti etthāpi eseva nayo. Tassāti tassa sattalokassa. So panāyaṃ sattaloko yena anukkamena dhammābhisamayaṃ pāpuṇi, taṃ teneva anukkamena dassento ‘‘mahābodhimaṇḍe’’tiādimāha. Yāvajjadivasāti ettha ajja-saddena sāsanassa avaṭṭhānakālaṃ vadati. Devamanussānanti ukkaṭṭhaniddesoti dassetuṃ – ‘‘na kevala’’ntiādi vuttaṃ. Etesampīti nāgasupaṇṇādīnampi. “为利益故”,即为成就世间与出世间之利益。“为安乐故”,此处亦同此理。“彼”,即彼有情世界(sattalokassa)。此有情世界依何次第证悟正法,为以同样次第开示,故说“于大菩提座(mahābodhimaṇḍe)”等。“直至今日”(yāvajjadivasā),此中“今日”(ajja)一词,意指教法住世之时。“天人”(devamanussānaṃ),为显示此乃最胜者的指示(ukkaṭṭhaniddeso),故说“不仅……”等。“亦为彼等”,即亦为龙(nāga)、金翅鸟(supaṇṇa)等。 Ayaṃ pucchāti iminā ‘‘katamo’’ti padassa sāmaññato pucchābhāvo dassito, na visesatoti tassa pucchāvisesabhāvañāpanatthaṃ mahāniddese (mahāni. 150) āgatā sabbāpi pucchā atthuddhāranayena dasseti ‘‘pucchā ca nāmesā’’tiādinā. Adiṭṭhaṃ jotīyati etāyāti adiṭṭhajotanā. Diṭṭhaṃ saṃsandīyati etāyāti diṭṭhasaṃsandanā. Saṃsandanañca sākacchāvasena [Pg.125] vinicchayakaraṇaṃ. Vimatiṃ chindati etāyāti vimaticchedanā. Anumatiyā pucchā anumatipucchā. ‘‘Taṃ kiṃ maññatha, bhikkhave’’tiādi pucchāya ‘‘kā tumhākaṃ anumatī’’ti anumati pucchitā hoti. Kathetukamyatāpucchāti kathetukamyatāya pucchā. Lakkhaṇanti ñātuṃ icchito yo koci sabhāvo. Aññātanti yena kenaci ñāṇena aññātabhāvamāha. Adiṭṭhanti dassanabhūtena ñāṇena paccakkhaṃ viya adiṭṭhataṃ. Atulitanti ‘‘ettakaṃ eta’’nti tulābhūtena atulitataṃ. Atīritanti tīraṇabhūtena akatañāṇakiriyāsamāpanataṃ. Avibhūtanti ñāṇassa apākaṭabhāvaṃ. Avibhāvitanti ñāṇena apākaṭakatabhāvaṃ. “此是问”,此句以“何等”一词,显示其为普遍之问,而非特殊之问。为阐明其为特殊之问,故以抉择义理之法,开示《大解释》(Mahāniddesa)中所说的一切提问,如“此名为问”等。“能照亮未见者”,是为“未见照明”(adiṭṭhajotanā)。“能印证已见者”,是为“已见印证”(diṭṭhasaṃsandanā)。印证,即是通过讨论而作决断。“能断除疑惑者”,是为“断疑”(vimaticchedanā)。“以同意而问”,是为“同意问”(anumatipucchā)。如“诸比丘,汝等作何想”之问,即是问“汝等同意为何”。“以欲说而问”,是为“欲说问”(kathetukamyatāpucchā)。“相”(lakkhaṇa),即是任何欲知之自性。“未知”(aññāta),指未为任何智慧所知之状态。“未见”(adiṭṭha),指未为能见之智所亲见。“未衡量”(atulita),指未为能量之智所衡量为“此有尔许”。“未审察”(atīrita),指未为能审之智完成认知。“未显现”(avibhūta),指智慧未显了之状态。“未阐明”(avibhāvita),指未为智慧所阐明之状态。 Yehi guṇavisesehi nimittabhūtehi bhagavati ‘‘tathāgato’’ti ayaṃ samaññā pavattā, taṃdassanatthaṃ ‘‘aṭṭhahi kāraṇehi bhagavā tathāgato’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Guṇavisesanemittikāneva hi bhagavato sabbāni nāmāni. Yathāha – 世尊(bhagavā)之所以有“如来”(tathāgato)此一名号,乃因其具足种种殊胜功德以为标志。为开示此理,故说“以八种原因,世尊是如来”等。诚然,世尊的所有名号,皆以其殊胜功德为缘由。如所说: ‘‘Asaṅkhyeyyāni nāmāni, saguṇena mahesino; Guṇena nāmamuddheyyaṃ, api nāmasahassato’’ti. (dha. sa. aṭṭha. 1313; udā. aṭṭha. 53; paṭi. ma. aṭṭha. 1.1.76); 大仙之名号无量,皆随其功德而有;纵有千名,亦当依功德而称之。 Tathā āgatoti ettha ākāraniyamanavasena opammasampaṭipādanattho tathā-saddo. Sāmaññajotanāpi hi visese avatiṭṭhatīti. Paṭipadāgamanattho āgata-saddo, na ñāṇagamanattho ‘‘tathalakkhaṇaṃ āgato’’tiādīsu (dī. ni. aṭṭha. 1.7; ma. ni. aṭṭha. 1.12; saṃ. ni. aṭṭha. 2.3.78; a. ni. aṭṭha. 1.1.170; udā. aṭṭha. 18) viya, nāpi kāyagamanattho ‘‘āgato kho mahāsamaṇo, magadhānaṃ giribbaja’’ntiādīsu (mahāva. 63) viya. Tattha yadākāraniyamanavasena opammasampaṭipādanattho tathā-saddo, taṃkaruṇāpadhānattā mahākaruṇāmukhena purimabuddhānaṃ āgamanappaṭipadaṃ udāharaṇavasena sāmaññato dassento yaṃ-taṃ-saddānaṃ ekantasambandhabhāvato ‘‘yathā sabbaloka…pe… āgatā’’ti sādhāraṇato vatvā puna taṃ paṭipadaṃ mahāpadhānasuttādīsu (dī. ni. 2.1 ādayo) sambahulaniddesena supākaṭānaṃ āsannānañca vipassiādīnaṃ channaṃ sammāsambuddhānaṃ vasena nidassento ‘‘yathā vipassī bhagavā’’tiādimāha. Tattha yena abhinīhārenāti manussattaliṅgasampattihetusatthudassanapabbajjāabhiññādiguṇasampattiadhikāracchandānaṃ vasena aṭṭhaṅgasamannāgatena [Pg.126] mahāpaṇidhānena. Sabbesañhi buddhānaṃ kāyappaṇidhānaṃ imināva abhinīhārena samijjhatīti. Evaṃ mahābhinīhāravisesena ‘‘tathāgato’’ti padassa atthaṃ dassetvā idāni pāramipūraṇavasena dassetuṃ – ‘‘yathā vipassī bhagavā…pe… kassapo bhagavā dānapāramiṃ pūretvā’’tiādimāha. 于“如是来”(tathā āgato)中,“如是”(tathā)一词,是依方式限定而阐明譬喻之义。盖因普遍之说明亦立足于特殊之中。“来”(āgata)一词,是行道(paṭipadā)之义,非如“证得如是相”等句中的智慧证得之义,亦非如“大沙门已来至摩揭陀(Magadha)之山城(Giribbaja)”等句中的身体行来之义。此处,“如是”一词既是依方式限定而阐明譬喻,则以大悲为主,以过去诸佛的行道为例,作普遍开示。因“yathā”与“tathā”二词有必然关联,故先总说“如一切世间……来”,复于《大本经》(Mahāpadāna Sutta)等经中,以众多解释,明示毗婆尸(Vipassī)等近世六位正等觉者之道,故说“如毗婆尸世尊”等。其中,“以何誓愿”,即是以具足八支的大誓愿(mahāpaṇidhāna)。一切诸佛的身语誓愿,皆由此大誓愿而成就。如是,以大誓愿之殊胜,开示“如来”一词之义后,今为开示圆满波罗蜜之义,故说“如毗婆尸世尊……迦叶(Kassapa)世尊圆满布施波罗蜜”等。 Ettha ca suttantikānaṃ mahābodhippaṭipadāya kosallajananatthaṃ kā panetā pāramiyo, kenaṭṭhena pāramiyo, katividhā cetā, ko tāsaṃ kamo, kāni lakkhaṇarasapaccupaṭṭhānapadaṭṭhānāni, ko paccayo, ko saṃkileso, kiṃ vodānaṃ, ko paṭipakkho, kā paṭipatti, ko vibhāgo, ko saṅgaho, ko sampādanūpāyo, kittakena kālena sampādanaṃ, ko ānisaṃso, kiñcetāsaṃ phalanti pāramīsu ayaṃ vitthārakathā veditabbā. Sā panesā icchantena dīghāgamaṭīkāyaṃ (dī. ni. ṭī. 1.7) vuttanayeneva veditabbā, na idha dassitā. Yathāvuttāya paṭipadāya yathāvuttavibhāgānaṃ pāramīnaṃ pūritabhāvaṃ sandhāyāha – ‘‘samatiṃsa pāramiyo pūretvā’’ti. 于此,为令经师(suttantika)善巧了知大菩提道(mahābodhippaṭipadā),关于波罗蜜(pāramī),应知此详尽论述:何为波罗蜜?以何义为波罗蜜?有几种?其次第为何?其相、味、现起、近因(lakkhaṇarasapaccupaṭṭhānapadaṭṭhānāni)为何?何为缘(paccayo)?何为染污(saṃkileso)?何为清净(vodānaṃ)?何为对治(paṭipakkho)?何为修行(paṭipatti)?何为分别(vibhāgo)?何为总摄(saṅgaho)?何为成就之方便(sampādanūpāyo)?需时多久成就?有何功德(ānisaṃso)?其果为何?欲知此者,当依《长部复注》(Dīghāgamaṭīkā)所说之法,此处不述。鉴于前述之道与前述分别之波罗蜜皆已圆满,故说:“圆满三十波罗蜜。” Satipi mahāpariccāgānaṃ dānapāramibhāve pariccāgavisesabhāvadassanatthañceva sudukkarabhāvadassanatthañca mahāpariccāgehi visuṃ gahaṇaṃ. Tatoyeva ca aṅgapariccāgato visuṃ nayanapariccāgaggahaṇaṃ, pariccāgabhāvasāmaññepi dhanarajjapariccāgato puttadārapariccāgaggahaṇañca kataṃ. Gatapaccāgatikavattasaṅkhātāya pubbabhāgappaṭipadāya saddhiṃ abhiññāsamāpattinipphādanaṃ pubbayogo. Dānādīsuyeva sātisayappaṭipattinipphādanaṃ pubbacariyā, yā vā cariyāpiṭakasaṅgahitā. ‘‘Abhinīhāro pubbayogo, dānādippaṭipatti vā kāyavivekavasena ekacariyā vā pubbacariyā’’ti keci. Dānādīnañceva appicchatādīnañca saṃsāranibbānesu ādīnavānisaṃsānañca vibhāvanavasena sattānaṃ bodhittaye patiṭṭhāpanaparipācanavasena ca pavattā kathā dhammakkhānaṃ. Ñātīnaṃ atthacariyā ñātatthacariyā. Sāpi karuṇāyanavaseneva. Ādi-saddena lokatthacariyādayo saṅgaṇhāti. Kammassakatañāṇavasena anavajjakammāyatanasippāyatanavijjāṭṭhānaparicayavasena khandhāyatanādiparicayavasena lakkhaṇattayatīraṇavasena ca ñāṇacāro buddhicariyā. Sā pana atthato paññāpāramīyeva, ñāṇasambhāradassanatthaṃ visuṃ [Pg.127] gahaṇaṃ. Koṭīti pariyanto, ukkaṃsoti attho. Cattāro satipaṭṭhāne bhāvetvāti sambandho. Tattha bhāvetvāti uppādetvā. Brūhetvāti vaḍḍhetvā. Satipaṭṭhānādiggahaṇena āgamanappaṭipadaṃ matthakaṃ pāpetvā dasseti. Vipassanāsahagatā eva vā satipaṭṭhānādayo daṭṭhabbā. Ettha ca ‘‘yena abhinīhārenā’’tiādinā āgamanappaṭipadāya ādiṃ dasseti, ‘‘dānapārami’’ntiādinā majjhaṃ, ‘‘cattāro satipaṭṭhāne’’tiādinā pariyosānanti veditabbaṃ. 即使大舍离(mahāpariccāga)属于布施波罗蜜,但为了显示其舍离的殊胜性与极难行性,故单独列出大舍离。因此,从肢体舍离中单独列出眼目舍离;并且,即使同属舍离,舍弃财富、王国与舍弃妻子儿女亦被单独列出。前行(pubbayoga)是指与往返之行(gatapaccāgatikavatta)共同成就神通与等至。前修(pubbacariyā)是指在布施等中成就殊胜的行道,或指《所行藏》(cariyāpiṭaka)所摄之行道。有人说:“发愿是前行,布施等行道,或以身远离为独行道,是为前修。”法说(dhammakkhāna)是指通过阐明布施等、少欲等,以及轮回与涅槃的过患与功德,从而使众生安住于三菩提并使之成熟的说法。亲族利行(ñātatthacariyā)是利益亲族之行。此亦是出于悲悯。“等”字包含世间利行等。智行(buddhicariyā)是指依业果智,熟练无罪业处、工巧处、明处,熟练蕴、处等,以及思惟三相而行之智。然而,就其义而言,此即是般若波罗蜜,此处单独列出是为了显示智慧资粮。“究竟”(koṭī)是极限,“最胜”(ukkaṃsa)是殊胜之义。“修习四念处”(cattāro satipaṭṭhāne bhāvetvā)是其关联。其中,“修习”(bhāvetvā)指生起,“培育”(brūhetvā)指增长。举出念处等,是为了显示已将菩萨的来行道(āgamanappaṭipada)导向究竟。或者,应当将念处等视为与观(vipassanā)相应。此处应知,“以彼发愿”等句显示来行道之初,“布施波罗蜜”等句显示其中,“四念处”等句显示其终。 Sampatijātoti muhuttajāto nikkhantamatto. Nikkhantamattañhi mahāsattaṃ paṭhamaṃ brahmāno suvaṇṇajālena paṭiggaṇhiṃsu, tesaṃ hatthato cattāro mahārājāno ajinappaveṇiyā, tesaṃ hatthato manussā dukūlacumbaṭakena paṭiggaṇhiṃsu, manussānaṃ hatthato muccitvā pathaviyaṃ patiṭṭhito. Yathāhātiādinā mahāpadānadesanāya vuttavacanaṃ nidasseti. Setamhi chatteti dibbasetacchatte. Anudhāriyamāneti dhāriyamāne. Ettha ca chattaggahaṇeneva khaggādīni pañca kakudhabhaṇḍāni vuttānevāti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Khaggatālavaṇṭamorahatthakavālabījaniuṇhīsapaṭṭāpi hi chattena saha tadā upaṭṭhitā ahesuṃ. Chattādīniyeva ca tadā paññāyiṃsu, na chattādiggāhakā. Sabbā ca disāti dasa disā, nayidaṃ sabbadisāvilokanaṃ sattapadavītihāruttarakālaṃ. Mahāsatto hi manussānaṃ hatthato muccitvā puratthimaṃ disaṃ olokesi, tattha devamanussā gandhamālādīhi pūjayamānā, ‘‘mahāpurisa, idha tumhehi sadisopi natthi, kuto uttaritaro’’ti āhaṃsu. Evaṃ catasso disā catasso anudisā heṭṭhā uparīti sabbā disā anuviloketvā sabbattha attanā sadisaṃ adisvā ‘‘ayaṃ uttarā disā’’ti sattapadavītihārena agamāsi. Āsabhinti uttamaṃ. Aggoti sabbapaṭhamo. Jeṭṭhoti seṭṭhoti ca tasseva vevacanaṃ. Ayamantimā jāti, natthi dāni punabbhavoti imasmiṃ attabhāve pattabbaṃ arahattaṃ byākāsi. ‘‘Anekesaṃ visesādhigamānaṃ pubbanimittabhāvenā’’ti saṃkhittena vuttamatthaṃ ‘‘yañhī’’tiādinā vitthārato dasseti. Tattha etthāti – “刚出生”(sampatijāta)是指刹那间出生,刚刚出胎。这位大士(mahāsatta)刚刚出胎时,诸梵天首先以金网承接;四大天王从梵天手中接过,以羚羊皮承接;人类又从天王手中接过,以细棉布承接;最终从人手中脱离,站立于地上。“如是”等句显示了《大本经》(Mahāpadāna)中所说的言辞。“白伞”(setamhi chatte)是指天界的白伞。“持续举着”(anudhāriyamāne)是指被举着。此处应知,仅举出伞盖,实际上已包含了剑等五种王室宝器(kakudhabhaṇḍāni)。当时,剑、多罗扇、孔雀扇、拂尘和头巾也与伞盖一同出现。当时只显现了伞盖等物,而未显现持伞盖等物者。“遍观十方”(sabbā ca disā)是指十方,这并非指七步之后遍观四方。大士从人们手中脱离后,看向东方,那里的天人与人类以香花等供养,并说:“大士,此处无人能与您相比,更何况胜过您呢?”如此遍观四方、四隅、下方与上方所有方向,在任何地方都未见到与自己相等者,于是说:“这是最上的方向。”并走了七步。“最胜”(āsabhiṃ)是指最上的。“最上”(agga)是指第一的。“最尊”(jeṭṭha)和“最胜”(seṭṭha)是其同义词。“这是最后一次出生,现在没有来世了”,这是预言在此生中将证得阿罗汉果。“作为获得无数殊胜成就的先兆”,此乃简略之义,“因为”等句则详细阐明。此处“在此”是指—— ‘‘Anekasākhañca [Pg.128] sahassamaṇḍalaṃ,Chattaṃ marū dhārayumantalikkhe; Suvaṇṇadaṇḍā vītipatanti cāmarā,Na dissare cāmarachattagāhakā’’ti. (su. ni. 693) – “千枝万盖遍布虚空,诸天空中擎伞环;金柄拂尘飘拂过,不见持拂与伞者。” Imissā gāthāya. Sabbaññutaññāṇameva sabbattha appaṭihatacāratāya anāvaraṇañāṇanti āha – ‘‘sabbaññutānāvaraṇañāṇapaṭilābhassā’’ti. Tathā ayaṃ bhagavāpi gato…pe… pubbanimittabhāvenāti etena abhijātiyaṃ dhammatāvasena uppajjanakavisesā sabbabodhisattānaṃ sādhāraṇāti dasseti. Pāramitānissandā hi teti. 以此偈颂(说明)。一切智智因其于一切处无碍运行,故为无障智,即所谓“获得一切智无障智”。同样,这位世尊(bhagavā)也已行至……(略)……作为前兆的缘故。由此显示,诸菩萨依自然法则出生之殊胜,乃是所有菩萨所共通的。因为这些是波罗蜜的流溢。 Vikkamīti agamāsi. Marūti devā. Samāti vilokanasamatāya samā sadisiyo. Mahāpuriso hi yathā ekaṃ disaṃ vilokesi, evaṃ sesadisāpi, na katthaci vilokane vibandho tassa ahosīti. Samāti vā viloketuṃ yuttāti attho. Na hi tadā bodhisattassa virūpabībhacchavisamarūpāni viloketuṃ ayuttāni disāsu upaṭṭhahantīti. “行进”(vikkamī)是指向前行走。“天神”(marū)是指诸天。“平等”(samā)是指观看时是相同的,是相似的。因为大士(mahāpurisa)观看一个方向时,也同样观看其他方向,他的观看在任何地方都没有障碍。或者说,“平等”是指适合观看。因为那时菩萨观看时,没有不适合观看的丑陋、可憎、不规则的形相出现在各个方向。 ‘‘Evaṃ tathā gato’’ti kāyagamanaṭṭhena gatasaddena tathāgatasaddaṃ niddisitvā idāni ñāṇagamanaṭṭhena taṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘atha vā’’tiādimāha. Tattha nekkhammenāti alobhappadhānena kusalacittuppādena. Kusalā hi dhammā idha nekkhammaṃ, na pabbajjādayo. ‘‘Paṭhamajjhānenā’’ti ca vadanti. Pahāyāti pajahitvā. Gato adhigato, paṭipanno uttarivisesanti attho. Pahāyāti vā pahānahetu, pahānalakkhaṇaṃ vā. Hetulakkhaṇattho hi ayaṃ pahāyasaddo. Kāmacchandādippahānahetukañhi ‘‘gato’’ti ettha vuttaṃ gamanaṃ avabodho, paṭipatti eva vā kāmacchandādippahānena ca lakkhīyati. Esa nayo padāletvātiādīsupi. Abyāpādenāti mettāya. Ālokasaññāyāti vibhūtaṃ katvā manasikaraṇena upaṭṭhitaālokasañjānanena. Avikkhepenāti samādhinā. Dhammavavatthānenāti kusalādidhammānaṃ yāthāvanicchayena. ‘‘Sappaccayanāmarūpavavatthānenā’’tipi vadanti. Evaṃ kāmacchandādinīvaraṇappahānena ‘‘abhijjhaṃ loke pahāyā’’tiādinā (vibha. 508) vuttāya paṭhamajjhānassa pubbabhāgappaṭipadāya bhagavato tathāgatabhāvaṃ dassetvā idāni saha upāyena aṭṭhahi [Pg.129] samāpattīhi aṭṭhārasahi ca mahāvipassanāhi taṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘ñāṇenā’’tiādimāha. Nāmarūpapariggahakaṅkhāvitaraṇānañhi vibandhabhūtassa mohassa dūrīkaraṇena ñātapariññāyaṃ ṭhitassa aniccasaññādayo sijjhanti, tathā jhānasamāpattīsu abhiratinimittena pāmojjena tattha anabhiratiyā vinoditāya jhānādīnaṃ samadhigamoti samāpattivipassanānaṃ arativinodanaavijjāpadālanādiupāyo, uppaṭipāṭiniddeso pana nīvaraṇasabhāvāya avijjāya heṭṭhā nīvaraṇesupi saṅgahadassanatthanti daṭṭhabbo. Samāpattivihārappavesavibandhanena nīvaraṇāni kavāṭasadisānīti āha – ‘‘nīvaraṇakavāṭaṃ ugghāṭetvā’’ti. “如是已去”(Evaṃ tathā gato),是先以身行之义解释“已去”(gata)一词,现在则以智行之义来显示“如来”(tathāgata),故说“或者”等句。其中,“出离”(nekkhamma)是指以无贪为主的善心生起。此处善法即是出离,而非出家等。也有人说“以初禅”。“舍离”(pahāya)是指断除。“已去”(gato)是指已证得、已行至更高殊胜之境的意思。或者说,“舍离”是断除之因,或是断除之相。此“舍离”一词具有因与相之义。因为此处所说的“行”(gamana),即“已去”,是指以断除欲贪等为因而觉悟,或者说,修行是以断除欲贪等为特征的。此理亦通于“破开”等句。“无瞋”(abyāpādena)是指慈心。“光明想”(ālokasaññāyā)是指通过清晰作意而生起的对光明之想。“不散乱”(avikkhepena)是指禅定。“法抉择”(dhammavavatthānena)是指如实辨别善等诸法。也有人说“缘起名色之抉择”。如此,通过断除欲贪等五盖,如《分别论》(Vibha. 508)中所说的“舍离世间之贪”等,先显示世尊(bhagavā)成就如来之道的初禅前行,现在则连同方便,以八等至和十八大观(mahāvipassanā)来显示,故说“以智慧”等句。因为通过远离障碍名色遍知与度疑的愚痴,安住于知遍知时,无常想等便能成就;同样,通过以禅定等至中喜乐为因的喜悦,遣除于彼之不乐,从而证得禅那等,这便是等至与观(vipassanā)的遣除不乐、破除无明等方便。然而,当知,次第颠倒的解释,是为了显示具有盖之自性的无明,亦被包含在诸盖之中。由于诸盖阻碍进入等至住,故诸盖如同门闩,所以说“开启诸盖门闩”。 ‘‘Rattiṃ vitakketvā vicāretvā divā kammante payojetī’’ti (ma. ni. 1.251) vuttaṭṭhāne vitakkavicārā dhūmāyanā adhippetāti āha – ‘‘vitakkavicāradhūma’’nti. Kiñcāpi paṭhamajjhānūpacāreyeva dukkhaṃ, catutthajjhānopacāreyeva ca sukhaṃ pahīyati, atisayappahānaṃ pana sandhāyāha – ‘‘catutthajjhānena sukhadukkhaṃ pahāyā’’ti. Rūpasaññāti saññāsīsena rūpāvacarajjhānāni ceva tadārammaṇāni ca vuttāni. Rūpāvacarajjhānampi hi ‘‘rūpa’’nti vuccati uttarapadalopena ‘‘rūpī rūpāni passatī’’tiādīsu (ma. ni. 2.248; 3.312; dha. sa. 248; paṭi. ma. 1.209). Tassa ārammaṇampi kasiṇarūpaṃ ‘‘rūpa’’nti vuccati purimapadalopena ‘‘bahiddhā rūpāni passati suvaṇṇadubbaṇṇānī’’tiādīsu (dī. ni. 2.173-174; ma. ni. 2.249; dha. sa. 244-245). Tasmā idha rūpe rūpajjhāne taṃsahagatasaññā rūpasaññāti evaṃ saññāsīsena rūpāvacarajjhānāni vuttāni. Rūpaṃ saññā assāti rūpasaññaṃ, rūpassa nāmanti vuttaṃ hoti. Evaṃ pathavīkasiṇādibhedassa tadārammaṇassa cetaṃ adhivacananti veditabbaṃ. Paṭighasaññāti cakkhādīnaṃ vatthūnaṃ rūpādīnaṃ ārammaṇānañca paṭighātena paṭihananena visayivisayasamodhāne samuppannā dvipañcaviññāṇasahagatā saññā paṭighasaññā. Nānattasaññāyoti nānatte gocare pavattā saññā, nānattā vā saññā nānattasaññā, aṭṭha kāmāvacarakusalasaññā, dvādasa akusalasaññā, ekādasa kāmāvacarakusalavipākasaññā, dve akusalavipākasaññā, ekādasa kāmāvacarakiriyasaññāti etāsaṃ catucattālīsasaññānametaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Etā hi yasmā rūpasaññādibhede nānatte [Pg.130] nānāsabhāve gocare pavattanti, yasmā ca nānattā nānāsabhāvā aññamaññaṃ asadisā, tasmā ‘‘nānattasaññā’’ti vuccanti. “夜晚寻思,白日作业”,在该处所说的寻伺(vitakkavicāra)被意指为烟,因此说“寻伺之烟”(vitakkavicāradhūma)。虽然在初禅的近行定中就已舍弃忧,在第四禅的近行定中才舍弃乐,但此处是就其超胜的舍弃而言,因此说“以第四禅舍弃苦乐”。“色想”(rūpasaññā),是以“想”为首,指色界禅那(rūpāvacarajjhāna)及其所缘(ārammaṇa)。色界禅那也被称为“色”,如在“有色者见诸色”等句中,是省略了后一词(uttarapadalopena)。其所缘,即遍处色(kasiṇarūpa),也被称为“色”,如在“外观诸色,有好有坏”等句中,是省略了前一词(purimapadalopena)。因此,此处所说的“色想”,是以“想”为首,指色界禅那,即在色与色禅那中相应的想。“色是其想”(rūpaṃ saññā assa)即是“色想”,意即“色之名”。当知,这是对地遍(pathavīkasiṇa)等各种类别及其所缘的称谓。“有对想”(paṭighasaññā),是指眼等根(vatthu)与色等境(ārammaṇa)相触(paṭighāta)、相击(paṭihanana)时,在根境和合(visayivisayasamodhāna)的情况下,与双五识(dvipañcaviññāṇa)相应的想。“种种想”(nānattasaññā),是指在种种(nānatta)所缘(gocara)上生起的想,或是种种不同的想。即八种欲界善想、十二种不善想、十一种欲界善异熟想、两种不善异熟想、十一种欲界唯作想,此四十四种想的总称。因为这些想在色想等种种不同、各种自性(nānāsabhāva)的所缘中生起,又因为它们是种种不同、各种自性、彼此不相似的,因此被称为“种种想”。 Aniccassa, aniccanti vā anupassanā aniccānupassanā, tebhūmakadhammānaṃ aniccataṃ gahetvā pavattāya anupassanāyetaṃ nāmaṃ. Niccasaññanti saṅkhatadhamme ‘‘niccā sassatā’’ti pavattaṃ micchāsaññaṃ. Saññāsīsena diṭṭhicittānampi gahaṇaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. Esa nayo ito paresupi. Nibbidānupassanāyāti saṅkhāresu nibbijjanākārena pavattāya anupassanāya. Nandinti sappītikataṇhaṃ. Virāgānupassanāyāti saṅkhāresu virajjanākārena pavattāya anupassanāya. Nirodhānupassanāyāti saṅkhārānaṃ nirodhassa anupassanāya. ‘‘Te saṅkhārā nirujjhantiyeva, āyatiṃ samudayavasena na uppajjantī’’ti evaṃ vā anupassanā nirodhānupassanā. Tenevāha – ‘‘nirodhānupassanāya nirodheti, no samudetī’’ti. Muccitukamyatā hi ayaṃ balappattāti. Paṭinissajjanākārena pavattā anupassanā paṭinissaggānupassanā. Paṭisaṅkhā santiṭṭhanā hi ayaṃ. Ādānanti niccādivasena gahaṇaṃ. Santatisamūhakiccārammaṇānaṃ vasena ekattaggahaṇaṃ ghanasaññā. Āyūhanaṃ abhisaṅkharaṇaṃ. Avatthāvisesāpatti vipariṇāmo. Dhuvasaññanti thirabhāvaggahaṇaṃ. Nimittanti samūhādighanavasena sakiccaparicchedatāya ca saṅkhārānaṃ saviggahaggahaṇaṃ. Paṇidhinti rāgādipaṇidhiṃ. Sā panatthato taṇhāvasena saṅkhāresu nanditā. Abhinivesanti attānudiṭṭhiṃ. 对无常者,或观“无常”,是为无常随观(aniccānupassanā),这是执取三界法(tebhūmakadhamma)的无常性而生起的随观之名。“常想”(niccasaññā),是指于有为法(saṅkhatadhamma)生起“常、恒”之邪想(micchāsaññā)。当知,以“想”为首,也包含邪见心(diṭṭhicitta)。此理亦通于下文。“厌离随观”(nibbidānupassanā),是指于诸行(saṅkhāra)以厌离之相(nibbijjanākāra)生起的随观。“喜贪”(nandi),是指伴随喜悦的渴爱(taṇhā)。“离贪随观”(virāgānupassanā),是指于诸行以离贪之相(virajjanākāra)生起的随观。“灭随观”(nirodhānupassanā),是指对诸行之灭的随观。或者,“彼诸行仅是息灭,未来不以生起(samudaya)的方式出现”,如是随观即是灭随观。因此说:“以灭随观而灭,不复生起。”这实际上是已达强盛的解脱欲(muccitukamyatā)。以舍遣之相(paṭinissajjanākāra)生起的随观,是为舍遣随观(paṭinissaggānupassanā)。这实际上是审察安住(paṭisaṅkhā santiṭṭhanā)。“取”(ādāna),是以常等方式去执取(gahaṇa)。以相续(santati)、集合(samūha)、作用(kicca)、所缘(ārammaṇa)故,执取为一体(ekattaggahaṇa),即是“坚固想”(ghanasaññā)。“积集”(āyūhana),即是造作(abhisaṅkharaṇa)。“变异”(vipariṇāma),是指状态(avatthāvisesa)的改变。“恒常想”(dhuvasaññā),是执取恒常不变(thirabhāva)。“相”(nimitta),是指由于聚合等的坚固性(samūhādighana),以及各自作用的限定(sakiccaparicchedatāya),而对诸行(saṅkhāra)产生的有形相的执取(saviggahaggahaṇa)。“愿求”(paṇidhi),是指贪欲等愿求(rāgādipaṇidhi)。就其义而言,它是因为渴爱(taṇhā)而对诸行产生的欢喜(nanditā)。“执取”(abhinivesa),是指我见(attānudiṭṭhi)。 Aniccadukkhādivasena sabbadhammatīraṇaṃ adhipaññādhammavipassanā. Sārādānābhinivesanti asāre sāraggahaṇavipallāsaṃ. Issarakuttādivasena loko samuppannoti abhiniveso sammohābhiniveso. Keci pana ‘‘ahosiṃ nu kho ahamatītamaddhānantiādinā pavattasaṃsayāpatti sammohābhiniveso’’ti vadanti. Saṅkhāresu leṇatāṇabhāvaggahaṇaṃ ālayābhiniveso. ‘‘Ālayaratā ālayasammuditā’’ti (dī. ni. 2.64; ma. ni. 1.281; 2.337; saṃ. ni. 1.172; mahāva. 7) vacanato ālayo taṇhā, sāyeva cakkhādīsu rūpādīsu ca abhinivesavasena pavattiyā ālayābhinivesoti keci. ‘‘Evaṃvidhā saṅkhārā paṭinissajjīyantī’’ti pavattaṃ ñāṇaṃ paṭisaṅkhānupassanā. Vaṭṭato vigatattā vivaṭṭaṃ, nibbānaṃ. Tattha ārammaṇakaraṇasaṅkhātena anupassanena pavattiyā vivaṭṭānupassanā, gotrabhū. Saṃyogābhinivesanti saṃyujjanavasena saṅkhāresu [Pg.131] abhinivisanaṃ. Diṭṭhekaṭṭheti diṭṭhiyā sahajātekaṭṭhe pahānekaṭṭhe ca. Oḷāriketi uparimaggavajjhe kilese apekkhitvā vuttaṃ, aññathā dassanapahātabbāpi dutiyamaggavajjhehi oḷārikāti. Aṇusahagateti aṇubhūte. Idaṃ heṭṭhimamaggavajjhe apekkhitvā vuttaṃ. Sabbakileseti avasiṭṭhasabbakilese. Na hi paṭhamādimaggehipi pahīnā kilesā puna pahīyantīti. 以无常、苦等审察一切法,是增上慧法观(adhipaññādhammavipassanā)。执取实质的执著,是指于无实质中执取实质的颠倒。认为世界由自在天所造(Issarakutta)等而执著,是痴执著。但有人说:“我于过去世存在吗?”等生起的疑惑,是痴执著。于诸行中执取为庇护所与归依处,是爱执著。如经言:“乐于爱,喜于爱”(长部2.64;中部1.281;2.337;相应部1.172;大品7),爱即是渴爱;有人说,此渴爱因执著于眼等及色等而转起,故是爱执著。“此类诸行应被舍弃”,如此转起的智,是省察随观(paṭisaṅkhānupassanā)。因脱离轮回(vaṭṭa),故为出离轮回(vivaṭṭa),即涅槃。于彼(涅槃),以之为所缘而转起的随观,是出离轮回随观(vivaṭṭānupassanā),即种姓智(gotrabhū)。结执著(saṃyogābhinivesa)即以结缚的方式对诸行产生执着。于见为一处(diṭṭhekaṭṭha)即是与见俱生为一处,以及在断除时成为一处。粗显(oḷārika)是就上道所应断的烦恼而言,否则,见所断的(烦恼)对第二道所应断的(烦恼)而言也是粗显的。微细俱行(aṇusahagata)是指微细的(烦恼)。这是就下道所应断的(烦恼)而言。一切烦恼是指剩余的一切烦恼。因为初道等所断的烦恼不会再次被断除。 Kakkhaḷattaṃ kathinabhāvo. Paggharaṇaṃ dravabhāvo. Lokiyavāyunā bhastāya viya yena taṃtaṃkalāpassa uddhumāyanaṃ, thaddhabhāvo vā, taṃ vitthambhanaṃ. Vijjamānepi kalāpantarabhūtānaṃ kalāpantarabhūtehi phuṭṭhabhāve taṃtaṃbhūtavivittatā rūpapariyanto ākāsoti yesaṃ yo paricchedo, tehi so asamphuṭṭhova, aññathā bhūtānaṃ paricchedabhāvo na siyā byāpitabhāvāpattito. Yasmiṃ kalāpe bhūtānaṃ paricchedo, tehi asamphuṭṭhabhāvo asamphuṭṭhalakkhaṇaṃ. Tenāha – bhagavā ākāsadhātuniddese (dha. sa. 637) ‘‘asamphuṭṭho catūhi mahābhūtehī’’ti. 粗硬性(kakkhaḷatta)即坚硬。流动(paggharaṇa)即液体状态。如同皮囊被世间风所吹,由此而有各个色聚的膨胀,或僵硬的状态,此即支撑(vitthambhana)。即使在一色聚中的诸大种与另一色聚中的诸大种相互接触的情况下,各个大种的分离状态,即是作为色之界限的虚空(rūpapariyanto ākāsa),此虚空是它们的界限,它与它们是不相触的,否则,诸大种的界限状态就不存在了,因为会陷入遍满状态。在哪个色聚中存在诸大种的界限,与它们不相触,即是不相触的特征。因此,世尊在《虚空界解释》(ākāsadhātuniddesa)中说(法集论 637):“不与四大种相触”。 Virodhipaccayasannipāte visadisuppatti ruppanaṃ. Cetanāpadhānattā saṅkhārakkhandhadhammānaṃ cetanāvasenetaṃ vuttaṃ – ‘‘saṅkhārānaṃ abhisaṅkharaṇalakkhaṇa’’nti. Tathā hi suttantabhājanīye saṅkhārakkhandhavibhaṅge (vibha. 92) ‘‘cakkhusamphassajā cetanā’’tiādinā cetanāva vibhattā. Abhisaṅkharalakkhaṇā ca cetanā. Yathāha – ‘‘tattha katamo puññābhisaṅkhāro, kusalā cetanā kāmāvacarā’’tiādi. Pharaṇaṃ savipphārikatā. Assaddhiyeti assaddhiyahetu. Nimittatthe bhummaṃ. Esa nayo kosajjetiādīsu. Vūpasamalakkhaṇanti kāyacittapariḷāhūpasamalakkhaṇaṃ. Līnuddhaccarahite adhicitte pavattamāne paggahaniggahasampahaṃsanesu abyāvaṭatāya ajjhupekkhanaṃ paṭisaṅkhānaṃ pakkhapātupacchedato. 当敌对因缘聚合时,生起不相似的状态,即是变坏(ruppana)。由于思(cetanā)是行蕴诸法的主导,故依思而说:“诸行的特征是造作(abhisaṅkharaṇa)”。如在《经分别》(suttantabhājanīya)的〈行蕴分别〉(vibha. 92)中,以“眼触所生思”等,唯独分别了思。而思即具有造作的特征。如说:“在此,什么是福行(puññābhisaṅkhāra)?即是欲界的善思”等。遍满(pharaṇa)即是扩展性(saviṭṭhārikatā)。于不信(assaddhiye),是说以不信为因。此处的处格是用于因由义。此理亦可用于懈怠(kosajja)等。寂止(vūpasama)的特征是止息身心热恼。当增上心于远离昏沉(līna)、掉举(uddhacca)而转起时,对于策励(paggaha)、抑制(niggaha)、激励(sampahaṃsana)不加功用,此舍置,因断除了偏袒,即是省察(paṭisaṅkhāna)。 Musāvādādīnaṃ visaṃvādanādikiccatāya lūkhānaṃ apariggāhakānaṃ paṭipakkhabhāvato pariggāhakasabhāvā sammāvācā, siniddhabhāvato sampayuttadhamme sammāvācāpaccayasubhāsitānaṃ sotārañca puggalaṃ pariggaṇhātīti sā pariggahalakkhaṇā. Kāyikakiriyā kiñci kattabbaṃ samuṭṭhāpeti, sayañca samuṭṭhahanaṃ ghaṭanaṃ hotīti sammākammantasaṅkhātā viratīpi [Pg.132] samuṭṭhānalakkhaṇā daṭṭhabbā, sampayuttadhammānaṃ vā ukkhipanaṃ samuṭṭhāpanaṃ kāyikakiriyāya bhārukkhipanaṃ viya. Jīvamānassa sattassa, sampayuttadhammānaṃ vā jīvitindriyapavattiyā, ājīvasseva vā suddhi vodānaṃ. ‘‘Saṅkhārā’’ti idha cetanā adhippetāti vuttaṃ – ‘‘saṅkhārānaṃ cetanālakkhaṇa’’nti. Namanaṃ ārammaṇābhimukhabhāvo. Āyatanaṃ pavattanaṃ. Āyatanavasena hi āyasaṅkhātānaṃ cittacetasikānaṃ pavatti. Taṇhāya hetulakkhaṇanti vaṭṭassa janakahetubhāvo, maggassa pana nibbānasampāpakattanti ayametesaṃ viseso. 妄语等因其具有欺骗等作用,是粗恶的、不摄受的,而正语是它们的对治,故正语的自性是摄受;又因其润泽性,能摄受相应法,以及由正语为缘的善说能摄受听闻者,故其特征是摄受。身业能发起某件应做之事,而自身发起即是努力,故名为正业的离(virati)亦应被视为具有发起的特征;或者,是提起相应法,如同身业中举起重物一般。(正命的特征是)令活着的有情、或依命根(jīvitindriya)而转起的相应法、或生计本身,得以清净、遍净。此处所谓“行”,意指思,故说:“诸行的特征是思”。倾向即是面向所缘的状态。处即是转起。因为依于处,名为“入”的心与心所法得以转起。渴爱的特征是因,即作为轮回的生起因;而道的(特征)则是作为涅槃的到达因。此即它们的差别。 Tathalakkhaṇaṃ aviparītasabhāvo. Ekaraso aññamaññanātivattanaṃ anūnādhikabhāvo. Yuganaddhā samathavipassanāva. ‘‘Saddhāpaññā paggahāvikkhepā’’tipi vadanti. Khayoti kilesakkhayo maggo. Anuppādapariyosānatāya anuppādo phalaṃ. Passaddhi kilesavūpasamo. Chandassāti kattukāmatāchandassa. Mūlalakkhaṇaṃ patiṭṭhābhāvo. Samuṭṭhānalakkhaṇaṃ ārammaṇappaṭipādakatāya sampayuttadhammānaṃ uppattihetutā. Samodhānaṃ visayādisannipātena gahetabbākāro, yā saṅgatīti vuccati. Samaṃ, saha odahanti anena sampayuttadhammāti vā samodhānaṃ, phasso. Samosaranti sannipatanti etthāti samosaraṇaṃ. Vedanāya vinā appavattamānā sampayuttadhammā vedanānubhavananimittaṃ samosaṭā viya hontīti evaṃ vuttaṃ. Gopānasīnaṃ kūṭaṃ viya sampayuttānaṃ pāmokkhabhāvo pamukhalakkhaṇaṃ. Tato, tesaṃ vā sampayuttadhammānaṃ uttari padhānanti tatuttari. Paññuttarā hi kusalā dhammā. Vimuttiyāti phalassa. Tañhi sīlādiguṇasārassa paramukkaṃsabhāvena sāraṃ. Ayañca lakkhaṇavibhāgo chadhātupañcajhānaṅgādivasena taṃtaṃsuttapadānusārena porāṇaṭṭhakathāyaṃ āgatanayena ca katoti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Tathā hi pubbe vuttopi koci dhammo pariyāyantarappakāsanatthaṃ puna dassito, tato eva ca ‘‘chandamūlakā kusalā dhammā manasikārasamuṭṭhānā phassasamodhānā vedanāsamosaraṇā’’ti, ‘‘paññuttarā kusalā dhammā’’ti, ‘‘vimuttisāramidaṃ brahmacariya’’nti, ‘‘nibbānogadhañhi, āvuso, brahmacariyaṃ nibbānapariyosāna’’nti (saṃ. ni. 5.512) ca suttapadānaṃ vasena ‘‘chandassa mūlalakkhaṇa’’ntiādi vuttaṃ. 如相,即不颠倒之自性。一味,即不互相超越、无增无减之状态。双运,即止与观。亦有谓“信、慧、策励(paggaha)、不散乱(avikkhepa)”者。尽,即烦恼之灭尽,亦即道。以不生为究竟,不生即是果。轻安,即烦恼之止息。欲,即欲作之欲。根本相,即安住之性。生起相,即由所缘之引导,作为相应法生起之因。和合,即由境等聚集所取之相,亦即所谓之会合。或者,相应法共同投入于此,故名和合,即是触。聚集,即诸法会集于此,故称聚集。若无受,相应法即不生起,犹如为感受受(vedanā)之行相而聚集,是故如是说。犹如椽梁之顶端,(心)是相应法中最首要者,此即首要之相。进而,于此等相应法中最殊胜者,即是彼最殊胜(tatuttari)者。盖善法以慧(paññā)为最上。解脱,即指果。彼以戒等功德精华之最殊胜状态为精髓。此相之分别,当知是依据六界、五禅支等,顺应经句,以及古义注所传之方法而作。犹如前所说的任何法,为以不同方式开示,再次在此显现。是故亦说“善法以欲为根本,以作意为生起,以触为和合,以受为聚集”,“善法以慧为最上”,“此梵行以解脱为精髓”,“贤友,梵行以涅槃为基础,以涅槃为究竟”(相应部 5.512)等经句,依据此等而说“欲之根本相”等。 Tathadhammā [Pg.133] nāma cattāri ariyasaccāni aviparītasabhāvattā. Tathāni taṃsabhāvattā, avitathāni amusāsabhāvattā, anaññathāni aññākārarahitattā. Jātipaccayasambhūtasamudāgataṭṭhoti jātipaccayā sambhūtaṃ hutvā sahitassa attano paccayānurūpassa uddhaṃ uddhaṃ āgatabhāvo, anupavattatthoti attho. Atha vā sambhūtaṭṭho ca samudāgataṭṭho ca sambhūtasamudāgataṭṭho, na jātito jarāmaraṇaṃ na hoti, na ca jātiṃ vinā aññato hotīti jātipaccayasambhūtaṭṭho, itthañca jātito samudāgacchatīti jātipaccayasamudāgataṭṭho. Yā yā jāti yathā yathā paccayo hoti, tadanurūpaṃ pātubhāvoti attho. Avijjāya saṅkhārānaṃ paccayaṭṭhoti etthāpi na avijjā saṅkhārānaṃ paccayo na hoti, na ca avijjaṃ vinā saṅkhārā uppajjanti. Yā yā avijjā yesaṃ yesaṃ saṅkhārānaṃ yathā yathā paccayo hoti, ayaṃ avijjāya saṅkhārānaṃ paccayaṭṭho, paccayabhāvoti attho. 名为如是法(Tathadhammā)者,即四圣谛,因其自性不颠倒故。彼等是如(tathāni),因其具此自性;是不虚妄(avitathāni),因其非欺骗;是不异(anaññathāni),因其无其他形态。“生缘而生起与集起”之义,即由生为缘而生起,已生起后,随顺自身之缘而辗转生起,此即相续之义。或者,“生起”之义与“集起”之义,合为“生起与集起”之义。老死非不从生而有,亦非离生而从他处有,此即“生缘而生起”之义;如此从生而集起,此即“生缘而集起”之义。其义为:有何种生,以何种方式为缘,即有相应的显现。“无明为行之缘”于此亦然,非是无明不行之缘,亦非离无明而诸行生起。何种无明,以何种方式,为哪些行之缘,此即“无明为行之缘”之义,亦即为缘之状态。 Bhagavā taṃ jānāti passatīti sambandho. Tenāti bhagavatā. Taṃ vibhajjamānanti yojetabbaṃ. Tanti rūpāyatanaṃ. Iṭṭhāniṭṭhādīti ādi-saddena majjhattaṃ saṅgaṇhāti, tathā atītānāgatapaccuppannaparittaajjhattabahiddhātadubhayādibhedaṃ. Labbhamānakapadavasenāti ‘‘rūpāyatanaṃ diṭṭhaṃ, saddāyatanaṃ sutaṃ, gandhāyatanaṃ rasāyatanaṃ phoṭṭhabbāyatanaṃ mutaṃ, sabbaṃ rūpaṃ manasā viññāta’’nti (dha. sa. 966) vacanato diṭṭhapadañca viññātapadañca rūpārammaṇe labbhati. Anekehi nāmehīti ‘‘rūpārammaṇaṃ iṭṭhaṃ aniṭṭhaṃ majjhattaṃ parittaṃ atītaṃ anāgataṃ paccuppannaṃ ajjhattaṃ bahiddhā diṭṭhaṃ viññātaṃ rūpaṃ rūpāyatanaṃ rūpadhātu vaṇṇanibhā sanidassanaṃ sappaṭighaṃ nīlaṃ pītaka’’nti evamādīhi anekehi nāmehi. Terasahi vārehīti rūpakaṇḍe āgate terasa niddesavāre sandhāyāha. Dvepaññāsāya nayehīti ekekasmiṃ vāre catunnaṃ catunnaṃ vavatthāpananayānaṃ vasena dvipaññāsāya nayehi. Tathamevāti aviparītadassitāya appaṭivattiyadesanatāya ca tathameva hoti. Jānāmi abbhaññāsinti vattamānātītakālesu ñāṇappavattidassanena anāgatepi ñāṇappavatti vuttāyevāti daṭṭhabbā. Vidita-saddo anāmaṭṭhakālaviseso veditabbo ‘‘diṭṭhaṃ sutaṃ muta’’ntiādīsu (dī. ni. 3.188; ma. ni. 1.7-8; saṃ. ni. 3.208; a. ni. 4.23) viya. Na upaṭṭhāsīti attattaniyavasena na upagañchi[Pg.134]. Yathā rūpārammaṇādayo dhammā yaṃsabhāvā yaṃpakārā ca, tathā ne passati jānāti gacchatīti tathāgatoti evaṃ padasambhavo veditabbo. Keci pana ‘‘niruttinayena pisodarādipakkhepena vā dassīsaddassa lopaṃ, āgata-saddassa cāgamaṃ katvā tathāgato’’ti vaṇṇenti. “世尊知彼、见彼”,此是关联。“由彼”(Tena)即“由世尊”。应联系为“当分别解释彼时”。“彼”(Taṃ)即色处。“可爱、不可爱等”,此中“等”字摄取中性,以及过去、未来、现在、小、内、外、此二者等差别。依可得之词,如《法集论》(Dhammasaṅgaṇi)所说:“色处被见,声处被闻,香处、味处、触处被觉知,一切色被心所识知”,故于色所缘上可得“见”与“识知”二词。以众多名称,即“色所缘为可爱、不可爱、中性、小、过去、未来、现在、内、外、所见、所识知、色、色处、色界、显色、光泽、有见、有对、青、黄”等众多名称。“以十三种方式”,是指色蕴篇中的十三种解释(niddesa)方式。“以五十二种理趣”,即于每一种方式中,依四种确立理趣,而成五十二种理趣。“如是”,即因不颠倒地开示与教法不退转,故为如是。“我知,我已证知”,此句通过显示智慧于现在与过去时生起,当知未来智慧之生起亦已含摄于此说中。“已知”(Vidita)一词,当知其不指定特定时间,如“所见、所闻、所觉”等。“不执取”(na upaṭṭhāsi),即不以我、我所而接近。诸法如色所缘等,有何自性、有何行相,即如是见彼、知彼、趣彼,故为如来。当如是理解此词之构成。然而,有人依词源学(niruttinayena),或通过如“pisodara”等词的省略方式,解释为:将“dassī”一词省略,并加入“āgata”一词,而成“Tathāgato”。 Yaṃ rattinti yassaṃ rattiyaṃ. Accantasaṃyoge cetaṃ upayogavacanaṃ. Tiṇṇaṃ mārānanti kilesābhisaṅkhāradevaputtasaṅkhātānaṃ tiṇṇaṃ mārānaṃ. Anupavajjanti niddosatāya na upavajjaṃ. Anūnanti pakkhipitabbābhāvena na ūnaṃ. Anadhikanti apanetabbābhāvena na adhikaṃ. Sabbākāraparipuṇṇanti atthabyañjanādisampattiyā sabbākārena paripuṇṇaṃ. No aññathāti ‘‘tathevā’’ti vuttamevatthaṃ byatirekena sampādeti. Tena yadatthaṃ bhāsitaṃ, tadatthanipphādanato yathā bhāsitaṃ bhagavatā, tathevāti aviparītadesanataṃ dasseti. Gadatthoti etena tathaṃ gadatīti tathāgatoti da-kārassa ta-kāraṃ katvā niruttinayena vuttanti dasseti. Tathā gatamassāti tathāgato. Gatanti ca kāyassa vācāya vā pavattīti attho. Tathāti ca vutte yaṃ-taṃ-saddānaṃ abyabhicāritasambandhatāya yathāti ayamattho upaṭṭhitoyeva hoti. Kāyavācākiriyānañca aññamaññānulomena vacanicchāyaṃ kāyassa vācā, vācāya ca kāyo sambandhabhāvena upatiṭṭhatīti imamatthaṃ dassento āha – ‘‘bhagavato hī’’tiādi. Imasmiṃ pana atthe tathāvāditāya tathāgatoti ayampi attho siddho hoti. So pana pubbe pakārantarena dassitoti āha – ‘‘evaṃ tathākāritāya tathāgato’’ti. “于彼夜”(Yaṃ rattiṃ)即“于其夜中”(yassaṃ rattiyaṃ),此为表示完全关联的方位格用法。“三魔”,即名为烦恼、行、天子之三魔。“无过失”(Anupavajjaṃ),因无过错,故无过失。“无缺”(Anūnaṃ),因无可增益,故无缺。“无多”(Anadhikaṃ),因无可损减,故无多。“一切行相圆满”(Sabbākāraparipuṇṇaṃ),因义理、文句等具足,故一切行相圆满。“非异”(No aññathā),此句以否定方式确证了前文“如是”(tatheva)之义。因此,为成就所说之义,故世尊所说如是,即显示其教说不颠倒。“说真实者”(Gadattho),此句显示:“如实而说(tathaṃ gadati),故为如来”,是依词源学将da音转为ta音而说。“其行如是,故为如来”。“行”(Gataṃ)者,义为身或语之行动。而说“如”(tathā)时,因其与“彼”(yaṃ-taṃ)等词有不变之关联,故“如实”(yathā)之义自然现前。为显示身语之行相互随顺,语随心意,身亦随语,二者相互关联之义,故说“世尊实……”等。于此义中,“因如实说,故为如来”之义亦得成立。然此义先前已由他种方式开示,故说:“如是,因如实行,故为如来”。 Tiriyaṃ aparimāṇāsu lokadhātūsūti etena yadeke ‘‘tiriyaṃ viya upari adho ca santi lokadhātuyo’’ti vadanti, taṃ paṭisedheti. Desanāvilāsoyeva desanāvilāsamayo yathā ‘‘puññamayaṃ dānamaya’’ntiādīsu (dī. ni. 3.305; itivu. 60; netti. 33). Nipātānaṃ vācakasaddasannidhāne tadatthajotanabhāvena pavattanato gata-saddoyeva avagatatthaṃ atītatthañca vadatīti āha – ‘‘gatoti avagato atīto’’ti. Atha vā abhinīhārato paṭṭhāya yāva [Pg.135] sambodhi, etthantare mahābodhiyānapaṭipattiyā hānaṭṭhānasaṃkilesanivattīnaṃ abhāvato yathā paṇidhānaṃ, tathā gato abhinīhārānurūpaṃ paṭipannoti tathāgato. Atha vā mahiddhikatāya paṭisambhidānaṃ ukkaṃsādhigamena anāvaraṇañāṇatāya ca katthacipi paṭighātābhāvato yathā ruci, tathā kāyavācācittānaṃ gatāni gamanāni pavattiyo etassāti tathāgato. Yasmā ca loke vidhayuttagatapakārasaddā samānatthā dissanti, tasmā yathāvidhā vipassiādayo bhagavanto, ayampi bhagavā tathāvidhoti tathāgato. Yathā yuttā ca te bhagavanto, ayampi bhagavā tathā yuttoti tathāgato. Atha vā yasmā saccaṃ tatvaṃ tacchaṃ tathanti ñāṇassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ, tasmā tathena ñāṇena āgatoti tathāgatoti evampi tathāgatasaddassa attho veditabbo. “于无量世界中横向”,此句驳斥了有人所说“世界如横向一般,亦有上、下”之论。“教法之庄严”(Desanāvilāsa)即是“由教法庄严所成”(desanāvilāsamayo),犹如“功德所成”、“布施所成”等。因不变词(nipāta)邻近能诠词时,有彰显其义之作用,故“gata”一词既说“已解”义,亦说“已逝”义,是故说:“gata即已解、已逝”。或者,从发愿(abhinīhāra)乃至正觉(sambodhi),于此期间,依大菩提乘(mahābodhiyāna)而行,无有退堕处、烦恼、还退,故能如其誓愿而行,随顺发愿而实践,是为如来。或者,因具大神通、以无碍解达究竟证悟、具无碍智,于任何处皆无障碍,故其身、语、意之行、往、转,皆能如其所乐,是为如来。又因世间“方式”(vidha)、“相应”(yutta)、“行”(gata)、“种类”(pakāra)等词,可见其义相同,是故,毗婆尸(Vipassī)等世尊是何等方式,此世尊亦是彼等方式,故为如来。彼等世尊如何相应,此世尊亦如是相应,故为如来。或者,因“真实”(saccaṃ)、“真如”(tatvaṃ)、“不虚”(tacchaṃ)、“如”(tathā)皆为智慧之异名,故由如实之智而来,是为如来。当如是理解如来一词之义。 ‘‘Pahāya kāmādimale yathā gatā,Samādhiñāṇehi vipassiādayo; Mahesino sakyamunī jutindharo,Tathāgato tena tathāgato mato. 如毗婆尸(Vipassī)等诸大仙,以定慧舍欲垢而行;释迦牟尼持光者,亦如是而行,故名如来。 ‘‘Tathañca dhātāyatanādilakkhaṇaṃ,Sabhāvasāmaññavibhāgabhedato; Sayambhuñāṇena jinoyamāgato,Tathāgato vuccati sakyapuṅgavo. 如实了知界、处等法相,及其自相、共相之分别;此胜者以自觉智而来,故释迦雄长(Sakyapuṅgavo)被称为如来。 ‘‘Tathāni saccāni samantacakkhunā,Tathā idappaccayatā ca sabbaso; Anaññaneyyena yato vibhāvitā,Yāthāvato tena jino tathāgato. 以普眼(samantacakkhu)尽观诸如是谛,亦完全明了此缘性法;由不待他导之智如实阐明,是故胜者名为如来。 ‘‘Anekabhedāsupi lokadhātusu,Jinassa rupāyatanādigocare; Vicittabhede tathameva dassanaṃ,Tathāgato tena samantalocano. 于种种差别之诸界(lokadhātu)中,胜者(Jina)于色处(rūpāyatana)等所缘,亦如是见种种差别;如来因此为普眼者(samantalocano)。 ‘‘Yato [Pg.136] ca dhammaṃ tathameva bhāsati,Karoti vācāyanulomamattano; Guṇehi lokaṃ abhibhuyyirīyati,Tathāgato tenapi lokanāyako. 又,彼如实宣说正法,言行一致;以诸功德超胜世间,如来因此亦为世间导师(lokanāyaka)。 ‘‘Yathābhinīhāramato yathāruci,Pavattavācā tanucittabhāvato; Yathāvidhā yena purā mahesino,Tathāvidho tena jino tathāgato’’ti. (dī. ni. ṭī. 1.7) – 随其本愿(abhinīhāra)与意乐(ruci),言语随于身心状态;往昔诸大仙(mahesi)如何,今此胜者(Jina)亦复如是,故名如来。 Saṅgahagāthā mukhamattameva, kasmā? Appamādapadaṃ viya sakalakusaladhammasampaṭipattiyā sabbabuddhaguṇānaṃ saṅgāhakattā. Tenevāha – ‘‘sabbākārenā’’tiādi. Sesamettha uttānatthameva. 此摄颂(saṅgahagāthā)仅是开端。何以故?犹如不放逸(appamāda)句,为成就一切善法,能总摄一切佛德故。是故说:“以一切行相”等。此中余者,其义自明。 171. Dutiye uppattīti paṭhamāya jātiyā nibbattiṃ vatvā ariyāya jātiyā nibbattiṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘nipphattī’’ti āha. Tadā hissa buddhabhāvanipphattīti. ‘‘Dullabho’’tiādiṃ vatvā kāraṇassa dūrasambhārabhāvato tattha kāraṇaṃ dassento ‘‘ekavāra’’ntiādimāha. Idaṃ vuttaṃ hoti – tattha vāragaṇanā nāma māsasaṃvaccharakappagaṇanādikā, kappānaṃ ekaṃ asaṅkhyeyyaṃ dve asaṅkhyeyyāni tīṇi asaṅkhyeyyānipi pāramiyo pūretvāpi buddhena bhavituṃ na sakkā, heṭṭhimakoṭiyā pana cattāri asaṅkhyeyyāni kappasatasahassañca nirantaraṃ dasa pāramiyo pūretvā buddhabhāvaṃ pattuṃ sakkā, na ito aññathāti iminā kāraṇena dullabho pātubhāvo buddhānanti. 171. 第二,关于“生起”(uppatti):在说明了第一次的出生后,为显示圣者的出生,而说“成就”(nipphatti)。因为那时是其佛位的成就之时。在说了“难得”(dullabho)等之后,由于其因需要长远积集,为显示此中之因,而说“一次”(ekavāra)等。此义是说:此处的次数计算,是指月、年、劫等计算。纵然圆满一个、两个乃至三个阿僧祇(asaṅkhyeyya)劫的波罗蜜,亦不能成佛。然而,以最低限度而言,须于四阿僧祇劫并十万劫中,不间断地圆满十波罗蜜,方能证得佛位,舍此别无他途。以此因缘,诸佛出世,甚为难得。 172. Tatiye niccaṃ na hotīti abhiṇhappavattikaṃ na hoti kadācideva sambhavato. Yebhuyyena manussā acchariyaṃ disvā accharaṃ paharanti, taṃ sandhāya vuttaṃ – ‘‘accharaṃ paharitvā passitabbo’’ti. Samannāgatattāti etena acchariyā guṇadhammā etasmiṃ santīti acchariyoti dasseti. Apica ādito pabhuti abhinīhārāvaho, tato parampi anaññasādhāraṇe guṇadhamme āciṇṇavāti acchariyoti āha – ‘‘āciṇṇamanussotipi acchariyamanusso’’tiādi. Mahābodhiñāṇameva maṇḍabhūtaṃ mahābodhimaṇḍo. Sabbaññutaññāṇapadaṭṭhānañhi maggañāṇaṃ, maggañāṇapadaṭṭhānañca sabbaññutaññāṇaṃ [Pg.137] ‘‘mahābodhī’’ti vuccati. Anivattakenāti bodhiyā niyatabhāvāpattiyā mahābodhisattabhāvato anivattanasabhāvena. Buddhakārakadhammānaṃ pūraṇampi na aññassa kassaci āciṇṇantiādinā hetuavatthāya phalāvatthāya sattānaṃ upakārāvatthāya cāti tīsupi avatthāsu lokanātho anaññasādhāraṇānaṃ guṇadhammānaṃ āciṇṇatāya acchariyamanusso vuttoti dasseti. 172. 第三,“不常有”(niccaṃ na hoti)者,谓非恒常发生,仅偶而出兴故。通常,人们见到稀有之事便弹指赞叹,就此而说“应弹指赞叹而观”。“具足故”(samannāgatattā)者,以此显示,因彼身中具有稀有之功德法,故为“稀有”(acchariya)。复次,从最初即能发起本愿,此后亦修习不共之功德法,故为稀有。如说:“虽是常人,亦是稀有人”等。大菩提智即是精华(maṇḍa),故为大菩提场(mahābodhimaṇḍa)。一切知智(sabbaññutaññāṇa)的近因是道智(maggañāṇa),道智的近因是一切知智,此被称为“大菩提”。“不退转”(anivattaka)者,谓由必证菩提,从大菩萨位起,即具不退转之自性。圆满成佛之法,亦非任何他人所能常行,以此等故,显示了世尊(lokanātha)于因位、果位及利益有情位此三位中,因常行不共之功德法,故被称为稀有人。 173. Catutthe kāle kiriyāti kālakiriyā. Katarasmiṃ kāle kīdisī kiriyā. Sāmaññajotanā hi visese avatiṭṭhati, visesatthinā ca viseso anuppayojitabboti āha – ‘‘ekasmiṃ kāle pākaṭā kiriyā’’ti. Katarasmiṃ pana ekasmiṃ kāle, kathañca pākaṭāti? Kappānaṃ satasahassādhikāni anekāni asaṅkhyeyyāni abhikkamitvā yathādhippetamanorathapāripūrivasena samupaladdhe ekasmiṃ kāle, sadevaloke ativiya acchariyamanussassa parinibbānanti accantapākaṭā. Anutāpakarāti cetodukkhāvahā. Dasasahassacakkavāḷesūti vuttaṃ tassa buddhakkhettabhāvena paricchinnattā, tadaññesañca avisayattā. 173. 第四,“时至而作”(kāle kiriyā)即是“命终”(kālakiriyā)。于何时有何等作为?诚然,总说依于别说,求别说者当究其别,故云“于一时显现之作为”。然则,于何等一时?又如何显现?谓:经过无数阿僧祇并十万余劫,依所期之愿圆满而得之某一时刻,即是彼至极稀有人于含括天界之世间中般涅槃,此乃极其显明之事。“能令追悔”(anutāpakara)者,谓能引生心苦。说“于十千世界(dasasahassacakkavāḷa)”者,因此处被限定为佛土(buddhakkhetta),且非其他有情之所行境故。 174. Pañcame dutiyassa buddhassāti dutiyassa sabbaññubuddhassa abhāvā. Sutabuddho nāma sutamayena ñāṇena bujjhitabbassa buddhattā. Catusaccabuddho nāma catunnaṃ ariyasaccānaṃ anavasesato buddhattā. Paccekabuddho nāma paccekaṃ attanoyeva yathā catusaccasambodho hoti, evaṃ buddhattā. Sammāsambuddho eva hi yathā sadevakassa lokassa catusaccasambodho hoti, evaṃ saccāni abhisambujjhati. Cattāri vā aṭṭha vā soḷasa vāti idaṃ katamahābhinīhārānaṃ mahābodhisattānaṃ paññādhikasaddhādhikavīriyādhikavibhāgavasena vuttaṃ. ‘‘Paññādhikānañhi saddhā mandā hoti, paññā tikkhā. Saddhādhikānaṃ paññā majjhimā hoti. Vīriyādhikānaṃ paññā mandā, paññānubhāvena ca sammāsambodhi adhigantabbā’’ti aṭṭhakathāyaṃ vuttaṃ. Avisesena pana vimuttiparipācanīyadhammānaṃ tikkhamajjhimamudubhāvena tayopete bhedā yuttāti vadanti. Tividhā hi bodhisattā abhinīhārakkhaṇe bhavanti ugghaṭitaññuvipañcitaññuneyyabhedena. Tesu [Pg.138] ugghaṭitaññū sammāsambuddhassa sammukhā cātuppadikaṃ gāthaṃ suṇanto tatiyapade apariyositeyeva chahi abhiññāhi saha paṭisambhidāhi arahattaṃ pattuṃ samatthūpanissayo hoti. Dutiyo satthu sammukhā ekaṃ gāthaṃ suṇanto apariyositeyeva catutthapade chahi abhiññāhi arahattaṃ pattuṃ samatthūpanissayo hoti. Itaro bhagavato sammukhā cātuppadikagāthaṃ sutvā pariyositāya gāthāya chahi abhiññāhi arahattaṃ pattuṃ samatthūpanissayo hoti. Tayopete vinā kālabhedena katābhinīhārā laddhabyākaraṇā pāramiyo pūrento yathākkamaṃ yathāvuttabhedena kālena sammāsambodhiṃ pāpuṇanti, tesu tesu pana kālabhedesu aparipuṇṇesu te te mahāsattā divase divase vessantaradānasadisaṃ dānaṃ dentāpi tadanurūpaṃ sīlādisesapāramidhamme ācinantāpi antarā buddhā bhavissantīti akāraṇametaṃ. Kasmā? Ñāṇassa aparipaccanato. Paricchinnakālanipphāditaṃ viya hi sassaṃ paricchinnakāle nipphāditā sammāsambodhi tadantarā sabbussāhena vāyamantenapi na sakkā pāpuṇitunti pāramipūrī yathāvuttakālavisesena sampajjatīti veditabbaṃ. Saddhinti samānakāle. 174. 第五,“第二佛”者,谓无有第二位一切知佛(sabbaññubuddha)故。闻法觉者(sutabuddha)乃依闻慧而觉悟所应觉悟者。四谛觉者(catusaccabuddha)乃因彻底觉悟四圣谛。独觉(paccekabuddha)乃因独自为己觉悟四圣谛。唯有正等觉者(sammāsambuddha)方能令含括天神之世间亦觉悟四圣谛,如其自身所证。所谓四、八或十六(阿僧祇劫),乃依发大誓愿之大菩萨们慧、信、精进增上之别而说。义注(aṭṭhakathā)云:“慧增上者信力弱而慧根利;信增上者慧根中;精进增上者慧根钝,然依智慧之力方能证得正等觉。”亦有说者言,依解脱成熟法(vimuttiparipācanīyadhamma)之利、中、钝,此三种分别方为合理。菩萨于发愿之时有三种,即:速知者(ugghaṭitaññu)、广演知者(vipañcitaññu)、所引导者(neyya)之别。其中,速知者于正等觉者面前听闻四句偈,于第三句尚未结束时,即具足以上六神通与无碍解证得阿罗汉果之潜能。第二者于导师面前听闻一偈,于第四句尚未结束时,即具足以上六神通证得阿罗汉果之潜能。另一者于世尊面前听闻四句偈,于偈颂结束后,即具足以上六神通证得阿罗汉果之潜能。此三者若无时间差别,则于发愿、得授记、圆满波罗蜜后,依其次第,于前述不同之时量中,证得正等觉。然于彼等各自时量尚未圆满之时,彼诸大士纵然日日行如韦桑达拉(Vessantara)之布施,积集相应之戒等其余波罗蜜法,亦无中途成佛之理。何以故?智慧未成熟故。犹如庄稼须待限定之时方能成熟,正等觉亦须于限定之时方能成就,其间纵然倾力精勤,亦不能得。当知波罗蜜之圆满,须由如前所述之特定时间方能成就。“信”(saddhiṃ)者,谓于同时。 Asahāyoti nippariyāyato vuttaṃ. Sahaayanaṭṭho hi sahāyaṭṭho. Paṭipattivasena bhagavatā saha samaṃ ayanaṃ nāma kassacipi nattheva. Hatthādiavayavato paṭi paṭi minitabbato paṭimā vuccati attabhāvo. Samattho nāma natthīti devo vā māro vā brahmā vā koci natthi. Paṭisamoti paṭinidhibhāvena samo. Paṭibhāgaṃ dātunti ‘‘cattāro satipaṭṭhānā’’tiādinā vuttassa dhammabhāgassa dhammakoṭṭhāsassa paṭipakkhabhūtaṃ katvā bhāgaṃ koṭṭhāsaṃ paṭivacanaṃ dātuṃ samattho nāma natthi. Natthi etassa sīlādiguṇehi paṭibimbabhūto puggaloti appaṭipuggalo. Tenāha – ‘‘añño kocī’’tiādi. Tisahassimahāsahassīnaṃ vibhāgo parato āvi bhavissati. Sesamettha suviññeyyameva. “无伴者(Asahāyo)”,是无譬喻的直接说法。因为同伴的含义是共同行走。就修行实践而言,没有任何人能与世尊平等同行。由于身体(attabhāvo)是由手等各个部分所构成,可以被一一衡量,故被称为“形像(paṭimā)”。所谓“能与之匹敌者”,是指没有天神、魔罗或梵天等任何存在可以与他相比。所谓“相似(paṭisamo)”,是指作为替代品而相同。能针对世尊所说的“四念处”等法义,提出对立的法义作为反驳者,确实不存在。因为没有哪个人(puggala)在戒行等功德方面能作为他的映像,所以他是“无可匹敌者(appaṭipuggalo)”。因此说“没有其他人”等。三千大千世界(tisahassimahāsahassī)的区分将在后面说明。其余部分在此很容易理解。 175. Chaṭṭhādīsu tasmiṃ puggaleti sammāsambuddhe. Tanti paññācakkhu. Pātubhūtameva hoti tassa sahassa uppajjanato. Uppattīti uppajjanaṃ. Nipphattīti parivuddhi. Kīvarūpassāti kīdisassa. Sāvakavisayeva hatthagataṃ paññācakkhu nāma dvinnaṃ aggasāvakānaṃyevāti āha – ‘‘sāriputtattherassā’’tiādi. Samādhipaññāti samādhisahagatā paññā. ‘‘Samādhisaṃvattanikā [Pg.139] khippanisantiādivisesāvahā paññā’’ti keci. Ālokoti paññāāloko eva. Tathā obhāso. Tīṇipīti tīṇipi suttāni. Lokiyalokuttaramissakānīti pubbabhāgapaññāya adhippetattā vuttaṃ. 175. 第六等中,“于彼人(tasmiṃ puggale)”是指正自觉者。‘教法(Tanti)’是指慧眼(paññācakkhu),它随着自身的生起而显现。‘生起(Uppatti)’就是出生。‘圆满(Nipphatti)’就是增长。‘何等相(Kīvarūpassa)’是问是何种形态。在声闻的境界中,所谓的慧眼是掌握在两位上首弟子手中的,因此说“舍利弗(Sāriputta)长老”等。‘定慧(Samādhipaññā)’是指与定相应的智慧。有人说:“是能引生禅定、带来速疾智等特殊功德的智慧”。‘光明(Āloko)’就是智慧之光,‘辉耀(obhāso)’也是如此。‘三者(Tīṇipi)’是指三部经。说“世间与出世间混合”,是因为它意指的是前分慧(pubbabhāgapaññā)。 Uttamadhammānanti attano uttaritarassa abhāvena seṭṭhadhammānaṃ. Daṭṭhabbato dassanaṃ, bhagavato rūpakāyo. Tatthapi visesato rūpāyatanaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘cakkhuviññāṇena daṭṭhuṃ labhatī’’ti. Natthi ito uttaranti anuttaraṃ, tadeva anuttariyaṃ, dassanañca taṃ anuttariyañcāti dassanānuttariyaṃ. Sesapadesupi eseva nayo. Ayaṃ pana padaviseso – suyyatīti savanaṃ, bhagavato vacanaṃ. Labbhatīti lābho, bhagavati saddhā. Sikkhitabbato sikkhā. Sīlasamādhipaññāparicaraṇaṃ pāricariyā, upaṭṭhānaṃ. Anussaraṇaṃ anussati, satthu guṇānussaraṇaṃ. Imesanti yathāvuttānaṃ channaṃ anuttariyānaṃ. Pātubhāvo hotīti tathāgatassa pātubhāvā tappaṭibaddhattā tabbisayattā ca pātubhāvo hoti. ‘‘Dassanānuttariya’’nti ca sadevake loke uttaritarassa bhagavato rūpassa na dassanamattaṃ adhippetaṃ, atha kho tassa rūpadassanamukhena aveccappasādena buddhaguṇe okappetvā ogāhetvā dassanaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘āyasmā hī’’tiādi. Idampi dassanānuttariyanti pubbe vuttato nibbisesattā vuttaṃ. Dasabalaṃ dassanāya labhitvāti ānandatthero viya pasādabhattimettāpubbakaṃ dasabalaṃ dassanāya labhitvā. Dassanaṃ vaḍḍhetvāti dassanamukhena pavattaṃ vipassanācāraṃ vaḍḍhetvā. Dassanamukhena yāva anulomañāṇaṃ vipassanācāraṃ vaḍḍhetvā tadanantaraṃ aṭṭhamakamahābhūmiṃ okkamanto dassanaṃ sotāpattimaggaṃ pāpeti nāma. Idha parato pavattaṃ dassanaṃ dassanameva nāma, mūladassanaṃ pana saccadassanassapi kāraṇabhāvato dassanānuttariyaṃ nāma. Esa nayo sesānuttariyesupi. “无上法(Uttamadhamma)”是指因自身之上更无胜者,故为最胜之法。所谓“见(dassana)”,是指见到世尊的色身,其中特别是指色处(rūpāyatana)。所以说:“能以眼识得见。”没有比此更殊胜的,称为“无上(anuttara)”,此即“无上性(anuttariya)”,见与此无上性结合,故称“见无上(dassanānuttariya)”。其余诸句,理路亦同。此处对词语的特别解释是:“闻(savana)”是指听闻世尊的言教;“得(lābha)”是指于世尊处获得信心;“学(sikkhā)”是指学习戒、定、慧;“承事(pāricariyā)”是指侍奉;“随念(anussati)”是指忆念,即随念导师的功德。‘这些’是指前述六种无上。‘出现(Pātubhāvo)’,是指因如来的出现,与此相关、以此为境,故有此(六无上)的出现。“见无上”并非仅指在天人世间见到世尊无与伦比的色身,而是指通过见此色身为门径,以不坏净信(aveccappasāda)信解、深入佛陀功德而见。所以说“具寿(āyasmā)”等。此亦为“见无上”,是因与前述无差别而说。所谓“得见十力”,是如阿难(Ānanda)长老一般,以信心、虔诚与慈爱为先,得见十力。所谓“增长见”,是指通过见为门径,增长观(vipassanā)的行持。通过见为门径,增长观的行持,直至随顺智(anulomañāṇa),其后踏入第八大人地(aṭṭhamakamahābhūmi),此“见”即能引至须陀洹道(sotāpattimagga)。此处,由他缘而转起的见,仅名为“见”;而根本之见,因其为见谛之因,故名“见无上”。其余无上,理路亦同。 Dasabale saddhaṃ paṭilabhatīti sammāsambuddhe bhagavati saddhaṃ paṭilabhati. Tisso sikkhā sikkhitvāti tisso pubbabhāgasikkhā sikkhitvā. Paricaratīti upaṭṭhānaṃ karoti. ‘‘Itipi so bhagavā’’tiādinā buddhānussativasena anussatijjhānaṃ uppādetvā taṃ padaṭṭhānaṃ katvā vipassanaṃ vaḍḍhento ‘‘anussatiṃ vaḍḍhetvā’’ti vutto. “于十力处获得信心”,即于正自觉者世尊处获得信心。“修习三学”,即修习前分三学(pubbabhāgasikkhā)。“承事”,即作侍奉。以“如是,彼世尊(Itipi so bhagavā)”等句,通过佛随念的方式生起随念禅(anussatijjhāna),以此为足处增长观(vipassanā)的人,被称为“增长随念”。 Sacchikiriyā [Pg.140] hotīti paccakkhakaraṇaṃ hoti. Maggakkhaṇe hi labbhamānā paṭisambhidā phalakkhaṇe sacchikatā nāma hoti tato paraṃ atthādīsu yathicchitaṃ viniyogakkhamabhāvato. Catassoti gaṇanaparicchedo. Paṭisambhidāti pabhedā. Kassa pana pabhedāti? ‘‘Atthe ñāṇaṃ atthapaṭisambhidā’’tiādivacanato (vibha. 718-721) ñāṇassetā pabhedā. Tasmā catasso paṭisambhidāti cattāro ñāṇappabhedāti attho. Atthapaṭisambhidāti atthe paṭisambhidā, atthapabhedassa salakkhaṇavibhāvanavavatthānakaraṇasamatthaṃ atthe pabhedagataṃ ñāṇanti attho. Tathā dhammapabhedassa salakkhaṇavibhāvanavavatthānakaraṇasamatthaṃ dhamme pabhedagataṃ ñāṇaṃ dhammapaṭisambhidā. Niruttipabhedassa salakkhaṇavibhāvanavavatthānakaraṇasamatthaṃ niruttābhilāpe pabhedagataṃ ñāṇaṃ niruttipaṭisambhidā. Paṭibhānapabhedassa salakkhaṇavibhāvanavavatthānakaraṇasamatthaṃ paṭibhāne pabhedagataṃ ñāṇaṃ paṭibhānapaṭisambhidā. “现证(Sacchikiriyā)”就是现前通达。于道刹那所获得的无碍解,在果刹那称为已现证,因为此后能够随心所欲地运用于义等之中。‘四’是数量的限定。‘无碍解(Paṭisambhidā)’是类别。那么是谁的类别呢?从‘于义的智慧是义无碍解’等语句可知,这些是智慧的类别。因此,四无碍解就是四种智慧类别的意思。义无碍解,是指在义方面的无碍解,即是能对义的类别进行自相辨析与确立、于义的类别中生起的智慧。同样,能对法的类别进行自相辨析与确立、于法的类别中生起的智慧,是法无碍解。能对词语的类别进行自相辨析与确立、于词语表达的类别中生起的智慧,是词无碍解。能对辩才的类别进行自相辨析与确立、于辩才的类别中生起的智慧,是辩无碍解。 Atthesu ñāṇantiādīsu atthoti saṅkhepato hetuphalaṃ. Tañhi hetuvasena araṇīyaṃ gantabbaṃ pattabbaṃ, tasmā ‘‘attho’’ti vuccati. Pabhedato pana yaṃ kiñci paccayuppannaṃ, nibbānaṃ, bhāsitattho, vipāko, kiriyāti ime pañca dhammā ‘‘attho’’ti veditabbā. Taṃ atthaṃ paccavekkhantassa tasmiṃ pabhedagataṃ ñāṇaṃ atthapaṭisambhidā. Dhammoti saṅkhepato paccayo. So hi yasmā tanti dahati vidahati pavatteti ceva pāpeti ca ṭhapeti ca, tasmā ‘‘dhammo’’ti vuccati. Pabhedato pana yo koci phalanibbattako hetu ariyamaggo bhāsitaṃ kusalaṃ akusalanti pañcavidhoti veditabbo, taṃ dhammaṃ paccavekkhantassa tasmiṃ dhamme pabhedagataṃ ñāṇaṃ dhammapaṭisambhidā. 在“于义之智”等句中,“义(attha)”,概括而言,即是因与果。因为那(果)是应被求取、趋向、证得的,所以称为“义”。从类别上说,则任何缘生法、涅槃、所说义、异熟、唯作,这五种法当知为“义”。于省察此义时,于其类别中生起的智慧,即是义无碍解。所谓“法(dhamma)”,概括而言,即是因缘。因为它能住持、措置、转起、引至并安立(诸法),故称“法”。从类别上说,则任何能生果之因、圣道、言教、善、不善,这五种当知为“法”。于省察此法时,于其类别中生起的智慧,即是法无碍解。 Atthadhammaniruttābhilāpe ñāṇanti tasmiṃ atthe ca dhamme ca sabhāvaniruttisaddaṃ ārammaṇaṃ katvā paccavekkhantassa tasmiṃ sabhāvaniruttiabhilāpe pabhedagataṃ ñāṇaṃ. Evamayaṃ niruttipaṭisambhidā saddārammaṇā nāma jātā, na paññattiārammaṇā. Kasmā? Yasmā saddaṃ sutvā ‘‘ayaṃ sabhāvanirutti, ayaṃ na sabhāvaniruttī’’ti pajānāti. Paṭisambhidāpatto hi ‘‘phasso’’ti vutte ‘‘ayaṃ sabhāvaniruttī’’ti jānāti, ‘‘phassā’’ti vā ‘‘phassa’’nti vā vutte ‘‘ayaṃ na sabhāvaniruttī’’ti jānāti. Vedanādīsupi eseva nayo. Ayaṃ panesa [Pg.141] nāmākhyātopasaggābyayapadampi jānātiyeva sabhāvaniruttiyā yāthāvato jānanato. Ñāṇesu ñāṇanti sabbatthakañāṇaṃ ārammaṇaṃ katvā paccavekkhantassa pabhedagataṃ ñāṇaṃ. 于义、法、词语表达之智——即对于那个义和法,以自性语之声为所缘进行观察,从而在那个自性语和表达中产生的分别智。这样,这种词无碍解是以声音为所缘而产生的,不是以概念为所缘。为什么呢?因为听到声音后,能够知道“这是自性语,这不是自性语”。获得无碍解的人,听到“触”(phasso)一词,就知道“这是自性语”;听到“phassā”或者“phassa”,就知道“这不是自性语”。于受等也是同样的道理。而且,由于如实了知自性语,此智也能了知名词、动词、前缀、不变词等词类。于诸智之智——即以遍一切智为所缘进行观察,从而产生的分别智。 Imā pana catasso paṭisambhidā sekkhabhūmiyaṃ asekkhabhūmiyanti dvīsu ṭhānesu pabhedaṃ gacchanti. Adhigamo pariyatti savanaṃ paripucchā pubbayogoti imehi pañcahi kāraṇehi visadā honti. Adhigamo nāma saccappaṭivedho. Pariyatti nāma buddhavacanaṃ. Tañhi gaṇhantassa paṭisambhidā visadā honti. Savanaṃ nāma dhammassavanaṃ. Sakkaccaṃ dhammaṃ suṇantassapi hi paṭisambhidā visadā honti. Paripucchā nāma aṭṭhakathā. Uggahitapāḷiyā atthaṃ kathentassapi hi paṭisambhidā visadā honti. Pubbayogo nāma pubbayogāvacaratā. Haraṇapaccāharaṇanayena paṭipākaṭakammaṭṭhānassapi paṭisambhidā visadā hontīti. Lokiyalokuttarā vāti ettha tisso paṭisambhidā lokiyā, atthapaṭisambhidā siyā lokiyā, siyā lokuttarāti evaṃ vibhajitvā attho veditabbo. 然而,这四种无碍解在有学地与无学地这两种情况下有所区别。通过证悟、学习、听闻、提问、先前修习这五个原因可以变得清晰。证悟指的是通达真理。学习指的是佛语。当有人学习佛语时,无碍解就会变得清晰。听闻指的是听闻佛法。即使是恭敬地听闻佛法,无碍解也会变得清晰。提问指的是义注。即使是讲解已经学过的巴利经文的意义,无碍解也会变得清晰。先前修习指的是实践先前的修行。即使是以导入导出之理修习已显明的业处,无碍解也会变得清晰。至于世间或出世间,其中的三种无碍解是世间的,义无碍解既可以是世间的,也可以是出世间的,应该这样区分理解。 Buddhuppādeyevāti avadhāraṇena buddhuppāde eva labbhanato, abuddhuppāde alabbhanato anaññasādhāraṇo paṭivedho adhippeto. Evañca katvā ‘‘mahato cakkhussā’’tiādīsu paññāmahattādikampi anaññasādhāraṇameva adhippetanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Tathā vijjāvimuttiphalasacchikiriyādayopi paresaṃ tabbhāvāvahā daṭṭhabbā. Yā kāci dhātuyo lokiyā lokuttarā vā, sabbā tā imāheva saṅgahitā, ettheva antogadhāti vuttaṃ – ‘‘imāva aṭṭhārasa dhātuyo nānāsabhāvato nānādhātuyo’’ti. Svāyamattho anekadhātunānādhātuñāṇavibhaṅgena (vibha. 751) dīpetabbo. ‘‘Sacchikiriyā’’ti vuttattā ‘‘vijjāti phale ñāṇa’’nti vuttaṃ. 唯有佛陀出世时——以限定词的缘故,唯有佛陀出世时才能获得,非佛陀出世时不能获得,因此指的是不共之证悟。这样理解后,在“大眼”等词语中,智慧广大等也应被理解为唯有佛陀才有的不共之法。同样,明与解脱果的现证等,也应被理解为能够引导他人获得这些成就。无论是世间的还是出世间的一切界,都包含在这十八界中,都摄属于此,所以说“这十八界因各自不同的自性而成为种种界”。这个含义应该用多界种种界智的分析(《分别论》751)来阐明。“现证”一词的缘故,所以说“明就是对于果的智慧”。 187. Yasmā cakkati aparāparaṃ parivattatīti cakkaṃ, tasmā iriyāpathāpi aparāparaṃ parivattanaṭṭhena cakkasadisattā cakkanti vuttā, tathā patirūpadesavāsādisampattiyo. Tato paṭṭhāya dhammacakkaṃ abhinīharati nāmāti ettha tadā mahāsatto attānaṃ abhinīhārayogaṃ karonto ‘‘dhammacakkaṃ abhinīharati nāmā’’ti vutto tato paṭṭhāya dhammacakkābhinīhāravibandhakaradhammānuppajjanato. Abhinīhaṭaṃ nāmāti etthapi ayameva [Pg.142] nayo. Arahattamaggaṃ paṭivijjhantopi dhammacakkaṃ uppādetiyeva nāma tadatthaṃ ñāṇaṃ paripācetīti katvā. Arahattaphalakkhaṇe dhammacakkaṃ uppāditaṃ nāma tasmiṃ khaṇe dhammacakkassa uppādanāya kātabbakiccassa kassaci abhāvā. Paṭivedhañāṇañhi idha ‘‘dhammacakka’’nti adhippetaṃ. Idāni desanāñāṇavasena dhammacakkaṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘kadā pavatteti nāmā’’tiādimāha. Na kevalaṃ therasseva, atha kho sabbesampi sāsanikānaṃ dhammakathā bhagavato dhammadesanā catunnaṃ ariyasaccānaṃ catunnañca ekattādinayānaṃ avirādhanatoti dassetuṃ – ‘‘yo hi koci bhikkhu vā’’tiādi āraddhaṃ. Sesaṃ suviññeyyameva. 187. 因为车轮不断地滚动、转动,所以称为“轮”(cakkaṃ)。因此,行姿也因其不断转换,与轮相似,故被称为“轮”;同样,适宜的住处等成就也是如此。“从此开始,名为发起法轮”者,是说当时大士正致力于令自身适合发起,故说“名为发起法轮”,因为从那时起,障碍发起法轮的诸法不再生起。“名为已发起”也是同样的道理。即使是正在证悟阿罗汉道,也名为“生起法轮”,因为是为了令智慧成熟以达彼岸。在阿罗汉果的刹那,名为“法轮已生起”,因为在那一刹那,已无任何为生起法轮所应做之事。此处的“法轮”意指证悟智。现在为了显示以说法智转法轮,而说“何时名为转动”等。不仅是长老,一切佛弟子说法,都是世尊的说法,这是为了显示其不违背四圣谛与四种一性等理趣,所以开始说“若有任何比丘”等。其余的则容易了知。 Ekapuggalavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 一人品释义终。 14. Etadaggavaggo 14. 最胜品 (14) 1. Paṭhamaetadaggavaggo (14)1. 第一最胜品 Etadaggapadavaṇṇanā 最胜句释义 188. Etadaggesu paṭhamavaggassa paṭhame ādimhi dissatīti ettha aggasaddoti ānetvā yojetabbaṃ. Ajjataggeti ajjadivasaṃ ādiṃ katvāti attho. Aṅgulaggenāti aṅgulikoṭiyā. Ambilagganti ambilakoṭṭhāso. Koṭibhūtāti paramakoṭibhūtā tasmiṃ ṭhāne tādisānaṃ aññesaṃ abhāvato. Tato eva seṭṭhabhūtātipi aggā. Etadaggasannikkhepoti etadagge ṭhapanaṃ aṭṭhuppattiādīhi catūhipi kāraṇehi. Mahāpaññatāya therena etadaggaṭṭhānassa laddhabhāvaṃ vitthārato dassetuṃ – ‘‘katha’’ntiādimāha. Dve padantarānīti kaṇḍambamūle yugandharapabbateti dvīsu ṭhānesu dve padāni dassetvā. Muṇḍapīṭhakanti yaṃ sattaṅgaṃ pañcaṅgaṃ vā na hoti, kevalaṃ muṇḍakapīṭhaṃ, taṃ sandhāyetaṃ vuttaṃ. Avattharitvā nisīdīti buddhānubhāvena ajjhottharitvā nisīdi. Tenāha – ‘‘evaṃ nisīdanto’’tiādi. Kāyasakkhiṃ katvāti nāmakāyena desanāya sampaṭicchanavasena sakkhibhūtaṃ katvā. Kusalā dhammā akusalā dhammā abyākatā dhammāti iti-saddo ādyattho, tena sabbaṃ abhidhammadesanaṃ saṅgaṇhāti. 188. 在《最胜品》第一品之初可见,应引入“agga”(最上)一词来连结。“ajjatagge”(今日最上)意为“从今日起”。“aṅgulaggena”(指尖)即手指之顶端。“ambilaggaṃ”(酸果之最)即酸果之部分。“koṭibhūtā”(至极)者,因于彼处无有其他同类者,故为究竟至极。由此亦为最胜,故称“agga”。“etadaggasannikkhepo”(置于最胜)者,即以事之起因等四种原因而置于最胜位。具大慧的长老为广说获得最胜地位之事,而说“kathaṃ”(云何)等。“dve padantarāni”(两句之间)者,谓于犍昙婆树下(kaṇḍambamūle)与持双山(Yugandhara)二处,各示现两句。“muṇḍapīṭhakaṃ”(光座)者,指非七支或五支,仅为光秃之座。“avattharitvā nisīdi”(未铺设而坐)者,谓以佛陀威力加持而坐,如已铺设。故云“evaṃ nisīdanto”(如是而坐)等。“kāyasakkhiṃ katvā”(以身作证)者,谓以名身领受教说,作为见证。所谓“善法、不善法、无记法”者,“iti”(如此)一词有“等”之义,由此总摄一切阿毗达摩教说。 Pāṭihāriyaṭṭhāneti yamakapāṭihāriyassa kataṭṭhāne. Passathāti tesaṃ bahubhāvaṃ sandhāya vuttaṃ. Assāti manussasamūhassa ekabhāvaṃ. Ākappanti [Pg.143] ākāraṃ. Mahājanoti sadevake loke sabbo mahājano. Yathā nirayadassanaṃ saṃvegajananatthaṃ, evaṃ devalokadassanampi saṃvegajananatthameva ‘‘anupubbikathāyaṃ saggakathā viya evaṃ sabbasampattisamupetopi saggo anicco addhuvo cavanadhammo’’ti. Sajjetvāti samapaṇṇāsāya mucchanāhi yathā kāmena nivādetuṃ sakkā, evaṃ sajjetvā. “神变处”(Pāṭihāriyaṭṭhāne)者,即行双神变(yamakapāṭihāriya)之处。“passatha”(你们看)者,是针对他们数量众多而说。“assa”(此)者,指此人群之整体。“ākappaṃ”(仪容)者,指姿态。“mahājano”(大众)者,指含天人在内的世间所有大众。如示現地狱是为了引生悚惧,示现天界也是为了引生悚惧,即如次第说中之天界说:“即使是具足一切成就的天界,也是无常、不坚固、有衰灭之法。”“sajjetvā”(准备好)者,谓准备好五十种音阶,以便能随心所欲地演奏。 Puthujjanapañcakaṃ pañhanti puthujjanapañhaṃ ādiṃ katvā pavattitaṃ khīṇāsavapañhapariyantaṃ pañhapañcakaṃ. Paṭhamaṃ…pe… pucchīti puthujjanavisaye pañhaṃ pucchi. Paṭisambhidā yathābhinīhāraṃ yathāsakaṃ vipassanābhinīhārena paṭhamabhūmiyādayo viya pavattitavisayāti vuttaṃ – ‘‘te attano attano paṭisambhidāvisaye ṭhatvā kathayiṃsū’’ti. Buddhavisaye pañhaṃ pucchīti – “凡夫五问”者,指以凡夫之问为首,以漏尽者之问为终的五种问题。最初……乃至……他问了关于凡夫境界的问题。无碍解的境界是依各自的愿求而生起,犹如依各自的观(vipassanā)之愿求而有初地等境界,故说:“他们各自安住于自己的无碍解境界而讲述”。他问了关于佛陀境界的问题—— ‘‘Ye ca saṅkhātadhammāse, ye ca sekhā puthū idha; Tesaṃ me nipako iriyaṃ, puṭṭho pabrūhi mārisā’’ti. (su. ni. 1044) – “已达究竟诸贤者,及此众多有学人;彼等行仪我今问,智者受问请宣说。” Idaṃ pañhaṃ pucchi. Tattha saṅkhātadhammāti saṅkhātā ñātā catusaccadhammā, ye ca saṅkhātadhammā catūhi maggehi paṭividdhacatusaccadhammāti attho. Iminā asekkhā kathitā. Puthu-saddo ubhayatthapi yojetabbo ‘‘ye puthū saṅkhātadhammā, ye ca puthū sekhā’’ti. Tesanti tesaṃ dvinnaṃ sekkhāsekkhapuggalānaṃ me puṭṭhoti yojetabbaṃ, mayā puṭṭhoti attho. Iriyanti sekkhāsekkhabhūmiyā āgamanappaṭipadaṃ. Iriyati gacchati sekkhabhūmiṃ asekkhabhūmiñca etāyāti iriyā, taṃ tesaṃ iriyaṃ āgamanappaṭipadaṃ mayā puṭṭho pabrūhi kathehīti attho. Evaṃ bhagavā buddhavisaye pañhaṃ pucchitvā ‘‘imassa nu kho, sāriputta, saṃkhittena bhāsitassa kathaṃ vitthārena attho daṭṭhabbo’’ti āha. Thero pañhaṃ oloketvā ‘‘satthā maṃ sekkhāsekkhānaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ āgamanappaṭipadaṃ pucchatī’’ti pañhe nikkaṅkho hutvā ‘‘āgamanappaṭipadā nāma khandhādivasena bahūhipi mukhehi sakkā kathetuṃ, katarākārena nu kho kathento satthu ajjhāsayaṃ gaṇhituṃ sakkhissāmī’’ti ajjhāsaye kaṅkhi, taṃ sandhāyetaṃ vuttaṃ – ‘‘dhammasenāpati…pe… na sakkotī’’ti. Pucchitapañhaṃ vissajjetuṃ paṭibhāne asati disāvilokanaṃ sattānaṃ sabhāvoti dassento, ‘‘puratthima…pe... nāsakkhī’’ti āha. Tattha pañhuppattiṭṭhānanti pañhuppattikāraṇaṃ. 此为所问之问题。其中,“已通达法”(saṅkhātadhammā)是指已了知的四圣谛法,以及由四道所证悟的四圣谛法,此为其义。此句说的是无学(asekkha)者。“众多”(puthu)一词应连接于两者,即“众多已通达法”与“众多有学(sekkhā)者”。“于彼等”(tesaṃ)应连接为“于彼等有学与无学二种人(sekkhāsekkhapuggala),我被问”,意即“我被问”。“行道”(iriya)是指趣向有学与无学之地的行道。凭借此道而行、而趣向有学地与无学地,故为“行道”。意即:“我被问及彼等之行道,即趣向之行道,请宣说、请告知。”如是,世尊(bhagavā)于佛陀境界中提问后,说道:“舍利弗(sāriputta),对此简略之说,应如何详见其义?”长老审视问题后,心无疑惑,想:“导师问我有学与无学比丘们趣向之行道。”又想:“趣向之行道,可以蕴等多种方式宣说,然以何种方式宣说,方能契合导师之意趣?”他对意趣有所疑惑,针对此而说:“法将……乃至……不能。”为显示当被问及问题而无辩才时,环顾四方是众生之本性,故说:“东方……乃至……不能。”其中,“问题生起之处”(pañhuppattiṭṭhānaṃ)即问题生起之因(pañhuppattikāraṇaṃ)。 Therassa [Pg.144] kilamanabhāvaṃ jānitvāti ‘‘sāriputto pañhe nikkaṅkho, ajjhāsaye me kaṅkhamāno kilamatī’’ti therassa kilamanabhāvaṃ ñatvā. Catumahābhūtikakāyapariggahanti etena khandhamukhena nāmarūpapariggaho vutto. ‘‘Bhūtamidanti, sāriputta, samanupassasī’’ti hi vadantena bhagavatā khandhavasena nāmarūpapariggaho dassito. Evaṃ kirassa bhagavato ahosi ‘‘sāriputto mayā naye adinne kathetuṃ na sakkhissati, dinne pana naye mamajjhāsayaṃ gahetvā khandhavasena kathessatī’’ti. Therassa saha nayadānena so pañho nayasatena nayasahassena upaṭṭhāsi. Tenāha – ‘‘aññātaṃ bhagavā, aññātaṃ sugatā’’ti. “知长老疲惫”者,谓知长老“舍利弗于问题无惑,然于我之意趣有惑而疲惫”之疲惫状态。“把握四大所成之身”者,此谓以蕴为门而把握名色。世尊言:“舍利弗,汝观此大种否?”实即以蕴的方式开示了名色之把握。原来世尊曾如是思惟:“若我不授予方法,舍利弗将不能说;然若授予方法,彼将领会我之意趣,而以蕴的方式解说。”长老一经授予方法,彼问题即以百种、千种方法显现于心。是故彼言:“已了知,世尊!已了知,善逝!” Arūpāvacare paṭisandhi nāma na hotīti bodhisambhārasambharaṇassa anokāsabhāvato vuttaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘abhabbaṭṭhānattā’’ti, laddhabyākaraṇānaṃ bodhisattānaṃ uppattiyā abhabbadesattāti attho. Rūpāvacare nibbattīti kammavasitāsambhavato arūpāvacare anibbattitvā rūpāvacare nibbatti. 所谓“于无色界(arūpāvacara)中无结生(paṭisandhi)”者,乃因其非积集菩提资粮之处。是故说:“因其为不适宜处”,意即对已得授记之菩萨而言,是其不适宜出生之处。所谓“生于色界(rūpāvacara)”者,乃因业自在力之故,不生于无色界而生于色界。 Parosahassantiādinā parosahassajātakaṃ dasseti. Tattha parosahassampīti atirekasahassampi. Samāgatānanti sannipatitānaṃ bhāsitassa atthaṃ jānituṃ asakkontānaṃ bālānaṃ. Kandeyyuṃ te vassasataṃ apaññāti te evaṃ samāgatā apaññā ime bālattā sasā viya vassasatampi vassasahassampi rodeyyuṃ parideveyyuṃ. Rodamānāpi pana atthaṃ vā kāraṇaṃ vā neva jāneyyunti dīpeti. Ekova seyyo puriso sapaññoti evarūpānaṃ bālānaṃ parosahassatopi eko paṇḍitapurisova seyyo varataroti attho. Kīdiso sapaññoti āha – ‘‘yo bhāsitassa vijānāti attha’’nti, ayaṃ jeṭṭhantevāsiko viya yo bhāsitassa atthaṃ jānāti, so tādiso sapañño varataroti attho. Dutiye parosatajātake jhāyeyyunti yāthāvato atthaṃ jānituṃ samāhitā hutvā cinteyyuṃ. Sesamettha vuttanayameva. 以“千余”等句,显示《千余本生》。其中,“亦千余”(parosahassampi)者,谓亦超过一千。“聚集者”(samāgatānaṃ)者,谓聚集一处而不能了知所说之义的愚人。“彼无慧者,哭泣百年”者,谓此等如是聚集之无慧者,因其愚痴,如兔(sasā)般哭泣百年乃至千年,悲泣哀号。此句阐明,彼等纵然哭泣,亦终不能了知其义或其理。“独一智者更为胜”者,意谓比起千余如是之愚人,独一贤智之人更为殊胜、更优。问何为智者?答曰:“能了知所说之义者”,意谓如上座弟子般能了知所说之义,如是智者更为殊胜。于第二《百余本生》中,“应禅思”(jhāyeyyuṃ)者,谓应专注而思惟,以如实了知其义。其余部分,如前所述。 Tatiyajātake ye saññinoti ṭhapetvā nevasaññānāsaññāyatanalābhino avasesacittakasatte dasseti. Tepi duggatāti tassā nevasaññānāsaññāyatanasamāpattiyā alābhato tepi duggatā dukkhaṃ upagatā saññībhave. ‘‘Saññā rogo saññā gaṇḍo saññā salla’’nti [Pg.145] (ma. ni. 3.24) hi te saññāya ādīnavadassino. Yepi asaññinoti asaññībhave nibbatte acittakasatte dasseti. Tepi imissāyeva samāpattiyā alābhato duggatāyeva. Jhānasukhaṃ anaṅgaṇaṃ niddosaṃ yathāvuttadosābhāvato. Balavacittekaggatāsabhāvenapi taṃ anaṅgaṇaṃ nāma jātaṃ. Nevasaññī nāsaññīti āhāti atīte kira bārāṇasiyaṃ brahmadatte rajjaṃ kārente bodhisatto araññāyatane kālaṃ karonto antevāsikehi puṭṭho ‘‘nevasaññī nāsaññī’’ti āha. Purimajātake vuttanayeneva tāpasā jeṭṭhantevāsikassa kathaṃ na gaṇhiṃsu. Bodhisatto ābhassarato āgantvā ākāse ṭhatvā imaṃ gāthamāha. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘sesaṃ vuttanayeneva veditabba’’nti. 于第三本生中,“有想者”(ye saññino)者,乃指除去非想非非想处成就者外,其余有心之有情。“彼等亦堕恶趣”(tepi duggatā)者,谓因未得彼非想非非想处等至,彼等于有想有情之生存状态中亦堕恶趣、遭遇痛苦。彼等实为见想之过患者,如言:“想为病,想为痈,想为箭。”“亦无想者”(yepi asaññino)者,乃指生于无想有情之生存状态中的无心有情。彼等亦因未得此等至而堕于恶趣。禅定之乐为“无垢”(anaṅgaṇaṃ),即无过失,因无如前所述之过患。亦因其强力心一境性之自性,而名为“无垢”。所谓“说非想非非想”者:据说,往昔于波罗奈(Bārāṇasī)城,梵授(Brahmadatta)王治世时,菩萨于林中住处命终,为弟子所问,答曰:“非想非非想。”如前本生所述,苦行者们不取上座弟子之言。菩萨从光音天(ābhassara)而来,立于空中,说此偈颂。是故言:“其余应如前述而知。” Catutthajātake (jā. 1.1.135) candassa viya ābhā etassāti candābhaṃ, odātakasiṇaṃ. Sūriyābhanti sūriyassa viya ābhā etassāti sūriyābhaṃ, pītakasiṇaṃ. Yodha paññāya gādhatīti yo puggalo idha sattaloke idaṃ kasiṇadvayaṃ paññāya gādhati, ārammaṇaṃ katvā anuppavisati, tattha vā patiṭṭhahati. Avitakkena dutiyajjhānena ābhassarūpago hotīti so puggalo tathā katvā paṭiladdhena dutiyena jhānena ābhassarabrahmalokūpago hoti. Sesaṃ purimanayeneva veditabbanti iminā imaṃ dasseti (jā. aṭṭha. 1.1.135 candābhajātakavaṇṇanā) – atīte bārāṇasiyaṃ brahmadatte rajjaṃ kārente bodhisatto araññāyatane kālaṃ karonto antevāsikehi pucchito ‘‘candābhaṃ sūriyābha’’nti vatvā ābhassare nibbatto. Tāpasā jeṭṭhantevāsikassa na saddahiṃsu. Bodhisatto āgantvā ākāse ṭhito imaṃ gāthaṃ abhāsi. 于第四本生中,“其光如月”,故为“月光”(candābha),此指白遍(odātakasiṇa)。“其光如日”,故为“日光”(sūriyābha),此指黄遍(pītakasiṇa)。“于此以慧而深入”者,谓若有人(puggala)于此有情世间,以智慧深入此二遍,以此为所缘而进入,或安住于其中。“以无寻之第二禅,得生光音天”者,谓彼人如是行已,以所证得之第二禅,得生于光音梵天界。“其余应如前法而知”者,以此显示:往昔于波罗奈城(Bārāṇasī),梵授(Brahmadatta)王治世时,菩萨于林中住处命终,为弟子所问,答曰“月光、日光”,后生于光音天。苦行者们不信上座弟子之言。菩萨前来,立于空中,说此偈颂。 Pañcamajātake āsīsethevāti āsācchedaṃ akatvā attano kammesu āsaṃ kareyyeva. Na nibbindeyyāti na nibbedaṃ uppādeyya, na ukkaṇṭheyyāti attho. Voti nipātamattaṃ. Yathā icchinti ahañhi saṭṭhihatthā narakā uṭṭhānaṃ icchiṃ, somhi tatheva jāto, tato uṭṭhitoyevāti dīpeti. 于第五本生中,“应存希望”(āsīsetheva)者,谓不应断绝希望,当于自身之业存有希望。“不应厌离”(na nibbindeyya)者,意谓不应生起厌离,不应厌倦。“vo”仅为不变词。“如我所愿”(yathā icchiṃ)者,此句阐明:我实曾愿从六十肘深之地狱中出离,我即如是而生,并已从彼处出离。 Atīte (jā. aṭṭha. 4.13.sarabhamigajātakavaṇṇanā) kira bārāṇasiyaṃ brahmadatte rajjaṃ kārente bodhisatto sarabhamigayoniyaṃ nibbattitvā araññe paṭivasati. Rājā migavittako ahosi [Pg.146] thāmasampanno. Ekadivasaṃ gantvā amacce āha – ‘‘yassa passena migo palāyati, teneva so dātabbo’’ti. Athekadivasaṃ sarabhamigo uṭṭhāya rañño ṭhitaṭṭhānena palāyi. Atha naṃ amaccā uppaṇḍesuṃ. Rājā cintesi – ‘‘ime maṃ parihāsanti, mama pamāṇaṃ na jānantī’’ti gāḷhaṃ nivāsetvā pattikova khaggaṃ ādāya ‘‘sarabhaṃ gaṇhissāmī’’ti vegena pakkhandi. Atha naṃ disvā tīṇi yojanāni anubandhi. Sarabho araññaṃ pāvisi. Rājāpi pāvisiyeva. Tattha sarabhamigassa gamanamagge saṭṭhihatthamatto mahāpūtipātanarakaāvāṭo atthi, so tiṃsahatthamattaṃ udakena puṇṇo tiṇehi ca paṭicchanno. Sarabho udakagandhaṃ ghāyitvāva āvāṭabhāvaṃ ñatvā thokaṃ osakkitvā gato. Rājā pana ujukameva āgacchanto tasmiṃ pati. 往昔(《本生经注》4.13萨拉布鹿本生释义),于波罗奈(Bārāṇasī)城,梵授王(Brahmadatta)治国时,菩萨投生为萨拉布鹿(sarabhamiga),栖于林中。国王喜爱狩猎,孔武有力。一日,他去对大臣们说:“鹿从谁身边逃走,便由谁负责。”后于某日,萨拉布鹿起身从国王所立之处逃走。于是大臣们嘲笑他。国王心想:“此辈嘲笑于我,不知我之能耐。”便紧束衣衫,徒步持剑,心道“我必擒此萨拉布鹿”,疾速追去。国王追了它三由旬。萨拉布鹿进入森林,国王亦随之进入。于彼处,萨拉布鹿行经之路上,有一六十肘深之大腐烂地狱坑,其中三十肘深积水,为草所覆。萨拉布鹿嗅得水气,便知是坑,稍稍退后绕行而去。国王却径直前来,堕入其中。 Sarabho tassa padasaddaṃ asuṇanto nivattitvā taṃ apassanto ‘‘narakaāvāṭe patito bhavissatī’’ti ñatvā āgantvā olokento taṃ gambhīre udake appatiṭṭhe kilamantaṃ disvā tena katāparādhaṃ hadaye akatvā sañjātakāruñño ‘‘mā mayi passante varāko nassatu, imamhā taṃ dukkhā mocessāmī’’ti āvāṭatīre ṭhito ‘‘mā bhāyi, mahārāja, ahaṃ taṃ dukkhā mocessāmī’’ti vatvā attano piyaputtaṃ uddharituṃ ussāhaṃ karonto viya tassuddharaṇatthāya silāya yoggaṃ katvā ‘‘vijjhissāmī’’ti āgataṃ rājānaṃ saṭṭhihatthā narakā uddharitvā assāsetvā piṭṭhiṃ āropetvā araññā nīharitvā senāya avidūre otāretvā ovādamassa datvā pañcasu sīlesu patiṭṭhāpesi. Rājā senaṅgaparivuto nagaraṃ gantvā ‘‘ito paṭṭhāya sakalaraṭṭhavāsino pañca sīlāni rakkhantū’’ti dhammabheriṃ carāpesi. Mahāsattena pana attano kataguṇaṃ kassaci akathetvā sāyaṃ nānaggarasabhojanaṃ bhuñjitvā alaṅkatasayane sayitvā paccūsakāle mahāsattassa guṇaṃ saritvā uṭṭhāya sayanapiṭṭhe pallaṅkena nisīditvā pītipuṇṇena hadayena udānaṃ udānento ‘‘āsīsetheva puriso’’tiādinā imā cha gāthā abhāsi. 萨拉布鹿听不到他的脚步声,便转身回顾,不见其人,心知:“他必定堕入地狱坑了。”于是回来察看,见他在深水中无处立足,疲惫挣扎。它不把国王之前所犯的过错放在心上,生起悲悯之心:“莫让此可怜人在我眼前丧命,我当救他脱离此苦。”便立于坑边说道:“大王莫惧,我将救你脱离此苦。”说罢,犹如奋力救拔自己的爱子一般,为救出国王,它以石为踏脚,将那前来意欲射杀自己的国王从六十肘深的地狱坑中救拔出来,加以安慰,然后将他负于背上,带出森林,在离军队不远处放下,对他说了教诫,令他安住于五戒。国王率军返回都城,下令:“自今而后,全国人民皆应守护五戒。”并敲响法鼓宣告。国王夜间享用种种上味佳肴,卧于华丽卧榻之上。黎明时分,他忆念起大士之功德,从卧榻上起身,结跏趺坐,满心喜悦,自说感兴偈,诵出“智者应求愿”等此六首偈颂。 Tattha ahitā hitā cāti dukkhaphassā sukhaphassā ca, maraṇaphassā, jīvitaphassātipi attho. Sattānañhi maraṇaphasso ahito, jīvitaphasso hito. Tesaṃ acintito maraṇaphasso āgacchatīti dasseti[Pg.147]. Acintitampīti mayā ‘‘āvāṭe patissāmī’’ti na cintitaṃ, ‘‘sarabhaṃ māressāmī’’ti cintitaṃ. Idāni pana me cintitaṃ naṭṭhaṃ, acintitameva jātanti udānavasena vadati. Bhogāti yasaparivārā, ete cintāmayā na honti. Tasmā ñāṇavatā vīriyameva kātabbanti vadati. Vīriyavato hi acintitampi hotiyeva. 此中,“非益与益”即是苦触与乐触,亦有死触与生触之义。于诸有情,死触为非益,生触为益。此显示,非所思虑之死触亦会到来。“亦有非所思虑者”是说,我未曾思虑“我会堕入坑中”,而思虑“我要杀死萨拉布鹿”。如今我所思虑者已失,非所思虑者却已发生,故以感兴语说之。“资财”指名望与随从,此等非由思虑而成。故说有智者当行精进。于精进者,非所思虑之事亦能成办。 Tassetaṃ udānaṃ udānentasseva aruṇaṃ uṭṭhahi. Purohito pātova sukhaseyyapucchanatthaṃ āgantvā dvāre ṭhito tassa udānagītasaddaṃ sutvā cintesi – ‘‘rājā hiyyo migavaṃ agamāsi, tattha sarabhamigaṃ viddho bhavissati, tena maññe udānaṃ udānetī’’ti. Evaṃ brāhmaṇassa rañño paripuṇṇabyañjanaṃ udānaṃ sutvā sumajjite ādāse mukhaṃ olokentassa chāyā viya raññā ca sarabhena ca katakāraṇaṃ pākaṭaṃ ahosi, so nakhaggena dvāraṃ ākoṭesi. Rājā ‘‘ko eso’’ti pucchi. Ahaṃ, deva, purohitoti. Athassa dvāraṃ vivaritvā ‘‘ito ehācariyā’’ti āha. So pavisitvā rājānaṃ jayāpetvā ekamantaṃ ṭhito ‘‘ahaṃ, mahārāja, tayā araññe katakāraṇaṃ jānāmi, tvaṃ ekaṃ sarabhamigaṃ anubandhanto narake patito, atha naṃ so sarabho silāya yoggaṃ katvā narakato uddhari, so tvaṃ tassa guṇaṃ saritvā udānaṃ udānesī’’ti vatvā ‘‘sarabhaṃ giriduggasmi’’ntiādinā dve gāthā abhāsi. 他正自说此感兴偈时,黎明已至。国师(purohita)一大早前来问安,立于门外,听闻他感兴偈之声,心想:“国王昨日前往狩猎,想必是在那里射中了萨拉布鹿,我猜他是因此而自说感兴偈。”婆罗门听闻国王文辞具足的感兴偈,犹如在擦拭明亮的镜中看见自己的影像,国王与萨拉布鹿之间所发生之事便清晰地显现出来。他遂以指甲叩门。国王问:“是谁?”“天王,是国师。”国王为他开门,说道:“老师,请进。”他进入后,向国王致意,立于一旁说道:“大王,我已知晓你在林中所为之事。你追逐一只萨拉布鹿时堕入地狱坑,后为彼萨拉布鹿以石为踏脚,从地狱坑中救出。你忆念其恩德,故自说感兴偈。”说罢,便诵出以“萨拉布鹿于山 दुर्ग”开头的两首偈颂。 Tattha anusarīti anubandhi. Vikkantanti uddharaṇatthāya kataparakkamaṃ. Anujīvasīti upajīvasi, tassānubhāvena tayā jīvitaṃ laddhanti attho. Samuddharīti uddharaṇaṃ akāsi. Silāya yoggaṃ sarabho karitvāti silāya sopānasadisāya narakato uddharaṇayoggataṃ karitvā. Alīnacittanti saṅkocaṃ appattacittaṃ. Ta migaṃ vadesīti suvaṇṇasarabhamigaṃ idha sirisayane nipanno vaṇṇesi. Taṃ sutvā rājā, ‘‘ayaṃ mayā saddhiṃ na migavaṃ āgato, sabbañca pavattiṃ jānāti, kathaṃ nu kho jānāti, pucchissāmi na’’nti cintetvā – ‘‘kiṃ tvaṃ nu tatthevā’’ti navamagāthamāha. Tattha bhiṃsarūpanti kiṃ nu te ñāṇaṃ balavajātikaṃ, tenetaṃ jānāsīti vadati. Brāhmaṇo ‘‘nāhaṃ sabbaññubuddho, byañjanaṃ amakkhetvā tayā kathitagāthāya pana mayhaṃ attho upaṭṭhātī’’ti dīpento ‘‘na cevaha’’nti dasamagāthamāha[Pg.148]. Tattha subhāsitānanti byañjanaṃ amakkhetvā suṭṭhu bhāsitānaṃ. Atthaṃ tadānentīti yo tesaṃ attho, taṃ ānenti upadhārentīti attho. Tadā purohito dhammasenāpati ahosi. Tenevāha – ‘‘atītepī’’tiādi. Sesaṃ uttānatthameva. 此中,“追随”(anusarī)即是“跟随”(anubandhi)。“勇猛”(vikkantaṃ)即是为救拔而作出的努力。“你赖以活命”(anujīvasi)即是“你依靠”,义为:你因他的威力而获得生命。“救拔”(samuddhari)即是作了救拔。“萨拉布鹿以石为踏脚”(silāya yoggaṃ sarabho karitvā)即是以石作成如阶梯般,使之能从地狱坑中救拔。“心不退怯”(alīnacittaṃ)即是心未达到退缩。“你称赞那鹿”(taṃ migaṃ vadesi)即是(你)卧于此吉祥卧榻上,称赞那金萨拉布鹿(suvaṇṇasarabhamiga)。国王听后心想:“此人未曾与我同去狩猎,却知晓全部经过。他究竟是如何知晓的?我当问他。”于是说了第九首偈颂:“你难道在彼处?”此中,“可畏之形”(bhiṃsarūpaṃ)是说:“你的智慧难道是强力一类,因此而知晓此事?”婆罗门为阐明“我非一切知佛,然于你所说偈颂,不涂饰其文句,义理自现于我”,而说了第十首偈颂:“我实非……”。此中,“于善说者”(subhāsitānaṃ)即是不涂饰文句而善说者。“能引其义”(atthaṃ tadānenti)义为:彼等之义,能引生、能审度。当时,国师即是法将(舍利弗)。因此说:“于过去世亦……”等。余者义自明显。 Aññāsikoṇḍaññattheravatthu 阿若憍陈如长老事 Aññāsikoṇḍaññattherādayotiādīsu pana yāthāvasarasaguṇavasenāti yathāsabhāvaguṇavasena. Pabbajjāvasena paṭivedhavasena suciraṃ sunipuṇaṃ rattindivaparicchedajānanavasena ca rattaññutā veditabbāti taṃ dassento ‘‘ṭhapetvā hi sammāsambuddha’’ntiādimāha. Pākaṭova hotīti satipaññāvepullappattiko pākaṭo vibhūto hoti. Aññāsikoṇḍaññoti sāvakesu sabbapaṭhamaṃ cattāri ariyasaccāni ñātakoṇḍañño. Sabbesupi etadaggesūti sabbesupi etadaggasuttesu, sabbesu vā etadaggaṭṭhapanesu. 于“阿若憍陈如长老等”等句中,“依各自机缘与功德”即是“依各自的自性功德”。应知“长上”(rattaññutā)是依出家、依证悟、以及依长久善巧了知昼夜划分而言。为显示此义,而说“除正自觉者”等语。“变得显现”是指,已达念与慧广大者,变得显现、卓越。“阿若憍陈如”(Aññāsikoṇḍañña)即是于声闻中,最初了知四圣谛的憍陈如。“于一切此等第一中”即是于一切《第一经》中,或于一切置为第一中。 Dhurapattānīti pattānaṃ pamukhabhūtāni bāhirapattāni. Navutihatthānīti majjhimapurisassa hatthena navutiratanāni. Padumeneva taṃ taṃ padesaṃ uttarati atikkamatīti padumuttaro, bhagavā. Gandhadāmamālādāmādīhīti ādisaddena pattadāmādiṃ saṅgaṇhāti. Tattha gandhadāmehi katamālā gandhadāmaṃ. Lavaṅgatakkolajātipupphādīhi katamālā mālādāmaṃ. Tamālapattādīhi katamālā pattadāmaṃ. Vaṅgapaṭṭeti vaṅgadese uppannaghanasukhumavatthe. Uttamasukhumavatthanti kāsikavatthamāha. “主叶”(dhurapatta)是指叶子中主要的外部叶子。“九十肘”(navutihattha)是指以中等身材之人的手量为九十肘。“如莲花般超越彼处彼处”,即超越、度过每一处地方,故世尊名为“莲花上佛”(Padumuttara)。“以香鬘、花鬘等”中的“等”字包括了叶鬘等。其中,以香料制成的花环为“香鬘”(gandhadāma);以丁香、豆蔻、茉莉花等制成的花环为“花鬘”(mālādāma);以答摩罗叶等制成的花环为“叶鬘”(pattadāma)。“孟加拉布”(Vaṅgapaṭṭa)指产于孟加拉(Vaṅga)地区的厚实精细布。“最上等精细布”是指迦尸布(kāsikavattha)。 Teparivaṭṭadhammacakkappavattanasuttantapariyosāneti ettha ‘‘idaṃ dukkhaṃ ariyasacca’’ntiādinā saccavasena, ‘‘dukkhaṃ ariyasaccaṃ pariññeyya’’ntiādinā kiccavasena, ‘‘dukkhaṃ ariyasaccaṃ pariññāta’’ntiādinā katavasena ca tīhi ākārehi parivaṭṭetvā catunnaṃ saccānaṃ desitattā tayo parivaṭṭā etassa atthīti tiparivaṭṭaṃ, tiparivaṭṭameva teparivaṭṭaṃ, teparivaṭṭañca taṃ dhammacakkappavattanañcāti teparivaṭṭadhammacakkappavattanaṃ, tadeva suttantaṃ, tassa pariyosāneti attho. “于《三转法轮经》结尾处”之义。此处,以“此是苦圣谛”等为“谛转”,以“苦圣谛应遍知”等为“劝转”,以“苦圣谛已遍知”等为“证转”,如是以三行相转四圣谛,故有三转。此有三转,故名“三转”(tiparivaṭṭaṃ)。“三转”(tiparivaṭṭaṃ)即是“三转”(teparivaṭṭaṃ)。此三转之转法轮,即是《三转法轮经》,此即其经,于其结尾处之义。 Sāligabbhaṃ phāletvā ādāyāti sāligabbhaṃ phāletvā tattha labbhamānaṃ sālikhīrarasaṃ ādāya. Anucchavikanti buddhānaṃ anucchavikaṃ khīrapāyasaṃ pacāpema. Veṇiyo purisabhāvavasena bandhitvā kalāpakaraṇe [Pg.149] kalāpaggaṃ. Khale kalāpānaṃ ṭhapanadivase khalaggaṃ. Madditvā vīhīnaṃ rāsikaraṇadivase khalabhaṇḍaggaṃ. Koṭṭhesu hi dhaññassa pakkhipanadivase koṭṭhaggaṃ. “破开稻谷后取得”是指破开稻谷后,取得其中可得的稻乳汁(sālikhīrarasa)。“适合的”是指我们烹煮适合诸佛的乳粥(khīrapāyasa)。在捆扎稻束时,(供养)新束,为“束首” (kalāpagga)。在打谷场堆放稻束之日,(供养)新场,为“场首”(khalagga)。在碾压稻谷堆积成堆之日,(供养)新谷,为“堆首”(khalabhaṇḍagga)。在将谷物放入谷仓之日,(供养)新仓,为“仓首”(koṭṭhagga)。 Dve gatiyoti dve eva nipphattiyo, dve niṭṭhāti attho. Tasmiṃ kumāre sabbaññutaṃ patteti koṇḍaññamāṇavasseva laddhiyaṃ ṭhatvā itarepi cha janā putte anusāsiṃsu. Bodhirukkhamūle pācīnapassaṃ acalaṭṭhānaṃ nāma, yaṃ ‘‘vajirāsana’’ntipi vuccati. Mahataṃ mahatiyo vahatīti ‘‘pācīnamukho’’ti avatvā ‘‘pācīnalokadhātuabhimukho’’ti vuttaṃ. Maṃsacakkhupi lokanāthassa appaṭighātaṃ mahāvisayañcāti. Caturaṅgasamannāgatanti ‘‘kāmaṃ taco ca nhāru ca, aṭṭhi ca avasissatū’’tiādinā (ma. ni. 2.184; saṃ. ni. 2.22, 237; a. ni. 2.5; mahāni. 196) vuttacaturaṅgasamannāgataṃ. “两种趣向”即两种成就,两种终结之义。其余六人亦立于青年婆罗门憍陈如(Koṇḍañña)之预言,教导其子:“当那位王子证得一切智时……”。菩提树下东面之地,名为不动处,亦称“金刚座”(vajirāsana)。不说“面向东方”,而说“面向东方世界”,是因为能为伟大有情带来伟大利益。世尊的肉眼亦无障碍且所见广大。“具足四支”是指具足如(经中)所说:“但任其皮、筋、骨存留,身中血肉枯干”(中部2.184;相应部2.22, 237;增支部2.5;大义释196)等之四支精进。 Idaṃ pana sabbamevāti ‘‘kassa nu kho ahaṃ paṭhamaṃ dhammaṃ desessāmī’’tiādinayappavattaṃ (ma. ni. 1.284; 2.341; mahāva. 10) sabbameva. Parivitakkamattameva tathā atthasiddhiyā abhāvato. Pupphitaphalitaṃ katvāti abhiññāpaṭisambhidāhi sabbapāliphullaṃ, maggaphalehi sabbaso phalabhārabharitañca karonto pupphitaṃ phalitaṃ katvā. Apakkamitukāmo hutvāti dvepi aggasāvake attano nipaccakāraṃ karonte disvā tesaṃ guṇātirekataṃ bahu maññanto buddhānaṃ santikā apakkamitukāmo hutvā. Tatthevāti chaddantadahatīreyeva. “而这一切”是指如“我应先为谁说法?”(中部1.284; 2.341; 大品10)等所述的一切。这仅是思惟而已,因为无法如此达成目的。“使其开花结果”是指,以神通与无碍解令一切教法圆满开花,以道与果令其完全硕果累累,而使其开花结果。“欲离去”是指,见到两位上首弟子对自己恭敬行事,深知其功德超胜,而欲从诸佛处离去。“就在那里”是指就在六牙池(Chaddantadaha)边。 Sāriputta-moggallānattheravatthu 舍利弗与目犍连长老的故事 189-190. Dutiyatatiyesu iddhimantānanti ettha manta-saddo atisayatthavisayoti therassa atisayikaiddhitaṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘iddhiyā sampannāna’’nti vuttaṃ. Saha paṃsūhi kīḷiṃsūti sahapaṃsukīḷitā. Idhalokattabhāvamevāti diṭṭhadhammikaattabhāvameva. Soḷasa paññā paṭivijjhitvā ṭhitoti majjhimanikāye anupadasuttantadesanāya ‘‘mahāpañño, bhikkhave, sāriputto, puthupañño, bhikkhave, sāriputto, hāsapañño, bhikkhave, sāriputto, javanapañño, bhikkhave, sāriputto, tikkhapañño, bhikkhave, sāriputto, nibbedhikapañño, bhikkhave, sāriputto’’ti (ma. ni. 3.93) evamāgatā [Pg.150] mahāpaññādikā cha, tasmiṃyeva sutte āgatā navānupubbavihārasamāpattipaññā, arahattamaggapaññāti imā soḷasavidhā paññā paṭivijjhitvā sacchikatvā ṭhito. 189-190. 在第二和第三个“有神通者”(iddhimantānaṃ)中,“mant”一词用于表达超胜之义,为显示长老超胜的神通力,故说“具足神通”(iddhiyā sampannānaṃ)。“与尘土一同嬉戏”是指一起玩沙的同伴(sahapaṃsukīḷitā)。“此世之身”即是现世之身(diṭṭhadhammikaattabhāva)。“已通达十六种慧而住”是指,如《中部·随经》中所说:“诸比丘,舍利弗是大慧者、广慧者、速慧者、捷慧者、利慧者、决择慧者。”(中部3.93)如此而来的大慧等六种,以及同一经中提到的九次第住定慧,与阿罗汉道慧,他已通达、作证这十六种慧而住。 Pañhasākacchanti pañhassa pucchanavasena vissajjanavasena ca sākacchaṃ karoti. Atthikehi upaññātaṃ magganti etaṃ anubandhanassa kāraṇavacanaṃ. Idañhi vuttaṃ hoti – yaṃnūnāhaṃ imaṃ bhikkhuṃ piṭṭhito piṭṭhito anubandheyyaṃ. Kasmā? Yasmā idaṃ piṭṭhito piṭṭhito anubandhanaṃ nāma atthikehi upaññātaṃ maggaṃ, ñāto ceva upagato ca maggoti attho. Atha vā atthikehi amhehi maraṇe sati amatenapi bhavitabbanti evaṃ kevalaṃ atthīti upaññātaṃ, anumānañāṇena upagantvā ñātaṃ nibbānaṃ nāma atthi, taṃ magganto pariyesantoti evampettha attho daṭṭhabbo. “问答”是指通过提问与回答的方式进行讨论。“有益者所知的道路”是作为(紧随其后)之理由的表述。此义是说:“我何不紧随此比丘之后?”为何?因为这紧随其后,即是所谓“有益者所知的道路”,意为已被了知且已走近的道路。或者,应作如是解:我等有益者,因有死,故必有不死,如是仅知其“有”,以推论智而得知确有涅槃,并寻觅、遍求之。 Nesaṃ parisāyāti dvinnaṃ aggasāvakānaṃ parivārabhūtaparisāya. Dve aggasāvaketi sāriputtamoggallāne dve mahānubhāve sāvake. Ṭhānantareti aggasāvakattasaññite ṭhānantare ṭhapesi. Kasmā panettha ‘‘aggasāvake’’ti avatvā ‘‘mahāsāvake’’ti vuttaṃ. Yadi aññepi mahātherā abhiññātādiguṇavisesayogena ‘‘mahāsāvakā’’ti vattabbataṃ labhanti, imeyeva pana sāvakesu anaññasādhāraṇabhūtā visesato ‘‘mahāsāvakā’’ti vattabbāti dassanatthaṃ ‘‘dvepi mahāsāvake’’ti vuttaṃ. “于彼等众中”是指于两位上首弟子的眷属众中。“两位上首弟子”是指舍利弗(Sāriputta)与目犍连(Moggallāna)两位大威德弟子。“于位阶中”是指将他们安立于名为“上首弟子”的位阶中。为何此处不说“上首弟子”,而说“大弟子”?纵然其他大长老亦因具足神通等特殊功德而可被称为“大弟子”,然此二位弟子于诸弟子中,具有不共于他人的殊胜,为显示此义,故说“两位大弟子”。 Mahākassapattheravatthu 大迦叶长老的故事 191. Catutthe yasmā dhutavādadhutadhammadhutaṅgāni dhutamūlakāni, tasmā ‘‘dhuto veditabbo’’ti āraddhaṃ, tattha kilese dhuni dhutavāti dhuto, dhutakileso puggalo, kilesadhunano vā dhammo, kilesadhunano dhammoti ca sapubbabhāgo ariyamaggo daṭṭhabbo. Taṃ dhutasaññitaṃ kilesadhunanadhammaṃ vadati, pare tattha patiṭṭhāpetīti dhutavādo. Catukkañcettha sambhavatīti taṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘ettha panā’’tiādi āraddhaṃ. Tayidanti nipāto, tassa so ayanti attho. Dhutabhūtassa dhutabhūtā dhammā dhutadhammā. Appicchatā santuṭṭhitā heṭṭhā vuttā eva[Pg.151]. Kilese sammā likhati tacchatīti sallekho, kilesajegucchī, tassa bhāvo sallekhatā. Dvīhipi kāmehi viviccatīti paviveko, yonisomanasikārabahulo puggalo, tassa bhāvo pavivekatā. Iminā sarīraṭṭhapanamattena atthīti idamaṭṭhi ttha-kārassa ṭṭha-kāraṃ katvā, tassa bhāvo idamaṭṭhitā, imehi vā kusaladhammehi atthi idamaṭṭhi, yena ñāṇena ‘‘pabbajitena nāma paṃsukūlikaṅgādīsu patiṭṭhitena bhavitabba’’nti yathānusiṭṭhaṃ dhutaguṇe samādiyati ceva pariharati ca, taṃ ñāṇaṃ idamaṭṭhitā. Tenāha – ‘‘idamaṭṭhitā ñāṇamevā’’ti. Dhutadhammā nāmāti dhutaṅgasevanāya paṭipakkhabhūtānaṃ pāpadhammānaṃ dhunanavasena pavattiyā dhutoti laddhanāmāya dhutaṅgacetanāya upakārakā dhammāti katvā dhutadhammā nāma. Anupatantīti tadantogadhā tappariyāpannā honti tadubhayasseva pavattivisesabhāvato. Paṭikkhepavatthūsūti dhutaṅgasevanāya paṭikkhipitabbavatthūsu pahātabbavatthūsu. 191. 第四,因为头陀说(dhutavāda)、头陀法(dhutadhamma)、头陀支(dhutaṅga)都以“头陀”为根本,故开示“应知头陀”。于此,抖落烦恼者为“头陀”(dhuto),即烦恼已抖落之人(puggala);或指抖落烦恼之法,而抖落烦恼之法,当知即是有前分(sapubbabhāga)的圣道。宣说那名为“头陀”的抖落烦恼之法,并使他人安住于此,故名“头陀说者”(dhutavādo)。为显示此处有四种可能,故开示“于此……”等。《Tayidaṃ》(tad idaṃ)是助词,意为“彼即此”。已成头陀者之法,即是头陀法。少欲、知足已如前述。善于削减、刨除烦恼,故为“削减”(sallekho),即厌恶烦恼者,其状态为“削减性”(sallekhatā)。远离两种欲,故为“远离”(paviveko),即多作如理作意之人,其状态为“远离性”(pavivekatā)。仅以此身安住而有,故为“此依”(idamaṭṭhi),由`ttha`音转为`ṭṭha`音,其状态为“此依性”(idamaṭṭhitā);或因有此等善法而有,故为“此依”。凭借此智,了知“出家者当安住于粪扫衣支等”,并如所教导受持、行持头陀功德,此智即是“此依性”。故言:“此依性即是智”。所谓“头陀法”,是因修习头陀支,以抖落其对治之恶法的方式而生起,故此等助益于名为“头陀”的头陀支思(dhutaṅgacetanā)之法,名为“头陀法”。“随行”(anupatanti),即是包含于其中、摄属于彼,因为两者皆是其行相的差别。“于应舍断之事中”(paṭikkhepavatthūsu),即于修习头陀支时应舍断、应弃舍之事中。 Paṃsukūlikaṅgaṃ…pe… nesajjikaṅganti uddesopi peyyālanayena dassito. Yadettha vattabbaṃ, taṃ sabbaṃ visuddhimagge (visuddhi. 1.22 ādayo) vitthārato vuttaṃ. Dhutavādaggahaṇeneva therassa dhutabhāvopi gahito hotīti ‘‘dhutavādāna’’nteva vuttaṃ. Ayaṃ mahāti abhinīhārādimahantatāyapi sāsanassa upakāritāyapi ayaṃ thero mahā, guṇamahantatāya pasaṃsāvacanameva vā etaṃ therassa yadidaṃ mahākassapoti yathā ‘‘mahāmoggallāno’’ti. 粪扫衣支(paṃsukūlikaṅgaṃ)……乃至……常坐不卧支(nesajjikaṅgaṃ),此列举亦以省略(peyyāla)的方式显示。此处应说之事,皆已在《清净道论》(Visuddhimagga 1.22ff.)中详述。仅以“头陀说者”(dhutavāda)一词,即已含摄长老的头陀状态,故仅言“诸头陀说者”。此为“大”(mahā),是因此长老因宿愿等而伟大,亦因其对教法的助益而伟大,或此“大迦叶”(Mahākassapa)之称,亦如“大目犍连”(Mahāmoggallāna)一般,是因其功德伟大而有的赞誉之辞。 Satthu dhammadesanāya vatthuttaye sañjātappasādatāya upāsakabhāve ṭhitattā vuttaṃ – ‘‘uposathaṅgāni adhiṭṭhāyā’’tiādi. Etassa aggabhāvassāti yojetabbaṃ. Saccakāroti saccabhāvāvaho kāro, avisaṃvādanavasena vā tadatthasādhanoti attho. Kolāhalanti kutūhalavipphāro. Satthā sattame sattame saṃvacchare dhammaṃ kathento sattānaṃ savanayoggaṃ kālaṃ sallakkhento divā sāyanhasamayaṃ katheti, rattiyaṃ sakalayāmaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘brāhmaṇo brāhmaṇe āha – ‘bhoti kiṃ rattiṃ dhammaṃ suṇissasi divā’’’ti. Vissāsikoti vissāsikabhāvo. ‘‘Tato paṭṭhāya so’’ti vā pāṭho. 因听闻导师说法而于三事(vatthuttaya)中生起净信,安住于优婆塞(upāsaka)位,故言“受持布萨支(uposathaṅga)……”等。应连接为“此最胜的状态”。“谛行”(saccakāra)是带来真实状态的行为,或意为以不欺的方式成就其义。“喧闹”(kolāhala)是好奇心的爆发。导师每隔七年说法一次,在观察到众生听法的适当时机后,于白日傍晚时分说法,夜晚则通宵说法。故言:“婆罗门对婆罗门女说:‘夫人(bhotī),您是想晚上听法,还是白天听法?’”“可信赖”(vissāsiko)指可信赖的状态。或有异读作“从那时起他”(Tato paṭṭhāya so)。 Dve [Pg.152] asaṅkhyeyyāni pūritapāramissāti idaṃ sā paramparāya sotapatitaṃ atthaṃ gahetvā āha. Adinnavipākassāti avipakkavipākassa. Bhaddake kāleti yutte kāle. Nakkhattanti nakkhattena lakkhitaṃ chaṇaṃ. Tasmiṃ tasmiñhi nakkhatte anubhavitabbachaṇāni nakkhattāni nāma, itarāni pana chaṇāni nāma. Sammāpatitadukkhato vimocanena tato niyyānāvahatāya icchitatthassa labhāpanato ca niyyānikaṃ. Tesanti suvaṇṇapadumānaṃ. Olambakāti suvaṇṇaratanavicittā ratanadāmā. Puññaniyāmenāti puññānubhāvasiddhena niyāmena. Svassa bārāṇasirajjaṃ dātuṃ katokāso. Phussarathanti maṅgalarathaṃ. Setacchattauṇhīsavālabījanikhaggamaṇipādukāni pañcavidhaṃ rājakakudhabhaṇḍanti vadanti. Idha pana setacchattaṃ visuṃ gahitanti sīhāsanaṃ pañcamaṃ katvā vadanti. Pārupanakaṇṇanti pārupanavatthassa dasantaṃ. Dibbavatthadāyipuññānubhāvacodito ‘‘nanu tātā thūla’’nti āha. Aho tapassīti aho kapaṇo ahaṃ rājāti attho. Buddhānaṃ saddahitvāti buddhānaṃ sāsanaṃ saddahitvā. Caṅkamanasatānīti iti-saddo ādyattho. Tena hi aggisālādīni pabbajitasāruppāni ṭhānāni saṅgaṇhāti. “圆满二阿僧祇(asaṅkhyeyya)波罗蜜”,此乃依循传统听闻而得之义。“未予果报”(adinnavipāka)即果报未熟。“于善时”(bhaddake kāle)即于适当时机。“星宿”(nakkhatta)即以星宿为标志的节日。于彼彼星宿日应经历的节日名为“星宿”,其余则名为“节日”。因能从业已降临的苦难中解脱,带来出离,并获得所求之义利,故称“出离导向”(niyyānika)。“彼等”(tesaṃ)指那些金莲花。“垂饰”(olambaka)指以黄金珠宝装饰的华丽宝鬘。“以福德之必然”(puññaniyāmena)即以福德威力成就之必然法则。他获得给予波罗奈(Bārāṇasī)王位的机会。“普沙马车”(phussaratha)即吉祥马车。白伞、头冠、拂尘、宝剑、宝履,此五者被称为五种王室徽宝(rājakakudhabhaṇḍa)。但于此,白伞被单独列出,而以狮子座为第五项。“衣角”(pārupanakaṇṇa)即覆身衣物之边缘。为布施天衣的福德威力所驱使,他说:“父亲,您难道很粗壮吗?”“啊,苦行者!”(aho tapassī)意为:“啊,我这国王真是可怜!”“信解诸佛”(buddhānaṃ saddahitvā)即信解诸佛的教法。“数百经行处等”(caṅkamanasatāni iti),此中“iti”一词为“等”之义。因此,它含摄了火堂(aggisālā)等适合出家人的场所。 Sādhukīḷitanti ariyānaṃ parinibbutaṭṭhāne kātabbasakkāraṃ vadati. Nappamajji, nirogā ayyāti pucchitākāradassanaṃ. Parinibbutā devāti devī paṭivacanaṃ adāsi. Paṭiyādetvāti niyyātetvā. Samaṇakapabbajjanti samitapāpehi ariyehi anuṭṭhātabbapabbajjaṃ. So hi rājā paccekabuddhānaṃ vesassa diṭṭhattā ‘‘idameva bhaddaka’’nti tādisaṃyeva liṅgaṃ gaṇhi. Tatthevāti brahmaloke eva. Vīsatime vasse sampatteti āharitvā sambandho. Brahmalokato cavitvā nibbattattā, brahmacariyādhikārassa ca cirakālasambhūtattā ‘‘evarūpaṃ kathaṃ mā kathethā’’ti āha. Vīsati dharaṇāni nikkhanti vadanti, pañcapalaṃ nikkhanti apare. Itthākaroti itthiratanassa uppattiṭṭhānaṃ. Ayyadhītāti amhākaṃ ayyassa dhītā, bhaddakāpilānīti attho. Samānapaṇṇanti sadisapaṇṇaṃ sadisalekhaṃ kumārassa kumārikāya ca yuttaṃ paṇṇalekhaṃ. Te purisā samāgataṭṭhānato magadharaṭṭhe mahātitthagāmaṃ maddaraṭṭhe sāgalanagarañca uddissa apakkamantā aññamaññaṃ vissajjantā nāma hontīti ‘‘ito ca etto ca pesesu’’nti vuttā. “善供养”(sādhukīḷita)指于圣者般涅槃处所应作的恭敬供养。“尊者无恙否?未放逸否?”此为显示问候之貌。王后回答道:“大王,他已般涅槃。”“准备好后”(paṭiyādetvā)即交付、托付之后。“沙门出家”(samaṇakapabbajjā)是由已平息诸恶的圣者所应行之出家。那位国王因曾见辟支佛的威仪,心想:“这才是善的”,便受持了那样的形相。“就在那里”(tattheva)即就在梵天界。应连接为“当他满二十岁时”。因其从梵天界死后转生于此,且其梵行之因缘已长久具足,故说:“为何不说这样的话?”有人说一“尼卡”(nikkha)为二十“陀罗那”(dharaṇa),另一些人说为五“巴拉”(pala)。“女宝矿”(itthākara)即女宝(itthiratana)的出生之处。“尊者之女”(ayyadhītā)意为“我们尊者之女”,即跋陀迦比罗尼(Bhaddakāpilānī)。“相似信函”(samānapaṇṇa)指王子与公主相配的、内容相似的信函。那些人从集会处出发,朝向摩揭陀国(Magadharaṭṭha)的大渡口村和末陀国(Maddaraṭṭha)的娑伽罗城(Sāgalanagara),他们互相派遣信使,故言“从这里和那里派遣了”。 Pupphadāmanti hatthihatthappamāṇaṃ pupphadāmaṃ. Tānīti tāni ubhohi ganthāpitāni dve pupphadāmāni. Teti ubho bhaddā ceva pippalikumāro ca[Pg.153]. Lokāmisenāti kāmassādena. Asaṃsaṭṭhāti na saṃyuttā ghaṭe jalantena viya padīpena ajjhāsaye samujjalantena vimokkhabījena samussāhitacittattā. Yantabaddhānīti sassasampādanatthaṃ tattha tattha dvārakavāṭayojanavasena baddhāni nikkhamanatumbāni. Kammantoti kasikammakaraṇaṭṭhānaṃ. Dāsikagāmāti dāsānaṃ vasanagāmā. Osāretvāti pakkhipitvā. Ākappakuttavasenāti ākāravasena kiriyāvasena. Ananucchavikanti pabbajitabhāvassa ananurūpaṃ. Tassa matthaketi dvedhāpathassa dvidhābhūtaṭṭhāne. Etesaṃ saṅgahaṃ kātuṃ vaṭṭatīti nisīdatīti sambandho. Sā pana tattha satthu nisajjā edisīti dassetuṃ – ‘‘nisīdanto panā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Tattha yā buddhānaṃ aparimitakālasambhūtācinteyyāpariññeyyapuññasambhārūpacayanibbattā rūpappabhāvabuddhaguṇavijjotitā dvattiṃsamahāpurisalakkhaṇaasītianubyañjanasamujjalitā byāmappabhāketumālālaṅkatā sabhāvasiddhitāya akittimā rūpakāyasirī, taṃyeva mahākassapassa adiṭṭhapubbappasādasaṃvaddhanatthaṃ aniggūhitvā nisinno bhagavā ‘‘buddhavesaṃ gahetvā…pe… nisīdī’’ti vutto. Asītihatthappadesaṃ byāpetvā pavattiyā asītihatthāti vuttā. Satasākhoti bahusākho anekasākho. Suvaṇṇavaṇṇova ahosi nirantaraṃ buddharasmīhi samantato samokiṇṇabhāvato. “花环”是指象鼻长的花环。“那些”是指他们俩所编结的两个花环。“他们”是指跋陀(Bhaddā)和毕波离童子(Pippalikumāro)。“世间欲味”是指感官享受之乐。“不混杂”是指不相应,因为心意为解脱之种所激励,其意乐犹如在罐中燃烧的灯火般明亮。“系缚的器具”是指为了生产谷物,在各处通过安装门扇的方式系缚的汲水器(nikkhamanatumbāni)。“工作场所”是指从事农耕的地方。“奴隶村”是指奴隶们居住的村庄。“放置”是指放入。“以威仪”是指以姿态、以行为。“不相称”是指与出家身份不相符。“在其顶上”是指在岔路分成两边之处。“适合汇集这些”,因此他坐下,这是(上下文的)关联。之所以说“而坐时”等,是为了说明当时世尊的坐姿是这样的:诸佛经无量时劫,积集不可思议、不可知量的福德资粮而成就,由身光、佛德所照耀,由三十二大士相(dvattiṃsamahāpurisalakkhaṇa)、八十随形好(asītianubyañjanasamujjalitā)所庄严,由寻光、顶髻光所装饰,自然成就、非造作的色身之光,为了增长大迦叶(Mahākassapa)前所未见的信心,世尊不加隐藏而坐,因此说“取佛威仪……乃至……而坐”。因遍布八十肘的范围而行,故说“八十肘”。“百枝”是指多枝、众多枝条。“如金色”是指因佛陀的光明无间断地遍满四周。 Tīsu ṭhānesūti dūrato nātidūre āsanneti tīsu ṭhānesu. Tīhi ovādehīti ‘‘tasmātiha te, kassapa, evaṃ sikkhitabbaṃ ‘tibbaṃ me hirottappaṃ paccupaṭṭhitaṃ bhavissati theresu navesu majjhimesū’ti. Evañhi te, kassapa, sikkhitabbaṃ. Tasmātiha te, kassapa, evaṃ sikkhitabbaṃ ‘yaṃ kiñci dhammaṃ suṇissāmi kusalūpasaṃhitaṃ, sabbaṃ taṃ aṭṭhiṃ katvā manasi karitvā sabbaṃ cetasā samannāharitvā ohitasoto dhammaṃ suṇissāmī’ti, evañhi te, kassapa, sikkhitabbaṃ. Tasmātiha te, kassapa, evaṃ sikkhitabbaṃ ‘sātasahagatā ca me kāyagatāsati na vijahissatī’ti, evañhi te, kassapa, sikkhitabba’’nti (saṃ. ni. 2.154) imehi tīhi ovādehi. Ettha hi bhagavā paṭhamaṃ ovādaṃ therassa brāhmaṇajātikattā jātimānappahānatthamabhāsi, dutiyaṃ bāhusaccaṃ nissāya uppajjanakaahaṃkārappahānatthaṃ, tatiyaṃ upadhisampattiṃ nissāya uppajjanakaattasinehappahānatthaṃ[Pg.154]. Mudukā kho tyāyanti mudukā kho te ayaṃ. Kasmā pana bhagavā evamāha? Therena saha cīvaraṃ parivattetukāmatāya. Kasmā parivattetukāmo jātoti? Theraṃ attano ṭhāne ṭhapetukāmatāya. Kiṃ sāriputtamoggallānā natthīti? Atthi, evaṃ panassa ahosi ‘‘imena ciraṃ ṭhassanti, kassapo pana vīsativassasatāyuko, so mayi parinibbute sattapaṇṇiguhāyaṃ vasitvā dhammavinayasaṅgahaṃ katvā mama sāsanaṃ pañcavassasahassaparimāṇakālappavattanakaṃ karissatīti attano ṭhāne ṭhapesi. Evaṃ bhikkhū kassapassa sussūsitabbaṃ maññissantī’’ti. Tasmā evamāha. “于三处”是指于远处、不远处、近处这三处。“以三教诫”是指:“是故,迦叶,你应如是学:‘于上座、新学、中等比丘,我当发起强烈的惭愧心。’迦叶,你应如是学。‘是故,迦叶,你应如是学:‘凡我所闻任何与善相应之法,皆当专注、作意、全心全意、倾耳谛听。’迦叶,你应如是学。‘是故,迦叶,你应如是学:‘与喜俱行之身至念将不离于我。’迦叶,你应如是学。”(《相应部》2.154)以此三教诫。于此,世尊为破除长老因出身婆罗门而有之种姓慢,说第一教诫;为破除其因多闻而生起之我慢,说第二教诫;为破除其因依止具足而生起之我爱,说第三教诫。“你的衣是柔软的”是指你的这件衣服确实柔软。世尊为何如此说?因为想和长老交换衣。为何想交换?因为想将长老置于自己的地位。舍利弗和目犍连不在吗?在。但(世尊)思忖:“他们不会长久住世,而迦叶有一百二十岁寿量,我般涅槃后,他将于七叶窟(Sattapaṇṇiguhā)居住,作法与律的结集,使我的教法流传五千年之久。”因此将长老置于自己的地位。这样,比丘们就会认为应当听从迦叶。因此如此说。 Candūpamoti candasadiso hutvā. Kiṃ parimaṇḍalatāya? No, apica kho yathā cando gaganatalaṃ pakkhandamāno na kenaci saddhiṃ santhavaṃ vā sinehaṃ vā ālayaṃ vā karoti, na ca na hoti mahājanassa piyo manāpo, ayampi evaṃ kenaci saddhiṃ santhavādīnaṃ akaraṇena bahujanassa piyo manāpo candūpamo hutvā khattiyakulādīni cattāri kulāni upasaṅkamatīti attho. Apakasseva kāyaṃ apakassa cittanti teneva santhavādīnaṃ akaraṇena kāyañca cittañca apakaḍḍhitvā, apanetvāti attho. Niccaṃ navoti niccanavakova, āgantukasadiso hutvāti attho. Āgantuko hi paṭipāṭiyā sampattagehaṃ pavisitvā sace naṃ gharasāmikā disvā ‘‘amhākampi puttabhātaro vippavāsaṃ gantvā evaṃ vicariṃsū’’ti anukampamānā nisīdāpetvā bhojenti, bhuttamattoyeva ‘‘tumhākaṃ bhājanaṃ gaṇhathā’’ti uṭṭhāya pakkamati, na tehi saddhiṃ santhavaṃ vā karoti, kiccakaraṇīyāni vā saṃvidahati, evamayampi paṭipāṭiyā sampattaṃ gharaṃ pavisitvā yaṃ iriyāpathe pasannā manussā denti, taṃ gahetvā chinnasanthavo tesaṃ kiccakaraṇīye abyāvaṭo hutvā nikkhamatīti dīpeti. “如月”是说如月亮一般。是因为圆满吗?不是。而是说,犹如月亮行于天空,不与任何事物有亲密、爱恋或执着,却为大众所喜爱悦意。此(比丘)亦如是,因不与任何人亲密等,而为众人所喜爱悦意,如月亮般前往刹帝利等四种姓家,此为其义。“远离其身,远离其心”是指,因不与人亲密等,而牵引、移开身心,此为其义。“恒常如新”是指恒为新来之人,即如客一般,此为其义。客人次第进入到达的家,家主若见之,心生怜悯想:‘我们的儿子、兄弟离家远行时,也是如此吧’,便令其坐下并供养食物。食毕,(客人)即起离去,不与他们亲近,亦不安排事务。此(比丘)亦如是,次第进入到达的家,接受人们因其威仪而心生欢喜所施之物,断绝亲近,不理会他们的事务而离去,此为所示之义。 Appagabbhoti nappagabbho, aṭṭhaṭṭhānena kāyapāgabbhiyena, catuṭṭhānena vacīpāgabbhiyena, anekaṭṭhānena manopāgabbhiyena ca virahitoti attho. Aṭṭhaṭṭhānaṃ kāyapāgabbhiyaṃ nāma saṅghagaṇapuggalabhojanasālajantāgharanahānatitthabhikkhācāramaggesu antaragharapavesane ca kāyena appatirūpakaraṇaṃ. Catuṭṭhānaṃ vacīpāgabbhiyaṃ nāma saṅghagaṇapuggalaantaragharesu appatirūpavācānicchāraṇaṃ. Anekaṭṭhānaṃ manopāgabbhiyaṃ nāma tesu tesu [Pg.155] ṭhānesu kāyavācāhi ajjhācāraṃ anāpajjitvāpi manasā kāmavitakkādīnaṃ vitakkanaṃ. Sabbesampi imesaṃ pāgabbhiyānaṃ abhāvena appagabbho hutvā kulāni upasaṅkamatīti attho. Kassapasaṃyuttena ca candūpamappaṭipadāditherassa dhutavādesu aggabhāvassa bodhitattā vuttaṃ ‘‘etadeva kassapasaṃyuttaṃ aṭṭhuppattiṃ katvā’’ti. “不鲁莽”是指远离八处身鲁莽、四处语鲁莽及多处意鲁莽,此为其义。八处身鲁莽是指,于僧团、团体、个人、食堂、蒸气浴室、浴场、渡口、乞食道及进入俗家时,身行不当。四处语鲁莽是指,于僧团、团体、个人及俗家之中,出不当言。多处意鲁莽是指,于彼彼之处,虽身语未犯过,然心起欲寻等思惟。因无所有此等鲁莽,故为不鲁莽者而前往各家,此为其义。又,因《迦叶相应》(Kassapasaṃyutta)中以如月行道等开示了长老于头陀行中为最上,故说“即以此《迦叶相应》为事由”。 Anuruddhattheravatthu 阿那律长老事 192. Pañcame bhojanapapañcamattanti gocaragāme piṇḍāya caraṇāhāraparibhogasaññitaṃ bhojanapapañcamattaṃ. Dīparukkhānanti lohadantakaṭṭhamayānaṃ mahantānaṃ dīparukkhānaṃ. Lohamayesupi hi tesu dīpādhāresu dīparukkhakāti ruḷhiresā daṭṭhabbā. Olambakadīpamaṇḍaladīpasañcaraṇadīpādikā sesadīpā. 192. 第五,“食之戏论”是指在行乞村落中行乞与受用食物,此即食之戏论。“灯树”是指铁、象牙、木所制的大灯树。须知,即使在那些铁制的灯架中,“灯树”一词亦是约定俗成的用法。悬灯、轮灯、行灯等是其余的灯。 Anupariyāyi padakkhiṇakaraṇavasena. Ahaṃ tenāti yena tuyhaṃ attho, ahaṃ tena pavāremi, tasmā taṃ āharāpetvā gaṇhāti attho. Suvaṇṇapātiyaṃyevassa bhattaṃ uppajjīti devatānubhāvena uppajji, na kiñci pacanakiccaṃ atthi. Satta mahāpurisavitakke vitakkesīti ‘‘appicchassāyaṃ dhammo, nāyaṃ dhammo mahicchassā’’tiādike satta mahāpurisavitakke vitakkesi. Aṭṭhameti ‘‘nippapañcārāmassāyaṃ dhammo, nāyaṃ dhammo papañcārāmassā’’ti etasmiṃ purisavitakke. “随行”(Anupariyāyi)是以右绕的方式。“我以此”(Ahaṃ tena)是说:你有什么需要,我便以此邀请,因此是说让他取来受用。“其金钵中食物生起”(Suvaṇṇapātiyaṃyevassa bhattaṃ uppajji)是依天神威力而生起,没有任何烹煮之事。“思惟七种大士寻”(Satta mahāpurisavitakke vitakkesi)是思惟了‘此法为少欲者所有,非为大欲者所有’等七种大士寻。“于第八”(Aṭṭhameti)是指于‘此法为乐于无戏论者所有,非为乐于戏论者所有’此一大士寻中。 Mama saṅkappamaññāyāti ‘‘appicchassāyaṃ dhammo, nāyaṃ dhammo mahicchassā’’tiādinā (dī. ni. 3.358; a. ni. 8.30) mahāpurisavitakkavasena āraddhamattaṃ matthakaṃ pāpetuṃ asamatthabhāvena ṭhitaṃ mama saṅkappaṃ jānitvā. Manomayenāti manomayena viya manasā nimmitasadisena, pariṇāmitenāti attho. Iddhiyāti ‘‘ayaṃ kāyo idaṃ cittaṃ viya hotū’’ti evaṃ pavattāya adhiṭṭhāniddhiyā. “了知我的思惟”(Mama saṅkappamaññāya)是了知我那以“此法为少欲者所有,非为大欲者所有”(《长部》3.358;《增支部》8.30)等大士寻的方式刚刚开始,却因无力达到顶点而停住的思惟。“以意所成身”(Manomayena)是如意所成,如心所造,意思是经转化而成。“以神通”(Iddhiyā)是指以“愿此身如其心”的方式发起的决意神变(adhiṭṭhāniddhi)。 Yadā me ahu saṅkappoti yasmiṃ kāle mayhaṃ ‘‘kīdiso nu kho aṭṭhamo mahāpurisavitakko’’ti parivitakko ahosi, yadā me ahu saṅkappo, tato mama saṅkappamaññāya iddhiyā upasaṅkami, uttari desayīti yojanā. Uttari desayīti ‘‘nippapañcārāmassāyaṃ dhammo nippapañcaratino[Pg.156], nāyaṃ dhammo papañcārāmassa papañcaratino’’ti (dī. ni. 3.358; a. ni. 8.30) imaṃ aṭṭhamaṃ mahāpurisavitakkaṃ pūrento upari desayi. Taṃ pana desitaṃ dassento āha – ‘‘nippapañcarato buddho, nippapañcamadesayī’’ti, papañcā nāma rāgādayo kilesā, tesaṃ vūpasamanatāya tadabhāvato ca lokuttaradhammā nippapañcā nāma. Yathā taṃ pāpuṇāti, tathā dhammaṃ desesi, sāmukkaṃsikaṃ catusaccadesanaṃ adesayīti attho. “当我生起念头时”(Yadā me ahu saṅkappo),即当我生起“第八种大士寻究竟是怎样的”此寻思之时。当我生起此念,他便了知我的思惟,以神通前来,进一步开示——应如此连结。“进一步开示”(uttari desayi)是说,他圆满开示了这第八种大士寻:“此法为乐于无戏论、喜于无戏論者所有,非为乐于戏论、喜于戏论者所有”(《长部》3.358;《增支部》8.30)。为显示其所说,而说:“佛陀乐于无戏论,宣说无戏论法”。所谓的戏论(papañca),即是贪等烦恼。因其止息、因其不存在,故出世间法名为无戏论。为令证得彼法而说法,意思是宣说了自证圆满的四谛之教。 Tassāhaṃ dhammamaññāyāti tassa satthu desanādhammaṃ jānitvā. Vihāsinti yathānusiṭṭhaṃ paṭipajjanto vihariṃ. Sāsane ratoti sikkhattayasaṅgahe sāsane abhirato. Tisso vijjā anuppattāti pubbenivāsañāṇaṃ, dibbacakkhuñāṇaṃ, āsavakkhayañāṇanti imā tisso vijjā mayā anuppattā sacchikatā. Tato eva kataṃ buddhassa sāsanaṃ, anusiṭṭhi ovādo anuṭṭhitoti attho. “我了知其法”(Tassāhaṃ dhammamaññāya)是了知那位导师所说的法。“我安住”(Vihāsiṃ)是如所教诫地行道而住。“乐于教诫”(Sāsane rato)是乐于摄于三学的教诫。“已得三明”(Tisso vijjā anuppattā)是宿住智(pubbenivāsañāṇa)、天眼智(dibbacakkhuñāṇa)、漏尽智(āsavakkhayañāṇa),此三明我已证得、已作证。因此,佛陀的教诫已完成,意思是教诲(anusiṭṭhi)、训诫(ovāda)皆已实行。 Bhaddiyattheravatthu 跋提长老事 193. Chaṭṭhe ucca-saddena samānattho uccā-saddoti āha – ‘‘uccākulikānanti ucce kule jātāna’’nti. Kāḷī sā devīti kāḷavaṇṇatāya kāḷī sā devī. Kulānukkamena rajjānuppatti mahākulinassevāti vuttaṃ – ‘‘soyeva cā’’tiādi. 193. 于第六偈,“高”(ucca)一词与“高”(uccā)同义,故说:“出身高贵者”(uccākulikānaṃ)是生于高贵家族。“迦梨(Kāḷī)其天女”是因其肤色黑而为迦梨天女。“依家族次第而有王权”是说王权生于大族,故说“唯有他”等。 Lakuṇḍakabhaddiyattheravatthu 小跋提长老事 194. Sattame rittakoti deyyavatthurahito. Guṇe āvajjetvāti bhagavato rūpaguṇe ceva ākappasampadādiguṇe ca attano adhippāyaṃ ñatvā ambapakkassa paṭiggahaṇaṃ paribhuñjananti evamādike yathāupaṭṭhite guṇe āvajjetvā. 194. 于第七偈,“空”(rittako)是无布施物。“忆念功德”(Guṇe āvajjetvā)是忆念世尊的色身功德、威仪具足等功德,以及了知自己的意趣后接受、食用熟芒果等,如是忆念现起的功德。 Piṇḍolabhāradvājattheravatthu 宾头卢颇罗堕长老事 195. Aṭṭhame abhītanādabhāvena sīhassa viya nādo sīhanādo, so etesaṃ atthīti sīhanādikā, tesaṃ sīhanādikānaṃ. Garahitabbapasaṃsitabbadhamme yāthāvato jānantasseva garahā pasaṃsā [Pg.157] ca yuttarūpāti āha – ‘‘buddhā ca nāmā’’tiādi. Khīṇā jātītiādīhi paccavekkhaṇañāṇassa bhūmiṃ dasseti. Tena hi ñāṇena ariyasāvako paccavekkhanto ‘‘khīṇā jātī’’tiādiṃ pajānāti. Katamā panassa jāti khīṇā, kathañca pajānātīti? Na tāvassa atītā khīṇā pubbeva khīṇattā, na anāgatā anāgate vāyāmābhāvato, na paccuppannā vijjamānattā. Yā pana maggassa abhāvitattā uppajjeyya ekacatupañcavokārabhavesu ekacatupañcakkhandhappabhedā jāti, sā maggassa bhāvitattā anuppādadhammataṃ āpajjanena khīṇā. Taṃ so maggabhāvanāya pahīnakilese paccavekkhitvā ‘‘kilesābhāve vijjamānampi kammaṃ āyatiṃ appaṭisandhikaṃ hotī’’ti jānanto pajānāti. 195. 于第八偈,因无畏而吼,如狮子之吼,故为狮子吼(sīhanāda)。此吼为彼等所有,故为作狮子吼者(sīhanādikā),即“作狮子吼者”(sīhanādikānaṃ)。唯有如实了知应呵责法与应赞叹法者,其呵责与赞叹方为妥当,故说“诸佛”等。以“生已尽”(khīṇā jāti)等句显示了省察智(paccavekkhaṇañāṇa)的所缘。圣弟子(ariyasāvaka)即依此智省察而了知“生已尽”等。然则,他的何种生已尽?如何了知?非其过去生已尽,因其早已尽故;非未来生,因于未来无功用故;非现在生,因其存在故。然因未修道而可能生于一、四、五蕴有中,有一、四、五蕴差别之生,此生因已修道而达不生法性,故为已尽。他省察以修道所断的烦恼后,了知“烦恼无故,虽有业,未来亦不结生”,如是而知。 Vusitanti vuṭṭhaṃ parivuṭṭhaṃ, kataṃ caritaṃ niṭṭhitanti attho. Brahmacariyanti maggabrahmacariyaṃ. Puthujjanakalyāṇakena hi saddhiṃ satta sekkhā maggabrahmacariyaṃ vasanti nāma, khīṇāsavo vuṭṭhavāso. Tasmā ariyasāvako attano brahmacariyavāsaṃ paccavekkhanto ‘‘vusitaṃ brahmacariya’’nti pajānāti. Kataṃ karaṇīyanti catūsu saccesu catūhi maggehi pariññāpahānasacchikiriyābhāvanābhisamayavasena soḷasavidhaṃ kiccaṃ niṭṭhāpitanti attho. Puthujjanakalyāṇakādayo hi taṃ kiccaṃ karonti, khīṇāsavo katakaraṇīyo. Tasmā ariyasāvako attano karaṇīyaṃ paccavekkhanto ‘‘kataṃ karaṇīya’’nti pajānāti. Nāparaṃ itthattāyāti idāni puna itthabhāvāya evaṃ soḷasavidhakiccabhāvāya, kilesakkhayāya vā maggabhāvanāya kiccaṃ me natthīti pajānāti. Atha vā itthattāyāti itthabhāvato imasmā evaṃpakārā idāni vattamānakkhandhasantānā aparaṃ khandhasantānaṃ mayhaṃ natthi, ime pana pañcakkhandhā pariññātā tiṭṭhanti chinnamūlakā rukkhā viya, te carimakaviññāṇanirodhena anupādāno viya jātavedo nibbāyissantīti pajānāti. “已住”(Vusitaṃ)是已住立、已圆满而住,意思是已作、已行、已终。“梵行”(Brahmacariyaṃ)是道梵行(maggabrahmacariya)。善凡夫(puthujjanakalyāṇaka)与七有学(sekkhā)可说是在修习道梵行,而漏尽者(khīṇāsava)是已住梵行者。因此,圣弟子(ariyasāvaka)省察自己的梵行时,了知“梵行已立”。“所作已作”(Kataṃ karaṇīyaṃ)是说于四谛中,以四道,通过遍知、断、作证、修习、现观的方式,十六行相之事已毕。善凡夫等是作其事者,漏尽者是已作所作者。因此,圣弟子省察自己所应作时,了知“所作已作”。“更无此有”(Nāparaṃ itthattāya)是了知:如今为了再有此状态,即为了十六行相之事,或为了断烦恼、修道,我已无事可作。或者,“为此有”(itthattāya)是了知:从此状态,即从此现在的蕴相续之后,我更无其他蕴相续;此五蕴已被遍知,如断根之树而住,将于最终识灭尽时,如无薪之火般寂灭。 Mantāṇiputtapuṇṇattheravatthu 曼陀尼子富楼那长老事 196. Navame aṭṭhārasasupi vijjāṭṭhānesu nipphattiṃ gatattā ‘‘sabbasippesu kovido hutvā’’ti vuttaṃ. Abhidayāabbhaññāvahasseva dhammassa tattha upalabbhanato ‘‘mokkhadhammaṃ adisvā’’ti vuttaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘idaṃ vedattayaṃ nāmā’’tiādi[Pg.158]. Tathā hi anena duggatiparimuccanampi dullabhaṃ, abhiññāparivārānaṃ aṭṭhannaṃ samāpattīnaṃ lābhitāya sayaṃ ekadesena upasanto paramukkaṃsagataṃ uttamadamathasamathaṃ anaññasādhāraṇaṃ bhagavantaṃ sambhāvento ‘‘ayaṃ puriso’’tiādimāha. Piṭakāni gahetvā āgacchantīti phalabhājanāni gahetvā assāmikāya āgacchanti. Buddhānanti gāravavasena bahuvacananiddeso kato. Paribhuñjīti devatāhi pakkhittadibbojaṃ vanamūlaphalāphalaṃ paribhuñji. Patte patiṭṭhāpitasamanantarameva hi devatā tattha dibbojaṃ pakkhipiṃsu. Sammasitvāti paccavekkhitvā, parivattetvāti ca vadanti. Arahattaṃ pāpuṇiṃsūti mahādevattherassa anumodanakathāya anupubbikathāsakkhikāya suvisodhitacittasantānā arahattaṃ pāpuṇiṃsu. 196. 第九,由于在十八明处(vijjāṭṭhāna)已臻圆满,故说“精通一切技艺”。因唯有能带来增上与神通(abhiññā)之法才能在那里被获得,故说“未见解脱法”。因此说:“此名为三吠陀(vedattaya)”等。如是,此人甚至连脱离恶趣(duggati)都很难,然而他因证得八等至(samāpatti)及神通为眷属,自身已部分寂静,故在赞叹已达最胜、无与伦比之究竟调伏寂止(damathasamatha)的世尊时,说“此男子”等语。“手持篮器而来”(Piṭakāni gahetvā āgacchanti)意为:如无主之物般,手持果盘而来。“诸佛”(Buddhānaṃ)一词是为表尊重而使用的复数形式。“受用”(Paribhuñji)者,即享用诸天所置的天食及林中根果。钵刚放下,诸天便立即在其中置入天食。“思择”(Sammasitvā)即“省察”(paccavekkhitvā),亦有人说为“转换”(parivattetvā)。“证得阿罗汉果”(Arahattaṃ pāpuṇiṃsu)者,即因大天(Mahādeva)长老随喜开示,其说法次第分明,亲证可验,令彼等心相续极清净,故证得阿罗汉果。 Dasahi kathāvatthūhīti appicchakathā santuṭṭhikathā pavivekakathā asaṃsaggakathā vīriyārambhakathā sīlasampadākathā samādhisampadākathā paññāsampadākathā vimuttisampadākathā vimuttiñāṇadassanasampadākathāti imehi dasahi kathāvatthūhi. Jātibhūmiraṭṭhavāsinoti jātibhūmivantadesavāsino, satthu jātadesavāsinoti attho. Sīsānulokikoti purato gacchantassa sīsaṃ anu anu passanto. Okāsaṃ sallakkhetvāti sākacchāya avasaraṃ sallakkhetvā. Sattavisuddhikkamaṃ pucchīti ‘‘kiṃ nu kho, āvuso, sīlavisuddhatthaṃ bhagavati brahmacariyaṃ vussatī’’tiādinā (ma. ni. 1.257) satta visuddhiyo pucchi. Dhammakathikānaṃ aggaṭṭhāne ṭhapesi savisesena dasakathāvatthulābhitāya. “以十种论事”(Dasahi kathāvatthūhi)是指:少欲论、知足论、远离论、不杂论、精进论、戒具足论、定具足论、慧具足论、解脱具足论、解脱知见具足论此十种论事。“出生地国人”(Jātibhūmiraṭṭhavāsino)意为出生地所在国之人,即导师出生地之人。“随头观者”(Sīsānulokiko)意为:紧随其后,注视着走在前面之人的头。“观察时机”(Okāsaṃ sallakkhetvā)意为观察到交谈的机会。“以七清净的次第提问”(Sattavisuddhikkamaṃ pucchi)是指,如“贤友,是否为了戒清净而在世尊处修行梵行?”(中部1.257)等,依次询问七种清净。(世尊)将他置于诸说法者中的第一位,因为他特别通达这十种论事。 Mahākaccānattheravatthu 摩诃迦旃延长老事 197. Dasame saṃkhittena kathitadhammassāti madhupiṇḍikasuttantadesanāsu viya saṅkhepena desitadhammassa. Taṃ desanaṃ vitthāretvāti taṃ saṅkhepadesanaṃ āyatanādivasena vitthāretvā. Atthaṃ vibhajamānānanti tassā saṅkhepadesanāya atthaṃ vibhajitvā kathentānaṃ. Atthavasena vāti ‘‘ettakā etassa atthā’’ti atthavasena vā desanaṃ pūretuṃ sakkonti. Byañjanavasena vāti ‘‘ettakāni ettha byañjanāni desanāvasena vattabbānī’’ti byañjanavasena vā pūretuṃ sakkonti. Ayaṃ pana mahākaccānatthero ubhayavasenapi sakkoti tassa saṅkhepena uddiṭṭhassa vitthārena satthu ajjhāsayānurūpaṃ [Pg.159] desanato, tasmā tattha aggoti vutto. Vuttanayenevāti ‘‘pātova subhojanaṃ bhuñjitvā uposathaṅgāni adhiṭṭhāyā’’tiādinā heṭṭhā vuttanayeneva. Aññehīti aññāsaṃ itthīnaṃ kesehi ativiya dīghā. Na kevalañca dīghā eva, atha kho siniddhanīlamudukañcikā ca. Nikkesīti appakesī yathā ‘‘anudarā kaññā’’ti. 197. 第十,“简说之法”(saṃkhittena kathitadhammassa)者,犹如《蜜丸经》中简要宣说的教法。“详说其法”(Taṃ desanaṃ vitthāretvā)者,即将该简要教法依处等详细展开。“分别义理者”(Atthaṃ vibhajamānānaṃ)者,即对那简要教法的义理进行分析讲述。“依义”(Atthavasena)者,谓“此中义理有如此多”,能依义理圆满阐释教法。“依文”(Byañjanavasena)者,谓“此处文句有如此多,应当依教法说明”,能依文句圆满阐释教法。然而摩诃迦旃延长老能依此二种方式,对世尊简要开示的教法,随顺世尊的意趣作详细解说,故称其为第一。“如前述”(Vuttanayeneva)者,即如前文所说“清晨享用美食后,受持布萨支”等相同的方式。“比其他”(Aññehi)者,指比其他女人的头发长得多。不仅长,而且光润、乌黑、柔软、卷曲。“无发”(Nikkesī)者,即少发,犹如“无腹之少女”(anudarā kaññā)意为纤腰。 Paṇiyanti vikketabbabhaṇḍaṃ. Āvajjetvāti upanissayaṃ kesānaṃ pakatibhāvāpattiñca āvajjetvā. Gāravenāti muṇḍasīsāpi there gāravena ekavacaneneva āgantvā. Nimantetvāti svātanāya nimantetvā. Imissā itthiyāti yathāvuttaseṭṭhidhītaramāha. Diṭṭhadhammikovāti avadhāraṇaṃ aṭṭhānapayuttaṃ, diṭṭhadhammiko yasapaṭilābhova ahosīti attho. Yasapaṭilābhoti ca bhavasampattipaṭilābho. Sattasu hi javanacetanāsu paṭhamā diṭṭhadhammavedanīyaphalā, pacchimā upapajjavedanīyaphalā, majjhe pañca aparāpariyavedanīyaphalā, tasmā paṭhamaṃ ekaṃ cetanaṃ ṭhapetvā sesā yathāsakaṃ paripuṇṇaphaladāyino honti, paṭhamacetanāya pana diṭṭhadhammiko yasapaṭilābhova ahosi. “商品”(Paṇiyaṃ)指待售的货物。“思惟”(Āvajjetvā)者,即思惟其所依及头发恢复自然状态。“以恭敬心”(Gāravena)者,意为:她虽然剃了头,但仍怀着对长老的恭敬心,独自前来。“邀请”(Nimantetvā)者,即邀请明日用餐。“此女”(Imissā itthiyā)者,指如前所述的富商之女。“仅在现法中”(Diṭṭhadhammiko vā)中的“仅”(vā)字,此处为不当的强调,其意为:仅在现法中获得名誉。“获得名誉”(Yasapaṭilābho)即获得世间成就。因为在七个速行心中,第一个是现法受果,最后一个是生报受果,中间五个是后报受果。因此,除去第一个心,其余的都能各自带来圆满的果报,而第一个心念仅在现法中带来了名誉。 Paṭhamaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 第一最上者品释义终。 14. Etadaggavaggo 14. 最上者品 (14) 2. Dutiyaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā (14)二、第二最上者品释义 Cūḷapanthakattheravatthu 周利盘陀伽长老事 198-200. Dutiyassa paṭhame manena nibbattitanti abhiññāmanena uppāditaṃ. Manena katakāyoti abhiññācittena desantaraṃ pattakāyo. Manena nibbattitakāyoti abhiññāmanasā nimmitakāyo ‘‘aññaṃ kāyaṃ abhinimminātī’’tiādīsu (dī. ni. 1.236-237; paṭi. ma. 3.14) viya. Ekasadiseyevāti attasadiseyeva. Ekavidhamevāti attanā katappakārameva. Etapparamo hi yebhuyyena sāvakānaṃ iddhinimmānavidhi. Aggo nāma jāto ekadesena satthu iddhinimmānānuvidhānato. 198-200. 第二品之初,“以意所生”(manena nibbattitaṃ)是指以神通心所生。“以意所成身”(Manena katakāyo)是指以神通心到达他方的身体。“以意所化身”(Manena nibbattitakāyo)是指以神通心所化作的身体,犹如“化作另一身体”(aññaṃ kāyaṃ abhinimmināti)等处所说。“同一相貌”(Ekasadise)即与自身相貌相同。“同一类型”(Ekavidhaṃ)即与自己所作的类型相同。对声闻弟子而言,这大体上是其神通化作之法的极限。他之所以被称为“第一”,是因为在某种程度上随行了世尊的神通化作。 Lābhitāyāti [Pg.160] ettha lābhīti īkāro atisayattho. Tena therassa catunnaṃ rūpāvacarajjhānānaṃ atisayena savisesalābhitaṃ dasseti. Arūpāvacarajjhānānaṃ lābhitāyāti etthāpi eseva nayo. Na kevalañcetā cetosaññāvivaṭṭakusalatā rūpārūpajjhānalābhitāya eva, atha kho imehipi kāraṇehīti dassetuṃ – ‘‘cūḷapanthako cā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Cetoti cettha cittasīsena samādhi vutto, tasmā cetaso samādhissa vivaṭṭanaṃ cetovivaṭṭo, ekasmiṃyevārammaṇe samādhicittaṃ vivaṭṭetvā heṭṭhimassa heṭṭhimassa uparūpari hāpanato rūpāvacarajjhānalābhī cetovivaṭṭakusalo nāma. ‘‘Sabbaso rūpasaññāna’’ntiādinā (dha. sa. 265) vuttasaññā atikkamitvā ‘‘ākāsānañcāyatanasaññāsahagataṃ…pe… nevasaññānāsaññāyatanasaññāsahagata’’nti (dha. sa. 265-268) saññāsīsena vuttajjhānānaṃ vivaṭṭakusalo, tathā itthipurisādisaññā niccasaññādito cittaṃ vivaṭṭetvā kevale rūpārūpadhammamatte asaṅkhate nibbāne ca visesato vaṭṭanato ca suññatānupassanābahulo saññāvivaṭṭakusalo. Samādhikusalatāya cetovivaṭṭakusalatā tabbahulavihāritāya. Tathā vipassanākusalatāya saññāvivaṭṭakusalatā. Ekoti cūḷapanthakattheraṃ vadati. Samādhilakkhaṇeti savitakkasavicārādisamādhisabhāve. Puna ekoti mahāpanthakattheramāha. Vipassanālakkhaṇeti sattaanupassanā aṭṭhārasamahāvipassanādivipassanāsabhāve. Samādhigāḷhoti samādhismiṃ ogāḷhacitto subhāvitabhāvanatā. Aṅgasaṃkhitteti caturaṅgikativaṅgikādivasena jhānaṅgānaṃ saṅkhipane. Ārammaṇasaṃkhitteti kasiṇugghāṭimākāsādinibbattanena kasiṇādiārammaṇānaṃ saṃkhipane. Aṅgavavatthāpaneti vitakkādīnaṃ jhānaṅgānaṃ vavatthāpane. Ārammaṇavavatthāpaneti pathavīkasiṇādijjhānārammaṇānaṃ vavatthāpane. “获得”(lābhitā)一词中,“获得者”(lābhī)的长音“ī”表示卓越之义。由此显示长老于四种色界禅有超胜、特殊的获得。在“获得无色界禅”中也是同样的道理。此心与想转向的善巧,不仅是因为获得了色界与无色界禅,也是为了说明这些原因——如“周利盘陀伽(Cūḷapanthako)等”中所说。“心”(ceto)在此以心为首,说的是定,因此心的定之转向称为“心转向”(cetovivaṭṭa)。于单一所缘上,令定心转向,舍弃下下者而趋于上上,获得色界禅者,名为“心转向善巧者”。如“‘完全超越所有色想’等”(法集论 265)所说的想,超越之后,与“‘空无边处想相应……乃至非想非非想处想相应’” (法集论 265-268)等以想为首的诸禅转向善巧。同样,将心从男女等想、常想等转向,唯独转向于色、无色法,尤其转向于无为的涅槃,并且多修空观者,名为“想转向善巧者”(saññāvivaṭṭakusala)。由定善巧而有心转向善巧,因其多安住于此。同样,由观(vipassanā)善巧而有想转向善巧。“一”指的是周利盘陀伽长老。于定相者,即于有寻有伺等定之自性。“又一”指的是大盘陀伽长老。于观相者,即于七随观、十八大观等观之自性。深于定者,谓心深入定中,善修习禅修。于略摄诸支者,即以四支、三支等方式略摄禅支。于略摄所缘者,即通过揭开遍处而生起虚空等,以此略摄遍处(kasiṇa)等所缘。于分别诸支者,即于分别寻等禅支。于分别所缘者,即于分别地遍(pathavīkasiṇa)等禅所缘。 Jhānaṅgehīti rūpāvacarajjhānaṅgehi, jhānaṅgāneva jhānaṃ. Puna jhānaṅgehīti arūpāvacarajjhānaṅgehi. Bhātāti jeṭṭhabhātā. Assāti kuṭumbiyassa. Suvaṇṇapūjanti sovaṇṇamayaṃ pupphapūjaṃ katvā. Devapureti tāvatiṃsabhavane sudassanamahānagare. Aggadvārenāti tasmiṃ divase aggaṃ sabbapaṭhamaṃ vivaṭena nagaradvārena nikkhamitvā. “由禅支”者,谓由色界禅之禅支,禅支即是禅。再言“由禅支”者,谓由无色界禅之禅支。“兄长”者,谓年长之兄。“他的”(assā)者,谓家主的。“金供养”者,谓做了黄金所成的花之供养。“于天城中”者,谓位于三十三天(Tāvatiṃsa)的善见(Sudassana)大城中。“由正门”者,谓于当日从最先开启的主要城门而出。 Kokanadanti [Pg.161] padumavisesanaṃ yathā ‘‘kokāsaka’’nti. Taṃ kira bahupattaṃ vaṇṇasampannaṃ atisugandhañca hoti. ‘‘Kokanadaṃ nāma setapaduma’’ntipi vadanti. Pātoti pageva. Ayañhettha attho – yathā kokanadasaṅkhātaṃ padumaṃ pāto sūriyuggamanavelāyaṃ phullaṃ vikasitaṃ avītagandhaṃ siyā virocamānaṃ, evaṃ sarīragandhena guṇagandhena ca sugandhaṃ saradakāle antalikkhe ādiccamiva attano tejasā tapantaṃ aṅgehi niccharaṇakajutiyā aṅgīrasaṃ sammāsambuddhaṃ passāti. “Kokanada”是莲花的别名,犹如“kokāsaka”。据说此莲花多瓣、色泽圆满、且极芳香。也有人说“Kokanada是白莲花”。“Pāto”即是清晨。此中之义为:犹如名为Kokanada的莲花,于清晨日出之时,盛开绽放,芳香不散,光彩照人;同样地,看那以身香与德香而芬芳,于秋日空中犹如太阳以自身光芒照耀,以从肢体散发的光辉而遍照的盎耆罗娑(Aṅgīrasa)、正自觉者。 Cūḷapanthako kira kassapasammāsambuddhakāle pabbajitvā paññavā hutvā aññatarassa dandhabhikkhuno uddesagahaṇakāle parihāsakeḷiṃ akāsi. So bhikkhu tena parihāsena lajjito neva uddesaṃ gaṇhi, na sajjhāyamakāsi. Tena kammenāyaṃ pabbajitvāva dandho jāto, tasmā gahitagahitapadaṃ upariuparipadaṃ gaṇhantassa nassati. Iddhiyā abhisaṅkharitvā suddhaṃ coḷakhaṇḍaṃ adāsīti tassa pubbahetuṃ disvā tadanurūpe kammaṭṭhāne niyojento suddhaṃ coḷakhaṇḍaṃ adāsi. So kira pubbe rājā hutvā nagaraṃ padakkhiṇaṃ karonto nalāṭato sede muccante parisuddhena sāṭakena nalāṭaṃ puñchi, sāṭako kiliṭṭho ahosi. So ‘‘imaṃ sarīraṃ nissāya evarūpo parisuddhasāṭako pakatiṃ jahitvā kiliṭṭho jāto, aniccā vata saṅkhārā’’ti aniccasaññaṃ paṭilabhi. Tena kāraṇenassa rajoharaṇameva paccayo jāto. 据说周利盘陀伽(Cūḷapanthaka)在迦叶(Kassapa)正自觉者时代出家,他有智慧,在一位迟钝比丘领受教诵时,对他开玩笑作弄。那位比丘因被作弄而感到羞愧,便不再领受教诵,也不再读诵。由于此业,他今生出家后变得迟钝,因此当他学习后面的字句时,前面学过的就忘了。经文说“以神通力造作,给了一块洁净的布”,这是因为佛陀见到他的宿因,为了让他从事相应的业处,而给了他一块洁净的布。据说他过去世曾为国王,在巡城时,额头流汗,便用一块洁净的布擦拭额头,布就变脏了。他思惟:“因为这个身体,这样洁净的布舍弃了它的本性而变脏了。诸行真是无常啊!”由此获得了无常想。因此,(擦拭)去除污垢的布就成了他(觉悟)的助缘。 Lomānīti coḷakhaṇḍatantagataaṃsuke vadati. ‘‘Kiliṭṭhadhātukānī’’ti kiliṭṭhasabhāvāni. Evaṃgatikamevāti idaṃ cittampi bhavaṅgavasena pakatiyā paṇḍaraṃ parisuddhaṃ rāgādisampayuttadhammavasena saṃkiliṭṭhaṃ jātanti dasseti. Nakkhattaṃ samānetvāti nakkhattaṃ samannāharitvā, āvajjetvāti attho. Biḷārassatthāyāti biḷārassa gocaratthāya. Jalapathakammikenāti samuddakammikena. Cārinti khāditabbatiṇaṃ. Saccakāranti saccabhāvāvahaṃ kāraṃ, ‘‘attanā gahite bhaṇḍe aññesaṃ na dātabba’’nti vatvā dātabbalañjanti vuttaṃ hoti. Tatiyena paṭihārenāti tatiyena sāsanena. Pattikā hutvāti sāmino hutvā. “Lomāni”(毛)者,是指布片丝线上的纤维。“Kiliṭṭhadhātukāni”(染污界)者,谓具有染污自性的事物。如此显示——此心依有分(bhavaṅga)而言,其自性本是光亮、清净的,但因与贪等相应之法,而变得染污。“Nakkhattaṃ samānetvā”(观察星宿)者,谓忆念星宿,意即省察。“Biḷārassatthāya”(为了猫)者,谓为了猫的食物。“Jalapathakammikena”(以水路为业者)者,谓以航海为业者。“Cārin”(食)者,谓应食之草。“Saccakāraṃ”(定金)者,谓带来真实状态的行为,意即说“自己已收定的货物,不应再给他人”,这被称为应付的定金。“Tatiyena paṭihārena”(以第三信)者,谓以第三个教令。“Pattikā hutvā”(成为拥有者)者,谓成为主人。 Appakenapīti thokenapi parittenapi. Medhāvīti paññavā. Pābhatenāti bhaṇḍamūlena. Vicakkhaṇoti vohārakusalo. Samuṭṭhāpeti attānanti mahantaṃ dhanaṃ yasañca uppādetvā tattha attānaṃ saṇṭhapeti patiṭṭhāpeti[Pg.162]. Yathā kiṃ? Aṇuṃ aggiṃva sandhamaṃ, yathā paṇḍito puriso parittakaṃ aggiṃ anukkamena gomayacuṇṇādīni pakkhipitvā mukhavātena dhamento samuṭṭhāpeti vaḍḍheti, mahantaṃ aggikkhandhaṃ karoti, evameva paṇḍito thokampi pābhataṃ labhitvā nānāupāyehi payojetvā dhanañca yasañca vaḍḍheti, vaḍḍhetvā puna tattha attānaṃ patiṭṭhāpeti. Tāya eva vā pana dhanassa mahantatāya attānaṃ samuṭṭhāpeti, abhiññātaṃ pākaṭaṃ karotīti attho. “Appakenapi”(以少量)者,谓以少许、微量。“Medhāvī”(智者)者,谓有智慧者。“Pābhatena”(以资本)者,谓以货物之本金。“Vicakkhaṇo”(明辨者)者,谓善于经营者。“Samuṭṭhāpeti attānaṃ”(建立自身)者,谓生起巨大之财富与名声,并令自身立足于此。譬如什么?“Aṇuṃ aggiṃva sandhamaṃ”(如吹燃微火),犹如智者,次第投入牛粪粉末等,以口吹气,令微火燃起、增长,终成一巨大火聚。同样地,智者即使得到少量资本,也能以各种方法运用,增长财富与名声,增长之后,再令自身立足于此。或者,正是由于财富的巨大而建立自身,意思是使自己变得知名、显赫。 Subhūtittheravatthu 须菩提长老的故事 201-202. Tatiye raṇāti hi rāgādayo kilesā vuccantīti ‘‘saraṇā dhammā’’tiādīsu (dha. sa. 100 dukamātikā) rāgādayo kilesā ‘‘raṇā’’ti vuccanti. Raṇanti etehīti raṇā. Yehi abhibhūtā sattā nānappakārena kandanti paridevanti, tasmā te rāgādayo ‘‘raṇā’’ti vuttā. Desitaniyāmato anokkamitvāti desitānokkamanato anupagantvā deseti, satthārā desitaniyāmeneva anodissakaṃ katvā dhammaṃ desetīti vuttaṃ hoti. Evanti evaṃ mettājhānato vuṭṭhāya bhikkhāgahaṇe sati. Bhikkhādāyakānaṃ mahapphalaṃ bhavissatīti idaṃ cūḷaccharāsaṅghātasuttena (a. ni. 1.51 ādayo) dīpetabbaṃ. Accharāsaṅghātamattampi hi kālaṃ mettacittaṃ āsevantassa bhikkhuno dinnadānaṃ mahapphalaṃ hoti mahānisaṃsaṃ, tena ca so amoghaṃ raṭṭhapiṇḍaṃ bhuñjatīti ayamattho tattha āgatoyeva. Nimittaṃ gaṇhitvāti ākāraṃ sallakkhetvā. 201-202. 第三,“染”(raṇa)是指贪等烦恼,所以在“有染法”(saraṇā dhammā)等(见《法集论》百种双品)中,贪等烦恼被称为“染”。众生被这些烦恼所征服,便以各种方式哭泣哀号,因此贪等烦恼被称为“染”。“不从所指示的(教诫)中违越”,意思是:不违背已教导的(内容)而宣说,即导师说法时,按照已教导的规则,不做特别指定,而宣说佛法。像这样,当比丘从慈心禅定出来乞食时,给予食物的人将会获得大的果报,这个道理应当用《弹指经》(Cūḷaccharāsaṅghātasutta)(增支部1.51)来解释。即使是片刻时间修习慈心的比丘,他接受的布施也会有大的果报和大的利益,因此他享用国家的食物也不会是白白浪费,这个意义在那里已经包含了。“执取相”,意思是:观察事物的特征。 Khadiravaniyarevatattheravatthu 卡迪拉瓦尼亚·瑞瓦达长老的故事 203. Pañcame vanasabhāganti sabhāgaṃ vanaṃ, sabhāganti ca sappāyanti attho. Yañhi pakativiruddhaṃ byādhiviruddhañca na hoti, taṃ ‘‘sabhāga’’nti vuccati. Udakasabhāgantiādīsupi imināva nayena attho veditabbo. Kalyāṇakammāyūhanakkhaṇoti kalyāṇakammūpacayassa okāso. Tiṇṇaṃ bhātikānanti upatisso, cundo, upasenoti imesaṃ tiṇṇaṃ jeṭṭhabhātikānaṃ. Tissannañca bhaginīnanti cālā, upacālā, sīsupacālāti imesaṃ tissannaṃ jeṭṭhabhaginīnaṃ. Ettha ca sāriputtatthero sayaṃ pabbajitvā [Pg.163] cālā, upacālā, sīsupacālāti tisso bhaginiyo, cundo upasenoti ime bhātaro pabbājesi, revatakumāro ekova gehe avasissati. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘amhākaṃ…pe… pabbājentī’’ti. Mahallakatarāti vuddhatarā. Idañca kumārikāya cirajīvitaṃ abhikaṅkhamānā āhaṃsu. Sā kira tassa ayyikā vīsativassasatikā khaṇḍadantā palitakesā valittacā tilakāhatagattā gopānasivaṅkā ahosi. Vidhāvanikanti vidhāvanakīḷikaṃ. Tissannaṃ sampattīnanti anussavavasena manussadevamokkhasampattiyo sandhāya vadati, manussadevabrahmasampattiyo vā. Sīvalissa puññaṃ vīmaṃsissāmāti ‘‘sīvalinā katapuññassa vipākadānaṭṭhānamida’’nti ñatvā evamāha. Sabhāgaṭṭhānanti samaṃ desaṃ. 203. 第五,“与林相宜”(vanasabhāga)意为与森林相称,也就是合适(sappāya)的意思。凡是不与自然冲突、不与疾病冲突的,就称为“相宜”。“水相宜”(udakasabhāga)等等的意义也应该用这种方式来理解。“善业积累时”(kalyāṇakammāyūhanakkhaṇa)是指积累善业的机会。“三兄弟”(Tiṇṇaṃ bhātikānaṃ)指的是伍巴谛萨(Upatissa)、纯陀(Cunda)、优波先那(Upasena)这三位兄长。“三姊妹”(Tissannañca bhaginīnaṃ)指的是遮罗(Cālā)、邬巴嘉娜(Upacālā)、尸须波遮罗(Sīsupacālā)这三位姐姐。在此,舍利弗长老自己出家后,又让遮罗、邬巴嘉娜、尸须波遮罗三位姊妹以及纯陀、优波先那两位兄弟出家,只剩下瑞瓦达(Revata)童子一个人留在家里。所以说“我们……令其出家”。“更年长者”(mahallakatara)就是更老。这是少女们期望她长寿而说的话。据说那位少女的祖母已经一百二十岁,牙齿残缺,头发花白,皮肤褶皱,身上有斑点,驼背得像屋梁一样。“追逐嬉戏”(vidhāvanika)是指追逐玩耍的游戏。“三种成就”(tissannaṃ sampattīnaṃ)指的是通过听闻而得到的人、天、解脱的成就,或者是指人、天、梵天的成就。“我们将思量西瓦莉(Sīvalī)的福德”(Sīvalissa puññaṃ vīmaṃsissāma)是说,在知道“这是西瓦莉所做福德的果报之处”后,他才这么说。“相宜之处”(sabhāgaṭṭhāna)就是平坦的地方。 Taṃ bhūmirāmaṇeyyakanti kiñcāpi arahanto gāmante kāyavivekaṃ na labhanti, cittavivekaṃ pana labhanteva. Tesañhi dibbappaṭibhāgānipi ārammaṇāni cittaṃ cāletuṃ na sakkonti, tasmā gāmo vā hotu araññādīnaṃ vā aññataraṃ, ‘yattha arahanto viharanti, taṃ bhūmirāmaṇeyyakaṃ’, so bhūmippadeso ramaṇīyo evāti attho. “彼地是悦意处”(Taṃ bhūmirāmaṇeyyakaṃ)——即使阿罗汉在村落边上无法获得身远离(kāyaviveka),但他们肯定能获得心远离(cittaviveka)。因为即使是天界般的所缘也无法动摇他们的心,因此无论是村落还是森林等其他地方,“凡阿罗汉居住的地方,就是悦意的地方”,意思是那个地方确实是令人愉悦的。 Kaṅkhārevatattheravatthu 多疑的瑞瓦达长老的故事 204. Chaṭṭhe akappiyo, āvuso, guḷoti ekadivasaṃ thero antarāmagge guḷakaraṇaṃ okkamitvā guḷe piṭṭhampi chārikampi pakkhitte disvāna ‘‘akappiyo guḷo, sāmiso na kappati guḷo vikāle paribhuñjitu’’nti kukkuccāyanto evamāha. Akappiyā muggāti ekadivasaṃ antarāmagge vacce muggaṃ jātaṃ disvā ‘‘akappiyā muggā, pakkāpi muggā jāyantī’’ti kukkuccāyanto evamāha. Sesamettha sabbaṃ uttānameva. 204. 第六,“贤友(āvuso),糖是不如法的”。某日,长老在路上走进一处制糖作坊,看见有人在糖里掺了米粉和灰,就心生追悔说:“糖是不如法的,有杂质的糖在非时食用是不适宜的。”“绿豆是不如法的”。某日,在路上看见长出的绿豆,就心生追悔说:“绿豆是不如法的,(因为)煮熟的绿豆还会生长。”此中其余部分皆是显而易见的。 Soṇakoḷivisattheravatthu 索那·拘利维沙长老的故事 205. Sattame hāpetabbameva ahosi accāraddhavīriyattā. Udakena samupabyūḷheti udakena thalaṃ ussāretvā tattha tattha rāsikate. Haritūpalittāyāti gomayaparibhaṇḍakatāya. Tividhena udakena posentīti khīrodakaṃ gandhodakaṃ kevalodakanti evaṃ tividhena udakena posenti paripālenti. Parissāvetvāti parisodhetvā gahite taṇḍuleti yojetabbaṃ. Devo maññeti devo viya[Pg.164]. Vīṇovādenāti ‘‘taṃ kiṃ maññasi, soṇa, yadā te vīṇāya tantiyo accāyatā honti, api nu te vīṇā tasmiṃ samaye saravatī vā hoti kammaññā vāti? No hetaṃ, bhanteti. Evameva kho, soṇa, accāraddhavīriyaṃ uddhaccāya saṃvattati, atisithilavīriyaṃ kosajjāya saṃvattati. Tasmātiha tvaṃ, soṇa, vīriyasamataṃ adhiṭṭhaha, indriyānañca samataṃ paṭivijjhā’’ti (mahāva. 243) evaṃ vīṇaṃ upamaṃ katvā pavattitena vīṇopamovādena. Vīriyasamathayojanatthāyāti vīriyassa samathena yojanatthāya. 205. 第七,“应舍弃”(hāpetabbaṃ)是因为过度精进的缘故。“以水堆积”(Udakena samupabyūḷhe),即用水将陆地抬高,然后在各处堆积。“涂青”(Haritūpalittāya),即用牛粪涂抹。“用三种水滋养”(Tividhena udakena posenti),即用乳水、香水、清水这三种水滋养护持。“滤净后”(Parissāvetvā),应与“取洗净之米”(parisodhetvā gahite taṇḍule)连接。“当如天神”(Devo maññe),即像天神一样。“以琴喻教诫”(Vīṇovādena),即以琴为譬喻而说的教诫:‘索那,你怎么认为?当你的琴弦过于紧绷时,你的琴在那时会发出美妙的声音,或是适合演奏吗?’‘不会的,尊者。’‘同样的,索那,过度精进会导致掉举,过于松懈会导致懈怠。因此,索那,你应当确立精进的平衡,并且通达诸根的平衡。’(《大品》243)。“为精进平衡之结合故”(Vīriyasamathayojanatthāya),即为了使精进达到平衡。 Soṇakuṭikaṇṇattheravatthu 索那·拘提迦那长老的故事 206. Aṭṭhame kuṭikaṇṇoti vuccatīti ‘‘koṭikaṇṇo’’ti vattabbe ‘‘kuṭikaṇṇo’’ti voharīyati. Kulaghare bhavā kulagharikā. Sā kira avantiraṭṭhe kulaghare mahāvibhavassa seṭṭhissa bhariyā. Dasabalassa dhammakathaṃ sutvā sotāpattiphale patiṭṭhāya cintesīti idaṃ aṅguttarabhāṇakānaṃ matena vuttaṃ. Suttanipātaṭṭhakathāyaṃ pana ‘‘sapariso bhagavantaṃ upasaṅkamma dhammadesanaṃ assosi, na ca kañci visesaṃ adhigañchi. Kasmā? So hi dhammaṃ suṇanto hemavataṃ anussaritvā ‘āgato nu kho me sahāyako, no’ti disādisaṃ oloketvā taṃ apassanto ‘vañcito me sahāyo, yo evaṃ vicittappaṭibhānaṃ bhagavato desanaṃ na suṇātī’ti vikkhittacitto ahosī’’ti vuttaṃ. 206. 第八,被称为“拘提迦那”(kuṭikaṇṇa),本应说“俱胝耳”(koṭikaṇṇa),却被说成“拘提迦那”(kuṭikaṇṇa)。“出身望族”(kulagharikā)指生于望族之家。据说她曾是阿槃提(Avanti)国一位大富长者的妻子。听闻十力世尊的说法后,证得入流果,然后开始思考,这是依据增支部诵者的观点所说。然而在《经集注》中却说:‘他带领眷属去拜见世尊听法,却没有证得任何殊胜的果位。为什么呢?因为他在听法的时候,忆念着雪山(Hemavata)的友人,心想“我的朋友来了吗?”,四处张望却看不到他,于是心生散乱:“我的朋友错失了,竟没有听到世尊如此精彩善巧的说法!”’ Yasmā paṭisandhijātiabhinikkhamanabodhiparinibbānesveva dvattiṃsa pubbanimittāni hutvāva paṭivigacchanti, na ciraṭṭhitikāni honti, dhammacakkappavattane (saṃ. ni. 5.1081; paṭi. ma. 2.30) pana tāni savisesāni hutvā cirataraṃ ṭhatvā nirujjhanti, tasmā vuttaṃ – ‘‘tiyojanasahassaṃ himavantaṃ akālapupphitaṃ disvā’’tiādi. Aggabalakāyāti sabbapurato gacchantā balakāyā. Kena pupphitabhāvaṃ jānāsīti kena kāraṇena himavantassa pupphitabhāvaṃ jānāsīti, yena kāraṇena imaṃ akālapupphapāṭihāriyaṃ jātaṃ, taṃ jānāsīti vuttaṃ hoti. Tassa pavattitabhāvanti tassa dhammacakkassa bhagavatā pavattitabhāvaṃ. Sadde nimittaṃ gaṇhīti sadde ākāraṃ sallakkhesi. Tatoti ‘‘ahaṃ ‘etaṃ amatadhammaṃ tampi [Pg.165] jānāpessāmī’ti tava santikaṃ āgatosmī’’ti yaṃ vuttaṃ, tadanantaranti attho. 因为三十二种前兆只在结生、出生、出家、成道和般涅槃时出现后便会消失,不会持续很久;但在转法轮时(相应部5.1081;无碍解道2.30),它们会特别地显现,并持续更长时间后才消失,因此说:“见到三千由旬的雪山(Himavanta)非时节地开花”等等。“前锋部队”(Aggabalakāya)是指所有在最前方行进的部队。“你因何而知其开花?”(Kena pupphitabhāvaṃ jānāsi)即,你因何原因知道雪山开花?意思是说,你因何而知这非时节开花的奇迹发生了?“其转起之状态”(Tassa pavattitabhāvaṃ),即世尊转动法轮的状态。“于声中取相”(Sadde nimittaṃ gaṇhīti)是指留意声音中的相貌。“其后”(Tato)是指在‘我已了知此不死之法,亦欲令你了知,故我来到你这里’这句话之后的意思。 Sātāgiro hemavatassa buddhuppādaṃ kathetvā taṃ bhagavato santikaṃ ānetukāmo ‘‘ajja pannaraso’’tiādigāthamāha. Tattha (su. ni. aṭṭha. 1.153) ajjāti ayaṃ rattindivo pakkhagaṇanato pannaraso, upavasitabbato uposatho. Tīsu vā uposathesu ajja pannaraso uposatho, na cātuddasiuposatho, na sāmaggīuposatho. Divi bhavāni dibbāni, dibbāni ettha atthīti dibbāni. Kāni tāni? Rūpāni. Tañhi rattiṃ devānaṃ dasasahassilokadhātuto sannipatitānaṃ sarīravatthābharaṇavimānappabhāhi abbhādiupakkilesavirahitāya candappabhāya ca sakalajambudīpo alaṅkato ahosīti ativiya alaṅkato ca parivisuddhidevassa bhagavato sarīrappabhāya. Tenāha – ‘‘dibbā ratti upaṭṭhitā’’ti. 萨达吉拉(Sātāgira)对雪山(Hemavata)讲述佛陀出世之事,想将他带到世尊面前,便说了“今日十五”等偈颂。于此(《经集注》1.153),“今日”(ajja)是指依昼夜与半月计算的第十五日,是应当守持的布萨(uposatha)日。在三种布萨日中,今日是十五布萨日,不是十四布萨日,也不是和合布萨日。“生于天界”(Divi bhavāni)即是天界的(dibbāni)。此处有天界之物,故称“天界的”。那些是什么?是形色。因为在那一夜,从一万个世界前来集会的诸天,其身体、衣服、饰品、宫殿的光辉,以及无云等染的月光,令整个瞻部洲(Jambudīpa)庄严无比;又因具足最极清净功德的世尊的身光,而更为庄严。因此说:“天界之夜已到来”。 Evaṃ rattiguṇavaṇṇanāpadesenapi sahāyassa cittaṃ pasādaṃ janento buddhuppādaṃ kathetvā āha – ‘‘anomanāmaṃ satthāraṃ, handa passāma gotama’’nti. Tattha anomehi alāmakehi sabbākāraparipūrehi guṇehi nāmaṃ assāti anomanāmo. Tathā hissa ‘‘bujjhitā saccānīti buddho, bodhetā pajāyāti buddho’’tiādinā (mahāni. 192; cūḷani. pārāyanatthutigāthāniddeso 97; paṭi. ma. 1.162) nayena buddhoti anomehi guṇehi nāmaṃ. ‘‘Bhaggarāgoti bhagavā, bhaggadosoti bhagavā’’tiādinā (mahāni. 84) nayena bhagavāti anomehi guṇehi nāmaṃ. Esa nayo ‘‘arahaṃ sammāsambuddho vijjācaraṇasampanno’’tiādīsu. Diṭṭhadhammikādiatthehi devamanusse anusāsati ‘‘imaṃ pajahatha, imaṃ samādāya vattathā’’ti satthā. Taṃ anomanāmaṃ satthāraṃ. Handāti vacasāyatthe nipāto. Passāmāti tena attānaṃ saha saṅgahetvā paccuppannabahuvacanaṃ. Gotamanti gotamagottaṃ. Idaṃ vuttaṃ hoti – ‘‘satthā, na satthā’’ti mā vimatiṃ akāsi, ekantabyavasito hutvāva ehi passāma gotamanti. 如此,以夜晚功德的解说,在令友人内心生起信心的同时,讲述佛陀出世之事,然后说:“具无上之名的导师(satthāraṃ),来,我们去拜见乔达摩(Gotama)。”于此,“无上之名”(anomanāmo)是指以无与伦比、完美无缺的功德而得名。正如经中所说:“觉悟真理名为佛陀,教导众生名为佛陀”等,以无上功德而得名佛陀。“断除贪欲名为世尊(bhagavā),断除瞋恚名为世尊”等,以无上功德而得名世尊。这种方式也适用于“阿罗汉、正等觉者、明行足”等名号。能以现法利益等义理教导天人,说“你们应当舍弃这个,应当奉行这个”的就是导师。那位具无上之名的导师。“来”(handa)是劝请语助词。“我们去拜见”(passāma)是将自己也包括在内的现在时复数。“乔达摩”是乔达摩的姓氏。这句话的意思是:“不要疑惑‘他是否是导师’,应当坚定地相信,来,我们去拜见乔达摩。” Evaṃ vutte hemavato ‘‘ayaṃ sātāgiro ‘anomanāmaṃ satthāra’nti bhaṇanto tassa sabbaññutaṃ pakāseti, sabbaññuno ca dullabhā loke, sabbaññupaṭiññehi pūraṇādisadiseheva loko upadduto. So pana yadi sabbaññū, addhā tādilakkhaṇaṃ patto bhavissati, tena evaṃ gahessāmī’’ti [Pg.166] cintetvā tādilakkhaṇaṃ pucchanto āha – ‘‘kacci mano’’tiādi. Tattha kaccīti pucchā. Manoti cittaṃ. Supaṇihitoti suṭṭhu ṭhapito acalo asampavedhī. Sabbesu bhūtesu sabbabhūtesu. Tādinoti tādilakkhaṇaṃ pattasseva sato. Pucchā eva vā ayaṃ ‘‘so tava satthā sabbabhūtesu tādī, udāhu no’’ti. Iṭṭhe aniṭṭhecāti evarūpe ārammaṇe. Saṅkappāti vitakkā. Vasīkatāti vasaṃ gamitā. Idaṃ vuttaṃ hoti – yaṃ taṃ satthāraṃ vadasi, tassa te satthuno kacci tādilakkhaṇaṃ sampattassa sato sabbabhūtesu mano supaṇihito, udāhu yāva paccayaṃ na labhati, tāva supaṇihito viya khāyati. So vā te satthā kacci sabbabhūtesu sattesu tādī, udāhu no, ye ca iṭṭhāniṭṭhesu ārammaṇesu rāgadosavasena saṅkappā uppajjeyyuṃ, tyāssa kacci vasīkatā, udāhu kadāci tesampi vasena vattatīti. 如是说时,雪山(Hemavata)心想:“这位萨达吉拉(Sātāgira)称‘具无上之名的导师’,是在显示他的一切知性。世间难有一切知者,那些自称一切知者如富兰那(Pūraṇa)等人只会扰乱世间。若他真是一切知者,必定已证得如是相,我当如此验证。”于是为求证如是相而问道:“心是否”等。于此,“是否”(kacci)是问词。“心”(mano)指心意。“善安住”(supaṇihito)即妥善安置,不动摇,不摇动。“于一切有情”(sabbesu bhūtesu)即对所有有情。“如是”(tādino)指已证得如是相者。或者这问题是:“你的导师对一切有情可曾是如是相?还是不是?”于可喜不可喜之境中。“寻思”(saṅkappā)即思维(vitakkā)。“调伏”(vasīkatā)谓已得自在。这是说:你所称的那位导师,若已证得如是相,他的心于一切有情中可曾善安住?或者直到还没有得到因缘时,才看似善安住?你的导师可曾对一切有情是如是相?又,在可喜不可喜的境界中,由于贪欲与瞋恚而生起的寻思,他可曾调伏那些寻思?或者有时也随着那些寻思而转? Tīṇi vassānīti soṇassa pabbajitadivasato paṭṭhāya tīṇi vassāni. Tadā kira bhikkhū yebhuyyena majjhimadeseyeva vasiṃsu, tasmā tattha katipayā eva ahesuṃ. Te ca ekasmiṃ nigame eko dveti evaṃ visuṃ visuṃ vasiṃsu, therānañca katipaye bhikkhū ānetvā aññesu ānīyamānesu pubbaṃ ānītā kenacideva karaṇīyena pakkamiṃsu, kañci kālaṃ āgametvā puna tesu ānīyamānesu itare pakkamiṃsu, evaṃ punappunaṃ ānayanena sannipāto cireneva ahosi, thero ca tadā ekavihārī ahosi. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘tīṇi vassāni gaṇaṃ pariyesitvā’’ti. Tīṇi vassānīti ca accantasaṃyoge upayogavacanaṃ. Satthu adhippāyaṃ ñatvāti attano āṇāpaneneva ‘‘iminā saddhiṃ ekagandhakuṭiyaṃ vasitukāmo bhagavā’’ti satthu adhippāyaṃ jānitvā. Bhagavā kira yena saddhiṃ ekagandhakuṭiyaṃ vasitukāmo, tassa senāsanapaññattiyaṃ ānandattheraṃ āṇāpeti. 从索那(Soṇa)出家之日算起,已经过了三年。据说当时比丘(bhikkhu)们大多居住在中土区域(Majjhimadesa),因此在那里的人很少。他们分散在各个村落,或一人或两人这样各自居住。当一些长老比丘被带来时,先前被带来的人因为某些事情离开了;过了一段时间,当另一些人被带来时,先前的人又离开了。这样反复召集,集会过了很久才成功。而长老当时独自居住在一处。因此说:“寻觅僧团三年”。这里的“三年”是表示连续时间的用法。“了知导师之意”是指(阿难)通过(世尊)对自己下的命令,了知了世尊“想与此人同住一间香室(gandhakuṭi)”的意愿。据说世尊如果想和某人同住一间香室,就会命令阿难(Ānanda)长老为那个人安排住处。 Ajjhokāse vītināmetvāti ajjhokāse nisajjāya vītināmetvā. Yasmā bhagavā āyasmato soṇassa samāpattisamāpajjanena paṭisanthāraṃ karonto sāvakasādhāraṇā sabbā samāpattiyo anulomappaṭilomaṃ samāpajjanto bahudeva rattiṃ ajjhokāse nisajjāya vītināmetvā pāde pakkhāletvā vihāraṃ pāvisi, tasmā āyasmāpi soṇo bhagavato adhippāyaṃ ñatvā tadanurūpaṃ sabbā tā samāpattiyo [Pg.167] samāpajjanto bahudeva rattiṃ ajjhokāse nisajjāya vītināmetvā pāde pakkhāletvā vihāraṃ pāvisīti vadanti. Pavisitvā ca bhagavatā anuññāto cīvaratirokaraṇiyaṃ katvā bhagavato pādapasse nisajjāya vītināmesi. Ajjhesīti āṇāpesi. Paṭibhātu taṃ bhikkhu dhammo bhāsitunti bhikkhu tuyhaṃ dhammo bhāsituṃ upaṭṭhātu, ñāṇamukhaṃ āgacchatu, yathāsutaṃ yathāpariyattaṃ dhammaṃ bhaṇāhīti attho. Aṭṭhakavaggiyānīti aṭṭhakavaggabhūtāni kāmasuttādisoḷasasuttāni (mahāni. 1). Suggahitoti sammā uggahito. Sabbe vare yācīti vinayadharapañcamena gaṇena upasampadā dhuvanhānaṃ cammattharaṇaṃ gaṇaṅgaṇūpāhanaṃ cīvaravippavāsoti ime pañca vare yāci. Sutte āgatamevāti udānapāḷiyaṃ āgatasuttaṃ sandhāya vadati. “在露天处度过”,即在露天处坐着度过。因为世尊(bhagavā)为接待具寿(āyasmā)索那(Soṇa),以进入等至的方式,顺逆出入所有声闻共通的等至,在露天处坐着度过了大半夜,洗足后进入精舍。因此,据说具寿索那也了知世尊之意,做了相应之事,进入所有那些等至,在露天处坐着度过了大半夜,洗足后进入精舍。进入后,得世尊允许,以衣作屏(cīvaratirokaraṇiyaṃ),在世尊足边坐着度过。“请求”(Ajjhesi)即是命令。“比丘,愿你善说于法”(Paṭibhātu taṃ bhikkhu dhammo bhāsituṃ),意即:比丘,愿你生起说法之念,智慧之门开启,请如所闻、如所学而说法。“义品”(Aṭṭhakavaggiyāni)即是义品中的《欲经》(Kāmasutta)等十六经。“善受持”(Suggahito)即正确受持。“请求所有愿”(Sabbe vare yāci)即请求五种特许:以持律者为第五人的僧团行具足戒(upasampadā)、常沐浴、皮革铺垫、多带凉鞋、衣物离身。“如经中所来”(Sutte āgatameva)是指《自说经》(Udāna)中的经文。 Sīvalittheravatthu 西瓦离长老的故事 207. Navame sākacchitvā sākacchitvāti raññā saddhiṃ paṭivirujjhanavasena punappunaṃ sākacchaṃ katvā. Guḷadadhinti patthinnaṃ guḷasadisaṃ kaṭhinadadhiṃ. Atiañchitunti ativiya ākaḍḍhituṃ. Kañjiyaṃ vāhetvāti dadhimatthuṃ pavāhetvā, parissāvetvāti attho. ‘‘Dadhito kañjiyaṃ gahetvā’’tipi pāṭho. Nanti suppavāsaṃ. Bījapacchiṃ phusāpentīti iminā sambandho. Yāva na ukkaḍḍhantīti yāva dāne na ukkaḍḍhanti, dātukāmāva hontīti adhippāyo mahādukkhaṃ anubhosīti pasavanibandhanaṃ mahantaṃ dukkhaṃ anubhosi. Sāmikaṃ āmantetvāti sattāhaṃ mūḷhagabbhā tibbāhi kharāhi dukkhavedanāhi phuṭṭhā ‘‘sammāsambuddho vata so bhagavā, yo imassa evarūpassa dukkhassa pahānāya dhammaṃ deseti. Suppaṭipanno vata tassa bhagavato sāvakasaṅgho, yo imassa evarūpassa dukkhassa pahānāya paṭipanno. Susukhaṃ vata nibbānaṃ, yatthidaṃ evarūpaṃ dukkhaṃ na saṃvijjatī’’ti (udā. 18) imehi tīhi vitakkehi taṃ dukkhaṃ adhivāsentī satthu santikaṃ pesetukāmatāya sāmikaṃ āmantetvā. Pure maraṇāti maraṇato puretarameva. Iṅgitanti ākāraṃ. Jīvitabhattanti jīvitasaṃsaye dātabbabhattaṃ. Sabbakammakkhamo ahosīti sattavassikehi dārakehi kātabbaṃ yaṃ kiñci kammaṃ kātuṃ samatthatāya sabbassa kammassa khamo ahosi. Teneva so sattāhaṃ mahādāne [Pg.168] dīyamāne jātadivasato paṭṭhāya dhammakaraṇaṃ ādāya saṅghassa udakaṃ parissāvetvā adāsi. 207. 第九:“反复商议”,即因与国王意见相左而再三商议。“糖凝乳”,即如糖块般坚硬的凝乳。“过度拉扯”,即过度地拉扯。“滤去酸酪浆”,即排去凝乳的乳清,意为过滤。亦有读作“从凝乳中取出酸酪浆”。“彼”,即指善生(Suppavāsa)。“触碰种子袋”,与此相关联。“直至未被取走”,即指直至布施时未被取走,意为想要布施。“承受极大痛苦”,即承受分娩所带来的巨大痛苦。“召唤丈夫后”,即她怀滞胎七日,被剧烈而粗重的痛苦感受所折磨时,思惟:“那位世尊(bhagavā)真是正等觉者,他宣说正法是为了断除这种痛苦。那位世尊的声闻僧团真是善行者,他们为了断除这种痛苦而修行。涅槃真是安乐,那里没有这种痛苦。”(参考《自说经》18)她以这三种思惟忍受着痛苦,想要派人去导师那里,因而召唤了丈夫。“临终前”,即在死亡之前。“表示”,即指样貌。“活命食”,即在生命危急时刻应给予的食物。“能胜任一切工作”,即能够做七岁孩童所能做的任何事情,所以能胜任所有工作。因此,在这七天的大布施中,他从出生那天起就拿着滤水囊,为僧团过滤水并供养。 Yomantiādigāthāya ‘‘yo bhikkhu imaṃ rāgapalipathañceva kilesaduggañca saṃsāravaṭṭañca catunnaṃ saccānaṃ appaṭivijjhanakamohañca atīto cattāro oghe tiṇṇo hutvā pāraṃ anuppatto, duvidhena jhānena jhāyī, taṇhāya abhāvena anejo, kathaṃkathāya abhāvena akathaṃkathī, upādānānaṃ abhāvena anupādiyitvā kilesanibbānena nibbuto, tamahaṃ brāhmaṇaṃ vadāmī’’ti attho. “超越者”等偈颂的意义是:“若有比丘已超越贪欲的泥沼、烦恼的险路、轮回的流转以及对四圣谛不通达的愚痴,渡过四暴流而抵达彼岸,以二种禅而禅修,因无渴爱而无所动摇,因无疑惑而无疑,因无执取而不执取,以烦恼的寂灭而涅槃,我称他为婆罗门。” Sabbesaṃyeva pana kesānaṃ oropanañca arahattasacchikiriyā ca apacchāapurimā ahosīti iminā therassa khuraggeyeva arahattuppatti dīpitā. Ekacce pana ācariyā evaṃ vadanti ‘‘heṭṭhā vuttanayena dhammasenāpatinā ovāde dinne ‘yaṃ mayā kātuṃ sakkā, tamahaṃ jānissāmī’ti pabbajitvā vipassanākammaṭṭhānaṃ gahetvā taṃ divasaṃyeva aññataraṃ vicittaṃ kuṭikaṃ disvā pavisitvā mātukucchiyaṃ satta vassāni attanā anubhūtadukkhaṃ anussaritvā tadanusārena atītānāgate ñāṇaṃ nentassa ādittā viya tayo bhavā upaṭṭhahiṃsu. Ñāṇassa paripākaṃ gatattā vipassanāvīthiṃ otaritvā tāvadeva maggappaṭipāṭiyā sabbepi āsave khepento arahattaṃ pāpuṇī’’ti. Ubhayathāpi therassa arahattuppattiyeva pakāsitā, thero pana pabhinnappaṭisambhido chaḷabhiñño ahosi. 然所有头发的剃除与阿罗汉果的证悟,并非先后发生。此言表明长老在剃刀触及发梢时即证得阿罗汉果。另有一些阿阇梨说:“法将(dhammasenāpati)依前述方式教导后,(他心想)‘我能做到的事,我将了知’,于是出家,领受观(vipassanā)业处。当天看见一座奇异的孤邸(kuṭi),进入后忆念自己在母胎中七年所感受的痛苦,并依此将智导向过去和未来,三有(bhava)如燃火般显现。由于智已成熟,他进入观之道,立即依道之次第,灭尽一切漏(āsava),证得阿罗汉果。”两种说法都阐明了长老证得阿罗汉果,而长老是已得无碍解(paṭisambhidā)、具足六神通(abhiññā)者。 Vakkalittheravatthu 瓦咖利长老的故事 208. Dasame āhārakaraṇavelanti bhojanakiccavelaṃ. Adhigacche padaṃ santanti saṅkhārūpasamaṃ sukhanti laddhanāmaṃ santaṃ padaṃ nibbānaṃ adhigaccheyya. Paṭhamapādena pabbate ṭhitoyevāti paṭhamena pādena gijjhakūṭe pabbate ṭhitoyeva. Sesamettha suviññeyyameva. 208. 第十:“食事时”,即进食的时间。“得至寂静处”,即证得名为“诸行止息,乐”的寂静处——涅槃。“以第一句‘立于山’而言”,即立于鹫峰山(Gijjhakūṭa)上。其余的在此都易于了知。 Dutiyaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 第二最胜品释义终。 14. Etadaggavaggo 14. 最胜品 (14) 3. Tatiyaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā (14) 3. 第三最胜品释义 Rāhula-raṭṭhapālattheravatthu 罗睺罗与护国长老的故事 209-210. Tatiyassa [Pg.169] paṭhamadutiyesu tisso sikkhāti adhisīlaadhicittaadhipaññāsaṅkhātā tisso sikkhā. Cuddasa bhattacchede katvāti sattāhaṃ nirāhāratāya ekekasmiṃ divase dvinnaṃ bhattacchedānaṃ vasena cuddasa bhattacchede katvā. 209-210. 第三品第一、二颂中的“三学”是指增上戒学(adhisīla)、增上心学(adhicitta)、增上慧学(adhipaññā)这三学。“作十四餐之断”,即七天不食,以每日断二餐的方式,作了十四餐之断。 Tesanti tesaṃ tāpasānaṃ. Lābubhājanādiparikkhāraṃ saṃvidhāyāti lābubhājanāditāpasaparikkhāraṃ saṃvidahitvā. Sapariḷāhakāyadhātukoti ussannapittatāya sapariḷāhakāyasabhāvo. Satasahassāti satasahassaparimāṇā. Satasahassaṃ parimāṇaṃ etesanti satasahassā uttarapadalopena yathā ‘‘rūpabhavo rūpa’’nti, atthiatthe vā akārapaccayo daṭṭhabbo. Pāṇātipātādiakusaladhammasamudācārasaṅkhāto āmagandho kuṇapagandho natthi etesanti nirāmagandhā, yathāvuttakilesasamudācārarahitāti attho. Kilesasamudācāro hettha ‘‘āmagandho’’ti vutto. Kiṃkāraṇā? Amanuññattā, kilesaasucimissattā, sabbhi jigucchitattā, paramaduggandhabhāvavahattā ca. Tathā hi ye ye ussannakilesā sattā, te te atiduggandhā honti. Teneva nikkilesānaṃ matasarīrampi duggandhaṃ na hoti. Dānaggaparivahanaketi dānaggadhuravahanake. Māpakoti divase divase parimitaparibbayadānavasena dhaññamāpako. “他们”,即指那些苦行者(tāpasa)。“准备葫芦钵等资具后”,即备妥葫芦钵等苦行者所需的资具。“身体有热恼者”,即因胆汁过盛而身体有热恼。“十万”,即数量为十万。“其数为十万”,如“色有是色”般省略了后半部分,或应视为在‘有’的意义上加了‘a’的后缀。“他们没有杀生等不善法行所构成的腥臭或尸臭”,故为“无腥臭者”,意即远离了所说的烦恼之行。此处的“腥臭”即指烦恼之行。是何原因?因其不可喜、与烦恼不净相杂、为善士所厌恶,且带来极度的恶臭。诚然,凡是烦恼炽盛的有情,都极其腥臭。因此,无烦恼者的尸身亦无臭味。“布施的承担者”,即承担布施重任者。“量者”,即每日以有限的费用布施谷物者。 Pāḷiyanti vinayapāḷiyaṃ. Migajātakaṃ āharitvā kathesīti atīte kira bodhisatto migayoniyaṃ nibbattitvā migagaṇaparivuto araññe vasati. Athassa bhaginī attano puttakaṃ upanetvā ‘‘bhātika imaṃ bhāgineyyaṃ migamāyaṃ sikkhāpehī’’ti āha. Bodhisatto ‘‘sādhū’’ti paṭissuṇitvā ‘‘gaccha tāta, asukavelāyaṃ nāma āgantvā sikkheyyāsī’’ti āha. So mātulena vuttavelaṃ anatikkamitvā taṃ upasaṅkamitvā migamāyaṃ sikkhi. So ekadivasaṃ vane vicaranto pāsena baddho baddharavaṃ viravi. Migagaṇo palāyitvā ‘‘putto te pāsena baddho’’ti tassa mātuyā ārocesi. Sā bhātu santikaṃ gantvā ‘‘bhātika bhāgineyyo [Pg.170] te migamāyaṃ sikkhāpito’’ti pucchi. Bodhisatto ‘‘mā tvaṃ puttassa kiñci pāpakaṃ āsaṅki, suggahitā tena migamāyā, idāni taṃ hāsayamāno āgacchissatī’’ti vatvā ‘‘migaṃ tipallattha’’ntiādimāha. “在圣典中”,即在律藏(Vinayapiṭaka)中。“讲述鹿本生”,即:据说,过去菩萨投生为鹿,为鹿群围绕,住在森林里。当时他的妹妹带着自己的儿子来对他说:“兄长,请教我的这个外甥鹿的幻术。”菩萨应诺:“善哉”,然后对外甥说:“孩子,你可在某时前来学习。”他没有错过舅舅所说的时间,前去学习了鹿的幻术。有一天,他在林中游荡时,被陷阱困住,发出了被缚的哀鸣。鹿群逃散,并告诉他的母亲:“你的儿子被陷阱困住了。”她来到兄长那里问道:“兄长,你的外甥是否已受教鹿的幻术?”菩萨说:“你不要为儿子担心任何不幸,他已善学鹿的幻术,现在他正戏耍着回来呢。”于是说了“鹿三颠”等偈。 Tattha miganti bhāgineyyamigaṃ. Tipallatthaṃ vuccati sayanaṃ, ubhohi passehi ujukameva ca nipannakavasena tīhākārehi pallatthaṃ assa, tīṇi vā pallatthāni assāti tipallattho, taṃ tipallatthaṃ. Anekamāyanti bahumāyaṃ bahuvañcanaṃ. Aṭṭhakkhuranti ekekasmiṃ pāde dvinnaṃ dvinnaṃ vasena aṭṭhahi khurehi samannāgataṃ. Aḍḍharattāpapāyinti purimayāmaṃ atikkamitvā majjhimayāme araññato āgamma pānīyassa pivanato aḍḍharatte āpaṃ pivatīti aḍḍharattāpapāyī. ‘‘Aḍḍharatte āpapāyi’’ntipi pāṭho. Mama bhāgineyyaṃ migaṃ ahaṃ sādhukaṃ migamāyaṃ uggaṇhāpesiṃ. Kathaṃ? Yathā ekena sotena chamāyaṃ assasanto chahi kalāhi atibhoti bhāgineyyo. Idaṃ vuttaṃ hoti – ayañhi tava puttaṃ tathā uggaṇhāpesiṃ, yathā ekasmiṃ uparimanāsikāsote vātaṃ sannirumbhitvā pathaviyaṃ allīnena ekena heṭṭhimanāsikāsotena tatheva chamāyaṃ assasanto chahi kalāhi luddakaṃ atibhoti, chahi koṭṭhāsehi ajjhottharati vañcetīti attho. Katamehi chahi? Cattāro pāde pasāretvā ekena passena seyyāya, khurehi tiṇapaṃsukhaṇanena, jivhāninnāmanena, udarassa uddhumātabhāvakaraṇena, uccārapassāvavissajjanena, vātassa nirumbhanenāti. Atha vā tathā naṃ uggaṇhāpesiṃ, yathā ekena sotena chamāyaṃ assasanto. Chahīti heṭṭhā vuttehi chahi kāraṇehi. Kalāhīti kalāyissati, luddakaṃ vañcessatīti attho. Bhotīti bhaginiṃ ālapati. Bhāgineyyoti evaṃ chahi kāraṇehi vañcakaṃ bhāgineyyaṃ niddisati. 此处“鹿”,是指外甥鹿。“三卧”,是指其卧姿,因其从两侧及正直躺卧,有三种姿态,或有三处卧处,故称“三卧”。“多诈”,即指多诡计、多欺骗。“八蹄”,即指每足有二蹄,具足八蹄。“半夜饮水”,即指它过了初夜,于中夜时分从森林里回来喝水,所以叫做“半夜饮水者”。也有读作“半夜饮水”。我曾好好教导外甥鹿学习鹿的诡计。如何教导呢?就像它用一个鼻孔在地上呼吸时,能用六种技巧胜过。这就是说,我这样教导你的孩子,让他堵住上面的鼻孔,用贴着地面的下面的鼻孔呼吸,同样在地上呼吸,就能用六种技巧胜过猎人,用六个部分全面欺骗他。是哪六种呢?伸开四肢侧卧,用蹄子挖掘草和土,垂下舌头,鼓胀肚子,排泄大小便,以及屏住呼吸。或者说,我这样教导他,就像用一个鼻孔在地上呼吸时,就能用六种技巧——即前面所说的六种方法。“技巧”,即指它能施展技巧,欺骗猎人。“贤妹”,是称呼姐妹。“外甥”,就是指用这六种方法欺骗人的外甥。 Evaṃ bodhisatto bhāgineyyassa migamāyaṃ sādhukaṃ uggahitabhāvaṃ vadanto bhaginiṃ samassāsesi. Sopi migapotako pāse baddho anibandhitvāyeva bhūmiyaṃ mahāphāsukapassena pāde pasāretvā nipanno pādānaṃ āsannaṭṭhāne khurehi eva paharitvā paṃsuñca tiṇāni ca uppāṭetvā uccārapassāvaṃ vissajjetvā sīsaṃ pātetvā jivhaṃ ninnāmetvā sarīraṃ kheḷakilinnaṃ katvā vātaggahaṇena udaraṃ uddhumātakaṃ katvā akkhīni parivattetvā heṭṭhānāsikāsotena vātaṃ sañcarāpento uparimanāsikāsotena [Pg.171] vātaṃ sannirumbhitvā sakalasarīraṃ thaddhabhāvaṃ gāhāpetvā matakākāraṃ dassesi, nīlamakkhikāpi naṃ samparivāresuṃ, tasmiṃ tasmiṃ ṭhāne kākā nilīyiṃsu. Luddo āgantvā udare hatthena paharitvā ‘‘pātova baddho bhavissati, pūtiko jāto’’ti tassa bandhanarajjuṃ mocetvā ‘‘ettheva dāni naṃ ukkantitvā maṃsaṃ ādāya gamissāmī’’ti nirāsaṅko hutvā sākhāpalāsaṃ gahetuṃ āraddho. Migapotakopi uṭṭhāya catūhi pādehi ṭhatvā kāyaṃ vidhunitvā gīvaṃ pasāretvā mahāvātena chinnavalāhako viya vegena mātu santikaṃ agamāsi. Satthā ‘‘na, bhikkhave, rāhulo idāneva sikkhākāmo, pubbepi sikkhākāmoyevā’’ti evaṃ migajātakaṃ āharitvā kathesi. 菩萨如此说明外甥已善学鹿的诡计后,便安慰其妹。那只小鹿被陷阱套住,却不挣扎,它四肢舒展,安适地躺在地上,用蹄子刨着靠近脚的地方,扬起尘土和草,排出大小便,垂下头,伸出舌头,屏住呼吸使腹部鼓起,转动眼睛,用下鼻孔出气,闭塞上鼻孔,让整个身体变得僵硬,装出一副死去的模样。苍蝇也围了上来,乌鸦也停落在各处。猎人走来用手拍打它的肚子,说:“想必是早上被套住的,已经腐臭了。”于是解开束缚它的绳子,心想:“就在这里把它切开,拿走肉回去。”便毫无戒备地去拾取树枝树叶。小鹿立刻起身,用四条腿站立,抖动身体,伸长脖子,像被狂风吹散的乌云一样快速地跑到母亲身边。导师说:“诸比丘,罗睺罗不是现在才乐于学习,过去也是如此。”于是讲述了这个鹿本生故事。 Ambalaṭṭhiyarāhulovādaṃ desesīti ‘‘passasi no tvaṃ, rāhula, imaṃ parittaṃ udakāvasesaṃ udakādāne ṭhapitanti? Evaṃ, bhante. Evaṃ parittakaṃ kho, rāhula, tesaṃ sāmaññaṃ, yesaṃ natthi sampajānamusāvāde lajjā’’ti evamādinā ambalaṭṭhiyarāhulovādaṃ (ma. ni. 2.107 ādayo) kathesi. Gehasitaṃ vitakkaṃ vitakkentassāti āyasmā kira rāhulo bhagavato piṭṭhito piṭṭhito gacchantova pādatalato yāva upari kesantā tathāgataṃ olokesi, so bhagavato buddhavesavilāsaṃ disvā ‘‘sobhati bhagavā dvattiṃsamahāpurisalakkhaṇavicittasarīro byāmappabhāparikkhittatāya vippakiṇṇasuvaṇṇacuṇṇamajjhagato viya vijjulatāparikkhitto kanakapabbato viya yantasamākaḍḍhitaratanavicittasuvaṇṇaagghikaṃ viya paṃsukūlacīvarappaṭicchannopi rattakambalaparikkhittakanakapabbato viya pavāḷalatāpaṭimaṇḍitasuvaṇṇaghaṭikaṃ viya cīnapiṭṭhacuṇṇapūjitasuvaṇṇacetiyaṃ viya lākhārasānulitto kanakathūpo viya rattavalāhakantaragato taṅkhaṇamuggatapuṇṇacando viya aho samatiṃsapāramitānubhāvena sajjitassa attabhāvassa sirisampattī’’ti cintesi. Tato attānampi oloketvā ‘‘ahampi sobhāmi, sace bhagavā catūsu mahādīpesu cakkavattirajjaṃ akarissa, mayhaṃ pariṇāyakaṭṭhānantaramadassa, evaṃ sante ativiya jambudīpatalaṃ atisobhissā’’ti attabhāvaṃ nissāya gehasitaṃ chandarāgaṃ uppādesi. Taṃ sandhāyetaṃ vuttaṃ – ‘‘satthu ceva attano ca rūpasampattiṃ disvā gehasitaṃ vitakkaṃ vitakkentassā’’ti. 在《芒果树苗林教诫罗睺罗经》(Ambalaṭṭhiyarāhulovāda)中,世尊这样开示:“罗睺罗,你看到这水器里剩下的这一点水了吗?”“是的,世尊。”“罗睺罗,那些明知故犯说谎而不感到羞耻的人,他们的沙门性就像这般稀少。”世尊以这样的方式讲述了《芒果树苗林教诫罗睺罗经》。至于“思索与在家相关的思绪”这一句:据说具寿罗睺罗跟随在世尊身后,从脚底到头顶都在观察如来。他看到世尊的佛陀庄严相,心想:“世尊多么庄严啊!他身体由三十二大士相所庄严,为一寻光所围绕,犹如处于遍撒的金粉之中,又如为闪电所环绕的金山,犹如精工打造、饰以众宝的黄金供器,即使穿着粪扫衣也像被红毯覆盖的金山,如同用珊瑚藤装饰的黄金宝瓶,像用细粉供奉的黄金塔庙,又如涂了紫胶的黄金窣堵波,就像在红云中即刻升起的满月。啊!这是圆满三十波罗蜜的威力所成就的自身荣耀啊!”然后他又观察自己,心想:“我也很庄严,如果世尊在四大洲成为转轮圣王,就会把统领之位传给我,那样的话,整个瞻部洲都将更加光辉灿烂!”于是他因为依恋自身而生起了与在家相关的贪欲。此即所谓“看见导师和自己的色相庄严而生起与在家相关的思绪”。 Bhagavāpi [Pg.172] purato gacchantova cintesi – ‘‘paripuṇṇacchavimaṃsalohito dāni rāhulassa attabhāvo, rajanīyesu rūpārammaṇādīsu cittassa pakkhandanakālo jāto, nipphalatāya nu kho rāhulo vītināmetī’’ti. Atha sahāvajjaneneva pasanne udake macchaṃ viya parisuddhe ādāsamaṇḍale mukhanimittaṃ viya ca tassa taṃ cittuppādaṃ addasa, disvā ca ‘‘ayaṃ rāhulo mayhaṃ atrajo hutvā mama pacchato āgacchanto ‘ahaṃ sobhāmi, mayhaṃ vaṇṇāyatanaṃ pasanna’nti attabhāvaṃ nissāya gehasitaṃ chandarāgaṃ uppādeti, atitthe pakkhando, uppathaṃ paṭipanno, agocare carati, disāmūḷhaaddhiko viya agantabbaṃ disaṃ gacchati, ayaṃ kho panassa kileso abbhantare vaḍḍhanto attatthampi yathābhūtaṃ passituṃ na dassissati paratthampi ubhayatthampi, tato nirayepi paṭisandhiṃ gaṇhāpessati, tiracchānayoniyampi pettivisayepi asurakāyepi sambādhepi mātukucchisminti anamatagge saṃsāravaṭṭe paripātessati. Yathā kho pana anekaratanapūrā mahānāvā bhinnaphalakantarena udakaṃ ādiyamānā muhuttampi na ajjhupekkhitabbā hoti, vegena vegenassā vivaraṃ pidahituṃ vaṭṭati, evameva ayampi na ajjhupekkhitabbo. Yāvassa ayaṃ kileso abbhantare sīlaratanādīni na vināseti, tāvadeva naṃ niggaṇhissāmī’’ti ajjhāsayaṃ akāsi. Tato rāhulaṃ āmantetvā ‘‘yaṃ kiñci, rāhula, rūpaṃ atītānāgatapaccuppannaṃ ajjhattaṃ vā bahiddhā vā oḷārikaṃ vā sukhumaṃ vā hīnaṃ vā paṇītaṃ vā yaṃ dūre santike vā, sabbaṃ rūpaṃ ‘netaṃ mama, nesohamasmi, na meso attā’ti evametaṃ yathābhūtaṃ sammappaññāya daṭṭhabbanti. Rūpameva nu kho bhagavā rūpameva nu kho sugatāti. Rūpampi rāhula, vedanāpi rāhula, saññāpi rāhula, saṅkhārāpi rāhula, viññāṇampi rāhulā’’ti mahārāhulovādasuttaṃ (ma. ni. 2.113 ādayo) abhāsi. Taṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘yaṃ kiñci rāhula…pe… kathesī’’ti vuttaṃ. 世尊在前行时心想:“罗睺罗如今身体圆满,血肉充盈,正是心对能染污的色等境生起执著的时期,他是否会虚度此生呢?”世尊一思惟,便立刻察觉到罗睺罗的心念,如同在清澈的水中看见鱼,如同在明亮的镜子里看见自己的面容一般。察觉到之后,世尊思惟:“这罗睺罗作为我的儿子,却跟随在我身后,生起‘我仪容美好,我的外貌令人愉悦’的念头,依仗着自身而生起对世俗的贪欲。就像涉入不当之处,走上歧途,在非行境中行走,像迷失方向的旅人走向不该去的方向。这种烦恼在他内心增长,将使他无法如实地看待自身和他人的利益,乃至会导致他投生到地狱、畜生、饿鬼、阿修罗道,乃至在无始的轮回中,甚至在狭窄的母胎中,一次又一次地投生。就像一艘装满各种珍宝的大船,一旦船板破裂渗水,就片刻也不能耽搁,必须尽快堵住漏洞一样,罗睺罗的情况也是如此,不可放任不管。在他内心的烦恼摧毁戒律等珍宝之前,我必须制止他。”于是世尊下定决心。之后,世尊呼唤罗睺罗,告诉他:“罗睺罗,无论是过去、未来、现在的色,内在的或外在的,粗糙的或细腻的,低劣的或殊胜的,遥远的或近处的,所有的色,都应当以正慧如实地观察:‘这不是我的,我不是它,它不是我的自体。’”罗睺罗问道:“世尊,仅仅是色吗?善逝,仅仅是色吗?”世尊回答:“罗睺罗,色也是如此;罗睺罗,受也是如此;罗睺罗,想也是如此;罗睺罗,行也是如此;罗睺罗,识也是如此。”这就是《大教诫罗睺罗经》(中部2.113等)所说的。为了说明这个道理,所以说“凡罗睺罗……所说”等等。 Saṃyuttake pana rāhulovādoti rāhulasaṃyutte vuttarāhulovādaṃ sandhāya vadanti. Tattha ‘‘sādhu me, bhante, bhagavā saṃkhittena dhammaṃ desetu, yamahaṃ, bhante, bhagavato dhammaṃ sutvā eko vūpakaṭṭho appamatto ātāpī pahitatto vihareyya’’nti therena yācito ‘‘taṃ kiṃ maññasi, rāhula, cakkhu niccaṃ vā aniccaṃ vāti? Aniccaṃ, bhante. Yaṃ panāniccaṃ[Pg.173], dukkhaṃ vā taṃ sukhaṃ vāti? Dukkhaṃ, bhante. Yaṃ panāniccaṃ dukkhaṃ vipariṇāmadhammaṃ, kallaṃ nu taṃ samanupassituṃ ‘etaṃ mama, esohamasmi, eso me attā’’’tiādinā rāhulovādaṃ (saṃ. ni. 2.188 ādayo) ārabhi. Therassa vipassanācāroyeva, na pana mahārāhulovādo viya vitakkūpacchedāya vuttoti adhippāyo. 然而在相应部中,所谓“罗睺罗教诫”是指罗睺罗相应中所说的罗睺罗教诫。当时长老请求说:“世尊,请世尊为我简略说法,我听闻世尊的法后,能够独自远离,不放逸,精勤热忱地修行。”长老请求后,世尊便问道:“罗睺罗,你认为如何?眼睛是常还是无常呢?”“是无常的,世尊。”“凡是无常的,是苦还是乐呢?”“是苦的,世尊。”“凡是无常、是苦、是变易之法,适合认为‘这是我的,我是这个,这是我的自体’吗?”等等,由此开始了罗睺罗教诫(相应部2.188等)。这仅仅是长老的观修教导,不像《大教诫罗睺罗经》那样是为了止息寻思而说的,这是(此处的)意图。 Athassa satthā ñāṇaparipākaṃ ñatvātiādīsu bhagavato kira rahogatassa paṭisallīnassa evaṃ cetaso parivitakko udapādi ‘‘paripakkā kho rāhulassa vimuttiparipācanīyā dhammā, yannūnāhaṃ rāhulaṃ uttari āsavānaṃ khaye vineyya’’nti? Athassa bhagavā pubbaṇhasamayaṃ nivāsetvā pattacīvaramādāya sāvatthiyaṃ piṇḍāya caritvā pacchābhattaṃ piṇḍapātapaṭikkanto āyasmantaṃ rāhulaṃ āmantesi – ‘‘gaṇhāhi, rāhula, nisīdanaṃ, yena andhavanaṃ tenupasaṅkamissāma divāvihārāyā’’ti. ‘‘Evaṃ, bhante’’ti kho āyasmā rāhulo bhagavato paṭissutvā nisīdanaṃ ādāya bhagavato piṭṭhito piṭṭhito anubandhi. Tena kho pana samayena anekāni devatāsahassāni bhagavantaṃ abhivanditvā anubandhitā honti ‘‘ajja bhagavā āyasmantaṃ rāhulaṃ uttari āsavānaṃ khaye vinessatī’’ti. Atha kho bhagavā andhavanaṃ ajjhogāhetvā aññatarasmiṃ rukkhamūle paññatte āsane nisīdi. Āyasmāpi rāhulo bhagavantaṃ abhivādetvā ekamantaṃ nisīdi. Atha āyasmantaṃ rāhulaṃ āmantetvā ‘‘taṃ kiṃ maññasi, rāhula, cakkhu niccaṃ vā aniccaṃ vāti? Aniccaṃ, bhante. Yaṃ panāniccaṃ, dukkhaṃ vā taṃ sukhaṃ vāti? Dukkhaṃ, bhante. Yaṃ panāniccaṃ dukkhaṃ vipariṇāmadhammaṃ, kallaṃ nu taṃ samanupassituṃ ‘etaṃ mama, esohamasmi, eso me attā’’’tiādinā rāhulovādaṃ (saṃ. ni. 4.121) adāsi. Taṃ sandhāyetaṃ vuttaṃ – ‘‘andhavane nisinno cūḷarāhulovādaṃ kathesī’’ti. 那时,世尊知道罗睺罗的智慧已成熟,据说世尊在隐退独处时,心中生起这样的思绪:“罗睺罗的解脱因缘已成熟,我何不进一步教导罗睺罗,使他灭尽诸漏呢?”于是世尊在上午着衣持衣钵,前往舍卫城(Sāvatthī)乞食。饭食完毕,从乞食归来,世尊对具寿罗睺罗说:“罗睺罗,拿上坐具,我们去盲林作日间住。”“是的,世尊。”具寿罗睺罗答应世尊后,拿着坐具紧随世尊其后。那时,有数千天神礼拜世尊后也跟随着,心想:“今天世尊将引导具寿罗睺罗灭尽诸漏。”随后世尊进入盲林,在一棵树下敷设好的座位上坐下。具寿罗睺罗也礼拜世尊后,坐于一旁。然后世尊对具寿罗睺罗说:“你意下如何,罗睺罗,眼是常还是无常?”“是无常,世尊。”“凡是无常的,是苦还是乐?”“是苦,世尊。”“凡是无常、苦、变易之法,适合认为‘这是我的,我是这个,这是我的自体’吗?”等等,给予了罗睺罗教诫(《相应部》4.121)。鉴于此,才说:“坐在盲林中,宣说小罗睺罗教诫。” Koṭisatasahassadevatāhīti āyasmatā rāhulena padumuttarassa bhagavato pādamūle pathavindhararājakāle patthanaṃ ṭhapentena saddhiṃ patthanaṃ ṭhapitadevatāyevetā. Tāsu pana kāci bhūmaṭṭhadevatā, kāci antalikkhaṭṭhakā, kāci cātumahārājikādidevaloke, kāci brahmaloke nibbattā, imasmiṃ pana divase sabbā ekaṭṭhāne andhavanasmiṃyeva sannipatitā. 与具寿罗睺罗在莲花上佛(Padumuttara)世尊足下、在持地王时期发愿时,一同发愿的天神就是这百千俱胝位。在这些天神中,有些是地居天神,有些是空居天神,有些是四大天王等天界的天神,有些是生于梵天界的天神。然而,在今天,所有天神都聚集在同一个地方,即盲林。 Ābhidosikanti [Pg.174] pārivāsikaṃ ekarattātikkantaṃ pūtibhūtaṃ. Ekarattātikkantasseva hi nāmasaññā esā, yadidaṃ ābhidosikoti. Ayaṃ panettha vacanattho – pūtibhāvadosena abhibhūtoti abhidoso, abhidosoyeva ābhidosiko. Kummāsanti yavakummāsaṃ. Adhivāsetvāti ‘‘tena hi, tāta raṭṭhapāla, adhivāsehi svātanāya bhatta’’nti pitarā nimantito svātanāya bhikkhaṃ adhivāsetvā. Ettha ca thero pakatiyā ukkaṭṭhasapadānacāriko svātanāya bhikkhaṃ nāma nādhivāseti, mātu anuggahena pana adhivāseti. Mātu kirassa theraṃ anussaritvā anussaritvā mahāsoko uppajjati, rodaneneva dukkhī viya jātā, tasmā thero ‘‘sacāhaṃ taṃ apassitvā gamissāmi, hadayampissā phaleyyā’’ti anuggahena adhivāsesi. Paṇḍitā hi bhikkhū mātāpitūnaṃ ācariyupajjhāyānaṃ vā kātabbaṃ anuggahaṃ ajjhupekkhitvā dhutaṅgasuddhikā na bhavanti. “隔夜馊食”是指过了一夜而变质的食物。所谓“隔夜馊”即是指超过一夜的意思。此处词义为:被腐败变质之过所侵袭的,称为“馊”;“馊”本身即是“隔夜馊”。“粗麦粥”是指大麦粗麦粥。“接受邀请”是指:“那么,护国(Raṭṭhapāla)贤者,请接受明天的斋饭。”被父亲邀请后,长老接受了次日的斋饭。此处,长老本来是精进的次第乞食者,通常不接受次日的斋饭,但出于对母亲的怜悯而接受。原来他的母亲常常思念长老,生起巨大的忧愁,哭泣着,状似痛苦,因此长老心想:“如果我不去看她就离开,她的心会破碎”,故因怜悯而接受邀请。有智慧的比丘,不会为了苦行清净而忽视对父母、阿阇梨或戒师应做的帮助。 Alaṅkatapaṭiyatte itthijaneti pitarā uyyojite itthijane. Pitā kirassa dutiyadivase sakanivesane mahantaṃ hiraññasuvaṇṇassa puñjaṃ kārāpetvā kilañjehi paṭicchādāpetvā āyasmato raṭṭhapālassa purāṇadutiyikāyo ‘‘etha tumhe vadhū, yena alaṅkārena alaṅkatā pubbe raṭṭhapālassa kulaputtassa piyā hotha manāpā, tena alaṅkārena alaṅkarothā’’ti āṇāpetvā paṇītaṃ khādanīyaṃ bhojanīyaṃ paṭiyādāpetvā kāle ārocite āgantvā paññatte āsane nisinnaṃ ‘‘idaṃ te, raṭṭhapāla, mattikaṃ dhanaṃ, aññaṃ pettikaṃ, aññaṃ pitāmahaṃ; sakkā, tāta raṭṭhapāla, bhoge ca bhuñjituṃ, puññāni ca kātuṃ? Ehi tvaṃ, tāta raṭṭhapāla, sikkhaṃ paccakkhāya hīnāyāvattitvā bhoge ca bhuñjassu, puññāni ca karohī’’ti yācitvā tena paṭikkhipitvā dhamme desite ‘‘ahaṃ imaṃ uppabbājessāmī’’ti ānayiṃ, so ‘‘dāni me dhammakathaṃ kātuṃ āraddho, alaṃ me vacanaṃ na karissatī’’ti uṭṭhāya gantvā tassa orodhānaṃ dvāraṃ vivarāpetvā ‘‘ayaṃ vo sāmiko, gacchatha, yaṃ kiñci katvāna gaṇhituṃ vāyamathā’’ti uyyojesi. Tīsu vayesu ṭhitā nāṭakitthiyo theraṃ parivārayiṃsu. Tāsu ayaṃ asubhasaññaṃ uppādesi. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘alaṅkatapaṭiyatte itthijane asubhasaññaṃ uppādetvā’’ti. “装饰妥当的女子们”是指被父亲派遣的女子们。据说,第二天,他的父亲在家中堆积了大量金银,用席垫覆盖,对具寿护国(Raṭṭhapāla)以前的妻子们下令:“来吧,你们这些媳妇,用从前能令护国良家子(kulaputta)喜爱、中意的装饰来打扮自己。”并准备了精美的嚼食(khādanīya)和啖食(bhojanīya),在适时告知。待护国前来,在铺设好的座位上坐下后,父亲说:“护国,这是你母亲的财产,另有父亲的,另有祖父的。亲爱的护国,你既能享受财富,又能积累福德。回来吧,亲爱的护国,舍戒还俗,享受财富,广修福德吧。”他(护国)拒绝了请求,并宣说佛法。父亲心想:“我本想劝他还俗,他现在却开始对我说法了,不会听我的话了。”便起身离开,打开内眷的门,说:“这是你们的主人,去吧,想尽办法争取他!”三种年龄段的舞女们围绕着长老。长老对她们生起不净想。因此说:“对装饰妥当的女子们生起不净想。” Ṭhitakova [Pg.175] dhammaṃ desetvāti – “站着说法”是指: ‘‘Passa cittakataṃ bimbaṃ, arukāyaṃ samussitaṃ; Āturaṃ bahusaṅkappaṃ, yassa natthi dhuvaṃ ṭhiti. “观此彩绘的形体,疮痍之身,堆积而起;多病多思虑,无有常住。 ‘‘Passa cittakataṃ rūpaṃ, maṇinā kuṇḍalena ca; Aṭṭhiṃ tacena onaddhaṃ, saha vatthehi sobhati. “观此彩绘之色身,以珠宝耳环为饰;骨骼为皮所覆,与衣裳共显其美。 ‘‘Alattakakatā pādā, mukhaṃ cuṇṇakamakkhitaṃ; Alaṃ bālassa mohāya, no ca pāragavesino. “双足染茜草色,面涂粉末;足以迷惑愚者,而非求彼岸者。 ‘‘Aṭṭhāpadakatā kesā, nettā añjanamakkhitā; Alaṃ bālassa mohāya, no ca pāragavesino. “头发编成八股辫,眼涂眼线膏;足以迷惑愚者,而非求彼岸者。 ‘‘Añjanīvaṇṇavā cittā, pūtikāyo alaṅkato; Alaṃ bālassa mohāya, no ca pāragavesino. “犹如新绘的眼线盒,腐朽之身被装饰;足以迷惑愚者,而非求彼岸者。 ‘‘Odahi migavo pāsaṃ, nāsadā vāguraṃ migo; Bhutvā nivāpaṃ gacchāmi, kandante migabandhake’’ti. (ma. ni. 2.302; theragā. 769-774) – “猎人设下罗网,鹿未入陷阱;我已食饵而离去,猎人徒然哭泣。” Imāhi gāthāhi dhammaṃ desetvā. 以这些偈颂说法。 Ākāsaṃ uppatitvāti ākāsaṃ pakkhanditvā. Kasmā pana thero ākāsena gato? Pitā kirassa seṭṭhi sattasu dvārakoṭṭhakesu aggaḷāni dāpetvā malle āṇāpesi ‘‘sace nikkhamitvā gacchati, hatthapādesu naṃ gahetvā kāsāyāni haritvā gihivesaṃ gaṇhāpethā’’ti. Tasmā thero ‘‘ete mādisaṃ mahākhīṇāsavaṃ hatthe vā pāde vā gahetvā apuññaṃ pasaveyyuṃ, taṃ nesaṃ mā ahosī’’ti cintetvā ākāsena agamāsi. Migacīranti evaṃnāmakaṃ uyyānaṃ. Catupārijuññapaṭimaṇḍitanti jarāpārijuññaṃ, byādhipārijuññaṃ, bhogapārijuññaṃ, ñātipārijuññanti imehi catūhi pārijuññehi paṭimaṇḍitaṃ. Pārijuññanti ca parihānīti attho. Sesamettha suviññeyyameva. “腾空而起”即是飞身进入虚空。长老为何要从空中走?据说他的父亲富翁在七重门楼处都上了门闩,并命令力士说:“如果他要出来,就抓住他的手脚,剥掉他的袈裟,让他穿上俗人的衣服!”因此长老心想:“这些人如果抓住像我这样的大漏尽者(阿罗汉)的手或脚,就会造下恶业,不要让他们这样!”作是念已,他就从空中离开了。“鹿苑”(Migacīra)即是名叫鹿苑的园林。“以四种衰败装饰”指的是老衰、病衰、财富衰败、亲属衰败这四种衰败。“衰败”即是衰退的意思。其余部分很容易理解。 Kuṇḍadhānattheravatthu 军荼钵那长老的故事 211. Tatiye salākaṃ gaṇhantīti salākagāhakā. Sunāparantajanapadaṃ gacchantepi paṭhamameva salākaṃ gaṇhīti sambandho. Chabbassantareti channaṃ [Pg.176] vassānaṃ abbhantare. Mettīti mittabhāvo. Bhedake satīti bhedakaraṇe sati. Gumbasabhāgatoti gumbasamīpato, ayameva vā pāṭho. Itthī hutvāti itthī viya hutvā, manussitthivaṇṇaṃ māpetvāti attho. Dīgharattānugatoti dīghakālaṃ anubandho. Ettakaṃ addhānanti ettakaṃ kālaṃ. Handāvusoti gaṇhāvuso. Atthaṃ gahetvāti bhūtatthaṃ gahetvā, ayameva vā pāṭho. Koṇḍo jātoti dhutto jāto. 211. 第三,“拿取筹签者”即是抽签者。即使去到苏那巴兰达(Sunāparanta)国,也是一开始就拿筹签,这是其中的关联。“六年之内”是指六年的时间里。“友谊”是指朋友的状态。“当有离间者时”是指发生离间行为时。“从丛林附近”是指靠近丛林,这或许是另一种读法。“变成女人”是指变得像女人一样,意思是幻化成人间女子的形象。“长期跟随”是指长时间地跟随。“这么长的时间”是指这么久的时期。“来吧,贤友”是指“拿吧,贤友”。“领会了意义”是指领会了真实的意义,这或许是另一种读法。“成了骗子”是指变得狡猾。 Māvoca pharusaṃ kañcīti kañci ekapuggalaṃ pharusaṃ mā avoca. Vuttā paṭivadeyyu tanti tayā pare dussīlāti vuttā tampi tatheva paṭivadeyyuṃ. Dukkhā hi sārambhakathāti esā kāraṇuttarā yugaggāhakathā nāma dukkhā. Paṭidaṇḍā phuseyyu tanti kāyadaṇḍādīhi paraṃ paharantassa tādisāva paṭidaṇḍā tava matthake pateyyuṃ. “不要对任何人说粗恶语”是指不要对任何一个个体说粗恶语。“被说者会反驳你”是指,例如你对别人说“你是破戒者”,他们也会同样地反驳你。“好争辩是痛苦的”是指这种好胜、执拗的言论是痛苦的。“惩罚会还报于你”是指,用身体的惩罚等攻击他人者,同样的惩罚也会落到你的头上。 Sace neresi attānanti sace attānaṃ niccalaṃ kātuṃ sakkhissasi. Kaṃso upahato yathāti mukhavaṭṭiyaṃ chinditvā talamattaṃ katvā ṭhapitaṃ kaṃsatālaṃ viya. Tādisañhi hatthehi pādehi daṇḍena vā pahatampi saddaṃ na karoti. Esa pattosi nibbānanti sace evarūpo bhavituṃ sakkhissasi, imaṃ paṭipadaṃ pūrayamāno eso tvaṃ idāni appattopi nibbānaṃ pattosi nāma. Sārambho te na vijjatīti ‘‘evañca sati tvaṃ dussīlo, ahaṃ susīlo’’ti evamādiko uttarikaraṇavācālakkhaṇo sārambho te na vijjati, na bhavissatiyevāti attho. Parikkilesenāti saṃkilesahetunā. “若你能调伏自己”是指如果你能让自己寂然不动。“犹如破碎的铜锣”是指犹如边缘被切掉、只剩下底部的铜钹。像这样,即使被手、脚或棍棒击打也不会发出声音。“你已证得涅槃”是指如果你能成为这样的人,圆满此道,那么即使你现在尚未证得,也名为已证得涅槃。“你没有争论”是指像“你破戒,我持戒”这类带有争胜言辞特征的争论,你将不会有,也就是将不再存在的意思。“因染污”是指因烦恼。 Vaṅgīsattheravatthu 婆耆舍长老的故事 212. Catutthe sampannapaṭibhānānanti paripuṇṇapaṭibhānānaṃ. Cutiṃ yo vedi…pe… sabbasoti yo sattānaṃ cutiñca paṭisandhiñca sabbākārena pākaṭaṃ katvā jānāti, taṃ ahaṃ alagganatāya asattaṃ, paṭipattiyā suṭṭhu gatattā sugataṃ, catunnaṃ saccānaṃ sambuddhattā buddhaṃ brāhmaṇaṃ vadāmīti attho. Yassa gatinti yassete devādayo gatiṃ na jānanti, tamahaṃ āsavānaṃ khīṇatāya khīṇāsavaṃ, kilesehi ārakattā arahantaṃ brāhmaṇaṃ vadāmīti attho. 212. 第四,“具足辩才者”是指具有圆满辩才的人。“了知……死”……乃至……“一切”是指,谁能以一切方式清楚地了知众生的死亡和再生,我称他为“无著”,因其不执著;称他为“善逝”,因其善于行道;称他为“佛陀”、“婆罗门”,因其觉悟了四圣谛,此即其义。“其趣向”是指,天神等不了知他的趣向,我称他为“漏尽者”,因其诸漏已尽;称他为“阿罗汉”、“婆罗门”,因其远离诸烦恼,此即其义。 Upasenavaṅgantaputtattheravatthu 优波先那·万甘达子长老的故事 213. Pañcame [Pg.177] sabbapāsādikānanti sabbaso pasādaṃ janentānaṃ. Kintāyanti kiṃ te ayaṃ. Atilahunti atisīghaṃ. Yassa tasmiṃ attabhāve uppajjanārahānaṃ maggaphalānaṃ upanissayo natthi, taṃ buddhā ‘‘moghapuriso’’ti vadanti ariṭṭhalāḷudāyiādike viya. Upanissaye satipi tasmiṃ khaṇe magge vā phale vā asati ‘‘moghapurisā’’ti vadantiyeva dhaniyattherādike viya. Imassapi tasmiṃ khaṇe maggaphalānaṃ abhāvato ‘‘moghapurisā’’ti āha, tucchamanussāti attho. Bāhullāyāti parisabāhullāya. Anekapariyāyenāti anekakāraṇena. 213. 第五,“诸威仪具足者”是指能令一切人生起净信者。“何益于你”是指“这对你有什么用呢”。“极轻快”是指非常快速。若人在其自体中,不具备生起道果的近因缘,诸佛就称他为“愚人”,如阿利吒(Ariṭṭha)、愚笨优陀夷(Lāḷudāyī)等人。即使具备近因缘,但若在那一刻没有生起道或果,也仍然称为“愚人”,如达尼亚(Dhaniya)长老等人。因为此人在那一刻没有道果,所以说“愚人”,意思是空虚之人。“因众多”是指因会众众多。“以种种方便”是指以种种原因。 Icchāmahaṃ, bhikkhaveti bhagavā kira taṃ addhamāsaṃ na kañci bodhaneyyasattaṃ addasa, tasmā evamāha, evaṃ santepi tantivasena dhammadesanā kattabbā siyā. Yasmā panassa etadahosi – ‘‘mayi okāsaṃ kāretvā paṭisallīne bhikkhū adhammikaṃ katikavattaṃ karissanti, taṃ upaseno bhindissati, ahaṃ tassa pasīditvā bhikkhūnaṃ dassanaṃ anujānissāmi. Tato maṃ passitukāmā bahū bhikkhū dhutaṅgāni samādiyissanti, ahañca tehi ujjhitasanthatapaccayā sikkhāpadaṃ paññapessāmī’’ti, tasmā evamāha. Therassāti upasenattherassa. Manāpāni te bhikkhu paṃsukūlānīti ‘‘bhikkhu tava imāni paṃsukūlāni manāpāni attano ruciyā khantiyā gahitānī’’ti pucchati. Na kho me, bhante, manāpāni paṃsukūlānīti, bhante, na mayā attano ruciyā khantiyā gahitāni, galaggāhena viya matthakatāḷanena viya ca gāhito mayāti dasseti. Pāḷiyaṃ āgatamevāti vinayapāḷiṃ sandhāya vadati. “诸比丘,我想要……”据说世尊有半个月没有见到任何可教化的有情,因此这样说。即便如此,也应依循教法说法。因为他曾这样想:“若我允许(他们)独住,比丘们将会制定非法的约定,优波先那(Upasena)将会破除它。我因他而心生欢喜,将准许比丘们前来见我。届时,许多想见我的比丘将会受持头陀行,我也会因他们舍弃铺垫卧具而为他们制定学处。”因此这样说。“长老的……”这是指优波先那长老。“比丘,这些粪扫衣合你心意吗?”这是在问:“比丘,这些粪扫衣是你依自己的喜好与意愿而接受的吗?”“尊者,这些粪扫衣并非我所喜好。”这表明:“尊者,这些(粪扫衣)不是我依自己的喜好与意愿而接受的,而是像被扼住喉咙、敲击头顶一般(被迫)接受的。”“‘已见于巴利圣典中’,这是指《律藏》而言。” Dabbattheravatthu 达跋长老事 214. Chaṭṭhe aṭṭhārasasu mahāvihāresūti rājagahassa samantato ṭhitesu aṭṭhārasasu mahāvihāresu. Upavijaññāti āsannapasūtikālā. Rahogatoti rahasi gato. Saṅghassa veyyāvaccakaraṇe kāyaṃ yojetukāmo cintesīti thero kira attano katakiccabhāvaṃ disvā ‘‘ahaṃ imaṃ sarīraṃ dhāremi, tañca kho vātamukhe ṭhitapadīpo viya aniccatāmukhe ṭhitaṃ nacirasseva nibbāyanadhammaṃ yāva [Pg.178] na nibbāyati, tāva kiṃ nu kho ahaṃ saṅghassa veyyāvaccaṃ kareyya’’nti cintento iti paṭisañcikkhati ‘‘tiroraṭṭhesu bahū kulaputtā bhagavantaṃ adisvāva pabbajanti, te ‘bhagavantaṃ passissāma ceva vandissāmā’ti ca dūratopi āgacchanti, tatra yesaṃ senāsanaṃ nappahoti, te silāpattakepi seyyaṃ kappenti. Pahomi kho panāhaṃ attano ānubhāvena tesaṃ tesaṃ kulaputtānaṃ icchāvasena pāsādavihāraaḍḍhayogādīni mañcapīṭhattharaṇāni nimminitvā dātuṃ? Punadivase cettha ekacce ativiya kilantarūpā honti, te gāravena bhikkhūnaṃ purato ṭhatvā bhattānipi na uddisāpenti, ahaṃ kho pana tesaṃ bhattānipi uddisituṃ pahomī’’ti. Iti paṭisañcikkhanto ‘‘yaṃnūnāhaṃ saṅghassa senāsanañca paññapeyyaṃ, bhattāni ca uddiseyya’’nti cintesi. Sabhāgasabhāgānanti suttantikādiguṇavasena sabhāgānaṃ, na mittasanthavavasena. Thero hi yāvatikā suttantikā honti, te uccinitvā uccinitvā ekato tesaṃ anurūpameva senāsanaṃ paññapeti. Venayikābhidhammikakammaṭṭhānikakāyadaḷhibahulesupi eseva nayo. Teneva pāḷiyaṃ (pārā. 380) vuttaṃ – ‘‘yete bhikkhū suttantikā, tesaṃ ekajjhaṃ senāsanaṃ paññapetī’’tiādi. 214. 第六,在王舍城(Rājagaha)周围的十八座大寺院中。“临产”即临近分娩之时。“独处”即去往僻静处。据说,长老想为僧团服务而出力,当他看到自己应做之事已毕,便思惟道:‘我维持此身,而此身犹如风中之灯,立于无常之口,不久即将熄灭。在它熄灭之前,我能为僧团做些什么服务呢?’他如此审察:‘边远地区的许多良家子(kulaputta)未曾见过世尊便已出家,他们为得见世尊、礼拜世尊而远道而来。其中有些人没有住处,便睡在石板上。我能否以自己的神通力,随顺那些良家子的意愿,为他们化现出殿堂、精舍、半圆屋等,并提供床、座、铺垫物呢?次日,其中有些人极为疲惫,因心怀恭敬,站在比丘们面前,甚至无法让人为自己安排食物。而我则能为他们安排食物。’如此审察后,他想:‘我应当为僧团安排住处,并分配食物。’“同类者”是依《经藏》等功德而分的同类,而非依友情亲疏。长老将所有诵经者一一选出,集中为他们安排相应的住处。对于持律者、论师、业处修行者及体魄强健者等,也是同样的方法。因此,巴利圣典(《波罗夷》380)中说:‘那些是诵经的比丘,为他们集中安排住处’等。 Aṅguliyā jalamānāyāti tejokasiṇacatutthajjhānaṃ samāpajjitvā vuṭṭhāya abhiññāñāṇena aṅgulijalanaṃ adhiṭṭhahitvā teneva tejodhātusamāpattijanitena aggijālena aṅguliyā jalamānāya. Ayaṃ mañcotiādīsu pana there ‘‘ayaṃ mañco’’tiādiṃ vadante nimmitāpi attano attano gataṭṭhāne ‘‘ayaṃ mañco’’tiādiṃ vadanti. Ayañhi nimmitānaṃ dhammatā. “手指燃烧时”是指:(尊者)进入火遍第四禅,出定后,以神通智决意令手指燃烧,由火界定所生之火焰使手指燃烧。至于“这是床”等,当长老说“这是床”等时,那些化现之物也在各自所在之处说“这是床”等。这确实是化现之物的法性。 ‘‘Ekasmiṃ bhāsamānasmiṃ, sabbe bhāsanti nimmitā; Ekasmiṃ tuṇhimāsine, sabbe tuṇhī bhavanti te’’ti. (dī. ni. 2.286); “一者言说时,所有化现者皆言说;一者默然坐,彼等亦皆默然。”(长部2.286) Yasmiṃ pana vihāre mañcapīṭhādīni na paripūrenti, tattha attano ānubhāvena pūrenti, tena nimmitānaṃ avatthukaṃ vacanaṃ na hoti sabbattha mañcapīṭhādīnaṃ sabbhāvato. Sabbavihāresu ca gamanamagge samappamāṇe katvā adhiṭṭhāti. Katikasaṇṭhānādīnaṃ pana nānappakārattā tasmiṃ tasmiṃ vihāre katikavattāni visuṃ visuṃ kathāpetīti veditabbaṃ. Aniyametvā [Pg.179] nimmitānañhi ‘‘ekasmiṃ bhāsamānasmi’’ntiādidhammatā vuttā. Tathā hi ye vaṇṇavayasarīrāvayavaparikkhārakiriyāvisesādīhi niyamaṃ akatvā nimmitā honti, te aniyametvā nimmitattā iddhimatā sadisāva honti. Ṭhānanisajjādīsu bhāsitatuṇhībhāvādīsu vā yaṃ yaṃ iddhimā karoti, taṃ tadeva karonti. Sace pana nānappakāre kātukāmo hoti, keci paṭhamavaye, keci majjhimavaye, keci pacchimavaye, tathā dīghakese upaḍḍhamuṇḍe missakakese upaḍḍharattacīvare paṇḍukacīvare, padabhāṇadhammakathāsarabhaññapañhapucchanapañhavissajjanarajanapacanacīvarasibbanadhovanādīni karonte, aparepi vā nānappakāre kātukāmo hoti, tena pādakajjhānato vuṭṭhāya ‘‘ettakā bhikkhū paṭhamavayā hontū’’tiādinā nayena parikammaṃ katvā puna samāpajjitvā vuṭṭhāya adhiṭṭhite adhiṭṭhānacittena saddhiṃ icchiticchitappakārāyeva honti. Puna attano vasanaṭṭhānameva āgacchatīti tehi saddhiṃ janapadakathaṃ kathento anisīditvā attano vasanaṭṭhānaṃ veḷuvanameva paccāgacchati. Pāḷiyanti vinayapāḷiyaṃ. 若某寺院床座等物不齐全,他便以自己的神通力使其齐全。因此,化现者之言并非无据,因为各处寺院的床座等物都是真实存在的。他在所有寺院中,将道路修得平整,然后作意加持。然而,应知由于约定形式等多种多样,他让(化现者)在各个寺院中分别宣说不同的约定。对于未经限定而化现者,其法性如(前文)所说“一者言说时”等。确实,那些在肤色、年龄、身形、用具、行为等细节上未经限定而化现者,因未经限定,便与神通者本人无异。在站立、坐下、言说、默然等方面,神通者怎么做,他们就怎么做。但若想化现出种种不同形态,例如,有些是青年,有些是中年,有些是老年;或长发,或半剃,或杂色发;或着半染衣,或着淡黄衣;或在诵读,或在说法,或在唱诵,或在提问,或在解答,或在染色,或在烹煮,或在缝衣,或在洗衣等等,若想化现其他种种形态,神通者便从基础禅定中出定,以“愿有这么多比丘是青年”等方式作预备(心念),再入定,出定后作意加持,(所化现者)便会随着决意心而成为所期望的各种样子。“他又回到自己的住处”,是指他与他们谈论世俗之事,但并不坐下,便返回自己的住处,即竹林(Veḷuvana)精舍。“在巴利圣典中”是指在《律藏》中。 Pilindavacchattheravatthu 毕陵伽婆蹉长老事 215. Sattame piyānanti piyāyitabbānaṃ. Manāpānanti manavaḍḍhanakānaṃ. Pilindoti panassa gottaṃ, vacchoti nāmanti ettha vuttavipariyāyenapi vadanti ‘‘pilindoti nāmaṃ, vacchoti gotta’’nti. Teneva ācariyadhammapālattherena theragāthāsaṃvaṇṇanāya (theragā. aṭṭha. 1.8 pilindavacchattheragāthāvaṇṇanā) vuttaṃ – ‘‘pilindotissa nāmaṃ akaṃsu, vacchoti pana gottaṃ. Tena so aparabhāge pilindavacchoti paññāyitthā’’ti. Saṃsandetvāti ekato katvā. 215. 第七,“可爱者”是指应被喜爱者。“可意者”是指能令心增长者。“毕陵陀”是他的姓,“婆蹉”是他的名。于此,也有人反过来说:“毕陵陀是名,婆蹉是姓。”因此,法护(Dhammapāla)尊者在《长老偈释义》(Theragāthā-vaṇṇanā)中(《长老偈释义》1.8,毕陵伽婆蹉长老偈释义)说:“他们为他取名为毕陵陀,而婆蹉是其姓。因此,他后来被称为毕陵伽婆蹉。”“比较”即合在一起。 Satthu dhammadesanaṃ sutvā paṭiladdhasaddho pabbajitvāti idaṃ aṅguttarabhāṇakānaṃ kathāmaggena vuttaṃ. Apare pana bhaṇanti – anuppanneyeva amhākaṃ bhagavati sāvatthiyaṃ brāhmaṇagehe nibbattitvā pilindavacchoti paññāto saṃsāre saṃvegabahulatāya paribbājakapabbajjaṃ pabbajitvā cūḷagandhāraṃ nāma vijjaṃ sādhetvā ākāsacārī paracittavidū ca hutvā rājagahe lābhaggayasaggappatto paṭivasati. Atha yadā amhākaṃ bhagavā abhisambuddho hutvā anukkamena rājagahaṃ upagato, tato paṭṭhāya buddhānubhāvena [Pg.180] tassa sā vijjā na sampajjati, atthakiccaṃ na sādheti. So cintesi – ‘‘sutaṃ kho pana metaṃ ‘ācariyapācariyānaṃ bhāsamānānaṃ yattha mahāgandhāravijjā dharati, tattha cūḷagandhāravijjā na sampajjatī’ti. Samaṇassa pana gotamassa āgatakālato paṭṭhāya nāyaṃ mama vijjā sampajjati, nissaṃsayaṃ samaṇo gotamo mahāgandhāravijjaṃ jānāti, yannūnāhaṃ taṃ payirupāsitvā tassa santike vijjaṃ pariyāpuṇeyya’’nti. So bhagavantaṃ upasaṅkamitvā etadavoca – ‘‘ahaṃ, mahāsamaṇa, tava santike ekaṃ vijjaṃ pariyāpuṇitukāmo, okāsaṃ me karohī’’ti. Bhagavā ‘‘tena hi pabbajā’’ti āha. So ‘‘vijjāya parikammaṃ pabbajjā’’ti maññamāno pabbajīti. Paravambhanavasenāti paresaṃ garahanavasena. “听闻导师说法后获得信心而出家”,这是增支部诵者(Aṅguttarabhāṇaka)的说法。另一些人则说:我们的世尊尚未出世时,他在舍卫城(Sāvatthī)一个婆罗门家中出生,名叫毕陵伽婆蹉。他因为对轮回深感厌离,出家做了游行者,修习了一种名叫小乾陀罗(Cūḷagandhāra)的明咒,能够飞行于空中,知晓他人心意,在王舍城得到了极高的利养与声誉。后来我们的世尊证悟成佛,次第来到王舍城,从那时起,因佛陀的威力,他的明咒就失效了,无法达成目的。他心想:‘我曾听师长们说,“哪里有大乾陀罗(Mahāgandhāra)明咒,哪里小乾陀罗明咒就不能起作用”。自从沙门乔达摩到来之后,我的明咒就失效了,毫无疑问,沙门乔达摩懂得大乾陀罗明咒,我不如去亲近他,向他学习这种明咒。’于是他去拜访世尊,说道:‘大沙门,我想在您这里学习一种明咒,请您允许我。’世尊说:‘那么你就出家吧。’他以为‘出家是学习明咒的准备’,就出家了。所谓‘轻蔑他人’,即是‘呵责他人’之义。 Akakkasanti apharusaṃ. Viññāpaninti atthaviññāpaniṃ. Saccanti bhūtatthaṃ. Nābhisajeti yāya girāya aññaṃ kujjhāpanavasena na lagāpeyya, khīṇāsavo nāma evarūpameva giraṃ na bhāseyya, tasmā tamahaṃ brūmi brāhmaṇaṃ vadāmīti attho. “不粗暴”即不粗恶。“能令人知”即能令人知晓义理。“真实”即真实之义。“不触怒”指不以能激怒他人的言语去纠缠他人;漏尽者实不说此类语,是故经云“我称之为婆罗门”。 Anuvicinitvāti anuvicāretvā. Caṇḍikataṃ gacchantanti sīghagatiyā gacchantaṃ. “随伺察”意思是反复思量。“急速行进”意思是快速行走。 Bāhiyadārucīriyattheravatthu 跋希亚·达鲁奇利耶长老的故事 216. Aṭṭhame ekarattivāsena gantvāti devatānubhāvena gantvā. ‘‘Buddhānubhāvenā’’tipi vadanti. Evaṃ gato ca vihāraṃ pavisitvā sambahule bhikkhū bhuttapātarāse kāyālasiyavimocanatthāya abbhokāse caṅkamante disvā ‘‘kahaṃ etarahi satthā’’ti pucchi. Bhikkhū ‘‘sāvatthiyaṃ piṇḍāya paviṭṭho’’ti vatvā taṃ pucchiṃsu – ‘‘tvaṃ pana kuto āgato’’ti? Suppārakā āgatomhīti. Kadā nikkhantosīti? Hiyyo sāyaṃ nikkhantomhīti. Dūrato āgato, tava pāde dhovitvā telena makkhetvā thokaṃ vissamāhi, āgatakāle satthāraṃ dakkhissatīti. Ahaṃ, bhante, satthu vā attano vā jīvitantarāyaṃ na jānāmi, ekarattenevamhi katthaci aṭṭhatvā anisīditvā vīsayojanasatikaṃ maggaṃ āgato, satthāraṃ passitvāva vissamissāmīti. So evaṃ vatvā taramānarūpo sāvatthiṃ pavisitvā bhagavantaṃ anopamāya buddhasiriyā piṇḍāya carantaṃ disvā [Pg.181] ‘‘cirassaṃ vata me diṭṭho sammāsambuddho’’ti diṭṭhaṭṭhānato paṭṭhāya oṇatasarīro gantvā antaravīthiyameva pañcapatiṭṭhitena vanditvā gopphakesu daḷhaṃ gahetvā evamāha – ‘‘desetu me, bhante, bhagavā dhammaṃ, desetu me sugato dhammaṃ, yaṃ mamassa dīgharattaṃ hitāya sukhāyā’’ti. 216. 第八,他凭借天神威力一夜之间到达。也有人说是“凭借世尊威力”而到达。这样到达后,他进入寺院,看见许多比丘用过早餐后,为了解除身体的疲倦而在户外经行,便问道:“导师现在何处?”比丘们回答:“已进入舍卫城(Sāvatthī)托钵。”又问他:“你从何处来?”答:“我从苏帕拉卡来。”问:“何时出发?”答:“昨日傍晚出发。”比丘们说:“你远道而来,先洗脚涂油稍作休息,待导师回来时再拜见。”他说:“尊者,我不知道导师或我自己还能活多久,我仅用一夜时间,未曾在任何地方停下安坐,行经一百二十由旬路程而来,唯有见到导师之后才能休息。”说罢便匆忙进入舍卫城,看见世尊以无与伦比的威仪正在托钵,便想:“我终于见到正等正觉者了!”从看见之处开始,俯身前进,在街巷中五体投地礼拜,紧握佛足说道:“世尊,请为我说法!善逝,请为我说法!这将使我长夜安乐。” Atha naṃ satthā ‘‘akālo kho tāva, bāhiya, antaragharaṃ paviṭṭhomhi piṇḍāyā’’ti paṭikkhipi. Taṃ sutvā bāhiyo, ‘‘bhante, saṃsāre saṃsarantena kabaḷīkārāhāro na no laddhapubbo, tumhākaṃ vā mayhaṃ vā jīvitantarāyaṃ na jānāmi, desetha me dhamma’’nti. Satthā dutiyampi paṭikkhipiyeva. Evaṃ kirassa ahosi ‘‘imassa maṃ diṭṭhakālato paṭṭhāya sakalasarīraṃ pītiyā nirantaraṃ ajjhotthaṭaṃ hoti, balavapītivegena dhammaṃ sutvāpi na sakkhissati paṭivijjhituṃ, majjhattupekkhā tāva tiṭṭhatu, ekaratteneva vīsayojanasataṃ maggaṃ āgatattā darathopissa balavā, sopi tāva paṭippassambhatū’’ti. Tasmā dvikkhattuṃ paṭikkhipitvā tatiyaṃ yācito antaravīthiyaṃ ṭhitova ‘‘tasmātiha te, bāhiya, evaṃ sikkhitabbaṃ diṭṭhe diṭṭhamattaṃ bhavissatī’’tiādinā (udā. 10) nayena dhammaṃ deseti. Imamatthaṃ saṃkhipitvā dassento ‘‘satthāraṃ piṇḍāya paviṭṭha’’ntiādimāha. Tattha antaraghareti antaravīthiyaṃ. 世尊拒绝说:“跋希亚,现在不是时候,我已进入村中托钵。”跋希亚听后说:“尊者,在轮回中流转时,我们并非未曾不得段食,而您或我的生命危难,我却无法预知,请为我说法。”世尊第二次又拒绝了。原来世尊这样想:“此人从见到我时起,整个身体就被喜悦(pīti)持续地充满,由于强烈的喜悦,即使听法也无法通达,让他先安住于中舍(majjhattupekkhā)。他仅用一夜就行走了一百二十由旬路程,身体也极为疲惫,也让他先平静下来。”因此两次拒绝后,第三次被请求时,世尊站在街巷中为他开示:“跋希亚,你应当这样修学:于所见中,唯有见……”(《自说经》1.10)。为简要说明此意,所以说“导师已入村托钵”等语。此处“村中”(antaragharaṃ)即指街巷之中。 Aparipuṇṇapattacīvaratāya pattacīvaraṃ pariyesantoti so kira vīsativassasahassāni samaṇadhammaṃ karonto ‘‘bhikkhunā nāma attano paccaye labhitvā aññaṃ anoloketvā sayameva bhuñjituṃ vaṭṭatī’’ti ekabhikkhussapi pattena vā cīvarena vā saṅgahaṃ nākāsi. Tenassa ‘‘iddhimayapattacīvaraṃ na uppajjissatī’’ti ñatvā ehibhikkhubhāvena pabbajjaṃ na adāsi. Tāvadeva ca pabbajjaṃ yācito ‘‘paripuṇṇaṃ te pattacīvara’’nti pucchitvā ‘‘aparipuṇṇa’’nti vutte ‘‘tena hi pattacīvaraṃ pariyesāhī’’ti vatvā pakkāmi. Tasmā so pattacīvaraṃ pariyesanto saṅkāraṭṭhānato coḷakhaṇḍāni saṃkaḍḍhati. 因为衣钵不齐全,他去寻找衣钵。据说他修行沙门法两万年之久,心想:“比丘得到自己的资具后,不应看顾他人,应当自己受用。”因此从未用衣或钵帮助过任何一位比丘。世尊了知“神通化现的衣钵不会为他出现”,便没有以“善来比丘”的方式给予他出家。当跋希亚请求出家时,世尊问:“你的衣钵齐全吗?”得到“不齐全”的回答后,便说:“那么,你去寻找衣钵吧。”说完便离开了。因此,他为了寻找衣钵,便从垃圾堆里捡拾碎布。 Sahassamapīti paricchedavacanaṃ. Ekasahassaṃ dvesahassānīti evaṃ sahassena ce paricchinnā gāthā honti, tā ca anatthapadasaṃhitā ākāsavaṇṇapabbatavaṇṇādīni pakāsakehi anibbānadīpakehi anatthakehi padehi saṃhitā yāva bahukā honti, tāva pāpikā evāti attho[Pg.182]. Ekaṃ gāthāpadaṃ seyyoti ‘‘appamādo amatapadaṃ…pe… yathā matā’’ti (dha. pa. 21) evarūpā ekagāthāpi seyyoti attho. “千”(sahassa)是限定词。即使偈颂以一千、两千等数量来限定,但若其中充满了无义之词(anatthapada),如描述天空、山脉颜色等,这些词句既不能阐明涅槃(nibbāna),又毫无意义,那么偈颂越多,就越是恶劣(pāpikā)。而一个偈句(gāthāpada)则更殊胜;例如像‘不放逸是甘露道……犹如已死’(《法句经》21)这样的一首偈颂,也更为殊胜,此其义也。 Kumārakassapattheravatthu 童子迦叶长老的故事 217. Navame ekaṃ buddhantaraṃ sampattiṃ anubhavamānoti sāvakabodhiyā niyatatāya puññasambhārassa ca sātisayattā vinipātaṃ agantvā ekaṃ buddhantaraṃ devesu ca manussesu ca sampattiṃ anubhavamāno. ‘‘Ekissā kuladārikāya kucchimhi uppanno’’ti vatvā tamevassa uppannabhāvaṃ mūlato paṭṭhāya dassetuṃ – ‘‘sā cā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Tattha sāti kuladārikā. Ca-saddo byatirekattho. Tena vuccamānaṃ visesaṃ jotayati. Kulagharanti patikulagehaṃ. Gabbhanimittanti gabbhassa saṇṭhitabhāvaviggahaṃ. Satipi visākhāya sāvatthivāsikulapariyāpannatte tassā tattha padhānabhāvadassanatthaṃ ‘‘visākhañcā’’tiādi vuttaṃ yathā ‘‘brāhmaṇā āgatā, vāsiṭṭhopi āgato’’ti. Bhagavatā evaṃ gahitanāmattāti yojanā. Yasmā rājaputtā loke ‘‘kumārā’’ti voharīyanti, ayañca rañño kittimaputto, tasmā āha – ‘‘rañño…pe… sañjāniṃsū’’ti. 217. 第九,经历一个佛间期的成就,是说因决定于声闻菩提,且福德资粮超胜,故不堕恶趣,于一个佛间期中,在天界与人界享受成就。为从根源开示其“生于一良家女腹中”一事,故说“而彼女”等。其中,“彼女”(sā)即良家女。“而”(ca)字为区别义,用以彰显所述之殊胜。“良家”(kulaghara)即夫家。“胎相”(gabbanmitta)即胎儿稳固成形之状。虽然毘舍佉(Visākhā)也属舍卫城(Sāvatthī)的良家,但为显示其于此处的首要地位,故说“以及毘舍佉”等,如同说“婆罗门来了,婆私吒(Vāsiṭṭha)也来了”。应连结为“因世尊(Bhagavā)如是称其名故”。因为世间称王子(rājaputta)为“童子”(kumāra),而此人是国王的义子(kittimaputta),是故说“国王……等皆知”。 Pañcadasa pañhe abhisaṅkharitvāti ‘‘bhikkhu, bhikkhu, ayaṃ vammiko rattiṃ dhūpāyati, divā pajjalatī’’tiādinā vammikasutte (ma. ni. 1.249) āgatanayena pañcadasa pañhe abhisaṅkharitvā. Pāyāsiraññoti ‘‘natthi paraloko, natthi sattā opapātikā, natthi sukatadukkaṭānaṃ kammānaṃ phalaṃ vipāko’’ti (dī. ni. 2.410, 412) evaṃladdhikassa pāyāsirājassa. Rājā hi tadā anabhisitto hutvā pasenadinā kosalena dinnasetabyanagaraṃ ajjhāvasanto imaṃ diṭṭhiṃ gaṇhi. Pañcadasahi pañhehi paṭimaṇḍetvāti ‘‘taṃ kiṃ maññasi, rājañña, ime candimasūriyā imasmiṃ vā loke parasmiṃ vā devā vā te manussā’’ti evamādīhi (dī. ni. 2.411) pañcadasahi pañhehi paṭimaṇḍitaṃ katvā. Suttanteti pāyāsisuttante (dī. ni. 2.406 ādayo). 造作十五问后:即如《蚁垤经》(Vammikasutta)中所说“比丘,比丘,此蚁垤夜间冒烟,白日燃烧”等,以此方式造作十五问。对波耶西王(Pāyāsi)而言:即对持“无有他世,无有化生有情,无有善作、恶作业之果报”此见的波耶西王而言。当时,此王尚未灌顶,居住在憍萨罗(Kosala)国波斯匿王(Pasenadi)所赐的塞达卞(Setabyā)城,持此邪见。以十五问庄严:即以“王种,汝意云何?此日月在此世间或在他世间?彼等为天神或为人?”等十五问加以庄严。于经中:即于《波耶西经》(Pāyāsisuttanta)中。 Mahākoṭṭhikattheravatthu 摩诃拘絺罗长老事 218. Dasamaṃ uttānatthameva. 218. 第十,其义自明。 Tatiyaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 第三第一品释义终。 14. Etadaggavaggo 14. 第一品 (14) 4. Catutthaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā (14) 4. 第四第一品释义 Ānandattheravatthu 阿难长老事 219-223. Catutthavaggassa [Pg.183] paṭhame heṭṭhā vuttappamāṇanti heṭṭhā koṇḍaññattherassa vatthumhi ‘‘tassa dhurapattāni navutihatthāni honti, kesaraṃ tiṃsahatthaṃ, kaṇṇikā dvādasahatthā, pādena patiṭṭhitaṭṭhānaṃ ekādasahattha’’nti evaṃ vuttappamāṇaṃ. Rañño pesesīti paccantassa kupitabhāvaṃ ārocetvā pesesi. Theragāthāsaṃvaṇṇanāyaṃ (theragā. aṭṭha. 2.1016 ānandattheragāthāvaṇṇanā) pana ‘‘paccantassa kupitabhāvaṃ rañño anārocetvā sayameva taṃ vūpasamesi, taṃ sutvā rājā tuṭṭhamānaso puttaṃ pakkosāpetvā ‘varaṃ te, sumana, dammi, gaṇhāhī’ti āhā’’ti vuttaṃ. Na metaṃ cittaṃ atthīti mama evarūpaṃ cittaṃ natthi. Avañjhanti atucchaṃ. Aññaṃ varehīti aññaṃ patthehi, aññaṃ gaṇhāhīti vuttaṃ hoti. Udakaṃ adhiṭṭhāyāti ‘‘udakaṃ hotū’’ti adhiṭṭhahitvā. Gatenāti gamanena. Na āmisacakkhukāti cīvarādipaccayasaṅkhātaṃ āmisaṃ na olokenti. 219-223. 于第四品之初,下方所说之量:即下方憍陈如(Koṇḍañña)长老事中,如是所说之量:“其车辕长九十肘,轮辐三十肘,轮毂十二肘,轮足所踏处十一肘。” 他禀告国王:即禀告边境骚乱后派遣(使者)。但在《长老偈释义》(Theragāthā-aṭṭhakathā)中则说:“(阿难)未向国王禀告边境骚乱,独自将其平息。国王闻后心悦,召来其子曰:‘须摩那(Sumana),我予汝一愿,取之。’” 我无此心:即我无如是之心。不空:即非空无。汝求他愿:即是说,汝可求取他物,领取他物。决意于水:即决意“愿此为水”。以行:即以行走。不以利养为眼:即不看视衣等资具所成的利养。 Vasanaṭṭhānasabhāgeyevāti vasanaṭṭhānasamīpeyeva. Ekantavallabhoti upaṭṭhākaṭṭhāne ekantena vallabho. Etassevāti etasseva bhikkhussa. Dvejjhakathā na hontīti dvidhābhūtakathā na honti, anekantikakathā na hontīti vuttaṃ hoti. Anibaddhāti aniyatā. Lohitena galantenāti itthambhūtakkhāne karaṇavacanaṃ, galantena lohitena yuttoti attho. Anvāsattoti anugato. Uṭṭhehi, āvuso ānanda, uṭṭhehi, āvuso ānandāti turite idamāmeḍitavacanaṃ. Duvidhena udakenāti sītudakena uṇhudakena ca. Tividhena dantakaṭṭhenāti khuddakaṃ mahantaṃ majjhimanti evaṃ tippakārena dantakaṭṭhena. Nava vāre anupariyāyatīti satthari pakkosante paṭivacanadānāya thinamiddhavinodanatthaṃ navakkhattuṃ anupariyāyati. Tenevāha – ‘‘evañhissa ahosī’’tiādi. Sesamettha suviññeyyameva. 于住处之区域:即于住处附近。绝对喜爱:即于侍者之位绝对喜爱。即此:即此比丘。无模棱两可之言:即无模棱两可之言,是说无有不定之言。无系缚:即不定。以流淌之血:此为情状说明之工具格,义为“与流淌之血相应”。紧随:即跟随。起,贤友阿难,起,贤友阿难:此为催促之重复语。以二种水:即以冷水与热水。以三种齿木:即以小、大、中此三类齿木。经行九次:即导师召唤时,为作应答及遣除昏沉睡眠,经行九次。是故说:“彼曾如是”等。此处余者皆易了知。 Uruvelakassapattheravatthu 优楼频螺迦叶长老事 224. Dutiye yaṃ vattabbaṃ, taṃ vitthārato vinayapāḷiyaṃ āgatameva. 224. 第二,所应说者,已于律藏中广说。 Kāḷudāyittheravatthu 黑优陀夷长老事 225. Tatiye [Pg.184] gamanākappanti gamanākāraṃ. Sesamettha uttānameva. 225. 第三,行仪:即行走之威仪。此处余者,其义自明。 Bākulattheravatthu 跋俱罗长老事 226. Catutthe nirābādhānanti ābādharahitānaṃ. Yathā ‘‘dvāvīsati dvattiṃsā’’tiādimhi vattabbe ‘‘bāvīsati bāttiṃsā’’tiādīni vuccanti, evamevaṃ dve kulāni assāti dvikulo, dvekuloti vā vattabbe bākuloti vuttanti āha – ‘‘bākuloti dvīsu kulesu vaḍḍhitattā evaṃladdhanāmo’’ti. Upayogenāti ānubhāvena. Phāsukakāleti arogakāle. Gadduhanamattampīti goduhanamattampi kālaṃ. Idha pana na sakalo goduhanakkhaṇo adhippeto, atha kho gāviṃ thane gahetvā ekakhīrabinduduhanakālamattaṃ adhippetaṃ. Ārogyasālanti āturānaṃ arogabhāvakaraṇatthāya katasālaṃ. 226. 第四,于无病者:即于无病者。犹如当说“二十二”(dvāvīsati)、“三十二”(dvattiṃsa)等时,却说成“bāvīsati”、“bāttiṃsa”等;同理,当说“有二家”(dve kulāni assā)即“二家”(dvikulo)或“两家”(dvekulo)时,却说成“跋俱罗”(bākulo)。故说:“跋俱罗,因于二家成长而得此名。” 以方便:即以威力。于安乐时:即于无病时。仅挤牛乳顷:即挤牛乳之短时。此处非指整个挤牛乳之时,而是指执母牛之乳,仅挤一滴乳汁之顷。疗养堂:即为令病者康复而造之堂。 Nimujjanummujjanavasenāti jāṇuppamāṇe udake thokaṃyeva nimujjanummujjanavasena. Chaḍḍetvā palāyīti macchassa mukhasamīpeyeva chaḍḍetvā palāyi. Dārakassa tejenāti dārakassa puññatejena. Māriyamānāva marantīti daṇḍādīhi pothetvā māriyamānāva maranti, na jālena baddhatāmattena amāriyamānā. Nīhaṭamattova matoti nīhaṭakkhaṇeyeva mato. Tenassa māraṇatthaṃ upakkamo na kato, yena upakkamena dārakassa ābādho siyā. Tanti macchaṃ. Sakalamevāti avikalameva paripuṇṇāvayavameva. Na keḷāyatīti na nandati, kismiñci na maññati. Piṭṭhito phālentīti dārakassa puññatejena piṭṭhito phālentī. Bheriṃ carāpetvāti ‘‘puttaṃ labhi’’nti ugghosanavasena bheriṃ carāpetvā. Pakatiṃ ācikkhīti attano puttabhāvaṃ kathesi. Kucchiyā dhāritattā amātā kātuṃ na sakkāti jananībhāvato amātā kātuṃ na sakkā. Macchaṃ gaṇhantāpīti macchaṃ vikkiṇitvā gaṇhantāpi. Tathā gaṇhantā ca tappariyāpannaṃ sabbaṃ gaṇhanti nāmāti āha – ‘‘vakkayakanādīni bahi katvā gaṇhantā nāma natthī’’ti. Ayampi amātā kātuṃ na sakkāti dinnaputtabhāvato na sakkā. 以沉浮:即于及膝深之水中,略作沉浮。弃而逃:即于鱼口之侧弃而逃。以孩童之威力:即以孩童之福德威力。被杀而死:即被杖等捶打而死,非仅被网缚而未被杀。方出(水)即死:即于出水之刹那即死。是故未对其作杀害之加行,若作此加行,则孩童或将有疾。彼:即彼鱼。皆完整:即无残缺,肢体圆满。不戏:即不喜,于任何事皆不在意。从背裂开:即因孩童之福德威力而从背裂开。使人击鼓:即以“我得一子”之宣告而使人击鼓。说其本性:即言己为子之事。因曾怀于腹中故不能非其母:即因生母之故而不能非其母。买鱼者:即卖鱼后取(钱)者。如是取者,亦取其所属一切,故云:“无有除去肾、肝等而后取者。” 此亦不能非其母:即因其为所予之子故不能(非其母)。 Sobhitattheravatthu 须ဘ多长老事 227. Pañcamaṃ [Pg.185] uttānatthameva. 227. 第五,其义自明。 Upālittheravatthu 优波离长老事 228. Chaṭṭhe bhārukacchakavatthunti aññataro kira bhārukacchadesavāsī bhikkhu supinante purāṇadutiyikāya methunaṃ dhammaṃ paṭisevitvā ‘‘assamaṇo ahaṃ vibbhamissāmī’’ti bhārukacchaṃ gacchanto antarāmagge āyasmantaṃ upāliṃ passitvā etamatthaṃ ārocesi. Āyasmā upāli, evamāha – ‘‘anāpatti, āvuso, supinantenā’’ti. Yasmā supinante avisayattā evaṃ hoti. Tasmā upālitthero bhagavatā avinicchitapubbampi imaṃ vatthuṃ nayaggāhena evaṃ vinicchini. Gahapatino dve dārakā honti putto ca bhāgineyyo ca. Atha so gahapati gilāno hutvā āyasmantaṃ ajjukaṃ etadavoca – ‘‘imaṃ, bhante, okāsaṃ yo imesaṃ dārakānaṃ saddho hoti pasanno, tassa ācikkheyyāsī’’ti. Tena ca samayena tassa ca gahapatino bhāgineyyo saddho hoti pasanno. Athāyasmā ajjuko taṃ okāsaṃ tassa dārakassa ācikkhi. So tena sāpateyyena kuṭumbañca saṇṭhapesi, dānañca paṭṭhapesi. Atha tassa gahapatino putto āyasmantaṃ ānandaṃ etadavoca – ‘‘ko nu kho, bhante ānanda, pituno dāyajjo putto vā bhāgineyyo vā’’ti. Putto kho, āvuso, pituno dāyajjoti. Āyasmā, bhante, ayyo ajjuko amhākaṃ sāpateyyaṃ amhākaṃ methunakassa ācikkhīti. Assamaṇo, āvuso, so ajjukoti. Athāyasmā ajjuko āyasmantaṃ ānandaṃ etadavoca – ‘‘dehi me, āvuso ānanda, vinicchaya’’nti. Te ubhopi upālittherassa santikaṃ agamaṃsu. Athāyasmā upāli, āyasmantaṃ ānandaṃ etadavoca – ‘‘yo nu kho, āvuso ānanda, sāmikena ‘imaṃ okāsaṃ itthannāmassa ācikkhā’ti vutto, tassa ācikkhati, kiṃ so āpajjatī’’ti? Na, bhante, kiñci āpajjati antamaso dukkaṭamatthampīti. Ayaṃ, āvuso, āyasmā ajjuko sāmikena ‘‘imaṃ okāsaṃ itthannāmassa ācikkhā’’ti vutto tassa ācikkhati, anāpatti, āvuso, āyasmato ajjukassāti. Bhagavā taṃ sutvā ‘‘sukathitaṃ, bhikkhave, upālinā’’ti vatvā [Pg.186] sādhukāramadāsi, taṃ sandhāyetaṃ vuttaṃ. Kumārakassapavatthu (a. ni. aṭṭha. 1.1.217) pana heṭṭhā āgatameva. 228. 第六,跋入咖恰之事。据说,有一位住在跋入咖恰地方的比丘,在梦中与前妻行淫后,心想:“我已不是沙门,我将还俗”,便前往跋入咖恰。途中遇见具寿优波离,告知了此事。具寿优波离说:“贤友,梦中所为无罪。”因为梦中之事非(心)所缘,故而如此。因此,优波离长老即使此事未经世尊裁决,仍以理推断,作此判决。有一位居士有两个孩子:儿子和外甥。后来这位居士生病了,他对具寿阿朱迦(Ajjuka)说:“尊者,这两个孩子中,谁有信心、有净信,就把这笔财产告知谁。”当时,这位居士的外甥有信心、有净信。于是具寿阿朱迦就把这笔财产告知了那个孩子。他用这笔财产安顿家庭,并开始行施。后来,这位居士的儿子对具寿阿难说:“尊者阿难,父亲的继承人,是儿子还是外甥呢?”(阿难答:)“贤友,儿子才是父亲的继承人。”(儿子说:)“尊者,阿朱迦尊者把我们的财产告知了我们的亲戚。”(阿难说:)“贤友,那位阿朱迦不是沙门。”于是具寿阿朱迦对具寿阿难说:“贤友阿难,请为我裁决。”他们两人一同前往优波离长老之处。于是具寿优波离对具寿阿难说:“贤友阿难,若主人说‘将此财产告知某某’,受托者即告知于他,他会犯何罪?”(阿难答:)“尊者,不犯任何罪,乃至恶作罪亦无。”(优波离说:)“贤友,具寿阿朱迦是受主人所托‘将此财产告知某某’,他才告知的。贤友,具寿阿朱迦无罪。”世尊听闻后,说道:“诸比丘,优波离说得好!”并给予了赞许。此话即是针对此事而说。至于童子迦叶之事,前面已经述及。 Channaṃ khattiyānanti bhaddiyo sakyarājā anuruddho ānando bhagu kimilo devadattoti imesaṃ channaṃ khattiyānaṃ. Pasādhakoti maṇḍayitā. Pāḷiyanti saṅghabhedakkhandhakapāḷiyanti (cūḷava. 330 ādayo). 六位刹帝利,即:释迦王跋提(Bhaddiya)、阿那律、阿难、跋瞿(Bhagu)、金毗罗、提婆达多。装饰者(pasādhaka),即装扮者(maṇḍayitā)。巴利(pāḷi),即《僧团分裂犍度》(Saṅghabhedakkhandhaka)的巴利文(出自《小品》330页等)。 Nandakattheravatthu 南达咖长老之事 229. Sattame ekasamodhāneti ekasmiṃ samodhāne, ekasmiṃ sannipāteti attho. Sesaṃ suviññeyyameva. 229. 第七,于一合(ekasamodhāne)者,意为于一集合处,于一集会处。余者易知。 Nandattheravatthu 难陀长老之事 230. Aṭṭhame na taṃ catusampajaññavasena aparicchinditvā oloketīti sātthakasappāyagocaraasammohasampajaññasaṅkhātānaṃ catunnaṃ sampajaññānaṃ vasena aparicchinditvā taṃ disaṃ na oloketi. So hi āyasmā ‘‘yamevāhaṃ indriyesu aguttadvārataṃ nissāya sāsane anabhiratiādivippakārappatto, tameva suṭṭhu niggahessāmī’’ti ussāhajāto balavahirottappo, tattha ca katādhikārattā indriyasaṃvaro ukkaṃsapāramippatto catusampajaññaṃ amuñcitvāva sabbadisaṃ āloketi. Vuttañcetaṃ bhagavatā – 230. 第八,“不以四正知辨别而观察”者,谓不以有义利(sātthaka)、适宜(sappāya)、行处(gocara)、无痴正知(asammohasampajañña)此四种正知辨别,即不观察彼方。彼具寿实念:“我正因于诸根门不守护,故于教法中遭遇不喜乐等过患,我必善加调伏之。”由是生起精勤,具足强烈的惭与愧,且于此已作修行,根律仪已达究竟圆满,恒不舍离四正知而观察一切方向。此亦为世尊所说: ‘‘Sace, bhikkhave, nandassa puratthimā disā āloketabbā hoti, sabbaṃ cetaso samannāharitvā nando puratthimaṃ disaṃ āloketi ‘evaṃ me puratthimaṃ disaṃ ālokayato nābhijjhādomanassā pāpakā akusalā dhammā anvāsavissantī’ti. Itiha tattha sampajāno hoti. Sace, bhikkhave, nandassa pacchimā disā, uttarā disā, dakkhiṇā disā, uddhaṃ, adho, anudisā anuviloketabbā hoti, sabbaṃ cetaso samannāharitvā nando anudisaṃ anuviloketi ‘evaṃ me anudisaṃ anuvilokayato…pe… sampajāno hotī’’’ti (a. ni. 8.9). “诸比丘,若难陀需观察东方,难陀则收摄全心而观察东方,(思惟:)‘我如是观察东方时,贪欲、忧恼等恶不善法将不流入。’如是,他于彼处保持正知。诸比丘,若难陀需观察西方、北方、南方、上方、下方、四维,他则收摄全心而观察四维,(思惟:)‘我如是观察四维时……乃至……他于彼处保持正知。’”(增支部8.9) Abhisekagehapavesanaāvāhamaṅgalesu [Pg.187] vattamānesūti idha tīṇi maṅgalāni vuttāni, vinayaṭṭhakathāyaṃ pana ‘‘taṃ divasameva nandakumārassa kesavissajjanaṃ, paṭṭabandho, gharamaṅgalaṃ, chattamaṅgalaṃ, āvāhamaṅgalanti pañca maṅgalāni hontī’’ti vuttaṃ. Tattha kulamariyādavasena kesoropanaṃ kesavissajjanaṃ. Yuvarājapaṭṭabandhanaṃ paṭṭabandho. Abhinavagharappavesanamaho gharamaṅgalaṃ. Vivāhakaraṇamaho āvāhamaṅgalaṃ. Yuvarājachattamaho chattamaṅgalaṃ. 于“灌顶、入宅、婚礼等吉祥事”中,此处说有三事。然于《律藏义注》中则说:“当日,难陀王子有剃发、头带、新屋、伞盖、婚礼此五种吉祥事。”其中,依家族传统剃发,为剃发礼。为储君系上头带,为头带礼。迁入新居之庆典,为新屋礼。成婚之庆典,为婚礼。储君之伞盖庆典,为伞盖礼。 Nandakumāraṃ abhisekamaṅgalaṃ na tathā pīḷesi, yathā janapadakalyāṇiyā vuttavacananti ajjhāharitabbaṃ. Tadeva pana vacanaṃ sarūpato dassetuṃ – ‘‘pattaṃ ādāya gamanakāle’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Janapadakalyāṇīti janapadamhi kalyāṇī uttamā cha sarīradosarahitā pañca kalyāṇasamannāgatā. Sā hi yasmā nātidīghā nātirassā nātikisā nātithūlā nātikāḷī nāccodātāti atikkantā mānusavaṇṇaṃ, asampattā dibbavaṇṇaṃ, tasmā cha sarīradosarahitā. Chavikalyāṇaṃ maṃsakalyāṇaṃ nhārukalyāṇaṃ aṭṭhikalyāṇaṃ vayakalyāṇanti imehi pana kalyāṇehi samannāgatattā pañca kalyāṇasamannāgatā nāma. Tassā hi āgantukobhāsakiccaṃ natthi, attano sarīrobhāseneva dvādasahatthe ṭhāne ālokaṃ karoti, piyaṅgusāmā vā hoti suvaṇṇasāmā vā, ayamassā chavikalyāṇatā. Cattāro panassā hatthapādā mukhapariyosānañca lākhārasaparikammakataṃ viya rattapavāḷarattakambalasadisaṃ hoti, ayamassā maṃsakalyāṇatā. Vīsati pana nakhapattāni maṃsato amuttaṭṭhāne lākhārasapūritāni viya, muttaṭṭhāne khīradhārāsadisāni honti, ayamassā nhārukalyāṇatā. Dvattiṃsa dantā suphusitā sudhotavajirapanti viya khāyanti, ayamassā aṭṭhikalyāṇatā. Vīsaṃvassasatikāpi samānā soḷasavassuddesikā viya hoti nippalitena, ayamassā vayakalyāṇatā. Iti imehi pañcahi kalyāṇehi samannāgatattā ‘‘janapadakalyāṇī’’ti vuccati. Tuvaṭanti sīghaṃ. 应补充(此句)为:灌顶之礼并未如国美所言那般逼迫难陀王子。为显示其言之本貌,故说“取钵离去时”等。国美(janapadakalyāṇī)者,乃国中第一美女,身无六疵,具足五美。其身不高、不矮、不瘦、不胖、不黑、不白,超越凡俗之色,未及天人之色,故称身无六疵。又因具足肤美、肉美、筋美、骨美、龄美,故称具足五美。其身无需外光,自身光芒即能照亮十二肘之地,肤色或如黍米,或如黄金,此为其肤美。其四肢与唇,犹如涂漆,色如红珊瑚、红毛毯,此为其肉美。其二十指甲,连肉之处如注满虫漆,离肉之处如乳汁之流,此为其筋美。其三十二齿,紧密洁白,犹如磨亮之金刚石列,此为其骨美。纵寿一百二十岁,仍如十六岁少女,无有白发,此为其龄美。因具足此五美,故称“国美”。速速(tuvaṭaṃ),意为迅速(sīghaṃ)。 Imasmiṃ ṭhāne nivattessati, imasmiṃ ṭhāne nivattessatīti cintentamevāti so kira tathāgate gāravavasena ‘‘pattaṃ vo, bhante, gaṇhathā’’ti vattuṃ avisahanto evaṃ cintesi – ‘‘sopānasīse pattaṃ gaṇhissatī’’ti[Pg.188]. Satthā tasmimpi ṭhāne na gaṇhi. Itaro ‘‘sopānapādamūle gaṇhissatī’’ti cintesi. Satthā tatthāpi na gaṇhi. Itaro ‘‘rājaṅgaṇe gaṇhissatī’’ti cintesi. Satthā tatthāpi na gaṇhi. Evaṃ ‘‘idha gaṇhissati, ettha gaṇhissatī’’ti cintentameva satthā vihāraṃ netvā pabbājesi. “他会在这里停下,他会在这里停下”,他这样想着。据说他因敬重如来,不敢说“尊者,请拿您的钵”,于是心想:“世尊会在台阶顶端拿钵。”世尊即使在那里也没有拿。那人又想:“世尊会在台阶底部拿钵。”世尊即使在那里也没有拿。那人又想:“世尊会在王宫庭院拿钵。”世尊即使在那里也没有拿。就这样,在他一直想着“世尊会在这里拿,会在这里拿”时,世尊已将他带到寺院剃度出家了。 Mahākappinattheravatthu 摩诃劫宾那长老的故事 231. Navame sutavittakoti dhammassavanapiyo. Paṭihārakassāti dovārikassa. Saccakārenāti saccakiriyāya. Satthā ‘‘uppalavaṇṇā āgacchatū’’ti cintesi. Therī āgantvā sabbā pabbājetvā bhikkhunīupassayaṃ gatāti idaṃ aṅguttarabhāṇakānaṃ kathāmaggaṃ dassentena vuttaṃ. Teneva dhammapadaṭṭhakathāyaṃ (dha. pa. aṭṭha. 1.mahākappinattheravatthu) vuttaṃ – 231. 第九偈中,喜爱听闻佛法,即是以闻法为财富者。“守门人”即是门卫。“以真实行”即是以真实誓言(saccakiriyā)。世尊心想:“愿莲花色(Uppalavaṇṇā)前来。”长老尼来后,为所有女子剃度,前往比丘尼住处。这是《增支部》的诵者在阐述其说法时所言。因此,在《法句经义注》(Dhammapadaṭṭhakathā)中也说道(dha. pa. aṭṭha. 1.mahākappinattheravatthu)—— ‘‘Tā satthāraṃ vanditvā ekamantaṃ ṭhitā pabbajjaṃ yāciṃsu. Evaṃ kira vutte satthā uppalavaṇṇāya āgamanaṃ cintesīti ekacce vadanti. Satthā pana tā upāsikāyo āha – ‘sāvatthiṃ gantvā bhikkhunīupassaye pabbājethā’ti. Tā anupubbena janapadacārikaṃ caramānā antarāmagge mahājanena abhihaṭasakkārasammānā padasāva vīsayojanasatikaṃ maggaṃ gantvā bhikkhunīupassaye pabbajitvā arahattaṃ pāpuṇiṃsū’’ti. 她们顶礼世尊后,站在一旁请求出家。据说世尊听了这话,心想莲花色(Uppalavaṇṇā)要来了。但世尊对那些优婆夷(upāsikā)说:“你们去舍卫城(Sāvatthī)的比丘尼住处出家吧。”她们次第游历诸国,一路上受到大众丰厚的供养和尊敬,徒步行走一百二十由旬的路程,在比丘尼住处出家后证得了阿罗汉果。 Dhammapītīti dhammapāyako, dhammaṃ pivantoti attho. Dhammo ca nāmesa na sakkā bhājanena yāguādīni viya pātuṃ, navavidhaṃ pana lokuttaradhammaṃ nāmakāyena phusanto ārammaṇato sacchikaronto pariññābhisamayādīhi dukkhādīni ariyasaccāni paṭivijjhanto dhammaṃ pivati nāma. Sukhaṃ setīti desanāmattametaṃ, catūhipi iriyāpathehi sukhaṃ viharatīti attho. Vippasannenāti anāvilena nirupakkilesena. Ariyappavediteti buddhādīhi ariyehi pavedite satipaṭṭhānādibhede bodhipakkhiyadhamme. Sadā ramatīti evarūpo dhammapīti vippasannena cetasā viharanto paṇḍiccena samannāgato sadā ramati abhiramati. Bāhitapāpattā ‘‘brāhmaṇā’’ti theraṃ ālapati. “法饮者”(Dhammapīti)即饮法者,是饮法的意思。法不像粥等可以用器皿来饮用,而是以名身(nāmakāya)触证九种出世间法(lokuttaradhamma),从所缘境证得,通过遍知、现观等方式通达苦等圣谛(ariyasacca),这称为饮法。“安乐而住”(Sukhaṃ seti)这只是一种说法,意指在四种威仪(iriyāpatha)中都能安乐地生活。“以清净心”(Vippasannena)即无浊、无烦恼。“圣者所说”(Ariyappavedite)即佛陀等圣者所开示的念处(satipaṭṭhāna)等菩提分法(bodhipakkhiyadhamme)。“常喜乐”(Sadā ramati)是说,像这样的法饮者,以清净心安住,具足智慧,恒常喜乐、欢喜。因已断除诸恶,故称长老为“婆罗门”(brāhmaṇa)。 Sāgatattheravatthu 萨咖达长老的故事 232. Dasame [Pg.189] chabbaggiyānaṃ vacanenāti kosambikā kira upāsakā āyasmantaṃ sāgataṃ upasaṅkamitvā abhivādetvā ekamantaṃ ṭhitā evamāhaṃsu – ‘‘kiṃ, bhante, ayyānaṃ dullabhañca manāpañca, kiṃ paṭiyādemā’’ti? Evaṃ vutte chabbaggiyā bhikkhū kosambike upāsake etadavocuṃ – ‘‘atthāvuso kāpotikā, nāma pasannā bhikkhūnaṃ dullabhā ca manāpā ca, taṃ paṭiyādethā’’ti. Atha kosambikā upāsakā ghare ghare kāpotikaṃ pasannaṃ paṭiyādetvā āyasmantaṃ sāgataṃ piṇḍāya carantaṃ disvā etadavocuṃ – ‘‘pivatu, bhante, ayyo sāgato kāpotikaṃ pasannaṃ, pivatu, bhante, ayyo sāgato kāpotikaṃ pasanna’’nti. Athāyasmā sāgato ghare ghare kāpotikaṃ pasannaṃ pivitvā nagaramhā nikkhamanto nagaradvāre pati. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘chabbaggiyānaṃ vacanena sabbagehesu kāpotikaṃ pasannaṃ paṭiyādetvā’’tiādi. Tattha kāpotikā nāma kapotapādasamānavaṇṇā rattobhāsā. Pasannāti surāmaṇḍassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Vinaye samuṭṭhitanti surāpānasikkhāpade (pāci. 326 ādayo) āgataṃ. 232. 第十则中,“因六群比丘之言”是说:据说憍赏弥(Kosambī)的优婆塞们前去拜见具寿萨咖达,行礼后,站在一旁这样说道:“尊者,有什么是长老们难得又喜欢的?我们应该准备什么?”听了这话,六群比丘对憍赏弥的优婆塞们说:“贤友(āvuso),有一种叫‘鸽色清酒’(kāpotikā pasannā)的东西,是比丘们难得又喜欢的,你们就准备那个吧。”于是憍赏弥的优婆塞们就在家家户户准备了鸽色清酒,看见具寿萨咖达托钵乞食时就说:“尊者萨咖达请喝鸽色清酒,尊者萨咖达请喝鸽色清酒!”于是具寿萨咖达就在家家户户喝了鸽色清酒,出城时,醉倒在城门口。因此说:“因六群比丘之言,在各家准备了鸽色清酒”等。其中,“鸽色”(kāpotikā)是指颜色像鸽子脚,略带红色。“清酒”(pasannā)是酒液的异名。这出自《律》中的饮酒学处(sikkhāpada)(波逸提326等)。 Rādhattheravatthu 罗陀长老的故事 233. Ekādasame satthā sāriputtattherassa saññaṃ adāsīti brāhmaṇaṃ pabbājetuṃ saññaṃ adāsi, āṇāpesīti vuttaṃ hoti. Bhagavā kira taṃ brāhmaṇaṃ pabbajjaṃ alabhitvā kisaṃ lūkhaṃ dubbaṇṇaṃ uppaṇḍuppaṇḍukajātaṃ disvā bhikkhū āmantesi – ‘‘ko, bhikkhave, tassa brāhmaṇassa adhikāraṃ saratī’’ti. Evaṃ vutte āyasmā sāriputto bhagavantaṃ etadavoca – ‘‘ahaṃ kho, bhante, tassa brāhmaṇassa adhikāraṃ sarāmī’’ti. Kiṃ pana tvaṃ, sāriputta, brāhmaṇassa adhikāraṃ sarasīti. Idha me, bhante, so brāhmaṇo rājagahe piṇḍāya carantassa kaṭacchubhikkhaṃ dāpesi, imaṃ kho ahaṃ, bhante, tassa brāhmaṇassa adhikāraṃ sarāmī’’ti. Sādhu sādhu, sāriputta. Kataññuno hi, sāriputta, sappurisā katavedino, tena hi tvaṃ, sāriputta, taṃ brāhmaṇaṃ pabbājehi upasampādehīti. Aṭṭhuppattiyaṃ āgatoti alīnacittajātakassa (jā. 1.2.11-12) aṭṭhuppattiyaṃ (jā. aṭṭha. 2.2.alīnacittajātakavaṇṇanā) āgato. 233. 在第十一个故事中,“导师授意舍利弗长老”意为给予剃度婆罗门的许可,即是下达了命令。据说,世尊看到那位未能出家的婆罗门变得瘦弱、粗糙、面色难看、全身发白,就对比丘们说:“诸位比丘,谁还记得这位婆罗门的恩德?”这样说完后,具寿舍利弗对世尊说:“世尊,我记得这位婆罗门的恩德。”世尊问:“舍利弗,你记得婆罗门的什么恩德呢?”舍利弗答:“世尊,当时我在王舍城(Rājagaha)乞食,这位婆罗门布施给我一勺饭。世尊,我记得的就是这位婆罗门的这个恩德。”世尊赞叹:“善哉,善哉,舍利弗!舍利弗,善人乃知恩图报者。既然如此,舍利弗,你就为那位婆罗门剃度,为他授具足戒吧。”“出自缘起故事”是说,这出自《无懈怠心本生》(Alīnacittajātaka, Jā. 1.2.11-12)的缘起故事(本生义注 2.2.《无懈怠心本生》释义)。 Nidhīnanti [Pg.190] tattha tattha nidahitvā ṭhapitānaṃ hiraññasuvaṇṇādipūrānaṃ nidhikumbhīnaṃ. Pavattāranti kicchajīvike duggatamanusse anukampaṃ katvā ‘‘ehi, te sukhena jīvanupāyaṃ dassessāmī’’ti nidhiṭṭhānaṃ netvā hatthaṃ pasāretvā ‘‘imaṃ gahetvā sukhaṃ jīvā’’ti ācikkhitāraṃ viya. Vajjadassinanti dve vajjadassino ‘‘iminā naṃ asāruppena vā khalitena vā saṅghamajjhe niggaṇhissāmī’’ti randhagavesako ca, anaññātaṃ ñāpanatthāya ñātaṃ anuggaṇhanatthāya sīlādīnamassa vuddhikāmatāya taṃ taṃ vajjaṃ olokanena ullumpanasabhāvasaṇṭhito ca. Ayaṃ idha adhippeto. Yathā hi duggatamanusso ‘‘imaṃ gaṇhāhī’’ti tajjetvāpi pothetvāpi nidhiṃ dassente kopaṃ na karoti, pamuditova hoti, evamevaṃ evarūpe puggale asāruppaṃ vā khalitaṃ vā disvā ācikkhante kopo na kātabbo, tuṭṭheneva bhavitabbaṃ. ‘‘Bhante, mahantaṃ vo kammaṃ kataṃ mayhaṃ ācariyupajjhāyaṭṭhāne ṭhatvā ovadantehi, punapi maṃ vadeyyāthā’’ti pavāretabbameva. “宝藏”(Nidhīnaṃ)是指那些被埋藏在各处,装满金银等财物的宝藏罐。“指示者”(Pavattāraṃ)好比对生活艰难的贫苦人生起悲悯,说:“来,我将告诉你安乐生活的方法”,然后带他们到藏宝处,伸出手说:“拿着这个好好生活”的人。“见过失者”(Vajjadassī)有两种:一种是伺机寻找过错的人,想:“我要以此不当或过失在僧伽中制伏他”;另一种是为了让不知者知晓,让已知者收敛,希望其增长戒行等,通过观察其种种过失而具有救护本性的人。此处意指后者。就像贫苦人即使被呵斥、被捶打,当有人指示宝藏时,他不但不生气反而欢喜;同样地,当这样的人指出不当或过失时,也不应生气,应当欢喜。应当这样邀请:“尊者,您们站在我阿阇梨、戒师(upajjhāya)的立场上教诫我,为我做了极大的帮助,请再次教导我。” Niggayhavādinti ekacco hi saddhivihārikādīnaṃ asāruppaṃ vā khalitaṃ vā disvā ‘‘ayaṃ me mukhodakadānādīhi sakkaccaṃ upaṭṭhahati, sace naṃ vakkhāmi, na maṃ upaṭṭhahissati, evaṃ me parihāni bhavissatī’’ti taṃ vattuṃ avisahanto na niggayhavādī nāma hoti, so imasmiṃ sāsane kacavaraṃ ākirati. Yo pana tathārūpaṃ vajjaṃ disvā vajjānurūpaṃ tajjento paṇāmento daṇḍakammaṃ karonto vihārā nīharanto sikkhāpeti, ayaṃ niggayhavādī nāma seyyathāpi, sammāsambuddho. Vuttañhetaṃ – ‘‘niggayha niggayhāhaṃ, ānanda, vakkhāmi, pavayha pavayha, ānanda, vakkhāmi, yo sāro, so ṭhassatī’’ti (ma. ni. 3.196). Medhāvinti dhammojapaññāya samannāgataṃ. Tādisanti evarūpaṃ paṇḍitaṃ bhajeyya payirupāseyya. Tādisañhi ācariyaṃ bhajamānassa antevāsikassa seyyo hoti na pāpiyo, vaḍḍhiyeva hoti, no parihānīti. 呵责者:有些人见到同住弟子等的不当或过失时,心想:“他恭敬地为我端水等服侍,若我指出其过,他便不再服侍我,我将因此受损。”因不敢言说,故不名为呵责者,此人是在此教法中散布秽物。而见到此类过失后,能依过失之轻重,或呵责、或训诫、或施以惩罚、或逐出寺院,以此教导之,此人方名为呵责者,犹如正自觉者。经中亦言:“阿难,我将呵责再呵责而说,拣择再拣择而说,有核心者将存留。”慧者:指具足法味之慧。应当亲近、侍奉如此智者。因为亲近这样的老师,弟子只会更好,不会更差;只会增长,不会减损。 Mogharājattheravatthu 莫伽罗阇长老的故事 234. Dvādasame kaṭṭhavāhananagareti kaṭṭhavāhanena gahitattā evaṃladdhanāmake nagare. Atīte kira bārāṇasivāsī eko rukkhavaḍḍhakī sake ācariyake adutiyo. Tassa soḷasa sissā ekamekassa sahassaṃ antevāsikā. Evaṃ te sattarasādhikā soḷasa sahassā ācariyantevāsikā [Pg.191] sabbepi bārāṇasiṃ upanissāya jīvikaṃ kappentā pabbatasamīpaṃ gantvā rukkhe gahetvā tattheva nānāpāsādavikatiyo niṭṭhāpetvā kullaṃ bandhitvā gaṅgāya bārāṇasiṃ ānetvā sace rājā atthiko hoti, rañño ekabhūmakaṃ vā sattabhūmakaṃ vā pāsādaṃ yojetvā denti. No ce, aññesampi vikkiṇitvā puttadāraṃ posenti. Atha nesaṃ ekadivasaṃ ācariyo ‘‘na sakkā vaḍḍhakikammena niccaṃ jīvituṃ, dukkarañhi jarākāle etaṃ kamma’’nti cintetvā antevāsike āmantesi – ‘‘tātā, udumbarādayo appasārarukkhe ānethā’’ti. Te ‘‘sādhū’’ti paṭissuṇitvā ānayiṃsu. So tehi kaṭṭhasakuṇaṃ katvā tassabbhantaraṃ pavisitvā vātena yantaṃ pūresi. Kaṭṭhasakuṇo suvaṇṇahaṃsarājā viya ākāse laṅghitvā vanassa upari caritvā antevāsīnaṃ purato oruhi. 234. 第十二,在木运城:因被木运者所占,故得此名。过去,波罗奈城(Bārāṇasī)有一木匠,其技艺无人能及。彼有十六弟子,每一弟子又各有一千学徒。如是,师徒共一万六千零一十七人,皆依波罗奈城维生。他们前往山边伐木,就地制成各种宫殿构件,再结为木筏,顺恒河(Gaṅgā)运至波罗奈城。若国王需要,便为国王建造一层乃至七层的宫殿;若否,则售予他人,以养家小。一日,其师心想:“以木匠活计难以长久维生,年老时做此工作甚为辛苦。”于是召集学徒言:“孩子们,去取优昙钵(udumbara)等无心材的树木来。”他们应诺“善”后,便取了来。他用这些木头造了一只木鸟,进入其内部,用风力充满机关。木鸟犹如金鹅王,跃入空中,飞越森林,降于学徒面前。 Athācariyo sisse āha – ‘‘tātā īdisāni kaṭṭhavāhanāni katvā sakkā sakalajambudīpe rajje gahetuṃ, tumhepi tātā etāni karotha, rajjaṃ gahetvā jīvissāma, dukkaraṃ vaḍḍhakisippena jīvitu’’nti. Te tathā katvā ācariyassa paṭivedesuṃ. Tato ne ācariyo āha – ‘‘katamaṃ tātā rajjaṃ gaṇhāmā’’ti? Bārāṇasirajjaṃ ācariyāti. Alaṃ tātā, mā etaṃ rucittha, mayañhi taṃ gahetvāpi ‘‘vaḍḍhakirājā, vaḍḍhakiyuvarājā’’ti vaḍḍhakivādā na muccissāma, mahanto jambudīpo, aññattha gacchāmāti. Tato saputtadārakā kaṭṭhavāhanāni abhiruhitvā sajjāvudhā hutvā himavantābhimukhā gantvā himavati aññataraṃ nagaraṃ pavisitvā rañño nivesaneyeva paccuṭṭhaṃsu. Te tattha rajjaṃ gahetvā ācariyaṃ rajje abhisiñciṃsu. So ‘‘kaṭṭhavāhano rājā’’ti pākaṭo ahosi, taṃ nagaraṃ tena gahitattā ‘‘kaṭṭhavāhananagara’’nteva nāmaṃ labhi. 于是其师对弟子们说:“孩子们,造出此等木制乘具,便可夺取整个瞻部洲(Jambudīpa)的王位。孩子们,你们也造吧,夺取王位后我们便可维生,靠木匠手艺谋生太难了。”他们照做后向师父报告。于是师父对他们说:“孩子们,我们去夺取哪个王国呢?”(弟子答:)“师父,波罗奈王国。”(师父说:)“够了,孩子们,莫选此国。即便我们夺取了那里,也摆脱不了‘木匠王、木匠储君’之名。瞻部洲如此之大,我们去别处吧。”于是他们携妻带子,登上木制乘具,全副武装,朝雪山(Himavanta)方向而去,进入雪山中某座城市,直抵王宫。他们在那里夺取了王位,为师父举行灌顶,立之为王。他以“木运王”之名而著称,那座城也因被他所占而得名“木运城”。 Tapacāranti tapacaraṇaṃ. Pāsāṇacetiye piṭṭhipāsāṇe nisīdīti pāsāṇakacetiyanti laddhavohāre piṭṭhipāsāṇe sakkena māpite mahāmaṇḍape nisīdi. Tattha kira mahato pāsāṇassa upari pubbe devaṭṭhānaṃ ahosi, uppanne pana bhagavati vihāro jāto, so teneva purimavohārena ‘‘pāsāṇacetiya’’nti vuccati. 苦行:即修习苦行。坐于岩石支提的平坦岩石上:他坐在由帝释天(Sakka)所造、名为“岩石支提”(Pāsāṇacetiya)的大亭楼阁内的平坦岩石上。据说,那里原是一块巨石之上的天神居所,世尊出世后,则成为了一座精舍,但仍沿用旧称,名为“岩石支提”。 Tena [Pg.192] pucchite dutiyo hutvā satthāraṃ pañhaṃ pucchīti – 彼(第一位)问后,他作为第二人向导师提问: ‘‘Muddhaṃ muddhādhipātañca, bāvarī paripucchati; Taṃ byākarohi bhagavā, kaṅkhaṃ vinaya no ise’’ti. (su. ni. 1031) – “顶与胜于顶者,跋瓦睿(Bāvarī)如是问;世尊,请您解说,导师,请除我等疑惑。” Evaṃ tena pañhe pucchite bhagavatā ca – 当他如此提问后,世尊则答: ‘‘Avijjā muddhāti jānāhi, vijjā muddhādhipātinī; Saddhāsatisamādhīhi, chandavīriyena saṃyutā’’ti. (su. ni. 1032) – “当知无明是顶,明为胜于顶者;其与信、念、定,以及欲、精进相结合。” Pañhe vissajjite dutiyo hutvā pañhaṃ pucchi. 问题解答后,他作为第二人提问。 Athassa…pe… pañhaṃ kathesīti – 于是……他说了问题: ‘‘Kathaṃ lokaṃ avekkhantaṃ, maccurājā na passatī’’ti. (su. ni. 1124) – “如何观察世间,死王才不见彼?” Tena pañhe pucchite – 当他提出问题后—— ‘‘Suññato lokaṃ avekkhassu, mogharāja sadā sato; Attānudiṭṭhiṃ ūhacca, evaṃ maccutaro siyā; Evaṃ lokaṃ avekkhantaṃ, maccurājā na passatī’’ti. (su. ni. 1125) – “莫伽罗阇,常具正念,观世间为空;拔除我见,如是超越死亡。如是观世间,死王不见彼。” Pañhaṃ vissajjesi. (世尊)解答了问题。 Sesajanāti tasmiṃ samāgame sannipatitā sesajanā. Na kathīyantīti ‘‘ettakā sotāpannā’’tiādinā na vuccanti. Evaṃ pārāyane vatthu samuṭṭhitanti pārāyanavagge idaṃ vatthu samuṭṭhitaṃ. 其余人:指于彼集会中聚集的其余人等。不说:指不以“有若干入流者(sotāpanna)”等方式言说。如是,《彼岸道品》之事生起:即此故事于《彼岸道品》(Pārāyanavagga)中生起。 Catutthaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 第四最第一品释义终。 Therapāḷisaṃvaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 《长老偈》释义终。 14. Etadaggavaggo 14. 最第一品 (14) 5. Pañcamaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā (14)五、第五最第一品释义 Mahāpajāpatigotamītherīvatthu 摩诃波阇波提乔达弥长老尼的故事 235. Theripāḷisaṃvaṇṇanāya paṭhame yadidaṃ mahāgotamīti ettha ‘‘yadidaṃ mahāpajāpati gotamī’’ti ca paṭhanti. Tattha gotamīti gottaṃ. Nāmakaraṇadivase [Pg.193] panassā laddhasakkārā brāhmaṇā lakkhaṇasampattiṃ disvā ‘‘sace ayaṃ dhītaraṃ labhissati, cakkavattirañño mahesī bhavissati. Sace puttaṃ labhissati, cakkavattirājā bhavissatī’’ti ubhayathāpi ‘‘mahatīyevassā pajā bhavissatī’’ti byākariṃsu, tasmā puttapajāya ceva dhītupajāya ca mahantatāya ‘‘mahāpajāpatī’’ti vohariṃsu. Tadubhayaṃ pana saṃsandetvā ‘‘mahāpajāpatigotamī’’ti vuttaṃ. Vārabhikkhanti vārena dātabbaṃ bhikkhaṃ. Nāmaṃ akaṃsūti gottaṃyeva nāmaṃ akaṃsu. Mātucchanti cūḷamātaraṃ. Mātubhaginī hi mātucchāti vuccati. Kalahavivādasuttapariyosāneti ‘‘kutopahūtā kalahā vivādā’’tiādinā suttanipāte āgatassa kalahavivādasuttassa (su. ni. 868 ādayo) pariyosāne. Idañca aṅguttarabhāṇakānaṃ kathāmaggānusārena vuttaṃ. Apare pana ‘‘tasmiṃyeva suttanipāte ‘attadaṇḍābhayaṃ jāta’ntiādinā āgatassa attadaṇḍasuttassa (su. ni. 941 ādayo) pariyosāne’’ti vadanti. Nikkhamitvā pabbajitānanti ettha ehibhikkhupabbajjāya ete pabbajitāti vadanti. Teneva suttanipāte attadaṇḍasuttasaṃvaṇṇanāya (su. ni. aṭṭha. 2.942 ādayo) vuttaṃ – ‘‘desanāpariyosāne pañcasatā sākiyakumārā koḷiyakumārā ca ehibhikkhupabbajjāya pabbajitā. Te gahetvā bhagavā mahāvanaṃ pāvisī’’ti. Sesamettha suviññeyyameva. 235. 在《长老尼偈》的释义中,首先是关于大乔达弥(Mahāgotamī)的记载。这里,有人读作“大爱道·乔达弥(Mahāpajāpatī Gotamī)”。其中,“乔达弥”是姓氏。在命名日那天,受到尊敬的婆罗门们观察到她具有殊胜的相,预言说:“如果她生女儿,将会成为转轮王的王后;如果她生儿子,将会成为转轮王。”无论生儿子还是女儿,都预言说“她的眷属必定广大”,因此,因其子嗣与女儿的眷属众多,故称她为“大爱道”。将这两个词结合起来,便称为“大爱道·乔达弥”。“轮供食”(Vārabhikkhaṃ)指依轮次当施的食物。“取名”即是确定姓氏。“姨母”指小姨,母亲的姐妹被称为“姨母”。“在《争论斗讼经》的结尾”指在《经集》中以“争论斗讼从何而生”等开头的《争论斗讼经》(Suttanipāta 868ff.)的结尾。这是根据《增支部》诵者的说法。也有人说:“是在同一部《经集》中以‘执持自身为杖生怖畏’等开头的《自身执杖经》(Attadaṇḍasutta, Suttanipāta 941ff.)的结尾”。关于“出家为僧者”(Nikkhamitvā pabbajitānaṃ),此处说他们是以“善来比丘”(ehibhikkhu)的方式出家。因此在《经集·自身执杖经》(Attadaṇḍasutta)的义注中(Suttanipāta-aṭṭhakathā 2.942ff.)说:“说法结束时,五百位释迦族(Sākiya)王子和拘利族(Koḷiya)王子以‘善来比丘’的方式出家。世尊带领他们进入大林(Mahāvana)。”其余部分在这里很容易理解。 Khemātherīvatthu Khemā长老尼的故事 236. Dutiye parapariyāpannā hutvāti paresaṃ dāsī hutvā. Suvaṇṇarasapiñjaro ahosīti suvaṇṇarasapiñjaro viya ahosi. 236. 在第二段中,“成为依附他人者”是指“成为他人的奴仆”。“曾是黄金笼”是指“犹如黄金笼一般”。 Makkaṭakova jālanti yathā nāma makkaṭako suttajālaṃ katvā majjhaṭṭhāne nābhimaṇḍale nipanno pariyante patitaṃ paṭaṅgaṃ vā makkhikaṃ vā vegena gantvā vijjhitvā tassa rasaṃ pivitvā punāgantvā tasmiṃyeva ṭhāne nipajjati, evameva ye sattā rāgarattā dosapaduṭṭhā mohamūḷhā sayaṃkataṃ taṇhāsotaṃ anupatanti, te taṃ samatikkamituṃ na sakkonti, evaṃ duratikkamaṃ. Etampi chetvāna vajanti dhīrāti paṇḍitā etaṃ bandhanaṃ chinditvā anapekkhino nirālayā hutvā arahattamaggena sabbaṃ dukkhaṃ pahāya vajanti gacchantīti attho. “如同蜘蛛结网”是指,如同蜘蛛结好丝网后,停留在中央的腹部,如果有飞蛾或苍蝇落在网上,就迅速前去刺穿,吸取它们的汁液后又返回原来的地方躺卧。同样地,那些被贪欲染着、被嗔恚恼怒、被愚痴迷惑的众生,随顺自己所造的渴爱之流,他们无法超越它,如此难以超越。“智者斩断这束缚”是指,智者斩断此束缚后,不希求、不执着,以阿罗汉道舍弃一切痛苦而离去,这是它的意思。 Uppalavaṇṇātherīvatthu 莲花色长老尼的故事 237. Tatiyaṃ [Pg.194] uttānatthameva. 237. 第三段也是意义浅显。 Paṭācārātherīvatthu 芭达嘉拉长老尼的故事 238. Catutthe paṭihārasatenapīti dvārasatenapi. Paṭihārasaddo hi dvāre dovārike ca dissati. Kulasabhāganti attano gehasamīpaṃ. 238. 在第四段中,“即使有一百重防护”是指“即使有一百重门”。“防护”一词,既指门,也指守门人。“家族同分”是指自己家宅附近。 Tāṇāyāti tāṇabhāvāya patiṭṭhānatthāya. Bandhavāti putte ca pitaro ca ṭhapetvā avasesā ñātisuhajjā. Antakenādhipannassāti maraṇena abhibhūtassa. Pavattiyañhi puttādayo annapānādidānena ceva uppannakiccanittharaṇena ca tāṇā hutvāpi maraṇakāle kenaci upāyena maraṇaṃ paṭibāhituṃ asamatthatāya tāṇatthāya leṇatthāya na santi nāma. Teneva vuttaṃ – ‘‘natthi ñātīsu tāṇatā’’ti. “为求救护”是指为求救护、为求依止。“亲族”指的是除了子女和父母以外,其余的亲戚朋友。“被死神控制的人”指的是被死亡征服的人。因为在世俗中,子女等虽然可以通过布施饮食以及完成应做的事情来提供救护,但是在临死的时候,由于没有任何办法能够阻挡死亡,所以他们实际上并不能成为真正的救护之处、庇护之处。因此说:‘亲族之中没有救护。’ Etamatthavasanti etaṃ tesaṃ aññamaññassa tāṇaṃ bhavituṃ asamatthabhāvasaṅkhātaṃ kāraṇaṃ jānitvā paṇḍito catupārisuddhisīlena saṃvuto rakkhitagopito hutvā nibbānagamanaṃ aṭṭhaṅgikaṃ maggaṃ sīghaṃ sodheyyāti attho. “明白这个道理”是指智者知道他们彼此无法互相救护的状况,因此应当守护四清净戒,善加保护自己,迅速清净通往涅槃的八支圣道。这就是它的意义。 Dhammadinnātherīvatthu 法施长老尼的故事 239. Pañcame parāyattaṭṭhāneti paresaṃ dāsiṭṭhāne. Sujātattherassa adhikārakammaṃ katvāti sā kira attano kese vikkiṇitvā sujātattherassa nāma aggasāvakassa dānaṃ datvā patthanaṃ akāsi. Taṃ sandhāyetaṃ vuttaṃ. Hatthe pasāriteti tassa hatthāvalambanatthaṃ pubbāciṇṇavasena hatthe pasārite. So kira anāgāmī hutvā gehaṃ āgacchanto yathā aññesu divasesu ito cito ca olokento sitaṃ kurumāno hasamāno āgacchati, evaṃ anāgantvā santindriyo santamānaso hutvā agamāsi. Dhammadinnā sīhapañjaraṃ ugghāṭetvā vīthiṃ olokayamānā tassa āgamanākāraṃ disvā ‘‘kiṃ nu kho eta’’nti cintetvā tassa paccuggamanaṃ kurumānā sopānasīse ṭhatvā olambanatthaṃ hatthaṃ pasāresi. Upāsako attano hatthaṃ samiñjesi. Sā [Pg.195] ‘‘pātarāsabhojanakāle jānissāmī’’ti cintesi. Upāsako pubbe tāya saddhiṃ ekato bhuñjati. Taṃ divasaṃ pana taṃ anapaloketvā yogāvacarabhikkhu viya ekakova bhuñji. Tenāha – ‘‘bhuñjamānopi imaṃ detha, imaṃ harathāti na byāharī’’ti. Tattha imaṃ dethāti imaṃ khādanīyaṃ vā bhojanīyaṃ vā detha. Imaṃ harathāti imaṃ khādanīyaṃ vā bhojanīyaṃ vā apaharatha. Santhavavasenāti kilesasanthavavasena. Cirakālaparibhāvitāya ghaṭadīpajālāya viya abbhantare dibbamānāya hetusampattiyā codiyamānā āha – ‘‘evaṃ sante…pe… mayhaṃ pabbajjaṃ anujānāthā’’ti. 239. 在第五段中,“依赖他人生存者”是指“处于他人奴仆的地位”。据说她卖掉自己的头发,供养名为善生(Sujāta)长老的大弟子,并作了发愿。这里指的是这件事。“伸手相迎”是指她为了让他扶着手,依照往常的习惯伸出手。据说这位已证阿那含果(anāgāmī)的优婆塞回家时,不像往日那样东张西望、嬉笑颜开,而是收摄诸根,心意寂静地走来。法施打开狮子栏,向外张望,见他举止异常,心想:“这是怎么回事?”便上前相迎,站在台阶顶端伸手想要扶他。优婆塞却收回自己的手。她想:“早餐时便知分晓。”原来优婆塞平日与她一同用餐,那天却像修行的比丘一样独自用膳。因此说:“即使在用餐时,他也没有说‘给这个’或‘拿那个’。”此处“给这个”指的是给予嚼食(khādanīya)或啖食(bhojanīya),“拿那个”指的是拿走嚼食或啖食。“因亲爱故”是指因烦恼亲爱而生。犹如长期燃烧的油灯,她内心被因缘具足所启发,显现光辉,于是说:“既然如此……请允许我出家。” Ayaṃ tāva seṭṭhi gharamajjhe ṭhitova dukkhassantaṃ akāsīti sā kira ‘‘dhammadinne tuyhaṃ doso natthi, ahaṃ pana ajja paṭṭhāya santhavavasena…pe… kulagharaṃ gacchā’’ti vutte evaṃ cintesi – ‘‘pakatipuriso evaṃ vattā nāma natthi, addhā etena lokuttaradhammo nāma paṭividdho’’ti. Tenassā ayaṃ saṅkappo ahosi ‘‘ayaṃ tāva seṭṭhi gharamajjhe ṭhitova dukkhassantaṃ akāsī’’ti. Majjhimanikāyaṭṭhakathāyaṃ (ma. ni. aṭṭha. 1.460) pana ‘‘atha kasmā mayā saddhiṃ yathāpakatiyā ālāpasallāpamattampi na karothāti so cintesi – ‘ayaṃ lokuttaradhammo nāma garu bhāriyo na pakāsetabbo; sace kho panāhaṃ na kathessāmi, ayaṃ hadayaṃ phāletvā ettheva kālaṃ kareyyā’ti tassā anuggahatthāya kathesi – ‘dhammadinne ahaṃ satthu dhammadesanaṃ sutvā lokuttaradhammaṃ nāma adhigato, taṃ adhigatassa evarūpā lokiyakiriyā na vaṭṭatī’’’ti vuttaṃ. “这位富翁身在家中就已证得苦的止息”是指,据说他对法施(Dhammadinnā)说:“法施,你并没有错,但我从今天开始,将以友谊的方式……乃至……去各家各户。”听到这些话,她心想:“普通的男人不会这样说话,这个人一定是证悟了出世间法。”因此她产生了这样的想法:“这位富翁身在家中就已证得苦的止息。”但在《中部》义注(Majjhimanikāyaṭṭhakathā)中说:“他心想:‘为什么她不像往常一样和我简单地交谈几句呢?这出世间法深奥难懂,不能轻易示人;如果我不说,她可能会伤心欲绝而死。’为了帮助她,就对法施说:‘法施,我听了导师的说法后,已经证悟了出世间法,证悟此法后,就不适合做世俗的事情了。’” Pañcakkhandhādivasena pañhe pucchīti ‘‘sakkāyo sakkāyoti ayye vuccati, katamo nu kho ayye sakkāyo vutto bhagavatā’’tiādinā cūḷavedallasutte (ma. ni. 1.460 ādayo) āgatanayena pucchi. Pucchitaṃ pucchitaṃ vissajjesīti ‘‘pañca kho ime, āvuso visākha, upādānakkhandhā sakkāyo vutto bhagavatā’’tiādinā (ma. ni. 1.460 ādayo) tattheva āgatanayena vissajjesi. Sūrabhāvanti tikkhabhāvaṃ. Anadhigataarahattamaggassa uggahena vinā tattha pañho na upaṭṭhātīti āha – ‘‘uggahavasena arahattamaggepi pucchī’’ti. Taṃ nivattentīti ‘‘vimuttiyā panāyye kiṃ paṭibhāgo’’ti pucchite ‘‘vimuttiyā kho, āvuso visākha, nibbānaṃ paṭibhāgo’’ti (ma. ni. 1.466) vutte ‘‘nibbānassa, panāyye, kiṃ paṭibhāgo’’ti puna pucchite taṃ nivattentī ‘‘accasarāvuso [Pg.196] visākhā’’tiādimāha. Tattha accasarāti apucchitabbaṃ pucchanto pañhaṃ atikkāmitā ahosīti attho. Nāsakkhi pañhānaṃ pariyantaṃ gahetunti pañhānaṃ paricchedappamāṇaṃ gahetuṃ nāsakkhi. Pañhānañhi paricchedaṃ gahetuṃ yuttaṭṭhāne aṭṭhatvā tato paraṃ pucchanto nāsakkhi pañhānaṃ pariyantaṃ gahetuṃ. Appaṭibhāgadhammassa ca paṭibhāgaṃ pucchi. Nibbānaṃ nāmetaṃ appaṭibhāgaṃ, na sakkā nīlaṃ vā pītakaṃ vāti kenaci dhammena saddhiṃ paṭibhāgaṃ katvā dassetuṃ, tañca tvaṃ iminā adhippāyena pucchasīti attho. Nibbānogadhanti nibbānaṃ ogāhetvā ṭhitaṃ, nibbānantogadhaṃ nibbānaṃ anuppaviṭṭhanti attho. Nibbānaparāyaṇanti nibbānaṃ paraṃ ayanamassa parāgati, na tato paraṃ gacchatīti attho. Nibbānaṃ pariyosānaṃ avasānaṃ assāti nibbānapariyosānaṃ. “以五蕴等为主题提问”,即如《小吠陀经》(Cūḷavedallasutta)中所说的方式提问:“尊者,常说‘有身’、‘有身’,那么,尊者,世尊所说的‘有身’是什么呢?”“对于被问到的问题一一解答”,即如该经中所说的方式回答:“贤友毘舍佉,世尊所说的‘有身’,就是这五取蕴。”“勇猛”是指敏锐。若未以领会的方式通达阿罗汉道,则无法提出此问,故说:“以领会的方式,亦问阿罗汉道。”“她制止他”,即当被问到:“尊者,解脱的对等是什么?”时,回答说:“贤友毘舍佉,解脱的对等是涅槃。”当再被问到:“尊者,涅槃的对等是什么?”时,她制止他说:“贤友毘舍佉,你已越界了”等等。此处“越界”的意思是:询问不应问之事,超越了问题的范围。“无法把握问题的边际”,即无法把握问题的界限范围。因为他没有在应把握界限的适当之处停止,而继续追问,所以无法把握问题的边际。并且,他询问了无对等之法的对等。“涅槃”是无对等的,无法与青或黄等任何法作对等来说明,而你却是以这个意趣来提问。“浸入涅槃”,意思是浸入涅槃而住,进入涅槃之内。“以涅槃为归趣”,意思是涅槃是其最高的归趣,此后不再前行。“以涅槃为终极”,意思是涅槃是其究竟、终点。 Pureti atītesu khandhesu. Pacchāti anāgatesu khandhesu. Majjheti paccuppannesu khandhesu. Akiñcananti yassa etesu tīsu taṇhāgāhasaṅkhātaṃ kiñcanaṃ natthi, tamahaṃ rāgakiñcanādīhi akiñcanaṃ kassaci gahaṇassa abhāvena anādānaṃ brāhmaṇaṃ vadāmīti attho. “前”,是在于过去的诸蕴。“后”,是在于未来的诸蕴。“中”,是在于现在的诸蕴。“一无所有”的意思是:对此三者,无有名为渴爱与执取的任何障碍,我称此人为“婆罗门”,他因无贪爱等任何障碍而一无所有,因无任何执取而无所取。 Paṇḍitāti dhātuāyatanādikusalatāsaṅkhātena paṇḍiccena samannāgatā. Vuttañhetaṃ – “智者”,是具足了名为“善巧于界、处等”之智慧的人。正如所说—— ‘‘Kittāvatā nu kho, bhante, paṇḍito hoti? Yato kho, ānanda, bhikkhu dhātukusalo ca hoti āyatanakusalo ca paṭiccasamuppādakusalo ca ṭhānāṭṭhānakusalo ca, ettāvatā kho, ānanda, bhikkhu paṇḍito hotī’’ti. “尊者,怎样才算是智者呢?”“阿难,当一位比丘善巧于界、善巧于处、善巧于缘起、善巧于处非处时,阿难,到这种程度,这位比丘就是智者了。” Mahāpaññāti mahante atthe mahante dhamme mahantā niruttiyo mahantāni paṭibhānāni pariggahaṇe samatthāya paññāya samannāgatā. Imissā hi theriyā asekkhappaṭisambhidāppattatāya paṭisambhidāyo pūretvā ṭhitatāya paññāmahattaṃ. Yathā taṃ dhammadinnāyāti yathā dhammadinnāya bhikkhuniyā byākataṃ, ahaṃ evameva byākareyyanti attho. Tanti nipātamatthaṃ. “大智慧”,是具足了能够把握广大义理、广大法、广大言辞、广大辩才之智慧的人。因为这位长老尼已证得无学四无碍解,圆满了无碍解,所以智慧广大。“如法施(Dhammadinnā)”,意思是:如法施比丘尼所解说的那样,我也要那样解说。“Taṃ”只是一个虚词。 Nandātherīvatthu 难陀长老尼的故事 240. Chaṭṭhe [Pg.197] aññaṃ maggaṃ apassantīti aññaṃ upāyaṃ apassantī. Vissatthāti nirāsaṅkā. Itthinimittanti itthiyā subhanimittaṃ, subhākāranti vuttaṃ hoti. Dhammapade gāthaṃ vatvāti – 240. 第六则。“不见其他道路”,即不见其他方法。“无畏”,即无有疑虑。“女相”,即女子的净相,意为美好的形相。在《法句经》中说了偈颂,即—— ‘‘Aṭṭhīnaṃ nagaraṃ kataṃ, maṃsalohitalepanaṃ; Yattha jarā ca maccu ca, māno makkho ca ohito’’ti. (dha. pa. 150) – “骨建之城,血肉涂饰;老、死、我慢与虚伪,皆藏于其中。”(《法句经》150) Imaṃ gāthaṃ vatvā. Tatrāyamadhippāyo – yatheva hi pubbaṇṇāparaṇṇādīnaṃ odahanatthāya kaṭṭhāni ussāpetvā vallīhi bandhitvā mattikāya vilimpitvā nagarasaṅkhātaṃ bahiddhā gehaṃ karonti, evamidaṃ ajjhattikampi tīṇi aṭṭhisatāni ussāpetvā nhāruvinaddhaṃ maṃsalohitalepanaṃ tacapaṭicchannaṃ jīraṇalakkhaṇāya jarāya maraṇalakkhaṇassa maccuno ārogyasampadādīni paṭicca uppajjanalakkhaṇassa mānassa sukatakāraṇavināsanalakkhaṇassa makkhassa ca odahanatthāya nagaraṃ kataṃ. Evarūpo eva hi ettha kāyikacetasiko ābādho ohito, ito uddhaṃ kiñci gayhūpagaṃ natthīti. 说此偈。其意趣是:正如为了存放前期谷物与后期谷物等,人们竖起木头,用藤蔓捆绑,涂上泥土,在外面建造名为“城”的屋舍;同样,这内在的身体也是竖起三百根骨头,以筋腱捆绑,涂上血肉,覆盖皮肤,为了存放具有衰败特性的“老”,具有死亡特性的“死”,缘健康圆满等而生起的“我慢”,以及具有破坏善因特性的“虚伪”,而造成的“城”。如此,身心的疾苦皆藏于其中,于此之上,再无任何可取之物。 Suttaṃ abhāsīti – 宣说了经文,即—— ‘‘Caraṃ vā yadi vā tiṭṭhaṃ, nisinno uda vā sayaṃ; Samiñjeti pasāreti, esā kāyassa iñjanā. “行或立,坐或卧,屈与伸,此为身之动。” ‘‘Aṭṭhinahārusaṃyutto, tacamaṃsāvalepano; Chaviyā kāyo paṭicchanno, yathābhūtaṃ na dissatī’’ti. (su. ni. 195-196) – “骨筋相连,皮肉涂饰,身体为皮肤所覆,不见其真实。”(《经集》195-196) Ādinā suttamabhāsi. 宣说了以此为开头的经文。 Soṇātherīvatthu 苏那长老尼的故事 241. Sattame sabbepi visuṃ visuṃ gharāvāse patiṭṭhāpesīti ettha sabbepi visuṃ visuṃ gharāvāse patiṭṭhāpetvā ‘‘puttāva maṃ paṭijaggissanti, kiṃ me visuṃ kuṭumbenā’’ti sabbaṃ sāpateyyampi vibhajitvā adāsīti veditabbaṃ. Teneva hi tato paṭṭhāya ‘‘ayaṃ amhākaṃ kiṃ karissatī’’ti attano santikaṃ āgataṃ ‘‘mātā’’ti saññampi na kariṃsu. Tathā hi naṃ katipāhaccayena jeṭṭhaputtassa bhariyā ‘‘aho amhākaṃ ayaṃ jeṭṭheputto [Pg.198] meti dve koṭṭhāse datvā viya imameva gehaṃ āgacchatī’’ti āha. Sesaputtānaṃ bhariyāyopi evamevaṃ vadiṃsu. Jeṭṭhadhītaraṃ ādiṃ katvā tāsaṃ gehaṃ gatakāle tāpi naṃ evameva vadiṃsu. Sā avamānappattā hutvā ‘‘kiṃ me imesaṃ santike vutthena, bhikkhunī hutvā jīvissāmī’’ti bhikkhunīupassayaṃ gantvā pabbajjaṃ yāci, tā naṃ pabbājesuṃ. Imameva vatthuṃ dassento ‘‘bahuputtikasoṇā tesaṃ attani agāravabhāvaṃ ñatvā ‘gharāvāsena kiṃ karissāmī’ti nikkhamitvā pabbajī’’ti āha. 241. 第七则。“她将他们都分别安置在各自的家中”,此处应知,她将他们都分别安置在各自的家中后,心想:“儿子们会照顾我,我何必另外持家呢?”于是将所有财产都分给了他们。正因如此,从那以后,当她来到他们身边时,他们心想:“她能为我们做什么呢?”连“母亲”的表示都没有了。的确,过了几天,长子的妻子说:“唉,我们这位婆婆,好像给了我们长子两份财产似的,老是来我们家。”其他儿子的妻子们也这么说。从长女开始,当她去她们家时,她们也对她说了同样的话。她受到轻视,心想:“我跟这些人住在一起有什么用?我要做比丘尼维生。”于是前往比丘尼僧院请求出家,她们便让她出家了。为了说明这个故事,才说:“多子的苏那(Soṇā)了知他们对自己不恭敬,心想‘在家生活有什么用?’便离家出家了。” Vihāraṃ gacchantiyoti bhikkhuvihāraṃ gacchantiyo. Dhammamuttamanti navavidhalokuttaradhammaṃ. So hi uttamadhammo nāma yo hi taṃ na passati, tassa vassasatampi jīvanato taṃ dhammaṃ passantassa paṭivijjhantassa ekāhampi ekakkhaṇampi jīvitaṃ seyyo. Āgantukajanoti vihāragataṃ bhikkhunījanaṃ sandhāya vadati. Anupadhāretvāti asallakkhetvā. “前往寺院”,即前往比丘寺院。“无上法”,即九种出世间法。此法之所以是无上法,是因为若不见此法,虽寿百岁,亦不如见此法、证悟此法者,一日乃至一刹那的生命。“来客”,是指来到寺院的比丘尼众。“不加留意”,即不加省察。 Bakulātherīvatthu 跋库拉长老尼的故事 242. Aṭṭhamaṃ uttānatthameva. 242. 第八则,其义自明。 Kuṇḍalakesātherīvatthu 军荼罗髻长老尼的故事 243. Navame catukketi vīthicatukke. Catunnaṃ samāhāro catukkaṃ. Cārakatoti bandhanāgārato. Ubbaṭṭetvāti uddharitvā. 243. 第九则。“四衢”,即道路的十字路口。“四”是四者的集合。“从监狱”,即从囚禁处。“拔出”,即救出。 Muhuttamapi cintayeti muhuttaṃ taṅkhaṇampi ṭhānuppattikapaññāya taṅkhaṇānurūpaṃ atthaṃ cintituṃ sakkuṇeyya. Sahassamapi ce gāthā, anatthapadasaṃhitāti ayaṃ gāthā dārucīriyattherassa bhagavatā bhāsitā, idhāpi ca sāyeva gāthā dassitā. Therigāthāsaṃvaṇṇanāyaṃ ācariyadhammapālattherenapi kuṇḍalakesittheriyā vatthumhi ayameva gāthā vuttā. Dhammapadaṭṭhakathāyaṃ pana kuṇḍalakesittheriyā vatthumhi – 即使是片刻的思考,如果具备了处所生智(ṭhānuppattikapaññā),也能在那个片刻思维与之相应的义理。“即使有一千首偈颂,如果其中没有义句”(Sahassamapi ce gāthā, anatthapadasaṃhitā)——这首偈是世尊对木衣长老(Dārucīriya)说的,在这里也引用了这首偈。在《长老尼偈释义》(Therīgāthāsaṃvaṇṇanā)中,法护(Dhammapāla)长老阿阇梨也在军荼罗髻(Kuṇḍalakesī)长老尼的故事中引用了这首偈。而在《法句义注》(Dhammapadaṭṭhakathā)中,关于军荼罗髻长老尼的故事则说: ‘‘Yo ca gāthāsataṃ bhāse, anatthapadasaṃhitā; Ekaṃ dhammapadaṃ seyyo, yaṃ sutvā upasammatī’’ti. (dha. pa. aṭṭha. 1.102) – “若人诵百偈,无有义相应;不如一法句,闻已得寂静。” Ayaṃ gāthā āgatā. Taṃtaṃbhāṇakānaṃ kathāmaggānusārena tattha tattha tathā vuttanti na idha ācariyassa pubbāparavirodho saṅkitabbo. 此偈已出现。各个说法师(bhāṇaka)按照各自的说法次第,于此处彼处如此宣说,不应因此怀疑导师前后不一致。 Bhaddākāpilānītherī-bhaddākaccānātherīvatthu 跋陀迦毗罗尼长老尼与跋陀迦旃延长老尼的故事 244-245. Dasamaṃ [Pg.199] ekādasamañca uttānatthameva. 244-245. 第十与第十一偈,其义浅显。 Kisāgotamītherīvatthu 瘦乔达弥长老尼的故事 246. Dvādasame tīhi lūkhehīti vatthalūkhasuttalūkharajanalūkhasaṅkhātehi tīhi lūkhehi. Siddhatthakanti sāsapabījaṃ. 246. 第十二,“三种粗糙物”(tīhi lūkhehi)是指粗糙的布、粗糙的线、粗糙的染料这三种粗糙物。“白芥子”(Siddhatthaka)是指芥菜籽。 Taṃ puttapasusammattanti taṃ rūpabalādisampanne putte ca pasū ca labhitvā ‘‘mama puttā abhirūpā balasampannā paṇḍitā sabbakiccasamatthā, mama goṇo arogo abhirūpo mahābhāravaho, mama gāvī bahukhīrā’’ti evaṃ puttehi ca pasūhi ca sammattaṃ naraṃ. Byāsattamanasanti cakkhuviññeyyādīsu ārammaṇesu hiraññasuvaṇṇādīsu pattacīvarādīsu vā yaṃ yaṃ laddhaṃ hoti, tattha tattheva lagganāya sattamānasaṃ. Suttaṃ gāmanti niddaṃ upagataṃ sattakāyaṃ. Mahoghovāti yathā evarūpaṃ gāmaṃ gambhīrato vitthārato ca mahanto mahānadiogho antamaso sunakhampi asesetvā sabbaṃ ādāya gacchati, evaṃ vuttappakāraṃ naraṃ maccu ādāya gacchatīti attho. Amataṃ padanti maraṇarahitaṃ koṭṭhāsaṃ, amataṃ mahānibbānanti attho. Sesamettha uttānameva. “沉溺于子嗣与牲畜”(Taṃ puttapasusammattanti)是指:得到容貌端正、力量充沛的子女和牲畜后,就认为‘我的子女们容貌端正、力量充沛、智慧聪明、能胜任一切事务;我的公牛无病健康、容貌端正、能负重载;我的母牛产奶丰富’等等,像这样因子女和牲畜而沉溺的人。“心意执著”(Byāsattamanasanti)是指:对于眼识所认知的对象等所缘,无论是得到的金银财宝,还是衣钵等等,心都执着于那些事物。“沉睡的村庄”(Suttaṃ gāmaṃ)是指:众生如同陷入睡眠的状态。“大洪水”(Mahoghovāti)是指:如同这样一条河流,从深度和广度上来说都是巨大的洪流,甚至连一条狗也不放过,全部席卷而去;同样地,死神也将上述那种人带走。“不死句”(Amataṃ padaṃ)是指:没有死亡的部分,也就是大涅槃的意思。其余含义很明显。 Siṅgālakamātātherīvatthu 辛伽罗迦之母长老尼的故事 247. Terasamaṃ uttānatthameva. 247. 第十三偈,其义浅显。 (Pañcamaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā.) (第五最上品释义终。) Theripāḷisaṃvaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 《长老尼经释义》终。 14. Etadaggavaggo 14. 最上品 (14) 6. Chaṭṭhaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā (14)六、第六最上品释义 Tapussa-bhallikavatthu 提婆沙与跋梨迦的故事 248. Upāsakapāḷisaṃvaṇṇanāya [Pg.200] paṭhame sabbapaṭhamaṃ saraṇaṃ gacchantānanti sabbesaṃ paṭhamaṃ hutvā saraṇaṃ gacchantānaṃ. Ito paranti sattasattāhato paraṃ. Gamanūpacchedaṃ akāsīti gamanavicchedaṃ akāsi. Yathā te goṇā dhuraṃ chaḍḍetvā pothiyamānāpi na gacchanti, tathā akāsīti attho. Tesanti tapussabhallikānaṃ. Adhimuccitvāti āvisitvā. Yakkhassa āvaṭṭo yakkhāvaṭṭo. Evaṃ sesesupi. Atītabuddhānaṃ āciṇṇaṃ olokesīti atītabuddhā kena bhājanena paṭiggaṇhiṃsūti buddhāciṇṇaṃ olokesi. Dvevācike saraṇe patiṭṭhāyāti saṅghassa anuppannattā buddhadhammavasena dvevācike saraṇe patiṭṭhahitvā. Cetiyanti pūjanīyavatthuṃ. Jīvakesadhātuyāti jīvamānassa bhagavato kesadhātuyā. 248. 在《优婆塞经释义》的开篇,“一切最初归依者”是指最先归依者。“此后”是指七七四十九日之后。“止其行步”意为中断行走。如同那些公牛卸下轭具后,即使被鞭打也不前行,其意亦是如此。“彼等”是指提婆沙(Tapussa)与跋梨迦(Bhallika)。“胜解”即进入。“夜叉(yakkha)之涡”即夜叉的漩涡。其余类似之处亦应如此理解。“观察过去诸佛所行”,是观察过去诸佛用何钵接受供养,即观察过去诸佛的惯例。“于二语归依中安住”,因为当时僧团尚未出现,故依佛与法二者而建立二语归依。“制多”指应受供养之物。“生身发舍利”即世尊在世时的头发舍利。 Anāthapiṇḍikaseṭṭhivatthu 给孤独长者的故事 249. Dutiye teneva guṇenāti teneva dāyakabhāvasaṅkhātena guṇena. So hi sabbakāmasamiddhatāya vigatamaccheratāya karuṇādiguṇasamaṅgitāya ca niccakālaṃ anāthānaṃ piṇḍamadāsi. Tena sabbakālaṃ upaṭṭhito anāthānaṃ piṇḍo etassa atthīti anāthapiṇḍikoti saṅkhaṃ gato. Yojanikavihāre kāretvāti yojane yojane ekamekaṃ vihāraṃ kāretvā. ‘‘Evarūpaṃ dānaṃ pavattesī’’ti vatvā tameva dānaṃ vibhajitvā dassento ‘‘devasikaṃ pañca salākabhattāni hontī’’tiādimāha. Tattha salākāya gāhetabbaṃ bhattaṃ salākabhattaṃ. Ekasmiṃ pakkhe ekadivasaṃ dātabbaṃ bhattaṃ pakkhikabhattaṃ. Dhuragehe ṭhapetvā dātabbaṃ bhattaṃ dhurabhattaṃ. Āgantukānaṃ dātabbaṃ bhattaṃ āgantukabhattaṃ. Evaṃ sesesupi. Pañca āsanasatāni gehe niccapaññattāneva hontīti gehe nisīdāpetvā bhuñjantānaṃ pañcannaṃ bhikkhusatānaṃ pañca āsanasatāni niccapaññattāni honti. 249. 第二,是因功德之故,即因其具施主之德。他因具足一切圆满财富、远离悭吝、怀有慈悲等美德,故常布施食物予无依者。因此,他恒常为无依者准备食物,故被称为“给孤独”(Anāthapiṇḍika)。“每由旬建一精舍”,即在每一由旬处建造一座寺院。说完“应如是行布施”,便将布施物品分门别类地展示出来:“每日应有五百份筹食”等等。其中,以筹码领取的食物是筹食。每半月供养一日的食物是半月食。在主屋常备的食物是常食。为来客所供的食物是客食。其余亦如是类推。“家中恒常备有五百个座位”,即为令五百比丘安坐受食,故恒常备此五百座位。 Cittagahapativatthu 质多居士的故事 250. Tatiye migā eva migarūpāni. Bhikkhaṃ samādāpetvāti, ‘‘bhante, mayhaṃ anuggahaṃ karotha, idha nisīditvā bhikkhaṃ gaṇhathā’’ti bhikkhāgahaṇatthaṃ samādāpetvā[Pg.201]. Vivaṭṭaṃ uddissa upacitaṃ nibbedhabhāgiyakusalaṃ upanissayo. Saḷāyatanavibhattimeva desesīti saḷāyatanavibhāgappaṭisaṃyuttameva dhammakathaṃ kathesi. Therenāti tattha sannihitānaṃ sabbesaṃ jeṭṭhena mahātherena. Pañhaṃ vissajjetuṃ asakkontenāti cittena gahapatinā ‘‘yā imā, bhante thera, anekavihitā diṭṭhiyo loke uppajjanti, ‘sassato loko’ti vā, ‘asassato loko’ti vā, ‘antavā loko’ti vā, ‘anantavā loko’ti vā, ‘taṃ jīvaṃ taṃ sarīra’nti vā, ‘aññaṃ jīvaṃ aññaṃ sarīra’nti vā, ‘hoti tathāgato paraṃ maraṇā’ti vā, ‘na hoti tathāgato paraṃ maraṇā’ti vā, ‘hoti ca na hoti ca tathāgato paraṃ maraṇā’ti vā, ‘neva hoti na na hoti tathāgato paraṃ maraṇā’ti vā yāni cimāni dvāsaṭṭhi diṭṭhigatāni brahmajāle gaṇitāni, imā nu kho, bhante, diṭṭhiyo kismiṃ sati honti, kismiṃ asati na hontī’’ti evamādinā (saṃ. ni. 4.345) pañhe puṭṭhe taṃ pañhaṃ vissajjetuṃ asakkontena. Imaṃ kira pañhaṃ yāvatatiyaṃ puṭṭho mahāthero tuṇhī ahosi. Atha isidattatthero cintesi – ‘‘ayaṃ thero neva attanā byākaroti, na aññaṃ ajjhesati, upāsako ca bhikkhusaṅghaṃ vihesati, ahametaṃ byākaritvā phāsuvihāraṃ katvā dassāmī’’ti. Evaṃ cintetvā ca āsanato vuṭṭhāya therassa santikaṃ gantvā ‘‘byākaromahaṃ, bhante, cittassa gahapatino etaṃ pañha’’nti (saṃ. ni. 4.345) āha. Evaṃ vutte thero ‘‘byākarohi tvaṃ, āvuso isidatta, cittassa gahapatino etaṃ pañha’’nti isidattaṃ ajjhesi. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘pañhaṃ vissajjetuṃ asakkontena ajjhiṭṭho’’ti. 250. 第三,鹿即是鹿形。“劝令乞食”,即‘尊者,请您怜悯我,请坐此处接受乞食’,为乞食而劝请。以朝向解脱、已累积的抉择分善为助缘。“只讲六处分别”,即只讲与六处分别相应的法谈。“长老”,是指在场所有比丘中最年长之大长老。“不能回答问题”,是指质多居士问:‘尊者,世间生起种种不同之见解,例如“世界是常”、“世界是无常”、“世界有边”、“世界无边”、“命即是身”、“命异身异”、“如来死后存在”、“如来死后不存在”、“如来死后既存在又不存在”、“如来死后既非存在也非不存在”,以及《梵网经》(Brahmajāla)中所列举之六十二种见解。尊者,这些见解在何种情况下产生?在何种情况下不产生?’像这样(saṃ. ni. 4.345)被提问,却无法回答此问题。据说此问题被问了三次,大长老皆保持沉默。这时,伊西达多(Isidatta)长老心想:‘这位长老既不亲自回答,亦不请他人回答,优婆塞却在困扰比丘僧团,我应回答此问题,令其获得安乐住。’如是想着,便从座位上站起,走到长老面前说:‘尊者,我愿回答质多居士此问题。’(saṃ. ni. 4.345)长老听后,便邀请伊西达多说:‘贤友伊西达多,你来回答质多居士此问题吧。’故说‘不能回答问题而被邀请’。 Pañhaṃ vissajjetvāti ‘‘yā imā, gahapati, anekavihitā diṭṭhiyo loke uppajjanti ‘sassato loko’ti vā, ‘asassato loko’ti vā…pe… yāni cimāni dvāsaṭṭhi diṭṭhigatāni brahmajāle gaṇitāni, imā kho, gahapati, diṭṭhiyo sakkāyadiṭṭhiyā sati honti, sakkāyadiṭṭhiyā asati na hontī’’tiādinā nayena pañhaṃ vissajjetvā. Gihisahāyakabhāve ñāteti therassa gihisahāyakabhāve cittena gahapatinā ñāte. Citto kira, gahapati, tassa pañhaveyyākaraṇe tuṭṭho ‘‘kuto, bhante, ayyo isidatto āgacchatī’’ti vatvā ‘‘avantiyā kho ahaṃ, gahapati, āgacchāmī’’ti vutto ‘‘atthi, bhante, avantiyā [Pg.202] isidatto nāma kulaputto amhākaṃ adiṭṭhasahāyo pabbajito, diṭṭho so āyasmatā’’ti pucchi. Thero ca ‘‘evaṃ, gahapatī’’ti vatvā ‘‘kahaṃ nu kho, bhante, so āyasmā etarahi viharatī’’ti puna puṭṭho tuṇhī ahosi. Atha citto gahapati ‘‘ayyo no, bhante, isidatto’’ti pucchitvā ‘‘evaṃ, gahapatī’’ti vutte attano gihisahāyabhāvaṃ aññāsi. 解答问题后,即以“居士,世间生起种种见解,如‘世界是常’或‘世界是无常’……乃至《梵网经》中所计数的六十二种见解,居士,这些见解皆因有身见而生,若无身见则不生起”之方式解答了问题。质多居士心中了知长老曾是在家时的友人。据说,质多居士对他的解答感到满意,问道:“尊者,伊西达多(Isidatta)具寿从何处来?”答曰:“居士,我从阿槃提(Avanti)来。”又问:“尊者,在阿槃提有一位名叫伊西达多的良家子,是我们未曾谋面的友人,他已出家,具寿您见过他吗?”长老答:“是的,居士。”再问:“那么,尊者,那位具寿现在住在何处?”长老默然不语。于是质多居士问道:“尊者,您就是我们的伊西达多吗?”答曰:“正是,居士。”质多居士于是知晓了(他就是)自己在家时的友人。 Tejosamāpattipāṭihāriyaṃ dassetvāti ekasmiṃ kira divase citto gahapati ‘‘sādhu me, bhante, ayyo uttarimanussadhammā iddhipāṭihāriyaṃ dassetū’’ti mahātheraṃ yāci. Thero ‘‘tena hi tvaṃ, gahapati, āḷinde uttarāsaṅgaṃ paññāpetvā tattha tiṇakalāpaṃ okirā’’ti vatvā tena ca tathā kate sayaṃ vihāraṃ pavisitvā ca ghaṭikaṃ datvā tathārūpaṃ iddhābhisaṅkhāraṃ abhisaṅkhāresi, yathā tāḷacchiggaḷena ca aggaḷantarikāya ca acci nikkhamitvā tiṇāni jhāpeti, uttarāsaṅgaṃ na jhāpeti. Atha citto gahapati uttarāsaṅgaṃ papphoṭetvā saṃviggo lomahaṭṭhajāto ekamantaṃ ṭhito theraṃ bahi nikkhamantaṃ disvā ‘‘abhiramatu, bhante, ayyo macchikāsaṇḍe, ramaṇīyaṃ ambāṭakavanaṃ, ahaṃ ayyassa ussukkaṃ karissāmi cīvarapiṇḍapātasenāsanagilānapaccayabhesajjaparikkhārāna’’nti āha. Tato thero ‘‘na dāni idha vasituṃ sakkā’’ti tamhā vihārā pakkāmi. Taṃ sandhāyetaṃ vuttaṃ – ‘‘tejosamāpatti pāṭihāriyaṃ dassetvā ‘idāni idha vasituṃ na yutta’nti yathāsukhaṃ pakkāmī’’ti. Dve aggasāvakātiādīsu yaṃ vattabbaṃ, taṃ vitthārato vinayapāḷiyaṃ āgatameva. 示现火光定神变:据说某日,质多居士请求大长老:“尊者,请为我示现超人法的神通变化。”长老说:“那么,居士,你可在走廊铺设上衣(uttarāsaṅga),并在其上撒些草。”质多居士照办后,长老进入精舍,插上门闩,然后发起如是神通力,使得火焰从钥匙孔与门闩缝隙中冒出,烧尽了草,却不烧上衣。于是质多居士拍打着上衣,心生惊悚,汗毛竖立,站于一旁。他看见长老从里面出来,便说:“尊者,愿具寿欢喜住于马奇咖三答(Macchikāsaṇḍa),安巴达迦(Ambāṭaka)林苑甚是宜人,我将为具寿尽力提供衣、食、卧具、医药等资具。”之后,长老心想:“现在不宜再住于此处。”便离开了那座精舍。此即所谓——“示现火光定神变后,因‘现在不宜住于此处’,故随意离开了。”关于两位上首弟子等事,其详细内容已在律藏中宣说。 Saddhoti lokiyalokuttarāya saddhāya samannāgato. Sīlenāti agāriyasīlaṃ anagāriyasīlanti duvidhaṃ sīlaṃ, tesu idha agāriyaṃ sīlaṃ adhippetaṃ, tena samannāgatoti attho. Yasobhogasamappitoti yādiso anāthapiṇḍikādīnaṃ pañcaupāsakasataparivārasaṅkhāto agāriyo yaso, tādiseneva yasena, yo ca dhanadhaññādiko ceva sattavidhaariyadhanasaṅkhāto cāti duvidho bhogo, tena ca samannāgatoti attho. Yaṃ yaṃ padesanti puratthimādīsu disāsu evarūpo kulaputto yaṃ yaṃ padesaṃ bhajati, tattha tattha evarūpena lābhasakkārena pūjitova hotīti attho. 有信(Saddho)者,即具足世间与出世间之信。具戒(Sīlena)者,戒有在家戒与出家戒二种,此处意指在家戒,即具足此戒之义。具足名声与财富(Yasobhogasamappito)者,其名声如同给孤独(Anāthapiṇḍika)长者等五百优婆塞(upāsaka)所围绕的在家名声;其财富则有财物谷物等(世间财富)与七种圣财(出世间财富)二种,具足此二者即是此义。无论这位良家子(kulaputta)前往东方等任何方向的任何地方,在所到之处,皆能受到如是的利养与恭敬。 Hatthakaāḷavakavatthu 阿拉威人哈达嘎事 251. Catutthe [Pg.203] catubbidhena saṅgahavatthunāti dānapiyavacanaatthacariyāsamānattatāsaṅkhātena catubbidhena saṅgahavatthunā. ‘‘Sve bhattacāṭiyā saddhiṃ āḷavakassa pesetabbo ahosī’’ti vuttamatthaṃ pākaṭaṃ katvā dassetuṃ – ‘‘tatrāyaṃ anupubbikathā’’tiādimāha. Migavatthāya araññaṃ gantvāti āḷavako rājā vividhanāṭakūpabhogaṃ chaḍḍetvā corappaṭibāhanatthañca paṭirājanisedhanatthañca byāyāmakaraṇatthañca sattame sattame divase migavaṃ gacchanto ekadivasaṃ balakāyena saddhiṃ ‘‘yassa passena migo palāyati, tasseva so bhāro’’ti katakatikavatto migavatthāya araññaṃ gantvā. Ekaṃ miganti attano ṭhitaṭṭhānena palātaṃ eṇimigaṃ. Anubandhitvāti tiyojanamaggaṃ ekakova anubandhitvā. Javasampanno hi rājā dhanuṃ gahetvā pattikova tiyojanaṃ taṃ migamanubandhi. Ghātetvāti yasmā eṇimigā tiyojanavegā eva honti, tasmā parikkhiṇajavaṃ taṃ migaṃ udakaṃ pavisitvā ṭhitaṃ ghātetvā. Dvidhā chetvā dhanukoṭiyaṃ lagetvā nivattetvā āgacchantoti anatthikopi maṃsena ‘‘nāsakkhi migaṃ gahetu’’nti apavādamocanatthaṃ dvidhā chinnaṃ dhanukoṭiyaṃ lagetvā āgacchanto. Sandacchāyanti ghanacchāyaṃ bahalapattapalāsaṃ. 251. 第四,以四摄事:即以布施、爱语、利行、同事四种摄事。为了阐明“明日应将饭锅一同送给阿拉威(夜叉)”之义,故说“此处有次第说”等。阿拉威王舍弃各种戏剧娱乐,为防盗贼、阻敌国、锻炼身体,每七日前往森林狩猎。他曾立下规矩:“鹿从谁的方位逃跑,就由谁负责。”有一次,他前往森林狩猎。一只羚鹿从他所站之处逃走。他独自追赶了三由旬远。这位国王速度矫健,手持弓箭,如步兵般追赶那只鹿三由旬。因为羚鹿只能跑三由旬远,当那只精疲力竭的鹿进入水中站立时,他便将其射杀。他虽不需鹿肉,但为免遭“未能捕获鹿”之讥,便将鹿劈成两半,挂在弓梢上返回。浓荫处,即树叶繁茂、树荫浓密之处。 Rukkhe adhivatthā devatāti āḷavakaṃ yakkhaṃ sandhāya vadati. So hi mahārājūnaṃ santikā varaṃ labhitvā majjhanhikasamaye tassa rukkhassa chāyāya phuṭṭhokāsaṃ paviṭṭhe pāṇino khādanto tattha paṭivasati. Āḷavakassa nisīdanapallaṅke nisīdīti yattha abhilakkhitesu maṅgaladivasādīsu āḷavako nisīditvā siriṃ anubhoti, tasmiṃyeva dibbaratanapallaṅke nisīdi. Attano gamane asampajjamāne ‘‘kiṃ nu kho kāraṇa’’nti āvajjentāti tadā kira sātāgirahemavatā bhagavantaṃ jetavaneyeva vanditvā ‘‘yakkhasamāgamaṃ gamissāmā’’ti saparivārā nānāyānehi ākāsena gacchanti, ākāse ca yakkhānaṃ na sabbattha maggo atthi, ākāsaṭṭhāni vimānāni pariharitvā maggaṭṭhāneneva maggo hoti, āḷavakassa pana vimānaṃ bhūmaṭṭhaṃ suguttaṃ pākāraparikkhittaṃ susaṃvihitadvāraṭṭālakagopuraṃ upari kaṃsajālasañchannamañjūsāsadisaṃ tiyojanaṃ ubbedhena, tassa upari maggo hoti, te taṃ padesamāgamma gantumasamatthā [Pg.204] ahesuṃ. Buddhānañhi nisinnokāsassa uparibhāgena yāva bhavaggā koci gantumasamattho, tasmā attano gamane asampajjamāne ‘‘kiṃ nu kho kāraṇa’’nti āvajjesuṃ. Tesaṃ kathaṃ sutvā cintesīti yasmā assaddhassa saddhākathā dukkathā hoti dussīlādīnaṃ sīlakathādayo viya, tasmā tesaṃ yakkhānaṃ santikā bhagavato pasaṃsaṃ sutvā eva aggimhi pakkhittaloṇasakkharā viya abbhantare uppannakopena paṭapaṭāyamānahadayo hutvā cintesi. Pabbatakūṭanti kelāsapabbatakūṭaṃ. “居住于树之天神”,此乃指阿拉威(Āḷavaka)夜叉。他曾从四大天王处获得特权,得以吞食在正午时分进入其树荫范围内的生灵,并居住于此。“坐在阿拉威的宝座上”:在那些指定的吉祥日等日子里,阿拉威会坐在那里享受威福,(世尊)就坐在那张天界的珍宝之座上。“当他们发现自己无法前进时,心想:‘究竟是何原因?’”:据说当时,萨达吉拉(Sātāgira)与雪山(Hemavata)(二位夜叉大将)在祇陀林(Jetavana)礼拜世尊后,正与眷属乘坐各种交通工具,于空中前往夜叉集会。然而,在夜叉界的空中,并非处处皆有通道,必须绕开空中的宫殿,唯有在通道处方能通行。阿拉威的宫殿建于地面,有坚固的围墙环绕,门楼、箭塔、城门布局完善,顶部覆盖着铜网,高达三由旬,形如宝箱,其上方才是通道。他们来到此地,便无法前行。因为在佛陀所坐之处的上方,直至有顶天,都无人能够飞越。因此,当他们发现自己无法前进时,便思索其原因。“听到他们的话后,他心想”:因为对于无信者,说信之语是难堪的,如同对无戒者说戒一般。因此,当他从那些夜叉处听到对世尊的赞美时,内心便如盐粒投火,噼啪作响,怒火中烧,如是思量。“山顶”,即指凯拉萨(Kelāsa)山的山顶。 Ito paṭṭhāya āḷavakayuddhaṃ vitthāretabbanti so kira manosilātale vāmapādena ṭhatvā ‘‘passatha dāni tumhākaṃ vā satthā mahānubhāvo, ahaṃ vā’’ti dakkhiṇapādena saṭṭhiyojanamattaṃ kelāsakūṭapabbataṃ akkami, taṃ ayokūṭappahato viya niddhantaayapiṇḍo papaṭikāyo muñci. So tatra ṭhatvā ‘‘ahaṃ āḷavako’’ti ugghosesi, sakalajambudīpaṃ saddo phari. Tiyojanasahassavitthatahimavāpi sampakampi yakkhassānubhāvena. So vātamaṇḍalaṃ samuṭṭhāpesi ‘‘eteneva samaṇaṃ palāpessāmī’’ti. Te puratthimādibhedā vātā samuṭṭhahitvā aḍḍhayojanayojanadviyojanatiyojanappamāṇāni pabbatakūṭāni padāletvā vanagaccharukkhādīni ummūletvā āḷavinagaraṃ pakkhandā jiṇṇahatthisālādīni cuṇṇentā chadaniṭṭhakā ākāse bhamentā. Bhagavā ‘‘mā kassaci uparodho hotū’’ti adhiṭṭhāsi. Te vātā dasabalaṃ patvā cīvarakaṇṇamattampi cāletuṃ nāsakkhiṃsu. Tato mahāvassaṃ samuṭṭhāpesi ‘‘udakena ajjhottharitvā samaṇaṃ māressāmī’’ti. Tassānubhāvena uparūpari satapaṭalasahassapaṭalādibhedā valāhakā uṭṭhahitvā pavassiṃsu. Vuṭṭhidhārāvegena pathavī chiddā ahosi. Vanarukkhādīnaṃ upari mahogho āgantvā dasabalassa cīvare ussāvabindumattampi temetuṃ nāsakkhi. Tato pāsāṇavassaṃ samuṭṭhāpesi. Mahantāni mahantāni pabbatakūṭāni dhūmāyantāni pajjalantāni ākāsenāgantvā dasabalaṃ patvā dibbamālāguḷāni sampajjiṃsu. Tato paharaṇavassaṃ samuṭṭhāpesi. Ekatodhārā ubhatodhārā asisattikhurappādayo dhūmāyantā pajjalantā ākāsenāgantvā dasabalassa pādamūle dibbapupphāni ahesuṃ. 自此,当详述阿拉威夜叉之战。据说,他左脚立于雄黄石板上,说:“现在你们看看,是你们的导师有大威力,还是我!”便用右脚踏上六十由旬之高的凯拉萨(Kelāsa)山峰。那山峰犹如被铁锤击打的烧红铁块,迸裂飞散。他立于其上,高喊:“我是阿拉威!”声音传遍整个瞻部洲(Jambudīpa)。三千由旬宽的雪山也因夜叉的威力而震动。他兴起风团,心想:“以此将沙门吹走。”于是,从东方等各方兴起狂风,摧毁了半由旬、一由旬、二由旬、三由旬高的山峰,拔起了林中的树木,冲入阿拉威(Āḷavī)城,将旧象厩等粉碎,屋瓦在空中飞舞。世尊(Bhagavā)决意:“愿无人受害。”那些风吹到十力者之处,连其衣角都无法吹动分毫。接着,他兴起大雨,心想:“用水淹死沙门。”依其威力,成百上千层乌云重叠涌现而降雨。雨势之猛,使大地开裂。洪水漫过林木之上,却未能沾湿十力者袈裟上的一滴露水。之后,他兴起石雨。巨大的山峰冒着烟、燃着火从空中飞来,到达十力者之处,化作了天界的花鬘。再后,他兴起兵器雨。单刃、双刃的剑、矛、剃刀箭等,冒着烟、燃着火从空中飞来,在十力者的足下化作了天界的花朵。 Tato [Pg.205] aṅgāravassaṃ samuṭṭhāpesi. Kiṃsukavaṇṇā aṅgārā ākāsenāgantvā dasabalassa pādamūle dibbapupphāni hutvā vikiriṃsu. Tato kukkuḷavassaṃ samuṭṭhāpesi. Accuṇho kukkuḷo ākāsenāgantvā dasabalassa pādamūle candanacuṇṇaṃ hutvā nipati. Tato vālikavassaṃ samuṭṭhāpesi. Atisukhumā vālikā dhūmāyantā pajjalantā ākāsenāgantvā dasabalassa pādamūle dibbapupphāni hutvā nipatiṃsu. Tato kalalavassaṃ samuṭṭhāpesi. Taṃ dhūmāyantaṃ pajjalantaṃ ākāsenāgantvā dasabalassa pādamūle dibbagandhaṃ hutvā nipati. Tato andhakāraṃ samuṭṭhāpesi ‘‘bhiṃsetvā samaṇaṃ palāpessāmī’’ti. Caturaṅgasamannāgataṃ andhakārasadisaṃ hutvā dasabalaṃ patvā sūriyappabhāvihatamivandhakāraṃ antaradhāyi. Evaṃ yakkho imāhi navahi vātavassapāsāṇapaharaṇaṅgārakukkuḷavālikakalalandhakāravuṭṭhīhi bhagavantaṃ palāpetumasakkonto nānāvidhappaharaṇahatthaanekappakārarūpabhūtagaṇasamākulāya caturaṅginiyā senāya sayameva bhagavantaṃ abhigato. Te bhūtagaṇā anekappakāravikāre katvā ‘‘gaṇhatha hanathā’’ti bhagavato upari āgacchantā viya ca honti. Apica kho niddhantalohapiṇḍaṃ viya makkhikā bhagavantaṃ allīyitumasamatthā eva ahesuṃ. 其后,他兴起炭火雨。赤如甄叔迦花的炭火从空中飞来,在十力者的足下化作天花散落。接着,他兴起热灰雨。滚烫的热灰从空中飞来,在十力者的足下化作栴檀粉洒落。然后,他兴起沙雨。极细的沙粒冒着烟、燃着火从空中飞来,在十力者的足下化作天花洒落。又次,他兴起污泥雨。那冒着烟、燃着火的污泥从空中飞来,在十力者的足下化作天香洒落。最后,他兴起黑暗,心想:“以此恐吓沙门,令其逃走。”那具足四支、如暗夜般的黑暗,一到十力者之处,便如被日光所破一般消失无踪。就这样,夜叉用这九种风、雨、石、兵器、炭火、热灰、沙、泥、黑暗之雨,未能使世尊退避,便亲自率领手持各种兵器、由无数变相鬼神组成的四支军队,向世尊逼近。那些鬼神众变现出种种怪状,叫喊着“捉住他!杀掉他!”,作势扑向世尊。然而,他们却像苍蝇一般,完全无法靠近烧红的铁块。 Evaṃ sabbarattiṃ anekappakāravibhiṃsākāradassanenapi bhagavantaṃ cāletumasakkonto āḷavako cintesi – ‘‘yaṃnūnāhaṃ kenaci ajeyyaṃ dussāvudhaṃ muñceyya’’nti. Sace hi so duṭṭho ākāse taṃ dussāvudhaṃ muñceyya, dvādasa vassāni devo na vasseyya. Sace pathaviyaṃ muñceyya, sabbarukkhatiṇādīni sussitvā dvādasavassantaraṃ na puna ruheyyuṃ. Sace samudde muñceyya, tattakapāle udakabindu viya sabbaṃ susseyya. Sace sinerupabbate muñceyya, khaṇḍākhaṇḍaṃ hutvā vikireyya. So evaṃmahānubhāvaṃ dussāvudhaṃ uttarisāṭakaṃ muñcitvā aggahesi. Yebhuyyena dasasahassilokadhātudevatā vegena sannipatiṃsu ‘‘ajja bhagavā āḷavakaṃ damessati, tattha dhammaṃ sossāmā’’ti. Yuddhadassanakāmāpi devatā sannipatiṃsu. Evaṃ sakalampi ākāsaṃ devatāhi paripuṇṇaṃ ahosi. Athāḷavako bhagavato samīpe uparūpari vicaritvā vatthāvudhaṃ muñci[Pg.206]. Taṃ asanicakkaṃ viya ākāse bheravasaddaṃ karontaṃ dhūmāyantaṃ pajjalantaṃ bhagavantaṃ patvā yakkhassa mānamaddanatthaṃ pādapuñchanacoḷaṃ hutvā pādamūle nipati. Āḷavako taṃ disvā chinnavisāṇo viya usabho, uddhaṭadāṭho viya sappo nittejo nimmado nipātitamānaddhajo ahosi. Evamidaṃ āḷavakayuddhaṃ vitthāretabbaṃ. 阿拉威(Āḷavaka)夜叉见整夜示现种种恐怖之相,仍无法动摇世尊,便思忖道:“我当掷出无人能敌的都沙神衣(dussāvudhaṃ)。”此神衣若掷于空中,天将十二年不雨;若掷于大地,一切草木皆将干枯,十二年内不再生长;若掷于大海,海水将如热锅上的一滴水,悉数蒸干;若掷于须弥山(Sineru),山亦将碎为齑粉。于是,他解下如此大威力的上衣神衣,持在手中。此时,一万世界中大多数天神迅速集会,心想:“今日世尊将调伏阿拉威,我等可于彼处听闻正法。”欲观战的天神也都前来集会。于是,整个天空充满了天神。其后,阿拉威在世尊身旁上下盘旋,掷出神衣。那神衣如雷电轮,在空中发出可怖声响,冒着烟、燃着火,飞向世尊。为摧伏夜叉之慢,神衣化作一块拭脚布,落在世尊足下。阿拉威见此情景,犹如被断角之公牛,犹如被拔牙之毒蛇,威光尽失,傲气全消,慢幢倾倒。阿拉威夜叉之战,当如是广说。 Aṭṭha pañhe pucchīti – 他问了八个问题: ‘‘Kiṃ sūdha vittaṃ purisassa seṭṭhaṃ,Kiṃ su suciṇṇaṃ sukhamāvahāti; Kiṃ su have sādutaraṃ rasānaṃ,Kathaṃ jīviṃ jīvitamāhu seṭṭha’’nti. (saṃ. ni. 1.246; su. ni. 183) – “于此,何为人之最上财?何法善行能招乐?诸味之中何为最上味?云何生活,说为最上生?” Ādinā aṭṭha pañhe pucchi. Satthā vissajjesīti – 以此为首,问了八个问题。导师解答道: ‘‘Saddhīdha vittaṃ purisassa seṭṭhaṃ,Dhammo suciṇṇo sukhamāvahāti; Saccaṃ have sādutaraṃ rasānaṃ,Paññājīviṃ jīvitamāhu seṭṭha’’nti. (saṃ. ni. 1.246; su. ni. 184) – “于此,信为人之最上财,正法善行能招乐。诸味之中,谛为最上味,依慧生活,说为最上生。” Ādinā vissajjesi. Vikkandamānāyāti accantaṃ paridevamānāya. Vikkandamānāyāti,意为:极度悲伤地哭泣着。 Mahānāmasakkavatthu 摩诃男释迦之事 252. Pañcame satthā tato paraṃ paṭiññaṃ nādāsīti saṃvaccharato paraṃ sikkhāpadapaññattiyā paccayappavāraṇāsādiyanassa vāritattā ‘‘paṭiññaṃ nādāsī’’ti vuttaṃ. Tathā hi bhagavā tatiyavārepi mahānāmena sakkena ‘‘icchāmahaṃ, bhante, saṅghaṃ yāvajīvaṃ bhesajjena pavāretu’’nti (pāci. 304-305) vutte ‘‘sādhu sādhu, mahānāma, tena hi tvaṃ, mahānāma, saṅghaṃ yāvajīvaṃ bhesajjena pavārehī’’ti paṭiññaṃ adāsiyeva. Evaṃ paṭiññaṃ datvā pacchā chabbaggiyehi bhikkhūhi mahānāmassa sakkassa viheṭhitabhāvaṃ sutvā chabbaggiye bhikkhū vigarahitvā sikkhāpadaṃ paññapesi ‘‘agilānena bhikkhunā cātumāsappaccayapavāraṇā sāditabbā aññatra punappavāraṇāya aññatra niccappavāraṇāya. Tato ce uttari sādiyeyya, pācittiya’’nti. Tasmā paṭhamaṃ anujānitvāpi pacchā sikkhāpadabandhanena vāritattā ‘‘paṭiññaṃ nādāsī’’ti vuttaṃ. 252. 第五则,“世尊在那之后没有给予承诺”:之所以如此说,是因为后来制定了学处(sikkhāpada),禁止(比丘)接受资具的邀请。事实上,当摩诃男(Mahānāma)释迦第三次说:“尊者,我希望能终身以医药邀请僧团”(波逸提 304-305)时,世尊确实给予了承诺:“善哉,善哉,摩诃男!那么,摩诃男,你就终身以医药邀请僧团吧。”如此给予承诺后,世尊听闻六群比丘骚扰摩诃男释迦,便呵责了六群比丘,并制定学处:“无病比丘,可接受四个月的资具邀请,除非是再次邀请,除非是永久邀请。若超过此限而接受,则犯波逸提(pācittiya)。”因此,虽然最初予以允许,但后来因学处的制定而禁止,故说“没有给予承诺”。 Uggagahapatyādivatthu 郁伽长者等事 253-256. Chaṭṭhasattamaaṭṭhamanavamāni [Pg.207] suviññeyyāneva. 253-256. 第六、第七、第八和第九则,确实易于理解。 Nakulapitugahapativatthu 那拘罗父居士之事 257. Dasame susumāragirinagareti evaṃnāmake nagare. Tassa kira nagarassa vatthupariggahadivase avidūre udakarahade susumāro saddamakāsi, giraṃ nicchāresi. Atha nagare anantarāyena māpite tameva susumāragirakaraṇaṃ subhanimittaṃ katvā ‘‘susumāragirī’’tvevassa nāmaṃ akaṃsu. Keci pana ‘‘susumārasaṇṭhānattā susumāro nāma eko giri, so tassa nagarassa samīpe, tasmā taṃ susumāragiri etassa atthīti susumāragirīti vuccatī’’ti vadanti. Bhesakaḷāvaneti bhesakaḷānāmake vane. ‘‘Bhesakalāvane’’tipi pāṭho. Kathaṃ pana bhagavati nesaṃ puttasaññā patiṭṭhāsīti āha – ‘‘ayaṃ kirā’’tiādi. Daharasseva daharā ānītāti me daharasseva sato daharā ānītāti attho. Aticaritāti atikkamitvā caranto. 257. 第十则中,“鳄山城”(Susumāragiri)是一座以此为名的城市。据说,该城奠基之日,附近水池中有鳄鱼发出叫声。人们认为这是吉兆,便将此城命名为“鳄山城”。另有人说:“因有山形似鳄鱼,名为鳄山,邻近此城,故此城因有鳄山而被称为鳄山城。”“贝沙迦林”(Bhesakaḷāvana)即名为贝沙迦的森林。亦有作“Bhesakalāvane”的异读。至于世尊如何令他们生起视如己子之想,经中说:“据说……”等。“我幼时即被带来”意为“我尚年幼时即被带来”。“越轨”(aticaritā)即超越范围而行。 (Chaṭṭhaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā.) (第六最上品释义终。) Upāsakapāḷisaṃvaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 优婆塞品释义终。 14. Etadaggavaggo 14. 最上品 (14) 7. Sattamaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā (14) 7. 第七最上品释义 Sujātāvatthu 善生事 258. Upāsikāpāḷisaṃvaṇṇanāya paṭhamaṃ suviññeyyameva. 258. 优婆夷品释义的开篇易于理解。 Visākhāvatthu 毘舍佉事 259. Dutiye mahālatāpasādhanassāti mahālatāpiḷandhanassa. Tasmiñca piḷandhane catasso vajiranāḷiyo upayogaṃ agamaṃsu. Muttānaṃ ekādasa nāḷiyo, pavāḷassa dvāvīsati nāḷiyo, padumarāgamaṇīnaṃ tettiṃsa nāḷiyo. Iti etehi ca aññehi ca indanīlādīhi nīlapītalohitodātamañjiṭṭhasāmakabaravaṇṇavasena sattavaṇṇehi vararatanehi niṭṭhānaṃ agamāsi, taṃ sīse paṭimukkaṃ yāva pādapiṭṭhiyā bhassati, pañcannaṃ [Pg.208] hatthīnaṃ balaṃ dhārayamānāva naṃ itthī dhāretuṃ sakkoti. Antoaggi bahi na nīharitabbotiādīnaṃ attho upari āvi bhavissati. Sesamettha suviññeyyameva. 259. 第二则中,“大藤蔓饰物”(mahālatāpasādhana)即大藤蔓首饰(mahālatāpiḷandhana)。于此首饰中,用金刚管四根、珍珠管十一根、珊瑚管二十二根、红宝石管三十三根。此饰物由以上及蓝宝石等,依蓝、黄、红、白、茜、黑、杂色等七色上等宝物制成。佩于头顶,垂至脚背。唯有具五象之力的女子方能佩戴。“内火不外扬”等句的意义,将于后文阐明。其余于此易于理解。 Khujjuttarā-sāmāvatīvatthu 库竹达拉与萨玛瓦蒂事 260-261. Tatiyacatutthesu pāyāsassāti bahalatarassa pāyāsassa. Taṃ pāyāsaṃ bhuñjantesūti taṃ bahalataraṃ garusiniddhaṃ pāyāsaṃ bhuñjantesu. Jīrāpetuṃ asakkontoti antarāmagge appāhāratāya mandagahaṇikattā jīrāpetuṃ asakkonto. Vāḷamigaṭṭhāneti vāḷamigehi adhiṭṭhitaṭṭhāne. Anuvijjantoti vicārento. Sālāti naḷakārasālā. Mudhā na karissatīti mūlyaṃ vinā na karissati. Ālimpesīti aggiṃ adāsi, aggiṃ jālesīti attho. Pekkhāti āgamehi. Upadhisampadāti sarīrasampatti. Vaṭarukkhaṃ patvāti nigrodharukkhaṃ patvā. Suvaṇṇakaṭaketi suvaṇṇavalaye. Abbhuṃ meti me avaḍḍhīti attho. Anto asodhetvāti paṇṇasālāya anto kassaci atthibhāvaṃ vā natthibhāvaṃ vā anupadhāretvā. Sesaṃ suviññeyyameva. 260-261. 第三、四则中,“pāyāsa”指浓稠的粥。“食此粥时”指食此浓稠油腻之粥时。“无法消化”指因途中食物少、消化力弱而无法消化。“猛兽之地”指猛兽所居之处。“寻找”(anuvijjanto)指探查。“屋舍”(sālā)指芦苇屋。“不会白做”指不会不收报酬。“点燃”(ālimpesi)指给予火,即点火之意。“Pekkha”是“等待”的意思。“依止成就”(upadhisampadā)指身体的圆满。“到达榕树”指到达尼拘律树。“金手镯”(suvaṇṇakaṭake)指金手环。“为我增长”意为“于我而言有所增长”。“未察内部”指未探查草屋之内是否有人。其余易于理解。 Uttarānandamātāvatthu 难陀母优多罗事 262. Pañcame upanissayaṃ disvāti iminā yathā visesādhigamassa satipi paccuppannapaccayasamavāye avassaṃ upanissayasampadā icchitabbā, evaṃ diṭṭhadhammavedanīyabhāvena vipaccanakassa kammassapi paccuppannasamavāyo viya upanissayasampadāpi savisesā icchitabbāti dasseti. Tathā hi ukkaṃsagatasappurisūpanissayayonisomanasikāresu labbhamānesupi upanissayarahitassa visesādhigamo na sampajjatevāti. Kappiyaṃ katvāti yathā kappiyaṃ hoti, tathā katvā. Patte patiṭṭhapeyyāti āhāraṃ dānamukhe vissajjeyya. Tīhi cetanāhīti pubbabhāgamuñcaanumodanācetanāhi. Vuttañhetaṃ – 262. 第五则中,“见依止”(upanissayaṃ disvā)一句,是说即使有当下因缘和合,欲证得殊胜,亦必须具足依止成就。同样地,对于现法受之业而言,除了当下因缘和合之外,亦应特别重视依止成就。因为即使有上等善士为依止,以及如理作意等条件,若无依止,亦无法成就殊胜。“如法而行”(kappiyaṃ katvā)指如法地去做。“置于钵中”(patte patiṭṭhapeyyā)指将食物作为布施而舍出。“以三思”指前行思、舍思与随喜思。对此曾有言: ‘‘Pubbeva dānā sumano, dadaṃ cittaṃ pasādaye; Datvā attamano hoti, esā puññassa sampadā’’ti. (a. ni. 6.37; pe. va. 305); “施前心欣悦,施时心澄净;施后心欢喜,此为福成就。” Tava [Pg.209] manaṃ sandhārehīti ‘‘ajja bhattaṃ cirāyita’’nti kodhato tava cittaṃ sandhārehi, mā kujjhīti attho. Olokitolokitaṭṭhānaṃ…pe… samparikiṇṇaṃ viya ahosīti tena kasitaṭṭhānaṃ sabbaṃ suvaṇṇabhāvāpattiyā mahākosātakipupphehi sañchannaṃ viya ahosi. Tādiseti tayā sadise. Na kopemīti na vināsemi, jātiyā na hīḷemi. Pūjaṃ karotīti sammāsambuddhassa pūjaṃ karoti. Antaravatthunti gehaṅgaṇaṃ. Bhoti sambodhane nipāto. Jeti avaññālapanaṃ. Sayaṃ ariyasāvikābhāvato satthuvasena ‘‘sapitikā dhītā’’ti vatvā satthu sammukhā dhammassavanena tassā visesādhigamaṃ paccāsīsantī ‘‘dasabale khamanteyeva khamissāmī’’ti āha. Kadariyanti thaddhamacchariṃ. “你当调伏自心”意即:因“今日饭食迟了”而起嗔心,你当调伏,莫要生气。所见之处……乃至……皆变成金色,犹如遍覆大拘舍多耆花。“于如是者”指于如你者。“我不嗔”(na kopemi)即我不毁坏,不因出身而轻贱。“作供养”指供养正等觉者。“内院”(antaravatthu)指家中庭院。“Bhoti”是称呼语。“Je”是不敬的称呼。她因自己是圣弟子,以导师为依,故说“有父之女”,并期望她在导师面前听闻法义而证得殊胜,于是说:“我将忍耐,犹如十力者忍耐一般。”“悭吝”(kadariya)指顽固的吝啬。 Suppavāsāvatthu 善觉事 263. Chaṭṭhe paṇītadāyikānanti paṇītarasavatthūnaṃ dāyikānaṃ. Āyuno ṭhitihetuṃ bhojanaṃ dentī āyuṃ deti nāma. Esa nayo vaṇṇaṃ detītiādīsu. Tenāha – ‘‘pañca ṭhānānī’’ti. Kammasarikkhakañcetaṃ phalanti dassento ‘‘āyuṃ kho pana datvā’’tiādimāha. Tattha datvāti dānahetu. Bhāginīti bhāgavatī laddhuṃ bhabbā. 263. 第六则中,“布施殊胜之物者”(paṇītadāyikānaṃ)指布施上味食物者。布施作为生命存续之因的食物,即名为布施寿命。此理亦适用于“布施容色”等。是故说“五处”。为显示业与果的相似性,故说“布施寿命”等。此中“布施”(datvā)是布施之因。“有分者”(bhāginī)指有福分、堪能获得者。 Suppiyāvatthu 苏碧娅事 264. Sattame ūrumaṃsaṃ chinditvā dāsiyā adāsīti āgataphalā viññātasāsanā ariyasāvikā attano sarīradukkhaṃ acintetvā tassa bhikkhuno rogavūpasamameva paccāsīsantī attano ūrumaṃsaṃ chinditvā dāsiyā adāsi. Satthāpi tassā tathāpavattaṃ ajjhāsayasampattiṃ disvā ‘‘mama sammukhībhāvūpagamanenevassā vaṇo ruhitvā sañchavi jāyati, phāsubhāvo hotī’’ti ca disvā ‘‘pakkosatha na’’nti āha. Sā cintesīti ‘‘sabbalokassa hitānukampako satthā na maṃ dukkhāpetuṃ pakkosati, atthettha kāraṇa’’nti cintesi. Attanā katakāraṇaṃ sabbaṃ kathesīti buddhānubhāvavibhāvanatthaṃ kathesi, na attano daḷhajjhāsayatāya vibhāvanatthaṃ. Gilānupaṭṭhākīnaṃ aggaṭṭhāne ṭhapesīti agaṇitattadukkhā gilānānaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ gelaññavūpasamane yuttappayuttāti gilānupaṭṭhākīnaṃ aggaṭṭhāne ṭhapesīti. 264. 第七则中,“割下自己的大腿肉给婢女”,是指这位已证圣果、通达教法的圣女弟子,不顾自身痛苦,只期盼那位比丘的疾病痊愈,便割下自己的大腿肉给了婢女。世尊见她如此行事及意乐圆满,又知“只要她来我面前,其伤口便会愈合,长出新皮,恢复安乐”,便说:“叫她过来。”她心想:“于一切世间行利益怜悯的世尊,不会为令我痛苦而召我,此处必有因缘。”“她讲述了自己所做的一切”,是为了彰显佛陀的威力,而非为了显示自己坚定的意乐。“将她置于侍病者之首位”,是指她不计自身痛苦,适宜且精勤地为病比丘解除病苦,故将她置于侍病者之首位。 Kātiyānīvatthu 迦提亚尼事 265. Aṭṭhame [Pg.210] aveccappasannānanti ratanattayaguṇe yāthāvato ñatvā pasannānaṃ, so panassa pasādo maggenāgatattā kenaci akampanīyo. Adhigatenāti maggādhigameneva adhigatena. ‘‘Avigatenā’’ti vā pāṭho, tassattho ‘‘kadāci avigacchantenā’’ti. So appadhaṃsiyo ca hoti, tasmā vuttaṃ – ‘‘adhigatena acalappasādenā’’ti. Tattha kāyasakkhiṃ katvāti pamukhaṃ katvā, vacanatthato pana nāmakāyena desanāya sampaṭicchanavasena sakkhibhūtaṃ katvāti attho. Ummaggaṃ khanitvāti gharasandhicchedanena antopavisanamaggaṃ khanitvā. Dullabhassavananti dullabhasaddhammassavanaṃ. Mahāpathavī pavisitabbā bhaveyyāti avīcippavesanaṃ vadati. 265. 第八,“不坏净”(aveccappasannānaṃ)是指如实了知三宝功德而生净信者,此净信因由道而来,故不为任何事物所动摇。“已证得”(adhigatena)是指由证得道而得。或作“不退失”(avigatenā),其义为“永不退失”。此净信亦不可毁,故说“以已证得之不动摇的净信”。于此,“以身作证”(kāyasakkhiṃ katvā)是说作为首要,但从文义上说,是指以名身领受教法而作为见证。“挖地道”(ummaggaṃ khanitvā)是指凿穿房屋的连接处,挖出进入内部的通道。“难得听闻”(dullabhassavanaṃ)是指难得听闻正法。“应入大地”(mahāpathavī pavisitabbā bhaveyyā)是说进入无间地狱(Avīci)。 Nakulamātāvatthu 那拘罗母事 266. Navame vissāsakathaneneva nakulamātā nakulapitā ca satthuvissāsikā nāma jātāti vuttaṃ – ‘‘vissāsikānanti vissāsakathaṃ kathentīnaṃ upāsikāna’’nti. Gahapatānīti gehasāminī. Vuttamevāti upāsakapāḷiyaṃ nakulapitukathāyaṃ vuttanayameva. 266. 第九,仅由信任之语,那拘罗母(Nakulamātā)与那拘罗父(Nakulapitā)即被称为“导师的信任者”,如言:“信任者,是指说信任之语的优婆夷们”。“家主妇”(Gahapatānī)即女主人。“如前所述”是指,正如在优婆塞篇中关于那拘罗父的叙述方式一样。 Kāḷīkuraragharikāvatthu 俱罗罗伽罗迦莉事 267. Dasame anussavenevāti paccakkhato rūpadassanena satthu sammukhā dhammassavanena ca vinā kevalaṃ anussavaneneva parassa vacanaṃ anugatassavaneneva uppannena pasādena. Anussavikappasādanti anussavato āgatappasādaṃ. 267. 第十,“仅由传闻”(anussaveneva)是指,未曾亲见导师色身、未曾于导师面前听闻法,仅由传闻,即随闻他人之语而生起的净信。“由传闻而来的净信”(Anussavikappasādaṃ)是指从传闻而来的净信。 (Sattamaetadaggavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā.) (第七殊胜品释义终。) Upāsikāpāḷisaṃvaṇṇanā samattā. 优婆夷品释义圆满。 Niṭṭhitā ca manorathapūraṇiyā 《满足希求》已终。 Aṅguttaranikāya-aṭṭhakathāya 增支部义注 Etadaggavaggavaṇṇanāya anuttānatthadīpanā. 殊胜品释义之难显义阐明。 15. Aṭṭhānapāḷi (paṭhamavagga) 15. 非处经(初品) (15) 1. Aṭṭhānapāḷi-paṭhamavaggavaṇṇanā (15)1. 非处经第一品释义 268. Aṭṭhānapāḷivaṇṇanāyaṃ [Pg.211] avijjamānaṃ ṭhānaṃ aṭṭhānaṃ, natthi ṭhānanti vā aṭṭhānaṃ. Anavakāsoti etthāpi eseva nayo. Tadatthanigamanameva hi ‘‘netaṃ ṭhānaṃ vijjatī’’ti vacananti. Tenāha – ‘‘ubhayenapī’’tiādi. Yanti kāraṇatthe paccattavacanaṃ. Hetuattho cettha kāraṇatthoti āha – ‘‘yanti yena kāraṇenā’’ti. Ukkaṭṭhaniddesenettha diṭṭhisampatti veditabbāti vuttaṃ – ‘‘maggadiṭṭhiyā sampanno’’ti. Kuto panāyamattho labbhatīti? Liṅgato, liṅgaṃ cetassa niccato upagamanappaṭikkhepo. Catubhūmakesūti idaṃ catutthabhūmakasaṅkhārānaṃ ariyasāvakassa visayabhāvūpagamanato vuttaṃ, na pana te ārabbha niccato upagamanasabbhāvato. Vakkhati hi ‘‘tadabhāve catutthabhūmakasaṅkhārā panā’’tiādinā. Abhisaṅkhatasaṅkhāraabhisaṅkharaṇakasaṅkhārānaṃ sappadesattā nippadesasaṅkhāraggahaṇatthaṃ ‘‘saṅkhatasaṅkhāresū’’ti vuttaṃ, lokuttarasaṅkhārānaṃ pana nivattane kāraṇaṃ sayameva vakkhati. Etaṃ kāraṇaṃ natthīti tathā upagamane setughāto natthi. Tejussadattāti saṃkilesavidhamanatejassa adhikabhāvato. Tathā hi te gambhīrabhāvena duddasā akusalānaṃ ārammaṇaṃ na hontīti. Idaṃ pana pakaraṇavasena vuttaṃ. Appahīnavipallāsānañhi santānesu kusaladhammānampi te ārammaṇaṃ na honti. 268. 在《非处经》的释义中,“非处”(aṭṭhānaṃ)即不存在之处,或说“无有是处”。“无有机会”(anavakāso)亦是此理。其义的结论即是“此非可能处”之语。因此说“由二者……”等。“yanti”一词,于此为因缘义的独立句,此中因缘义即是原因义,故说“yanti,即以何原因为”。于此,以最胜的解释当知为“见成就”,故说“成就道见”。然此义由何而得?由其相而得,其相即是拒绝执取为常。说“于四地中”,是就四地诸行成为圣弟子所缘境而说,并非就彼等而有执取为常之实有性。诚如接下来将说“彼若无有,则四地诸行……”等。因为已造作之行与能造作之行有其所依,为包含无所依之行,故说“于有为行中”;而出世间诸行的止息因缘,之后自会说明。若如是执取,则无有断桥者。“威力炽盛”是因摧破烦恼的威力强盛。确实,彼等因甚深故难见,不成为不善法之所缘。此乃依文脉而说。于未断颠倒者的相续中,彼等亦不成为善法之所缘。 269. Asukhe sukhanti vipallāso ca idha sukhato upagamanassa ṭhānanti dassento ‘‘ekanta…pe… attadiṭṭhivasenā’’ti padhānadiṭṭhimāha. Gūthanti gūthaṭṭhānaṃ, diṭṭhiyā nibbānassa avisayabhāvo heṭṭhā vutto evāti kasiṇādipaṇṇattisaṅgahatthanti vuttaṃ. 269. “于苦计乐”即是颠倒(vipallāso),为显示此乃执乐之处,故说“一向……乃至……以我见故”,此指主要之见。“粪”即粪秽处,下文已说邪见不以涅槃为境,故说此是为了总括遍处等概念。 270. Paricchedoti paricchindanaṃ paricchijja tassa gahaṇaṃ. Svāyaṃ yesu niccādito upagamanaṃ sambhavati, tesaṃ vasenayeva kātabboti dassento ‘‘sabbavāresu vā’’tiādimāha. Sabbavāresūti ‘‘niccato upagaccheyyā’’tiādinā āgatesu sabbesu suttapadesu. Puthujjano hīti hi-saddo hetuattho. Yasmā yaṃ yaṃ saṅkhāraṃ puthujjano niccādivasena gaṇhāti, taṃ taṃ ariyasāvako aniccādivasena gaṇhanto yāthāvato [Pg.212] jānanto taṃ gāhaṃ taṃ diṭṭhiṃ vissajjeti, tasmā yattha gāho, tattha vissajjanāti catubhūmakasaṅkhārā idha saṅkhāraggahaṇena na gayhantīti attho. 270. “限定”(pariccheda)即是限定、限定后而执取。为显示此限定仅就可能被执为常等者而作,故说“于一切场合……”等。“于一切场合”是指,在“执取为常”等一切经句中。“凡夫(puthujjano)云何”中的“云何”(hi)一词是原因义。因为凡夫将任何行执取为常等,圣弟子则了知彼行,如实地执取为无常等,并舍弃彼执取、彼邪见。是故,何处有执取,何处即有舍弃,其义为:四地诸行于此不为“行”一词所摄。 271. Puttasambandhena mātupitusamaññā dattakittimādivasenapi puttavohāro loke dissati, so ca kho pariyāyenāti nippariyāyena siddhaṃ taṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘janikāva mātā, janakova pitā’’ti vuttaṃ. Tathā ānantariyakammassa adhippetattā ‘‘manussabhūtova khīṇāsavo arahāti adhippeto’’ti vuttaṃ. ‘‘Aṭṭhānameta’’ntiādinā ‘‘mātuādīnaṃyeva jīvitā voropane ariyasāvakassa abhabbabhāvadassanato tadaññaṃ ariyasāvako jīvitā voropetīti idaṃ atthato āpannamevā’’ti maññamāno vadati – ‘‘kiṃ pana ariyasāvako aññaṃ jīvitā voropeyyā’’ti? ‘‘Aṭṭhānametaṃ anavakāso, yaṃ diṭṭhisampanno puggalo sañcicca pāṇaṃ jīvitā voropeyya, netaṃ ṭhānaṃ vijjatī’’ti vacanato ‘‘etampi aṭṭhāna’’nti vuttaṃ. Tenevāha – ‘‘sace hī’’tiādi. Evaṃ sante kasmā ‘‘mātara’’ntiādinā visesetvā vuttanti āha – ‘‘puthujjanabhāvassa panā’’tiādi. Tattha baladīpanatthanti saddhādibalasamannāgamadīpanatthaṃ. Ariyamaggenāgatasaddhādhibalavasena hi ariyasāvako tādisaṃ sāvajjaṃ na karoti. 271. 由子女关系而有父母之称,世间亦见有由领养、收养等而称子女者,此乃方便说。为显示究竟说,故言:“生母方为母,生父方为父”。同样,因意指无间业,故说:“意指唯有人身之漏尽阿罗汉”。由“无有是处”等句,显示圣弟子不可能杀害母亲等,有人认为“由此义理,圣弟子会杀害他人之事亦可推知”,而说:“然则圣弟子会杀害他人吗?”由“无有是处,无有机会,具足见之人(diṭṭhisampanno puggalo)会故意夺取众生命,无有是处”之语,故说“此亦非处”。因此说“若……”等。既然如此,为何以“母亲”等特别说明?答曰:“然为凡夫……”等。其中,“为显示力”是指为显示具足信等之力。圣弟子实由圣道所得信等之力,而不作如是有过失之事。 275. Pañcahi kāraṇehīti idamettha nipphādakāni tesaṃ pubbabhāgiyāni ca kāraṇāni kāraṇabhāvasāmaññena ekajjhaṃ gahetvā vuttaṃ, na pana sabbesaṃ samānayogakkhamattā. Ākārehīti kāraṇehi. Anussāvanenāti anurūpaṃ sāvanena. Bhedassa anurūpaṃ yathā bhedo hoti, evaṃ bhinditabbānaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ attano vacanassa sāvanena viññāpanena. Tenāha – ‘‘nanu tumhe’’tiādi. Kaṇṇamūle vacībhedaṃ katvāti etena pākaṭaṃ katvā bhedakaravatthudīpanaṃ vohāro, tattha attano nicchitamatthaṃ rahassavasena viññāpanaṃ anussāvananti dasseti. 275. “由五因缘”,此处是就因缘之共性,将能成之因与前分之因一并总括而说,并非所有因缘皆有同等作用。“由行相”即由因缘。“由随说”(Anussāvanena)即由随顺而说。随顺于分裂,即为令分裂发生,向应被分裂的比丘们宣说、告知自己的言论。因此说“汝等岂非……”等。“于耳边作语离间”,此显示公开宣说能导致分裂之事为“常法”(vohāro),而于其中秘密告知自己所决断之义,则为“随说”。 Kammameva uddeso vā pamāṇanti tehi saṅghabhedasiddhito vuttaṃ, itare pana tesaṃ sambhārabhūtā. Tenāha – ‘‘vohārā’’tiādi. Tatthāti voharaṇe. Cutianantaraṃ phalaṃ anantaraṃ nāma, tasmiṃ anantare niyuttāni, tannibbattanena anantarakaraṇasīlāni, anantarappayojanāni cāti ānantariyāni, tāni eva kammānīti ānantariyakammāni. 从业能成就僧团分裂,故说业即是意趣或标准,其余则为其资具。因此说“言说……”等。“于此”即于言说中。死后立即结果,名为“无间”(anantaraṃ)。与此无间果相连者、由能生彼而有无间作用之自性者、以及有无间之目的者,是为“无间业”(ānantariyāni)。彼等即是业,故称“无间诸业”(ānantariyakammāni)。 Kammatoti [Pg.213] ‘‘evaṃ ānantariyakammaṃ hoti, evaṃ ānantariyakammasadisa’’nti evaṃ kammavibhāgato. Dvāratoti kāyadvārato. Kappaṭṭhitiyatoti ‘‘idaṃ kappaṭṭhitiyavipākaṃ, idaṃ na kappaṭṭhitiyavipāka’’nti evaṃ kappaṭṭhitiyavibhāgato. Pākasādhāraṇādīhīti ‘‘idamettha vipaccati, idaṃ na vipaccatī’’ti vipaccanavibhāgato, gahaṭṭhapabbajitānaṃ sādhāraṇāsādhāraṇato, ādi-saddena vedanādivibhāgato ca. 从业的分别而言,即如“如此是无间业,如此是类似无间业”。从门而言,即从身门。从劫住的分别而言,即如“此为劫住异熟,此非劫住异熟”。从异熟的共同性等而言,即如“此于此处成熟,此不于此处成熟”,如此从成熟的分别而言;从在家者与出家者的共同及不共同而言;并通过“等”字,也包括从感受等的分别而言。 Kammato tāva vinicchayo vuccatīti sambandho. Yasmā manussattabhāve ṭhitasseva kusaladhammānaṃ tikkhavisadabhāvāpatti, yathā tiṇṇaṃ bodhisattānaṃ bodhittayanibbattiyaṃ, evaṃ manussabhāve ṭhitasseva edisānaṃ akusaladhammānampi tikkhavisadabhāvāpattīti āha – ‘‘manussabhūtassevā’’ti. Pākatikamanussānampi ca kusaladhammānaṃ visesappatti vimānavatthuaṭṭhakathāyaṃ vuttanayeneva veditabbā. Yathāvutto ca attho samānajātiyassa vikopane garutaro, na tathā vijātiyassāti vuttaṃ – ‘‘manussabhūtaṃ mātaraṃ vā pitaraṃ vā’’ti. Liṅgaparivatte ca so eva ekakammanibbatto bhavaṅgappabandho jīvitindriyapabandho ca, na aññoti āha – ‘‘api parivattaliṅga’’nti. Arahattaṃ pattepi eseva nayo. Tassa vipākantiādi kammassa ānantariyabhāvasamatthanaṃ. Catukkoṭiyañcettha sambhavati. Tattha paṭhamā koṭi dassitā, itarāsu visaṅketabhāvaṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘yo panā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Yadipi tattha visaṅketo, kammaṃ pana garutaraṃ ānantariyasadisaṃ bhāyitabbanti āha – ‘‘bhāriyaṃ…pe… tiṭṭhatī’’ti. Ayaṃ pañhoti ñāpanicchānibbattā kathā. 首先说明业的决择,这是关联。因为处于人身者,善法能达到极其锐利明净的状态,就像三菩萨成就菩提时那样;同样,处于人身者,不善法也能达到如此锐利明净的状态,所以说“生而为人者”。普通人善法的殊胜成就,应当依照《天宫事义注》(Vimānavatthuaṭṭhakathā)中所说的方法来理解。而所说的含义是:伤害同类者罪过更重,不像伤害异类者那样,所以说“杀害生而为人者之母或父”。性别转变时,仍然是同一个业所产生的有分(bhavaṅga)相续和命根(jīvitindriya)相续,并非其他,所以说“即使转变性别”。证得阿罗汉(arahanta)果时,道理也是如此。关于业的异熟(vipāka)等,是为证明业的无间性(ānantariya)。这里有四句分别的可能。第一句已说明,为了显示其他句的不确定性,所以说“若复有人”等。即使那些情况不确定,但业更为深重,应当畏惧其如同无间业,所以说“重业……存在”。这是一个由求知欲所引发的论述。 Abhisandhināti adhippāyena. Ānantariyaṃ phusatīti maraṇādhippāyeneva ānantariyavatthuno vikopitattā vuttaṃ. Ānantariyaṃ na phusatīti ānantariyavatthuabhāvato ānantariyaṃ na hoti. Sabbattha hi purimaṃ abhisandhicittaṃ appamāṇaṃ, vadhakacittaṃ pana tadārammaṇaṃ jīvitindriyañca ānantariyabhāve pamāṇanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Saṅgāmacatukkaṃ sampattavasena yojetabbaṃ. Yo hi parasenāya aññañca yodhaṃ pitarañca kammaṃ karonte disvā yodhassa usuṃ khipati ‘‘etaṃ vijjhitvā mama pitaraṃ vijjhissatī’’ti, yathādhippāyaṃ gate pitughātako hoti. ‘‘Yodhe viddhe mama pitā palāyissatī’’ti khipati, usuṃ ayathādhippāyaṃ gantvā pitaraṃ māreti, vohāravasena pitughātakoti vuccati, ānantariyaṃ pana natthīti. Coracatukkaṃ pana yo ‘‘coraṃ māressāmī’’ti [Pg.214] coravesena gacchantaṃ pitaraṃ māreti, ānantariyaṃ phusatītiādinā yojetabbaṃ. Tenevāti teneva payogena. Arahantaghātako hotiyevāti arahato māritattā vuttaṃ, puthujjanasseva taṃ dinnaṃ hotīti etthāyamadhippāyo – yathā vadhakacetanā paccuppannārammaṇāpi pabandhavicchedanavasena jīvitindriyaṃ ārammaṇaṃ katvā pavattati, na evaṃ cāgacetanā. Sā hi cajitabbavatthuṃ ārammaṇaṃ katvā cajanamattameva hoti, aññasantakabhāvakaraṇañca tassa cajanaṃ, tasmā yassa taṃ santakaṃ kataṃ, tasseva dinnaṃ hotīti. “以意图”(Abhisandhināti)即“以意趣”(adhippāyena)。“触及无间业”(Ānantariyaṃ phusati)是说,因为以杀害的意趣破坏了无间业的对象。“不触及无间业”(Ānantariyaṃ na phusati)是说,因为无间业的对象不存在,所以不成其为无间业。应知,在一切处,前行的意图心(abhisandhicitta)是无量的,而杀害心(vadhakacitta)及其所缘与命根(jīvitindriya)则是构成无间业的标准。战场四句(saṅgāmacatukka)应结合成就来理解:若有人看见另一位士兵和自己的父亲在敌军中,便向那士兵射箭,心想“射穿此人后,箭将射中我父亲”,若箭如其所愿(射死父亲),则构成杀父(无间业)。若他射箭时心想“射中那士兵,我父亲就能逃脱”,但箭未如其意,反而杀死了父亲,那么依世俗言说,他被称为杀父者,但并不构成无间业。盗贼四句(coracatukka)则应结合“触及无间业”等来理解,例如有人意图“我要杀死盗贼”,却杀死了装扮成盗贼的父亲。“以彼”(Teneva)即“以彼之努力”。“他确实成为杀阿罗汉者”(Arahantaghātako hotiyeva),是因杀害了阿罗汉(arahanta)而说。此处的含义是:正如杀害思(vadhakacetanā)虽以现前为所缘,却通过切断(生命)相续而缘取命根,布施思(cāgacetanā)并非如此。它缘取所应施舍之物,仅是施舍而已,其施舍是使之成为他人所有物。因此,物品是施予那位令其成为自己所有物的人。 Lohitaṃ samosaratīti abhighātena pakuppamānaṃ sañcitaṃ hoti. Mahantataranti garutaraṃ. Sarīrappaṭijaggane viyāti satthurūpakāyappaṭijaggane viya. “血液汇聚”(lohitaṃ samosarati),意指因打击而激动、积聚。“更大”(mahantataraṃ)即“更重”(garutaraṃ)。“如同守护身体”(sarīrappaṭijaggane viya),即如同守护导师(satthu)的色身(rūpakāya)。 Asannipatiteti idaṃ sāmaggiyadīpanaṃ. Bhedo ca hotīti saṅghassa bhedo ca hoti. Vaṭṭatīti saññāyāti ‘‘īdisaṃ karaṇaṃ saṅghabhedāya na hotī’’ti saññāya. Tathā navato ūnaparisāyāti navato ūnaparisāya karontassa tathāti yojetabbaṃ. Tathāti ca iminā ‘‘na ānantariyakamma’’nti imaṃ ākaḍḍhati, na pana ‘‘bhedova hotī’’ti idaṃ. Heṭṭhimantena hi navannameva vasena saṅghabhedo. Dhammavādino anavajjāti yathādhammaṃ anavaṭṭhānato. Saṅghabhedassa pubbabhāgo saṅgharāji. “未集会”(asannipatite),这是对和合(sāmaggī)的反显。“分裂确实会发生”(bhedo ca hoti),即僧团(saṅgha)的分裂会发生。“是允许的”(vaṭṭati),是指以“这样的行为不会导致僧团分裂”的认知(saññā)。“同样,对于少于九人的僧团”(tathā navato ūnaparisāya),是指对于在少于九人的僧团(parisā)中行事者,也应如此理解。这个“同样”(tathā),是引出“这不是无间业”,而不是“分裂一定会发生”。因为按照最低限度,僧团分裂是由九人造成的。如法论者(dhammavādin)没有过失,因为他们没有不如法地安住。僧团分裂的前分是僧团的裂痕(saṅgharāji)。 Kāyadvārameva pūrenti kāyakammabhāveneva lakkhitabbato. Saṇṭhahantehi kappe…pe… muccatīti idaṃ kappaṭṭhakathāya (kathā. 654 ādayo) na sameti. Tattha hi aṭṭhakathāya (kathā. aṭṭha. 654-657) vuttaṃ – ‘‘āpāyikoti idaṃ suttaṃ yaṃ so ekaṃ kappaṃ asītibhāge katvā tato ekabhāgamattaṃ kālaṃ tiṭṭheyya, taṃ āyukappaṃ sandhāya vutta’’nti. Kappavināseyevāti ca āyukappavināse evāti atthe sati natthi virodho. Ettha ca saṇṭhahanteti idampi ‘‘sveva vinassissatī’’ti viya abhūtaparikappavasena vuttaṃ. Ekadivasameva niraye paccati, tato paraṃ kappābhāve āyukappassapi abhāvatoti avirodhato atthayojanā daṭṭhabbā. Sesānīti saṅghabhedato aññāni ānantariyakammāni. 他们只圆满身门,因为应以身业的状态来标记。“当劫住立时……解脱”,这与《论事》(Kathāvatthu)及其义注(aṭṭhakathā) (论事 654等)不相符。因为其义注(论事义注 654-657)中说:“‘堕恶趣者’,此经是针对寿命劫(āyukappa)而说,即那人将一劫分为八十份,只停留其中一份的时间。”而“只在劫坏灭时”,若其义为“只在寿命劫坏灭时”,则没有矛盾。在这里,“当住立时”,这也是以不真实的设想来说的,就像“他明天就会毁灭”一样。应知,其义理的结合没有矛盾,因为(他)只在地狱中受煮一天,此后因劫不存在,寿命劫也就不存在了。“其余的”是指僧团分裂之外的其他无间业。 Yadi tāni ahosikammasaṅkhaṃ gacchanti, evaṃ sati kathaṃ nesaṃ ānantariyatā cutianantaraṃ vipākadānābhāvato. Atha sati phaladāne cutianantaro [Pg.215] eva etesaṃ phalakālo, na aññoti phalakālaniyamena niyatatā icchitā, na phaladānaniyamena. Evampi niyataphalakālānaṃ aññesampi upapajjavedanīyānaṃ diṭṭhadhammavedanīyānañca niyatatā āpajjeyya, tasmā vipākadhammadhammānaṃ paccayantaravikalatādīhi avipaccamānānampi attano sabhāvena vipākadhammatā viya balavatā ānantariyena vipāke dinne avipaccamānānampi ānantariyānaṃ phaladāne niyatasabhāvā ānantariyasabhāvā ca pavattīti attano sabhāvena phaladānaniyameneva niyatā ānantariyatā ca veditabbā. Avassañca ānantariyasabhāvā tato eva niyatasabhāvā ca tesaṃ pavattīti sampaṭicchitabbametaṃ, aññassa balavato ānantariyassa abhāve sati cutianantaraṃ ekantena phaladānato. 若那些业成为无效业(ahosikamma),这样一来,它们怎么会是无间业呢?因为死后没有给予异熟。又或者,若有果报,则其果报时必定是死后即刻,而非他时;如此,其决定性是因果报时间的规定,而非因给予果报的规定。即使这样,其他果报时间固定的业,例如顺生受业(upapajjavedanīya)和顺现法受业(diṭṭhadhammavedanīya),也会因此而成为决定性的。因此,当一个强力的无间业给予异熟时,即使其他(无间业)未成熟,其给予果报的作用,也具有决定的自性和无间的自性,这就像那些本性为能生果法者,即使因缺少其他缘等而未成熟,其能生果之性仍由自性而有。因此应当知道,无间性是由于自身性质决定了异熟的必然性而成立的。必须承认,这些业的无间性质和由此决定的固定性质会发生,这是因为在没有其他更强力的无间业存在的情况下,它们会在死后必定给予异熟。 Nanu evaṃ aññesampi upapajjavedanīyānaṃ aññasmiṃ vipākadāyake asati cutianantarameva ekantena phaladānato niyatasabhāvā ānantariyasabhāvā ca pavatti āpajjatīti? Nāpajjati asamānajātikena cetopaṇidhivasena upaghātakena ca nivattetabbavipākattā anantare ekantaphaladāyakattābhāvā, na pana ānantariyānaṃ paṭhamajjhānādīnaṃ dutiyajjhānādīni viya asamānajātikaṃ phalanivattakaṃ atthi sabbānantariyānaṃ avīciphalattā, na ca heṭṭhūpapattiṃ icchato sīlavato cetopaṇidhi viya uparūpapattijanakakammaphalaṃ ānantariyaphalaṃ nivattetuṃ samattho cetopaṇidhi atthi anicchantasseva avīcipātanato, na ca ānantariyopaghātakaṃ kiñci kammaṃ atthi, tasmā tesaṃyeva anantare ekantavipākajanakasabhāvā pavattīti. Anekāni ca ānantariyāni katāni ekantena vipāke niyatasabhāvattā uparatāvipaccanasabhāvāsaṅkattā nicchitāni sabhāvato niyatāneva. Tesu pana samānasabhāvesu ekena vipāke dinne itarāni attanā kattabbakiccassa teneva katattā na dutiyaṃ tatiyampi ca paṭisandhiṃ karonti, na samatthatāvighātattāti natthi tesaṃ ānantariyakatānivatti, garugarutarabhāvo pana tesaṃ labbhatevāti saṅghabhedassa siyā garutarabhāvoti ‘‘yena…pe… vipaccatī’’ti āha. Ekassa pana aññāni upatthambhakāni hontīti daṭṭhabbāni. Paṭisandhivasena vipaccatīti vacanena itaresaṃ pavattivipākadāyitā anuññātā viya dissati. No vā tathā sīlavatīti yathā pitā sīlavā, tathā sīlavatī [Pg.216] no vā hotīti yojanā. Sace mātā sīlavatī, mātughāto paṭisandhivasena vipaccatīti yojanā. 难道不是这样吗?对于其他当生受的业,在没有其他能给予果报的业时,死后立即必定会给予果报,岂不就成了无间业的定性吗?不会。因为(其他业)的果报,可因不同类的意愿及障碍业而被阻止,故无死后立即必定给予果报之事。然而,无间业并没有像初禅等对于第二禅等那样,有不同类的法能阻止其果报,因为一切无间业的果报都是无间地狱。并且,不像希求下生之持戒者的意愿,有能阻止生于上界之业果的意愿,(对于无间业)并没有能阻止其果报的意愿,因为纵使不愿,也会堕入无间地狱。也没有任何业能障碍无间业。因此,只有它们才具有死后立即必定产生果报的自性。所造的众多无间业,因其果报必然成熟的定性,以及不会停止不成熟的自性,故其自性是确定的。在这些同类的业中,当一业已给予果报时,其余的业因其应做之事已被彼业所完成,故不会再有第二、第三次的结生,这并非其能力被破坏,因此所造的无间业不会不生效。然而,它们确实有轻重之别,故破僧之业或为更重,如言:“由彼……而成熟”。应知,一业可由其他业所支持。“以结生而成熟”之说,似乎是允许了其他业在生命期中给予果报。或者,“她不如是持戒”,应连接为:如父持戒,母或持戒或不持戒。若母持戒,则杀母之业以结生而成熟。 Pakatattoti anukkhitto. Samānasaṃvāsakoti apārājiko. Samānasīmāyanti ekasīmāyaṃ. 正常者(pakatatta),谓未被举罪者。同住者(samānasaṃvāsaka),谓未犯波罗夷者。同界者(samānasīmā),谓于一界中。 276. Satthu kiccaṃ kātuṃ asamatthoti yaṃ satthārā kātabbakiccaṃ anusāsanādi, naṃ kātuṃ asamatthoti bhagavantaṃ paccakkhāya. Aññaṃ titthakaranti aññaṃ satthāraṃ. Vuttañhetaṃ – 276. 不能行导师之事,即不能行导师所应做的教诫等事,是舍弃世尊。另奉外道为师。如是说—— ‘‘Titthaṃ jānitabbaṃ, titthakaro jānitabbo, titthiyā jānitabbā, titthiyasāvakā jānitabbā. Tattha titthaṃ nāma dvāsaṭṭhi diṭṭhiyo. Ettha hi satthā taranti uplavanti ummujjanimujjaṃ karonti, tasmā titthanti vuccanti. Tādisānaṃ diṭṭhīnaṃ uppādetā titthakaro nāma pūraṇakassapādiko. Tassa laddhiṃ gahetvā pabbajitā titthiyā nāma. Te hi titthe jātāti titthiyā. Yathāvuttaṃ vā diṭṭhigatasaṅkhātaṃ titthaṃ etesaṃ atthīti titthikā, titthikā eva titthiyā. Tesaṃ paccayadāyakā titthiyasāvakāti veditabbā’’ti (ma. ni. aṭṭha. 1.140). “应知外道(tittha),应知外道师(titthakara),应知外道徒(titthiya),应知外道声闻(titthiyasāvaka)。其中,‘外道’者,六十二见。于此,诸师渡越、漂浮、沉浮,故称之为‘外道’(渡口)。生起此等见者,名为外道师,如富兰那·迦叶(Pūraṇa Kassapa)等。受持其见解而出家者,名为外道徒。彼等于外道中生,故为外道徒。或如所说,彼等有此名为‘见’之外道,故为‘外道者’(titthika),外道者即外道徒。应知,布施彼等资具者,为外道声闻。”(《中部·义注》1.140) 277. Abhijātiādīsu pakampanadevatūpasaṅkamanādinā jātacakkavāḷena samānayogakkhamaṃ dasasahassaparimāṇaṃ cakkavāḷaṃ jātikhettaṃ. Saraseneva āṇāpavattanaṭṭhānaṃ āṇākhettaṃ. Visayabhūtaṃ ṭhānaṃ visayakhettaṃ. Dasasahassī lokadhātūti imāya lokadhātuyā saddhiṃ imaṃ lokadhātuṃ parivāretvā ṭhitā dasasahassī lokadhātu. Tattakānaṃyeva jātikhettabhāvo dhammatāvasena veditabbo. ‘‘Pariggahavasenā’’ti keci, ‘‘sabbesaṃyeva buddhānaṃ tattakaṃyeva jātikhettaṃ tannivāsīnaṃyeva devatānaṃ dhammābhisamayo’’ti ca vadanti. Mātukucchi okkamanakālādīnaṃ channaṃ eva gahaṇaṃ nidassanamattaṃ mahābhinīhārādikālepi tassa pakampanassa labbhanato. Āṇākhettaṃ nāma yaṃ ekajjhaṃ saṃvaṭṭati vivaṭṭati ca, āṇā pavattati āṇāya tannivāsidevatānaṃ sirasā sampaṭicchanena, tañca kho kevalaṃ buddhānaṃ ānubhāveneva, na adhippāyavasena. Adhippāyavasena [Pg.217] pana ‘‘yāvatā vā pana ākaṅkheyyā’’ti (a. ni. 3.81) vacanato tato parampi āṇā vatteyyeva. 277. 于诞生等时,由震动、天神来集等而生的轮围世界中,与此(世界)同等安稳的万数轮围世界,为“生处(jātikhetta)”。教令自然运行之处,为“教令处(āṇākhetta)”。所缘境界之处,为“境界处(visayakhetta)”。“十千世界”,是与此世界一同,围绕此世界而住的十千世界。应知彼等之所以为生处,是依法性如此。有人说:“由摄受故”;又有人说:“一切诸佛的生处皆是如此,唯有住于其中的天神才能现观正法”。提及入母胎时等六时,仅为例示,因于发大誓愿等时亦有此震动。“教令处”者,谓一同成坏之处,教令通过其处天神顶礼奉受而运行,此唯由诸佛威力,非由意乐。若由意乐,则依“随意所欲”(《增支部》3.81)之说,教令亦可遍及更远处。 Na uppajjantīti pana atthīti ‘‘na me ācariyo atthi, sadiso me na vijjatī’’tiādiṃ (ma. ni. 1.285; mahāva. 11; kathā. 405) imissā lokadhātuyā ṭhatvā vadantena bhagavatā ‘‘kiṃ panāvuso, sāriputta, atthetarahi aññe samaṇā vā brāhmaṇā vā bhagavatā samasamā sambodhiyanti, evaṃ puṭṭho ahaṃ, bhante, ‘no’ti vadeyya’’nti (dī. ni. 3.161) vatvā tassa kāraṇaṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘aṭṭhānametaṃ anavakāso, yaṃ ekissā lokadhātuyā dve arahanto sammāsambuddhā apubbaṃ acarimaṃ uppajjeyyu’’nti imaṃ suttaṃ (a. ni. 1.277; vibha. 809; ma. ni. 3.129; mi. pa. 5.1.1) āharantena dhammasenāpatinā ca buddhakhettabhūtaṃ imaṃ lokadhātuṃ ṭhapetvā aññattha anuppatti vuttā hotīti adhippāyo. 至于说“不出现”之义,其意趣是:世尊立于此世界而说“我无师,无与我等者”等语(《中部》1.285;《大品》11;《论事》405);以及法将舍利弗说:“若我被如是问:‘贤友舍利弗,如今有其他沙门、婆罗门与世尊同等而正觉吗?’尊者,我当答言:‘无有’”(《长部》3.161),为示其因而引此经:“于一世界,二阿罗汉、正等觉者不前不后而出现,无有是处,无此可能”(《增支部》1.277;《分别论》809;《中部》3.129;《弥兰王问经》5.1.1),此即是说,除此佛土世界外,于他处亦不出现。 Ekatoti saha, ekasmiṃ kāleti attho, so pana kālo kathaṃ paricchinnoti carimabhave paṭisandhiggahaṇato paṭṭhāya yāva dhātuparinibbānāti dassento, ‘‘tatthā’’tiādimāha. Anacchariyattāti dvīsupi uppajjamānesu acchariyattābhāvatoti attho. Dvīsupi uppajjamānesu anacchariyatā, kimaṅgaṃ pana bahūsūti dassento, ‘‘yadi cā’’tiādimāha. Buddhā nāma majjhe bhinnasuvaṇṇaṃ viya ekasadisāti tesaṃ desanāpi ekarasā ekadhāti āha – ‘‘desanāya ca visesābhāvato’’ti. Etenapi anacchariyattameva sādheti. Vivādabhāvatoti etena vivādābhāvatthaṃ dve buddhā ekato na uppajjantīti dasseti. Etaṃ kāraṇanti etaṃ anacchariyatādikāraṇaṃ. Tatthāti milindapañhe. “同时”(ekato),义为“一起”(saha),即“于同一时”。此“时”如何界定?为示其从最后有之结生,乃至界遍涅槃,故说“于彼”等。“不稀有故”(anacchariyattā),义为二者出现亦无稀有。为示“二者出现尚不稀有,何况众多”,故说“若”等。诸佛如碎金块,体性同一,其教法亦一味、一同,故说“教法无差别故”。此亦成立不稀有之义。“无诤论故”(vivādābhāvato),此句显示为免诤论,二佛不一同出现。“此是原因”,即此不稀有等原因。“于彼”,谓于《弥兰王问经》。 Ekaṃ eva buddhaṃ dhāretīti ekabuddhadhāraṇī. Etena evaṃsabhāvā ete buddhaguṇā, yena dutiyabuddhaguṇe dhāretuṃ asamatthā ayaṃ lokadhātūti dasseti. Paccayavisesanipphannānañhi guṇadhammānaṃ bhāriyo viseso mahāpathaviyāpi dussahoti sakkā viññātuṃ. Tathā hi abhisambodhisamaye upagatassa lokanāthassa guṇabhāraṃ bodhirukkhassa tīsupi disāsu mahāpathavī sandhāretuṃ nāsakkhi. Tasmā ‘‘na dhāreyyā’’ti vatvā tameva adhāraṇaṃ pariyāyantarehi pakāsento ‘‘caleyyā’’tiādimāha. Tattha caleyyāti paripphandeyya. Kampeyyāti pavedheyya[Pg.218]. Nameyyāti ekapassena nameyya. Onameyyāti osīdeyya. Vinameyyāti vividhaṃ ito cito ca nameyya. Vikireyyāti vātena thusamuṭṭhi viya vippakireyya. Vidhameyyāti vinasseyya. Viddhaṃseyyāti sabbaso viddhastā bhaveyya. Tathābhūtā ca na katthaci tiṭṭheyyāti āha – ‘‘na ṭhānamupagaccheyyā’’ti. 仅能承受一佛,故为“一佛所持”。此言显示,佛陀功德的自性即是如此,此世界无法承受第二尊佛的功德。须知,由殊胜因缘而生的功德法,其份量之重,纵使大地亦难承受。譬如,世尊将要证得圆满菩提时,其功德之重,菩提树下三方的大地都无法承受。因此说“不能承受”,又用其他方式来阐释此不能承受之义,说了“将会震动”等。其中,“震动”即是摇荡,“颤动”即是战栗,“倾斜”即是向一方倾斜,“下沉”即是陷没,“扭曲”即是向各个方向弯曲,“散裂”即是像风吹糠秕一样四处飞散,“毁坏”即是消亡,“粉碎”即是彻底毁灭。像这样,就无处可立了,所以说“无有住处”。 Idāni tattha nidassanaṃ dassento, ‘‘yathā, mahārājā’’tiādimāha. Tattha eke puriseti ekasmiṃ purise. Samupādikāti samaṃ uddhaṃ pajjati pavattatīti samupādikā, udakassa upari samaṃ gāminīti attho. ‘‘Samuppādikā’’tipi paṭhanti, ayamevattho. Vaṇṇenāti saṇṭhānena. Pamāṇenāti ārohena. Kisathūlenāti kisathūlabhāvena, pariṇāhenāti attho. Dvinnampīti dvepi, dvinnampi vā sarīrabhāraṃ. 今为说明此义,而说“大王,譬如”等。其中,“一人”指一个男子。“浮板”(samupādikā)指与水面平行向上行进,意即能在水面上平稳移动。亦有读作“浮起板”(samuppādikā),其义相同。“颜色”指形状。“量度”指身高。“粗细”指身体是瘦是胖,意即围度。“二者”指两者,或指两者的身体重量。 Chādentanti rocentaṃ ruciṃ uppādentaṃ. Tandikatoti tena bhojanena tandibhūto. Anonamitadaṇḍajātoti yāvadatthaṃ bhojanena onamituṃ asakkuṇeyyatāya anonamanadaṇḍo viya jāto. Sakiṃ bhutto vameyyāti ekampi ālopaṃ ajjhoharitvā vameyyāti attho. “令人欢喜”是指喜欢、产生兴趣。“厌倦”是指因为那个食物而感到厌倦。“如不弯的杖”是指因为食物而无法弯腰,就像不弯的杖一样。“吃一口就吐”是指即使吃一口食物也会呕吐的意思。 Atidhammabhārena pathavī calatīti dhammena nāma pathavī tiṭṭheyya. Sā kiṃ teneva calati vinassatīti adhippāyena pucchati. Puna thero ‘‘ratanaṃ nāma loke kuṭumbaṃ sandhārentaṃ abhimatañca lokena attano garusabhāvatāya sakaṭabhaṅgassa kāraṇaṃ atibhārabhūtaṃ diṭṭhaṃ. Evaṃ dhammo ca hitasukhavisesehi taṃsamaṅgīnaṃ dhārento abhimato ca viññūnaṃ gambhīrappameyyabhāvena garusabhāvattā atibhārabhūto pathavīcalanassa kāraṇaṃ hotī’’ti dassento, ‘‘idha, mahārāja, dve sakaṭā’’tiādimāha. Eteneva tathāgatassa mātukucchiokkamanādikāle pathavīkampanakāraṇaṃ saṃvaṇṇitanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Ekassāti ekasmā, ekassa vā sakaṭassa ratanaṃ, tasmā sakaṭā gahetvāti attho. 大地因法的重负而震动,然而大地本应依正法而安住。她难道会因此而震动并毁灭吗?此为提问之意。长老又说:“世间的‘珍宝’,能维持家庭,为世人所喜爱,但因其自身的沉重,被视为导致车子毁坏的过重负担。同样,正法以其利益安乐的殊胜之处承载着具足此法者,为智者所推崇,又因其深奥难测而极为沉重,成为大地震动的原因。”长老为说明此点,而说“大王,此处有二车”等。当知,如来入母胎等时大地震动的原因,即由此得到阐明。所谓“一者”(ekassa),即“从一者”(ekasmā),或指“一车之宝”,故其义为“从那辆车取走”。 Osāritanti uccāritaṃ, vuttanti attho. Aggoti sabbasattehi aggo. Jeṭṭhoti vuddhataro. Seṭṭhoti pasatthataro. Visiṭṭhehi sīlādīhi guṇehi samannāgatattā visiṭṭho. Uggatatamoti uttamo. Pavaroti [Pg.219] tasseva vevacanaṃ. Natthi etassa samoti asamo. Asamā pubbabuddhā, tehi samoti asamasamo. Natthi etassa paṭisamo paṭipuggaloti appaṭisamo. Natthi etassa paṭibhāgoti appaṭibhāgo. Natthi etassa paṭipuggaloti appaṭipuggalo. “被宣说”(osārita)即被宣扬,意为被说出。“最胜”(aggo)即于一切众生中为最胜。“最长”(jeṭṭho)即更年长。“最优”(seṭṭho)即更卓越。“殊胜”(visiṭṭho)指因具足戒等殊胜功德。“至高”(uggatatamo)即最上。“卓越”(pavaro)是其同义词。“无等”(asamo)即没有与他相等者。“无等等”(asamasamo)指过去的诸佛是无等者,而他与彼等相等。“无比”(appaṭisamo)即没有与他匹敌的对等之人。“无对”(appaṭibhāgo)即没有与他相当者。“无双”(appaṭipuggalo)即没有与他对等之人。 Sabhāvapakatikāti sabhāvabhūtā akittimā pakati. Kāraṇamahantattāti kāraṇānaṃ mahantatāya, mahantehi buddhakaradhammehi pāramisaṅkhātehi kāraṇehi buddhaguṇānaṃ nibbattitoti vuttaṃ hoti. Pathavīādīni mahantāni vatthūni, mahantā cakkavāḷādayo attano attano visaye ekekāva, evaṃ sammāsambuddhopi mahanto attano visaye eko eva. Ko ca tassa visayo? Buddhabhūmi, yāvatakaṃ vā ñeyyaṃ. ‘‘Ākāso viya anantavisayo bhagavā eko eva hotī’’ti vadanto paracakkavāḷesupi dutiyassa buddhassa abhāvaṃ dasseti. “自性本然”是指本性真实,非人为造作。“因缘广大”是指因缘的广大性,也就是指以波罗蜜为代表的广大佛因功德能够产生佛的功德。正如大地等广大的事物,广大的宇宙等,在各自的领域都是独一无二的,同样,正等觉者在自己的领域里也是独一无二的。他的领域是什么呢?是佛的境界,以及所有应被知晓的领域。“如同虚空一般拥有无边领域的世尊只有一位”,这句话也显示了在其他宇宙中没有第二尊佛。 Imināva padenāti ‘‘ekissā lokadhātuyā’’ti iminā eva padena. Dasa cakkavāḷasahassāni gahitānīti jātikhettāpekkhāya gahitāni. Ekacakkavāḷenevāti iminā eva ekacakkavāḷena, na yena kenaci. Yathā ‘‘imasmiṃyeva cakkavāḷe uppajjantī’’ti vutte imasmimpi cakkavāḷe jambudīpe eva, tatthāpi majjhimadese evāti paricchindituṃ vaṭṭati, evaṃ ‘‘ekissā lokadhātuyā’’ti jātikhette adhippetepi imināva cakkavāḷena paricchindituṃ vaṭṭati. “唯此一句”即指“于一世界”这个说法。十千世界被包含,是就生处而言。所谓“唯一世界”,即特指这一个世界,不是随便哪个。正如说“只在这个世界出现”时,也要限定于这个世界的瞻部洲(Jambudīpa),甚至要进一步限定于中土区域(Majjhimadesa)一样,同样,“于一世界”虽然是就生处而言,也应当用这一个世界来限定。 Paṭhamavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 第一品释义终。 15. Aṭṭhānapāḷi (dutiyavagga) 15. 不可能之处品(第二品) (15) 2. Aṭṭhānapāḷi-dutiyavaggavaṇṇanā (15) 2. 不可能之处品第二品释义 278. Vivādupacchedatoti vivādupacchedakāraṇā. Dvīsu uppannesu yo vivādo bhaveyya, tassa anuppādoyevettha vivādupacchedo. Ekasmiṃ dīpetiādinā dīpantarepi ekajjhaṃ na uppajjati, pageva ekadīpeti dasseti. Sopi parihāyethāti cakkavāḷassa padese eva pavattitabbattā parihāyeyya. 278. “为断诤故”(vivādupacchedato)即为了断除诤论之因。当二者生起时,或有诤论,于此,不令其生起即是断诤。以“于一洲”等句显示,二者尚且不能同时生起于不同洲(dīpa),何况于同一洲。“彼亦将衰亡”(sopi parihāyethā)者,谓其仅能于世界(cakkavāḷa)之一隅行世,故将衰亡。 279-280. Manussattanti [Pg.220] manussabhāvo tasseva pabbajjādiguṇānaṃ yoggabhāvato. Liṅgasampattīti purisabhāvo. Hetūti manovacīpaṇidhānapubbikā hetusampadā. Satthāradassananti satthusammukhībhāvo. Pabbajjāti kammakiriyavādīsu tāpasesu, bhikkhūsu vā pabbajjā. Guṇasampattīti abhiññādiguṇasampadā. Adhikāroti buddhe uddissa adhiko kāro, savisesā upakārakiriyā adhiko sakkāroti vuttaṃ hoti. Chandova chandatā, sammāsambodhiṃ uddissa sātisayo kattukamyatākusalacchando. Aṭṭhadhammasamodhānāti etesaṃ aṭṭhannaṃ dhammānaṃ samāyogena. Abhinīhāroti kāyapaṇidhānaṃ. Samijjhatīti nipphajjati. Ayamettha saṅkhepo, vitthāro pana paramatthadīpaniyā cariyāpiṭakavaṇṇanāya (cariyā. aṭṭha. pakiṇṇakakathā) vuttanayena veditabbo. Sabbākāraparipūramevāti paripuṇṇalakkhaṇatāya sattuttamādīhi sabbākārena sampannameva. Na hi itthiyā kosohitavatthaguyhatādi sambhavati. Dutiyapakati ca nāma paṭhamapakatito nihīnā eva. Tenevāha – anantaravāre ‘‘yasmā’’tiādi. 279-280. “人身”(manussatta)是指人类的存在,因为它适合出家等功德。“根具足”(liṅgasampatti)是指具备男性的特征。“因”(hetu)是指以意业和语业为先导的因缘成就。“见导师”(satthāradassana)是指亲眼见到佛陀。“出家”(pabbajjā)是指在业行论的苦行者或比丘中出家。“德具足”(guṇasampatti)是指成就神通等功德。“ अधिकार”(adhikāra)是指为了佛陀而做的增上之行,也就是殊胜的奉事与恭敬。“欲”(chanda)就是欲求,特指为了追求正等正觉的殊胜善法欲。“八法和合”(aṭṭhadhammasamodhāna)是指这八种法的结合。“发愿”(abhinīhāra)是指身之立愿。“成就”(samijjhati)是指实现。这里是简要的说明,详细的解释应当按照《所行藏释义·胜义灯》(Paramatthadīpanī Cariyāpiṭaka-vaṇṇanā)的《杂品说》(Pakiṇṇakakathā)里所说的方式去理解。“一切方面完全圆满”是指因具备圆满的特征,故在身为最上等有情方面,一切行相皆已具足。因为女性不可能有阴藏等隐秘的部位。第二种自然状态也总是比第一种自然状态低劣。因此在紧接着的段落中说“因为”等。 281. Idha purisassa tattha nibbattanatoti imasmiṃ manussaloke purisabhūtassa tattha brahmaloke brahmattabhāvena nibbattanato. Tena asatipi purisaliṅge purisākārā brahmāno hontīti dasseti. Taṃyeva ca purisākāraṃ sandhāya vuttaṃ bhagavatā ‘‘yaṃ puriso brahmattaṃ kāreyyā’’ti. Tenevāha – ‘‘samānepī’’tiādi. Yadi evaṃ itthiyo brahmaloke na uppajjeyyunti āha – ‘‘brahmatta’’ntiādi. 281. “在此处男子生于彼处”是指在这人间的男子,以梵天的身份生于梵天界。这表明即使没有男性的性器官,具有男子形象的也能成为梵天。世尊所说的“男子可以成就梵天”,正是指这种男子形象。因此才说“即使相同”等等。如果问“这样说来,女子就不能往生梵天了吗?”,回答是“梵天”等等。 290-295. ‘‘Kāyaduccaritassā’’tiādipāḷiyā kammaniyāmo nāma kathito. Samañjanaṃ samaṅgo, samannāgamo, so etassa atthīti samaṅgī, samannāgato, samañjanasīlo vā samaṅgī, pubbabhāge upakaraṇasamudāyato pabhuti āyūhanavasena āyūhanasamaṅgītā, sanniṭṭhāpakacetanāvasena cetanāsamaṅgitā. Cetanāsantativasena vā āyūhanasamaṅgitā, taṃtaṃcetanākkhaṇavasena cetanāsamaṅgītā. Katūpacitassa avipakkavipākassa kammassa vasena kammasamaṅgitā. Kamme pana vipaccituṃ āraddhe vipākappavattivasena vipākasamaṅgitā. Kammādīnaṃ upaṭṭhānakālavasena upaṭṭhānasamaṅgitā. Kusalākusalakammāyūhanakkhaṇeti kusalakammassa akusalakammassa [Pg.221] ca samīhanakkhaṇe. Tathāti iminā kusalākusalakammapadaṃ ākaḍḍhati. Yathā kataṃ kammaṃ phaladānasamatthaṃ hoti, tathā kataṃ upacitaṃ. Vipākārahanti dutiyabhavādīsu vipaccanārahaṃ. Uppajjamānānaṃ upapattinimittaṃ upaṭṭhātīti yojanā. Upapattiyā uppajjanassa nimittaṃ kāraṇanti upapattinimittaṃ, kammaṃ, kammanimittaṃ, gatinimittañca. Aṭṭhakathāyaṃ pana gatinimittavaseneva yojanā dassitā. Kammakammanimittānampi upaṭṭhānaṃ yathārahaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. ‘‘Yānissa tāni pubbe katāni kammāni, tānissa tasmiṃ samaye olambanti ajjholambanti abhilambanti’’ti (ma. ni. 3.248) vacanato sāyanhe mahantānaṃ pabbatakūṭānaṃ chāyā viya āsannamaraṇassa sattassa citte supine viya vipaccituṃ katokāsaṃ kammaṃ, tassa nimittaṃ gatinimittaṃ upatiṭṭhateva. Calatīti parivattati. Ekena hi kammunā tajje nimitte upaṭṭhite paccayavisesavasena tato aññena kammunā tadaññassa nimittassa upaṭṭhānaṃ parivattanaṃ. Sesā niccalā avasesā catubbidhāpi samaṅgitā niccalā aparivattanato. 290-295. “身恶行”(kāyaduccarita)等巴利文经句所说的业决定法则(kammaniyāma)已得到阐明。相应(samaṅgo)即是相应(samañjanaṃ),具足(samannāgamo)。拥有这些特质者即是相应者(samaṅgī),亦即具足者(samannāgato),或习惯于相应者(samaṅgī)。从最初助缘聚集开始,依努力而有努力相应(āyūhanasamaṅgītā),依决定思(sanniṭṭhāpakacetanā)而有思相应(cetanāsamaṅgitā)。或依思之相续而有努力相应,依各别思刹那而有思相应。依已造作积聚而未成熟之业而有业相应(kammasamaṅgitā)。当业开始成熟时,依异熟之生起而有异熟相应(vipākasamaṅgitā)。依业等现起之时而有现起相应(upaṭṭhānasamaṅgitā)。善不善业之努力刹那,即是善业与不善业之希求刹那。“如是”一词在此引申善不善业之义。如所造之业能予果报,如是所造之业亦能积聚。堪受异熟(vipākārahaṃ)是指在第二生等之中能够成熟的业。其解释为:为即将出生者现起投生之相(upapattinimitta)。投生之生起的原因即是投生之相,亦即业、业相(kammanimitta)与趣相(gatinimitta)。然而在义注中,仅以趣相之方式解释。业与业相之现起亦应如理观察。如《中部》(ma. ni. 3.248)所说:“凡是他过去所造之业,于彼时皆悬挂、依附、缠绕着他。”因此,犹如傍晚巨大山峰之阴影,对于临死之有情而言,其心中犹如梦境般,已得成熟机会之业及其趣相必然现起。“转变”(calati)即是“转换”(parivattati)。因为一个业之相应相现起,由于特殊因缘,导致另一个业之另一相现起,此即是转换。其余四种相应皆是恒常不变的,因其不转换故。 Sunakhavājikoti sunakhehi migavājavasena vajanasīlo, sunakhaluddakoti attho. Talasantharaṇapūjanti bhūmitalassa pupphehi santharaṇapūjaṃ. Āyūhanacetanā kammasamaṅgitāvasenāti kāyaduccaritassa aparāparaṃ āyūhanena sanniṭṭhāpakacetanāya tasseva pakappane kammakkhayakarañāṇena akhepitattā yathūpacitakammunā ca samaṅgibhāvassa vasena. 犬猎师(sunakhavājiko)是指习惯用狗追逐猎物的猎人,亦即猎犬者(sunakhaluddako)之义。地面铺花供养(talasantharaṇapūjā)是指用鲜花铺在地面上进行供养。努力思(āyūhanacetanā)与业相应(kammasamaṅgitā)之义,是说由于不断努力造作身恶行,并以决定思(sanniṭṭhāpakacetanā)策划此恶行,且未被业尽智(kammakkhayakarañāṇa)所破除,以及随所积聚之业而具足相应之故。 Kammanti akusalakammaṃ. Tasmiṃyeva khaṇeti āyūhanakkhaṇeyeva. Tassāti kammasamaṅgino puggalassa saggo vārito, tañce kammaṃ vipākavāraṃ labheyyāti adhippāyo. Saggo vāritoti ca nidassanamattaṃ. Manussalokopissa vāritovāti. Apare pana purimehi vipākāvaraṇassa anuddhaṭattā ‘‘tasmiṃyeva khaṇe’’ti ca avisesena vuttattā taṃ dosaṃ pariharituṃ ‘‘āyūhitakammaṃ nāmā’’tiādimāha. Yadā kammaṃ vipākavāraṃ labhatīti idaṃ katokāsassa appaṭibāhiyattā vuttaṃ. Tathā hi bhagavā tatiyapārājikavatthusmiṃ (pārā. 162 ādayo) paṭisallīyi, imasmiṃ sutte ‘‘kāyaduccaritasamaṅgī’’ti āgatattā vipākūpaṭṭhānasamaṅgitā na labbhanti. “业”(kammaṃ)是指不善业(akusalakammaṃ)。“就在那个刹那”(tasmiṃyeva khaṇe)即是“就在努力造作的刹那”(āyūhanakkhaṇeyeva)。“他的”(tassa)是指具足业相应之人(kammasamaṅgino puggalassa)的天道(sagga)被阻碍,其意是如果此业能获得异熟之机会。“天道被阻碍”(saggo vārito)仅是举例。他的人间(manussaloka)亦被阻碍。然而,另一些人为了避免此过失,因之前异熟之障碍(vipākāvaraṇa)未被消除,且“就在那个刹那”被不加区分地提及,故说“所谓已造作之业”(āyūhitakammaṃ nāma)等等。“当业获得异熟之机会”(yadā kammaṃ vipākavāraṃ labhati)此语,是说已得机会之业不会被阻碍。例如,世尊(bhagavā)在第三波罗夷(tatiyapārājika)事(vatthu)中独处(paṭisallīyi),而在此经中,由于提及“具足身恶行者”(kāyaduccaritasamaṅgī),故不能获得异熟现起相应(vipākūpaṭṭhānasamaṅgitā)。 (Dutiyavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā.) (第二品释义终。) Aṭṭhānapāḷivaṇṇanāyaṃ anuttānatthadīpanā niṭṭhitā. 《八事巴利释义》中《未显义明灯》终。 16. Ekadhammapāḷi 16. 一法巴利 (16) 1. Ekadhammapāḷi-paṭhamavaggavaṇṇanā (16)1.一法巴利初品释义 296. Ekadhammapāḷivaṇṇanāyaṃ [Pg.222] idha dhamma-saddo sabhāvattho ‘‘kusalā dhammā’’tiādīsu viyāti āha – ‘‘ekasabhāvo’’ti. Ekantenāti ekaṃsena, avassanti attho. Vaṭṭeti saṃsāravaṭṭe. Nibbindanatthāyāti anabhiramanatthāya. Virajjanatthāyāti arajjanatthāya. Virajjanāyāti palujjanāya. Tenevāha – ‘‘vigamāyā’’ti. Rāgādīnaṃ nirodhāyāti maggañāṇena rāgādīnaṃ nirodhanatthāya. Maggañāṇena nirodhanaṃ nāma accantaṃ appavattikaraṇanti āha – ‘‘appavattikaraṇatthāyā’’ti. Yathā khādanīyassa mukhe katvā khādanaṃ nāma yāvadeva ajjhoharaṇatthaṃ, evaṃ rāgādīnaṃ nirodhanaṃ vaṭṭanirodhanatthamevāti vuttaṃ – ‘‘vaṭṭasseva vā nirujjhanatthāyā’’ti. Yasmā kilesesu khīṇesu itaraṃ vaṭṭadvayampi khīṇameva hoti, tasmā mūlameva gaṇhanto ‘‘upasamāyāti kilesavūpasamanatthāyā’’ti āha. Saṅkhatadhammānaṃ abhijānanaṃ nāma tattha lakkhaṇattayāropanamukhenevāti āha – ‘‘aniccādi…pe… abhijānanatthāyā’’ti. Sambujjhitabbāni nāma cattāri ariyasaccāni tabbinimuttassa ñeyyassa abhāvato. ‘‘Catunnaṃ saccānaṃ bujjhanatthāyā’’ti vatvā tayidaṃ bujjhanaṃ yassa ñāṇassa vasena ijjhati, tassa ñāṇassa vasena dassetuṃ – ‘‘bodhi vuccatī’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Appaccayanibbānassāti amatadhātuyā. 296. 在一法巴利释义中,此处的“法”(dhamma)是自性之义,如“善法”(kusalā dhammā)等,所以说“一自性”(ekasabhāvo)。“究竟”(ekantena)是指绝对、必定之义。“于流转中”(vaṭṭe)是指在轮回流转中。“为厌离”(nibbindanatthāya)是为了不乐之义。“为离染”(virajjanatthāya)是为了不染之义。“离染”(virajjanāya)是指坏灭之义。因此说“为离去”(vigamāya)。“为灭尽贪等”(rāgādīnaṃ nirodhāya)是指以道智灭尽贪等的目的。“以道智灭尽”是指究竟令其不生起,所以说“为令其不生起故”(appavattikaraṇatthāya)。如同将嚼食(khādanīya)放入口中咀嚼,只是为了吞咽,同样,灭尽贪等只是为了断除轮回的目的,所以说“或为轮回灭尽故”(vaṭṭasseva vā nirujjhanatthāya)。因为当诸烦恼灭尽时,其余二种轮回也随之灭尽,所以抓住根本而说:“为寂灭”(upasamāya),是指为烦恼寂灭的缘故。“遍知”有为法是指通过建立三相来认知,所以说“为遍知无常等故”。所应觉悟者是指四圣谛,因为没有能脱离它们的所知法。说了“为觉悟四谛故”后,为了说明此觉悟是依何种智慧而成就,才说“菩提被称为”等语。“无缘涅槃”(appaccayanibbāna)是指不死界。 Ussāhajananatthanti kammaṭṭhāne abhiruciuppādanāya. Visakaṇṭakoti guḷassa vāṇijasamaññā. ‘‘Kismiñci dese desabhāsā’’ti keci. Ucchuraso samapākapakko cuṇṇādīhi missetvā piṇḍīkato guḷo, apiṇḍīkato phāṇitaṃ. Pākavisesena khaṇḍakhaṇḍasedito khaṇḍo, malābhāvaṃ āpanno sakkarā. “为激发精进”是指于业处生起喜悦。“蜜刺”(visakaṇṭaka)是糖的商人名称。有人说:“在某个地方,有地方的语言。”甘蔗汁经适当熬煮,与粉末等混合成块的为“糖”(guḷa),未成块的为“糖蜜”(phāṇita)。经特殊熬制而切成块的为“粗糖”(khaṇḍa),去除杂质后得到的为“砂糖”(sakkarā)。 Saratīti sati. Anu anu saratīti anussati, anu anurūpā satītipi anussati. Duvidhaṃ hotīti payojanavasena duvidhaṃ hoti. Cittasampahaṃsanatthanti pasādanīyavatthusmiṃ pasāduppādanena bhāvanācittassa paritosanatthaṃ. Vipassanatthanti vipassanāsukhatthaṃ. Upacārasamādhinā hi citte samāhite vipassanāsukhena ijjhati. Cittuppādoti bhāvanāvasena pavatto cittuppādo. Upahaññati patihaññati paṭikūlattā ārammaṇassa. Tato [Pg.223] eva ukkaṇṭhati, kammaṭṭhānaṃ riñcati, nirassādo hoti bhāvanassādassa alabbhanato. Pasīdati buddhaguṇānaṃ pasādanīyattā. Tathā ca kaṅkhādicetokhilābhāvena vinīvaraṇo hoti. Dametvāti nīvaraṇanirākaraṇena nibbisevanaṃ katvā. Evaṃ kammaṭṭhānantarānuyuñjanena cittaparidamanassa upamaṃ dassento, ‘‘katha’’ntiādimāha. 忆念是为念。持续忆念是为随念,与念相应相续亦是随念。分为两种是依作用而分。为了令心喜悦,是在可喜悦的对象中生起净信,使修习之心获得满足。为了观,即为了观之乐。因为以近行定使心安定时,观之乐便得以成就。心生起是指依修习而转起的心生起。因所缘境令人厌恶,心便受打击、排斥。因此而厌烦,舍弃业处,因得不到修习之味而索然无味。因佛陀的功德令人喜悦,所以心生净信,如此便能去除疑惑等心荒芜而无盖障。调伏是指通过去除诸盖而令其调顺。为了显示像这样不断修习其他业处来调伏心的譬喻,所以说了“如何”等。 Ko ayaṃ…pe… anussarīti ko ayaṃ mama abbhantare ṭhatvā anussari. Pariggaṇhantoti bāhirakaparikappitassa anussarakassa sabbaso abhāvadassanametaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘na añño kocī’’ti. Disvāti pariyesananayena vuttappakāraṃ cittameva anussarīti disvā sabbampetanti etaṃ hadayavatthuādippabhedaṃ sabbampi. Idañca rūpaṃ purimañca arūpanti idaṃ ruppanasabhāvattā rūpaṃ, purimaṃ ataṃsabhāvattā arūpanti saṅkhepato rūpārūpaṃ vavatthapetvā. Pañcakkhandhe vavatthapetvāti yojanā. Sambhāvikāti samuṭṭhāpikā. Tassāti samudayasaccassa. Nirodhoti nirodhanimittaṃ. Appanāvāroti yathāraddhāya desanāya nigamanavāro. “此为何人…乃至…忆念者?”是问:此为何人住于我内而忆念?“执取者”,这是显示完全没有外在所构想的忆念者。因此说:“没有其他人”。“见”者,即是依寻求之法,见到如前所述,心本身即是忆念者;而“一切”是指心所依处等所有差别。“此色与先前无色”,此有变坏之自性故为色,前者无彼自性故为无色,如是简要地确立色与无色。这是解释确立五蕴之义。“能生起者”,是生起者。“彼者”,是集谛的。“灭”者,是灭之相。“安止节”,是随所说法的总结节。 297. Eseva nayoti iminā yvāyaṃ ‘‘taṃ paneta’’ntiādinā atthanayo buddhānussatiyaṃ vibhāvitoti atidisati, svāyaṃ atideso payojanavasena navasupi anussatīsu sādhāraṇavasena vuttopi ānāpānassatiādīsu tīsu vipassanatthāneva hontīti iminā apavādena nivattitoti tāsaṃ ekappayojanatāva daṭṭhabbā. Dhamme anussati dhammānussatīti samāsapadavibhāgadassanampi vacanatthadassanapakkhikamevāti āha – ‘‘ayaṃ panettha vacanattho’’ti. Dhammaṃ ārabbhāti hi dhammassa anussatiyā visayabhāvadassanametaṃ. Esa nayo sesesupi. Sīlaṃ ārabbhāti attano pārisuddhisīlaṃ ārabbha. Cāgaṃ ārabbhāti attano cāgaguṇaṃ ārabbha. Devatā ārabbhāti ettha devatāguṇasadisatāya attano saddhāsīlasutacāgapaññāsu devatāsamaññā. Bhavati hi taṃsadisepi tabbohāro yathā ‘‘tāni osadhāni, esa brahmadatto’’ti ca. Tenāha – ‘‘devatā sakkhiṭṭhāne ṭhapetvā’’tiādi. Tattha devatā sakkhiṭṭhāne ṭhapetvāti ‘‘yathārūpāya saddhāya samannāgatā tā devatā ito cutā tattha upapannā, mayhampi tathārūpā saddhā saṃvijjati. Yathārūpena sīlena, yathārūpena [Pg.224] sutena, yathārūpena cāgena, yathārūpāya paññāya samannāgatā tā devatā ito cutā tattha upapannā, mayhampi tathārūpā paññā saṃvijjatī’’ti evaṃ devatā sakkhiṭṭhāne ṭhapetvā. Assāsapassāsanimittaṃ nāma tattha laddhabbappaṭibhāganimittaṃ. Gatāti ārammaṇakaraṇavasena upagatā pavattā. 297. “此即是理趣”,以此(说明)在佛随念(buddhānussati)中已阐明的“彼又此”等义理,(此处)加以引申。此引申虽依作用而普遍适用于九种随念,但在入出息念(ānāpānassati)等三种中,因“仅为观(vipassanā)之用”此一例外而被排除,故应知彼等仅具单一作用。“于法之随念是为法随念”,此复合词的分析亦属词义解释一类,故说:“此是此处之词义”。“缘于法”,此是显示法为随念之所缘。此理趣亦通于其余。“缘于戒”是指缘于自己的清净戒。“缘于施”是指缘于自己的布施功德。“缘于天”,此处是因自己的信、戒、闻、施、慧与天(devatā)之功德相似,故得天之名。因为与彼相似者亦得彼名,如“彼等是药草”及“此是梵授(Brahmadatta)”。因此说:“将天置于证人之处”等。其中,将天置于证人之处是指:“彼诸天具备如是信,从此死后生于彼处,我亦有如是信。彼诸天具备如是戒、如是闻、如是施、如是慧,从此死后生于彼处,我亦有如是慧”,如是将天置于证人之处。所谓“出入息相”,是指于彼处所应得之似相。“已至”,是指依作为所缘而趋近、转起。 Upasammati ettha dukkhanti upasamo, nibbānaṃ. Accantameva ettha upasammati vaṭṭattayanti accantūpasamo, nibbānameva. Khiṇoti khepeti kileseti khayo, ariyamaggo. Te eva upasametīti upasamo, ariyamaggo eva. Khayo ca so upasamo cāti khayūpasamo. Tatracāyaṃ upasamo dhammo evāti dhammānussatiyā upasamānussati ekasaṅgahoti? Saccaṃ ekasaṅgaho dhammabhāvasāmaññe adhippete, saṅkhatadhammato pana asaṅkhatadhammo sātisayo uḷāratamapaṇītatamabhāvatoti dīpetuṃ visuṃ nīharitvā vuttaṃ. Imameva hi visesaṃ sandhāya bhagavā – ‘‘dhammānussatī’’ti vatvāpi upasamānussatiṃ avoca anussarantassa savisesaṃ santapaṇītabhāvena upaṭṭhānato. Evañca katvā idha khayūpasamaggahaṇampi samatthitanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Yatheva hi samānepi lokuttaradhammabhāve ‘‘yāvatā, bhikkhave, dhammā saṅkhatā vā asaṅkhatā vā, virāgo tesaṃ aggamakkhāyatī’’tiādivacanato (itivu. 90) maggaphaladhammehi nibbānadhammo sātisayo, evaṃ phaladhammato maggadhammo kilesappahānena acchariyadhammabhāvato, tasmā accantūpasamena saddhiṃ khayūpasamopi gahitoti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Vipassanatthāneva hontīti kasmā vuttanti? ‘‘Ekantanibbidāyātiādivacanato’’ti keci, taṃ akāraṇaṃ buddhānussatiādīsupi tathā desanāya āgatattā. Yathā pana buddhānussatiādīni kammaṭṭhānāni vipassanatthāni honti, nimittasampahaṃsanatthānipi honti, na evametāni, etāni pana vipassanatthānevāti tathā vuttaṃ. 于此寂静痛苦,是为寂静,即涅槃。于此究竟寂静轮回,是为究竟寂静,亦即涅槃。断尽、灭除烦恼,是为灭尽,即圣道。彼(圣道)令(烦恼)寂静,故为寂静,亦即圣道。灭尽与彼寂静,是为灭尽寂静。此中,此寂静即是法,故寂静随念是否摄于法随念中?诚然,若意指法性共通,则为同一所摄。然为显示有为法与无为法相比,无为法因其最为崇高、最为寂妙而更超胜,故单独提出而说。世尊(Bhagavā)正是着眼于此差别,说了法随念后,复说寂静随念,因为当忆念时,(寂静)会以特别寂静、寂妙的状态现起。如是,应知此处提及“灭尽寂静”亦是合理的。正如虽同为出世间法,但依“诸比丘,所有法,或有为或无为,离贪于其中堪称第一”等语,涅槃法超胜于道、果法;同样,道法因断除烦恼而为希有法,故超胜于果法。因此,应知“灭尽寂静”与“究竟寂静”一同被提及。为何说“仅为观(vipassanā)之用”?有人说:“因有‘纯为厌离’等语”,此说不成立,因佛随念等中亦有如是教说。然而,佛随念等业处既可为观之用,亦可为令心喜悦之用,此等(寂静随念等)则不然,彼等仅为观之用,故如是说。 Paṭhamavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 第一品释义终。 16. Ekadhammapāḷi 16. 一法品 (16) 2. Ekadhammapāḷi-dutiyavaggavaṇṇanā (16) 2. 一法品第二品释义 298. Micchā passati tāya, sayaṃ vā micchā passati, micchādassanameva vā tanti micchādiṭṭhi, yaṃ kiñci viparītadassanaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘dvāsaṭṭhividhāyā’’tiādi[Pg.225]. Micchādiṭṭhi etassāti micchādiṭṭhiko. Tassa micchādiṭṭhikassa. 298. 依此而邪见,或自己邪见,或仅是邪见,是为邪见,即任何颠倒之见。因此说:“六十二种”等。“彼有邪见”是为邪见者。彼邪见者的。 299. Sammā passati tāya, sayaṃ vā sammā passati, sammādassanamattameva vā tanti sammādiṭṭhi. Pañcavidhāyāti kammassakatājhānavipassanāmaggaphalavasena pañcavidhāya. Tattha jhānacittuppādapariyāpannaṃ ñāṇaṃ jhānasammādiṭṭhi, vipassanāñāṇaṃ vipassanāsammādiṭṭhi. 299. 依此而正见,或自己正见,或仅是正见,是为正见。“五种”,即依业所有、禅那、观、道、果而有五种。其中,包含于禅那心生起中的智是禅那正见,观智是观正见。 302. Pañcasu khandhesu ‘‘nicca’’ntiādinā pavatto anupāyamanasikāro. 302. 于五蕴中以“常”等方式而转起的,是不如理作意。 303. ‘‘Anicca’’ntiādinā pavatto upāyamanasikāro. Yāva niyāmokkamanāti yāva micchattaniyāmokkamanā. Micchattaniyāmokkamananayo pana sāmaññaphalasuttavaṇṇanāyaṃ taṭṭīkāya ca vuttanayeneva veditabbo. 303. 以“无常”等方式而转起的,是如理作意。“直到出离决定”,即直到出离邪性决定。至于出离邪性决定的理趣,则应依《沙门果经》释义及其复注中所说之理趣而知。 304. Ayaṃ tividhā saggāvaraṇā ceva hotīti kammapathappattiyā mahāsāvajjabhāvato vuttaṃ. Saggāvaraṇāya hontiyā maggavibandhakabhāve vattabbameva natthīti vuttaṃ – ‘‘maggāvaraṇā cā’’ti. ‘‘Sassato loko’’tiādikā dasavatthukā antaggāhikā micchādiṭṭhi. Maggāvaraṇāva hoti viparītadassanabhāvato, na saggāvaraṇā akammapathapattitoti adhippāyo. Idaṃ pana vidhānaṃ paṭikkhipitvāti viparītadassanañca na maggāvaraṇañcāti viruddhametaṃ uddhammabhāvato. Tathā hi sati appahīnāya eva sakkāyadiṭṭhiyā maggādhigamena bhavitabbanti adhippāyena yathāvuttavidhānaṃ paṭikkhipitvā. ‘‘Na saggāvaraṇā’’ti saggūpapattiyā avibandhakattaṃ vadantehi diṭṭhiyā saggāvahatāpi nāma anuññātā hotīti taṃ vādaṃ paṭikkhipantena ‘‘diṭṭhi nāma saggaṃ upanetuṃ samatthā nāma natthī’’ti vuttaṃ. Kasmā? Ekantagarutarasāvajjabhāvato. Tenāha – ‘‘ekantaṃ nirayasmiṃyeva nimujjāpetī’’tiādi. 304. “此三者亦为天界之障”,是因其达到业道,为极重过患而说。既为天界之障,其为道之障碍便不待言,故说“亦为道障”。“世间是常”等十事执边邪见,因其为颠倒见,故仅为道障,非天界之障,因其未达到业道,此为其意。然而,驳斥此说……(认为)“是颠倒见却非道障”,此说与正法相违。若然,则意味着未断身见亦能证得圣道,以此意趣而驳斥前说。言“非天界之障”者,谓其不障碍生天,乃至认可邪见亦能引生天界,为驳斥此论,故说“邪见实无能力引生天界”。何以故?因其是极重过患。是故说“其必沉沦于地狱”等。 305. Vaṭṭaṃ viddhaṃsetīti maggasammādiṭṭhi kilesavaṭṭaṃ kammavaṭṭañca viddhaṃseti. Vipākavaṭṭaṃ kā nu viddhaṃseti nāma. Evaṃ pana attano kāraṇena viddhastabhavaṃ phalasammādiṭṭhi paṭibāhatīti vuttaṃ avasaradānato. Iccetaṃ kusalanti arahattaṃ pāpetuṃ sace sakkoti, evametaṃ vipassanāya paṭisandhianākaḍḍhanaṃ [Pg.226] kusalaṃ anavajjaṃ. Satta bhave detīti sotāpattimaggassa paccayabhūtā vipassanāsammādiṭṭhi tassa puggalassa satta bhave deti. Evamayanti pañcavidhampi sammādiṭṭhiṃ sandhāya vuttaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘lokiyalokuttarā sammādiṭṭhi kathitā’’ti. Imasmiṃ panattheti ‘‘nāhaṃ, bhikkhave, aññaṃ ekadhammampi samanupassāmī’’tiādinā vutte gatimaggasaṅkhāte atthe. ‘‘Sugatiṃ saggaṃ lokaṃ upapajjantī’’ti vuttattā ‘‘lokikā bhavanipphādikāva veditabbā’’ti vuttaṃ. 305. “摧毁轮转”者,道正见摧毁烦恼轮转与业轮转。然则,谁能摧毁果报轮转呢?如是,因其(生起之)因已被摧毁,果正见因不给予机会而遮止(果报轮转),故如是说。“此是善”者,若能引至阿罗汉果,如是,此观(vipassanā)不引来结生,是善、无过。“给予七有”者,作为入流道之缘的观正见,能使该人(puggala)经历七有。“如是”者,是总括五种正见而说。是故说:“已说世间与出世间正见。”“于此义中”者,于“诸比丘,我不见有其他一法……”等所说,名为“趣道”之义中。因经说“往生善趣天界”,故说“当知仅有世间(正见)能产生(未来)有”。 306. Yathādiṭṭhīti atthabyāpanicchāyaṃ yathā-saddo, tena uttarapadatthappadhāno samāsoti āha – ‘‘yā yā diṭṭhī’’ti. Tassā tassā anurūpanti taṃtaṃdiṭṭhianurūpanti attho. Samattanti anavasesaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘paripuṇṇa’’nti. Samādinnanti ādimajjhapariyosānesu samaṃ ekasadisaṃ katvā ādinnaṃ gahitaṃ anissaṭṭhaṃ. Tadetanti yadetaṃ ‘‘yañceva kāyakamma’’ntiādinā vuttaṃ, tadetaṃ kāyakammaṃ. Yathādiṭṭhiyaṃ ṭhitakāyakammanti yā pana diṭṭhi ‘‘natthi tatonidānaṃ pāpa’’ntiādinā pavattā, tassaṃ diṭṭhiyaṃ ṭhitakassa ṭhitamattassa anissaṭṭhassa taṃdiṭṭhikassa kāyakammaṃ. Diṭṭhisahajātaṃ kāyakammanti tassa yathādiṭṭhikassa paresaṃ hatthamuddādinā viññāpanakāle tāya diṭṭhiyā sahajātaṃ kāyakammaṃ. Na cettha vacīkammāsaṅkā uppādetabbā pāṇaghātādīnaṃyeva adhippetattā. Diṭṭhānulomikaṃ kāyakammanti yathā paresaṃ pākaṭaṃ hoti, evaṃ diṭṭhiyā anulomikaṃ katvā pavattitaṃ kāyakammaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘samādinnaṃ gahitaṃ parāmaṭṭha’’nti. Tatthātiādi suviññeyyameva. Eseva nayoti iminā yathāvuttāya diṭṭhiyā ṭhitavacīkammaṃ, diṭṭhisahajātaṃ vacīkammaṃ, diṭṭhānulomikaṃ vacīkammanti tividhaṃ hotīti evamādi atidisati. Micchādiṭṭhikassāti kammapathappattāya micchādiṭṭhiyā micchādiṭṭhikassa. ‘‘Yāya kāyaci micchādiṭṭhiyā micchādiṭṭhikassa sato’’ti apare. 306. “如其所见”(Yathādiṭṭhi)者,“如”(yathā)字是为阐明其义,因此说此复合词以后分词义为主,即“彼彼之见”。“与其彼彼相应”者,义为与彼彼之见相应。“完全”者,无余也。是故说“圆满”。“受持”者,于初、中、后平等一致地受纳、执取、不舍。“此”者,即“身业”等所说之身业。“依见而住之身业”者,即持有“由此无恶”等见者,于彼见安住、仅住不舍,此具见者之身业。“与见俱生之身业”者,即彼如是见者,以手势等告知他人时,与彼见俱生之身业。此处不应生起口业之疑,因其意指杀生等。“随顺见之身业”者,为令他人明见,随顺于见而行之身业。是故说“受持、执取、执取”。“于此”等,易于了知。“此理亦然”者,以此类推,依前所说之见而住之口业、与见俱生之口业、随顺见之口业亦有三种等。“邪见者”,即具有达到业道之邪见的邪见者。另有说:“以任何邪见而为邪见者”。 Diṭṭhisahajātāti yathāvuttāya diṭṭhiyā sahajātā cetanā. Esa nayo sesapadesupi. Patthanāti ‘‘idaṃ nāma kareyya’’nti taṇhāpatthanā. Cetanāpatthanānaṃ vasenāti yathāvuttadiṭṭhigatanissitacetasikanikāmanānaṃ vasena. Cittaṭṭhapanāti cittassa paṇidahanā. Phassādayoti cetanādiṭṭhitaṇhādivinimuttā phassādidhammā. Yasmā diṭṭhi pāpikā, tasmā tassa puggalassa sabbe te dhammā aniṭṭhāya…pe… saṃvattantīti yojanā. Purimassevāti [Pg.227] tittakapadasseva. Tittakaṃ kaṭukanti ca ubhayaṃ idha aniṭṭhapariyāyaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ ‘‘pacchā te kaṭukaṃ bhavissatī’’tiādīsu viya. “与见俱生”者,与如前所说之见俱生的思。此理亦通于其余诸句。“希求”者,“愿我能做此事”之渴爱希求。“依思与希求之力”者,依于如前所说之见,依止于此的心所欲求之力。“心住”者,心之志向。“触等”者,脱离思、见、渴爱等之触等诸法。“因为见是恶的,所以彼人之一切法皆导向不悦意……等”,应如是连结。“如前者”,即如前之“苦”(tittaka)一词。“苦”与“辛辣”(kaṭuka)二者,于此皆应视为不悦意之同义词,犹如“其后于汝将为苦”等句。 Amboyanti ambo ayaṃ. Tameva pūjanti tameva pubbe laddhaparisiñcanadānādipūjaṃ. Nivesareti pavisiṃsu. Asātasannivāsenāti amadhuranimbamūlasaṃsaggena. “庵婆”(Ambo)者,此庵婆树也。“只尊敬它”者,即只尊敬彼先前曾得灌水、布施等供养者。“进入”者,已进入。“与不快共住”者,与不甜的苦楝树(nimba)根为伴。 Taṃ pana paṭikkhipitvā…pe… vuttanti sabbāpi micchādiṭṭhi ekantasāvajjattā aniṭṭhāya dukkhāya saṃvattatīti adhippāyena vuttaṃ. Anantarasutteti dasamasutte. Yojetvā veditabbānīti navamasutte viya yojetvā veditabbāni. Cittaṭṭhapanāva patthanāti ettha paṇidhi cāti vattabbaṃ. 然,驳斥彼……所说者,意谓一切邪见因其全然有过,故导向不悦与痛苦。“于次经中”者,于第十经中。“应连结而知”者,应如第九经般连结而知。于“心住即是希求”处,应说“及志向”(paṇidhi)。 Dutiyavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 第二品释义终。 16. Ekadhammapāḷi 16. 一法品 (16) 3. Ekadhammapāḷi-tatiyavaggavaṇṇanā (16) 3. 一法品第三品释义 308. Tatiyassa paṭhame ayāthāvadiṭṭhikoti aniccādibhāvesu dhammesu niccātiādinā uppannadiṭṭhiko. Tenāha – ‘‘tāyeva micchādiṭṭhiyā viparītadassano’’ti saddhammāti ettha santo pasattho sundaro dhammo, yo manussadhammotipi vuccati. Tato hi micchādiṭṭhiko paraṃ vuṭṭhāpeyya, na ariyadhammato. Tenāha – ‘‘dasakusalakammapathadhammato’’ti. Evarūpāti iminā pāthikaputtādike saṅgaṇhāti. 308. 第三品第一(经)中,“不如实见者”,谓于无常等法生起常等见者。是故说:“以彼邪见而颠倒见”。“正法”(saddhamma)者,于此,是寂静、可赞、美妙之法,亦称“人法”(manussadhamma)。邪见者实令他人从此法退转,而非从圣法。是故说:“从十善业道法”。“如是”者,以此含摄跋提咖子(Pāthikaputta)等人。 309. Sabbaññubodhisattoti sabbaññubhāgī bodhisatto. Ādi-saddena pūritapāramikā paccekabodhisattā ekaccasāvakabodhisattā ca saṅgayhanti. 309. “一切智菩萨”(Sabbaññubodhisatta)者,分得一切智分之菩萨。以“等”字,摄入已圆满波罗蜜的独觉菩萨及某些声闻菩萨。 310. Paramāti mahāsāvajjabhāvena paramā, ukkaṃsagatāti attho. Tesanti ānantariyakammānaṃ. Paricchedoti vipākavasena pariyosānaṃ. Vaṭṭassa mūlaṃ, tato taṃsamaṅgīpuggalo vaṭṭassa khāṇūti vuccati. Tenāha – ‘‘tāyā’’tiādi. Tañce gāhaṃ na vissajjeti, tassa punapi tabbhāvāvahattā vuttaṃ – ‘‘bhavato vuṭṭhānaṃ natthī’’ti, na pana sabbaso vuṭṭhānassa abhāvato. Yādise hi paccaye paṭicca ayaṃ taṃ dassanaṃ okkanto puna kadāci tappaṭipakkhe paccaye paṭicca tato sīsukkhipanamassa na hotīti na [Pg.228] vattabbaṃ. Akusalañhi nāmetaṃ abalaṃ dubbalaṃ, na kusalaṃ viya mahābalaṃ. Aññathā sammattaniyāmo viya micchattaniyāmopi accantiko siyā, na ca micchattaniyāmo accantiko. Teneva papañcasūdaniyaṃ (ma. ni. aṭṭha. 2.100) – 310. “极重(Paramā)”是因罪业极为深重,是最上的,意为达到顶点。“彼等(Tesaṃ)”是指无间业。“界限(Paricchedo)”是指依果报的终结。“轮回之根”,因此,具备此(邪见)的个人(puggala)被称为“轮回之桩”。故说“由此”等等。如果他不舍弃那种执取,因为它会再次导致那种状态,所以说“从‘有’中没有出离”,但并非完全没有出离的可能。因为此人缘于某种因缘而陷入那种见解,不能说他在某个时候缘于与此相反的因缘,就不可能从中抬头。不善法本来就是无力、脆弱的,不像善法一样有大力量。否则,邪性决定也会像正性决定一样成为究竟的,但邪性决定并非究竟的。因此《戏论破除》(Papañcasūdanī)中说: ‘‘Kiṃ panesa ekasmiṃyeva attabhāve niyato hoti, udāhu aññasmimpīti? Ekasmiṃyeva niyato, āsevanavasena bhavantarepi taṃ diṭṭhiṃ roceti evā’’ti – “那么,此人仅在这一生中是决定的,还是在其他生也是如此呢?仅在这一生中是决定的,但由于串习的缘故,在来世也同样会喜爱那种见解。” Vuttaṃ. Tatoyeva ca sumaṅgalavilāsiniyampi (dī. ni. aṭṭha. 1.170-172) vuttaṃ – 已说。因此,在《善悦》(Sumaṅgalavilāsinī)中也说: ‘‘Ye vā pana tesaṃ laddhiṃ gahetvā rattiṭṭhāne divāṭṭhāne nisinnā sajjhāyanti vīmaṃsanti, tesaṃ ‘karoto na karīyati pāpaṃ, natthi hetu, natthi paccayo, mato ucchijjatī’ti tasmiṃ ārammaṇe micchāsati santiṭṭhati, cittaṃ ekaggaṃ hoti, javanāni javanti. Paṭhamajavane satekicchā honti, tathā dutiyādīsu. Sattame buddhānampi atekicchā anivattino ariṭṭhakaṇṭakasadisā, tattha koci ekaṃ dassanaṃ okkamati, koci dve, koci tīṇipi, ekasmiṃ okkantepi dvīsu tīsu okkantesupi niyatamicchādiṭṭhikova hoti. Patto saggamaggāvaraṇañceva mokkhamaggāvaraṇañca, abhabbo tassattabhāvassa anantaraṃ saggampi gantuṃ, pageva mokkhaṃ, vaṭṭakhāṇu nāmesa satto pathavigopako, yebhuyyena evarūpassa bhavato vuṭṭhānaṃ natthī’’ti. “又或者,有些人执持他们的学说,日夜坐着诵读、审察,对于他们,在‘作者不造恶,无因,无缘,死后断灭’这样的所缘上,邪念安住,心一境性,速行奔行。第一个速行是可治的,第二等也是如此。到了第七个速行,即使对诸佛而言也是不可治、不可逆转的,如同阿里吒刺(ariṭṭhakaṇṭaka)。在那里,有人陷入一种见解,有人两种,有人三种;即使只陷入一种、两种或三种,也成为决定邪见者。他已达到天道之障与解脱道之障,在此生之后不堪能去往天界,更不用说解脱了。这种众生名为‘轮回之桩’、‘覆地者’,通常,这样的人无法从‘有’中出离。” Piṭṭhicakkavāḷeti jhāyamānacakkavāḷassa parato ekasmiṃ okāse. Yaṃ jhāyamānānaṃ ajjhāyamānānañca cakkavāḷānamantaraṃ, yattha lokantarikanirayasamaññā, tādise ekasmiṃ okāse. Paccatiyevāti cakkavāḷe jhāyamāne ajjhāyamānepi attano kammabalena paccatiyeva. “在轮围山背后(Piṭṭhicakkavāḷe)”是指在燃烧的轮围山之外的某个地方。即在燃烧的与不燃烧的轮围山之间,有名为“世间地狱(lokantarikaniraya)”之处,就在那样的某个地方。“必定被烧煮(Paccati eva)”是指,无论轮围山是在燃烧还是不燃烧,(受报者)都必定因自己的业力而被烧煮。 311. Catutthe ‘‘mā khalī’’ti vacanaṃ upādāya evaṃladdhanāmoti taṃ kira sakaddamāya bhūmiyā telaghaṭaṃ gahetvā gacchantaṃ, ‘‘tāta, mā khalī’’ti sāmiko āha. So pamādena khalitvā patitvā sāmikassa bhayena palāyituṃ āraddho. Sāmiko upadhāvitvā sāṭakakaṇṇe aggahesi. So sāṭakaṃ chaḍḍetvā acelako hutvā palāto paṇṇena vā tiṇena vā paṭicchādetumpi ajānanto jātarūpeneva ekaṃ gāmaṃ [Pg.229] pāvisi. Manussā taṃ disvā ‘‘ayaṃ samaṇo arahā appiccho, natthi iminā sadiso’’ti pūvabhattādīni gahetvā upasaṅkamitvā ‘‘mayhaṃ sāṭakaṃ anivatthabhāvena idaṃ uppanna’’nti tato paṭṭhāya sāṭakaṃ labhitvāpi na nivāsesi, tadeva ca pabbajjaṃ aggahesi. Tassa santike aññepi aññepīti pañcasatā manussā pabbajiṃsu. Taṃ sandhāyetaṃ vuttaṃ – ‘‘mā khalīti vacanaṃ upādāya evaṃladdhanāmo titthakaro’’ti. 311. 第四种,“勿滑(mā khalī)”:他是因这句话而得名的。据说他拿着油罐走在泥泞的地上,主人说:“孩子,不要滑倒。”他因放逸而滑倒,出于对主人的恐惧而开始逃跑。主人追上去抓住了他的衣角。他丢下衣服,赤身逃跑,不知道用树叶或草来遮盖,就这样以天生之形进入了一个村庄。人们看见他,认为“这位沙门是阿罗汉,少欲,无人能及”,就拿着糕饼、米饭等上前供养。他心想:“我是因为不穿衣服才得到这些的”,从此即使得到衣服也不穿,并接受了那样的出家方式。在他那里,一个接一个地,有五百人出家了。针对此事而说:“因‘勿滑’这句话而得名的外道师(titthakaro)”。 Samāgataṭṭhāneti dvinnaṃ nadīnaṃ udakappavāhassa sannipātaṭṭhāne. Dvinnaṃ udakānanti dvinnaṃ udakappavāhānaṃ. Yathāvuttaṭṭhāne macchaggahaṇatthaṃ khipitabbato khippaṃ, kuminaṃ, tadeva idha khippanti vuttaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘kumina’’nti. Ucchūhīti udakaucchūhi. Tucchapuriso ariyadhammābhāvato. Jhānamattampi hi tassa nattheva, kuto ariyamaggo. Manussakhippaṃ maññeti manussā patitvā byasanappattiatthaṃ oṭṭitaṃ kuminaṃ viya. Tenāha – ‘‘mahājanassā’’tiādi. “在交会处(Samāgataṭṭhāne)”是指两条河的水流汇合的地方。“两水(Dvinnaṃ udakānaṃ)”是指两条水流。在如前所述的地方,为了捕鱼而应投掷的,是“khippaṃ”,即鱼梁(kuminaṃ)。那在这里就被称为“khippaṃ”。因此说“鱼梁(kuminaṃ)”。“以蔗(Ucchūhi)”是指以水蔗。“空洞之人(Tucchapuriso)”是因为没有圣法。他连禅定都没有,更何况圣道。他认为那是“人类的陷阱(Manussakhippaṃ)”,就像为了让人类堕入并遭遇不幸而设置的鱼梁一样。因此说“大众的”等等。 312. Pañcamādīsu bāhirakasāsananti avisesena vuttaṃ – tassa sabbassapi aniyyānikattā satthupaṭiññassapi asabbaññubhāvato. Tenāha – ‘‘tattha hī’’tiādi. Gaṇoti sāvakagaṇo. Tathābhāvāyāti ācariyena vuttākāratāya samaṅgibhāvatthaṃ. Jaṅghasatanti bahū aneke satte. Samakameva akusalaṃ pāpuṇātīti tesaṃ sabbesaṃ ekajjhaṃ samādapanepi tesaṃ akusalena samakameva akusalaṃ pāpuṇāti ekajjhaṃ bahūnaṃ samādapanepi tathā ussahanassa balavabhāvato. Visuṃ visuṃ samādapane vattabbameva natthi. Yathā hi dhammacariyāyaṃ samakamevāti vattabbā kalyāṇamittatā, evaṃ adhammacariyāyaṃ akalyāṇamittatāti. 312. 在第五等中,“外道教法(bāhirakasāsanaṃ)”是无差别地说的,因为其全部都没有出离性,且自称导师者也不是一切知者。因此说“在此中”等等。“众(Gaṇo)”是指弟子众。“为如是性(Tathābhāvāya)”是为了具备老师所说的那种状态。“百行(Jaṅghasataṃ)”指许多、众多的众生。“同样地获得不善”是指,即使同时劝导所有那些人,(劝导者)也因他们的不善而同样地获得不善。即使同时劝导许多人也是如此,因为努力的力量很强。在分别劝导时,就更不用说了。因为正如在法行中,善友关系可说是“同样地(得善果)”,同样地,在非法行中,恶友关系也是如此。 313. Suṭṭhu akkhāteti ekantato niyyānikabhāvena akkhāte. Satthā ca sabbaññū hotīti asabbaññuno niyyānikabhāvena kathetuṃ asakkuṇeyyattā. Dhammo ca svākkhāto sammāsambuddhappaveditattā. Gaṇo ca suppaṭipanno satthārā suvinītattā. Samādapako hītiādi suppaṭipattiyā nidassanaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. 313. “善说(Suṭṭhu akkhāte)”是指被一向作为出离而宣说。导师是一切知者,因为非一切知者不能宣说为出离之法。法是善说的(svākkhāto),因为是正等觉者所宣说。僧团是善行道的(suppaṭipanno),因为被导师很好地调伏。“劝导者”等,应被看作是善行道的例子。 314. Pamāṇaṃ jānitabbanti ‘‘ayaṃ ettakena yāpeti, imassa ettakaṃ dātuṃ yutta’’nti evaṃ pamāṇaṃ jānitabbaṃ. Atireke…pe… nibbānasampatti vā natthi durakkhātattā dhammassa. Tassāti paṭiggāhakassa. Appicchapaṭipadā nāma natthi durakkhāte dhammavinayeti adhippāyo. 314. “应知量(Pamāṇaṃ jānitabbaṃ)”是说,应这样知量:“此人靠这么多维生,适合给他这么多。”过量……乃至……也没有涅槃成就,因为法被恶说。“彼(Tassa)”是指接受者。“在被恶说的法与律中,没有所谓的少欲行”,此是意趣。 315. Dāyakassa [Pg.230] vaso nāma uḷāruḷāratābhedo ajjhāsayo. Deyyadhammassa pana thokabahutāva deyyadhammassa vaso nāma. Attano thāmoti yāpanappamāṇaṃ. Yadi hītiādi ‘‘katha’’ntiādinā saṅkhepato vuttassa atthassa vivaraṇaṃ. Anuppannassāti anuppanno assa puggalassa. Cakkhubhūto hotīti mahājanassa cakkhu viya hoti. Sāsanaṃ ciraṭṭhititaṃ karotīti anuppannalābhuppādanena mahājanassa pasāduppādanena ca ciraṭṭhitikaṃ karoti. 315. 所谓“施主的自在(Dāyakassa vaso)”是指广大差别的意乐。而所谓“施物的自在”就是施物的多寡。“自己的力量(Attano thāmo)”是指维生的量。“如果”等,是对以“如何”等简略所说之义的解释。“对未生起者(Anuppannassa)”是指对此人未生起的(利养)。“成为眼目(Cakkhubhūto hoti)”是指他像大众的眼睛一样。“使教法长久住立”是指通过令未生起的利养生起、令大众生起净信,而使教法长久住立。 Kuṭumbariyavihāreti kuṭumbariyagāmasannissitavihāre. Bhuñjanatthāyāti tasmiṃyeva gehe nisīditvā bhuñjanatthāya. Gahetvā gamanatthāyāti gehato bahi gahetvā gamanatthāya. Dhurabhattānīti niccabhattāni. Cūḷupaṭṭhākanti veyyāvaccakaraṃ. Vīmaṃsitvāti yathā uddissa kataṃ na hoti, evaṃ vīmaṃsitvā. Mahājano appiccho bhavituṃ maññatīti mahājano sayaṃ appiccho bhavituṃ maññati diṭṭhānugatiṃ āpajjanena. Mahājanassāti bahujanassa. Avattharitvāti vitthārikaṃ katvā. Kuṭumbariyavihāre(家族村寺)是指靠近家族村的寺院。Bhuñjanatthāya(为食)是指就在那屋里坐下而食。Gahetvā gamanatthāya(为取走)是指从屋里拿了带走。Dhurabhattāni(常食)是指固定的日常食物。Cūḷupaṭṭhākaṃ(小侍者)是指仆役。Vīmaṃsitvā(考察后)是指考察到(此食物)并非是特别为(自己)所作。Mahājano appiccho bhavituṃ maññati(大众认为会变得少欲)是指大众因模仿所见而自认为会变得少欲。Mahājanassa(大众的)是指多数人的。Avattharitvā(展开后)是指使其广布。 316. Pañcātapatappanaṃ catūsu passesu aggisantāpassa upari sūriyasantāpassa ca tappanaṃ, tañca kho gimhakāle. Chinnappapātapabbatasikharato patanaṃ maruppapātapatanaṃ. Pubbaṇhādīsu ādiccābhimukhāvaṭṭanaṃ ādiccānuparivattanaṃ. 316. 五热苦行(pañcātapatappana):四面以火炙烤,上方以日曝晒,且是在夏季。从断崖山顶坠落,从旱地悬崖坠落。上午等时段面向太阳转动,围绕太阳转动。 317. Ayampīti svākkhāte dhammavinaye kusītopi. Sāmaññanti tapacaraṇaṃ. Dupparāmaṭṭhanti micchācaritaṃ saṃkiliṭṭhaṃ. Nirayāyupakaḍḍhatīti nirayadukkhāya naṃ kaḍḍhati. 317. 此亦如是,即使在善说之法与律中懈怠者。沙门性(sāmañña)即苦行。难以把握(dupparāmaṭṭha)即邪行染污。牵引至地狱,即将其牵引至地狱之苦。 318. Vuttappakāreti pañcātapatappanādike vuttappakāre. 318. Vuttappakāre(如前所述的方式)是指如前文所述的五热苦行等。 319. Evanti vuttappakārāya cittappasādavhayasuppaṭipattiyā. Tena samaṇadhammakaraṇasukhañca saṅgaṇhāti. 319. Evaṃ(如是)是指以如前所述、名为“心净”的善行道(suppaṭipatti)。因此亦摄受修习沙门法之乐。 320. Navakanipāteti imasmiṃyeva aṅguttaranikāye vakkhamānaṃ navakanipātaṃ sandhāyāha. Nava puggalāti sattakkhattuparamakolaṃkolādayo nava puggalā. Sabbatthāti imasmiṃ sutte vuttāvasiṭṭhesu sabbesu suttesu. 320. “于九集中”(Navakanipāte)是指就此《增支部》(Aṅguttaranikāya)中将要宣说的九集而说。“九种人”(Nava puggalā)是指极七返有者(sattakkhattuparama)、家家者(kolaṃkola)等九种人。“于一切处”(Sabbattha)是指在此经中所说的其余一切经中。 Tatiyavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 第三品释义终。 16. Ekadhammapāḷi 16. 一法经 (16) 4. Ekadhammapāḷi-catutthavaggavaṇṇanā (16)一法经第四品释义 322. Catutthassa [Pg.231] paṭhame saññāṇabhūtāti upalakkhaṇabhūtā. Pañcadasayojanāvaṭṭakkhandhāti pañcadasayojanakkhandhaparikkhepā. Yathā cāti ca-saddena kadambarukkhādīnaṃ kappaṭṭhāyibhāvaṃ viya yojanasatubbedhādibhāvaṃ samuccinoti, na pana jambuyā jambudīpassa viya tehi aparagoyānādīnaṃ saññāṇabhāvaṃ. Rāmaṇeyyakanti ramaṇīyabhāvaṃ. Sesapadesūti vanarāmaṇeyyakādipadesu. Uggataṃ kūlaṃ ussitabhāvo etassāti ukkūlaṃ, vigataṃ apagataṃ kūlaṃ etassāti vikūlanti āha – ‘‘unnataṭṭhānaṃ ninnaṭṭhāna’’nti ca. Nandiyāvaṭṭamacchapiṭṭhenevāti kujjakakulisakamacchasaṅghātapiṭṭheneva. 322. 第四(品)的初(经),saññāṇabhūtā(作为标记)是指作为特征。Pañcadasayojanāvaṭṭakkhandhā(十五由旬的圆周)是指十五由旬的周界。Yathā ca(如同……与)是指以“与”字,将咖丹巴(kadamba)树等能住立一劫的状态,与(其)百由旬的高度等状态连接起来,但并非像阎浮树(jambu)之于瞻部洲(Jambudīpa)那样,以它们作为西牛货洲(Aparagoyāna)等的标记。Rāmaṇeyyakaṃ(可爱)是指可爱的状态。Sesapadesu(于其余部分)是指于森林可爱处等地方。Ukkūlaṃ(高岸)是指其岸高耸的状态,vikūlaṃ(无岸)是指其岸消失,故说“高地与低地”。Nandiyāvaṭṭamacchapiṭṭheneva(如同南迪亚瓦塔鱼的背)是指如同驼背的库利萨鱼群的背。 323. Dutiyādīsu cattāro apāyā aññatra manussehīti adhippetā, na devā aññatra manussehīti hīnāya jātiyā adhippetattā. Upādāyupādāyāpi majjhimadeso labbhati, yattha gati bhikkhūnaṃ bhikkhunīnaṃ upāsakānaṃ upāsikānaṃ aññesampi kammavādikiriyavādiviññujātikānaṃ, yo patirūpadesoti vuccati. Tenāha – ‘‘sakalopi hī’’tiādi. 323. 在第二(经)等中,“除人趣外”是意指四恶趣,而非意指天神,因为这是意指低劣的生处。凭借各种因缘,亦可生于中土(Majjhimadesa),那是比丘、比丘尼、优婆塞、优婆夷以及其他业论者、作论者、智者所去之处,被称为适宜之地(patirūpadesa)。因此说:“即使全部……”等。 324. Eḷāti doso. Tenāha – ‘‘niddosamukhāti attho’’ti. 324. Eḷā(过失)是指dosa(过错)。因此说:“niddosamukhā(面容无过)是此义”。 326. Tathāgatassa guṇe jānitvā cakkhunāpi dassanaṃ dassanameva, ajānitvā pana dassanaṃ tiracchānagatānampi hotiyevāti āha – ‘‘ye tathāgatassa guṇe jānitvā’’tiādi. 326. 若知如来之功德而以眼见,此方为真见;若不知而见,则与畜生之见无异。故说:“那些知道如来功德的人……”等等。 327. Pakāsetvā kathitanti saccāni pakāsetvā kathitaṃ. 327. 如实显扬并宣说,即为显扬并宣说诸谛。 328. Sutānaṃ dhammānaṃ asammoso dhāraṇanti āha – ‘‘dhārentīti na pammussantī’’ti. 328. 对于所听闻之法不忘失,称为持法。故说:“忆持即不忘失”。 329. Atthānatthaṃ upaparikkhantīti ‘‘ayaṃ imissā pāḷiyā attho, ayaṃ na attho’’ti atthānatthaṃ upaparikkhanti. Anatthaparihārena hi atthaggahaṇaṃ yathā adhammaparivajjanena dhammappaṭipatti. 329. 考察意义与非意义,即“此为这段经文之义,此非义”般考察意义与非意义。因为唯有舍弃无义,方能把握有义,犹如远离非法,方能实践正法。 330. Anulomapaṭipadanti nibbānassa anulomikaṃ paṭipadaṃ. 330. 随顺行道(anulomapaṭipadā)即趣向涅槃之随顺之道。 331. Saṃvegajanakesu [Pg.232] kāraṇesūti saṃvegajanakesu jātiādīsu kāraṇesu. Saṃvejanīyesu ṭhānesu sahottappañāṇaṃ saṃvego. 331. 于生起悚惧之因缘中,即于生、老、死等生起悚惧之因缘中。于令人悚惧之处,伴随惭愧(ottappa)之智的便是悚惧(saṃvega)。 332. Upāyenāti yena upāyena vaṭṭūpacchedo, tena upāyena. Padhānavīriyaṃ karontīti sammappadhānasaṅkhātaṃ vīriyaṃ karonti uppādenti. 332. 以方便(upāya)即指能断绝轮回之方法。努力精进(padhānavīriya)即生起正勤(sammappadhāna)之精进。 333. Vavassajīyanti vissajjīyanti ettha saṅkhārāti vavassaggo, asaṅkhatā dhātūti āha – ‘‘vavassaggo vuccati nibbāna’’nti. 333. “诸行于此被舍弃、被遣除”,故为vavassaggo(舍离)。此即无为界,故说:“vavassaggo(舍离)被称为涅槃”。 334. Uttamannānanti uttamānaṃ pañcannaṃ bhojanānaṃ. Uttamarasānanti uttamānaṃ rasānaṃ. Uñchācārenāti uñchācariyāya kassaci apariggahabhūtassa kiñci ayācitvā gahaṇaṃ uñchācāro. Ettha cātiādinā annādīnaṃ aggabhāvo nāma manāpaparamo icchitakkhaṇalābho, na tesaṃ lābhitāmattanti dasseti. Paṭilabhantīti denti paṇītabhāvena. Bhattassa ekapātīti ekapātipūraṃ bhattaṃ. Idaṃ kiṃ nāmāti ‘‘idaṃ annaggarasaggaṃ nāma hoti, na hotī’’ti pucchati. Uñchena kapālābhatenāti missakabhattena. Yāpenteti yāpanasīsena yāpanahetuṃ bhattaṃ vadati. Upādāya aggarasaṃ nāmāti taṃ taṃ upādāyupādāya annaggarasaggaṃ daṭṭhabbanti dasseti. Cakkavattiāhārato hi cātumahārājikānaṃ āhāro aggoti evaṃ yāva paranimmitavasavattidevā netabbaṃ. 334. Uttamannānaṃ(最上食)是指五种最上等的食物。Uttamarasānaṃ(最上味)是指最上等的滋味。Uñchācārena(以拾遗食)是指不积蓄任何财物者,不乞求而拾取食物,此为拾遗行。Ettha ca(于此,与……)等词是说,食物等的“最上”是指最合心意、在欲求的刹那即能获得,而不仅是获得它们而已。Paṭilabhanti(他们获得)是指(他人)以精美的方式给予。Bhattassa ekapātī(一钵食)是指一满钵的食物。Idaṃ kiṃ nāma(这是什么)是问:‘这可称为最上食、最上味吗?’ Uñchena kapālābhatena(以乞食钵中所获)是指杂食。Yāpenti(他们维持)是指为了维持生命而说此食物。Upādāya aggarasaṃ nāma(名为依缘而有的最上味)是说,应当观察到最上食、最上味是依此依彼而有。例如,相较于转轮王(Cakkavatti)的食物,四大天王(Cātumahārājika)的食物为最上,应如是乃至推至他化自在天(Paranimmitavasavattideva)。 335. Attharaso nāma cattāri sāmaññaphalāni ‘‘ariyamaggānaṃ phalabhūto raso’’ti katvā. Dhammaraso nāma cattāro maggā ‘‘sāmaññaphalassa hetubhūto raso’’ti katvā vimuttiraso nāma amataṃ nibbānaṃ ‘‘sabbasaṅkhārasamatho’’ti katvā. 335. 所谓“义味”(attharaso),即四沙门果,因其是“圣道之果味”。所谓“法味”(dhammaraso),即四圣道,因其是“沙门果之因味”。所谓“解脱味”(vimuttiraso),即不死涅槃,因其是“一切行之止息”。 Catutthavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 第四品释义终。 Jambudīpapeyyālo niṭṭhito. 瞻部洲篇终。 17. Pasādakaradhammavaggavaṇṇanā 17. 令净信法品释义 366. Addhamidanti sandhivasena pāḷiyaṃ rassaṃ katvā vuttaṃ, ma-kāro padasandhikaroti āha – ‘‘addhā ida’’nti. Ekaṃso esāti ekaṃso hetu [Pg.233] esa lābhānaṃ. Pāpakaṃ nāmāti appakampi pāpaṃ nāma byattaṃ ekaṃsena na karoti. Tathassāti tathā sammāpaṭipajjamānassa assa. Āraññikattaṃ…pe… tecīvarikattanti imesaṃ dhutadhammānaṃ gahaṇeneva itaresampi taṃsabhāgānaṃ gahitabhāvo daṭṭhabbo. Thāvarappattabhāvoti sāsane thirabhāvappatti therabhāvo. Ākappassa sampattīti ‘‘añño me ākappo karaṇīyo’’ti evaṃ vuttassa ākappassa sampatti. Kolaputtīti kolaputtiyanti āha – ‘‘kulaputtabhāvo’’ti. Sampannarūpatāti upadhisampadā. Vacanakiriyāyāti vacanappayogassa madhurabhāvo mañjussaratā. Tenassa lābho uppajjatīti idaṃ na lābhuppādanūpāyadassanaparaṃ, atha kho evaṃ sammāpaṭipajjamānassa anicchantasseva lābho uppajjatīti lābhassa abyabhicārahetudassanaparaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. Yathāha – 366. Addhamidaṃ(确实如此)是由于连音(sandhi)的缘故,在巴利文中缩短而说,m音起到了连接词语的作用,即addhā idaṃ。Ekaṃso esa(此为确定)是指此为获得利养的确定原因。Pāpakaṃ nāma(所谓恶)是指有智慧者(byatta)即使微小的恶也绝不会去做。Tathassa(如是之人)是指如是正确修行之人。Āraññikattaṃ…pe… tecīvarikattaṃ(阿兰若行……乃至……三衣行)是指通过受持这些头陀行(dhutadhamma),当知其他同类的行法也已被受持。Thāvarappattabhāvo(已达稳固)是指在教法(sāsana)中达到稳固的状态,即长老的状态。Ākappassa sampatti(威仪圆满)是指对于所说“我应行持另一威仪”者,其威仪的圆满。Kolaputtī(良家子)是指良家子的状态(kulaputtabhāvo)。Sampannarūpatā(形色圆满)是指资质圆满(upadhisampadā)。Vacanakiriyā(言语行为)是指言语运用的甜美,即悦耳之声。Tenassa lābho uppajjati(彼得利养)并非旨在开示获得利养的方法,而应理解为,旨在开示利养不空耗之因:如是正确修行者,即使不希求,利养也会生起。正如所说: ‘‘Ākaṅkheyya ce, bhikkhave, bhikkhu lābhī assaṃ cīvarapiṇḍapātasenāsanagilānappaccayabhesajjaparikkhārānanti, sīlesvevassa paripūrakārī’’ti (ma. ni. 1.65). “诸比丘,若比丘希望:‘愿我获得衣、食、卧具、病缘医药资具’,则应圆满于戒。”(ma. ni. 1.65)。 Pasādakaradhammavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 净信法品释义终。 18. Aparaaccharāsaṅghātavaggavaṇṇanā 18. 后弹指顷品释义 382. Idampi suttanti ettha pi-saddo heṭṭhā vuttacūḷaccharāsaṅghātasuttaṃ sampiṇḍeti. Cūḷaccharāsaṅghātasutte appanaṃ appattāya mettāya tāvamahanto vipāko dassito, kimaṅgaṃ pana imissā appanāppattāya mettāyāti dassetuṃ – ‘‘appanāppattāya hī’’tiādimāha. Vipākakathāyeva natthīti vipāke kathāyeva natthi, ayameva vā pāṭho. Gaṇanānupubbatāti gaṇanānupubbatāya. Paṭhamaṃ uppannantipi paṭhamaṃ, paṭhamaṃ samāpajjatīti idaṃ pana na ekantalakkhaṇaṃ. Ciṇṇavasībhāvo hi aṭṭhasamāpattilābhī ādito paṭṭhāya matthakaṃ pāpentopi samāpajjituṃ sakkoti, matthakato paṭṭhāya ādiṃ pāpentopi, antarantarā okkantopi samāpajjituṃ sakkoti eva. Pubbuppattiyaṭṭhena pana paṭhamaṃ nāma hoti. Vibhaṅgeti jhānavibhaṅge. Vipassanaṃ kayiramānaṃ lakkhaṇūpanijjhānakiccaṃ maggena sijjhati taggatasammohaviddhaṃsanato[Pg.234]. Apica vipassanāya lakkhaṇūpanijjhānaṃ maggena uppannena sijjhati itarathā parivattanato, tasmā maggo lakkhaṇūpanijjhānaṃ, na aniccādilakkhaṇānaṃ ārammaṇakaraṇato. Yathā phalaṃ nibbānassa asaṅkhatalakkhaṇaṃ ārammaṇakaraṇavasena upanijjhāyati, evaṃ maggopi. Evampissa lakkhaṇūpanijjhānataṃ veditabbaṃ. Vattabbameva natthi arittajjhānatāya. Sesaṃ visesaṃ, arittajjhānā evāti attho. 382. 此经中“亦”字,总括前文所说的《小弹指顷经》。在《小弹指顷经》中,尚未证得安止(appanā)的慈心(mettā),其果报已显示得如此广大,何况此已证得安止的慈心呢?为显示此义,故说:“因为已证得安止”等。“实则没有果报的说法”,即于果报中实无说法,或此即是另一种读法。“数的次第”,即“以数的次第”。最初生起者即最初,最初入定者即最初,但这并非绝对的特征。因为熟练自在、得八定者,可以从头至尾入定,亦可从尾至头,或于中间随意入定。然依先生起之义,故称最初。《无碍解道》(Vibhaṅga)是在《禅那无碍解》(Jhānavibhaṅga)中所说。修习观(vipassanā)时,观照诸法特相(lakkhaṇūpanijjhāna)的作用是由道(magga)来成就的,因道能破除与此相关的迷惑。再者,观的特相观照是通过已生起的道来成就的,否则就会转变。因此,道即是特相观照,而非因其以无常等特相为所缘。如同果(phala)通过以涅槃(nibbāna)的无为相(asaṅkhatalakkhaṇa)为所缘来观照,道亦如是。应如是知其特相观照性。关于禅那(jhāna)的不空缺性(arittajjhānatā),则无庸赘言。其余是特别的,其义是彼等确实是不空缺的禅那。 386-387. Hitapharaṇanti sattesu hitānurūpaṃ jhānassa pharitvā pavattanaṃ. Cetopaṭipakkhato vimuccati etāyāti cetovimutti, appanāppattā mettā. Tenāha – ‘‘idhā’’tiādi. Eseva nayoti iminā karuṇādīnampi appanāppattataṃ atidisati. Vaṭṭaṃ honti kammavaṭṭabhāvato. Vaṭṭapādā hontīti vipākavaṭṭassa kāraṇaṃ honti. 386-387. “利益遍满”(Hitapharaṇa)是指禅那(jhāna)随顺众生的利益而周遍生起。“心解脱”(cetovimutti)是指由此从心的对立法中解脱,即是证得安止(appanā)的慈心(mettā)。因此说“在此”等语。“同样的道理”(Eseva naya)是指由此也类推悲(karuṇā)等亦能证得安止的境界。“轮回”(vaṭṭa)是指它们是业轮回(kammavaṭṭa)的状态。“轮回之足”(vaṭṭapāda)是指它们成为异熟轮回(vipākavaṭṭa)的原因。 390. Ajjhattaparikammavasenāti attano kesādīsu parikammakaraṇavasena. Aṭṭhārasavidheti aṭṭhārasappabhede. Kāyeti rūpakāye. Rūpakāyo hi idha aṅgapaccaṅgānaṃ kesādīnañca dhammānaṃ samūhaṭṭhena hatthikāyarathakāyādayo viya kāyoti adhippeto. Samūhavisayatāya cassa kāyasaddassa samudāyūpādanatāya ca asubhākārassa ‘‘kāye’’ti ekavacanaṃ. Tathā ārammaṇādivibhāgena anekabhedabhinnampi cittaṃ cittabhāvasāmaññena ekajjhaṃ gahetvā ‘‘citte’’ti ekavacanaṃ kataṃ. Kāyānupassīti imassa atthaṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘tameva kāyaṃ paññāya anupassanto’’ti āha. Tameva kāyanti ca avadhāraṇena vedanādianupassanaṃ nivatteti. Tena ca puna kāyaggahaṇassa payojanaṃ sūcitanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. ‘‘Kāye’’ti hi vatvāpi puna ‘‘kāyānupassī’’ti dutiyaṃ kāyaggahaṇaṃ asammissato vavatthānaghanavinibbhogādidassanatthaṃ kataṃ. Tena vedanādayopi ettha sitā, ettha paṭibaddhāti kāyavedanādianupassanappasaṅgepi āpanne na kāye vedanānupassī cittānupassī dhammānupassī vā. Atha kho kāyānupassīyevāti kāyasaṅkhātavatthusmiṃ kāyānupassanākārasseva dassanena asammissato vavatthānaṃ dassitaṃ hoti. Tathā na kāye aṅgapaccaṅgavinimuttaekadhammānupassī, nāpi kesalomādivinimuttaitthipurisānupassī. Yopi cettha kesalomādiko bhūtupādāyasamūhasaṅkhāto kāyo, katthapi na bhūtupādāyavinimuttaekadhammānupassī, atha kho rathasambhārānupassako viya aṅgapaccaṅgasamūhānupassī[Pg.235], nāgarāvayavānupassako viya kesalomādisamūhānupassī, kadalikkhandhapattavaṭṭivinibbhujjako rittamuṭṭhiviniveṭhako viya ca bhūtupādāyasamūhānupassīyevāti nānappakārato samūhavaseneva kāyasaṅkhātassa vatthuno dassanena ghanavinibbhogo dassito hoti. Na hettha yathāvuttasamūhavinimutto kāyo vā itthī vā puriso vā añño vā koci dhammo dissati, yathāvuttadhammasamūhamatteyeva pana tathā tathā sattā micchābhinivesaṃ karonti. 390. “于内作业”(Ajjhattaparikamma)之义,是指对自己头发等所作的准备作业。“十八种”即十八类。“于身”指于色身。此处的色身,是以肢体、毛发等诸法的集合体之义,如同象身、车身等,而被意指为“身”。由于此观以集合为所缘,且“身”一词指称集合,并显示不净相,故用单数“身”。同样,心虽以所缘等区分而有多种,但以心的共性统摄为一,故“于心”也用单数。为说明“身随观者”(kāyānupassī)之义,故说:“即以智慧随观此身。”用“唯此身”来限定,则排除了受等随观。应当明白,此举亦显示了再次使用“身”字的用意。虽已说“于身”(kāye),又说“身随观者”(kāyānupassī),这第二次使用“身”字,是为了显示不混杂、确定、剖析密集等义。因此,即使受等亦依止于此、系缚于此,在涉及身、受、心、法随观的场合,也不是于身作受随观、心随观或法随观,而只是身随观者。即在名为身的事物上,仅以身随观的方式来观察,由此显示了不混杂的确定性。同样,不是于身作脱离肢体的单一法随观,也不是作脱离毛发的男女随观。此处由四大种及所造色构成的毛发等集合之身,于任何处皆非作脱离四大种及所造色的单一法随观,而是如观察车具者观察肢体集合,如观察城郭构成者观察毛发集合,如剖析芭蕉树干、剥开叶鞘者,如解开空拳者一般,仅是四大种及所造色集合的随观者。如是,通过多种方式,仅依集合观察名为“身”的事物,由此显示了对密集的剖析。此处实不可见离于前述集合的身、女、男或任何其他法,然而众生却仅于前述诸法之集合,生起种种错误执取。 Aṭṭhārasavidhenāti aṭṭhārasavidhā. Satipaṭṭhānabhāvakassāti satipaṭṭhānabhāvaṃ bhāventassa. Tīsu bhavesu kilese ātapetīti ātāpo, vīriyassetaṃ nāmaṃ. Yadipi hi kilesānaṃ pahānaṃ ātāpananti, taṃ sammādiṭṭhiādīnampi attheva. Ātapasaddo viya pana ātāpasaddopi vīriyeva niruḷho. Atha vā paṭipakkhappahāne sampayuttadhammānaṃ abbhussahanavasena pavattamānassa vīriyassa sātisayaṃ tadātāpananti vīriyameva tathā vuccati, na aññadhammā, tasmā ātāpoti vīriyassa nāmaṃ, so assa atthīti ātāpī. Ayañca īkāro pasaṃsāya atisayassa vā dīpakoti ātāpiggahaṇena sammappadhānasamaṅgitaṃ dasseti. Tenevāha – ‘‘ātāpīti…pe… vīriyena vīriyavā’’ti. Sampajānoti sampajaññasaṅkhātena ñāṇena samannāgato. Tenāha – ‘‘aṭṭhārasavidhena…pe… sammā pajānanto’’ti. Ayaṃ panettha vacanattho – sammā samantato sāmañca pajānanto sampajāno, asammissato vavatthāne aññadhammānupassitābhāvena sammā aviparītaṃ sabbākārappajānena samantato uparūparivisesāvahabhāvena pavattiyā sammā pajānantoti attho. “十八种”即十八类。“修习念住者”,即修习念住之人。于三有中烧尽诸烦恼,故名“热诚”(ātāpo),此是精进之名。虽说断除烦恼即是“热”(ātāpana),此义于正见等法亦有,然“热诚”一词如“热”字,通常专指精进。或又,于断除对立法时,精进以策励相应诸法的方式而转起,其超胜之相即是“热”,故唯有精进被称为“热”,而非他法。是故“热诚”为精进之名,有此热诚者,名为“热诚者”(ātāpī)。此中长音“ī”表示赞叹或超胜,故取“热诚者”一词,显示其具足正精进。是故云:“热诚者……乃至……有精进,具精进。”“正知者”(sampajāno),即具足名为正知之慧。是故云:“以十八种……乃至……正知。”此中语意如下:正知者,即正确地(sammā)、周遍地(samantato)、亲自(sāmaṃ)了知。或义为:于不混杂之抉择中,因不随观他法而为“正”;因无颠倒而为“正”;因了知一切行相而“周遍”;因能引生更高超之殊胜而于转起中“正知”。 Kāyo ca idha lujjanappalujjanaṭṭhena lokoti adhippetoti āha – ‘‘tasmiṃyeva kāyasaṅkhāte loke’’ti. Pañcakāmaguṇikataṇhanti rūpādīsu pañcasu kāmaguṇesu pavattamānaṃ taṇhaṃ. Yasmā panettha abhijjhāgahaṇena kāmacchando, domanassaggahaṇena byāpādo saṅgahaṃ gacchati, tasmā nīvaraṇapariyāpannabalavadhammadvayadassanena nīvaraṇappahānaṃ vuttaṃ hotīti veditabbaṃ. Visesena cettha abhijjhāvinayena kāyasampattimūlakassa anurodhassa, domanassavinayena kāyavipattimūlakassa virodhassa, abhijjhāvinayena ca kāye abhiratiyā, domanassavinayena kāyabhāvanāya anabhiratiyā, abhijjhāvinayena kāye abhūtānaṃ [Pg.236] subhasukhabhāvādīnaṃ pakkhepassa, domanassavinayena kāye bhūtānaṃ asubhāsukhabhāvādīnaṃ apanayanassa ca pahānaṃ vuttaṃ. Tena yogāvacarassa yogānubhāvo yogasamatthatā ca dīpitā hoti. Yogānubhāvo hi esa, yadidaṃ anurodhavirodhavippamutto aratiratisaho abhūtapakkhepabhūtāpanayanavirahito ca hoti. Anurodhavirodhavippamutto cesa aratiratisaho abhūtaṃ apakkhipanto bhūtañca anapanento yogasamattho hotīti. Suddharūpasammasanameva kathitanti kevalaṃ kāyānupassanābhāvato vuttaṃ. 身体在此处被称为“世间”,意指其具有毁坏和破碎的性质,故说“在此被称为色身的世间里”。五欲的渴爱,是指对色等五种感官对象所生起的渴爱。因为在此处,通过“贪欲”一词包含了欲贪,通过“忧”一词包含了瞋恚,因此应当明白这是以显示属于五盖的两种强力之法来说明断除五盖。特别是在这里:通过调伏贪欲来断除以身体的成就为根源的贪着,通过调伏忧来断除以身体的缺陷为根源的抗拒;通过调伏贪欲来断除对身体的喜爱,通过调伏忧来断除对身体的不喜;通过调伏贪欲来断除对身体本无的净、乐等相的妄加,通过调伏忧来断除对身体本有的不净、苦等相的去除。由此显示了修行者的修行威力(yogānubhāvo)和修行能力(yogasamatthatā)。这种修行威力就是:摆脱贪着与抗拒,能忍受不乐与乐,远离对本无之物的妄加和对本有之物的去除。若能摆脱贪着与抗拒,能忍受不乐与乐,不妄加本无之物,不去除本有之物,就是具有修行能力。说纯粹思惟色法,是因为这仅仅是身随观念处的修习。 Sukhādibhedāsu vedanāsūti sukhadukkhaadukkhamasukhasāmisanirāmisabhedāsu vedanāsu. Tattha sukhayatīti sukhā, sampayuttadhamme kāyañca laddhassāde karotīti attho. Suṭṭhu vā khādati, khanati vā kāyikaṃ cetasikañca ābādhanti sukhā, sukaraṃ okāsadānaṃ etissāti vā sukhā. Dukkhayatīti dukkhā, sampayuttadhamme kāyañca pīḷeti vibādhatīti attho. Duṭṭhu vā khādati, khanati vā kāyikaṃ cetasikañca sātanti dukkhā, dukkaraṃ okāsadānaṃ etissāti vā dukkhā. Dukkhasukhappaṭikkhepena adukkhamasukhāti upekkhā vuttā. Vediyati ārammaṇarasaṃ anubhavatīti vedanā. Vediyamānoti anubhavamāno. Sukhaṃ vedanaṃ vediyāmīti pajānātīti kāyikaṃ vā cetasikaṃ vā sukhaṃ vedanaṃ vediyamāno ‘‘ahaṃ sukhaṃ vedanaṃ vediyāmī’’ti pajānātīti attho. Tattha kāmaṃ uttānaseyyakāpi dārakā thaññapivanādikāle sukhaṃ vedanaṃ vediyamānā ‘‘sukhaṃ vedanaṃ vediyāmā’’ti pajānanti, na panetaṃ evarūpaṃ pajānanaṃ sandhāya vuttaṃ. Evarūpañhi jānanaṃ sattupaladdhiṃ na jahati, attasaññaṃ na ugghāṭeti, kammaṭṭhānaṃ vā satipaṭṭhānabhāvanā vā na hoti. Imassa pana bhikkhuno jānanaṃ sattupaladdhiṃ jahati, attasaññaṃ ugghāṭeti, kammaṭṭhānañceva satipaṭṭhānabhāvanā ca hoti. Idañhi ‘‘ko vediyati, tassa vedanā, kiṃ kāraṇā vedanā’’ti evaṃ sampajānantassa vediyanaṃ sandhāya vuttaṃ. 于乐等不同之受,即于乐、苦、不苦不乐、有染、无染等不同之受。其中,能使人愉悦者为乐,意为令相应法与身体获得法味。或善于吞噬、挖掘身心之疾,故为乐;或易于为其提供机会,故为乐。能使人痛苦者为苦,意为逼迫、恼害相应法与身体。或不善于吞噬、挖掘身心之乐,故为苦;或难于为其提供机会,故为苦。通过排除苦乐而说不苦不乐,即是舍受。感受,即是体验所缘之味。感受者,即是体验者。当他感受乐受时,如实了知“我正在感受乐受”,意即当他感受身体上或心理上的乐受时,他如实了知“我正在感受乐受”。譬如,即使是仰卧的婴儿在吮吸母乳时,也能知道“我正在感受乐受”,但这并非此处所说的如实了知。因为这种了知不舍有情见,不破我见,亦非业处或念住修习。然而,这位比丘的了知能舍有情见,能破我见,既是业处,也是念住修习。这实际上是针对如此正知“谁在感受?此受属谁?受由何缘?”而感受者所说。 Tattha ko vediyatīti? Na koci satto vā puggalo vā vediyati. Kassa vedanāti? Na kassaci sattassa vā puggalassa vā vedanā. Kiṃ kāraṇā vedanāti? Vatthuārammaṇā ca panassa vedanāti. Tasmā esa evaṃ pajānāti ‘‘taṃ taṃ sukhādīnaṃ vatthubhūtaṃ rūpādiṃ ārammaṇaṃ katvā vedanāva [Pg.237] vediyati, taṃ pana vedanāpavattiṃ upādāya ‘ahaṃ vediyāmī’ti vohāramattaṃ hotī’’ti. Evaṃ ‘‘sukhādīnaṃ vatthubhūtaṃ rūpādiṃ ārammaṇaṃ katvā vedanāva vediyatī’’ti sallakkhento esa ‘‘sukhaṃ vedanaṃ vediyāmī’’ti pajānātīti veditabbo. 其中,“谁在感受”?并无任何众生或个人在感受。“此受属谁”?不属于任何众生或个人。“受由何缘”?此受乃依于事与所缘。因此,他如此了知:“以色等作为乐等之事的所缘,唯有受在感受,而依于受的生起,才有‘我感受’的世俗言说。”如此思惟“以色等作为乐等之事的所缘,唯有受在感受”者,当知他即是如实了知“我感受乐受”。 Atha vā sukhaṃ vedanaṃ vediyāmīti pajānātīti sukhavedanākkhaṇe dukkhāya vedanāya abhāvato sukhaṃ vedanaṃ vediyamāno ‘‘sukhaṃ vedanaṃyeva vediyāmī’’ti pajānāti. Tena yā pubbe bhūtapubbā dukkhā vedanā, tassā idāni abhāvato imissā ca sukhāya vedanāya ito paraṃ paṭhamaṃ abhāvato ‘‘vedanā nāma aniccā addhuvā vipariṇāmadhammā’’ti itiha tattha sampajāno hoti. Dukkhaṃ vedanaṃ vediyāmīti pajānātītiādīsupi eseva nayo. 或者,当他如实了知“我感受乐受”时,是在感受乐受的刹那,由于没有苦受,正在感受乐受的他如实了知“我只感受乐受”。由此,过去曾有的苦受现在已不存在,而此乐受此前亦不存在,此后亦将消失,因此他于此如实了知“所谓的受是无常的、不恒久的、是变易法”。对于“我感受苦受”等情况,道理也是一样。 Sāmisaṃ vā sukhantiādīsu yasmā kilesehi āmasitabbato āmisā nāma pañca kāmaguṇā. Ārammaṇakaraṇavasena saha āmisehīti sāmisā, tasmā sāmisā sukhā nāma pañcakāmaguṇāmisanissitā chasu dvāresu uppannā chagehassitā somanassavedanā. Sāmisā dukkhā nāma chagehassitā domanassavedanā. Sā ca chasu dvāresu ‘‘iṭṭhārammaṇaṃ nānubhavissāmi nānubhavāmī’’ti vitakkayato uppannā kāmaguṇanissitā domanassavedanā veditabbā. Nirāmisā sukhā nāma chanekkhammassitā somanassavedanā. Sā ca chasu dvāresu iṭṭhārammaṇe āpāthagate aniccādivasena vipassanaṃ paṭṭhapetvā ussukkāpetuṃ sakkontassa ‘‘ussakkitā me vipassanā’’ti somanassajātassa uppannā somanassavedanā daṭṭhabbā. 关于“有染乐”等:五种欲乐因能被烦恼所触,故名为“染”(āmisa)。以之为所缘,与染俱行,故为“有染”(sāmisa)。因此,有染乐是指依止五欲之染,于六门生起,依于六处的喜受。有染苦是指依于六处的忧受。此忧受应知是于六门中,因思惟“我将无法体验”或“我正在无法体验可爱所缘”而生起的、依止五欲的忧受。无染乐是指依于六种出离的喜受。此喜受应见为于六门中,当可爱所缘现前时,能以无常等方式建立观而精进者,因“我的观已策励”而生起喜悦的喜受。 Nirāmisā dukkhā nāma chanekkhammassitā domanassavedanā. Sā pana chasu dvāresu iṭṭhārammaṇe āpāthagate anuttaravimokkhasaṅkhātaariyaphaladhammesu pihaṃ paṭṭhapetvā tadadhigamāya aniccādivasena vipassanaṃ paṭṭhapetvā ussukkāpetuṃ asakkontassa ‘‘imampi pakkhaṃ imampi māsaṃ imampi saṃvaccharaṃ vipassanaṃ ussukkāpetvā ariyabhūmiṃ pāpuṇituṃ nāsakkhi’’nti anusocato uppannā domanassavedanā. 无染苦是指依于六种出离的忧受。此忧受是于六门中,当可爱所缘现前时,对被称为无上解脱的圣果法生起希求,为证得它而以无常等方式建立观,却无法精进,因而悲伤“即使精进修观了这半月、这整月、这一年,仍无法证得圣地”,由此生起的忧受。 Sāmisā adukkhamasukhā nāma chagehassitā upekkhāvedanā. Sā ca chasu dvāresu iṭṭhārammaṇe āpāthagate guḷapiṇḍake nilīnamakkhikā viya rūpādīni anuvattamānā tattheva laggā laggitā hutvā uppannā kāmaguṇanissitā [Pg.238] upekkhāvedanā. Nirāmisā adukkhamasukhā nāma chanekkhammassitā upekkhāvedanā. Sā pana chasu dvāresu iṭṭhādiārammaṇe āpāthagate iṭṭhe arajjantassa, aniṭṭhe adussantassa, asamapekkhanena amuyhantassa uppannā vipassanāñāṇasampayuttā upekkhāvedanā. Evaṃ vuttanti mahāsatipaṭṭhānasutte vuttaṃ. Sāva vedanā veditabbāti lujjanappalujjanaṭṭhena sā vedanā ‘‘loko’’ti veditabbā. 有染不苦不乐受是指依于六处的舍受。此受是于六门中,当可爱所缘现前时,犹如停留在糖块上的苍蝇,追随色等所缘,执着于彼而生起的、依止五欲的舍受。无染不苦不乐受是指依于六种出离的舍受。此受是于六门中,当可爱等所缘现前时,于可爱境不贪,于不可爱境不瞋,以不迷乱之心而生起的、与观智相应的舍受。如是《大念住经》中所说。应知彼受,即是因其具有毁坏和破碎的性质,故应知彼受为“世间”。 Evaṃ vitthāriteti ‘‘sarāgaṃ vā cittaṃ sarāgaṃ cittanti pajānāti, vītarāgaṃ vā cittaṃ…pe… sadosaṃ vā cittaṃ, vītadosaṃ vā cittaṃ, samohaṃ vā cittaṃ, vītamohaṃ vā cittaṃ, saṃkhittaṃ vā cittaṃ, vikkhittaṃ vā cittaṃ, mahaggataṃ vā cittaṃ, amahaggataṃ vā cittaṃ, sauttaraṃ vā cittaṃ, anuttaraṃ vā cittaṃ, samāhitaṃ vā cittaṃ, asamāhitaṃ vā cittaṃ, vimuttaṃ vā cittaṃ, avimuttaṃ vā cittanti pajānātī’’ti evaṃ satipaṭṭhānasutte (dī. ni. 2.381; ma. ni. 1.114) vitthāretvā dassite soḷasavidhe citte. 如是广说,即“了知心有贪为有贪,了知心离贪为离贪……了知心有瞋为有瞋,了知心离瞋为离瞋,了知心有痴为有痴,了知心离痴为离痴,了知心收摄为收摄,了知心散乱为散乱,了知心广大为广大,了知心非广大为非广大,了知心有上为有上,了知心无上为无上,了知心已入定为已入定,了知心未入定为未入定,了知心已解脱为已解脱,了知心未解脱为未解脱”,如此在《大念处经》(Satipaṭṭhānasutta)中广说开示的十六种心。 Tattha sarāganti aṭṭhavidhaṃ lobhasahagataṃ. Vītarāganti lokiyakusalābyākataṃ. Idaṃ pana yasmā sammasanaṃ na dhammasamodhānaṃ, tasmā idha ekapadepi lokuttaraṃ na labbhati. Sesāni cattāri akusalacittāni neva purimapadaṃ, na pacchimapadaṃ bhajanti. Sadosanti duvidhaṃ domanassasahagataṃ. Vītadosanti lokiyakusalābyākataṃ. Sesāni dasa akusalacittāni neva purimapadaṃ, na pacchimapadaṃ bhajanti. Samohanti vicikicchāsahagatañceva uddhaccasahagatañcāti duvidhaṃ. Yasmā pana moho sabbākusalesu uppajjati, tasmā sesānipi idha vattantiyeva. Imasmiññeva hi duke dvādasākusalacittāni pariyādinnānīti. Vītamohanti lokiyakusalābyākataṃ. 其中,“有贪”是指八种与贪俱行的心。“离贪”是指世间善与无记心。然而,因为这是思惟(sammasana)而非法的组合(dhammasamodhāna),所以在此处,即使是一个词,也得不到出世间法。其余四种不善心,既不属于前一词,也不属于后一词。“有瞋”是指两种与忧俱行的心。“离瞋”是指世间善与无记心。其余十种不善心,既不属于前一词,也不属于后一词。“有痴”是指与疑俱行及与掉举俱行的两种心。然而,因为痴在一切不善心中生起,所以其余不善心也在此处适用。正是在此二法对中,十二种不善心皆被含摄。“离痴”是指世间善与无记心。 Saṃkhittanti thinamiddhānupatitaṃ. Etañhi saṅkucitacittaṃ nāma ārammaṇe saṅkocavasena pavattanato. Vikkhittanti uddhaccasahagataṃ. Etañhi pasaṭacittaṃ nāma ārammaṇe savisesaṃ vikkhepavasena visaṭabhāvena pavattanato. Mahaggatanti rūpāvacaraṃ arūpāvacarañca. Amahaggatanti kāmāvacaraṃ. Sauttaranti kāmāvacaraṃ. Anuttaranti rūpāvacaraṃ arūpāvacarañca. Tatrāpi sauttaraṃ rūpāvacaraṃ, anuttaraṃ arūpāvacarameva. Samāhitanti yassa appanāsamādhi vā upacārasamādhi vā atthi. Asamāhitanti ubhayasamādhivirahitaṃ. Vimuttanti [Pg.239] tadaṅgavikkhambhanavimuttīhi vimuttaṃ. Avimuttanti ubhayavimuttirahitaṃ. Samucchedappaṭippassaddhinissaraṇavimuttīnaṃ pana idha okāsova natthi, okāsābhāvo ca sammasanacārassa adhippetattā veditabbo. “收摄”是指为昏沉睡眠所困。此心于所缘中收缩而转起,故名收摄心。“散乱”是指与掉举俱行。此心于所缘中格外散漫而转起,故名散乱心。“广大”是指色界与无色界。“非广大”是指欲界。“有上”是指欲界。“无上”是指色界与无色界。于此之中,色界为“有上”,无色界方为“无上”。“已入定”是指具有安止定(appanāsamādhi)或近行定(upacārasamādhi)。“未入定”是指无此二定。“已解脱”是指由支分解脱(tadaṅgavimutti)与镇伏解脱(vikkhambhanavimutti)而解脱。“未解脱”是指无此二解脱。至于断灭解脱(samucchedavimutti)、止息解脱(paṭippassaddhivimutti)与出离解脱(nissaraṇavimutti),在此处则无机会,当知无此机会是因其意指思惟行境(sammasanacāra)之故。 Upādānassa khandhā upādānakkhandhā, upādānassa paccayabhūtā dhammapuñjā dhammarāsayoti attho. Upādānehi ārammaṇakaraṇādivasena upādātabbā vā khandhā upādānakkhandhā. Cha ajjhattikabāhirāyatanānīti cakkhu sotaṃ ghānaṃ jivhā kāyo manoti imāni cha ajjhattikāyatanāni ceva, rūpaṃ saddo gandho raso phoṭṭhabbo dhammāti imāni cha bāhirāyatanāni ca. Ettha pana lokuttaradhammā na gahetabbā sammasanacārassa adhippetattā. Satta sambojjhaṅgāti satisambojjhaṅgādayo satta sambojjhaṅgā. Satiādayo hi sambodhissa, sambodhiyā vā aṅgāti sambojjhaṅgā. Tathā hi sambujjhati āraddhavipassakato paṭṭhāya yogāvacaroti sambodhi, yāya vā so satiādikāya sattadhammasāmaggiyā sambujjhati, kilesaniddāto uṭṭhāti, saccāni vā paṭivijjhati, sā dhammasāmaggī sambodhi, tassa sambodhissa, tassā vā sambodhiyā aṅgāti sambojjhaṅgā. 执取之蕴即是取蕴(upādānakkhandha),意为作为执取之缘的法蕴、法聚。或由执取而作为所缘等被执取的蕴,即是取蕴。“六内六外处”是指眼、耳、鼻、舌、身、意此六内处,及色、声、香、味、触、法此六外处。在此不应取诸出世间法,因其意指思惟行境故。“七觉支”(satta sambojjhaṅga)是指念觉支等七种觉支。念等是觉悟(bodhi)之支分,故名觉支。如是,瑜伽行者(yogāvacara)从开始修习观(vipassanā)时即觉悟,此为“觉”;或由念等七法和合而觉悟,从烦恼之眠中醒来,或彻见诸谛,此法之和合为“觉”;此“觉”之支分,故名觉支。 Cattāri ariyasaccānīti ‘‘dukkhaṃ dukkhasamudayo dukkhanirodho dukkhanirodhagāminipaṭipadā’’ti (saṃ. ni. 5.1071-1072) evaṃ vuttāni cattāri ariyasaccāni. Tattha purimāni dve saccāni vaṭṭaṃ pavattihetubhāvato. Pacchimāni vivaṭṭaṃ nivaṭṭatadadhigamūpāyabhāvato. Tesu bhikkhuno vaṭṭe kammaṭṭhānābhiniveso hoti sarūpato pariggahasambhavato. Vivaṭṭe natthi abhiniveso avisayattā avisayatte ca payojanābhāvato. Pañcadhā vuttesūti satipaṭṭhānasutte vuttesu. Suddhaarūpasammasanamevāti rūpena amissitattā kevalaṃ arūpasammasanameva. Khandhāyatanasaccakoṭṭhāsānaṃ pañcakkhandhasaṅgahato ‘‘rūpārūpasammasana’’nti vuttaṃ. Pubbabhāgiyānampi satipaṭṭhānānaṃ saṅgahitattā ‘‘lokiyalokuttaramissakāneva kathitānī’’ti āha. 四圣谛(cattāri ariyasaccāni),即所说的“苦、苦集、苦灭、导向苦灭之道”(《相应部》Saṃyutta Nikāya 5.1071-1072)四种圣谛。其中,前二谛为轮回(vaṭṭa),因其是流转之因;后二谛为还灭(vivaṭṭa),因其是止息及证得该止息之法。于此,比丘于轮回中专注业处(kammaṭṭhāna),因其自性可被把握故;于还灭中则不专注,因其非(思惟)所缘,且非所缘则无作用故。“于五种说中”,是指于《念处经》中所说。“纯无色思惟”,是因不与色法混合,故唯是无色思惟。因蕴、处、谛诸部分为五蕴所摄,故说为“色与无色思惟”。又因含摄了前分诸念处,故说“所说是世间与出世间混合的”。 394. Anibbattānanti ajātānaṃ. Payogaṃ parakkamanti ettha bhusaṃ yogo payogo, payogova parakkamo, payogasaṅkhātaṃ parakkamanti attho. Cittaṃ ukkhipatīti kosajjapakkhe patituṃ apadānavasena ukkhipati. Padhānavīriyanti [Pg.240] sammappadhānalakkhaṇappattavīriyaṃ. Lokiyāti lokiyasammappadhānakathā. Sabbapubbabhāgeti sabbamaggānaṃ pubbabhāge. Kassapasaṃyuttapariyāyenāti kassapasaṃyutte āgatasuttena ‘‘uppannā me pāpakā akusalā dhammā appahīyamānā anatthāya saṃvatteyyu’’nti (saṃ. ni. 2.145) āgatattā. Sā lokiyāti veditabbā. 394. “未生起者”(anibbattānaṃ),即未生者(ajātānaṃ)。“努力精进”(payogaṃ parakkamaṃ):于此,极力应用为“努力”(payoga),努力即是“精进”(parakkama),意为名为“努力”的精进。“策励其心”(cittaṃ ukkhipati):为不堕于懈怠(kosajja)一侧,以不放弃的方式策励。“精进努力”(padhānavīriyaṃ):是达到正勤(sammappadhāna)特征的精进。“世间”(lokiya):指关于世间正勤之说。“一切前分”(sabbapubbabhāge):于一切道的前分。“依《迦叶相应》之理趣”:因《迦叶相应》(Kassapasaṃyutta)中的经文说:“我已生的恶不善法若不舍断,将导致无益”。当知此为世间法。 Samathavipassanāvāti avadhāraṇena maggaṃ nivattetvā tassa nivattane kāraṇaṃ dassento, ‘‘maggo panā’’tiādimāha. Sakiṃ uppajjitvāti idaṃ bhūtakathanamattaṃ. Niruddhassa puna anuppajjanato ‘‘na koci guṇo’’ti āsaṅkeyyāti āha – ‘‘so hī’’tiādi. Anantarameva yathā phalaṃ uppajjati, tathā pavattiyevassa paccayadānaṃ. Purimasmimpīti ‘‘anuppannā me kusalā dhammā uppajjamānā anatthāya saṃvatteyyu’’nti etthapi. Vuttanti porāṇaṭṭhakathāyaṃ. Taṃ pana tathāvuttavacanaṃ na yuttaṃ dutiyasmiṃ viya purimasmiṃ maggassa aggahaṇe kāraṇābhāvato. Purimasmiṃ aggahite magge anuppajjamāno maggo anatthāya saṃvatteyyāti āpajjeyya, na cetaṃ yuttaṃ āpajjamāne tasmiṃ padhānatthasambhavato. Catukiccasādhanavasenāti anuppannākusalānuppādanādicatukiccasādhanavasena. “止与观”(samathavipassanā):是以限定的方式排除道,为示其排除之因,故说“道则……”等。“一生起已”:此仅为陈述事实。因已灭者不再生,故或疑“无何功德”,因此说“彼实……”等。正如(道心之后)果(心)立即生起,道亦为其相续提供条件。于前句亦然,即于“我未生之善法若生起,将导致无益”处。此乃古义注(porāṇaṭṭhakathā)所说。然彼说不妥,因与第二句不同,于前句中无不取道之理由。若于前句不取道,则将导致“未生之道将导致无益”,此不应理,因于彼时可成就精进之义故。“由成就四事”:是指由成就“未生之恶令不生”等四事。 Vuttanayenāti ‘‘asamudācāravasena vā ananubhūtārammaṇavasena vā’’tiādinā vuttanayena. Vijjamānāti dharamānasabhāvā. Khaṇattayapariyāpannattā uppādādisamaṅgino vattamānabhāvena uppannaṃ vattamānuppannaṃ. Tañhi uppādato paṭṭhāya yāva bhaṅgā uddhaṃ pannaṃ pattanti nippariyāyato ‘‘uppanna’’nti vuccati. Anubhavitvā bhavitvā ca vigataṃ bhutvāvigataṃ. Anubhavanabhavanāni hi bhavanasāmaññena bhutvā-saddena vuttāni. Sāmaññameva hi upasaggena visesīyati. Idha vipākānubhavanavasena tadārammaṇaṃ avipakkavipākassa sabbathā avigatattā bhavitvāvigatamattavasena kammañca ‘‘bhutvāvigatuppanna’’nti vuttaṃ. Na aṭṭhasāliniyaṃ viya rajjanādivasena anubhūtāpagataṃ javanaṃ uppajjitvā niruddhatāvasena bhūtāpagatañca saṅkhataṃ bhūtāpagatuppannanti. Tasmā idha okāsakatuppannaṃ vipākameva vadati, na tattha viya kammampi. Aṭṭhasāliniyañhi bhūtāvigatuppannaṃ okāsakatuppannañca aññathā dassitaṃ. Vuttañhi tattha (dha. sa. aṭṭha. 1 kāmāvacarakusalapadabhājanīya) – “以所说之理”:即“或由于不现行故,或由于未曾体验所缘故”等所说之理。“存在者”:即具有持续的自性。由于包含三刹那,具足生等,以现在法之状态生起者,为“现在已生”。彼从生时起,乃至坏时,向上已达,故无异议地称为“已生”。体验后、存在后而消失者,为“已受用已离”。体验与存在,以“存在”之通称,由“bhutvā”一词而说。通称正是由前缀而特定化。于此,由体验异熟故,彼所缘对未熟之异熟而言完全未离,仅以“已存在已离”之方式,业亦被称为“已受用已离而生”。不像在《含义阐明》(Aṭṭhasālinī)中,由染著等方式体验后已离去的速行,以及由生已即灭故,有为法被称为“已有已离”,合称为“已有已离而生”。是故,于此,“机缘生起”仅指异熟,不像彼处亦说业。在《含义阐明》中,“已有已离而生”与“机缘生起”有另外的解释。如彼处所言(《法集论义注》第一章“欲界善品释”)—— ‘‘Ārammaṇarasaṃ [Pg.241] anubhavitvā niruddhaṃ anubhūtāpagatasaṅkhātaṃ kusalākusalaṃ, upādādittayaṃ anuppatvā niruddhaṃ bhūtāpagatasaṅkhātaṃ sesasaṅkhatañca bhūtāpagatuppannaṃ nāma. ‘Yānissa tāni pubbe katāni kammānī’ti evamādinā nayena vuttaṃ kammaṃ atītampi samānaṃ aññaṃ vipākaṃ paṭibāhitvā attano vipākassokāsaṃ katvā ṭhitattā, tathākatokāsañca vipākaṃ anuppannampi samānaṃ evaṃ kate okāse ekantena uppajjanato okāsakatuppannaṃ nāmā’’ti. “体验所缘之味后灭尽,名为‘已体验已离’的善与不善法;以及已达到生等三刹那而灭尽,名为‘已有已离’的其余有为法,此二者合称名为‘已有已离而生’。如‘彼于往昔所造之业’等经文所说,业虽已过去,然能排除其他异熟,为自身之异熟创造机缘而住立。如是已造机缘之异熟,虽尚未生,然机缘已造,则必定会生,故名为‘机缘生起’。” Idha pana sammohavinodaniyaṃ vuttanayeneva bhutvāvigatuppannaṃ okāsakatuppannañca dassitaṃ. Vuttañhi, sammohavinodaniyaṃ (vibha. aṭṭha. 406) – 然而于此,正是以《痴惑冰消》(Sammohavinodanī)中所说之理,开示了“已受用已离而生”与“机缘生起”。如《痴惑冰消》(《分别论义注》406)所言—— ‘‘Kamme pana jahite ārammaṇarasaṃ anubhavitvā niruddho vipāko bhutvāvigataṃ nāma. Kammaṃ uppajjitvā niruddhaṃ bhutvāvigataṃ nāma. Tadubhayampi bhutvāvigatuppannanti saṅkhyaṃ gacchati. Kusalākusalaṃ kammaṃ aññakammassa vipākaṃ paṭibāhitvā attano vipākassa okāsaṃ karoti. Evaṃ kate okāse vipāko uppajjamāno okāsakaraṇato paṭṭhāya uppannoti vuccati. Idaṃ okāsakatuppannaṃ nāmā’’ti. “体验所缘之味后灭尽的异熟,名为‘已受已离’(bhutvāvigata)。业生起后灭尽,亦名为‘已受已离’。此二者皆计为‘已受已离而生’(bhutvāvigatuppanna)。善与不善业排除其他业的异熟,为自身的异熟创造机缘。如是机缘已造,当异熟生起时,即说为从造机缘之时起为已生。此即名为‘机缘生起’(okāsakatuppanna)。” Tattha aṭṭhasāliniyā ayamadhippāyo – ‘‘satipi sabbesampi cittuppādānaṃ saṃvedayitasabhāvā ārammaṇānubhavane savipallāse pana santāne cittābhisaṅkhāravasena pavattito abyākatehi visiṭṭho kusalākusalānaṃ sātisayo visayānubhavanākāro. Yathā vikappaggāhavasena rāgādīhi tabbipakkhehi ca akusalaṃ kusalañca nippariyāyato ārammaṇarasaṃ anubhavati, na tathā vipāko kammavegakkhittattā, nāpi kiriyā ahetukānaṃ atidubbalatāya, sahetukānañca khīṇakilesassa chaḷaṅgupekkhāvato uppajjamānānaṃ atisantavuttittā, tasmā rajjanādivasena ārammaṇarasānubhavanaṃ sātisayanti akusalaṃ kusalañca uppajjitvā niruddhatāsāmaññena sesasaṅkhatañca bhūtāpagata’’nti vuttaṃ. Sammohavinodaniyā pana vipākānubhavanavasena tadārammaṇaṃ avipakkapākassa sabbathā avigatattā bhavitvāvigatamattavasena kammañca bhutvāpagatanti [Pg.242] vuttaṃ. Teneva tattha okāsakatuppannanti vipākamevāha, na kammampi, tasmā idhāpi sammohavinodaniyaṃ vuttanayeneva bhutvāpagatuppannaṃ okāsakatuppannañca vibhattanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. 此处《含义阐明》(Aṭṭhasālinī)的意旨是:“虽则一切心生起时于体验所缘皆有感受之自性,然在有颠倒的相续中,由心行力而转起的善与不善,其体验所缘的方式,有超胜于无记法之殊异。譬如,由于分别执取,不善法之贪等及其对治之善法,皆能无异议地体验所缘之味,而异熟则不然,因其为业力所抛;造作亦不然,因无因者极弱,而有因者于烦恼已尽、具足六支舍者生起时,其行相极为寂静。是故,以染著等方式体验所缘之味,乃善与不善之殊胜处。而善与不善,以及其余有为法,以生已即灭之共相,被称为‘已有已离’(bhūtāpagata)。”然而,《痴惑冰消》(Sammohavinodanī)则说,由于体验异熟故,彼所缘对未熟之果而言完全未离,仅以“已存在已离”(bhavitvāvigata)之方式,而业则被称为“已有已离”(bhūtāpagata)。因此,彼处说“机缘生起”(okāsakatuppanna)仅指异熟,不指业。是故,于此亦应知,正是以《痴惑冰消》所说之理,分别“已受用已离而生”(bhutvāvigatuppanna)与“机缘生起”(okāsakatuppanna)。 Pañcakkhandhā pana vipassanāya bhūmi nāmāti sammasanassa ṭhānabhāvato vuttaṃ. Tesūti atītādibhedesu. Anusayitakilesāti appahīnā maggena pahātabbā adhippetā. Tenāha – ‘‘atītā vā…pe… na vattabbā’’ti. Hontu tāva ‘‘atītā’’ti vā ‘‘paccuppannā’’ti vā na vattabbā, ‘‘anāgatā’’ti pana kasmā na vattabbā, nanu kāraṇalābhe uppajjanārahā appahīnaṭṭhena thāmagatā kilesā anusayāti vuccantīti? Saccametaṃ, anāgatabhāvopi nesaṃ na paricchinno itarānāgatakkhandhānaṃ viyāti ‘‘anāgatā vāti na vattabbā’’ti vuttaṃ. Yadi hi nesaṃ paricchinno anāgatabhāvo siyā, tato ‘‘paccuppannā, atītā’’ti ca vattabbā siyuṃ, paccayasamavāye pana uppajjanārahataṃ upādāya anāgatavohāro tattha veditabbo. “五蕴是观(vipassanā)之地,是因其为思察之处所而说。‘于彼等中’者,即于过去等差别中。‘随眠烦恼’者,意指未断、当由道断者。故说:‘或过去……乃至……不可说’。纵然‘或过去’或‘或现在’不可说,然为何‘或未来’亦不可说?难道于得缘之时,有生起之可能、以未断故而有力的烦恼,不被称为随眠吗?诚然如是。然彼等之未来性亦不确定,如其他未来蕴一样,故说‘或未来亦不可说’。若彼等之未来性确定,则亦可说为‘现在’、‘过去’。然应知,于彼处,是缘于‘因缘和合时有生起之可能性’而有‘未来’之说。” Idaṃ bhūmiladdhuppannaṃ nāmāti idaṃ yathāvuttaṃ kilesajātaṃ appahīnaṭṭhena bhūmiladdhuppannaṃ nāma kāraṇalābhe sati vijjamānakiccakaraṇato. Tāsu tāsu bhūmisūti manussadevādiattabhāvasaṅkhātesu upādānakkhandhesu. Ārammaṇakaraṇavasena hi bhavanti ettha kilesāti bhūmiyo, upādānakkhandhā. Asamugghātagatāti tasmiṃ tasmiṃ santāne anuppattidhammataṃ anāpāditatāya samugghātaṃ samucchedaṃ na gatāti asamugghātagatā. Bhūmiladdhuppannaṃ nāmāti ettha laddhabhūmikaṃ bhūmiladdhanti vuttaṃ aggiāhito viya. Okāsakatuppannasaddepi ca aṭṭhasāliniyaṃ (dha. sa. aṭṭha. 1 kāmāvacarakusalapadabhājanīya) āgatanayena okāso kato etena kusalākusalakammena, okāso kato etassa vipākassāti ca duvidhatthepi evameva katasaddassa paranipāto veditabbo. Idha pana okāsakatuppannasaddena vipākasseva gahitattā ‘‘okāso kato etassa vipākassā’’ti evaṃ viggaho daṭṭhabbo. “此名为‘已得地已生’(bhūmiladdhuppanna)。此如前所说之烦恼,以未断故,于得缘时能作现有之事用,故名为‘已得地已生’。‘于诸地’者,即于名为人、天等自体之诸取蕴中。烦恼于此中以造作所缘而存在,故诸取蕴为‘地’。‘未根除’(asamugghātagata)者,即于各自相续中,因未达不生法性,故未至根除、断绝。名为‘已得地已生’者,于此,‘已得之地’(laddhabhūmikaṃ)即是‘地已得’(bhūmiladdha),其构词法如‘置火’(aggiāhito)一般。于‘机缘生起’(okāsakatuppanna)一词,亦如《含义阐明》所来之理,‘此善不善业已造机缘’及‘此异熟之机缘已被造’,于此二义的分析中,皆应知‘已造’(kata)一词是后置的。然于此,‘机缘生起’一词仅取异熟义,故应见其释为‘此异熟之机缘已被造’。” Khaṇattayasamaṅgitāya samudācārappattaṃ samudācāruppannaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘sampati vattamānaṃyevā’’ti. Ārammaṇaṃ adhiggayha daḷhaṃ gahetvā pavattaṃ ārammaṇādhiggahituppannaṃ. Vikkhambhanappahānavasena appahīnā avikkhambhitā. Samucchedappahānavasena appahīnā asamugghātitā. Nimittaggāhavasena ārammaṇassa adhiggahitattā [Pg.243] taṃ ārammaṇaṃ anussaritānussaritakkhaṇe kilesuppattihetubhāvena upatiṭṭhanato adhiggahitameva nāmaṃ hotīti āha – ‘‘ārammaṇassa adhiggahitattā’’ti. Ettha ca āhaṭakhīrarukkho viya nimittaggāhavasena adhiggahitaṃ ārammaṇaṃ, anāhaṭakhīrarukkho viya avikkhambhitatāya antogatakilesaārammaṇaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. Nimittaggāhikā avikkhambhitakilesā vā puggalā vā āhaṭānāhaṭakhīrarukkhasadisā. Purimanayenevāti avikkhambhituppanne vuttanayeneva. Vitthāretabbanti ‘‘imasmiṃ nāma ṭhāne nuppajjissantī’’ti na vattabbā. Kasmā? Asamugghātitattā. Yathā kiṃ? Yathā sace khīrarukkhaṃ kuṭhāriyā āhaneyyuṃ, imasmiṃ nāma ṭhāne khīraṃ na nikkhameyyāti na vattabbaṃ, evaṃ. Idaṃ asamugghātituppannaṃ nāmāti evaṃ yojetvā vitthāretabbaṃ. 与三刹那相合,达到现行(samudācāra)状态,为现行所生。因此说:“正在现行。”执取所缘,牢固执取而转起,为执取所缘而生。以镇伏断(vikkhambhanappahāna)的方式未断除,故未镇伏。以永断(samucchedappahāna)的方式未断除,故未根除。因为以取相(nimittaggāha)的方式执取所缘,所以在忆念所缘的每一个刹那,都作为烦恼生起的因由而现起,因此说“由于执取所缘”。于此,应知:以取相的方式执取所缘,犹如已割的乳汁树;由于未镇伏而内含烦恼的所缘,犹如未割的乳汁树。取相者、未镇伏烦恼者或人(puggala),犹如已割和未割的乳汁树。“如前所述”,即是依于对“未镇伏生”(avikkhambhituppanna)所说的方式。应详述为:“不能说‘在这个地方必不会生起’。”为什么呢?因为没有被根除。譬如什么?譬如如果用斧砍乳汁树,不能断言“这个地方一定不会流出乳汁”,就是这样。这名为“未根除生”(asamugghātituppanna),应如是结合而详加解释。 Imesu uppannesūti yathāvuttesu aṭṭhasu uppannesu. Idaṃ na maggavajjhaṃ appahātabbavatthuttā. Maggavajjhaṃ maggena paheyyavatthuttā. Rattoti rāgena samannāgato. Esa nayo duṭṭho mūḷhoti etthāpi. Vinibaddhoti mānasaṃyojanena virūpaṃ nibandhito. Parāmaṭṭhoti diṭṭhiparāmāsena dhammasabhāvaṃ atikkamma parato āmaṭṭho. Aniṭṭhaṅgatoti niṭṭhaṃ agato, saṃsayāpannoti attho. Thāmagatoti anusayavasena daḷhataṃ upagato. Yuganaddhāti pahātabbappahāyakayuge naddhā viya vattanakā ekakālikattā. Saṃkilesikāti saṃkilesadhammasahitā. 于此等“已生起”(uppanna)中,即如前所述的八种已生起中。此非“道所应断”(maggavajjha),因其为不可断除之事。“道所应断”者,因其为可被道断除之事。“贪著者”(ratto)是指与贪相应者。此理亦适用于“瞋者”(duṭṭho)与“痴者”(mūḷho)。“被系缚者”(vinibaddho)是指被慢结(mānasaṃyojana)以不正的方式系缚。“被执取者”(parāmaṭṭho)是指被见取(diṭṭhiparāmāsa)超越法的自性而执取。“未达究竟者”(aniṭṭhaṅgato)是指未达究竟,即处于疑惑中。“坚固者”(thāmagato)是指由于随眠(anusaya)而变得坚固。“双运者”(yuganaddha)是指应断之法与能断之法,因其同时运作,犹如被轭系于一处。“杂染者”(saṃkilesika)是指与杂染法(saṃkilesadhamma)相应者。 Pāḷiyanti paṭisambhidāpāḷiyaṃ (paṭi. ma. 3.21). Tikālikesupi kilesesu vāyāmābhāvadassanatthaṃ ajātaphalataruṇarukkho pāḷiyaṃ nidassito, aṭṭhakathāyaṃ pana jāto satto asamudāhaṭakileso nāma natthīti ‘‘jātaphalarukkhena dīpetabba’’nti vatvā tamatthaṃ vivarituṃ ‘‘yathā hī’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Atha vā maggena pahīnakilesānameva atītādibhedena tidhā navattabbataṃ pākaṭaṃ kātuṃ ajātaphalarukkho upamāvasena pāḷiyaṃ ābhato, atītādīnaṃ appahīnatādassanatthampi ‘‘jātaphalarukkhena dīpetabba’’nti aṭṭhakathāyaṃ vuttaṃ. Tattha yathā acchinne rukkhe nibbattanārahāni phalāni chinne anuppajjamānāni kadāci sasabhāvāni ahesuṃ, honti, bhavissanti vāti atītādibhāvena na vattabbāni, evaṃ maggena pahīnakilesā ca daṭṭhabbā magge anuppanne uppattirahānaṃ uppanne sabbena sabbaṃ abhāvato[Pg.244]. Yathā ca chede asati phalāni uppajjissantīti chedanassa sātthakatā, evaṃ maggabhāvanāya ca sātthakatā yojetabbā. Nāpi na pajahatīti uppajjanārahānaṃ pajahanato vuttaṃ. Uppajjitvāti lakkhaṇe tvā-saddo. Maggassa uppajjanakiriyāya hi samudayappahānanibbānasachikaraṇakiriyā viya khandhānaṃ parijānanakiriyā lakkhīyati. 在圣典(Pāḷi)中,即《无碍解道》(Paṭisambhidāmagga)中。为了显示于三时(tikālika)烦恼(kilesa)中缺乏精进,圣典中以未结果的幼树为例示;然而,在义注(aṭṭhakathā)中,则说“没有烦恼不现行的已生有情”,故云“应当用已结果的树来说明”,为了阐明此义,故说“譬如”等。或者,为了明确显示已被道(magga)所断的烦恼,不会因过去等差别而有三种说法,故圣典中以未结果的树作譬喻;义注中为了显示过去等烦恼未被断除的情况,亦说“应当用已结果的树来说明”。于此,譬如在未被砍伐的树上,本应生长的果实,一旦被砍伐就不会再生长,故不能以过去等方式说其曾有、现有或将有自性——同样,应观察已被道所断的烦恼,在道未生起时本可生起,一旦道生起,则完全灭尽。又如不砍伐,果实就会生起,可见砍伐是有意义的;同样,应理解修习道(maggabhāvanā)亦有其意义。“亦非不舍弃”,是说它舍弃了那些本会生起的烦恼。“Uppajjitvā”中的“tvā”词缀表示特征。因为道的生起作用,是以遍知诸蕴(khandha)的作用为特征,犹如以断集(samudaya)、证灭(nibbāna)的作用为特征一般。 Tepi pajahatiyevāti ye tehi kilesehi janetabbā upādinnakkhandhā, tepi pajahatiyeva tannimittassa abhisaṅkhāraviññāṇassa nirodhanato. Tenāha – ‘‘vuttampi ceta’’ntiādi. Abhisaṅkhāraviññāṇassa nirodhenāti kammaviññāṇassa anuppattidhammatāpādanena. Etthāti etasmiṃ sotāpattimaggañāṇe hetubhūte. Eteti nāmarūpasaññitā saṅkhārā. Sabbabhavehi vuṭṭhātiyevātipi vadantīti arahattamaggo sabbabhavehi vuṭṭhātiyevāti vadanti taduppattito uddhaṃ bhavūpapattiyā kilesassapi abhāvato. “彼亦断除”,即由彼等烦恼所生的所取蕴,彼等也确实断除,因为断灭了以彼(烦恼)为因的行识。因此说:“此亦曾说”等。“断灭行识”,是指使其业识达到不生的状态。“于此”,是指于此作为因的须陀洹道智(Sotāpattimaggañāṇa)中。“彼等”,是指被称为名色(Nāmarūpa)的诸行。亦有说“从一切有中出离”者,即是说阿罗汉道(Arahattamaggo)确实从一切有中出离,因为从它生起以后,不再有任何生的生起,以及任何烦恼。 Ekacittakkhaṇikattā maggassāti adhippāyena ‘‘kathaṃ anuppannānaṃ…pe… ṭhitiyā bhāvanā hotī’’ti pucchati. Maggappavattiyāyeva ubhayakiccasiddhito āha – ‘‘maggappavattiyāyevā’’ti. Maggo hītiādinā tamatthaṃ vivarati. Anuppanno nāma vuccati, tasmā tassa bhāvanā anuppannānaṃ uppādāya bhāvanā vuttāti yojetabbā. Vattuṃ vaṭṭatīti yāvatā maggassa pavattiyeva ṭhiti, tattakāneva nibbattitalokuttarāni. 以“道仅一心刹那”为意趣,而问:“如何为未生起者……乃至……为住立而修习?”因由道的生起即能成就两种作用,故说:“唯由道的生起。”以“道实是”等文句阐明其义。其被称为未生起,因此,对它的修习,应结合为“为了令未生者生起而修习”。可以说,道的生起即是住立,出世间法亦仅于此生起。 398-401. Kattukamyatāchandaṃ adhipatiṃ karitvā paṭiladdhasamādhi chandasamādhīti āha – ‘‘chandaṃ nissāya pavatto samādhi chandasamādhī’’ti padhānasaṅkhārāti catukiccasādhakassa sammappadhānavīriyassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘padhānabhūtā saṅkhārā padhānasaṅkhārā’’ti. Tattha padhānabhūtāti vīriyabhūtā. Saṅkhatasaṅkhārādinivattanatthaṃ padhānaggahaṇanti. Atha vā taṃ taṃ visesaṃ saṅkharotīti saṅkhāro, sabbaṃ vīriyaṃ. Tattha catukiccasādhakato sesanivattanatthaṃ padhānaggahaṇanti, padhānabhūtā seṭṭhabhūtāti attho. Catubbidhassa pana vīriyassa adhippetattā bahuvacananiddeso kato. Tehi dhammehīti chandasamādhinā padhānasaṅkhārehi ca. Iddhipādanti ettha ijjhatīti iddhi, samijjhati nipphajjatīti attho. Ijjhanti vā etāya sattā iddhā vuddhā ukkaṃsagatā hontītipi iddhi. Paṭhamenatthena iddhi eva pādo [Pg.245] iddhipādo, iddhikoṭṭhāsoti attho. Dutiyenatthena iddhiyā pādoti iddhipādo, pādoti patiṭṭhā, adhigamūpāyoti attho. Tena hi yasmā uparūparivisesasaṅkhātaṃ iddhiṃ pajjanti pāpuṇanti, tasmā pādoti vuccati. Tenāha – ‘‘iddhiyā pādaṃ, iddhibhūtaṃ vā pādaṃ iddhipāda’’nti. 398-401. 以欲作欲(Kattukamyatāchanda)为增上而获得的定,是为欲定,故说:“依欲而转起的定,是为欲定。”精进诸行(Padhānasaṅkhārā)是能成办四种作用的正勤精进(Sammappadhānavīriya)的同义词。因此说:“作为精进的诸行,是为精进诸行。”其中,“作为精进”即是以精进为体。为排除有为行等,而取“精进”一词。或者说,因能造作种种殊胜,故为“行”,此指一切精进。于此,为成办四种作用而排除其余,故取“精进”一词,“作为精进”即“作为最胜”之义。又因意指四种精进,故作复数解释。“通过此等法”,即通过欲定与精进诸行。于“神足”(Iddhipāda)中,“成就”(ijjhati)即是“神变”(iddhi),义为“圆满、达成”。或“众生因此而成就、增长、达于卓越”,故为“神变”。依第一义,神变即是足,为神足(iddhipādo),义为神变的一部分。依第二义,神变之足为神足,“足”义为“基石、证得之方便”。因此,由于能次第达到名为“殊胜”的神变,故称为“足”。因此说:“神变之足,或以神变为体的足,是为神足。” Atha vā iddhipādanti nipphattipariyāyena ijjhanaṭṭhena, ijjhanti etāya sattā iddhā vuddhā ukkaṃsagatā hontīti iminā vā pariyāyena iddhīti saṅkhaṃ gatānaṃ upacārajjhānādikusalacittasampayuttānaṃ chandasamādhipadhānasaṅkhārānaṃ adhiṭṭhānaṭṭhena pādabhūtaṃ sesacittacetasikarāsinti attho. Teneva iddhipādavibhaṅge (vibha. 434-437) ‘‘iddhipādoti tathābhūtassa vedanākkhandho…pe… viññāṇakkhandho’’ti vuttaṃ. Sā eva ca tathāvuttā iddhi yasmā heṭṭhimā heṭṭhimā uparimāya uparimāya tayo chandasamādhippadhānasaṅkhārā pādabhūtā adhiṭṭhānabhūtā, tasmā vuttaṃ ‘‘iddhibhūtaṃ vā pāda’’nti. Tathā heṭṭhā dhammā iddhipi honti iddhipādāpi, sesā pana sampayuttakā cattāro khandhā iddhipādāyeva. Vīriyacittavīmaṃsāsamādhippadhānasaṅkhārasaṅkhātāpi tayo tayo dhammā iddhipi honti iddhipādāpi, sesā pana sampayuttakā cattāro khandhā iddhipādāyeva. 或者,所谓神足(iddhipāda),从成就的角度而言,是“能成就”的意思;或从“众生以此而有成就、增长、达到殊胜”的角度而言,名为“神变”(iddhi)者,其义为:与近行定等善心相应的欲三摩地胜行等,是其余心、心所聚的根基(pāda),即立足处(adhiṭṭhāna)。因此,在《神足分别》(Iddhipādavibhaṅga)中说:“神足即是此类的受蕴……乃至……识蕴。” 正是如此所说的神变,因为下位法是上位法的根基与立足处,所以说“神变即是足”。同样,下位法既是神变也是神足,而其余相应四蕴则仅是神足。由精进、心、观三摩地胜行所构成的三法,既是神变也是神足,而其余相应四蕴则仅是神足。 Apica pubbabhāgo pubbabhāgo iddhipādo nāma, paṭilābho paṭilābho iddhi nāmāti veditabbā. Ayamattho upacārena vā vipassanāya vā dīpetabbo. Paṭhamajjhānaparikammañhi iddhipādo nāma, paṭhamajjhānaṃ iddhi nāma. Dutiyajhāna… tatiyajhāna… catutthajhāna… ākāsānañcāyatana… viññāṇañcāyatana… ākiñcaññāyatana… nevasaññānāsaññāyatanaparikammaṃ iddhipādo nāma, nevasaññānāsaññāyatanaṃ iddhi nāma. Sotāpattimaggassa vipassanā iddhipādo nāma, sotāpattimaggo iddhi nāma. Sakadāgāmi-anāgāmi-arahattamaggassa vipassanā iddhipādo nāma, arahattamaggo iddhi nāma. Paṭilābhenapi dīpetuṃ vaṭṭatiyeva. Paṭhamajjhānañhi iddhipādo nāma, dutiyajjhānaṃ iddhi nāma. Dutiyajjhānaṃ iddhipādo nāma, tatiyajjhānaṃ iddhi nāma…pe… anāgāmimaggo iddhipādo nāma, arahattamaggo iddhi nāma. 再者,当知预备阶段(pubbabhāga)名为神足,获得成就(paṭilābha)名为神变。此义当通过近行定或观(vipassanā)来阐明。初禅的预备(parikamma)名为神足,初禅名为神变。第二禅……第三禅……第四禅……空无边处……识无边处……无所有处……非想非非想处的预备名为神足,非想非非想处名为神变。须陀洹道(sotāpattimagga)的观名为神足,须陀洹道名为神变。斯陀含道、阿那含道、阿罗汉道的观名为神足,阿罗汉道名为神变。亦可通过获得的次第来阐明:初禅名为神足,第二禅名为神变;第二禅名为神足,第三禅名为神变……乃至……阿那含道名为神足,阿罗汉道名为神变。 Sesesupīti vīriyasamādhiādīsupi. Tattha hi vīriyaṃ, cittaṃ, vīmaṃsaṃ adhipatiṃ karitvā paṭiladdhasamādhi vīriyasamādhi, cittasamādhi, vīmaṃsāsamādhīti [Pg.246] attho veditabbo. Chandādīsu ekanti chandādīsu catūsu ādito vuttattā ādibhūtaṃ ekaṃ padhānaṃ chandanti adhippāyo. Tenevāha – ‘‘tadāssa paṭhamiddhipādo’’ti. Evaṃ sesāpīti etena vīriyaṃ cittaṃ vīmaṃsaṃ nissāya vipassanaṃ vaḍḍhetvā arahattaṃ pāpuṇantānaṃ vasena dutiyavīriyiddhipādādayo yojetabbāti dasseti. Iminā hi suttantena catunnaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ matthakappattaṃ kammaṭṭhānaṃ dassitaṃ. Eko hi bhikkhu chandaṃ avassayati, kattukamyatākusaladhammacchandena atthanipphattiyaṃ sati ‘‘ahaṃ lokuttaradhammaṃ nibbattessāmi, natthi mayhaṃ etassa nibbattane bhāro’’ti chandaṃ jeṭṭhakaṃ chandaṃ dhuraṃ chandaṃ pubbaṅgamaṃ katvā lokuttaradhammaṃ nibbatteti. Eko vīriyaṃ avassayati, eko cittaṃ, eko paññaṃ avassayati, paññāya atthanipphattiyaṃ sati ‘‘ahaṃ lokuttaradhammaṃ nibbattessāmi, natthi mayhaṃ etassa nibbattane bhāro’’ti paññaṃ jeṭṭhakaṃ paññaṃ dhuraṃ paññaṃ pubbaṅgamaṃ katvā lokuttaradhammaṃ nibbatteti. “于其余亦尔”者,即于精进定等亦尔。于此,当知其义为:以精进、心、或观(vīmaṃsā)为主导而得之定,即是精进定、心定、观定。“于欲等中之一”者,意指于欲等四法中,以最初所说之欲为首要。故说:“此为彼之第一神足。” “如是其余亦尔”者,此句显示,对依于精进、心、观而增长观(vipassanā)、证得阿罗汉果者,当配以第二精进神足等。此经实乃开示四种比丘已达究竟之业处(kammaṭṭhāna)。其一比丘,依于欲,以其行善法之欲,于义利成就时,作是念:“我当生起出世间法,于生起此法,我无重负。”遂以欲为首、以欲为先、以欲为导,而生起出世间法。另一比丘依于精进,一比丘依于心,一比丘依于慧(paññā),于以慧成就义利时,作是念:“我当生起出世间法,于生起此法,我无重负。”遂以慧为首、以慧为先、以慧为导,而生起出世间法。 Kathaṃ? Yathā hi catūsu amaccaputtesu ṭhānantaraṃ patthetvā vicarantesu eko upaṭṭhānaṃ avassayati, eko sūrabhāvaṃ, eko jātiṃ, eko mantaṃ. Kathaṃ? Tesu hi paṭhamo upaṭṭhāne appamādakāritāya atthanipphattiyā sati labbhamānaṃ ‘‘lacchāmetaṃ ṭhānantara’’nti upaṭṭhānaṃ avassayati. Dutiyo upaṭṭhāne appamattopi ‘‘ekacco saṅgāme paccupaṭṭhite saṇṭhātuṃ na sakkoti, avassaṃ pana rañño paccanto kuppissati, tasmiṃ kuppite rathassa purato kammaṃ katvā rājānaṃ ārādhetvā āharāpessāmetaṃ ṭhānantara’’nti sūrabhāvaṃ avassayati. Tatiyo ‘‘sūrabhāvepi sati ekacco hīnajātiko hoti, jātiṃ sodhetvā ṭhānantaraṃ dento mayhaṃ dassatī’’ti jātiṃ avassayati. Catuttho ‘‘jātimāpi eko amantanīyo hoti, mantena kattabbakicce uppanne āharāpessāmetaṃ ṭhānantara’’nti mantaṃ avassayati. Te sabbepi attano attano avassayabalena ṭhānantarāni pāpuṇiṃsu. 如何?譬如四位大臣之子,为求官职而奔走。一者依于侍奉,一者依于勇健,一者依于出身,一者依于谋略。如何?其中第一位,因于侍奉中不放逸而成就其事,心念“我必得此官职”,故依于侍奉。第二位,虽于侍奉中不放逸,然心念“有人临阵却不能立,国王边境必将动乱,动乱之时,我于战车前效力,取悦国王,必能为我带来此官职”,故依于勇健。第三位,心念“纵然勇健,亦有出身卑贱者,国王查验出身而授官职时,必将授予我”,故依于出身。第四位,心念“纵有出身,亦有不善谋略者,若遇需以谋略成办之事,必能为我带来此官职”,故依于谋略。彼等皆以各自所依之力,而获得官职。 Tattha upaṭṭhāne appamatto hutvā ṭhānantaraṃ patto viya chandaṃ avassāya kattukamyatākusaladhammacchandena ‘‘atthanipphattiyaṃ sati ahaṃ lokuttaradhammaṃ nibbattessāmi, natthi mayhaṃ etassa nibbattane sāro’’ti chandaṃ jeṭṭhakaṃ chandaṃ dhuraṃ chandaṃ pubbaṅgamaṃ katvā lokuttaradhammanibbattako daṭṭhabbo [Pg.247] raṭṭhapālatthero (ma. ni. 2.293 ādayo) viya. So hi āyasmā ‘‘chande sati kathaṃ nānujānissantī’’ti sattāhampi bhattāni abhuñjitvā mātāpitaro anujānāpetvā pabbajitvā chandameva avassāya lokuttaradhammaṃ nibbattesi. Sūrabhāvena rājānaṃ ārādhetvā ṭhānantaraṃ patto viya vīriyaṃ jeṭṭhakaṃ vīriyaṃ dhuraṃ vīriyaṃ pubbaṅgamaṃ katvā lokuttaradhammanibbattako daṭṭhabbo soṇatthero (mahāva. 243 ādayo) viya. So hi āyasmā vīriyaṃ dhuraṃ katvā lokuttaradhammaṃ nibbattesi. 其中,当知犹如于侍奉中不放逸而得官职者,依于欲(chanda)而生起出世间法者,当如护国(Raṭṭhapāla)长老。彼具寿曾因“欲愿若此,父母岂能不许?”之念,绝食七日,终得父母应允而出家,正是纯粹依于欲而生起了出世间法。又当知犹如以勇健取悦国王而得官职者,以精进为首、以精进为先、以精进为导而生起出世间法者,当如苏那(Soṇa)长老。彼具寿正是以精进为先而生起了出世间法。 Jātisampattiyā ṭhānantaraṃ pattoviya cittaṃ jeṭṭhakaṃ cittaṃ dhuraṃ cittaṃ pubbaṅgamaṃ katvā lokuttaradhammanibbattako daṭṭhabbo sambhūtatthero (theragā. aṭṭha. 2 sambhūtattheragāthāvaṇṇanā) viya. So hi āyasmā cittaṃ jeṭṭhakaṃ cittaṃ dhuraṃ cittaṃ pubbaṅgamaṃ katvā lokuttaradhammaṃ nibbattesi. Mantaṃ avassāya ṭhānantaraṃ patto viya vīmaṃsaṃ jeṭṭhakaṃ vīmaṃsaṃ dhuraṃ vīmaṃsaṃ pubbaṅgamaṃ katvā lokuttaradhammanibbattako daṭṭhabbo thero mogharājā (su. ni. 1122 ādayo; cūḷani. mogharājamāṇavapucchāniddeso 85) viya. So hi āyasmā vīmaṃsaṃ jeṭṭhakaṃ vīmaṃsaṃ dhuraṃ vīmaṃsaṃ pubbaṅgamaṃ katvā lokuttaradhammaṃ nibbattesi. Tassa hi bhagavā ‘‘suññato lokaṃ avekkhassū’’ti (su. ni. 1125; cūḷani. mogharājamāṇavapucchāniddeso 88) suññatākathaṃ kathesi. Paññānissitamānaniggahatthañca dvikkhattuṃ pucchito pañhaṃ na kathesi. Ettha ca punappunaṃ chanduppādanaṃ tosanaṃ viya hotīti chandassa upaṭṭhānasadisatā vuttā, thāmabhāvato vīriyassa sūrattasadisatā, ‘‘chadvārādhipati rājā’’ti (dha. pa. aṭṭha. 2.erakapattanāgarājavatthu) vacanato pubbaṅgamatā cittassa visiṭṭhajātisadisatā. 犹如凭借出身高贵而获得高位者,当知以心为首、以心为要、以心为先导而成就出世间法者,如同桑布达(Sambhūta)长老。具寿桑布达即是以心为首、以心为要、以心为先导而成就了出世间法。犹如凭借咒语而获得高位者,当知以审察为首、以审察为要、以审察为先导而成就出世间法者,如同莫伽罗阇(Mogharāja)长老。具寿莫伽罗阇即是以审察为首、以审察为要、以审察为先导而成就了出世间法。世尊曾为他说空性之法:“应观世间空”(suññato lokaṃ avekkhassu)。并且为了降伏他因智慧而生的我慢,世尊被问了两次也未回答问题。于此,一再地生起意欲(chanda)犹如令人满足,故说意欲的现起与侍奉相似;由于其坚固,故说精进与勇健相似;根据“心是六门主宰王”(chadvārādhipati rājā)之说,心的前导作用与高贵出身相似。 402-406. Attano saddhādhureti attano saddhākicce saddahanakiriyāya. Indaṭṭhaṃ kāretīti anuvattanavasena sampayuttadhammesu indaṭṭhaṃ kāreti, tasmā ādhipateyyaṭṭhena saddhā eva indriyanti saddhindriyaṃ. Tathā vīriyādīnaṃ sakasakakiccesūti āha – ‘‘vīriyindriyādīsupi eseva nayo’’ti. Visodhentoti vipakkhavivajjanasapakkhanisevanasarikkhūpanissayasaṅgaṇhanalakkhaṇehi tīhi kāraṇehi visodhanavasena sodhento. 402-406. “于己之信的重任中”(attano saddhādhureti),意即于自身的信务中,通过相信的行为。“使其有主导作用”(Indaṭṭhaṃ kāreti)意即,通过随顺的方式,使其在相应法中起主导作用。因此,以主权义,信即是根,故称信根(saddhindriyaṃ)。同样,关于精进等各自的作用,(经中)说:“精进根等也是此理”(vīriyindriyādīsupi eseva nayo)。“净化”(Visodhento)意即,通过三种方式而净化:远离对立法、亲近同分法、把握适宜的依止。 Assaddhe puggale parivajjayatoti buddhādīsu pasādasinehābhāvena saddhārahite lūkhapuggale sabbaso vajjayato. Saddhe puggale sevatoti [Pg.248] buddhādīsu saddhādhimutte vakkalittherasadise sevato. Pasādanīyeti pasādāvahe sampasādanīyasuttādike (dī. ni. 3.141 ādayo). Paccavekkhatoti pāḷito atthato ca pati pati avekkhantassa cintentassa. Visujjhatīti paṭipakkhamalavigamato paccayavasena sabhāvasaṃsuddhito visuddhaphalanibbattito ca saddhindriyaṃ visujjhati. Esa nayo sesesupi. Sammappadhāneti sammappadhānappaṭisaṃyutte (saṃ. ni. 5.651-662 ādayo) suttante. Esa nayo sesesupi. Jhānavimokkheti paṭhamajjhānādijjhānāni ceva paṭhamavimokkhādivimokkhe ca. Kāmañcettha jhānāniyeva vimokkhā, pavattiākāravasena pana visuṃ gahaṇaṃ. “远离不信之人”(assaddhe puggale parivajjayato),意指完全避开对佛陀等缺乏净信与爱乐、无信心的粗鄙之人。“亲近有信之人”(saddhe puggale sevato),意指亲近对佛陀等有信解、如瓦咖利(Vakkali)长老之人。“于能引生净信之法中”(pasādanīye),指于能引生净信的《自欢喜经》(Sampasādanīya Sutta)等经典中。“审察”(paccavekkhato),指从文句与义理两方面,一再地观察、思惟。“得清净”(visujjhati):信根之所以清净,是由于对立的垢秽已去除,由于诸缘而自性清净,以及由于清净之果已生起。此理亦通于其余诸根(esa nayo sesesupi)。“于正勤中”(sammappadhāne),指于《相应部》(Saṃyutta Nikāya)中与正勤相应的诸经。此理亦通于其余诸根。“于禅定与解脱中”(jhānavimokkhe),指于初禅等诸禅,以及初解脱等诸解脱。于此,禅定本身即是解脱,然因作用方式不同而分别论述。 Gambhīrañāṇacariyanti gambhīrānaṃ ñāṇānaṃ pavattiṭṭhānaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘saṇhasukhuma’’ntiādi. Khandhantaranti sabhāvajātibhūmiādivasena khandhānaṃ nānattaṃ. Esa nayo sesesupi. Akatābhinivesoti pubbe akatabhāvanābhiniveso. Saddhādhurādīsūti saddhādhure paññādhure ca. Avasāneti bhāvanāpariyosāne. Vivaṭṭetvāti saṅkhārārammaṇato vivaṭṭetvā nibbānaṃ ārammaṇaṃ katvā. Arahattaṃ gaṇhātīti maggaparamparāya arahattaṃ gaṇhāti. Akampiyaṭṭhenāti paṭipakkhehi akampiyabhāvena. Etenevassa sampayuttadhammesu thirabhāvopi vibhāvito daṭṭhabbo. Na hi sampayuttadhammesu thirabhāvena vinā paṭipakkhehi akampiyatā sambhavati. Sampayuttadhammesu thirabhāveneva hi akusalānaṃ abyākatānañca nesaṃ balavabhāvūpapatti. Assaddhiyeti assaddhiyahetu. Nimittatthe hetaṃ bhummavacanaṃ. Esa nayo sesesupi. “甚深智行处”(Gambhīrañāṇacariyaṃ),指甚深智慧生起之处。因此说“微细、精妙”(saṇhasukhuma)等。“蕴差别”(Khandhantaraṃ),指诸蕴因自性、种类、地等不同而有的差异。此理亦通于其余。“无固执”(Akatābhinivesoti),指对先前未曾修习过的法门不固执。“于信的重任等中”(Saddhādhurādīsūti),指于信的重任与慧的重任中。“究竟时”(Avasāneti),指修行圆满时。“转向后”(Vivaṭṭetvāti),指从行的所缘转向,以涅槃为所缘。“证得阿罗汉”(Arahattaṃ gaṇhātīti),指通过道的次第而证得阿罗汉果。“以不动摇义”(Akampiyaṭṭhenāti),指不为对立法所动摇。由此当知,其于相应法中的坚固性亦得以阐明。若于相应法中不坚固,则不可能不为对立法所动摇。正是由于在相应法中的坚固性,这些(相应)法才生起强有力的状态。“于不信中”(Assaddhiye),指因不信故。此处的地格(第七格)用于所缘义。此理亦通于其余。 418. Ādipadānanti satiādipadānaṃ. Saraṇaṭṭhenāti cirakatacirabhāsitānaṃ anussaraṇaṭṭhena. Upaṭṭhānalakkhaṇāti kāyādīsu asubhākārādisallakkhaṇamukhena tattha upatiṭṭhanasabhāvā. Upatiṭṭhanañca ārammaṇaṃ upagantvā ṭhānaṃ, avissajjanaṃ vā ārammaṇassa. Apilāpanalakkhaṇāti asammussanasabhāvā, udake alābu viya ārammaṇe plavitvā gantuṃ appadānaṃ, pāsāṇassa viya niccalassa ārammaṇassa ṭhapanaṃ sāraṇaṃ asammuṭṭhakaraṇaṃ apilāpanaṃ. Sāpateyyanti santakaṃ. Apilāpanaṃ asammuṭṭhaṃ karoti apilāpeti, sāyaṃ pātañca rājānaṃ issariyasampattiṃ sallakkhāpeti sāretīti attho. Kaṇhasukkasappaṭibhāge dhammeti kaṇhasukkasaṅkhāte sappaṭibhāge dhamme. Kaṇho hi dhammo sukkena, sukko [Pg.249] ca kaṇhena sappaṭibhāgo. Vitthāra-saddo ādisaddattho. Tena ‘‘ime cattāro dhammā sammappadhānā, ime cattāro iddhipādā, imāni pañcindriyāni, imāni pañca balāni, ime satta bojjhaṅgā, ayaṃ ariyo aṭṭhaṅgiko maggo, ayaṃ samatho, ayaṃ vipassanā, ayaṃ vijjā, ayaṃ vimutti, ime lokuttaradhammāti evaṃ kho, mahārāja, apilāpanalakkhaṇā satī’’ti (mi. pa. 2.1.13) imaṃ pāḷisesaṃ saṅgaṇhāti. Therenāti nāgasenattherena. So hi dhammānaṃ kiccaṃ lakkhaṇaṃ katvā asseti ‘‘apilāpanalakkhaṇā sati, ākoṭanalakkhaṇo vitakko’’tiādinā. Evañhi dhammā subodhā hontīti. Sammosapaccanīkaṃ kiccaṃ asammoso, na sammosābhāvamattanti āha – ‘‘asammosarasā vā’’ti. Yassa dhammassa balena sampayuttadhammā ārammaṇābhimukhā bhavanti, sā sati. Tasmā sā tesaṃ ārammaṇābhimukhabhāvaṃ paccupaṭṭhāpesi, sayaṃ vā ārammaṇābhimukhabhāvena paccupatiṭṭhatīti vuttaṃ – ‘‘gocarābhimukhībhāvapaccupaṭṭhānā’’ti. Sammā pasattho bojjhaṅgoti sambojjhaṅgo. Bodhiyā vakkhamānāya dhammasāmaggiyā, bodhissa vā ariyasāvakassa aṅgoti bojjhaṅgo. Yā hītiādinā tameva saṅkhepato vuttamatthaṃ vivarati. ‘‘Yā hi ayaṃ dhammasāmaggī’’ti etassa ‘‘bodhīti vuccatī’’ti iminā sambandho. Dhammasāmaggiyāti dhammasamūhena, yāya dhammasāmaggiyāti sambandho. Patiṭṭhānāyūhanā oghataraṇasuttavaṇṇanāyaṃ (saṃ. ni. aṭṭha. 1.1.1) ‘‘kilesavasena patiṭṭhānaṃ, abhisaṅkhāravasena āyūhanā. Taṇhā diṭṭhivasena patiṭṭhānaṃ, avasesakilesābhisaṅkhārehi āyūhanā. Taṇhāvasena patiṭṭhānaṃ, diṭṭhivasena āyūhanā. Sassatadiṭṭhiyā patiṭṭhānaṃ, ucchedadiṭṭhiyā āyūhanā. Līnavasena patiṭṭhānaṃ, uddhaccavasena āyūhanā. Kāmasukhallikānuyogavasena patiṭṭhānaṃ, attakilamathānuyogavasena āyūhanā. Sabbākusalābhisaṅkhāravasena patiṭṭhānaṃ, sabbalokiyakusalābhisaṅkhāravasena āyūhanā’’ti evaṃ vuttesu sattasu pakāresu idha avuttānaṃ vasena veditabbā. Paṭipakkhabhūtāyāti ettha līnappatiṭṭhānakāmasukhallikānuyogaucchedābhinivesānaṃ dhammavicayavīriyapītippadhānā dhammasāmaggī paṭipakkho, uddhaccāyūhanaattakilamathānuyogasassatābhinivesānaṃ passaddhisamādhiupekkhāpadhānā dhammasāmaggī paṭipakkho. Sati pana ubhayatthāpi icchitabbā. Tathā hi sā ‘‘sabbatthikā’’ti vuttā. 418. “根本义”(Ādipadāna)即是念等根本义。“忆持义”(Saraṇaṭṭhena)是指能够忆念长久以来所做与所说之事。“现起相”(Upaṭṭhānalakkhaṇā)是指通过观察身等的不净相等相,于彼现起的自性。现起,是指趋向所缘而住,或不舍弃所缘。“不忘失相”(Apilāpanalakkhaṇā)是指不迷失的自性,如同水中的葫芦,不让它在所缘上漂走,如同磐石般不动摇地建立所缘,忆持,使不迷失。“资财”(Sāpateyya)即是自有之物。不忘失即是使不迷失,此念能够让国王日夜忆念王权富贵之义。“于黑白有分之法”(Kaṇhasukkasappaṭibhāge dhamme)即于名为黑白有分之法。因为黑法与白法为对分,白法与黑法为对分。“广说”(Vitthāra)一词有“等”(ādi)的含义。因此,它涵盖了‘大王,所谓不忘失相之念,即是四正勤、四神足、五根、五力、七觉支、八圣道、奢摩他、毘婆舍那(vipassanā)、明、解脱等出世间法’(《弥兰陀问经》Mi. pa. 2.1.13)这一段经文的剩余部分。“长老”(Therena)是指龙军(Nāgasena)长老。他以诸法之作用与相来解释说:‘念以不忘失为相,寻以冲击为相’等等,如是诸法易于理解。对治迷失的作用即是不迷失,不仅仅是没有迷失的状态,故说‘或以不迷失为味’。由于某个法的力量,相应诸法能够面向所缘境,此法即是念。因此,念能够使它们现起面向所缘境之状态,或自身以面向所缘境的状态而现起,故说‘以面向所缘境为现起’。正确且值得称赞的觉支,即是“正觉支”(sambojjhaṅga)。是菩提——即将来解说的法和合的支分,或是觉悟的圣弟子的支分,故为觉支。“Yā hi”等词,阐明了简略所述的该义理。“此法之和合”与“被称为菩提”是相互关联的。“以法和合”即是以法之集合,与‘由彼法和合’相关联。“安住”(Patiṭṭhāna)与“积集”(āyūhana)在《度暴流经释义》(Oghataraṇasuttavaṇṇanāyaṃ)(《相应部注》Saṃ. ni. aṭṭha. 1.1.1)中说:‘依烦恼为安住,依行为积集。依爱与见为安住,依其余烦恼与行为积集。依爱为安住,依见为积集。依常见为安住,依断见为积集。依昏沉为安住,依掉举为积集。依耽著欲乐为安住,依自我折磨为积集。依一切不善行为安住,依一切世间善行为积集。’于此所述七种方式中,未说及者亦应依此了知。“作为对治”(Paṭipakkhabhūtāya)者,于此,对于昏沉的安住、耽著欲乐、断见执取,以择法、精进、喜为主的法和合是对治;对于掉举的积集、自我折磨、常见执取,以轻安、定、舍为主的法和合是对治。而念在这两种情况下都是需要的,诚如所说:“于一切处有用”(sabbatthikā)。 Kilesasantānaniddāya [Pg.250] uṭṭhahatīti etena sikhāppattavipassanāya sahagatānampi satiādīnaṃ bojjhaṅgabhāvaṃ dasseti. Vuṭṭhānagāminivipassanā hi kilese nirodhentī eva pavattatīti. Cattāri vātiādinā pana maggaphalasahagatānaṃ bojjhaṅgabhāvaṃ dasseti. Sattahi bojjhaṅgehi bhāvitehi saccappaṭivedho hotīti kathamidaṃ jānitabbanti codanaṃ sandhāyāha – ‘‘yathāhā’’tiādi. Jhānaṅgamaggaṅgādayo viyāti etena bodhibojjhaṅgasaddānaṃ samudāyāvayavavisayataṃ dasseti. Senaṅgarathaṅgādayo viyāti etena puggalapaññattiyā avijjamānapaññattibhāvaṃ dasseti. 从烦恼相续的睡眠中奋起,这显示了与达到顶点的毘婆舍那(vipassanā)相应的念等,也具有觉支的性质。因为导向出起的毘婆舍那,确实是以灭除烦恼的方式运行的。而“四等”句,则显示了与道、果相应的觉支的性质。如果说“七觉支被修习,就能证悟真理”,那么如何理解这一点呢?针对这个疑问,(论师)说“如经所说”等。如同禅支、道支等,这显示了菩提和觉支这两个词既可以指整体,也可以指部分。如同军队、战车等,这显示了个体(puggala)的概念是一种不存在的概念。 Bodhāya saṃvattantīti bojjhaṅgāti kāraṇattho aṅgasaddoti katvā vuttaṃ. Bujjhantīti bodhiyo, bodhiyo eva aṅgāni bojjhaṅgānīti vuttaṃ – ‘‘bujjhantīti bojjhaṅgā’’ti. Vipassanādīnaṃ kāraṇādīnaṃ bujjhitabbānañca saccānaṃ anurūpaṃ paccakkhabhāvena paṭimukhaṃ aviparītatāya sammā ca bujjhantīti evaṃ atthavisesadīpakehi upasaggehi ‘‘anubujjhantī’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Bodhisaddo hi sabbavisesayuttabujjhanaṃ sāmaññena saṅgaṇhāti. Saṃ-saddo pasaṃsāyaṃ sundarabhāve ca dissatīti āha – ‘‘pasattho sundaro ca bojjhaṅgo sambojjhaṅgo’’ti. 导向菩提,所以称为觉支,这是将“支”(aṅga)一词作原因义解。觉悟者们即是菩提,觉悟者们的支分即是觉支,如(论师)所说:‘因为觉悟,故称觉支’。与毘婆舍那(vipassanā)等原因以及所应觉知的诸谛相应,以现见、面对、不颠倒、正确的方式觉悟,因此用‘随觉’等具有特殊意义的接头词来说明。菩提一词以总括的方式涵盖了一切具有殊胜差别的觉悟。‘saṃ-’这个接头词表示称赞和美好,因此说:‘值得称赞的、美好的觉支,即是正觉支(sambojjhaṅga)。’ Dhamme vicinatīti dhammavicayo. Tattha dhammeti catusaccadhamme tabbinimuttassa sabhāvadhammassa abhāvato. Tato eva so pavicayalakkhaṇo. Obhāsanarasoti visayobhāsanaraso. Asammuyhanākārena paccupatiṭṭhatīti asammohapaccupaṭṭhāno. 于法观察,故称择法。此处“法”是指四圣谛法,因为离开了四圣谛,就没有自性法。因此,它的特相是辨别。它的作用是照亮所缘。以不迷乱的方式现起是它的现前相。 Vīrassa bhāvo, kammaṃ vāti vīriyaṃ. Īrayitabbatoti pavattetabbato. Paggahalakkhaṇanti kosajjapakkhe patituṃ adatvā sampayuttadhammānaṃ paggahalakkhaṇaṃ. Tato eva sampayuttadhamme upatthambhanarasaṃ. Anosīdanaṃ asaṃsīdanaṃ. 勇者的状态或行为,故称精进。因为应当策励。它的特相是策励,不使其落入懈怠一方,而策励相应法。因此,它的作用是支持相应法。它的现前相是不沉沦、不退转。 Pīṇayatīti tappeti. Pīṇanakiccena sampayuttadhammānaṃ viya taṃsamuṭṭhānapaṇītarūpehi kāyassābyapanaṃ. Pharaṇapītivasena hetaṃ lakkhaṇaṃ vuttaṃ, tathā rasoti. Udaggabhāvo odagyaṃ, taṃ paccupaṭṭhapetīti odagyapaccupaṭṭhānā. Ubbegapītivasena cetaṃ vuttaṃ. 使喜悦,即是使满足。以喜悦的作用,滋润相应诸法以及由它们生起的殊胜色法。此相是依遍满喜而说,作用亦如是。昂扬的状态即是踊跃,使之现起,故以踊跃为现起。这是依激动喜而说。 Kāyacittadarathappassambhanatoti kāyadarathassa cittadarathassa ca passambhanato vūpasamanato. Tenāha – ‘‘upasamalakkhaṇā’’ti, kāyacittadarathānaṃ [Pg.251] vūpasamanalakkhaṇāti attho. Kāyoti cettha vedanādayo tayo khandhā. Daratho sārambho, dukkhadomanassapaccayānaṃ uddhaccādikānaṃ kilesānaṃ, tathāpavattānaṃ vā catunnaṃ khandhānametaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Darathanimmaddanena pariḷāhaparipphandanavirahito sītibhāvo aparipphandanasītibhāvo. 身心热恼的平息,即是身热恼和心热恼的平息与止息。因此说“以止息为相”,意思是身心热恼止息的特相。这里的“身”指的是受等三蕴。“热恼”指的是激动,是苦和忧愁为缘的掉举等烦恼,或者是指如此流转的四蕴的同义词。通过摧毁热恼,远离热恼和动荡,获得清凉无扰的寂静状态。 Sammā cittassa ṭhapanaṃ samādhānaṃ. Avikkhepo sampayuttānaṃ avikkhittatā. Yena sampayuttā avikkhittā honti, so dhammo avikkhepo. Avisāro attano eva avisaraṇabhāvo. Atha vā vikkhepappaṭipakkhatāya avikkhepalakkhaṇo. Nhānīyacuṇṇassa udakaṃ viya sampayuttadhammānaṃ sampiṇḍanakiccatāya avisārabhāvena lakkhitabbo avisāralakkhaṇo. Nivāte dīpacciṭṭhiti viya cetaso ṭhitibhāvena paccupatiṭṭhatīti cittaṭṭhitipaccupaṭṭhāno. 心的善安立是等持。不散乱是相应法的不散乱性。使相应法不散乱的法,即是不散乱。不流散是自身的不流散性。或者,因其为散乱的对立面,故以不散乱为相。犹如水凝聚沐浴粉,因其有凝聚相应法的作用,故以不流散为相。如无风处的灯焰,以心的安住状态为现起,即是心住的现起。 Ajjhupekkhanatoti samappavattesu assesu sārathi viya sampayuttadhammānaṃ ajjhupekkhanato. Paṭisaṅkhānalakkhaṇāti majjhattabhāve ṭhatvā vīmaṃsanasaṅkhātappaṭisaṅkhānalakkhaṇā. Samavāhitalakkhaṇāti samaṃ avisamaṃ yathāsakakiccesu sampayuttadhammānaṃ pavattanalakkhaṇā. Udāsīnabhāvena pavattamānāpi sesasampayuttadhamme yathāsakakiccesu pavatteti, yathā rājā tuṇhī nisinnopi atthakaraṇe dhammaṭṭhe yathāsakaṃ kiccesu appamatto pavatteti. Alīnānuddhatappavattipaccayattā ūnādhikanivāraṇarasā. Pakkhapātupacchedanarasāti ‘‘idaṃ nihīnakiccaṃ hotu, idaṃ atirekatarakicca’’nti evaṃ pakkhapātanavasena viya pavatti pakkhapāto, taṃ upacchindantī viya hotīti pakkhapātupacchedanarasā. Sampayuttadhammānaṃ sakasakakicce majjhattabhāvena paccupatiṭṭhatīti majjhattabhāvapaccupaṭṭhāno. Bojjhaṅgānaṃ uparūpari uppādanameva brūhanaṃ vaḍḍhanañcāti āha – ‘‘uppādetī’’ti. 平等观照,犹如御者之于平稳行进的诸马,是对相应法的平等观照。以审察为相,即住于中立状态而行考察之相。以平衡运作为相,即使相应法于各自的作用中平等、不偏地运作之相。虽以中立之态运作,却能令其余相应法各尽其职,犹如国王默然安坐,仍能令司法官于各自事务中不放逸地行事。因其为远离沉滞与掉举之运作的缘,故以防止过与不及为作用。以断除偏袒为作用,即断除“令此事不足,令彼事过度”之类的偏袒。以相应法各司其职时的中立状态为现起,即是中立的现起。觉支的次第生起即是培育与增长,故说“令生起”。 Sati ca sampajaññañca satisampajaññaṃ, satipadhānaṃ vā sampajaññaṃ satisampajaññaṃ. Taṃ sabbattha satokāribhāvāvahattā satisambojjhaṅgassa uppādāya hoti. Yathā paccanīkadhammappahānaṃ anurūpadhammasevanā ca anuppannānaṃ kusalānaṃ dhammānaṃ uppādāya hoti, evaṃ satirahitapuggalavivajjanā, satokāripuggalasevanā, tattha ca yuttatā satisambojjhaṅgassa uppādāya [Pg.252] hotīti imamatthaṃ dasseti, ‘‘satisampajañña’’ntiādinā. Sattasu ṭhānesūti ‘‘abhikkante paṭikkante sampajānakārī hoti, ālokite vilokite sampajānakārī hoti, samiñjite pasārite sampajānakārī hoti, saṅghāṭipattacīvaradhāraṇe sampajānakārī hoti, asite pīte khāyite sāyite sampajānakārī hoti, uccārapassāvakamme sampajānakārī hoti, gate ṭhite nisinne sutte jāgarite bhāsite tuṇhībhāve sampajānakārī hotī’’ti (dī. ni. 2.376; ma. ni. 1.109) evaṃ vuttesu abhikkantādīsu sattasu ṭhānesu. Tissadattatthero nāma yo bodhimaṇḍe suvaṇṇasalākaṃ gahetvā ‘‘aṭṭhārasasu bhāsāsu katarabhāsāya dhammaṃ kathemī’’ti parisaṃ padhāresi. Abhayattheroti dattābhayattheramāha. Abhinivesanti vipassanābhinivesaṃ. 念(sati)与正知(sampajañña)为“念正知”(satisampajañña);或以念为主的正知为“念正知”。因为它在一切处都能带来正念行事,所以能促进念觉支(satisambojjhaṅga)的生起。正如舍弃相违之法、修习随顺之法,能够令未生之善法生起一样;远离失念之人、亲近具念之人,并且于彼处精勤,也能促进念觉支的生起。此义由“念正知”等语所开示。所谓“七处”,就是指在“前进后退时保持正知,左右顾盼时保持正知,屈伸时保持正知,穿着僧伽梨(saṅghāṭi)、手持衣钵(pattacīvara)时保持正知,食、饮、嚼、尝时保持正知,大小便利时保持正知,行、住、坐、卧、醒、语、默时保持正知”(长部2.376;中部1.109)等经文中所说的七种处境。帝萨达多(Tissadatta)长老,是指在菩提座(bodhimaṇḍa)下拿着金筹,思量“我应该用十八种语言中的哪一种来向会众说法”的那位长老。无畏长老(Abhayatthera)是指达多无畏长老(Dattābhayatthera)。执取,指的是对观(vipassanā)的执取。 Paripucchakatāti pariyogāhetvā pucchakabhāvo. Ācariye payirupāsitvā pañcapi nikāye saha aṭṭhakathāya pariyogāhetvā yaṃ yaṃ tattha gaṇṭhiṭṭhānabhūtaṃ, taṃ taṃ ‘‘idaṃ, bhante, kathaṃ, imassa ko attho’’ti khandhāyatanādiatthaṃ pucchantassa hi dhammavicayasambojjhaṅgo uppajjati. Tenāha – ‘‘khandhadhātu…pe… bahulatā’’ti. 反复询问,是指在彻底通达之后提问的状态。亲近阿阇梨,将五部尼柯耶(Nikāya)连同其义注(aṭṭhakathā)一并通达之后,每当遇到其中的疑难之处,便请教:“尊者,这是怎么回事?此是何义?”如此询问蕴、处等义理,择法觉支(dhammavicayasambojjhaṅga)便会生起。是故说:“蕴、界……多修习。” Vatthuvisadakiriyāti ettha cittacetasikānaṃ pavattiṭṭhānabhāvato sarīraṃ tappaṭibaddhāni cīvarādīni ca vatthūnīti adhippetāni. Tāni yathā cittassa sukhāvahāni honti, tathā karaṇaṃ tesaṃ visadakiriyā. Tenāha – ‘‘ajjhattikabāhirāna’’ntiādi. Ussannadosanti vātapittādivasena upacitadosaṃ. Sedamalamakkhitanti sedena ceva jallikāsaṅkhātena sarīramalena ca makkhitaṃ. Ca-saddena aññampi sarīrassa pīḷāvahaṃ accāsanādiṃ saṅgaṇhāti. Senāsanaṃ vāti vā-saddena malaggahitapattādīnaṃ saṅgaho daṭṭhabbo. Paribhaṇḍakaraṇādīhīti ādi-saddena pattapacanādīnaṃ saṅgaho daṭṭhabbo. Avisadeti vatthumhi avisade sati, visayabhūte vā. Kathaṃ bhāvanamanuyuttassa tāni ajjhattikabāhiravatthūni visayo? Antarantarā pavattanakacittuppādavaseneva vuttaṃ. Te hi cittuppādā cittekaggatāya aparisuddhabhāvāya saṃvattanti. Cittacetasikesūti nissayādipaccayabhūtesu cittacetasikesu. Ñāṇampīti api-saddo sampiṇḍanattho. Tena ‘‘na kevalaṃ vatthuyeva, atha kho tasmiṃ aparisuddhe ñāṇampi aparisuddhaṃ [Pg.253] hotī’’ti nissayāparisuddhiyā taṃnissitāparisuddhi viya visayassa aparisuddhatāya visayino aparisuddhiṃ dasseti. 于“事物清净”(vatthuvisadakiriyā)一句中,所谓“事物”(vatthu),意指作为心与心所生起之处的身体,以及与身体相关的衣袍等。使它们能为心带来安乐,即是令其清净。是故说“内外”等。“病增盛”(ussannadosa)指因风、胆汁等而积聚的病。“为汗垢所染”(sedamalamakkhita)指为汗水及名为“垢”(jallikā)的身体污垢所染。“ca”字亦包含对身体有害的过食等。“或卧坐具”(senāsanaṃ vā)一句中的“或”字,当知亦包含被污垢所染的钵等。“通过整理用具等”一句中的“等”字,当知亦包含煮钵食等。“不净”(avisada)指当事物不净时,或当其成为所缘时。修习者如何以内外事物为所缘(visaya)?此乃就间断生起的心识活动而言。那些心识的生起,会导致心一境性(cittekaggatā)的不清净。“于心与心所”(cittacetasikesu)指于作为依止等缘的心与心所。“智亦”(ñāṇampi)一句中的“亦”(api)字为总括义。是故,“不仅事物不净,当其不净时,智亦不清净”,此句显示了所缘不净则能缘者亦不净,犹如依止不净则所依者亦不净。 Samabhāvakaraṇanti kiccato anūnādhikabhāvakaraṇaṃ. Saddhindriyaṃ balavaṃ hoti, saddheyyavatthusmiṃ paccayavasena adhimokkhakiccassa paṭutarabhāvena paññāya avisadatāya vīriyādīnañca sithilatādinā saddhindriyaṃ balavaṃ hoti. Tenāha – ‘‘itarāni mandānī’’ti. Tatoti tasmā, saddhindriyassa balavabhāvato itaresañca mandattāti attho. Kosajjapakkhe patituṃ adatvā sampayuttadhammānaṃ paggaṇhanaṃ anubalappadānaṃ paggaho. Paggahova kiccaṃ paggahakiccaṃ. Kātuṃ na sakkotīti ānetvā sambandhitabbaṃ. Ārammaṇaṃ upagantvā ṭhānaṃ, anissajjanaṃ vā upaṭṭhānaṃ. Vikkhepappaṭipakkho, yena vā sampayuttā avikkhittā honti, so avikkhepo. Rūpagataṃ viya cakkhunā yena yāthāvato visayasabhāvaṃ passati, taṃ dassanakiccaṃ kātuṃ na sakkoti balavatā saddhindriyena adhibhūtattā. Sahajātadhammesu hi indaṭṭhaṃ kārentānaṃ sahapavattamānānaṃ dhammānaṃ ekadesatāvaseneva atthasiddhi, na aññathā. Tasmāti vuttamevatthaṃ kāraṇabhāvena paccāmasati. Tanti saddhindriyaṃ. Dhammasabhāvapaccavekkhaṇenāti yassa saddheyyassa vatthuno uḷāratādiguṇe adhimuccanassa sātisayappavattiyā saddhindriyaṃ balavaṃ jātaṃ, tassa paccayapaccayuppannatādivibhāgato yāthāvato vīmaṃsanena. Evañhi evaṃdhammatānayena yāthāvasarasato pariggayhamāne savipphāro adhimokkho na hoti ‘‘ayaṃ imesaṃ dhammānaṃ sabhāvo’’ti parijānanavasena paññābyāpārassa sātisayattā. Dhuriyadhammesu hi yathā saddhāya balavabhāve paññāya mandabhāvo hoti, evaṃ paññāya balavabhāve saddhāya mandabhāvo hoti. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘taṃ dhammasabhāvapaccavekkhaṇena hāpetabba’’nti. “平衡作用”(samabhāvakaraṇa)是指作用上无增无减。信根(saddhindriya)强盛,是指在可信赖的对象上,由于胜解(adhimokkha)作用特别敏锐,智慧(paññā)不清晰,精进(vīriya)等也变得迟钝,因此信根就显得强盛。因此说:“其余诸根就变得微弱”。“因此”(tato),即是说,由于信根强盛,其余诸根就显得微弱了。“策励”(paggaha)是不让懈怠(kosajja)有可乘之机,支持和辅助相应诸法。策励本身就是策励的作用(kicca)。“不能做”(kātuṃ na sakkoti)应联系上下文。“现起”(upaṭṭhāna)是趋近所缘(ārammaṇa)而安住,或是不舍弃。“不散乱”(avikkhepa)是散乱(vikkhepa)的对治,通过不散乱使相应诸法不散乱。如同眼睛看到色法(rūpagata),能够如实地了知所缘(visaya)的自性,却不能完成见的作用(dassanakicca),这是因为被强盛的信根所压制。在俱生法(sahajātadhamma)中,当诸法同时运作并行使根的作用时,唯有通过它们的协同一致,才能成就其事,别无他途。“因此”(tasmā),前面所说的道理作为原因来忆念。“它”(taṃ)指的是信根。“通过观察法性”(dhammasabhāvapaccavekkhaṇa),是指对于可信赖对象的高尚功德等产生特别的胜解(adhimuccana)时,信根就会变得强盛,对于这种因缘(paccaya)所生(paccayuppanna)的种种差别进行如实的审察。如果能够这样依循着事物的本来面目(evaṃdhammatānaya)去把握,胜解就不会变得过度广大,因为智慧(paññā)的作用(byāpāra)增强了,能够如实地了解“这就是诸法的自性”。在主要诸法(dhuriyadhamma)中,如果信(saddhā)强,那么慧(paññā)就会弱;如果慧强,那么信就会弱。所以说:“应该通过观察法性来削弱它”。 Tathā amanasikārenāti yenākārena bhāvanamanuyuñjantassa saddhindriyaṃ balavaṃ jātaṃ, tenākārena bhāvanāya ananuyuñjanatoti vuttaṃ hoti. Idha duvidhena saddhindriyassa balavabhāvo attano vā paccayavisesena kiccuttariyato vīriyādīnaṃ vā mandakiccatāya. Tattha paṭhamavikappe hāpanavidhi dassito, dutiyavikappe pana yathā manasikaroto vīriyādīnaṃ mandakiccatāya saddhindriyaṃ balavaṃ jātaṃ, tathā amanasikārena vīriyādīnaṃ [Pg.254] paṭukiccabhāvāvahena manasikārena saddhindriyaṃ tehi samarasaṃ karontena hāpetabbaṃ. Iminā nayena sesindriyesupi hāpanavidhi veditabbo. 同样,“不作意”是指,修行者以何种方式勤修而导致信根变得强盛,就不再以那种方式勤修。此处信根强盛有两种情况:一是自身有特殊因缘,导致作用优越;二是精进等作用微弱。在第一种情况中,已经说明了削弱的方法;在第二种情况中,若因某种作意导致精进等作用微弱而使信根强盛,则应停止那种作意,并通过能令精进等作用变得敏锐的作意,使信根与其他诸根达到平衡,从而将其削弱。依此方法,其余诸根的削弱方法也应当这样理解。 Vakkalittheravatthūti so hi āyasmā saddhādhimuttatāya katādhikāro satthu rūpadassanappasuto eva hutvā viharanto satthārā ‘‘kiṃ te, vakkali, iminā pūtikāyena diṭṭhena, yo kho, vakkali, dhammaṃ passati, so maṃ passatī’’tiādinā (saṃ. ni. 3.87) nayena ovaditvā kammaṭṭhāne niyojitopi taṃ ananuyuñjanto paṇāmito attānaṃ vinipātetuṃ papātaṭṭhānaṃ abhiruhi. Atha naṃ satthā yathānisinnova obhāsavissajjanena attānaṃ dassetvā – 瓦咖利长老的故事是这样的:这位具寿(āyasmā)因信增上,只是一味沉溺于瞻仰导师的色身而住。导师用“瓦咖利,看这腐朽的身体有什么用呢?瓦咖利,见法者即见我”等(《相应部》3.87)道理教诫他,即使为他讲了禅修业处,他也不肯勤奋修行,于是灰心丧气,想要跳崖自杀。这时,导师仍然坐在原地,放出光明,显现自身,对他说—— ‘‘Pāmojjabahulo bhikkhu, pasanno buddhasāsane; Adhigacche padaṃ santaṃ, saṅkhārūpasamaṃ sukha’’nti. (dha. pa. 381) – 比丘若常乐欢喜,于佛陀教法中具净信;当证寂静之境,诸行止息之乐。 Gāthaṃ vatvā ‘‘ehi, vakkalī’’ti āha. So teneva amatena abhisitto haṭṭhatuṭṭho hutvā vipassanaṃ paṭṭhapesi, saddhāya pana balavabhāvena vipassanāvīthiṃ na otari. Taṃ ñatvā bhagavā tassa indriyasamattappaṭipādanāya kammaṭṭhānaṃ sodhetvā adāsi. So satthārā dinnanaye ṭhatvā vipassanaṃ ussukkāpetvā maggappaṭipāṭiyā arahattaṃ pāpuṇi. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘vakkalittheravatthu cettha nidassana’’nti. Etthāti saddhindriyassa adhimattabhāve sesindriyānaṃ sakiccākaraṇe. Itarakiccabhedanti upaṭṭhānādikiccavisesaṃ. Passaddhādīti ādi-saddena samādhiupekkhāsambojjhaṅgānaṃ saṅgaho. Hāpetabbanti yathā saddhindriyassa balavabhāvo dhammasabhāvapaccavekkhaṇena hāyati, evaṃ vīriyindriyassa adhimattatā passaddhiādibhāvanāya hāyati samādhipakkhiyattā tassā. Tathā hi samādhindriyassa adhimattataṃ kosajjapātato rakkhantī vīriyādibhāvanā viya vīriyindriyassa adhimattataṃ uddhaccapātato rakkhantī passaddhādibhāvanā ekaṃsato hāpeti. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘passaddhādibhāvanāya hāpetabba’’nti. 导师说完偈颂后,说:“来,瓦咖利。”瓦咖利听闻这甘露法语,欢喜踊跃,开始修习观。但由于信根过于强大,他未能进入观的路径。世尊知道后,为了使他的诸根平衡,调整禅修方法并教导他。瓦咖利依循导师所教导的方法安住,努力修习观,依照次第证得阿罗汉果。因此说:“这里以瓦咖利长老的事迹作为例子。”这里是指当信根过强时,其余诸根不能各司其职。其他作用的差别是指念等作用的特殊性。“轻安等”中的“等”字包含定、舍觉支。所谓“应当削弱”是指如同以观察法性来削弱信根的强大,同样要通过修习轻安等来削弱精进根的过强,因为轻安等属于止的一方。正如修习精进等能防止定根落入懈怠,修习轻安等也能防止精进根落入掉举,从而削弱其过强之势。因此说:“应当通过修习轻安等来削弱。” Soṇattherassa vatthūti sukhumālasoṇattherassa vatthu. So hi āyasmā satthu santike kammaṭṭhānaṃ gahetvā sītavane viharanto ‘‘mama sarīraṃ sukhumālaṃ, na ca sakkā sukheneva sukhaṃ adhigantuṃ, kilametvāpi samaṇadhammo [Pg.255] kātabbo’’ti ṭhānacaṅkamameva adhiṭṭhāya padhānamanuyuñjanto pādatalesu phoṭesu uṭṭhitesupi vedanaṃ ajjhupekkhitvā daḷhavīriyaṃ karonto accāraddhavīriyatāya visesaṃ nibbattetuṃ nāsakkhi. Satthā tattha gantvā vīṇūpamovādena ovaditvā vīriyasamatāyojanavidhiṃ dassento kammaṭṭhānaṃ visodhetvā gijjhakūṭaṃ gato. Theropi satthārā dinnanayena vīriyasamataṃ yojetvā bhāvento vipassanampi ussukkāpetvā arahatte patiṭṭhāsi. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘soṇattherassa vatthu dassetabba’’nti. Sesesupīti satisamādhipaññindriyesupi. 索那(Soṇa)长老的故事。这位具寿(āyasmā)从导师处领受业处后,住在寒林中。他想:“我的身体娇嫩,不能轻易地通过安逸获得安乐,即使疲惫也要修行沙门法。”于是下定决心,只通过站立和经行来精进修行。即使脚底起了水泡,感受到了疼痛,他也保持忍耐,以坚定的精进修行。但由于过度精进,未能生起殊胜的证悟。导师前往那里,用琴的比喻来教诫他,指示了调和精进的方法,并且净化了他的业处,然后前往鹫峰山。长老依照导师所教的方法,调和精进,并且努力修习观,最终证得了阿罗汉果。因此说:“应当讲述索那长老的故事”。其余的也一样,是指念、定、慧等诸根。 Samatanti saddhāpaññānaṃ aññamaññaṃ anūnādhikabhāvaṃ, tathā samādhivīriyānaṃ. Yathā hi saddhāpaññānaṃ visuṃ dhuriyadhammabhūtānaṃ kiccato aññamaññānativattanaṃ visesato icchitabbaṃ, yato nesaṃ samadhuratāya appanā sampajjati, evaṃ samādhivīriyānaṃ kosajjuddhaccapakkhikānaṃ samarasatāya sati aññamaññūpatthambhanato sampayuttadhammānaṃ antadvayapātābhāvena sammadeva appanā ijjhati. Balavasaddhotiādi byatirekamukhena vuttassevatthassa samatthanaṃ. Tassattho – yo balavatiyā saddhāya samannāgato avisadañāṇo, so mudhappasanno hoti, na aveccappasanno. Tathā hi avatthusmiṃ pasīdati seyyathāpi titthiyasāvakā. Kerāṭikapakkhanti sāṭheyyapakkhaṃ bhajati. Saddhāhīnāya paññāya atidhāvanto ‘‘deyyavatthupariccāgena vinā cittuppādamattenapi dānamayaṃ puññaṃ hotī’’tiādīni parikappeti hetuppaṭirūpakehi vañcito, evaṃbhūto sukkhatakkaviluttacitto paṇḍitānaṃ vacanaṃ nādiyati, saññattiṃ na gacchati. Tenāha – ‘‘bhesajjasamuṭṭhito viya rogo atekiccho hotī’’ti. Yathā cettha saddhāpaññānaṃ aññamaññaṃ samabhāvo atthāvaho, anatthāvaho visamabhāvo, evaṃ samādhivīriyānaṃ aññamaññaṃ avikkhepāvaho samabhāvo, itaro vikkhepāvaho cāti kosajjaṃ abhibhavati, tena appanaṃ na pāpuṇātīti adhippāyo. Uddhaccaṃ abhibhavatīti etthāpi eseva nayo. Taṃ ubhayanti saddhāpaññādvayaṃ samādhivīriyadvayañca. Samaṃ kattabbanti samarasaṃ kātabbaṃ. 平衡,是指信与慧相互间无增无减,定与精进亦然。信与慧各自作为主导法,在作用上需要互不超越,因为它们的平衡能成就安止。同样,定与精进分别对治懈怠与掉举,当它们力量均等时,能相互扶持,使相应诸法不堕二边,从而圆满成就安止。所谓“信强者”等,是以反面的方式来阐明此义。其义为:若人信根强盛而智慧不明,则成盲信,非不坏净信,犹如外道弟子于不实之处生起净信。若以信心薄弱的智慧驰骋,则会趋向狡诈,被似是而非的理由所欺,妄加揣测:“无需舍弃所施之物,仅凭心念生起即是布施福德”等。如此之人,心为干枯的逻辑所掠夺,不听智者之言,不受劝告。故说:“如病由药起,则不可救药。”于此,信与慧的平衡带来利益,不平衡则带来损害。同样,定与精进的平衡带来不散乱,不平衡则带来散乱。这是说,(若定强于精进,)则为懈怠所胜,故不能证得安止。(若精进强于定,)则为掉举所胜,此理亦然。“彼二者”,是指信慧二者与定进二者。“应作平等”,即应使之力量均等。 Samādhikammikassāti samathakammaṭṭhānikassa. Evanti evaṃ sante, saddhāya thokaṃ balavabhāve satīti attho. Saddahantoti ‘‘pathavī pathavīti manasikaraṇamattena [Pg.256] kathaṃ jhānuppattī’’ti acintetvā ‘‘addhā sammāsambuddhena vuttavidhi ijjhissatī’’ti saddahanto saddhaṃ janento. Okappentoti ārammaṇaṃ anuppavisitvā viya adhimuccanavasena avakappento pakkhandanto. Ekaggatā balavatī vaṭṭati samādhippadhānattā jhānassa. Ubhinnanti samādhipaññānaṃ. Samādhikammikassa samādhino adhimattatā viya paññāya adhimattatāpi icchitabbāti āha – ‘‘samatāyapī’’ti, samabhāvenapīti attho. Appanāti lokiyaappanā. Tathā hi ‘‘hotiyevā’’ti sāsaṅkaṃ vadati. Lokuttarappanā pana tesaṃ samabhāveneva icchitā. Yathāha – ‘‘samathavipassanaṃ yuganaddhaṃ bhāvetī’’ti (a. ni. 4.170; paṭi. ma. 2.5). “修习定业者”,即修习止业处者。“如是”,即在这样的情况下,意思是当信心稍微强盛时。“信受者”,是说不思虑“仅作意‘地、地’如何能生起禅那”,而是确信“正自觉者所说之法必定成就”,从而生起信心。“倾信者”,是说以胜解的方式,犹如已进入所缘,而跃入其中。因为禅那以定为主,故心一境性应强盛。“二者”,指定与慧。对于修习定业者,正如希求定的增上,也应希求慧的增上,故说“亦应平等”,意即(二者)也应处于平衡状态。“安止”,指世间安止。因此,(经中)才带有疑虑地说“确实会有的”。而出世间安止,则只求二者平衡。如言:“止观双运而修习”。 Yadi visesato saddhāpaññānaṃ samādhivīriyānañca samatāva icchitā, kathaṃ satīti āha – ‘‘sati pana sabbattha balavatī vaṭṭatī’’ti. Sabbatthāti līnuddhaccapakkhikesu pañcasu indriyesu. Uddhaccapakkhike gaṇhanto ‘‘saddhāvīriyapaññāna’’nti āha. Aññathāpīti ca gahetabbā siyā. Tathā hi kosajjapakkhikena ca samādhināicceva vuttaṃ, na ‘‘passaddhisamādhiupekkhāhī’’ti. Sāti sati. Sabbesu rājakammesu niyutto sabbakammiko. Tenāti tena sabbattha icchitabbatthena kāraṇena. Āha aṭṭhakathāyaṃ. Sabbattha niyuttā sabbatthikā sabbattha līne uddhate ca citte icchitabbattā, sabbena vā līnuddhaccapakkhiyena bojjhaṅgagaṇena atthetabbāti sabbatthā, sāva sabbatthikā. Cittanti kusalacittaṃ. Tassa hi satipaṭisaraṇaṃ parāyaṇaṃ appattassa pattiyā anadhigatassa adhigamāya. Tenāha – ‘‘ārakkhapaccupaṭṭhānā’’tiādi. 若特别希求信与慧、定与精进的平衡,那么念又如何?答曰:“然而念在一切处皆强盛为宜。”“一切处”,指在与沉滞、掉举相关的五根中。当论及掉举一方时,说“信、精进、慧”。也应有其他理解。因为对于懈怠一方,只说了定,而未说“轻安、定、舍”。“彼”即是念。如国王的大臣,遍理一切事务。“是故”,即因此念于一切处皆为所需。义注中说:“遍一切处适用,故为‘遍一切处用’;因心沉滞或掉举时皆需念,或因一切与沉滞、掉举相关的觉支组皆需念,故为‘遍一切处用’,彼即是‘遍一切处用’之义。”“心”,指善心。念实为善心之护卫与归宿,为令未得者得,未证者证。故说“以守护为现前”等。 Khandhādibhedesu anogāḷhapaññānanti pariyattibāhusaccavasenapi khandhāyatanādīsu appatiṭṭhitabuddhīnaṃ. Bahussutasevanā hi sutamayañāṇāvahā. Taruṇavipassanāsamaṅgīpi bhāvanāmayañāṇe ṭhitattā ekaṃsato paññavā eva nāma hotīti āha – ‘‘samapaññāsa…pe… puggalasevanā’’ti. Ñeyyadhammassa gambhīrabhāvavasena tapparicchedakañāṇassa gambhīrabhāvaggahaṇanti āha – ‘‘gambhīresu khandhādīsu pavattāya gambhīrapaññāyā’’ti. Tañhi ñeyyaṃ tādisāya paññāya caritabbato gambhīrañāṇacariyaṃ. Tassā vā paññāya tattha pabhedato pavatti gambhīrañāṇacariyā, tassā paccavekkhaṇāti āha – ‘‘gambhīrapaññāya pabhedapaccavekkhaṇā’’ti. “于蕴等差别慧未深入者”,是说即使博学多闻,于蕴、处等法智慧仍未确立者。亲近多闻者能带来闻所成智。即使具足初观者,因安住于修所成智,故确实可称为有慧者,因此说:“与具足同等智慧……乃至……亲近此人”。因所知法甚深,故抉择彼之智亦甚深,是说:“于甚深之蕴等中转起的甚深智慧”。彼所知法应由此等智慧行之,故为“深智行”。或彼智慧于其中由差别而转起,即是“深智行”;对此的省察,故说:“对甚深智慧的差别省察”。 Pañcavidhabandhanakammakāraṇaṃ [Pg.257] niraye nibbattasattassa yebhuyyena sabbapaṭhamaṃ karontīti devadūtasuttādīsu ādito vuttattā ca āha – ‘‘pañcavidhabandhanakammakāraṇato paṭṭhāyā’’ti. Sakaṭavahanādikāleti ādi-saddena tadaññaṃ manussehi tiracchānehi ca vibādhitabbakālaṃ saṅgaṇhāti. Ekaṃ buddhantaranti idaṃ aparāparesu petesuyeva uppajjanakasattavasena vuttaṃ, ekaccānaṃ vā petānaṃ ekaccatiracchānānaṃ viya dīghāyukatā siyāti tathā vuttaṃ. Tathā hi kāḷo nāgarājā catunnaṃ buddhānaṃ sammukhībhāvaṃ labhitvā ṭhitopi metteyyassapi bhagavato sammukhībhāvaṃ labhissatīti vadanti, yatassa kappāyukatā vuttā. “五种束缚业”,因为在地狱中受生的有情,大多最先造作此业,且在《天使经》(Devadūtasutta)等经中最初即有宣说,故云:“从五种束缚业开始”。“牵车等时”,此中“等”字,摄余被人与畜生所恼害之时。“一佛之间”,此是就辗转投生为饿鬼的众生而说;或因某些饿鬼可能如某些畜生般长寿,故如是说。诚然,据说黑龙王(Kāḷo nāgarājā)曾得见四佛,未来还将得见弥勒(Metteyya)世尊,因其寿命长达一劫。 Evaṃ ānisaṃsadassāvinoti vīriyāyatto eva sabbo lokiyo lokuttaro ca visesādhigamoti evaṃ vīriye ānisaṃsadassanasīlassa. Gamanavīthinti sapubbabhāgaṃ nibbānagāminipaṭipadaṃ, saha vipassanāya ariyamaggappaṭipāṭi, sattavisuddhiparamparā vā. Sā hi ‘‘bhikkhuno vaṭṭaniyyānāya gantabbā paṭipajjitabbā paṭipadā’’ti katvā gamanavīthi nāma. “如是见功德者”,即如是见精进之功德者,谓一切世间与出世间之殊胜成就,皆依精进而得。“行道”,指具前行部分的趣涅槃之道,或与观(vipassanā)相应的圣道次第,或七清净的次第相续。此道乃“比丘为出离轮回所应行、所应修之道”,故名为“行道”。 Kāyadaḷhībahuloti yathā tathā kāyassa daḷhīkammappasuto. Piṇḍapātanti raṭṭhapiṇḍaṃ. Paccayadāyakānaṃ attani kārassa attano sammāpaṭipattiyā mahapphalabhāvassa karaṇena piṇḍassa bhikkhāya paṭipūjanā piṇḍapātāpacāyanaṃ. “多强身者”,指不择手段致力于强化身体者。“乞食”,指从村落所得之食。“尊敬乞食”,是说通过自身的正确修行,使资具施主对自己所作的供养能有大果报,以此来回报所得之食。 Nīharantoti pattatthavikato nīharanto. Taṃ saddaṃ sutvāti taṃ upāsikāya vacanaṃ paṇṇasālādvāre ṭhitova pañcābhiññatāya dibbasotena sutvā. Manussasampatti, dibbasampatti, nibbānasampattīti imā tisso sampattiyo. Dātuṃ sakkhissasīti tayi katena dānamayena veyyāvaccamayena ca puññakammena khettavisesabhāvūpagamanena aparāparaṃ devamanussānaṃ sampattiyo ante nibbānasampattiñca dātuṃ sakkhissasīti thero attānaṃ pucchati. Sitaṃ karontoti ‘‘akiccheneva mayā vaṭṭadukkhaṃ samatikkanta’’nti paccavekkhaṇāvasāne sañjātapāmojjavasena sitaṃ karonto. “取出”,是指从钵中取出食物者。“闻其声已”,是指长老站在草庵门口,以五神通中的天耳通听到了那位优婆夷说的话。人间成就、天界成就、涅槃成就,这三种称为成就。“你能施与”是长老自问:你能以你所做的布施功德、服务功德,以及作为殊胜福田的功德,不断地给予天人与人类各种成就,最终给予涅槃成就吗?“展颜微笑”是因为在省察“我已轻易地超越轮回苦”之后,由于喜悦而露出了笑容。 Nipparissayakāloti nirupaddavakālo, tadā bhikkhusaṅghassa sulabhā paccayā hontīti paccayahetukā cittapīḷā natthīti adhippāyo. Passantānaṃyevāti anādare sāmivacanaṃ. Khīradhenunti khīradāyikaṃ dhenuṃ[Pg.258]. Kiñcideva katvāti kiñcideva bhatikammaṃ katvā. Ucchuyantakammanti ucchuyantasālāya kātabbaṃ kiccaṃ. Tameva magganti upāsakena paṭipannamaggaṃ. Upakaṭṭhāyāti āsannāya. Vippaṭipannanti jātidhammakuladhammādilaṅghanena asammāpaṭipannaṃ. Evanti yathā asammāpaṭipanno putto tāya eva asammāpaṭipattiyā kulasantānato bāhiro hutvā pitu santikā dāyajjassa na bhāgī, evaṃ kusītopi teneva kusītabhāvena na sammāpaṭipanno satthu santikā laddhabbaariyadhanadāyajjassa na bhāgī. Āraddhavīriyova labhati sammāpaṭipajjanato. Uppajjati vīriyasambojjhaṅgoti yojanā, evaṃ sabbattha. “无灾时节”是指没有障碍的时候,意思是那时比丘僧团容易获得资具,因此没有因资具而生的心苦。“见者尚且”是不尊重时的属格(sāmivacanaṃ)。“乳牛”是指能产奶的母牛。“做些什么事”就是做些什么活计。“甘蔗榨坊的工作”是指在甘蔗榨坊应该做的事情。“那条道路”即优婆塞所奉行的道路。“近处”是指临近。“违背”是指因违犯种姓法、家族法等而不如法行。“如是”就像不如法行的儿子,由于这种不如法行而从家族传承中脱离,不能从父亲那里分得遗产;同样地,懈怠者也因懈怠而不如法行,不能从导师那里获得本应获得的圣财之遗产。只有发起精勤者才能因为如法行而获得。应连接“生起精进觉支”,所有地方都这样理解。 Mahāti sīlādiguṇehi mahanto vipulo anaññasādhāraṇo. Taṃ panassa guṇamahattaṃ dasasahassilokadhātukampanena loke pākaṭanti dassento ‘‘satthuno hī’’tiādimāha. “大”是指具有戒等功德,伟大且非他人所能共有的。为了显示他的功德是如此伟大,以至于震动了十千世界,所以说了“导师之……”等。 Yasmā satthusāsane pabbajitassa pabbajjūpagamanena sakyaputtiyabhāvo sañjāyati, tasmā buddhaputtabhāvaṃ dassento ‘‘asambhinnāyā’’tiādimāha. 因随导师之教出家者,以出家而成就释迦子之身份,故为显示佛子之身份,而说“不混杂”等语。 Alasānaṃ bhāvanāya nāmamattampi ajānantānaṃ kāyadaḷhībahulānaṃ yāvadatthaṃ bhuñjitvā seyyasukhādianuyuñjanakānaṃ tiracchānagatikānaṃ puggalānaṃ dūrato vajjanā kusītapuggalaparivajjanāti āha – ‘‘kucchiṃ pūretvā ṭhitaajagarasadise’’tiādi. ‘‘Divasaṃ caṅkamena nisajjāya āvaraṇīyehi dhammehi cittaṃ parisodhessāmā’’tiādinā bhāvanārambhavasena āraddhavīriyānaṃ daḷhaparakkamānaṃ kālena kālaṃ upasaṅkamanā āraddhavīriyapuggalasevanāti āha – ‘‘āraddhavīriye’’tiādi. Visuddhimagge (visuddhi. 1.64-65) pana jātimahattapaccavekkhaṇā sabrahmacārimahattapaccavekkhaṇāti idaṃ dvayaṃ na gahitaṃ, thinamiddhavinodanatā sammappadhānapaccavekkhaṇatāti idaṃ dvayaṃ gahitaṃ. Tattha ānisaṃsadassāvitāya eva sammappadhānapaccavekkhaṇā gahitā hoti lokiyalokuttaravisesādhigamassa vīriyāyattatādassanabhāvato, thinamiddhavinodanaṃ pana tadadhimuttatāya eva gahitaṃ hoti. Vīriyuppādane yuttappayuttassa thinamiddhavinodanaṃ atthasiddhamevāti. Tattha [Pg.259] thinamiddhavinodanakusītapuggalaparivajjanaāraddhavīriyapuggalasevanatadadhi- muttatāpaṭipakkhavidhamanapaccayūpasaṃhāravasena apāyabhayapaccavekkhaṇādayo samuttejanavasena vīriyasambojjhaṅgassa uppādakā daṭṭhabbā. 那些连修习之名都不知、身体强壮又贪图饮食睡眠之乐、趋向畜生道的人,应当远离。如说:“吃饱喝足,如同蟒蛇。”那些常想“我当日日经行坐禅,从诸盖中净化内心”而开始勤修精进、勇猛不懈的人,应当适时亲近。如说:“亲近精进之人。”《清净道论》(Visuddhimagga)中没有采用思惟出身之伟大和思惟同梵行者之伟大这两种方法,而采用了去除昏沉睡眠和正勤思惟这两种方法。其中采用正勤思惟是因为表明世间和出世间的殊胜成就都依赖于精进;采用去除昏沉睡眠则是因为对精进有胜解的缘故。在努力产生精进时,去除昏沉睡眠自然就能实现。因此,去除昏沉睡眠、远离懈怠之人、亲近精进之人、对此有胜解,以及通过对治障碍、思惟恶道怖畏等,这些都应当被看作是能以激发的方式生起精进觉支的助缘。 Buddhānussatiyā upacārasamādhiniṭṭhattā vuttaṃ – ‘‘yāva upacārā’’ti. Sakalasarīraṃ pharamānoti pītisamuṭṭhānehi paṇītarūpehi sakalasarīraṃ pharamāno, dhammasaṅghaguṇe anussarantassapi yāva upacārā sakalasarīraṃ pharamāno pītisambojjhaṅgo uppajjatīti evaṃ sesaanussatīsu, pasādanīyasuttantapaccavekkhaṇāya ca yojetabbaṃ tassāpi vimuttāyatanabhāvena taggatikattā. Evarūpe kāleti ‘‘dubbhikkhabhayādīsū’’ti vuttakāle. Samāpatti…pe… na samudācarantīti idaṃ upasamānussatiyā vasena vuttaṃ. Saṅkhārānañhi vasena sappadesavūpasamepi nippadesavūpasame viya tathā saññāya pavattito bhāvanāmanasikāro kilesavikkhambhanasamattho hutvā upacārasamādhiṃ āvahanto tathārūpapītisomanassasamannāgato pītisambojjhaṅgassa upādāya hotīti. Tattha ‘‘vikkhambhitā kilesā’’ti pāṭho. Na samudācarantīti iti-saddo kāraṇattho. Yasmā na samudācaranti, tasmā taṃ nesaṃ asamudācāraṃ paccavekkhantassāti yojanā. Na hi kilese paccavekkhantassa bojjhaṅguppatti yuttā, pasādanīyesu ṭhānesu pasādasinehābhāvena lūkhahadayatāya lūkhatā. Sā tattha ādaragāravākaraṇena viññāyatīti āha – ‘‘asakkaccakiriyāya saṃsūcitalūkhabhāve’’ti. 因佛随念成就近行定,所以说“乃至近行”。以喜所生的殊胜色法遍满全身,忆念法、僧功德时,乃至近行定,喜觉支生起,其余随念也应如此。应与省察《悦意经》(Pasādanīyasuttanta)相应,因为这也是解脱处且趣向于此。所谓“如是时”,是指“饥荒等怖畏时”。入定……乃至……不现行,这是就寂止随念而言。因为诸行止息时,即使是部分的止息,由于作意仍然像完全止息一样进行,这种修习作意能够镇伏烦恼,引生近行定,并且伴随着喜乐,所以成为喜觉支的助缘。此处“烦恼已镇伏”是正确的读法。“不现行”中的“iti”表示原因。因为烦恼不现行,所以应连接为观察其不现行。若观察烦恼,则觉支不生起,因为在令人净信的境界中,由于缺乏净信与爱乐,心变得粗糙。此可通过不恭敬尊重而得知,所以说“因不恭敬的行为而显现粗糙的状态”。 Paṇītabhojanasevanatāti paṇītasappāyabhojanasevanatā. Utuiriyāpathasukhaggahaṇena sappāyautuiriyāpathaggahaṇaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. Tañhi tividhampi sappāyaṃ seviyamānaṃ kāyassa kalyatāpādanavasena cittassa kalyataṃ āvahantaṃ duvidhāyapi passaddhiyā kāraṇaṃ hoti. Ahetukasattesu labbhamānaṃ sukhadukkhanti ayameko anto, issarādivisamahetukanti pana ayaṃ dutiyo. Ete ubho ante anupagamma yathāsakaṃ kammunā hotīti ayaṃ majjhimā paṭipatti. Majjhatto payogo yassa so majjhattapayogo, tassa bhāvo majjhattapayogatā. Ayañhi sabhāvāsāraddhatāya taṃpassaddhakāyatāya kāraṇaṃ hoti, passaddhidvayaṃ [Pg.260] āvahati. Eteneva sāraddhakāyapuggalaparivajjanapassaddhakāyapuggalasevanānaṃ tadāvahanatā saṃvaṇṇitāti daṭṭhabbaṃ. 受用殊妙饮食,即是受用适宜的殊妙饮食。应当理解,受用适宜的时节与威仪也是如此。这三种适宜之事如果能够受用,能使身体康健,进而使心良善,成为引发两种轻安的因缘。无因的众生所感受的苦乐是一种极端,由自在天等不平等的因而产生的苦乐是另一种极端。不落入这两种极端,而是各自随业而有,这就是中道。具有中道勤勇的人,他的状态就是中道勤勇性。因为这种状态自然地不躁动,所以能使身心轻安,带来两种轻安。由此也应当明白,远离身心躁动的人,亲近身心轻安的人,都能带来轻安,这道理已经阐述过了。 Vatthuvisadakiriyā indriyasamattappaṭipādanā ca paññāvahā vuttā, samādhānāvahāpi tā honti. Samādhānāvahabhāveneva paññāvahabhāvatoti vuttaṃ – ‘‘vatthuvisadakiriyā…pe… veditabbā’’ti. 净治处所和调理诸根平衡,被称为能带来智慧,也能带来定。正因为能带来定,所以能带来智慧,因此说“净治处所……乃至……应当知晓”。 Kāraṇakosallabhāvanākosallānaṃ nānantariyabhāvato rakkhanākosallassa ca taṃmūlakattā ‘‘nimittakusalatā nāma kasiṇanimittassa uggahakusalatā’’icceva vuttaṃ. Kasiṇanimittassāti ca nidassanamattaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. Asubhanimittādikassapi hi yassa kassaci jhānuppattinimittassa uggahakosallaṃ nimittakusalatā evāti. Atisithilavīriyatādīhīti ādi-saddena paññāpayogamandataṃ payogavekallañca saṅgaṇhāti. Tassa paggaṇhananti tassa līnassa cittassa dhammavicayasambojjhaṅgādisamuṭṭhāpanena layāpattito samuddharaṇaṃ. Vuttañhetaṃ bhagavatā – 因善巧与修习善巧的无间性,以及守护善巧以其为根本,故说“相善巧即是于遍处相的取善巧”。而“于遍处相”当知仅是示例,因为对于不净相等任何能生起禅那的相,于彼取善巧即是相善巧。“过于懈怠等”一句中的“等”字,包括了智慧运用迟钝与修行缺失。所谓“策励彼心”,即是通过生起择法觉支等,将那沉滞的心从昏沉状态中振作起来。世尊曾如是说: ‘‘Yasmiñca kho, bhikkhave, samaye līnaṃ cittaṃ hoti, kālo tasmiṃ samaye dhammavicayasambojjhaṅgassa bhāvanāya, kālo vīriyasambojjhaṅgassa bhāvanāya, kālo pītisambojjhaṅgassa bhāvanāya. Taṃ kissa hetu? Līnaṃ, bhikkhave, cittaṃ, taṃ etehi dhammehi susamuṭṭhāpayaṃ hoti. Seyyathāpi, bhikkhave, puriso parittaṃ aggiṃ ujjāletukāmo assa. So tattha sukkhāni ceva tiṇāni pakkhipeyya, sukkhāni ca gomayāni pakkhipeyya, sukkhāni ca kaṭṭhāni pakkhipeyya, mukhavātañca dadeyya, na ca paṃsukena okireyya, bhabbo nu kho so puriso parittaṃ aggiṃ ujjāletunti? Evaṃ, bhante’’ti (saṃ. ni. 5.234). “诸比丘,当心沉滞时,其时当修择法觉支,当修精进觉支,当修喜觉支。是何缘故?诸比丘,沉滞之心,易为这些法所策起。譬如,诸比丘,有人欲燃小火,彼于其中投入干草、干牛粪、干木柴,并以口吹气,不撒尘土,彼人能否燃起小火?”“诚然,世尊。” Ettha ca yathāsakaṃ āhāravasena dhammavicayasambojjhaṅgādīnaṃ bhāvanā samuṭṭhāpanāti veditabbā, sā anantaraṃ vibhāvitā eva. 于此当知,所谓修习择法觉支等,即是依各自的食而令其生起,此点紧接着已作阐明。 Accāraddhavīriyatādīhīti ādi-saddena paññāpayogabalavataṃ pamoduppilāpanañca saṅgaṇhāti. Tassa niggaṇhananti tassa uddhatassa cittassa samādhisambojjhaṅgādisamuṭṭhāpanena uddhatāpattito nisedhanaṃ. Vuttampi cetaṃ bhagavatā – “过于精进等”一句中的“等”字,包括了智慧运用过强与欣喜踊跃。所谓“抑制彼心”,即是通过生起定觉支等,制止那掉举的心,使其免于掉举。世尊亦曾如是说: ‘‘Yasmiñca [Pg.261] kho, bhikkhave, samaye uddhataṃ cittaṃ hoti, kālo tasmiṃ samaye passaddhisambojjhaṅgassa bhāvanāya, kālo samādhisambojjhaṅgassa bhāvanāya, kālo upekkhāsambojjhaṅgassa bhāvanāya. Taṃ kissa hetu? Uddhataṃ, bhikkhave, cittaṃ, taṃ etehi dhammehi suvūpasamaṃ hoti. Seyyathāpi, bhikkhave, puriso mahantaṃ aggikkhandhaṃ nibbāpetukāmo assa, so tattha allāni ceva tiṇāni pakkhipeyya, allāni ca gomayāni nikkhipeyya, allāni ca kaṭṭhāni pakkhipeyya, mukhavātañca na dadeyya, paṃsukena ca okireyya, bhabbo nu kho so puriso mahantaṃ aggikkhandhaṃ nibbāpetunti? Evaṃ, bhante’’ti (saṃ. ni. 5.234). “诸比丘,当心掉举时,其时当修轻安觉支,当修定觉支,当修舍觉支。是何缘故?诸比丘,掉举之心,易为这些法所善平息。譬如,诸比丘,有人欲灭大火聚,彼于其中投入湿草、湿牛粪、湿木柴,不以口吹气,并覆之以尘土,彼人能否熄灭大火聚?”“诚然,世尊。” Etthāpi yathāsakaṃ āhāravasena passaddhisambojjhaṅgādīnaṃ bhāvanā samuṭṭhāpanāti veditabbā. Tattha passaddhisambojjhaṅgassa bhāvanā vuttā eva, samādhisambojjhaṅgassa vuccamānā, itarassa anantaraṃ vakkhati. 于此亦当知,所谓修习轻安觉支等,即是依各自的食而令其生起。其中,轻安觉支的修习已说,定觉支的修习正在解说,其余的(舍觉支)将于紧后说明。 Paññāpayogamandatāyāti paññābyāpārassa appakabhāvena. Yathā hi dānaṃ alobhappadhānaṃ, sīlaṃ adosappadhānaṃ, evaṃ bhāvanā amohappadhānā. Tattha yadā paññā na balavatī hoti, tadā bhāvanā pubbenāparaṃ visesāvahā na hoti. Anabhisaṅgato viya āhāro purisassa, yogino cittassa abhiruciṃ na janeti, tena taṃ nirassādaṃ hoti. Tathā bhāvanāya sammadeva avīthipaṭipattiyā upasamasukhaṃ na vindati, tenapi cittaṃ nirassādaṃ hoti. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘paññāpayogamandatāyā…pe… nirassādaṃ hotī’’ti. Tassa saṃveguppādanaṃ pasāduppādanañca tikicchananti taṃ dassento, ‘‘aṭṭha saṃvegavatthūnī’’tiādimāha. Tattha jātijarābyādhimaraṇāni yathārahaṃ sugatiyaṃ duggatiyañca hontīti tadaññameva pañcavidhabandhanādikhuppipāsādiaññamaññaviheṭhanādihetukaṃ apāyadukkhaṃ daṭṭhabbaṃ. Tayidaṃ sabbaṃ tesaṃ tesaṃ sattānaṃ paccuppannabhavanissitaṃ gahitanti atīte anāgate ca kāle vaṭṭamūlakadukkhāni visuṃ gahitāni. Ye pana sattā āhārūpajīvino, tattha ca uṭṭhānaphalūpajīvino, tesaṃ aññehi asādhāraṇajīvitadukkhaṃ aṭṭhamaṃ saṃvegavatthu gahitanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Ayaṃ vuccati samaye sampahaṃsanatāti ayaṃ bhāvanācittassa sampahaṃsitabbasamaye vuttanayeneva saṃvegajananavasena [Pg.262] ceva pasāduppādanavasena ca sammadeva pahaṃsanā, saṃvegajananapubbakapasāduppādanena tosanāti attho. “智慧运用迟钝”,即智慧的作用微弱。犹如布施以无贪为首,戒以无瞋为首,修习则以无痴为首。于此,当智慧不强时,修习便不能由前导向于后的殊胜。犹如未消化的食物之于人,不能在修行者的心中生起喜悦,因此它变得无味。同样,由于修习未循正道,不能证得寂静之乐,因此心也变得无味。故说:“因智慧运用迟钝……乃至……变得无味”。为示其对治之法在于令生悚惧与净信,故说“八悚惧事”等。其中,生、老、病、死,依善趣、恶趣而有,除此之外,由五种束缚等、饥渴等、相互伤害等为因的恶趣苦,当如是知。这一切皆依众生现在世的生命而取,故过去与未来时中轮回根本之苦则分别而取。又,那些以食维生的众生,其中又以辛劳之果维生者,他们有别于他人的谋生之苦,当知此被取为第八悚惧事。此谓“适时令喜”,即于当令其欢喜之时,依所说之法,通过令生悚惧与令生净信而正令修习之心欢喜,其义为:以令生悚惧为前导,再以令生净信而使之满足。 Sammāpaṭipattiṃ āgammāti līnuddhaccavirahena samathavīthipaṭipattiyā ca sammā avisamaṃ sammadeva bhāvanāpaṭipattiṃ āgamma. Alīnantiādīsu kosajjapakkhiyānaṃ dhammānaṃ anadhimattatāya alīnaṃ, uddhaccapakkhikānaṃ anadhimattatāya anuddhataṃ, paññāpayogasampattiyā upasamasukhādhigamena ca anirassādaṃ, tato eva ārammaṇe samappavattaṃ samathavīthipaṭipannaṃ. Alīnānuddhatāhi vā ārammaṇe samappavattaṃ, anirassādatāya samathavīthipaṭipannaṃ. Samappavattiyā vā alīnaṃ anuddhataṃ, samathavīthipaṭipattiyā anirassādanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Tattha alīnatāya paggahe, anuddhatatāya niggahe, anirassādatāya sampahaṃsane na byāpāraṃ āpajjati. Ayaṃ vuccati samaye ajjhupekkhanatāti ayaṃ ajjhupekkhitabbasamaye bhāvanācittassa paggahaniggahasampahaṃsanesu byāvaṭatāsaṅkhātaṃ paṭipakkhaṃ abhibhuyya ajjhupekkhanā vuccati. Paṭipakkhavikkhambhanato vipassanāya adhiṭṭhānabhāvūpagamanato ca upacārajjhānampi samādhānakiccanipphattiyā puggalassa samāhitabhāvasādhanamevāti tattha samadhurabhāvenāha – ‘‘upacāraṃ vā appanaṃ vā’’ti. Esa uppajjatīti esa samādhisambojjhaṅgo anuppanno uppajjati. “依于正行”,即是依于远离沉滞与掉举,以及依于寂止之道,而正确、无偏、如实地进行修习。于“不沉滞”等句中,因懈怠一边的法不过量,故“不沉滞”;因掉举一边的法不过量,故“不掉举”;因智慧运用圆满及证得寂静之乐,故“不无味”;正因如此,心于所缘中平等而转,行于寂止之道。或可说,因不沉滞、不掉举,故于所缘中平等而转;因不无味,故行于寂止之道。或当知,因平等而转,故不沉滞、不掉举;因行于寂止之道,故不无味。于此,因不沉滞,故不须策励;因不掉举,故不须抑制;因不无味,故不须令喜。此谓“适时舍置”,即于当舍置时,修习之心克服了在策励、抑制、令喜等方面的勤作,此谓之舍置。因镇伏了对治法,且因观(vipassanā)已达能作为基础的状态,故近行定亦能完成令心专注之作用,为个人(puggala)成就等持状态,因此以平等并重的方式说:“近行或安止”。“此生起者”,即此未曾生起的定觉支得以生起。 Anurodhavirodhappahānavasena majjhattabhāvo upekkhāsambojjhaṅgassa kāraṇaṃ tasmiṃ sati sijjhanato, asati ca asijjhanato, so ca majjhattabhāvo visayavasena duvidhoti āha – ‘‘sattamajjhattatā saṅkhāramajjhattatā’’ti. Tadubhayena ca virujjhanaṃ passaddhisambojjhaṅgabhāvanāya eva dūrīkatanti anurujjhanasseva pahānavidhiṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘sattamajjhattatā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘sattasaṅkhārakelāyanapuggalaparivajjanatā’’ti. Upekkhāya hi visesato rāgo paṭipakkho. Tathā cāha – ‘‘upekkhā rāgabahulassa visuddhimaggo’’ti (visuddhi. 1.269). Dvīhākārehīti kammassakatāpaccavekkhaṇaṃ, attasuññatāpaccavekkhaṇanti, imehi dvīhi kāraṇehi. Dvīhevāti avadhāraṇaṃ saṅkhyāsamānatādassanatthaṃ. Saṅkhyā eva hettha samānā, na saṅkhyeyyaṃ sabbathā samānanti. Assāmikabhāvo anattaniyatā. Sati hi attani tassa kiñcanabhāvena cīvaraṃ aññaṃ vā kiñci attaniyaṃ nāma siyā, so [Pg.263] pana koci natthevāti adhippāyo. Anaddhaniyanti na addhānakkhamaṃ, na ciraṭṭhāyī ittaraṃ aniccanti attho. Tāvakālikanti tasseva vevacanaṃ. 以舍离随顺与违逆故,中舍状态是舍觉支的因;当其存在时则成就,不存在时则不成就。此中舍状态依所缘分为两种,即“有情中舍性”(sattamajjhattatā)与“行中舍性”(saṅkhāramajjhattatā)。此二者中的违逆,已由修习轻安觉支所远离,为示仅舍离随顺之法,故说“有情中舍性”等。是故说:“远离于有情与诸行存有爱著之人(puggala)”。于舍,贪特别为其对治。如是亦说:“舍是多贪者之清净道。”(《清净道论》Visuddhimagga 1.269)。“以两种行相”,即省察业属己(kammassakatāpaccavekkhaṇa)与省察空无我(attasuññatāpaccavekkhaṇa),以此二因。说“唯二”是为限定,以示数量相等。此处仅数量相等,所数之法并非全然相同。无主性即非我所性。若实有我,则以其为所有主,衣等任何事物皆可名为“我所”,然彼实无有,此是其义。“不恒久”(anaddhaniya)意即不堪长时、不长住、短暂、无常。“暂时”(tāvakālika)是其同义词。 Mamāyatīti mamattaṃ karoti, mamāti taṇhāya pariggayha tiṭṭhati. Dhanāyantāti dhanaṃ dabbaṃ karontā. “执为我所”(mamāyati)即是造作我所(mamattaṃ karoti),即以渴爱执取为“我所有”。“求财”(dhanāyantā)即是营办财物(dhanaṃ dabbaṃ karontā)。 419. Sammādassanalakkhaṇāti sammā aviparītaṃ aniccādivasena dassanasabhāvā. Sammāabhiniropanalakkhaṇoti sammadeva ārammaṇe cittassa abhiniropanasabhāvo. Caturaṅgasamannāgatā vācā janaṃ saṅgaṇhātīti tabbipakkhaviratisabhāvā sammāvācā bhedakaramicchāvācāpahānena jane sampayutte ca pariggaṇhanakiccavatī hotīti ‘‘pariggahalakkhaṇā’’ti vuttā. Visaṃvādanādikiccatāya hi lūkhānaṃ apariggāhakānaṃ musāvādādīnaṃ paṭipakkhabhūtā siniddhabhāvena pariggahaṇasabhāvā sammājappanakiccā sammāvācā tappaccayasubhāsitasampaṭiggāhake jane sampayuttadhamme ca pariggaṇhantī pavattatīti pariggahalakkhaṇā. Yathā cīvarakammādippayogasaṅkhāto kammanto kātabbaṃ cīvararajanādikaṃ samuṭṭhāpeti nipphādeti, taṃtaṃkiriyānipphādako vā cetanāsaṅkhāto kammanto hatthacalanādikaṃ kiriyaṃ samuṭṭhāpeti, evaṃ sāvajjakattabbakiriyāsamuṭṭhāpakamicchākammantappahānena sammākammanto niravajjassa kattabbassa niravajjākārena samuṭṭhāpanakiccavā hotīti āha – ‘‘sammāsamuṭṭhāpanalakkhaṇo’’ti. Sampayuttadhammānaṃ vā ukkhipanaṃ samuṭṭhāpanaṃ kāyikakiriyāya bhārukkhipanaṃ viya. Sammāvodāpanalakkhaṇoti jīvamānassa puggalassa, sampayuttadhammānaṃ vā jīvitindriyavuttiyā, ājīvasseva vā sammadeva sodhanaṃ vodāpanaṃ lakkhaṇaṃ etassāti sammāvodāpanalakkhaṇo. Atha vā kāyavācānaṃ khandhasantānassa ca saṃkilesabhūtamicchāājīvappahānena sammāājīvo ‘‘vodāpanalakkhaṇo’’ti vutto. Sammāvāyāmasatisamādhīsu vattabbaṃ heṭṭhā vuttameva. 419. 正见(sammādassana)的特相是正确而不颠倒地观照无常等,具有如实观照的自性。正思惟(sammāsaṅkappa)的特相是心完全正确地专注于所缘境,具有专注的自性。正语(sammāvācā)的自性是远离其对立面,通过断除离间语等邪语,对众人及相应法具有摄受作用,因此被称为“摄受特相”(pariggahalakkhaṇā)。因为妄语等粗恶之语具有欺骗等作用,不能摄受他人,而作为其对立面的正语,以温和之态,履行正说之务,在能接受善言的人们及相应法中发挥摄受作用,因此具有摄受的特相。正如名为造衣等作业的业(kammanta),能使应作的染衣等事生起、完成;或者说,名为思(cetanā)的业能使手的活动等行为生起;同样地,正业(sammākammanta)通过断除能生起有过失行为的邪业,以无过失的方式履行产生无过失行为之务,所以说“具有正生起相”(sammāsamuṭṭhāpanalakkhaṇo)。或者说,对于相应法来说,具有提起、生起的作用,就像身体的动作能够承担重物一样。正命(sammā-ājīva)的特相是,对于活着的个人(puggala),或者对于与命根作用相关的诸法,或者纯粹对于生计的正确净化,此即“正净化相”(sammāvodāpanalakkhaṇo)。又或者说,通过断除作为身语以及蕴相续之染污的邪命,正命被称为“净化相”。关于正精进(sammāvāyāma)、正念(sammāsati)、正定(sammāsamādhi),前面已经说过。 Paññāya kusalānaṃ dhammānaṃ pubbaṅgamabhāvato sabbepi akusalā dhammā tassā paṭipakkhāvāti vuttaṃ – ‘‘aññehipi attano paccanīkakilesehi saddhi’’nti. Atha vā attano paccanīkakilesā diṭṭhekaṭṭhā avijjādayo paññāya ujupaccanīkabhāvato. Passatīti passantī [Pg.264] viya hoti vibandhābhāvato. Tenāha – ‘‘tappaṭicchādaka…pe… asammohato’’ti. Sammāsaṅkappādīnaṃ micchāsaṅkappādayo ujuvipaccanīkāti āha – ‘‘sammāsaṅkappādayo…pe… pajahantī’’ti. Tathevāti iminā attano paccanīkakilesehi saddhinti imamatthaṃ anukaḍḍhati. Visesatoti sammādiṭṭhiyā vuttakiccato visesena. Etthāti etesu sammāsaṅkappādīsu. 由于慧(paññā)是诸善法的前导,一切不善法都是它的对治,所以说“以及其他与自身相违的烦恼”。或者说,与自身相违的烦恼,如无明(avijjā)等,它们与邪见(diṭṭhi)有共同的基础,是慧的直接对治。“能见”,是说(慧)犹如正在观看,因其无有障碍。因此说“遮蔽它的……乃至……因无痴”。正思惟(sammāsaṅkappa)等与邪思惟(micchāsaṅkappa)等是直接相违的,故说“正思惟等……乃至……断除”。“同样地”一词,是引述“与自身相违的烦恼”此义。“特别地”,是说与为正见所说的作用有差别。“于此”,是指于此等正思惟等之中。 Esā sammādiṭṭhi nāmāti lokiyaṃ lokuttarañca ekajjhaṃ katvā vadati missakatābhāvato. Tenāha – ‘‘pubbabhāge’’tiādi. Ekārammaṇā nibbānārammaṇattā. Kiccatoti pubbabhāge dukkhādīhi ñāṇehi kātabbakiccassa idha nipphattito, imasseva vā ñāṇassa dukkhādippakāsanakiccato. Cattāri nāmāni labhati dukkhapariññādicatukiccasādhanato. Tīṇi nāmāni labhati kāmasaṅkappādippahānakiccanipphattito. Sikkhāpadavibhaṅge (vibha. 703 ādayo) ‘‘viraticetanā taṃsampayuttā ca dhammā sikkhāpadānī’’ti vuttāni, tattha padhānānaṃ viraticetanānaṃ vasena ‘‘viratiyopi honti cetanādayopī’’ti āha. ‘‘Sammā vadati etāyā’’tiādinā atthasambhavato sammāvācādayo tayo viratiyopi honti cetanādayopi. Musāvādādīhi viramaṇakāle viratiyo, subhāsitādivācābhāsanādikāle cetanādayo yojetabbā. Maggakkhaṇe pana viratiyova maggalakkhaṇappattito. Na hi cetanā niyyānasabhāvā. Atha vā ekassa ñāṇassa dukkhādiñāṇatā viya ekāya viratiyā musāvādādiviratibhāvo viya ca ekāya cetanāya sammāvācādikiccattayasādhanasabhāvā sammāvācādibhāvāsiddhito ‘‘maggakkhaṇe viratiyovā’’ti vuttaṃ. 说“此名为正见(sammādiṭṭhi)”,是总括世间(lokiya)与出世间(lokuttara)而言,因其并非杂乱。是故说“于前分(pubbabhāga)”等。(出世间正见)以涅槃(nibbāna)为唯一所缘。从作用而言,因前分中由苦等智所应作之务于此(道之刹那)得以完成,或因正是此智具有开示苦等的作用。(此正见)获得四种名称,因其成就了知苦等四种作用。获得三种名称,因其成就了断除欲寻等作用。在《学处分别》(Sikkhāpadavibhaṅga)中说:“离(virati)思(cetanā)及彼相应法是学处(sikkhāpada)。”此处依主要的离思而说“既是离,也是思等”。由“依此而正说”等义,可知正语(sammāvācā)等三者既是离,也是思等。当远离妄语等时是离,当说善语等时应配以思等。然于道之刹那(maggakkhaṇa),因证得道相,故唯是离。思并无出离(niyyāna)之自性。或者说,犹如一智有苦等智性,一离有远离妄语等性,一思有成就正语等三务之性,然因正语等(作为思的)体性于道之刹那不成立,故说“于道之刹那唯是离”。 Cattāri nāmāni labhatīti catusammappadhānacatusatipaṭṭhānavasena labhati. Maggakkhaṇeti ānetvā sambandho. Pubbabhāgepi maggakkhaṇepi sammāsamādhi evāti yadipi samādhiupakārakānaṃ abhiniropanānumajjanasampiyāyanabrūhanasantasukhānaṃ vitakkādīnaṃ vasena catūhi jhānehi sammāsamādhi vibhatto, tathāpi vāyāmo viya anuppannākusalānuppādanādicatuvāyāmakiccaṃ, sati viya ca asubhāsukhāniccānattesu kāyādīsu subhādisaññāpahānalakkhaṇaṃ catusatikiccaṃ, eko samādhi catujjhānasamādhikiccaṃ na sādhetīti pubbabhāgepi paṭhamajjhānasamādhi, paṭhamajjhānasamādhi [Pg.265] eva maggakkhaṇepi, tathā pubbabhāgepi catutthajjhānasamādhi, catutthajjhānasamādhi eva maggakkhaṇepīti attho. “获得四种名称”,是依四正勤(catusammappadhāna)与四念处(catusatipaṭṭhāna)而得。应联系到“于道之刹那(maggakkhaṇa)”。(此理如下:)于前分(pubbabhāga)与道之刹那,正定(sammāsamādhi)是同一的。虽然正定依寻(vitakka)等助益定(samādhi)之法——即安立、沉入、喜爱、增长及寂静乐——而分为四种禅那(jhāna),然而,犹如精进(vāyāma)有令未生之不善不生等四种作用,念(sati)有于不净、苦、无常、无我之身等上舍离净想等四种作用,(但)一个定不能成就四种禅那定的所有作用。因此,前分中的初禅定(paṭhamajjhāna-samādhi),于道之刹那亦是初禅定;同样,前分中的第四禅定(catutthajjhāna-samādhi),于道之刹那亦是第四禅定。其义如此。 ‘‘Kiṃ panāyaṃ maggadhammānaṃ desanānukkamo, kevalaṃ vācāya kamavattinibhāvato, udāhu kañci visesaṃ upādāyā’’ti vicāraṇāyaṃ kañci visesaṃ upādāyāti dassento āha – ‘‘imesū’’tiādi. Tattha bhāvanānubhāvā hitaphalāya sātisayaṃ tikkhavisadabhāvappattiyā acchariyabbhutasamatthatāyogena sabbaso paṭipakkhavidhamanena yāthāvato dhammasabhāvabodhanena ca sammādiṭṭhiyā bahukāratā veditabbā. Tenāha – ‘‘ayaṃ hī’’tiādi. “那么,此道法教导的次第,是仅仅出于言语的次第使然,还是依据某种特殊之处呢?”为考察此,并为说明“依据某种特殊之处”,(论师)说:“于此等……”等。于此,当知正见(sammādiṭṭhi)有大助益,因其通过修习(bhāvanā)之力,为达利益之果(hitaphala),已臻极利极明之境,具足不可思议之奇特能力,彻底摧破一切对立法,并如实了知诸法自性(dhammasabhāva)。是故(论师)说:“此实……”等。 Tassāti sammādiṭṭhiyā. Bahukāroti dhammasampaṭivedhe bahūpakāro. Idāni tamatthaṃ upamāhi vibhāvetuṃ, ‘‘yathā hī’’tiādi vuttaṃ. “彼”(tassa)指正见(sammādiṭṭhi)。“大助益”(bahukāro)指于洞见法(dhammasampaṭivedha)时有大助益。今为以譬喻阐明其义,故说“犹如……”等。 Vacībhedassa kārako vitakko sāvajjānavajjavacībhedanivattanappavattanākārāya sammāvācāyapi upakārako evāti āha – ‘‘svāyaṃ…pe… sammāvācāyapi upakārako’’ti. Sammāsaṅkappo hi saccavācāya virativācāyapi visesapaccayo micchāsaṅkappatadekaṭṭhakilesappahānato. 寻(vitakka)为语之发端。而此(正思惟,sammāsaṅkappa)亦能以止息有过之语、发起无过之语的方式,助益于正语(sammāvācā)。故说:“彼……乃至……亦助益于正语。”实因正思惟是谛语(saccavācā)及离语(virativācā)的殊胜助缘,以其能断除邪思惟(micchāsaṅkappa)及与之一义的烦恼(kilesa)故。 Saṃvidahitvātiādīsu sammā vidahanaṃ kammantappayojanañca ekantānavajjavacīkāyakammavasena icchitabbanti virativācāvasena saṃvidahanaṃ viratikammantasseva payojanañca nidassitanti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Evaṃ hissa sammāvācāya sammākammantassāpi bahukāratā jotitā siyā. Vacībhedaniyāmikā hi vacīduccaritavirati kāyikakiriyaniyāmikāya kāyaduccaritaviratiyā upakārikā. Tathā hi visaṃvādanādimicchāvācato avirato micchākammantatopi na viramateva. Yathāha – ‘‘ekaṃ dhammaṃ atītassa…pe… natthi pāpaṃ akāriya’’nti. Tasmā avisaṃvādanādisammāvācāya ṭhito sammākammantampi pūretiyevāti vacīduccaritavirati kāyaduccaritaviratiyā upakārikā. 于“善安排后”(saṃvidahitvā)等句中,当知其意为,正安排(sammā vidahana)与业之目的(kammantappayojana)皆是所期望的完全无过之语业与身业;并且,以离语(virativācā)的方式来安排,是为了开示离(恶)业(viratikammanta)的目的。如是,则能阐明其(正思惟)于正语、正业亦有大助益。实因规范言语的离语恶行(vacīduccaritavirati),有助于规范身行的离身恶行(kāyaduccaritavirati)。诚然,不离妄语等邪语者,亦必不离邪业。如言:“违越一法者……乃至……无恶不可为。”是故,住于不妄语等正语者,亦必能圆满正业。由此可知,离语恶行有助于离身恶行。 Yasmā ājīvapārisuddhi nāma dussīlyappahānapubbikā, tasmā sammāvācākammantānantaraṃ sammāājīvo desitoti dassetuṃ – ‘‘catubbidhaṃ panā’’tiādi [Pg.266] vuttaṃ. Ettāvatāti parisuddhasīlājīvikāmattena. Idaṃ vīriyanti catusammappadhānavīriyaṃ. 以命清净(ājīvapārisuddhi)实以断恶戒(dussīlya)为前行,是故,为示于正语(sammāvācā)、正业(sammākammanta)后说正命(sammāājīva),故说“然则四种……”等。“仅此”(ettāvatā)意指仅凭清净的戒(sīla)与命(ājīva)。“此精进”(idaṃ vīriyaṃ)指四正勤(catusammappadhāna)之精进。 Vīriyārambhopi sammāsatipariggahito eva nibbānāvaho, na kevaloti dassetuṃ – ‘‘tato’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Sūpaṭṭhitāti bahiddhāvikkhepaṃ pahāya suṭṭhu upaṭṭhitā kātabbā. Samādhissa upakāradhammā nāma yathāvuttavatthuvisadakiriyādayo. Tappaṭipakkhato anupakāradhammā veditabbā. Gatiyoti nipphattiyo. Samanvesitvāti sammā pariyesitvā. 为示发起精进(vīriyārambha)亦唯有被正念(sammāsati)所摄持,方能导向涅槃(nibbāna),非仅精进本身,故说“其后……”等。“善现起”(sūpaṭṭhitā)指舍离外在散乱(bahiddhāvikkhepa),令其善现起。“定之助益法”(samādhissa upakāradhamma)指如前所说令所缘清晰等。“与此相违”当知即非助益法。“趣”(gati)指成就(nipphatti)。“遍寻”(samanvesitvā)指正寻求(sammā pariyesitvā)。 427. Yathā itthīsu kathā pavattā adhitthīti vuccati, evaṃ attānaṃ adhikicca pavattā ajjhattaṃ. ‘‘Evaṃ pavattamānā mayaṃ ‘attā’ti gahaṇaṃ gamissāmā’’ti iminā viya adhippāyena attānaṃ adhikicca uddissa pavattā sattasantatipariyāpannā ajjhattaṃ. Tasmiṃ ajjhattarūpe, attano kesādivatthuke kasiṇarūpeti attho. Parikammavasena ajjhattaṃ rūpasaññīti parikammakaraṇavasena ajjhattaṃ rūpasaññī, na appanāvasena. Na hi paṭibhāganimittārammaṇā appanā ajjhattavisayā sambhavati. Taṃ pana ajjhattaṃ parikammavasena laddhaṃ kasiṇanimittaṃ avisuddhameva hoti, na bahiddhā parikammavasena laddhaṃ viya visuddhaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘taṃ panā’’tiādi. 427. 犹如关于女人的谈论被称为“增上女人”(adhitthī),如是,缘于自身而转起的,即为“内”。仿佛怀着“如是行者,我等将趣于‘我’之执取”此等意趣,缘于自身、指向自身、摄于有情相续而转起的,即为“内”。于彼“内色”中,义为于以自身发等为所缘的遍处色(kasiṇarūpa)。“于内有色想”是依预备修习(parikamma)而言,指因作预备修习而于内有色想,非依安止(appanā)而言。实因以似相(paṭibhāganimitta)为所缘的安止,不可能以内在为境。且彼依内在预备修习所得的遍处相(kasiṇanimitta)实为不净,不如依外在预备修习所得者清净。是故说:“然彼……”等。 Yassevaṃ parikammaṃ ajjhattaṃ uppannanti yassa puggalassa evaṃ vuttappakārena ajjhattaṃ parikammaṃ jātaṃ. Nimittaṃ pana bahiddhāti paṭibhāganimittaṃ sasantatipariyāpannaṃ na hotīti bahiddhā. Parittānīti yathāladdhāni suppasarāvamattāni. Tenāha – ‘‘avaḍḍhitānī’’ti. Parittavasenevāti vaṇṇavasena ābhoge vijjamānepi parittavaseneva idaṃ abhibhāyatanaṃ vuttaṃ parittatā hettha abhibhavanassa kāraṇaṃ. Vaṇṇābhoge satipi asatipi abhibhavatīti abhibhu, parikammaṃ, ñāṇaṃ vā. Abhibhu āyatanaṃ etassāti abhibhāyatanaṃ, jhānaṃ. Abhibhavitabbaṃ vā ārammaṇasaṅkhātaṃ āyatanaṃ etassāti abhibhāyatanaṃ. Atha vā ārammaṇābhibhavanato abhibhu ca taṃ āyatanañca yogino sukhavisesānaṃ adhiṭṭhānabhāvato manāyatanadhammāyatanabhāvato cāti sasampayuttajjhānaṃ abhibhāyatanaṃ. Abhibhāyatanabhāvanā nāma tikkhapaññasseva sambhavati, na itarassāti āha – ‘‘ñāṇuttariko puggalo’’ti. Abhibhavitvā samāpajjatīti ettha abhibhavanaṃ [Pg.267] samāpajjanañca upacārajjhānādhigamanasamanantarameva appanājhānuppādananti āha – ‘‘saha nimittuppādenevettha appanaṃ pāpetī’’ti. Saha nimittuppādenāti ca appanāparivāsābhāvassa lakkhaṇavacanametaṃ. Yo khippābhiññoti vuccati, tatopi ñāṇuttarasseva abhibhāyatanabhāvanā. Etthāti etasmiṃ nimitte. Appanaṃ pāpetīti bhāvanāappanaṃ neti. “于其人如是之内在预备修习已生起”,意指于某个人,已如所说方式生起内在的预备修习。“然相于外”,指似相(paṭibhāganimitta)不摄于自相续,故为外在。“少”指如所获得的仅蔓菁子量。是故说“未增长”。“仅依于少”,指纵有色光,亦仅依于少而说此胜处,因于此,少即是胜越之因。无论有无色光皆能胜越,故为“胜者”(abhibhu),或指预备修习,或指智。此为胜者之处(āyatana),故为胜处(abhibhāyatana),即禅那。或此为当胜越之所缘处,故为胜处。或因能胜越所缘,故为“胜”,又因是瑜伽行者特殊安乐之所依,且属意处、法处,故彼相应之禅那为“处”,合为胜处。唯利慧者方能修习胜处,非余人所能,故说“智增上的个人”。于此,“胜越而入定”之胜越与入定,指证得近行定后,立即生起安止定,故说“于此,随相之生起即达安止”。“随相之生起”是说明无安止别住(appanāparivāsa)之相的语句。纵然是所谓“速通达者”,亦唯有智增上者能修习胜处。“于此”指于此相。“达安止”指导向修习安止。 Ettha ca keci ‘‘uppanne upacārajjhāne taṃ ārabbha ye heṭṭhimantena dve tayo javanavārā pavattanti, te upacārajjhānapakkhikā eva, tadanantaraṃ bhavaṅgaparivāsena upacārasevanāya ca vinā appanā hoti, saha nimittuppādeneva appanaṃ pāpetī’’ti vadanti, taṃ tesaṃ matimattaṃ. Na hi pārivāsikaparikammena appanāvāro icchito, nāpi mahaggatappamāṇajjhānesu viya upacārajjhāne ekantato paccavekkhaṇā icchitabbā. Tasmā upacārajjhānādhigamato paraṃ katipayabhavaṅgacittāvasāne appanaṃ pāpuṇanto ‘‘saha nimittuppādenevettha appanaṃ pāpetī’’ti vutto. Saha nimittuppādenāti ca adhippāyikamidaṃ vacanaṃ, na nītatthaṃ, tattha adhippāyo vuttanayeneva veditabbo. Na antosamāpattiyaṃ tadā tathārūpassa ābhogassa asambhavato. Samāpattito vuṭṭhitassa ābhogo pubbabhāgabhāvanāvasena jhānakkhaṇe pavattaṃ abhibhavanākāraṃ gahetvā pavattoti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Abhidhammaṭṭhakathāyaṃ pana ‘‘imināssa pubbābhogo kathito’’ti vuttaṃ. Antosamāpattiyaṃ tadā tathā ābhogābhāve kasmā jhānasaññāyapīti vuttanti āha – ‘‘abhibhavasaññā hissa antosamāpattiyampi atthī’’ti. 于此,有人说:“近行定生起时,缘彼而转起的下至两三个速行心流,皆属近行定;其后,无须有分之别住(bhavaṅgaparivāsa)与近行之习行,即有安止,随相之生起即达安止。”此仅彼等之臆见。实不期以别住(pārivāsika)之预备修习得安止之分,亦不应如于大心、无量心禅那中,于近行定中一味求省察。是故,证近行定后,于数个有分心之末,达安止者,被称为“于此,随相之生起即达安止”。“随相之生起”此语为意引导句,非了义句,其意趣当如前述而知。因于入定之内,尔时不可能有如是之作意。当知从定而出者之作意,是依前分修习,取禅那刹那所转起之胜越行相而转起。于《阿毗达摩义注》(Abhidhammaṭṭhakathā)中则说:“此说其前分作意。”若于入定之内,尔时无如是作意,因何亦说有禅那之想?答曰:“实因其于入定之内亦有胜越之想。” Vaḍḍhitappamāṇānīti vipulappamāṇānīti attho, na ekaṅguladvaṅgulādivaḍḍhiṃ pāpitāni tathā vaḍḍhanassevettha asambhavato. Tenāha – ‘‘mahantānī’’ti. Bhattavaḍḍhitakanti bhuñjanabhājane vaḍḍhetvā dinnaṃ bhattaṃ, ekāsane purisena bhuñjitabbabhattato upaḍḍhabhattanti attho. “增量”意为“大量”,并非指增加了一寸、两寸等,因为在此处不可能有那样的增加。因此说“巨大”。“增食”是指在食盘中增加后给予的食物,其意为一个人一坐所食之半。 Rūpe saññā rūpasaññā, sā assa atthīti rūpasaññī, na rūpasaññī arūpasaññī. Saññāsīsena jhānaṃ vadati. Rūpasaññāya anuppādanamevettha alābhitā. Bahiddhāva uppannanti bahiddhāvatthusmiṃyeva uppannaṃ. Ettha ca – “于色之想”为“色想”(rūpasaññā),拥有此想者为“有色想者”(rūpasaññī);非有色想者,即“无色想者”(arūpasaññī)。此乃以“想”(saññā)为首而论禅那(jhāna)。此处,未得即是色想不生起。“仅于外生起”意为“仅于外在所缘上生起”。于此: ‘‘Ajjhattaṃ rūpasaññī bahiddhā rūpāni passati parittāni suvaṇṇadubbaṇṇāni. Ajjhattaṃ rūpasaññī bahiddhā rūpāni passati appamāṇāni suvaṇṇadubbaṇṇāni[Pg.268]. Ajjhattaṃ arūpasaññī bahiddhā rūpāni passati parittāni suvaṇṇadubbaṇṇāni. Ajjhattaṃ arūpasaññī bahiddhā rūpāni passati appamāṇāni suvaṇṇadubbaṇṇānī’’ti (dī. ni. 3.338, 358; a. ni. 8.65; 10.29) – “于内有色想者,观外在诸色,有限量者,美者与丑者。于内有色想者,观外在诸色,无量者,美者与丑者。于内无色想者,观外在诸色,有限量者,美者与丑者。于内无色想者,观外在诸色,无量者,美者与丑者。”(长部3.338, 358; 增支部8.65; 10.29) Evamidha cattāri abhibhāyatanāni āgatāni. Abhidhamme (dha. sa. 244-245) pana ‘‘ajjhattaṃ arūpasaññī bahiddhā rūpāni passati parittāni suvaṇṇadubbaṇṇāni, appamāṇāni suvaṇṇadubbaṇṇānī’’ti evamāgatāni. Tattha ca kāraṇaṃ abhidhammaṭṭhakathāyaṃ vuttameva. Tathā hi vuttaṃ aṭṭhasāliniyaṃ (dha. sa. aṭṭha. 204) – 如是,此处已述四种胜处(abhibhāyatana)。但在阿毗达摩(abhidhamma)中(法集论 244-245)则如是说:“于内无色想者,观外在诸色,有限量者,美者与丑者;无量者,美者与丑者。”其原因已在阿毗达摩义注(abhidhammaṭṭhakathā)中说明。诚如《含义阐明》(aṭṭhasālinī)(法集论义注 204)中所说: ‘‘Kasmā pana yathā suttante ‘ajjhattaṃ rūpasaññī eko bahiddhā rūpāni passati parittānī’tiādi vuttaṃ, evaṃ avatvā idha catūsupi abhibhāyatanesu ajjhattaṃ arūpasaññitāva vuttāti. Ajjhattarūpānaṃ anabhibhavanīyato. Tattha vā hi idha vā bahiddhā rūpāneva abhibhavitabbāni, tasmā tāni niyamato vattabbānī’’ti. “然则,为何不像经藏(suttanta)中所说‘于内有色想者,观外在有限诸色’等,而于此四种胜处中,仅说‘于内无色想’呢?因为内在诸色是不可胜过的。无论在经藏或此处,都只有外在诸色应被胜过,是故必须论及它们。” Tatrāpi idhapi vuttāni ‘‘ajjhattaṃ rūpasaññī ajjhattaṃ arūpasaññīti idaṃ pana satthu desanāvilāsamattamevā’’ti. Ayaṃ panettha adhippāyo – idha vaṇṇābhogarahitāni sahitāni ca sabbāni parittāni suvaṇṇadubbaṇṇāni abhibhuyyāti. Pariyāyakathā hi suttantadesanāti. Abhidhamme pana nippariyāyadesanattā vaṇṇābhogarahitāni visuṃ vuttāni, tathā sahitāni. Atthi hi ubhayattha abhibhavanavisesoti. Tathā idha pariyāyadesanattā vimokkhānampi abhibhavanapariyāyo atthīti ‘‘ajjhattaṃ rūpasaññī’’tiādinā paṭhamadutiyaabhibhāyatanesu paṭhamavimokkho, tatiyacatutthaabhibhāyatanesu dutiyavimokkho, vaṇṇābhibhāyatanesu tatiyavimokkho ca abhibhavanapattito saṅgahito. Abhidhamme pana nippariyāyadesanattā vimokkhābhibhāyatanāni asaṅkarato desetuṃ vimokkhe vajjetvā abhibhāyatanāni kathitāni. Sabbāni ca vimokkhakiccāni jhānāni vimokkhadesanāyaṃ vuttāni. Tadetaṃ ‘‘ajjhattaṃ rūpasaññī’’ti āgatassa abhibhāyatanadvayassa abhidhamme abhibhāyatanesu avacanato ‘‘rūpī rūpāni passatī’’tiādīnañca sabbavimokkhakiccasādhāraṇavacanabhāvato vavatthānaṃ katanti viññāyati. 在此二处亦说:“‘于内有色想’、‘于内无色想’,这仅是导师说法的善巧而已。”此中意谓:此处,所有有限的、美与丑的、不作意颜色(vaṇṇābhogarahitāni)与作意颜色(sahitāni)者,皆被胜过。因为经藏的教说为方便说。但在阿毗达摩中,因是无方便说,故不作意颜色者与作意颜色者被分别论述,因为二者在胜过上有差别。同样,此处因是方便说,故诸解脱(vimokkha)亦有胜过之方便,即以“于内有色想”等,于第一、第二胜处中摄入第一解脱,于第三、第四胜处中摄入第二解脱,于颜色胜处(vaṇṇābhibhāyatanesu)中,因达到胜过而摄入第三解脱。但在阿毗达摩中,因是无方便说,为不混淆地教导,故在论述胜处时排除了诸解脱。而所有具解脱作用的禅那,皆在解脱的教说中述及。是故可知,之所以作此区别,是因为“于内有色想”而来的两种胜处,在阿毗达摩的胜处中未被提及,且“有色者见诸色”(rūpī rūpāni passati)等语,是通用于一切解脱作用的。 Ajjhattarūpānaṃ [Pg.269] anabhibhavanīyatoti idaṃ abhidhamme katthacipi ‘‘ajjhattarūpāni passatī’’ti avatvā sabbattha yaṃ vuttaṃ – ‘‘bahiddhā rūpāni passatī’’ti, tassa kāraṇavacanaṃ. Tena yaṃ aññahetukaṃ suttante ‘‘bahiddhā rūpāni passatī’’ti vacanaṃ, taṃ tena hetunā vuttaṃ. Yaṃ pana desanāvilāsahetukaṃ ajjhattaṃ arūpasaññitāya eva abhidhamme vacanaṃ, na tassa aññaṃ kāraṇaṃ maggitabbanti dasseti. Ajjhattarūpānaṃ anabhibhavanīyatā ca tesaṃ bahiddhārūpānaṃ viya avibhūtattā. Desanāvilāso ca yathāvuttavavatthānavasena veditabbo veneyyajjhāsayavasena vijjamānapariyāyakathanabhāvato. Desanāvilāso hi nāma veneyyajjhāsayānurūpaṃ vijjamānassa ca pariyāyassa vibhāvanaṃ, na yassa kassaci, tasmā ‘‘idha pariyāyadesanattā’’tiādinā vuttappakāraṃ vavatthānaṃ desanāvilāsanibandhananti daṭṭhabbaṃ. “内在诸色不可胜过”——此句乃是说明为何在阿毗达摩中,任何地方都未说“观内在诸色”,而处处皆说“观外在诸色”的原因。因此,经藏中所说“观外在诸色”是出于另一原因,而此处则是出于此(不可胜过)原因。至于阿毗达摩中仅说“于内无色想”,乃是出于说法善巧之故,此句表明不应为此寻求其他原因。内在诸色之所以不可胜过,是因为它们不像外在诸色那样显现。说法的善巧,应依前述区别来理解,因其是随顺所化有情的意乐而说示现有的方便。所谓说法善巧,即是随顺所化有情的意乐而阐明现有的方便,并非对任何人皆可,是故当知,以“此处因是方便说”等方式所作的区别,乃是基于说法的善巧。 Suvaṇṇadubbaṇṇānīti eteneva siddhattā na nīlādiabhibhāyatanāni vattabbānīti ce? Na nīlādīsu katādhikārānaṃ nīlādibhāvasseva abhibhavanakāraṇattā. Na hi tesaṃ parisuddhāparisuddhavaṇṇānaṃ parittatā appamāṇatā vā abhibhavanakāraṇaṃ, atha kho nīlādibhāvo evāti. Etesu ca parittādikasiṇarūpesu yaṃyaṃcaritassa imāni abhibhāyatanāni ijjhanti, taṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘imesu panā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. 若问:既然已由“美与丑”成立,是否青等胜处就不必说了呢?答:不然。因为对于已在青等(遍)中修行者而言,青等的状态本身即是胜过之因。对他们来说,那些净与不净颜色的有限或无限,并非胜过之因,而是青等的状态本身。为说明在这些有限等的遍(kasiṇa)色中,何种胜处能为哪种根行者所成就,故说“于此等中……”等。 Sabbasaṅgāhikavasenāti nīlavaṇṇanīlanidassananīlanibhāsānaṃ sādhāraṇavasena. Vaṇṇavasenāti sabhāvavaṇṇavasena. Nidassanavasenāti passitabbatāvasena, cakkhuviññāṇavīthiyā gahetabbatāvasena. Obhāsavasenāti sappabhāsatāya avabhāsanavasena. Vaṇṇadhātuyā vāti añjanarajatavatthādivaṇṇadhātuyā. Lokiyāneva rūpāvacarajjhānabhāvato. “以总摄方式”是指共通于青色、青相、青光。“以颜色方式”是指以自性颜色方式。“以相方式”是指以可见、可为眼识过程所取的方式。“以光方式”是指以有光泽而照亮的方式。“或以颜色界方式”是指如眼影粉、银、布等之颜色界。因其是色界禅,故仅是世间的。 435. Rūpīti ettha yenāyaṃ sasantatipariyāpannena rūpena samannāgato, taṃ yassa jhānassa hetubhāvena visiṭṭharūpaṃ hoti. Yena visiṭṭhena rūpīti vucceyya, tadeva sasantatipariyāpannarūpanimittaṃ jhānaṃ. Idha pana paramatthato rūpibhāvasādhakanti āha – ‘‘ajjhattaṃ kesādīsū’’tiādi. Rūpajjhānaṃ rūpanti uttarapadalopena vuttaṃ – ‘‘rūpūpapattiyā’’tiādīsu (dha. sa. 160-161, 185-190 ādayo, 244-245 ādayo; vibha. 625) viya. 435. 此处“有色者”(rūpī),是指他所具有的、包含于自身相续中的色,此色乃是作为某禅那之因的殊胜色。他因之被称为“有色者”的此殊胜色,即是以包含于自身相续中的色为相的禅那。然此处,为从胜义上成就“有色者”之状态,故说“于内发等……”。“色禅”省略后分而称为“色”,犹如“为生于色界……”(rūpūpapattiyā)等(法集论 160-161, 185-190等; 分别论 625)中所说。 Subhantveva [Pg.270] adhimutto hotīti ayaṃ tatiyavimokkho. Idha suparisuddhanīlādivaṇṇakasiṇajjhānavasena vuttoti dassetvā idāni paṭisambhidāpāḷiyaṃ tassa brahmavihārajjhānavasena āgatabhāvaṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘paṭisambhidāmagge panā’’tiādi āraddhaṃ. Idha pana uparipāḷiyaṃyeva brahmavihārānaṃ āgatattā taṃ nayaṃ paṭikkhipitvā parisuddhanīlādivaṇṇakasiṇavaseneva subhavimokkho anuññāto. “唯胜解于净”,此为第三解脱。此句显示,此处是依于极清净的青等颜色遍禅而说。如今为显示在《无碍解道》(paṭisambhidāmagga)的圣典中,此解脱是依于梵住禅而来,故开始论述“然于《无碍解道》中……”等。然此处,因上文圣典中已述及诸梵住,故排斥彼说,而仅许可以极清净的青等颜色遍成就净解脱。 443. Parikammapathaviyāpīti akatāya vā katāya vā daḷhamaṇḍalādisaṅkhātaparikammapathaviyāpi. Uggahanimittādīnaṃ pathavīkasiṇanti nāmaṃ nissite nissayavohāravasena vuttanti daṭṭhabbaṃ, yathā ‘‘mañcā ukkuṭṭhiṃ karontī’’ti. 443. “亦于预备地”是指亦于已作或未作的、被称为“坚固圆相”等的预备地上。当知,称取相(uggahanimitta)等为“地遍”(pathavīkasiṇa),是依于所依处而对所依者作的称呼,犹如说“床在叫喊”。 Sīlānīti pātimokkhasaṃvarādīni cattāri sīlāni. Sodhetvāti anāpajjanena āpannavuṭṭhāpanena kilesehi appaṭipīḷanena ca visodhetvā. Tividhañhi sīlassa visodhanaṃ nāma – anāpajjanaṃ āpannavuṭṭhāpanaṃ kilesehi ca appaṭipīḷananti. Kammaṭṭhānabhāvanaṃ paribundheti uparodheti pavattituṃ na detīti palibodho rakārassa lakāraṃ katvā, paribandhoti attho. Upacchinditvāti samāpannena saṅgāhaṇena vā uparundhitvā, apalibodhaṃ katvāti attho. Kalyāṇamittaṃ upasaṅkamitvāti – “戒”指波罗提木叉律仪等四种戒。“净治”指通过不违犯、忏悔已犯、不为烦恼所逼迫而净化。戒的清净实有三种:不违犯、忏悔已犯、不为烦恼所逼迫。“障碍”(palibodha)指妨碍、阻止禅修生起,此词是将 r 音作 l 音,即 paribandha(束缚)之义。“截断”指通过入定或摄持而阻断,意即去除障碍。“亲近善友”即: ‘‘Piyo garu bhāvanīyo, vattā ca vacanakkhamo; Gambhīrañca kathaṃ kattā, no caṭṭhāne niyojako’’ti. (a. ni. 7.37) – “可爱、可敬、可尊重,善于教诫且能纳谏;能说甚深法,不于非处劝导。” Evamādiguṇasamannāgataṃ ekantahitesiṃ vuddhipakkhe ṭhitaṃ kalyāṇamittaṃ upasaṅkamitvā. 应当亲近这样一位具足如是等功德、纯粹为利益者、安住于增长之方的善友。 Ananurūpaṃ vihāranti aṭṭhārasannaṃ dosānaṃ aññatarena samannāgataṃ. Vuttañhetaṃ aṭṭhakathāsu – “不适宜的住所”是指具备十八种过失(dosa)中任何一种的住所。义注(aṭṭhakathā)中曾这样说过: ‘‘Mahāvāsaṃ navāvāsaṃ, jarāvāsañca panthaniṃ; Soṇḍiṃ paṇṇañca pupphañca, phalaṃ patthitameva ca. “大住所、新住所、老旧住所,以及路边舍;池塘边、叶屋,以及花、果常被人求取之处。 ‘‘Nagaraṃ dārunā khettaṃ, visabhāgena paṭṭanaṃ; Paccantasīmā sappāyaṃ, yattha mitto na labbhati. “城市、有木材处、田地,与不善者为邻的市镇;边陲之地虽适宜,却无友可寻觅。 ‘‘Aṭṭhārasetāni ṭhānāni, iti viññāya paṇḍito; Ārakā parivajjeyya, maggaṃ sappaṭibhayaṃ yathā’’ti. (visuddhi. 1.52); “智者明了此十八处,应远远避开,犹如险途。” Anurūpeti [Pg.271] gocaragāmato nātidūranaccāsannatādīhi pañcahi aṅgehi samannāgate. Vuttañhetaṃ bhagavatā – “适宜住处”是指具备离行乞村落不太远、不太近等五种条件的处所。世尊是这样说的: ‘‘Kathañca, bhikkhave, senāsanaṃ pañcaṅgasamannāgataṃ hoti? Idha, bhikkhave, senāsanaṃ nātidūraṃ hoti naccāsannaṃ gamanāgamanasampannaṃ divā appākiṇṇaṃ rattiṃ appasaddaṃ appanigghosaṃ appaḍaṃsamakasavātātapasarīsapasamphassaṃ. Tasmiṃ kho pana senāsane viharantassa appakasirena uppajjanti cīvarapiṇḍapātasenāsanagilānapaccayabhesajjaparikkhārā. Tasmiṃ kho pana senāsane therā bhikkhū viharanti bahussutā āgatāgamā dhammadharā vinayadharā mātikādharā. Te kālena kālaṃ upasaṅkamitvā paripucchati paripañhati ‘idaṃ, bhante, kathaṃ imassa ko attho’ti. Tassa te āyasmanto avivaṭañceva vivaranti, anuttānīkatañca uttāniṃ karonti, anekavihitesu ca kaṅkhāṭhāniyesu dhammesu kaṅkhaṃ paṭivinodenti. Evaṃ kho, bhikkhave, senāsanaṃ pañcaṅgasamannāgataṃ hotī’’ti (a. ni. 10.11). “诸比丘,怎样的住处(senāsana)才算是具备五种条件的住处呢?诸比丘,于此,住处既不太远也不太近,往来方便;白天不喧杂,夜晚少音声、少噪音,少虻、蚊、风、热、爬虫之扰。而且,住于彼处,能不费力地获得衣服、饮食、住所、病缘医药等资具。复次,彼处有诸长老比丘居住,他们博学多闻,传承圣教,持法、持律、持摩夷。可时时前往请益:‘尊者,此是何义?此句何解?’彼等具寿会为之开显未开显者,阐明未阐明者,于种种可疑之法,为之断疑。诸比丘,这样的住处就是具备五种条件的住处。” Ettha ca nātidūraṃ naccāsannaṃ gamanāgamanasampannanti ekaṃ aṅgaṃ, divā appākiṇṇaṃ rattiṃ appasaddaṃ appanigghosanti ekaṃ, appaḍaṃsamakasavātātapasarīsapasamphassanti ekaṃ, tasmiṃ kho pana senāsane viharantassa…pe… parikkhārāti ekaṃ, tasmiṃ kho pana senāsane therā…pe… kaṅkhaṃ paṭivinodentīti ekanti evaṃ pañcaṅgāni veditabbāni. 此处,“不太远也不太近,往来方便”为一分;“白天不喧杂,夜晚少音声、少噪音”为一分;“少虻、蚊、风、热、爬虫之扰”为一分;“住于彼处……资具”为一分;“彼处有诸长老……为之断疑”为一分。应知此为五分。 Khuddakapalibodhaṃ upacchinditvāti dīghakesanakhalomānaṃ chedanena cīvarakammacīvararajanapattapacanamañcapīṭhādisodhanavasena khuddakapalibodhaṃ upacchinditvā. “断除微细障碍”是指通过剪除长发、指甲、体毛,以及缝制、染色衣物,烧制钵,清洁床椅等,来断除微细的障碍。 453. Uddhumātakādīsūti ettha ādi-saddena vinīlakavipubbakavicchiddakavikkhāyitakahatavikkhittakalohitakapuḷavakaaṭṭhikānaṃ saṅgaho daṭṭhabbo. Tattha bhastā viya vāyunā uddhaṃ jīvitapariyādānā yathānukkamaṃ samuggatena sūnabhāvena dhumātattā uddhumātaṃ, uddhumātameva uddhumātakaṃ, paṭikūlattā vā kucchitaṃ uddhumātanti uddhumātakaṃ, tathārūpassa chavasarīrassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Vinīlaṃ vuccati viparibhinnanīlavaṇṇaṃ, vinīlameva vinīlakaṃ, paṭikūlattā vā kucchitaṃ vinīlanti vinīlakaṃ, maṃsussadaṭṭhānesu rattavaṇṇassa[Pg.272], pubbasannicayaṭṭhānesu setavaṇṇassa, yebhuyyena ca nīlavaṇṇassa nilaṭṭhāne nīlasāṭakapārutasseva chavasarīrassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Paribhinnaṭṭhānesu vissandamānapubbaṃ vipubbaṃ, vipubbameva vipubbakaṃ, paṭikūlattā vā kucchitaṃ vipubbanti vipubbakaṃ, tathārūpassa chavasarīrassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Vicchiddaṃ vuccati dvidhā chindanena apadhāritaṃ, vicchiddameva vicchiddakaṃ, paṭikūlattā vā kucchitaṃ vicchiddanti vicchiddakaṃ, vemajjhe chinnassa chavasarīrassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Ito ca etto ca vividhākārena soṇasiṅgālādīhi khāyitaṃ vikkhāyitaṃ, vikkhāyitameva vikkhāyitakaṃ, paṭikūlattā vā kucchitaṃ vikkhāyitanti vikkhāyitakaṃ, tathārūpassa chavasarīrassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. 453. 关于“膨胀相(uddhumātaka)等”,此中“等”字,当知包含青瘀相(vinīlaka)、脓烂相(vipubbaka)、断坏相(vicchiddaka)、食残相(vikkhāyitaka)、散乱相(vikkhitta)、斩斫离散相(hatavikkhittaka)、血涂相(lohitaka)、虫聚相(puḷavaka)、骸骨相(aṭṭhika)。其中,如充满风的皮囊,因命绝后身体依次肿胀而膨起,称为膨胀相;膨胀相即是膨胀相;或因其可厌,故称可鄙的膨胀相,此为此类尸身之名。青瘀相,指颜色变异为青色;青瘀相即是青瘀相;或因其可厌,故称可鄙的青瘀相,此为肌肉丰厚处呈红色、脓液积聚处呈白色、而大部分地方呈青色,犹如披着青色衣物的尸身之名。脓烂相,指从破裂处流淌脓液;脓烂相即是脓烂相;或因其可厌,故称可鄙的脓烂相,此为此类尸身之名。断坏相,指被从中劈开为二;断坏相即是断坏相;或因其可厌,故称可鄙的断坏相,此为从中间断裂的尸身之名。食残相,指被狗、豺狼等从各处以各种方式啃食;食残相即是食残相;或因其可厌,故称可鄙的食残相,此为此类尸身之名。 Vividhā khittaṃ vikkhittaṃ, vikkhittameva vikkhittakaṃ, paṭikūlattā vā kucchitaṃ vikkhittanti vikkhittakaṃ, aññena hatthaṃ, aññena pādaṃ, aññena sīsanti evaṃ tato tato vikkhittassa chavasarīrassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Hatañca taṃ purimanayeneva vikkhittakañcāti hatavikkhittakaṃ, kākapadākārena aṅgapaccaṅgesu satthena hanitvā vuttanayeneva vikkhittassa chavasarīrassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Lohitaṃ kirati vikkhipati ito cito ca paggharatīti lohitakaṃ, paggharitalohitamakkhitassa chavasarīrassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Puḷavā vuccanti kimayo, puḷave kiratīti puḷavakaṃ, kimiparipuṇṇassa chavasarīrassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Aṭṭhiyeva aṭṭhikaṃ, paṭikūlattā vā kucchitaṃ aṭṭhīti aṭṭhikaṃ, aṭṭhisaṅkhalikāyapi ekaṭṭhikassapi etaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Imesu dasasu asubhesu paṭhamajjhānameva uppajjati, na dutiyādīni. Tenāha – idha ‘‘paṭhamajjhānasahagatā saññā’’ti. Tathā hi aparisaṇṭhitajalāya sīghasotāya nadiyā arittabaleneva nāvā tiṭṭhati, vinā arittena na sakkā ṭhapetuṃ. Evamevaṃ dubbalattā ārammaṇassa vitakkabaleneva cittaṃ ekaggaṃ hutvā tiṭṭhati, vinā vitakkena na sakkā ṭhapetuṃ. Tasmā paṭhamajjhānamevettha hoti, na dutiyādīni. Ārammaṇassa dubbalatā cettha paṭikūlabhāvena cittaṃ ṭhapetuṃ asamatthatā. 种种散乱,故为散乱相(vikkhittaka);散乱相即是散乱相;或因其可厌,故称可鄙的散乱相,此为一手在此、一足在彼、头颅在别处,如此散落各处的尸身之名。遭砍斫且如前述般散乱,故为斩斫离散相(hatavikkhittaka),此为肢体被刀剑砍成乌鸦脚印状,并如前述般散乱的尸身之名。血液四处流溢、溅洒,故为血涂相(lohitaka),此为流淌的血液所涂满的尸身之名。“puḷavā”意为“kimayo”(蛆虫)。蛆虫滋生,故为虫聚相(puḷavaka),此为充满蠕虫的尸身之名。仅存骸骨,即为骸骨相(aṭṭhika);或因其可厌,故称可鄙的骸骨相,此名可用于整副骨架(aṭṭhisaṅkhalikā),亦可用于单块骨头。于此十不净中,仅能生起初禅,不能生起二禅等。故说——此乃“与初禅相应的想(saññā)”。譬如在无岸的急流中,船只仅能依桨力而停住,无桨则无法停留。同样,因此所缘微弱,心仅能依寻(vitakka)之力而达一境性安住,无寻则无法安住。是故,于此仅有初禅,无二禅等。此中所缘的弱点,在于其可厌的本质,(本身)无力令心安住。 ‘‘Rukkho mato, lohaṃ mata’’ntiādīsu yaṃ khandhappabandhaṃ upādāya rukkhādisamaññā, tasmiṃ anupacchinnepi allatādivigamanaṃ nissāya matavohāro sammutimaraṇaṃ. Saṅkhārānaṃ khaṇabhaṅgasaṅkhātaṃ khaṇikamaraṇaṃ. Samucchedamaraṇanti arahato santānassa sabbaso ucchedabhūtaṃ maraṇaṃ. Vipassanābhāvanāvasena cetaṃ vuttaṃ. Maraṇānussatibhāvanāyaṃ pana tividhampetaṃ nādhippetaṃ [Pg.273] asaṃvegavatthuto anupaṭṭhahanato abāhullato ca. Maraṇānussatiyañhi ekena bhavena paricchinnassa jīvitindriyappabandhassa vicchedo maraṇanti adhippeto saṃvegavatthuto upaṭṭhahanato bāhullato ca. Idāni imameva maraṇaṃ sandhāya vikappantaraṃ dassento, ‘‘heṭṭhā vuttalakkhaṇā vā’’tiādimāha. “树死了,铁死了”等说法中,依于蕴相续而有树等名称,即使此(蕴相续)未断,但因湿润等消失,而有“死”的说法,此为世俗死。诸行刹那坏灭,称为刹那死。断灭死是指阿罗汉的相续完全断灭的死亡。这是就观(vipassanā)修而言。然而,在修习死随念时,这三种死并非意趣所在,因为它们不是悚惧事、不现起、也不普遍。在死随念中,意趣所在的死亡,是指为一期生命所限定的命根相续的断绝,因为这是悚惧事、能现起、且普遍。现在,为了针对这种死亡显示另一种分别,因此说“或者具有前述的特征”等。 Asitapītādibhedeti asitapītakhāyitasāyitappabhede, asitabbakhāditabbasāyitabbavibhāgeti attho kālabhedavacanicchāya abhāvato yathā ‘‘duddha’’nti. Kabaḷaṃ karīyatīti kabaḷīkāro, āharīyatīti āhāro, kabaḷīkāro ca so āhāro cāti kabaḷīkārāhāro. Vatthuvasena cetaṃ vuttaṃ. Savatthuko eva hi āhāro idha kammaṭṭhānabhāvena adhippeto. Ojālakkhaṇo pana āhāro ojaṭṭhamakaṃ rūpaṃ āharatīti āhāroti vuccati. So idha nādhippeto paṭikūlākāraggahaṇassa asambhavato. Nava paṭikūlānīti gamanapariyesanaparibhogāsayanidānaaparipakkaparipakkaphalanissandappaṭikūlavasena nava paṭikūlāni. Samakkhanappaṭikūlaṃ pana paribhogādīsu labbhamānattā idha visuṃ na gahitaṃ, aññathā tena saddhiṃ ‘‘dasa paṭikūlānī’’ti vattabbaṃ. Visuddhimagge (visuddhi. 1.303-304) pana samakkhanaṃ paribhogādīsu labbhamānampi nissandavasena visesato paṭikūlanti visuṃ gahetvā dasahākārehi paṭikūlatā vuttā. 所谓“食、饮等差别”,即食、饮、嚼、尝的种类,其意为应食、应饮、应嚼、应尝的区分。此中并无意表达时间差异,犹如“乳”(duddha)字。团块被制作故称“团食”(kabaḷīkāra),被摄取故称“食”(āhāra),既是团食又是食,故称“段食”(kabaḷīkārāhāra)。此乃就其物质体而言。此处作为业处(kammaṭṭhāna)所意指的是有物质的食。而以滋养素为特征的食,因其带来以滋养素为第八的色法(ojaṭṭhamakaṃ rūpaṃ)而称为食,但此处不取,因其无法作为把握厌恶相的对象。所谓九种厌恶,即依行乞、遍求、受用、处所、积集、未消化、已消化、果、流出而有九种厌恶。至于涂抹之厌恶,因在受用等过程中即可获得,故此处不另举,否则应连同它说“十种厌恶”。然而在《清净道论》(Visuddhimagga)中,涂抹虽在受用等过程中即可获得,但因其作为流出物而尤为厌恶,故单独列出,以十种行相宣说厌恶。 Uppajjanakasaññanti paṭikūlākāraggahaṇavasena uppajjanakasaññaṃ. Saññāsaddo cāyaṃ ‘‘rūpasaññā saddasaññā’’tiādīsu (saṃ. ni. 3.57) sañjānanalakkhaṇe dhamme āgato, ‘‘aniccasaññā dukkhasaññā’’tiādīsu vipassanāya āgato, ‘‘uddhumātakasaññāti vā sopākarūpasaññāti vā ime dhammā ekaṭṭhā, udāhu nānaṭṭhā’’tiādīsu samathe āgato. Idha pana samathassa parikamme daṭṭhabbo. Āhārehi paṭikūlākāraggahaṇaṃ, tappabhāvitaṃ vā upacārajjhānaṃ idha ‘‘āhāre paṭikūlasaññā’’ti adhippetaṃ. 生起想:即通过把握厌恶相(paṭikūlākāra)而生起的想。此中“想”(saññā)一词,于“色想、声想”等(《相应部》3.57)中,指以识知为相之法;于“无常想、苦想”等中,指观(vipassanā);于“‘肿胀想(uddhumātaka-saññā)或尸骸想(sopākarūpa-saññā)等法为一或为异?’”等中,指止(samatha)。而此处,当知是指止的预备(parikamma)阶段。于食物中把握厌恶相,或由之培育的近行定(upacārajjhāna),于此皆意指“食厌想”(āhāre paṭikūlasaññā)。 Ukkaṇṭhitasaññanti nibbindanākārena uppajjanakasaññaṃ. Aniccasaññanti ettha aniccaṃ khandhapañcakaṃ uppādavayaññathattabhāvato, hutvā abhāvato vā, tasmiṃ anicce khandhapañcake aniccanti uppajjamānā aniccalakkhaṇapariggāhikā saññā aniccasaññā. Tenāha – ‘‘pañcannaṃ upādānakkhandhāna’’ntiādi. Tattha udayo [Pg.274] nibbattilakkhaṇaṃ, vayo vipariṇāmalakkhaṇaṃ, aññathattaṃ jarā. Udayabbayaññathattaggahaṇena aniccalakkhaṇaṃ dasseti. Uppādavayaññathattabhāvato hi khandhapañcakaṃ aniccanti vuccati. Yassa ca sabhāvena khandhapañcakaṃ aniccanti vuccati, taṃ aniccalakkhaṇaṃ. Tena hi taṃ aniccanti lakkhīyati, aniccalakkhaṇañca udayabbayānaṃ amanasikārā santatiyā paṭicchannattā na upaṭṭhāti, udayabbayaṃ pana pariggahetvā santatiyā vikopitāya aniccalakkhaṇaṃ yāthāvasarasato upaṭṭhāti. Na hi sammadeva udayabbayaṃ sallakkhentassa pubbāpariyena pavattamānānaṃ dhammānaṃ aññoññabhāvaṃ sallakkhaṇena santatiyā ugghāṭitāya dhammā sambandhabhāvena upaṭṭhahanti, atha kho ayosalākā viya asambandhabhāvenāti suṭṭhutaraṃ aniccalakkhaṇaṃ pākaṭaṃ hoti. 厌想:即以厌离行相生起之想。无常想:此中,五蕴因有生、灭、异,或因曾有而无,故为无常。于此无常五蕴中,生起把握无常相之想,即是无常想。故云“五取蕴”等。其中,“生”是生起相,“灭”是变坏相,“异”是老。通过把握生、灭、异,即显示无常相。五蕴因有生、灭、异之性,故称无常。五蕴被称为无常所依之自性,即是无常相。以此,它被识记为无常。然无常相因不作意生灭,为相续所覆,故不现起。若把握生灭,破除相续,无常相便如实现起。实则,正当观照生灭,通过识辨前后生起诸法的相异性而揭开相续时,诸法并非以关连的状态现起,而是如铁条般,以不相连的状态现起,如是,无常相则更为显明。 ‘‘Yadaniccaṃ, taṃ dukkha’’nti (saṃ. ni. 3.15, 45, 46, 76, 77, 85; 2.4.1, 4) vacanato tadeva khandhapañcakaṃ abhiṇhappaṭipīḷanato dukkhaṃ, abhiṇhappaṭipīḷanākāro pana dukkhalakkhaṇaṃ. Tenevāha – ‘‘anicce khandhapañcake…pe… saññaṃ bhāvetī’’ti. Tattha paṭipīḷanaṃ nāma yathāpariggahitaṃ udayavayavasena saṅkhārānaṃ nirantaraṃ paṭipīḷiyamānatā vibādhiyamānatā. Dukkhalakkhaṇañca abhiṇhasampaṭipīḷanassa amanasikārā iriyāpathehi paṭicchannattā na upaṭṭhāti, abhiṇhasampaṭipīḷanaṃ pana manasi karitvā iriyāpathe labbhamānadukkhappaṭicchādakabhāve ugghāṭite dukkhalakkhaṇaṃ yāthāvasarasato upaṭṭhāti. Tathā hi iriyāpathehi paṭicchannattā dukkhalakkhaṇaṃ na upaṭṭhāti, te ca iriyāpathā abhiṇhasampaṭipīḷanāmanasikārena paṭicchādakā jātā. Ekasmiñhi iriyāpathe uppannassa dukkhassa vinodakaṃ iriyāpathantaraṃ tassa paṭicchādakaṃ viya hoti, evaṃ sesāpi. Iriyāpathānaṃ pana taṃtaṃdukkhapatitākārabhāve yāthāvato ñāte tesaṃ dukkhappaṭicchādakabhāvo ugghāṭito nāma hoti saṅkhārānaṃ nirantaraṃ dukkhābhitunnatāya pākaṭabhāvato. Tasmā abhiṇhasampaṭipīḷanaṃ manasi karitvā iriyāpathe labbhamānadukkhappaṭicchādakabhāve ugghāṭite dukkhalakkhaṇaṃ yāthāvasarasato upaṭṭhāti. 依“凡无常者,即是苦”(《相应部》3.15等)之说,彼五蕴因恒受逼迫故为苦,而恒受逼迫之行相即是苦相。故云:“于无常五蕴中……修习想”。此中所谓逼迫,即是诸行如所把握,依于生灭,持续不断地被逼恼、被损害。苦相,因不作意恒常逼迫,为威仪所覆,故不现起。然若作意恒常逼迫,揭开威仪中所得的覆苦之性,苦相便如实现起。的确,苦相因威仪所覆而不现起,而彼等威仪,正因不作意恒常逼迫而成其覆障。于一威仪中生起之苦,另一威仪能除遣之,犹如覆障,其余亦然。然若如实了知诸威仪陷入彼彼苦之行相,则其覆苦之性即名揭开,因诸行恒为苦所刺迫之状态已显明故。是故,若作意恒常逼迫,揭开威仪中所得的覆苦之性,苦相便如实现起。 ‘‘Yaṃ dukkhaṃ, tadanattā’’ti vacanato tadeva khandhapañcakaṃ avasavattanato anattā, avasavattanākāro pana anattalakkhaṇaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘paṭipīḷanaṭṭhenā’’tiādi[Pg.275]. Anattalakkhaṇañca nānādhātuvinibbhogassa amanasikārā ghanena paṭicchannattā na upaṭṭhāti, nānādhātuyo pana vinibbhujjitvā ‘‘aññā pathavīdhātu, aññā āpodhātū’’tiādinā, ‘‘añño phasso, aññā vedanā’’tiādinā ca visuṃ visuṃ katvā ghanavinibbhoge kate samūhaghane kiccārammaṇaghane ca bhedite anattalakkhaṇaṃ yāthāvasarasato upaṭṭhāti. Yā hesā aññamaññūpatthambhesu samuditesu rūpārūpadhammesu ekattābhinivesavasena aparimadditasaṅkhārehi mamāyamānā samūhaghanatā, tathā tesaṃ tesaṃ dhammānaṃ kiccabhedassa satipi paṭiniyatabhāve ekato gayhamānā kiccaghanatā, tathā sārammaṇadhammānaṃ satipi ārammaṇakaraṇabhede ekato gayhamānā ārammaṇaghanatā. Sā catūsu dhātūsu ñāṇena vinibbhujitvā dissamānāsu hatthena parimaddiyamāno pheṇapiṇḍo viya vilīnaṃ āgacchati, yathāpaccayaṃ pavattamānā suññā ete dhammamattāti avasavattanākārasaṅkhātaṃ anattalakkhaṇaṃ pākaṭataraṃ hoti. “凡是苦的,就是无我”,依此所说,五蕴因不能自主故为无我,而不能自主相即是无我相。所以说:‘以逼迫义’等等。无我相由于不作意种种界分别,被坚固性所遮盖故不显现;若将种种界一一剖析,作‘地界是一,水界是另一’等观,或作‘触是一,受是另一’等分别,破除聚合坚固性、作用坚固性与所缘坚固性后,无我相即如实显现。对于那些相互支撑而生起的色法与非色法,未经审察的诸行以一体之想执为‘我所有’,此即聚合坚固性;以及诸法作用虽有差异却被执为同一,此即作用坚固性;乃至有所缘诸法虽所缘作用各异却被执为同一,此即所缘坚固性——当以智慧将四界分解开来而能被看见时,这些坚固性犹如用手揉搓泡沫聚块般消散。诸法唯依缘而生起,仅是空法,像这样,以无法自主相为特性的无我相便愈发明晰。 Aparaaccharāsaṅghātavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 另一弹指品释义终。 19. Kāyagatāsativaggavaṇṇanā 19. 身至念品释义 563. Cetasā phuṭoti cittena pharito. Cittena pharaṇañca samuddassa dvidhā sambhavatīti āha – ‘‘duvidhaṃ pharaṇa’’ntiādi. Purimena atthenāti ‘‘sampayogavasena vijjaṃ bhajantī’’ti vuttena atthena. Pacchimenāti ‘‘vijjābhāge vijjākoṭṭhāse vattantī’’ti vuttena. 563. “以心遍满”(cetasā phuṭo),即是以心遍布(cittena pharito)。心的遍满有两种可能,所以说“两种遍满”等等。前者的意思是“以相应故而修习明”所说的意思。后者的意思是“在明的部分、明的范围中运作”所说的意思。 564. Mahato saṃvegāya saṃvattatītiādīsu ayaṃ pana aparo nayo. Yāthāvato kāyasabhāvappavedanato mahato saṃvegāya saṃvattati. Atthāyāti diṭṭhadhammikādiatthāya. Yogakkhemāyāti catūhi yogehi khemabhāvāya. Satisampajaññāyāti sabbattha satiavippavāsāya sattaṭṭhāniyasampajaññāya ca. Ñāṇadassanappaṭilābhāyāti vipassanāñāṇādhigamāya. Vijjāvimuttiphalasacchikiriyāyāti tisso vijjā cittassa adhimutti nibbānaṃ cattāri sāmaññaphalānīti etesaṃ paccakkhakaraṇāya. 564. 在“导致极大警醒”等句中,这是另一种方法。如实宣说身的自性,能导致极大警醒。“为利益”,即为现法等利益。“为离轭安稳”,即从四种轭中得到安稳。“为正念与正知”,即在一切处不离失正念,以及为七处正知。“为获得智见”,即为证得观智。“为现证明与解脱之果”,即为亲证三明、心解脱、涅槃和四沙门果。 584. Paññāpaṭilābhāyātiādīsu [Pg.276] soḷasasu padesu paññāpaṭilābhāya paññāvuddhiyā paññāvepullāya paññābāhullāyāti imāni cattāri paññāvasena bhāvavacanāni, sesāni dvādasa puggalavasena bhāvavacanāni. Sappurisasaṃsevoti sappurisānaṃ bhajanaṃ. Saddhammassavananti tesaṃ sappurisānaṃ santike sīlādippaṭipattidīpakassa saddhammavacanassa savanaṃ. Yoniso manasikāroti sutānaṃ dhammānaṃ atthūpaparikkhāvasena upāyena manasikāro. Dhammānudhammappaṭipattīti lokuttaradhamme anugatassa sīlādippaṭipadādhammassa paṭipajjanaṃ. 584. 在“为获得智慧”等十六处中,“为获得智慧”、“为增长智慧”、“为广大智慧”、“为丰饶智慧”这四句是以智慧为角度的表述,其余十二句是以人为角度的表述。“亲近善士”是指亲近善人。“听闻正法”是指在那些善士身边听闻能够阐明戒等行道的正法言教。“如理作意”是指以探究所闻之法的意义的方式作意。“法次法向”是指实践随顺于出世间法的戒等行道之法。 Channaṃ abhiññāñāṇānanti iddhividhadibbasotacetopariyapubbenivāsadibbacakkhuāsavakkhayañāṇānaṃ. Tesattatīnaṃ ñāṇānanti paṭisambhidāpāḷiyaṃ (paṭi. ma. 1.1-2 mātikā) ‘‘sotāvadhāne paññā sutamaye ñāṇaṃ, sutvāna saṃvare paññā sīlamaye ñāṇa’’ntiādinā ñāṇakathāya niddiṭṭhānaṃ sāvakasādhāraṇāsādhāraṇānaṃ ñāṇānaṃ. Imesañhi tesattatiñāṇānaṃ sutamayañāṇādīni sattasaṭṭhiñāṇāni sāvakassa sādhāraṇāni, ‘‘indriyaparopariyatte ñāṇaṃ, sattānaṃ āsayānusaye ñāṇaṃ, yamakapāṭihīre ñāṇaṃ, mahākaruṇāsamāpattiyā ñāṇaṃ, sabbaññutaññāṇaṃ, anāvaraṇañāṇa’’nti (paṭi. ma. 1.68-73 mātikā) imāni cha asādhāraṇañāṇāni sāvakehi. “六神通智”是指神变通、天耳通、他心通、宿命通、天眼通、漏尽智。“七十三种智”是指在《无碍解道》(Paṭisambhidāmagga)中,以“听闻时的智慧是闻所成智,听闻后防护时的智慧是戒所成智”等方式,在“智论”中所述的声闻共通和不共通的那些智慧。在这七十三种智中,闻所成智等六十七种智是声闻所共通的;“根上下智、众生意乐随眠智、双神变智、大悲定智、一切知智、无碍智”这六种是声闻所不共通的。 Sattasattatīnaṃ ñāṇānanti ettha – 于“七十七种智”中,此处是指: ‘‘Jātipaccayā jarāmaraṇanti ñāṇaṃ, asati jātiyā natthi jarāmaraṇanti ñāṇaṃ. Atītampi addhānaṃ jātipaccayā jarāmaraṇanti ñāṇaṃ, asati jātiyā natthi jarāmaraṇanti ñāṇaṃ. Anāgatampi addhānaṃ jātipaccayā jarāmaraṇanti ñāṇaṃ, asati jātiyā natthi jarāmaraṇanti ñāṇaṃ. Yampissa taṃ dhammaṭṭhitiñāṇaṃ, tampi khayadhammaṃ vayadhammaṃ virāgadhammaṃ nirodhadhammanti ñāṇaṃ. Bhavapaccayā jātīti ñāṇaṃ…pe… upādānapaccayā bhavoti ñāṇaṃ, taṇhāpaccayā upādānanti ñāṇaṃ, vedanāpaccayā taṇhāti ñāṇaṃ, phassapaccayā vedanāti ñāṇaṃ, saḷāyatanapaccayā phassoti ñāṇaṃ, nāmarūpapaccayā saḷāyatananti ñāṇaṃ, viññāṇapaccayā nāmarūpanti ñāṇaṃ, saṅkhārapaccayā viññāṇanti ñāṇaṃ, avijjāpaccayā saṅkhārāti ñāṇaṃ, asati [Pg.277] avijjāya natthi saṅkhārāti ñāṇaṃ, atītampi addhānaṃ avijjāpaccayā saṅkhārāti ñāṇaṃ, asati avijjāya natthi saṅkhārāti ñāṇaṃ, anāgatampi addhānaṃ avijjāpaccayā saṅkhārāti ñāṇaṃ, asati avijjāya natthi saṅkhārāti ñāṇaṃ, yampissa taṃ dhammaṭṭhitiñāṇaṃ, tampi khayadhamaṃ vayadhammaṃ virāgadhammaṃ nirodhadhammanti ñāṇa’’nti – “‘缘于生而有老死’是智,‘无生则无老死’是智。于过去世,‘缘于生而有老死’是智,‘无生则无老死’是智。于未来世,‘缘于生而有老死’是智,‘无生则无老死’是智。其法住智,亦是知其为坏法、灭法、离贪法、寂灭法之智。‘缘于有而有生’是智……乃至……‘缘于取而有有’是智,‘缘于爱而有取’是智,‘缘于受而有爱’是智,‘缘于触而有受’是智,‘缘于六处而有触’是智,‘缘于名色而有六处’是智,‘缘于识而有名色’是智,‘缘于行而有识’是智,‘缘于无明而有行’是智,‘无无明则无行’是智。于过去世,‘缘于无明而有行’是智,‘无无明则无行’是智。于未来世,‘缘于无明而有行’是智,‘无无明则无行’是智。其法住智,亦是知其为坏法、灭法、离贪法、寂灭法之智。” Bhagavatā nidānavagge (saṃ. ni. 2.34-35) jarāmaraṇādīsu ekādasasu paṭiccasamuppādaṅgesu paccekaṃ satta satta katvā vuttāni sattasattatiñāṇāni. 世尊在《因缘品》(相应部2.34-35)中,对于老死等十一种缘起支,每一支各说七种,总共说了七十七种智。 Tattha dhammaṭṭhitiñāṇanti paccayākārañāṇaṃ. Paccayākāro hi dhammānaṃ pavattisaṅkhātāya ṭhitiyā kāraṇattā ‘‘dhammaṭṭhitī’’ti vuccati, tattha ñāṇaṃ dhammaṭṭhitiñāṇaṃ, ‘‘jātipaccayā jarāmaraṇa’’ntiādinā vuttasseva chabbidhassa ñāṇassetaṃ adhivacanaṃ. Khayadhammanti khayagamanasabhāvaṃ. Vayadhammanti vayagamanasabhāvaṃ. Virāgadhammanti virajjanasabhāvaṃ. Nirodhadhammanti nirujjhanasabhāvanti attho. 此处,“法住智”即是缘起智。缘起,因是诸法生起状态之因,故被称为“法住”,于此之智即是法住智。这是对“缘于生而有老死”等所说的六种智的别名。“坏法”意为有坏灭性质。“灭法”意为有消逝性质。“离贪法”意为有离染性质。“寂灭法”意为有寂灭性质。 Lābhotiādīsu lābhoyeva upasaggena visesetvā ‘‘paṭilābho’’ti vutto. Puna tasseva atthavivaraṇavasena ‘‘patti sampattī’’ti vuttaṃ. Phusanāti adhigamanavasena phusanā. Sacchikiriyāti paṭilābhasacchikiriyā. Upasampadāti nipphādanā. 在“利”等词中,“利”(lābha)一词由前缀加以区别后,称为“得”(paṭilābha)。再为解释其义,说为“至”(patti)、“成就”(sampatti)。“触”(phusanā)是就证得的意义而言的触及。“现证”(sacchikiriyā)是获得的现证。“具足”(upasampadā)是成就。 Sattannañca sekkhānanti tisso sikkhā sikkhantīti sekkhasaññitānaṃ sotāpattimaggaṭṭhādīnaṃ sattannaṃ. Puthujjanakalyāṇakassa cāti nibbānagāminiyā paṭipadāya yuttattā sundaraṭṭhena kalyāṇasaññitassa puthujjanassa. Vaḍḍhitaṃ vaḍḍhanaṃ ekāyāti vaḍḍhitavaḍḍhanā. Yathāvuttānaṃ aṭṭhannampi paññānaṃ vasena visesatova arahato paññāvasena paññāvuddhiyā. Tathā paññāvepullāya. 七有学(sekkhā):即修习三学,故名有学,指住于须陀洹道(sotāpattimagga)等七种人。以及贤善凡夫(puthujjanakalyāṇaka):指因与趣向涅槃之道相应,以美好之义而名为贤善的凡夫。增长又增长,是依如前所说的八种慧,尤其是依阿罗汉的慧,而有智慧的增长。智慧也同样得以广大。 Yassa kassacipi visesato anurūpadhammassa mahantaṃ nāma kiccasiddhiyā veditabbanti tadassa kiccasiddhiyā dassento ‘‘mahante atthe pariggaṇhātī’’tiādimāha. Tattha atthādīnaṃ mahantabhāvo mahāvisayatāya veditabbo, mahāvisayatā ca tesaṃ paṭisambhidāmagge āgatanayena veditabbā. Sīlakkhandhassa pana hetumahantatāya, paccayamahantatāya, nissayamahantatāya[Pg.278], pabhedamahantatāya, kiccamahantatāya, phalamahantatāya, ānisaṃsamahantatāya ca mahantabhāvo veditabbo. Tattha hetu alobhādayo. Paccayo hirottappasaddhāsativīriyādayo. Nissayo sāvakabodhipaccekabodhiniyatatā taṃsamaṅgino ca purisavisesā. Pabhedo cārittavārittādivibhāgo. Kiccaṃ tadaṅgādivasena paṭipakkhavidhamanaṃ. Phalaṃ saggasampadā nibbānasampadā ca. Ānisaṃso piyamanāpatādi. Ayamettha saṅkhepo, vitthāro pana visuddhimagge (visuddhi. 1.9) ākaṅkheyyasuttādīsu (ma. ni. 1.64 ādayo) ca āgatanayena veditabbo. Iminā nayena samādhikkhandhādīnampi mahantatā yathārahaṃ niddhāretvā vattabbā. Ṭhānāṭṭhānādīnaṃ mahantabhāvo pana mahāvisayatāya veditabbo. Tattha ṭhānāṭṭhānānaṃ mahāvisayatā bahudhātukasuttādīsu āgatanayena veditabbā. 无论何人,若具足相应的殊胜之法,当知其事业成就为大。为显示其事业成就,故说“摄受大义”等。其中,义等的伟大,当知是由于其所缘广大;而所缘广大,当依《无碍解道》(Paṭisambhidāmagga)中所说之理了知。至于戒蕴的伟大,当从因伟大、缘伟大、依止伟大、分类伟大、作用伟大、果伟大、功德伟大来了知。其中,因是无贪等。缘是惭、愧、信、念、精进等。依止是声闻菩提、独觉菩提的决定性,以及具足此法的殊胜之人。分类是作持与止持等差别。作用是以镇伏对治等方式摧破敌对法。果是天界圆满与涅槃圆满。功德是可爱、可意等。此为简略说明,详尽者当依《清净道论》(Visuddhimagga 1.9)及《希求经》(Ākaṅkheyyasutta, Majjhima Nikāya 1.64)等中所说之理了知。循此道理,定蕴等的伟大也应如理确定而说。至于处非处等的伟大,当知是由于其所缘广大。其中,处非处的所缘广大,当依《多界经》(Bahudhātukasutta)等中所说之理了知。 Vihārasamāpattīnaṃ mahāvisayatā samādhikkhandhe mahāvisayatāniddhāraṇanayena veditabbā, ariyasaccānaṃ sakalayānasaṅgāhakato saccavibhaṅge (vibha. 189 ādayo) taṃsaṃvaṇṇanāsu (vibha. aṭṭha. 189 ādayo) ca āgatanayena, satipaṭṭhānādīnaṃ satipaṭṭhānavibhaṅgādīsu (vibha. 355 ādayo) taṃsaṃvaṇṇanādīsu (vibha. aṭṭha. 355 ādayo) ca āgatanayena, sāmaññaphalānaṃ mahato hitassa mahato sukhassa mahato atthassa mahato yogakkhemassa nipphattibhāvato santapaṇītaatakkāvacarapaṇḍitavedanīyabhāvato, abhiññānaṃ mahāsambhārato mahāvisayato mahākiccato mahānubhāvato mahānipphattito, nibbānassa madanimmadanādimahatthasiddhito ca mahantabhāvo veditabbo. Pariggaṇhātīti sabhāvādito paricchijja gaṇhāti jānāti, paṭivijjhatīti attho. 诸住等至(Vihārasamāpatti)的所缘广大,当依定蕴中确定所缘广大之理了知;圣谛的伟大,在于其能含摄一切乘,当依《分别论》(Vibhaṅga 189)及其释义(vaṇṇanā)中所说之理了知;念处等的伟大,当依《念处分别》(Satipaṭṭhānavibhaṅga, Vibhaṅga 355)及其释义等中所说之理了知;沙门果(sāmaññaphala)的伟大,在于其能成就大利益、大安乐、大义利、大安稳,以及其寂静、殊胜、非寻思所行、唯智者所证的特质;神通(abhiññā)的伟大,在于其大资粮、大所缘、大作用、大威力、大成就;涅槃的伟大,在于其能成就调伏骄慢等大义。当知此等皆为伟大。“遍取”(Pariggaṇhāti)是从自性等方面加以限定而把握、了知,此即“通达”(paṭivijjhati)之义。 Puthupaññāti etthāpi vuttanayānusārena attho veditabbo. Ayaṃ pana viseso – puthu nānākkhandhesu ñāṇaṃ pavattatīti ‘‘ayaṃ rūpakkhandho nāma…pe… ayaṃ viññāṇakkhandho nāmā’’ti evaṃ pañcannaṃ khandhānaṃ nānākaraṇaṃ paṭicca ñāṇaṃ pavattati. Tesupi ekavidhena rūpakkhandho…pe… ekādasavidhena rūpakkhandho. Ekavidhena vedanākkhandho…pe… bahuvidhena vedanākkhandho. Ekavidhena saññākkhandho…pe… bahuvidhena saññākkhandho. Ekavidhena saṅkhārakkhandho…pe… bahuvidhena saṅkhārakkhandho. Ekavidhena viññāṇakkhandho…pe… bahuvidhena [Pg.279] viññāṇakkhandhoti evaṃ ekekassa khandhassa ekavidhādivasena atītādivasenapi nānākaraṇaṃ paṭicca ñāṇaṃ pavattati. “多慧”(Puthupaññā)一词,其义亦当依前述之理了知。但此有差别:智慧于种种蕴中转起,即依于“此是色蕴……此是识蕴”如此五蕴的种种差别而转起智慧。于彼等蕴中,又依于“色蕴为一类……色蕴为十一类;受蕴为一类……受蕴为多类;想蕴为一类……想蕴为多类;行蕴为一类……行蕴为多类;识蕴为一类……识蕴为多类”,如此每一蕴的一类等差别,以及过去等差别,依种种差别而转起智慧。 Puthu nānādhātūsūti ‘‘ayaṃ cakkhudhātu nāma…pe… ayaṃ manoviññāṇadhātu nāma. Tattha soḷasa dhātuyo kāmāvacarā, dve cātubhūmikā’’ti evaṃ dhātūsu nānākaraṇaṃ paṭicca ñāṇaṃ pavattati. Tayidaṃ upādinnadhātuvasena vuttaṃ. Paccekabuddhānañhi dvinnañca aggasāvakānaṃ upādinnadhātūsu eva nānākaraṇaṃ paṭicca ñāṇaṃ pavattati, tañca kho ekadesatova, na nippadesato. Bahiddhā anupādinnadhātūnaṃ nānākaraṇaṃ tesaṃ avisayova, sabbaññubuddhānaṃyeva pana ‘‘imāya dhātuyā ussannattā imassa rukkhassa khandho seto hoti, imassa kāḷo, imassa maṭṭho, imassa kharo, imassa bahalataco, imassa sukkhataco. Imassa pattaṃ vaṇṇasaṇṭhānādivasena evarūpaṃ. Imassa pupphaṃ nīlaṃ, pītaṃ, lohitaṃ, odātaṃ, sugandhaṃ, duggandhaṃ, missakagandhaṃ. Phalaṃ khuddakaṃ, mahantaṃ, dīghaṃ, vaṭṭaṃ, suvaṇṇaṃ, dubbaṇṇaṃ, maṭṭhaṃ, pharusaṃ, sugandhaṃ, duggandhaṃ, madhuraṃ, tittakaṃ, ambilaṃ, kaṭukaṃ, kasāvaṃ. Kaṇṭako tikhiṇo, atikhiṇo, ujuko, kuṭilo, tambo, nīlo, lohito, odāto’’tiādinā dhātunānattaṃ paṭicca ñāṇaṃ pavattati. 于种种界中(nānādhātūsu)有慧:即依于“此是眼界……此是意识界。其中十六界属欲界,二界通四地”,如此于诸界的种种差别而转起智慧。此乃就所执取界(upādinnadhātu)而言。独觉佛(Paccekabuddha)与二大弟子,亦仅依于所执取界的种种差别而转起智慧,且仅是一部分,而非全部。外在的非所执取界(anupādinnadhātu)的种种差别,非其所行境。唯有全知佛陀(sabbaññubuddha)能依于界的种种差别而转起智慧,了知:“因某界增盛,此树之干为白、为黑、为滑、为粗、皮厚、皮薄。此树之叶,颜色形状等为如是。此树之花,为青、黄、赤、白,或香、或臭、或杂香。其果或小、或大、或长、或圆,色善、色不善,或滑、或涩,或香、或臭,或甜、或苦、或酸、或辣、或涩。其刺或利、或不利,或直、或曲,或铜色、或青、或赤、或白”等。 Puthu nānāāyatanesūti ‘‘idaṃ cakkhāyatanaṃ nāma…pe… idaṃ dhammāyatanaṃ nāma. Tattha dasāyatanā kāmāvacarā, dve cātubhūmakā’’ti evaṃ āyatananānattaṃ paṭicca ñāṇaṃ pavattati. 于种种处中(nānāāyatanesu)有慧:即依于“此是眼处……此是法处。其中十处属欲界,二处通四地”,如此依于处的种种差别而转起智慧。 Puthu nānāpaṭiccasamuppādesūti ajjhattabahiddhābhedato santānabhedato ca nānappabhedesu paṭiccasamuppādaṅgesu. Avijjādiaṅgāni hi paccekaṃ paṭiccasamuppādasaññitāni. Tenāha – saṅkhārapiṭake ‘‘dvādasa paccayā dvādasa paṭiccasamuppādā’’ti (saṃ. ni. ṭī. 1.1.110). 于种种缘起中(nānāpaṭiccasamuppādesu)有慧:即于依内外之别、相续之别而有种种差别的缘起支(paṭiccasamuppādaṅga)中转起智慧。无明等诸支,一一皆名为“缘起”。是故,于《相应部》疏钞(Saṃyutta Nikāya ṭīkā 1.1.110)中说:“十二缘即十二缘起”。 Puthu nānāsuññatamanupalabbhesūti nānāsabhāvesu niccasārādivirahitesu suññasabhāvesu, tato eva itthipurisaattattaniyādivasena anupalabbhamānasabhāvesu. Ma-kāro hettha padasandhikaro. 于种种空与不可得中(nānāsuññatamanupalabbhesu)有慧:即于种种自性中,因其无常、无我等,故为空性;又正因如此,于其中不可得女人、男人、我、我所等自性。此中“ma”字为语连接音。 Puthu nānāatthesūti atthapaṭisambhidāvisayesu paccayuppannādinānāatthesu. Dhammesūti dhammapaṭisambhidāvisayesu paccayādinānādhammesu. Niruttīsūti [Pg.280] tesaṃyeva atthadhammānaṃ niddhāraṇavacanasaṅkhātesu nānāniruttīsu. Puthu nānāpaṭibhānesūti atthapaṭisambhidādivisayesu imāni ñāṇāni idamatthajotakānīti tathā tathā paṭibhānato upatiṭṭhanato paṭibhānānīti laddhanāmesu nānāñāṇesu. 于种种义中(nānāatthesu)有慧:即于义无碍解(atthapaṭisambhidā)所行境的缘生法等种种义中。于种种法中(nānādhammesu):即于法无碍解(dhammapaṭisambhidā)所行境的缘等种种法中。于种种词中(nānāniruttīsu):即于名为确定彼等义与法的言说之种种词中。于种种辩才中(nānāpaṭibhānesu):即于义无碍解等所行境中,因“此等智为阐明此义”而如是如是显现、现起,故得名为“辩才”(paṭibhāna)的种种智中。 Puthu nānāsīlakkhandhesūtiādīsu sīlassa puthuttaṃ nānattañca vuttameva, itaresaṃ pana vuttanayānusārena suviññeyyattā pākaṭameva. Yaṃ pana abhinnaṃ ekameva nibbānaṃ, tattha upacāravasena puthuttaṃ gahetabbanti āha – ‘‘puthu nānājanasādhāraṇe dhamme samatikkammā’’ti. Tenassa madanimmadanādipariyāyena puthuttaṃ paridīpitaṃ hoti. 在“种种戒蕴”等处,已说明戒的众多与各异。至于其余诸法,依循已说之理,亦易了知,故甚明显。然而,对于那不可分割、唯一的涅槃,则是以譬喻的方式来理解其众多性,如言:“超越种种凡夫所共之法”。由此,通过“摧伏骄慢”等不同言说,阐明了其众多性。 Vipule attheti mahante atthe. Mahantapariyāyo hi vipulasaddo. Gambhīresūti sasādīhi viya mahāsamuddo anupacitañāṇasambhārehi alabbhaneyyappatiṭṭhesu khandhesu ñāṇaṃ pavattatīti visayassa gambhīratāya ñāṇassa gambhīratā vibhāvitā. “于广大义”即“于宏大义”。“广大”一词,实为“宏大”的同义词。所谓“于甚深”,是指智慧于诸蕴中运行;对于未积集智慧资粮者而言,此诸蕴是无法立足之处,犹如大海之于兔等。此乃以所缘之甚深,阐明智慧之甚深。 Tikkhavisadabhāvādiguṇehi asādhāraṇattā paresaṃ paññāya na sāmantā, atha kho suvidūravidūreti asamantapaññā ākārassa rassattaṃ katvā. Keci ‘‘asamatthapaññā’’ti paṭhanti, tesaṃ yathāvuttaguṇehi aññehi asādhāraṇattā natthi etissā kāyaci samatthanti asamatthā paññāti yojanā. Atthavavatthānatoti atthappabhedassa yāthāvato sanniṭṭhānato. Na añño koci sakkoti abhisambhavitunti ñāṇagatiyā sampāpuṇituṃ na añño kocipi sakkoti, tasmā ayaṃ suvidūravidūreti asamantapaññā. Idāni puggalantaravasena asamantapaññaṃ vibhāvetuṃ, ‘‘puthujjanakalyāṇakassā’’tiādi āraddhaṃ. 因具有锐利、明澈等不共特质,他人的智慧无法与之相比,因此称为“无邻极远智”(asamantapaññā)。也有人读作“无能及智”(asamatthapaññā),其解释是:因为这种智慧具有上述功德及其他不共特质,确实没有任何智慧可以与之相比,所以称为无能及智。“决了义趣”是指如实地确定各种意义的差别。在智慧的行境上,确实没有其他人能够达到,因此这种智慧是“无邻极远智”。现在为了从不同人的角度来辨别无邻极远智,所以开始了“凡夫善士”(puthujjanakalyāṇaka)等内容的讲解。 ‘‘Paññāpabhedakusalo abhinnañāṇo adhigatappaṭisambhido catuvesārajjappatto dasabaladhārī purisāsabho purisasīho purisanāgo purisājañño purisadhorayho anantañāṇo anantatejo anantayaso aḍḍho mahaddhano balavā netā vinetā anunetā paññāpetā vinijjhāpetā pekkhatā pasādetā. So hi bhagavā anuppannassa maggassa uppādetā, asañjātassa maggassa sañjanetā, anakkhātassa maggassa akkhātā, maggaññū maggavidū maggakovido. Maggānugāmī ca pana etarahi sāvakā viharanti pacchā samannāgatā. “于智慧差别善巧、具无碍智、已证得四无碍解、已达四无畏、具十力、是人中之牛、人中之狮子、人中之龙、人中之骏马、人中之领袖、具无量智慧、无量威力、无量名望、富有、大富、强有力、是引导者、调伏者、劝导者、开示者、明辨者、观察者、使人信服者。那位世尊,是未生起道的生起者、未出生道的出生者、未宣说道的宣说者,是知路者、明路者、善于行路者。而现在,弟子们随道而行,后来获得成就。” ‘‘So [Pg.281] hi bhagavā jānaṃ jānāti, passaṃ passati, cakkhubhūto ñāṇabhūto dhammabhūto brahmabhūto vattā pavattā atthassa ninnetā amatassa dātā dhammassāmī tathāgato, natthi tassa bhagavato aññātaṃ adiṭṭhaṃ aviditaṃ asacchikataṃ aphassitaṃ paññāya. Atītaṃ anāgataṃ paccuppannaṃ upādāya sabbe dhammā sabbākārena buddhassa bhagavato ñāṇamukhe āpāthaṃ āgacchanti, yaṃ kiñci neyyaṃ nāma atthi taṃ sabbaṃ jānitabbaṃ, attattho vā parattho vā ubhayattho vā diṭṭhadhammiko vā attho samparāyiko vā attho uttāno vā attho gambhīro vā attho gūḷho vā attho paṭicchanno vā attho neyyo vā attho nīto vā attho anavajjo vā attho nikkileso vā attho vodāno vā attho paramattho vā attho, sabbaṃ taṃ antobuddhañāṇe parivattati. “因为,彼世尊知其所知,见其所见,是眼,是智,是法,是梵,是说者,是宣说者,是义理的引导者,是不死甘露的施与者,是法主,是如来。于彼世尊,没有不被知晓的,没有不被见到的,没有不被觉知的,没有不被证实的,没有不被智慧触及的。过去、未来、现在,所有诸法,以种种方式,都来到佛陀世尊的智慧之门前。凡是应知之法,皆可被了知,无论是为了自身利益,为了他人利益,为了双方利益,无论是现世的利益,还是来世的利益,无论是显明的利益,还是深奥的利益,无论是隐藏的利益,还是被覆盖的利益,无论是需要引导的利益,还是已经被引导的利益,无论是无过失的利益,还是无烦恼的利益,无论是清净的利益,还是究竟的利益——这一切都在佛陀的智慧中运转。” ‘‘Sabbaṃ kāyakammaṃ buddhassa bhagavato ñāṇānuparivatti, sabbaṃ vacīkammaṃ buddhassa bhagavato ñāṇānuparivatti, sabbaṃ manokammaṃ buddhassa bhagavato ñāṇānuparivatti. Atīte buddhassa bhagavato appaṭihataṃ ñāṇaṃ, anāgate buddhassa bhagavato appaṭihataṃ ñāṇaṃ, paccuppanne buddhassa bhagavato appaṭihataṃ ñāṇaṃ, yāvatakaṃ neyyaṃ, tāvatakaṃ ñāṇaṃ. Yāvatakaṃ ñāṇaṃ, tāvatakaṃ neyyaṃ. Neyyapariyantikaṃ ñāṇaṃ, ñāṇapariyantikaṃ neyyaṃ, neyyaṃ atikkamitvā ñāṇaṃ nappavattati, ñāṇaṃ atikkamitvā neyyapatho natthi, aññamaññapariyantaṭṭhāyino te dhammā, yathā dvinnaṃ samuggapaṭalānaṃ sammā phusitānaṃ heṭṭhimaṃ samuggapaṭalaṃ uparimaṃ nātivattati, uparimaṃ samuggapaṭalaṃ heṭṭhimaṃ nātivattati, aññamaññapariyantaṭṭhāyino, evamevaṃ buddhassa bhagavato neyyañca ñāṇañca aññamaññapariyantaṭṭhāyino. Yāvatakaṃ neyyaṃ, tāvatakaṃ ñāṇaṃ. Yāvatakaṃ ñāṇaṃ, tāvatakaṃ neyyaṃ, neyyapariyantikaṃ ñāṇaṃ, ñāṇapariyantikaṃ neyyaṃ, neyyaṃ atikkamitvā ñāṇaṃ nappavattati, ñāṇaṃ atikkamitvā neyyapatho natthi. Aññamaññapariyantaṭṭhāyino te dhammā. Sabbadhammesu buddhassa bhagavato ñāṇaṃ pavattati. “佛陀世尊的一切身业都随智慧运转,一切语业都随智慧运转,一切意业都随智慧运转。过去,佛陀世尊的智慧无碍;未来,佛陀世尊的智慧无碍;现在,佛陀世尊的智慧无碍。有多少应知法,就有多少智慧;有多少智慧,就有多少应知法。智慧以应知法为边际,应知法以智慧为边际。智慧不超越应知法而转起,超越智慧则无应知法之道。此二法互相为边际而存在,犹如两个紧密合缝的盒盖,下盖不超越上盖,上盖不超越下盖,互相为边际而存在。同样地,佛陀世尊的应知法和智慧,互相为边际而存在。有多少应知法,就有多少智慧;有多少智慧,就有多少应知法。智慧以应知法为边际,应知法以智慧为边际。智慧不超越应知法而转起,超越智慧则无应知法之道。此二法互相为边际而存在。佛陀世尊的智慧于一切法中运转。” ‘‘Sabbe [Pg.282] dhammā buddhassa bhagavato āvajjanappaṭibaddhā ākaṅkhappaṭibaddhā manasikārappaṭibaddhā cittuppādappaṭibaddhā, sabbasattesu buddhassa bhagavato ñāṇaṃ pavattati. Sabbesaṃ sattānaṃ buddho āsayaṃ jānāti, anusayaṃ jānāti, caritaṃ jānāti, adhimuttiṃ jānāti, apparajakkhe mahārajakkhe tikkhindriye mudindriye svākāre dvākāre suviññāpaye duviññāpaye bhabbā sabbe satte pajānāti, sadevako loko samārako sabrahmako sassamaṇabrāhmaṇī pajā sadevamanussā antobuddhañāṇe parivattati. “一切法都与佛陀世尊的专注相关、与希求相关、与作意相关、与心的生起相关,佛陀世尊的智慧在一切众生中运行。佛陀了知一切众生的意乐、随眠、品行、胜解,了知少尘者与多尘者、利根者与钝根者、具善相者与具恶相者、易教导者与难教导者,了知众生之可教化与否。包括天界、魔界、梵天界,以及沙门婆罗门,连同天人在内的所有世间,都在佛陀的智慧范围内运转。” ‘‘Yathā ye keci macchakacchapā antamaso timitimiṅgalaṃ upādāya antomahāsamudde parivattanti, evameva sadevako loko samārako sabrahmako sassamaṇabrāhmaṇī pajā sadevamanussā antobuddhañāṇe parivattati. Yathā ye keci pakkhino antamaso garuḷaṃ venateyyaṃ upādāya ākāsassa padese parivattanti, evameva yepi te sāriputtasamā paññāya, tepi buddhañāṇassa padese parivattanti, buddhañāṇaṃ devamanussānaṃ paññaṃ pharitvā atighaṃsitvā tiṭṭhati. Yepi te khattiyapaṇḍitā brāhmaṇapaṇḍitā gahapatipaṇḍitā samaṇapaṇḍitā nipuṇā kataparappavādā vālavedhirūpā, vobhindantā maññe caranti paññāgatena diṭṭhigatāni, te te pañhaṃ abhisaṅkharitvā abhisaṅkharitvā’’ti (paṭi. ma. 3.5) – “正如所有鱼鳖,乃至提弥提明伽罗鱼,都依存于大海之中而游动;同样地,包含诸天、魔众、梵天的世间,连同沙门婆罗门及人天众生,都依存于佛陀的智慧之中而流转。正如所有飞鸟,乃至金翅鸟(garuḷa)维那提耶(venateyya),都依存于天空之中而翱翔;同样地,即使那些智慧如舍利弗(Sāriputta)的人,也都在佛陀智慧的领域中流转,佛陀的智慧遍覆、超越人天之智慧而安住。那些刹帝利智者、婆罗门智者、居士智者、沙门智者,他们精明能干,擅长破斥他论,如同善射者能射穿毛发,自认为能以智慧摧破各种见解,他们反复构思种种问题……” Ādinā niddiṭṭhapāḷiṃ peyyālamukhena saṃkhipitvā dassento ‘‘paññāpabhedakusalo pabhinnañāṇo…pe… te pañhaṃ abhisaṅkharitvā abhisaṅkharitvā’’tiādimāha. 为以节略方式显示开篇所引之文,故说:“于智慧差别善巧,具分别智……彼等反复构思、构思问题”等。 Tattha pabhinnañāṇoti atthādīsu pabhedagatañāṇo. ‘‘Pabhedañāṇo’’tipi paṭhanti, soyeva attho. Te pañhanti te te attanā adhippetaṃ pañhaṃ. Niddiṭṭhakāraṇāti vissajjitakāraṇā. Upakkhittakāti bhagavato paññāveyyattiyena samīpe khittakā antevāsikā sampajjanti. 于此,“分别智”(pabhinnañāṇa)指于义理等达到辨异的智慧。亦有读作“辨异智”(pabhedañāṇa)者,其义相同。“那些问题”是指他们各自所意欲提出的问题。“其因已示者”(Niddiṭṭhakāraṇā)是指其原因已被解答的人。“被置于近处者”(Upakkhittakā)是指由于世尊的智慧明晰,而被安置在其身边成为亲传弟子的人。 Bhavati [Pg.283] abhibhavatīti bhūri. Kiṃ? Rāgādiṃ. Upasagge satipi tadeva padaṃ tamatthaṃ vadatīti upasaggena vināpi so attho viññeyyo anekatthattā dhātūnanti vuttaṃ – ‘‘abhibhuyyatī’’ti. Kārakabyattayena cetaṃ vuttaṃ, tasmā rāgaṃ abhibhuyyatīti sā sā maggapaññā attanā attanā vajjhaṃ rāgaṃ abhibhuyyati abhibhavati, madatīti attho. Abhibhavatīti sā sā phalapaññā taṃ taṃ rāgaṃ bhavi abhibhavi maddīti bhūripaññā. ‘‘Abhibhavitā’’ti vā pāṭho, ‘‘abhibhavitvā’’tipi paṭhanti. Abhibhavitvāti ca kiriyāya siddhabhāvadassanaṃ. Paññā ce siddhā, rāgābhibhavo ca siddho evāti. Sesesupi eseva nayo. 能存在、能征服,故为“广”(bhūri)。征服什么?贪等。即使有前缀(upasagga),该词亦能表达此义;因词根(dhātu)具有多重含义,故即使没有前缀,此义亦应被理解——如言“被胜伏”(abhibhuyyati)。此乃就作者格的转换而言,因此“征服贪”是指彼彼道慧(maggapaññā)各自征服、压制其所应摧毁之贪,意即调伏。能征服,是彼彼果慧(phalapaññā)已征服、已压制、已摧毁彼彼之贪,故为广慧(bhūripaññā)。或有读作“能征服者”(abhibhavitā),亦有读作“征服后”(abhibhavitvā)。而“征服后”是表示行为的完成状态。若智慧已成就,则对贪的征服亦必已成就。于其余(烦恼)亦同此理。 Rāgādīsu pana rajjanalakkhaṇo rāgo. Dussanalakkhaṇo doso. Muyhanalakkhaṇo moho. Kujjhanalakkhaṇo kodho, upanandhanalakkhaṇo upanāho. Pubbakālaṃ kodho, aparakālaṃ upanāho. Paraguṇamakkhanalakkhaṇo makkho, yugaggāhalakkhaṇo palāso. Parasampattikhīyanalakkhaṇā issā, attano sampattiniggūhanalakkhaṇaṃ macchariyaṃ. Attanā katapāpappaṭicchādanalakkhaṇā māyā, attano avijjamānaguṇappakāsanalakkhaṇaṃ sāṭheyyaṃ. Cittassa uddhumātabhāvalakkhaṇo thambho, karaṇuttariyalakkhaṇo sārambho. Unnatilakkhaṇo māno, abbhunnatilakkhaṇo atimāno. Mattabhāvalakkhaṇo mado, pañcakāmaguṇesu cittavossaggalakkhaṇo pamādo. Bhavati abhibhavati arinti bhūri asarūpato parassa akārassa lopaṃ katvā. Tenāha – ‘‘ariṃ maddanipaññāti bhūripaññā’’ti. Bhavati ettha thāvarajaṅgamanti bhūri vuccati pathavī yathā ‘‘bhūmī’’ti bhūri viyāti bhūripaññā vitthatavipulaṭṭhena sabbaṃ sahatāya ca. Tenāha – ‘‘tāyā’’tiādi. Tattha pathavisamāyāti vitthatavipulaṭṭheneva pathavisamāya. Vitthatāyāti pajānitabbe visaye vitthatāya, na ekadese vattamānāya. Vipulāyāti uḷārabhūtāya. Samannāgatoti puggalo. Iti-saddo kāraṇatthe, iminā kāraṇena puggalassa bhūripaññāya samannāgatattā tassa paññā bhūripaññā nāmāti attho. ‘‘Bhūripaññassa paññā bhūripaññapaññā’’ti vattabbe ekassa paññāsaddassa lopaṃ katvā ‘‘bhūripaññā’’ti vuttaṃ. 于贪等中,染著是贪之相,瞋害是瞋之相,迷惑是痴之相。忿怒是嗔(kodha)之相,怀恨是恨(upanāha)之相。嗔在前,恨在后。覆蔽他人之德是覆(makkha)之相,争强好胜是竞(palāsa)之相。嫉妒他人所得是嫉(issā)之相,隐藏自身所得是悭(macchariya)之相。掩饰己过是伪(māyā)之相,彰显己所无之德是诳(sāṭheyya)之相。心顽固是憍(thambha)之相,争强好胜是慢(sārambha)之相。高举是慢(māna)之相,极高举是过慢(atimāna)之相。沉醉是骄(mada)之相,于五妙欲中心放纵是放逸(pamāda)之相。能存在、能征服敌人(ari),故为“广”(bhūri),此乃省略了(ari中)“a”音而形成。是故说:“能摧破敌人之慧,即为广慧。”于此中,有情与无情得以存在,故大地(pathavī)被称为“地”(bhūri),如称“भूमि”(bhūmi);广慧(bhūripaññā)亦如“地”,因其广博浩大,能含摄一切。是故说:“以彼……”等。其中,“如大地”即是因其广博浩大之义而如大地。广博者,谓于所应知之境普遍了知,非仅住于一处。浩大者,谓其殊胜。具足者,谓个人。“iti”一词用于表因,意谓:因此原因,该个人具足广慧,故其慧名为广慧。本应说“广慧者之慧”(bhūripaññassa paññā),但省略了一个“慧”字,而说为“广慧”。 Apicāti [Pg.284] paññāpariyāyadassanatthaṃ vuttaṃ. Paññāyametanti paññāya etaṃ. Adhivacananti adhikaṃ vacanaṃ. Bhūrīti bhūte atthe khandhādike ramati saccasabhāvena, diṭṭhi viya na abhūteti bhūri. Medhāti asani viya siluccaye kilese medhati hiṃsatīti medhā, khippaṃ gahaṇadhāraṇaṭṭhena vā medhā. Pariṇāyikāti yassuppajjati, taṃ sattaṃ attahitappaṭipattiyaṃ sampayuttadhamme ca yāthāvalakkhaṇappaṭivedhe pariṇetīti pariṇāyikā. Imeheva aññānipi paññāpariyāyavacanāni honti. 又,为说明智慧的种种表述而说。“以智慧”(Paññāyametaṃ)即“以此智慧”(paññāya etaṃ)。“增上语”(adhivacana)即“殊胜之语”(adhikaṃ vacanaṃ)。“广”(bhūri)是指在真实义中,以真实自性安住在蕴等事物上,不像邪见那样执取虚妄,所以称为广大。“慧”(medhā)是指像雷电一样摧毁堆积如山的烦恼,或者因为能够快速地领悟和记住,所以称为智慧。“引导者”(pariṇāyikā)是指能够引导生起智慧的有情(satta),使其在利益自身的修行道路上,以及在如实地彻知诸法真实相上得到引导。这些也都是智慧的异名。 Paññābāhullanti paññā bahulā assāti paññābahulo, tassa bhāvo paññābāhullaṃ. Tañca paññāya bāhullaṃ pavatti evāti tamatthaṃ paññāgarukassa puggalassa vasena dassento, ‘‘idhekacco paññāgaruko hotī’’tiādimāha. Tattha idhekaccoti puthujjanakalyāṇako, ariyo vā. Paññā garu ekassāti paññāgaruko. Paññāya carito pavattito paññācarito, paññāya caritaṃ pavattaṃ assāti vā paññācarito. Anulomikakhantiādivibhāgā paññā āsayo etassāti paññāsayo. Paññāya adhimutto tanninnoti paññādhimutto. Samussitaṭṭhena paññā dhajo etassāti paññādhajo. Paññāketūti tasseva vevacanaṃ. Paññānimittaṃ ādhipateyyaṃ etassāti paññādhipateyyo. Paññāsaṅkhāto vicayo, dhammasabhāvavicinanaṃ vā bahulaṃ etassāti vicayabahulo. Nānappakārena dhammasabhāvavicinanaṃ bahulaṃ assāti pavicayabahulo. Okkhāyanaṃ yāthāvato dhammānaṃ upaṭṭhānaṃ bahulaṃ etassāti okkhāyanabahulo. Paññāya tassa tassa dhammassa sammāpekkhanā sampekkhā, sampekkhāya ayanaṃ pavattanaṃ sampekkhāyanaṃ, sampekkhāyanaṃ dhammo pakati assāti sampekkhāyanadhammo. Sampekkhāyanaṃ vā yāthāvato dassanadhammo sabhāvo etassāti sampekkhāyanadhammo. Sabbaṃ dhammajātaṃ vibhūtaṃ vibhāvitaṃ katvā viharaṇasīloti vibhūtavihārī. “多慧”(paññābāhulla)是指智慧很多,拥有很多智慧的人被称为多慧者,而多慧的状态就称为“多慧”。为了显示重视智慧的个人(puggala)的特质,说明智慧的运作情况,所以才说“这里有一种重视智慧的个人”等等。“这里有一种”指的是贤善凡夫(puthujjanakalyāṇaka)或者圣者(ariya)。“以智慧为重者”(paññāgaruko)是指智慧是其所重者。“智慧行者”(paññācarito)是指依智慧而行事;也可以说他的行为是由智慧推动的。“智慧所依者”(paññāsayo)是指他的根基是随顺忍(anulomikakhanti)等分类的智慧。“智慧胜解者”(paññādhimutto)是指他的心倾向于智慧。“智慧幢者”(paññādhajo)是指他的旗帜是高举的智慧。“智慧旗”(paññāketu)是“智慧幢者”的同义词。“智慧主导者”(paññādhipateyyo)是指智慧是他的标志和主导。“多观察者”(vicayabahulo)是指他的特点是以智慧进行观察,或者经常观察诸法的自性。“多辨别者”(pavicayabahulo)是指以多种方式经常观察诸法的实相。“多明照者”(okkhāyanabahulo)是指经常如实显现诸法。以智慧正确地观察一一法,此即“正观”(sampekkhā);“正观”的行进、运作,即“正观行”(sampekkhāyanaṃ);“正观行”是其法、其本性者,即“正观行法”(sampekkhāyanadhammo)。或者,“正观行”是其如实见法之自性者,即“正观行法”。“明了住者”(vibhūtavihārī)是指彻照一切法类而安住的品行。 Taccaritotiādīsu taṃ-saddena paññā paccāmaṭṭhā, tasmā tattha ‘‘paññācarito’’tiādinā attho veditabbo. Sā paññā caritā garukā bahulā assāti taccarito taggaruko tabbahulo. Tassaṃ paññāyaṃ ninno poṇo pabbhāro adhimuttoti tanninno tappoṇo tappabbhāro tadadhimutto. Sā paññā adhipati tadadhipati, tadadhipatito āgato [Pg.285] tadādhipateyyo. Paññāgarukotiādīni ‘‘kāmaṃ sevantaṃyeva jānāti, ayaṃ puggalo nekkhammagaruko’’tiādīsu (paṭi. ma. 1.114) viya purimajātito pabhuti vuttāni. Taccaritotiādīni imissā jātiyā vuttāni. Idāni vuttamevatthaṃ nidassanavasenapi dassetuṃ – ‘‘yathā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Evamevantiādīni dassitabbanigamanaṃ. 于“彼行”(taccarito)等词中,“彼”(taṃ)字回指智慧,因此其义应理解为“慧行”(paññācarito)等。彼慧是所行、所重、所多者,故为“彼行者”(taccarito)、“彼重者”(taggaruko)、“彼多者”(tabbahulo)。于彼慧,其心倾向、低垂、倾斜、胜解,故为“倾向彼者”(tanninno)、“低垂于彼者”(tappoṇo)、“倾斜于彼者”(tappabbhāro)、“胜解彼者”(tadadhimutto)。彼慧是主,故为“以彼为主”(tadadhipati);由“以彼为主”而来,故为“以彼为主导者”(tadādhipateyyo)。“重慧”等词,如于“虽受用欲乐,亦知此人重于出离”(《无碍解道》Paṭisambhidāmagga 1.114)等处所说,是就过去生而言。而“彼行”等词,是就此生而言。今为以譬喻显示已说之义,故说“犹如”等。“如是”等词,是为所示之义作总结。 Sīghapaññāti attano visaye sīghappavattikā paññā, yā samāraddhā attano paññākiccaṃ adandhāyantī avitthāyantī khippameva sampāpeti. Tenāha – ‘‘sīghaṃ sīghaṃ sīlāni paripūretī’’tiādi. Tattha sīghaṃ sīghanti bahūnaṃ sīlādīnaṃ saṅgahatthaṃ dvikkhattuṃ vuttaṃ. Sīlānīti cārittavārittavasena paññattāni pātimokkhasaṃvarasīlāni, ṭhapetvā vā indriyasaṃvaraṃ tassa visuṃ gahitattā itarāni tividhasīlāni. Indriyasaṃvaranti cakkhādīnaṃ channaṃ indriyānaṃ rāgappaṭighappavesaṃ akatvā satikavāṭena nivāraṇaṃ thakanaṃ. Bhojane mattaññutanti paccavekkhitaparibhogavasena bhojane pamāṇaññubhāvaṃ. Jāgariyānuyoganti divasassa tīsu koṭṭhāsesu rattiyā paṭhamamajjhimakoṭṭhāsesu ca jāgarati na niddāyati, samaṇadhammameva karotīti jāgaro, jāgarassa bhāvo, kammaṃ vā jāgariyaṃ, jāgariyassa anuyogo jāgariyānuyogo, taṃ jāgariyānuyogaṃ. Sīlakkhandhanti sekkhaṃ vā asekkhaṃ vā sīlakkhandhaṃ. Evamitarepi khandhā veditabbā. Paññākkhandhanti maggapaññā ca sekkhāsekkhānaṃ lokiyapaññā ca. Vimuttikkhandhanti phalavimutti. Vimuttiñāṇadassanakkhandhanti paccavekkhaṇañāṇaṃ. Sīghapaññāniddesasadisoyeva lahupaññāniddeso, tathā hāsapaññāniddeso. Javanapaññāniddeso pana kalāpasammasananayena pavatto. Tikkhapaññāniddeso vīriyassa ussukkāpanavasena, nibbedhikapaññāniddeso sabbaloke anabhiratasaññāvasena pavatto. Tattha turitakiriyā sīghatā. Adandhatā lahutā. Vegāyitattaṃ khippatā. “速慧(sīghapaññā)”是指于自己的领域中迅速生起的智慧,此慧一旦发起,即能不迟缓、不延滞地迅速完成其智慧的作用。因此说“速速圆满诸戒”等。此处“速速”一词重复,是为了总括众多的戒等法。“诸戒”是指依行止(cārittavāritta)而制定的波罗提木叉(pātimokkha)律仪戒,除去已被单独列出的根律仪(indriyasaṃvara)之外的其余三种戒。“根律仪”即是对眼等六根,不让贪与瞋侵入,以正念之门防护、遮止。“于食知量(bhojane mattaññutā)”是指通过省察受用,而了知饮食的份量。“勤修觉醒(jāgariyānuyoga)”是指在白天的三时及夜晚的初分与中分保持清醒而不睡眠,只修行沙门法,此即为“觉醒(jāgara)”;觉醒的状态或行为称为“觉醒(jāgariya)”;对觉醒的致力称为“勤修觉醒”。“戒蕴(sīlakkhandha)”指有学或无学的戒蕴。其余诸蕴也应如是了知。“慧蕴(paññākkhandha)”指道慧以及有学与无学的世间慧。“解脱蕴(vimuttikkhandha)”指果解脱。“解脱智见蕴(vimuttiñāṇadassanakkhandha)”指省察智。“速慧的解释(sīghapaññāniddesa)”与“轻慧的解释(lahupaññāniddesa)”相似,“喜慧的解释(hāsapaññāniddesa)”亦然。“速行慧的解释(javanapaññāniddesa)”则以聚思惟的方式展开。“锐慧的解释(tikkhapaññāniddeso)”以策励精进的方式展开,“决择慧的解释(nibbedhikapaññāniddeso)”则以对一切世间不喜乐想的方式展开。其中,行动迅速是“速性(sīghatā)”;不迟缓是“轻性(lahutā)”;迅疾是“快性(khippatā)”。 Hāsabahuloti pītibahulo. Sesapadāni tasseva vevacanāni. Atha vā hāsabahuloti mūlapadaṃ. Vedabahuloti tassā eva pītiyā sampayuttasomanassavedanāvasena niddesapadaṃ. Tuṭṭhibahuloti nātibalavapītiyā tuṭṭhākāravasena. Pāmojjabahuloti balavapītiyā pamuditabhāvavasena. Sīlāni paripūretīti haṭṭhappahaṭṭho udaggūdaggo [Pg.286] sampiyāyamāno sīlāni sampādeti. Pītisomanassasahagatā hi paññā abhirativasena ārammaṇe phullitā vikasitā viya pavattati, na evaṃ upekkhāsahagatāti. “多喜(hāsabahula)”即是多喜悦(pītibahula)。其余词语是它的同义词。或者说,“多喜”是根本词。“多受(vedabahula)”是就与此喜相应的喜受(somanassavedanā)而言的解释词。“多满足(tuṭṭhibahula)”是就不太强烈的喜悦所表现出的满足状态而言。“多欢悦(pāmojjabahula)”是就强烈的喜悦所表现出的欢欣状态而言。“圆满诸戒”是指怀着欢喜、雀跃、欣悦、喜爱之情而成就诸戒。因为与喜(pīti)和喜受相应的智慧,以乐于其中的方式,于所缘中如花朵绽放般地生起,而与舍相应的智慧则非如此。 Aniccato khippaṃ javatīti ‘‘khandhapañcakaṃ anicca’’nti vegāyitena pavattati, paṭipakkhadūrībhāvena pubbābhisaṅkhārassa sātisayattā indena vissaṭṭhavajiraṃ viya lakkhaṇaṃ avirajjhantī adandhāyantī aniccalakkhaṇaṃ vegasā paṭivijjhati, tasmā sā javanapaññā nāmāti attho. Sesapadesupi eseva nayo. Evaṃ lakkhaṇārammaṇikavipassanāvasena javanapaññaṃ dassetvā balavavipassanāvasena dassetuṃ – ‘‘rūpa’’ntiādi vuttaṃ. Tattha khayaṭṭhenāti yattha yattha uppajjati, tattha tattheva bhijjanato khayasabhāvattā. Bhayaṭṭhenāti bhayānakabhāvato. Asārakaṭṭhenāti attasāravirahato niccasārādivirahato ca. Tulayitvāti tulābhūtāya vipassanāpaññāya tuletvā. Tīrayitvāti tāya eva tīraṇabhūtāya tīretvā. Vibhāvayitvāti yāthāvato pakāsetvā pākaṭaṃ katvā. Atha vā tulayitvāti kalāpasammasanavasena tulayitvā. Tīrayitvāti udayabbayānupassanāvasena tīretvā. Vibhāvayitvāti bhaṅgānupassanādivasena pākaṭaṃ katvā. Vibhūtaṃ katvāti saṅkhārupekkhānulomavasena phuṭaṃ katvā. Rūpanirodheti rūpakkhandhassa nirodhabhūte nibbāne. Khippaṃ javatīti ninnapoṇapabbhāravasena javati pavattati. Idāni sikhāppattavipassanāvasena javanapaññaṃ dassetuṃ, puna ‘‘rūpa’’ntiādi vuttaṃ. “于无常迅速奔驰”,即是说“五蕴无常”,它以迅疾之势流转。由于远离对治法,且宿行(pubbābhisaṅkhāra)强盛,犹如帝释(Inda)所投掷的金刚杵(vajira)一般,不离其相,不稍迟缓,迅速地洞穿无常相(aniccalakkhaṇa),因此名为速行慧(javanapaññā)。其余文句亦同此理。如是,通过以相为所缘的观(lakkhaṇārammaṇikavipassanā)开显了速行慧后,为开显强力之观(balavavipassanā),而说“色”等。其中,“以灭尽义(khayaṭṭhena)”是指,无论于何处生起,即于彼处坏灭,故有灭尽的自性。“以怖畏义(bhayaṭṭhena)”是指,具有怖畏的性质。“以无实义(asārakaṭṭhena)”是指,缺少我之实、常之实等。“称量(tulayitvā)”是指,以如秤般的观慧(vipassanāpaññā)来称量。“审察(tīrayitvā)”是指,以彼审察性的智慧来审察。“明了(vibhāvayitvā)”是指,如实地阐明,令其显现。或者,“称量”是指,以聚思惟(kalāpasammasana)的方式来称量;“审察”是指,以生灭随观(udayabbayānupassanā)的方式来审察;“明了”是指,以坏灭随观(bhaṅgānupassanā)等方式令其显现。“令其显现(vibhūtaṃ katvā)”是指,以行舍智与随顺智的方式令其明晰。“于色之灭(rūpanirodhe)”是指,于作为色蕴(rūpakkhandha)寂灭的涅槃(nibbāna)。“迅速奔驰”是指,如水流向低洼倾斜处般地奔驰、流转。现在,为开显达到顶点的观(sikhāppattavipassanā)中的速行慧,而再说“色”等。 Ñāṇassa tikkhabhāvo nāma savisesaṃ paṭipakkhasamucchindanena veditabboti ‘‘khippaṃ kilese chindatīti tikkhapaññā’’ti vatvā te pana kilese vibhāgena dassento, ‘‘uppannaṃ kāmavitakka’’ntiādimāha. Samathavipassanāhi vikkhambhanatadaṅgavasena pahīnampi ariyamaggena asamūhatattā uppattidhammataṃ anatītatāya asamūhatuppannanti vuccati, taṃ idha ‘‘uppanna’’nti adhippetaṃ. Nādhivāsetīti santānaṃ āropetvā na vāseti. Pajahatīti samucchedavasena pajahati. Vinodetīti khipati. Byantiṃ karotīti vigatantaṃ karoti. Anabhāvaṃ gametīti anu abhāvaṃ gameti, vipassanākkamena ariyamaggaṃ patvā samucchedavaseneva abhāvaṃ gamayatīti attho. Ettha ca kāmappaṭisaṃyutto vitakko kāmavitakko. ‘‘Ime sattā [Pg.287] marantū’’ti paresaṃ maraṇappaṭisaṃyutto vitakko byāpādavitakko. ‘‘Ime sattā vihiṃsiyantū’’ti paresaṃ vihiṃsāpaṭisaṃyutto vitakko vihiṃsāvitakko. Pāpaketi lāmake. Akusale dhammeti akosallasambhūte dhamme. Tikkhapañño nāma khippābhiñño hoti, paṭipadā cassa na calatīti āha – ‘‘ekamhi āsane cattāro ariyamaggā’’tiādi. 所谓智(ñāṇa)的锐利性(tikkhabhāva),当知是由于能特别地正断敌对法。说到“能迅速斩断诸烦恼,故为锐慧(tikkhapaññā)”,为分别开示那些烦恼,而说“已生起的欲寻(kāmavitakka)”等。虽已通过止(samatha)与观(vipassanā),以镇伏断(vikkhambhana-pahāna)及彼分断(tadaṅga-pahāna)的方式断除,但因未被圣道(ariyamagga)根除,未超越其生起之法性,故说为“未根除而生起”,此处的“已生起”即是此意。“不容忍(nādhivāseti)”是指不让其在心相续中安住。“舍弃(pajahati)”是指以正断断(samuccheda-pahāna)的方式舍弃。“遣除(vinodeti)”是指驱逐。“令其终结(byantiṃ karoti)”是指使其灭绝。“令其无有(anabhāvaṃ gameti)”是指使其趋向于无,意即通过观的次第,到达圣道,以正断断的方式使其不存在。此处,与欲相应的寻(vitakka)是欲寻;“愿此等众生死去”是与他人死亡相应的寻,即是瞋寻(byāpādavitakka);“愿此等众生受伤害”是与伤害他人相应的寻,即是害寻(vihiṃsāvitakka)。“诸恶(pāpake)”即是诸卑劣法。“诸不善法(akusale dhamme)”即是由不善巧所生起的法。锐慧者是速通达者(khippābhiñña),其行道(paṭipadā)不动摇,故说“于一座中证四圣道”等。 ‘‘Sabbe saṅkhārā aniccā dukkhā vipariṇāmadhammā saṅkhatā paṭiccasamuppannā khayadhammā vayadhammā virāgadhammā nirodhadhammā’’ti yāthāvato dassanena saccappaṭivedho ijjhati, na aññathāti kāraṇamukhena nibbedhikapaññaṃ dassetuṃ – ‘‘sabbasaṅkhāresu ubbegabahulo hotī’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Tattha ubbegabahuloti ‘‘sabbe saṅkhārā aniccā’’tiādinā (dha. pa. 277) nayena sabbasaṅkhāresu abhiṇhappavattasaṃvego. Uttāsabahuloti ñāṇabhayavasena sabbasaṅkhāresu bahuso utrastamānaso. Tena ādīnavānupassanamāha. Ukkaṇṭhanabahuloti saṅkhārato uddhaṃ visaṅkhārābhimukhatāya ukkaṇṭhanabahulo. Iminā nibbidānupassanamāha. Aratibahulotiādinā tassā eva aparāparūpapattiṃ. Bahimukhoti sabbasaṅkhārato bahibhūtaṃ nibbānaṃ uddissa pavattañāṇamukho. Tathā pavattitavimokkhamukho. Nibbijjhanaṃ paṭivijjhanaṃ nibbedho, so etissā atthīti nibbedhikā, nibbijjhatīti vā nibbedhikā, sā eva paññā nibbedhikapaññā. Anibbiddhapubbanti anamatagge saṃsāre antaṃ pāpetvā anividdhapubbaṃ. Appadālitapubbanti tasseva atthavacanaṃ, antakaraṇeneva appadālitapubbanti attho. Lobhakkhandhanti lobharāsiṃ, lobhakoṭṭhāsaṃ vā. “‘诸行皆是无常、苦、变易法,是有为、缘生、毁坏法、消亡法、离贪法、寂灭法。’如是如实见,方能证悟圣谛,别无他途。为从因由上阐明彻见慧(nibbedhikapaññā),故说‘于诸行多有悚惧(ubbegabahula)’等。于此,‘多有悚惧’,是依‘诸行无常’等(《法句经》277)之理,于诸行恒常生起悚惧(saṃvega)。‘多有恐惧(uttāsabahula)’,是以智见之怖,于诸行数数心生惊惧。此说观过患(ādīnavānupassanā)。‘多有厌患(ukkaṇṭhanabahula)’,是超越诸行、朝向无为(visaṅkhāra)而多有厌患。此说观厌离(nibbidānupassanā)。‘多有不乐(aratibahula)’等,是说其(厌离)相继生起。‘外向(bahimukha)’,是智慧朝向超越诸行之涅槃而转起,解脱之门亦如是转起。穿透(nibbijjhana)、彻入(paṭivijjhana)即是彻见(nibbedha)。具此者为‘彻见者’(nibbedhikā),或能穿透者为‘彻见者’。此即彻见慧。‘从未被彻见’(anibbiddhapubba),是在无始轮回(anamatagge saṃsāra)中,从未被彻见以至于令其终结。‘从未被破穿’(appadālitapubba)与上句同义,意为从未被破穿以至于令其终结。‘贪蕴’(lobhakkhandha),即贪之积聚,或贪之部分。” Kāyagatāsativaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 身至念品释义终。 20. Amatavaggavaṇṇanā 20. 不死品释义 600-611. Natthi ettha mataṃ maraṇaṃ vināsoti amataṃ, nibbānanti āha – ‘‘maraṇavirahitaṃ nibbānaṃ paribhuñjantī’’ti. Amatassa vā nibbānassa adhigamahetutāya [Pg.288] amatasadisaatappakasukhapatitatāya ca kāyagatāsati ‘‘amata’’nti vuttā. Paribhuñjantīti jhānasamāpajjanena vaḷañjanti. Viraddhanti anadhigamena virajjhitaṃ. Tenāha – ‘‘virādhitaṃ nādhigata’’nti. Āraddhanti sādhitaṃ nipphāditaṃ. Tañca paripuṇṇaṃ nāma hotīti āha – ‘‘āraddhanti paripuṇṇa’’nti. Pamādiṃsūti kālabyattayenedaṃ vuttanti āha – ‘‘pamajjantī’’ti. 600-611. 此处无有死亡(mata)、命终(maraṇa)、毁灭(vināsa),故为不死(amata),即是涅槃。故说:“受用无有死亡之涅槃。”又,身至念(kāyagatāsati)乃证得不死或涅槃之因,且安住于似不死之无热恼乐中,故被称为“不死”。“受用”(Paribhuñjanti),即以禅那等至而行用。“错失”(Viraddha),即因未证得而错过。故说:“错过(virādhita)即未得(nādhigata)。”“已得”(Āraddha),即已成就、已圆满。而此即名为圆满,故说:“已得(āraddha)即是圆满(paripuṇṇa)。”“曾放逸”(Pamādiṃsu),这是时态上的用法,故说其义为“放逸”(pamajjanti)。 Amatavaggavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā. 不死品释义终。 Iti manorathapūraṇiyā aṅguttaranikāya-aṭṭhakathāya 《满足希求》即《增支部》义注 Ekakanipātavaṇṇanāya anuttānatthadīpanā samattā. 《一集》释义之未显义阐释究竟。 Paṭhamo bhāgo niṭṭhito. 第一部分终。 | |||
| English | |||
| Pali Canon | Commentaries | Sub-commentaries | Other |
| 1101 Pārājika Pāḷi 1102 Pācittiya Pāḷi 1103 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Vinaya) 1104 Cūḷavagga Pāḷi 1105 Parivāra Pāḷi | 1201 Pārājikakaṇḍa Aṭṭhakathā-1 1202 Pārājikakaṇḍa Aṭṭhakathā-2 1203 Pācittiya Aṭṭhakathā 1204 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Vinaya) 1205 Cūḷavagga Aṭṭhakathā 1206 Parivāra Aṭṭhakathā | 1301 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-1 1302 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-2 1303 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-3 | 1401 Dvemātikāpāḷi 1402 Vinayasaṅgaha Aṭṭhakathā 1403 Vajirabuddhi Ṭīkā 1404 Vimativinodanī Ṭīkā-1 1405 Vimativinodanī Ṭīkā-2 1406 Vinayālaṅkāra Ṭīkā-1 1407 Vinayālaṅkāra Ṭīkā-2 1408 Kaṅkhāvitaraṇīpurāṇa Ṭīkā 1409 Vinayavinicchaya-uttaravinicchaya 1410 Vinayavinicchaya Ṭīkā-1 1411 Vinayavinicchaya Ṭīkā-2 1412 Pācityādiyojanāpāḷi 1413 Khuddasikkhā-mūlasikkhā 8401 Visuddhimagga-1 8402 Visuddhimagga-2 8403 Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā-1 8404 Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā-2 8405 Visuddhimagga nidānakathā 8406 Dīghanikāya (pu-vi) 8407 Majjhimanikāya (pu-vi) 8408 Saṃyuttanikāya (pu-vi) 8409 Aṅguttaranikāya (pu-vi) 8410 Vinayapiṭaka (pu-vi) 8411 Abhidhammapiṭaka (pu-vi) 8412 Aṭṭhakathā (pu-vi) 8413 Niruttidīpanī 8414 Paramatthadīpanī Saṅgahamahāṭīkāpāṭha 8415 Anudīpanīpāṭha 8416 Paṭṭhānuddesa dīpanīpāṭha 8417 Namakkāraṭīkā 8418 Mahāpaṇāmapāṭha 8419 Lakkhaṇāto buddhathomanāgāthā 8420 Sutavandanā 8421 Kamalāñjali 8422 Jinālaṅkāra 8423 Pajjamadhu 8424 Buddhaguṇagāthāvalī 8425 Cūḷaganthavaṃsa 8427 Sāsanavaṃsa 8426 Mahāvaṃsa 8429 Moggallānabyākaraṇaṃ 8428 Kaccāyanabyākaraṇaṃ 8430 Saddanītippakaraṇaṃ (padamālā) 8431 Saddanītippakaraṇaṃ (dhātumālā) 8432 Padarūpasiddhi 8433 Mogallānapañcikā 8434 Payogasiddhipāṭha 8435 Vuttodayapāṭha 8436 Abhidhānappadīpikāpāṭha 8437 Abhidhānappadīpikāṭīkā 8438 Subodhālaṅkārapāṭha 8439 Subodhālaṅkāraṭīkā 8440 Bālāvatāra gaṇṭhipadatthavinicchayasāra 8446 Kavidappaṇanīti 8447 Nītimañjarī 8445 Dhammanīti 8444 Mahārahanīti 8441 Lokanīti 8442 Suttantanīti 8443 Sūrassatinīti 8450 Cāṇakyanīti 8448 Naradakkhadīpanī 8449 Caturārakkhadīpanī 8451 Rasavāhinī 8452 Sīmavisodhanīpāṭha 8453 Vessantaragīti 8454 Moggallāna vuttivivaraṇapañcikā 8455 Thūpavaṃsa 8456 Dāṭhāvaṃsa 8457 Dhātupāṭhavilāsiniyā 8458 Dhātuvaṃsa 8459 Hatthavanagallavihāravaṃsa 8460 Jinacaritaya 8461 Jinavaṃsadīpaṃ 8462 Telakaṭāhagāthā 8463 Milidaṭīkā 8464 Padamañjarī 8465 Padasādhanaṃ 8466 Saddabindupakaraṇaṃ 8467 Kaccāyanadhātumañjusā 8468 Sāmantakūṭavaṇṇanā |
| 2101 Sīlakkhandhavagga Pāḷi 2102 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Dīgha) 2103 Pāthikavagga Pāḷi | 2201 Sīlakkhandhavagga Aṭṭhakathā 2202 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Dīgha) 2203 Pāthikavagga Aṭṭhakathā | 2301 Sīlakkhandhavagga Ṭīkā 2302 Mahāvagga Ṭīkā (Dīgha) 2303 Pāthikavagga Ṭīkā 2304 Sīlakkhandhavagga-abhinavaṭīkā-1 2305 Sīlakkhandhavagga-abhinavaṭīkā-2 | |
| 3101 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Pāḷi 3102 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Pāḷi 3103 Uparipaṇṇāsa Pāḷi | 3201 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā-1 3202 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā-2 3203 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā 3204 Uparipaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā | 3301 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā 3302 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā 3303 Uparipaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā | |
| 4101 Sagāthāvagga Pāḷi 4102 Nidānavagga Pāḷi 4103 Khandhavagga Pāḷi 4104 Saḷāyatanavagga Pāḷi 4105 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Saṃyutta) | 4201 Sagāthāvagga Aṭṭhakathā 4202 Nidānavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4203 Khandhavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4204 Saḷāyatanavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4205 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Saṃyutta) | 4301 Sagāthāvagga Ṭīkā 4302 Nidānavagga Ṭīkā 4303 Khandhavagga Ṭīkā 4304 Saḷāyatanavagga Ṭīkā 4305 Mahāvagga Ṭīkā (Saṃyutta) | |
| 5101 Ekakanipāta Pāḷi 5102 Dukanipāta Pāḷi 5103 Tikanipāta Pāḷi 5104 Catukkanipāta Pāḷi 5105 Pañcakanipāta Pāḷi 5106 Chakkanipāta Pāḷi 5107 Sattakanipāta Pāḷi 5108 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Pāḷi 5109 Navakanipāta Pāḷi 5110 Dasakanipāta Pāḷi 5111 Ekādasakanipāta Pāḷi | 5201 Ekakanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5202 Duka-tika-catukkanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5203 Pañcaka-chakka-sattakanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5204 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Aṭṭhakathā | 5301 Ekakanipāta Ṭīkā 5302 Duka-tika-catukkanipāta Ṭīkā 5303 Pañcaka-chakka-sattakanipāta Ṭīkā 5304 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Ṭīkā | |
| 6101 Khuddakapāṭha Pāḷi 6102 Dhammapada Pāḷi 6103 Udāna Pāḷi 6104 Itivuttaka Pāḷi 6105 Suttanipāta Pāḷi 6106 Vimānavatthu Pāḷi 6107 Petavatthu Pāḷi 6108 Theragāthā Pāḷi 6109 Therīgāthā Pāḷi 6110 Apadāna Pāḷi-1 6111 Apadāna Pāḷi-2 6112 Buddhavaṃsa Pāḷi 6113 Cariyāpiṭaka Pāḷi 6114 Jātaka Pāḷi-1 6115 Jātaka Pāḷi-2 6116 Mahāniddesa Pāḷi 6117 Cūḷaniddesa Pāḷi 6118 Paṭisambhidāmagga Pāḷi 6119 Nettippakaraṇa Pāḷi 6120 Milindapañha Pāḷi 6121 Peṭakopadesa Pāḷi | 6201 Khuddakapāṭha Aṭṭhakathā 6202 Dhammapada Aṭṭhakathā-1 6203 Dhammapada Aṭṭhakathā-2 6204 Udāna Aṭṭhakathā 6205 Itivuttaka Aṭṭhakathā 6206 Suttanipāta Aṭṭhakathā-1 6207 Suttanipāta Aṭṭhakathā-2 6208 Vimānavatthu Aṭṭhakathā 6209 Petavatthu Aṭṭhakathā 6210 Theragāthā Aṭṭhakathā-1 6211 Theragāthā Aṭṭhakathā-2 6212 Therīgāthā Aṭṭhakathā 6213 Apadāna Aṭṭhakathā-1 6214 Apadāna Aṭṭhakathā-2 6215 Buddhavaṃsa Aṭṭhakathā 6216 Cariyāpiṭaka Aṭṭhakathā 6217 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-1 6218 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-2 6219 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-3 6220 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-4 6221 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-5 6222 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-6 6223 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-7 6224 Mahāniddesa Aṭṭhakathā 6225 Cūḷaniddesa Aṭṭhakathā 6226 Paṭisambhidāmagga Aṭṭhakathā-1 6227 Paṭisambhidāmagga Aṭṭhakathā-2 6228 Nettippakaraṇa Aṭṭhakathā | 6301 Nettippakaraṇa Ṭīkā 6302 Nettivibhāvinī | |
| 7101 Dhammasaṅgaṇī Pāḷi 7102 Vibhaṅga Pāḷi 7103 Dhātukathā Pāḷi 7104 Puggalapaññatti Pāḷi 7105 Kathāvatthu Pāḷi 7106 Yamaka Pāḷi-1 7107 Yamaka Pāḷi-2 7108 Yamaka Pāḷi-3 7109 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-1 7110 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-2 7111 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-3 7112 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-4 7113 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-5 | 7201 Dhammasaṅgaṇi Aṭṭhakathā 7202 Sammohavinodanī Aṭṭhakathā 7203 Pañcapakaraṇa Aṭṭhakathā | 7301 Dhammasaṅgaṇī-mūlaṭīkā 7302 Vibhaṅga-mūlaṭīkā 7303 Pañcapakaraṇa-mūlaṭīkā 7304 Dhammasaṅgaṇī-anuṭīkā 7305 Pañcapakaraṇa-anuṭīkā 7306 Abhidhammāvatāro-nāmarūpaparicchedo 7307 Abhidhammatthasaṅgaho 7308 Abhidhammāvatāra-purāṇaṭīkā 7309 Abhidhammamātikāpāḷi | |
| Français | |||
| Canon Pali | Commentaires | Sous-commentaires | Autres |
| 1101 Pārājika Pāḷi 1102 Pācittiya Pāḷi 1103 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Vinaya) 1104 Cūḷavagga Pāḷi 1105 Parivāra Pāḷi | 1201 Pārājikakaṇḍa Aṭṭhakathā-1 1202 Pārājikakaṇḍa Aṭṭhakathā-2 1203 Pācittiya Aṭṭhakathā 1204 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Vinaya) 1205 Cūḷavagga Aṭṭhakathā 1206 Parivāra Aṭṭhakathā | 1301 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-1 1302 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-2 1303 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-3 | 1401 Dvemātikāpāḷi 1402 Vinayasaṅgaha Aṭṭhakathā 1403 Vajirabuddhi Ṭīkā 1404 Vimativinodanī Ṭīkā-1 1405 Vimativinodanī Ṭīkā-2 1406 Vinayālaṅkāra Ṭīkā-1 1407 Vinayālaṅkāra Ṭīkā-2 1408 Kaṅkhāvitaraṇīpurāṇa Ṭīkā 1409 Vinayavinicchaya-uttaravinicchaya 1410 Vinayavinicchaya Ṭīkā-1 1411 Vinayavinicchaya Ṭīkā-2 1412 Pācityādiyojanāpāḷi 1413 Khuddasikkhā-mūlasikkhā 8401 Visuddhimagga-1 8402 Visuddhimagga-2 8403 Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā-1 8404 Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā-2 8405 Visuddhimagga nidānakathā 8406 Dīghanikāya (pu-vi) 8407 Majjhimanikāya (pu-vi) 8408 Saṃyuttanikāya (pu-vi) 8409 Aṅguttaranikāya (pu-vi) 8410 Vinayapiṭaka (pu-vi) 8411 Abhidhammapiṭaka (pu-vi) 8412 Aṭṭhakathā (pu-vi) 8413 Niruttidīpanī 8414 Paramatthadīpanī Saṅgahamahāṭīkāpāṭha 8415 Anudīpanīpāṭha 8416 Paṭṭhānuddesa dīpanīpāṭha 8417 Namakkāraṭīkā 8418 Mahāpaṇāmapāṭha 8419 Lakkhaṇāto buddhathomanāgāthā 8420 Sutavandanā 8421 Kamalāñjali 8422 Jinālaṅkāra 8423 Pajjamadhu 8424 Buddhaguṇagāthāvalī 8425 Cūḷaganthavaṃsa 8427 Sāsanavaṃsa 8426 Mahāvaṃsa 8429 Moggallānabyākaraṇaṃ 8428 Kaccāyanabyākaraṇaṃ 8430 Saddanītippakaraṇaṃ (padamālā) 8431 Saddanītippakaraṇaṃ (dhātumālā) 8432 Padarūpasiddhi 8433 Mogallānapañcikā 8434 Payogasiddhipāṭha 8435 Vuttodayapāṭha 8436 Abhidhānappadīpikāpāṭha 8437 Abhidhānappadīpikāṭīkā 8438 Subodhālaṅkārapāṭha 8439 Subodhālaṅkāraṭīkā 8440 Bālāvatāra gaṇṭhipadatthavinicchayasāra 8446 Kavidappaṇanīti 8447 Nītimañjarī 8445 Dhammanīti 8444 Mahārahanīti 8441 Lokanīti 8442 Suttantanīti 8443 Sūrassatinīti 8450 Cāṇakyanīti 8448 Naradakkhadīpanī 8449 Caturārakkhadīpanī 8451 Rasavāhinī 8452 Sīmavisodhanīpāṭha 8453 Vessantaragīti 8454 Moggallāna vuttivivaraṇapañcikā 8455 Thūpavaṃsa 8456 Dāṭhāvaṃsa 8457 Dhātupāṭhavilāsiniyā 8458 Dhātuvaṃsa 8459 Hatthavanagallavihāravaṃsa 8460 Jinacaritaya 8461 Jinavaṃsadīpaṃ 8462 Telakaṭāhagāthā 8463 Milidaṭīkā 8464 Padamañjarī 8465 Padasādhanaṃ 8466 Saddabindupakaraṇaṃ 8467 Kaccāyanadhātumañjusā 8468 Sāmantakūṭavaṇṇanā |
| 2101 Sīlakkhandhavagga Pāḷi 2102 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Dīgha) 2103 Pāthikavagga Pāḷi | 2201 Sīlakkhandhavagga Aṭṭhakathā 2202 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Dīgha) 2203 Pāthikavagga Aṭṭhakathā | 2301 Sīlakkhandhavagga Ṭīkā 2302 Mahāvagga Ṭīkā (Dīgha) 2303 Pāthikavagga Ṭīkā 2304 Sīlakkhandhavagga-abhinavaṭīkā-1 2305 Sīlakkhandhavagga-abhinavaṭīkā-2 | |
| 3101 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Pāḷi 3102 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Pāḷi 3103 Uparipaṇṇāsa Pāḷi | 3201 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā-1 3202 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā-2 3203 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā 3204 Uparipaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā | 3301 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā 3302 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā 3303 Uparipaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā | |
| 4101 Sagāthāvagga Pāḷi 4102 Nidānavagga Pāḷi 4103 Khandhavagga Pāḷi 4104 Saḷāyatanavagga Pāḷi 4105 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Saṃyutta) | 4201 Sagāthāvagga Aṭṭhakathā 4202 Nidānavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4203 Khandhavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4204 Saḷāyatanavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4205 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Saṃyutta) | 4301 Sagāthāvagga Ṭīkā 4302 Nidānavagga Ṭīkā 4303 Khandhavagga Ṭīkā 4304 Saḷāyatanavagga Ṭīkā 4305 Mahāvagga Ṭīkā (Saṃyutta) | |
| 5101 Ekakanipāta Pāḷi 5102 Dukanipāta Pāḷi 5103 Tikanipāta Pāḷi 5104 Catukkanipāta Pāḷi 5105 Pañcakanipāta Pāḷi 5106 Chakkanipāta Pāḷi 5107 Sattakanipāta Pāḷi 5108 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Pāḷi 5109 Navakanipāta Pāḷi 5110 Dasakanipāta Pāḷi 5111 Ekādasakanipāta Pāḷi | 5201 Ekakanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5202 Duka-tika-catukkanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5203 Pañcaka-chakka-sattakanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5204 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Aṭṭhakathā | 5301 Ekakanipāta Ṭīkā 5302 Duka-tika-catukkanipāta Ṭīkā 5303 Pañcaka-chakka-sattakanipāta Ṭīkā 5304 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Ṭīkā | |
| 6101 Khuddakapāṭha Pāḷi 6102 Dhammapada Pāḷi 6103 Udāna Pāḷi 6104 Itivuttaka Pāḷi 6105 Suttanipāta Pāḷi 6106 Vimānavatthu Pāḷi 6107 Petavatthu Pāḷi 6108 Theragāthā Pāḷi 6109 Therīgāthā Pāḷi 6110 Apadāna Pāḷi-1 6111 Apadāna Pāḷi-2 6112 Buddhavaṃsa Pāḷi 6113 Cariyāpiṭaka Pāḷi 6114 Jātaka Pāḷi-1 6115 Jātaka Pāḷi-2 6116 Mahāniddesa Pāḷi 6117 Cūḷaniddesa Pāḷi 6118 Paṭisambhidāmagga Pāḷi 6119 Nettippakaraṇa Pāḷi 6120 Milindapañha Pāḷi 6121 Peṭakopadesa Pāḷi | 6201 Khuddakapāṭha Aṭṭhakathā 6202 Dhammapada Aṭṭhakathā-1 6203 Dhammapada Aṭṭhakathā-2 6204 Udāna Aṭṭhakathā 6205 Itivuttaka Aṭṭhakathā 6206 Suttanipāta Aṭṭhakathā-1 6207 Suttanipāta Aṭṭhakathā-2 6208 Vimānavatthu Aṭṭhakathā 6209 Petavatthu Aṭṭhakathā 6210 Theragāthā Aṭṭhakathā-1 6211 Theragāthā Aṭṭhakathā-2 6212 Therīgāthā Aṭṭhakathā 6213 Apadāna Aṭṭhakathā-1 6214 Apadāna Aṭṭhakathā-2 6215 Buddhavaṃsa Aṭṭhakathā 6216 Cariyāpiṭaka Aṭṭhakathā 6217 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-1 6218 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-2 6219 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-3 6220 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-4 6221 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-5 6222 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-6 6223 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-7 6224 Mahāniddesa Aṭṭhakathā 6225 Cūḷaniddesa Aṭṭhakathā 6226 Paṭisambhidāmagga Aṭṭhakathā-1 6227 Paṭisambhidāmagga Aṭṭhakathā-2 6228 Nettippakaraṇa Aṭṭhakathā | 6301 Nettippakaraṇa Ṭīkā 6302 Nettivibhāvinī | |
| 7101 Dhammasaṅgaṇī Pāḷi 7102 Vibhaṅga Pāḷi 7103 Dhātukathā Pāḷi 7104 Puggalapaññatti Pāḷi 7105 Kathāvatthu Pāḷi 7106 Yamaka Pāḷi-1 7107 Yamaka Pāḷi-2 7108 Yamaka Pāḷi-3 7109 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-1 7110 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-2 7111 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-3 7112 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-4 7113 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-5 | 7201 Dhammasaṅgaṇi Aṭṭhakathā 7202 Sammohavinodanī Aṭṭhakathā 7203 Pañcapakaraṇa Aṭṭhakathā | 7301 Dhammasaṅgaṇī-mūlaṭīkā 7302 Vibhaṅga-mūlaṭīkā 7303 Pañcapakaraṇa-mūlaṭīkā 7304 Dhammasaṅgaṇī-anuṭīkā 7305 Pañcapakaraṇa-anuṭīkā 7306 Abhidhammāvatāro-nāmarūpaparicchedo 7307 Abhidhammatthasaṅgaho 7308 Abhidhammāvatāra-purāṇaṭīkā 7309 Abhidhammamātikāpāḷi | |
| Deutsch | |||
| Pali-Kanon | Kommentare | Subkommentare | Sonstige |
| 1101 Pārājika Pāḷi 1102 Pācittiya Pāḷi 1103 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Vinaya) 1104 Cūḷavagga Pāḷi 1105 Parivāra Pāḷi | 1201 Pārājikakaṇḍa Aṭṭhakathā-1 1202 Pārājikakaṇḍa Aṭṭhakathā-2 1203 Pācittiya Aṭṭhakathā 1204 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Vinaya) 1205 Cūḷavagga Aṭṭhakathā 1206 Parivāra Aṭṭhakathā | 1301 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-1 1302 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-2 1303 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-3 | 1401 Dvemātikāpāḷi 1402 Vinayasaṅgaha Aṭṭhakathā 1403 Vajirabuddhi Ṭīkā 1404 Vimativinodanī Ṭīkā-1 1405 Vimativinodanī Ṭīkā-2 1406 Vinayālaṅkāra Ṭīkā-1 1407 Vinayālaṅkāra Ṭīkā-2 1408 Kaṅkhāvitaraṇīpurāṇa Ṭīkā 1409 Vinayavinicchaya-uttaravinicchaya 1410 Vinayavinicchaya Ṭīkā-1 1411 Vinayavinicchaya Ṭīkā-2 1412 Pācityādiyojanāpāḷi 1413 Khuddasikkhā-mūlasikkhā 8401 Visuddhimagga-1 8402 Visuddhimagga-2 8403 Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā-1 8404 Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā-2 8405 Visuddhimagga nidānakathā 8406 Dīghanikāya (pu-vi) 8407 Majjhimanikāya (pu-vi) 8408 Saṃyuttanikāya (pu-vi) 8409 Aṅguttaranikāya (pu-vi) 8410 Vinayapiṭaka (pu-vi) 8411 Abhidhammapiṭaka (pu-vi) 8412 Aṭṭhakathā (pu-vi) 8413 Niruttidīpanī 8414 Paramatthadīpanī Saṅgahamahāṭīkāpāṭha 8415 Anudīpanīpāṭha 8416 Paṭṭhānuddesa dīpanīpāṭha 8417 Namakkāraṭīkā 8418 Mahāpaṇāmapāṭha 8419 Lakkhaṇāto buddhathomanāgāthā 8420 Sutavandanā 8421 Kamalāñjali 8422 Jinālaṅkāra 8423 Pajjamadhu 8424 Buddhaguṇagāthāvalī 8425 Cūḷaganthavaṃsa 8427 Sāsanavaṃsa 8426 Mahāvaṃsa 8429 Moggallānabyākaraṇaṃ 8428 Kaccāyanabyākaraṇaṃ 8430 Saddanītippakaraṇaṃ (padamālā) 8431 Saddanītippakaraṇaṃ (dhātumālā) 8432 Padarūpasiddhi 8433 Mogallānapañcikā 8434 Payogasiddhipāṭha 8435 Vuttodayapāṭha 8436 Abhidhānappadīpikāpāṭha 8437 Abhidhānappadīpikāṭīkā 8438 Subodhālaṅkārapāṭha 8439 Subodhālaṅkāraṭīkā 8440 Bālāvatāra gaṇṭhipadatthavinicchayasāra 8446 Kavidappaṇanīti 8447 Nītimañjarī 8445 Dhammanīti 8444 Mahārahanīti 8441 Lokanīti 8442 Suttantanīti 8443 Sūrassatinīti 8450 Cāṇakyanīti 8448 Naradakkhadīpanī 8449 Caturārakkhadīpanī 8451 Rasavāhinī 8452 Sīmavisodhanīpāṭha 8453 Vessantaragīti 8454 Moggallāna vuttivivaraṇapañcikā 8455 Thūpavaṃsa 8456 Dāṭhāvaṃsa 8457 Dhātupāṭhavilāsiniyā 8458 Dhātuvaṃsa 8459 Hatthavanagallavihāravaṃsa 8460 Jinacaritaya 8461 Jinavaṃsadīpaṃ 8462 Telakaṭāhagāthā 8463 Milidaṭīkā 8464 Padamañjarī 8465 Padasādhanaṃ 8466 Saddabindupakaraṇaṃ 8467 Kaccāyanadhātumañjusā 8468 Sāmantakūṭavaṇṇanā |
| 2101 Sīlakkhandhavagga Pāḷi 2102 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Dīgha) 2103 Pāthikavagga Pāḷi | 2201 Sīlakkhandhavagga Aṭṭhakathā 2202 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Dīgha) 2203 Pāthikavagga Aṭṭhakathā | 2301 Sīlakkhandhavagga Ṭīkā 2302 Mahāvagga Ṭīkā (Dīgha) 2303 Pāthikavagga Ṭīkā 2304 Sīlakkhandhavagga-abhinavaṭīkā-1 2305 Sīlakkhandhavagga-abhinavaṭīkā-2 | |
| 3101 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Pāḷi 3102 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Pāḷi 3103 Uparipaṇṇāsa Pāḷi | 3201 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā-1 3202 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā-2 3203 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā 3204 Uparipaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā | 3301 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā 3302 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā 3303 Uparipaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā | |
| 4101 Sagāthāvagga Pāḷi 4102 Nidānavagga Pāḷi 4103 Khandhavagga Pāḷi 4104 Saḷāyatanavagga Pāḷi 4105 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Saṃyutta) | 4201 Sagāthāvagga Aṭṭhakathā 4202 Nidānavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4203 Khandhavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4204 Saḷāyatanavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4205 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Saṃyutta) | 4301 Sagāthāvagga Ṭīkā 4302 Nidānavagga Ṭīkā 4303 Khandhavagga Ṭīkā 4304 Saḷāyatanavagga Ṭīkā 4305 Mahāvagga Ṭīkā (Saṃyutta) | |
| 5101 Ekakanipāta Pāḷi 5102 Dukanipāta Pāḷi 5103 Tikanipāta Pāḷi 5104 Catukkanipāta Pāḷi 5105 Pañcakanipāta Pāḷi 5106 Chakkanipāta Pāḷi 5107 Sattakanipāta Pāḷi 5108 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Pāḷi 5109 Navakanipāta Pāḷi 5110 Dasakanipāta Pāḷi 5111 Ekādasakanipāta Pāḷi | 5201 Ekakanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5202 Duka-tika-catukkanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5203 Pañcaka-chakka-sattakanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5204 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Aṭṭhakathā | 5301 Ekakanipāta Ṭīkā 5302 Duka-tika-catukkanipāta Ṭīkā 5303 Pañcaka-chakka-sattakanipāta Ṭīkā 5304 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Ṭīkā | |
| 6101 Khuddakapāṭha Pāḷi 6102 Dhammapada Pāḷi 6103 Udāna Pāḷi 6104 Itivuttaka Pāḷi 6105 Suttanipāta Pāḷi 6106 Vimānavatthu Pāḷi 6107 Petavatthu Pāḷi 6108 Theragāthā Pāḷi 6109 Therīgāthā Pāḷi 6110 Apadāna Pāḷi-1 6111 Apadāna Pāḷi-2 6112 Buddhavaṃsa Pāḷi 6113 Cariyāpiṭaka Pāḷi 6114 Jātaka Pāḷi-1 6115 Jātaka Pāḷi-2 6116 Mahāniddesa Pāḷi 6117 Cūḷaniddesa Pāḷi 6118 Paṭisambhidāmagga Pāḷi 6119 Nettippakaraṇa Pāḷi 6120 Milindapañha Pāḷi 6121 Peṭakopadesa Pāḷi | 6201 Khuddakapāṭha Aṭṭhakathā 6202 Dhammapada Aṭṭhakathā-1 6203 Dhammapada Aṭṭhakathā-2 6204 Udāna Aṭṭhakathā 6205 Itivuttaka Aṭṭhakathā 6206 Suttanipāta Aṭṭhakathā-1 6207 Suttanipāta Aṭṭhakathā-2 6208 Vimānavatthu Aṭṭhakathā 6209 Petavatthu Aṭṭhakathā 6210 Theragāthā Aṭṭhakathā-1 6211 Theragāthā Aṭṭhakathā-2 6212 Therīgāthā Aṭṭhakathā 6213 Apadāna Aṭṭhakathā-1 6214 Apadāna Aṭṭhakathā-2 6215 Buddhavaṃsa Aṭṭhakathā 6216 Cariyāpiṭaka Aṭṭhakathā 6217 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-1 6218 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-2 6219 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-3 6220 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-4 6221 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-5 6222 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-6 6223 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-7 6224 Mahāniddesa Aṭṭhakathā 6225 Cūḷaniddesa Aṭṭhakathā 6226 Paṭisambhidāmagga Aṭṭhakathā-1 6227 Paṭisambhidāmagga Aṭṭhakathā-2 6228 Nettippakaraṇa Aṭṭhakathā | 6301 Nettippakaraṇa Ṭīkā 6302 Nettivibhāvinī | |
| 7101 Dhammasaṅgaṇī Pāḷi 7102 Vibhaṅga Pāḷi 7103 Dhātukathā Pāḷi 7104 Puggalapaññatti Pāḷi 7105 Kathāvatthu Pāḷi 7106 Yamaka Pāḷi-1 7107 Yamaka Pāḷi-2 7108 Yamaka Pāḷi-3 7109 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-1 7110 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-2 7111 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-3 7112 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-4 7113 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-5 | 7201 Dhammasaṅgaṇi Aṭṭhakathā 7202 Sammohavinodanī Aṭṭhakathā 7203 Pañcapakaraṇa Aṭṭhakathā | 7301 Dhammasaṅgaṇī-mūlaṭīkā 7302 Vibhaṅga-mūlaṭīkā 7303 Pañcapakaraṇa-mūlaṭīkā 7304 Dhammasaṅgaṇī-anuṭīkā 7305 Pañcapakaraṇa-anuṭīkā 7306 Abhidhammāvatāro-nāmarūpaparicchedo 7307 Abhidhammatthasaṅgaho 7308 Abhidhammāvatāra-purāṇaṭīkā 7309 Abhidhammamātikāpāḷi | |
| हिंदी | |||
| पाली कैनन | कमेंट्री | उप-टिप्पणियाँ | अन्य |
| 1101 पाराजिक पाळि 1102 पाचित्तिय पाळि 1103 महावग्ग पाळि (विनय) 1104 चूळवग्ग पाळि 1105 परिवार पाळि | 1201 पाराजिककण्ड अट्ठकथा-1 1202 पाराजिककण्ड अट्ठकथा-2 1203 पाचित्तिय अट्ठकथा 1204 महावग्ग अट्ठकथा (विनय) 1205 चूळवग्ग अट्ठकथा 1206 परिवार अट्ठकथा | 1301 सारत्थदीपनी टीका-1 1302 सारत्थदीपनी टीका-2 1303 सारत्थदीपनी टीका-3 | 1401 द्वेमातिकापाळि 1402 विनयसंगह अट्ठकथा 1403 वजिरबुद्धि टीका 1404 विमतिविनोदनी टीका-1 1405 विमतिविनोदनी टीका-2 1406 विनयालंकार टीका-1 1407 विनयालंकार टीका-2 1408 कंखावितरणीपुराण टीका 1409 विनयविनिच्छय-उत्तरविनिच्छय 1410 विनयविनिच्छय टीका-1 1411 विनयविनिच्छय टीका-2 1412 पाचित्यादियोजनापाळि 1413 खुद्दसिक्खा-मूलसिक्खा 8401 विसुद्धिमग्ग-1 8402 विसुद्धिमग्ग-2 8403 विसुद्धिमग्ग-महाटीका-1 8404 विसुद्धिमग्ग-महाटीका-2 8405 विसुद्धिमग्ग निदानकथा 8406 दीघनिकाय (पु-वि) 8407 मज्झिमनिकाय (पु-वि) 8408 संयुत्तनिकाय (पु-वि) 8409 अङ्गुत्तरनिकाय (पु-वि) 8410 विनयपिटक (पु-वि) 8411 अभिधम्मपिटक (पु-वि) 8412 अट्ठकथा (पु-वि) 8413 निरुत्तिदीपनी 8414 परमत्थदीपनी सङ्गहमहाटीकापाठ 8415 अनुदीपनीपाठ 8416 पट्ठानुद्देस दीपनीपाठ 8417 नमक्कारटीका 8418 महापणामपाठ 8419 लक्खणातो बुद्धथोमनागाथा 8420 सुतवन्दना 8421 कमलाञ्जलि 8422 जिनालंकार 8423 पज्जमधु 8424 बुद्धगुणगाथावली 8425 चूळगन्थवंस 8427 सासनवंस 8426 महावंस 8429 मोग्गल्लानब्याकरणं 8428 कच्चायनब्याकरणं 8430 सद्दनीतिप्पकरणं (पदमाला) 8431 सद्दनीतिप्पकरणं (धातुमाला) 8432 पदरूपसिद्धि 8433 मोग्गल्लानपञ्चिका 8434 पयोगसिद्धिपाठ 8435 वुत्तोदयपाठ 8436 अभिधानप्पदीपिकापाठ 8437 अभिधानप्पदीपिकाटीका 8438 सुबोधालंकारपाठ 8439 सुबोधालंकारटीका 8440 बालावतार गण्ठिपदत्थविनिच्छयसार 8446 कविदप्पणनीति 8447 नीतिमञ्जरी 8445 धम्मनीति 8444 महारहनीति 8441 लोकनीति 8442 सुत्तन्तनीति 8443 सूरस्सतीनीति 8450 चाणक्यनीति 8448 नरदक्खदीपनी 8449 चतुरारक्खदीपनी 8451 रसवाहिनी 8452 सीमविसोधनीपाठ 8453 वेस्सन्तरगीति 8454 मोग्गल्लान वुत्तिविवरणपञ्चिका 8455 थूपवंस 8456 दाठावंस 8457 धातुपाठविलासिनिया 8458 धातुवंस 8459 हत्थवनगल्लविहारवंस 8460 जिनचरितय 8461 जिनवंसदीपं 8462 तेलकटाहगाथा 8463 मिलिदटीका 8464 पदमञ्जरी 8465 पदसाधनं 8466 सद्दबिन्दुपकरणं 8467 कच्चायनधातुमञ्जुसा 8468 सामन्तकूटवण्णना |
| 2101 सीलक्खन्धवग्ग पाळि 2102 महावग्ग पाळि (दीघ) 2103 पाथिकवग्ग पाळि | 2201 सीलक्खन्धवग्ग अट्ठकथा 2202 महावग्ग अट्ठकथा (दीघ) 2203 पाथिकवग्ग अट्ठकथा | 2301 सीलक्खन्धवग्ग टीका 2302 महावग्ग टीका (दीघ) 2303 पाथिकवग्ग टीका 2304 सीलक्खन्धवग्ग-अभिनवटीका-1 2305 सीलक्खन्धवग्ग-अभिनवटीका-2 | |
| 3101 मूलपण्णास पाळि 3102 मज्झिमपण्णास पाळि 3103 उपरिपण्णास पाळि | 3201 मूलपण्णास अट्ठकथा-1 3202 मूलपण्णास अट्ठकथा-2 3203 मज्झिमपण्णास अट्ठकथा 3204 उपरिपण्णास अट्ठकथा | 3301 मूलपण्णास टीका 3302 मज्झिमपण्णास टीका 3303 उपरिपण्णास टीका | |
| 4101 सगाथावग्ग पाळि 4102 निदानवग्ग पाळि 4103 खन्धवग्ग पाळि 4104 सळायतनवग्ग पाळि 4105 महावग्ग पाळि (संयुत्त) | 4201 सगाथावग्ग अट्ठकथा 4202 निदानवग्ग अट्ठकथा 4203 खन्धवग्ग अट्ठकथा 4204 सळायतनवग्ग अट्ठकथा 4205 महावग्ग अट्ठकथा (संयुत्त) | 4301 सगाथावग्ग टीका 4302 निदानवग्ग टीका 4303 खन्धवग्ग टीका 4304 सळायतनवग्ग टीका 4305 महावग्ग टीका (संयुत्त) | |
| 5101 एककनिपात पाळि 5102 दुकनिपात पाळि 5103 तिकनिपात पाळि 5104 चतुक्कनिपात पाळि 5105 पञ्चकनिपात पाळि 5106 छक्कनिपात पाळि 5107 सत्तकनिपात पाळि 5108 अट्ठकादिनिपात पाळि 5109 नवकनिपात पाळि 5110 दसकनिपात पाळि 5111 एकादसकनिपात पाळि | 5201 एककनिपात अट्ठकथा 5202 दुक-तिक-चतुक्कनिपात अट्ठकथा 5203 पञ्चक-छक्क-सत्तकनिपात अट्ठकथा 5204 अट्ठकादिनिपात अट्ठकथा | 5301 एककनिपात टीका 5302 दुक-तिक-चतुक्कनिपात टीका 5303 पञ्चक-छक्क-सत्तकनिपात टीका 5304 अट्ठकादिनिपात टीका | |
| 6101 खुद्दकपाठ पाळि 6102 धम्मपद पाळि 6103 उदान पाळि 6104 इतिवुत्तक पाळि 6105 सुत्तनिपात पाळि 6106 विमानवत्थु पाळि 6107 पेतवत्थु पाळि 6108 थेरगाथा पाळि 6109 थेरीगाथा पाळि 6110 अपदान पाळि-1 6111 अपदान पाळि-2 6112 बुद्धवंस पाळि 6113 चरियापिटक पाळि 6114 जातक पाळि-1 6115 जातक पाळि-2 6116 महानिद्देस पाळि 6117 चूळनिद्देस पाळि 6118 पटिसम्भिदामग्ग पाळि 6119 नेत्तिप्पकरण पाळि 6120 मिलिन्दपञ्ह पाळि 6121 पेटकोपदेस पाळि | 6201 खुद्दकपाठ अट्ठकथा 6202 धम्मपद अट्ठकथा-1 6203 धम्मपद अट्ठकथा-2 6204 उदान अट्ठकथा 6205 इतिवुत्तक अट्ठकथा 6206 सुत्तनिपात अट्ठकथा-1 6207 सुत्तनिपात अट्ठकथा-2 6208 विमानवत्थु अट्ठकथा 6209 पेतवत्थु अट्ठकथा 6210 थेरगाथा अट्ठकथा-1 6211 थेरगाथा अट्ठकथा-2 6212 थेरीगाथा अट्ठकथा 6213 अपदान अट्ठकथा-1 6214 अपदान अट्ठकथा-2 6215 बुद्धवंस अट्ठकथा 6216 चरियापिटक अट्ठकथा 6217 जातक अट्ठकथा-1 6218 जातक अट्ठकथा-2 6219 जातक अट्ठकथा-3 6220 जातक अट्ठकथा-4 6221 जातक अट्ठकथा-5 6222 जातक अट्ठकथा-6 6223 जातक अट्ठकथा-7 6224 महानिद्देस अट्ठकथा 6225 चूळनिद्देस अट्ठकथा 6226 पटिसम्भिदामग्ग अट्ठकथा-1 6227 पटिसम्भिदामग्ग अट्ठकथा-2 6228 नेत्तिप्पकरण अट्ठकथा | 6301 नेत्तिप्पकरण टीका 6302 नेत्तिविभाविनी | |
| 7101 धम्मसङ्गणी पाळि 7102 विभङ्ग पाळि 7103 धातुकथा पाळि 7104 पुग्गलपञ्ञत्ति पाळि 7105 कथावत्थु पाळि 7106 यमक पाळि-1 7107 यमक पाळि-2 7108 यमक पाळि-3 7109 पट्ठान पाळि-1 7110 पट्ठान पाळि-2 7111 पट्ठान पाळि-3 7112 पट्ठान पाळि-4 7113 पट्ठान पाळि-5 | 7201 धम्मसङ्गणि अट्ठकथा 7202 सम्मोहविनोदनी अट्ठकथा 7203 पञ्चपकरण अट्ठकथा | 7301 धम्मसङ्गणी-मूलटीका 7302 विभङ्ग-मूलटीका 7303 पञ्चपकरण-मूलटीका 7304 धम्मसङ्गणी-अनुटीका 7305 पञ्चपकरण-अनुटीका 7306 अभिधम्मावतारो-नामरूपपरिच्छेदो 7307 अभिधम्मत्थसङ्गहो 7308 अभिधम्मावतार-पुराणटीका 7309 अभिधम्ममातिकापाळि | |
| Indonesia | |||
| Kanon Pali | Komentar | Sub-komentar | Lainnya |
| 1101 Pārājika Pāḷi 1102 Pācittiya Pāḷi 1103 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Vinaya) 1104 Cūḷavagga Pāḷi 1105 Parivāra Pāḷi | 1201 Pārājikakaṇḍa Aṭṭhakathā-1 1202 Pārājikakaṇḍa Aṭṭhakathā-2 1203 Pācittiya Aṭṭhakathā 1204 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Vinaya) 1205 Cūḷavagga Aṭṭhakathā 1206 Parivāra Aṭṭhakathā | 1301 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-1 1302 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-2 1303 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-3 | 1401 Dvemātikāpāḷi 1402 Vinayasaṅgaha Aṭṭhakathā 1403 Vajirabuddhi Ṭīkā 1404 Vimativinodanī Ṭīkā-1 1405 Vimativinodanī Ṭīkā-2 1406 Vinayālaṅkāra Ṭīkā-1 1407 Vinayālaṅkāra Ṭīkā-2 1408 Kaṅkhāvitaraṇīpurāṇa Ṭīkā 1409 Vinayavinicchaya-uttaravinicchaya 1410 Vinayavinicchaya Ṭīkā-1 1411 Vinayavinicchaya Ṭīkā-2 1412 Pācityādiyojanāpāḷi 1413 Khuddasikkhā-mūlasikkhā 8401 Visuddhimagga-1 8402 Visuddhimagga-2 8403 Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā-1 8404 Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā-2 8405 Visuddhimagga nidānakathā 8406 Dīghanikāya (pu-vi) 8407 Majjhimanikāya (pu-vi) 8408 Saṃyuttanikāya (pu-vi) 8409 Aṅguttaranikāya (pu-vi) 8410 Vinayapiṭaka (pu-vi) 8411 Abhidhammapiṭaka (pu-vi) 8412 Aṭṭhakathā (pu-vi) 8413 Niruttidīpanī 8414 Paramatthadīpanī Saṅgahamahāṭīkāpāṭha 8415 Anudīpanīpāṭha 8416 Paṭṭhānuddesa dīpanīpāṭha 8417 Namakkāraṭīkā 8418 Mahāpaṇāmapāṭha 8419 Lakkhaṇāto buddhathomanāgāthā 8420 Sutavandanā 8421 Kamalāñjali 8422 Jinālaṅkāra 8423 Pajjamadhu 8424 Buddhaguṇagāthāvalī 8425 Cūḷaganthavaṃsa 8427 Sāsanavaṃsa 8426 Mahāvaṃsa 8429 Moggallānabyākaraṇaṃ 8428 Kaccāyanabyākaraṇaṃ 8430 Saddanītippakaraṇaṃ (padamālā) 8431 Saddanītippakaraṇaṃ (dhātumālā) 8432 Padarūpasiddhi 8433 Mogallānapañcikā 8434 Payogasiddhipāṭha 8435 Vuttodayapāṭha 8436 Abhidhānappadīpikāpāṭha 8437 Abhidhānappadīpikāṭīkā 8438 Subodhālaṅkārapāṭha 8439 Subodhālaṅkāraṭīkā 8440 Bālāvatāra gaṇṭhipadatthavinicchayasāra 8446 Kavidappaṇanīti 8447 Nītimañjarī 8445 Dhammanīti 8444 Mahārahanīti 8441 Lokanīti 8442 Suttantanīti 8443 Sūrassatinīti 8450 Cāṇakyanīti 8448 Naradakkhadīpanī 8449 Caturārakkhadīpanī 8451 Rasavāhinī 8452 Sīmavisodhanīpāṭha 8453 Vessantaragīti 8454 Moggallāna vuttivivaraṇapañcikā 8455 Thūpavaṃsa 8456 Dāṭhāvaṃsa 8457 Dhātupāṭhavilāsiniyā 8458 Dhātuvaṃsa 8459 Hatthavanagallavihāravaṃsa 8460 Jinacaritaya 8461 Jinavaṃsadīpaṃ 8462 Telakaṭāhagāthā 8463 Milidaṭīkā 8464 Padamañjarī 8465 Padasādhanaṃ 8466 Saddabindupakaraṇaṃ 8467 Kaccāyanadhātumañjusā 8468 Sāmantakūṭavaṇṇanā |
| 2101 Sīlakkhandhavagga Pāḷi 2102 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Dīgha) 2103 Pāthikavagga Pāḷi | 2201 Sīlakkhandhavagga Aṭṭhakathā 2202 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Dīgha) 2203 Pāthikavagga Aṭṭhakathā | 2301 Sīlakkhandhavagga Ṭīkā 2302 Mahāvagga Ṭīkā (Dīgha) 2303 Pāthikavagga Ṭīkā 2304 Sīlakkhandhavagga-abhinavaṭīkā-1 2305 Sīlakkhandhavagga-abhinavaṭīkā-2 | |
| 3101 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Pāḷi 3102 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Pāḷi 3103 Uparipaṇṇāsa Pāḷi | 3201 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā-1 3202 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā-2 3203 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā 3204 Uparipaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā | 3301 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā 3302 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā 3303 Uparipaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā | |
| 4101 Sagāthāvagga Pāḷi 4102 Nidānavagga Pāḷi 4103 Khandhavagga Pāḷi 4104 Saḷāyatanavagga Pāḷi 4105 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Saṃyutta) | 4201 Sagāthāvagga Aṭṭhakathā 4202 Nidānavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4203 Khandhavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4204 Saḷāyatanavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4205 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Saṃyutta) | 4301 Sagāthāvagga Ṭīkā 4302 Nidānavagga Ṭīkā 4303 Khandhavagga Ṭīkā 4304 Saḷāyatanavagga Ṭīkā 4305 Mahāvagga Ṭīkā (Saṃyutta) | |
| 5101 Ekakanipāta Pāḷi 5102 Dukanipāta Pāḷi 5103 Tikanipāta Pāḷi 5104 Catukkanipāta Pāḷi 5105 Pañcakanipāta Pāḷi 5106 Chakkanipāta Pāḷi 5107 Sattakanipāta Pāḷi 5108 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Pāḷi 5109 Navakanipāta Pāḷi 5110 Dasakanipāta Pāḷi 5111 Ekādasakanipāta Pāḷi | 5201 Ekakanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5202 Duka-tika-catukkanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5203 Pañcaka-chakka-sattakanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5204 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Aṭṭhakathā | 5301 Ekakanipāta Ṭīkā 5302 Duka-tika-catukkanipāta Ṭīkā 5303 Pañcaka-chakka-sattakanipāta Ṭīkā 5304 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Ṭīkā | |
| 6101 Khuddakapāṭha Pāḷi 6102 Dhammapada Pāḷi 6103 Udāna Pāḷi 6104 Itivuttaka Pāḷi 6105 Suttanipāta Pāḷi 6106 Vimānavatthu Pāḷi 6107 Petavatthu Pāḷi 6108 Theragāthā Pāḷi 6109 Therīgāthā Pāḷi 6110 Apadāna Pāḷi-1 6111 Apadāna Pāḷi-2 6112 Buddhavaṃsa Pāḷi 6113 Cariyāpiṭaka Pāḷi 6114 Jātaka Pāḷi-1 6115 Jātaka Pāḷi-2 6116 Mahāniddesa Pāḷi 6117 Cūḷaniddesa Pāḷi 6118 Paṭisambhidāmagga Pāḷi 6119 Nettippakaraṇa Pāḷi 6120 Milindapañha Pāḷi 6121 Peṭakopadesa Pāḷi | 6201 Khuddakapāṭha Aṭṭhakathā 6202 Dhammapada Aṭṭhakathā-1 6203 Dhammapada Aṭṭhakathā-2 6204 Udāna Aṭṭhakathā 6205 Itivuttaka Aṭṭhakathā 6206 Suttanipāta Aṭṭhakathā-1 6207 Suttanipāta Aṭṭhakathā-2 6208 Vimānavatthu Aṭṭhakathā 6209 Petavatthu Aṭṭhakathā 6210 Theragāthā Aṭṭhakathā-1 6211 Theragāthā Aṭṭhakathā-2 6212 Therīgāthā Aṭṭhakathā 6213 Apadāna Aṭṭhakathā-1 6214 Apadāna Aṭṭhakathā-2 6215 Buddhavaṃsa Aṭṭhakathā 6216 Cariyāpiṭaka Aṭṭhakathā 6217 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-1 6218 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-2 6219 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-3 6220 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-4 6221 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-5 6222 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-6 6223 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-7 6224 Mahāniddesa Aṭṭhakathā 6225 Cūḷaniddesa Aṭṭhakathā 6226 Paṭisambhidāmagga Aṭṭhakathā-1 6227 Paṭisambhidāmagga Aṭṭhakathā-2 6228 Nettippakaraṇa Aṭṭhakathā | 6301 Nettippakaraṇa Ṭīkā 6302 Nettivibhāvinī | |
| 7101 Dhammasaṅgaṇī Pāḷi 7102 Vibhaṅga Pāḷi 7103 Dhātukathā Pāḷi 7104 Puggalapaññatti Pāḷi 7105 Kathāvatthu Pāḷi 7106 Yamaka Pāḷi-1 7107 Yamaka Pāḷi-2 7108 Yamaka Pāḷi-3 7109 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-1 7110 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-2 7111 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-3 7112 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-4 7113 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-5 | 7201 Dhammasaṅgaṇi Aṭṭhakathā 7202 Sammohavinodanī Aṭṭhakathā 7203 Pañcapakaraṇa Aṭṭhakathā | 7301 Dhammasaṅgaṇī-mūlaṭīkā 7302 Vibhaṅga-mūlaṭīkā 7303 Pañcapakaraṇa-mūlaṭīkā 7304 Dhammasaṅgaṇī-anuṭīkā 7305 Pañcapakaraṇa-anuṭīkā 7306 Abhidhammāvatāro-nāmarūpaparicchedo 7307 Abhidhammatthasaṅgaho 7308 Abhidhammāvatāra-purāṇaṭīkā 7309 Abhidhammamātikāpāḷi | |
| 日文 | |||
| パーリ仏典 | 註釈書 | 副註釈書 | その他 |
| 1101 パーラージカ・パーリ 1102 パーチッティヤ・パーリ 1103 マハーヴァッガ・パーリ(ヴィナヤ) 1104 チューラヴァッガ・パーリ 1105 パリヴァーラ・パーリ | 1201 パーラージカカンダ・アッタカター-1 1202 パーラージカカンダ・アッタカター-2 1203 パーチッティヤ・アッタカター 1204 マハーヴァッガ・アッタカター(ヴィナヤ) 1205 チューラヴァッガ・アッタカター 1206 パリヴァーラ・アッタカター | 1301 サーラッタディーパニー・ティーカー-1 1302 サーラッタディーパニー・ティーカー-2 1303 サーラッタディーパニー・ティーカー-3 | 1401 ドヴェマーティカー・パーリ 1402 ヴィナヤサンガハ・アッタカター 1403 ヴァジラブッディ・ティーカー 1404 ヴィマティヴィノーダニー・ティーカー-1 1405 ヴィマティヴィノーダニー・ティーカー-2 1406 ヴィナヤーランカーラ・ティーカー-1 1407 ヴィナヤーランカーラ・ティーカー-2 1408 カンカーウィタラニープラーナ・ティーカー 1409 ヴィナヤヴィニッチャヤ-ウッタラヴィニッチャヤ 1410 ヴィナヤヴィニッチャヤ・ティーカー-1 1411 ヴィナヤヴィニッチャヤ・ティーカー-2 1412 パーチッティヤーディヨージャナー・パーリ 1413 クッダシッカー-ムーラシッカー 8401 ヴィスッディマッガ-1 8402 ヴィスッディマッガ-2 8403 ヴィスッディマッガ・マハーティーカー-1 8404 ヴィスッディマッガ・マハーティーカー-2 8405 ヴィスッディマッガ・ニダーナカター 8406 ディーガニカーヤ(プ・ヴィ) 8407 マッジマニカーヤ(プ・ヴィ) 8408 サンユッタニカーヤ(プ・ヴィ) 8409 アングッタラニカーヤ(プ・ヴィ) 8410 ヴィナヤピタカ(プ・ヴィ) 8411 アビダンマピタカ(プ・ヴィ) 8412 アッタカター(プ・ヴィ) 8413 ニルッティディーパニー 8414 パラマッタディーパニー・サンガハマハーティカーパータ 8415 アヌディーパニーパータ 8416 パッターヌッデーサ・ディーパニーパータ 8417 ナマッカラ・ティーカー 8418 マハーパナーマ・パータ 8419 ラッカナート・ブッダトーマナーガーター 8420 スタヴァンダナー 8421 カマラーニャジャリ 8422 ジナランカーラ 8423 パッジャマドゥ 8424 ブッダグナガーター・ヴァリー 8425 チューラガンタヴァンサ 8427 サーサナヴァンサ 8426 マハーヴァンサ 8429 モッガラーナ・ビャーカラナン 8428 カッチャーヤナ・ビャーカラナン 8430 サッダニーティッパカラナン(パダマーラー) 8431 サッダニーティッパカラナン(ダートゥマーラー) 8432 パダルーパシッディ 8433 モッガラーナ・パンチカー 8434 パヨーガシッディ・パータ 8435 ヴットーダヤ・パータ 8436 アビダーナッパディーピカー・パータ 8437 アビダーナッパディーピカー・ティーカー 8438 スボーダーランカーラ・パータ 8439 スボーダーランカーラ・ティーカー 8440 バーラーヴァターラ・ガンティパダッタヴィニッチャヤサーラ 8446 カヴィダッパナニーティ 8447 ニーティマンジャリー 8445 ダンマニーティ 8444 マハーラハニーティ 8441 ローカニーティ 8442 スタンタニーティ 8443 スーラッサティニーティ 8450 チャーナキャニーティ 8448 ナラダッカディーパニー 8449 チャトゥラーラッカディーパニー 8451 ラサヴァーヒニー 8452 シーマヴィソーダニー・パータ 8453 ヴェッサンタラ・ギーティ 8454 モッガラーナ・ヴッティヴィヴァラナパンチカー 8455 トゥーパヴァンサ 8456 ダーターヴァンサ 8457 ダートゥパータヴィラーヴィシニヤー 8458 ダートゥヴァンサ 8459 ハッタヴァナッガラヴィハーラヴァンサ 8460 ジナチャリタヤ 8461 ジナヴァンサディーパン 8462 テーラカターガーター 8463 ミリダ・ティーカー 8464 パダマンジャリー 8465 パダサーダナン 8466 サッダビンドゥパカラナン 8467 カッチャーヤナ・ダートゥマンジューサー 8468 サーマンタクータ・ヴァンナナー |
| 2101 シーラッカンダワッガ・パーリ 2102 マハーワッガ・パーリ(ディーガ) 2103 パーティカワッガ・パーリ | 2201 シーラッカンダワッガ・アッタカター 2202 マハーワッガ・アッタカター(ディーガ) 2203 パーティカワッガ・アッタカター | 2301 シーラッカンダワッガ・ティーカー 2302 マハーワッガ・ティーカー(ディーガ) 2303 パーティカワッガ・ティーカー 2304 シーラッカンダワッガ・アビナワティーカー-1 2305 シーラッカンダワッガ・アビナワティーカー-2 | |
| 3101 ムーラパンナーサ・パーリ 3102 マッジマパンナーサ・パーリ 3103 ウパリパンナーサ・パーリ | 3201 ムーラパンナーサ・アッタカター-1 3202 ムーラパンナーサ・アッタカター-2 3203 マッジマパンナーサ・アッタカター 3204 ウパリパンナーサ・アッタカター | 3301 ムーラパンナーサ・ティーカー 3302 マッジマパンナーサ・ティーカー 3303 ウパリパンナーサ・ティーカー | |
| 4101 サガーター・ワッガ・パーリ 4102 ニダーナ・ワッガ・パーリ 4103 カンダ・ワッガ・パーリ 4104 サラーヤタナ・ワッガ・パーリ 4105 マハーワッガ・パーリ(サンユッタ) | 4201 サガーター・ワッガ・アッタカター 4202 ニダーナ・ワッガ・アッタカター 4203 カンダ・ワッガ・アッタカター 4204 サラーヤタナ・ワッガ・アッタカター 4205 マハーワッガ・アッタカター(サンユッタ) | 4301 サガーター・ワッガ・ティーカー 4302 ニダーナ・ワッガ・ティーカー 4303 カンダ・ワッガ・ティーカー 4304 サラーヤタナ・ワッガ・ティーカー 4305 マハーワッガ・ティーカー(サンユッタ) | |
| 5101 エーカカニパータ・パーリ 5102 ドゥカニパータ・パーリ 5103 ティカニパータ・パーリ 5104 チャトゥッカニパータ・パーリ 5105 パンチャカニパータ・パーリ 5106 チャッカニパータ・パーリ 5107 サッタカニパータ・パーリ 5108 アッタカーディニパータ・パーリ 5109 ナヴァカニパータ・パーリ 5110 ダサカニパータ・パーリ 5111 エーカーダサカニパータ・パーリ | 5201 エーカカニパータ・アッタカター 5202 ドゥカ・ティカ・チャトゥッカニパータ・アッタカター 5203 パンチャカ・チャッカ・サッタカニパータ・アッタカター 5204 アッタカーディニパータ・アッタカター | 5301 エーカカニパータ・ティーカー 5302 ドゥカ・ティカ・チャトゥッカニパータ・ティーカー 5303 パンチャカ・チャッカ・サッタカニパータ・ティーカー 5304 アッタカーディニパータ・ティーカー | |
| 6101 クッダカパータ・パーリ 6102 ダンマパダ・パーリ 6103 ウダーナ・パーリ 6104 イティヴッタカ・パーリ 6105 スッタニパータ・パーリ 6106 ヴィマーナヴァットゥ・パーリ 6107 ペーヴァットゥ・パーリ 6108 テーラガーター・パーリ 6109 テーリーガーター・パーリ 6110 アパダーナ・パーリ-1 6111 アパダーナ・パーリ-2 6112 ブッダヴァンサ・パーリ 6113 チャリヤーピタカ・パーリ 6114 ジャータカ・パーリ-1 6115 ジャータカ・パーリ-2 6116 マハーニッデーサ・パーリ 6117 チューラニッデーサ・パーリ 6118 パティサンビダーマッガ・パーリ 6119 ネッティッパカラナ・パーリ 6120 ミリンダパンハ・パーリ 6121 ペータコーパデーサ・パーリ | 6201 クッダカパータ・アッタカター 6202 ダンマパダ・アッタカター-1 6203 ダンマパダ・アッタカター-2 6204 ウダーナ・アッタカター 6205 イティヴッタカ・アッタカター 6206 スッタニパータ・アッタカター-1 6207 スッタニパータ・アッタカター-2 6208 ヴィマーナヴァットゥ・アッタカター 6209 ペータヴァットゥ・アッタカター 6210 テーラガーター・アッタカター-1 6211 テーラガーター・アッタカター-2 6212 テーリーガーター・アッタカター 6213 アパダーナ・アッタカター-1 6214 アパダーナ・アッタカター-2 6215 ブッダヴァンサ・アッタカター 6216 チャリヤーピタカ・アッタカター 6217 ジャータカ・アッタカター-1 6218 ジャータカ・アッタカター-2 6219 ジャータカ・アッタカター-3 6220 ジャータカ・アッタカター-4 6221 ジャータカ・アッタカター-5 6222 ジャータカ・アッタカター-6 6223 ジャータカ・アッタカター-7 6224 マハーニッデーサ・アッタカター 6225 チューラニッデーサ・アッタカター 6226 パティサンビダーマッガ・アッタカター-1 6227 パティサンビダーマッガ・アッタカター-2 6228 ネッティッパカラナ・アッタカター | 6301 ネッティッパカラナ・ティーカー 6302 ネッティヴィバーヴィニー | |
| 7101 ダンマサンガニー・パーリ 7102 ヴィバンガ・パーリ 7103 ダートゥカター・パーリ 7104 プッガラパンニャッティ・パーリ 7105 カター・ヴァットゥ・パーリ 7106 ヤマカ・パーリ-1 7107 ヤマカ・パーリ-2 7108 ヤマカ・パーリ-3 7109 パッターナ・パーリ-1 7110 パッターナ・パーリ-2 7111 パッターナ・パーリ-3 7112 パッターナ・パーリ-4 7113 パッターナ・パーリ-5 | 7201 ダンマサンガニ・アッタカター 7202 サンモーハヴィノーダニー・アッタカター 7203 パンチャパカラナ・アッタカター | 7301 ダンマサンガニー・ムーラティーカー 7302 ヴィバンガ・ムーラティーカー 7303 パンチャパカラナ・ムーラティーカー 7304 ダンマサンガニー・アヌティーカー 7305 パンチャパカラナ・アヌティーカー 7306 アビダンマーヴァターロ・ナーマルーパパリッチェード 7307 アビダンマッタ・サンガホ 7308 アビダンマーヴァターラ・プラーナティーカー 7309 アビダンマ・マーティカーパーリ | |
| ខ្មែរ | |||
| ព្រះត្រៃបិដកបាលី | អដ្ឋកថា | ដីកា | ផ្សេងទៀត |
| 1101 បារាជិកបាឡិ 1102 បាចិត្តិយបាឡិ 1103 មហាវគ្គបាឡិ (វិន័យ) 1104 ចូឡវគ្គបាឡិ 1105 បរិវារបាឡិ | 1201 បារាជិកកណ្ឌអដ្ឋកថា-១ 1202 បារាជិកកណ្ឌអដ្ឋកថា-២ 1203 បាចិត្តិយអដ្ឋកថា 1204 មហាវគ្គអដ្ឋកថា (វិន័យ) 1205 ចូឡវគ្គអដ្ឋកថា 1206 បរិវារអដ្ឋកថា | 1301 សារត្ថទីបនីដីកា-១ 1302 សារត្ថទីបនីដីកា-២ 1303 សារត្ថទីបនីដីកា-៣ | 1401 ទ្វេមាតិកាបាឡិ 1402 វិនយសង្គហអដ្ឋកថា 1403 វជិរពុទ្ធិដីកា 1404 វិមតិវិនោទនីដីកា-១ 1405 វិមតិវិនោទនីដីកា-២ 1406 វិនយាលង្ការដីកា-១ 1407 វិនយាលង្ការដីកា-២ 1408 កង្ខាវិតរណីបុរាណដីកា 1409 វិនយវិនិច្ឆយ-ឧត្តរវិនិច្ឆយ 1410 វិនយវិនិច្ឆយដីកា-១ 1411 វិនយវិនិច្ឆយដីកា-២ 1412 បាចិត្យាទិយោជនាបាឡិ 1413 ខុទ្ទសិក្ខា-មូលសិក្ខា 8401 វិសុទ្ធិមគ្គ-១ 8402 វិសុទ្ធិមគ្គ-២ 8403 វិសុទ្ធិមគ្គ-មហាដីកា-១ 8404 វិសុទ្ធិមគ្គ-មហាដីកា-២ 8405 វិសុទ្ធិមគ្គ និទានកថា 8406 ទីឃនិកាយ (បុ-វិ) 8407 មជ្ឈិមនិកាយ (បុ-វិ) 8408 សំយុត្តនិកាយ (បុ-វិ) 8409 អង្គុត្តរនិកាយ (បុ-វិ) 8410 វិនយបិដក (បុ-វិ) 8411 អភិធម្មបិដក (បុ-វិ) 8412 អដ្ឋកថា (បុ-វិ) 8413 និរុត្តិទីបនី 8414 បរមត្ថទីបនី សង្គហមហាដីកាបាឋ 8415 អនុទីបនីបាឋ 8416 បដ្ឋានុទ្ទេស ទីបនីបាឋ 8417 នមក្ការដីកា 8418 មហាបណាមបាឋ 8419 លក្ខណាតោ ពុទ្ធថោមនាគាថា 8420 សុតវន្ទនា 8421 កមលាញ្ជលិ 8422 ជិនាលង្ការ 8423 បជ្ជមធុ 8424 ពុទ្ធគុណគាថាវលី 8425 ចូឡគន្ថវង្ស 8427 សាសនវង្ស 8426 មហាវង្ស 8429 មោគ្គល្លានព្យាករណំ 8428 កច្ចាយនព្យាករណំ 8430 សទ្ទនីតិប្បករណំ (បទមាលា) 8431 សទ្ទនីតិប្បករណំ (ធាតុមាលា) 8432 បទរូបសិទ្ធិ 8433 មោគ្គល្លានបញ្ចិកា 8434 បយោគសិទ្ធិបាឋ 8435 វុត្តោទយបាឋ 8436 អភិធានប្បទីបិកាបាឋ 8437 អភិធានប្បទីបិកាដីកា 8438 សុពោធាលង្ការបាឋ 8439 សុពោធាលង្ការដីកា 8440 បាលាវតារ គណ្ឋិបទត្ថវិនិច្ឆយសារ 8446 កវិទប្បណនីតិ 8447 នីតិមញ្ជរី 8445 ធម្មនីតិ 8444 មហារហនីតិ 8441 លោកនីតិ 8442 សុត្តន្តនីតិ 8443 សូរស្សតិនីតិ 8450 ចាណក្យនីតិ 8448 នរទក្ខទីបនី 8449 ចតុរារក្ខទីបនី 8451 រសវាហិនី 8452 សីមវិសោធនីបាឋ 8453 វេស្សន្តរគីតិ 8454 មោគ្គល្លាន វុត្តិវិវរណបញ្ចិកា 8455 ថូបវង្ស 8456 ទាឋាវង្ស 8457 ធាតុបាឋវិលាសិនិយា 8458 ធាតុវង្ស 8459 ហត្ថវនគល្លវិហារវង្ស 8460 ជិនចរិតយ 8461 ជិនវង្សទីបំ 8462 តេលកដាហគាថា 8463 មិលិទដីកា 8464 បទមញ្ជរី 8465 បទសាធនំ 8466 សទ្ទពិន្ទុបករណំ 8467 កច្ចាយនធាតុមញ្ជុសា 8468 សាមន្តកូដវណ្ណនា |
| 2101 សីលក្ខន្ធវគ្គបាឡិ 2102 មហាវគ្គបាឡិ (ទីឃ) 2103 បាថិកវគ្គបាឡិ | 2201 សីលក្ខន្ធវគ្គអដ្ឋកថា 2202 មហាវគ្គអដ្ឋកថា (ទីឃ) 2203 បាថិកវគ្គអដ្ឋកថា | 2301 សីលក្ខន្ធវគ្គដីកា 2302 មហាវគ្គដីកា (ទីឃ) 2303 បាថិកវគ្គដីកា 2304 សីលក្ខន្ធវគ្គ-អភិនវដីកា-១ 2305 សីលក្ខន្ធវគ្គ-អភិនវដីកា-២ | |
| 3101 មូលបណ្ណាសបាឡិ 3102 មជ្ឈិមបណ្ណាសបាឡិ 3103 ឧបរិបណ្ណាសបាឡិ | 3201 មូលបណ្ណាសអដ្ឋកថា-១ 3202 មូលបណ្ណាសអដ្ឋកថា-២ 3203 មជ្ឈិមបណ្ណាសអដ្ឋកថា 3204 ឧបរិបណ្ណាសអដ្ឋកថា | 3301 មូលបណ្ណាសដីកា 3302 មជ្ឈិមបណ្ណាសដីកា 3303 ឧបរិបណ្ណាសដីកា | |
| 4101 សគាថាវគ្គបាឡិ 4102 និទានវគ្គបាឡិ 4103 ខន្ធវគ្គបាឡិ 4104 សឡាយតនវគ្គបាឡិ 4105 មហាវគ្គបាឡិ (សំយុត្ត) | 4201 សគាថាវគ្គអដ្ឋកថា 4202 និទានវគ្គអដ្ឋកថា 4203 ខន្ធវគ្គអដ្ឋកថា 4204 សឡាយតនវគ្គអដ្ឋកថា 4205 មហាវគ្គអដ្ឋកថា (សំយុត្ត) | 4301 សគាថាវគ្គដីកា 4302 និទានវគ្គដីកា 4303 ខន្ធវគ្គដីកា 4304 សឡាយតនវគ្គដីកា 4305 មហាវគ្គដីកា (សំយុត្ត) | |
| 5101 ឯកកនិបាតបាឡិ 5102 ទុកនិបាតបាឡិ 5103 តិកនិបាតបាឡិ 5104 ចតុក្កនិបាតបាឡិ 5105 បញ្ចកនិបាតបាឡិ 5106 ឆក្កនិបាតបាឡិ 5107 សត្តកនិបាតបាឡិ 5108 អដ្ឋកាទិនិបាតបាឡិ 5109 នវកនិបាតបាឡិ 5110 ទសកនិបាតបាឡិ 5111 ឯកាទសកនិបាតបាឡិ | 5201 ឯកកនិបាតអដ្ឋកថា 5202 ទុក-តិក-ចតុក្កនិបាតអដ្ឋកថា 5203 បញ្ចក-ឆក្ក-សត្តកនិបាតអដ្ឋកថា 5204 អដ្ឋកាទិនិបាតអដ្ឋកថា | 5301 ឯកកនិបាតដីកា 5302 ទុក-តិក-ចតុក្កនិបាតដីកា 5303 បញ្ចក-ឆក្ក-សត្តកនិបាតដីកា 5304 អដ្ឋកាទិនិបាតដីកា | |
| 6101 ខុទ្ទកបាឋបាឡិ 6102 ធម្មបទបាឡិ 6103 ឧទានបាឡិ 6104 ឥតិវុត្តកបាឡិ 6105 សុត្តនិបាតបាឡិ 6106 វិមានវត្ថុបាឡិ 6107 បេតវត្ថុបាឡិ 6108 ថេរគាថាបាឡិ 6109 ថេរីគាថាបាឡិ 6110 អបទានបាឡិ-១ 6111 អបទានបាឡិ-២ 6112 ពុទ្ធវង្សបាឡិ 6113 ចរិយាបិដកបាឡិ 6114 ជាតកបាឡិ-១ 6115 ជាតកបាឡិ-២ 6116 មហានិទ្ទេសបាឡិ 6117 ចូឡនិទ្ទេសបាឡិ 6118 បដិសម្ភិទាមគ្គបាឡិ 6119 នេត្តិប្បករណបាឡិ 6120 មិលិន្ទបញ្ហាបាឡិ 6121 បេដកោបទេសបាឡិ | 6201 ខុទ្ទកបាឋអដ្ឋកថា 6202 ធម្មបទអដ្ឋកថា-១ 6203 ធម្មបទអដ្ឋកថា-២ 6204 ឧទានអដ្ឋកថា 6205 ឥតិវុត្តកអដ្ឋកថា 6206 សុត្តនិបាតអដ្ឋកថា-១ 6207 សុត្តនិបាតអដ្ឋកថា-២ 6208 វិមានវត្ថុអដ្ឋកថា 6209 បេតវត្ថុអដ្ឋកថា 6210 ថេរគាថាអដ្ឋកថា-១ 6211 ថេរគាថាអដ្ឋកថា-២ 6212 ថេរីគាថាអដ្ឋកថា 6213 អបទានអដ្ឋកថា-១ 6214 អបទានអដ្ឋកថា-២ 6215 ពុទ្ធវង្សអដ្ឋកថា 6216 ចរិយាបិដកអដ្ឋកថា 6217 ជាតកអដ្ឋកថា-១ 6218 ជាតកអដ្ឋកថា-២ 6219 ជាតកអដ្ឋកថា-៣ 6220 ជាតកអដ្ឋកថា-៤ 6221 ជាតកអដ្ឋកថា-៥ 6222 ជាតកអដ្ឋកថា-៦ 6223 ជាតកអដ្ឋកថា-៧ 6224 មហានិទ្ទេសអដ្ឋកថា 6225 ចូឡនិទ្ទេសអដ្ឋកថា 6226 បដិសម្ភិទាមគ្គអដ្ឋកថា-១ 6227 បដិសម្ភិទាមគ្គអដ្ឋកថា-២ 6228 នេត្តិប្បករណអដ្ឋកថា | 6301 នេត្តិប្បករណដីកា 6302 នេត្តិវិភាវិនី | |
| 7101 ធម្មសង្គណីបាឡិ 7102 វិភង្គបាឡិ 7103 ធាតុកថាបាឡិ 7104 បុគ្គលបញ្ញត្តិបាឡិ 7105 កថាវត្ថុបាឡិ 7106 យមកបាឡិ-១ 7107 យមកបាឡិ-២ 7108 យមកបាឡិ-៣ 7109 បដ្ឋានបាឡិ-១ 7110 បដ្ឋានបាឡិ-២ 7111 បដ្ឋានបាឡិ-៣ 7112 បដ្ឋានបាឡិ-៤ 7113 បដ្ឋានបាឡិ-៥ | 7201 ធម្មសង្គណិអដ្ឋកថា 7202 សម្មោហវិនោទនីអដ្ឋកថា 7203 បញ្ចបករណអដ្ឋកថា | 7301 ធម្មសង្គណី-មូលដីកា 7302 វិភង្គ-មូលដីកា 7303 បញ្ចបករណ-មូលដីកា 7304 ធម្មសង្គណី-អនុដីកា 7305 បញ្ចបករណ-អនុដីកា 7306 អភិធម្មាវតារោ-នាមរូបបរិច្ឆេទោ 7307 អភិធម្មត្ថសង្គហោ 7308 អភិធម្មាវតារ-បុរាណដីកា 7309 អភិធម្មមាតិកាបាឡិ | |
| 한국인 | |||
| 팔리 대장경 | 주석서 | 부주석서 | 기타 |
| 1101 빠라지카 빨리 1102 빠찟띠야 빨리 1103 마하왁가 빨리 (비나야) 1104 출라왁가 빨리 1105 빠리와라 빨리 | 1201 빠라지까깐다 앗타카타-1 1202 빠라지까깐다 앗타카타-2 1203 빠찟띠야 앗타카타 1204 마하왁가 앗타카타 (비나야) 1205 출라왁가 앗타카타 1206 빠리와라 앗타카타 | 1301 사랏타디빠니 띠까-1 1302 사랏타디빠니 띠까-2 1303 사랏타디빠니 띠까-3 | 1401 드베마띠까빨리 1402 위나야상가하 앗타카타 1403 와지라붓디 띠까 1404 위마띠위노다니 띠까-1 1405 위마띠위노다니 띠까-2 1406 위나야랑까라 띠까-1 1407 위나야랑까라 띠까-2 1408 깡카위따라니뿌라나 띠까 1409 위나야위닛차야-웃따라위닛차야 1410 위나야위닛차야 띠까-1 1411 위나야위닛차야 띠까-2 1412 빠찟땨디요자나빨리 1413 쿳닷시카-물라시카 8401 위숟디막가-1 8402 위숟디막가-2 8403 위숟디막가-마하띠까-1 8404 위숟디막가-마하띠까-2 8405 위숟디막가 니다나까타 8406 디가니까야 (뿌-위) 8407 맛지마니까야 (뿌-위) 8408 삼윳따니까야 (뿌-위) 8409 앙굳따라니까야 (뿌-위) 8410 위나야삐따까 (뿌-위) 8411 아비담마삐따까 (뿌-위) 8412 앗타카타 (뿌-위) 8413 니룻띠디빠니 8414 빠라맛타디빠니 상가하마하띠까빠타 8415 아누디빠니빠타 8416 빳타누ㄸ데사 디빠니빠타 8417 나막까라띠까 8418 마하빠나마빠타 8419 락카나또 붓다토마나가타 8420 수타완다나 8421 까말란자리 8422 지나랑까라 8423 빳자마두 8424 붓다구나가타왈리 8425 출라간타왕사 8427 사사나왕사 8426 마하왕사 8429 목갈라나뱌까라낭 8428 깟차야나뱌까라낭 8430 삿다니띠빠까라낭 (빠다말라) 8431 삿다니띠빠까라낭 (다두말라) 8432 빠다루빠싣디 8433 목갈라나빤찌까 8434 빠요가싣디빠타 8435 붇또다야빠타 8436 아비다나빠디피까빠타 8437 아비다나빠디피까띠까 8438 수보다랑까라빠타 8439 수보다랑까라띠까 8440 발라와따라 간티빠닷타위닛차야사라 8446 까위닷빠나니띠 8447 니띠만자리 8445 담마니띠 8444 마하라하니띠 8441 로까니띠 8442 숫딴따니띠 8443 수랏사띠니띠 8450 짜낙야니띠 8448 나라닥카디빠니 8449 짜뚜라락카디빠니 8451 라사와히니 8452 시마위소다니빠타 8453 웨산따라기띠 8454 목갈라나 붇띠위와라나빤찌까 8455 투빠왕사 8456 다타왕사 8457 다두빠타윌라시니야 8458 다두왕사 8459 핟타와나갈라위하라왕사 8460 지나짜리따야 8461 지나왕사디빵 8462 떼라까타하가타 8463 밀리다띠까 8464 빠다만자리 8465 빠다사다낭 8466 삿다빈두빠까라낭 8467 깟차야나다두만주사 8468 사만따꿋타완나나 |
| 2101 실락칸다왁가 빨리 2102 마하왁가 빨리 (디가) 2103 빠티까왁가 빨리 | 2201 실락칸다왁가 앗타카타 2202 마하왁가 앗타카타 (디가) 2203 빠티까왁가 앗타카타 | 2301 실락칸다왁가 띠까 2302 마하왁가 띠까 (디가) 2303 빠티까왁가 띠까 2304 실락칸다왁가-아비나와띠까-1 2305 실락칸다왁가-아비나와띠까-2 | |
| 3101 물라빤나사 빨리 3102 맛지마빤나사 빨리 3103 우빠리빤나사 빨리 | 3201 물라빤나사 앗타카타-1 3202 물라빤나사 앗타카타-2 3203 맛지마빤나사 앗타카타 3204 우빠리빤나사 앗타카타 | 3301 물라빤나사 띠까 3302 맛지마빤나사 띠까 3303 우빠리빤나사 띠까 | |
| 4101 사가타왁가 빨리 4102 니다나왁가 빨리 4103 칸다왁가 빨리 4104 살라야따나왁가 빨리 4105 마하왁가 빨리 (삼윳따) | 4201 사가타왁가 앗타카타 4202 니다나왁가 앗타카타 4203 칸다왁가 앗타카타 4204 살라야따나왁가 앗타카타 4205 마하왁가 앗타카타 (삼윳따) | 4301 사가타왁가 띠까 4302 니다나왁가 띠까 4303 칸다왁가 띠까 4304 살라야따나왁가 띠까 4305 마하왁가 띠까 (삼윳따) | |
| 5101 에까까니빠따 빨리 5102 두까니빠따 빨리 5103 띠까니빠따 빨리 5104 짜뚝까니빠따 빨리 5105 빤짜까니빠따 빨리 5106 착까니빠따 빨리 5107 삿따까니빠따 빨리 5108 앗타까디니빠따 빨리 5109 나와까니빠따 빨리 5110 다사까니빠따 빨리 5111 에까다사까니빠따 빨리 | 5201 에까까니빠따 앗타카타 5202 두까-띠까-짜뚝까니빠따 앗타카타 5203 빤짜까-착까-삿따까니빠따 앗타카타 5204 앗타까디니빠따 앗타카타 | 5301 에까까니빠따 띠까 5302 두까-띠까-짜뚝까니빠따 띠까 5303 빤짜까-착까-삿따까니빠따 띠까 5304 앗타까디니빠따 띠까 | |
| 6101 쿳닥까빠타 빨리 6102 담마빠다 빨리 6103 우다나 빨리 6104 이띠웃따까 빨리 6105 숫따니빠따 빨리 6106 위마나왓투 빨리 6107 베따왓투 빨리 6108 테라가타 빨리 6109 테리가타 빨리 6110 아빠다나 빨리-1 6111 아빠다나 빨리-2 6112 붓다왕사 빨리 6113 짜리야삐따까 빨리 6114 자따까 빨리-1 6115 자따까 빨리-2 6116 마하닷데사 빨리 6117 출라닷데사 빨리 6118 빠티삼비다막가 빨리 6119 넷띠빠까라나 빨리 6120 밀린다빤하 빨리 6121 뻬따꼬빠데사 빨리 | 6201 쿳닥까빠타 앗타카타 6202 담마빠다 앗타카타-1 6203 담마빠다 앗타카타-2 6204 우다나 앗타카타 6205 이띠웃따까 앗타카타 6206 숫따니빠따 앗타카타-1 6207 숫따니빠따 앗타카타-2 6208 위마나왓투 앗타카타 6209 베따왓투 앗타카타 6210 테라가타 앗타카타-1 6211 테라가타 앗타카타-2 6212 테리가타 앗타카타 6213 아빠다나 앗타카타-1 6214 아빠다나 앗타카타-2 6215 붓다왕사 앗타카타 6216 짜리야삐따까 앗타카타 6217 자따까 앗타카타-1 6218 자따까 앗타카타-2 6219 자따까 앗타카타-3 6220 자따까 앗타카타-4 6221 자따까 앗타카타-5 6222 자따까 앗타카타-6 6223 자따까 앗타카타-7 6224 마하닷데사 앗타카타 6225 출라닷데사 앗타카타 6226 빠티삼비다막가 앗타카타-1 6227 빠티삼비다막가 앗타카타-2 6228 넷띠빠까라나 앗타카타 | 6301 넷띠빠까라나 띠까 6302 넷띠위바비니 | |
| 7101 담마상가니 빨리 7102 위방가 빨리 7103 다뚜까타 빨리 7104 뿍갈라빤냣띠 빨리 7105 까타왓투 빨리 7106 야마까 빨리-1 7107 야마까 빨리-2 7108 야마까 빨리-3 7109 빳타나 빨리-1 7110 빳타나 빨리-2 7111 빳타나 빨리-3 7112 빳타나 빨리-4 7113 빳타나 빨리-5 | 7201 담마상가니 앗타카타 7202 삼모하위노다니 앗타카타 7203 빤짜빠까라나 앗타카타 | 7301 담마상가니-물라띠까 7302 위방가-물라띠까 7303 빤짜빠까라나-물라띠까 7304 담마상가니-아누띠까 7305 빤짜빠까라나-아누띠까 7306 아비담마와따로-나마루빠빠릳체도 7307 아비담맛타상가호 7308 아비담마와따라-뿌라나띠까 7309 아비담마마띠까빨리 | |
| ອັກສອນລາວ | |||
| ປາລີ | ອັດຖະກະຖາ | ຏີກາ | ອັນຍາ |
| 1101 ປາຣາຊິກະ ປາລີ 1102 ປາຈິດຕິຍະ ປາລີ 1103 ມະຫາວັກຄະ ປາລີ (ວິໄນ) 1104 ຈູລະວັກຄະ ປາລີ 1105 ປະລິວາລະ ປາລີ | 1201 ປາຣາຊິກະກັນທະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-1 1202 ປາຣາຊິກະກັນທະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-2 1203 ປາຈິດຕິຍະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 1204 ມະຫາວັກຄະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ (ວິໄນ) 1205 ຈູລະວັກຄະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 1206 ປະລິວາລະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ | 1301 ສາຣັດຖະທີປະນີ ຏີກາ-1 1302 ສາຣັດຖະທີປະນີ ຏີກາ-2 1303 ສາຣັດຖະທີປະນີ ຏີກາ-3 | 1401 ທເວມາຕິກາປາລີ 1402 ວິນະຍະສັງຄະຫະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 1403 ວະຊິລະພຸດທິ ຏີກາ 1404 ວິມະຕິວິໂນທະນີ ຏີກາ-1 1405 ວິມະຕິວິໂນທະນີ ຏີກາ-2 1406 ວິນະຍາລັງກາລະ ຏີກາ-1 1407 ວິນະຍາລັງກາລະ ຏີກາ-2 1408 ກັງຂາວິຕະຣະນີປຸຣານະ ຏີກາ 1409 ວິນະຍະວິນິດສະຍະ-ອຸຕຕະຣະວິນິດສະຍະ 1410 ວິນະຍະວິນິດສະຍະ ຏີກາ-1 1411 ວິນະຍະວິນິດສະຍະ ຏີກາ-2 1412 ປາຈິຕະຍາທິໂຍຊະນາປາລີ 1413 ຂຸທະທະສິກຂາ-ມູລະສິກຂາ 8401 ວິສຸດທິມັກຄະ-1 8402 ວິສຸດທິມັກຄະ-2 8403 ວິສຸດທິມັກຄະ-ມະຫາຏີກາ-1 8404 ວິສຸດທິມັກຄະ-ມະຫາຏີກາ-2 8405 ວິສຸດທິມັກຄະ ນິທານະກະຖາ 8406 ທີຆະນິກາຍະ (ປຸ-ວິ) 8407 ມັດຊິມະນິກາຍະ (ປຸ-ວິ) 8408 ສັງຍຸຕຕະນິກາຍະ (ປຸ-ວິ) 8409 ອັງຄຸຕຕະລະນິກາຍະ (ປຸ-ວິ) 8410 ວິນະຍະປິຕະກະ (ປຸ-ວິ) 8411 ອະພິທັມມະປິຕະກະ (ປຸ-ວິ) 8412 ອັດຖະກະຖາ (ປຸ-ວິ) 8413 ນິລຸຕຕິທີປະນີ 8414 ປະຣະມັດຖະທີປະນີ ສັງຄະຫະມະຫາຏີກາປາຖະ 8415 ອະນຸທີປະນີປາຖະ 8416 ປັດຖານຸທເທສະ ທີປະນີປາຖະ 8417 ນະມັກກາລະຏີກາ 8418 ມະຫາປະຖາມະປາຖະ 8419 ລັກຂະນາໂຕ ພຸດທະຖະມະນາຄາຖາ 8420 ສຸຕະວັນທະນາ 8421 ກະມະລາຍຈະລິ 8422 ຊິນາລັງກາລະ 8423 ປັດຊະມະທຸ 8424 ພຸດທະຄຸນະຄາຖາວະລີ 8425 ຈູລະຄັນຖະວັງສະ 8426 ມະຫາວັງສະ 8427 ສາສະນະວັງສະ 8428 ກັດຈາຍະນະພະຍາກະລະນັງ 8429 ມົກຄັນທານະພະຍາກະລະນັງ 8430 ສັດທະນີຕິປະກະລະນັງ (ປະທະມາລາ) 8431 ສັດທະນີຕິປະກະລະນັງ (ຘາຕຸມາລາ) 8432 ປະທະຣູປະສິດທິ 8433 ໂມຄັນທານະປັນຈິກາ 8434 ປະໂຍຄະສິດທິປາຖະ 8435 ວຸຕະໂທຍະປາຖະ 8436 ອະພິທານະປະປະທີປິກາປາຖະ 8437 ອະພິທານະປະປະທີປິກາຏີກາ 8438 ສຸໂພທາລັງກາລະປາຖະ 8439 ສຸໂພທາລັງກາລະຏີກາ 8440 ພາລາວະຕາລະ ຄັນຖິປະທັດຖະວິນິດສະຍະສາລະ 8441 ໂລກະນີຕິ 8442 ສຸດຕັນຕະນີຕິ 8443 ສູລັດສະຕິນີຕິ 8444 ມະຫາລະຫະນີຕິ 8445 ທັມມະນີຕິ 8446 ກະວິທັບປະຖານີຕິ 8447 ນີຕິມັນຊະລີ 8448 ນະລະທັກຂະທີປະນີ 8449 ຈະຕຸຣາລັກຂະທີປະນີ 8450 ຈານັກຍະນີຕິ 8451 ລະສະວາຫິນີ 8452 ສີມາວິໂສທະນີປາຖະ 8453 ເວສສັນຕະລະຄີຕິ 8454 ໂມຄັນທານະ ວຸຕຕິວິວະລະນະປັນຈິກາ 8455 ຖູປະວັງສະ 8456 ທາຐາວັງສະ 8457 ຘາຕຸປາຖະວິລາສິນີຍາ 8458 ຘາຕຸວັງສະ 8459 ຫັດຖະວະນະຄັນລະວິຫາລະວັງສະ 8460 ຊິນະຈະລິຕະຍະ 8461 ຊິນະວັງສະທີປັງ 8462 ເຕລະກະຕາຫາຄາຖາ 8463 ມິລິທະຏີກາ 8464 ປະທະມັນຊະລີ 8465 ປະທະສາຘະນັງ 8466 ສັດທະພິນທຸປະກະລະນັງ 8467 ກັດຈາຍະນະຘາຕຸມັນຊຸສາ 8468 ສາມັນຕະກູຏະວັນນະນາ |
| 2101 ສີລັກຂັນທະວັກຄະ ປາລີ 2102 ມະຫາວັກຄະ ປາລີ (ທີຆະ) 2103 ປາຖິກະວັກຄະ ປາລີ | 2201 ສີລັກຂັນທະວັກຄະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 2202 ມະຫາວັກຄະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ (ທີຆະ) 2203 ປາຖິກະວັກຄະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ | 2301 ສີລັກຂັນທະວັກຄະ ຏີກາ 2302 ມະຫາວັກຄະ ຏີກາ (ທີຆະ) 2303 ປາຖິກະວັກຄະ ຏີກາ 2304 ສີລັກຂັນທະວັກຄະ-ອະພິນະວະຏີກາ-1 2305 ສີລັກຂັນທະວັກຄະ-ອະພິນະວະຏີກາ-2 | |
| 3101 ມູລະປັນຍາສະ ປາລີ 3102 ມັດຊິມະປັນຍາສະ ປາລີ 3103 ອຸປະລິປັນຍາສະ ປາລີ | 3201 ມູລະປັນຍາສະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-1 3202 ມູລະປັນຍາສະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-2 3203 ມັດຊິມະປັນຍາສະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 3204 ອຸປະລິປັນຍາສະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ | 3301 ມູລະປັນຍາສະ ຏີກາ 3302 ມັດຊິມະປັນຍາສະ ຏີກາ 3303 ອຸປະລິປັນຍາສະ ຏີກາ | |
| 4101 ສະຄາຖາວັກຄະ ປາລີ 4102 ນິທານະວັກຄະ ປາລີ 4103 ຂັນທະວັກຄະ ປາລີ 4104 ສະຫຼາຍາຕະນະວັກຄະ ປາລີ 4105 ມະຫາວັກຄະ ປາລີ (ສັງຍຸຕຕະ) | 4201 ສະຄາຖາວັກຄະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 4202 ນິທານະວັກຄະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 4203 ຂັນທະວັກຄະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 4204 ສະຫຼາຍາຕະນະວັກຄະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 4205 ມະຫາວັກຄະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ (ສັງຍຸຕຕະ) | 4301 ສະຄາຖາວັກຄະ ຏີກາ 4302 ນິທານະວັກຄະ ຏີກາ 4303 ຂັນທະວັກຄະ ຏີກາ 4304 ສະຫຼາຍາຕະນະວັກຄະ ຏີກາ 4305 ມະຫາວັກຄະ ຏີກາ (ສັງຍຸຕຕະ) | |
| 5101 ເອກະກະນິປາຕະ ປາລີ 5102 ທຸກະນິປາຕະ ປາລີ 5103 ຕິກະນິປາຕະ ປາລີ 5104 ຈະຕຸກກະນິປາຕະ ປາລີ 5105 ປັຈຈະກະນິປາຕະ ປາລີ 5106 ຉັກກະນິປາຕະ ປາລີ 5107 ສັດຕະກະນິປາຕະ ປາລີ 5108 ອັດຖະກາທິນິປາຕະ ປາລີ 5109 ນະວະກະນິປາຕະ ປາລີ 5110 ທະສະກະນິປາຕະ ປາລີ 5111 ເອກາທະສະກະນິປາຕະ ປາລີ | 5201 ເອກະກະນິປາຕະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 5202 ທຸກະ-ຕິກະ-ຈະຕຸກກະນິປາຕະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 5203 ປັຈຈະກະ-ຉັກກະ-ສັດຕະກະນິປາຕະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 5204 ອັດຖະກາທິນິປາຕະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ | 5301 ເອກະກະນິປາຕະ ຏີກາ 5302 ທຸກະ-ຕິກະ-ຈະຕຸກກະນິປາຕະ ຏີກາ 5303 ປັຈຈະກະ-ຉັກກະ-ສັດຕະກະນິປາຕະ ຏີກາ 5304 ອັດຖະກາທິນິປາຕະ ຏີກາ | |
| 6101 ຂຸທະທະກະປາຖະ ປາລີ 6102 ທຳມະປະທະ ປາລີ 6103 ອຸທານະ ປາລີ 6104 ອິຕິວຸຕຕະກະ ປາລີ 6105 ສຸດຕະນິປາຕະ ປາລີ 6106 ວິມານະວັດຖຸ ປາລີ 6107 ເປຕະວັດຖຸ ປາລີ 6108 ເຖລະຄາຖາ ປາລີ 6109 ເຖລີຄາຖາ ປາລີ 6110 ອະປະທານະ ປາລີ-1 6111 ອະປະທານະ ປາລີ-2 6112 ພຸດທະວັງສະ ປາລີ 6113 ຈະຣິຍາປິຕະກະ ປາລີ 6114 ຊາຕະກະ ປາລີ-1 6115 ຊາຕະກະ ປາລີ-2 6116 ມະຫານິທເທສະ ປາລີ 6117 ຈູລະນິທເທສະ ປາລີ 6118 ປະຕິສັມພິທາມັກຄະ ປາລີ 6119 ເນຕຕິປະກະລະນະ ປາລີ 6120 ມິລິນທະປັນຫາ ປາລີ 6121 ເປຏະກົປເທສະ ປາລີ | 6201 ຂຸທະທະກະປາຖະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 6202 ທຳມະປະທະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-1 6203 ທຳມະປະທະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-2 6204 ອຸທານະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 6205 ອິຕິວຸຕຕະກະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 6206 ສຸດຕະນິປາຕະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-1 6207 ສຸດຕະນິປາຕະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-2 6208 ວິມານະວັດຖຸ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 6209 ເປຕະວັດຖຸ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 6210 ເຖລະຄາຖາ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-1 6211 ເຖລະຄາຖາ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-2 6212 ເຖລີຄາຖາ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 6213 ອະປະທານະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-1 6214 ອະປະທານະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-2 6215 ພຸດທະວັງສະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 6216 ຈະຣິຍາປິຕະກະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 6217 ຊາຕະກະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-1 6218 ຊາຕະກະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-2 6219 ຊາຕະກະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-3 6220 ຊາຕະກະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-4 6221 ຊາຕະກະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-5 6222 ຊາຕະກະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-6 6223 ຊາຕະກະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-7 6224 ມະຫານິທເທສະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 6225 ຈູລະນິທເທສະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 6226 ປະຕິສັມພິທາມັກຄະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-1 6227 ປະຕິສັມພິທາມັກຄະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ-2 6228 ເນຕຕິປະກະລະນະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ | 6301 ເນຕຕິປະກະລະນະ ຏີກາ 6302 ເນຕຕິວິພາວິນີ | |
| 7101 ທຳມະສັງຄະນີ ປາລີ 7102 ວິພັງຄະ ປາລີ 7103 ຘາຕຸກະຖາ ປາລີ 7104 ປຸກຄະລະປັນຍັດຕິ ປາລີ 7105 ກະຖາວັດຖຸ ປາລີ 7106 ຍະມະກະ ປາລີ-1 7107 ຍະມະກະ ປາລີ-2 7108 ຍະມະກະ ປາລີ-3 7109 ປັດຖານະ ປາລີ-1 7110 ປັດຖານະ ປາລີ-2 7111 ປັດຖານະ ປາລີ-3 7112 ປັດຖານະ ປາລີ-4 7113 ປັດຖານະ ປາລີ-5 | 7201 ທຳມະສັງຄະນິ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 7202 ສັມໂມຫະວິໂນທະນີ ອັດຖະກະຖາ 7203 ປັຈຈະປະກະລະນະ ອັດຖະກະຖາ | 7301 ທຳມະສັງຄະນີ-ມູລະຏີກາ 7302 ວິພັງຄະ-ມູລະຏີກາ 7303 ປັຈຈະປະກະລະນະ-ມູລະຏີກາ 7304 ທຳມະສັງຄະນີ-ອະນຸຏີກາ 7305 ປັຈຈະປະກະລະນະ-ອະນຸຏີກາ 7306 ອະພິທັມມາວະຕາໂຣ-ນາມະຣູປະປະຣິຈເທໂທ 7307 ອະພິທັມມັດຖະສັງຄະໂຫ 7308 ອະພິທັມມາວະຕາລະ-ປຸຣານະຏີກາ 7309 ອະພິທັມມາມາຕິກາປາລີ | |
| मराठी | |||
| पाळी | अट्ठकथा | टीका | अन्य |
| 1101 पाराजिक पाळी 1102 पाचित्तिय पाळी 1103 महावग्ग पाळी (विनय) 1104 चूळवग्ग पाळी 1105 परिवार पाळी | 1201 पाराजिककंड अट्ठकथा-१ 1202 पाराजिककंड अट्ठकथा-२ 1203 पाचित्तिय अट्ठकथा 1204 महावग्ग अट्ठकथा (विनय) 1205 चूळवग्ग अट्ठकथा 1206 परिवार अट्ठकथा | 1301 सारत्थदीपनी टीका-१ 1302 सारत्थदीपनी टीका-२ 1303 सारत्थदीपनी टीका-३ | 1401 द्वेमातिकापाळी 1402 विनयसंगह अट्ठकथा 1403 वजिरबुद्धि टीका 1404 विमतिविनोदनी टीका-१ 1405 विमतिविनोदनी टीका-२ 1406 विनयालंकार टीका-१ 1407 विनयालंकार टीका-२ 1408 कंखावितरणीपुराण टीका 1409 विनयविनिच्छय-उत्तरविनिच्छय 1410 विनयविनिच्छय टीका-१ 1411 विनयविनिच्छय टीका-२ 1412 पाचित्यादियोजनापाळी 1413 खुद्दसिक्खा-मूलसिक्खा 8401 विसुद्धिमग्ग-१ 8402 विसुद्धिमग्ग-२ 8403 विसुद्धिमग्ग-महाटीका-१ 8404 विसुद्धिमग्ग-महाटीका-२ 8405 विसुद्धिमग्ग निदानकथा 8406 दीघनिकाय (पु-वि) 8407 मज्झिमनिकाय (पु-वि) 8408 संयुत्तनिकाय (पु-वि) 8409 अंगुत्तरनिकाय (पु-वि) 8410 विनयपिटक (पु-वि) 8411 अभिधम्मपिटक (पु-वि) 8412 अट्ठकथा (पु-वि) 8413 निरुत्तिदीपनी 8414 परमत्थदीपनी संगहमहाटीकापाठ 8415 अनुदीपनीपाठ 8416 पट्ठानुद्देस दीपनीपाठ 8417 नमक्कारटीका 8418 महापणामपाठ 8419 लक्खणातो बुद्धथोमनागाथा 8420 सुतवंदना 8421 कमलांजलि 8422 जिनालंकार 8423 पज्जमधु 8424 बुद्धगुणगाथावली 8425 चूळगंथवंस 8426 महावंस 8427 सासनवंस 8428 कच्चायनव्याकरणं 8429 मोग्गल्लानव्याकरणं 8430 सद्दनीतिप्पकरणं (पदमाला) 8431 सद्दनीतिप्पकरणं (धातुमाला) 8432 पदरूपसिद्धि 8433 मोग्गल्लानपंचिका 8434 पयोगसिद्धिपाठ 8435 वुत्तोदयपाठ 8436 अभिधानप्पदीपिकापाठ 8437 अभिधानप्पदीपिकाटीका 8438 सुबोधालंकारपाठ 8439 सुबोधालंकारटीका 8440 बालावतार गंठिपदत्थविनिच्छयसार 8441 लोकनीति 8442 सुत्तंतनीति 8443 सूरस्सतीनीति 8444 महारहनीति 8445 धम्मनीति 8446 कविदप्पणनीति 8447 नीतिमंजरी 8448 नरदक्खदीपनी 8449 चतुरारक्खदीपनी 8450 चाणक्यनीति 8451 रसवाहिनी 8452 सीमाविसोधनीपाठ 8453 वेस्संतरगीति 8454 मोग्गल्लान वुत्तिविवरणपंचिका 8455 थूपवंस 8456 दाठावंस 8457 धातुपाठविलासिनिया 8458 धातुवंस 8459 हत्थवनगल्लविहारवंस 8460 जिनचरितय 8461 जिनवंसदीपं 8462 तेलकटाहगाथा 8463 मिलिदटीका 8464 पदमंजरी 8465 पदसाधनं 8466 सद्दबिंदुपकरणं 8467 कच्चायनधातुमंजुसा 8468 सामंतकूटवण्णना |
| 2101 सीलक्खंधवग्ग पाळी 2102 महावग्ग पाळी (दीघ) 2103 पाथिकवग्ग पाळी | 2201 सीलक्खंधवग्ग अट्ठकथा 2202 महावग्ग अट्ठकथा (दीघ) 2203 पाथिकवग्ग अट्ठकथा | 2301 सीलक्खंधवग्ग टीका 2302 महावग्ग टीका (दीघ) 2303 पाथिकवग्ग टीका 2304 सीलक्खंधवग्ग-अभिनवटीका-१ 2305 सीलक्खंधवग्ग-अभिनवटीका-२ | |
| 3101 मूलपण्णास पाळी 3102 मज्झिमपण्णास पाळी 3103 उपरिपण्णास पाळी | 3201 मूलपण्णास अट्ठकथा-१ 3202 मूलपण्णास अट्ठकथा-२ 3203 मज्झिमपण्णास अट्ठकथा 3204 उपरिपण्णास अट्ठकथा | 3301 मूलपण्णास टीका 3302 मज्झिमपण्णास टीका 3303 उपरिपण्णास टीका | |
| 4101 सगाथावग्ग पाळी 4102 निदानवग्ग पाळी 4103 खंधवग्ग पाळी 4104 सळायतनवग्ग पाळी 4105 महावग्ग पाळी (संयुत्त) | 4201 सगाथावग्ग अट्ठकथा 4202 निदानवग्ग अट्ठकथा 4203 खंधवग्ग अट्ठकथा 4204 सळायतनवग्ग अट्ठकथा 4205 महावग्ग अट्ठकथा (संयुत्त) | 4301 सगाथावग्ग टीका 4302 निदानवग्ग टीका 4303 खंधवग्ग टीका 4304 सळायतनवग्ग टीका 4305 महावग्ग टीका (संयुत्त) | |
| 5101 एककनिपात पाळी 5102 दुकनिपात पाळी 5103 तिकनिपात पाळी 5104 चतुक्कनिपात पाळी 5105 पंचकनिपात पाळी 5106 छक्कनिपात पाळी 5107 सत्तकनिपात पाळी 5108 अट्ठकादिनिपात पाळी 5109 नवकनिपात पाळी 5110 दसकनिपात पाळी 5111 एकादसकनिपात पाळी | 5201 एककनिपात अट्ठकथा 5202 दुक-तिक-चतुक्कनिपात अट्ठकथा 5203 पंचक-छक्क-सत्तकनिपात अट्ठकथा 5204 अट्ठकादिनिपात अट्ठकथा | 5301 एककनिपात टीका 5302 दुक-तिक-चतुक्कनिपात टीका 5303 पंचक-छक्क-सत्तकनिपात टीका 5304 अट्ठकादिनिपात टीका | |
| 6101 खुद्दकपाठ पाळी 6102 धम्मपद पाळी 6103 उदान पाळी 6104 इतिवुत्तक पाळी 6105 सुत्तनिपात पाळी 6106 विमानवत्थु पाळी 6107 पेतवत्थु पाळी 6108 थेरगाथा पाळी 6109 थेरीगाथा पाळी 6110 अपदान पाळी-१ 6111 अपदान पाळी-२ 6112 बुद्धवंस पाळी 6113 चरियापिटक पाळी 6114 जातक पाळी-१ 6115 जातक पाळी-२ 6116 महानिद्देस पाळी 6117 चूळनिद्देस पाळी 6118 पटिसंभिदामग्ग पाळी 6119 नेत्तिप्पकरण पाळी 6120 मिलिंदपंह पाळी 6121 पेटकोपदेस पाळी | 6201 खुद्दकपाठ अट्ठकथा 6202 धम्मपद अट्ठकथा-१ 6203 धम्मपद अट्ठकथा-२ 6204 उदान अट्ठकथा 6205 इतिवुत्तक अट्ठकथा 6206 सुत्तनिपात अट्ठकथा-१ 6207 सुत्तनिपात अट्ठकथा-२ 6208 विमानवत्थु अट्ठकथा 6209 पेतवत्थु अट्ठकथा 6210 थेरगाथा अट्ठकथा-१ 6211 थेरगाथा अट्ठकथा-२ 6212 थेरीगाथा अट्ठकथा 6213 अपदान अट्ठकथा-१ 6214 अपदान अट्ठकथा-२ 6215 बुद्धवंस अट्ठकथा 6216 चरियापिटक अट्ठकथा 6217 जातक अट्ठकथा-१ 6218 जातक अट्ठकथा-२ 6219 जातक अट्ठकथा-३ 6220 जातक अट्ठकथा-४ 6221 जातक अट्ठकथा-५ 6222 जातक अट्ठकथा-६ 6223 जातक अट्ठकथा-७ 6224 महानिद्देस अट्ठकथा 6225 चूळनिद्देस अट्ठकथा 6226 पटिसंभिदामग्ग अट्ठकथा-१ 6227 पटिसंभिदामग्ग अट्ठकथा-२ 6228 नेत्तिप्पकरण अट्ठकथा | 6301 नेत्तिप्पकरण टीका 6302 नेत्तिविभाविनी | |
| 7101 धम्मसंगणी पाळी 7102 विभंग पाळी 7103 धातुकथा पाळी 7104 पुग्गलपंयत्ति पाळी 7105 कथावत्थु पाळी 7106 यमक पाळी-१ 7107 यमक पाळी-२ 7108 यमक पाळी-३ 7109 पट्ठान पाळी-१ 7110 पट्ठान पाळी-२ 7111 पट्ठान पाळी-३ 7112 पट्ठान पाळी-४ 7113 पट्ठान पाळी-५ | 7201 धम्मसंगणि अट्ठकथा 7202 सम्मोहविनोदनी अट्ठकथा 7203 पंचपकरण अट्ठकथा | 7301 धम्मसंगणी-मूलटीका 7302 विभंग-मूलटीका 7303 पंचपकरण-मूलटीका 7304 धम्मसंगणी-अनुटीका 7305 पंचपकरण-अनुटीका 7306 अभिधम्मावतारो-नामरूपपरिच्छेदो 7307 अभिधम्मत्थसंगहो 7308 अभिधम्मावतार-पुराणटीका 7309 अभिधम्ममातिकापाळी | |
| မြန်မာ | |||
| ပါဠိတော် | အဋ္ဌကထာ | ဋီကာ | အခြား |
| 1101 ပါရာဇိက ပါဠိ 1102 ပါစိတ္တိယ ပါဠိ 1103 မဟာဝဂ္ဂ ပါဠိ (ဝိနယ) 1104 စူဠဝဂ္ဂ ပါဠိ 1105 ပရိဝါရ ပါဠိ | 1201 ပါရာဇိကကဏ္ဍ အဋ္ဌကထာ-၁ 1202 ပါရာဇိကကဏ္ဍ အဋ္ဌကထာ-၂ 1203 ပါစိတ္တိယ အဋ္ဌကထာ 1204 မဟာဝဂ္ဂ အဋ္ဌကထာ (ဝိနယ) 1205 စူဠဝဂ္ဂ အဋ္ဌကထာ 1206 ပရိဝါရ အဋ္ဌကထာ | 1301 သာရတ္ထဒီပနီ ဋီကာ-၁ 1302 သာရတ္ထဒီပနီ ဋီကာ-၂ 1303 သာရတ္ထဒီပနီ ဋီကာ-၃ | 1401 ဒွေမာတိကာပါဠိ 1402 ဝိနယသင်္ဂဟ အဋ္ဌကထာ 1403 ဝဇိရဗုဒ္ဓိ ဋီကာ 1404 ဝိမတိဝိနောဒနီ ဋီကာ-၁ 1405 ဝိမတိဝိနောဒနီ ဋီကာ-၂ 1406 ဝိနယာလင်္ကာရ ဋီကာ-၁ 1407 ဝိနယာလင်္ကာရ ဋီကာ-၂ 1408 ကင်္ခာဝိတရဏီပုရာဏ ဋီကာ 1409 ဝိနယဝိနိစ္ဆယ-ဥတ္တရဝိနိစ္ဆယ 1410 ဝိနယဝိနိစ္ဆယ ဋီကာ-၁ 1411 ဝိနယဝိနိစ္ဆယ ဋီကာ-၂ 1412 ပါစိတျာဒိယောဇနာပါဠိ 1413 ခုဒ္ဒသိက္ခာ-မူလသိက္ခာ 8401 ဝိသုဒ္ဓိမဂ္ဂ-၁ 8402 ဝိသုဒ္ဓိမဂ္ဂ-၂ 8403 ဝိသုဒ္ဓိမဂ္ဂ-မဟာဋီကာ-၁ 8404 ဝိသုဒ္ဓိမဂ္ဂ-မဟာဋီကာ-၂ 8405 ဝိသုဒ္ဓိမဂ္ဂ နိဒါနကထာ 8406 ဒီဃနိကာယ (ပု-ဝိ) 8407 မဇ္ဈိမနိကာယ (ပု-ဝိ) 8408 သံယုတ္တနိကာယ (ပု-ဝိ) 8409 အင်္ဂုတ္တရနိကာယ (ပု-ဝိ) 8410 ဝိနယပိဋက (ပု-ဝိ) 8411 အဘိဓမ္မပိဋက (ပု-ဝိ) 8412 အဋ္ဌကထာ (ပု-ဝိ) 8413 နိရုတ္တိဒီပနီ 8414 ပရမတ္ထဒီပနီ သင်္ဂဟမဟာဋီကာပါဌ 8415 အနုဒီပနီပါဌ 8416 ပဋ္ဌာနုဒ္ဒေသ ဒီပနီပါဌ 8417 နမက္ကာရဋီကာ 8418 မဟာပဏာမပါဌ 8419 လက္ခဏာတော ဗုဒ္ဓထောမနာဂါထာ 8420 သုတဝန္ဒနာ 8421 ကမလာဉ္ဇလိ 8422 ဇိနာလင်္ကာရ 8423 ပဇ္ဇမဓု 8424 ဗုဒ္ဓဂုဏဂါထာဝလီ 8425 စူဠဂန္ထဝံသ 8427 သာသနဝံသ 8426 မဟာဝံသ 8429 မောဂ္ဂလ္လာနဗျာကရဏံ 8428 ကစ္စာယနဗျာကရဏံ 8430 သဒ္ဒနီတိပ္ပကရဏံ (ပဒမာလာ) 8431 သဒ္ဒနီတိပ္ပကရဏံ (ဓါတုမာလာ) 8432 ပဒရူပသိဒ္ဓိ 8433 မောဂလ္လာနပဉ္စိကာ 8434 ပယောဂသိဒ္ဓိပါဌ 8435 ဝုတ္တောဒယပါဌ 8436 အဘိဓါနပ္ပဒီပိကာပါဌ 8437 အဘိဓါနပ္ပဒီပိကာဋီကာ 8438 သုဗောဓါလင်္ကာရပါဌ 8439 သုဗောဓါလင်္ကာရဋီကာ 8440 ဗာလာဝတာရ ဂဏ္ဌိပဒတ္ထဝိနိစ္ဆယသာရ 8446 ကဝိဒပ္ပဏနီတိ 8447 နီတိမဉ္ဇရီ 8445 ဓမ္မနီတိ 8444 မဟာရဟနီတိ 8441 လောကနီတိ 8442 သုတ္တန္တနီတိ 8443 သူရဿတိနီတိ 8450 စာဏကျနီတိ 8448 နရဒက္ခဒီပနီ 8449 စတုရာရက္ခဒီပနီ 8451 ရသဝါဟိနီ 8452 သီမဝိသောဓနီပါဌ 8453 ဝေဿန္တရဂီတိ 8454 မောဂ္ဂလ္လာန ဝုတ္တိဝိဝရဏပဉ္စိကာ 8455 ထူပဝံသ 8456 ဒါဌာဝံသ 8457 ဓါတုပါဌဝိလာသိနိယာ 8458 ဓါတုဝံသ 8459 ဟတ္ထဝနဂလ္လဝိဟာရဝံသ 8460 ဇိနစရိတယ 8461 ဇိနဝံသဒီပံ 8462 တေလကဋာဟဂါထာ 8463 မိလိဒဋီကာ 8464 ပဒမဉ္ဇရီ 8465 ပဒသာဓနံ 8466 သဒ္ဒဗိန္ဒုပကရဏံ 8467 ကစ္စာယနဓါတုမဉ္ဇုသာ 8468 သာမန္တကူဋဝဏ္ဏနာ |
| 2101 သီလက္ခန္ဓဝဂ္ဂ ပါဠိ 2102 မဟာဝဂ္ဂ ပါဠိ (ဒီဃ) 2103 ပါထိကဝဂ္ဂ ပါဠိ | 2201 သီလက္ခန္ဓဝဂ္ဂ အဋ္ဌကထာ 2202 မဟာဝဂ္ဂ အဋ္ဌကထာ (ဒီဃ) 2203 ပါထိကဝဂ္ဂ အဋ္ဌကထာ | 2301 သီလက္ခန္ဓဝဂ္ဂ ဋီကာ 2302 မဟာဝဂ္ဂ ဋီကာ (ဒီဃ) 2303 ပါထိကဝဂ္ဂ ဋီကာ 2304 သီလက္ခန္ဓဝဂ္ဂ-အဘိနဝဋီကာ-၁ 2305 သီလက္ခန္ဓဝဂ္ဂ-အဘိနဝဋီကာ-၂ | |
| 3101 မူလပဏ္ဏာသ ပါဠိ 3102 မဇ္ဈိမပဏ္ဏာသ ပါဠိ 3103 ဥပရိပဏ္ဏာသ ပါဠိ | 3201 မူလပဏ္ဏာသ အဋ္ဌကထာ-၁ 3202 မူလပဏ္ဏာသ အဋ္ဌကထာ-၂ 3203 မဇ္ဈိမပဏ္ဏာသ အဋ္ဌကထာ 3204 ဥပရိပဏ္ဏာသ အဋ္ဌကထာ | 3301 မူလပဏ္ဏာသ ဋီကာ 3302 မဇ္ဈိမပဏ္ဏာသ ဋီကာ 3303 ဥပရိပဏ္ဏာသ ဋီကာ | |
| 4101 သဂါထာဝဂ္ဂ ပါဠိ 4102 နိဒါနဝဂ္ဂ ပါဠိ 4103 ခန္ဓဝဂ္ဂ ပါဠိ 4104 သဠာယတနဝဂ္ဂ ပါဠိ 4105 မဟာဝဂ္ဂ ပါဠိ (သံယုတ္တ) | 4201 သဂါထာဝဂ္ဂ အဋ္ဌကထာ 4202 နိဒါနဝဂ္ဂ အဋ္ဌကထာ 4203 ခန္ဓဝဂ္ဂ အဋ္ဌကထာ 4204 သဠာယတနဝဂ္ဂ အဋ္ဌကထာ 4205 မဟာဝဂ္ဂ အဋ္ဌကထာ (သံယုတ္တ) | 4301 သဂါထာဝဂ္ဂ ဋီကာ 4302 နိဒါနဝဂ္ဂ ဋီကာ 4303 ခန္ဓဝဂ္ဂ ဋီကာ 4304 သဠာယတနဝဂ္ဂ ဋီကာ 4305 မဟာဝဂ္ဂ ဋီကာ (သံယုတ္တ) | |
| 5101 ဧကကနိပါတ ပါဠိ 5102 ဒုကနိပါတ ပါဠိ 5103 တိကနိပါတ ပါဠိ 5104 စတုက္ကနိပါတ ပါဠိ 5105 ပဉ္စကနိပါတ ပါဠိ 5106 ဆက္ကနိပါတ ပါဠိ 5107 သတ္တကနိပါတ ပါဠိ 5108 အဋ္ဌကာဒိနိပါတ ပါဠိ 5109 နဝကနိပါတ ပါဠိ 5110 ဒသကနိပါတ ပါဠိ 5111 ဧကာဒသကနိပါတ ပါဠိ | 5201 ဧကကနိပါတ အဋ္ဌကထာ 5202 ဒုက-တိက-စတုက္ကနိပါတ အဋ္ဌကထာ 5203 ပဉ္စက-ဆက္က-သတ္တကနိပါတ အဋ္ဌကထာ 5204 အဋ္ဌကာဒိနိပါတ အဋ္ဌကထာ | 5301 ဧကကနိပါတ ဋီကာ 5302 ဒုက-တိက-စတုက္ကနိပါတ ဋီကာ 5303 ပဉ္စက-ဆက္က-သတ္တကနိပါတ ဋီကာ 5304 အဋ္ဌကာဒိနိပါတ ဋီကာ | |
| 6101 ခုဒ္ဒကပါဌ ပါဠိ 6102 ဓမ္မပဒ ပါဠိ 6103 ဥဒါန ပါဠိ 6104 ဣတိဝုတ္တက ပါဠိ 6105 သုတ္တနိပါတ ပါဠိ 6106 ဝိမာနဝတ္ထု ပါဠိ 6107 ပေတဝတ္ထု ပါဠိ 6108 ထေရဂါထာ ပါဠိ 6109 ထေရီဂါထာ ပါဠိ 6110 အပဒါန ပါဠိ-၁ 6111 အပဒါန ပါဠိ-၂ 6112 ဗုဒ္ဓဝံသ ပါဠိ 6113 စရိယာပိဋက ပါဠိ 6114 ဇာတက ပါဠိ-၁ 6115 ဇာတက ပါဠိ-၂ 6116 မဟာနိဒ္ဒေသ ပါဠိ 6117 စူဠနိဒ္ဒေသ ပါဠိ 6118 ပဋိသမ္ဘိဒါမဂ္ဂ ပါဠိ 6119 နေတ္တိပ္ပကရဏ ပါဠိ 6120 မိလိန္ဒပဉှ ပါဠိ 6121 ပေဋကောပဒေသ ပါဠိ | 6201 ခုဒ္ဒကပါဌ အဋ္ဌကထာ 6202 ဓမ္မပဒ အဋ္ဌကထာ-၁ 6203 ဓမ္မပဒ အဋ္ဌကထာ-၂ 6204 ဥဒါန အဋ္ဌကထာ 6205 ဣတိဝုတ္တက အဋ္ဌကထာ 6206 သုတ္တနိပါတ အဋ္ဌကထာ-၁ 6207 သုတ္တနိပါတ အဋ္ဌကထာ-၂ 6208 ဝိမာနဝတ္ထု အဋ္ဌကထာ 6209 ပေတဝတ္ထု အဋ္ဌကထာ 6210 ထေရဂါထာ အဋ္ဌကထာ-၁ 6211 ထေရဂါထာ အဋ္ဌကထာ-၂ 6212 ထေရီဂါထာ အဋ္ဌကထာ 6213 အပဒါန အဋ္ဌကထာ-၁ 6214 အပဒါန အဋ္ဌကထာ-၂ 6215 ဗုဒ္ဓဝံသ အဋ္ဌကထာ 6216 စရိယာပိဋက အဋ္ဌကထာ 6217 ဇာတက အဋ္ဌကထာ-၁ 6218 ဇာတက အဋ္ဌကထာ-၂ 6219 ဇာတက အဋ္ဌကထာ-၃ 6220 ဇာတက အဋ္ဌကထာ-၄ 6221 ဇာတက အဋ္ဌကထာ-၅ 6222 ဇာတက အဋ္ဌကထာ-၆ 6223 ဇာတက အဋ္ဌကထာ-၇ 6224 မဟာနိဒ္ဒေသ အဋ္ဌကထာ 6225 စူဠနိဒ္ဒေသ အဋ္ဌကထာ 6226 ပဋိသမ္ဘိဒါမဂ္ဂ အဋ္ဌကထာ-၁ 6227 ပဋိသမ္ဘိဒါမဂ္ဂ အဋ္ဌကထာ-၂ 6228 နေတ္တိပ္ပကရဏ အဋ္ဌကထာ | 6301 နေတ္တိပ္ပကရဏ ဋီကာ 6302 နေတ္တိဝိဘာဝိနီ | |
| 7101 ဓမ္မသင်္ဂဏီ ပါဠိ 7102 ဝိဘင်္ဂ ပါဠိ 7103 ဓါတုကထာ ပါဠိ 7104 ပုဂ္ဂလပညတ္တိ ပါဠိ 7105 ကထာဝတ္ထု ပါဠိ 7106 ယမက ပါဠိ-၁ 7107 ယမက ပါဠိ-၂ 7108 ယမက ပါဠိ-၃ 7109 ပဋ္ဌာန ပါဠိ-၁ 7110 ပဋ္ဌာန ပါဠိ-၂ 7111 ပဋ္ဌာန ပါဠိ-၃ 7112 ပဋ္ဌာန ပါဠိ-၄ 7113 ပဋ္ဌာန ပါဠိ-၅ | 7201 ဓမ္မသင်္ဂဏိ အဋ္ဌကထာ 7202 သမ္မောဟဝိနောဒနီ အဋ္ဌကထာ 7203 ပဉ္စပကရဏ အဋ္ဌကထာ | 7301 ဓမ္မသင်္ဂဏီ-မူလဋီကာ 7302 ဝိဘင်္ဂ-မူလဋီကာ 7303 ပဉ္စပကရဏ-မူလဋီကာ 7304 ဓမ္မသင်္ဂဏီ-အနုဋီကာ 7305 ပဉ္စပကရဏ-အနုဋီကာ 7306 အဘိဓမ္မာဝတာရော-နာမရူပပရိစ္ဆေဒေါ 7307 အဘိဓမ္မတ္ထသင်္ဂဟော 7308 အဘိဓမ္မာဝတာရ-ပုရာဏဋီကာ 7309 အဘိဓမ္မမာတိကာပါဠိ | |
| português | |||
| Páli | Aṭṭhakathā | Ṭīkā | Outro |
| 1101 Ofensas Graves (Pārājika) 1102 Ofensas Leves (Pācittiya) 1103 Grande Seção do Vīnaya (Mahāvagga) 1104 Pequena Seção do Vīnaya (Cūḷavagga) 1105 Apêndice do Vīnaya (Parivāra) | 1201 Comentário das Ofensas Graves - Vol. 1 1202 Comentário das Ofensas Graves - Vol. 2 1203 Comentário das Ofensas Leves 1204 Comentário da Grande Seção do Vīnaya 1205 Comentário da Pequena Seção do Vīnaya 1206 Comentário do Apêndice do Vīnaya | 1301 Subcomentário que Elucida o Sentido Essencial - Vol. 1 1302 Subcomentário que Elucida o Sentido Essencial - Vol. 2 1303 Subcomentário que Elucida o Sentido Essencial - Vol. 3 | 1401 Texto das Duas Matrizes 1402 Comentário do Compêndio do Vīnaya 1403 Subcomentário de Vajirabuddhi 1404 Subcomentário que Dissipa Dúvidas - Vol. 1 1405 Subcomentário que Dissipa Dúvidas - Vol. 2 1406 Subcomentário do Ornamento do Vīnaya - Vol. 1 1407 Subcomentário do Ornamento do Vīnaya - Vol. 2 1408 Antigo Subcomentário que Supera Dúvidas 1409 Decisão sobre o Vīnaya e Decisão Superior 1410 Subcomentário da Decisão sobre o Vīnaya - Vol. 1 1411 Subcomentário da Decisão sobre o Vīnaya - Vol. 2 1412 Texto da Aplicação das Regras 1413 Pequeno Treinamento e Treinamento Fundamental 8401 Caminho da Purificação - Vol. 1 8402 Caminho da Purificação - Vol. 2 8403 Grande Subcomentário do Caminho da Purificação - Vol. 1 8404 Grande Subcomentário do Caminho da Purificação - Vol. 2 8405 História da Origem do Caminho da Purificação 8406 Coleção dos Longos Discursos (índice Pāli-Vietnamita) 8407 Coleção dos Discursos Médios (índice Pāli-Vietnamita) 8408 Coleção dos Discursos Agrupados (índice Pāli-Vietnamita) 8409 Coleção dos Discursos Numerados (índice Pāli-Vietnamita) 8410 Cesto da Disciplina (índice Pāli-Vietnamita) 8411 Cesto do Abhidhamma (índice Pāli-Vietnamita) 8412 Comentários (índice Pāli-Vietnamita) 8413 Elucidação da Etimologia 8414 Grande Subcomentário do Compêndio que Elucida o Sentido Supremo 8415 Texto do Subcomentário Elucidativo 8416 Texto Elucidativo sobre a Exposição das Condições 8417 Subcomentário da Saudação 8418 Grande Texto de Saudação 8419 Versos de Louvor a Buda pelos Sinais 8420 Saudação com Recitação 8421 Oferenda de Lótus 8422 Ornamento dos Vencedores 8423 Mel dos Versos 8424 Coleção de Versos sobre as Qualidades de Buda 8425 Pequena Crônica dos Livros 8427 Crônica do Ensinamento 8426 Grande Crônica 8429 Gramática de Moggallāna 8428 Gramática de Kaccāyana 8430 Tratado sobre a Gramática - Série de Palavras 8431 Tratado sobre a Gramática - Série de Raízes 8432 Realização das Formas das Palavras 8433 Comentário de Moggallāna 8434 Texto sobre a Realização da Aplicação 8435 Texto sobre a Origem dos Versos 8436 Texto do Dicionário Iluminado 8437 Subcomentário do Dicionário Iluminado 8438 Texto sobre o Ornamento da Boa Compreensão 8439 Subcomentário do Ornamento da Boa Compreensão 8440 Essência da Decisão sobre os Termos do Glossário de Bālāvatāra 8446 Ética do Poeta 8447 Coleção de Ética 8445 Ética do Dhamma 8444 Grande Ética Secreta 8441 Ética do Mundo 8442 Ética dos Suttas 8443 Ética do Herói 8450 Ética de Cāṇakya 8448 Elucidação sobre os Perigos para os Homens 8449 Elucidação sobre as Quatro Proteções 8451 O Fluxo do Sabor - Histórias Edificantes 8452 Texto sobre a Purificação dos Limites 8453 Canto de Vessantara 8454 Explicação do Comentário de Moggallāna 8455 Crônica das Estupas 8456 Crônica da Relíquia do Dente 8457 O Esplendor da Leitura dos Elementos 8458 Crônica das Relíquias 8459 Crônica do Mosteiro de Hatthavanagalla 8460 História do Vencedor 8461 Ilha da Linhagem dos Vencedores 8462 Versos da Panela de Óleo 8463 Subcomentário de Milinda 8464 Cacho de Flores de Palavras 8465 Realização das Palavras 8466 Tratado sobre os Pontos da Gramática 8467 Coleção de Raízes de Kaccāyana 8468 Descrição do Pico de Sāmantakūṭa |
| 2101 Seção da Moralidade - Dīgha 2102 Grande Seção - Dīgha 2103 Seção de Pāthika - Dīgha | 2201 Comentário da Seção da Moralidade - Dīgha 2202 Comentário da Grande Seção - Dīgha 2203 Comentário da Seção de Pāthika - Dīgha | 2301 Subcomentário da Seção da Moralidade - Dīgha 2302 Subcomentário da Grande Seção - Dīgha 2303 Subcomentário da Seção de Pāthika - Dīgha 2304 Novo Subcomentário da Seção da Moralidade - Vol. 1 2305 Novo Subcomentário da Seção da Moralidade - Vol. 2 | |
| 3101 Cinquenta Discursos Fundamentais - Majjhima 3102 Cinquenta Discursos Médios - Majjhima 3103 Cinquenta Discursos Superiores - Majjhima | 3201 Comentário dos Cinquenta Fundamentais - Vol. 1 3202 Comentário dos Cinquenta Fundamentais - Vol. 2 3203 Comentário dos Cinquenta Médios 3204 Comentário dos Cinquenta Superiores | 3301 Subcomentário dos Cinquenta Fundamentais 3302 Subcomentário dos Cinquenta Médios 3303 Subcomentário dos Cinquenta Superiores | |
| 4101 Seção com Versos - Saṃyutta 4102 Seção das Causas - Saṃyutta 4103 Seção dos Agregados - Saṃyutta 4104 Seção das Seis Bases dos Sentidos - Saṃyutta 4105 Grande Seção - Saṃyutta | 4201 Comentário da Seção com Versos - Saṃyutta 4202 Comentário da Seção das Causas - Saṃyutta 4203 Comentário da Seção dos Agregados - Saṃyutta 4204 Comentário da Seção das Seis Bases - Saṃyutta 4205 Comentário da Grande Seção - Saṃyutta | 4301 Subcomentário da Seção com Versos - Saṃyutta 4302 Subcomentário da Seção das Causas - Saṃyutta 4303 Subcomentário da Seção dos Agregados - Saṃyutta 4304 Subcomentário da Seção das Seis Bases - Saṃyutta 4305 Subcomentário da Grande Seção - Saṃyutta | |
| 5101 Grupos de Um - Aṅguttara 5102 Grupos de Dois - Aṅguttara 5103 Grupos de Três - Aṅguttara 5104 Grupos de Quatro - Aṅguttara 5105 Grupos de Cinco - Aṅguttara 5106 Grupos de Seis - Aṅguttara 5107 Grupos de Sete - Aṅguttara 5108 Grupos de Oito, etc. - Aṅguttara 5109 Grupos de Nove - Aṅguttara 5110 Grupos de Dez - Aṅguttara 5111 Grupos de Onze - Aṅguttara | 5201 Comentário dos Grupos de Um - Aṅguttara 5202 Comentário dos Grupos de Dois, Três e Quatro 5203 Comentário dos Grupos de Cinco, Seis e Sete 5204 Comentário dos Grupos de Oito, etc. | 5301 Subcomentário dos Grupos de Um - Aṅguttara 5302 Subcomentário dos Grupos de Dois, Três e Quatro 5303 Subcomentário dos Grupos de Cinco, Seis e Sete 5304 Subcomentário dos Grupos de Oito, etc. | |
| 6101 Pequena Leitura (Khuddakapāṭha) 6102 Versos do Dhamma (Dhammapada) 6103 Exclamações Inspiradas (Udāna) 6104 Assim Foi Dito (Itivuttaka) 6105 Coleção de Discursos (Suttanipāta) 6106 Histórias das Mansões Celestiais 6107 Histórias dos Fantasmas 6108 Versos dos Monges Anciãos 6109 Versos das Monjas Anciãs 6110 Histórias Passadas - Vol. 1 6111 Histórias Passadas - Vol. 2 6112 História dos Budas (Buddhavaṃsa) 6113 Cesto das Condutas (Cariyāpiṭaka) 6114 Histórias de Nascimentos - Vol. 1 6115 Histórias de Nascimentos - Vol. 2 6116 Grande Exposição (Mahāniddesa) 6117 Pequena Exposição (Cūḷaniddesa) 6118 Caminho da Discriminação Analítica 6119 O Guia (Nettippakaraṇa) 6120 As Perguntas de Milinda 6121 Instrução do Cesto (Peṭakopadesa) | 6201 Comentário da Pequena Leitura 6202 Comentário do Dhammapada - Vol. 1 6203 Comentário do Dhammapada - Vol. 2 6204 Comentário do Udāna 6205 Comentário do Itivuttaka 6206 Comentário do Suttanipāta - Vol. 1 6207 Comentário do Suttanipāta - Vol. 2 6208 Comentário das Histórias das Mansões 6209 Comentário das Histórias dos Fantasmas 6210 Comentário dos Versos dos Monges - Vol. 1 6211 Comentário dos Versos dos Monges - Vol. 2 6212 Comentário dos Versos das Monjas 6213 Comentário das Histórias Passadas - Vol. 1 6214 Comentário das Histórias Passadas - Vol. 2 6215 Comentário da História dos Budas 6216 Comentário do Cesto das Condutas 6217 Comentário das Histórias de Nascimentos - Vol. 1 6218 Comentário das Histórias de Nascimentos - Vol. 2 6219 Comentário das Histórias de Nascimentos - Vol. 3 6220 Comentário das Histórias de Nascimentos - Vol. 4 6221 Comentário das Histórias de Nascimentos - Vol. 5 6222 Comentário das Histórias de Nascimentos - Vol. 6 6223 Comentário das Histórias de Nascimentos - Vol. 7 6224 Comentário da Grande Exposição 6225 Comentário da Pequena Exposição 6226 Comentário do Caminho da Discriminação - Vol. 1 6227 Comentário do Caminho da Discriminação - Vol. 2 6228 Comentário do Guia | 6301 Subcomentário do Guia 6302 Elucidação do Guia | |
| 7101 Enumeração dos Fenômenos (Dhammasaṅgaṇī) 7102 Análise (Vibhaṅga) 7103 Discurso sobre os Elementos (Dhātukathā) 7104 Designação das Pessoas (Puggalapaññatti) 7105 Pontos da Discussão (Kathāvatthu) 7106 O Livro dos Pares - Vol. 1 7107 O Livro dos Pares - Vol. 2 7108 O Livro dos Pares - Vol. 3 7109 Condições de Originação - Vol. 1 7110 Condições de Originação - Vol. 2 7111 Condições de Originação - Vol. 3 7112 Condições de Originação - Vol. 4 7113 Condições de Originação - Vol. 5 | 7201 Comentário da Enumeração dos Fenômenos 7202 Comentário que Dissipa a Confusão 7203 Comentário dos Cinco Tratados | 7301 Subcomentário Principal da Enumeração dos Fenômenos 7302 Subcomentário Principal da Análise 7303 Subcomentário Principal dos Cinco Tratados 7304 Subcomentário Secundário da Enumeração dos Fenômenos 7305 Subcomentário Secundário dos Cinco Tratados 7306 Introdução ao Abhidhamma - Análise de Nome e Forma 7307 Compêndio do Abhidhamma 7308 Antigo Subcomentário da Introdução ao Abhidhamma 7309 Matriz do Abhidhamma | |
| русский | |||
| Палийский канон | Комментарии | Субкомментарии | Другое |
| 1101 Параджика-пали 1102 Пачиттия-пали 1103 Махавагга-пали (Виная) 1104 Чулавагга-пали 1105 Паривара-пали | 1201 Параджиканда-аттхакатха-1 1202 Параджиканда-аттхакатха-2 1203 Пачиттия-аттхакатха 1204 Махавагга-аттхакатха (Виная) 1205 Чулавагга-аттхакатха 1206 Паривара-аттхакатха | 1301 Сараттхадипани-тика-1 1302 Сараттхадипани-тика-2 1303 Сараттхадипани-тика-3 | 1401 Двематика-пали 1402 Винаясангаха-аттхакатха 1403 Ваджирабуддхи-тика 1404 Вимативинодани-тика-1 1405 Вимативинодани-тика-2 1406 Винаяланкара-тика-1 1407 Винаяланкара-тика-2 1408 Канкхавитаранипурана-тика 1409 Винаявиниччая-уттаравиниччая 1410 Винаявиниччая-тика-1 1411 Винаявиниччая-тика-2 1412 Пачиттиядийоджана-пали 1413 Кхуддасиккха-муласиккха 8401 Висуддхимагга-1 8402 Висуддхимагга-2 8403 Висуддхимагга-махатика-1 8404 Висуддхимагга-махатика-2 8405 Висуддхимагга-ниданакатха 8406 Дигханикая (пу-ви) 8407 Мадджхиманикая (пу-ви) 8408 Самъюттаникая (пу-ви) 8409 Ангуттараникая (пу-ви) 8410 Винаяпитака (пу-ви) 8411 Абхидхаммапитака (пу-ви) 8412 Аттхакатха (пу-ви) 8413 Нируттидипани 8414 Параматтхадипани Сангахамахатикапатха 8415 Анудипанипатха 8416 Паттхануддеса дипанипатха 8417 Намаккаратика 8418 Махапанамапатха 8419 Лаккханато буддхатхоманагатха 8420 Сутавандана 8421 Камаланджали 8422 Джиналанкара 8423 Паджамадху 8424 Буддхагунагатхавали 8425 Чулагантхавамса 8427 Сасанавамса 8426 Махавамса 8429 Моггалланабьякарана 8428 Каччаянабьякарана 8430 Садданитиппакарана (падамала) 8431 Садданитиппакарана (дхатумала) 8432 Падарупасиддхи 8433 Могалланапанчика 8434 Пайогасиддхипатха 8435 Вуттодаяпатха 8436 Абхидханаппадипикапатха 8437 Абхидханаппадипикатика 8438 Субодхаланкарапатха 8439 Субодхаланкаратика 8440 Балаватара гантхипадаттхавиниччаясара 8446 Кавидаппананити 8447 Нитиманджари 8445 Дхамманити 8444 Махараханити 8441 Локанити 8442 Суттантанити 8443 Сурассатинити 8450 Чанакьянити 8448 Нарадаккхадипани 8449 Чатурараккхадипани 8451 Расавахини 8452 Симависодханипатха 8453 Вессантарагити 8454 Моггаллана вуттививаранапанчика 8455 Тхупавамса 8456 Датхавамса 8457 Дхатупатхавиласиния 8458 Дхатувамса 8459 Хаттхаванагаллавихаравамса 8460 Джиначаритая 8461 Джинавамсадипа 8462 Телакатахагатха 8463 Милидатика 8464 Падаманджари 8465 Падасадхана 8466 Саддабиндупакарана 8467 Каччаянадхатуманджуса 8468 Самантакутаваннана |
| 2101 Силаккхандхавагга-пали 2102 Махавагга-пали (Дигха) 2103 Патхикавагга-пали | 2201 Силаккхандхавагга-аттхакатха 2202 Махавагга-аттхакатха (Дигха) 2203 Патхикавагга-аттхакатха | 2301 Силаккхандхавагга-тика 2302 Махавагга-тика (Дигха) 2303 Патхикавагга-тика 2304 Силаккхандхавагга-абхинаватика-1 2305 Силаккхандхавагга-абхинаватика-2 | |
| 3101 Мулапаннаса-пали 3102 Мадджхимапаннаса-пали 3103 Упарипаннаса-пали | 3201 Мулапаннаса-аттхакатха-1 3202 Мулапаннаса-аттхакатха-2 3203 Мадджхимапаннаса-аттхакатха 3204 Упарипаннаса-аттхакатха | 3301 Мулапаннаса-тика 3302 Мадджхимапаннаса-тика 3303 Упарипаннаса-тика | |
| 4101 Сагатхавагга-пали 4102 Ниданавагга-пали 4103 Кхандхавагга-пали 4104 Салаятанавагга-пали 4105 Махавагга-пали (Самъютта) | 4201 Сагатхавагга-аттхакатха 4202 Ниданавагга-аттхакатха 4203 Кхандхавагга-аттхакатха 4204 Салаятанавагга-аттхакатха 4205 Махавагга-аттхакатха (Самъютта) | 4301 Сагатхавагга-тика 4302 Ниданавагга-тика 4303 Кхандхавагга-тика 4304 Салаятанавагга-тика 4305 Махавагга-тика (Самъютта) | |
| 5101 Экаканипата-пали 5102 Дуканипата-пали 5103 Тиканипата-пали 5104 Чатукканипата-пали 5105 Панчаканипата-пали 5106 Чхакканипата-пали 5107 Саттаканипата-пали 5108 Аттхакадинипата-пали 5109 Наваканипата-пали 5110 Дасаканипата-пали 5111 Экадасаканипата-пали | 5201 Экаканипата-аттхакатха 5202 Дука-тика-чатукканипата-аттхакатха 5203 Панчака-чхакка-саттаканипата-аттхакатха 5204 Аттхакадинипата-аттхакатха | 5301 Экаканипата-тика 5302 Дука-тика-чатукканипата-тика 5303 Панчака-чхакка-саттаканипата-тика 5304 Аттхакадинипата-тика | |
| 6101 Кхуддакапатха-пали 6102 Дхаммапада-пали 6103 Удана-пали 6104 Итивуттака-пали 6105 Суттанипата-пали 6106 Виманаваттху-пали 6107 Петаваттху-пали 6108 Тхерагатха-пали 6109 Тхеригатха-пали 6110 Ападана-пали-1 6111 Ападана-пали-2 6112 Буддхавамса-пали 6113 Чарияпитака-пали 6114 Джатака-пали-1 6115 Джатака-пали-2 6116 Маханиддеса-пали 6117 Чуланиддеса-пали 6118 Патисамбхидамагга-пали 6119 Неттиппакарана-пали 6120 Милиндапаньха-пали 6121 Петакопадеса-пали | 6201 Кхуддакапатха-аттхакатха 6202 Дхаммапада-аттхакатха-1 6203 Дхаммапада-аттхакатха-2 6204 Удана-аттхакатха 6205 Итивуттака-аттхакатха 6206 Суттанипата-аттхакатха-1 6207 Суттанипата-аттхакатха-2 6208 Виманаваттху-аттхакатха 6209 Петаваттху-аттхакатха 6210 Тхерагатха-аттхакатха-1 6211 Тхерагатха-аттхакатха-2 6212 Тхеригатха-аттхакатха 6213 Ападана-аттхакатха-1 6214 Ападана-аттхакатха-2 6215 Буддхавамса-аттхакатха 6216 Чарияпитака-аттхакатха 6217 Джатака-аттхакатха-1 6218 Джатака-аттхакатха-2 6219 Джатака-аттхакатха-3 6220 Джатака-аттхакатха-4 6221 Джатака-аттхакатха-5 6222 Джатака-аттхакатха-6 6223 Джатака-аттхакатха-7 6224 Маханиддеса-аттхакатха 6225 Чуланиддеса-аттхакатха 6226 Патисамбхидамагга-аттхакатха-1 6227 Патисамбхидамагга-аттхакатха-2 6228 Неттиппакарана-аттхакатха | 6301 Неттиппакарана-тика 6302 Неттивибхавини | |
| 7101 Дхаммасангани-пали 7102 Вибханга-пали 7103 Дхатукатха-пали 7104 Пуггалапаннятти-пали 7105 Катхаваттху-пали 7106 Ямака-пали-1 7107 Ямака-пали-2 7108 Ямака-пали-3 7109 Паттхана-пали-1 7110 Паттхана-пали-2 7111 Паттхана-пали-3 7112 Паттхана-пали-4 7113 Паттхана-пали-5 | 7201 Дхаммасангани-аттхакатха 7202 Саммохивинодани-аттхакатха 7203 Панчапакарана-аттхакатха | 7301 Дхаммасангани-мулатика 7302 Вибханга-мулатика 7303 Панчапакарана-мулатика 7304 Дхаммасангани-анутика 7305 Панчапакарана-анутика 7306 Абхидхаммаватаро-намарупапариччхедо 7307 Абхидхамматтхасангахо 7308 Абхидхаммаватара-пуранатика 7309 Абхидхаммаматика-пали | |
| සිංහල | |||
| පාලි කැනනය | විවරණ | අටුවා | වෙනත් |
| 1101 පාරාජික පාළි 1102 පාචිත්තිය පාළි 1103 මහාවග්ග පාළි (විනය) 1104 චූළවග්ග පාළි 1105 පරිවාර පාළි | 1201 පාරාජිකකණ්ඩ අට්ඨකථා-1 1202 පාරාජිකකණ්ඩ අට්ඨකථා-2 1203 පාචිත්තිය අට්ඨකථා 1204 මහාවග්ග අට්ඨකථා (විනය) 1205 චූළවග්ග අට්ඨකථා 1206 පරිවාර අට්ඨකථා | 1301 සාරත්ථදීපනී ටීකා-1 1302 සාරත්ථදීපනී ටීකා-2 1303 සාරත්ථදීපනී ටීකා-3 | 1401 ද්වෙමාතිකාපාළි 1402 විනයසංගහ අට්ඨකථා 1403 වජිරබුද්ධි ටීකා 1404 විමතිවිනෝදනී ටීකා-1 1405 විමතිවිනෝදනී ටීකා-2 1406 විනයාලංකාර ටීකා-1 1407 විනයාලංකාර ටීකා-2 1408 කඞ්ඛාවිතරණීපුරාණ ටීකා 1409 විනයවිනිච්ඡය-උත්තරවිනිච්ඡය 1410 විනයවිනිච්ඡය ටීකා-1 1411 විනයවිනිච්ඡය ටීකා-2 1412 පාචිත්යාදියෝජනාපාළි 1413 ඛුද්දසික්ඛා-මූලසික්ඛා 8401 විසුද්ධිමග්ග-1 8402 විසුද්ධිමග්ග-2 8403 විසුද්ධිමග්ග-මහාටීකා-1 8404 විසුද්ධිමග්ග-මහාටීකා-2 8405 විසුද්ධිමග්ග නිදානකථා 8406 දීඝනිකාය (පු-වි) 8407 මජ්ඣිමනිකාය (පු-වි) 8408 සංයුත්තනිකාය (පු-වි) 8409 අඞ්ගුත්තරනිකාය (පු-වි) 8410 විනයපිටක (පු-වි) 8411 අභිධම්මපිටක (පු-වි) 8412 අට්ඨකථා (පු-වි) 8413 නිරුත්තිදීපනී 8414 පරමත්ථදීපනී සඞ්ගහමහාටීකාපාඨ 8415 අනුදීපනීපාඨ 8416 පට්ඨානුද්දේස දීපනීපාඨ 8417 නමක්කාරටීකා 8418 මහාපණාමපාඨ 8419 ලක්ඛණාතෝ බුද්ධථෝමනාගාථා 8420 සුතවන්දනා 8421 කමලාඤ්ජලි 8422 ජිනාලඞ්කාර 8423 පජ්ජමධු 8424 බුද්ධගුණගාථාවලී 8425 චූළගන්ථවංස 8427 සාසනවංස 8426 මහාවංස 8429 මොග්ගල්ලානබ්යාකරණං 8428 කච්චායනබ්යාකරණං 8430 සද්දනීතිප්පකරණං (පදමාලා) 8431 සද්දනීතිප්පකරණං (ධාතුමාලා) 8432 පදරූපසිද්ධි 8433 මොග්ගල්ලානපඤ්චිකා 8434 පයෝගසිද්ධිපාඨ 8435 වුත්තෝදයපාඨ 8436 අභිධානප්පදීපිකාපාඨ 8437 අභිධානප්පදීපිකාටීකා 8438 සුබෝධාලඞ්කාරපාඨ 8439 සුබෝධාලඞ්කාරටීකා 8440 බාලාවතාර ගණ්ඨිපදත්ථවිනිච්ඡයසාර 8446 කවිදප්පණනීති 8447 නීතිමඤ්ජරී 8445 ධම්මනීති 8444 මහාරහනීති 8441 ලෝකනීති 8442 සුත්තන්තනීති 8443 සූරස්සතිනීති 8450 චාණක්යනීති 8448 නරදක්ඛදීපනී 8449 චතුරාරක්ඛදීපනී 8451 රසවාහිනී 8452 සීමවිසෝධනීපාඨ 8453 වෙස්සන්තරගීති 8454 මොග්ගල්ලාන වුත්තිවිවරණපඤ්චිකා 8455 ථූපවංස 8456 දාඨාවංස 8457 ධාතුපාඨවිලාසිනියා 8458 ධාතුවංස 8459 හත්ථවනගල්ලවිහාරවංස 8460 ජිනචරිතය 8461 ජිනවංසදීපං 8462 තේලකටාහගාථා 8463 මිලිදටීකා 8464 පදමඤ්ජරී 8465 පදසාධනං 8466 සද්දබින්දුපකරණං 8467 කච්චායනධාතුමඤ්ජුසා 8468 සාමන්තකූටවණ්ණනා |
| 2101 සීලක්ඛන්ධවග්ග පාළි 2102 මහාවග්ග පාළි (දීඝ) 2103 පාථිකවග්ග පාළි | 2201 සීලක්ඛන්ධවග්ග අට්ඨකථා 2202 මහාවග්ග අට්ඨකථා (දීඝ) 2203 පාථිකවග්ග අට්ඨකථා | 2301 සීලක්ඛන්ධවග්ග ටීකා 2302 මහාවග්ග ටීකා (දීඝ) 2303 පාථිකවග්ග ටීකා 2304 සීලක්ඛන්ධවග්ග-අභිනවටීකා-1 2305 සීලක්ඛන්ධවග්ග-අභිනවටීකා-2 | |
| 3101 මූලපණ්ණාස පාළි 3102 මජ්ඣිමපණ්ණාස පාළි 3103 උපරිපණ්ණාස පාළි | 3201 මූලපණ්ණාස අට්ඨකථා-1 3202 මූලපණ්ණාස අට්ඨකථා-2 3203 මජ්ඣිමපණ්ණාස අට්ඨකථා 3204 උපරිපණ්ණාස අට්ඨකථා | 3301 මූලපණ්ණාස ටීකා 3302 මජ්ඣිමපණ්ණාස ටීකා 3303 උපරිපණ්ණාස ටීකා | |
| 4101 සගාථාවග්ග පාළි 4102 නිදානවග්ග පාළි 4103 ඛන්ධවග්ග පාළි 4104 සළායතනවග්ග පාළි 4105 මහාවග්ග පාළි (සංයුත්ත) | 4201 සගාථාවග්ග අට්ඨකථා 4202 නිදානවග්ග අට්ඨකථා 4203 ඛන්ධවග්ග අට්ඨකථා 4204 සළායතනවග්ග අට්ඨකථා 4205 මහාවග්ග අට්ඨකථා (සංයුත්ත) | 4301 සගාථාවග්ග ටීකා 4302 නිදානවග්ග ටීකා 4303 ඛන්ධවග්ග ටීකා 4304 සළායතනවග්ග ටීකා 4305 මහාවග්ග ටීකා (සංයුත්ත) | |
| 5101 එකකනිපාත පාළි 5102 දුකනිපාත පාළි 5103 තිකනිපාත පාළි 5104 චතුක්කනිපාත පාළි 5105 පඤ්චකනිපාත පාළි 5106 ඡක්කනිපාත පාළි 5107 සත්තකනිපාත පාළි 5108 අට්ඨකාදිනිපාත පාළි 5109 නවකනිපාත පාළි 5110 දසකනිපාත පාළි 5111 එකාදසකනිපාත පාළි | 5201 එකකනිපාත අට්ඨකථා 5202 දුක-තික-චතුක්කනිපාත අට්ඨකථා 5203 පඤ්චක-ඡක්ක-සත්තකනිපාත අට්ඨකථා 5204 අට්ඨකාදිනිපාත අට්ඨකථා | 5301 එකකනිපාත ටීකා 5302 දුක-තික-චතුක්කනිපාත ටීකා 5303 පඤ්චක-ඡක්ක-සත්තකනිපාත ටීකා 5304 අට්ඨකාදිනිපාත ටීකා | |
| 6101 ඛුද්දකපාඨ පාළි 6102 ධම්මපද පාළි 6103 උදාන පාළි 6104 ඉතිවුත්තක පාළි 6105 සුත්තනිපාත පාළි 6106 විමානවත්ථු පාළි 6107 පේතවත්ථු පාළි 6108 ථේරගාථා පාළි 6109 ථේරීගාථා පාළි 6110 අපදාන පාළි-1 6111 අපදාන පාළි-2 6112 බුද්ධවංස පාළි 6113 චරියාපිටක පාළි 6114 ජාතක පාළි-1 6115 ජාතක පාළි-2 6116 මහානිද්දේස පාළි 6117 චූළනිද්දේස පාළි 6118 පටිසම්භිදාමග්ග පාළි 6119 නෙත්තිප්පකරණ පාළි 6120 මිලින්දපඤ්හ පාළි 6121 පේටකෝපදේස පාළි | 6201 ඛුද්දකපාඨ අට්ඨකථා 6202 ධම්මපද අට්ඨකථා-1 6203 ධම්මපද අට්ඨකථා-2 6204 උදාන අට්ඨකථා 6205 ඉතිවුත්තක අට්ඨකථා 6206 සුත්තනිපාත අට්ඨකථා-1 6207 සුත්තනිපාත අට්ඨකථා-2 6208 විමානවත්ථු අට්ඨකථා 6209 පේතවත්ථු අට්ඨකථා 6210 ථේරගාථා අට්ඨකථා-1 6211 ථේරගාථා අට්ඨකථා-2 6212 ථේරීගාථා අට්ඨකථා 6213 අපදාන අට්ඨකථා-1 6214 අපදාන අට්ඨකථා-2 6215 බුද්ධවංස අට්ඨකථා 6216 චරියාපිටක අට්ඨකථා 6217 ජාතක අට්ඨකථා-1 6218 ජාතක අට්ඨකථා-2 6219 ජාතක අට්ඨකථා-3 6220 ජාතක අට්ඨකථා-4 6221 ජාතක අට්ඨකථා-5 6222 ජාතක අට්ඨකථා-6 6223 ජාතක අට්ඨකථා-7 6224 මහානිද්දේස අට්ඨකථා 6225 චූළනිද්දේස අට්ඨකථා 6226 පටිසම්භිදාමග්ග අට්ඨකථා-1 6227 පටිසම්භිදාමග්ග අට්ඨකථා-2 6228 නෙත්තිප්පකරණ අට්ඨකථා | 6301 නෙත්තිප්පකරණ ටීකා 6302 නෙත්තිවිභාවිනී | |
| 7101 ධම්මසංගණී පාළි 7102 විභඞ්ග පාළි 7103 ධාතුකථා පාළි 7104 පුග්ගලපඤ්ඤත්ති පාළි 7105 කථාවත්ථු පාළි 7106 යමක පාළි-1 7107 යමක පාළි-2 7108 යමක පාළි-3 7109 පට්ඨාන පාළි-1 7110 පට්ඨාන පාළි-2 7111 පට්ඨාන පාළි-3 7112 පට්ඨාන පාළි-4 7113 පට්ඨාන පාළි-5 | 7201 ධම්මසංගණි අට්ඨකථා 7202 සම්මෝහවිනෝදනී අට්ඨකථා 7203 පඤ්චපකරණ අට්ඨකථා | 7301 ධම්මසංගණී-මූලටීකා 7302 විභඞ්ග-මූලටීකා 7303 පඤ්චපකරණ-මූලටීකා 7304 ධම්මසංගණී-අනුටීකා 7305 පඤ්චපකරණ-අනුටීකා 7306 අභිධම්මාවතාරෝ-නාමරූපපරිච්ඡේදෝ 7307 අභිධම්මත්ථසංගහෝ 7308 අභිධම්මාවතාර-පුරාණටීකා 7309 අභිධම්මමාතිකාපාළි | |
| Español | |||
| El Canon Pali | Los Comentarios | Los Subcomentarios | Otros |
| 1101 Pārājika Pāḷi 1102 Pācittiya Pāḷi 1103 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Vinaya) 1104 Cūḷavagga Pāḷi 1105 Parivāra Pāḷi | 1201 Pārājikakaṇḍa Aṭṭhakathā-1 1202 Pārājikakaṇḍa Aṭṭhakathā-2 1203 Pācittiya Aṭṭhakathā 1204 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Vinaya) 1205 Cūḷavagga Aṭṭhakathā 1206 Parivāra Aṭṭhakathā | 1301 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-1 1302 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-2 1303 Sāratthadīpanī Ṭīkā-3 | 1401 Dvemātikāpāḷi 1402 Vinayasaṅgaha Aṭṭhakathā 1403 Vajirabuddhi Ṭīkā 1404 Vimativinodanī Ṭīkā-1 1405 Vimativinodanī Ṭīkā-2 1406 Vinayālaṅkāra Ṭīkā-1 1407 Vinayālaṅkāra Ṭīkā-2 1408 Kaṅkhāvitaraṇīpurāṇa Ṭīkā 1409 Vinayavinicchaya-uttaravinicchaya 1410 Vinayavinicchaya Ṭīkā-1 1411 Vinayavinicchaya Ṭīkā-2 1412 Pācityādiyojanāpāḷi 1413 Khuddasikkhā-mūlasikkhā 8401 Visuddhimagga-1 8402 Visuddhimagga-2 8403 Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā-1 8404 Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā-2 8405 Visuddhimagga nidānakathā 8406 Dīghanikāya (pu-vi) 8407 Majjhimanikāya (pu-vi) 8408 Saṃyuttanikāya (pu-vi) 8409 Aṅguttaranikāya (pu-vi) 8410 Vinayapiṭaka (pu-vi) 8411 Abhidhammapiṭaka (pu-vi) 8412 Aṭṭhakathā (pu-vi) 8413 Niruttidīpanī 8414 Paramatthadīpanī Saṅgahamahāṭīkāpāṭha 8415 Anudīpanīpāṭha 8416 Paṭṭhānuddesa dīpanīpāṭha 8417 Namakkāraṭīkā 8418 Mahāpaṇāmapāṭha 8419 Lakkhaṇāto buddhathomanāgāthā 8420 Sutavandanā 8421 Kamalāñjali 8422 Jinālaṅkāra 8423 Pajjamadhu 8424 Buddhaguṇagāthāvalī 8425 Cūḷaganthavaṃsa 8427 Sāsanavaṃsa 8426 Mahāvaṃsa 8429 Moggallānabyākaraṇaṃ 8428 Kaccāyanabyākaraṇaṃ 8430 Saddanītippakaraṇaṃ (padamālā) 8431 Saddanītippakaraṇaṃ (dhātumālā) 8432 Padarūpasiddhi 8433 Mogallānapañcikā 8434 Payogasiddhipāṭha 8435 Vuttodayapāṭha 8436 Abhidhānappadīpikāpāṭha 8437 Abhidhānappadīpikāṭīkā 8438 Subodhālaṅkārapāṭha 8439 Subodhālaṅkāraṭīkā 8440 Bālāvatāra gaṇṭhipadatthavinicchayasāra 8446 Kavidappaṇanīti 8447 Nītimañjarī 8445 Dhammanīti 8444 Mahārahanīti 8441 Lokanīti 8442 Suttantanīti 8443 Sūrassatinīti 8450 Cāṇakyanīti 8448 Naradakkhadīpanī 8449 Caturārakkhadīpanī 8451 Rasavāhinī 8452 Sīmavisodhanīpāṭha 8453 Vessantaragīti 8454 Moggallāna vuttivivaraṇapañcikā 8455 Thūpavaṃsa 8456 Dāṭhāvaṃsa 8457 Dhātupāṭhavilāsiniyā 8458 Dhātuvaṃsa 8459 Hatthavanagallavihāravaṃsa 8460 Jinacaritaya 8461 Jinavaṃsadīpaṃ 8462 Telakaṭāhagāthā 8463 Milidaṭīkā 8464 Padamañjarī 8465 Padasādhanaṃ 8466 Saddabindupakaraṇaṃ 8467 Kaccāyanadhātumañjusā 8468 Sāmantakūṭavaṇṇanā |
| 2101 Sīlakkhandhavagga Pāḷi 2102 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Dīgha) 2103 Pāthikavagga Pāḷi | 2201 Sīlakkhandhavagga Aṭṭhakathā 2202 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Dīgha) 2203 Pāthikavagga Aṭṭhakathā | 2301 Sīlakkhandhavagga Ṭīkā 2302 Mahāvagga Ṭīkā (Dīgha) 2303 Pāthikavagga Ṭīkā 2304 Sīlakkhandhavagga-abhinavaṭīkā-1 2305 Sīlakkhandhavagga-abhinavaṭīkā-2 | |
| 3101 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Pāḷi 3102 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Pāḷi 3103 Uparipaṇṇāsa Pāḷi | 3201 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā-1 3202 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā-2 3203 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā 3204 Uparipaṇṇāsa Aṭṭhakathā | 3301 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā 3302 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā 3303 Uparipaṇṇāsa Ṭīkā | |
| 4101 Sagāthāvagga Pāḷi 4102 Nidānavagga Pāḷi 4103 Khandhavagga Pāḷi 4104 Saḷāyatanavagga Pāḷi 4105 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Saṃyutta) | 4201 Sagāthāvagga Aṭṭhakathā 4202 Nidānavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4203 Khandhavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4204 Saḷāyatanavagga Aṭṭhakathā 4205 Mahāvagga Aṭṭhakathā (Saṃyutta) | 4301 Sagāthāvagga Ṭīkā 4302 Nidānavagga Ṭīkā 4303 Khandhavagga Ṭīkā 4304 Saḷāyatanavagga Ṭīkā 4305 Mahāvagga Ṭīkā (Saṃyutta) | |
| 5101 Ekakanipāta Pāḷi 5102 Dukanipāta Pāḷi 5103 Tikanipāta Pāḷi 5104 Catukkanipāta Pāḷi 5105 Pañcakanipāta Pāḷi 5106 Chakkanipāta Pāḷi 5107 Sattakanipāta Pāḷi 5108 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Pāḷi 5109 Navakanipāta Pāḷi 5110 Dasakanipāta Pāḷi 5111 Ekādasakanipāta Pāḷi | 5201 Ekakanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5202 Duka-tika-catukkanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5203 Pañcaka-chakka-sattakanipāta Aṭṭhakathā 5204 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Aṭṭhakathā | 5301 Ekakanipāta Ṭīkā 5302 Duka-tika-catukkanipāta Ṭīkā 5303 Pañcaka-chakka-sattakanipāta Ṭīkā 5304 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Ṭīkā | |
| 6101 Khuddakapāṭha Pāḷi 6102 Dhammapada Pāḷi 6103 Udāna Pāḷi 6104 Itivuttaka Pāḷi 6105 Suttanipāta Pāḷi 6106 Vimānavatthu Pāḷi 6107 Petavatthu Pāḷi 6108 Theragāthā Pāḷi 6109 Therīgāthā Pāḷi 6110 Apadāna Pāḷi-1 6111 Apadāna Pāḷi-2 6112 Buddhavaṃsa Pāḷi 6113 Cariyāpiṭaka Pāḷi 6114 Jātaka Pāḷi-1 6115 Jātaka Pāḷi-2 6116 Mahāniddesa Pāḷi 6117 Cūḷaniddesa Pāḷi 6118 Paṭisambhidāmagga Pāḷi 6119 Nettippakaraṇa Pāḷi 6120 Milindapañha Pāḷi 6121 Peṭakopadesa Pāḷi | 6201 Khuddakapāṭha Aṭṭhakathā 6202 Dhammapada Aṭṭhakathā-1 6203 Dhammapada Aṭṭhakathā-2 6204 Udāna Aṭṭhakathā 6205 Itivuttaka Aṭṭhakathā 6206 Suttanipāta Aṭṭhakathā-1 6207 Suttanipāta Aṭṭhakathā-2 6208 Vimānavatthu Aṭṭhakathā 6209 Petavatthu Aṭṭhakathā 6210 Theragāthā Aṭṭhakathā-1 6211 Theragāthā Aṭṭhakathā-2 6212 Therīgāthā Aṭṭhakathā 6213 Apadāna Aṭṭhakathā-1 6214 Apadāna Aṭṭhakathā-2 6215 Buddhavaṃsa Aṭṭhakathā 6216 Cariyāpiṭaka Aṭṭhakathā 6217 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-1 6218 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-2 6219 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-3 6220 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-4 6221 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-5 6222 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-6 6223 Jātaka Aṭṭhakathā-7 6224 Mahāniddesa Aṭṭhakathā 6225 Cūḷaniddesa Aṭṭhakathā 6226 Paṭisambhidāmagga Aṭṭhakathā-1 6227 Paṭisambhidāmagga Aṭṭhakathā-2 6228 Nettippakaraṇa Aṭṭhakathā | 6301 Nettippakaraṇa Ṭīkā 6302 Nettivibhāvinī | |
| 7101 Dhammasaṅgaṇī Pāḷi 7102 Vibhaṅga Pāḷi 7103 Dhātukathā Pāḷi 7104 Puggalapaññatti Pāḷi 7105 Kathāvatthu Pāḷi 7106 Yamaka Pāḷi-1 7107 Yamaka Pāḷi-2 7108 Yamaka Pāḷi-3 7109 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-1 7110 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-2 7111 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-3 7112 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-4 7113 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi-5 | 7201 Dhammasaṅgaṇi Aṭṭhakathā 7202 Sammohavinodanī Aṭṭhakathā 7203 Pañcapakaraṇa Aṭṭhakathā | 7301 Dhammasaṅgaṇī-mūlaṭīkā 7302 Vibhaṅga-mūlaṭīkā 7303 Pañcapakaraṇa-mūlaṭīkā 7304 Dhammasaṅgaṇī-anuṭīkā 7305 Pañcapakaraṇa-anuṭīkā 7306 Abhidhammāvatāro-nāmarūpaparicchedo 7307 Abhidhammatthasaṅgaho 7308 Abhidhammāvatāra-purāṇaṭīkā 7309 Abhidhammamātikāpāḷi | |
| แบบไทย | |||
| บาลีแคน | ข้อคิดเห็น | คำอธิบายย่อย | อื่น |
| 1101 ปาราชิกปาฬิ 1102 ปาจิตติยปาฬิ 1103 มหาวคฺคปาฬิ (วินัย) 1104 จูฬวคฺคปาฬิ 1105 ปริวารปาฬิ | 1201 ปาราชิกกณฺฑอฏฺฐกถา-๑ 1202 ปาราชิกกณฺฑอฏฺฐกถา-๒ 1203 ปาจิตฺติยอฏฺฐกถา 1204 มหาวคฺคอฏฺฐกถา (วินัย) 1205 จูฬวคฺคอฏฺฐกถา 1206 ปริวารอฏฺฐกถา | 1301 สารตฺถทีปนีฏีกา-๑ 1302 สารตฺถทีปนีฏีกา-๒ 1303 สารตฺถทีปนีฏีกา-๓ | 1401 ทเวมาติกาปาฬิ 1402 วินยสํคหอฏฺฐกถา 1403 วชิรพุทฺธิฏีกา 1404 วิมติวิโนทนีฏีกา-๑ 1405 วิมติวิโนทนีฏีกา-๒ 1406 วินยาลงฺการฏีกา-๑ 1407 วินยาลงฺการฏีกา-๒ 1408 กงฺขาวิตรณีปุราณฏีกา 1409 วินยวินิจฉย-อุตฺตรวินิจฉย 1410 วินยวินิจฉยฏีกา-๑ 1411 วินยวินิจฉยฏีกา-๒ 1412 ปาจิตฺยาทิโยชนาปาฬิ 1413 ขุทฺทสิกฺขา-มูลสิกฺขา 8401 วิสุทฺธิมคฺค-๑ 8402 วิสุทฺธิมคฺค-๒ 8403 วิสุทฺธิมคฺค-มหาฏีกา-๑ 8404 วิสุทฺธิมคฺค-มหาฏีกา-๒ 8405 วิสุทฺธิมคฺค-นิทานกถา 8406 ทีฆนิกาย (ปุ-วิ) 8407 มชฺฌิมนิกาย (ปุ-วิ) 8408 สํยุตฺตนิกาย (ปุ-วิ) 8409 องฺคุตฺตรนิกาย (ปุ-วิ) 8410 วินยปิฎก (ปุ-วิ) 8411 อภิธมฺมปิฎก (ปุ-วิ) 8412 อฏฺฐกถา (ปุ-วิ) 8413 นิรุตฺติทีปนี 8414 ปรมตฺถทีปนี สงฺคหมหาฏีกาปาฐ 8415 อนุทีปนีปาฐ 8416 ปฎฺฐานุทฺเทสทีปนีปาฐ 8417 นมกฺการฏีกา 8418 มหาปณามปาฐ 8419 ลกฺขณาโต พุทฺธโถมนาคาถา 8420 สุตวทน 8421 กมลาญฺชลิ 8422 ชินาลงฺการ 8423 ปชฺชมธุ 8424 พุทฺธคุณคาถาวลี 8425 จูฬคนฺถวํส 8427 สาสนวํส 8426 มหาวํส 8429 โมคฺคลฺลานพฺยากรณํ 8428 กจฺจายนพฺยากรณํ 8430 สทฺทานีติปฺปกรณํ (ปทมาลา) 8431 สทฺทานีติปฺปกรณํ (ธาตุมาลา) 8432 ปทรูปสิทฺธิ 8433 โมคคฺลานปญฺจิกา 8434 ปโยคสิทฺธิปาฐ 8435 วุตฺโตทยปาฐ 8436 อภิธานปฺปทีปิกาปาฐ 8437 อภิธานปฺปทีปิกาฏีกา 8438 สุโพธาลงฺการปาฐ 8439 สุโพธาลงฺการฏีกา 8440 พาลาวตาร คณฺฐิปทตฺถวินิจฺฉยสาร 8446 กวิทปฺปณนีติ 8447 นีติมญฺชรี 8445 ธมฺมนีติ 8444 มหารหนีติ 8441 โลกนีติ 8442 สุตฺตนฺตนีติ 8443 สูรสฺสตินีติ 8450 จาณกฺยนีติ 8448 นรทกฺขทีปนี 8449 จตุราวรกฺขทีปนี 8451 รสวาหินี 8452 สีมวิโสธนีปาฐ 8453 เวสฺสนฺตรคีติ 8454 โมคฺคลฺลาน วุตฺติวิวรณปญฺจิกา 8455 ถูปวํส 8456 ทาฐาวํส 8457 ธาตุปาฐวิลาสินิยา 8458 ธาตุวํส 8459 หตฺถวนคัลลวิหารวํส 8460 ชนจริตย 8461 ชนวํสทีปํ 8462 เตลกฏาหคาถา 8463 มิลิทฏีกา 8464 ปทมญฺชรี 8465 ปทสาธนํ 8466 สทฺทพินฺทุปกรณํ 8467 กจฺจายนธาตุมญฺชุสา 8468 สามนฺตกูฏวณฺณนา |
| 2101 สีลกฺขนฺธวคฺคปาฬิ 2102 มหาวคฺคปาฬิ (ทีฆ) 2103 ปาถิกวคฺคปาฬิ | 2201 สีลกฺขนฺธวคฺคอฏฺฐกถา 2202 มหาวคฺคอฏฺฐกถา (ทีฆ) 2203 ปาถิกวคฺคอฏฺฐกถา | 2301 สีลกฺขนฺธวคฺคฏีกา 2302 มหาวคฺคฏีกา (ทีฆ) 2303 ปาถิกวคฺคฏีกา 2304 สีลกฺขนฺธวคฺค-อภินวฏีกา-๑ 2305 สีลกฺขนฺธวคฺค-อภินวฏีกา-๒ | |
| 3101 มูลปณฺณาสปาฬิ 3102 มชฺฌิมปณฺณาสปาฬิ 3103 อุปริปณฺณาสปาฬิ | 3201 มูลปณฺณาสอฏฺฐกถา-๑ 3202 มูลปณฺณาสอฏฺฐกถา-๒ 3203 มชฺฌิมปณฺณาสอฏฺฐกถา 3204 อุปริปณฺณาสอฏฺฐกถา | 3301 มูลปณฺณาสฏีกา 3302 มชฺฌิมปณฺณาสฏีกา 3303 อุปริปณฺณาสฏีกา | |
| 4101 สคาถาวคฺคปาฬิ 4102 นิทานวคฺคปาฬิ 4103 ขนฺธวคฺคปาฬิ 4104 สฬายตนวคฺคปาฬิ 4105 มหาวคฺคปาฬิ (สํยุตฺต) | 4201 สคาถาวคฺคอฏฺฐกถา 4202 นิทานวคฺคอฏฺฐกถา 4203 ขนฺธวคฺคอฏฺฐกถา 4204 สฬายตนวคฺคอฏฺฐกถา 4205 มหาวคฺคอฏฺฐกถา (สํยุตฺต) | 4301 สคาถาวคฺคฏีกา 4302 นิทานวคฺคฏีกา 4303 ขนฺธวคฺคฏีกา 4304 สฬายตนวคฺคฏีกา 4305 มหาวคฺคฏีกา (สํยุตฺต) | |
| 5101 เอกกนิปาตปาฬิ 5102 ทุกนิปาตปาฬิ 5103 ติกนิปาตปาฬิ 5104 จตุกฺกนิปาตปาฬิ 5105 ปญฺจกนิปาตปาฬิ 5106 ฉกฺกนิปาตปาฬิ 5107 สตฺตกนิปาตปาฬิ 5108 อฏฺฐกาทินิปาตปาฬิ 5109 นวกนิปาตปาฬิ 5110 ทสกนิปาตปาฬิ 5111 เอกาทสกนิปาตปาฬิ | 5201 เอกกนิปาตอฏฺฐกถา 5202 ทุก-ติก-จตุกฺกนิปาตอฏฺฐกถา 5203 ปญฺจก-ฉกฺก-สตฺตกนิปาตอฏฺฐกถา 5204 อฏฺฐกาทินิปาตอฏฺฐกถา | 5301 เอกกนิปาตฏีกา 5302 ทุก-ติก-จตุกฺกนิปาตฏีกา 5303 ปญฺจก-ฉกฺก-สตฺตกนิปาตฏีกา 5304 อฏฺฐกาทินิปาตฏีกา | |
| 6101 ขุทฺทกปาฐปาฬิ 6102 ธมฺมปทปาฬิ 6103 อุทานปาฬิ 6104 อิติวุตฺตกปาฬิ 6105 สุตฺตนิบาตปาฬิ 6106 วิมานวตฺถุปาฬิ 6107 เปตวตฺถุปาฬิ 6108 เถรคาถาปาฬิ 6109 เถรีคาถาปาฬิ 6110 อปทานปาฬิ-๑ 6111 อปทานปาฬิ-๒ 6112 พุทธวงฺสปาฬิ 6113 จริยาปิฏกปาฬิ 6114 ชาตกปาฬิ-๑ 6115 ชาตกปาฬิ-๒ 6116 มหานิทฺเทสปาฬิ 6117 จูฬนิทฺเทสปาฬิ 6118 ปฏิสมฺภิทามคฺคปาฬิ 6119 เนตฺติปฺปกฺรณปาฬิ 6120 มิลินฺทปญฺหาปาฬิ 6121 เปฏโกปเทสปาฬิ | 6201 ขุทฺทกปาฐอฏฺฐกถา 6202 ธมฺมปทอฏฺฐกถา-๑ 6203 ธมฺมปทอฏฺฐกถา-๒ 6204 อุทานอฏฺฐกถา 6205 อิติวุตฺตกอฏฺฐกถา 6206 สุตฺตนิบาตอฏฺฐกถา-๑ 6207 สุตฺตนิบาตอฏฺฐกถา-๒ 6208 วิมานวตฺถุอฏฺฐกถา 6209 เปตวตฺถุอฏฺฐกถา 6210 เถรคาถาอฏฺฐกถา-๑ 6211 เถรคาถาอฏฺฐกถา-๒ 6212 เถรีคาถาอฏฺฐกถา 6213 อปทานอฏฺฐกถา-๑ 6214 อปทานอฏฺฐกถา-๒ 6215 พุทธวงฺสอฏฺฐกถา 6216 จริยาปิฏกอฏฺฐกถา 6217 ชาตกอฏฺฐกถา-๑ 6218 ชาตกอฏฺฐกถา-๒ 6219 ชาตกอฏฺฐกถา-๓ 6220 ชาตกอฏฺฐกถา-๔ 6221 ชาตกอฏฺฐกถา-๕ 6222 ชาตกอฏฺฐกถา-๖ 6223 ชาตกอฏฺฐกถา-๗ 6224 มหานิทฺเทสอฏฺฐกถา 6225 จูฬนิทฺเทสอฏฺฐกถา 6226 ปฏิสมฺภิทามคฺคอฏฺฐกถา-๑ 6227 ปฏิสมฺภิทามคฺคอฏฺฐกถา-๒ 6228 เนตฺติปฺปกฺรณอฏฺฐกถา | 6301 เนตฺติปฺปกฺรณฏีกา 6302 เนตฺติวิภาวินี | |
| 7101 ธมฺมสงฺคณีปาฬิ 7102 วิภงฺคปาฬิ 7103 ธาตุกถาปาฬิ 7104 ปุคฺคลปญฺญตฺติปาฬิ 7105 กถาวตฺถุปาฬิ 7106 ยมกปาฬิ-๑ 7107 ยมกปาฬิ-๒ 7108 ยมกปาฬิ-๓ 7109 ปฎฺฐานปาฬิ-๑ 7110 ปฎฺฐานปาฬิ-๒ 7111 ปฎฺฐานปาฬิ-๓ 7112 ปฎฺฐานปาฬิ-๔ 7113 ปฎฺฐานปาฬิ-๕ | 7201 ธมฺมสงฺคณิอฏฺฐกถา 7202 สมฺโมหวินิทนีอฏฺฐกถา 7203 ปญฺจปกรณอฏฺฐกถา | 7301 ธมฺมสงฺคณีมูลฏีกา 7302 วิภงฺคมูลฏีกา 7303 ปญฺจปกรณมูลฏีกา 7304 ธมฺมสงฺคณีอนุฏีกา 7305 ปญฺจปกรณอนุฏีกา 7306 อภิธมฺมาวตาโร-นามรูปปริจฺเฉโท 7307 อภิธมฺมตฺถสงฺคโห 7308 อภิธมฺมาวตาร-ปุราณฏีกา 7309 อภิธมฺมมาติกาปาฬิ | |
| བོད་མི | |||
| པཱ་ལི་གསུང་རབ། | འགྲེལ་བཤད། | འགྲེལ་བཤད་ཕྲན། | གཞན། |
| 1101 ཕ་ར་ཇི་ཀ་པཱ་ལི། 1102 པཱ་ཙི་ཏི་ཡ་པཱ་ལི། 1103 མ་ཧཱ་ཝག་ག་པཱ་ལི། (ཝི་ན་ཡ) 1104 ཙཱུ་ལ་ཝག་ག་པཱ་ལི། 1105 པ་རི་ཝཱ་ར་པཱ་ལི། | 1201 ཕ་ར་ཇི་ཀ་ཀཎྜ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༡ 1202 ཕ་ར་ཇི་ཀ་ཀཎྜ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༢ 1203 པཱ་ཙི་ཏི་ཡ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 1204 མ་ཧཱ་ཝག་ག་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། (ཝི་ན་ཡ) 1205 ཙཱུ་ལ་ཝག་ག་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 1206 པ་རི་ཝཱ་ར་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། | 1301 སཱ་རཏྠ་དཱི་པ་ནཱི་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༡ 1302 སཱ་རཏྠ་དཱི་པ་ནཱི་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༢ 1303 སཱ་རཏྠ་དཱི་པ་ནཱི་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༣ | 1401 དྭེ་མཱ་ཏི་ཀཱ་པཱ་ལི། 1402 ཝི་ན་ཡ་སངྒ་ཧ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 1403 ཝ་ཇི་ར་བུད་དྷི་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 1404 ཝི་མ་ཏི་ཝི་ནོ་ད་ནཱི་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༡ 1405 ཝི་མ་ཏི་ཝི་ནོ་ད་ནཱི་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༢ 1406 ཝི་ན་ཡཱ་ལངྐཱ་ར་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༡ 1407 ཝི་ན་ཡཱ་ལངྐཱ་ར་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༢ 1408 ཀངྑཱ་ཝི་ཏ་ར་ཎཱི་པུ་རཱ་ཎ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 1409 ཝི་ན་ཡ་ཝི་ནི་ཙ་ཡ་ཨུ་ཏྟ་ར་ཝི་ནི་ཙ་ཡ། 1410 ཝི་ན་ཡ་ཝི་ནི་ཙ་ཡ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༡ 1411 ཝི་ན་ཡ་ཝི་ནི་ཙ་ཡ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༢ 1412 པཱ་ཙི་ཏྱཱ་དི་ཡོ་ཇ་ནཱ་པཱ་ལི། 1413 ཁུད་ད་སིཀྑཱ་མཱུ་ལ་སིཀྑཱ། 8401 ཝི་སུད་དྷི་མགྒ-༡ 8402 ཝི་སུད་དྷི་མགྒ-༢ 8403 ཝི་སུད་དྷི་མགྒ་མ་ཧཱ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༡ 8404 ཝི་སུད་དྷི་མགྒ་མ་ཧཱ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༢ 8405 ཝི་སུད་དྷི་མགྒ་ནི་དཱ་ན་ཀ་ཐཱ། 8406 དཱི་གྷ་ནི་ཀཱ་ཡ། (པུ་ཝི) 8407 མཛྷི་མ་ནི་ཀཱ་ཡ། (པུ་ཝི) 8408 སཾ་ཡུཏྟ་ནི་ཀཱ་ཡ། (པུ་ཝི) 8409 ཨངྒུ་ཏྟ་ར་ནི་ཀཱ་ཡ། (པུ་ཝི) 8410 ཝི་ན་ཡ་པི་ཊ་ཀ། (པུ་ཝི) 8411 ཨ་བྷི་དྷམྨ་པི་ཊ་ཀ། (པུ་ཝི) 8412 ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། (པུ་ཝི) 8413 ནི་རུཏྟི་དཱི་པ་ནཱི། 8414 པ་ར་མཏྠ་དཱི་པ་ནཱི་སངྒ་ཧ་མ་ཧཱ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ་པཱ་ཋ། 8415 ཨ་ནུ་དཱི་པ་ནཱི་པཱ་ཋ། 8416 པཊྛཱ་ནུདྡེ་ས་དཱི་པ་ནཱི་པཱ་ཋ། 8417 ན་མཀྐཱ་ར་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 8418 མ་ཧཱ་པ་ཎཱ་མ་པཱ་ཋ། 8419 ལཀྑ་ཎཱ་ཏོ་བུདྡྷ་ཐོ་མ་ནཱ་གཱ་ཐཱ། 8420 སུ་ཏ་ཝནྡ་ནཱ། 8421 ཀ་མ་ལཱཉྫ་ལི། 8422 ཇི་ནཱ་ལངྐཱ་ར། 8423 པཛྫ་མ་དྷུ། 8424 བུདྡྷ་གུ་ཎ་གཱ་ཐཱ་ཝ་ལཱི། 8425 ཙཱུ་ལ་གནྠ་ཝཾ་ས། 8427 སཱ་ས་ན་ཝཾ་ས། 8426 མ་ཧཱ་ཝཾ་ས། 8429 མོགྒ་ལླཱ་ན་བྱཱ་ཀ་ར་ཎཾ། 8428 ཀཙྩཱ་ཡ་ན་བྱཱ་ཀ་ར་ཎཾ། 8430 སདྡ་ནཱི་ཏི་པྤ་ཀ་ར་ཎཾ། (པ་ད་མཱ་ལཱ) 8431 སདྡ་ནཱི་ཏི་པྤ་ཀ་ར་ཎཾ། (དྷཱ་ཏུ་མཱ་ལཱ) 8432 པ་ད་རཱུ་པ་སིད་དྷི། 8433 མོ་ག་ལླཱ་ན་པཉྩ་ཀཱ། 8434 པ་ཡོ་ག་སིད་དྷི་པཱ་ཋ། 8435 བུཏྟོ་ད་ཡ་པཱ་ཋ། 8436 ཨ་བྷི་དྷཱ་ན་པྤ་དཱི་པི་ཀཱ་པཱ་ཋ། 8437 ཨ་བྷི་དྷཱ་ན་པྤ་དཱི་པི་ཀཱ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 8438 སུ་བོ་དྷཱ་ལངྐཱ་ར་པཱ་ཋ། 8439 སུ་བོ་དྷཱ་ལངྐཱ་ར་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 8440 བཱ་ལཱ་ཝ་ཏཱ་ར་གཎྛི་པ་དཏྠ་ཝི་ནི་ཙ་ཡ་སཱ་ར། 8446 ཀ་ཝི་དཔྤ་ཎ་ནཱི་ཏི། 8447 ནཱི་ཏི་མཉྫ་རཱི། 8445 དྷམྨ་ནཱི་ཏི། 8444 མ་ཧཱ་ར་ཧ་ནཱི་ཏི། 8441 ལོ་ཀ་ནཱི་ཏི། 8442 སུཏྟནྟ་ནཱ་ཏི། 8443 སཱུ་རསྶ་ཏི་ནཱི་ཏི། 8450 ཙཱ་ཎཀྱ་ནཱི་ཏི། 8448 ན་ར་དཀྑ་དཱི་པ་ནཱི། 8449 ཙ་ཏུ་རཱ་རཀྑ་དཱི་པ་ནཱི། 8451 ར་ས་ཝཱ་ཧི་ནཱི། 8452 སཱི་མ་ཝི་སོ་ད་ནཱི་པཱ་ཋ། 8453 ཝེསྶནྟ་ར་གཱི་ཏི། 8454 མོགྒ་ལླཱ་ན་བུཏྟི་ཝི་ཝ་ར་ཎ་པཉྩ་ཀཱ། 8455 ཐཱུ་པ་ཝཾ་ས། 8456 དཱ་ཊྷཱ་ཝཾ་ས། 8457 དྷཱ་ཏུ་པཱ་ཋ་ཝི་ལཱ་སི་ནི་ཡཱ། 8458 དྷཱ་ཏུ་ཝཾ་ས། 8459 ཧཏྠ་ཝ་ན་གལླ་ཝི་ཧཱ་ར་ཝཾ་ས། 8460 ཇི་ན་ཙ་རི་ཏ་ཡ། 8461 ཇི་ན་ཝཾ་ས་དཱི་པཾ། 8462 ཏེ་ལ་ཀ་ཊཱ་ཧ་གཱ་ཐཱ། 8463 མི་ལི་ད་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 8464 པ་ད་མཉྫ་རཱི། 8465 པ་ད་སཱ་ད་ནཾ། 8466 སདྡ་བིནྡུ་པ་ཀ་ར་ཎཾ། 8467 ཀཙྩཱ་ཡ་ན་དྷཱ་ཏུ་མཉྫུ་སཱ། 8468 སཱ་མནྟ་ཀཱུ་ཊ་ཝཎྞ་ནཱ། |
| 2101 སཱི་ལཀྑནྡྷ་ཝག་ག་པཱ་ལི། 2102 མ་ཧཱ་ཝག་ག་པཱ་ལི། (དཱི་གྷ) 2103 པཱ་ཐི་ཀ་ཝག་ག་པཱ་ལི། | 2201 སཱི་ལཀྑནྡྷ་ཝག་ག་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 2202 མ་ཧཱ་ཝག་ག་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། (དཱི་གྷ) 2203 པཱ་ཐི་ཀ་ཝག་ག་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། | 2301 སཱི་ལཀྑནྡྷ་ཝག་ག་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 2302 མ་ཧཱ་ཝག་ག་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། (དཱི་གྷ) 2303 པཱ་ཐི་ཀ་ཝག་ག་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 2304 སཱི་ལཀྑནྡྷ་ཝག་ག་ཨ་བྷི་ན་ཝ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༡ 2305 སཱི་ལཀྑནྡྷ་ཝག་ག་ཨ་བྷི་ན་ཝ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ-༢ | |
| 3101 མཱུ་ལ་པཎྞཱ་ས་པཱ་ལི། 3102 མཛྷི་མ་པཎྞཱ་ས་པཱ་ལི། 3103 ཨུ་པ་རི་པཎྞཱ་ས་པཱ་ལི། | 3201 མཱུ་ལ་པཎྞཱ་ས་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༡ 3202 མཱུ་ལ་པཎྞཱ་ས་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༢ 3203 མཛྷི་མ་པཎྞཱ་ས་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 3204 ཨུ་པ་རི་པཎྞཱ་ས་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། | 3301 མཱུ་ལ་པཎྞཱ་ས་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 3302 མཛྷི་མ་པཎྞཱ་ས་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 3303 ཨུ་པ་རི་པཎྞཱ་ས་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། | |
| 4101 ས་གཱ་ཐཱ་ཝག་ག་པཱ་ལི། 4102 ནི་དཱ་ན་ཝག་ག་པཱ་ལི། 4103 ཁནྡྷ་ཝག་ག་པཱ་ལི། 4104 ས་ལཱ་ཡ་ཏ་ན་ཝག་ག་པཱ་ལི། 4105 མ་ཧཱ་ཝག་ག་པཱ་ལི། (སཾ་ཡུཏྟ) | 4201 ས་གཱ་ཐཱ་ཝག་ག་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 4202 ནི་དཱ་ན་ཝག་ག་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 4203 ཁནྡྷ་ཝག་ག་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 4204 ས་ལཱ་ཡ་ཏ་ན་ཝག་ག་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 4205 མ་ཧཱ་ཝག་ག་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། (སཾ་ཡུཏྟ) | 4301 ས་གཱ་ཐཱ་ཝག་ག་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 4302 ནི་དཱ་ན་ཝག་ག་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 4303 ཁནྡྷ་ཝག་ག་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 4304 ས་ལཱ་ཡ་ཏ་ན་ཝག་ག་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 4305 མ་ཧཱ་ཝག་ག་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། (སཾ་ཡུཏྟ) | |
| 5101 ཨེ་ཀ་ཀ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་པཱ་ལི། 5102 དུ་ཀ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་པཱ་ལི། 5103 ཏི་ཀ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་པཱ་ལི། 5104 ཙ་ཏུཀྐ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་པཱ་ལི། 5105 པཉྩ་ཀ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་པཱ་ལི། 5106 ཆཀྐ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་པཱ་ལི། 5107 སཏྟ་ཀ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་པཱ་ལི། 5108 ཨཊྛ་ཀཱ་དི་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་པཱ་ལི། 5109 ན་ཝ་ཀ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་པཱ་ལི། 5110 ད་ས་ཀ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་པཱ་ལི། 5111 ཨེ་ཀཱ་ད་ས་ཀ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་པཱ་ལི། | 5201 ཨེ་ཀ་ཀ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 5202 དུ་ཀ་ཏི་ཀ་ཙ་ཏུཀྐ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 5203 པཉྩ་ཀ་ཆཀྐ་སཏྟ་ཀ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 5204 ཨཊྛ་ཀཱ་དི་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། | 5301 ཨེ་ཀ་ཀ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 5302 དུ་ཀ་ཏི་ཀ་ཙ་ཏུཀྐ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 5303 པཉྩ་ཀ་ཆཀྐ་སཏྟ་ཀ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 5304 ཨཊྛ་ཀཱ་དི་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། | |
| 6101 ཁུད་ད་ཀ་པཱ་ཋ་པཱ་ལི། 6102 དྷམྨ་པ་ད་པཱ་ལི། 6103 ཨུ་དཱ་ན་པཱ་ལི། 6104 ཨི་ཏི་ཝུཏྟ་ཀ་པཱ་ལི། 6105 སུཏྟ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་པཱ་ལི། 6106 ཝི་མཱ་ན་ཝཏྠུ་པཱ་ལི། 6107 པེ་ཏ་ཝཏྠུ་པཱ་ལི། 6108 ཐེ་ར་གཱ་ཐཱ་པཱ་ལི། 6109 ཐེ་རཱི་གཱ་ཐཱ་པཱ་ལི། 6110 ཨ་པ་དཱ་ན་པཱ་ལི-༡ 6111 ཨ་པ་དཱ་ན་པཱ་ལི-༢ 6112 བུདྡྷ་ཝཾ་ས་པཱ་ལི། 6113 ཙ་རི་ཡཱ་པི་ཊ་ཀ་པཱ་ལི། 6114 ཛཱ་ཏ་ཀ་པཱ་ལི-༡ 6115 ཛཱ་ཏ་ཀ་པཱ་ལི-༢ 6116 མ་ཧཱ་ནི་དྡེ་ས་པཱ་ལི། 6117 ཙཱུ་ལ་ནི་དྡེ་ས་པཱ་ལི། 6118 པ་ཊི་སམ་བྷི་དཱ་མགྒ་པཱ་ལི། 6119 ནེཏྟི་པྤ་ཀ་ར་ཎ་པཱ་ལི། 6120 མི་ལིནྡ་པཉྷ་པཱ་ལི། 6121 པེ་ཊ་ཀོ་པ་དེ་ས་པཱ་ལི། | 6201 ཁུད་ད་ཀ་པཱ་ཋ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 6202 དྷམྨ་པ་ད་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༡ 6203 དྷམྨ་པ་ད་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༢ 6204 ཨུ་དཱ་ན་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 6205 ཨི་ཏི་ཝུཏྟ་ཀ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 6206 སུཏྟ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༡ 6207 སུཏྟ་ནི་པཱ་ཏ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༢ 6208 ཝི་མཱ་ན་ཝཏྠུ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 6209 པེ་ཏ་ཝཏྠུ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 6210 ཐེ་ར་གཱ་ཐཱ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༡ 6211 ཐེ་ར་གཱ་ཐཱ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༢ 6212 ཐེ་རཱི་གཱ་ཐཱ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 6213 ཨ་པ་དཱ་ན་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༡ 6214 ཨ་པ་དཱ་ན་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༢ 6215 བུདྡྷ་ཝཾ་ས་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 6216 ཙ་རི་ཡཱ་པི་ཊ་ཀ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 6217 ཛཱ་ཏ་ཀ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༡ 6218 ཛཱ་ཏ་ཀ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༢ 6219 ཛཱ་ཏ་ཀ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༣ 6220 ཛཱ་ཏ་ཀ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༤ 6221 ཛཱ་ཏ་ཀ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༥ 6222 ཛཱ་ཏ་ཀ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༦ 6223 ཛཱ་ཏ་ཀ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༧ 6224 མ་ཧཱ་ནི་དྡེ་ས་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 6225 ཙཱུ་ལ་ནི་དྡེ་ས་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 6226 པ་ཊི་སམ་བྷི་དཱ་མགྒ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༡ 6227 པ་ཊི་སམ་བྷི་དཱ་མགྒ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ-༢ 6228 ནེཏྟི་པྤ་ཀ་ར་ཎ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། | 6301 ནེཏྟི་པྤ་ཀ་ར་ཎ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 6302 ནེཏྟི་ཝི་བྷཱི་ནཱི། | |
| 7101 དྷམྨ་སངྒ་ཎཱི་པཱ་ལི། 7102 ཝི་བྷངྒ་པཱ་ལི། 7103 དྷཱ་ཏུ་ཀ་ཐཱ་པཱ་ལི། 7104 པུགྒ་ལ་པཉྙཏྟི་པཱ་ལི། 7105 ཀ་ཐཱ་ཝཏྠུ་པཱ་ལི། 7106 ཡ་མ་ཀ་པཱ་ལི-༡ 7107 ཡ་མ་ཀ་པཱ་ལི-༢ 7108 ཡ་མ་ཀ་པཱ་ལི-༣ 7109 པཊྛཱ་ན་པཱ་ལི-༡ 7110 པཊྛཱ་ན་པཱ་ལི-༢ 7111 པཊྛཱ་ན་པཱ་ལི-༣ 7112 པཊྛཱ་ན་པཱ་ལི-༤ 7113 པཊྛཱ་ན་པཱ་ལི-༥ | 7201 དྷམྨ་སངྒ་ཎི་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 7202 སམྨོ་ཧ་ཝི་ནོ་ད་ནཱི་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། 7203 པཉྩ་པ་ཀ་ར་ཎ་ཨཊྛ་ཀ་ཐཱ། | 7301 དྷམྨ་སངྒ་ཎཱི་མཱུ་ལ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 7302 ཝི་བྷངྒ་མཱུ་ལ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 7303 པཉྩ་པ་ཀ་ར་ཎ་མཱུ་ལ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 7304 དྷམྨ་སངྒ་ཎཱི་ཨ་ནུ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 7305 པཉྩ་པ་ཀ་ར་ཎ་ཨ་ནུ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 7306 ཨ་བྷི་དྷམྨཱ་ཝ་ཏཱ་རོ་ནཱ་མ་རཱུ་པ་པ་རི་ཙྪེ་དོ། 7307 ཨ་བྷི་དྷམྨཏྠ་སངྒ་ཧོ། 7308 ཨ་བྷི་དྷམྨཱ་ཝ་ཏཱ་ར་པུ་རཱ་ཎ་ཊཱི་ཀཱ། 7309 ཨ་བྷི་དྷམྨ་མཱ་ཏི་ཀཱ་པཱ་ལི། | |
| Tiếng Việt | |||
| Kinh điển Pali | Chú giải | Phụ chú giải | Khác |
| 1101 Pārājika Pāḷi 1102 Pācittiya Pāḷi 1103 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Tạng Luật) 1104 Cūḷavagga Pāḷi 1105 Parivāra Pāḷi | 1201 Chú Giải Pārājikakaṇḍa - 1 1202 Chú Giải Pārājikakaṇḍa - 2 1203 Chú Giải Pācittiya 1204 Chú Giải Mahāvagga (Tạng Luật) 1205 Chú Giải Cūḷavagga 1206 Chú Giải Parivāra | 1301 Phụ Chú Giải Sāratthadīpanī - 1 1302 Phụ Chú Giải Sāratthadīpanī - 2 1303 Phụ Chú Giải Sāratthadīpanī - 3 | 1401 Dvemātikāpāḷi 1402 Chú Giải Vinayasaṅgaha 1403 Phụ Chú Giải Vajirabuddhi 1404 Phụ Chú Giải Vimativinodanī - 1 1405 Phụ Chú Giải Vimativinodanī - 2 1406 Phụ Chú Giải Vinayālaṅkāra - 1 1407 Phụ Chú Giải Vinayālaṅkāra - 2 1408 Phụ Chú Giải Kaṅkhāvitaraṇīpurāṇa 1409 Vinayavinicchaya-uttaravinicchaya 1410 Phụ Chú Giải Vinayavinicchaya - 1 1411 Phụ Chú Giải Vinayavinicchaya - 2 1412 Pācityādiyojanāpāḷi 1413 Khuddasikkhā-mūlasikkhā 8401 Thanh Tịnh Đạo - 1 8402 Thanh Tịnh Đạo - 2 8403 Đại Phụ Chú Giải Thanh Tịnh Đạo - 1 8404 Đại Phụ Chú Giải Thanh Tịnh Đạo - 2 8405 Lời Tựa Thanh Tịnh Đạo 8406 Trường Bộ Kinh (Vấn Đáp) 8407 Trung Bộ Kinh (Vấn Đáp) 8408 Tương Ưng Bộ Kinh (Vấn Đáp) 8409 Tăng Chi Bộ Kinh (Vấn Đáp) 8410 Tạng Luật (Vấn Đáp) 8411 Tạng Vi Diệu Pháp (Vấn Đáp) 8412 Chú Giải (Vấn Đáp) 8413 Niruttidīpanī 8414 Paramatthadīpanī Saṅgahamahāṭīkāpāṭha 8415 Anudīpanīpāṭha 8416 Paṭṭhānuddesa dīpanīpāṭha 8417 Phụ Chú Giải Namakkāra 8418 Mahāpaṇāmapāṭha 8419 Lakkhaṇāto buddhathomanāgāthā 8420 Sutavandanā 8421 Kamalāñjali 8422 Jinālaṅkāra 8423 Pajjamadhu 8424 Buddhaguṇagāthāvalī 8425 Cūḷaganthavaṃsa 8426 Mahāvaṃsa 8427 Sāsanavaṃsa 8428 Kaccāyanabyākaraṇaṃ 8429 Moggallānabyākaraṇaṃ 8430 Saddanītippakaraṇaṃ (padamālā) 8431 Saddanītippakaraṇaṃ (dhātumālā) 8432 Padarūpasiddhi 8433 Mogallānapañcikā 8434 Payogasiddhipāṭha 8435 Vuttodayapāṭha 8436 Abhidhānappadīpikāpāṭha 8437 Phụ Chú Giải Abhidhānappadīpikā 8438 Subodhālaṅkārapāṭha 8439 Phụ Chú Giải Subodhālaṅkāra 8440 Bālāvatāra gaṇṭhipadatthavinicchayasāra 8441 Lokanīti 8442 Suttantanīti 8443 Sūrassatinīti 8444 Mahārahanīti 8445 Dhammanīti 8446 Kavidappaṇanīti 8447 Nītimañjarī 8448 Naradakkhadīpanī 8449 Caturārakkhadīpanī 8450 Cāṇakyanīti 8451 Rasavāhinī 8452 Sīmavisodhanīpāṭha 8453 Vessantaragīti 8454 Moggallāna vuttivivaraṇapañcikā 8455 Thūpavaṃsa 8456 Dāṭhāvaṃsa 8457 Dhātupāṭhavilāsiniyā 8458 Dhātuvaṃsa 8459 Hatthavanagallavihāravaṃsa 8460 Jinacaritaya 8461 Jinavaṃsadīpaṃ 8462 Telakaṭāhagāthā 8463 Phụ Chú Giải Milinda 8464 Padamañjarī 8465 Padasādhanaṃ 8466 Saddabindupakaraṇaṃ 8467 Kaccāyanadhātumañjusā 8468 Sāmantakūṭavaṇṇanā |
| 2101 Sīlakkhandhavagga Pāḷi 2102 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Trường Bộ) 2103 Pāthikavagga Pāḷi | 2201 Chú Giải Sīlakkhandhavagga 2202 Chú Giải Mahāvagga (Trường Bộ) 2203 Chú Giải Pāthikavagga | 2301 Phụ Chú Giải Sīlakkhandhavagga 2302 Phụ Chú Giải Mahāvagga (Trường Bộ) 2303 Phụ Chú Giải Pāthikavagga 2304 Phụ Chú Giải Mới Sīlakkhandhavagga - 1 2305 Phụ Chú Giải Mới Sīlakkhandhavagga - 2 | |
| 3101 Mūlapaṇṇāsa Pāḷi 3102 Majjhimapaṇṇāsa Pāḷi 3103 Uparipaṇṇāsa Pāḷi | 3201 Chú Giải Mūlapaṇṇāsa - 1 3202 Chú Giải Mūlapaṇṇāsa - 2 3203 Chú Giải Majjhimapaṇṇāsa 3204 Chú Giải Uparipaṇṇāsa | 3301 Phụ Chú Giải Mūlapaṇṇāsa 3302 Phụ Chú Giải Majjhimapaṇṇāsa 3303 Phụ Chú Giải Uparipaṇṇāsa | |
| 4101 Sagāthāvagga Pāḷi 4102 Nidānavagga Pāḷi 4103 Khandhavagga Pāḷi 4104 Saḷāyatanavagga Pāḷi 4105 Mahāvagga Pāḷi (Tương Ưng Bộ) | 4201 Chú Giải Sagāthāvagga 4202 Chú Giải Nidānavagga 4203 Chú Giải Khandhavagga 4204 Chú Giải Saḷāyatanavagga 4205 Chú Giải Mahāvagga (Tương Ưng Bộ) | 4301 Phụ Chú Giải Sagāthāvagga 4302 Phụ Chú Giải Nidānavagga 4303 Phụ Chú Giải Khandhavagga 4304 Phụ Chú Giải Saḷāyatanavagga 4305 Phụ Chú Giải Mahāvagga (Tương Ưng Bộ) | |
| 5101 Ekakanipāta Pāḷi 5102 Dukanipāta Pāḷi 5103 Tikanipāta Pāḷi 5104 Catukkanipāta Pāḷi 5105 Pañcakanipāta Pāḷi 5106 Chakkanipāta Pāḷi 5107 Sattakanipāta Pāḷi 5108 Aṭṭhakādinipāta Pāḷi 5109 Navakanipāta Pāḷi 5110 Dasakanipāta Pāḷi 5111 Ekādasakanipāta Pāḷi | 5201 Chú Giải Ekakanipāta 5202 Chú Giải Duka-tika-catukkanipāta 5203 Chú Giải Pañcaka-chakka-sattakanipāta 5204 Chú Giải Aṭṭhakādinipāta | 5301 Phụ Chú Giải Ekakanipāta 5302 Phụ Chú Giải Duka-tika-catukkanipāta 5303 Phụ Chú Giải Pañcaka-chakka-sattakanipāta 5304 Phụ Chú Giải Aṭṭhakādinipāta | |
| 6101 Khuddakapāṭha Pāḷi 6102 Dhammapada Pāḷi 6103 Udāna Pāḷi 6104 Itivuttaka Pāḷi 6105 Suttanipāta Pāḷi 6106 Vimānavatthu Pāḷi 6107 Petavatthu Pāḷi 6108 Theragāthā Pāḷi 6109 Therīgāthā Pāḷi 6110 Apadāna Pāḷi - 1 6111 Apadāna Pāḷi - 2 6112 Buddhavaṃsa Pāḷi 6113 Cariyāpiṭaka Pāḷi 6114 Jātaka Pāḷi - 1 6115 Jātaka Pāḷi - 2 6116 Mahāniddesa Pāḷi 6117 Cūḷaniddesa Pāḷi 6118 Paṭisambhidāmagga Pāḷi 6119 Nettippakaraṇa Pāḷi 6120 Milindapañha Pāḷi 6121 Peṭakopadesa Pāḷi | 6201 Chú Giải Khuddakapāṭha 6202 Chú Giải Dhammapada - 1 6203 Chú Giải Dhammapada - 2 6204 Chú Giải Udāna 6205 Chú Giải Itivuttaka 6206 Chú Giải Suttanipāta - 1 6207 Chú Giải Suttanipāta - 2 6208 Chú Giải Vimānavatthu 6209 Chú Giải Petavatthu 6210 Chú Giải Theragāthā - 1 6211 Chú Giải Theragāthā - 2 6212 Chú Giải Therīgāthā 6213 Chú Giải Apadāna - 1 6214 Chú Giải Apadāna - 2 6215 Chú Giải Buddhavaṃsa 6216 Chú Giải Cariyāpiṭaka 6217 Chú Giải Jātaka - 1 6218 Chú Giải Jātaka - 2 6219 Chú Giải Jātaka - 3 6220 Chú Giải Jātaka - 4 6221 Chú Giải Jātaka - 5 6222 Chú Giải Jātaka - 6 6223 Chú Giải Jātaka - 7 6224 Chú Giải Mahāniddesa 6225 Chú Giải Cūḷaniddesa 6226 Chú Giải Paṭisambhidāmagga - 1 6227 Chú Giải Paṭisambhidāmagga - 2 6228 Chú Giải Nettippakaraṇa | 6301 Phụ Chú Giải Nettippakaraṇa 6302 Nettivibhāvinī | |
| 7101 Dhammasaṅgaṇī Pāḷi 7102 Vibhaṅga Pāḷi 7103 Dhātukathā Pāḷi 7104 Puggalapaññatti Pāḷi 7105 Kathāvatthu Pāḷi 7106 Yamaka Pāḷi - 1 7107 Yamaka Pāḷi - 2 7108 Yamaka Pāḷi - 3 7109 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi - 1 7110 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi - 2 7111 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi - 3 7112 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi - 4 7113 Paṭṭhāna Pāḷi - 5 | 7201 Chú Giải Dhammasaṅgaṇi 7202 Chú Giải Sammohavinodanī 7203 Chú Giải Pañcapakaraṇa | 7301 Phụ Chú Giải Gốc Dhammasaṅgaṇī 7302 Phụ Chú Giải Gốc Vibhaṅga 7303 Phụ Chú Giải Gốc Pañcapakaraṇa 7304 Phụ Chú Giải Tiếp Theo Dhammasaṅgaṇī 7305 Phụ Chú Giải Tiếp Theo Pañcapakaraṇa 7306 Abhidhammāvatāro-nāmarūpaparicchedo 7307 Abhidhammatthasaṅgaho 7308 Phụ Chú Giải Cổ Điển Abhidhammāvatāra 7309 Abhidhammamātikāpāḷi | |